Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 DDI Negative

Puerto Rico Neg - DDI 2023 LS

Puerto Rico Neg - DDI 2023 LS.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
T – In the US
1NC
Interpretation: The aff must defend fiscal redistribution IN the United States
Merriam Webster ND – (Merriam-Webster, Incorporated is an American company that publishes reference books and is especially known for its dictionaries. It is the oldest dictionary publisher in the United States); https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/in //sp
in—used as a function word to indicate inclusion, location, or position within limits
Lin v. United States proves courts still consider the United States as not including territories
Kollar-Kotelly 16 – (Colleen Kollar-Kotelly is a United States District Judge for the District of Columbia); Lin v. United States, 177 F. Supp. 3d 242, 258-59 (D.D.C. 2016); https://casetext.com/case/lin-v-us-republic-of-china //sp
The FSIA's term “United States” is narrowly construed to mean only “the continental United States and those islands that are part of the United States and its possessions,” Amerada Hess , 488 U.S. at 440, 109 S.Ct. 683, and does not include territories over which the United States might exercise some form of jurisdiction. See id. at 440–41, 109 S.Ct. 683 ; Persinger v. Islamic Rep. of Iran , 729 F.2d 835, 839 (D.C.Cir.1984). For example, the “high seas” fall outside the FSIA's definition of the “United States” even though the high seas might otherwise be within the United States' admiralty jurisdiction. Amerada Hess , 488 U.S. at 440–41, 109 S.Ct. 683. Similarly, a U.S. embassy in a foreign country does not constitute the “United States” for purposes of the FSIA because, even though the United States exercises certain forms of jurisdiction over its embassies, embassies are not within the continental United States and are not islands or possessions of the United States. Persinger , 729 F.2d at 839–842. See also Perez v. The Bahamas , 652 F.2d 186, 189 n.1 (D.C.Cir.1981) (expressing doubt that a territory falling within the “Fishery Conservation Zone suffices as territory of the United States within the meaning of the FSIA” because it was clear that Congress intended the Fishery Conservation Management Act to extend U.S. jurisdiction only for limited maritime purposes). Here, Plaintiffs argue that the tortious activity at issue occurred “within the United States” because when the nationality decrees were issued in 1946, Taiwan was “subject to complete American military occupation” and therefore should be considered “within the United States” for purposes of the FSIA's non-commercial tort exception. See Pls.' Opp'n to ROC's Mot. at 18. Plaintiffs' argument is unavailing and contrary to the established case law described above. The Supreme Court and the D.C. Circuit have definitely held that the FSIA's term, “United States,” is narrowly construed to mean only “the continental United States and those islands that are part of the United States and its possessions,” Amerada Hess , 488 U.S. at 440, 109 S.Ct. 683, and does not include territories over which the United States might exercise some form of jurisdiction. See id. at 440–41, 109 S.Ct. 683 ; Persinger , 729 F.2d at 839
2NC – “in”
In means within an area
Oxford Dictionary ND – (The Oxford English Dictionary is the principal historical dictionary of the English language, published by Oxford University Press); https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/us/definition/english/in_1#:~:text=at%20a%20point%20within%20an,about%20it%20in%20the%20paper //sp
in - at a point within an area or a space
a country in Africa
The kids were playing in the street.
It's in that drawer.
I read about it in the paper.
In indicates limits
Dictionary ND – (Dictionary.com is an online dictionary whose domain was first registered on May 14, 1995); https://www.dictionary.com/browse/in //sp
in - (used to indicate inclusion within space, a place, or limits):
walking in the park.
2NC – Puerto Rico is not US
Courts agree that the phrase “in the United States” exclude Puerto Rico
United States Court of Appeals, First Circuit 01, "FindLaw's United States First Circuit case and opinions.," https://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-1st-circuit/1421147.html //sp
Nieves's interpretation conflicts with the plain meaning of the statute. Section 13501(1)(C) only gives the Secretary jurisdiction “to the extent the transportation is in the United States ” (emphasis added). The definition of the “United States,” for purposes of § 13501(1)(C), excludes Puerto Rico. 49 U.S.C. § 13102(20). A plain reading of the statute, therefore, would place intra-island transportation beyond the scope of the Secretary's jurisdiction because such transportation is not “in the United States” for purposes of the statute. Transportation undertaken by Nieves would thus fall outside the Secretary's jurisdiction. To the extent that some portion of a motor carrier's activities fall within the Secretary's jurisdiction, the exemption applies broadly to covered employees. Morris v. McComb, 332 U.S. 422, 434-36, 68 S.Ct. 131, 92 L.Ed. 44 (1947). However, if all of the transportation undertaken by Nieves falls outside of the Secretary's jurisdiction, the company is ineligible for the motor carrier exemption. In short, under the plain meaning of the statutory language, Nieves is subject to the FLSA.
