Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Internal NB › I/L---Pilots Solve---2NC

Pilot programs are key to effective regulatory implementation.

Colleen V. Chien 19, Justin D'Atri Visiting Professor of Business Law, Columbia Law School; Professor, Santa Clara University School of Law; 2013-2015 White House Senior Advisor, Innovation and Intellectual Property, “Rigorous Policy Pilots: Experimentation in the Administration of the Law,” 104 Iowa L. Rev. 2313, July 2019, Lexis

In the government, fear of making a Type 1 or “false positive” error—taking a mistaken step—leads to an overabundance of Type 2 or “false negative” errors—failing to take a productive step. At root, however, is the problem of “what [the] government doesn’t know,” regarding what changes to law or policy to consider taking, what the impact of such changes might be, and which among several potential changes is most likely to achieve a policy goal, all topics about which there may be many opinions, but little relevant evidence. Uncertainty about whether a law or policy change will achieve its intended purpose, fear of making a mistake in the face of this uncertainty, and institutional inertia all contribute to status quo bias—whether in favor of preserving regulations that don’t work or failing to adopt new policies that do.

One way to address both the knowledge gap and risk aversion in policy development is by introducing a temporary change to law or policy for the purpose of learning from it, through a “policy pilot.” Implemented with rigor, through the application of, “well-designed and well-implemented methods tailored to the questions being asked”—rigorous policy pilots are a generative yet under-used tool for addressing informational deficits that stand in the way of developing effective law and policy.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Internal NB › I/L---Spillover---2NC

Costs of experimentation are decreasing, interest is going up, but establishing a precedent for rigorous evaluation is key

Colleen V. Chien 19, Justin D'Atri Visiting Professor of Business Law, Columbia Law School; Professor, Santa Clara University School of Law; 2013-2015 White House Senior Advisor, Innovation and Intellectual Property, “Rigorous Policy Pilots: Experimentation in the Administration of the Law,” 104 Iowa L. Rev. 2313, July 2019, Lexis

It is also worth remembering that calls for rigorous evaluation are not new and their results have not necessarily been encouraging. Critics have described evaluation mandates embedded in the Government Performance and Results Act of 1993 (“GPRA”), the GPRA Modernization Act of 2010 (“GPRAMA”), and successive generations of retrospective review requirements as hampered by resource constraints, pro forma compliance, and a lack of oversight.

However, several developments make it an opportune time to persevere and attempt to answer, not abandon their call. First the costs of controlled experimentation are going down, thanks to the advance of open data, and the adoption of “agile” and “policy lab” approaches in government, which have increased the expertise and decreased measurement and assessment costs. Second, the embrace of performance- or results-based lawmaking has shifted attention away from policy processes and towards policy outcomes, discoverable through trial and error or disciplined experimentation. Third, the 2018 Evidence Act, if implemented as intended, should significantly shore up agency capacity for rigorous evaluation. The Act requires departments and agencies within the Act’s jurisdiction to submit annual plans for identifying and addressing policy relevant questions that specify “data to . . . facilitate the use of evidence in policy making.” It establishes an Interagency Council on Evaluation Policy, requires each relevant agency to designate a Chief Evaluation Officer and requires the Office of Management and Budget (“OMB”) to establish an Advisory Committee on Data for Evidence Building to advise on expanding access to and use of federal data for evidence building. These activities should inform and ease at least two of the steps of rigorous piloting described below—identifying important questions and developing the evidence to evaluate them.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Internal NB › UQ---2NC

Current experimental regulatory frameworks are ineffective---recommitting to meaningful evidence-based evaluations is vital.

Kristen Underhill 19, Associate Professor of Law, Columbia Law School, “Broken Experimentation, Sham Evidence-Based Policy,” 38 Yale L. & Pol'y Rev. 150, Fall 2019, Lexis

