Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › I/L › I/L- BCI Unreliable

Business Confidence is wrong

Irwin 17 Neil Irwin, 7-4-2017, "Confidence Boomed After the Election. The Economy Hasn’t. (Published 2017)," No Publication, https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/04/upshot/confidence-boomed-after-the-election-the-economy-hasnt.html?mcubz=3&_r=0&mtrref=undefined

After Donald J. Trump won the presidential election, Americans’ optimism about the economic future soared. But midway through the year, that optimism has not translated into concrete economic gains. This seeming contradiction exposes a reality about the role of psychology in economics — or more specifically, how psychology is connected only loosely to actual growth. It will take more than feelings to fix the sluggishness that has been evident in the United States and other major economies for years. Confidence isn’t some magic elixir for the economy: Businesses will hire and invest only when they see concrete evidence of demand for their products, and consumers intensify their spending only when their incomes justify it. The sharp rise in economic optimism after the election came through no matter how the question was asked or who answered, whether the survey was intended to capture consumer confidence or consumer comfort or consumer sentiment. It was true in surveys of small-business owners and of C.E.O.s of some of the biggest companies in the world. And the rise during the winter months in these surveys has mostly been sustained in the months since. But the economy is plodding along at the same modest rate it has for the last eight years nonetheless — at least when you look at “hard” data around economic activity instead of “soft” data like surveys, as analysts put it. President Trump said on Twitter on Sunday that the stock market was at an “all-time high” and that unemployment was at its lowest level in years, both of which are true (he added that wages would start going up, which is certainly possible). But in overall measures of economic activity, the expansion looks much as it has for years, with steady growth of around 2 percent. The Trump economy so far looks an awful lot like the Obama economy. For all of business executives’ apparent enthusiasm, the nation is adding jobs more slowly in 2017 than it did in 2016, and investment spending by businesses is growing modestly; new orders for capital goods are up only 0.7 percent so far in 2017. Consumers’ spending was 2.7 percent higher in the first four months this year than in the same period of 2016, adjusted for inflation — which is slower than the 3.2 percent year-over-year gain at the end of 2016. And while the stock market has been surging and the Federal Reserve has raised short-term interest rates, long-term Treasury bond yields remain very low, suggesting that traders do not buy the idea that growth is poised to accelerate. A falling dollar suggests currency markets see improving prospects in Europe and elsewhere. There is no sign a recession is brewing, but neither is there evidence for the kind of boom you might expect if you believe that confidence is a crucial driver of economic growth. This is less surprising when you look at the historical record of confidence surveys. When financial commentators talk about the economy, they often use the elusive concept of confidence as part of their narrative. It’s hard to describe what is happening in the global economy, with billions of people producing trillions of dollars of goods and services. Using a vague psychological concept is a tidy way of describing why things happen when the underlying drivers are uncertain. To say that “the economy is slowing down because people are less confident” sounds a lot better than “the economy is slowing down for a whole bunch of complex reasons that I’m not really sure about.” Confidence has a kind of mystical explanatory power thanks to its vagueness. But “confidence” isn’t really some psychological pixie dust that determines the economic future. Rather, it often reflects underlying fundamentals — whether consumers see job opportunities readily available, for example, and whether businesses are seeing strong advance orders. “Confidence generally goes up when we see strong income growth or big gains in household wealth,” said Karen Dynan, a senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics whose former work for the Treasury Department and Federal Reserve included forecasting consumer spending. “You’ll typically see higher consumption spending after that happens. But it’s caused by the rise in income and wealth, not the rise in confidence.” Sometimes these surveys can pick up on shifts in those fundamentals before they are evident in more concrete data points. But that doesn’t mean that they do a fantastic job on their own of predicting the economic future. Since 1999, there has been a fairly strong correlation between the Conference Board’s consumer confidence index and the growth in personal consumption expenditures over the ensuing six months, just as you might expect. (And if the past relationship holds, spending levels will accelerate.) But that chart looks about the same if you instead look at the relationship between growth over the preceding six months and the next six months. In fact, that correlation was stronger than confidence. In other words, if you had just predicted that the immediate future would be similar to the recent past, you would have done a better job projecting consumer spending during the last couple of decades than if you had relied only on a confidence survey. Confidence surveys can make economic forecasts more accurate, according to some analysis — but only in certain circumstances, and if used correctly. For example, Michelle L. Barnes and Giovanni P. Olivei of the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston found that forecasts were more accurate when they built in data from the Reuters/University of Michigan survey (now the Bloomberg/Michigan survey) that is also used to calculate consumer sentiment. And Stéphane Dées and Pedro Soares Brinca of the European Central Bank found that confidence surveys can provide information about the future that economic fundamentals do not at economic turning points, and may be a factor in how crises spread between countries. Those results suggest that why confidence shifts matters a great deal. At certain moments, ordinary consumers and businesses may instantly pick up on shifting economic fundamentals that would take time to show up in the official economic data. For example, from July through November of 2007, consumer sentiment and confidence numbers plummeted, even as measures of consumer spending and employment were relatively steady. Credit was tightening and the housing crisis was worsening, but consumers seemed to pick up that the economy was on the verge of a recession (which began in December 2007) before it was at all clear from official data. For every example like that, though, you can also find the reverse. Those same measures of confidence fell precipitously in September 2005, in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina. That disaster ultimately had no major impact on the overall economy. When confidence rises or falls suddenly, the move will predict a shift in economic performance only if something happens to the fundamentals to justify it. The early warning that confidence surveys offered on the 2008 recession was useful, but the downturn happened not because consumer confidence fell, but because the underlying forces around housing and credit that it reflected were so damaging. The post-Katrina drop wasn’t matched by any major deterioration in economic fundamentals, so it was a mere historical blip. One clue as to which precedent applies here is in the partisan breakdown in sentiment surveys. Instead of an across-the-board improvement in confidence, it appears that Republicans became sharply more confident while Democrats became somewhat less so. That implies that the postelection confidence surge was about conservatives feeling more giddy about their side winning than about the broad mass of Americans picking up on improving economic fundamentals not yet evident in the data. The Trump administration’s promises of major tax cuts, infrastructure spending and pro-growth regulatory policy have been slow in coming, but could conceivably change that over time. But history shows that confidence alone won’t cut it.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › I/L › I/L- BCI Unreliable