“United States” means the 50 states and D.C.
Words & Phrases 3 – WORDS & PHRASES, Vol. 43, 2003, p. 469
FIa.App. 3 Dist. 19,76. Term "United States," as used in statute providing for exclusion of income and losses derived from sources outside of United States, means only the 50 states and the District of Columbia. West's F.S.A. § 220.13(1)(b)2b. Heft- ler Const. Co. and Subsidiaries v. Department of Revenue, 334 So.2d 129, certiorari denied 341 So.2d 1082.-Tax 1001.1, 1074.1.
“United States” does not include territories
Words & Phrases 3 – WORDS & PHRASES, Vol. 43, 2003, p. 468-469
C.A.9 (Hawai'i) 1994. As used in the constitution, term "United States" does not include all territories subject to jurisdiction of the United States government.-Rabang v. LN.S., 35 F.3d
Supreme Court rules that Puerto Rico is NOT a part of the United States
US Supreme Court 01 – (Downes v. Bidwell, 182 U.S. 244 (1901)); https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/182/244/ //sp
The circuit courts have jurisdiction, regardless of amount, of actions against a collector of customs for duties exacted and paid under protest upon merchandise alleged not to have been imported.
The Island of Porto Rico is not a part of the United States within that provision of the Constitution which declares that "all duties, imposts, and excises shall be uniform throughout the United States."
“United States” means the 50 states and DC
Collins Dictionary ND – (The Collins English Dictionary is a printed and online dictionary of English. It is published by HarperCollins in Glasgow); https://www.collinsdictionary.com/us/dictionary/english/united-states //sp
The United States of America is the official name for the country in North America that consists of fifty states and the District of Columbia. It is bordered by Canada in the north and Mexico in the south. The form United States is also used.
Territory
“United States territory” means ALL of them
Cornell Law ND – “Definition: territory of the United States from 16 USC § 6602(9)," Cornell Law, https://www.law.cornell.edu/definitions/uscode.php?width=840&height=800&iframe=true&def_id=16-USC-692518803-905695884&term_occur=999&term_src= //sp
territory of the United States
(9) Territory of the United States The term “territory of the United States” means— (A) American Samoa; (B) the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands; (C) the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico; (D) Guam; (E) the United States Virgin Islands; and (F) any other territory or possession of the United States.
“United States territory” is ANY area that the US exercises sovereignty
Law Insider ND – "Territory of the United States Definition," Law Insider, https://www.lawinsider.com/dictionary/territory-of-the-united-states //sp
Territory of the United States means any geographic area over which the United States exercises sovereignty.
Territory of the United States means the United States, Puerto Rico, the United States Virgin Islands, and any territory, insular possession, or other location subject to the jurisdiction of the United States.
“territory,” in the context of the United States, refers to the following areas:
Roger Williams School of Law 20 – "What is a US Territory?," Roger Williams School of Law, https://law.rwu.edu/library/blog/what-us-territory //sp
A territory (notice the little t) is an insular area which is unincorporated area. “There are currently thirteen, three in the Caribbean (Navassa Island, Puerto Rico and the United States Virgin Islands) and ten in the Pacific (American Samoa, Baker Island, Guam, Howland Island, Jarvis Island, Johnston Atoll, Kingman Reef, Midway Atoll, the Northern Mariana Islands and Wake Atoll).”
AT – Capital T
“Territory” does not mean what they think
Roger Williams School of Law 20 – "What is a US Territory?," Roger Williams School of Law, https://law.rwu.edu/library/blog/what-us-territory //sp
A Territory (big T) is an insular area which is incorporated. At this time “only one exists currently, Palmyra Atoll. With an area of 1.56 square miles, Palmyra consists of about fifty small islands and lies approximately one thousand miles south of Honolulu.”
Court Politics DA
1NC
Roberts won’t do away with Chevron now because he wants to maintain court legitimacy.
