Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 UTNIF Disadvantage

Federalism DA - UTNIF 2023

Federalism DA - UTNIF 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Federalism DA – UTNIF – Starter Packet
With very few exceptions, the U.S. Constitution does not permit Congress to force states to administer federal programs or to adopt federal policy.61 However, because federal grants are considered voluntary, Congress routinely sets grant conditions to drive policy at the state level.62 The U.S. Supreme Court has upheld the imposition of grant obligations to steer state policies under the Constitution’s (loosely worded) Spending Clause, which empowers Congress “to lay and collect Taxes…to…provide for the…general Welfare of the United States.”63
1NC
1NC – Jobs Guarantee
Jobs regulations are handled by the states now. A federal job guarantee uniquely undermines state sovereignty.
MacDonald 23 – Alexander MacDonald is an in-house counsel at Instacart. Before coming to Instacart, he worked in the Washington, DC offices of Littler Mendelson, PC, where he advised management on all aspects of labor-management relations, [“The Department of Labor’s Independent Contractor Rule: A Quiet Threat to Federalism?”, The Federalist Society, 3/30/2023, https://fedsoc.org/commentary/fedsoc-blog/the-department-of-labor-s-independent-contractor-rule-a-quiet-threat-to-federalism]RA
The U.S. Department of Labor is considering a new rule that would narrow the definition of “independent contractor” under federal wage-and-hour law. The Department published a preliminary version of the rule last fall, and it is expected to post a final version this spring. But even though the proposal has been public for months, there is still widespread confusion about how far it would go. For example, in recent comments to the media, former National Labor Relations Board Chairman William Gould IV suggested that the proposal would “preempt” certain state laws, including California’s laws for app-based drivers. Though he may not know it, Gould is both right and wrong. While the proposed rule would not “preempt” state laws per se, it would interfere with states’ ability to experiment with new work rules. And in that way, it would undermine democratic decision making and bedrock principles of federalism. To understand the nuance, some background is necessary. When Gould mentioned preemption, he was talking about Proposition 22. Prop 22 was approved by California voters in 2020 by a nearly 6-to-4 margin. The law created a new, comprehensive system for the state’s app-based workers. It guaranteed the workers a minimum hourly rate, offered them new benefits, and required certain safety precautions. It also guaranteed that the workers could continue to operate as independent contractors. That last guarantee was necessary because California has some of the strictest worker-classification laws in the country. Without Prop 22, there was a risk that app-based workers would have had to become employees—a result most of them said they didn’t want. Prop 22 was vehemently opposed by the state’s biggest labor unions, including the SEIU, which immediately sued to block the law. A trial judge initially declared the law unconstitutional. But last month, an appellate panel reversed the trial judge’s order. The panel held that Prop 22 was constitutional except for two provisions dealing with amendments. It carved those provisions out and upheld the law’s core features. It was this decision that prompted Gould’s statement. Gould said that he expected the California Supreme Court to weigh in and reverse the appellate court. But even if it didn’t, he said that the Department of Labor’s new rule would “preempt” Prop 22. That statement was both right and wrong. It was wrong because, formally speaking, the rule won’t preempt anything. The FLSA explicitly allows states to adopt their own wage-and-hour standards. Nothing about the FLSA preempts those standards or forces states to follow federal rules. So technically speaking, the rule would not “preempt” Prop 22. Prop 22 will set a standard for California law, and the Department’s rule will set one for federal law. But practically speaking, the rule will complicate things in California. When the Department proposed the rule, it said that it would consider certain kinds of control as evidence of an employment relationship for federal purposes. Those kinds of control could include, for example, mandatory training. So mandatory training could be evidence of employment even if companies are required to provide the training under state law. That result implicates Prop 22. Among other things, Prop 22 requires drivers to take certain safety and harassment training. So according to the rule, mere compliance with Prop 22 could be evidence of employment under federal law. And if workers are employees under federal law, they might not be able to work as independent contractors under state law. Companies and workers have to arrange their relationships to meet minimum legal requirements. And those arrangements could get quite complicated if the workers have different statuses under different laws. The result, then, is that the Department’s rule could make it more difficult to adopt creative programs like Prop 22. Prop 22 represents a voter-initiated experiment in worker classification and benefits. It’s an effort to preserve flexibility while also offering workers new benefits and guarantees. Reasonable people can disagree about whether it’s the best way to handle new kinds of work, such as work in the “gig economy.” But most people would say that states should at least be able to try new approaches. After all, that kind of experimentation undergirds our federal system. The founders wanted most policy to get made at the state level. They knew different states would try different solutions. And by studying those solutions, other states could make informed decisions about their own policies. Every state could run its own experiments, and those experiments would power the laboratory of democracy. The Department’s proposal would subvert the federal system without saying so. Without any notice or public debate, it would lock workers nationwide into a single kind of work arrangement. State governments would have less room to experiment and design creative programs. Likewise, voters would have less freedom to express their own preferences. They would be left with one top-down model—a model workers, businesses, and voters have already rejected.
