Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Affirmative
CPs › AT: Congress CP

CP can't access the case. A pivotal component of the intellectual and ideological project underpinning the maintenance of this colonialist legal regime is the notion that Congress's plenary power over the territories is unbounded by meaningful judicially-enforced Constitutional constraints.

Torruella 7, Former chief judge of that court United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit

[Juan R. Torruella, Puerto Rican jurist. He served as a United States circuit judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit from 1984 until his death, and as chief judge of that court from 1994 to 2001, “The Insular Cases: The Establishment Of A Regime of Political Apartheid,” Penn Law: Legal Scholarship Repository, 2007, ] /RS

In the fourth academic sally, Professor James Bradley Thayer, in an article singularly lacking in any reference to supporting authorities, minced no words in asserting that "America [should not] forget her precedence of teaching nations how to live." 45 Reflecting a belief that was dear to the hearts of manifest destiny exponents of the time,46 Thayer argued that "there is no lack of power in our nation, - of legal, constitutional power, to govern these islands as colonies, substantially as England might govern them." 47 Cavalierly disposing of Marshall's and Taney's opinions as mere dicta, he concluded that not only did the Constitution not cover the territories, but also that, "except as to one or two particulars, [the power of Congress to govern the territories was] to be measured only by the terms of the cessions which it has accepted, or of the treaty under which a territory may have come in." 48 Beyond these restraints the territories were "subject to the absolute power of Congress." 49 As we shall see, this was a viewpoint that was to gain adherents in high judicial circles.

2023 DDI Affirmative
CPs › AT: Congress CP

Congress CP can't solve the case

Bayonet 22[Gabriel Prats; 2021-2022; The author is a third year law school student from the Inter American School of Law. ; "Vaello-Madero: Putting on Hold Equal Rights for Territorial Citizens," Revista Juridica de la Universidad Interamericana de Puerto Rico 56, no. 1 (2021-2022): 39-71//JJB]

The first impression after the Vaello-Madero decision is that, while Congress is fully aware of the implications and possible repercussions of this case, it will pursue the orthodox route of dealing with the territories every time these are in the political hotseat: appeasement via economic means and leave the important issues in suspense. In this case, even if the SSI program's benefits were extended to the territories, the Congressional status quo would still remain unchanged. In the race to revamp constitutional rights to conform with modern societal values in the U.S., the territories would remain competing with the fifty states while stuck in first gear. It is a piecemeal approach to territorial problem-solving that ultimately leads to nothing. "That solution is no solution."' 5 Hence, while expectations are high in the judiciary for the attention the territories are receiving, the same cannot be said about Congressional action. The territorial predicament is just another deja vu issue that is not even on their pri151 Vaello-Madero, --- S.t. at 14 (Gorsuch, J., concurring). 68 [vol. LVL 1:39 VAELLO-MADERO ority list, and it seems it will remain so in the coming years. From the SARS CoV-2 pandemic, the political storm that has been brewing since before the 2020 elections and the ongoing conflict in Ukraine, it is hard to fathom that the U.S. territories are on Congress' to-do list. Also, because territorial law and policy is a subject that came into fruition generations ago, by lawmakers with wholly different political views and ideals, it is somewhat of an enigma to the current Congressional body. Much of that history is unknown, many of those doctrines are misplaced, and much of the exterior activism pushing for change is misunderstood. Thus, any hope for change rests on the shoulders of future judicial action, which should be consistent among the territories. The fact of the matter is this: the judiciary is more concerned with the precedent and historical understanding on the statutes they interpret, which makes them the best arbiters of the doctrines of their own creation. VI. Conclusion While this article mainly engages with the effects of the Vaello-Madero case on territorial law and policy, it should be noted that the doctrines from the Insular Cases exist for a reason. For example, the doctrine of express incorporation had the effect that Congress could decide that the Internal Revenue Code does not apply to the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, thus granting the island fiscal autonomy that the states do not have. Yet, this economic policy is on the borderline of dispute for the Commonwealth's political status, and this article does not intend to cross that barrier. In essence, there is no denying the Insular Cases brought with them egregious racial language towards the inhabitants of the territories, but the overall fundamental doctrines should be studied for their overall legal effects, not the demeaning remarks that accompany them. This does not, by any means, imply that the language used in the Insular Cases should be forgotten or pushed aside. For cases involving equal protection, it is a persuasive source for the historical mistreatment the judiciary undertook against the inhabitants of the territories during the early phases of the 2 0th century. But the modern approach should center around the contemporary judicial standards of the Fourteenth Amendment and the rights it guarantees vis-a-vis the power the Territorial Clause grants Congress upon the territories. As the First Circuit noted, the equal protection question posed by the VaelloMadero case brings forth the issue of legislative intent, given that the welfare programs at issue are designed for individuals who rely upon those benefits to have the means to sustain themselves. Yet, "equal protection has generally not been a promising avenue for Americans to attack federal welfare programs, 2021-20221 69 REVISTA JURiDICA U.I.P.R. whether or not they live in the territories."" The reason lies in that neither poverty nor territorial residency is considered as a suspect classification.1 53 Nevertheless, the exclusion of territorial residents from these types of programs has produced thoughtful observations on the district court level. For example, in Pena Martinez v. Azar,15 4 a case arguing that the exclusion of Puerto Ricans from SSI, SNAP and Medicare Part D subsidies violated equal protection under the Fifth Amendment, the district court noted that "[t]he federal safety net is flimsier and more porous in Puerto Rico than in the rest of the nation." 155 Recently, Congress has been more proactive towards the territories on issues concerning funding for food, medical and disability assistance, due to the territorial governments' financial and climate struggles. 56 The extension of the Pandemic Unemployment Assistance (PUA) program and the American Rescue Plan to the territories during the pandemic is a classic case in point.' 57 However, having to pin one's hopes and dreams for equal treatment upon a catalyst of undesirable circumstances seems anathema to the fundamental values of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness so profoundly rooted in the American legal system. What good is hope for equality when it remains linked to an avoidable humanitarian crisis due to either financial instabilities or natural disasters? Equal treatment and protection of the laws under the Constitution should not be a matter of territorial Ragnarok,1 58 wherefrom disaster a new and better world emerges. Instead, as the fiduciary responsible for constructing just and sensible laws that benefit the American people, Congress must make a greater effort to provide equality for U.S. citizens who happen to be territorial residents. Otherwise, outdated and unfair laws that adversely affect these citizens will continue to be subject to change by judicial fiat.

