Economy DA - UTNIF 2023
Economy DA - UTNIF 2023.docx
Indexed text preview
Economy DA – UTNIF – Starter Packet 1NC Shell- General- 1NC Economy is stable, but risks are still present Center on Budget Policy and Priorities, 5-1-2023, "Chart Book: Tracking the Recovery From the Pandemic Recession," Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, https://www.cbpp.org/research/economy/tracking-the-recovery-from-the-pandemic-recession The COVID-19 pandemic precipitated a devastatingly sharp contraction of economic activity and huge job losses in early 2020, as government restrictions and fear of the virus kept people at home and businesses shut. Workers in industries and occupations that paid low wages and required face-to-face encounters — disproportionately women, workers of color, workers without a bachelor’s degree, and foreign-born workers — were particularly affected, experiencing massive employment and earnings losses. Federal policymakers enacted substantial relief and recovery measures in 2020 and 2021 to support the economy and relieve hardship. These measures helped fuel an economic recovery beginning in May 2020 that made the deepest recession in the post-World War II era also the shortest. (According to the National Bureau of Economic Research, the acknowledged arbiter of business-cycle dating, the contraction in economic activity marking the pandemic recession lasted only two months: March and April 2020.) The expansion in economic activity in the recovery proved to be stronger and faster than initial projections. These projections may have been colored by what happened in the Great Recession of 2007-2009, which at the time was by far the worst recession since the Great Depression and the recovery from which was disappointingly slow, with high unemployment lasting years after the economy began to grow. But the causes of and policy responses to the two recessions were quite different. In particular: A global financial crisis in 2008 turned what started out as a mild recession into the Great Recession, while a global public health crisis precipitated the pandemic recession. The recovery from the Great Recession was impeded by the lingering effects of a burst housing bubble and banking crisis on households’ income and wealth and on bank lending, which depressed growth in consumer spending and business investment. By contrast, the course of the pandemic economy was influenced by ebbs and flows in virus caseloads and the extent of voluntary and official lockdowns and social distancing measures to address the virus; when the health situation improved, business and consumer activity began to pick up quickly. Policymakers’ fiscal response to the Great Recession, notably the Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP) and the 2009 Recovery Act, was large for its time and effective at arresting an even sharper downturn. But it was neither large enough nor sustained long enough to promote a rapid recovery with stronger job growth. The response to the pandemic recession, including the CARES Act and three other measures in March and April 2020, a December 2020 package, and the 2021 American Rescue Plan, was much larger. This suggests that policymakers had learned key lessons from the Great Recession experience. The Federal Reserve took similar monetary policy steps in both recessions, cutting its target interest rate for monetary policy effectively to zero and implementing large-scale asset purchases (quantitative easing). Without sufficient help from fiscal measures, however, expansionary monetary policy was unsuccessful at stimulating a rapid recovery or raising the inflation rate to the Fed’s policy target of 2 percent following the Great Recession. In contrast, these policies paired with strong fiscal measures supported a much faster recovery from the pandemic recession. In the recovery from the Great Recession, the Fed’s expansionary monetary policy was consistent with achieving both of the Fed’s dual-mandate goals of high employment and stable prices, which required lowering unemployment and raising the inflation rate. Initially this also was true in the recovery from the pandemic recession. But the emergence of inflation in 2021 created a more challenging environment for monetary policy, requiring efforts to bring down inflation while maintaining high employment. The Fed reversed its expansionary monetary policy in March 2022 and began raising its short-term interest rate target and reducing its holdings of long-term assets (quantitative tightening). The Fed has stressed that it will take the steps necessary to keep higher inflation expectations from becoming entrenched. The economy has largely healed, and the groups that experienced the largest losses in the recession have recouped a substantial share of their losses. This chart book tracks the pandemic economy, looking at both the macroeconomics (economic growth, employment, wages, and prices) and how different demographic groups have fared. Overall, the policy response was