2023
DDI
Negative
Off Case Positions › Fem/Gender K › 1NC Shell
Joy 99 [Morny Joy is a Professor of Classics and Religion at the University of Calgary. “Beyond the given and the all-giving: extraneous speculations on women and the gift,” Vol. 17 No. 1 (1999): Approaching Religion, https://doi.org/10.30674/scripta.67247]//zemh
Apart from registering this sobering reflection, it is beyond the scope of this presentation to undertake a thorough investigation of the exact reliability of the base data concerned with potlatch itself. 112 MORNY JOY But it does indicate that a close scrutiny of all such imposed categories is imperative and a beginning has been made in an important study by Christopher Bracken, The Potlatch Papers: A Colonial Case History (1997). The concomitant problem that I wish to focus on in this paper is of equal moment with regard to unwarranted assumptions — it is the refusal to acknowledge women as full participants or agents in these procedures concerned with the gift.
Mauss is culpable in this regard. He is content to replicate material regarding women's role from Boas and Malinowski: All these institutions reveal the same kind of social and psychological pattern. Food, women, children, possessions, charms, land, labour, services, religious offices, rank — everything is stuff to be given away and repaid. (Mauss 1967: 11-12)
2023
DDI
Negative
Off Case Positions › Ballot PIK › 1NC
Bataille, ’91 [Georges Bataille, obsessive pervert and crazy librarian (I’ve been told), “The Accursed Share: An Essay on the General Economy (Vol. 1: Consumption)”, translated by Robert Hurley, published in 1991, pp. 59-61 *Bataille was a product of his time. We do not endorse any gendered or ableist language //jwc]
The victim is a surplus taken from the mass of useful wealth. And he can only be withdrawn from it in order to be consumed profitlessly, and therefore utterly destroyed. Once chosen, he is the accursed share, destined for violent consumption. But the curse tears him away from the order of things; it gives him a recognizable figure, which now radiates intimacy, anguish, the profundity of living beings. Nothing is more striking than the attention that is lavished on him. Being a thing, he cannot truly be withdrawn from the real order, which binds him, unless destruction rids him of his "thinghood," eliminating his usefulness once and for all. As soon as he is consecrated and during the time between the consecration and death, he enters into the closeness of the sacrificers and participates in their consumptions: He is one of their own and in the festival in which he will perish, he sings, dances and enjoys all the pleasures with them. There is no more servility in him; he can even receive arms and fight. He is lost in the immense confusion of the festival. And that is precisely his undoing. The victim will be the only one in fact to leave the real order entirely, for he alone is carried along to the end by the movement of the festival. The sacrificer is divine only with reservations. The future is heavily reserved in him; the future is the weight that he bears as a thing. The official theologians whose tradition Sahagun collected were well aware of this, for they placed the voluntary sacrifice of Nanauatzin above the others, praised warriors for being consumed by the gods, and gave divinity the meaning of consumption. We cannot know to what extent the victims of Mexico accepted their fate. It may be that in a sense certain of them "considered it an honor" to be offered to the gods. But their immolation was not voluntary. Moreover, it is clear that, from the time of Sahagun's informants, these death orgies were tolerated because they impressed foreigners. The Mexicans immolated children that were chosen from among their own. But severe penalties had to be decreed against those who walked away from their procession when they went up to the altars. Sacrifice comprises a mixture of anguish and frenzy. The frenzy is more powerful than the anguish, but only providing its effects are diverted to the exterior, onto a foreign prisoner. It suffices for the sacrificer to give up the wealth that the victim could have been for him. This understandable lack of rigor does not, however, change the meaning of the ritual. The only valid excess was one that went beyond the bounds, and one whose consumption appeared worthy of the gods. This was the price men paid to escape their downfall and remove the weight introduced in them by the avarice and cold calculation of the real order.
2023
DDI
Negative
Off Case Positions › JG Counter-plan › 1NC Shell
Nunn Et al. Ryan Nunn, Jimmy O’Donnell, and Jay Shambaugh, 12-2018, Nunn works at the Hamilton Project and Brookings Institute, O’Donnell is an analyst at the Hamilton Project, and Shambaugh works at the Hamilton Project, Brookings Institute, and George Washington University, “Labor Market Considerations for a National Jobs’s Guarantee”, Published at the Hamilton Project, VDR
Second, and more importantly, a job guarantee might lower the productivity of a given worker. Because the administrative allocation of workers would likely not match peoples’ talents with occupations as well as a market allocation would, individuals would quite likely find themselves creating less output per hour than if they had found employment outside of the job guarantee program. The size of this productivity reduction would depend on the ability of the job guarantee program administrators to match participants with productive employment. During downturns in private labor demand, when the program would likely be flooded with applicants, it seems unlikely that workers would be well-matched in all cases. However, if the alternative for many workers is not private employment, but rather nonemployment, then output per capita could still be higher with a job guarantee. A related concern is that a large number of people might stay in relatively unproductive guaranteed jobs for long periods of time. In these cases, they will almost certainly be less productive than if they were allocated by a labor market to their best-matched employment option. Thus, a significant concern for job guarantee programs that are large enough and well-paying enough to draw people from the private sector is the negative effect they would have on productivity, which has clear negative implications for living standards. Conversely, the more targeted a program is—i.e., the more limited a program is to individuals who are unemployed or not wellutilized in the private labor market—and the more emphasis that is placed on training and eventually transitioning people to the private labor market, the less one would be concerned about deleterious productivity implications.
