Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Universality PIC › Author Indicts

TURN, Coates further entrenches the theory that the foundations of white supremacy which America is built upon are Sonderweg and are fated to exist.

Williams 17. “How Ta-Nehisi Coates Gives Whiteness Power.” The New York Times, 6 Oct. 2017, www.nytimes.com/2017/10/06/opinion/ta-nehisi-coates-whiteness-power.html. Accessed 18 July 2023. ID.ELC

BERLIN — In the study of German history, there is the notion of sonderweg, literally the “special path,” down which the German people are fated to wander. In different eras, and depending on who employed it, the term could imply different things. It began as a positive myth during the imperial period that some German scholars told themselves about their political system and culture. During and after World War II it turned distinctly negative, a way for outsiders to make sense of the singularity of Germany’s crimes. Yet whether viewed from within or without, left or right, the Germans could be seen through such a lens to possess some collective essence — a specialness — capable of explaining everything. In this way, one could speak of a trajectory “from Luther to Hitler” and interpret history not as some chaotic jumble but as a crisp, linear process. There is something both terrifying and oddly soothing about such a formulation. For better or worse, it leaves many very important matters beyond the scope of choice or action. It imagines Germans as having been either glorious or terrible puppets, the powerful agents of forces nonetheless beyond their control. A similar unifying theory has been taking hold in America. Its roots lie in the national triple sin of slavery, land theft and genocide. In this view, the conditions at the core of the country’s founding don’t just reverberate through the ages — they determine the present. No matter what we might hope, that original sin — white supremacy — explains everything, an all-American sonderweg. No one today has done more to push this theory in the mainstream than the 42-year-old author Ta-Nehisi Coates. Anyone interested in the durability of racism in American life is probably still discussing his breakout 2015 memoir “,” a moving and despairing letter to his then-15-year-old son that warned: “You have been cast into a race in which the wind is always at your face and the hounds are always at your heels ... The plunder of black life was drilled into this country in its infancy and reinforced across its history, so that plunder has become an heirloom, an intelligence, a sentience, a default setting to which, likely to the end of our days, we must invariably return.” The book won Mr. Coates millions of readers and fans, many of whom are white. This week he published “We Were Eight Years in Power: An American Tragedy,” a collection of essays bridging the Obama and Trump eras, and here deepens his vision of American sonderweg. Consider this extraordinary description he offers of a social process so multifaceted as neighborhood gentrification, which in urban areas like New York is far from a straightforwardly white phenomenon: To empathize on any human level with the lynched and the raped, and then to watch all of the beneficiaries just going on with their heedless lives, could fill you with the most awful rage. I feel it myself, for example, walking through Washington, D.C., or Brooklyn, where gentrification has blown through like a storm. And I feel it not just because of the black people swept away but because I know that “gentrification” is but a more pleasing name for white supremacy, is the interest on enslavement, the interest on Jim Crow, the interest on redlining, compounding across the years, and these new urbanites living off of that interest are, all of them, exulting in a crime. In my own young black life, I have done my part to gentrify a half-dozen mixed neighborhoods ranging from Spanish Harlem to Fort Greene to the ninth arrondissement of Paris. Many of my well-educated black, Latino, Asian and Arab friends have done the same. Most of us harbored conflicted feelings about the processes we were engaged in, but few of us considered advancing white supremacy to be one of them. Mr. Coates, who formerly lived in Harlem, briefly catches himself in the essay, admitting, “And I know, even in my anger, even as I write this, that I am no better.” Yet in the very next sentence he abandons any pretense of class-based analysis. “White people are, in some profound way, trapped,” he doubles down. “It took generations to make them white, and it will take more to unmake them.” So expansive is the racial netting we are wrapped in, Mr. Coates writes, “it’s likely that should white supremacy fall, the means by which that happens might be unthinkable to those of us bound by present realities and politics.” Elsewhere in the book he notes “that white supremacy was so foundational to this country that it would not be defeated in my lifetime, my child’s lifetime, or perhaps ever.” Amazingly, despite his near godlike status within white liberal circles, in the collection’s finest essay, “The Case for Reparations,” originally published in The Atlantic in 2014, Mr. Coates worries that “today, progressives are loath to invoke white supremacy as an explanation for anything.” It is a jaw-dropping sentence if you take even a moment to consider the current discourse in progressive circles. “We Were Eight Years in Power” can leave a reader with the distinct impression that its author is glad, relieved even, that Donald Trump was elected president. It is exhibits A through Z of Mr. Coates’s national indictment, proof that the foundations of the United States are anti-black and that the past is not dead — it’s not even past, to echo William Faulkner.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Universality PIC › UBI bad for Reparations

Provoking White backlash leads to the metastasizing of Reparations to other groups of society. Wrecks any form of salve for Black struggles.

Damon Linker, 19. Damon Linker is the Senior Correspondent at “The Week”, and Senior Writing Fellow in the Center of Critical Writing at the University of Pennsylvania. “Fear the Reparations Backlash.” The Week, 12 Mar. 2019, theweek.com/articles/828360/fear-reparations-backlash. Accessed 21 July 2023. ID.ELC

Might it nonetheless be worth the consequences? Perhaps — if we could know that demands for reparations would be limited to the descendants of slaves. But we can know no such thing. On the contrary, the dynamic of grievance politics in the United States tells us that reparations for African Americans would only be the start. Just as anti-discrimination law and affirmative action began with blacks and then spread to different races, ethnic groups, and other protected classes, so calls for reparations would quickly metastasize to different groups demanding recompense for past and present injustices. If you doubt it, consider that just last week a in the House of Representatives originally intended to single out those who traffic in anti-Semitism quickly morphed into a generic denunciation of "hate" directed against a laundry list of groups: "African Americans, Latinos, Native Americans, Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders, and other people of color, Jews, Muslims, Hindus, Sikhs, the LGBTQ community, immigrants, and others." The case for treating the injustices suffered by African Americans in the United States as sui generis — and worthy of a uniquely aggressive response, including reparations — is quite strong. But that doesn't mean that activists who claim to speak for members of other groups will go happily along. They almost certainly will not. The one thing on which they are likely to agree is that the group that should be forced to pay repeated penalties for its collective sin\ is the white population of the country, and especially its supposedly most privileged class: straight, able-bodied white males. Can anyone seriously believe that a politics organized around the effort of a series of minority groups to extract reparation payments from whites will be anything other than hideously toxic? The best way to avoid the brutal backlash that would follow may be to avoid provoking it in the first place.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Universality PIC › UBI bad for Reparations

Any attempts to enact reparation policies is met with white backlash, Creating cultural and political divide.

