Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Negative
Reparations CP › 1NC – Shell

$6.1 trillion dollars is the only way to resolve 124 years of colonialism.

Javier 22 -- [Javier A. 10/17/2022, "Puerto Rico's Right to Colonial Reparations," MANO, 10-17-2022, https://manomagazine.com/puertoricocolonialreparations/, accessed 7-18-2023] // David

Although the topic of colonial reparations for Puerto Rico has been ongoing for decades, there is a newfound interest, particularly within Puerto Rican circles. More and more people recognize that after 124 years of abuse, humiliation, human rights violations, and economic exploitation through colonialism the United States owes Puerto Rico compensation. According to the renowned lawyer, diplomat, and independence leader Wilma E. Collazo Reverón, Esq., Puerto Rico does have a right to reparations based on international law, particularly the UN Principles and Guidelines applicable to human rights violations. As can be expected, the issue of reparations for Puerto Rico—or any colony for that matter—is controversial. It is easier to balance a camel on the head of a pin than to convince a colonizing country to pay reparations to its former colony. First, Puerto Rico must claim reparations from Spain and the United States, not just the Americans. Second, we must recognize that, although we would like Puerto Rico to receive reparations, will Spain and the United States actually be willing to sit down and negotiate such reparations and reach special agreements? To this day, the United States shies away from even talking about reparations for the descendants of enslaved Africans in the Black community, let alone Hawaiians or Indigenous nations. If the U.S. cannot even come to terms with and consider reparations for African Americans, Hawaiians, and Native Americans, why would they do so for Puerto Ricans? The United States has historically ignored bills in Congress having to do with “reparations” because they—the white members of Congress and their white constituents—don’t want to acknowledge that Blacks and Native Americans deserve reparations for centuries of slavery and genocide: centuries of brutal racism, segregationist laws, terror, lynching, institutional persecutions and racist policies that kept, and keep, millions of African Americans and Indigenous people in poverty. Sadly, many in Congress and American society believe that to accept such reparations would amount to an admission that the U.S. has committed heinous and wrongful acts on entire peoples, acts that many Americans would rather forget then address. Yet, as some Americans—mainly whites—wish to forget such historical wrongs, those directly impacted by the wrongs of the past are still claiming reparations for their peoples. As Americans are suspicious of the entire idea of reparations, how have others dealt with such demands? After World War II, Germany negotiated, approved, and allocated billions of Deutsche Marks in reparations for Israel and the thousands of Jewish citizens of various countries for the Holocaust. With these funds, Israel was able to establish and foster its economy and modern infrastructure throughout the country. And last year, after ignoring for decades the demands of Namibia and the thousands of victims of German colonialism in that African country—massacres, assassinations, occupation—Germany finally agreed to send €1.1 billion in reparations. Today, Jamaican officials are even asking Britain to compensate them £7.6 billion (approximately $8.5 billion) in reparations for the transatlantic slave trade that made Britain so wealthy and powerful. In 2013, the Caribbean Community (CARICOM) established the CARICOM Reparations Commission, as a regional body composed of member countries “to establish the moral, ethical and legal case for the payment of reparations by the governments of all former colonial powers and the relevant institutions of those countries, to the nations and peoples of the Caribbean Community for the Crimes against Humanity of Native Genocide, the Transatlantic Slave Trade and the system of slavery.” In 1988, despite American avoidance of the concept of reparations, President Ronald Reagan signed a law (the Civil Rights Act of 1988) that recognized the inappropriate, illegal, and unfair detention of thousands of Japanese Americans during World War II. The United States government actually apologized and authorized reparations, at $20,000 each, for the now-elderly survivors who suffered such detention. Knowing this background, what can we as Puerto Ricans do to move Puerto Rico as close as possible to a colonial compensation resolution that, although not called “reparations,” could support the concept? First, Puerto Rico should present a detailed and comprehensive list of all the political, economic, cultural, and social damages and abuses with an estimate of the cost to comply with a wide-ranging and inclusive reparation. According to the renowned Puerto Rican economist Dr. José Israel Alameda Lozada in “The Socioeconomic Cost of Colonialism in Puerto Rico: 1898 to the Present,” the estimated total cost of U.S. colonialism from 1900 to 2017— the total value of land use and human use—is equal to over $6.1 trillion. Yes, trillion with a T. According to his research and data, the cost of U.S. colonialism in Puerto Rico is 59.9 times the current value of Puerto Rico’s nominal GDP. If a sovereign Puerto Rico negotiates a comprehensive reparations (colonial compensation) package with the United States accepting such colonial cost and damages of $6.1 trillion, according to the calculation of Dr. Alameda Lozada’s research, the new Republic of Puerto Rico could receive $122.1 billion a year for the next 50 years. After 124 years of abuse, terror, human rights violations, and colonial exploitation, that amount would be fair—but I seriously doubt that the United States would find this solution remotely acceptable. What is fair and moral is not always what happens, particularly in the post-colonial relationship between a metropolis and its former colony. Puerto Rico was good enough to occupy, colonize, and extract wealth from for 124 years, but not good enough to actually receive fair compensation for the disaster that is U.S. colonial rule. To this important calculation by Dr. Alameda Lozada, one can also add the colonial cost and economic damages of other colonial crimes, such as political persecution, the terror unleashed by the repressive agencies of the colonial and federal regimes, the lives destroyed by such persecution, the environmental damages to land and sea, massacres in Río Piedras and Ponce, the occupation of land by military bases, the harmful effects of the use of dangerous chemicals to communities, the Puerto Ricans assassinated for political reasons, and the disappearances and torture of Puerto Ricans at the end of the 1950 Revolution. Yes, the list is long. We must also remember the forced sterilization, the sexual abuse of Puerto Rican women by the U.S. military, the bombing of Vieques and Culebra, the destruction and humiliating use of our national heritage, the prohibition of our national flag, the attacks and policies against our Spanish language, the enduring negative effects of colonial indoctrination and assimilationist policies, and various other abuses. The colonial cost and damages of all this persecution, terror, abuse, and death would amount to billions more in reparations. For example, how much do Americans owe Puerto Rico for the expropriation and land use of the United States Army Garrison Ft. Buchanan since 1923? Let’s see. The 746.16 acres that make up the Ft. Buchanan military base are worth approximately $560 million. For having used Ft. Buchanan for 99 years via colonial expropriation, the United States owes Puerto Rico the amount of $55.4 billion in back pay. Who will hand them the bill? How much more are we owed for the unilateral colonial expropriation and use of Roosevelt Roads Naval Station, Ft. Allen, and Ramey Air Force Base? Billions more. If we were to come up with a slightly more comprehensive list and calculation of reparations regarding U.S. colonial rule in Puerto Rico, how would we do it? Here is a proposal: According to Dr. Alameda Lozada, the total estimated cost of colonialism from 1900 to 2017 is equivalent to about $6.1 trillion. What the U.S. owes Puerto Rico for the unilateral colonial expropriation and use of Ft. Buchanan for 99 years: $55.4 billion. According to academic, author, and historian Dr. José Che Paralitici, from 1898 to the present, there have been approximately more than 2,000 political prisoners, mainly pro-independence supporters and patriots; more than 1,000 prisoners on Vieques and Culebra; thousands more arrested over the decades for persecution; and over 125,000 Puerto Ricans with police dossiers, known as carpetas, from the intelligence units of the Puerto Rico Police and the FBI. These carpetas were routinely used to persecute, intimidate, harass, silence, and destroy the lives of countless Puerto Ricans. We need to agree on fair compensation for general and aggravated damages for someone who has suffered violations to their human and civil rights—plus the pain, suffering, and loss of freedom and employment—by the colonial regime. According to a calculation used in the United Kingdom for compensation for victims of police abuse, each victim of such abuse (pain, damage, suffering, and loss) deserves approximately $1,111,563.20. Based on this basic calculation, the estimated 128,000 victims of direct colonial political persecution should receive a collective compensation of $142.2 billion. There are many more that are not included in this preliminary calculation. We must ensure that everyone who suffered political persecution must be counted. Compensation for the humiliation of colonialism, the damage to dignity, and the psychological impact of the colonial mentality: In the United States, this is known as “compensation for humiliation and loss of dignity.” In 2022, there are approximately nine million Puerto Ricans in the world. Colonialism has directly impacted the lives of all Puerto Ricans in the world since the Americans invaded our country, and for this, we have to demand compensation. If all nine million Puerto Ricans deserved $1,000,000 in compensation for the damage and humiliation of colonialism, Puerto Rico could receive a collective compensation of $9 trillion.