2023
DDI
Negative
Off Case Positions › T – Fiscal Redistribution › 1NC Shell – Fiscal Redistribution
Coady et al 20 — [David Coady, University of Tasmania, “Fiscal redistribution and social welfare: Doing more or more to do?,” ZBW, 2020, https://www.econstor.eu/bitstream/10419/228409/1/1700357220.pdf, accessed 7-20-2023; marlborough-mjen]
Existing analyses of fiscal redistribution are typically based on comparisons of inequality indices before and after taxes and transfers. This paper embeds the analysis of fiscal redistribution within the standard social welfare framework, which easily lends itself to a transparent and practical evaluation of the determinants of fiscal redistribution and of differences across countries and time. This framework is used to decompose fiscal redistribution into differences in fiscal effort, as reflected in the magnitude of redistributive tax and transfer (i.e., net tax) systems, and differences in fiscal progressivity, reflecting the distribution of net transfers across different income groups. Fiscal progressivity is further decomposed into two components, one reflecting the share of net transfers accruing to lower income groups (targeting performance), the other reflecting the social returns to targeting due to differences in the initial inequality of income (targeting returns). This helps clarify the concepts of progressivity and targeting and the relationship between them. 1
2023
DDI
Negative
Off Case Positions › T – Fiscal Redistribution › 1NC Shell – Fiscal Redistribution
Sheff Economics Research 16 [2/4/16, “Research from the Department of Economics, University of Sheffield”, medium, https://medium.com/@sheffeconomics/democratic-government-policies-tackling-inequality-before-elections-supports-democracy-17006e6eb29#:~:text=Fiscal%20redistribution%20is%20defined%20as,government%20via%20taxes%20and%20transfers.] RVP
Fiscal redistribution is defined as the reduction in income inequality, brought about by government via taxes and transfers. Their findings indicate that only in countries characterized as young democracies do elections exert a positive impact on fiscal redistribution.
2023
DDI
Negative
Generics Links › Inflation DA › 2NC – Extension
1 --- Providing excessive amounts of funds towards the ppl who have high propensity to spend inflates the value of the dollar and harms the economy
2 --- It’s a policy designed to drain all money from the economy, trillion and trillion of dollars means other programs such as medicaid
2023
DDI
Negative
Generics Links › Inflation DA › 1NC – Link – Economy
ACEMOGLU 19 [6/7/19, Daron is Professor of Economics at MIT, is a co-author (with James A. Robinson) of Why Nations Fail: The Origins of Power, Prosperity and Poverty (Profile, 2019) and a co-author (with Simon Johnson) of Power and Progress: Our Thousand-Year Struggle Over Technology and Prosperity (PublicAffairs, 2023). “Why Universal Basic Income Is a Bad Idea”, Project Syndicate, https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/why-universal-basic-income-is-a-bad-idea-by-daron-acemoglu-2019-06?barrier=accesspaylog] RVP
BOSTON – Owing to the inadequacy of the social safety net in the United States and other developed countries, proposals for a universal basic income (UBI) are gaining in popularity. The gap between the rich and everyone else has expanded significantly in recent years, and many fear that automation and globalization will widen it further.
To be sure, if the only choice is between mass impoverishment and a UBI, a UBI is preferable. Such a program would allow people to spend their money on whatever they value most. It would create a broad sense of ownership and a new constituency to shake up the system of big-money politics. Studies of conditional cash-transfer programs in developing economies have found that such policies can empower women and other marginalized groups.
2023
DDI
Negative
Generics Links › Inflation DA › 1NC – Link – UBI Expensive
Greenstein 19 [6/13/19, Robert is the Founder and President Emeritus of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. He is considered an expert on the federal budget and a range of domestic policy issues, including anti-poverty programs and various aspects of tax and health care policy. “Commentary: Universal Basic Income May Sound Attractive But, If It Occurred, Would Likelier Increase Poverty Than Reduce It”, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, https://www.cbpp.org/research/poverty-and-opportunity/commentary-universal-basic-income-may-sound-attractive-but-if-it] RVP
At first blush, universal basic income (UBI) seems a very attractive idea, especially to a progressive. Yet it suffers from two serious problems. First, the odds are very high that an effort to secure UBI would prove quixotic. Second, and more disconcerting, any possibility of overcoming the formidable obstacles to UBI will almost certainly require a left-right coalition that has significant conservative support — and conservative support for UBI rests on an approach that would increase poverty, rather than reduce it.
The key issues related to UBI include what it would cost, how it would be paid for, and the risks it poses. Let’s take these one at a time.
2023
DDI
Negative
Generics Links › Inflation DA › 1NC – Link – UBI Inflation
Boyce 19 [5/5/19, Paul is a Business Economics graduate from the UK and currently an editor at http://boycewire.com. “Universal Basic Income Is a Pandora’s Box”, FEE Stories, https://fee.org/articles/universal-basic-income-is-a-pandora-s-box/] RVP
The case for a Universal Basic Income (UBI) is a strong one, in some ways. A UBI would stimulate aggregate demand, help those affected by technological change, and create a basic income for the poor. Its effectiveness and impact, however, depend on how much is given out. The benefits and consequences of a $100 UBI will be very different than one of $1,000. Therefore, for the purpose of this analysis, I will look at the case for a $1,000 per month UBI—as suggested by presidential candidate Andrew Yang.
