Climate Jobs Guarantee Aff - UTNIF 2023
Climate Jobs Guarantee Aff - UTNIF 2023.docx
Indexed text preview
Climate Jobs Guarantee Aff – UTNIF – Starter Packet
1AC
1AC
Advantage 1: Economy
Job guarantees are affordable, resolve income inequality, and boost the national and local economy
Fogarty 15 Will Fogarty, Research Fellow for the Global Institute for Sustainable Prosperity. “Federally Funded, Locally Organized: An Affordable Job Guarantee Program”, Global Institute for Sustainable Prosperity (July 2015), https://www.global-isp.org/wp-content/uploads/WP-108.pdf
4. Low Cost of the Program Most program estimates peg the cost of a JG program between one and three percent of total G.D.P (Wray 2014, 1). As Figure 2 (below) shows, this is less than the 3.4% the United States already spends on generally ineffective anti-poverty programs.
Kaboub’s article about the low cost of full employment considers two possible cost scenarios: one in which the JG program hires all unemployed workers in the first year, and another in which the process is gradual. The latter scenario seems more politically plausible and will therefore be analyzed13. By the third year, the program will have hired all workers who are ready, willing, and able; he estimates a workforce of roughly 23 million (Kaboub 2012, 65)14 . He also proposes a wage structure with a base pay of $15 per hour and sliding scale up to $21 per hour, which exceeds the wages proposed in this paper (Kaboub 2012, 65)15 . Kaboub budgets a material cost of $50 billion for the projects themselves, and also includes an annual benefits package of $10,000 (Kaboub 2012, 65). Given a reasonable federal income tax of 15%, he calculates that the program will raise $121 billion in tax revenue (Kaboub 2012, 66). 16 It will save the federal government at least $234 billion in various cost reductions, including $150 billion in savings from unemployment benefits, $100 billion in food assistance programs, and $75 in incarceration costs (Kaboub 2012, 66). All things considered, the program will cost less than $600 billion—practically pennies in comparison to the $29 trillion that the Fed has spent bailing out Wall Street (Kaboub 2012, 66). Most importantly, by year three, the increased purchasing power of the formerly unemployed will generate over $1 trillion annually to U.S. G.D.P. (Kaboub 2012, 66). Once again, affordability is not an issue, but, regardless, this analysis demonstrates the JG program’s relatively low cost and its contribution to economic growth. 13 This proposal is not strictly committed to either the “shock therapy” or “gradual approach” (Kaboub 2012: 65). The shock therapy approach solves the issue immediately, but may cause some administrative and organizational mishaps. The gradual approach should decrease these miscues, but leaves people employable individuals unemployed that much longer. 14 The following estimates are not closely dependent on this figure of 23 million; a few million more will not wildly alter the analysis. In fact, I suspect that the figure will be below 23 million as the newly employed workers will spend their money and expand the economy. Private corporations will need to hire more workers in response, and will look to the JG program to do so. 15 Therefore, these estimates likely exceed the costs of the JG program proposed in this paper. 16 Let us temporarily leave aside that the federal government does not actually use tax revenue to spend. 14 IV.Economic Benefits of JG Program An increase to G.D.P. is certainly not the only economic benefit of the program nor its most important. The United States is the richest country in the world almost twice over, yet income inequality has been steadily increasing for decades and tens of millions of citizens remained unemployment against their will. Clearly, G.D.P. is not the only measure of a country’s economic wellbeing. First and foremost, The JG program will help struggling families by providing them with the means to afford the most basic necessities and allow them enjoy at least some material comforts. The increased purchasing power of the newly employed workers will trigger a boom in the aggregate demand of many goods and services. Businesses will respond to the increased activity and higher profits by hiring more workers into middle-management positions, which will curb rising income inequality. Local and state governments will also see significant increases in tax revenue. Workers will be able to afford homes and pay property taxes; they will consume more goods and services and pay the corresponding taxes. Unlike the federal government, local governments are not currency issuers and do rely on tax revenue and borrowing to spend. There is little reason to doubt that more money will help local and state governments operate more effectively and encourage the development of previously unaffordable projects.