strong and effective in promoting a rapid economic recovery. From a macroeconomic standpoint, the economy has largely healed, and the groups that experienced the largest losses in the recession have recouped a substantial share of their losses. The overall number of jobs rose above pre-pandemic levels in August 2022, but was still below what it likely would have been with normal job growth and no pandemic. Even amid strong job growth, challenges remain to achieving a full and equitable recovery and ongoing economic expansion, especially with the emergence of high inflation in 2021 and rapidly tightening monetary policy in 2022. Federal Jobs Guarantee Program doesn’t address current issues with unemployment and will only make them worse Bhandari 19 Ryan Bhandari, 3-25-2019, "What is the “Federal Jobs Guarantee” and What are People Saying About It?”, No Publication, https://www.thirdway.org/memo/what-is-the-federal-jobs-guarantee-and-what-are-people-saying-about-it An idea that is sure to get attention during the 2020 primaries is “a guaranteed federal job,” a proposal The New York Times noted was “a big idea from a bygone era.”1 It’s easy to see why people are interested in ideas that help people earn a good life, but how would this specific policy work in practice and what kind of effect would it have overall on the economy? Some, like Stony Brook University Professor Stephanie Kelton, a former advisor to Senator Bernie Sanders and proponent of the federal jobs guarantee, argue that bringing millions more into guaranteed federal jobs would lead to more buying power and contend that “it’s clear the economy as a whole does far better, and that means that the private sector does far better.” Yet, that opinion is far from universal. Others, like Annie Lowery in The Atlantic, approach the idea with a healthy skepticism: “But guaranteeing every American a job means ... finding work for people in every town in half a continent. It means accommodating the homeless, the violent, the drug addicted, and the illiterate in the workforce. It means expanding the Department of Labor to become something like the size of the Department of Defense…. It is a trillion-dollar logistical puzzle, wrapped in a politically fraught stimulus effort, inside an experimental economic enigma. And none of these proposals quite know how to solve it.” In this memo, we unpack the policy and lay out five concerns that potential supporters should be aware of. What is the federal jobs guarantee? A federal jobs guarantee is as simple as it sounds on the surface: everyone in the country will be guaranteed a job by the US government should they desire one. There are two versions right now gaining attention. One plan is written by academics Mark Paul, Sandy Darity, and Darrick Hamilton. The other was written by Pavlina Tcherneva. In general, these plans promise: Guaranteed jobs in infrastructure repair, ecological restoration, caregiving, and community development projects. Benefits like health insurance, paid sick leave/vacation, and retirement plans. Control for state and local governments that will decide which kinds of jobs to create. A reduced uptake of welfare programs and unemployment insurance as well as decreased criminal justice costs. The key difference between the two plans is the minimum wage for the new jobs. The Tcherneva plan establishes a $15 minimum wage and the Paul et al. plan calls for an $11.80 minimum wage for all federally guaranteed jobs. Yet, both have the same underlying goal: Permanently solve the problem of involuntary unemployment by making the federal government the employer of last resort. What are the Concerns? Ensuring people have the opportunity to work and earn a good life is a shared value across the country. But, the federal jobs guarantee approach raises a number of concerns. And voters seem to be wary of it. In our polling, only 9% support a new program that guarantees a full-time government job—36 points less than those who support a new program where government works with business to create more good-paying jobs in the private sector. Among just Democrats, the divide was starker: 14% support a federal jobs guarantee while 59% want government to work with business to create private sector jobs. Politics aside, the federal jobs guarantee raises five substantive concerns. #1: It solves a different problem. Right now there are over seven million open jobs and six million unemployed people. Yet, many of these jobs are going unfilled. Why? Many people don’t have the right mix of skills or training. New jobs are often in different places than old ones. Childcare and transportation are often prohibitively expensive. And others struggle with opioid addiction and other conditions. And yet, a federal jobs guarantee doesn’t address any of this. Even during economic downturns, there are better and far more efficient ways to help workers and communities such as targeted public works programs, hiring credits for employers, temporary tax cuts for working families, extended