Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 DDI Disadvantage

Horsetrading DA Answers - DDI 2023

Horsetrading DA Answers - DDI 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Aff
Uniqueness
Cuts Now---General---2AC
The DA’s inevitable---Republicans will slash the welfare state
Sharon Zhang, 7-13-2023. News writer at Truthout covering politics, climate and labor, has written for Pacific Standard, The New Republic, and more, has a master’s degree in environmental studies. "Republicans Seek to Give Themselves $8k Raise in Bill Slashing Spending For Nearly Everything Else," https://truthout.org/articles/republicans-are-looking-to-give-themselves-8000-raises-while-slashing-welfare/.
House Republicans have made it a top priority this year to secure cuts to nearly every federal government program, spending months taking aim at welfare programs in order to allow millions of Americans to starve and languish. But in the latest draft of their 2024 spending bill that is moving through the chamber, Republicans are seeking to raise spending for one key group: themselves.
Under the legislative branch spending bill approved by the House Appropriations Committee last month, House members would receive a 4.6 percent pay raise, according to the Congressional Research Service, reports Roll Call. This would be an $8,000 raise over their current salaries of $174,000.
If Republicans get their way, the raise would come in a bill that otherwise cuts spending across the board except for defense, veterans’ care and border militarization — drastically decreasing funding for public programs and the social safety net.
This would include cuts to crucial anti-poverty programs like Social Security, Medicare, and free school lunches. It would also, according to a new draft of the labor, health and education funding bill released Thursday, eliminate federal funding for public health research on issues like firearm safety and ending HIV while slashing Education Department funding by 28 percent.
In other words, Republicans are seeking to quite literally enrich themselves while taking every move possible to cut benefits for the public, who they are supposed to serve.
---Cuts Now---General---1AR
McCarthy will force huge welfare cuts
Mark Mellman 7-19-23. President of The Mellman Group and has helped elect 30 U.S. senators, 12 governors and dozens of House members. Mellman served as pollster to Senate Democratic leaders for over 20 years, as president of the American Association of Political Consultants, a member of the Association’s Hall of Fame, and is president of Democratic Majority for Israel, 7-19-2023. "Mellman: Spending cuts and election losses," https://thehill.com/opinion/columnists/4104460-mellman-spending-cuts-and-election-losses/.
Seemingly oblivious to decades of poll data and campaign experience, House Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) is allowing the far-right Freedom Caucus to lead his Republican Conference like lemmings over the cliff into political oblivion.
It’s one of the oldest, strongest and most consistent poll findings on record.
Americans are happy to cut government spending in general, but adamantly oppose cuts in most all specific areas.
A few months ago, the Associated Press (AP) and the National Opinion Research Center (NORC) examined spending issues and found 60 percent of Americans saying the U.S. government was spending “too much.”
Presumably, that majority wants to pare federal outlays.
But which spending?
Just 29 percent say we are spending too much on the military. Little support for reductions there.
Social Security and Medicare? Just 7 percent and 10 percent, respectively, believe too much is being spent on those programs.
“OK,” you say, “we’re hitting third rails.” True perhaps, but those three third rails, plus interest on the debt, account for over half of federal expenditures.
“What about some of President Biden’s favorites,” Republicans might argue. “Should be easy pickings there.”
But only 11 percent want reductions in infrastructure spending. Just 25 percent see too much spending on the environment and 20 percent on scientific research. Even fewer, 16 percent, say the same about assistance with child care.
“Surely,” GOPers say, “we can demagogue welfare.” But only 18 percent would curtail “aid to the poor” in the AP/NORC survey. In YouGov polling earlier this year, just 15 percent favored cutting Medicaid, 17 percent would cut SNAP, only 16 percent supported cuts to Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children (WIC), and the same small number favored cutting Temporary Assistance for Needy Families.
So, no, voters don’t want to scale down those safety net programs.
Only 12 percent would countenance cuts to education spending and, GOP efforts to demonize law enforcement notwithstanding, just 23 percent favor reductions there.
My apologies for the long recitation of numbers, but I hope the point is clear. While voters want to cut government spending generally, large majorities oppose cuts in almost every specific category.