King 5/24 -- [Pamela King is a judge of the Third Judicial District in Minnesota, serving Olmsted County. She was appointed by Democratic Governor Mark Dayton on August 26, 2015, to succeed Robert Birnbaum when he retired. She won election to her seat in the general election on November 8, 2016., "Chevron doctrine: Not dead yet," E&E News by POLITICO, 5-24-2023, https://www.eenews.net/articles/chevron-doctrine-not-dead-yet/, accessed 7-24-2023] // David
The Supreme Court was asked to overrule Chevron deference just last year in a dispute over a Department of Health and Human Services rule governing Medicare drug reimbursements. Instead, the justices unanimously scrapped the regulation without ever mentioning Chevron deference. During arguments on the Medicare rule, three of the court’s conservative justices — Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch — signaled that they were prepared to overturn Chevron. But legal observers say the court’s more moderate conservatives — Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett — may be reluctant to completely do away with long-standing precedent. Roberts in particular has demonstrated interest in avoiding big swings in prior cases, said Peter Hsiao, a partner at the law firm King & Spalding. “Behind the scenes, you’ve got a chief justice that doesn’t want this court to be seen as a political court,” Hsiao said, “and his job and his mission is to maintain the court’s integrity.”
Siding with Vaello Madero follows liberal precedent.
Natelson 22 -- [Rob Natelson is the Independence Institute’s Senior Fellow in Constitutional Jurisprudence and heads the Institute’s Article V Information Center. He was a law professor for 25 years, serving at three different universities. Among other subjects, he taught Constitutional Law, Constitutional History, Advanced Constitutional Law, and First Amendment. He is also the Senior Fellow in Constitutional Jurisprudence at the Montana Policy Institute. Rob is especially known for his studies of the Constitution’s original meaning. His research has carried him to libraries throughout the United States and in Britain, including four months at Oxford. The results have included several break-though discoveries. , "The Fascinating Supreme Court Opinions in the Vaello Madero Case," Independence Institute, 5/10/2022, https://i2i.org/the-fascinating-supreme-court-opinions-in-the-vaello-madero-case/, accessed 7-24-2023] // David
Jose Luis Vaello Madero was a resident of Puerto Rico who received SSI payments in violation of federal law. When the feds sued him for restitution, he argued that denying SSI to residents of Puerto Rico violated the “equal protection component of the Fifth Amendment Due Process Clause.” In keeping with the court’s deference to most liberal precedent, Justice Kavanaugh’s opinion didn’t question the assumption that the Fifth Amendment Due Process Clause has an “equal protection component.” Nevertheless, all nine justices agreed that Congress still has discretion in making such decisions. They applied a test whereby a law discriminating among people is constitutional if the discrimination has a “rational basis.” Kavanaugh said Congress did, indeed, have a rational basis for denying SSI benefits to Puerto Ricans. He pointed out, for example, that Puerto Ricans are exempt from many federal taxes. In dissent, Justice Sotomayor argued that there was no rational basis. She noted that people on SSI are so poor they generally don’t pay federal taxes, whether they live in Puerto Rico or anywhere else in the United States. The main “takeaway” from Kavanaugh’s majority opinion is that Congress has great leeway in treating people differently based on financial considerations. This result is in keeping with the court’s 20th century liberal precedents.
Robert’s uses liberal rulings to justify future conservative action meaning Chevron deference gets overturned.