2023 DDI Affirmative
CPs › AT: Exec CP

Supreme Court is key to dismantle inequalities in America’s Territories.

Derieux and Weare 20[Cepeda Derieux & Neil C. Weare;08-27-2020; Adriel L Cepeda Derieux is a Senior Staff Attorney with the Voting Rights Project of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU). Neil Weare is the President and Founder of Equally American Legal Defense and Education Fund and an associate at Loeb and Loeb LLP ; "Law Journal Library," ]

Although the Supreme Court may have largely cabined the Insular Cases in Aurelius, that does not mean the Supreme Court should hesitate in a future case to place the Insular Cases in the dustbin of history alongside Plessy and Korematsu, where they belong. As framing documents for the continuing relationship between the United States and territories, the Insular Cases hold a power that goes far beyond the scope of their formal legal doctrine. Their rejection would loudly signal that residents of the territories "are constitutionally no different from, and thus not inferior to, their fellow citizens on the mainland."145 To paraphrase Justice Black, the Insular Cases' "interment," when it comes, cannot be "tactfully accomplished, without ceremony, eulogy, or report of their demise." 146 The Supreme Court played a central role in creating the structural, political, and economic inequalities afflicting residents of America's territories; it must also assume a leading role in dismantling them.

2023 DDI Affirmative
CPs › AT: Distinguish CP / "Overturn the Insular Cases but not Vaello-Madero" CP--Doesn't solve

Overturning Vaello-Madero is Necessary to stop structural inequality perpetuated by constitutional cases

Derieux and Weare 20 [Cepeda Derieux & Neil C. Weare;08-27-2020; Adriel L Cepeda Derieux is a Senior Staff Attorney with the Voting Rights Project of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU). Neil Weare is the President and Founder of Equally American Legal Defense and Education Fund and an associate at Loeb and Loeb LLP ; "Law Journal Library," ]