Damon Linker, 19. Damon Linker is the Senior Correspondent at “The Week”, and Senior Writing Fellow in the Center of Critical Writing at the University of Pennsylvania. “Fear the Reparations Backlash.” The Week, 12 Mar. 2019, theweek.com/articles/828360/fear-reparations-backlash. Accessed 21 July 2023. ID.ELC

The moral case for reparations may be strong, but the political and cultural consequences of enacting the policy are likely to be extremely high. Far from serving as a moment of moral reckoning and healing for the country, as its advocates contend, it would inspire a severe backlash that would inflame tensions on both sides of the color line — and set the stage for future calls from other groups for acts of public restitution for past injustices. It's a recipe for greatly intensified civic anger and resentment. As I when he first published his , Coates' case for reparations was important and compelling — but also wrong-headed. Coates asserted that American patriotism is a fraud. In his words, a form of American national pride that "proudly claim[s] the veteran and disown[s] the slaveholder," and that celebrates "freedom and democracy while forgetting America's origins in a slavery economy," is "patriotism à la carte." As he put it in one of the essay's most unforgettable lines, "To ignore the fact that one of the oldest republics in the world was erected on a foundation of white supremacy ... is to cover the sin of national plunder with the sin of national lying." In Coates' view — one endorsed by Brooks in his recent — the only way for the United States to purify its patriotism and truly expiate its racial sins is for it to fully own, accept, and atone for them by enacting a policy of reparations. That might sound good in theory, but it isn't at all the way it's likely to work in practice. White Americans love to think well of themselves and the country — loving the United States not just because it is ours but even more so because they believe the country is good in itself, intrinsically worthy or deserving of love. Debating and attempting to enact a policy of reparations would force white Americans to confront their country's longstanding and persistent racism and place that reckoning at the core of how they view the country's history and themselves. That is quite likely to spark a defensive political, social, and cultural reaction.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Universality PIC › UBI bad for Reparations

UBI misunderstood. It denies individuals to a fulfilled life, dampen s the human desire for self-improvement, and DOES NOT have the government take full responsibility. It turns society against each other and reinforces resentment.

John F.Cogan 21. John Cogan is a senior fellow at the Hoover Institution where his research focuses around U.S Budget and Fiscal Policy, Faculty member Public Policy Program at Stanford University. “The Economic Impact of a Universal Basic Income.” Hoover Institution, 14 Jan. 2021, www.hoover.org/research/economic-impact-universal-basic-income. Accessed 19 July 2023. ID.ELC

At this conceptual level, the critique of the UBI centers on three of its misconceptions, two of which are misconceptions of human nature. First, UBI proponents presume that it doesn’t matter whether individuals enjoy a level of material well-being through their own efforts or from government mandated payments from others. This ignores a crucial facet of living a fulfilled life, namely that an individual’s efforts and sacrifices to achieve a personal goal are essential to that person’s sense of self-worth. It is the striving to reach a personal goal, more than achieving a level of material wellbeing, that provides life’s true rewards. A second misconception is that unconditional aid will not dampen the natural human desire for self-reliance and selfimprovement. In reality, individuals receiving such aid have less reason to provide for themselves by being employed, looking for employment, or improving their skills. This is true regardless of whether or not the UBI has a means test. The degree to which these incentives influence behavior may vary from one person to another, but they operate on all persons, including those with a strong commitment to self-reliance. Recognition of this fundamental fact of human nature is the reason that down through the ages, charities, mutual aid societies, religious organizations, and governments have made requirements for self-improvement a cornerstone of their welfare policies. A third misconception is that the money to finance the UBI comes from the government. Government is merely a pass-through entity that transfers income from some members of society to UBI recipients. Such transfers, of course, take place in all compassionate societies, but they have invariably been accompanied by requirements that recipients accept corresponding responsibilities. Governmentally conferred welfare rights must necessarily be accompanied by governmentally imposed duties on recipients or other members of society. Under the UBI, the government confers a right to a decent living standard, but imposes no corresponding responsibilities on recipients. At the same time, it assumes that others should finance this living standard through their own labor. Such a policy divides a society between payers and recipients, potentially leading to resentment and discontentment. Providing individuals with free access to goods and services produced by other members of the society is a defining attribute of socialism. In this regard, the UBI is part and parcel of socialist policy

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Universality PIC › PIC – 1NC

Making Pragmatic Political choices has no weight in making measurable change. The system is an active barrier to radical change needed to salve black struggles.

Egginton, Xandi 20. Xandi Egginton is a sophomore majoring in Political Science and Anthropology. An intern with MarylandPIRG, and he grew up in the Baltimore area. “Political Pragmatism No Longer Makes Sense.” The John Hopkins News-Letter, 14 Apr. 2020, www.jhunewsletter.com/article/2020/04/political-pragmatism-no-longer-makes-sense. Accessed 24 July 2023.

I grew up in a household where the idea of political pragmatism always won. You wouldn’t base choices in democracy on your individual whims and wishes; instead, you’d choose to endorse those who you thought had the people’s best interests at heart. You voted no matter what because the only way to navigate our political system is to participate in it. There may be evil on all sides of the spectrum, but you always went for the lesser evil; otherwise, you were complicit in whatever the election’s outcome came to be. After all, if you didn’t cast a vote, then you didn’t choose to act in a way that — even if marginally — could have helped the vulnerable in society. Since moving from my family home in Mount Washington, a neighborhood that lies in the outskirts of Baltimore City, to the University’s Homewood Campus two years ago, I have realized the failures and ignorance of this argument. The reality is that in a world that is already radical in its measures of inequality and levels of corruption, the pragmatic “choice” has little weight for many people. At college, I am surrounded by friends whose lives are fractured because of policies and political realities that have existed for decades. College didn’t turn them radical; their lives did. A couple of days ago, I woke up and scrolled through my Twitter feed. It told me that 68 percent of those who have died in Chicago due to coronavirus (COVID-19) were black, when black people make up only 30 percent of the city’s . That is a radical and blatant sign of systemic oppression, but only one tiny example of the kind of injustices that plague communities across the nation. The next day, I opened up my Twitter feed once again, only to see a Baltimore City police officer walking through a predominantly black community in Southeast Baltimore purposefully coughing on . While this officer’s actions primarily represent his individual character, they are also emblematic of recurring issues within the police force, whose job is to protect and make all citizens feel safe. On a political level, the Republican and Democratic parties have both failed the people of this country for many years. This does not mean that every single politician has failed, but that the systems which uphold our democracy have failed. Instead of existing as a means by which to improve and save the lives of Americans, rich and poor, these systems have acted as barriers. For a long time, the establishment cores of both parties have been riddled with moneyed interests and shameless tactics of manipulation. This is apparent at local levels, like in , as well as all the way at the top, in So when friends tell me that they cannot and will not vote for Joe Biden, I support them and their decision, even though I am still unsure of what I will do with my own vote this fall. My life may have afforded me the ability to make the “pragmatic” choice, but that is not the case for so many people in the United States. In a time that is unprecedented in all ways, we should be able to see why radical change is necessary. I hope that, in 50 years, I can tell my grandchildren that the revolution didn’t feel like a revolution, but, instead, felt like a parting from a political system that was radical in its complacency and perpetration of inequality. I truly believed at one point that Sanders’ campaign, arguably the most revolutionary in American political history, could garner enough grassroots support to hand him the Democratic nomination. However, this fight doesn’t end with Sanders’ loss, and he will be the first to say exactly that. Because of how decentralized our federal government is, there is a lot we can do locally to implement radical change from the bottom up. In fact, I have seen signs of this radical change underway already. There is a movement in Baltimore, for one, to get big money out of our local elections by way of an . The point is, while every person affected negatively by the end of Sanders’ campaign should take time to heal and recuperate, the time to organize is now. Radical change awaits.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Universality PIC › PIC – 1NC

