Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › Case › Reparations Impossible/Bad

UBI is modern day sharecropping because it’s designed for black folk so that they stay dependent on the state, and never actually gain material wealth. The racist histories of the US are so intertwined with the approach to policies, that any type of fiscal redistribution is AND WILL ALWAYS BE antiblack.

Hamilton ‘19 [Brian Hamilton November 20, 2019; Brian Hamilton is an American entrepreneur and philanthropist. He is founder of the philanthropic organizations "Inmates to Entrepreneurs" and the "Brian Hamilton Foundation.]

But UBI is a lazy solution that fails to solve the real problem: how to give people an opportunity to create wealth. We need to get more people invested in our country as owners of real things that create this wealth—things like real estate, businesses, cars. Otherwise, like in the days of sharecropping, we risk continuing to have a whole class of people who are merely being sustained, but not given the chance for real economic advancement. After the Civil War, the southern region of the US was left destitute to a degree barely imaginable by today’s standards. Since the economic model of the south was heavily reliant on slave labor, the region’s economy was struggling to survive after the abolition of slavery. The answer? Sharecropping. The practice of giving people a modicum of economic incentives, where they could subsist at a low-income level, but where it was impossible for them to rise permanently, defined American poverty for decades. In the sharecropping system, a person would rent land from an owner and farm that plot. A “share” of the profits was also provided to the landlord/owner. Rents were set to make economic profit impossible. So, sharecroppers survived through very hard work, but they could not statistically rise as a group. As a result, people never became owners, which is a basic tenet of economic advancement. From an economic vantage point, sharecropping resembled a form of slavery, except that it also enveloped poor white people.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › Case › Reparations Impossible/Bad

Fiscal reparations won’t solve. Black people have been suffering since the beginning of social security’s creation, excluded from buying homes and retirement age stability. The effects of the social security’s systemic racism continue to exist.

Worland ‘20 [Worland, Justin. senior correspondent at TIME in the Washington, D.C. bureau. He received Covering Climate Now's inaugural Climate Journalist of the Year award in 2022, among other awards. (2020, June 11). America’s long overdue awakening on systemic racism. Time. https://time.com/5851855/systemic-racism-america/ C.T]

That’s the ugly history most Americans know and acknowledge. But systemic racism also found its way, more insidiously, into the institutions many Americans revere and seek to safe-guard. Established in the 1930s, Social Security helped ensure a stable old age for most Americans, but it initially excluded domestic and agricultural workers, leaving behind two-thirds of black Americans. Federal mortgage lending programs helped white Americans buy homes after World War II, but black Americans suffered from a shameful catch-22. Federal policy said that the very presence of a black resident in a neighborhood reduced the value of the homes there, effectively prohibiting African-American residents from borrowing money to buy a home. And sentencing laws of the past several decades meant that poor black Americans were thrown in prison for decades-long terms for consuming one type of cocaine while their wealthier white counterparts got a slap on the wrist for consuming another. There’s a straight line between these policies and the state of black America today. The lack of Social Security kept black Americans toiling in old age or forced them to the streets. The obstruction of black homeownership, among other factors, has left African Americans poorer and more economically vulnerable, with the average black household worth $17,000 in 2016 while the average white household was worth 10 times that. “Tough on crime” sentencing policies have ballooned the black prison population, torn apart families and left millions of children to grow up in single-parent homes.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › Case › Reparations Impossible/Bad

No quantifiable fiscal reparation can be made in exchange for immeasurable Black trauma caused by slavery

Bazelon et al ’23 (Coleman, Dr. Bazelon frequently advises regulatory and legislative bodies, including the US Federal Communications Commission and the US Congress. June. 8 “Quantification of Reparations for Transatlantic Chattel Slavery”, https://www.brattle.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Quantification-of-Reparations-for-Transatlantic-Chattel-Slavery.pdf accessed Jul. 10. Brattle) [AH]

The analyses above quantified harms during the period of enslavement related to lost labor, lost life, loss of liberty through false imprisonment, personal injury, and gender-based violence. There were additional harms inflicted upon the enslaved that are not (fully) captured by those estimates, including psychological mistreatment and deprivation of social and political life. Unfortunately, data limitations prevented us from quantifying these harms. These harms are important and we address them briefly below. Since legal institutions considered enslaved persons to be property, the enslaved could not fully participate in social and political affairs.81 As Professor Beckles notes: [D]ivisions and lack of egalitarianism […] made the Atlantic World deeply unstable. [Enslaved persons] were not incorporated into the Atlantic World as citizens with equal rights, but as chattel, enslaved, and as the inferior ‘Other’.82 Enslaved people were forced to leave their own families and cultural traditions behind and adopt European customs, religion, and language, furthering their isolation.83 Even as countries of formerly enslaved persons established their own governance systems post-independence, they faced issues of sovereignty from former colonizing powers, economic hardships, and hostility in an overwhelmingly racist global arena.84 Further, enslaved individuals faced incalculable physical, psychological, sexual, and emotional trauma that cannot be quantified.85 As Judge Patrick Robinson86 notes: [O]ne does not have to be a devotee of the Olympics of the oppressed to be able to agree that transatlantic chattel slavery as an atrocity exemplifying man’s inhumanity to man has never been surpassed… [A]s an atrocity, transatlantic chattel slavery was: striking for its duration of over four hundred years [and] unmatched for its barbarity.87 Underpinning this maltreatment was the institutionalized dehumanization of African people. As Professor Beckles notes: [The slave trade] fed the most barbaric system of human bondage the world had seen. Africans were reduced by slave relations to the legal status of nonhumans […] property, chattel, and real estate […] They had no right to life; their existence as social beings was at the pleasure of owners whose rights over them were effectively unlimited.88 Slavery had incalculable effects on the psyche of those it dominated and dehumanized, potentially leading to the internalization of Black “inferiority.”89 Racial ethnic groups have developed internal discrimination towards each other with a preference for whiteness90, a phenomenon bred out of slavery called colorism. 91 As Professor Beckles notes, “[t]hese sociolegal perceptions of Africans, and the punishments they received, reflected the British definition of them as property…nonhumans deserving of their enslavement.”92 In every aspect of life, the enslaved were reduced to nonbeings.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › States CP › 2NC – Solvency

The states need to atone through reparations EVEN MORE than the USFG – their representatives left federal legislature incomplete in order to protect their state powers to continue the horror of enslavement.

