Reparations Neg - DDI 2023 KM
Reparations Neg - DDI 2023 KM.docx
Indexed text preview
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations Radical Reparations K 1NC 1.Link: Their recount of history is determent on a description of the Atlantic Order – A system that is a global construct of anti-blackness that makes any reductive one country material approach to history fail to address the true political imaginary of reparations. Táíwò 22 (“Reconsidering Reparations”, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò. January 20th 2022, Pg.23-24, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò is Associate Professor of Philosophy at Georgetown University. He received his Ph.D. in philosophy at the University of California Los Angeles https://global.oup.com/academic/product/reconsidering-reparations-9780197508893?cc=us&lang=en&) HSLA: RP The story of the construction of our world is the story by which the ‘Atlantic Order,’ what historian Joseph Inikori terms the large but not yet global system of slavery and colonialism, came to encompass the whole globe.26 Racism and colonialism were the basic structure of the Atlantic Order, and they accompanied and catalyzed the expansion of the Atlantic Order into a fully global economic structure. And the outcome, the global economy, is today managed and directed by global capitalism: so if global racial empire is the what, then capitalism is the how. In the beginning, the connection between racism, colonialism, and capitalism was obvious. The latter was built with political and juridical structures that explicitly mentioned race and empire and overtly managed the affairs of business in the context of both. As Karl Marx succinctly explains in The Poverty of Philosophy: “Direct slavery is just as much the pivot of bourgeois industry as machinery, credits, etc. Without slavery you have no cotton; without cotton you have no modern industry. It is slavery that gave the colonies their value; it is the colonies that created world trade, and it is world trade that is the precondition of large-scale industry. Thus slavery is an economic category of the greatest importance.” But over time, as the world system has shifted—importantly, in large part because it has been successfully challenged in many ways by generations of people fighting for justice. As a result, forms of domination have become more complex, and power and wealth subtler and harder to understand. Nevertheless, the broad patterns and stratification that explicitly characterized past centuries largely hold today. Across the globe, racism distributes political rights in ways that favor the transfer of material and immaterial advantages toward the colonizers and away from the colonized, and those relationships and inertias persist even after the vocabulary of “colony” has given way to newer window-dressings. History is not merely an interesting point of comparison for our contemporary problems. Everything we experience happens in the flow of time from past to present to future, and so when we struggle to stay afloat in the present—to access health care, to secure food, to form healthy relationships—we are swimming among the currents of history. When we understand the structure of the world as the pattern of its motion, it turns out that history is one of the most powerful ways we can discern where these invisible currents we get caught in are coming from, and where they are going, to perceive where they will pull us under and drown us, and what it would take to avoid that fate. Armed with a global perspective, we can also see how consequences flow from some parts of the world to other parts, often across national borders, and in ways that complicate geographically and politically narrow ways of thinking about reparations. 2.Impact: Their nationalist wealth approach to understanding historic and present anti-blackness fails to account for the world economic order – A post-colonial project that makes any one nation attempt at reparations to addressing anti-blackness simply shift the scope of economic white supremacy in new ways globally – The Impact is endless shifts in anti-black violence. Táíwò 22 (“Reconsidering Reparations”, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò. January 20th 2022, Pg. 19-21, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò is Associate Professor of Philosophy at Georgetown University. He received his Ph.D. in philosophy at the University of California Los Angeles https://global.oup.com/academic/product/reconsidering-reparations-9780197508893?cc=us&lang=en&) HSLA: RP We live in a “world economic order.” As Martin Luther King, Jr. told us sixty years ago, you can’t go through a basic action in your day without participating in a global interaction. Odds are good that you ordered this book on a device with materials mined in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, assembled in China, and shipped to yet a third continent for sale. This global economic system that we have distributes rewards and even basic economic functions to different parts of the world through networks of trade, exchange, and movement. Some countries specialize in the manufacture of particular physical goods: perhaps petroleum, like Nigeria or Saudi Arabia; coffee and cocoa, like the Ivory Coast. Other countries specialize in being tax havens for the wealth of the world’s elite, like Switzerland and Monaco. A range of “internal” political activity organizes and optimizes this activity within the borders of nation states, through means such as taxation, subsidization, and regulation to zoning, housing, and education. To some extent, then, these sovereign nations control how things go within their borders. But their economic activity relies on what’s going on in the rest of the world, often more acutely than on what’s going on inside. Apparently “internal” Nigerian or Saudi decisions about producing petroleum actually succeed or fail based on which cars are on the road in China or the United States; how much cocoa to produce in the Ivory Coast depends on how much chocolate is being eaten in Belgium or France; the likelihood of which financial incentives will attract foreign licit and illicit capital to Monaco or Atlantic City depends on what the other tax havens are offering. It’s not entirely unsurprising, then, that we also live in a world political order: a system of countries that relate to each other, and institutions that work alongside, between, and above these. Alongside the United Nations, International Monetary Fund (IMF), and World Bank are a host of other institutions such as regional development banks that make up the formal and semi-formal politico-economic connections knitting the world together. Nongovernmental organizations add additional sinews, including, at