The aff is capitulation - instead of taking white backlash as an inevitable feature of American politics, we should embrace the opportunity to change politics through consciousness raising"

Vincent, Southerland 21. Vincent Is an assistant professor of Clinical Law and Co-Faculty director of the Center on Race, Inequality, and the Law at NYU. “Toward a Just Future: Anticipating and Overcoming a Sustained Resistance to Reparations.” N.Y.U. Review of Law & Social Change, 2021, socialchangenyu.com/review/toward-a-just-future-anticipating-and-overcoming-a-sustained-resistance-to-reparations/. Accessed 22 July 2023. ID.ELC

Even imagining just a few of the ways resistance might materialize informs the task ahead. If we hope to avoid a future where reparations have been made, but they still do not salve the grave wounds that this country has inflicted on itself, Of course, America must provide economic redress and attend to the material conditions flowing from enslavement and segregation But the road to reparations must do even more. It must lead us to fully reckon with American history, boldly confront the ideology of white supremacy that drives racial subordination, and draw on concrete experiences to make reparations real. Ultimately, advocates must work to change culture. IV. WHAT ADVOCATES SHOULD DO ABOUT IT NOW: MAKING CHANGE IN THESE TIMES None of this is easy-changing, culture never has been. But the tracks that we lay now can carry us to a future with reparations that create a new kind of world. What follows are three suggestions that advocates-in preparation for a sustained resistance to reparations-might deploy to ensure that reparative justice in the future is transformational. 10 1 A. Continue to Raise Consciousness About Racial Injustice. A movement for reparations at the national level must be driven by rigorous engagement at an individual and community level about America's history and legacy of racial inequality. This type of consciousness raising work strikes at all of the animating forces behind the resistance, especially the sense that nothing is owed to Black people. It is essential that advocates carry forward the consciousness-raising efforts undertaken during the uprisings of 2020 by continuing to foster awareness about the ways the racial status quo-and notions of racial superiority and inferiority-have shaped American society along lines that have fundamentally failed us all. 102 Though that type of engagement and consciousness raising often happens alongside traditional legal tools or doctrines, it is at the heart of social movements. 10 3 While advocates should not abandon the law, they must complement their commitment to legal advocacy with a robust support of social movements aimed at raising our collective racial consciousness.1 04 It is especially important to demonstrate that while America has grappled with race and racism in the past, it has done so haltingly, and that the work remains unfinished. At a basic level, such efforts require exposing the untruths we have told ourselves about race and inequality, and re-conceptualizing racial identity outside the context of domination and subjugation.1 05 In America "[w]e lie and cover up our sins and mute the traumas they cause. We dissociate the trauma from our national self-understanding and locate it, if at all, in the ungrateful cries of grievance and victimization among those who experienced the pain and loss." 106 In other words, we too often willingly turn away from the trauma that racial inequality has produced in favor of the comfort provided by the myths about having largely overcome our racial divide.1 0 7 Raising our collective consciousness is an antidote to that willful blindness. That work must include educational efforts to increase popular understanding of America's racial caste system and its legacy of distributing burdens and benefits along racial lines. 10 8 Such efforts are already underway. The Pulitzer Center's creation of a curriculum for the New York Times Magazine's 1619 Project is one example. 109 The 1619 Project challenges readers to reframe United States history and its foundational date as the year when African people were brought to American shores and enslaved. By doing so, "[i]t aims to reframe the country's history by placing the consequences of slavery and the contributions of [B]lack Americans at the very center of our national narrative." 110 The initiative explores vectors of life through a racial lens, raising consciousness about America's history of racial inequality. Since August 2019, roughly 4,500 classrooms have engaged with the curriculum, while school systems in New York, Illinois, Washington D.C., Delaware, and North Carolina have "adopted the project at a broad scale." 11 1 The Equal Justice Initiative (EJI), a nonprofit organization that "challenges poverty and racial injustice, advocates for equal treatment in the criminal justice system, and creates hope for marginalized communities" has likewise engaged in this type of work.1 1 2 In 2018, EJI opened a National Memorial for Peace and Justice and the Legacy Museum: From Enslavement to Mass Incarceration, spaces centered on reckoning with America's history of racial injustice and racial terrorism. 1 1 3 More than 750,000 people have visited these sites since they opened.1 1 4 EJI's research reports, which focused on America's racialized history, the era of Reconstruction, and the racial terror that followed, have been made available to educators and students nationwide to "advance a fuller, more accurate understanding of the nation's history of racial injustice."1 15 This type of historical work-work that builds and shapes our "collective memory"--can also help to subvert claims of innocence that stymie efforts to repair past racial harms still felt today. 116 These claims of innocence rest on the sense that one is not actively engaged in discrimination and therefore bears no responsibility for the racial inequality of the past or present.' 11 Tending to the historical narrative that displaces blame allows proponents of reparations to focus on a "distributive justice lens," which turns attention to the appropriate allocation of resources in the absence of racial subjugation. 118 Part of that work is also making visible to all the "psychological wage of whiteness"1 19-the material benefits and privileges that accrue to white skin in a racial caste system that is premised on notions of white superiority.1 20 Racial inequality is so deeply woven into America's fabric that the advantages and disadvantages of race have become expectations, and "inequities are obscured and rendered nearly invisible."1 2 1 That dynamic makes consciousness-raising necessary. Such work may be as simple as asking people to take stock of the ways that race, and for white people, how whiteness in particular, leads to advantage in their lives. 12 2 Advocates can and should engage in the type of education and consciousness raising I have suggested by looking to the broader movement for Black lives. The coalition Movement for Black Lives ("M4BL"), comprised of a collection of Black social justice organizations, is a model. 123 M4BL is, at its core, a "movement to recognize the full humanity of African Americans in public life." 124 The movement emerged in response to the death of Black people at the hands of law enforcement and armed vigilantes.1 2 5 It is complex, as all social movements are, but at its core asserts the dignity and humanity of Black life. 126 It does so in a country whose foundational values, expressed through an ideology of white supremacy, are at odds with those ideals. Fundamentally, the movement, and the advocates behind it, are changing culture and the historical calculus that undervalues Black life. 12 7 The end of enslavement and the victories of the Civil Rights Movement came, in part, because enough people recognized that a world that perpetuated the myths that drove enslavement and subjugation was a world that produced unacceptable injustices.1 2 8 The same shift in consciousness is needed in these times, and there is plenty of work to be done. 12 9 The scope of the damage leveled by COVID-19, when taken together with the damage done by a legacy of racial injustice, provides tangible evidence of the injustice, unfairness, and palpable pain experienced by Black people. By leveraging that evidence, advocates can engage with communities to imagine the kind of world we all want to live in.1 3 0 B. Be Concrete in Your Work Raising consciousness must be complemented by concrete steps toward reparative justice. Concrete steps have two benefits. First, they provide an actionable outlet for those whose consciousness on racial inequality has been raised. Second, they serve as a model for the type of transformation that reparations would drive on a large scale. This work-though focused on enacting reparations in the present-can blunt resistance rooted in concerns that reparations are impractical, or that focusing on America's past and atoning for racial inequality is divisive. In taking this approach, advocates should begin by pressing for reparative justice in their own communities, focusing exclusively on the heirs to a legacy of enslavement as the barometer for what is needed to repair and heal America. 13 1 Such an approach would be revolutionary, because it would put "racialized identities . . . to service to achieve social change through democratic renewal." 