Mulcare ’06 [Dr. Mulcare received his Ph.D. from the New School for Social Research. Prior to his time as a professor in Politics, Policy and International Relations at Salem State University, Dr. Mulcare taught at Temple University, Hunter College, New York University, and Eugene Lang College. He is an active member of the American Political Science Association. In 2014, he received the Outstanding Faculty Award. He teaches courses on American political institutions (the U.S. Congress, judicial system, presidency, and political parties) as well as specific policy areas (immigration and U.S. racial politics). He also teaches the department's Honor's course. Mulcare, Daniel. “Slavery.” Slavery - Federalism in America, 2006, encyclopedia.federalism.org/index.php/Slavery. ]

Many southern representatives to the Convention resembled their northern counterparts in their desire to change the Articles of Confederation; both viewed the document as creating a government incapable of defending the country or promoting national and foreign trade. Under the Constitution, they increased the powers granted to the federal government. Southerners were also intent on insuring that the federal government had little control over slavery within state borders. Some delegates declared that unless slavery was protected, they could not endorse the Constitution’s ratification. On the issue of representation, considerable debate occurred over whether slaves should be counted for representation in the House of Representatives as well as for direct taxation purposes. After much contestation, the delegates decided that each slave would be considered as three-fifths of a person; the agreement appeared in the Constitution under Article I, Section 2. While the compromise over slavery influenced how representation was assigned, two others directly affected the federal system’s structure. The first was the Slave Importation Clause. Placed into Article I, Section 9, it gave the federal government the right to regulate, tax, and even ban slave importation after 1808. This provision, supported by many southern states with a surplus of slaves, went into effect twenty years after the Constitution was drafted. It is important to note that it only referred to the international slave trade, not the movement or sale of slaves between states. The other provision appeared in Article IV, Section 2, which guaranteed slavery’s status by giving the federal government authority to assist in returning runaway slaves who cross state lines. These fugitives, euphemistically referred to as a “Person held to Service or Labour in one State,” were to be “delivered up on Claim of the Party to whom such Service or Labour may be due.” These provisions left untouched many of the vital issues regarding federal and state powers on the subject. Indeed, slavery was a sensitive topic; when discussed at the Convention, it raised the specter of dissolution of the union between the states. As such, those at the convention failed to address many key areas that directly concerned the position of slavery in the federal system. For instance, left unresolved was the civic status of slaves and free blacks within a state as well as their legal standing when they lawfully traveled across state lines. Much about slavery remained unclarified at the Constitution in the hopes that all of these problems would be resolved within the newly developed federal framework. This worked for decades, but the inability to resolve the place of slavery often led to bitter conflicts in nearly every aspect of national and state relations.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › States CP › 2NC – Solvency

States have historically done reparations right.

Hassan and Healy ’19 [Adeel Hassan is a reporter and editor on the National Desk. He is a founding member of , and much of his work focuses on identity and discrimination. He started the Morning Briefing for NYT Now and was its inaugural writer. He also served as an editor on the International Desk. Adeel graduated from Johns Hopkins and Columbia. Jack Healy is a Phoenix-based national correspondent for The New York Times. He focuses on the fast-changing politics and climate of the Southwest. He has worked in Iraq and Afghanistan and is a graduate of the University of Missouri’s journalism school. He adopted a street cat from Baghdad and still has the scars on his hands to prove it. Adeel Hassan and Jack Healy, 6-19-2019, "America Has Tried Reparations Before. Here Is How It Went. (Published 2019)," New York Times, https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/19/us/reparations-slavery.html]

More than 70 years after a racist mob massacred black residents in Rosewood, Fla., and burned the hamlet to the ground, Lizzie Jenkins’s mother received exactly $3,333.33 as recompense. In 1994, Florida became the first state to pass a reparations law acknowledging a need to confront an eruption of racist violence that government officials failed to stop. The law set aside $2 million for those who survived the 1923 massacre, which began with an allegation that a black man had assaulted a white woman. A white mob that included Ku Klux Klan members swarmed into the largely black hamlet of Rosewood and killed at least six black residents, and perhaps many more. Churches and houses were burned, and the residents scattered, never to return. Ms. Jenkins, 80, a historian and author whose aunt and uncle were attacked and nearly lynched in Rosewood, said that some survivors used the relatively modest payments to re-roof a house or do some remodeling. Her family used it to pay the taxes on the property where her aunt had grown up. “They didn’t get a whole lot of money,” she said of the victims, “but at least Florida acknowledged they had made a mistake.” When the reparations law passed, its supporters hailed it as a moment to “right an atrocious wrong,” while opponents complained about being held responsible for the “sins of our forefathers.” But Ms. Jenkins said the impact of reparations turned out to be surprisingly small, never enough to erase the bloody history or restore what had been taken.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › States CP › 2NC – Solvency

Reparations are about more than money, which states/cities exclusively understand.

Hassan and Healy ’19 [Adeel Hassan is a reporter and editor on the National Desk. He is a founding member of , and much of his work focuses on identity and discrimination. He started the Morning Briefing for NYT Now and was its inaugural writer. He also served as an editor on the International Desk. Adeel graduated from Johns Hopkins and Columbia. Jack Healy is a Phoenix-based national correspondent for The New York Times. He focuses on the fast-changing politics and climate of the Southwest. He has worked in Iraq and Afghanistan and is a graduate of the University of Missouri’s journalism school. He adopted a street cat from Baghdad and still has the scars on his hands to prove it. Adeel Hassan and Jack Healy, 6-19-2019, "America Has Tried Reparations Before. Here Is How It Went. (Published 2019)," New York Times, https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/19/us/reparations-slavery.html]

The men who survived brutal treatment by a Chicago police commander and his “midnight crew” of detectives wanted more than money. As part of a $5.5 million  measure enacted by the city in 2015, Chicago agreed to compensate 57 victims — nearly all African-American men from the city’s South Side — who said the police had beaten, shocked, suffocated and psychologically tortured them to obtain confessions. But the city also agreed to finance a Torture Justice Center to provide counseling to scores of victims of the commander, Jon Burge, and to other survivors of police brutality. The city supported building a public memorial, and agreed to weave lessons about the legacy of nearly 20 years of abuse into the public school curriculum. Students in Chicago now learn about police torture in history class. “Reparations have been and always will be more than an apology and a paycheck,” said Joey Mogul, a lawyer who wrote a draft of the reparations ordinance and represented several survivors. “We have to consider all the harm people have endured.”