Yet, catering to the demands of the Freedom Caucus, McCarthy will force every House Republican to vote for massive spending cuts in each and every one of these programs, alienating the vast majority of Americans.
Republican appropriators already proposed cutting education by over $22 billion, which would mean firing 220,000 teachers across the country, increasing class sizes. In addition, they’re cutting over a billion dollars from STEM education.
To say voters will be angry about such reductions puts it mildly.
Unlike Democrats, Republicans are actually defunding the police, eliminating $1 billion from the FBI, which means fewer agents and federal prosecutors, which means fewer criminals brought to justice.
The GOP is backing a nearly 40 percent, $4 billion cut to the Environmental Protection Agency, which translates into fewer resources to clean up the Great Lakes, the Chesapeake Bay and Long Island Sound, as well as less assistance for clean drinking water across the country.
Republicans are cutting cancer research, mental health support and preschool.
GOP House members will end up voting for these or similar cuts because McCarthy first surrendered to the Freedom Caucus on the debt limit negotiations and then gave them license to cut even more, after the deal was complete.
But Republicans are unlikely to stop with votes to slash crowd-pleasing spending. At the insistence of the far right, the GOP will likely shut down the government to force these unpopular cuts.
That’s what happened in 1996, and Democrats won races as a result.
That year we campaigned against the GOP shutdown and for preventing Republican cuts to Medicare, education and the environment. The result: 18 Republicans lost their seats to Democratic challengers, while only three Democrats were defeated.
Far fewer would flip the House in 2024.
Circumstances and context have changed, but Republicans seem intent on following the far right down the same path toward defeat in response to their effort to slash popular spending.
Cuts coming now---Congress will tighten eligibility and reduce spending
Melissa Kearney 23. Neil Moskowitz Professor of Economics at University of Maryland, and Luke Pardue, 5-24-2023. "Is Cutting the Safety Net an Effective Way to Reduce Government Spending?," https://econofact.org/is-cutting-the-safety-net-an-effective-way-to-reduce-government-spending.
High-stakes negotiations over the debt limit center on ways to bring government spending more in line with government revenues. The political contours of the debate have excluded cuts to Social Security and Medicare from consideration, as well as the possibility of raising taxes. With these options off the table, much of what is left to consider for budget cuts is a series of programs that provide services and support to low-income individuals and families. Some congressional policy makers are suggesting that federal spending cuts should come from tightened eligibility and reduced spending on programs whose primary function is to provide health insurance, food purchasing support, and conditional cash assistance to low-income individuals and families with children. How significantly would cuts to spending on the three programs at the center of the discussion — Medicaid, the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), and the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) — contribute to an overall reduction in federal government spending? And would the fiscal savings come at a long-term economic cost? Evidence shows that the type of income assistance provided by these programs to children from low-income families yields long-term economic benefits by improving their health, educational attainment, and economic self-sufficiency into adulthood.
Cuts Now---Social Security---2AC
Social Security cuts coming now
Keith Speights, 7-15-2023. Began writing for the Fool in 2012 and focuses primarily on healthcare investing topics, background includes serving in management and consulting for the healthcare technology, health insurance, medical device, and pharmacy benefits management industries. "Why Potential Social Security Benefit Cuts Could Be Bigger Than Projected," https://www.fool.com/retirement/2023/07/15/why-potential-social-security-benefit-cuts-could-b/.
The forecast for Social Security has gone from bad to worse.
Social Security is on a collision course with insolvency. That's one thing that everyone on Capitol Hill agrees upon.
But there are lots of areas of disagreement when it comes to Social Security. How to fix the program tops the list. Even the level of the benefit reductions that could be on the way doesn't have a consensus. Here's why those potential Social Security benefit cuts could be bigger than projected.
From bad to worse
Earlier this year, Social Security's trustees released their annual report detailing the status of the program's two trust funds -- the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance (OASI) trust fund and the Disability Insurance (DI) trust fund. Unsurprisingly, that status didn't look great.
In their latest report, the trustees stated that the combined trust funds will be depleted by 2034. After that point, they project that ongoing sources of revenue for Social Security will be able to fund only 80% of scheduled benefits.