Previous Experiments Are Not Comparable
2023
DDI
Negative
Bataille Case Answers › Thermodynamics True › 2NC – Yes Thermodynamics
NASA 21 [5/13/21, National Aeronautics and Space Administration Glenn Research Center, “First Law of Thermodynamics”, NASA, grc.nasa.gov/www/k-12/airplane/thermo1.html] RVP
Thermodynamics is a branch of physics which deals with the energy and work of a system. Thermodynamics deals only with the large scale response of a system which we can observe and measure in experiments. Small scale gas interactions are described by the kinetic theory of gases. There are three principal laws of thermodynamics which are described on separate slides. Each law leads to the definition of thermodynamic properties which help us to understand and predict the operation of a physical system. We will present some simple examples of these laws and properties for a variety of physical systems, although we are most interested in the thermodynamics of propulsion systems and high speed flows. Fortunately, many of the classical examples of thermodynamics involve gas dynamics.
In our observations of the work done on, or by a gas, we have found that the amount of work depends not only on the initial and final states of the gas but also on the process, or path which produces the final state. Similarly the amount of heat transferred into, or from a gas also depends on the initial and final states and the process which produces the final state. Many observations of real gases have shown that the difference of the heat flow into the gas and the work done by the gas depends only on the initial and final states of the gas and does not depend on the process or path which produces the final state. This suggests the existence of an additional variable, called the internal energy of the gas, which depends only on the state of the gas and not on any process. The internal energy is a state variable, just like the temperature or the pressure. The first law of thermodynamics defines the internal energy (E) as equal to the difference of the heat transfer (Q) into a system and the work (W) done by the system.
2023
DDI
Negative
Bataille Case Answers › Thermodynamics True › 2NC – Yes Thermodynamics
Lucas 22 [2/28/22, Jim is a contributing writer for Live Science. He covers physics, astronomy and engineering. Jim graduated from Missouri State University, where he earned a bachelor of science degree in physics with minors in astronomy and technical writing. After graduation he worked at Los Alamos National Laboratory as a network systems administrator, a technical writer-editor and a nuclear security specialist. “What is the first law of thermodynamics?”, LIVE SCIENCE, https://www.livescience.com/50881-first-law-thermodynamics.html] RVP
The first law of thermodynamics states that heat is a form of energy, and thermodynamic processes are therefore subject to the principle of conservation of energy. This means that heat energy cannot be created or destroyed, according to Britannica. It can, however, be transferred from one location to another and converted to and from other forms of energy.
Thermodynamics is the branch of physics that deals with the relationships between heat and other forms of energy. In particular, it describes how thermal energy is converted to and from other forms of energy and how it affects matter. The fundamental principles of thermodynamics are expressed in four laws.
2023
DDI
Negative
Bataille Case Answers › Thermodynamics True › 1NC – Yes Thermodynamics
Bois and Krauss ’96 [Autumn 1996, Yve-Alain is a professor of Art History at the School of Historical Studies at the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton, New Jersey. Rosalind Epstein is an American art critic, art theorist and a professor at Columbia University in New York City. “A User’s Guide to Entropy.” October, vol. 78, 1996, pp. 81. JSTOR, https://doi.org/10.2307/778906. Accessed 18 July 2023.] RVP
***this article had formatting issues on jstor, so im hoping its all good***
ZONE. Bataille conceived of a kind of thermodynamics in reverse because the sun's energy is in a state of superfluity, we are condemned to an ever-increasing overproduction, and it is this cosmic imbalance that is at the root of the cyclical character of certain regulatory mechanisms – like war – that are activated by a buildup of unspent energy (war, an unproductive expenditure represents the sudden release of an excessive amount of energy at the point when the pressure has become too great, like steam escaping through the safety valve of a pressure cooker). This model, which began to be formulated in 1933 in "The Notion of Expenditure," but which Bataille would further elaborate in The Accursed Share (1949), seems at first glance to depend on a law totally contrary to that of entropy. Yet the outcome Bataille has in mind would be every bit as eschatological as Carnot's own original prediction of the progressive cooling-down of the solar system.
2023
DDI
Negative
Bataille Case Answers › Cap Turn › 1NC – Cap Turn
Igrek, ‘9 [Apple Zefelius Igrek, assistant professor at Oklahoma State University in the Department of Philosophy, “Modes of Luxurious Walking,” published in September 2009, *edited for problematic language //jwc]
Any discussion of Bataillean waste, excess, and profligacy invites the question as to whether this general economy should be distinguished from modern capitalist societies in which blind, ruinous extravagance seems to be the predominant moral imperative. If anything, modern industrial economies are built on extraordinary waste and extreme ecological devastation; thus one could plausibly argue, as Jean-Joseph Goux has, that the risk-taking ethos of transnational capitalism is the quintessential post-bourgeois embodiment of Bataillean expenditure (Stoekl 137). There is, of course, an all too obvious blind spot to [problem with] this eternal perpetuation of cultural and economic excess: it cannot be sustained. As demand for energy dramatically increases over the next few decades, we will surely witness, as predicted by the petroleum geologist M. King Hubbert (in what is called, alluding to a bell-curve graph, "Hubbert's Peak"), a vast and imminent depletion of our fossil fuel resources. Stoekl draws the discomfiting but probable conclusion that "the more or less constant growth in productivity, production, and profits the world experienced over the last century, tracked with a commensurate population increase, based as both were on increases in energy production, is nearing its end" (119). If we will soon reach a point where we can no longer rely upon large quantities of highly concentrated sources of energy, without which the very essence of modern consumerist subjectivity will be thrown into disarray, then a call to personal sacrifice must not be far behind. Thus, Lisa H. Newton, in direct response to the problem of scarcity, argues for a simpler and more authentic life in contrast to the currently unsustainable levels of status-driven consumption (Stoekl 120). Sustaining our globalized economy at a more appropriate, more rational level will necessarily require a fundamental change in our approach to natural resources. This implies the conservation of energy, to be sure, but Newton also links this approach to a moral and religiously inspired perspective, one which renounces easy pleasure and artificial consumerism. The new self - simple, austere, rational - seems to be absolutely crucial to the survival of the planet. In this context, Bataille's theory of excess life and wild expenditure would appear to be deeply problematic.