132 It would require treating race like "the miner's canary": the condition of the racially marginalized would serve as the "sign of a danger that threatens us all."13 3 It carries with it the type of ethos that "those who have experienced discrimination speak with a special voice to which we should listen" as we seek reparative justice. 134 Such thinking rests on the premise that "[t]hose who are oppressed in the present world can speak most eloquently of a better one." 135 This type of framework ensures that reparative justice reaches those whose lives have been most harmed by racial inequality. It also ensures that those who have been most harmed have a central voice in defining reparative justice.1 36 Advocates should also study and support nascent reparative justice efforts that are already underway or that have proven successful,1 3 7 pressing for truly transformative measures whenever feasible and taking steps toward reparative justice whenever possible.1 38 Several local efforts provide ready opportunities for exploration and support. Burlington, Vermont's City Council passed a resolution in August 2020 that established a task force to study reparations for Vermont's role in slavery and to offer a formal apology on behalf of the city for that role. 139 The task force's work began in October 2020 and will continue for a year to determine how to proceed. 140 Asheville, North Carolina, approved a resolution in July 2020 to support community reparations for the city's Black residents. 14 1 The resolution details the vectors of racial inequality rooted in enslavement, segregation, incarceration, and condemns the legacy of racism in housing, education, employment, economic development, and health. 142 It offers an apology for perpetuating racial inequity and establishes a planning commission to make recommendations "that will make significant progress toward repairing the damage caused by public and private systemic Racism." 14 3 Evanston, Illinois, passed a reparations resolution in 2019,144 following the City Council's adoption of "a resolution affirning the City's commitment to end structural racism and achieve racial equity."1 4 5 The City has since held community meetings to gather public input on reparations, created a city council subcommittee to begin the reparations planning process, committed to use tax revenue collected from recreational cannabis sales to support reparations, and begun to identify areas of civic life to be supported by reparations.1 46 Following additional planning, distributions from the Reparations Fund are expected in the foreseeable future, with applications for distributions in amounts up to $25,000 available by mid-summer 2021.147 In September 2020, California became the first state government in the country to enact legislation to study and craft reparations proposals for slavery and its effects. 14 8 State legislators in Texas, New York, 14 9 Vermont, 15 0 and Pennsylvania15 1 have likewise announced or "introduced legislation that would apologize for their state's role in slavery; recognize the lasting, negative impact of slavery on current generations of African Americans; and explore monetary reparations."1 5 2 Advocates can lend their expertise, but of even greater value, they can listen, observe, and support. Putting the theoretical into practice can reveal what is possible.15 3 By examining the elements of local reparations movements and programs, advocates can address the concern that acknowledging and atoning for the harms of enslavement will deepen racial divisions. 154 The multi-faceted nature of racial inequality requires a dynamic response. Reparations advocates can draw on what has worked at the local level, while dispensing with that which has proven unworkable or inadvisable. Such efforts can also help assuage concerns that the financial cost is unbearable, unquantifiable, or cannot be borne by government revenue. Local reparations programs that seek to remedy racial inequality in the criminal legal system, education, employment, and health can provide models of success for national reparations programs. These examples tell all those willing to listen that reparations are not only possible, but that reparative justice can be transformative. The experience can help to alleviate the fears, apprehensions, and disagreements that make reparations so difficult to obtain. They can allow us-on a small scale-to reckon with our past, shift consciousness, learn lessons, and proceed with the elusive task of continuing to heal the national wounds that have long plagued America. 155 C. Apply Interest Convergence to Press for Wholesale Change In Part II, I described why the COVID-19 pandemic and uprisings for racial justice presented a unique opportunity to advance reparative justice. Leveraging the moment will require, among other things, "transforming the vision of a minority into a consensus acknowledged and embraced by the majority."1 5 6 A sizeable number of Americans-including the politically powerful-must come to understand that the relief reparations provide to Black people are in the interest of our nation. Fundamentally, this is a restatement of Professor Derrick Bell's interest convergence principle, which asserts that relief from racial discrimination, when it comes, requires that policy makers perceive the relief we seek will provide a clear benefit for the nation or portions of the populace beyond African Americans. No matter how harmful, exploitative, or life threatening a racist policy or practice is, petitions for reform are recognized and implemented only so long as they advance the nation's interests.157 In other words, convincing people that reparations are owed to Black people in light of America's history of racial genocide and terror is not by itself going to be enough. 158 Moral arguments are compelling, but substantive progress will only be made when Americans come to understand that reparative justice has value for all. It is of course true that "[t]he arguments that victims will have to make and perpetrators will have to accept before any reparations are awarded will raise consciousnesses about the obligation and need to correct past wrongs."1 59 After all, the object of "reparations is at its heart transformative. It recognizes the crimes of the powerful against the powerless. It condemns exploitation and adopts a vision of a more just world." 16 0 But it is only at the point when the powerful and the masses feel reparations are appropriate and in their interest that they will come. 16 1 And if that is the case, and we want reparations to be more than a financial payoff and a half-hearted apology when they arrive, subject to widespread resistance that undermines the value of those offerings, advocates must work alongside and in support of movements to change the calculus of what is in our nation's interests, leveraging the opportunity presented by crises-like those we are currently mired in-to do so. 162 One might bolster such a focus by engaging in advocacy that highlights, for example, the net positive impact of reparative justice policies on America as a whole, even as those policies are explicitly aimed only at the descendants of the enslaved. For example, some estimate that the racial wealth gap's "dampening effect on consumption and investment will cost the US economy between $1 trillion and $1.5 trillion between 2019 and 2028-4 to 6 percent of the projected GDP in 2028."163 If reparations were deployed to reduce, and ultimately eradicate the racial wealth gap that began at America's birth, 164 the American economy would be improved for many. 16 5 Government efforts to redress a legacy of racial inequality would require investments in education, health, justice, housing, and other facets of life with an eye toward equality for all. 166 These types of net gains could produce the support needed to make reparations a reality. The interests among advocates for reparations are converging with those of the growing portion of the population who have had their beliefs about America shaken by its failings and who are compelled by a need to repair our past; this convergence can be transformative. Both are motivated to remake our nation and create a new status quo. Advocates must leverage the alignment of such interests, make racial justice central in all that they do, and seek wholesale changes to American society to confront and address the nation's original sin. V. CONCLUSION The health and racial injustice crises we face have exposed the contradiction that haunts our country: a democracy where race and identity are used to justify the inequitable structure of society.1 6 7 Symbolically and tangibly, confronting this contradiction may lead us to topple the status quo, paving the way for us all to create something entirely new. Imagining the resistance to reparations allows advocates to engage in work that will bring America closer to reparative justice. By raising consciousness, taking concrete steps toward reparations now, and applying interest convergence, we may end up with a more just future, and with it, a better country than the one we currently inhabit.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Universality PIC › PIC – 1NC

Financial Reparations should be given to AFRICAN AMERICANS and those of AFRICAN DESCENT In the US.