The prospect of a 20% reduction in Social Security benefits in a little over a decade from now is unquestionably bad news. However, the situation could be even worse.
Social Security's trustees aren't the only ones who monitor the health of the program. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) also regularly makes projections about the long-term future of Social Security.
Last month, CBO projected that the combined Social Security trust funds will run out of money in 2033, one year earlier than the trustees' estimate. The nonpartisan agency also thinks that benefits will have to be slashed by 25% instead of 20% beginning in 2034. Starting in 2097, Social Security benefits would have to be 30% lower than scheduled benefits.
Behind the bleaker outlook
Are the CBO analysts simply the kind of people who view a glass of water not just as half-empty but also cracked and laced with arsenic? Not necessarily. However, they definitely have made more negative underlying assumptions about the future in their projections.
It's not that CBO anticipates less revenue than the Social Security trustees do. Both project that revenue for Social Security will remain between 13% and 14% of taxable payroll throughout the next 75 years. The reason behind CBO's bleaker outlook is the agency's expectations about spending.
At first, the gap between the two projections isn't all that great. For example, CBO looks for Social Security spending in 2023 to be 14.7% of taxable payroll. The program's trustees project spending of 14.5% of taxable payroll this year.
The difference between the two spending outlooks grows over time, though. By 2033, the CBO projects spending to reach 17.1% of taxable payroll. The Social Security trustees think the number will be 16.3%. Fast forward 50 years from now and the gap becomes worse, with the CBO predicting spending of 20.3% of taxable payroll versus 18.4% under the trustees' forecast.
---Cuts Now---Social Security---1AR
Republicans are determined
David Lerman, 6-15-2023. Editor of CQ Budget. "Conservatives’ Budget Plan Renews Battle Over Social Security Benefits, Tax Cuts," https://www.cpapracticeadvisor.com/2023/06/15/conservatives-budget-plan-renews-battle-over-seniors-benefits/81110/.
Social Security and Medicare finances are likely to be a major political football in the upcoming campaign, and featured prominently in this year’s early debate over the debt ceiling. Biden called out Republicans for aiming to gut seniors’ benefits in his State of the Union address; even before that, the GOP was saying the issue was off the table in deficit reduction talks.
Boyle, in his statement on Wednesday, said Republicans “are attempting to renege on our sacred promise to American workers and seniors by renewing their attacks on Social Security and Medicare.”
Social Security cuts inevitable---insolvency means it’ll run out of money
Brett Arends, 6-4-2023. Award-winning financial writer with many years experience writing about markets, economics and personal finance. He has received an individual award from the Society of American Business Editors and Writers for his financial writing, and was part of the Boston Herald team that won two others. He has worked as an analyst at McKinsey & Co., and is a Chartered Financial Consultant. "There’s a clause in the debt-ceiling deal that spells bad news for Social Security," https://www.marketwatch.com/story/the-debt-ceiling-deal-this-clause-is-bad-for-social-security-a0a9e429.
If there were no tax cheats in America, there would be no Social Security crisis. Benefits could be paid, and payroll taxes kept the same, for the next 75 years.
That’s not me talking. That’s math. It comes from the number crunchers at the Social Security Administration and the Internal Revenue Service.
And it explains why those of us who support Social Security should be pounding the table in outrage over one clause of the Biden-McCarthy debt-ceiling deal: the part where the president has to retreat from his crackdown on tax cheats just so McCarthy and the House Republicans would agree to prevent the federal government from defaulting on its debts.
It’s just two years since the administration got into law an extra $80 billion for the IRS to beef up enforcement. That was supposed to include hiring an estimated 87,000 IRS agents.
OK, so nobody likes paying taxes, and nobody likes the IRS. Cue the inevitable demagoguery about an army of militarized IRS tax enforcers, and so on. But this isn’t about whether taxes should be higher or lower. It’s about whether everyone should pay the taxes that they owe.
After all, if we’re going to cut taxes, shouldn’t that apply to those of us who obey the laws as well as those who don’t? Or do we just support a Tax Cuts for Criminals Act?
Why would any voter rally around a platform of standing with tax cheats?
The Congressional Budget Office calculated that the extra funding for the IRS would have reduced the deficit, because it would more than pay for itself. But this augmented IRS funding now been cut by an estimated $21 billion out of its budgeted $80 billion over a 10-year span.