BCI is unreliable

Buchanan 18 Neil H. Buchanan, 1-12-2018, "GOP Myth Number 1: Regulations Are Stifling Our Economy," Newsweek, https://www.newsweek.com/gop-myth-number-one-regulations-are-stifling-our-economy-779729

In my column last week, I said all that I want to say about the silly political conclusions in that Times piece and the Republicans' hypocritical claims about "stability" as a driver of business confidence. What I want to add here is a refutation of the idea that regulation is bad for the economy and that deregulation is therefore good. As I noted above, however, The Times article already does that to a large degree. "There is little historical evidence tying regulation levels to growth." "The evidence is weak that regulation actually reduces economic activity or that deregulation stimulates it." In each case, however, we are then treated to a "but." Immediately following that last quoted disclaimer, for example, we get this: "But business executives are largely convinced that the cost of complying with rules diverts money that could be invested elsewhere." The authors then list all of the reasons that the economy is doing well, none of which have anything to do with deregulation. "But business executives say the Trump administration deserves credit." Get it? It is not that there is any evidence of a real effect, but business types just feel it But surely that must matter, right? The great liberal economist John Maynard Keynes famously said that the "animal spirits" of the captains of industry were a better explanation of swings in business investment than anything else. And The Times thus quotes a liberal economist, Jared Bernstein, who first notes that there is no evidence that deregulation causes growth (which should be the headline, but I digress) but then says this: "What does matter is this idea that confidence matters. If their expectations about the future are positive, then it does make a difference." Has it made a difference? Not at all. Again, the article itself notes that all of the positive economic developments that we can see in the U.S. (developments which, unfortunately, still stubbornly do not include adequate increases in incomes for the non-rich) are extensions of trends that began in the Obama era and are mirrored in Europe and elsewhere. There is no Trump effect in Denmark or Germany. But what if it were true that these newly deregulated business owners and executives would respond to their newfound liberty by expanding their businesses? What if there really were a Deregulation Fairy who granted out wishes for higher GDP if only we agreed to let businesses be giddy about a hyper-conservative deregulatory agenda? Would that not be wonderful? Actually, no. The regulations that Trump is rolling back include things like canceling "several rules approved at the end of the President Barack Obama's term, including a regulation on limiting mining debris in streams, a requirement that broadband providers obtain permission from customers to collect and use online information, and a ban on plastic bottles in national parks." This reminds us that "deregulation" can be merely a euphemism for "making the world dirtier and more dangerous." Again, the article itself tells us as much: "[H]home builders have benefited from the killing of regulations written by the Obama administration, including a rule that broadened the definition of wetlands, which could have restricted home building in certain areas. The National Labor Relations Board also reversed a decision that made builders more responsible for the working conditions of their contractors' employees." So you liked it when Houston flooded due to excessive development, heedless of the effects of overbuilding? You thought it would be great if employers could evade worker safety regulations by turning their employees into independent contractors? Then the Deregulation Fairy is your gal. In the end, even the best version of the pro-deregulation story says that we can trade off our safety and health (and privacy) for an increase in measured GDP. But that merely reminds us how woefully narrow the definition of GDP is. There are intelligent methods to measure the usefulness of regulations and to reject the ones that are a net burden on society. In fact, we have used those methods for years, including under Obama. Trump is getting rid of all that, because Republicans know in their DNA that deregulation is good. Republicans and their business backers want everyone to forget about the consequences of giving them carte blanche with our lives. Just think of the jobs and growth -- which, according to the evidence, are not coming. But even if they do, the trade-offs are not worth it.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › I/L › I/L- BCI Unreliable