2023 DDI Negative
Guam PIC › Guam Soft-Left Impact

Economic failure in Guam raises the overall cost of living dramatically, harshly damages the agricultural industry, and re-invests Guam into US colonialism and lack over food sovereignty---COVID empirics prove.

Oberiano 20 [Kristin Oberiano is a Graduate Student Affiliate, Weatherhead Center for International Affairs. “A Pacific Island's Response to COVID-19: Guam and the Movement Toward Food Sovereignty.” Epicenter at the Heart of Research and Ideas. Harvard University. 03-06-2020. https://epicenter.wcfia.harvard.edu/blog/pacific-islands-response-covid-19-guam. Accessed 19-07-2023.]/ISJD

The US Navy also attempted to condemn Tumon Bay—the same area where USS Theodore Roosevelt sailors were quarantined—and transform it into a military-only recreational beach facility, barring Chamoru land owners and local residents from using the land for agriculture and the bay for fishing. And significantly, the  caused by destructive WWII American bombing and the subsequent rebuilding of infrastructure proved challenging to Chamoru farmers who wanted to return to their farms. To this day, a sign is erected every so often to warn drivers of “” that litter the island. The US military still retains 30 percent of the island; military property is bounded by fences, armed guards, and warning signs denoting federal ownership.

These postwar militarized land annexations displaced thousands of indigenous Chamoru families who utilized the land for a subsistence culture rooted in the Chamoru values of inafa’maolek (Chamoru for “to make good to each other”) and chenchule’ (giving) that nourished them for thousands of years.3 These values of community interdependence and reciprocal relations helped Chamoru society through bouts of droughts, natural disasters, epidemics, and war by emphasizing mutual responsibilities within the community. This means if a family had a large harvest of bananas or slaughtered an animal, the family would share it with other families who may not have any, and thus reifying relations that bonded those families in the first place. Inafa’maolek and chenchule’ go beyond the realm of food and resources and are the basis for how each person relates to one another and to the entire community.4 

2023 DDI Negative
Guam PIC › 1NC – Shell

A failed recovery by Guam means a return to 2020 – unemploys over 1 in 4 Guamanians and decimates quality of life

Ruane et. all 20 – (Maria Claret M. Ruane is a Ph.D. Professor of Economics at the School of Business & Public Administration at the University of Guam); "Guam Economic Report" University of Guam - School of Business and Public Administration and Omicron Delta Epsilon International Honor Society for Economics - Alpha Chapter of Guam at UOG, https://www.uog.edu/_resources/files/schools-and-colleges/school-of-business-and-public-administration/2020-Guam-Economic-Report-SBPA-ODE.pdf //sp

What a year 2020 had been! It was certainly a year that brought many changes to lives in Guam and around the world, definitely a year that kept us busy, undoubtedly a year characterized by uncertainty and questioning, and surely a year that many, if not most, of us could not wait to end! We wish we could say that the COVID-19 pandemic of 2020 would instantly go away as the clock strikes midnight on New Year’s Eve but, from all indications at this time, the virus that has become our invisible enemy and which, to-date, has claimed 121 of our loved ones, will be joining us as we usher in the year 2021. We might take comfort and perhaps even claim victory against this enemy on account that a vaccine has become available in the past few weeks and several thousands of our local population have been immunized with the first of a two-shot application. We might even be leaving the danger zone that this enemy had pushed us into for months and entering the path toward normalcy, although it is not clear what the “new normal” would look like but it is comforting to know that we have the capacity to create this “new normal”. As we continue to speculate as to what our near future, i.e., the year 2021, and our distant future would be, it is clear how the year 2020 and the COVID-19 pandemic have impacted many aspects of our lives. This report focuses on how the pandemic has impacted our economy. For many years and certainly in recent years, Guam’s economy was barely able to maintain its size, with economic growth averaging close to zero as some years posted small positive growth while more recent years posted negative growth, for example, - 0.3% growth in 2018, the last year when official data is available. The 2019 Guam Economic Report predicted a zero economic growth for Guam for the year 2019, a year when the tourism industry was setting new records in visitor arrivals and spending. Then the pandemic came in mid-March 2020, which impacted our economy in the following ways: Our tourism industry was decimated, with 76% less visitors coming to Guam during January-October 2020 compared to the same period in 2019. Less visitors to Guam in 2020 meant less spending, income, jobs and tax revenues for our economy, with our estimate showing a loss of $1.38B of local income and spending. More than $1.6B of U.S. Federal Government pandemic assistance was infused in our economy, more than enough to offset the estimated loss of $1.38B reported above. Not counting the Federal funds that were transferred to local families and businesses and just looking at their drastically lower incomes this year, one would expect households and businesses to cut back on their spending (Keynes' theory of consumption). By how much would be difficult to say since, to-date, there is no official measure for this negative effect. Consequently, we had to use our best judgement in this report to estimate that, compared to 2019, household spending in 2020 was probably 30% to 50% lower and business spending 50% to 70% lower. We believe these assumptions to be as realistic and as educated a guess as possible. With a few more assumptions, we estimated Guam’s economy in 2020 to have declined by -0.7% (best scenario) or -18.9% (worst scenario) compared to 2019. In the absence of the $1.6B U.S. Federal Government pandemic assistance to Guam in 2020, the scenario would be expectedly worse, as our economy in 2020 would have declined at the range of 42% to 49% compared to what it was in 2019. This would be worse than the 25% decrease in the U.S. economy during the Great Depression years between 1929 and 1933. The official unemployment rate for Guam was 17.3% for June 2020. For comparison, our own estimates for unemployment year-to-date (January to October 2020) were 19.8% using one approach and 26.6% using another approach.

2023 DDI Negative
Guam PIC › 1NC – Shell

Extending SSI to Guam hurts their economy – combats the recovery

Limtiaco 21 – (Steve Limtiaco is a news director for the Pacific Daily News. More than 20 years experience as an editor and investigative reporter. University of Arizona graduate); "Feds defend law that denies SSI income benefits to Guam residents with disabilities," guampdn, https://www.guampdn.com/news/local/feds-defend-law-that-denies-ssi-income-benefits-to-guam-residents-with-disabilities/article_421cc6e5-045c-548e-b223-7a178cadfc1f.html //sp

According to the Justice Department’s brief, the law that excludes Guam from the SSI program is constitutional and Congress can treat the territories differently if there is a rational basis for doing so. Including Guam and other territories in the SSI program would cost money, and Congress has the discretion to determine how federal funding is to be used, the Justice Department stated. More: 36th Guam Legislature inaugurated Monday Guam residents do not pay taxes to the federal government - their tax money remains with the local government – so they are not funding the SSI program and can reasonably be exempted, the Justice Department stated. It noted there are other federally funded programs to assist Guam residents. And giving SSI cash to Guam residents could reasonably hurt the island’s economy, the Justice Department’s filing states. “Congress could reasonably have thought that the influx of SSI payments would have a negative impact on the economy of Guam by contributing to inflation,” the Justice Department stated.

