Puerto Rico SS - DDI 2023 TT
Puerto Rico SS - DDI 2023 TT.docx
Indexed text preview
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab 1AC 1AC – Social Security ADV Advantage one is Social Security. In U.S. v Vaello Madero the court ruled that the federal government can deny territorial residents Social Security benefits, using the “rational basis test,” a lower standard of review for denying equal protections. Millhiser 22 [Ian Millhiser is a senior correspondent at Vox, where he focuses on the Supreme Court, the Constitution, and the decline of liberal democracy in the United States. He received a JD from Duke University and is the author of two books on the Supreme Court.; “The Supreme Court rules that cruel laws must still be enforced”; Vox; April 21, 2022; https://www.vox.com/2022/4/21/23035592/supreme-court-puerto-rico-vaello-madero-ssi-rational-basis-brett-kavanaugh-sonia-sotomayor]//eleanor United States v. Vaello Madero, which the Supreme Court decided on Thursday, is a heartbreaking case. It asks whether many of the poorest and most vulnerable Americans can be cut off by their own government simply because they live in the wrong part of the United States. But Vaello Madero is also a case about democracy, and whether democratic governments can enact policies that are needlessly cruel. In an 8-1 decision joined by every justice but Justice Sonia Sotomayor, the Court effectively answered that question in the affirmative. The case involves Jose Luis Vaello Madero, an American citizen who is very poor. After Vaello Madero became seriously ill in 2011, he started receiving benefits under a federal program called Supplemental Security Income (SSI), which provides financial assistance to aged, blind, or disabled individuals who lack the means to support themselves. About a year after he started receiving benefits, Vaello Madero moved from New York to Puerto Rico so that he could be closer to his family, and the government continued to deposit his SSI benefits into his bank account for a few years after that. In 2016, however, Vaello Madero filed for additional Social Security benefits, and the federal government learned for the first time that he’d relocated to Puerto Rico. This seemingly innocent decision had terrible consequences for Vaello Madero because, by law, SSI benefits are only available to residents of the 50 states, the District of Columbia, or the Northern Mariana Islands. Puerto Ricans are eligible for a different program, known as Aid to the Aged, Blind, and Disabled (AABD), but the benefits under AABD are far smaller than the benefits available under SSI. As Sotomayor notes in dissent, far fewer people are eligible for AABD benefits than would receive SSI benefits if SSI were available in Puerto Rico. And “Puerto Rico residents enrolled in AABD in 2021 received an average of $82 per month, compared to the $574 per month that the average SSI recipient received in Fiscal Year 2020.” Worse, the government didn’t simply cut off Vaello Madero’s SSI benefits. In 2017, it sued him for over $28,000, claiming that he must pay back the SSI benefits he received while living in Puerto Rico. And yet, in Vaello Madero, every justice but one joined an opinion, by Justice Brett Kavanaugh, holding that Congress could discriminate against Puerto Rican residents when deciding who is eligible for federal benefits. Under existing law, Vaello Madero was correctly decided. It’s rooted in a longstanding legal rule, known as the “rational basis” test, which provides that courts should typically defer to the policy decisions made by elected branches, especially when those decisions involve economic policy. This rational basis test is one of the most hard-fought progressive victories of the Franklin Roosevelt administration, because it ensured that the Supreme Court would stop sabotaging New Deal programs. But, as Vaello Madero shows, this sort of judicial deference can be a double-edged sword. Rational basis, briefly explained The rational basis test was a liberal democratic response to early 20th century Supreme Court decisions that sabotaged progressive legislation, often relying on highly dubious legal reasoning to do so. In the first third of the 20th century, the Court struck down federal child labor laws, invalidated minimum wage laws, stripped workers of their right to unionize, and struck down laws prohibiting employers from overworking their employees — among many other things. After the Court started striking down New Deal programs, Roosevelt went to war with the Court’s conservative majority— at one point threatening to add additional seats to the Supreme Court in order to dilute the conservative justices’ votes. Eventually, conservative Justice Owen Roberts broke with his four most right-wing colleagues and started voting with more liberal justices to dismantle the doctrines the Court had used to strike down things like child labor laws. The culmination of this turn towards judicial restraint was United States v. Carolene Products (1938), which