Business Confidence is meaningless- other economic indicators prove more reliable

Bagrie 18 Cameron Bagrie, 08-09-2018, "Business confidence is a hopeless indicator. But that doesn’t mean the economy isn’t in trouble," Spinoff, https://thespinoff.co.nz/business/09-08-2018/business-confidence-is-bullshit-but-that-doesnt-mean-the-economy-isnt-in-trouble

Business confidence has fallen off a cliff. Economist Cameron Bagrie says it’s meaningless, but other bad indicators can’t be ignored. The economy is headed for recession if you believe the readings from business confidence. Thankfully we can largely ignore business confidence readings. We can’t ignore other survey measures though that are saying growth has slowed and the official statistics are showing the same. The last three quarterly GDP prints have been 0.6, 0.6 and 0.5% and we only have data up to March 2018. That’s annualised growth in the low 2’s and a dip below 2% now looks likely. We have the potential for a growth pothole. That is becoming a concern as the wheels of the economy need to be turning and tax revenue coming in the door for social agenda demands to be met. A whopping net 45% of firms are pessimistic about the general economy according to the ANZ Business Outlook survey. That’s a level last seen around the global financial crisis. Of course, no one really believes things are that bad. We can’t blame the global scene as other countries would be seeing massive falls in confidence too if that was a key factor. Other countries are not. The New Zealand Institute of Economic Research (NZIER) is showing weak readings for business confidence within their Quarterly Survey of Business Opinion (QSBO) too. The good news is that business confidence is hopeless as an economic indicator. The correlation with economic growth is poor and I largely ignore business confidence readings. Changes in direction can provide some insightful information – whether things are picking up or slowing down, but not the levels. Businesses tend to be more upbeat regarding general confidence about the economy under a blue flag as opposed to a red one. Business confidence averaged minus 18 between 2000 and 2007. The economy (measured by real gross domestic product) grew on average by more than 3.5% per year. Yep, confidence was negative, but growth was positive. So, we ignore business confidence as an economic indicator. This is nothing new. It’s surprising headline business confidence figures receive so much attention. Commentators make the constant mistake of saying the ANZ survey is a business confidence survey. The same applies to the NZIER’s QSBO. They are surveys of business views across an array of key indicators including prospects for growth, hiring, whether firms are planning to invest and experiences with inflation / costs. These indicators matter. Business confidence is one question. The so-called “soft” or “perception” indicators are the hard data of tomorrow. They are estimates and view based but you can’t ignore them. They are well correlated with growth. In a perfect world we’d have timely “hard” official data and statistics. We don’t. Official data comes with a lag. So, we need to rely on sentiment-based indicators if we want timely readings on the economy and a guide as to the year ahead. The likes of the ANZ survey are showing a sombre mood when it comes to indicators that matter. The ANZ survey asks key questions about activity, employment, investment and profitability. When these indicators head to zero, which they have done now, growth can do the same. Those indicators were weak in 2000 during the so-called winter of discontent – and growth slowed to 0.9% year on year. Growth did rebound. But back then the economy was early in the economic expansion. The economy is late in the business cycle this time around. The economy has tended to go through a ten-year cycle, so businesses are naturally looking more nervously over their shoulders at present. The economy is going through substantial economic change too and businesses are wary. There is little argument over the need to change the economy. However, there are serious questions about the actual economic plan and what the new economy looks like. That is a key issue that needs addressed. Some of the weakness in survey measures could be put down to the way survey questions are phrased. Firms are asked their view and given three options; will conditions improve, stay the same, or worsen. For a lot of firms’ things are damned good. It’s telling that finding skilled staff is the biggest problem firms are facing. Businesses are facing capacity constraints. So, zero readings may reflect a levelling out at a high base. I also pay close attention to the gap between headline business confidence and what firms’ views are on prospects for their own business. This is a proxy for uncertainty and does influence the investment cycle. Firms tend to invest less when uncertainty is high. That uncertainty gap is wide at present and investment intentions are flat. A common misperception towards various confidence surveys is that they reflect the (biased) views of a narrow bunch of corporate CEOs. This is not the case. More than half of the respondents to the ANZ’s survey comes from firms who employ less than 20 employees. The survey is not weighted by firm size, so the voice of the small firms carries equal importance to large businesses. So it’s a puzzle why some think the negative survey responses are just the biased views of a few CEOs.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › I/L › I/L- Econ Resilient