NAACP 19. “Reparations.” NAACP, June 2019, naacp.org/resources/reparations. Accessed 19 July 2023. ID.ELC

WHEREAS, in the first order, the NAACP should support reparations for Black people in the United States. We need a race-centered economic empowerment package for African Americans that builds generational wealth and accounts for not only slavery but the decades upon decades of economic pillaging. Colorlines, a publication run by Race Forward. reported that "the U.S. government spends bill ions subsidizing fanning in America, yet Black farmers today receive only one-third to one-sixth of that... and the Southern Rural Development Initiative found that less than I percent of agriculture subsidy payments between 2001 and 2003 went to Blacks, Native Americans and Asian Americans." Worse inequality has only grown since the Great Depression wiped out any gains black people made in the post-civil rights era. Today, without intervention, it would take an African-American household 228 years to build the same amount of wealth as our white counterparts. Second, in determining what form reparations should take, the United States government should be required to atone in the following way: Reparations would involve a national apology, rights to the cannabis industry, financial payment, social service benefits, and land grants to every descendant of an enslaved African American and Black person a descendant of those living in the United States including during American slavery until the Jim Crow era. 1965. Because slavery involved kidnapping, barbarism, and the stripping of language, culture and heritage, many Black people are unaware of their specific African heritage and which country in fact their ancestors were stolen from. The forged documentation, lack of documentation or non-existent documentation, from birth certificates to slave manifest, be it resolved that eligibility for these reparations requires the following: people that were born in the United States or naturalized citizens that have noted their Black heritage on the census, identify as Black on their birth certificate and/or have documentation of enslaved parentage in the United States, documentation of parentage residing in the United States prior to and during the Jim Crow era, and currently identify as Black American or African American. Identification of African-American heritage is both a biological and physical representation of being African-American on a daily basis. Land grant of 40 acres: Each family of 3 or more individuals (parents & children) shall be granted 40 acres of tillable land. No taxes to be paid on the property for 5 years from the date the land is first bequeathed by the government. If taxes are not paid on the land or land is taken for any other reason (criminal seizure), those of African descent are to be given the first right of refusal and opportunity to purchase the land. Publication of land availability must be in place for one year from the date of tax lien is issued on the property. If after one year, no person of African descent (eligible based on the same criteria listed for reparation eligibility), then the land may be sold to an individual of Non-African descent. Social Services: Due to the disparity in life expectancy, that the descendants of enslaved people should be eligible earlier for receipt of benefits from Social Security, access to Medicare and other old age programs including store discounts, after participating in the workforce. The age for inclusion in these benefits distributions should be lowered by the difference in the life expectancy for African Americans as set within accepted insurance mortality tables. That the county including the Congress of the Unites States is aware of these discrepancies in mortality is evidenced by movements initiated during the George Bush, Jr. administration whereas the move to privatize social security was debated, part of the justification for the move was presented as an effort to make the system "benefit" African Americans in wealth creation by having African Americans in particular and all Americans "own" their wealth rather than dying and having less or nothing to leave to their descendants. WHEREAS, there needs to be a national reckoning, new policies and structures and systemic structural changes, the NAACP submits reparations are the first step in repairing the devastation inflicted by slavery and racial discrimination. Ultimately when the Black community as a whole is excelling the country excels. THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the NAACP reaffirms and stands in favor of financial reparations to African Americans and those of African Descent in the United States that are descendants of the slavery and the Jim Crow Era.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Radical Reparations K › Disability Reading Alt

The Alternative is Disability Justice as the foregrounds to understanding the role Reparations projects must have globally. Táíwò 22 (“Reconsidering Reparations”, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò. January 20th 2022, Pg.93-94, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò is Associate Professor of Philosophy at Georgetown University. He received his Ph.D. in philosophy at the University of California Los Angeles https://global.oup.com/academic/product/reconsidering-reparations-9780197508893?cc=us&lang=en&) HSLA: RP

This helps us shift our perspective in a general way. We no longer need to ask how many resources or goods to distribute to Pedro, who uses a wheelchair, to give him a bundle of “primary goods” equivalent to Royce’s, who can walk. Rather than focusing narrowly on evaluating how primary goods are distributed and focusing on those inequalities, we could just as well ask how stairs and ramps are distributed—in other words we should focus on what the fact that Pedro uses a wheelchair means in terms of his capabilities and functionings, and thus for his freedom. The fact about where the ramps and stairs are and how they are geographically distributed is a fact about our built social environment itself. Thus, a worldmaking perspective endows us with the mission, not simply of distributing “stuff ” in order for everyone to have equal amounts of it, but rather of creating a world where the variations we are born with are all socially translated into lives rich in capabilities.

Justice, then, sometimes literally comes down to a construction project. Among the things we need to produce and distribute are practical affordances: parts of the built environment that make it navigable and usable by people with a wide range of abilities. The question of which buildings are accessible to wheelchair users (for example) and which are not depends on design choices in the built environment—choices made by people. This has long been noticed by activists working for disability justice, such as architect Ronald Mace, who was influential in the development of the idea of ‘universal design’: the “design of products and environments to be usable to the greatest extent possible by people of all ages and abilities.”48 Just like the anti-colonial activists and revolutionaries of the 1960s and 1970s, disability justice activists, too, want to literally remake the world. Both the ethos and the concrete goals of disability justice help direct the constructive view of reparations in response to global racial empire and in the search of justice.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Radical Reparations K › Capabilties Approach Alt

The Alternative is a Capabilities Approach to Reparations. Táíwò 22 (“Reconsidering Reparations”, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò. January 20th 2022, Pg.88, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò is Associate Professor of Philosophy at Georgetown University. He received his Ph.D. in philosophy at the University of California Los Angeles https://global.oup.com/academic/product/reconsidering-reparations-9780197508893?cc=us&lang=en&) HSLA: RP

Nobel prize–winning economist and philosopher Amartya Sen took a different approach, believing that we can and should attempt to measure the intrinsic good we are after more directly. I will address what kind of intrinsic good the constructive view wants to target a little further down the road, but for the moment, following Sen, we will use “freedom” to denote the target intrinsic good for which social justice should strive. So how do we measure someone’s freedom? To answer this question, Sen joined forces with fellow philosopher Martha Nussbaum, and together they developed the “capabilities approach.”

Broadly speaking, I agree that the capabilities approach is on the right track, and will use it to help us build our constructive approach to reparations. The capabilities approach has the benefit not only of focusing more sharply on the actual outcomes we want than do resourcist approaches, but also of helping us to more effectively deconstruct the interactions of the complex factors that feed into those outcomes.