Evidence-based policy is gaining attention, and legislation and agency regulation have been no exception to calls for greater uptake of research evidence. Indeed, current interest in “moneyball for government” is part of a long history of efforts to promote research-based decisions in government, from the U.S. Census to cost-benefit analysis. But although evidence-based policy-making (EBPM) is often both feasible and desirable, there are reasons to be skeptical of the capacity of EBPM in governmental decision-making. EBPM is itself bounded by limits on rationality, the capacity of science, the objectivity of science, and the authority we wish to give technocrats. Where values are highly contentious, efforts to produce and use evidence in legislative and regulatory decisions may go so far awry that they become “sham” versions of evidence-based choices. In this Article, I name several of these sham practices, including the distortion of evidence, the engagement in “terminal” experimentation that destabilizes governmental programs, and “ratcheting” actions that defund entire priorities rather than individual approaches. Broken experimentation is also common, with evaluations of government programming and policies neglecting or misusing opportunities to provide rigorous evidence. I argue that the stakes of these misuses are high, resulting in losses of welfare and efficiency, erosion of scientific legitimacy, and infringement on the dignity of human subjects. But where genuine engagement with empirical evidence is possible, the game is surely worth the candle. This Article proposes novel ways to promote responsible uses of empirical evidence in both legislation and agency regulation, including evaluation mandates, pre-registration of evaluation protocols and transparency of research reports, ex ante decision commitments, and more attentive uses of judicial review.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Perm / Theory › Perm do the CP---Basic Income

It’s synonymous with UBI

Center for Hunger Free Communities 21, Drexel University, “Universal Basic Income: Key to Reducing Food Insecurity and Improving Health,” https://drexel.edu/hunger-free-center/research/briefs-and-reports/universal-basic-income/

If every person received the same basic income “floor” regardless of income, class, race, location of residence, or other status, the stigma of receiving support could be eliminated.

UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Perm / Theory › Perm do the CP---Basic Income

Covers everyone unconditionally

Stanford Basic Income Lab ND, “What is Basic Income?,” Stanford, https://basicincome.stanford.edu/about/what-is-ubi/#:~:text=Basic%20income%20is%20a%20regular,work%20requirement%20of%20other%20conditions.

Basic income is a regular cash payment to all members of a community, without a work requirement of other conditions.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Perm / Theory › Perm do the CP---Top

Increase

HEFC 4 (Higher Education Funding Council for England, “Joint Committee on the Draft Charities Bill Written Evidence”, June,http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/jt200304/jtselect/jtchar/167/167we98.htm)

9.1  The Draft Bill creates an obligation on the principal regulator to do all that it "reasonably can to meet the compliance objective in relation to the charity".[45] The Draft Bill defines the compliance objective as "to increase compliance by the charity trustees with their legal obligations in exercising control and management of the administration of the charity".[46] 9.2  Although the word "increase" is used in relation to the functions of a number of statutory bodies,[47] such examples demonstrate that "increase" is used in relation to considerations to be taken into account in the exercise of a function, rather than an objective in itself. 9.3  HEFCE is concerned that an obligation on principal regulators to "increase" compliance per se is unworkable, in so far as it does not adequately define the limits or nature of the statutory duty. Indeed, the obligation could be considered to be ever-increasing.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Perm / Theory › Perm do the CP---Top

Substantial

Words and Phrases 64 (40 W&P 759) (this edition of W&P is out of print; the page number no longer matches up to the current edition and I was unable to find the card in the new edition. However, this card is also available on google books, Judicial and statutory definitions of words and phrases, Volume 8, p. 7329)

The words “outward, open, actual, visible, substantial, and exclusive,” in connection with a change of possession, mean substantially the same thing. They mean not concealed; not hidden; exposed to view; free from concealment, dissimulation, reserve, or disguise; in full existence; denoting that which not merely can be, but is opposed to potential, apparent, constructive, and imaginary; veritable; genuine; certain; absolute; real at present time, as a matter of fact, not merely nominal; opposed to form; actually existing; true; not including admitting, or pertaining to any others; undivided; sole; opposed to inclusive. Bass v. Pease, 79 Ill. App. 308, 318.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Perm / Theory › Perm do the CP---Top

Should

Summers 94 (Justice – Oklahoma Supreme Court, “Kelsey v. Dollarsaver Food Warehouse of Durant”, 1994 OK 123, 11-8, http://www.oscn.net/applications/oscn/DeliverDocument.asp?CiteID=20287#marker3fn13)