2023
DDI
Negative
Bataille Case Answers › Fascism Turn › 2NC – Fascism Turn
Stevenson, ’17 [Guy Stevenson, associate lecturer at Goldsmiths, University of London, “Sacrifice and expenditure: the sexual economics of Georges Bataille and Ezra Pound,” published in 2017, //jwc]
Pound rather than Bataille advocates reforming the economic system to make ‘“good use” of the social’. Where Pound wants to organise a messy and manic situation masquerading as orderly and rational, Bataille denies the virtue in rationalising monetary exchange, pushing instead for a physical and desire-driven model of primitive economy based on the acceptance of chaotic and uncontrolled excess. If Pound’s enemies are usury and utilitarianism, Bataille’s, according to Baudrillard, ‘is utility, in its root. Rather than an apparently positive principle of capital: accumulation, investment, deprecation, etc. … [utility] is, on Bataille’s account, a principle of powerlessness, an utter inability to expend’ (192). In the light of Pound’s profound political and social opposition to Marxism, however, these economic differences are less significant than their similarities. Pound consistently espouses elitist, explicitly anti-socialist ideas throughout his literary, political and economic writings. Indeed, central to his philosophy was the belief in the sanctity of a number of men – active chiefly in the arts – with the intelligence to counteract the veniality of ‘the mob’ or ‘the bullet headed many’ and move culture forward (Pound, 1954b: 297). Alongside friends and literary collaborators Wyndham Lewis, T.E. Hulme and other so-called ‘men of 1914’, Pound opposed liberal but also socialist values with a radically conservative set of directives. Yet – in keeping with the ‘use-value’ foundation discussed earlier – Pound’s fundamental aim to solve what Douglas (1935: 30) characterised as ‘the paradox between poverty and distress on the one hand and potential plenty on the other’ coincides with Marx’s. In a reversal of the same dialectic, the attraction to excess that differentiates Bataille from orthodox Marxist economists also led him to flirt with his avowed enemies on the right. Despite his position as co-founder of Critique, the Parisian leftist magazine aimed at countering fascism, various of his essays demonstrate an interest in Hitler and Mussolini that was in many ways as emotionally charged as Pound’s. With a group of like-minded thinkers including Maurice Blanchot and Pierre Provost, Bataille envisioned Critique as a corrective to Action française, Pierre LaSerre’s radical rightist group that grew out of 1894’s Dreyfus Affair, and was inspired by Italian and German fascism. Unpardonably, to the Nietzschean Bataille, Action française also followed the Italian and German examples in appropriating Nietzsche to justify its totalitarian stance. And yet, in a 1933 essay entitled ‘The Psychological Structure of Fascism’, Bataille explains fascism’s mass appeal in terms of the heterogeneous truth discussed earlier. ‘The fascist leaders,’ he writes, ‘are incontestably part of heterogeneous existence. Opposed to democratic politicians, who represent in different countries the platitude inherent to homogeneous society, Mussolini and Hitler immediately stand out as something other’ (Bataille, 1985b: 143, emphasis in original). Looking beyond his objections to their politics, Bataille assigns value to these figureheads because they symbolise and facilitate unproductive expenditure. The strong man at the heart of a populist movement such as fascism, he says, is a conduit through which the ‘excessive energies’ accumulated by ‘the common consciousness’ can be channeled and released: The affective low that unites him with his followers – which takes the form of moral identification of the latter with the one they follow … is a function of the common consciousness of increasingly violent and excessive energies and powers that accumulate in the person of the leader and through him become widely available. (Bataille, 1933: 143–4, emphasis in original) Bataille is interested in Hitler and Mussolini as symptoms of the powerful natural human desire to transcend rational, political thought and discourse. While he acknowledges the dangers inherent in such a process – a form of mass ‘hypnosis’, as he later calls it (Bataille, 1985: 143) – he also celebrates its potential for psychological liberation. Quoting from the same essay, Habermas notes that Bataille was himself seduced by these leaders’ rupture with a ‘boring’ homogeneous reality: Into this rationalised world irrupt the fascist Fuhrer and this entranced masses. It is not without admiration that Bataille speaks of their heterogeneous existence … He is fascinated by the violence ‘that raises them [Hitler and Mussolini] above the people, the parties, and even the laws, a violence that penetrates the normal course of affairs, the peaceful but boring homogeneity that is impotent when it comes to maintaining itself by its own force.’ (Habermas, 1985: 218) Surprisingly, Pound’s promotion of Mussolini is based on something more prosaic – namely, the Italian’s ability to convert political ideology into action. In his 1933 tract Jefferson And/ Or Mussolini, Pound reveals himself to have been – to all intents and purposes – one of Bataille’s hypnotised masses, in thrall to what he calls Mussolini’s ‘straight stare’. The personal admiration, however, had its origins in a genuine belief that Italian fascism dealt in ‘fact’ rather than ‘merely theory’ (1935a: 103–4). Affirming a lineage between Mussolini’s dictatorship and the paternal agrarian politics of eighteenth-century American president Thomas Jefferson, he posits the Italian as the long-awaited answer to the question troubling ‘[modern] democracy: namely whether its alleged system, its de jure system, can still be handled by the men of good will; whether real issues as distinct from red herrings CAN be forced into the legislatures (House and Senate)’ (110, emphasis in original). Where Ramsay MacDonald and Franklin Roosevelt have ‘merely talked’, he writes, Mussolini has done ‘something, constructive or otherwise’ to challenge the status quo (110, emphasis in original). Both sympathetic towards the popular distaste for the unserviceable ‘platitudes’ of democratic governments, Pound’s and Bataille’s respective interests in control and excess led one to identify with fascism on practical and the other on spiritual and metaphysical terms. Conclusion What we see in Pound’s inter-war polemics and Bataille’s The Accursed Share are two writers who looked to the radical politics of the early twentieth century to validate and inform their unorthodox economic positions, but who also picked and chose from very different elements within those politics and, as a result, arrived at conclusions that contradicted their stated aims. As such, they indicate the seductive versatility of ideological positions that rejected the standard hermeneutics of socialism, liberalism, even conservatism. Roger Griffin (2007: 215) calls this ‘fascism’s multivalent, multifaceted nature as a utopian project of historical change that allowed any number of rival political visions to be projected onto it’. Just as Pound was able to ignore the violence so heavily implied by the ‘mass ecstasy and authority’ underpinning Mussolini’s rule, Bataille could look past its authoritarian nature and find evidence of the heterogeneous truth that orthodox economics was unable to accommodate. In both cases, fascism’s newness and otherness provided unusually fertile ground on which to experiment with alternative systems that might mirror patterns of energy in the natural world. Of course, in many quarters the horrors resulting from fascist ideology have de-validated the connections Pound made between economics and nature, and – in particular – economics and sexuality. It remains important to question the efficacy of a theory that promoted an ultra-repressive, eventually genocidal government as the key to fixing the world economy. More pressingly, Pound’s predication of his economic ideas on the racist belief in a Jewish moneylending conspiracy necessitates scrutiny of their logical and ethical validity. Although neither a conspiracy theorist nor a programmatic anti-Semite, the fact that Bataille savoured Aztec violence and was fascinated by fascist leaders carries its own impediment perhaps to a serious appreciation and certainly to the practical application of his economic ideas. From a historical but also cautiously theoretical perspective, however, these radical positions are revealing and instructive. On their most basic level, they are symptomatic of the wider correlation Michael Tratner identifies between sexuality and economics after World War One: theirs is the language of consumption and they proffer expenditure as a source of growth. As Tratner rightly points out, 60 years on from the first wave of Keynesian economics, Bataille’s ideas of an economy based on the perverse productivity of useless expenditure might actually appear more relevant than when they were first published: The strange sequence … of persons stepping outside of the logic of exchange and participating in acts of loss and useless behavior, and then finding that the economic system makes use of them, is not so very strange. It is the new logic of exchange itself in the twentieth century, the logic of deficits as a way to create growth. (Tratner, 2001: 49) But while Tratner’s analysis works up to a point, it glosses over the historical precedent for twentieth-century anxieties about expenditure, in the process applying an artificial order to the complex relationship between sexuality and economics after 1920. Indeed, what is intriguing about the conflation of sexual and economic language of the early to mid-twentieth century is its complicated and paradoxical embodiment of politically contradictory impulses, inconsistencies that are often ironed out in attempts to identify moments of major political and economic sea change. Bataille’s and Pound’s contributions to the economic debate between 1920 and 1960 – and to similar debates in the twenty-first century – are interesting exactly because of their resistance to such stable historical and political interpretation. By co-opting related language for apparently opposite ends, and by ending up in strange and unfamiliar political territory, they expose the perversely depoliticising effect of interpreting the economy according to metaphysical ‘truths’. Looked at from a certain angle, Bataille’s celebration of ‘useless expenditure’ conjures as violent a vision for the future as anything imagined by Hitler or Mussolini. Likewise, Pound’s attempt to reorganise the economy along rational ‘use-value’ lines is in many ways as progressive and utopian as Marx’s. Apart from shedding light on the special conditions of the period in history in which they were writing, their experiments serve as valuable warnings against the dangerous appeal and morally, politically distortionary effect of attempting to naturalise and, indeed, sexualise the economy.
