2023
DDI
Disadvantage
Ptx cuts › Tbc › Random
Hulse 6/8 [Carle, Capitol Hill reporter for the New York Times, “House Mutiny Leaves McCarthy Facing Tough Choices,” The New York Times, 6-8-23, https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/08/us/politics/kevin-mccarthy-house-republicans-mutiny.html]
“We’re going to force him into a monogamous relationship with one or the other,” Representative Matt Gaetz of Florida, one of the 11 Republicans who tied up the floor this week, said of Mr. McCarthy on the podcast hosted by Stephen K. Bannon.
On Thursday, Mr. Gaetz said some of the insurgents had engaged in “encouraging” talks with Representative Steve Scalise of Louisiana, the majority leader, about resolving the dispute, mainly centered on “how we’re going to think about the appropriations process.”
2023
DDI
Disadvantage
Ptx cuts › Tbc › Thx margaret
https://www.thefiscaltimes.com/newsletter/20230725-Conservatives-Look-Squeeze-McCarthy-Spending
House Conservatives Look to Squeeze McCarthy on Spending, Again
Members of the House Freedom Caucus warned Tuesday that they are not yet prepared to back a pair of Republican spending bills set to come to the floor this week. As GOP leaders look to start passing the 12 annual spending bills, the far-right group has been pressing Speaker Kevin McCarthy and their fellow Republicans for additional spending cuts, even if a showdown over spending levels results in a government shutdown this fall.
2023
DDI
Disadvantage
Politics DA—TT Lab › ! › Readiness—Subs—2NC
Sittlow 19 [Brian, naval officer, specializing in submarines, and a military fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations (CFR), “Funding the Nuclear Triad to Deter Great Power Adversaries,” Council on Foreign Relations, 10-17-2019, https://www.cfr.org/blog/funding-nuclear-triad-deter-great-power-adversaries]
In January 2019, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) released a report on the projected cost of U.S. strategic forces from 2019 to 2028 and forecasted a price tag of $494 billion. That is half a trillion dollars over ten years to maintain and modernize portions of the U.S. strategic deterrent apparatus—a staggering figure for most people to comprehend. However, the United States should continue to fund the maintenance and modernization of its strategic forces, particularly because China and Russia continue to develop and improve their own strategic forces. For the United States, the expense is a necessary investment that will preserve global stability and help deter potential great power adversaries in the future.
The world has relied on nuclear deterrence to avoid major power war for three-quarters of a century. This protection should not be taken for granted. Furthermore, the top priority of the U.S. National Defense Strategy is to be ready for great power competition with China and Russia. This is where U.S. funding and readiness efforts should be focused, and deterrence should be the centerpiece of this strategy.
2023
DDI
Disadvantage
Politics DA—TT Lab › ! › Readiness – 2NC
Coudriet 5/31 [Caroline, staff at Roll Call, “Hawks worry about defense caps in debt limit deal,” Roll Call, 5/31/23, https://rollcall.com/2023/05/31/hawks-worry-about-defense-caps-in-debt-limit-deal/]
A debt limit compromise that would cap defense spending for the next two years is aggravating congressional defense hawks who want the Pentagon to get a significant funding boost.
Many Republicans in particular have spent months arguing that the Biden administration’s proposed $842 billion for the Defense Department in fiscal 2024 shortchanges the Pentagon at a time of widespread concern about China’s military ambitions.
2023
DDI
Disadvantage
Politics DA—TT Lab › ! › Readiness – 2NC
Carberry 5/16 [Sean, Managing Editor at National Defense, “Debt Ceiling Fight Puts Defense Budget in Limbo,” 5/16/23, https://www.nationaldefensemagazine.org/articles/2023/5/16/budget-matters-debt-ceiling-fight-puts-defense-budget-in-limbo
This time of year, Congress is usually busy marking up the annual National Defense Authorization Act and mapping out the defense budget for the next fiscal year. However, just as the House Armed Services Committee was to begin work on the 2024 NDAA, Chairman Rep. Mike Rogers, R-Ala., pumped the brakes.
The entirety of his May 9 statement on the pause read:
2023
DDI
Disadvantage
Politics DA—TT Lab › I/L › AT: Dayen bad/old
Brooks & Folley, 7/24 [Emily Brooks, reporter for The Hill, Aris Folley, reporter for the Hill, ‘House, Senate divides over funding grow as time left for spending bill shrinks’, The Hill, https://thehill.com/business/appropriations/4110810-house-senate-divides-over-funding-grow-as-time-left-for-spending-bills-shrinks/ //alundy]
Lawmakers are sprinting to finish as much work as possible on a dozen appropriations bills before a long August recess begins at the end of the week.