The legal question to be resolved by the court is whether the word "should"13 in the May 18 order connotes futurity or may be deemed a ruling in praesenti.14 The answer to this query is not to be divined from rules of grammar;15 it must be governed by the age-old practice culture of legal professionals and its immemorial language usage. To determine if the omission (from the critical May 18 entry) of the turgid phrase, "and the same hereby is", (1) makes it an in futuro ruling - i.e., an expression of what the judge will or would do at a later stage - or (2) constitutes an in in praesenti resolution of a disputed law issue, the trial judge's intent must be garnered from the four corners of the entire record.16 "Should" not only is used as a "present indicative" synonymous with ought but also is the past tense of "shall" with various shades of meaning not always easy to analyze. See 57 C.J. Shall § 9, Judgments § 121 (1932). O. JESPERSEN, GROWTH AND STRUCTURE OF THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE (1984); St. Louis & S.F.R. Co. v. Brown, 45 Okl. 143, 144 P. 1075, 1080-81 (1914). For a more detailed explanation, see the Partridge quotation infra note 15. Certain contexts mandate a construction of the term "should" as more than merely indicating preference or desirability. Brown, supra at 1080-81 (jury instructions stating that jurors "should" reduce the amount of damages in proportion to the amount of contributory negligence of the plaintiff was held to imply an obligation and to be more than advisory); Carrigan v. California Horse Racing Board, 60 Wash. App. 79, (1990) (one of the Rules of Appellate Procedure requiring that a party "should devote a section of the brief to the request for the fee or expenses" was interpreted to mean that a party is under an obligation to include the requested segment); State v. Rack, 318 S.W.2d 211, 215 (Mo. 1958) ("should" would mean the same as "shall" or "must" when used in an instruction to the jury which tells the triers they "should disregard false testimony"). In praesenti means literally "at the present time." BLACK'S LAW DICTIONARY 792 (6th Ed. 1990). In legal parlance the phrase denotes that which in law is presently or immediately effective, as opposed to something that will or would become effective in the future [in futurol]. See Van Wyck v. Knevals, , 365, 1 S.Ct. 336, 337, 27 L.Ed. 201 (1882).

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Perm / Theory › Perm do the CP---Top

Resolved

OED 89 (Oxford English Dictionary, “Resolved,” Volume 13, p. 725)

Of the mind, etc.: Freed from doubt or uncertainty, fixed, settled. Obs.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Perm / Theory › Perm do Both---2NC

CONTROL GROUP---premature uniform application means there’s no baseline for comparison---this makes programs ineffective.

Colleen V. Chien 19, Justin D'Atri Visiting Professor of Business Law, Columbia Law School; Professor, Santa Clara University School of Law; 2013-2015 White House Senior Advisor, Innovation and Intellectual Property, “Rigorous Policy Pilots: Experimentation in the Administration of the Law,” 104 Iowa L. Rev. 2313, July 2019, Lexis

The range of open questions in law and policy that can be addressed by pilots are wide-ranging. They include, for example, the question of how giving a universal basic income ("UBI") to individuals impacts their well-being and employment. In 2017, the Finnish government began tracking the outcomes of 7,000 unemployed citizens, about a third to which it gave $ 600 a month, [*2317] to address this question; 14several U.S. jurisdictions are planning their own tests. 15Also unknown is how the administration of patent law and issuance of quality patents best advance the Constitutional goal of "promoting the progress of science and useful arts." 16Over the last decade, the United States Patent and Trademark Office ("USPTO") has run numerous pilots to address this question. 17As the D.C. Circuit has said, "there are some situations in which, "a month of experience will be worth a year of hearings.'" 18While experiments or pilots can address a variety of questions pertaining, e.g., to a policy's feasibility or stakeholder reactions, when the question concerns whether the policy has caused an observed outcome, a controlled trial that provides the treatment to one part of population, withholds it from another, and then compares the difference in outcomes provides the best insight. Such rigorous experiments can be designed, in turn, with or without randomization, and to vary the rules or laws that apply or to approximate such changes. A pilot that limits to whom a rule or policy applies constrains the risk but not the learning. As Justice Brandeis famously dissented, "a single courageous state may ... serve as a laboratory; and try novel social and economic experiments without risk to the rest of the country." 19