Inflation is a non-issue. Climate jobs guarantee includes an economic buffer controlling supply and demand, which also solves resource limitations.
Fogarty 15 Will Fogarty, Research Fellow for the Global Institute for Sustainable Prosperity. “Federally Funded, Locally Organized: An Affordable Job Guarantee Program”, Global Institute for Sustainable Prosperity (July 2015), https://www.global-isp.org/wp-content/uploads/WP-108.pdf
2. Inflation: A Non-Issue The conventional wisdom will claim that this proposal, if adopted, will trigger runaway inflation. This fear is misinformed, and greatly exaggerates the consequences of small annual price increases. Most policymakers accept that unemployment helps prevent inflation, although they would likely not say so in a campaign speech. The first obvious objection to this unspoken approach is ethical: Wray asks: Should a nation attempt to maintain macroeconomic stability by keeping a portion of its population sufficiently poor […]. More generally, is unemployment and poverty an acceptable policy tool to be used to maintain currency stability? (Wray 2012, 225) In other words, is inflation so bad that it justifies keeping tens of millions jobless? Ethics aside, the program will actually stabilize prices in the long-run by operating as a buffer stock mechanism, which will effectively allow the federal government to maintain wages at a target level. During an economic boom, private sector wages will not skyrocket because corporations will always have the option of hiring workers from the JG workers (Wray 2012, 224). Just as the buffer stock program for wool stabilizes its market, job security will stabilize the macro-economy far more effectively than widespread unemployment. Granted, the newly employed workers will have greater purchasing power and this may lead to modest increases to short-run prices in certain industries. However, the private sector will rebound by increasing their supply of those goods and services and consequently slow price increases; once again, when businesses need more employees to meet the new demand, they can hire workers from the JG program. It is ironic how the loudest advocates of an unregulated private sector have so little faith in its capacity to respond to increased demand! This brings us to an MMT analysis of inflation, which, in brief, demonstrates that inflation will only occur where the physical resources necessary for production are limited; otherwise, there is no reason to expect unmanageable inflation17 . There is also an important distinction between mild price increases, which the program should create, and problematic inflation (Mosler 2012, 70). Price increases typically reflect a market that is effectively allocating resources; inflation and hyperinflation occur only when there is a shortage or restriction on the supply of certain goods (Mosler 2012, 70). Wray demonstrates that inflation and hyperinflation are almost always tied to social and political upheaval, a civil war, a collapse of productive capacity, or an otherwise weak government (Wray 2012, 257). He concludes: There is nothing in the current or prospective condition [with the JG program] of the United States {or the United Kingdom or Japan – all high deficit nations at the end of 2011} that would lead one to expect high inflation, let alone hyperinflation (Wray 2012, 248). 17 Resource limitations are ever-growing due to climate change; thankfully, much of JG program will be dedicated to promoting and enforcing more sustainable production processes. 17 This paper does not have the space to fully assuage those who will be horrified by the prospect of price increases; nonetheless, it has intended to at least demonstrate that the program will not trigger problematic inflation.
Solves economic instability and prevents future crises through preparedness.