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › States CP › 2NC – Solvency

USFG Can’t Be Trusted/Surveillence Empirics/USFG Doesn’t Solve

Hassan and Healy ’19 [Adeel Hassan is a reporter and editor on the National Desk. He is a founding member of , and much of his work focuses on identity and discrimination. He started the Morning Briefing for NYT Now and was its inaugural writer. He also served as an editor on the International Desk. Adeel graduated from Johns Hopkins and Columbia. Jack Healy is a Phoenix-based national correspondent for The New York Times. He focuses on the fast-changing politics and climate of the Southwest. He has worked in Iraq and Afghanistan and is a graduate of the University of Missouri’s journalism school. He adopted a street cat from Baghdad and still has the scars on his hands to prove it. Adeel Hassan and Jack Healy, 6-19-2019, "America Has Tried Reparations Before. Here Is How It Went. (Published 2019)," New York Times, https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/19/us/reparations-slavery.html]

After World War II, Congress created the Indian Claims Commission to pay compensation to any federally recognized tribe for land that had been seized by the United States. The group’s mission was complicated by a paucity of written records, difficulties in putting a value on the land for its agricultural productivity or religious significance, and problems with determining boundaries and ownership from decades, or more than a century, earlier. The results were disappointing for Native Americans. The commission paid out about $1.3 billion, the equivalent of less than $1,000 for each Native American in the United States at the time the commission dissolved in 1978. “On one level, it was remarkable,” said Melody McCoy, a lawyer for the Native American Rights Fund, a nonprofit group that has represented tribes in hundreds of major cases. “Congress listened to the claims of tribal leaders.” But, Ms. McCoy said, the government took a paternalistic view, and kept Native Americans from having direct control of the funds, in the belief they were not “competent to receive such large amounts of money.” “They did not make those awards, whether it was $200 million, $20 million or $20,000 — they held that money in trust accounts,” she said. A separate agreement, struck with Congress in 1971, led to the biggest award — $962 million worth of land in Alaska, some 44 million acres — in return for Indians, Eskimos and Aleuts relinquishing their aboriginal claims to the rest of the state. Once again, the compensation was not awarded directly; instead, the land was put in the control of corporations, and the beneficiaries were given shares of stock in them.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › States CP › 2NC – Solvency

Empirics Prove – Detroit is working on implementing reparations at state level

Afana ’21 [Dana Afana is the city hall reporter at the Detroit Free Press. She graduated from Eastern Michigan University and has a background in government, business and development reporting.USA TODAY, 06-15-2021, "Detroit city council pushes ahead with reparations initiative," https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2021/06/15/city-council-oks-reparations-resolution/7708305002/]

Detroit City Council is moving forward with an effort to support reparations for African Americans. President Pro Tem Mary Sheffield’s resolution, which passed Tuesday without objection, aims to lay out a foundation to create a city task force or commission to design what reparations may look like for Detroiters and how to make it happen, whether through a committee or “higher level” entity at the state level. The resolution also states that African Americans have been unjustly enslaved, segregated, incarcerated, denied housing "through racist practices" in public and private markets, denied mortgages, displaced and faced racial steering, redlining, blockbusting, gentrification and more.  Sheffield said there are multiple community-led initiatives for reparations. "You have Proposal P. Then you have the petition-led initiative, which is trying to put the question on the ballot. The ideas we’re kind of waiting to see is what happens with those so we’re not duplicating something that may be placed on the ballot," Sheffield said. “Today was important because it also shows council’s support for the idea of reparations and supporting a process to explore it moving forward.”

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › States CP › 2NC – Solvency

States Are Already Solving

Beam ’21 [Adam Beam is a California Capitol reporter for The Associated Press.USA TODAY, 06-20-2021, "11 US mayors pledge to pay reparations for slavery to small groups of Black residents," https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2021/06/19/reparations-slavery-pledged-11-us-mayors-pilot-program/7753319002/]

SACRAMENTO, Calif. – Eleven U.S. mayors, from Los Angeles to tiny Tullahassee, Oklahoma, have pledged to pay  for slavery to a small group of Black residents in their cities, saying their aim is to set an example for the federal government on how a nationwide program could work. The mayors had no details on how much it would cost, who would pay for it or how people would be chosen. All of those details would be worked out with the help of local commissions comprised of representatives from Black-led organizations set up to advise the mayor of each city. But the mayors say they are committed to paying reparations instead of just talking about them. "Black Americans don't need another study that sits on a shelf," said St. Louis Mayor Tishaura Jones, the city's first Black female mayor and a member of the group. "We need decisive action to address the racial wealth gap holding communities back across our country." The effort comes as Juneteenth, which marks the end of slavery in the United States, has become a federal holiday. President Joe Biden signed a bill Thursday that was passed by , as a holiday. Slavery officially ended in the United States in 1865 with the adoption of the 13th Amendment to U.S. Constitution. But its effects have lingered far beyond that, contributing to disparities in wealth and health between white and Black populations.  Since 1989, lawmakers in Congress introduced a bill that would form a commission to study and develop reparations proposals in the United States. But it has never passed. Last year, California became the first state to set up its own reparations commission. That group held its first meeting this month. Friday's announcement marks the largest city-led effort at paying reparations to date, but it isn't the first. The San Francisco Board of Supervisors voted in March to appoint a 15-member African American Reparations Advisory Committee. That same month, the City Council of Evanston, Illinois, voted to pay $400,000 to eligible Black households, part of a pledge to spend $10 million over the next 10 years. Qualifying households would get $25,000 to use for things like home repair or putting a down payment on property. Last year, the City Council in Asheville, North Carolina, voted to approve reparations in the form of investments in areas of disparity for Black residents. 