Hasen 6/08 -- [Richard L. Hasen is an American legal scholar and law professor at the University of California, Los Angeles. He is an expert in legislation, election law and campaign finance., "Opinion," The New York Times, 6-8-2023, https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/08/opinion/milligan-roberts-court-voting-right-act.html, accessed 7-24-2023] // David
The Supreme Court’s voting rights ruling on Thursday in Allen v. Milligan is as shocking as it is welcome. The Voting Rights Act has lived to see another day, with implications for 2024 and beyond. The court ruled that Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act requires Alabama to draw a second majority-Black congressional district in which its voters can elect the candidate of their choice. In an opinion written by Chief Justice John Roberts and joined by Justices Ketanji Brown Jackson, Elena Kagan, Brett Kavanaugh and Sonia Sotomayor, the court also reaffirmed Section 2’s constitutionality and beat back Alabama’s arguments that the race-conscious statute should be read in a race-neutral way. Milligan is not a ruling that expands minority voting rights. But had the dissenting justices — Samuel Alito, Amy Coney Barrett, Neil Gorsuch and Clarence Thomas — gotten their way, it would have decimated effective minority representation as Congress, statehouses, county and school boards and city councils became much whiter and less broadly representative. The big mystery is why Chief Justice Roberts would write an opinion confirming that race-based remedies in politics are sometimes appropriate, given his role in 1982 as President Ronald Reagan’s point man opposing the expansion of Section 2, his 2013 opinion in Shelby County v. Holder striking down as unconstitutional another key part of the act and numerous recent decisions reading the act narrowly. It’s possible that he had a change of heart, but it’s more likely that his institutionalist side kicked in. He may have sided with Black Alabamians because he has genuinely changed his skeptical views about race-conscious remedies since he wrote the opinion for Shelby County, a case he did not even cite in his opinion in Milligan. He could have seen Milligan as simply applying well-settled precedents. But as recently as last year, when Alabama sought a stay before the 2022 elections of the lower-court ruling the court just affirmed, Chief Justice Roberts suggested rethinking or tinkering with those precedents even as he opposed the stay. (Justice Kavanaugh joined the other conservatives in imposing the stay, but he said he did so because the lower-court ruling came too close to the election, not on the merits of Alabama’s arguments on appeal.) But perhaps a more plausible answer for the chief justice’s blinking is that he could foresee the additional social upheaval and opprobrium that would have been generated against the Supreme Court had it ended significant minority representation in Congress and statehouses. Showing the court as an institution sometimes willing to side with minority plaintiffs could prove very important, especially if, as expected, Chief Justice Roberts and Justice Kavanaugh soon join the other conservative justices in rejecting race-based affirmative action in college admissions. Why were so many court watchers, including me, expecting a different decision in this case? Since Congress passed the Voting Rights Act in 1965 and amended it in 1982, the Supreme Court has repeatedly weighed in on its scope and meaning. Section 5 required states and localities with a history of racial discrimination in voting to get federal approval before changing their voting rules, with the burden of demonstrating that those changes would not make minority voters worse off. The court repeatedly upheld the constitutionality of Section 5. By 2013, however, the court held that Congress no longer had the power to require federal preapproval of voting changes. In Shelby County, Chief Justice Roberts declared that “history did not end in 1965” and that considerable improvement in the South made continued federal oversight unconstitutional. Section 5 prevented states from making minority voters’ situations worse, but it did little to improve minority representation in Congress and in other legislative bodies in which white voters consistently defeated candidates preferred by minority voters. The Supreme Court initially read the 15th Amendment as providing some requirement for minority voters to get a fair chance at representation, but the court shut that down in a 1980 case, City of Mobile v. Bolden. In response, in 1982 Congress rewrote Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act to give minority voters that chance. This was the state of affairs when Mr. Roberts was working for the Reagan administration to prevent an expansive rewriting of Section 2. Eventually, Congress settled on a compromise brokered by Senator Bob Dole, a Republican. The amended Section 2 would protect the ability of minority voters to elect representatives of their choice, provided that it did not guarantee proportional representation. After the Dole compromise, the Supreme Court created a complex legal test in Thornburg v. Gingles that allowed minority voters to win some but far from all cases challenging district lines. Since Gingles, the court has weighed in many times on Section 2’s meaning and scope, and in recent years conservatives have read the scope of the act less expansively. For example, it rejected a challenge to Texas’ redistricting in 2018, insisting that courts give states the benefit of the doubt when they draw district lines. And in 2021 in Brnovich v. Democratic National Committee, the court made it very hard for minority voters to use Section 2 to challenge restrictive voting rules, like voter ID laws. Milligan put the brakes on the judicial assault on Section 2 without expanding voting rights. It reaffirmed the weakened Gingles test. Given earlier rulings and the court’s emphasis in Milligan on the Dole compromise, the ruling will not lead to a flood of new districts where minority voters can elect candidates of their choice. But the court did reaffirm the constitutionality of Section 2. In recent years, Voting Rights Act opponents have put forward radical arguments to kill Section 2, recognizing that the new conservative supermajority on the Supreme Court could be receptive. In Milligan, however, the court shut many of these arguments down. In an odd echo of the uncited Shelby County case, Chief Justice Roberts declared in his ruling that “history did not stop in 1960.” His reference to the fact that discrimi

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.