unemployment insurance, and money to shore up state and local budgets. #2: The cost is enormous. A federal jobs guarantee will cost at least hundreds of billions of dollars per year and much more during a recession when the employment rolls for the government would naturally increase. Here are the cost estimates from both plans based on people participating in the jobs guarantee: 10 million people 15 million people Paul et al Plan $560 billion/year $840 billion/year Tcherneva Plan $468 billion/year $702 billion/year With annual federal outlays at roughly $4.5 trillion, we’re talking about anywhere from a 10-20% increase in spending to pay for the jobs guarantee. As for how to pay for it, advocates are split on whether it should be paid for at all. Paul et al. provide a few possible tax increases but don’t devote much attention to the matter. Stephanie Kelton says, “What the models show is you can do this without creating an inflation problem and therefore why would you pay for it with tax increases of one kind or another?”2Even though the cost of the program could be partially offset through decreasing social assistance costs, it’s still very uncertain how and when these savings would materialize. What we’re left with is a new program taking up funding that could be used instead for things like increased childcare, training support, expanded health care coverage, and more. #3: It could crowd out tens of millions of private sector jobs. There are currently 54 million people who earn $15 an hour or less. When they find out the federal government is offering $15 an hour plus benefits and permanent job security, many of those workers would quit their current job and join the federal workforce.3 Companies that could afford to would raise wages to keep some of these workers; other companies would simply go out of business. The labor markets would be controlled by the government in ways never seen before in America. And even if just half of low-wage private sector workers quit, the number of federal employees would rise by between 35 and 40 million.4 Costs to the government would then rise to anywhere from $1.6 trillion to $2.24 trillion per year, and the private sector would see massive repercussions. #4: Inflation would rise. A sudden increase in the cost of labor for businesses will lead to inflation throughout the economy because of higher business costs that will need to be passed on to consumers. In addition, when only those at the bottom of the income distribution get a defacto raise to $15, there are upstream consequences. Workers who were making $15 an hour may demand $20 an hour now. Workers making $20 an hour might want $25 an hour and so on. This may seem like a benefit, but “this is a story of serious wage-price spiral, unless we introduce other measures,” warns progressive economist Dean Baker.5 We have been very fortunate that inflation has been well under control for the last few decades. A federal jobs guarantee could change that pretty quickly. #5: It would be an administrative nightmare. Finally, matching millions of workers to the jobs envisioned under a jobs guarantee would be an administrative nightmare to implement. State and local governments will be tasked with finding the productive work to do, but how do we train millions of people to do these jobs? How does the Department of Labor oversee the millions of new jobs to make sure they’re legitimate? What are the qualifiers for the kind of work that’s eligible? What if a right-leaning state wants jobs done that a left-leaning federal government deems unproductive or socially unacceptable like building an oil pipeline or opening up a coal mine? Finally, how does the federal government fire workers who are guaranteed a job? Tcherneva argues that workers can be fired for not showing up or threatening the safety of others, but what about extremely poor performance? Conclusion The gravitational pull of a jobs guarantee is understandable. Uncertainty around job stability and the future of work has left many people very nervous. They don’t know when their next raise is going to be, and they don’t know if their job is going to exist ten years from now. Some on the political left believe the federal jobs guarantee provides comfort to voters by ensuring that anyone who wants a job will be provided one by the government. But behind this catchy slogan are a series of substantive issues that potential supporters should seriously consider. Further economic strains will trigger a deep recession instead of a slight business-cycle slowdown Zar 5-11 Jenna Zar, 05-11-2023 , "Consumer-led economic slowdown to hit the US," Economist Intelligence Unit, https://www.eiu.com/n/consumer-led-economic-slowdown-to-hit-the-us/ US economic data sent mixed signals throughout the first quarter of 2023. These mixed signals suggest that the US economy is at a turning point, coming out of a year of robust, but unsustainable, growth in 2022 and heading into a slowdown. Although downside risks persist, this