But major divides between the House and Senate on spending levels — as well as pressure from conservatives on Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) — forecast messy spending battles when lawmakers return.
2023
DDI
Disadvantage
Politics DA—TT Lab › I/L › Budget Deadline
Brooks & Folley, 7/24 [Emily Brooks, reporter for The Hill, Aris Folley, reporter for the Hill, ‘House, Senate divides over funding grow as time left for spending bill shrinks’, The Hill, https://thehill.com/business/appropriations/4110810-house-senate-divides-over-funding-grow-as-time-left-for-spending-bills-shrinks/ //alundy]
Lawmakers are sprinting to finish as much work as possible on a dozen appropriations bills before a long August recess begins at the end of the week.
But major divides between the House and Senate on spending levels — as well as pressure from conservatives on Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) — forecast messy spending battles when lawmakers return.
2023
DDI
Disadvantage
Politics DA—TT Lab › I/L › McCarthy – 2NC
Hulse 6/8 [Carle, Capitol Hill reporter for the New York Times, “House Mutiny Leaves McCarthy Facing Tough Choices,” The New York Times, 6-8-23, https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/08/us/politics/kevin-mccarthy-house-republicans-mutiny.html]
With his right flank in open revolt and keeping a stranglehold on the House floor, Speaker Kevin McCarthy faces two unappealing choices for how to govern.
He can cater to the demands of hard-right members of his conference, pushing through bills that will face a bipartisan legislative buzz saw in the Senate. Or he can steer around them on crucial issues, teaming up with Democrats to pass spending bills and other vital measures, and contend with constant threats to his job from his own party — if not outright removal.
2023
DDI
Disadvantage
Politics DA—TT Lab › Links › Spending
Elkind, 7/10 [Elizabeth, reporter for Fox News, ‘Conservatives warn McCarthy they’ll vote against spending bills that don’t cut ‘bloated’ government’, Fox News, https://www.yahoo.com/lifestyle/conservatives-warn-mccarthy-ll-vote-210018337.html //alundy]
They also said they would not support the idea of using rescinded unspent COVID-19 funding to exceed fiscal year 2022 levels.
"Rescissions are useful in reducing spending and we encourage their use, but we cannot support using them to shift funding to the very bureaucrats implementing the Biden agenda at roughly current levels of spending, thereby enshrining and continuing Democrats’ reckless inflationary spending," they wrote.
2023
DDI
Disadvantage
Politics DA—TT Lab › Links › FC demands
Elliot, 23 [Philip, correspondent for TIME, where he covers politics, 6-8-2023, ‘The Freedom Caucus Has Taken the House Hostage. Their Demand? Kevin McCarthy’s Spine’, TIME, https://time.com/6285840/house-freedom-caucus-hostage-kevin-mccarthy/ //alundy]
WASHINGTON — A group of 21 House conservatives sent Speaker Kevin McCarthy a letter Monday threatening to vote against government funding legislation unless it meets a series of demands.
The ultimatum from the 21 Republicans, part of an escalating battle over a must-pass bill, highlights the challenges McCarthy, R-Calif., will face in getting government funding legislation through the GOP-led House, particularly a measure that can pass the Democratic-controlled Senate and get President Joe Biden’s signature to become law.
2023
DDI
Disadvantage
Politics DA—TT Lab › Links › Theater
Elliot, 23 [Philip, correspondent for TIME, where he covers politics, 6-8-2023, ‘The Freedom Caucus Has Taken the House Hostage. Their Demand? Kevin McCarthy’s Spine’, TIME, https://time.com/6285840/house-freedom-caucus-hostage-kevin-mccarthy/ //alundy]
This is the week House Speaker Kevin McCarthy realized he was pinned down. A handful of his fellow Republicans had effectively taken the House floor hostage and were not quite ready to have a real negotiation. They wanted time to air their grievances. Rather than continue an active standoff for a third day or a worse outcome, the still-learning-the-job Speaker decided to pack it in for now, regroup in private over the now-unexpectedly-long weekend, and try to find detente with the far-right faction of his party before the lawmakers return next week.
“There’s a little chaos going on,” McCarthy acknowledged to reporters Wednesday evening, wrapping up a second day of stalemate. The whispers of a coming vote to boot the Speaker were spreading beyond the dozen or so Republicans who had been talking about it for weeks, the same group who were now openly defying McCarthy by holding up—and this is where it becomes Very Washington—legislation that they themselves actually support.