2023 DDI Negative
Guam PIC › 1NC – Shell

Guam’s economy is in a period of recovery after devastating 2020, but going strong

Office Of The Governor 22 – (Governor of Guam); "GDP for Guam Rises to 96% of Pre Pandemic Levels for 2021," Governor of Guam, https://governor.guam.gov/press_release/gdp-for-guam-rises-to-96-of-pre-pandemic-levels-for-2021/ //sp

Hagåtña, Guam – The Leon Guerrero-Tenorio Administration announces that Guam’s 2021 Gross Domestic Product (GDP) increased 1.1 percent in 2021 after decreasing 11.4 percent in 2020, according to the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis. “This strong, history-making 12.5% turnaround has validated Guam’s economic recovery with our Gross Domestic Product reaching $6.123 billion,” said Governor Lou Leon Guerrero. “The GDP is the most comprehensive measure of all economic activity on Guam, and the only year on record that was higher was 2019.” The GDP increase is attributed to: 6.8 percent increase in private fixed investment 3.3 percent increase in personal consumption expenditure 2.6 percent increase in government spending “The economic impact from COVID that Guam experienced in 2020 could have stalled our progress, but because our Administration quickly stood up programs that put federal recovery funds into the hands of residents and businesses that fueled Guam’s economy, we have realized a strong turnaround in just one year,” said Governor Leon Guerrero. “Consumer expenditures and private investment drove that historic recovery, and despite 2021 being our worst year for tourism with less than 80,000 visitors, our economic policies combined with long-term federal investment made up for the shortfall and put us back in growth territory. This demonstrates the resilience of our people and our businesses in how fast we are recovering.” “Now, in 2022, our tourism and construction sectors are rebounding with visitor arrivals up by 251% and the value of construction projects up by $208 million compared to a year ago,” said Lt. Governor Josh Tenorio. “These figures show our island’s ability to flourish in the face of any crisis and are a testament to the progress we’ve made together. We remain committed to increasing our support of all the initiatives that strengthen our economic health and prosperity.” In 2021, Private Fixed Investment on Guam was $1.6 Billion — the highest amount on record, even when adjusted to inflation. This and increased personal consumption expenditure offset the difficult year Guam had with the lowest number of tourists due to global pandemic disruptions. Guam’s Chief Economist Gary Hiles noted that policy decisions in both Federal and GovGuam arenas to maintain government employment helped contribute to the stability of the GDP recovery. He also noted that the acceleration of vendor payments and tax refunds were also a direct stimulus into the economy, as were war claims payments and economic policy moves by the Administration, such as refinancing several government bonds at lower interest rates, which saved taxpayers money. In addition to the ongoing recovery of Guam’s tourism industry in 2022, the Leon Guerrero-Tenorio Administration anticipates a significant increase in economic growth from the construction sector in CY 2022. Between 2021 and 2022 Year to date, $3.5 Billion in awards from the Department of Defense for contracts performed on Guam has been made. Awards made in these 2 years were the highest on record. Building And Construction Permits in CY 2021 had a combined total value of $267 Million. In the first 8 months of CY 2022, Building And Construction Permits have a combined total value of $471 Million, meaning that the value of construction being performed was up by $208 Million when compared to the 12 months in CY 2021. In addition to the very strong results from the GDP analysis, which provides the most comprehensive measure of Guam’s economic performance, the Governor noted that speculation about any weakening of Guam’s economy as federal COVID assistance ends have also been permanently dispelled with the strong performance of Gross Receipts Taxes for the past year which has remained steady even though the GRT rate for 90% of Guam businesses was lowered to 3%. “This, combined with multi-year federal obligations currently in place, our low 4.8% unemployment rate, increases in new business licenses, and our rapidly recovering tourism numbers, are all evidence that the people of Guam are heading into the biggest economic expansion in a generation,” concluded the Governor.

2023 DDI Negative
Court Politics DA › Impact – Ext.

Warming guarantees extinction.

Specktor 19 -- [Brandon Specktor, "Human Civilization Will Crumble by 2050 If We Don't Stop Climate Change Now, New Paper Claims," livescience, 6-4-2019, https://www.livescience.com/65633-climate-change-dooms-humans-by-2050.html, accessed 7-28-2023] // David

It seems every week there's a scary new report about how man-made climate change is going to cause the collapse of the world's ice sheets, result in the extinction of up to 1 million animal species and — if that wasn't bad enough — make our . This week, a new policy paper from an Australian think tank claims that those other reports are slightly off; the risks of climate change are actually much, much worse than anyone can imagine. , climate change poses a "near- to mid-term existential threat to human civilization," and there's a good chance society could collapse as soon as 2050 if serious mitigation actions aren't taken in the next decade. Published by the Breakthrough National Centre for Climate Restoration in Melbourne (an independent think tank focused on climate policy) and authored by a climate researcher and a former fossil fuel executive, the paper's central thesis is that climate scientists are too restrained in their predictions of how climate change will affect the planet in the near future. [] The current climate crisis, they say, is larger and more complex than any humans have ever dealt with before. General climate models — like the one that the (IPCC) used in 2018 to predict that a global temperature increase of 3.6 degrees Fahrenheit (2 degrees Celsius) could put hundreds of millions of people at risk — fail to account for the sheer complexity of Earth's many interlinked geological processes; as such, they fail to adequately predict the scale of the potential consequences. The truth, the authors wrote, is probably far worse than any models can fathom. How the world ends What might an accurate worst-case picture of the planet's climate-addled future actually look like, then? The authors provide one particularly grim scenario that begins with world governments "politely ignoring" the advice of scientists and the will of the public to decarbonize the economy (finding alternative energy sources), resulting in a global temperature increase 5.4 F (3 C) by the year 2050. At this point, the world's ice sheets vanish; brutal droughts kill many of the trees in the (removing one of the world's largest carbon offsets); and the planet plunges into a feedback loop of ever-hotter, ever-deadlier conditions. "Thirty-five percent of the global land area, and 55 percent of the global population, are subject to more than 20 days a year of lethal heat conditions, beyond the threshold of human survivability," the authors hypothesized. Meanwhile, droughts, floods and wildfires regularly ravage the land. Nearly one-third of the world's land surface turns to desert. Entire ecosystems collapse, beginning with the planet's coral reefs, the rainforest and the Arctic ice sheets. The world's tropics are hit hardest by these new climate extremes, destroying the region's agriculture and turning more than 1 billion people into refugees. This mass movement of refugees — coupled with and severe drops in food and water availability — begin to stress the fabric of the world's largest nations, including the United States. Armed conflicts over resources, perhaps culminating in nuclear war, are likely. The result, according to the new paper, is "outright chaos" and perhaps "the end of human global civilization as we know it."

2023 DDI Negative
Court Politics DA › AT – No Link/Court Capital Fake

Robert’s gives strategic victories to liberals to give them trust in the game – it’s not about public perception – it’s about Democrats perception of the courts.