US econ is resilient- COVID and 2009 prove

Palha 17 Sol Palha, 8-23-2017, "Is A Spectacular Stock Market Crash Just Around the Corner? ," HuffPost,

The stock market crash story is getting boring and annoying to a large degree. Since 2009, there has been a constant drumbeat of the market is going to crash stories. In 2009, many experts felt that the market had rallied too strongly and that it needed to pull back sharply before moving higher up. They were calling for 15%-20% correction. Ten years later and most of them are still waiting for this so-called crash. A stock market crash is a possibility but the possibility is not the same thing as certainty, and this is what seems to elude most of the naysayers. One day they will get it right as even a broken clock is correct twice a day. In the interim waiting for this stock market crash has cost these experts a fortune, both in lost capital gains and actual booked losses if they shorted this market. It’s 2017, and the markets are overbought, and we agree that they need to let out some steam, but as for a crash that will only occur when sentiment turns bullish. The crowd has not embraced this market and until they do corrections but not crashes is what we should expect. In fact, we penned an article titled “Dow Could Trade to 30K But not before This Happens”, where we discussed the possibility of the Dow trading to 30k before it crashes. The one factor that could alter this outlook would be for the masses to turn bullish suddenly. This market will experience a spectacular crash one day; nothing can trend upwards forever and eventually the market has to revert to the mean. Markets never crash on a sour note; the crowd is chanting in joy when the markets suddenly change direction. A simple look at previous bubbles will prove this; the housing bubble, for example, did not end on a note of fear; the crowd was ecstatic. Even the Tulip bubble that lasted from 1634-1637 ended on a note of extreme joy. Jim Rogers states that the next crash will be the worst one we have seen in our lifetimes. We’ve had financial problems in America — let’s use America — every four to seven years, since the beginning of the republic. Well, it’s been over eight since the last one. This is the longest or second-longest in recorded history, so it’s coming. And the next time it comes — you know, in 2008, we had a problem because of debt. Henry, the debt now, that debt is nothing compared to what’s happening now. In 2008, the Chinese had a lot of money saved for a rainy day. It started raining. They started spending the money. Now even the Chinese have debt, and the debt is much higher. The federal reserves, the central bank in America, the balance sheet is up over five times since 2008. It’s going to be the worst in your lifetime — my lifetime too. Be worried Business Insider In a broad manner of speaking, he is right, but the proverbial question as always is “when”; so far the naysayers have missed the mark by 1000 miles. This entire rally has been based on the fact that the Fed artificially propped the markets by keeping rates low for an insanely long period and infusing billions of dollars into the markets. One day the pied piper is going to collect but as we have stated over and over again over the years, that until the masses embrace this market, a crash is unlikely. A strong correction is, however, a certainty; it’s just a matter of time. The market has defied every call, and even some of the most ardent of bulls are now nervous; we stated this would occur over two years ago. The Market has put in over 36 new highs this year and is living up to the new name we gave it late in 2016. Up to that point, we referred to this market as the most hated bull market of all time; after that, we started to refer to this market as the most Insane Stock Market Bull of all time. Insanity by definition has no pattern so expect this market to do things no other market has ever done before. The markets will crash one day but these so-called experts have no idea of this event will occur