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › States CP › 2NC – Solvency

California Empirics Prove States Solve Aff

Austin and Hair ’23 [Sophie Austin covers the California Statehouse for The Associated Press in Sacramento. Before joining the AP, Austin was a data fellow at The Center for Public Integrity while earning a master’s degree in journalism and public affairs at American University. She has covered local and environmental news as an intern for The Dallas Morning News, and as an Emma Bowen Foundation Fellow at PolitiFact, she wrote political fact checks and climate policy stories ahead of the 2020 presidential election. Austin holds a bachelor’s degree in journalism from American University, where she was editor-in-chief of the Eagle, the student-run newspaper. Janie hair is an Urban Affairs and race/ethnicity reporter at The Associated Press in San Francisco. Sophie Austin and Janie Hair, 6-28-2023, "California's historic work on possible Black reparations moves to the Legislature," AP News, https://apnews.com/article/california-reparations-slavery-apology-0108745176cc1fd60eb036fba112f72b]

Members of California’s Black reparations task force handed off their historic two-year report to state lawmakers Thursday, beginning the next chapter in the long struggle to compensate the descendants of slavery. The first U.S. panel of its kind met one last time Thursday, urging supporters to press lawmakers into action on more than 100 recommendations. State legislators and Gov. Gavin Newsom must agree for any money to be paid or for any policy changes to be adopted. “This book of truth will be a legacy, will be a testament to the full story,” said Lisa Holder, a civil rights attorney and task force member. “Anyone who says that we are colorblind, that we have solved the problem of anti-Black animus and racism, I challenge you to read this document.” The mood was buoyant, but tinged with frustration and anger that hours earlier, the U.S. Supreme Court struck down affirmative action in higher education, programs that have disproportionately helped Black students. Task force members said their suggestions will pass legal muster because the proposed benefits would only go to descendants of enslaved people, not to all Black residents. The panel narrowly voted to limit any financial redress to residents who can document lineage from Black people who were in the U.S. in the 19th century. The 1,100-page report details California’s role in perpetuating discrimination against Black residents. Ideas for repairing the harm range from formally apologizing to paying descendants of enslaved people for having suffered under racist actions such as over-policing and housing discrimination. The panel also recommended creating a new agency to oversee reparations efforts. Turning the proposals into policies won’t be easy. State Sen. Steven Bradford said there are “a lot of folks” in the Legislature who do not support reparations and a 2021 Pew Research Center survey found that only 30% of U.S. adults favored the concept. A more recent survey by the nonpartisan Public Policy Institute of California found 54% of respondents had a negative opinion of California creating a reparations task force, although 59% said they would support a formal apology from the state to descendants. More than 200 people gathered at the Thursday meeting in Sacramento, with an overflow crowd outside the room. Inside, many stood at one point and began a call-and-response to demand action. “What do we want?” someone shouted. “Reparations,” the crowd responded. “When do we want them?” he asked. “Now!” California Secretary of State Shirley Weber, who wrote legislation creating the task force, said slavery stripped her of her identity and heritage and that she has visited Africa dozens of times, only to conclude there is nowhere for her to go back to. “I am an American,” she said. “This country has shaped and formed us and we have given to it. And we have a right to be here. We have a right to have the benefits.” Rev. Amos C. Brown, a longtime civil rights activist and vice-chair of the task force, said California’s projected $31.5 billion budget deficit should not stop the state from making reparations. “This state has committed a crime against Black folks, and it’s time for them to pay,” Brown said to cheers from the audience. “Deficits don’t last always.” The nine-member reparations panel convened in June 2021, the year after Newsom signed legislation creating the group. He and legislative leaders picked the members, including lawyers, educators, elected officials and civil rights leaders descended from enslaved people. Federal reparations efforts have stalled for decades, but cities, counties, school districts and universities have taken up the cause. An advisory group in San Francisco recommended that qualifying Black adults receive a $5 million lump-sum, guaranteed annual income of at least $97,000 and personal debt forgiveness. San Francisco supervisors are supposed to take up the proposals later this year.  California by creating a commission to examine the state’s involvement in slavery and consider addressing present-day economic and educational disparities experienced by Black people. Lawmakers approved the legislation earlier this month, but Gov. Kathy Hochul has yet to sign it. Illinois approved a reparations commission last year. California entered the union as a free state in 1850. In practice, it sanctioned slavery and approved policies and practices that thwarted Black people from owning homes and starting businesses. Black families were terrorized, their communities aggressively policed and their neighborhoods polluted, according to a groundbreaking report released last year as part of the committee’s work.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › States CP › 2NC – Solvency

States can give reparations – empirics

Germain ’22 [Jacquelyne Germain, 7-13-2022, "The fight for reparations has stalled in Congress. Here's what they look like in state and local governments," CNN, https://www.cnn.com/2022/07/13/us/reparations-state-local-commission-reaj/index.html]

Louis Weathers had a stable job and was married when he decided to buy a home in the Chicago suburb of Evanston in 1959 – but high interest rates and White real estate agents who seemed adamant about keeping him and other Black residents out of certain neighborhoods nearly discouraged him. More than six decades later, the 87-year-old received a payout to make up for the discriminatory housing practices that he and other Black residents experienced between 1919 and 1969. After three years in the making, Evanston gave Weathers and 15 other Black residents $25,000 each in May to put toward a down payment on a home, mortgages or home repairs. Like Weathers, generations of Black Americans have faced disparities in housing, transportation, business and other areas. And as descendants of enslaved people many say they have not been compensated for their labor and the lingering effects of systemic racism. Recent federal reparations efforts have stalled in Congress, but cities like Evanston are working to atone for the harms caused by slavery and institutional racism – and address the racial wealth gap. Last week, Detroit’s city council unanimously approved how it would structure the city’s first reparations task force. Meanwhile in Massachusetts, the Amherst Town Council approved the creation of a fund to allocate a total of $2 million in reparations over the course of about a decade. The push for reparations has gained momentum on the heels of the national uprising in the aftermath of George Floyd’s killing in 2020, which rekindled the Black Lives Matter movement. Kamilah Moore, of the California Reparations Task Force, said she sees reparations “as fulfilling the promises made to her ancestors” in the mid-19th century following the abolition of slavery. The federal government now has the chance to live up to those commitments, she said. “You can’t talk about a racial reckoning in this country without mentioning reparations,” she said. “Reparations are comprehensive enough to address all of the ills that still impact the African American community.” From cash payouts to issuing extensive reports and building a bureaucratic system to examine what reparations could look like, here is what some local and state governments have done so far: Robin Rue Simmons, a former Evanston alderman who introduced the idea to the city in 2019, said the Restorative Housing Reparations Program was created to remedy some of the harm caused by the city’s historical anti-Black housing policies. When it was approved last year, it was considered the country’s first reparations program. Since it was founded in 1860s, the city “created systems to segregate, limit, deny, and control Black citizens,” who were denied equal access to many areas, including schooling and housing. In the early 20th century, real estate agents developed a practice of informal racial zoning, almost exclusively offering Black residents housing on the city’s west side, according to a 2020 report commissioned by the city that details how the city perpetuated discriminatory practices toward Black residents. The report also highlights that Evanston banks typically refused mortgage loans to Black residents seeking to buy homes in predominantly White neighborhoods. When the city’s Restorative Housing Reparations program opened online applications in September, officials received more than 600 applications. In January, Weathers and 15 others were chosen at random from the first 122 applications submitted by eligible Black residents. The program’s payments were funded by donations and money collected by the city from cannabis sales taxes. Weathers says he was “elated” when he learned that he would receive a payout and decided it could help current and future generations of his family. Instead of using the money for himself, he transferred his payout to his 60-year-old son, Michael Weathers, to put toward his mortgage. “It was a no brainer,” he said. Rose Cannon, a long-time Evanston resident, said she was initially excited when she heard about reparations efforts coming to Evanston, but grew to be against them once the conversation shifted from direct cash payments to a housing program. For her, conflating housing equity efforts with reparations minimizes the larger reparations movement. “When you use the term reparations, we would like for it to be associated with the full repair of human beings, to close the racial income gap,” Cannon said. “Housing can only be a portion of it, maybe a silo of it.” The current program, Simmons said, is the city’s initial reparations effort and was informed by a mass of research that led them to identify the legacy of discriminatory housing practices. Following more work to address housing disparities, Simmons said the city is expected to focus its reparations efforts on economic development and education initiatives. A committee has recommended grants for Black businesses and the establishment of a Black history museum in the city, she added. “It’s not so much that the initial 16 recipients are going to completely transform the life circumstances for all of Black Evanston, but the fact that it has happened means that we can expand it and we can build on it and do more,” Simmons said. “Not just in housing, but in other areas as well.” Cities like St. Paul have taken steps to build a bureaucratic system to examine what a reparations package for Black Americans could look like. After the city apologized last year for its role in the institutional and structural racism experienced by its Black residents, officials established an advisory committee to create a framework for a reparations commission. A year later, the advisory committee has released a report recommending direct cash payments to eligible Black residents and the establishment of a permanent reparations committee focused on implementing reparations to address racial disparities in housing, healthcare, education, employment and more. As far as funding, the report identified various sources, including the city’s funding under the American Rescue Plan, sales taxes and philanthropic donations. Trahern Crews, a member of the partially influenced reparations efforts in Minnesota’s capital city.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › Carbon Dividend CP

