Pilot CP - DDI 2023
Pilot CP - DDI 2023.docx
Indexed text preview
Pilot Program CP
1NC
Pilot Program CP---1NC
The United States should ________ for residents of selected localities as part of a pilot project.
Pilot project solves, substantively improves implementation, and greases the political wheels if it’s successful.
Mark Paul et al. 18, Mark Paul is a postdoctoral associate at the Samuel DuBois Cook Center on Social Equity at Duke University; William Darity Jr. is Samuel DuBois Cook Professor of Public Policy, African and African American Studies, and Economics, and director of the Samuel DuBois Cook Center on Social Equity at Duke University; Darrick Hamilton is associate professor of economics and urban policy at the Milano School of International Affairs, Management and Urban Policy and Department of Economics, New School for Social Research, and director of the doctoral program in public and urban policy at the New School; Khaing Zaw is a research associate at the Samuel DuBois Cook Center on Social Equity at Duke University, “A Path to Ending Poverty by Way of Ending Unemployment: A Federal Job Guarantee,” RSF: The Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences, vol. 4, no. 3, Russell Sage Foundation, 2018, pp. 44–63
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION
Not only does the idea of a federal job guarantee have a lengthy history in American politics, it also has significant political support. For example, the Black Youth Project 100’s “Agenda to Build Black Futures” explicitly includes the charge that “All adults who want a job should have a right to employment through public or private opportunities through a federal jobs program.”
In 2014, Jesse Myerson’s article in Rolling Stone proposed five policies that should be supported by the millennial generation; one of them was a government employment guarantee. When the Huffington Post commissioned a national survey to assess the degree of support for each of the five, the only one with substantial support was the job guarantee (Swanson 2014; Resnikoff 2014). Overall, a plurality of respondents, 47 percent, said that they favored a job guarantee versus 41 percent who said no and 12 percent who had no opinion. Fifty-nine percent of households with incomes less than $40,000 favored the job guarantee, and 36 percent of households with incomes greater than $100,000 favored it.34
Given this public support, perhaps at the least, a local experiment is warranted—a local job guarantee. To help workers and communities with the most need, the local job guarantee would cover an economically depressed county or city and be coupled with residency requirements to eliminate concerns of in-migration. Partnering with a local government to implement a jobs guarantee program could lift thousands out of poverty and revitalize a regional economy.
The program would work with government and local community and business groups to assess sectors most in need of public services, such as local infrastructure or social services. In general, the local guarantee would mirror the proposed federal job guarantee; thus, the jobs are meant to provide local services and public goods in the region, rather than to produce private goods that can be exported out of the region. However, by providing public services and goods, the job guarantee would no doubt boost private economic productivity as well.
Such a local guarantee would test the economic and poverty-alleviating benefits of a job guarantee program, and it can also serve as a pilot program for a larger scale jobs guarantee program by providing improved estimates of costs and participation rates in relation to pre-guarantee conditions. As a pilot program, it would demonstrate how a job guarantee would work in practice in the United States, providing evidence to extrapolate toward the proposed federal version.35 In addition, as demonstrated by the Fight for 15, a minimum wage campaign that has succeeded in New York and California, and health-care reform, when the national Affordable Care Act was modeled after Massachusetts’s reforms, having successful local pilot programs can go a long way toward making a federal version politically feasible.
It spills up, avoids backlash, AND emboldens rigorous experimentation necessary for effective regulations.
Colleen V. Chien 19, Justin D'Atri Visiting Professor of Business Law, Columbia Law School; Professor, Santa Clara University School of Law; 2013-2015 White House Senior Advisor, Innovation and Intellectual Property, “Rigorous Policy Pilots: Experimentation in the Administration of the Law,” 104 Iowa L. Rev. 2313, July 2019, Lexis
The range of open questions in law and policy that can be addressed by pilots are wide-ranging. They include, for example, the question of how giving a universal basic income ("UBI") to individuals impacts their well-being and employment. In 2017, the Finnish government began tracking the outcomes of 7,000 unemployed citizens, about a third to which it gave $ 600 a month, [*2317] to address this question; 14several U.S. jurisdictions are planning their own tests. 15Also unknown is how the administration of patent law and issuance of quality patents best advance the Constitutional goal of "promoting the progress of science and useful arts." 16Over the last decade, the United States Patent and Trademark Office ("USPTO") has run numerous pilots to address this question. 17As the D.C. Circuit has said, "there are some situations in which, "a month of experience will be worth a year of hearings.'" 18While experiments or pilots can address a variety of questions pertaining, e.g., to a policy's feasibility or stakeholder reactions, when the question concerns whether the policy has caused an observed outcome, a controlled trial that provides the treatment to one part of population, withholds it from another, and then compares the difference in outcomes provides the best insight. Such rigorous experiments can be designed, in turn, with or without randomization, and to vary the rules or laws that apply or to approximate such changes. A pilot that limits to whom a rule or policy applies constrains the risk but not the learning. As Justice Brandeis famously dissented, "a single courageous state may ... serve as a laboratory; and try novel social and economic experiments without risk to the rest of the country." 19