Those who take the capabilities approach tend to talk about two main categories of things: capabilities and functionings.32 Functionings comprise “beings and doings”: for example, the state of being wellnourished, the action of eating food.33 Capabilities are the capacities to achieve functionings: in this case, the physical ability to feed one’s self and the financial and environmental ability to access nourishing food. We can think of ‘advantages’ and ‘disadvantages’ as discussed in the previous chapter in capabilities terms: advantages are things that expand or support a person’s capabilities, while disadvantages do the opposite

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Radical Reparations K › Alternative – 2NC

The Alternative is a reimagining of the role reparations in breaking the post-WW2 anti-black colonial order. Táíwò 22 (“Reconsidering Reparations”, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò. January 20th 2022, Pg.69-72, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò is Associate Professor of Philosophy at Georgetown University. He received his Ph.D. in philosophy at the University of California Los Angeles https://global.oup.com/academic/product/reconsidering-reparations-9780197508893?cc=us&lang=en&) HSLA: RP

In the decades following the Second World War, the globe underwent massive transformation. It was possible then to believe that the global colonial system was cracking, and possible to believe it was ready to crumble. Ultimately, however, while some meaningful power changed hands and the globe’s political architecture adjusted, the core of the system proved resilient. The channels distributing wealth, political rights, and violence around the globe continued to operate as new enforcement mechanisms arose, ranging from overt and formally acknowledged levers of power and influence (including the International Monetary Fund and World Bank) to the covert tactics of spycraft and propaganda that characterized the political conflict of the Cold War. The mid-twentieth century started the remaking of the world but it only got so far. The project of reparations is to finish the job.

In 1946, the year immediately following the disastrous global conflict, there were only 35 member nations of the United Nations. But the devastation of the World War spelled opportunity for the colonized of the world. The British Empire, which had ruled over a quarter of the world’s population and land before the war, was eclipsed in power by the United States and the Soviet Union.1 Other major imperial powers were in similarly dire economic and political straits, most notably the French and German states. Resistance was immediate and impossible to contain. A wave of movements seized the opportunity and rebelled, with tactics ranging from insider negotiations to open warfare. When the dust settled in 1970, the number of member-states in the United Nations had nearly quadrupled, from 35 to 127.2

Resistance often took the immediate form of a struggle for national independence. In the Third World, the colonial overlords were pushed out, time and again: a Vietnamese army defeated the French at Dien Bien Phu, and Algeria outlasted them in a war of attrition; Cape Verde, Guinea-Bissau, Angola, and Mozambique fought successful, linked wars against their Portuguese overlord; in Kenya, the Mau Mau rebellion violently opposed the rule of Britain, which was still smarting from its disastrous 1947 exit from the Indian subcontinent.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Radical Reparations K › Alternative – 2NC

The Alternative is a Black Cosmo-Constructive reading of Reparations - Key to addressing the global racial empire. Táíwò 22 (“Reconsidering Reparations”, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò. January 20th 2022, Pg. 84-85, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò is Associate Professor of Philosophy at Georgetown University. He received his Ph.D. in philosophy at the University of California Los Angeles https://global.oup.com/academic/product/reconsidering-reparations-9780197508893?cc=us&lang=en&) HSLA: RP

An organizing principle of Rawls’s thought is the idea that distributive justice concerns arrangements of people or associations. Justice is bound up with the idea of fairness, and fairness is bound up with the idea of being co-members of some kind of scheme of cooperation—for Rawls, the society. Rawls then develops a view of distributive justice that focuses on idealized closed societies because he believes this is the form of association between people that could explain duties to redistribute. In my view, among the mistakes Rawls and other authors made in ignoring the history of global racial empire is a mischaracterization of what states actually are, and in what sense they are separate from each other.23

Cosmopolitan approaches to distributive justice advocated by other thinkers aim to remedy the curious generalizations of a Rawlsian view. Some cosmopolitans advocate for global redistribution and intervention on grounds that ignore institutional separations of people altogether, preferring universal moral commitments to equality or dignity as the explanation for why the well-off should change things for the benefit of the worse off.24 But this book argues for a different kind of cosmopolitan view: one that looks at specific global superstructures— institutions, associations, chains of production, and norms—to ground a distributive justice analysis for specific historical reasons.25 The constructive view of reparations is cosmopolitan in this sense.

The global racial empire began with the development of the Atlantic order in the fifteenth century. This history maps where the social advantages and disadvantages of the global economic and political system have accumulated.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Radical Reparations K › Impact

Yes, Root Cause – Only understanding the global racial empire and the role reparations plays in it can realize historic and current U.S imposed anti-blackness. Táíwò 22 (“Reconsidering Reparations”, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò. January 20th 2022, Pg.33-34, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò is Associate Professor of Philosophy at Georgetown University. He received his Ph.D. in philosophy at the University of California Los Angeles https://global.oup.com/academic/product/reconsidering-reparations-9780197508893?cc=us&lang=en&) HSLA: RP

So understanding that our present world order is one that was built as a global racial empire helps us explain where advantage and disadvantage accumulates and for whom. Cumulative advantage and disadvantage are potential features of social systems of any size. But it is important to remember that we happen to live in one big global social system, so these patterns occur at massive as well as micro scales.

The system distributes social advantages such as wealth, bargaining power, prestige, and even attention toward certain parts of the world and certain populations within those regions. At a global scale, these forces shift advantages across countries and continents, toward the so called Global North. Disadvantages are shunted toward the developing nations, the Global South. At a lower scale, viewed within countries or regions, the order of things tends to shift advantages toward people racialized as white and disadvantages toward Indigenous peoples and those racialized as Black.

The global and the national scales are deeply related in ways that invite more nationally or regionally focused views of reparations. In fact, they often seem to have a sort of fractal structure—the racial realities visible at small scales, in the interactions and distributions of power and vulnerability within nations or communities, re-appear when analyzing relationships between nations or world regions. African American scholar W. E. B. Du Bois expressed this idea powerfully when he used “the Color Line” to explain divides between Black and white individuals in nineteenth century United States, as well as the geopolitical lines of power and conflict. The US Civil War—an internal battle over the institution of slavery in the world’s most powerful “slave power”—provides an excellent example of the connections between national and global politics that DuBois described.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Radical Reparations K › Links – 2NC

The way they retrace black history in America only reenforces notions of white history that refuses to understand how historical and current anti-blackness globally implicates and expands U.S violence. Harriot 22 (“Top 10 reasons why lineage-based reparations is a bad plan”, April 13th 2022, Michael Harriot, A journalist, poet, author, and storyteller that writes about political, economic, and social habits, especially in terms of white politics in relation to inequity, https://reparationscomm.org/reparations-news/10-reasons-why-lineage-based-reparations-is-a-bad-plan/#source) HSLA: RP

10. It is based on white history.

First of all, the bill states that “More than 4,000,000 Africans and their descendants were enslaved in the United States and the colonies that became the United States from 1619 to 1865,” which excludes the descendants of Africans who were enslaved in America by anyone other than English settlers who showed up a century after Europeans arrived on the continent with enslaved Africans. We still don’t know what happened to the Africans who revolted in the Spanish colony of San Miguel de Gualdape in 1526. Historians speculate that they may be living in North Carolina but are we to think, in 500 years, none of those people made it to California?