BCA revitalizes economy; Prevents recession

Cohen 23 (Ariel, nonresident senior fellow at the Atlantic Council’s Eurasia Center and a member of the Council of Foreign Relations. He is a recognized authority on international security and energy policy, and leading expert, senior fellow at the International Tax and Investment Center (ITIC), where he is managing director of the Energy, Growth, and Security Program (EGS), master’s degree and PhD from the Tuft’s Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy. “Bipartisan Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism - A Political Unicorn? ”, Forbes, March 15, 2023,, Accessed July 14, 2023) // CD

Some critics and high-emission countries argue that the system is ushering in a new era of protectionism, calling the CBAM a tariff in disguise aimed at weakening the competitive advantage of developing countries. Others, willing to acknowledge the charge of protectionism, counter by saying the CBAM is a green extension of friendshoring. For the US, the CBAM has a significant potential to revitalize and promote the domestic economy, especially many industrial sectors that have struggled recently., US goods are “40% more carbon efficient than the world average,” and over three times more carbon efficient than China. Implementing CBAM legislation would further improve US competitiveness by monetizing its relative efficiency. It would also bring back a significant amount of business and may improve the decades-long huge between Washington and Beijing. As other low-emission countries begin to use the CBAM, any delay in implementation could put US trade at a considerable disadvantage. Joining the CBAM initiative would place the United States at the forefront of global climate leadership and set a strong example of a modern sustainable economy while countering the environmental impact of global emissions from industrial production. This shared initiative would also likely strengthen diplomatic and trade relations with the EU by streamlining trade and climate policy in the transatlantic region. As the EU is virtue signaling its stalwart support for CBAM, proposing it in the US may also make it a valuable bargaining chip in future trade talks with Brussels.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › Carbon Dividend CP

A domestic carbon dividend combined with a BCA is the most efficient policy to address climate change, economic insecurity

Shultz and Baker 17 — [George P. Shultz was secretary of state (1982-89) and Treasury secretary (1972-74). James A. Baker III was secretary of state (1989-92) and Treasury secretary (1985-88)., “,” Wall Street Journal, 02-07-2017, http://www.sba.muohio.edu/evenwe/courses/eco201/fall18/readings/A%20Conservative%20Answer%20to%20Climate%20Change%20-%20WSJ.pdf, accessed 7-14-2023] - PG