Chait 7/03 -- [Jonathan Chait, "The Last Republican Politician," Intelligencer, 7-3-2023, https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/07/john-roberts-supreme-court-republican-party.html, accessed 7-24-2023] // David

The Republican Party has been in desperate need of a pragmatic leader who can gauge public opinion, shrewdly husband political capital, and advance the party’s agenda in sustainable ways. That leader has materialized in the form of John Roberts. The chief justice of the United States is attempting to navigate the disjuncture between voters, who on the whole are sharply divided but have slightly favored Democrats, and the power Republicans have accumulated through the Supreme Court, which is quasi-permanent and unbounded by any other political branch. In theory, Republicans could use their hammerlock on the high court to settle a long series of social and economic disputes in their party’s favor. This is the course many conservatives hoped, and liberals feared, the conservative Court would take, especially after Donald Trump was able to seat three justices and pad its right-wing majority. Instead, Roberts has pursued a more cautious strategy, and the question is if this will be enough to shore up the Court’s falling popularity and disarm Democratic threats to overhaul it. While he has given conservatives high-profile victories on long-standing social divisions like abortion rights and affirmative action, he has also given victories to liberals. In the term that ended in late June, the Roberts Court definitively repudiated the “independent state legislature” theory, which Trump’s supporters had pushed as his vehicle to attempt to overturn the 2020 election and with which other Republicans hoped to enable gerrymandered legislatures to entrench their power. Liberals, having fretted the case was a ticking time bomb for the Republic, exhaled in relief. Former federal judge J. Michael Luttig called the decision “the single most important constitutional case for American Democracy since the Nation’s Founding almost 250 years ago.” More surprisingly, the Court, which under Roberts in 2013 undid a crucial pillar of the Voting Rights Act of 1965, issued an expansive voting-rights ruling that will create more Black-majority legislative districts in southern states, which had previously been free to marginalize Black voters. Roberts and Brett Kavanaugh voted with the Court’s three liberals in these recent cases, joined by Amy Coney Barrett in the “independent state legislature” case. If you were to ask Roberts to explain this pattern, he would no doubt insist he is merely interpreting the law as written. As a nominee in 2005, he famously likened his role to an umpire calling balls and strikes, a conceit he has clung to even as the Court’s reputation for above-the-fray independence has dwindled. “We do not have Obama judges or Trump judges, Bush judges or Clinton judges,” he said in 2018 after Trump lashed out at a federal judge over an immigration ruling. But very few people actually believe him. A decade ago, Roberts reportedly reversed himself in deliberations about a lawsuit to overturn the Affordable Care Act, ultimately crafting a compromise that left in place parts of the law. Last year, reporting indicated he was lobbying Kavanaugh to pull back from a full-scale repeal of Roe v. Wade. The Wall Street Journal ran an extraordinary editorial hinting at the Court’s divisions and urging its conservatives to stand firm. (Shortly afterward, Politico obtained the preliminary draft of the court’s Roe repeal, a leak that conservatives employed as an argument for forging ahead.) The chief justice may not be taking polls and holding focus groups, but he is acting like a man who is well aware that the popular legitimacy of the institution he leads is in danger. The historical shadow looming over Roberts’s calculations is the confrontation between Franklin Roosevelt and the Supreme Court some 90 years ago. Roosevelt had found his economic reforms repeatedly overturned by a right-wing Supreme Court. After winning a landslide election, Roosevelt sought to take control of the Court by adding seats and appointing new and more liberal justices, only for the Court’s majority to reverse itself in 1937 and cede economic policy to Congress and the president. Liberals have long feared that once the new generation of conservatives had gained control of the Supreme Court, it would revert to something like its pre-’37 stance. Perhaps the new right-wing jurisprudence would be less overbearing on economic policy, and more aggressive on social policy, than the version of a century ago, but the overall contours of the scenario that kept progressive legal analysts up at night was an unshackled Supreme Court throwing around its weight without fear of backlash. Why would Roberts hesitate to seize the full range of power at his disposal — to the extent that he appears to be going against his own predilections? One reason is that the Court’s Republican majority is a historical accident. Unlike the Court that bedeviled FDR, which was the product of decades of Republican dominance that preceded him, the Roberts Court did not earn its majority as the result of Republicans winning a bunch of presidential elections. Democrats have won five of the last eight presidential elections and seven of the last eight popular votes. The GOP majority on the Court is a combination of better actuarial luck and more selfless partisan teamwork by Republican justices and some ruthlessness by Senator Mitch McConnell. An aging Thurgood Marshall did not stay on the Court long enough for a Democrat to succeed him; McConnell used his Senate majority to prevent Obama from installing Antonin Scalia’s replacement; Ruth Bader Ginsburg simply refused to step down despite her cancer diagnoses, even while Democrats held the presidency and the Senate; then Anthony Kennedy, despite being a swing justice, stepped down under Trump. Those four events created the current right-wing majority. It is perfectly legal, but it hardly derives from anything like a mandate to reshape American law. The rules of the Constitution make this result legitimate, too. But the Constitution also allows Democrats to either pack the Court or to reform it fundamentally in ways that would eliminate its Republican majority. They held off using this power when they controlled Congress and the presidency during Biden’s first two years. But if the Court exerts its authority in an abusive or too nakedly partisan fashion, the next Democratic Party–controlled government might decide it has to act. In the aftermath of the affirmative-action decision, President Biden ruled out packing the Court, though he told reporters, “This is not a normal Court.” This is the exact equilibrium Roberts wants: bad for Democrats, but not existentially bad. The legitimacy of the conservative Court has been the thematic crux of its burgeoning ethics scandals. The conservative movement has rallied around Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito even as they accepted undisclosed patronage from billionaires, branding reporters uncovering these financial relationships as activists seeking to discredit its prized majority. Roberts took a more conciliatory line, conceding ethics was an “issue of concern inside the Court.” The respective styles of Roberts and the Court’s right wing on ethics mirror their contrasting approach to jurisprudence: He seeks to conserve power by modulating it, and the right-wing justices seek to perpetuate their power by flaunting it. Roberts’s strategy appears to be giving Democrats enough trust in the fairness of the Court’s decisions, and hope that they can win some future cases, to keep them from flipping over the game board. By the same token, the threat of a Democratic Court-reforming response is a helpful one to keep the Republican judicial majority in check. It remains to be seen whether Roberts and his colleagues will take that bargain or continue a run of precedent smashing that causes Democrats to see the Republican Court as an existential threat. The myth that judges make rulings completely abstracted from any earthly considerations is the foundation of judicial legitimacy. Roberts, ironically, recognizes that maintaining that legitimacy means acting like a politician while pretending he’s just calling balls and strikes.

2023 DDI Negative
Court Politics DA › AT – No Link/Court Capital Fake

Roberts rules liberally to amass political capital to expand in future cases.