Within today's highly partisan political landscape, the need for quality evidence about the performance of law and policy presents a rare opportunity for agreement, on the methods if not the values or agendas advanced by evidence. Calls for "smarter use of data and evidence ... to orient decisions and accountability around service and results" 20and "an aggressive management agenda ... that delivers smarter, more innovative, and more accountable government for citizens ... . by applying ... evidence about what [*2318] works" 21have appeared in President Trump's and President Obama's management agendas, respectively. The passage of the Foundations for Evidence-Based Policy Making Act of 2018 ("2018 Evidence Act"), besides showing that Democrats and Republicans actually can agree on something, will consolidate and coordinate statistical expertise for assessment among rank and file bureaucrats across the federal government. 22

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Perm / Theory › Perm do Both---2NC

SHAM PILOTS---the perm sets a precedent for ‘sham experiments’ that aren’t allowed to shape program implementation.

Kristen Underhill 19, Associate Professor of Law, Columbia Law School, “Broken Experimentation, Sham Evidence-Based Policy,” 38 Yale L. & Pol'y Rev. 150, Fall 2019, Lexis

My goals in this Article begin with an effort to place current interest in EBPM in context, examining the theoretical appeal and advantages of EBPM, the limitations of evidence and its uptake in government decision-making, and a brief history of the rise and uncertain trajectory of EBPM at the federal level. The second aim of this work is to identify ways in which EBPM can go wrong. Building on recent examples in “evidence-based” efforts, I develop an original taxonomy of specific pathologies, ranging from the neglect and deliberate undermining of research (broken experimentation), to the distortion of evidence (a form of sham EBPM), to the disingenuous use of selective evidence to de-fund entire program categories (ratcheting). A third goal of this Article is to illuminate the stakes, potential costs, and possible benefits of sham EBPM, including implications for welfare, efficiency, scientific legitimacy, the production of knowledge, human subjects enrolled in governmental studies, and potential positive externalities.

Building on these arguments, my final aim herein is to propose remedies for the current pathologies in the production and uses of evidence. I begin, however, with a call to set a more realistic scope for the policy areas where we might hope to introduce research evidence productively. Some areas are more prone to EBPM pathologies than others, particularly problems of evidence distortion, weakening scientific legitimacy, and burdens on human subjects who enroll in research with no chance of policy payoff. But where EBPM is possible—where regulators or legislators are supportive of efforts to use empirical evidence productively—I propose that innovations such as ex ante policy commitments (e.g., pre-commitments contingent on research findings), evaluation mandates, and rules for evaluation transparency may avoid some of the pitfalls that currently stymie EBPM.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Perm / Theory › Theory---2NC

The CP is an opportunity cost!

Colleen V. Chien 19, Justin D'Atri Visiting Professor of Business Law, Columbia Law School; Professor, Santa Clara University School of Law; 2013-2015 White House Senior Advisor, Innovation and Intellectual Property, “Rigorous Policy Pilots: Experimentation in the Administration of the Law,” 104 Iowa L. Rev. 2313, July 2019, Lexis

Rigorous piloting involves selecting a test strategy that is appropriate to the question being asked. A “mixed methods” strategy of getting feedback, e.g., through surveys, interviews, case studies, and statistical (causal and non-causal) approaches is often best. Regardless of the specific method of evaluation, though, each of the other parts of specifying a pilot: articulating the question to be addressed, a theory of change, the evidence, how to measure it, and matching resources to the pilot, will require attention and in some cases, consultation with stakeholders, cost and convenience trade-offs, and implementation risk. In some cases, developing the right metric will be transformative, in others, framing the question correctly can unlock greater learning.

But when the question is, “did policy X have Y effect,” experimental or quasi-experimental approaches are understood to yield the best information. Volumes have been written about appropriate methods of evaluations. But also worth underscoring is what government pilots have revealed about the value of rigor, and the wasted opportunity associated with the lack thereof.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Solvency › Solvency---Improves Quality

Pilot programs key to problem solving and ensuring a proper mechanism to achieve success through testing.