It also rests on the tenuous definition of “descendant” and the actual definition of African-American, which doesn’t actually exist because race is just something white people made up.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Radical Reparations K › Links – 2NC

The Racial Contract builds global socioeconomic privilege that implicates national level anti-blackness – The Political imaginary of reparations must be bigger than national level wealth. Táíwò 22 (“Reconsidering Reparations”, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò. January 20th 2022, Pg.24-26, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò is Associate Professor of Philosophy at Georgetown University. He received his Ph.D. in philosophy at the University of California Los Angeles https://global.oup.com/academic/product/reconsidering-reparations-9780197508893?cc=us&lang=en&) HSLA: RP

In his landmark 1994 book The Racial Contract, philosopher Charles Mills borrows the “social contract” language of liberal political thought to make this same claim about the basic organization of the world’s social structures. He argues that we live in a world “built by the Racial Contract”; that is, “global white supremacy” is itself a political system, the one resulting from the fact that the world has been “foundationally shaped for the past five hundred years by the . . . gradual consolidation of global white supremacy.”28 Mills characterizes that political system in comprehensive, distributive terms, describing it as “a particular power structure of formal or informal rule, socioeconomic privilege, and norms for the differential distribution of material wealth and opportunities, benefits and burdens, rights and duties.”29 This book contends that he is correct.

As this chapter moves forward to explain the structure of today’s world in terms of the historical motions it embodies, it will be helpful to pause first to highlight a key pair of concepts that we will return to throughout the book—cumulative advantage and cumulative disadvantage.

Cumulative Processes

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Radical Reparations K › 1NC

3.The Alternative is Reparations in the Constructivist view - a Black Radical Reparations project. Táíwò 22 (“Reconsidering Reparations”, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò. January 20th 2022, Pg.1 , Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò is Associate Professor of Philosophy at Georgetown University. He received his Ph.D. in philosophy at the University of California Los Angeles https://global.oup.com/academic/product/reconsidering-reparations-9780197508893?cc=us&lang=en&) HSLA: RP

Here, Coates, or I myself, might have been surprised. At least some of those things are precisely what we want from reparations. Hughes exploits a haze of ambiguity around reparations: what are they about? Adolph Reed, Jr. describes the call for reparations for African Americans as a blend of “material, symbolic, and psychological components.”4 Reed explains that the United States’s long history of slavery and racial economic apartheid has cost African Americans in direct and indirect “material” ways, which include racially discriminatory lending practices, as well as the violent exclusion of Blacks from voting and other aspects of public political life. Reparations projects that involve financial payment of some kind might go some distance toward remedying this. But also important are means of addressing impersonal material considerations such as political representation, as well as attempts to counter symbolic injustices, such as monuments and memorials that continue to propagate the ideology of global racism. Finally, some proponents of reparations believe that they will raise collective racial consciousness and provide tools to address social pathologies that are related to the painful history of slavery and racial domination.

Reed thinks the ambiguity caused by these separate categories of goals is a liability, since elites can then exploit it by choosing the version of reparations that is cheapest for them: the symbolic. We have already seen this tendency at work: in Washington, D.C., the capital of the United States, the mayor decided to paint “Black Lives Matter” on the plaza in front of the White House, in response to the 2020 summer of protests against racist police violence. There, mere days later, law enforcement continued to brutalize protestors while the mayor supported a multimillion dollar budget increase to their budget.5 More important, overinvestment from any level of society into such symbolic reparations could detract energy and resources from an alternative, preferable political project: “building broad solidarity across race, gender, and other identities around shared concerns of daily life” like “access to quality health care, the right to a decent and dignified livelihood, affordable housing, quality education for all.” Here, Reed sounds the alarm later raised by Hughes—that the call for reparations for some distracts from a more worthy political project that would provide justice for all.

But what if the project for reparations was the project for “safer neighborhoods and better schools,” for a “less punitive justice system,” for “the right to a decent and dignified livelihood”? What if building the just world was reparations? Indeed, this book will ask, what other form of reparations could even be meaningful in the context of our reality?

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › Case › Universal Ethics Bad/Impossible

Universal ethics are illogical

Abun et al. 22 (Damianus Abun is a professor at Divine Word College of Laoag, Margarita A. Galat is a senior instructor at Divine Word College of Laoag, Stephen G. Guzon is an instructor from Divine Word College of Laoag, “A Critical Review of Moral Relativism, Universalism, and the Teaching of the Catholic Church on Catholic Morality,” 11-26-22, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4294591#:~:text=No%20society%20is%20considered%20better,been%20existing%20a%20long%20time.)[MO})

However, it has always been criticized that universalist morality does not give moral agents the freedom to exercise moral judgment. It disregards the cultural values that have been existing a long time. Some have argued that without free will, the universe is deterministic and morally uninteresting. If all moral choices and behavior are determined by outside forces, there can be no need for any person to ponder morality (LaFollette, 1991). The main concern is absolute morals and their sources are subject to human interpretations. It is emphasized that for morals to be truly absolute, they would have a universally unquestioned source, interpretation, and authority. Thus, the critics say, there is no conceivable source of such morals; there will never be universal agreement on what those morals are. However, Catholic Church has the answer. It has the authority to pronounce and interpret moral issues affecting human life through its magisterium.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › Case › Wealth Tax Bad/Won’t Work

Wealth taxes hurt those it’s supposed to help

PRI 22 (Pacific Research Institute is an organization whose mission is to advance free-market policy solutions, “Wealth Taxes are Economic Failures,” 3-11-22, https://www.pacificresearch.org/wealth-taxes-are-economic-failures)[MO]

By design, the wealth tax will further increase this tax burden. Should the affluent abandon California because of the greater drain on their assets – and history shows this will happen – they will take with them the dollars needed to fund schools, public safety, health care, and other public services utilized by Californians. Investment in the state economy, which creates jobs and wealth across all classes, should also decline.

This won’t hurt the moneyed residents who leave. They will be fine. The damage will be felt in the lower and middle classes.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › Case › Wealth Tax Bad/Won’t Work

Wealth taxes are not effective and almost impossible to implement

Schrager 2/2 (Allison Schrager is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist on economics, “Wealth Taxes Have Always Been a Terrible Idea,” 2-2-23, https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/wealth-taxes-have-always-been-a-terrible-idea/2023/02/02/f6a63b1e-a2ea-11ed-8b47-9863fda8e494_story.html)[MO]

But even if you don’t think such things are important, the wealth tax bills are a bad idea because they’ll be impossible to implement effectively. They may not even be constitutional. But they’re certainly impractical. Income is relatively easy to measure: Your employer sends you a regular paycheck that can be documented and has an objective value.