2023
DDI
Disadvantage
Politics DA—TT Lab › UQ › PC
Lillis, 23 [Mike, senior staff writer covering congress for The Hill, 6-28-2023, ‘McCarthy feels the heat as frustrated conservatives grow more aggressive’, The Hill, https://thehill.com/homenews/house/4070506-mccarthy-feels-the-heat-as-frustrated-conservatives-grow-more-aggressive/ //alundy]
In recent weeks, the Speaker has catered to his right flank by targeting next year’s spending at levels below those outlined in the bipartisan debt limit deal. He’s endorsed a resolution to censure Rep. Adam Schiff (D-Calif.) after an initial vote splintered the GOP. He’s swallowed a vote to impeach President Biden — even if only to punt the issue to committee.
He’s championed resolutions to expunge the two impeachments of former President Trump. And most recently, he’s adopted a harder line on the ouster of cabinet officials, like Garland.
2023
DDI
Disadvantage
Politics DA—TT Lab › UQ › Republican unity
Fox, 6/30 [Lauren, CNN congressional correspondent, 6-30-2023, ‘Republicans race to build for spending bills as divisions loom large’, CNN, https://www.cnn.com/2023/06/30/politics/republican-appropriations-fight/index.html //alundy]
Already, Republicans in the House have sought to slash federal spending back to fiscal year 2022 levels and, in some parts of the budget, even lower levels, marking up their bills in committee at billions less than what was agreed to in the debt ceiling package with the White House. It’s caused bipartisan consternation in the Senate and puts the two chambers on a collision course in the fall. The massive disparity in topline spending numbers between the House and Senate may grow as some members of the House Freedom Caucus have argued the numbers should be even lower than they are.
“You got a small group of people that are driving the numbers that we agreed to earlier, lower and lower,” GOP Rep. Steve Womack of Arkansas said. “My guess is that even with the numbers we have begun marking our bills to will not be sufficient. … We are trying to manage through all the noise, all the discussion, all of the division.”
2023
DDI
Disadvantage
Politics DA—TT Lab › UQ › Republican unity
Fox, 6/30 [Lauren, CNN congressional correspondent, 6-30-2023, ‘Republicans race to build for spending bills as divisions loom large’, CNN, https://www.cnn.com/2023/06/30/politics/republican-appropriations-fight/index.html //alundy]
House Republicans are furiously working through the recess to shore up support on a series of spending bills leaders hope to put on the floor as soon as July, another critical test for Speaker Kevin McCarthy’s struggle to hold onto his right flank and make good on a series of promises he made to clinch the gavel in January.
The House Appropriations Committee passed six spending bills ahead of the July Fourth recess, but negotiations are continuing over recess on whether those bills – and the six still working their way through committee – might need further changes to win support on the House floor. The speaker can only afford to lose a handful of members. It’s a massive undertaking and once again puts a spotlight on whether the Republican majority in the House can stay unified after bitter divisions stalled the chamber in June.
2023
DDI
Disadvantage
Politics DA—TT Lab › UQ › Republican unity
Katz, 7/20 [Eric, senior correspondant at the Government Executive specializing in federal agency operations, 7-20-2023, ‘The Senate is on a bipartisan glidepath toward avoiding a shutdown, Schumer says’, Government Executive, https://www.govexec.com/management/2023/07/senate-bipartisan-glidepath-toward-avoiding-shutdown-schumer-says/388700/ //alundy]
The Senate continues to advance spending bills without controversy and with bipartisan support, offering hope that lawmakers will avoid a lapse in appropriations this fall.
The Senate Appropriations Committee approved three more fiscal 2024 funding measures on Thursday, two of which—those funding the departments of Transportation and Housing and Urban Development, as well as the Energy Department—received unanimous, 29-0 votes. The third, which would set spending levels for the State Department and the U.S. Agency for International Development, received just two dissenting votes.
2023
DDI
Disadvantage
Politics DA—TT Lab › UQ › Debt ceiling
Elliot, 23 [Philip, correspondent for TIME, where he covers politics, 6-8-2023, ‘The Freedom Caucus Has Taken the House Hostage. Their Demand? Kevin McCarthy’s Spine’, TIME, https://time.com/6285840/house-freedom-caucus-hostage-kevin-mccarthy/ //alundy]
For the moment, McCarthy has dodged a noose of his own knitting. One of the conditions he agreed to way back in January in order to secure enough votes to become Speaker—on the 15th ballot, no less—was an agreement that any one of his members could, at any time, demand a vote of no confidence. That Motion-to-Vacate proffer left McCarthy starting his new gig as one of the weakest Speakers in decades, and his right flank knew it. They also allegedly secured assurances that any deal on the debt ceiling would include cuts; they now say they were betrayed in the backroom deal McCarthy quarterbacked because the increase in the nation’s borrowing cap didn’t come with sufficiently corresponding spending cuts.