Woken 01 [Miles D. Woken (PREPARED BY MILES D. WOKEN OF THE CENTER FOR TEACHING AND LEARNING, UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS AT SPRINGFIELD, BROOKENS LIBRARY), “Advantages of a Pilot Study”, University of Illinois at Springfield Center for Teaching and Learning, 2001 or later. http://spartan.ac.brocku.ca/~ekaciak/ABR1/Advantages%20of%20a%20Pilot%20Study.htm] //marlborough-oo/

A pilot study is a “pre-study” of your fuller study. You may think of it as a miniature version of your project. You may limit it by your using fewer subjects than you plan to include in the full study, or you may limit it because your scope is smaller in some other way; for example, the range of types of subjects may be more limited (e.g., you use only undergraduates in the pilot when you plan to use a broader range of the general population in the full study) or the procedures may be more limited (e.g., you test people on their ability to recall a certain kind of word when in the full study you plan to examine people’s ability to recall a greater range of words). A pilot study can help you work out some of the procedural bugs even though you know it is not likely to add anything new or important to your main study. Here are some more reasons to consider a pilot study:

1. It permits preliminary testing of the hypotheses that leads to testing more precise hypotheses in the main study. It may lead to changing some hypotheses, dropping some, or developing new hypotheses.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Solvency › Solvency---Avoids Backlash---AT: Experiments Unpopular

Experiments themselves are popular

Tina Rosenberg 17, editorial writer for The New York Times, “A Bipartisan Reason to Save Obamacare,” 1/4/17, https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/04/.../a-bipartisan-reason-to-save-obamacare.html

Republicans in Congress have objected to what they consider the Innovation Center’s overreach. “There have been some concerns about how wide and how mandatory the pilot programs will be,” said Mark McClellan, who ran the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services under President George W. Bush and is now a professor at Duke. But like the shift away from fee for service, experimentation itself has bipartisan support. “The concerns are not about the concept of piloting and expanding new approaches for payment,” he said.

More than a third of Medicare payments to providers now depend on value instead of volume. This has already helped to hold down costs. And value-based payments will get a huge increase from a law kicking in this year that moves Medicare payments of physicians away from fee for service. The law passed with overwhelming bipartisan support — and it can’t work without the Innovation Center’s projects.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Solvency › Solvency---Avoids Backlash---Healthcare

Healthcare pilots don’t require Congressional action

Jack Craver 16, Benefits Pro, “Republicans say no more Medicare pilot programs,” 10/4/16, https://www.benefitspro.com/2016/10/04/republicans-say-no-more-medicare-pilot-programs/

A majority of Republicans in the House of Representatives are calling on the Obama administration to halt Medicare pilot programs aimed at making the enormous federal health care program for the elderly more cost-effective. A letter signed by 179 GOP lawmakers says the administration has overstepped its authority in authorizing a number of programs that hospitals throughout the country have been obligated to partake in. Many of these initiatives, they claim, have been executed without Congressional approval. While they concede the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation has the authority, through the Affordable Care Act, to “test innovative models on a limited basis,” they allege the administration is using the programs to “substantially alter both the delivery and reimbursement of care.”

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Solvency › Solvency---Avoids Backlash

Pilot programs are comparatively better than the plan, avoid spending and don’t require Congressional approval

Joe Cantlupe 10, Staff writer at Health Leaders Media, “Health Reform Pilot Projects Look to Transform Healthcare,” Health Leaders Media, 1/15/10, http://www.healthleadersmedia.com/leadership/health-reform-pilot-projects-look-transform-healthcare

Supporters of the voluntary pilot programs and demonstration projects say the federal proposals can potentially give the healthcare system a chance to evaluate the success or failure of them without needless expense.

"Most of them are pretty small budgets," says Timothy Jost, a law professor at Washington and Lee University, adding the government can spend $5 million on a pilot to get people healthy rather than spending $1 billion on established programs that don't work.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Solvency › Solvency---UBI---AT: Empirics

Finland doesn’t disprove---it did unemployment payments, not a UBI.

John Rentoul 17, visiting professor at King’s College, “Basic income is the latest bad political idea that refuses to die,” The Independent, 1/2/17, https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/basic-income-pilots-scotland-ubi-glasgow-finland-canada-ontario-switzerland-referendum-refuses-to-die-a7505561.html

There is a reason why the basic income is the eternal news story. Someone, somewhere, is always saying what a marvellous idea it is. Some local government, or much less often a national government, is saying that it is going to look at it, or going to bring in a pilot scheme or even, every now and again, actually bring in a pilot scheme, which usually involves something which is nothing like a basic income.

