Advantage CP - UTNIF 2023
Advantage CP - UTNIF 2023.docx
Indexed text preview
UTNIF GRIPE File – Adv CPs – 2023 Thanks to all the UTNIF Students who worked on this file: Theo, Hasan, Lauren, Hadley, Sanjana, Addy, Dylan, Akash, Elizabeth, Alex, Varsha, Paris, and David Art Neg 1NC CP Text: The United States federal government ought to increase funding towards environmental art. Connecting art to science increases human engagement—that’s key to addressing climate change Mika Tosca and Adrian Galvin 19 (Mika is a trained climate scientist, having completed her Ph.D. work with Drs. Charlie Zender and James Randerson at the University of California, Irvine in 2012. While at Irvine, Dr. Tosca researched the interconnectivity of the climate with landscape fires and particulate (aerosol) emissions. Galvin went to graduate school at Carnegie Mellon University to study interaction design, and is now primarily a UX/UI designer with a specialization in data visualization for scientific research tools.) “Transcending Science: Can artists and designers help scientists solve the climate crisis?” ADS https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2019AGUFMED53B.05T/abstract Access Date: 7/1/23—VS In recent decades, despite glaring and increasing evidence of climate change, much of this knowledge remains abstruse, cumbersomely documented, and opaquely presented, making engagement with it by "nonscientists" difficult. Perhaps this is the reason why a large segment of the general population remains convinced that human beings have not caused the observed 20th and 21st century climate change. There exists, therefore, an exciting and necessary opportunity for scientists to collaborate with artists. In school, we learn that the scientific method begins with a hypothesis, progresses through research and analysis, and concludes with a result. The design process, in contrast, begins with human engagement and inquiry, progresses through ideation and prototyping, and concludes with a refined artifact. Perhaps the revolution we need to address climate change begins by making the human engagement of art-making an integral part of the scientific method. As a climate scientist teaching full time at an art university, I am uniquely positioned to explore these possibilities. I also maintain that improvements in data visualization can not only improve communication of climate change, but also facilitate exploratory research and help researchers ask qualitatively "better" scientific questions. Exploratory analysis, or a precursory evaluation of data with the intent of generating a research inquiry or hypothesis, is often hampered in efficacy by an arduous data-parsing process or incomplete and confusing data visualization. Here I present a collaboration with designer Adrian Galvin, in which we conducted a thorough workflow inquiry and iterative prototyping sessions to refine and redesign interactions and visual representations of a data delivery interface. The result of these efforts facilitated better science through streamlined exploratory investigation, and reduced the time taken to generate visualizations and correlations. Through the examples presented here, there is real potential for art and design to dramatically improve the way climate research is conducted and communicated. As we update our understanding of the environment, we must also update the tools we use to study it and the methods we use to present it to the public. Eco Artists have the power to transform our models of economy Ariunaa Jargalsaikhan 21 (Certified Public Accountant (Lifetime) MONICPA. Certified Tax Accountant. MACTA. Licensed Auditor. Mongolian Institute of Certified Public Accountants) “CAN ECO ART HELP MONGOLIA SOLVE THE CLIMATE CRISIS?” Jargal Defacto https://jargaldefacto.com/article/can-eco-art-help-mongolia-solve-the-climate-crisis?lang=en Access Date: 7/1/23—VS One of the major dilemmas in resolving the climate crisis is the linear “take–make–consume–dispose” approach to natural resources.2 For this reason, countries have begun to recognize the fundamental rights of nature as part of their constitutions. Initiated by Ecuador in 2008, this principle accepts that humans are part and parcel of nature, and not its independent proprietors.3 The rights of nature can endorse a new model of circular economy where each economic sector receives from and provides for another. The resulting networks eliminate waste by continuing the use of resources and develop like ecosystems do. Still, modes of operation adopted from the advent of industrialization are proving difficult to change. Rapid urbanization increases the sense of human detachment from the price it costs to make the energy, transport, food, and goods we consume. Eco artists are agents of transformation in attitudes toward the use of natural resources. People become aware of the impacts of climate change through Eco Art Ariunaa Jargalsaikhan 21 (Certified Public Accountant (Lifetime) MONICPA. Certified Tax Accountant. MACTA. Licensed Auditor. Mongolian Institute of