Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 UTNIF Counterplan

States CP - UTNIF 2023

States CP - UTNIF 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
States CP – UTNIF – Starter Packet
1NC
1NC – States CP
CP Text: The fifty states and all relevant territories should substantially increase fiscal redistribution by adopting a climate jobs guarantee and implementing a carbon tax.
States have the resources to establish jobs guarantee program now
Newman 21 (Nathan Newman; Criminal Justice and Sociology Professor at CUNY; “Reset Labor Markets With a Local Half-Time Job Guarantee”; The Nation; 9/21/21; https://www.thenation.com/article/economy/half-time-job-gaurantee/) [DTD]
Such local job guarantee programs would build on federal proposals in recent years by Bernie Sanders, Cory Booker, proponents of the Green New Deal, and policy centers like the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, the Center for American Progress, and the Levy Economics Institute of Bard College—all pushing federal programs to ensure that anyone wanting a job is guaranteed one by the government. While no federal job guarantee program looks likely to be approved in the current congressional session, the federal dollars flowing to states and local governments from the American Rescue Plan Act and Biden’s projected “Build Back Better” program create an opportunity for some states and local governments to pilot local versions that could be models for a future federal policy. Such federal funding will help offset the substantial initial costs of a job guarantee program—which in time, as multiple studies of job investment programs show, will substantially offset those initial costs. By raising the long-term income of participants, a job guarantee will stimulate the overall economy and increases local tax revenues. Higher job participation also tends to reduce other government spending, by improving school outcomes of participants’ children and reducing criminal justice costs. Beyond supporting participants themselves, a key goal of a job guarantee is to expand overall worker power in the economy to demand higher wages. Reducing the desperation of the unemployed will strengthen individual and collective bargaining in all local industries; the resulting higher wages and consumption in turn will stimulate local economies and tax revenue.
Carbon tax solves any funding shortfalls
Morris et al 16 (Adele Morris, former Joseph A. Pechman senior fellow in Economic Studies and policy director for Climate and Energy Economics at the Brookings Institution; Yoram Bauman; holds a Ph.D. in Economics from the University of Washington; David Bookbinder; former Chief Counsel at Niskanen Center; “What to consider when designing a state-level carbon tax”; Brookings Institution; 6/26/16; https://www.brookings.edu/research/state-level-carbon-taxes-options-and-opportunities-for-policymakers/) [DTD]
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Pricing carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases (GHGs) would address the market failure inherent in an economy that doesn’t price damaging emissions. Much has been written about the design of a federal-level carbon tax. This paper adapts these findings to the state level, motivated by pending federal regulations (which place implementation obligations on states), policy discussions in states with commitments to ambitious long-term emissions targets, and state budget shortfalls that could necessitate new revenue. Notwithstanding the myriad political impediments to a carbon tax, this paper explains how state policymakers can design one to fit their fiscal, economic, distributional, and environmental goals. A state-level carbon tax, particularly if set above prevailing emissions allowance prices in state cap-and-trade programs and applied economy-wide, could raise enough revenue in many states to play a substantial fiscal role; a $20 per ton tax on energy-related CO2 emissions could raise up to two or three percent of state GDP in the most emissions-intensive states. That is significant for a state tax; nationally, on average states collect only about five percent of GDP total from their own revenue instruments, including sales, property, income, and business taxes. A tax that rises at an annual rate above inflation should produce a reliable revenue source for decades even while it reduces emissions. States face many choices, including the sectors and sources of GHGs to cover, the point in the supply chain of fossil fuels at which to impose the tax, and other policy design elements. Importantly, the point of taxation is largely independent of who actually bears the economic burden of the tax because upstream producers or distributors will pass their costs along to those who buy their