established that, with some important exceptions, legislation — and especially economic legislation — “is not to be pronounced unconstitutional unless in the light of the facts made known or generally assumed it is of such a character as to preclude the assumption that it rests upon some rational basis within the knowledge and experience of the legislators.” Basically, under this rational basis test, courts will uphold nearly all legislation so long as the government is able to articulate some rational reason why it should exist. Kavanaugh’s opinion in Vaello Madero holds that Congress’s decision not to provide SSI benefits to Puerto Rican residents clears the very low bar set by the rational basis test. As Kavanaugh notes, “residents of Puerto Rico are typically exempt from most federal income, gift, estate, and excise taxes,” but they do pay “Social Security, Medicare, and unemployment taxes.” Meanwhile, on the benefits side, residents of Puerto Rico are eligible for some federal benefits — including Medicare, Social Security, and unemployment benefits — but not others. Given that residents of Puerto Rico, as a whole, pay fewer taxes than residents of the mainland, Kavanaugh concludes that it is rational for those same residents to receive fewer benefits. As a policy matter, this argument isn’t especially convincing. As Sotomayor writes in dissent, SSI is not a program for the territory of Puerto Rico, it is a program for individual Americans. And, because SSI is a program for the poor, “SSI recipients pay few if any taxes at all,” regardless of where they live. If Vaello Madero moved back to New York, it is unlikely that he would pay any federal income taxes, but he would nonetheless be eligible for SSI. But the rational basis test does not care if a federal policy is actually a good idea — the whole point of this test is to get judges out of the business of second-guessing Congress’s policy choices. And so, if you accept that the New Deal Court was correct to stop sabotaging Roosevelt’s policies, it’s difficult to argue persuasively that the current Court may override Congress’s approach to Puerto Rico. The Constitution only forbids certain kinds of discrimination Vaello Madero’s strongest legal argument is that there are exceptions to the rational basis rule. As the Supreme Court held in City of Cleburne v. Cleburne Living Center (1985), one important exception is that the Constitution typically forbids discrimination against groups that have “experienced a `history of purposeful unequal treatment’ or been subjected to unique disabilities on the basis of stereo-typed characteristics not truly indicative of their abilities.” Denial of social security services to US territories creates poverty and low living standards – climate disasters magnify deprivation. Hammond 21 [Andrew Hammond, Assistant Professor of Law, University of Florida Fredric G. Levin College of Law; “Territorial Exceptionalism and the American Welfare State”; Michigan Law Review; 2021; https://heinonline.org/HOL/Page?handle=hein.journals/mlr119&div=59&g_sent=1&casa_token=&collection=journals]//eleanor Vaello-Madero's exclusion from public benefits epitomizes the extent to which federal law places millions of Americans outside the welfare state. Federal law excludes these American citizens from crucial public benefits simply because they live in the U.S. territories. For instance, Puerto Rico, the Northern Mariana Islands (CNMI), and American Samoa are excluded from SNAP (food stamps). Instead, these three territories receive block grants for food assistance, which do not respond to a surge in increased need.9 That's why, after Hurricane Maria decimated the island, Puerto Rico languished as it waited to receive additional temporary aid from Congress. 10 When it comes to healthcare, federal law reimburses territories for their Medicaid programs at significantly lower rates than it does for states." And as with food assistance, the federal government caps medical assistance for each of these territories, a limit that does not exist for the fifty states or the District of Columbia.12 As Vaello-Madero's case illustrates, no American living in Puerto Rico can receive SSI benefits, regardless of age or disability. These discrepancies surrounding public benefits mirror the exclusion of territorial Americans in other areas of federal law. An American who lives in, say, Florida who then moves to the British Virgin Islands can vote in presidential elections via an absentee ballot." But if that same person moves to the U.S. Virgin Islands, she cannot. 14 To draw attention to its residents' disenfranchisement, Guam held a presidential straw poll on Election Day. 15 American Samoans possess an even stranger status. While those born in the other four territories are recognized by the federal government as citizens by birth, the State Department stamps American Samoans' passports with the following disclaimer: "The bearer [of this passport] is a United States national and not a United States citizen." 