Gerstein 6/30 -- [Josh Gerstein is POLITICO’s Senior Legal Affairs Reporter. Gerstein covers the intersection of law and politics, including Special Counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation of President Donald Trump and his associates, as well as ensuing counter-investigations into the origins of the FBI’s initial inquiry into the Trump-Russia saga., "The Supreme Court’s term was full of whimpers. Then it ended with a bang. ," 6/30/2023, https://www.politico.com/news/2023/06/30/supreme-court-term-end-roberts-conservative-00104511, accessed 7-24-2023] // David

If liberals expected a big course correction from a Supreme Court mired in ethics controversies and rocked by record-low approval ratings, the justices’ final decisions of the term laid that to rest. Moves by Chief Justice John Roberts in the weeks leading up to the grand finale seemed to signal an eagerness on his part to project an air of moderation. In surprising decisions on voting rights, election law and other issues, he aligned with the court’s liberal bloc, perhaps in the hope of showing that the court, dominated by conservatives, isn’t always looking to take a wrecking ball to long-established precedent. But if Roberts amassed some political capital from those decisions, he swiftly spent it on Thursday and Friday. In the three most politically divisive cases of the term, the court issued polarized 6-3 decisions — two of which Roberts wrote himself, and all of which delivered sweeping conservative victories on issues that are high priorities for the right. “The last two days of the term were absolutely cataclysmic and, to the extent people were asleep at the wheel, it’s because he kind of anesthetized them,” said New York University law professor Melissa Murray. Last June, the six-justice conservative majority cemented by former President Donald Trump flexed its muscles for the first time — with Roberts sometimes on the sidelines, as he was when the five other conservatives overturned Roe v. Wade. This term, he seemed intent on regaining some control. Earlier this month, the chief justice broke with his own history in voting-rights cases, taking the helm as the court, in a 5-4 vote, sided with Black voters in a Voting Rights Act case challenging alleged racial gerrymandering. The decision, which drew sharp dissents from the conservative bloc, is expected to help Democrats win several congressional seats in 2024. Then, Roberts again took the pen as the court refused to embrace a radical legal theory that could have given state legislatures far-ranging powers over elections — potentially even the power to nullify disputed elections, much as Trump and his allies tried to do in 2020. In other fractured decisions rebuffing adventurous conservative legal arguments, Roberts voted with the liberals to sustain President Joe Biden’s immigration policy and uphold the Indian Child Welfare Act. These opinions seemed of a piece with the chief justice’s reputation as a pragmatic institutionalist seeking to protect the court amid intense criticism. But some observers warned his moves were mere feints aimed at preserving the veneer of respectability around the court, even as the conservative supermajority’s project to dramatically reshape American law marched on. The unusual alliances and cross-cutting cleavages that marked some of the term’s earlier decisions were nowhere to be found on Thursday and Friday as the court’s highest-profile cases came down on predictable ideological lines. When the smoke cleared, the decades-long use of race to achieve diversity in college admissions was effectively dead, as was Biden’s marquee policy forgiving student debt for tens of millions of Americans. And the high court’s two-decade-plus string of decisions expanding the rights of the LGBTQ community was stopped in its tracks and beaten back by a ruling upholding the right of business owners to refuse service to same-sex couples on free-speech grounds.

2023 DDI Negative
Court Politics DA › AT – No Link/Court Capital Fake

Court capital is real.

Wurzer 22 -- [Cathy Wurzer is the host of Morning Edition and Minnesota Now on MPR News. She is also the co-host of Almanac, a weekly public affairs program produced by Twin Cities Public Television for Minnesota's statewide public television network- Jill Elaine Hasday (who was being interviewed) is a Distinguished McKnight University Professor and the Centennial Professor of Law at the University of Minnesota Law School. , "Top stories of 2022: Roe v. Wade's fall and its impact on Minnesota," MPR News, 12/22/2022, https://www.mprnews.org/episode/2022/12/22/top-stories-of-2022-roe-v-wades-fall-and-its-impact-on-minnesota, accessed 7-24-2023] // David

JILL HASDAY: OK, so I teach 14th Amendment. I teach constitutional law more generally. And one lesson I've always taught the students is there's only so much institutional capital the court has. And there's cases where they save it and there's cases where they spend it. Whatever you think of the opinion on the merits, it's just an enormous expenditure of institutional capital, the court overturning Roe in one fell swoop. Chief Justice Roberts in his concurrence, he doesn't like Roe either, but he wants to do it gradually. So we'll see. It's just it is an enormous expenditure of institutional capital and it does make the court's legitimacy vulnerable because the court doesn't have an army to enforce its decisions.

2023 DDI Negative
Court Politics DA › 2NC – UQ

Robert’s is an institutionalist.

Shesol 7/03 -- [Jeff Shesol, a historian, has written several books about American politics, including “Supreme Power,” the story of Franklin Roosevelt’s failed attempt to pack the Supreme Court., "Opinion," archive.li, 7-3-2023, https://archive.li/uC89H, accessed 7-27-2023] // David

Eleven years later, Malta no doubt retains its allure. The term that just ended must have been a torment for the chief. The court’s popularity has plunged to record lows; its members bicker on and off the bench; calls for the court to be packed are commonplace. Such circumstances would pain any chief justice, this one more than most. From the start of his tenure in 2005, he has painted himself as an institutionalist whose paramount concern is the court’s integrity. He conducts himself accordingly: He is decorous, almost regal; he speaks of moderation and judicial minimalism. He keeps a sovereign’s distance from modern life. In 1867, in a classic book on the English constitution, Walter Bagehot wrote that in times of change, “the most imposing institutions of mankind” maintain influence by demonstrating an “inherent dignity.” It is ironic, perhaps bitterly so, that a collapse in public esteem has become a hallmark of the Roberts court. Rarely, in recent decades, has the institution seemed less worthy of reverence.

2023 DDI Negative
Court Politics DA › 2NC – UQ

Robert’s is concerned about attacks on the Supreme Court.

Wire Reports 7/02 -- [Wire Reports, "Court wraps up turbulent season," Arkansas Online, 7-2-2023, https://www.arkansasonline.com/news/2023/jul/02/court-wraps-up-turbulent-season/, accessed 7-27-2023] // David

The court's legitimacy, raised by Democratic and liberal critics -- and some justices -- in response to last year's abortion ruling, among others was amplified by published reports of undisclosed, paid jet travel and fancy trips for Thomas and Alito from billionaire Republican donors. "I don't think the court consciously takes opinion into account," said Grove, the University of Texas professor. "But I think if there's anyone who might consciously think about these issues, it's the institutionalist, the chief justice. He's been extremely concerned about the attacks on the Supreme Court." On the term's final day, Roberts urged the public to not mistake disagreement among the justices for disparagement of the court. "Any such misperception would be harmful to this institution and our country," he wrote in the student loans case in response to a stinging dissent by Kagan.

2023 DDI Negative
Court Politics DA › 2NC – UQ

Court legitimacy is Justice Robert’s top priority.

Liptak 7/01 -- [Adam Liptak is an American journalist, lawyer and instructor in law and journalism. He is the Supreme Court correspondent for The New York Times. Liptak has written for The New Yorker, Vanity Fair, Rolling Stone, The New York Observer, Business Week and other publications. , "Along With Conservative Triumphs, Signs of New Caution at Supreme Court," No Publication, 7-1-2023, https://www.nytimes.com/2023/07/01/us/supreme-court-liberal-conservative.html, accessed 7-23-2023] // David