products. Thus states can choose a point of taxation that maximizes coverage, minimizes the number of taxpayers, and/or or coincides with existing state or federal tax or GHG reporting obligations. This paper reviews those and a host of other options regarding: • the tax treatment of carbon embodied in fuels, electricity, and goods that are imported or exported from the state; • tradeoffs arising across addressing the disproportionate burdens on low-income households and using the revenue in ways that promote economic growth; • how states can harmonize policies to avoid distortions in investment and trade; and • how a carbon tax can feature in state implementation plans for the Clean Power Plan and EPA rules under the Clean Air Act
Solvency
2NC – Solvency – Jobs Guarantee
State action creates the foundation for a national program
Reese 19 (Isaac Reese; “Explainer: Why the Green New Deal Doesn’t Need Congress”; United States Studies Centre; 6/20/19; https://www.ussc.edu.au/analysis/explainer-green-new-deal-congress-states) [DTD]
STATES GO IT ALONE US cities and states are adopting elements of the Green New Deal’s framework to address local needs. These local adaptations of the Green New Deal are becoming building blocks in accomplishing its establishment nationwide. For example, Maine’s version of the Green New Deal is the first to be backed by multiple major labour unions – an important ally in infrastructure reform. Meanwhile, the national Green New Deal has only recently gained the support of one labour union. The Illinois Green New Deal focuses on the environmental justice bill while at the national level there has been criticism for including it. Legislators in Washington encompassed utilities in the passage of its Green New Deal, which often are ignored in the climate change discussion regarding the transition of renewables. Grassroots activism has allowed these states to bring this legislation forward. None more apparent than in Minnesota. It’s Green New Deal, which has been youth-led, pulls from many aspects of the federal Green New Deal, but most significantly aims to transition Minnesota’s utilities to be 100 per cent carbon-free by 2030. Washington is the only state to pass its bill while the others are still in the process. It should be noted that Maine, Illinois and Washington’s legislative branches are Democrat-controlled, but Minnesota’s senate is Republican-controlled and its House of Representatives is Democrat-controlled. Some states have been building towards something akin to a Green New Deal long before the debate came to Capitol Hill. For example, California has been leading the nation on what sustainable, environmentally-minded reform looks like, and how possible it is to strive for, even without national direction. Although California’s climate and renewable energy policies are not labelled as a ‘Green New Deal’, they seek to accomplish many of the same core aims. SOWING THE SEEDS OF A GREEN NEW DEAL The Trump administration will likely never implement something akin to a Green New Deal. That doesn’t mean its death, however. The US federal system allows states to move in a different direction to the White House and this is a case where there is strong evidence that they could. As momentum builds and states continue to adopt and strengthen legislation with the Green New Deal in mind, the foundation for a national framework will be built incrementally. The Green New Deal is feasible and possible. Municipalities and states around the United States are already making it happen.
States have been empirically successful
Sierra Club no date (Sierra Club; “A Green New Deal Is Already Underway in States and Cities”; https://www.sierraclub.org/trade/green-new-deal-already-underway-states-and-cities) [DTD]
Momentum for a Green New Deal continues to grow. Over 100 members of Congress have endorsed the landmark Green New Deal resolution and polls show broad support for this bold plan to tackle the climate crisis and pollution, create millions of high-paying jobs, and counteract systemic injustices. The policy changes envisioned in the Green New Deal resolution are not hypothetical. In fact, many are already happening at the state and local level, where broad local coalitions of labor, environmental, and racial justice groups are winning pro-climate, pro-jobs, pro-equity policies that help lay the groundwork for a national Green New Deal. In addition to more than 100 cities nationwide that have already committed to 100 percent clean, renewable energy, here are just a few examples of state and city initiatives that offer models and momentum for a nationwide Green New Deal. NEW YORK CITY The New York City Council recently passed a job-creating bill that takes aim at the city's largest source of climate pollution: inefficient