Thirty years ago, as the atmosphere’s protective ozone layer was dwindling at alarming rates, we were serving proudly under President Ronald Reagan. We remember his leading role in negotiating the Montreal Protocol, which continues to protect and restore the delicate ozone layer. Today the world faces a similar challenge: the threat of climate change. Just as in the 1980s, there is mounting evidence of problems with the atmosphere that are growing too compelling to ignore. And, once again, there is uncertainty about what lies ahead. The extent to which climate change is due to man-made causes can be questioned. But the risks associated with future warming are so severe that they should be hedged. The responsible and conservative response should be to take out an insurance policy. Doing so need not rely on heavy-handed, growth-inhibiting government regulations. Instead, a climate solution should be based on a sound economic analysis that embodies the conservative principles of free markets and limited government. We suggest a solution that rests on four pillars. First, creating a gradually increasing carbon tax. Second, returning the tax proceeds to the American people in the form of dividends. Third, establishing border carbon adjustments that protect American competitiveness and encourage other countries to follow suit. And fourth, rolling back government regulations once such a system is in place. The first pillar, a carbon tax, is the most cost-effective way to reduce emissions. Unlike the current cumbersome regulatory approach, a levy on emissions would free companies to find the most efficient way to reduce their carbon footprint. A sensibly priced, gradually rising tax would send a powerful market signal to businesses that want certainty when planning for the future. A “carbon dividend” payment, the second pillar, would have tax proceeds distributed to the American people on a quarterly basis. This way, the revenue-neutral tax would benefit working families rather than bloat government spending. A $40-per-ton carbon tax would provide a family of four with roughly $2,000 in carbon dividends in the first year, an amount that could grow over time as the carbon tax rate increased. A carbon dividends policy could spur larger reductions in greenhouse-gas emissions than all of President Obama’s climate policies. At the same time, our plan would strengthen the economy, help working-class Americans, and promote national security, all while reducing regulations and shrinking the size of government. The third pillar is a border adjustment for carbon content. When American companies export to countries without comparable carbon pricing systems, they would receive rebates on the carbon taxes they have paid. Imports from such countries, meanwhile, would face fees on the carbon content of their products. Proceeds from such fees would also be returned to the American people through carbon dividends. Pioneering such a system would put America in the driver’s seat of global climate policy. It would also promote American competitiveness by penalizing countries whose lack of carbon reduction policies would otherwise give them an unfair trade advantage. The eventual elimination of regulations no longer necessary after the enactment of a carbon tax would constitute the final pillar. Almost all of the Environmental Protection Agency’s regulatory authority over carbon emissions could be eliminated, including an outright repeal of President Obama’s Clean Power Plan. Robust carbon taxes would also justify ending federal and state tort liability for emitters. With these principles in mind, on Wednesday the Climate Leadership Council is unveiling “The Conservative Case for Carbon Dividends.” The report was co-authored by conservative thinkers Martin Feldstein,Henry Paulson Jr., Gregory Mankiw,Ted Halstead,Tom Stephenson and Rob Walton. This carbon dividends program would help steer the U.S. toward a path of more durable economic growth by encouraging technological innovation and large-scale substitution of existing energy sources. It would also provide much-needed regulatory relief to U.S. industries. Companies, especially those in the energy sector, finally would have the predictability they now lack, removing one of the most serious impediments to capital investment. Perhaps most important, the carbon-dividends plan speaks to the increasing frustration and economic insecurity experienced by many working-class Americans. The plan would elevate the fortunes of the nation’s less-advantaged while strengthening the economy. A Treasury Department report published last month predicts that carbon dividends would mean income gains for about 70% of Americans. This plan will also be good for the long-term prospects of the Republican Party. About two-thirds of Americans worry a “great deal” or “fair amount” about climate change, according to a 2016 Gallup survey. Polls often show concern about climate change is higher among younger voters, and among Asians and Hispanics, the fastest-growing demographic groups. A carbon-dividends plan provides an opportunity to appeal to all three demographics. Controlling the White House and Congress means that Republicans bear the responsibility of exercising wise leadership on the defining challenges of our era. Climate change is one of these issues. It is time for the Grand Old Party to once again lead the way.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › Carbon Dividend CP

Universal basic income causes inflation

Chi et al 2020 [6-16-2020, YS Chi: Independent director of CFI Education and Ingram Industries. Board Member at Princeton University Press, Ban Ki-Moon Foundation, and Educational Testing Services. Advisory Board Member at KAIST, University of Surrey and Southern Federal State University. Julie Effron: She is on the boards of CFI Education and AIHR. She also previously co-founded ALICE, a hotel operations software company that raised $39M in financing before being acquired by Expedia. Julie holds a BA in Economics from the University of Pennsylvania. Ryan MacGregor: Ryan is a serial entrepreneur and former investment banker (Credit Suisse and Lehman Brothers), who earned an MBA from the University of Chicago Booth School of Business after serving in the U.S. Navy as a submarine officer; "Universal Basic Income (UBI)," Corporate Finance Institute, https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/career/universal-basic-income-ubi/] //LS

A UBI system is still a theoretical approach, one that comes with good intentions and noble goals. Still, widespread financial equality and independence offer the potential to cause some serious economic issues. One major issue with a universal basic income, raised by those who oppose such a practice, is inflation. It’s easy to see how the institution of a UBI may fuel inflation. If every individual is granted an unconditional income from the government, then there is money to be spent. Providing massive amounts of money to virtually every individual in the country translates to a massively expanded money supply. It means that there is a higher demand for goods and services that manufacturers and retailers produce and sell. The law of supply and demand dictates that, as demand pressure increases on producers and retailers, they must increase prices on the available supply of goods and services to avoid being overwhelmed by the increased demand. That is inflation. If the end result of a UBI turns out to be uncontrolled inflation, then the cost of living continues to increase. It would necessitate an increase in the level of universal basic income provided to all citizens or allowing the standard of living for UBI recipients to decline, as they are able to purchase fewer goods and services with the amount of UBI they receive. Unless something can be done to manage the situation, there would just be a vicious circle created of higher UBI leading to increased prices, leading to a necessary increase in the UBI amount, leading to still higher prices… you get the idea

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › UBI PIC

Universality-based approaches reinforce cycles of poverty and discrimination---targeted income is key to resolve structural inequities

Fleischer 22 [Kate, recent graduate of Smith College and a Ms. editorial assistant, “The Differences Between UBI and Guaranteed Income Reveal the Importance of Equity” 22 June 2022, https://msmagazine.com/2022/06/22/universal-basic-income-ubi-guaranteed-income-black-women-magnolia-mothers-trust/, Ms. Magazine. Accessed 14 July 2023]

Universal basic income (UBI) was propelled into mainstream awareness during Andrew Yang’s campaign for the 2020 Democratic presidential candidacy. Now, programs offering monthly cash payments to specific communities have sprung up across the country. But while the public often conflates UBI with these programs, economic justice activists warn that they have very different goals. Many anti-poverty groups agree that strategically targeted guaranteed income, not UBI, is the best path forward to ending poverty, advancing gender and racial equity and supporting low-income Americans.

In 2020, Yang’s focus on UBI helped raise public awareness of the policy. His “Freedom Dividend” promised to give $1,000 per month to every American adult—”everyone from a hedge fund billionaire in New York to an impoverished single mom in West Virginia,” Yang’s own site explained.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › UBI PIC

Unconditional, universal cash transfers waste money by giving it to people who don’t need it---guaranteed minimum avoids wasteful spending and costs less

Caddick 22 [Dominic, researcher specialising in the political economy of fiscal and monetary policy, BA in Economics from the University of Cambridge, “WHAT IF EVERYONE WAS ON UNIVERSAL CREDIT?” 28 January 2022, https://neweconomics.org/2022/01/what-if-everyone-was-on-universal-credit, New Economics Foundation]

The main drawback of a UBI is that it would be very expensive. One estimate from the Institute for Policy Research says that it would cost over £427bn a year to significantly reduce poverty in the UK: roughly double the Department for Work and Pension’s (DWP) current budget. This would require a significant change to our political landscape, as well as eventual major tax increases. Much of this money would be going to individuals who are already well-off, which is a questionable use of government funds. This could however be mitigated via progressive taxation that both partially funds a UBI and indirectly reduces payments to the wealthiest.