That separation of power is critical to successful environmental policy.
Stan Meiburg, 4-26-2021, Ph.D. is the Director of the Graduate Studies in Sustainability at Wake Forest University and a Fellow at the National Academy of Public Administration, [“American Federalism and the Environment”, Federalism.US, https://federalism.us/2021/04/american-federalism-and-the-environment/]
To a degree unprecedented in recent American history, the environment, especially but not limited to climate change, has moved to the front rank of our public policy concerns. Even more remarkable is the degree to which this concern is interwoven with other threads: economic recovery, racial and social justice, energy supply and demand, trade policy, financial investments, agricultural policy, and national security. This attention reminds us of the rise of the environmental movement over fifty years ago, symbolized by the prominence of Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring and the first Earth Day, April 22, 1970. Among the most significant consequences of that rise was the creation by then-President Nixon of a new federal organization, the United States Environmental Protection Agency, a combination of parts from fifteen agencies around the government. The new agency, known universally by its acronym, EPA, opened its doors on December 2, 1970, headed by a 38-year-old former state senator from Indiana, William Ruckelshaus. The following twenty years witnessed a tremendous expansion in federal environmental law. Congress passed and Presidents signed into law twenty major pieces of environmental legislation, including such landmarks as the Clean Air Act, the Clean Water Act, and Safe Drinking Water Act, the Toxic Substances Control Act, the Ocean Dumping Act, and the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act (better known as “Superfund”). Though many challenges remain, today we are the beneficiaries of these initiatives in the form of cleaner air, water and land. To cite one set of statistics: since 1970, real GDP has increased by 285%, we drive almost three times as many miles, we have added more than 125 million people to our population, and we use 48% more energy; yet our emissions of the so-called “criteria pollutants” –hydrocarbons, particles, sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxides, lead and carbon monoxide–have decreased by 77%. Though federal leadership has been essential, this success is not the result of unilateral federal action. Federalism has been at the heart of much of this progress and of many of its most intense controversies. The private sector and non-governmental organizations have both played vital roles, but the interplay of federal and state action has been and remains a hallmark of U.S. environmental policy. Like most federalism discussions, this one starts with the Constitution. EPA has broad authorities derived from the enumerated powers given to Congress in the commerce clause. This clause has been broadly interpreted through the years, but debates persist over its scope, as evidenced by current arguments about the jurisdiction of the Clean Water Act over the “navigable waters” of the United States. Apart from constitutional issues, the expansion of federal environmental law between 1970 and 1990 rested upon a parallel framework which President Nixon referred to as “the new federalism”. This new federalism contrasted with previous expansions of federal authority in the Progressive Era, the New Deal, and the Great Society by explicitly giving significant discretion to states in the administration of federal statutes. With the notable exceptions of Superfund and TSCA, the major environmental statutes provide for states to implement their permitting and enforcement authorities. The organization of EPA reflects this difference. EPA is decentralized, in that almost half of its staff reside in ten regional offices, located in standard federal region cities. However, unlike the Park Service, the Forest Service, the USDA extension service, the Natural Resources Conservation Service, the Federal Housing Administration, the Federal Highway Administration, or the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, EPA with few exceptions does not have staff stationed in state capitals or in field locations. EPA delegates authorities that such staff might exercise to state environmental agencies. States acquire these authorities by seeking delegation or approval from EPA, according to the provisions of the various environmental statutes. By and large this process was completed over thirty years ago, and it is fair to speak now of a U.S. environmental enterprise where governance is shared between states and EPA (and, to an increasing degree, tribal authorities).