2023
DDI
Negative
Bataille Case Answers › Fascism Turn › 1NC – Fascism Turn
Guy Stevenson, 03-10-2017, Stevenson is postdoctoral associate at Goldsmiths, University of London working on literary modernism and countercultural studies, “Sacrifice and expenditure: the sexual economics of Georges Bataille and Ezra Pound”, European Journal of Studies, http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/13825577.2016.1274542 //VDR
In a reversal of the same dialectic, the attraction to excess that differentiates Bataille from orthodox Marxist economists also led him to flirt with his avowed enemies on the right. Despite his position as co-founder of Critique, the Parisian leftist magazine aimed at coun- tering fascism, various of his essays demonstrate an interest in Hitler and Mussolini that was in many ways as emotionally charged as Pound’s. With a group of like-minded thinkers including Maurice Blanchot and Pierre Provost, Bataille envisioned Critique as a corrective to Action française, Pierre LaSerre’s radical rightist group that grew out of 1894’s Dreyfus Affair, and was inspired by Italian and German fascism. Unpardonably, to the Nietzschean Bataille, Action française also followed the Italian and German examples in appropriating Nietzsche to justify its totalitarian stance. And yet, in a 1933 essay entitled‘The Psychological Structure of Fascism’, Bataille explains fascism’s mass appeal in terms of the heterogeneous truth discussed earlier.‘The fascist leaders,’he writes,‘are incontestably part of heterogeneous existence. Opposed to democratic politicians, who represent in different countries the plat- itude inherent to homogeneous society, Mussolini and Hitler immediately stand out as some- thing other’ (Bataille, 1985b: 143, emphasis in original). Looking beyond his objections to their politics, Bataille assigns value to these figureheads because they symbolise and facilitate unproductive expenditure. The strong man at the heart of a populist movement such as fascism, he says, is a conduit through which the ‘excessive energies’ accumulated by ‘the common consciousness’ can be channeled and released:
The affective flow that unites him with his followers – which takes the form of moral identifi- cation of the latter with the one they follow ... is a function of the common consciousness of increasingly violent and excessive energies and powers that accumulate in the person of the leader and through him become widely available. (Bataille, 1933: 143–4, emphasis in original)
2023
DDI
Negative
Bataille Case Answers › Fascism Turn › 1NC – Fascism Turn
Richard Wolin, 1996, Wolin has a Ph. D. in Social and Political Thought from York University, “LEFT FASCISM: GEORGES BATAILLE AND THE GERMAN IDEOLOGY”, Constellations Volume 2 No 3, //VDR
Bataille purveys a critique of parliamentarianism that is as zealous as anything one finds in the work of Carl Schmitt. Parliamentary decision- making, he claims, partakes wholly of the order of the homogeneous. It aims solely at co-optation, the elimination of difference. As such, it is purely instrumental and serves primarily to suppress the breakthrough of heterogeneous elements that threaten to explode the normative bases of the given economic and political order. As Bataille observes, in a striking anticipation of Jean-Franqois Lyotard’s association of “consensus” and “terror”: “The reduction of differences in parliamentary practice indicates all the possible complexity of the internal activity of adaptation required by homogeneity.”60 Bataille can perceive no fundamental differences between the conduct of political and economic life in modern democratic societies, insofar as both are examples par excellence of homogeneity - this despite the fact that discussion aims at mutual understanding, whereas economic activity is goal-oriented and utilitarian .61 Given this curt dismissal of the institutional bases of democracy, it comes as little surprise that Bataille glorifies the role played by fascism in modern political life as a type of breakthrough of the heterogeneous. For Bataille, “the fascist leaders are incontestably part of heterogeneous existence. Opposed to democratic politicians, who represent in different countries the platitude inherent to homogeneous society, Mussolini and Hitler immedi- ately stand out as something other.”62 What he admires about these men and the movement they represent is that they embody “a force that situates them above other men,” which accounts for their “sovereignty.” Yet, he also esteems greatly their thoroughgoing antagonism to law: “the fact that laws are broken is only the most obvious sign of the transcendent, heterogeneous nature of fascist action.”63 Here, the parallels with Schmitt’s critique of bourgeois legal positivism are of course profound. Both Schmitt and Bataille view the institution of law as the consummate embodiment of the spirit of bourgeois rationalism. It symbolizes everything they detest about the reigning social order: its prosaic longing for security, its unrevolutionary nature, its abhorrence of “transcendence,” its anathematization of the vitality and intensity one finds in the “exception” (Schmitt) or “transgression” (Bataille). Moreover, for Bataille the system of law merits especially harsh treatment insofar as it signifies a type of consecretion of the profane order of things; as such, it stands as an impediment to contact with the heterogeneous or the sacred. Bataille concludes his endorsement of fascist politics with the following encomium: “Heterogeneous fascist action belongs to the entire set of higher forms. It makes an appeal to sentiments traditionally defined as exalted and noble and tends to constitute authority as an unconditional principle, situated above any utilitarian judgment.”64 As opposed to the bourgeois order of life, which, with its utilitarianism and its legalism, merely sanctifies “the prose of the world,” fascism offers a new political aesthetic, the return, as it were, of an aesthetic politics: a type of politics that reintroduces the long lost elements of charismatic leadership (in Bataille’s terms, 0 Blackwell Publishers Ltd. 1996 Georges Bataille and the German Ideology: Richard Wolin 415 “sovereignty”), violence, and martial glory. It is, moreover, a politics that facilitates a great emotional cathexis between leaders and masses, a point which Bataille emphasizes repeatedly. For one of fascism’s great attributes is that it “clearly demonstrates what can be expected from a timely recourse to reawakened affective forces” - forces capable of guaranteeing a measure of collective solidarity, which have been banished from a society in which the division of labor and rationalization reign supreme. In sum, fascism serves to reintroduce a type of ecstatic politics into the forlorn and disenchanted landscape of political modernity, a politics that aims at the creation of a quasi-Nietzschean ecstatic community.