When it comes to a minimum income guarantee (MIG), one advantage is that it can target support at the people who need it most. A MIG can also be adjusted to consider the different needs of different families, with higher MIGs for larger families and those with disabled members. Because of this targeting, the MIG approach generally provides a higher minimum income level for a much lower cost. But conversely, the big potential downside is that it could be complicated to administer.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › UBI PIC

Increasing government benefits to the wealthy uniquely causes inflation---they have a lower marginal propensity to consume.

Blahous 22 [Charles, J. Fish and Lillian F. Smith Chair and Senior Research Strategist at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University, received his PhD in computational quantum chemistry from the University of California at Berkeley and his BA from Princeton University, “To Stop Fueling Inflation, Stop Paying Rich People” 10 November 2022, https://www.discoursemagazine.com/economics/2022/11/10/to-stop-fueling-inflation-stop-paying-rich-people/, Discourse. Accessed 15 July 2023]

Americans continue to suffer from rampant price inflation. Since the spring of 2021, inflation has barreled along at a clip of roughly 8% per year as measured by the most accurate inflation index, the Chained Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers. While the Federal Reserve Board has turned its attention to bringing down inflation with a series of interest rate hikes, elected officials are unfortunately treating inflation as a political problem to be spun rather than as a substantive challenge to be met. Federal lawmakers are making the Fed’s task more difficult by running pointlessly large federal deficits, policies that might be defensible in a deflationary environment but are inexcusable in an inflationary one. If lawmakers wish to help fight inflation, they should cut federal spending and reduce deficits. A good place to start would be by ratcheting back government benefits for the richest Americans.

Runaway price inflation often presents lawmakers with difficult policy challenges. On the one hand, the right policy response is to engage in less deficit spending, because such spending fuels consumption and puts upward pressure on prices. On the other hand, Americans who are suffering from price inflation can ill afford a simultaneous reduction in their government-provided benefits. One way to balance these conflicting considerations is by reducing federal payments to the well-off. Upper-income people spend proportionally less of their money on necessary expenses than other Americans. They are therefore proportionally less affected by inflation, and they can better afford to part with some federal largesse. Meanwhile, to the extent that less spending on upper-income people reduces deficits and inflationary pressures, it relieves Americans’ general economic hardship.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › Unpayable Debt K

And thus, the alt is an affirmation of THE UNPAYABLE- black trauma, death, exploitation, and centuries of antiblackness means that this debt is unquantifiable and trying to reduce it to a number is antiblack. We refuse silence and speak the truth about how this debt is unpayable and challenging whiteness solves.

James and McKittrick ’14 [Hudson, Peter James, and Katherine McKittrick. “The Geographies of Blackness and Anti-Blackness: An Interview with Katherine McKittrick.” The CLR James Journal, vol. 20, no. 1/2, 2014, pp. 233-40. JSTOR, https://www.jstor.org/stable/26752069. Accessed 11 July 2023.] [CL]

Yes. I wonder a lot about why the classroom should be safe. It isn’t safe. I am not sure what safe learning looks like because the kinds of questions that need to be (and are) asked, across a range of disciplines and interdisciplines, necessarily attend to violence and sadness and the struggle for life. How could teaching narratives of sadness ever, under any circumstances, be safe!? And doubled onto this: which black or other marginalized faculty is safe in the academy, ever? Who are these safe people? Where are they? But there is also, on top of this all, an underlying discourse, one that emerges out of feminism and other “identity” discourses, that assumes that the classroom should be safe. This kind of “safe space” thinking sometimes includes statements on course outlines about respect for diversity and how the class (faculty? students?) will not tolerate inappropriate behavior: racism, homophobia, sexism, ableism. This kind of hate-prevention is a fantasy to me. It is a fantasy that replicates, rather than undoes, systems of injustice because it assumes, first, that teaching about anti-colonialism or sexism or homophobia can be safe (which is an injustice to those who have lived and live injustice!), second, that learning about anti-colonialism or sexism or homophobia is safe, easy, comfortable, and, third, that silencing and/or removing ‘bad’ and ‘intolerant’ students dismantles systems of injustice. Privileged students leave these safe spaces with transparently knowable oppressed identities safely tucked in their back pockets and a lesson on how to be aggressively and benevolently silent. The only people harmed in this process are students of colour, faculty of colour, and those who are the victims of potential yet unspoken intolerance. I call this a white fantasy because, at least for me, only someone with racial privilege would assume that the classroom could be a site of safety! This kind of privileged person sees the classroom as, a priori, safe, and a space that is tainted by dangerous subject matters (race) and unruly (intolerant) students. But the classroom is, as I see it, a colonial site that was, and always has been, engendered by and through violent exclusion! Remember Jamaica Kincaid’s Lucy?! How wretched are those daffodils!?! I am not suggesting that the classroom be a location that welcomes violence and hatefulness and racism; I am suggesting that learning and teaching and classrooms are, already, sites of pain. We cannot protect or save ourselves or our students by demanding silence or shaming ignorance or ‘warning’ the class that difficult knowledge is around the corner (as with “trigger” moments—the moment when the course director or teaching as sistant says: “look out, I need to acknowledge a trigger moment that will make you uncomfortable: we are going to talk about whiteness!”) All of this, too, also recalls the long history of silencing—subalterns not speaking and all of that. Why is silencing, now, something that protects or enables safety? Who does silence protect and who does silence make safe and who does silence erase? Who has the privilege to demand tolerance? In my teaching, although this is a day-to-day skirmish for me because the site where we begin to teach is already white supremacist, I try very hard to create class room conversations that work out how knowledge is linked to an ongoing struggle to end violence and that, while racist or homophobic practices are certainly not encouraged or welcome, when they do emerge (because they always do!) we need to situate these practices within the wider context of colonialism and anti-blackness. This is a pedagogy wherein the brutalities of racial violence are not descriptively rehearsed, but always already demand practical activities of resistance, encounter, and anti-colonial thinking.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › Unpayable Debt K

The black horizons of debt range from the contours, the limits, its constraining, but its beautiful. Acknowledging anti-black debt creates the starting point for the reimagination of a system where we no longer desire white credibility.