The Insular Cases figured prominently in the lower court briefing and at oral argument, with Vaello Madero arguing that the Insular Cases were evidence of racial animus towards residents of Puerto Rico and so reliance on them should warrant heightened scrutiny of Congress's denial of SSI benefits in Puerto Rico.139 The United States disclaimed any reliance or relevance of the Insular Cases, conceding "there is no dispute ... that equal protection principles apply to Puerto Rico," therefore "neither the incorporation doctrine nor the Insular Cases are relevant."140 Ultimately, the Insular Cases were not part of either the First Circuit or District Court's analysis. The United States has sought review of the First Circuit's decision by the Supreme Court.141 Its request for summary reversal 142 is audacious, given both the First Circuit panel's unanimous affirmation of the District Court's decision and the significant stakes involved. Absent summary reversal, review is probable given that the lower courts struck down a federal statute as unconstitutional. At the Supreme Court, the Insular Cases are likely to continue to figure prominently in the arguments raised by Vaello Madero and amici. But if Aurelius is any indication, the United States' express nonreliance on the Insular Cases may make the Court unwilling to reconsider the Insular Cases in the context of Vaello Madero, leaving other similar equal protection cases working their way through lower courts 143 to also be resolved without reference to the Insular Cases. Whatever the 138. Vaello-Madero, 956 F. 3d, aff'g, United States v. Vaello-Madero, 356 F. Supp. 3d 208 (D.P.R. 2019). 139. E.g., Oral Argument at 34:46, Vaello-Madero, 956 F.3d 12 (No. 19-1390), https:// www.courtlistener.com/audio/6634o/united-states-v-vaello-madero/ ?type=oa&q=&type= oa&order_by=score%2odesc&case_name=vaello-madero%2o&court=cal [https://perma.cc /96PS-VAVE]; Jose Luis Vaello Madero's Motion for Summary Judgment at 18-25, VaelloMadero, 356 F. Supp. 3d (No. 17-02133); see also Brief of Amicus Curiae Virgin Islands Bar Ass'n at 6-15, Vaello-Madero, 956 F 3d 12 (No. 19-1390); Commonwealth of Puerto Rico's Amicus Brief at 6-23, Vaello-Madero, 956 F.3d 12 (No. 19-1390). 140. Reply Brief for Appellant at 1i, Vaello-Madero, 956 F.3d (No. 19-1390); see also Reply Brief in Support of United States of America's Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment at 8 n.2, VaelloMadero, 356 F. Supp. 3d ("[E]ven if the Insular Cases were to be overturned by the Supreme Court, that would not affect the outcome here."). 141. Petition for Writ of Certiorari, United States v. Vaello Madero, No. 20-303 (U.S. July 1, 2020), https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/20/20-303/153244/20200904184238974__Vaello -Madero%20Pet.pdf [https://perma.cc/2YSU-H6G7]. 142. Id. at 20. 143. See, e.g., Pena Martinez v. Azar, 376 F Supp. 3d 191 (D.P.R. 2019); Schaller v. Soc. Sec. Admin., No. 20-1837 (3d Cit. filed Apr. 27, 2020); Schaller v. Soc. Sec. Admin., No. 1:2018cv00044 (D. Guam motion to dismiss denied June 19, 2020); Consejo de Salud v. United States, No. 18- 1045 (GAG) (D.P.R. motion for summary judgement granted Mar. 30. 2020). 305 THE YALE LAW JOURNAL FORUM Supreme Court says or does not say about the Insular Cases, its decision in Vaello Madero will either reject or confirm the underlying structural inequality that the Insular Cases have allowed to perpetuate these many years. And the fact that the United States is left to expressly disclaim any relevance or reliance on the Insular Cases in cases like Vaello Madero only serves to highlight the mischief they continue to cause in all manner of constitutional cases.

2023 DDI Affirmative
CPs › AT: CP Leave it to them

The Aff is a prerequisite. The first step to equality for Americans in the territories is a rejection of the Insular Cases through the overturning of Vaello-Madero

Weare 18, President and Founder of Equally American

[Neil Weare, President and Founder of Equally American, a non-profit organization committed to achieving equal rights for the nearly 4 million Americans living in U.S. territories. He worked for Guam’s non-voting Delegate to Congress prior to attending Yale Law School. "Why the Insular Cases Must Become the Next Plessy," Harvard Law Review, 3-28-2018, ] /RS

Underlying the current crises facing U.S. territories and the underwhelming federal response is a legal and political relationship that contradicts America’s most fundamental democratic and constitutional principles. The source of this un-American relationship is the Insular Cases, a series of controversial and deeply divided early 1900s Supreme Court decisions that validated the full extension of U.S. sovereignty to overseas territories without requiring the full extension of constitutional rights. As First Circuit Judge Juan Torruella recently explained in the Harvard Law Review Forum, these decisions allowed Americans in the territories “to be treated unequally from those in the rest of the nation solely by reason of their geographical residence.” Judge Torruella has become the most prominent critic of the Insular Cases, arguing forcefully that “the Insular Cases represent classic Plessy v. Ferguson legal doctrine and thought that should be totally eradicated from present-day constitutional reasoning.” Judge Torruella’s powerful words must serve as an inspiration to action.