Tcherneva 19 Pavlina R. Tcherneva is an associate professor at Bard College and a research associate at the Levy Economics Institute, Annandale-on-Hudson, NY. “The Federal Job Guarantee: Prevention, Not Just a Cure”, Taylor & Francis 62(4):253–272 (2019). DOI: 10.1080/05775132.2019.1635804
Epidemic treatments are often based on proactive solutions, early interventions, and direct approaches wherever possible. What the literature on the costs of unemployment and the social determinants of health suggests is that directly creating employment opportunities for the unemployed is in and of itself an important policy objective. One such direct approach to joblessness is the Job Guarantee, aka, employer of last resort, buffer stock employment, or public service employment (Wray Citation1998; Mitchell Citation1998; Harvey Citation1989; Tcherneva Citation2018). The advantage of this type of program is that it not only stresses job creation as an end in itself, but also explicitly aims to address other forms of social deprivation. This makes the Job Guarantee a unique multi-prong intervention tool that can tackle unemployment by addressing the material, psychosocial, and behavioral factors that produce the vicious dynamic that make joblessness such a challenging problem to solve. Existing work has emphasized the macroeconomic benefits of this proposal, including but not limited to its superior countercyclical stabilization mechanism, ability to formalize labor markets and establish an effective minimum wage, produce socially useful output, enhance human capital, and alleviate income and gender disparities (e.g., Tcherneva Citation2012). The aspect of the Job Guarantee that this paper stresses is that it is also a preventive program. It inoculates against the vile effects of unemployment by preventing the contagion effect from mass layoffs and the worsening of individual scarring effects, as well as by alleviating the outstanding community problems that are linked to unemployment, such as urban blight, crime, poverty, homelessness, and others. Preparedness When it comes to epidemics, preparedness and prevention are essential. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, for example, have a detailed readiness-response protocol in case of an outbreak. Government warehouses around the country contain stockpiles of vaccines (against N1H1, Ebola, etc.) that are shelved and can be disbursed in case of need. In a similar fashion, the Job Guarantee is a type of preparedness response. It is proposed as a permanent program that provides job opportunities for those who wish to work on an as-needed basis. By design, the Job Guarantee will maintain a reserve of types of jobs and places of work that can accommodate new entrants into the program and let them go without disruption should they find alternative employment. The ability to absorb or shed employees is not a unique challenge for the Job Guarantee. Indeed every labor market—in the private, nonprofit, or public sectors—deals with entrants and leavers on an ongoing basis. Furthermore the creation of jobs relatively quickly need not be a tall task. Experience has shown that large-scale employment programs can be up and running in a matter of months. Once such programs are in place, finding work for any additional entrants is a much easier task by comparison. Prevention The second, and perhaps more important, aspect of the intervention for the purposes of our discussion is prevention. Because the Job Guarantee complements private-sector employment by fluctuating countercyclically (expanding when private employment shrinks and shrinking when private employment expands), it ensures, by design, that mass unemployment does not develop and thereby restrains the contagion effect from an initial onset of private-sector layoffs. The first preventive feature of the Job Guarantee is that it does not allow unemployment to accelerate rapidly, as it does under the status quo. Typically, conventional policies turn their attention to unemployment with considerable delay. The existing automatic stabilizers—such as unemployment insurance (UI) or Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (TANF)—put a floor on collapsing aggregate demand but are not pro-employment growth policies by definition or design. Additional stimulus in the form of indirect measures (tax and interest rate cuts, subsidies, incentives) usually arrives too little and too late. And just as it is very difficult to contain an epidemic once it has spread, it is very difficult to reverse unemployment once we allow mass layoffs to persist and propagate. The Job Guarantee, by contrast, does not allow the contagion effect from mass layoffs to spread widely. First, it fundamentally changes aggregate spending patterns, as compared to those under existing welfare policies. Programs such as UI and TANF are small and temporary. Once they expire, the unemployed face greater economic insecurity. The instability in consumption that arises as a result is exacerbated by increasingly protracted jobless recoveries. When unemployment is a permanent feature of the economy, the uncertain prospects of reemployment fundamentally depress the spending patterns of households that include the unemployed and those with precarious work. By contrast the Job Guarantee is an employment safety net. As a “guarantee,” it promises that a job opportunity at an above-poverty wage will always be available should one need it, rain or shine, in good times or bad. The Job Guarantee also ensures that people never involuntarily slip into long-term unemployment. The existence of the Job Guarantee itself, and the ability to enroll in it without delay, makes