Climate change causes extinction
Sears 21, Nathan Alexander, PhD Candidate in Political Science at The University of Toronto, Former Professor of International Relations at the Universidad de Las Américas, Trudeau Fellow in Peace, Conflict and Justice at the Munk School of Global Affairs, “Great Powers, Polarity, and Existential Threats to Humanity: An Analysis of the Distribution of the Forces of Total Destruction in International Security”, Conference Paper: International Studies Association, 2021 Annual Conference, March/April 2021, https://tinyurl.com/bfbfspzx
Climate Change
Humanity faces existential risks from the large-scale destruction of Earth’s natural environment making the planet less hospitable for humankind (Wallace-Wells 2019). The decline of some of Earth’s natural systems may already exceed the “planetary boundaries” that represent a “safe operating space for humanity” (Rockstrom et al. 2009). Humanity has become one of the driving forces behind Earth’s climate system (Crutzen 2002). The major anthropogenic drivers of climate change are the burning of fossil fuels (e.g., coal, oil, and gas), combined with the degradation of Earth’s natural systems for absorbing carbon dioxide, such as deforestation for agriculture (e.g., livestock and monocultures) and resource extraction (e.g., mining and oil), and the warming of the oceans (Kump et al. 2003). While humanity has influenced Earth’s climate since at least the Industrial Revolution, the dramatic increase in greenhouse gas emissions since the mid-twentieth century—the “Great Acceleration” (Steffen et al. 2007; 2015; McNeill & Engelke 2016)— is responsible for contemporary climate change, which has reached approximately 1°C above preindustrial levels (IPCC 2018). Climate change could become an existential threat to humanity if the planet’s climate reaches a “Hothouse Earth” state (Ripple et al. 2020). What are the dangers? There are two mechanisms of climate change that threaten humankind. The direct threat is extreme heat. While human societies possesses some capacity for adaptation and resilience to climate change, the physiological response of humans to heat stress imposes physical limits—with a hard limit at roughly 35°C wet-bulb temperature (Sherwood et al. 2010). A rise in global average temperatures by 3–4°C would increase the risk of heat stress, while 7°C could render some regions uninhabitable, and 11–12°C would leave much of the planet too hot for human habitation (Sherwood et al. 2010). The indirect effects of climate change could include, inter alia, rising sea levels affecting coastal regions (e.g., Miami and Shanghai), or even swallowing entire countries (e.g., Bangladesh and the Maldives); extreme and unpredictable weather and natural disasters (e.g., hurricanes and forest fires); environmental pressures on water and food scarcity (e.g., droughts from less-dispersed rainfall, and lower wheat-yields at higher temperatures); the possible inception of new bacteria and viruses; and, of course, large-scale human migration (World Bank 2012; Wallace-Well 2019; Richards, Lupton & Allywood 2001). While it is difficult to determine the existential implications of extreme environmental conditions, there are historic precedents for the collapse of human societies under environmental pressures (Diamond 2005). Earth’s “big five” mass extinction events have been linked to dramatic shifts in Earth’s climate (Ward 2008; Payne & Clapham 2012; Kolbert 2014; Brannen 2017), and a Hothouse Earth climate would represent terra incognita for humanity. Thus, the assumption here is that a Hothouse Earth climate could pose an existential threat to the habitability of the planet for humanity (Steffen et al. 2018., 5). At what point could climate change cross the threshold of an existential threat to humankind? The complexity of Earth’s natural systems makes it extremely difficult to give a precise figure (Rockstrom et al. 2009; ). However, much of the concern about climate change is over the danger of crossing “tipping points,” whereby positive feedback loops in Earth’s climate system could lead to potentially irreversible and self-reinforcing “runaway” climate change. For example, the melting of Arctic “permafrost” could produce additional warming, as glacial retreat reduces the refractory effect of the ice and releases huge quantities of methane currently trapped beneath it. A recent study suggests that a “planetary threshold” could exist at global average temperature of 