The Supreme Court ended its term this week in familiar fashion, issuing blockbuster conservative decisions on affirmative action, gay rights and student loans that divided along partisan lines, with the court’s three Democratic appointees in dissent. While not quite as stunning as last June’s decisions eliminating the right to abortion and expanding gun rights, the new rulings were of a piece with them and were a further indication that the court remains receptive to the conservative legal movement’s agenda, including cutting back on a progressive conception of civil rights and frustrating President Biden’s initiatives. But the entire story of the most recent term is considerably more complicated than that of the previous one, which had seemed to establish an unyielding conservative juggernaut characterized by impatience and ambition — and built to last. A year later, the court remains deeply conservative but is more in tune with the fitfully incremental approach of Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr., who is attentive to his court’s legitimacy, than with the take-no-prisoners approach of Justice Clarence Thomas. The chief justice’s strategy — and votes — produced a fair number of liberal victories. “Chief Justice Roberts seems to be getting at least some of the conservative majority back into harness on incremental moves,” said Pamela S. Karlan, a law professor at Stanford. Indeed, the term that just ended was something of a triumph for the chief justice, who just a year ago seemed to be losing power, having failed to persuade a single colleague to join his compromise position in the case that did away with the constitutional right to abortion. When the latest term started in October, Justice Thomas appeared to have gained control of the court for the first time in his more than 30-year tenure, said Richard J. Lazarus, a law professor at Harvard. “Those tables have dramatically turned,” Professor Lazarus said. “Although the chief justice has struggled mightily under rising public expectations to address ethical issues within the court, mostly focused on Justice Thomas, the chief rather than Thomas remains the most influential justice on the court in terms of the outcomes in the court’s opinions.” Indeed, Chief Justice Roberts was in the majority in divided cases decided by signed opinions 86 percent of the time, second only to Justice Brett M. Kavanaugh, at 90 percent. Justice Thomas was last by this measure, at 55 percent. Thanks largely to alliances with Chief Justice Roberts and one or more of President Donald J. Trump’s three appointees — Justices Kavanaugh, Neil M. Gorsuch and Amy Coney Barrett — the court’s three liberals were in the majority in a considerable number of important cases. They included ones on the Voting Rights Act, immigration, the role of state legislatures in elections and Native American rights. The three liberals were on the winning side more often than the court’s two most conservative members, Justices Thomas and Samuel A. Alito Jr. “Looking across the entire docket — not just the term’s last two days — the data show a shift from the most conservative and aggressive court in modern history to one that has moderated,” said Lee Epstein, a law professor and political scientist at the University of Southern California. “Perhaps the justices — especially Roberts, Barrett and Kavanaugh — have faced up to the public’s waning confidence and decided to self-adjust. The red team versus the blue team in case after case isn’t a good look.” The percentage of unanimous decisions grew, by a large margin, to 47 percent from last term’s 28 percent. That, too, is evidence of efforts to forge consensus.

2023 DDI Negative
Court Politics DA › 2NC – UQ

Conservatives want to overturn Chevron.

O’Neil 7/24 -- [@Tyler2oneil, "Conservatives Urge Supreme Court to Overturn Chevron Deference," Daily Signal, 7-24-2023, https://www.dailysignal.com/2023/07/24/exclusive-conservatives-urge-supreme-court-tie-hands-unelected-bureaucrats-fleecing-fishermen/, accessed 7-24-2023] // David

FIRST ON THE DAILY SIGNAL—A conservative nonprofit launched by former Vice President Mike Pence is representing 11 conservative groups in supporting fishermen challenging the extensive power of the federal bureaucracy. Advancing American Freedom, which plays no role in Pence’s 2024 presidential campaign, filed an amicus brief in the Supreme Court case Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, in which the court will revisit the longstanding precedent of Chevron deference. The group exclusively gave The Daily Signal a copy of the brief. In Chevron v. National Resources Defense Council (1984), the Supreme Court held that whenever a law is ambiguous, a federal agency has the authority to interpret the scope and content of that ambiguity to achieve its ends, so long as the interpretation is “reasonable.” This precedent granted executive agencies tremendous power to effectively rewrite the law, critics like Advancing American Freedom claim. “The Left has used Chevron Deference to grow the administrative state and circumvent the approval of Congress to push their own agenda,” J. Marc Wheat, Advancing American Freedom’s general counsel, told The Daily Signal. “This is never what the Founders intended; unelected bureaucrats at various agencies do not have the power to legislate and we hope that the Supreme Court checks the Chevron Deference once and for all.” In Loper Bright, fishermen are challenging the National Marine Fisheries Service—represented by Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo. Federal law forces fishermen to carry inspectors aboard their vessels. A new Fisheries Service rule forces the fishermen to pay the salaries of these federal inspectors. The federal law requiring the inspections does not stipulate that fishermen must pay inspectors’ salaries, but the Fisheries Service insists that it has the power to demand payment under Chevron. A divided panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit sided with the Fisheries Service in August 2022, noting that the statute leaves “room for agency discretion.” Yet Judge Justin Walker dissented. “Did Congress authorize the National Marine Fisheries Service to make herring fishermen in the Atlantic pay the wages of federal monitors who inspect them at sea?” he asks in his dissent. “Congress unambiguously did not.” “Fishing is a hard way to earn a living,” he notes. While “Congress can make profitable fishing even harder by forcing fishermen to spend a fifth of their revenue on the wages of federal monitors embedded by regulation onto their ships,” it has not done so. “Until Congress does that, the Fisheries Service cannot.” Advancing American Freedom filed the amicus brief on Monday, representing itself and ten other conservative organizations. Eagle Forum, the National Center for Public Policy Research, Project 21 Black Leadership Network, Students for Life of America, and Young America’s Foundation joined the brief. The brief begins by quoting the Declaration of Independence, noting that the Founders faulted King George III for erecting “New Offices… to harass” them “and eat out their substance.” “Here, a New England fishing business is threatened with insolvency because a Federal agency seeks to swarm the industry with bureaucrats to consume the proceeds of some 20% of the daily catch,” the petitioners write. “Bureaucracies that have grown smug and fat through Chevron deference should reacquaint themselves with their country’s history.” “This case presents the question of Chevron deference dead on without any need to tack, offering an excellent opportunity to abandon this sinking ship and to offer lower courts a more seaworthy vessel for judicial review,” the petitioners write. Conservative Supreme Court justices have criticized Chevron deference in recent years. Justice Clarence Thomas wrote in his concurrence in Michigan v. EPA (2015) that Chevron “wrests from Courts the ultimate interpretative authority ‘to say what the law is,’ and hands it over to” the executive branch. Justice Neil Gorsuch wrote last fall that the court should acknowledge “that Chevron did not undo, and could not have undone, the judicial duty to provide an independent judgment of the law’s meaning.”

2023 DDI Negative
Court Politics DA › 2NC – UQ

BUT other conservatives are critical of the Chevron doctrine.

Howe 5/01 Amy Howe, Supreme Court will consider major case on power of federal regulatory agencies, SCOTUSblog (May. 1, 2023, 11:54 AM), // David

Some members of the court’s conservative majority have been critical of the Chevron doctrine in recent years. Justice Clarence Thomas has been among the doctrine’s most vocal critics, arguing in a concurring opinion in 2015 that Chevron deference “wrests from Courts the ultimate interpretative authority ‘to say what the law is,’ and hands it over to” the executive branch. He has been joined by Justice Neil Gorsuch, who in a dissent from the denial of review last fall argued that the court “should acknowledge forthrightly that Chevron did not undo, and could not have undone, the judicial duty to provide an independent judgment of the law’s meaning in the cases that come before the Nation’s courts.”

2023 DDI Negative
Court Politics DA › 1NC

Climate change disproportionately affects marginalized communities.