2023 DDI Affirmative
CPs › AT: CP Repurpose the insular cases to be anti-colonial

FG Insular cases reinforces the “subject” status of colonized people

Charlton and Fadgen '22 [Guy and Tim; 2022; Guy C. Charlton is an Associate Professor of Law at University of New England (Australia) and Adjunct Professor at AUT (New Zealand) and Curtin University (Australia). He holds a PhD (University of Auckland);J.D. (University of Wisconsin); and MA (Toronto). He is admitted to the Wisconsin Bar. Tim Fadgen is a Senior Lecturer in Public Policy at University of Auckland. He holds a PhD (University of Auckland) and J.D. (University of Maine). He is admitted to the Maine Bar and was a past member of the American Samoa and Western Samoa Bar, former Assistant Attorney General in American Samoa, and former Special Assistant to Samoa's Attorney General.; " CASE NOTE: FITISEMANU V. UNITED STATES: U.S. Citizenship in American Samoa and the Insular Cases," PACIFIC BASIN LAW JOURNAL, Vol. 39, Issue/No. 1, p. 41-42//JJB]

The underlying ethos of the Insular Cases is beyond the scope of this note. However, it is evident that using the Insular framework to argue that Samoan self-determination is enhanced inappropriately conceptualizes the notion of self-determination. First, it inappropriately equates the Territory's governmental autonomy and organizational capacity with the individual rights of native-born American Samoans. Given the plenary authority of Congress and the Executive over the territory which enables Federal Government can alter the constitutional structure and rights of the population of American Samoa as it deems fit, it is arguable that a grant of citizenship is likely more important to the "dignity" and "autonomy" of individuals in the territory than local autonomy subject to Congressional oversight. The precariousness of American Samoan rights 62. Article 3 states, "Indigenous peoples have the right to self-determination. By virtue of that right they freely determine their political status and freely pursue their economic, social and cultural development." G.A. Res. 61/295, annex, Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (Sept. 13, 2007), 63. These concepts are reflected in the seminal American Indian cases Johnson v. M'Intosh, 21 U.S. (8 Wheat.) 543 (1823); Cherokee Nation v. Georgia, 30 U.S. (5 Pet.) 1 (1831); and Worcester v. Georgia, 31 U.S. (6 Pet.) 515 (1832) written by Chief Justice Marshall. For a recent discussion of the relationship, see United States v. Wheeler, 435 U.S. 313 (1978) and United States v. Cooley, 141 S. Ct.1638 (2021). 64. Fitisemanu v. United States, 1 F.4th 862, 870 (10th Cir. 2021). 65. Jeffrey B. Teichert, Resisting Temptation in the Garden of Paradise: Preserving the Role of Samoan Custom in the Law of American Samoa, 3 GONZ. J. INT'L L. 35, 41-42 (2000). 2022 41 PACIFIC BASIN LAW JOURNAL under the Plenary Power doctrine, rather than exhibiting self-determination and dignity, seemingly reinforces the "subject" status of American Samoans as colonized peoples.

2023 DDI Affirmative
T › T Expand Social Security

Expanding social security includes expanding eligibility

Romig and Washington 22, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities

[Kathleen Romig and Sam Washington, Director of Social Security and Disability Policy at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, Research Assistant with the Center's Federal Fiscal Policy team, "Policymakers Should Expand and Simplify Supplemental Security Income," Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, 5-4-2022, ] /RS

Lawmakers should expand and update SSI to ensure that recipients can work, marry, save, keep more of their Social Security benefits, and accept help from their loved ones without facing harsh penalties. They also should expand eligibility to immigrants and residents of U.S. Territories and increase benefits to keep pace with rising standards of living. Both the SSI Restoration Act and President Biden’s campaign proposal on disability provide a roadmap to modernize SSI for the 21st century.

2023 DDI Affirmative
T › T Throughout U.S.

“The United States” means any territory under sovereignty of the U.S.

Ripple Judge on the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals '7[Kenneth F. Ripple;1-16-2007; Federal Judge on the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals; "Arnett v. C.I.R, 473 F.3d 790," ]

Indeed, with respect to the word "includes," the definition of "foreign country" largely mirrors the rule's definition of "United States" in its usage of "includes." See 26 C.F.R. § 1.911-2(g). The rule defines the "United States" as:

United States. The term "United States" when used in a geographical sense includes any territory under the sovereignty of the United States. It includes the states, the District of Columbia, the possessions and territories of the United States, the territorial waters of the United States, the air space over the United States, and the seabed and subsoil of those submarine areas which are adjacent to the territorial waters of the United States and over which the United States has exclusive rights, in accordance with international law, with respect to the exploration and exploitation of natural resources.