buildings. The new policy, cited as part of the city's own Green New Deal, will require about 50,000 large buildings to meet ambitious targets for reducing climate pollution. The building retrofits required by the policy are expected to create about 8,000 jobs each year. To protect low-income residents, the policy includes terms to prevent rent increases in rent-regulated buildings. MAINE Maine recently enacted a new "Act To Establish a Green New Deal for Maine." The law will create a task force of labor, youth, climate science, and other representatives to craft a strategy for achieving 80% renewable energy in Maine by 2040, creating good jobs in renewable energy and manufacturing, and ensuring low-income households have access to affordable solar power. The Maine AFL-CIO has praised the policy, saying that workers must "have a seat at the table in crafting bold climate protection policies." LOS ANGELES In April 2019, Los Angeles Mayor Garcetti released an update to the Sustainable City pLAn, calling it "L.A.'s Green New Deal." The plan lays out the most ambitious and achievable climate goals for the city to date. It would invest in L.A.'s local workforce and economy by creating good union jobs for thousands of technicians, electricians, engineers, and other clean energy workers. Critically, the plan tackles the ongoing poor air quality that Los Angeles and other Southern California communities continue to breathe as the worst region for smog pollution in the country. ILLINOIS The Future Energy Jobs Act gives low-income families priority access to solar panels, while providing solar-installation job training, particularly for formerly incarcerated people and communities fighting environmental injustice. The law also sets new energy-efficiency standards that are slated to further reduce air and climate pollution, create over 7,000 new jobs each year to retrofit buildings, and cut $4 billion in energy costs for Illinois families. CALIFORNIA In addition to committing to 100 percent clean energy by 2045, California’s Buy Clean policy helps stimulate clean manufacturing by requiring that tax dollars be spent on goods manufactured under conditions that protect our climate. The law will help ensure that when the state government buys steel for bridges or glass for offices, it sends tax dollars to manufacturers that are slashing their climate pollution and creating good jobs. NEW MEXICO New Mexico has enacted a historic law to transition to 100 percent carbon-free electricity by 2045. The bill sets interim milestones for clean energy adoption and invests heavily in NM communities, accounting for retiring an existing coal-fired generating plant while pursuing a just and equitable transition to a clean energy future for NM workers and families. PORTLAND In 2018, after a grassroots campaign led by communities of color, voters in Portland overwhelmingly approved a ballot referendum that will raise $30-70 million per year, via a fee on big retailer profits, for energy efficiency, renewable energy, job training, affordable housing, regenerative agriculture, and green infrastructure projects. A new task force of city stakeholders will be tasked with deciding annually the beneficiaries of the fund, with at least half of the revenue going toward investments in low income communities and communities of color. SEATTLE In August 2019, the Seattle city council unanimously passed a resolution calling for a city-level Green New Deal, which seeks to eliminate Seattle’s climate pollution by 2030, address historical and current injustices, and create thousands of good, green, well-paying, unionized jobs. The effort is being led by local environmental justice organizations and frontline communities of color, and includes a "Healthy Homes, Healthy Businesses" ordinance that would require new buildings in the city to run on clean electricity rather than gas appliances. PITTSBURGH Pittsburgh United's Clean Rivers Campaign has been pushing for job-creating green infrastructure projects that could drastically reduce flooding in some of the city’s vulnerable neighborhoods. They are one of many local coalitions across the country calling for, and often securing, public investments in green spaces to absorb rainwater, replacement of lead pipes, and other infrastructure upgrades to increase climate resilience and ensure clean water. DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA The Clean Energy DC Omnibus Act of 2018 requires DC to transition to 100 percent clean, renewable electricity sources by 2032. It also sets stronger, job-creating building performance standards to reduce energy use and make buildings more energy efficient and requires buses and large private vehicle fleets to transition away from dirty fuel and toward electric vehicles.