OXFAM ND -- [OXFAM, "Climate change and inequality," No Publication, ND, https://www.oxfamamerica.org/explore/issues/climate-action/climate-change-and-inequality/, accessed 7-28-2023] // David

At Oxfam, we know that climate change, poverty, and inequality are linked. The impact of shifting weather patterns, droughts, flooding, and storms hits poor and marginalized communities first and worst, causing unpredictable growing seasons, crop failures, and sharp increases in food prices. People in low-and lower-middle-income countries are around five times more likely than people in high-income countries to be displaced by sudden extreme weather disasters; and long standing gender, racial and economic inequalities mean that historically marginalized communities are the hardest hit and most impacted by the climate crisis. Climate change contributes to fragility and the risk of conflict and disaster. Climate-fueled disasters were the number one driver of internal displacement over the last decade - forcing an estimated 32 million people from their homes in 2022 alone. Hunger is already increasing due to climate change. People are being forced from their livelihoods, homes and communities due to climate shocks and persistent climate stress—indigenous peoples being among those at greatest risk of displacement. Climate change increases the need for life-saving assistance and protection for those facing humanitarian disasters. We also know that climate change has worsened global inequality. Across societies, the impacts of climate change affect women and men differently. Women and girls must walk further to collect water and fuel, and are often the last to eat. During and after extreme weather events, they are at increased risk of violence and exploitation. These inequalities can be seen in many other, often overlapping, dimensions too. And because Black, Brown, and Indigenous communities are more likely to live in poverty, they face these impacts while having fewer resources to respond to climate-induced natural disasters and adapt to changes in the climate. Our collective response to combat climate change must not only address the climate impacts, but also deliver systemic transformation that centers environmental justice in order to address the climate crisis as well as economic, gender, and racial injustice. We are dedicated to working with these communities to prepare for disasters and build resilience to adapt and find long-term solutions to climate change.

2023 DDI Negative
Court Politics DA › 1NC

Chevron deference is key to environmental progress.

Turrentine 6/21 -- [Jeff Turrentine, "What Happens If the Supreme Court Ends “Chevron Deference”?," NDRC , 6-21-2023, https://www.nrdc.org/stories/what-happens-if-supreme-court-ends-chevron-deference, accessed 7-24-2023] // David

At the time of the 1984 Chevron v. NRDC ruling, Doniger notes, it was widely perceived in legal and political circles that judges in the lower federal courts were inappropriately crafting policy by deciding for themselves what certain laws meant, effectively substituting their own ideas for the discernment of agency experts. “So the Supreme Court was basically saying to the lower courts: Stop inserting your own policy preferences under the guise of interpreting the law,” Doniger says. That order, in and of itself, is apolitical. The Chevron sword cuts both ways. In administrations that are seeking to relax protections (such as Reagan’s EPA in the Chevron case itself), agency heads won’t like having their decisions overruled by judges with a different way of seeing things. For presidential administrations that prioritize climate action, curbing pollution, and promoting environmental justice, Chevron deference has helped allow environmental progress. John Walke, director of NRDC’s Climate & Clean Energy program, has argued many cases in federal court where Chevron deference has come into play, and he thinks combatants on both sides of the political divide should bemoan the possibility of its erasure. “Regulatory agencies can be harmed, but deregulatory agencies can be harmed as well,” Walke says. Chevron deference’s detractors argue that the doctrine gives agencies a rubber stamp to impose onerous restrictions and rules. But as noted by the Brennan Center for Justice, a nonpartisan law and policy institute, federal agencies face legal challenges to their rules all the time—and only prevail in about 70 percent of these challenges, even with the Chevron doctrine on their side. In other words, their powers are far from unchecked. Both Doniger and Walke think that ending Chevron deference could potentially usher in a new era marked by legal and administrative chaos. For instance, in Chevron v. NRDC, the Supreme Court admonished the lower courts to not usurp agency prerogatives by making public policy through their rulings. Now the Supreme Court could reopen the door for federal judges to decide how executive-branch agencies should go about their daily business whenever Congress has used ambiguous language, which, it should be noted, isn’t always unintentional. Sometimes Congress is purposefully inexplicit in order to give the subject-area experts space to decide how best to implement a regulation. For example, an agency made up of occupational safety specialists should already be well equipped to decide how to handle the technical, nuts-and-bolts aspects of imposing workplace protections—rules about equipment usage, say, or the need for periodic employee rest breaks—without the meddling of judges. And given the complexity of weather patterns, EPA scientists are better equipped than judges at determining how much a state should curb its air pollution in order to protect people living in other states downwind. An even more obvious problem with giving judges this unrestrained interpretive authority? The federal court system is huge—and the roughly 850 judges who sit on the lower courts are a philosophically and ideologically diverse bunch, to say the least. And as the judicial appointments process has become increasingly partisan, the range of these judges’ views has gotten even wider. Ending Chevron deference would be tantamount to throwing a dart at a lower-court dartboard…and hoping for the best. “[There are] more than 10 different circuits, each with multiple judges,” Walke says. “Each with the ability to decide which reasonable interpretation is their preferred reasonable interpretation.” That’s probably not the result that those calling for an end to Chevron deference have in mind. But if their wishes come true, it could well be the one that we get.

2023 DDI Negative
Court Politics DA › 1NC

Robert’s uses liberal rulings to justify future conservative action meaning Chevron deference gets overturned.

Hasen 6/08 -- [Richard L. Hasen is an American legal scholar and law professor at the University of California, Los Angeles. He is an expert in legislation, election law and campaign finance., "Opinion," The New York Times, 6-8-2023, https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/08/opinion/milligan-roberts-court-voting-right-act.html, accessed 7-24-2023] // David