16 Last year, a federal judge disagreed, ruling that a person born in American Samoa is a U.S. citizen within the meaning of the Fourteenth Amendment. The Tenth Circuit heard argument on the case last fall. 18 Any inquiry into the public law that governs the U.S. territories necessarily runs up against a persistent democratic deficit. While some may dismiss these irregularities as mere fodder for academic debate, they ensnare over three million Americans. Five times as many Americans live in the territories than in the District of Columbia. Roughly as many Americans live in the territories 19 as those in Alaska, Delaware, Hawaii, and Wyoming combined. 20 While the federal government excludes these Americans from the official poverty measurements for the country, what data we have on poverty levels paints a stark picture.21 The Census Bureau estimates that the poverty rate in Puerto Rico in 2018 was 43.5%, compared to 11.8% in the fifty states and the District of Columbia. 22 Adults living in the U.S. Virgin Islands are two and a half times more likely to lack health insurance than those in the fifty states.23 This level of poverty and deprivation will only worsen as the five U.S. territories are particularly vulnerable to the ravages of the climate crisis. Those who live there will face increasingly tenuous living conditions due to extreme weather events made more frequent and more intense by a warming planet.24 In 2018, American Samoa suffered through Cyclone Gita25 and the CNMI withstood Typhoon Yutu-the most powerful storm to hit the United States since 1935.26 Two Category 5 hurricanes struck the U.S. Virgin Islands within a two-week period in 2017.27 One of them, Hurricane Maria, also decimated Puerto Rico.28 Precisely when territories need additional resources to recover from the rolling disaster that is climate change, federal law fails them. This Article lays bare the ways in which federal law denies certain Americans protection from hunger, sickness, and disability because they live in the country's territories. The Article explores the ways in which federal law disadvantages Americans who live in the territories by impeding their access to basic disability, food, and medical assistance. 29 There is a rich scholarly conversation on the exceptional status of the U.S. territories, much of it critical.3 0 But this literature does not focus on social protection, and it does not cover the distinct domains of disability law, food assistance, and health care. Moreover, this Article adds to the literature by seizing on two recent developments: significant congressional activity over the last several years and litigation winding through the federal courts right now. The groundswell of demands for racial justice and the outcome of the 2020 election may create an opportunity for significant progress in this neglected corner of federal law. Lack of social safety nets exacerbate poverty in the territories. Racine and Camacho 21 [Karl A. Racine is the attorney general for Washington, D.C. Leevin T. Camacho is the attorney general for Guam; “Dear Supreme Court: 3.5 million Americans in territories deserve same federal benefits”; USA Today; November 9, 2021; https://oag.dc.gov/release/op-ed-dear-scotus-35-million-americans-territories]//eleanor What do American citizens living in Puerto Rico, Guam, the U.S. Virgin Islands, the Northern Mariana Islands and American Samoa all have in common? They lack equal access to federal social safety net programs, like Supplemental Security Income and food stamps that lift families and children out of poverty. By now, you’re thinking that there must be a good explanation for why 3.5 million American citizens – 98% of whom are ethnic minorities – are excluded from these benefits. Think again. The exclusion of the territories – and in some cases Washington, D.C., – from federal assistance is directly linked to racist and discredited theories about colonial governance that remain the law of the land. In the early 1900s, the Supreme Court ruled that new territories coming into the union would not be afforded the same constitutional protections as the states in a series of decisions known as the "Insular Cases." In the Supreme Court’s own words, the newly acquired island territories were not governed by “Anglo-Saxon principles” and their islands were inhabited by “alien races” and “savages.” One can brush aside those racist caricatures as historical relics, however, the underlying rationale has tangible impacts today. Americans who live in certain territories are ineligible for Social Security Supplemental Income (SSI), Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF), the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) and more. Congress’ haphazard exclusion of the territories from national aid programs is permitted by the Insular Cases, which remain the law of the land. Righting a wrong Thankfully, there is a chance to right this wrong. The issue of equal access to federal benefits is coming before the Supreme Court