Until Tuesday, the grumblings from members of the ultraconservative Freedom Caucus were just that: background noise from rabble rousers who know just enough to gum up the system but aren’t usually ones to bring about a total meltdown. But when it came time for a procedural vote Tuesday, it quickly became clear that Republicans didn’t have the votes. Eleven Republicans joined with unified Democrats to tank the rules packages that needed to pass in order to set up the schedule for debate on the pro-gas stoves and anti-federal regs measures, and the betrayal left the GOP Leadership team shocked and shaken. (House Majority Leader Steve Scalise also voted against the package so that, under the standing House rules, he could bring it back to the floor at another time.)
2023
DDI
Disadvantage
Politics DA—TT Lab › UQ › McCarthy holding on
Lillis, 23 [Mike, senior staff writer covering congress for The Hill, 6-28-2023, ‘McCarthy feels the heat as frustrated conservatives grow more aggressive’, The Hill, https://thehill.com/homenews/house/4070506-mccarthy-feels-the-heat-as-frustrated-conservatives-grow-more-aggressive/ //alundy]
Six months into the new Congress, Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) is increasingly bending to the demands of the conservative fringe of his GOP conference, a dynamic highlighted this week by his surprise threat to impeach U.S. Attorney General Merrick Garland.
The Speaker has, to an extent, been successful in disarming his conservative detractors through the first half of the year, winning their support in January’s race for the gavel and sidelining them more recently in adopting must-pass legislation to raise the debt ceiling.
2023
DDI
Disadvantage
Politics DA—TT Lab › UQ › McCarthy holding on
Fox, 6/30 [Lauren, CNN congressional correspondent, 6-30-2023, ‘Republicans race to build for spending bills as divisions loom large’, CNN, https://www.cnn.com/2023/06/30/politics/republican-appropriations-fight/index.html //alundy]
But much has changed since the leaders ran that playbook for the debt ceiling. In the week after the House passed their bipartisan debt ceiling deal, the House Freedom Caucus rebelled, refusing to back a procedural step to bring a group of GOP messaging bills to the floor. It took a week for leaders to break the stalemate and even since, hardliners have vowed to deploy the tactic again if the speaker crosses them.
Ultimately, some members acknowledge they’ll have to eventually compromise with the Senate or risk a government shutdown.
2023
DDI
Disadvantage
Politics DA—TT Lab › UQ › McCarthy holding on
Elliot, 23 [Philip, correspondent for TIME, where he covers politics, 6-8-2023, ‘The Freedom Caucus Has Taken the House Hostage. Their Demand? Kevin McCarthy’s Spine’, TIME, https://time.com/6285840/house-freedom-caucus-hostage-kevin-mccarthy/ //alundy]
After an hour-long meeting Tuesday, it became clear that the far-right flank was doing more than blowing off some steam. As Wednesday came and went without any action on the floor, McCarthy realized he was boxed in, and the failure of those messaging bills were the least of his worries. Although the rebels are stopping short of kicking McCarthy to the curb, they are putting him on notice. “He’s got to be forced into monogamy with us as his coalition partner or [Democratic Leader] Hakeem [Jeffries],” said Rep. Matt Gaetz of Florida. “And if Hakeem is his coalition partner, then we’re not going to play out the failure theater on stuff like we saw put on the floor this week.”
The malcontents have said they’re well past the point of wrangling specific promises out of McCarthy. They believed they had sufficient guarantees back in January when they gave McCarthy the job he’s been chasing since his first days in Washington. Words can be broken, and the hard-right lawmakers now need to feel they have a more sincere partnership with the Speaker—and his fear. The biggest obstacle to the firebrands is a serious one, though: no one is waiting in the wings to step up should McCarthy appear mortally wounded.
2023
DDI
Disadvantage
Politics DA—TT Lab › UQ › McCarthy holding on
Mondeaux & Gorman, 7/26 [Cami Mondeaux, congressional reporter at the Washington Examiner; Reese Gorman, congressional reporter at the Washington Examiner; 7-26-2023, ‘No spending deal made between GOP leadership and Freedom Caucus, McCarthy says’, Washington examiner, https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/house/no-spending-deal-made-between-gop-leadership-freedom-caucus //alundy]
Just minutes before the House reconvened to vote on the rule, Rep. Ralph Norman (R-SC) announced a deal had been struck between HFC members and GOP leaders on the military spending bill, paving the way for its passage later this week.
“I previously was opposed to it, but they worked the things out with the top number, so we’re voting for the rule,” Norman told reporters ahead of the vote.