2NC – Solvency – Carbon Tax
Uniform state action is possible and solves leakage
Morris et al 16 (Adele Morris, former Joseph A. Pechman senior fellow in Economic Studies and policy director for Climate and Energy Economics at the Brookings Institution; Yoram Bauman; holds a Ph.D. in Economics from the University of Washington; David Bookbinder; former Chief Counsel at Niskanen Center; “What to consider when designing a state-level carbon tax”; Brookings Institution; 6/26/16; https://www.brookings.edu/research/state-level-carbon-taxes-options-and-opportunities-for-policymakers/) [DTD]
Harmonizing policies across jurisdictions Harmonizing carbon price policies across states (and perhaps federal or sub-federal jurisdictions in Canada, Mexico, and elsewhere) would simplify compliance for large firms, allow more upstream taxation, and help avoid driving investment and emitting activities to other jurisdictions, a phenomenon known as leakage. Formal linking, such as with a cap-and-trade system is one way to do this, but it is certainly not the only approach. Coordinating institutions can offer model tax legislation, analytical resources, and other tools that that could help states develop their policies and promote common policy design elements, such as points of taxation, carbon price trajectories, treatment of imported and exported fuels and electricity, and other approaches that would facilitate trade and reduce investment distortions. This work could also include states and provinces with cap-and-trade programs. For example, they could harmonize their floor prices on allowance auctions with tax levels in other jurisdictions. Precedents for this kind of cooperation include the IFTA fuel tax arrangement discussed earlier. In addition, the Multistate Tax Commission advises states on the adoption of uniform tax policies to simplify the tax code and ease the burden on interstate commerce. These discussions could extend to the context of carbon tax design. 49
State action leads to federal and international follow-on
Morris and Weber 15 (Adele Morris; former Joseph A. Pechman senior fellow in Economic Studies and policy director for Climate and Energy Economics at the Brookings Institution; Evan Weber; “To comply with the Clean Power Plan, states should tax carbon”; Brookings Institution; 9/2/15; https://www.brookings.edu/opinions/to-comply-with-the-clean-power-plan-states-should-tax-carbon/) [DTD]
Two years ago, with meaningful legislation to reduce climate-disrupting greenhouse gas pollution stalled, President Obama instructed the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to begin regulating emissions from our nation’s largest source: electric power plants. Under its Clean Air Act authority, the EPA recently released a final rule that sets state-specific emissions limits for 2030 and outlines ways states can achieve their targets. One of these options, as EPA has now clarified, is “a fee for CO2 emissions from affected [Electricity Generating Units]”—or more simply, a carbon tax. For many states, a carbon tax could be the most easily administrable and cost-effective compliance approach, and they should start taking the idea seriously. Since the release of the final rule, much attention has been given to how states can trade emissions allowances across borders to reach goals jointly, allowing more abatement where costs are lowest. The requirements for these complicated schemes occupy hundreds of pages of the rule, while EPA devotes only one sentence (in the preamble) to the potentially equally cost-minimizing carbon tax approach. The agency clearly prefers cap-and-trade over other options, as evidenced by the detail in the rule and EPA’s accompanying proposed federal plan for states who do not submit an acceptable (or any) implementation plan. However, another factor accounts for EPA’s apparent short shrift for a tax approach: the concept is remarkably simple to understand—one-sentence simple—and just as easy to administer. By gradually increasing the cost of emitting greenhouse gases from coal- and natural gas-fired power plants by charging a per-ton fee for the CO2 emissions the plants already monitor, states could both reduce electricity demand from fossil fuel sources and level the playing field for zero-emissions alternatives like wind and solar. States already know how to implement such a tax; every state already taxes fuels such as gasoline, diesel, and natural gas. A state would just need to show, by modeling (the kind EPA already does), that its proposed carbon tax trajectory will hit its Clean Power Plan target and be prepared to adjust it or take other actions if emissions are off course. This simplicity can provide real economic and environmental benefits. British Columbia, the first government in North America to implement a straight-up carbon tax, reduced its emissions 7.1 times faster than analysts expected, in part because the transparent and predictable price signal allowed business and consumers to invest efficiently and with foresight. A new paper from the Brookings Institution shows that a carbon tax has a slight efficiency edge over tradable performance standards. And, unlike trading schemes, a carbon tax won’t transfer ratepayer dollars from one state to utilities in other states. The benefits of a carbon tax, state or federal, will depend heavily on how the revenue is used. States could use the revenue any way they wish, including giving dividends to households or swapping out other taxes. Studies show that the most cost-effective policy would lower (or prevent increasing) other taxes that discourage working, investing, and saving. States could also use revenue to protect low-income households from energy cost increases, assist coal workers in the energy transition, fund climate adaptation, repair infrastructure, 

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.