will feel more like a business-cycle slowdown than a typical recession, followed by a modest recovery in 2024. Early signs of consumer strain are appearing For now, consumer spending remains the strong point of the US economy. However, this will slow more noticeably in the second quarter and contract slightly in the third as prices remain high and the full weight of monetary tightening over the last year comes to bear. The report highlights several economic indicators that are starting to weaken—including the savings rate, credit-card balances and loan delinquencies—suggesting that this consumer-led slowdown may be on the way. What does this mean for economic growth? Real private consumption surged by 3.7% quarter on quarter (annualised) in the first quarter of 2023. This helped to support real GDP growth of 1.1% in the first quarter, despite a steep decline in private inventories. However, even this story was mixed. Strong consumption growth in the first quarter was really a January story. A jump in real incomes at the start of 2023, together with still-low unemployment, helped to drive consumer spending. This had already started to taper off in February and March, and we do not expect this pace of growth to continue into the second quarter.” CAILIN BIRCH, GLOBAL ECONOMIST AND LEAD US ANALYST, EIU Manufacturing indices have been softening for several months, although the impact of this on overall GDP has thus far been offset by continued consumer demand. The two sectors will likely turn down in tandem in the coming months. The Fed has reached the end of its tightening cycle Previously expectations were for the Fed to raise interest rates a final time in June 2023. However, the failure of a third mid-size US bank in May and the looming debt-ceiling deadline in June mean that the Fed is likely to pause its tightening cycle for now. US economic decline ripples, creating global fragmentation- threatening the global economy with widespread famine, poverty, political instability, and inevitable conflict Schneyder 23 Alban Schneyder, 1-27-2023, "Fighting the recession to avoid fragmentation of the world," Le Cercle des économistes, https://lecercledeseconomistes.fr/en/fighting-the-recession-to-avoid-fragmentation-of-the-world/ As international institutions predict an economic slowdown in 2023, Gayle Smith warns of the risks of a recession in developed and developing countries. Fragmentation of the world, increase of extreme poverty and famine, decrease of development aid… Gayle Smith advocates a modernization of development banks and a bold solution to the emerging countries’ debt problem. A paper written for the Rencontres Économiques de Washington. If we fail to act to divert a global recession – or simply fail to help insulate the world’s low- and middle-income countries from the consequences of such a recession – we risk the creation of two separate economies serving different populations, rather than a single global economy for all of the world’s people. Young people faced with yet another global recession – the third in less than twenty years – will not draw the same conclusions about the world that their counterparts did in the aftermath of the Second World War, which ushered in a new era of stability and global cooperation. Instead, today’s youth will continue to lose faith in an international system that they have reasonably concluded does not represent their values, interests or futures. That is precisely why discussions about the future of the global economy cannot be limited to the wellbeing of high-income states, but must also include low- and middle-income countries and the young people who now represent almost 25% of the world’s population. A decline in poorer countries would threaten developed countries And there’s another reason to think holistically, and tackle managing the global economy by looking beyond just its top G20 economies. It is neither modern nor wise to regard these countries as irrelevant to the global economy other than as perpetual recipients of assistance – and any stated belief in equity would suggest as much. What is being overlooked is that these countries are potential net contributors to the global economy – if the world has the wisdom to make the investments needed. Unlike wealthier countries that have been able to turn to central banks, stimulus spending and supplemental budgets to dampen the effects of the global pandemic, previous recessions, and the fallout from the Russian invasion of Ukraine, poorer countries lack the access to the capital that can provide that kind of resilience. Even before the pandemic, finances in low-and middle-income nations were tight, and debt was high. And now, years later, skyrocketing food and energy prices – coupled with increased global interest rates – have stretched budgets even further. Sixty percent of low-income countries are now at risk of acute debt distress. Individually the collapse of these relatively small economi
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.