spending patterns more stable than in its absence. A permanent Job Guarantee program brings additional benefits to individuals and households. One of the most often cited reasons for job dissatisfaction is job insecurity; individuals in temporary work report overwhelmingly greater anxiety and unhappiness with their jobs relative to workers with stable full-time employment (Green, Kler, and Leeves Citation2010; Booth, Francesconi, and Frank Citation2002). The fear of unemployment has been found to substantially decrease the mental health of employees (Reichert and Tauchmann Citation2011). There is evidence that subsidized employment via public works has a much higher happiness return than unemployment or idleness (Crost Citation2011). Furthermore, active labor market programs, such as direct job creation, are more effective than income support programs (such as UI) in helping individuals transition to paid employment (Graversen and Ours Citation2006). The second preventive feature of the Job Guarantee is that it not only stops the contagion effect from unemployment in its tracks, but it also thwarts the social and economic costs of unemployment. It is, in a sense, a method of inoculation. As discussed above, providing jobs to the jobless is a worthy policy goal as an end in itself, as it prevents the scarring effects from unemployment. However, interventions focusing on providing jobs and income alone, with little regard for the multiplicity of problems that the unemployed experience, will not be entirely successful. Here the Job Guarantee offers another important preventive feature. Because the program can help alleviate other social problems, it can be a useful labor market intervention and institutional tool for addressing several deprivations in concert. Various programs in the United States have found that giving the homeless a job has been extremely effective in tackling homelessness (e.g., Cox Citation2015).
2 internal links:
1 – Crises: Job guarantees are key to economic preparedness. Jobs guarantee prevents shock response to the economy.
Zumaeta and Darity 22 Jorge N. Zumaeta and William Darity, “Federal Job Guarantee as a Path for Ending Income Inequality and Promoting Business Sustainability”, Research Square (August 4, 2022), https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-1906593/v1
Improving Business and Economic Efficiencies The FJG has tremendous potential for influencing positively business and economic efficiencies by creating productive working environments that align with innovation, higher federal labor standards, and training opportunities. We start from the premise that an efficient labor market will transfer efficiencies and competitiveness to the firms and businesses. For example, it is said that economic efficiency takes place when all goods and factors of production in an economy are distributed or allocated to maximize value and minimize waste and negative externalities. This could be accomplished only with a well-prepared labor force that has the hard and soft skills needed to determine better resource allocations all through the production process and delivery of services. Business and economic efficiency pivots on making cost-effective production decisions within company and industry sectors, making sensitive decisions to capture segments of the market, and efficient distribution of goods and services. According to the World Economic Forum, efficient workers with the most suitable job skills will be the ones delivering a higher level of efficiencies and productivity in the firms. The FJG will offer labor market stability which will provide the base for efficient labor markets that will incentivize employees and employers to promote productivity. Our FJG proposal recommends balancing the creation of direct government jobs and indirect private sector jobs which would vary depending on the phase of the business cycle of the economy. A well-trained workforce will add flexibility to labor markets allow workers to shift from declining firms and enable companies and the economy as a whole to respond to external shocks. Unfortunately, the dynamic upswings and downswings of the economy do not provide enough market stability for businesses to invest in the long-term educational development of their workers. On the contrary, most businesses, particularly small businesses, have the tendency to focus on the short-term benefits and financial bottom line. Indirect private-sector employees could be FJG employees leased to private sector companies, similarly to the State University System of Florida are Florida State employees but are leased to the university system. There are a few examples at the county level as well. Industries Recession-Resistant Over the last six recessions, some industries are more prone to stronger declines in employment levels than others. This depends on several factors and the nature of the decline of economic activity. Figure 6 shows that Education and Health Services major industries division has experienced a positive percent change in employment. It is imperative to pay attention that these very same industries experiencing qualified labor shortages. The FJG program should invest in services that align with these industries as key industries to smooth out the business cycles. Multiplier Effect on Strategic Industries Visual analysis of the industry-by-industry multipliers[3] from the Total Requirement (Appendix VI) rapidly reveals strong effects from the Manufacturing; Finance, Insurance, Real Estate, Rental and Leasing; and the Professional and Business Services industries. All these industries amount to 66
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.