If this seems abstract, consider the context and how it affects you and your retirement — and the retirements of everyone you know.
Social Security is now running an $80 billion annual deficit. That’s the amount benefits are expected to exceed payroll taxes this year. (So say the Social Security Administration’s trustees.)
Next year, that deficit is expected to top $150 billion. By 2026, we’re looking at $200 billion. The trust fund would run out of cash by 2034, and, without extra payroll taxes, it would have to slash benefits by a fifth or more.
Over the next 75 years, says the Congressional Budget Office, the entire funding gap for the program will average about 1.7% of gross domestic product per year.
Meanwhile, how much are tax cheats stealing from the rest of us? A multiple of that.
According to the most recent estimates from the IRS, tax cheats steal about $470 billion a year from the federal government. That figure is now four years out of date. And it’s the figure after enforcement measures.
Oh, and the Treasury’s inspector general for tax administration says it’s a lowball number.
But it still worked out at around 12% of all the taxes that people were supposed to pay, including payroll taxes. And around 2.3% of GDP.
Over the next 10 years, based on similar ratios to GDP, that would come to another $3.3 billion.
Sure, Social Security’s trust fund is theoretically separate from the rest of Uncle Sam’s finances. But that’s an accounting issue. A distinction without a difference.
Social Security is America’s retirement plan. Few can retire in dignity without it. Yet it is facing a fiscal crisis. By 2034, without changes, the program will be forced to cut benefits — drastically.
Some people want to cut benefits. Others want to raise the retirement age, which also means cutting benefits. Others want to raise taxes on benefits — which also means cutting benefits. Others want to hike payroll taxes, either on all of us or (initially) only on very high earners.
Cuts Now---Medicaid---2AC
Medicaid cuts coming now---the GOP will force them through
Peter Sullivan 23. Focuses on health care policy in Congress at Axios, Victoria Knight,Maya Goldman, 3-7-2023. "Medicaid has a target on its back," https://www.axios.com/2023/03/07/medicaid-target-republicans-budget.
Republicans looking for ways to reduce federal spending have served notice they won't cut Medicare and Social Security. But that could mean big proposed cuts for Medicaid.
Why it matters: Over 80 million people were enrolled in Medicaid as of November, higher than the number signed up for Medicare, and the pandemic and successive relief packages have swelled program rolls to record highs.
Between the lines: Medicaid often does not get the attention that Medicare does, but if the House GOP wants to put forward a budget that balances in 10 years, the math would likely force major cuts to the safety net program.
"It's basic arithmetic that if you're going to balance the budget and not touch Medicare, Social Security and probably defense, you have to cut Medicaid substantially," said Larry Levitt, a health policy expert at the Kaiser Family Foundation.
Sen. John Thune (R-S.D.) acknowledged how the numbers stack up and said "there are a lot of ideas" around Medicaid changes. "My assumption is when they talk about Social Security and Medicare, that’s kind of what they're excepting from this, and then I'm sure a lot of folks over there will probably want to except defense too, which doesn't leave a lot to work with," Thune told Axios.
Former President Trump has drawn a bright line against cutting Medicare and Social Security, but has not said the same about Medicaid. As president he supported GOP Obamacare repeal bills with major Medicaid cuts.
---Cuts Now---Medicaid---1AR
State cuts trigger the largest Medicaid losses in history
Ken Alltucker 23. USA TODAY, 4-19-23. "As states cut Medicaid, some fear they'll mistakenly end coverage for millions of eligible people," https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/health/2023/04/19/millions-lose-medicaid-states-begin-cuts/11594134002/.
The federal government provided billions in federal aid to states on the condition that they wouldn’t remove people from Medicaid until the COVID-19 public health emergency ended.
Now, with legislation allowing cuts to resume April 1, the federal government estimates about 15 million people will be disenrolled from Medicaid coverage as states resume the eligibility checks that were paused during the pandemic.
But how quickly that happens depends on where you live.
“It’s very frustrating,” said Moore, who lives in Highland, Arkansas, and is unable to work because of a debilitating back injury. “I have no income coming in. It's not li

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.