2023 DDI Affirmative
T › T Throughout U.S.

“In” means within the physical boundaries of

United States Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit '21[, United States Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit;7-20-2021; The United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit (in case citations, 8th Cir.) is a United States federal court with appellate jurisdiction over the following United States district courts: Eastern District of Arkansas Western District of Arkansas Northern District of Iowa Southern District of Iowa District of Minnesota Eastern District of Missouri Western District of Missouri District of Nebraska District of North Dakota District of South Dakota ; "Smart Communications Collier Inc. v. Pope County Sheriff's Office, 5 F.4th 895," https://casetext.com/case/smart-communications-collier-inc-v-pope-county-sheriffs-office//JJB]

Smart points to Simonoff v. Expedia, Inc. where a forum-selection clause required the parties to litigate in the "courts in King County, Washington." 643 F.3d 1202, 1205 (9th Cir. 2011). The Ninth Circuit reasoned that

[t]he word "in" means to " ‘express[ ] relation of presence, existence, situation, inclusion ... ; inclosed or surround by limits, as in a room.’ " ... Black's Law Dictionary 758 (6th ed. 1990) .... Hence the phrase "courts in" a state includes any court within the physical boundaries of the state, even if the court does not derive its power and authority from the sovereignty of the state.

2023 DDI Affirmative
T › T in the U.S.

Puerto Rico is a part of the U.S. and must follow all U.S. laws – Since U.S. already has complete jurisdiction over it, this independently shows we meet.

American History 'ND[Preparing For The Oath U.S. History And Civics For Citizenship; ND; Preparing for the Oath is a product of the National Museum of American History (NMAH) and U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS).; "U.S. Territories," ]

There are five major U.S. territories: Puerto Rico, U.S. Virgin Islands, American Samoa, Northern Mariana Islands, and Guam. A territory is a part of the United States that is not a state. Territories have their own local governments. They also must follow the laws of the U.S. federal government.

2023 DDI Affirmative
T › T in the U.S.

“The United States” means any territory under sovereignty of the U.S. federal goervment.

Ripple Judge on the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals '7[Kenneth F. Ripple;1-16-2007; Federal Judge on the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals; "Arnett v. C.I.R, 473 F.3d 790," ]

Indeed, with respect to the word "includes," the definition of "foreign country" largely mirrors the rule's definition of "United States" in its usage of "includes." See 26 C.F.R. § 1.911-2(g). The rule defines the "United States" as:

United States. The term "United States" when used in a geographical sense includes any territory under the sovereignty of the United States. It includes the states, the District of Columbia, the possessions and territories of the United States, the territorial waters of the United States, the air space over the United States, and the seabed and subsoil of those submarine areas which are adjacent to the territorial waters of the United States and over which the United States has exclusive rights, in accordance with international law, with respect to the exploration and exploitation of natural resources.

2023 DDI Affirmative
T › T in the U.S.

“In” means within the physical boundaries of

United States Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit '21[, United States Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit;7-20-2021; The United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit (in case citations, 8th Cir.) is a United States federal court with appellate jurisdiction over the following United States district courts: Eastern District of Arkansas Western District of Arkansas Northern District of Iowa Southern District of Iowa District of Minnesota Eastern District of Missouri Western District of Missouri District of Nebraska District of North Dakota District of South Dakota ; "Smart Communications Collier Inc. v. Pope County Sheriff's Office, 5 F.4th 895," https://casetext.com/case/smart-communications-collier-inc-v-pope-county-sheriffs-office//JJB]

Smart points to Simonoff v. Expedia, Inc. where a forum-selection clause required the parties to litigate in the "courts in King County, Washington." 643 F.3d 1202, 1205 (9th Cir. 2011). The Ninth Circuit reasoned that

[t]he word "in" means to " ‘express[ ] relation of presence, existence, situation, inclusion ... ; inclosed or surround by limits, as in a room.’ " ... Black's Law Dictionary 758 (6th ed. 1990) .... Hence the phrase "courts in" a state includes any court within the physical boundaries of the state, even if the court does not derive its power and authority from the sovereignty of the state.

2023 DDI Affirmative
T › T in the U.S.

We meet: Puerto Rico is in the U.S.

[rehighlighting in blue] - Kollar-Kotelly 16 – (Colleen Kollar-Kotelly is a United States District Judge for the District of Columbia); Lin v. United States, 177 F. Supp. 3d 242, 258-59 (D.D.C. 2016); https://casetext.com/case/lin-v-us-republic-of-china //sp