Certified Public Accountants) “CAN ECO ART HELP MONGOLIA SOLVE THE CLIMATE CRISIS?” Jargal Defacto https://jargaldefacto.com/article/can-eco-art-help-mongolia-solve-the-climate-crisis?lang=en Access Date: 7/1/23—VS Eco Art is an influential agent of education, civic mobilization, and community activism. This spring, twelve graphic design students from the Mongolian Academy of Fine Arts and 111 children participated in the “Nogoonbaatar” (Green Hero) Eco Art Festival. Their art is a sobering reminder of the destructive impacts of greenhouse gas emissions. Below are just a few examples of their work: Alongside children’s art, the “Nogoonbaatar” Eco Art Festival presented artworks by sixteen artists who turned the streets of a northern Ulaanbaatar ger district into a vibrant outdoor exhibition. The main site was once a wasteyard. Mr. S. Ulziitogtokh turned it into “Uulyn Park” in 2012 (Google maps mistakes it for Nogoon Nuuryn Park). The key attraction is a reservoir where neighborhood children can ice-skate in the winter and row boats in the summer. When I met Mr. Ulziitogtokh, he had just been presented with two cherry blossom trees by a kind elderly gentleman. “Did you know that there are 1,000 different types of Sakuras and that two of them grow in Mongolia?” he asked me with enthusiasm. He has planted trees all around the reservoir and waters them regularly – that is how the lake stays clean. This year, he is working to turn the boathouse into a small community center for children, where they can read books and learn to play musical instruments. The newly created artworks render the neighborhood a place full of color and character. The street is livened up with decorative murals by Ts.Tuvshinjargal and S.Batsaikhan, graffiti art by B.Ider (Ren) and O.Tuguldur, a mongol zurag mural by R.Chinzorig, mixed media prints on wood by J.Shijirbaatar, and printed illustrations by students A.Undramsan, B.Narankhuu and others. The messages in some of them are neutral and more decorative. Others depict scenes from nomadic traditions, children with happy faces and writings in Mongolian Cyrillic reminding viewers to “spread love.” Still, messages in others are more cautionary and sardonic, showing images of childhood innocence set against pictures of smoke from powerplants, or the question, “What color is the sky?” written in a font that suggests a children’s book but placed in the foreground of a suburban scene with a black sky. The eclectic collection of artworks turns the street into an unconventional gallery that tickles the minds of passers-by in spite of themselves. Inside the park, artworks enhance the fun and friendly atmosphere for children and invite visitors to enjoy the views of the lake from various vantage points. Paintings by Ts.Ariuntugs and M.Batzorig, ceramic sculptures by D.Otgonbayar, sculptures from recycled metal, wood, and other materials such as mirrors, bicycles by T.Enkhbold and plastic by R.Luvsandorj enrich the imagination and channel creative inspiration. There are unique sculptures that pay heartfelt homage to childhood in Sunny Rain by E.Tsagaantsooj and B.Bat-Erdene, and endangered wildlife in Spirit by M-Munkh-Erdene. One can play basketball at fun-size hoops in the shape of trees created by E.Jantsankhorol. They will chime when you score, as the ball collides with tiny bells attached to the net. Everyone is happy when you score your green goals. On top of the hill, overlooking the lake, N.Amarsaikhan's gregarious bench with an impressive mane of windfallen trees will embrace visitors. If they’re nice and gentle, it might show them green visions through its eye. AFF 2AC Climate change too much of a risk now—CP takes too long Luke Kempt et al 22 (Kempt was in the Centre for the Study of Existential Risk, and Darwin College, University of Cambridge, Cambridge CB2 1SB, United Kingdom. Chi Xu; School of Life Sciences, Nanjing University, Nanjing 210023, China. Joanna Depledge; Cambridge Centre for Environment, Energy and Natural Resource Governance, University of Cambridge, Cambridge CB2 3QZ, United Kingdom. Kristie L. Ebi; Center for Health and the Global Environment, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195. Goodwin Gibbins; Future of Humanity Institute, University of Oxford, Oxford OX2 0DJ, United Kingdom. Timothy A. Kohler; Department of Anthropology, Washington State University, Pullman, WA 99164-4910 Santa Fe Institute, Santa Fe, NM 87501 Cluster of Excellence ROOTS – Social, Environmental, and Cultural Connectivity in Past Societies, Christian-Albrechts-Universität, Kiel, 24118 Germany. Johan Rockström; Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, 14473 Potsdam, Germany. Marten Scheffer; Department of Environmental Sciences, University of Wageningen, 6708PB Wageningen, The Netherlands. Hans Joachim Schellnhuber; Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, 14473 Potsdam, Germany, Earth System Science Department, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100190, China. Will Steffen; Fenner School of Environment