Within today's highly partisan political landscape, the need for quality evidence about the performance of law and policy presents a rare opportunity for agreement, on the methods if not the values or agendas advanced by evidence. Calls for "smarter use of data and evidence ... to orient decisions and accountability around service and results" 20and "an aggressive management agenda ... that delivers smarter, more innovative, and more accountable government for citizens ... . by applying ... evidence about what [*2318] works" 21 have appeared in President Trump's and President Obama's management agendas, respectively. The passage of the Foundations for Evidence-Based Policy Making Act of 2018 ("2018 Evidence Act"), besides showing that Democrats and Republicans actually can agree on something, will consolidate and coordinate statistical expertise for assessment among rank and file bureaucrats across the federal government. 22
But while "adequate and well controlled studies" have long been required in certain contexts, 23experiments with laws and rules have a history of being constitutionally and legally suspect. As the Supreme Court stated in Truax v. Corrigan, "the Constitution was intended - its very purpose was - to prevent experimentation with the fundamental rights of the individual." 24
Rigorous pilots that provide a benefit to some, but not other, members of a population would appear to offend basic notions of equal protection. 25Imposing a regulatory burden on a subset of regulated entities likewise sounds in unfairness and risks running afoul of the Constitution's due process guarantees. Applying a rule randomly to one set of entities but not another would appear to some to present just the kind of "arbitrary, capricious" agency action judicial review was designed to set aside. 26
How rigorous testing can support evolution of the law is also not widely understood. By operating within existing legal frameworks, experiments can obscure more salient questions, including whether or not the framework is the right one in the first place. Rigorous experimentation is less flexible and adaptable than "democratic experimentalism" with which it shares some features. 27While Congress may feel empowered to take bolder steps when laws are framed as reversible and temporary, requirements of rigor can constrain agencies, feeding anti-regulatory impulses. Experimental evidence can be weaponized and politicized in the same way non-experimental evidence can. 28
[*2319] And yet, when compared to doing nothing or engaging in unreflective action, the benefits of rigorous experimentation become clearer: Rigorous pilots can prime legislative and policy-making efforts by underscoring the importance of evidence and prompting a discussion about the metrics that matter. Rigorous pilots can be used to test legal theories, and point out legal infirmities, provided that is the motivation. Further, among information sources, rigorous pilots are distinct in their ability to generate experiential feedback on the operation of law and policy.
But while rigorous policy pilots can thus be powerful tools, so far, they have been underused tools for informing the development of law and policy. In part this is due to a perception that certain types of rigorous pilots are possibly illegal. Citing a litany of difficulties, a recent recommendation of the Administrative Conference of the United States 29concluded that, "legal, policy, and ethical challenges ... may mean that regulatory agencies should use randomized study methods only under limited circumstances." 30But rigorous pilots have also been underused because of practical obstacles to designing and carrying them out, and a lack of awareness of the value they can add.
Spillover cements a decentralized model for policy innovation necessary to solve extinction.
Charles Weiss 22, the first Science and Technology Adviser to the World Bank, serving in that position from 1971-86, became Distinguished Professor of Science, Technology and International Affairs (STIA) at the Georgetown University School of Foreign Service in 1997, was the director of the STIA program from 1997-2006, now Distinguished Professor Emeritus, and a Visiting Scholar at the American Association for the Advancement of Science, “13 Playing with Fire,” Survival Nexus: Science, Technology, and World Affairs, Oxford University Press, 2022, pp. 251-266
We are needlessly allowing technology to take the world to the brink of disasters from accidental climate disruption, nuclear war, and pandemics— at the same time that we are allowing the means for controlling these technologies to erode. In effect, we are edging closer and closer to cliffs from which we have removed the guardrails. Fortunately, people are beginning to develop— or at least to think about— protections against some of these dangers.
A technology-based model of authoritarian government is being promoted and exported as a technological, economic, and political challenge to Western liberal democracies. The Internet and social media, conceived as vehicles for free exchange of information and platforms for untrammeled innovation, in some countries have become instruments of repression. At the same time, a systematic, worldwide campaign of misinformation and disinformation, spread via social and mass media, has deliberately sown distrust in the democratic process, in government, in international institutions, in science, in expertise of all kinds, and in the very idea that there is such a thing as truth. In the United States, the scientific consensus concerning climate change has been overwhelmed by misinformation and disinformation spread by political and business interests that it threatens, while public messaging regarding the CO VID-19 pandemic has been at best mixed. All this has made it difficult for people to understand the complex and dangerous new threats to the environment, to their health, to their security, and to democratic government.
Stimulating and Guiding Technological Change
Science and technology have much to contribute to the resolution of all these issues. We need better scientific understanding of the climate, of the ways in which diseases spread, and of the likely impact of gene drivers and geoengineering. We need technological innovations to prevent or cure non- communicable diseases, alleviate malnutrition, conserve resources, defend against cyberattack, and restructure our economies along more sustainable and equitable lines.