The FSIA's term “United States” is narrowly construed to mean only “the continental United States and those islands that are part of the United States and its possessions,” Amerada Hess , 488 U.S. at 440, 109 S.Ct. 683, and does not include territories over which the United States might exercise some form of jurisdiction. See id. at 440–41, 109 S.Ct. 683 ; Persinger v. Islamic Rep. of Iran , 729 F.2d 835, 839 (D.C.Cir.1984). For example, the “high seas” fall outside the FSIA's definition of the “United States” even though the high seas might otherwise be within the United States' admiralty jurisdiction. Amerada Hess , 488 U.S. at 440–41, 109 S.Ct. 683. Similarly, a U.S. embassy in a foreign country does not constitute the “United States” for purposes of the FSIA because, even though the United States exercises certain forms of jurisdiction over its embassies, embassies are not within the continental United States and are not islands or possessions of the United States. Persinger , 729 F.2d at 839–842. See also Perez v. The Bahamas , 652 F.2d 186, 189 n.1 (D.C.Cir.1981) (expressing doubt that a territory falling within the “Fishery Conservation Zone suffices as territory of the United States within the meaning of the FSIA” because it was clear that Congress intended the Fishery Conservation Management Act to extend U.S. jurisdiction only for limited maritime purposes). Here, Plaintiffs argue that the tortious activity at issue occurred “within the United States” because when the nationality decrees were issued in 1946, Taiwan was “subject to complete American military occupation” and therefore should be considered “within the United States” for purposes of the FSIA's non-commercial tort exception. See Pls.' Opp'n to ROC's Mot. at 18. Plaintiffs' argument is unavailing and contrary to the established case law described above. The Supreme Court and the D.C. Circuit have definitely held that the FSIA's term, “United States,” is narrowly construed to mean only “the continental United States and those islands that are part of the United States and its possessions,” Amerada Hess , 488 U.S. at 440, 109 S.Ct. 683, and does not include territories over which the United States might exercise some form of jurisdiction. See id. at 440–41, 109 S.Ct. 683 ; Persinger , 729 F.2d at 839

2023 DDI Affirmative
Case › AT: Welfare State Bad

The Welfare state good for a laundry list of reasons—it acts as an economic stabilizer and protects workers’ well-being.

Ghilarducci ’15. [ Teresa Ghilarducci is an American scholar on labor and retirement issues. She obtained a BA and Ph.D. in economics from the University of California at Berkeley.] “The Welfare State: A Terrible Name For An Essential System.” December 3, 2015. https://12ft.io/proxy?q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.theatlantic.com%2Fbusiness%2Farchive%2F2015%2F12%2Fthe-welfare-state-a-terrible-name-for-an-essential-system%2F418500%2F

At a time when Bernie Sanders is inspiring crowds with a version of socialism, the concept of “the welfare state” may be so retro that it is due for a similar revival. In an essay for Fortune this summer, the Stanford business professor Jeffrey Pfeffer made the case that firms should be hiring full-time employees rather than freelancers. He was effectively calling for an expansion of America’s social-safety net, since employees get access to state benefits that freelancers don’t. Pfeffer’s essay ostensibly addresses the gig economy, but it’s really about the importance of regular jobs with decent benefits. Without employers, part-time and self-employed workers are left to assemble a patchwork of employment insurance to go along with their patchwork of jobs. Pfeffer takes the occasion of the gig economy’s supposed rise to talk about the importance of work that’s dependable and well compensated. Many experts do estimate that gig work is becoming more prevalent, but the numbers are not entirely straightforward; the Economic Policy Institute’s Lawrence Mishel has argued in The Atlantic that the rise of Uber-like freelancing is actually overstated. At any rate, the Government Accountability Office has estimated that contingent workers, which includes temps, the self-employed, and on-call workers, accounted for about 8 percent of the workforce in 2010. While independent-contractor roles are indeed putting pressure on some of today’s workers to find substitutes for employee benefits such as employment insurance and health insurance, there have always been workers who are employed gig to gig. Some professionals who might not be thought of as gig workers, such as radiologists, dentists, and accountants, can find work that way. Up to 30 percent of the American workforce is part-time, temporary, or doing independent contract work—which means they don’t have employers to provide any benefits. So, regardless of whether the gig economy is growing, now is as good a time as ever to discuss the need for “the welfare state”—a highly useful policy program that has been given an off-putting name. “Welfare” has two main meanings: general well-being, and, in some circles, government handouts. Welfare, though, is not designed with either of those meanings in mind—it’s a system of programs, including Social Security, Medicare, and unemployment insurance, that automatically props up consumer spending during recessions by making sure workers are getting by. Yes, an individual who receives money when unexpected, uncontrollable events stop him or her from working is getting help from the government. But it also helps on the level of the economy, as it makes sure that aggregate demand stays high during labor-market slumps. In this sense, the welfare state stabilizes capitalism. How robust should America’s welfare programs be? Today, “welfare” has taken on a negative (and often racially charged) tint in the public’s eye, but there was, not long ago, a fierce debate about how to best help poor and struggling workers. The debate was over which of three routes the government should take: providing workers with benefits directly, encouraging companies to give employees benefits, or giving all Americans a guaranteed annual wage to obviate the need for either of the first two approaches. Surprisingly enough, this third option had the support of Richard Nixon. Some business executives have taken it upon themselves to steer their companies along the second path. Costco’s CEO, James Sinegal, and Ed Ossie, the COO of the insurance-software company Majesco, have both built successful businesses that are based on giving employees robust compensation packages. Pfeffer, in his article, quoted Ossie as saying, “Talented, trained employees treated well by their employers will treat customers well and deliver exceptional service.” This attitude is, of course, not the norm. Many American workers are left up to their country’s occasionally patchy policies. Almost half of workers don’t have any pension plans besides Social Security, and freelance workers are the least likely to have a supplement to Social Security. And the U.S. long stood alone among developed countries by not offering universal health care coverage. The solution to that, the Affordable Care Act, is essentially a compromise between letting employers provide coverage voluntarily and requiring the state to provide it to everyone. But in the big picture, when it comes to welfare, the U.S. is more like Sweden and Denmark than not—the skeleton is there. As some people reject expansions of “the welfare state” out of hand, it’s worth remembering that all advanced countries are welfare states, and there are good reasons for that.