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › I/L › I/L- Econ Resilient

Econ is resilient- Great Depression, World War II, COVID, Stock Market Crash, all prove

Pringle 21 Kenneth G. Pringle, 12-27-2021, "Lesson of the Century: Don’t Underestimate the Resilience of the U.S. Economy," No Publication, ]

By one measure of the U.S. economy, the Dow Jones Industrial Average, the past 100 years look like one long joyride to prosperity. Market crashes, recessions and depressions, wars, pandemics, and other economic shocks all appear as mere bumps in the road. On average, the Dow climbed 9% a year. The truth on the ground was more complex. Millions suffered during economic downturns, and a half-million died in overseas conflicts. America faced down fascism, communism, and terrorism even as fractures along political, class, race, and gender lines at times turned our streets, and seats of power, into battlegrounds. And yet, the economy and the market churned on. If there’s one lesson we’ve learned from delving into Barron’s archives in our centennial year, it is this: Don’t underestimate the resilience of the U.S. economy and stock market. We saw that theme time and again as we published a series of retrospective pieces during 2021—and the resilience is strikingly evident still. When the Covid-ravaged economy contracted in 2020, it was just the 19th time since 1920 in which real gross domestic product had declined, year over year. And nine of those years came between 1930 and 1949, a result of the Great Depression or post–World War II demobilization. Even 2020 seems like an outlier, with growth expected in 2021 and 2022, despite recent downgrades prompted by the Omicron outbreak. Big GDP jumps also were limited to the volatile ’30s and ’40s. Mostly, it has been a steady rise in GDP, from an estimated $670 billion in 1920 to a record $21.43 trillion in 2020. That’s a 30-fold increase, meaning that U.S. GDP has grown about 10 times as fast as the population, which has tripled from 106 million in 1920 to 331 million a century later. America was a smaller, poorer, and very different place 100 years ago. Most folks lived on farms, without electricity or indoor plumbing. Horses outnumbered automobiles. Business and politics were the sole province of white men. Women had the vote but were still second-class citizens. Jim Crow laws made sure that Blacks weren’t fully emancipated. The country also was in the grip of the Depression of 1920-21, the nation’s worst economic downturn to that point. It was a heck of a time for Clarence W. Barron to start a financial newsweekly. But he had seen the U.S. change from an agrarian to an industrial nation, and he felt there was no stopping the American business spirit. He was right. Entrepreneurs from Henry Ford and Thomas Edison to Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg have, to paraphrase Facebook’s founder, moved fast and broken things, turning new technologies into life-changing new industries. Our founder, Clarence Barron in 1921. National Photo Company Collection/Library of Congress They’ve also created companies that have lasted. General Electric , AT&T, Macy’s , DuPont , Sherwin-Williams, and many other of today’s household names date to the 19th century or earlier. These companies are the backbone of the economy, the force that gives it such resilience. Barron’s did have doubts from time to time. We once worried that modern leaders “seem puny figures beside the speculative kings of the last century,” but that was in 1936, and since then, plenty of worthy successors have arisen to challenge the titans of old. Here are some who helped keep the economy churning over the past 100 years. Automobiles were dangerous, open-air affairs until the late 1920s, and there weren’t many passable roads. They were novelties, playthings for the rich, and few saw that changing. Henry Ford perceived greater possibilities. He perfected mass-production techniques that let him build the Model T faster and cheaper than the handmade competition. Ford “put the motor within the reach of the ordinary wage-earning family and the cost is half that of a horse,” Barron wrote in 1924. While most Americans still depended on actual horsepower for conveyance and labor, “peak horse” had been reached. Ford’s automobiles and tractors were putting equines out to pasture. Railroads’ best days were past, too. Henry Ford, pictured with his first car and his 10 millionth. Over 15 million Model Ts were built between 1908 and 1927; by 1918, they accounted for half the cars on America's roads. Historica Graphica Collection/Heritage Images/Getty