Shaye ‘15 [Amarya Shaye, Black Lesbian. I write songs and scholarly texts. Blackness and Value; Part 3: On Blackness as Debt – WIT (womenintheology.org)] [CL]

There are a variety of ways in which one can understand blackness’ relation to value. As I’ve tried to set out in the two previous posts, within the system of global racial capitalism, the position of the black is one of permanent indebtedness. Blackness is the exclusion from the social relations of the credible. It is the inescapable nature of one’s debt, which is one’s blackness. This indebtedness is the means by which the credibility of those who can be creditors or debtors is maintained. The value of credibility requires the devaluation of indebtedness, which is to say, requires seeing debt as a threat. Seeing blackness as a threat. Criminalization is the technique by which this devaluation of indebtedness is maintained. Criminalization is the process of seeing from within the capitalist field of vision. In this range of visibility, blackness is only recognizeable as the threat of indebtedness, which is the threat of poverty. To protect credibility from this threat is the role of the carceral, which says it seeks the rehabilitation of the criminal. This is true, as Moten and Harney show us. The carceral mode of governance is concerned with blackness – which is to say indebtedness, which is to say bad debt -because it is concerned with maintaining the value of credibility. The promise of value, of being recognized as valuable, is what is policed. Do we see people going about their lives as if credibility isn’t valuable? Those are the criminal, the always indebted, the black. Do we see people who understand that the promise of value money offers is paid for with their flesh and blood? Those are the criminal, the poor, the threats. Understanding criminality through racial capital must radical reorient our field of vision, where debt is the horizon, the limit of our thought. To transgress the limit of debt, to inhabit the space where the indebted have been living their non-credible criminal lives, is to make a move that reevaluates the value money promises. This movement is to understand, with Moten, that credit runs only one way (which is toward whiteness and the aspiration for credibility), while debt runs in all directions, to the Ferguson protests, the striking fast food workers, the undocumented laborers, the precarious adjuncts, the disappeared Mexican students, and, and, and … To understand blackness as debt, as criminal, is to understand the value of the double in black thought. That value, as it is given by the racialized economy of credit/debt, is not respected. The double does the work of inflating and undercutting the terms of respectability, the proper, the police. Indebtedness and criminality in black study, then, are ways of naming the fact that there is something happening over where the non-credible criminal lives are cohabitating. They are a way of understanding the value of credibility requires the governance of these non-credible criminal lives, or their destruction. In response to the violence that is the imposition of a violating indebtedness, the indebted criminal black violates property, propriety, and the credibility of whiteness, of the police which protect this credibility, and of the state which governs this credibility.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS UBI + Reparations Neg 23 › Unpayable Debt K

Any monetary or material attempt to repay the unpayable debt of slavery is the raison d‘être of white benevolence, which works as a tool of white liberalism to reify its credibility. White benevolence is how the aff attempts to put a bandaid on this debt.

Gearin ‘22 [Gearin, L. R. M., was published in the Department of Peace and Global Studies, Earlham College 2022, July 5. (UN)settling unpayable debt: Theorizing and disrupting the production of white “benevolence” during giving to reparations funds. Journal of Critical Race Inquiry. https://jcri.ca/index.php/CRI/article/view/15010]

White benevolence is a way of inhabiting whiteness that allows white people to distance themselves from the violence of white supremacy. White benevolence works by attributing “goodness” to white people by virtue of their anti-racist actions. As such, occupying a position of benevolence is only possible through anti-racist action. White benevolence does not deny the presence or harm of racism; instead, while naming the violence of racism, it allows whiteness to appear less harmful (or even harmless) by making anti-racist work appear to compensate for an individual’s “share” of harm. In sum, white peoples’ relative power can appear less violent (to them) if they imagine that they are putting their position to good use. Because white benevolence is made possible by recognizing the harm of whiteness and following this recognition with reparative action, critical awareness of one’s whiteness is not enough to disrupt its reproduction. Indeed, the acknowledgement of the harms of whiteness and one’s implication in the violence of white supremacy actually facilitates the production of white benevolence. The danger of benevolent whiteness is that it allows white people to act as if they can possess structural power and resources within white supremacy in a neutral (or even positive) way. The concept of white benevolence does not name an actual position of goodness that white people can inhabit. Since any justification for holding onto structural power under white supremacy reproduces the violence of anti-Black racism, the idea of white benevolence is always a fantasy. Rather than naming a position that can be achieved, the term white benevolence is a conceptual tool for analyzing how this fantasy reproduces white supremacy. By imagining domination to be beneficial to colonized peoples, the positioning of white benevolence has a long history of being used as a justification for colonialism and racism. In his work on white settler nationalism in Australia, Damien Riggs (2004) proposes understanding the anti-racist practices of white people as part of a “continuum of DISRUPTING WHITE BENEVOLENCE 55 benevolence” (para. 10). Rather than assuming positions of white benevolence in Australia to be passive manifestations of a historical legacy, however, Riggs insists that claims to benevolence perform political functions that are specific to the anxieties of the present moment. Riggs writes, “practices of benevolence … may be understood as attempts at managing … anxiety [about the settler’s relationship to indigenous sovereignty], and therefore reasserting the normative status of whiteness” by claiming an untroubled relation between settler nationalism and indigenous sovereignty (2004, para. 26). Even white Australians who are critical of racism manage their relationship to colonial violence by citing their own actions to address racist harms. Riggs’ account of white benevolence in Australia illustrates how white people mobilize anti-racist practice to justify holding onto structural power. In this way, anti-racist action powerfully insulates white supremacy in Australia from challenge, and critical awareness of the violence of whiteness is inadequate for disrupting its reproduction. White benevolence is similar to white saviorism because both subjective positionings attribute value to white people through “generous” practices toward racialized people. As such, the liberal individualistic ideal that white individuals can contribute to anti-racism by acting to address the harms of white supremacy is central to both positionings. However, white saviorism as an analytical term is limited because it fails to fully disinvest from the idea that there is a “good” way to inhabit whiteness, whereas white benevolence as a conceptual term understands non-harmful whiteness to be a fantasy. The figure of the white savior is imagined as a well-intentioned yet innocently uncritical white person: someone who perpetrates racism due to a lack of awareness. The solution to white saviorism then appears to be educating white people about racialized power dynamics to bring them into greater critical awareness of their whiteness and to facilitate better structures of engagement between white people and racialized people. In contrast, the concept of white benevolence does not assume that critical awareness of whiteness will prevent white people from being harmful or reduce the harms they perpetuate. Instead, the concept of white benevolence highlights how attempts to acknowledge and critically reflect upon whiteness can actually re-generate the idea of inhabiting whiteness in a harmless or even positive way, a fantasy that works to insulate white supremacy from challenge.