2023 DDI Affirmative
Case › AT: Welfare State Bad

The welfare state is key to ensuring that wealth distribution reflects differences in household composition.

Bruenig ’22. [ Matthew Bruenig is an American lawyer, blogger, policy analyst, and commentator. He received his BA from the University of Oklahoma and JD from Boston University.] “Why We Need the Welfare State.” February 18th, 2022. https://www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2022/02/18/why-we-need-the-welfare-state/

One of the major historical rationales for the welfare state has been equalizing living standards between similar families with different numbers of workers and dependents. Around the 1970s, this rationale began to fall out of the welfare state discourse and, these days, you rarely hear anyone talk about it. This is in the first panel of the graphic we see two identical workers who do equal work and receive equal pay. One worker lives alone. The other lives with an elderly father, a disabled spouse, and two kids. Because the latter worker has to stretch his pay across five people while the former worker only has to stretch his pay across one person, the two identical workers have very unequal livelihoods. In the second panel, the welfare state comes in to fix this problem. Some of each worker’s pay is redirected into a central welfare state and then that welfare state pays out benefits to the elderly parent (old-age pension), the disabled spouse (disability benefits), and the children (child allowance). The welfare state thereby ensures that the two workers now enjoy equal livelihoods. Certain leftists who are skeptical of the welfare state will see the above graphic and say that the problem is actually the rich capitalist on the bottom. If we toppled him, then we wouldn’t need a welfare state. But this isn’t true. Consider the following graphic in which the employer at the bottom is no longer a factory run by a rich capitalist who profits handsomely but is instead run by the state or run as a worker co-op. a shame because the horizontal equality case for the welfare state is extremely strong and also helps explain why the welfare state should feature universal benefits rather than means-tested benefits. To help communicate this argument for the welfare state, I asked Jon White to recreate an old welfare state diagram from 1940s Switzerland. Despite the change in ownership, the problem of these two workers having unequal livelihoods remains the same. Even if all of the profits of the firm are redistributed down to the workers, it’s still the case that the worker who lives alone has vastly more income, on a per-person basis, than the worker who lives with an elderly father, a disabled spouse, and two kids. Only a welfare state that transfers income from workers to nonworkers and thereby enacts net transfers from households with few nonworkers to households with many nonworkers can fix this particular source of inequality. This is not to say that there is no difference between a privately-owned company, a state-owned enterprise, and a worker co-op. There are huge differences between them, including differences that have big effects on the distribution of income in society. But these differences do not solve the problem that the welfare state solves. Payments to capital and labor do not take into consideration differences in household composition and so they can never be reformed in a way that generates an egalitarian society. You can make pay differences between workers smaller. You can also redistribute income from capital to labor. But if you want to make sure that the final income distribution is sensitive to differences in household composition, there is no substitute for a universal welfare state.

2023 DDI Affirmative
Case › AT: SS Out of Money

‘Running out of money’ has zero implications

Aimee Picchi, 5-10-2023, "Will the Social Security fund run out — and what will happen if it does? Experts explain.," CBS News, ] RS

Yet experts say that some Americans, especially younger workers, have misunderstandings about the impact if the trust fund indeed goes bust — a prediction, by the way, that's by no means a certainty. Even if the trust fund becomes depleted, the Social Security Administration will continue to take in payroll taxes from workers and their employers, allowing the program to pay the majority of benefits, experts note.