Last year Elon Musk, John McDonnell and the Scottish National Party said what a marvellous idea it is. Fife council in Scotland is also looking at it. Two Canadian provinces are said to be interested, Ontario and Prince Edward Island, the second of which is normally useful only for pub quizzes.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Solvency › Solvency---UBI

Past and present existing BI Pilot Programs show values of long-term succession and support

Longoria and Kaur 23, Sandhu-Longoria, Amritpal Kaur. “Guaranteed Basic Income Pilot Programs Are Growing around the Country, and Community Leaders Are Doing Something about It.” USA Today, 17 Feb. 2023, www.usatoday.com/story/money/2023/02/17/how-universal-basic-income-program-works/11263986002/.

When the pandemic exposed nationwide income inequality, Mayors for a Guaranteed Income, founded in June 2020, began advocating for a guaranteed basic income at the local, state, and federal levels.

Now, pilot programs are popping up across the country. The movement already has 100 mayors on board, and they're getting county leaders to join the movement through Counties for a Guaranteed Income. The founder, Michael D. Tubbs, former mayor of Stockton, California, and special advisor on economic opportunity and mobility with California Gov. Gavin Newsom's office, launched the first mayor-led program in Stockton by selecting 125 random people, and guaranteeing them $500 a month for 24 months.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Solvency › Solvency---UBI

CP traits like trust and confidentiality key, without the aff cannot solve

HudsonUP 22 [11-21-2022. HudsonUP: The Spark of Hudson is an innovative, community learning center launching in Hudson, New York. A model for education and community development, The Spark is dedicated to supporting individuals from all corners of Hudson and beyond to learn, teach and grow. Founded by Susan Danziger and Albert Wenger, The Spark has recently spearheaded and supported a number of community initiatives in the wake of the COVID-19 crisis . "Why trust matters in a UBI pilot — HudsonUP". https://www.hudsonup.org/blog/why-trust-matters-in-a-ubi-pilot. 7-11-2023, Dhilan-GDS]

In order to build a program that works, we work to make sure that trust is front and center throughout the creation and implementation of our UBI pilot in Hudson. Why does it matter to make people feel safe and show that they can trust us? Because without that, we can’t reach the people that we really want to reach, those who we want to encourage to participate in our pilot. One of the most important things we had to do to create trust in Hudson was to connect with people and organizations that have strong roots in the community. This is critically important, both for initial outreach - introducing the program to the community, and getting people to apply for the pilot - and also for implementing the program. Having folks like Kaya Weidman of Kite’s Nest, Bryan MacCormack of Columbia County Sanctuary Movement, and Joan Hunt of Greater Hudson Promise Neighborhood means we can connect with people who already know and trust those individuals and the organizations they work with. Creating a team that centers these leaders was crucial in making our program a safe space. A second key part of building trust is making sure we keep participants’ identities confidential. This means we don’t share any potentially identifying information. In a city as small as Hudson, this limits what we can share by a lot, since even a detail that seems insignificant in a larger community could point to a specific person in Hudson. Maintaining participants’ privacy can complicate storytelling, because it means we can’t share anecdotes about participants that could be very powerful. But money is a strong force in society, and having a sudden influx of income can make change social atmospheres and make someone a target, even for people within their close community. Keeping participants safe, and making sure they feel comfortable in this program, has to be the number-one priority - and we will share the progress of the UBI pilot in a responsible way, keeping participants’ identities completely confidential.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Solvency › Solvency---UBI

Data suggests that the UBI would be on balance positive, but it is inconclusive. Need to follow up with a real examination.

Anthony Painter & Chris Thoung 15, Painter is Director of Policy and Strategy at the RSA, “Creative citizen, creative state,” Medium, The RSA, 12/3/15, https://medium.com/pathways-to-universal-basic-income/creative-citizen-creative-state-a3cef3f25775

Between 1968 and 1980, the US and Canadian Governments conducted five experiments into negative income tax. These pilots have some significant limitations. The data was not always of high quality. They were designed to separate control and treatment groups in areas so the impact on demand for labour is impossible to measure (if there was withdrawal of some labour, economic theory suggests that wages may be increased). Finally, the pilots were far more generous than the then existing Assistance for Families with Dependent Children programme so its impact was to introduce an additional scheme as opposed to a scheme that embodied a different set of principles.

“Where Basic Incomes or similar have been introduced they have had notably positive social effects overall.”