Overall wealth, and unrealized capital gains in particular, are much harder to measure. On what day do you assess the tax liability? What if asset values fall between when the tax is assessed and the tax bill is due? If the result of such a tax is that people sell their stocks and bonds around the same time each year to pay their tax bills and just generally lower the return on investments, it can depress asset values for everyone, not just the wealthy.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › Case › Wealth Tax Bad/Won’t Work

A wealth tax will have negative effects on the economy

Epstein 1/24 (Richard Epstein writes about constitutional and economical subjects, “The Wealth Tax is a Poor Idea,” 1-24-23, https://www.hoover.org/research/wealth-tax-poor-idea#:~:text=Think%20of%20the%20wealth%20tax,one%20may%20take%20multiple%20years)[MO] The wealth tax stands in sharp contrast to this long-standing practice. Generally, rich people have diverse holdings because they have the resources to cultivate them. Many such assets, like artwork or fractional interests in a family corporation, are nearly impossible to value, impossible to sell, or both. The nonrecognition rules thus keep them out of the tax system. Today, however, we have an estate tax that requires individuals to include in their gross estate all of these difficult-to-value items, which often makes it impossible to settle a tax dispute on large estates in less than several years. Think of the wealth tax as if it were an estate tax imposed on an annual basis, but with the added logistical headache of being impossible to calculate in year two until the tax liability for year one has been established, and that establishing the tax for year one may take multiple years. These administrative burdens pile up in individual cases, and they become larger the wider the net is extended around the asset base.

At this point, the acute tradeoff becomes clear: the only reliable asset class for wealth-taxation purposes is publicly traded stocks and bonds, which of course can decline rapidly in value after the tax is imposed, but also before it is collected. (Think of the position of Elon Musk and others in the class of 2022.) Necessarily, that type of tax will miss the portion of their wealth that they hold in unlisted and illiquid assets, and thus will not satisfy progressives for whom depriving the rich of wealth is every bit as important as providing additional income to the poor. National wealth taxes face this difficulty, which poses an even greater challenge for a state wealth tax, with its more limited territorial reach.

The revenue collected will fall short of expectations. Worse, the tax will damage the economy. Today’s ablest entrepreneurs will be forced to devote their time to defending their fortunes against the predation by the one or more states that lay claim to their wealth. Wealth creation and income from other sources will both fall as administrative expenses and high-stakes litigation rise. An overall decline in social wealth will likely lead to a reduction of investment and wages and consequently to a lower standard of living and a loss of tax revenues from other sources.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › Case › Reparations Impossible/Bad

Some of us truly don't want them

Owens 19 [Owens, "I didn't Earn Slavery I Don't Want Them", 2019, Wall Street Journal, https://www.wsj.com/articles/i-didnt-earn-slavery-reparations-and-i-dont-want-them-11558732429]

My great-great-grandfather Silas Burgess came to America shackled in the belly of a slave ship. He was sold on an auction block in Charleston, S.C., to the Burgess Plantation. Orphaned by age 8, he was fortunately surrounded by elder slaves who, though physically chained, mentally envisioned themselves as free men. They escaped, taking young Silas with them, making their way to West Texas via the southern route of the Underground Railroad. Silas became a risk-taking entrepreneur and the owner of 102 acres of farmland, which he cultivated and paid off within two years. I proudly carry the name of my first American ancestor—who, like millions of others drawn or brought to our country, struggled past overwhelming obstacles to live the American Dream. Silas founded the first black church and first black elementary school in his town. He was a proud Republican, a devout Christian, the patriarch of a large family, and a pillar of his community. He was proud and industrious and taught his children to be the same. Now, because of him, a bunch of Democratic presidential hopefuls want to give me money. Never mind that like Silas, I am an entrepreneur who has lived the American dream—having received a world-class education, built businesses, raised a remarkable family and, unlike most white Americans, earned a Super Bowl ring. Because of work I’ve never done, stripes I’ve never had, under a whip I’ll never know, Kamala Harris, Beto O’Rourke, Elizabeth Warren and others want to give me free stuff. Never mind that it will be taken from others, who also dreamed, worked and sacrificed to earn it. I wonder what great-great-grandpa Silas would think. At the core of the reparation movement is a divisive and demeaning view of both races. It grants to the white race a wicked superiority, treating them as an oppressive people too powerful for black Americans to overcome. It brands blacks as hapless victims devoid of the ability, which every other culture possesses, to assimilate and progress. Neither label is earned. The reparations movement conveniently forgets the 150 years of legal, social and economic progress attained by millions of American minorities. It also minimizes the sacrifice that hundreds of thousands of white Americans and a Republican president made laying down their lives to eradicate slavery. I think grandpa Silas would believe that this historical loss of life alone is payment in full. Every proud, contributing and thankful generation of black Americans since would think the same. The reparation movement also reinforces a spiritual view of racial relationships that is antithetical to America’s Judeo-Christian foundation. It defies the ideals of forgiveness and second chances and scorns individual accountability. Proponents of reparations act as though black Americans are incapable of carrying their own burdens, while white Americans must bear the sins of those who came before. The idea of reparations demeans America’s founding ideals. A culturally Marxist idea promoted by socialists, reparations denies the promise granted by an omnipotent God that we are truly equal and that regardless of race we are capable of overcoming obstacles and past injustices. By indoctrinating others into this cynical ideology, an elitist class of progressives exploits past differences and ensures that they will divide us in the future. It is their divisive message that marks the black race as forever broken, as a people whose healing comes only through the guilt, pity, profits and benevolence of the white race. This perception is playing out on our nation’s college campuses, where young white Americans claim privilege due to their skin color and young black Americans, with no apparent shame, accept this demeaning of their own color as truth. As they repeat this mantra, they seem unaware that this perception was also shared by the 1960s Southern white supremacists of my youth. They have accepted the theory that skin color alone is capable of making one race superior to the other—that through an irremovable white advantage, with no additional effort, values, personal initiative, honesty or education, white Americans will succeed, while black Americans will fail. At its very core this represents the condescending evil of racism. It certainly does not represent black America’s potential. Despite the Great Society programs that introduced all sorts of perverse, dependency-inducing, and antifamily incentives into the black community some 50 years ago, 40% of black households today live the middle-class American Dream according to the most recent census data, making between $35,000 and $99,999. Many rank among our nation’s most powerful and prestigious. There are tens of thousands of black Americans among our nation’s top 1% of income earners. The journeys of these Americans to wealth and prominence vary, like those of their white counterparts, but many benefited from having ancestors who embraced the opportunities their country provided and who left behind a legacy of proud, productive, patriotic and successful families. Why should these people be given a handout? Grandpa Silas never believed anyone owed him success. Why should I believe white Americans owe me anything? Socialist historians have for generations hidden the contributions and success of the black community in America. This has cost us our pride in our past, taken our appreciation for the present, and left us with a lack of vision for our future. The message from our past great black generations is simple: Character cannot be bought and will never allow itself to be diminished by bribery. Grandpa Silas’s life expectancy was 36. Mine is almost 76. According to a recent report from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, by living past 65, my life expectancy may be longer than whites of the same age. Which I guess is good, if reparations advocates are going to make me spend grandpa’s money.