2023 DDI Affirmative
Case › AT: Puerto Rico Has Automonomy

The Aff is a prerequisite. The first step to equality for Americans in the territories is a rejection of the Insular Cases through the overturning of Vaello-Madero

Weare 18, President and Founder of Equally American

[Neil Weare, President and Founder of Equally American, a non-profit organization committed to achieving equal rights for the nearly 4 million Americans living in U.S. territories. He worked for Guam’s non-voting Delegate to Congress prior to attending Yale Law School. "Why the Insular Cases Must Become the Next Plessy," Harvard Law Review, 3-28-2018, ] /RS

Underlying the current crises facing U.S. territories and the underwhelming federal response is a legal and political relationship that contradicts America’s most fundamental democratic and constitutional principles. The source of this un-American relationship is the Insular Cases, a series of controversial and deeply divided early 1900s Supreme Court decisions that validated the full extension of U.S. sovereignty to overseas territories without requiring the full extension of constitutional rights. As First Circuit Judge Juan Torruella recently explained in the Harvard Law Review Forum, these decisions allowed Americans in the territories “to be treated unequally from those in the rest of the nation solely by reason of their geographical residence.” Judge Torruella has become the most prominent critic of the Insular Cases, arguing forcefully that “the Insular Cases represent classic Plessy v. Ferguson legal doctrine and thought that should be totally eradicated from present-day constitutional reasoning.” Judge Torruella’s powerful words must serve as an inspiration to action.

2023 DDI Affirmative
Case › AT: Puerto Rico Has Automonomy

Absent the aff, Puerto Rico will remain under the control of the United States.

Peralta 6-21, Professor, Inter-American University of Puerto Rico School of Law

[Carlos Iván Gorrín Peralta, 6-21-23, Professor, Inter-American University of Puerto Rico School of Law; former president of the Inter-American Bar Association; vice president of the InterAmerican Academy of International and Comparative Law., “The Law of the Territories of the United States in Puerto Rico, the Oldest Colony in the World,” https://repository.law.miami.edu/umialr/vol54/iss2/4/] /RS

The territorial law and policy of the United States changed towards the turn of the 20th century, as territorial expansion was no longer motivated by the extension of national borders, but by geopolitical, strategic and economic objectives. The new territories acquired in the Spanish American war were different from those previously annexed. The resulting constitutional doctrine of the Insular Cases differentiated the previous incorporated territories from the new unincorporated territories, which were not destined to be part of the U.S. nor to be admitted as new states. Despite purported changes in the relation with the United States in 1950-1952, Puerto Rico is still an unincorporated territory, subject to plenary territorial powers without its participation in the government of its sovereign. During the second half of the twentieth century, the international law of human rights has recognized the right to self-determination of all peoples. As a result, the constitutional law of early twentieth century is at odds with the international legal obligations of the United States arising from customary law and those assumed under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Human Rights, which entered into force for the United States three decades ago. This article presents substantive and procedural avenues for the harmonization of U.S. constitutional law with international law through the exercise of the right of self-determination by the people of Puerto Rico.

2023 DDI Affirmative
Case › AT: Providing Benefits DS

AND the benefits go a long way—plan liberates trillions of dollars back into the economy

Abislaiman 21- attorney in San Juan

Isabel Abislaiman, " BRIEF OF AMICI CURIAE PLAINTIFF RUIZ-AVILES V. SSA, AND PLAINTIFF AND PLAINTIFF CLASS RIVERA-FUENTES, ET AL. V. SAUL, IN SUPPORT OF RESPONDENT," Supreme Court of the United States, 08-21-2021, https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/20/20-303/188432/20210824150801053_VaelloRuizAmicus%20Main%20EFILE%20Aug%2020%2021.pdf-- 嘉玮/MDC

For example, the U.S. leads or has access to the World’s most advanced scientific and economic thinking of the 21st century. Serious studies show that making even small changes in national healthcare policies can radically reduce healthcare costs and actually liberate trillions of dollars back into the economy. Jaana Remes et al., Prioritizing Health: A Prescription for Prosperity, McKinsey Global Institute (July 2020). According to the findings of the McKinsey report, prioritizing the health of all citizens translates into general economic prosperity. https://www.mckinsey. com/industries/healthcare-systems-and-services/ourinsights/prioritizing-health-a-prescription-forprosperity. As trillions of dollars could be liberated for the benefit of the national economy, the U.S. could be very well prepared to protect all citizens— disabled and not disabled, aged and not aged, poor and not poor, and still free up budget resources for many other purposes. It is widely known that citizens’ poor health is directly linked to economic losses nationwide, thus it makes no sense that Petitioner would argue in favor of preserving an antiquated law that discriminates with the only result of making sure a “discrete and insular minority” of U.S. citizens remain without assistance to handle the demands of poor health, and sustain the correlative economic burden, as a matter of “routine”. Pet.Br.25.