Here, it is well worthwhile to recall the remarks of Bernard-Henri LCvy cited above: “[fascism] is in the first instance a type of society, a model of community, a manner of thinking and of organizing the social bond.”6s For it is the restoration of the affective energies and intensities associated with a type of communitarian social bond prevalent in premodern societies that is in so many respects the guiding thread of Bataille’s intellectual oeuvre. His preoccupation with sacrifice, the sacred, and, lastly, the possibilities for cultural renewal embodied in fascist political action, are comprehensible in these terms alone. As one commentator has appropriately remarked concerning Bataille’s attempts to view fascism as a contemporary reincarna- tion of the “sacred” or “heterogeneous”: the worship of Otherness which underlies [Bataille’s] concept of the sacred inevitably leads to an acknowledgement of the attraction historical fascism exerts through the mana of its leaders. The category of the heterogeneous, as Bataille defines it, contains so much that is “nature” rather than “history” that its repeated application to manifestations of fascist power quite clearly produce a mythification. . .&
2023
DDI
Negative
Bataille Case Answers › Solvency › 1NC – UE is productive
Ascheim Et al, Kathryn Ascheim, Rhonda Garelick and Jean-Joseph Goux, 1990, Ascheim did her graduate work in the department of Molecular Biophysics and Biochemistry at Yale University , Garelick Garelick is the D.E. Hughes Jr. Distinguished Chair for English at SMU and writes in modernist and contemporary literature, Goux was a professor at Rice University teaching philosophy, economy, psychanalysis, “General Economics and Postmodern Capitalism”, Yale University Press, //VDR
It is clear that even the most unproductive seeming consumption (for example: tobacco, alcohol, but also pleasure trips, movies etc.) produces a profit-making industry, and thereby falls into the economic sphere according to the logic of the general equivalent. If one remains on strictly economic ground, it is in truth impossible to separate productive consumption from unproductive squandering. Ethical criteria alone could claim to make this distinction. It is perhaps one of the aspects of our society to have erased at once the opposition between the sacred and the profane, and with the same gesture, the difference between the useful and the useless, the necessary and the superfluous, primary need and secondary satisfaction, etc. Is it useful or superfluous to manufacture microwave ovens, quartz watches, video games, or collectively, to travel to the moon and Mars, to photograph Saturn's rings, etc.? Condillac had already written that "What is luxury for one people is not so for another, and for the same people, what was a luxury can cease to be one."9 Condillac and many others saw the very principle of the "progress of the arts" in this relativity of luxury, this movement whereby the choicest goods "enter into common use" (191). And it is doubtless this erasure, this blurring, that makes it so desperately difficult for Bataille to find the opposition between the glorious, sacrificial, spectacular consumption of the accursed share (founded upon the principle of a loss that lends grandeur and nobility) and prosaically utilitarian consumption. But if this line of demarcation cannot be found, it is the very result of democratic life which has weakened and dismantled these oppositions, which has made them lose their meaning of social cleavage and confined them to the realm of insular individual experience. All the examples of consumption societies that fascinate Bataille are extremely unequal, even cruelly hierarchical societies in which spectacular consumption is the tool with which the powerful maintain their position above the dazzled, miserable masses. The counterpart of the erosion of these hierarchical oppositions (and in the first place, the antimony sacred-profane) is certainly the domination of all activity by the categories of political economy. This does not, however, 9. Condillac, "Du Luxe," Le Commerce et le gouvernement, (Geneva: Slatkine Reprints, 1980), chapter 27, 190. Henceforth cited in the text. JEAN-JOSEPH GOUX 221 imply the reign of the "implacable, serene God of the useful," as Baudelaire writes. 10 Unless we understand it as a production marked by complete axiological indifference.
2023
DDI
Negative
Bataille Case Answers › Impact Defense › 2NC – Restricted Economy Defense
Goux et al 90 [Jean-Joseph Goux is Laurence Favrot Professor of French Studies at Rice University, et al. “General Economics and Postmodern Capitalism.” Yale French Studies, no. 78, 1990, pp. 206–24. JSTOR, https://doi.org/10.2307/2930123. marlborough-mjen]
In my view it is in this historical outcome that the most serious difficulty lies. This is also undoubtedly Bataille's view: he always wanted to continue his first sketch but this continuation exists in fragments. On the one hand, there is hardly any doubt that Bataille always harbored a will to subvert contemporary society, a will that was heightened by his searing contact with surrealism and politically engaged groups. On the other hand, it is clear that the discussions in La Part maudite concerning "the present facts" of the world situation in terms of general economics are more than disappointing. Every- thing suggests that Bataille was unable to articulate his mysticism of expenditure, of sovereignty, of major communication-expressed so flamboyantly in La Somme Atheologique, L'Erotisme or La Lit- terature et le mal-in terms of contemporary general economics.
Where do we situate Bataille's claim? What happens to the de- mand of the sacred in capitalist society? How do we reconcile the affirmation that capitalism represents an unprecedented break with all archaic (precapitalist) forms of expenditure and the postulate of the necessary universality of spending as pure loss? This is the diffi- culty. Bataille wants to maintain as a general anthropological princi- ple the necessity of unproductive expenditure while simultaneously upholding the historic singularity of capitalism with regard to this expenditure. Bourgeois society corresponds to a "general atrophy of former sumptuary processes" (41). An anomaly whereby loss is not absent (which would contradict the general principle) but virtually unreadable: "Today, the great and free social forms of unproductive expenditure have disappeared. Nevertheless, we should not conclude from this that the very principle of expenditure is no longer situated at the end of economic activity" (37). So what happens to ostentatious expenditure in capitalism? And can we really believe, furthermore, that the even more radical desacralization effected by communism could become a libertarian affirmation of sovereignty-the feast of self-consciousness, without divinities and myths?