this week in a little-discussed case called United States v. Vaello-Madero. For attorneys general like us – who represent jurisdictions that are denied equal footing as states – the case offers a real opportunity to confront our past and move forward on civil rights and racial justice. For starters, the exclusion of the territories from these programs exacerbates poverty. To put territory poverty rates into perspective, the national poverty rate hovers around 11.4%. At the state level, the poverty rates of the neediest states – Louisiana and Mississippi – are around 19%, according to the U.S. Census Bureau Dashboard. However, nearly 23% of Guamanians live in poverty, according to the 2019 Guam Statistical Yearbook. And in Puerto Rico and American Samoa, the poverty rates are 43.5% and nearly 60%, respectively. Clearly, there is a real need for these programs, yet the Americans who need them the most are excluded. And to make matters worse, there is no discernible pattern to which territories can receive which benefit. For example, the Northern Mariana Islands is the only territory where residents can receive SSI, and it is also the only territory where they are excluded from TANF. The SNAP operates in Guam, but not Puerto Rico, American Samoa or the Northern Mariana Islands. It’s almost as if Congress drew names out of a hat to determine which territory received which program. Struggle for justice Not only is this bad public policy, it also perpetuates corrosive and racist ideas about citizens in the territories. Therefore, it is incumbent on all Americans to not just recognize this – but do something about it. Because justice for Americans in the territories is critical to the struggle for racial justice nationwide. That creates health and standard of living disparities. Previdi & Velez Vega, 20 [Irene Lafarga Previdi, community engagement coordinator at the center for collaborative research in health disparities, Carmen Velez Vega, PhD from the University of Puerto Rico, chair of the social sciences department at University of Puerto Rico, 11-18-20 ‘Health Disparities research Framework Adaption to Reflect Puerto Rico’s Socio-Cultural Context’, file:///C:/Users/lundi/Downloads/ijerph-17-08544.pdf //alundy] Another legal aspect that impacts the quality of life of Puerto Ricans is federal transfer payments. These are divided into two categories, earned benefits such as Medicaid, Social Security and veterans’ pensions and direct aid such as nutritional assistance and grants [36]. In 2019, most of the transfer payments to individuals were earned benefits and not welfare related [40]. However, federal transfers to individuals in Puerto Rico are arbitrarily capped at levels below those of the states in U.S. [36]. This does not take into account the population levels or the need for these kinds of services but instead is a form of selective discrimination based on the fact that the archipelago is an unincorporated territory and not a state. If Puerto Rico were treated as a state, federal transfer programs for health, i.e., Medicaid and nutrition, i.e., Women, Infants and Children (WIC) Nutrition Program would be substantially greater. However, the fact is that Puerto Rico receives fewer U.S. federal dollars to Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2020, 17, 8544 7 of 11 assist with social programs than states with comparable populations [10]. This has, as a consequence, meant that people living in Puerto Rico have limited access to social support measures that could help to improve living conditions and thus their overall health. Puerto Ricans are being treated as second-class citizens due to the unequal treatment of the U.S. government through federal regulations, which are implemented arbitrarily without any consultation or participation from Puerto Ricans. These federal regulations influence the living conditions of Puerto Ricans at individual, interpersonal, community and societal levels (see Table 1). This has an impact on health outcomes and the quality of life, for example, higher costs for basic needs including healthcare and food due to cabotage regulations. This also can be understood through the concept of embodiment, which refers to “how we, like any living organism, literally incorporate, biologically, the world in which we live, including our societal and ecological circumstances” [41] (p. 351). This construct takes into consideration the fact that humans are social beings as well as biological beings, which means that in order to understand health disparities we must understand the living conditions of individuals and communities. For example, factors such as food insecurity and food deserts, deficient infrastructure (i.e., electricity, potable water, public transportation, internet access), economic and social deprivation, toxic environmental exposures, lack of access to adequate healthcare and poor job conditions all leave a physical mark on the body of individuals, communi
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.