and Society, The Australian National University, Canberra, ACT 2601, Australia. Timothy M. Lenton; Global Systems Institute, University of Exeter, Exeter EX4 4QE, United Kingdom.) “Climate Endgame: Exploring catastrophic climate change scenarios” PNAS https://www.pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073/pnas.2108146119#sec-3 Access Date: 7/1/23—VS There are four key reasons to be concerned over the potential of a global climate catastrophe. First, there are warnings from history. Climate change (either regional or global) has played a role in the collapse or transformation of numerous previous societies (37) and in each of the five mass extinction events in Phanerozoic Earth history (38). The current carbon pulse is occurring at an unprecedented geological speed and, by the end of the century, may surpass thresholds that triggered previous mass extinctions (39, 40). The worst-case scenarios in the IPCC report project temperatures by the 22nd century that last prevailed in the Early Eocene, reversing 50 million years of cooler climates in the space of two centuries (41). This is particularly alarming, as human societies are locally adapted to a specific climatic niche. The rise of large-scale, urbanized agrarian societies began with the shift to the stable climate of the Holocene ∼12,000 y ago (42). Since then, human population density peaked within a narrow climatic envelope with a mean annual average temperature of ∼13 °C. Even today, the most economically productive centers of human activity are concentrated in those areas (43). The cumulative impacts of warming may overwhelm societal adaptive capacity. Second, climate change could directly trigger other catastrophic risks, such as international conflict, or exacerbate infectious disease spread, and spillover risk. These could be potent extreme threat multipliers. Third, climate change could exacerbate vulnerabilities and cause multiple, indirect stresses (such as economic damage, loss of land, and water and food insecurity) that coalesce into system-wide synchronous failures. This is the path of systemic risk. Global crises tend to occur through such reinforcing “synchronous failures” that spread across countries and systems, as with the 2007–2008 global financial crisis (44). It is plausible that a sudden shift in climate could trigger systems failures that unravel societies across the globe. Perm Do Both-- Human engagement is still possible through the policies enacted by the plan Stewart Lockie 1-20-23 (James Cook University, Cairns, Australia, environmental sociologist.) “Sociologies of climate change are not enough. Putting the global biodiversity crisis on the sociological agenda” Taylor Francis Online https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/23251042.2023.2170310 Access Date: 7/1/23—VS Biodiversity and the ecosystem services it provides are deteriorating at rates unprecedented in human history – deterioration driven, principally, by land and sea use change, overexploitation of biodiversity resources, climate change, pollution, and invasive alien species (IPBES Citation2019). The Kunming-Montreal Framework thus aims to transform societies’ relationship with biodiversity and to galvanize ‘urgent and transformative action’ by government and non-government actors to reverse biodiversity loss. At the same time, the framework respects national sovereignty, human rights, the contributions and rights of indigenous peoples and local communities, the diversity of concepts and values people bring to understanding and managing biodiversity, the importance of gender equality, socioeconomic development, and inter-generational equity, and so on. Implementation is to be based on an ecosystem approach underpinned by science, traditional knowledge, innovation, education, and finance. Ban Meat NEG 1NC Text: The United States federal government should ban meat production. Meat demand “creates future pandemics,” making “Covid-19 pandemic look like a ‘dress rehearsal’ says scientists.” History of pandemics agrees. Dalton 21 Jane Dalton 1 – 30 – 21 (trained journalist writes news, features and opinion pieces at The Independent, often specialising in animal welfare and conservation. She frequently exposes cruelty and wrongdoing through hard-hitting exclusives. She is also interested in adult social care. During her early career on local papers, Jane won the Feature Writer of the Year award at Senews and was runner-up Reporter of the Year for the Emap media group. A graduate in French and Russian, she was regional editor at The Sunday Times before joining The Independent) “Meat-eating creates risk of future pandemic that ‘would make Covid seem a dress rehearsal’, scientists warn” The Independent 7 – 1 – 23 https://www.independent.co.uk/climate-change/news/meat-coronavirus-pandemic-science-animals-b1794996.html //EKoo Demand for regular supplies of affordable meat will create future pandemics that will make Covid-19 pandemic look like a “dress rehearsal", scientists are warning. Producing meat is creating the