2°C above preindustrial levels (Steffen et al. 2018; also IPCC 2018). Therefore, the analysis here takes the 2°C rise in global average temperatures as representing the lower-boundary of an existential threat to humanity, with higher temperatures increasing the risk of runaway climate change leading to a Hothouse Earth. The Paris Agreement on Climate Change set the goal of limiting the increase in global average temperatures to “well below” 2°C and to pursue efforts to limit the increase to 1.5°C. If the Paris Agreement goals are met, then nations would likely keep climate change below the threshold of an existential threat to humanity. According to Climate Action Tracker (2020), however, current policies of states are expected to produce global average temperatures of 2.9°C above preindustrial levels by 2100 (range between +2.1 and +3.9°C), while if states succeed in meeting their pledges and targets, global average temperatures are still projected to increase by 2.6°C (range between +2.1 and +3.3°C). Thus, while the Paris Agreements sets a goal 6 that would reduce the existential risk of climate change, the actual policies of states could easily cross the threshold that would constitute an existential threat to humanity (CAT 2020).
2NC Cards
Uniqueness
AT Non-unique / Overreach Now
Don’t throw the baby out with the bathwater. More government interference is the brink – we should want to INCREASE state sovereignty.
Katz 21 - Diane Katz is Senior Research Fellow in Regulatory Policy in the Thomas A. Roe Institute for Economic Policy Studies, of the Institute for Economic Freedom and Opportunity, at The Heritage Foundation, [“Biden Administration’s Overreach Affecting States’ Rights, Too”, The Heritage Foundation, 12/10/2021, https://www.heritage.org/government-regulation/commentary/biden-administrations-overreach-affecting-states-rights-too]RA
Since 2000, Congress and various presidents have approved more than 190 statutes with intergovernmental mandates, according to the Congressional Budget Office. Collectively, the laws have imposed more than 1,000 separate directives. The volume of red tape is massive. States are also much more dependent on federal grants-in-aid, which comprised nearly a third (32.4%) of total state spending in fiscal year 2020. The number of federally funded grant programs grew from 132 in 1960, to 387 in 1968, and 664 in 1998. That number is now 1,274—and growing. Washington is about to unleash the second injection of COVID-19 cash—some $1.9 trillion under the American Rescue Plan Act—along with $1.2 trillion from the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act. Moreover, if passed by the Senate, the inaptly named “Build Back Better” bill will dispense several trillion dollars more. The various conditions attached to the grants drive policy at the state level and inject federal involvement in virtually every aspect of local governance. Such excessive federal interference inhibits policy competition among states, as well as the relative transparency and accountability of state-level and local-level regulation. It also impedes the ability of both citizens and businesses to escape flawed policies by crossing state borders. Previous efforts to curb intergovernmental meddling, such as enactment of the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act, have largely failed. New actions are sorely needed. Congress should start by requiring legislative sponsors to identify the constitutional basis of their bills. Floor time should be allotted to debate the sufficiency of the justification. Congress should also codify President Reagan’s Executive Order 12612, which directed departments and agencies to grant states the “maximum administrative discretion possible” and to limit state discretion “only where constitutional authority for the action is clear and certain and the national activity is necessitated by the presence of a problem of national scope.” Agencies should also be required to conduct federalism assessments (for review by the Office of Management and Budget) for all proposed rules with federalism implications. Each assessment should analyze the state costs that the rule would impose, and agencies should be required to report the results of the assessments to Congress and the public. The challenge before the nation is to divest power from the administrative state, restore the constitutional constraints that best safeguard libert

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.