the top end, international heavyweights such as the Gates Foundation and international weapons manufacturers, alongside the more lucrative of the criminal business networks and empires. These political and economic “orders” describe the same world system. The separation between these two ways of looking at the world order is a matter of emphasis, to the extent that it is not simply imaginary. In many times and places the exercise of power is a fairly holistic matter. Accordingly, even institutions that seem purely focused on global economic relations, like the IMF, in effect and thus in fact operate politically, and vice versa. Understanding this is key to understanding the pressures that built our global social system, and the scope of what it will take to rebuild them in the direction of justice. On the constructive view of reparations, reparations are a worldmaking project. This involves thinking about justice and injustice in distributive terms: that is, as a matter of who gets what. But the relationship of persons to resources is not a static, one-time transaction. Resources flow to and away from people continuously. We can look at the politico-economic system of the world as something like a water management system, a web of aqueducts that spans the globe, channeling, instead of water, advantages and disadvantages from one place to another. The system describes which way future waters will naturally run, and where they will not run without novel intervention. If we try to explain modern finance, or philanthropy, or pollution, or medical care, we end up describing their motion in the world. The system of the world, then, is not best described by the metaphor of a blueprint, or an organizational chart of political powers, but as a set of inertias, gravities, pressures, and bottlenecks that bound and channel the endless flow of the present: material, money, media, violence, advantage, disadvantage. It is their motion in time that makes the system of the world, and we can map the system to the extent that we can predict the direction of motion. The stones of the aqueducts that contain and discipline the continuous motion of the past into the future were laid in the seventeenth, eighteenth, and nineteenth centuries. This was the period when several European powers vied to create channels of wealth that would link the globe together into a world economic order. For reasons we will explore later, I call the world order resulting from their collective project the Global Racial Empire. And just as the decisions ancient Roman engineers made in building their aqueducts continued to determine who had water long after those engineers, and their original imperial project, were dead, the global distribution system built by the Global Racial Empire continues to function. This fact is easily demonstrated, for the patterns in how advantage and disadvantage flow have changed very little. This perspective on world history helps explain why world historians treat reparations as “less about the transfer of resources . . . as it is about the transformation of all social relations . . . re-envisioning and reconstructing a world-system.”20 3.The Alternative is Reparations in the Constructivist view - a Black Radical Reparations project. Táíwò 22 (“Reconsidering Reparations”, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò. January 20th 2022, Pg.1 , Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò is Associate Professor of Philosophy at Georgetown University. He received his Ph.D. in philosophy at the University of California Los Angeles https://global.oup.com/academic/product/reconsidering-reparations-9780197508893?cc=us&lang=en&) HSLA: RP Here, Coates, or I myself, might have been surprised. At least some of those things are precisely what we want from reparations. Hughes exploits a haze of ambiguity around reparations: what are they about? Adolph Reed, Jr. describes the call for reparations for African Americans as a blend of “material, symbolic, and psychological components.”4 Reed explains that the United States’s long history of slavery and racial economic apartheid has cost African Americans in direct and indirect “material” ways, which include racially discriminatory lending practices, as well as the violent exclusion of Blacks from voting and other aspects of public political life. Reparations projects that involve financial payment of some kind might go some distance toward remedying this. But also important are means of addressing impersonal material considerations such as political representation, as well as attempts to counter symbolic injustices, such as monuments and memorials that continue to propagate the ideology of global racism. Finally, some proponents of reparations believe that they will raise collective racial consciousness and provide tools to address social pathologies that are related to the painful history of slavery and racial domination. Reed thinks the ambiguity caused by these separate categories of goals is a liability, since elites can then exploit it by choosing the version of reparations that is cheapest for them: the symbolic. We have already seen this tendency at work: in Washington, D.C., the capital of the United States, the mayor decided to paint “Black Lives Matter” on the plaza in front of the White House, in response to the 2020 summer of protests against racist police violence. There, mere days later, law enforcement continued to brutalize protestors while the mayor supported a multimillion dollar budget increase to their budget.5 More important, overinvestment from any level of society into such symbolic reparations could detract energy and resources from an alternative, preferable political project: “building broad solidarity across race, gender, and other identities around shared concerns of daily life” like “access to quality health care, the right to a decent and dignified livelihood, affordable housing, quality education for all.” Here, Reed sounds the alarm later raised by Hughes—that the call for reparations for some distracts from a more worthy political project that would provide justice for all. But what if the project for reparations was the project for “safer neighborhoods and better schools,” for a “less punitive justice system,” for “the right to a decent and dignified livelihood”? What if building the just world was reparations? Indeed, this book will ask, what other form of reparations could even be meaningful in the context of our reality? Keeanga-Yamahtta Taylor pointed out, in a discussion with Reed on this subject, that the struggle to build a just social system can’t be won through simple “universal” programs addressing “common” problems. Taylor gives the example of the large disparity rate in maternal mortality between Black mothers and