perfect breeding ground for diseases of the same kind to emerge, according to the South African academics. The risk is created by humans’ interactions with animals and a lack of learning from the past, they say. The coronavirus pandemic, many of the early cases of which were linked to a live-animal-slaughter market in China, has killed around 2.2 million people worldwide in a year. Experts from both the UN and the European Food Safety Authority have previously identified industrial animal farming as the cause of most new infectious diseases in humans in the past decade, and have likewise warned it risks starting new pandemics. Zoonotic diseases - those that jump from animals to humans - have become four times as frequent in the past 50 years. Animals kept in close confinement, either in street markets or intensive farming, are susceptible to disease because the stress of the conditions and even the sight of others being slaughtered weakens their immune systems, experts say. A report last May, called Is the next Pandemic on our Plate?, outlined how factory farming allowed pathogens to emerge and spread, and was supported by routine use of antibiotics, leading to the drugs becoming less effective. The World Health Organisation says that globally, about a billion cases of illness and millions of deaths occur every year from zoonoses – diseases that spread from animals to humans – and that 75 per cent of emerging zoonotic infectious diseases originate in wild animals. Prof Aliza le Roux, assistant dean of natural and agricultural sciences and associate professor of zoology at the University of the Free State (UFS), said: “Our demand for meat is driving cheaper and less controlled agricultural practices, cramming more animals into smaller spaces, feeding them less and less natural fodder. “Remember mad cow disease? Have you seen chicken batteries? We should not blame ‘exotic’ eating practices, but look at our own. “If we could see eating meat as a ‘treat’ and not a daily ‘right’, we can reduce pressure on the environment and reduce the speed at which another zoonotic virus can evolve.” Prof Robert Bragg, of the department of microbial, biochemical and food biotechnology, said: “There will be more pandemics, and there is a feeling among some scientists that this could just be a dress rehearsal for the real big pandemic. “Many virologists, including me, have been predicting an influenza pandemic for many years. Mankind has been warned about coming pandemics for many years, but people seem to want to listen only when they are in the midst of one.” The bird flu virus, H5N1, has a mortality rate of 60-65 per cent, he said. If it develops human-to-human transmission, “we could be in for a really serious pandemic”, he warned. Ebola was traced to people eating bats, and HIV was believed to have emerged from people eating chimpanzee meat, he said. And the 1918 Spanish flu, which killed 50 million people, started in pigs. “All of these have to do with the mistreatment of animals by man,” said Prof Bragg. “Mankind should also have learnt from the 1918 pandemic, but man is notoriously slow at learning lessons from the past.” Key to stop climate change is cutting meat demand. Fiona Harvey 10 – 26 – 22 (environment editor of the Guardian) “Meat consumption to two burgers a week to save planet, study suggests” The Guardian 7-1-23 https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/oct/26/cut-meat-consumption-save-planet-climate-crisis-fossil-fuels //EKoo Meat consumption should be reduced to the equivalent of about two burgers a week in the developed world, and public transport expanded about six times faster than its current rate, if the world is to avoid the worst ravages of the climate crisis, research has suggested. The State of Climate Action 2022 report examined global progress on 40 indicators that would be key to halving global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by 2030, in line with the goal of limiting temperature rises to 1.5C above pre-industrial levels. 2NC Violence against women connected historically and symbolically to violence against animals. Killing or using either’s reproductive systems forcibly is “not that bad.” Girlboss ND (a community of strong, curious, and ambitious women redefining success on our own terms. We are here to inform, entertain, and inspire action through the content and experiences we create. We are unapologetic in our beliefs and values of supporting girls and women who are chasing dreams both big and small) “Why I See Meat Eating As A Femnist Issue – And I Wish More Women Did” Girlboss 7 – 1 – 23 https://girlboss.com/blogs/read/meat-eating-is-a-feminist-issue //EKoo Perhaps only subconsciously, violence against women and girls has been linked to violence against animals in my mind since childhood. Growing up, I remember hearing, “Animals belong to mankind,” almost as often as hearing, “Wives, submit to your husbands.” I’ve never been hunting, but I passed my hunter safety cours
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.