The Supreme Court’s voting rights ruling on Thursday in Allen v. Milligan is as shocking as it is welcome. The Voting Rights Act has lived to see another day, with implications for 2024 and beyond. The court ruled that Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act requires Alabama to draw a second majority-Black congressional district in which its voters can elect the candidate of their choice. In an opinion written by Chief Justice John Roberts and joined by Justices Ketanji Brown Jackson, Elena Kagan, Brett Kavanaugh and Sonia Sotomayor, the court also reaffirmed Section 2’s constitutionality and beat back Alabama’s arguments that the race-conscious statute should be read in a race-neutral way. Milligan is not a ruling that expands minority voting rights. But had the dissenting justices — Samuel Alito, Amy Coney Barrett, Neil Gorsuch and Clarence Thomas — gotten their way, it would have decimated effective minority representation as Congress, statehouses, county and school boards and city councils became much whiter and less broadly representative. The big mystery is why Chief Justice Roberts would write an opinion confirming that race-based remedies in politics are sometimes appropriate, given his role in 1982 as President Ronald Reagan’s point man opposing the expansion of Section 2, his 2013 opinion in Shelby County v. Holder striking down as unconstitutional another key part of the act and numerous recent decisions reading the act narrowly. It’s possible that he had a change of heart, but it’s more likely that his institutionalist side kicked in. He may have sided with Black Alabamians because he has genuinely changed his skeptical views about race-conscious remedies since he wrote the opinion for Shelby County, a case he did not even cite in his opinion in Milligan. He could have seen Milligan as simply applying well-settled precedents. But as recently as last year, when Alabama sought a stay before the 2022 elections of the lower-court ruling the court just affirmed, Chief Justice Roberts suggested rethinking or tinkering with those precedents even as he opposed the stay. (Justice Kavanaugh joined the other conservatives in imposing the stay, but he said he did so because the lower-court ruling came too close to the election, not on the merits of Alabama’s arguments on appeal.) But perhaps a more plausible answer for the chief justice’s blinking is that he could foresee the additional social upheaval and opprobrium that would have been generated against the Supreme Court had it ended significant minority representation in Congress and statehouses. Showing the court as an institution sometimes willing to side with minority plaintiffs could prove very important, especially if, as expected, Chief Justice Roberts and Justice Kavanaugh soon join the other conservative justices in rejecting race-based affirmative action in college admissions. Why were so many court watchers, including me, expecting a different decision in this case? Since Congress passed the Voting Rights Act in 1965 and amended it in 1982, the Supreme Court has repeatedly weighed in on its scope and meaning. Section 5 required states and localities with a history of racial discrimination in voting to get federal approval before changing their voting rules, with the burden of demonstrating that those changes would not make minority voters worse off. The court repeatedly upheld the constitutionality of Section 5. By 2013, however, the court held that Congress no longer had the power to require federal preapproval of voting changes. In Shelby County, Chief Justice Roberts declared that “history did not end in 1965” and that considerable improvement in the South made continued federal oversight unconstitutional. Section 5 prevented states from making minority voters’ situations worse, but it did little to improve minority representation in Congress and in other legislative bodies in which white voters consistently defeated candidates preferred by minority voters. The Supreme Court initially read the 15th Amendment as providing some requirement for minority voters to get a fair chance at representation, but the court shut that down in a 1980 case, City of Mobile v. Bolden. In response, in 1982 Congress rewrote Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act to give minority voters that chance. This was the state of affairs when Mr. Roberts was working for the Reagan administration to prevent an expansive rewriting of Section 2. Eventually, Congress settled on a compromise brokered by Senator Bob Dole, a Republican. The amended Section 2 would protect the ability of minority voters to elect representatives of their choice, provided that it did not guarantee proportional representation. After the Dole compromise, the Supreme Court created a complex legal test in Thornburg v. Gingles that allowed minority voters to win some but far from all cases challenging district lines. Since Gingles, the court has weighed in many times on Section 2’s meaning and scope, and in recent years conservatives have read the scope of the act less expansively. For example, it rejected a challenge to Texas’ redistricting in 2018, insisting that courts give states the benefit of the doubt when they draw district lines. And in 2021 in Brnovich v. Democratic National Committee, the court made it very hard for minority voters to use Section 2 to challenge restrictive voting rules, like voter ID laws. Milligan put the brakes on the judicial assault on Section 2 without expanding voting rights. It reaffirmed the weakened Gingles test. Given earlier rulings and the court’s emphasis in Milligan on the Dole compromise, the ruling will not lead to a flood of new districts where minority voters can elect candidates of their choice. But the court did reaffirm the constitutionality of Section 2. In recent years, Voting Rights Act opponents have put forward radical arguments to kill Section 2, recognizing that the new conservative supermajority on the Supreme Court could be receptive. In Milligan, however, the court shut many of these arguments down. In an odd echo of the uncited Shelby County case, Chief Justice Roberts declared in his ruling that “history did not stop in 1960.” His reference to the fact that discrimination is a problem of the present and not just the past was a silent recognition of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s dissent in Shelby. In the longer term, the Voting Rights Act is not necessarily safe. Writing separately, Justice Kavanaugh signaled that plaintiffs could try to bring a Shelby-like argument against Section 2 in a future case, arguing that conditions have changed enough that this part of the act, too, once constitutional, no longer is. And that leaves the question of why Chief Justice Roberts let the Voting Rights Act live, given his earlier skepticism of race-based remedies. After all, this is the justice who famously declared in a 2007 case involving affirmative action in schools that “the way to stop discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race.” A plausible answer is that he was trying, consciously or unconsciously, to preserve the limited political capital of the court in the face of its waning legitimacy and increasing attacks from the left and the center on the court. Already this court has vastly changed the scope of constitutional rights in the United States, taking away the right to an abortion and expanding gun rights, to give two of many examples. At the same time that the court is recalibrating rights in a decidedly conservative direction, some of the same conservative justices have taken actions that raise ethics concerns, especially Justice Thomas, the lead dissenter in Milligan. The ruling in Milligan disrupts the narrative that the court is relentlessly revolutionary in its conservative jurisprudence. Chief Justice Roberts has long been very much an institutionalist, and he has pushed back in recent public pronouncements to shore up the court’s legitimacy. In this case, his institutionalism seems to have trumped his long-running fight against race-conscious remedies, at least in the election context. A ruling to the contrary would have made many legislative bodies in this country less broadly representative in an increasingly diverse United States, further inflaming a good part of the country against the court.

2023 DDI Negative
Court Politics DA › 1NC

Siding with Vaello Madero follows liberal precedent.

Natelson 22 -- [Rob Natelson is the Independence Institute’s Senior Fellow in Constitutional Jurisprudence and heads the Institute’s Article V Information Center. He was a law professor for 25 years, serving at three different universities. Among other subjects, he taught Constitutional Law, Constitutional History, Advanced Constitutional Law, and First Amendment. He is also the Senior Fellow in Constitutional Jurisprudence at the Montana Policy Institute. Rob is especially known for his studies of the Constitution’s original meaning. His research has carried him to libraries throughout the United States and in Britain, including four months at Oxford. The results have included several break-though discoveries. , "The Fascinating Supreme Court Opinions in the Vaello Madero Case," Independence Institute, 5/10/2022, https://i2i.org/the-fascinating-supreme-court-opinions-in-the-vaello-madero-case/, accessed 7-24-2023] // David

Jose Luis Vaello Madero was a resident of Puerto Rico who received SSI payments in violation of federal law. When the feds sued him for restitution, he argued that denying SSI to residents of Puerto Rico violated the “equal protection component of the Fifth Amendment Due Process Clause.” In keeping with the court’s deference to most liberal precedent, Justice Kavanaugh’s opinion didn’t question the assumption that the Fifth Amendment Due Process Clause has an “equal protection component.” Nevertheless, all nine justices agreed that Congress still has discretion in making such decisions. They applied a test whereby a law discriminating among people is constitutional if the discrimination has a “rational basis.” Kavanaugh said Congress did, indeed, have a rational basis for denying SSI benefits to Puerto Ricans. He pointed out, for example, that Puerto Ricans are exempt from many federal taxes. In dissent, Justice Sotomayor argued that there was no rational basis. She noted that people on SSI are so poor they generally don’t pay federal taxes, whether they live in Puerto Rico or anywhere else in the United States. The main “takeaway” from Kavanaugh’s majority opinion is that Congress has great leeway in treating people differently based on financial considerations. This result is in keeping with the court’s 20th century liberal precedents.

2023 DDI Negative
Court Politics DA › 1NC

Roberts won’t do away with Chevron now because he wants to maintain court legitimacy.

King 5/24 -- [Pamela King is a judge of the Third Judicial District in Minnesota, serving Olmsted County. She was appointed by Democratic Governor Mark Dayton on August 26, 2015, to succeed Robert Birnbaum when he retired. She won election to her seat in the general election on November 8, 2016., "Chevron doctrine: Not dead yet," E&E News by POLITICO, 5-24-2023, https://www.eenews.net/articles/chevron-doctrine-not-dead-yet/, accessed 7-24-2023] // David

The Supreme Court was asked to overrule Chevron deference just last year in a dispute over a Department of Health and Human Services rule governing Medicare drug reimbursements. Instead, the justices unanimously scrapped the regulation without ever mentioning Chevron deference. During arguments on the Medicare rule, three of the court’s conservative justices — Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch — signaled that they were prepared to overturn Chevron. But legal observers say the court’s more moderate conservatives — Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett — may be reluctant to completely do away with long-standing precedent. Roberts in particular has demonstrated interest in avoiding big swings in prior cases, said Peter Hsiao, a partner at the law firm King & Spalding. “Behind the scenes, you’ve got a chief justice that doesn’t want this court to be seen as a political court,” Hsiao said, “and his job and his mission is to maintain the court’s integrity.”

2023 DDI Negative
T – In the US › AT – Capital T

“Territory” does not mean what they think

Roger Williams School of Law 20 – "What is a US Territory?," Roger Williams School of Law, //sp

A Territory (big T) is an insular area which is incorporated. At this time “only one exists currently, Palmyra Atoll. With an area of 1.56 square miles, Palmyra consists of about fifty small islands and lies approximately one thousand miles south of Honolulu.”