white mothers: the accumulated history of disparate and discriminatory treatment and policy means that not all of the relevant social problems are, in fact, common to both.6 To build a just health care system, we would have to address both lack of access due to unjust economic structures and lack of access due to unfair gender- and race-based discrimination. From the point of view of building a just health care system, then, these goals aren’t substitutes for each other; they are complementary. In Freedom Dreams, Robin D. G. Kelley takes up a similar perspective. After a historical analysis of many eras of reparations campaigns in the United States, he concludes that “it was never entirely, or even primarily, about money. The demand for reparations was about social justice, reconciliation, reconstructing the internal life of black America, and eliminating institutional racism. This is why reparations proposals from black radical movements focus less on individual payments than on securing funds to build autonomous black institutions, improving community life, and in some cases establishing a homeland that will enable African Americans to develop a political economy geared more toward collective needs than toward accumulation.”7 The goal of Reconsidering Reparations is to argue for this perspective: the view that reparation is a construction project. Accordingly, I call this way of thinking about the relationship between justice’s past and future the constructive view of reparations. Links – 2NC The Racial Contract builds global socioeconomic privilege that implicates national level anti-blackness – The Political imaginary of reparations must be bigger than national level wealth. Táíwò 22 (“Reconsidering Reparations”, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò. January 20th 2022, Pg.24-26, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò is Associate Professor of Philosophy at Georgetown University. He received his Ph.D. in philosophy at the University of California Los Angeles https://global.oup.com/academic/product/reconsidering-reparations-9780197508893?cc=us&lang=en&) HSLA: RP In his landmark 1994 book The Racial Contract, philosopher Charles Mills borrows the “social contract” language of liberal political thought to make this same claim about the basic organization of the world’s social structures. He argues that we live in a world “built by the Racial Contract”; that is, “global white supremacy” is itself a political system, the one resulting from the fact that the world has been “foundationally shaped for the past five hundred years by the . . . gradual consolidation of global white supremacy.”28 Mills characterizes that political system in comprehensive, distributive terms, describing it as “a particular power structure of formal or informal rule, socioeconomic privilege, and norms for the differential distribution of material wealth and opportunities, benefits and burdens, rights and duties.”29 This book contends that he is correct. As this chapter moves forward to explain the structure of today’s world in terms of the historical motions it embodies, it will be helpful to pause first to highlight a key pair of concepts that we will return to throughout the book—cumulative advantage and cumulative disadvantage. Cumulative Processes Money, goods, knowledge, and technology can be or can provide social advantages. Debt, pollution, and knowledge gaps are social disadvantages. These are also products, the direct results of intentional human activity. We can ask basic questions about any given moment: Where are these advantages and disadvantages produced, and whose labor is involved in producing them? When they are produced, where do they go, and who gets access to them? More simply, who gets what, and how much of it? These are questions about distribution, or how advantages and disadvantages are spread out across people, countries, and social positions. This is a core concept that we can use to analyze many problems of injustice, which can happen when a system directs more or fewer advantages to a place or population than it ought to. The concept of distribution is intimately related to another important concept: accumulation, which marks how advantages and disadvantages build up over time. When we’re thinking about advantages, think paychecks. If you get paid more than your bills and expenses cost, you can save up the excess money—an accumulation of advantages. In any given moment of need, money in a bank account is an advantage. But how much you are able to keep in that account depends on the size of your paychecks over time, that is, your distribution of income. When we’re thinking about disadvantages, think about trash collection. If sanitation workers are not available or do not do their essential work, then, like the disposable income in a savings account, the trash accumulates. But in this latter case, the accumulation is adverse, and the amount of trash in an area ultimately represents the distribution of access to sanitation service over time. Since accumulation results from past distributions, this pair of concepts help us understand how past injustice explains present injustice, and how present injustice can explain future injustice. This also provides a route into a different way of thinking about the political situation, one that animates some reparations arguments. Rather than thinking of racial disparities in wealth or access to public health as evidence of some nefarious undiscovered intentional conspiracy, we can explain disparities in many cases as simply the present accumulated imprint of past racist distributions of resources and infrastructure The way they retrace black history in America only reenforces notions of white history that refuses to understand how historical and current anti-blackness globally implicates and expands U.S violence. Harriot 22 (“Top 10 reasons why lineage-based reparations is a bad plan”, April 13th 2022, Michael Harriot, A journalist, poet, author, and storyteller that writes about political, economic, and social habits, especially in terms of white politics in relation to inequity, https://reparationscomm.org/reparations-news/10-reasons-why-lineage-based-reparations-is-a-bad-plan/#source) HSLA: RP 10. It is based on white history. First of all, the bill states that “More than 4,000,000 Africans and their descendants were enslaved in the United States and the colonies that became the United States from 1619 to 1865,” which excludes the descendants of Africans who were enslaved in America by anyone other than English settlers who showed up a century after Europeans arrived on the continent with enslaved Africans. We still don’t know what happened to the Africans who revolted in
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.