2023
DDI
Negative
Bataille Case Answers › Impact Defense › 2NC – Restricted Economy Defense
Ascheim Et al, Kathryn Ascheim, Rhonda Garelick and Jean-Joseph Goux, 1990, Ascheim did her graduate work in the department of Molecular Biophysics and Biochemistry at Yale University , Garelick Garelick is the D.E. Hughes Jr. Distinguished Chair for English at SMU and writes in modernist and contemporary literature, Goux was a professor at Rice University teaching philosophy, economy, psychanalysis, “General Economics and Postmodern Capitalism”, Yale University Press, //VDR
Where do we situate Bataille's claim? What happens to the demand of the sacred in capitalist society? How do we reconcile the affirmation that capitalism represents an unprecedented break with all archaic (precapitalist) forms of expenditure and the postulate of the necessary universality of spending as pure loss? This is the difficulty. Bataille wants to maintain as a general anthropological principle the necessity of unproductive expenditure while simultaneously upholding the historic singularity of capitalism with regard to this expenditure. Bourgeois society corresponds to a "general atrophy of former sumptuary processes" (41). An anomaly whereby loss is not absent (which would contradicthe general principle) but virtually unreadable: "Today, the great and free social forms of unproductive expenditure have disappeared. Nevertheless, we should not conclude from this that the very principle of expenditure is no longer situated at the end of economic activity" (37). So what happens to ostentatious expenditure in capitalism? And can we really believe, furthermore, that the even more radical desacralization effected by communism could become a libertarian affirmation of sovereignty-the feast of self-consciousness, without divinities and myths? Everything suggests that Bataille was unable to articulate the mystical tension toward sovereign self-consciousness "without form and mode," "pure expenditure" (224) with a utopia of social life that would make it possible, nor to explain in a developed capitalist society the consumption of the surplus beyond its reinvestment in production. Now it is quite clear that today's capitalism has come a long way from the Calvinist ethic that presided at its beginning. The values of thrift, sobriety and asceticism no longer have the place that they held when Balzac could caricature the dominant bourgeois mentality with the characters of pere Grandet or the usurer Gobseck. It is doubtful that the spirit of capitalism, which according to Weber is 210 Yale French Studies expressed with an almost classical purity in Benjamin Franklin's principles ("he who kills a five shilling coin assassinates all that it could have produced: entire stacks of sterling pounds") [cited by Bataille, 163], could today be considered the spirit of the times. Undoubtedly, the pace at which all residual sacred elements inherited from feudalism are eliminated has quickened. But hasn't contemporary society undergone a transformation of the ethic of consumption, desire, and pleasure that renders the classical (Weberian) analyses of the spirit of capitalism (to which Bataille subscribes) inadequate? If the great opposition between the sacred and the profane no longer structures social life, if communal, sacrificial, and glorious expenditure has been replaced by private expenditure, it is no less true that advanced capitalism seems to exceed the principle of restricted economy and utility that presided at its beginning. No society has "wasted" as much as contemporary capitalism. What is the form of this waste, of this excess? These questions strike directly at the historical situation and philosophical signification of Bataille's thought. Is it not clear that his passion for the "notion of expenditure,"-which, beginning in 1933, is the matrix of all his economic reflections to come-emerge precisely at a turning point in the history of capitalism, in the 1920s and 1930s, which also saw the appearance of Lukacs and Heidegger?2 Can we not perceive within the principles of secularization and restricted economics that were the strength of early capitalism an internal conflicthat undermines them, and puts capitalism in contradiction with itself?
2023
DDI
Negative
Bataille Case Answers › Impact Defense › 1NC – Restricted Economy Defense
Mayfair Mei-hui Yang, 10/2000, Professor of Anthropology at the University of California Santa Barbara, “Putting Global Capitalism in Its Place: Economic Hybridity, Bataille, and Ritual Expenditure,” University of Chicago Journals, //VDR
Scholars such as Jean-Joseph Goux (1998) have pointed to a troubling overlap between Bataille’s views on luxury and sacrificial expenditure and postmodern consumer capitalism. Consumer capitalism is also predicated on massive consumption and waste rather than on the thrift, asceticism, and accumulation against which Bataille directed his theory of expenditure. It exhibits pot-latch features in the tendency for businesses to give goods away in the hope that “supply creates its own demand”; it collapses the distinction between luxury and useful goods and between need and desire (Goux1998).Unlike modernist capitalism, postmodern consumer capitalism is driven by consumption rather than pro-duction. Thus, Bataille’s vision of the ritual destruction of wealth as defying the principles of accumulative and productive capitalism does not address this different phase of consumer capitalism, whose contours have only become clear since his death in 1962.
It seems to me that despite their overt similarities, the principles of ritual consumption and those of con-sumer capitalism are basically incompatible. If Bataille had addressed our consumer society today, he would have said that this sort of consumption is still in the service of production and productive accumulation, since every act of consumption in the world of leisure, entertainment, media, fashion, and home de ́ cor merely feeds back into the growth of the economy rather than leading to the finality and loss of truly nonproductive expenditure. Even much of modern warfare is no longer truly destructive but tied into the furthering of mili-tary-industrial production. Nor, despite its economic excesses, does our consumer culture today challenge the basic economic logic of rational private accumu-lation as a self-depleting archaic sacrificial economydoes.15Furthermore, capitalist consumption is very much an individual consumption rather than one in-volving the whole community or social order.