But we cannot depend on science and technology to address these issues on their own. We also need policies and institutions that not only support research and encourage technological innovation but also guide scientific research and technological change in responsible directions. This will require both “top-down” measures by national governments and “bottom-up” pressures from public opinion, from nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) and from state and local governments that are often more directly responsive to public pressure. It will need ideas and inspiration from businesses, universities, research institutes, individual inventors, and ordinary citizens, and support from public opinion and from the actions and advocacy of individuals and communities. In some cases, it will require sustained effort to resist commercial, political, and military pressures to ignore broader social and environmental problems when investing in research and innovation and to deploy technologies before at least some of their consequences are understood and anticipated. The response to the COVID-19 pandemic and the denial of the reality of climate change in a number of countries show how even the best scientific advice can be undercut by the words and actions of shortsighted, self-interested political leaders.
We need to devise limits on technological innovations like autonomous weapons and hypersonic missiles that can lead to unintended nuclear war. We need to restructure our economy and redesign our cities to end, or at least to limit the use of fossil fuels and to increase the efficiency of our use of energy and materials. We need controls on technologies like artificial intelligence, gene drivers, and geoengineering, all of which both promise major benefits and involve great risks. We need to defend ourselves against technology-based attacks on the values of freedom of thought, communication, innovation, and access to information that were embodied in the original design of the Internet and social media but are now under attack.
At the same time, we need new science and technology to develop novel approaches to environmental sustainability: improved sources of renewable energy and innovative approaches to efficient energy use. We need both to expand and to restructure our electric energy grids to electrify our economy and to improve their efficiency, reliability, and security. We need to restructure our agricultural economy, our urban infrastructure and our transportation systems. We need explicit measures to ensure that everyone can participate in the benefits of technological change. We need research and development on orphan technologies, and vaccines and cures for the diseases that mainly affect people in low- income countries. Not a small menu.
Some of these issues, like climate change, nuclear weapons, and global health, are governed by long-standing regimes, norms, and institutions that now need strengthening and refurbishing to meet new political, economic, and techno logical challenges. Nonproliferation and anti-missile agreements need to be restored and extended to limit or ban development and deployment of hyper sonic missiles, destabilizing weapons that are now under rapid development in many countries. Voluntary national limits on greenhouse gas emissions need to be urgently increased. Time is running out, and costs will be much greater the longer we take for effective action to mitigate and adapt to climate disruption. In the global health sphere, the system for emergency preparedness and pandemic control needs increased and sustained political and financial support to replace the long-standing pattern of crisis-to-crisis, feast-or-famine funding. Most low- income countries still need basic health infrastructure, both to provide health services to their population and to identify and control epidemic disease that could spread beyond their borders.
Cyberweapons, too, can quickly get out of control and wreak enormous damage on critical infrastructure, including the systems of command-and- control on which we would depend to prevent accidental escalation of a localized conflict to full-scale war. Like hypersonic missiles, the response to these weapons depends on artificial intelligence. Unlike hypersonic missiles, cyberweapons do not lend themselves to the type of verifiable arms control regime that has so far been successful for nuclear weapons. What is more, many governments op pose any limits on the use of cyberweapons, despite the risk they pose of acci dental escalation. Continued research and international discussion on how these weapons can be controlled are urgent priorities.
Geoengineering and gene drivers also take the world into uncharted terri tory. Their governance is complicated by the fact that they are accessible not only to governments, but also to private businesses, NGOs, and individuals. It is far from clear how decisions should be made as to whether and under what circumstances these technologies should be developed, and what criteria should govern any such decisions. Advocates for these technologies have developed roadmaps for deploying them in a way that minimizes risks. Still, there are fundamental disagreements over whether geoengineering and gene drivers should be developed and implemented at all, and there is substantial support for the idea that one or both should be banned outright. Critics have called for moratoriums until the broader questions can be explored by a broad range of worldwide stakeholders, disciplines, and cultures. However, the disagreements we have outlined will probably never be totally resolved to everyone’s satisfaction, and deployment decisions will eventually have to be made one way or the other.
The governance of the Internet and social media involves measures to pre serve the global Internet and to address those issues of cybersecurity that are of common concern to countries with very different political systems and very different ideas concerning civil liberties and human rights. The competition be tween authoritarian and democratic governments over freedom of information and innovation is likely to go on for a long time, but both sides have a strong in terest in maintaining a functioning global Internet and in avoiding catastrophic damage to information and telecommunication systems.
Several academies of science, research institutes, NGOs, and religious organ izations have proposed codes of conduct and declarations of principle to deal with the difficult philosophical, ethical, and practical issues involved in all these issues. These represent a useful beginning, and one may hope that they will reach the level of consensus that would allow them to be codified into national legisla tion or international agreements.
Dealing with these issues will require respect for expertise in the fields to which we have often referred: science, technology, politics, economics, business, law, and culture. We will need to incorporate scientific advice into decision making processes, and to acknowledge and manage the risks and uncertainties in our understanding of the science and the technology we are trying to manage, a
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.