Images Road-building would catch up with car buying, culminating in the Interstate Highway System, which set loose America’s car culture—along with its suburbs, sprawl, and pollution. Ford’s company now is heading strong into the age of the electric vehicle. Yet, his legacy is complicated: He was a vocal anti-Semite who hired strikebreaking goons and saw conspiracies everywhere. “Moral grandeur,” as Barron’s wrote in 1923, doesn’t always accompany industrial genius. This magazine has rarely reviewed movies, but Fantasia— Disney ’s feature-length 1940 cartoon starring a famous mouse—caught our attention. The “greatest change in the motion picture art since the coming of sound,” Barron’s wrote, was “the new sound-production technique” in Fantasia. A major reason that the audience felt it was because “sitting directly in the pit with the orchestra” was Disney’s use of eight, state-of-the-art audio oscillators bought from a new company, Hewlett-Packard . Bill Hewlett and David Packard famously started work in a rented Palo Alto garage, now a landmark billed as the “Birthplace of ‘Silicon Valley.’ ” Oscillators were the start of a very fruitful partnership. By 1976, Hewlett-Packard was among those rare companies that “combine technological excellence, crackerjack marketing, and financial soundness,” wrote Alan Abelson, Barron’s celebrated columnist and editor. The founders stepped away from active management in the late ’70s, and some big names followed, including Carly Fiorina. She pulled off the 1999 merger with Compaq that made H-P the No. 1 PC producer—and cost her the job. Many mergers and acquisitions later, HP Inc. is the legal descendant of the Palo Alto start-up. And the work begun in that garage helped turn an analog world digital. Muriel Siebert had to announce the news herself. “First lady member of the New York Stock Exchange!” read the ad, featuring Siebert’s smiling face, which ran in Barron’s on Jan. 8, 1968, and in The Wall Street Journal four days earlier. “First lady member of the New York Stock Exchange!” read the ad, featuring Muriel Siebert, which ran in Barron’s on Jan. 8, 1968. Uncredited Siebert started as a $65-a-week equity-research trainee at Bache & Co. in the 1950s, eventually becoming the first woman to head one of the NYSE’s member firms. Siebert Financial was among the first to offer discounted trades, and was also a leader in moving to online trading. Siebert, who went on to become New York state’s first female superintendent of banks, was lionized upon her 2013 death, by which time workplaces across the country had done more to improve their record on hiring and promoting women and people of color. In finance, the capital managed by retail investors is known as dumb money. That’s opposed to the smart money of large financial institutions, whose resources and influence enable greater returns. In creating the index fund, Jack Bogle made dumb money a lot smarter. The concept is simple: Since the S&P 500 index routinely outperforms managed mutual funds, a passive fund composed of S&P 500 shares also would beat managed funds. And with no fees, to boot. “This is a new and unique concept in investing whose time has come,” Bogle told Barron’s in 1978, two years after launching the precursor to the Vanguard 500 Index fund. Indexing wouldn’t take off until the ’90s. But by 2019, index funds had surpassed actively managed funds in assets, having “trounced active funds for a decade.” Yet, passive investing brought critics, who “warn of market meltdowns,” we wrote in 2018, noting that one analyst “went so far as to call index investing ‘worse than Marxism.’ ” Bogle, who died in 2019, was clear that he didn’t want everyone indexing. But he did democratize the once-exclusive club of Wall Street. Upon his death, we wrote, “If one man can be held responsible for today’s market—for better or worse—it’s Jack Bogle.” It didn’t take long for Clarence Barron’s bet on the American business spirit to prove prescient. Just months after his magazine’s debut, on May 9, 1921, the depression ended and the Roaring ’20s began. By 1927, Barron’s circulation had reached 30,000. Barron made the connection between public information and markets. Wall Street profits on opacity; the job of the financial press is to shed light into the murk, giving “the thoughtful investor” a chance “to budge the world of wealth,” as he put it. As Barron’s embarks on its second century, the U.S. economy shows little signs of slowing. It’s impossible to minimize the pandemic’s damage, with 800,000 U.S. deaths and Omicron causing new waves of cases. Yet, the economy seems to be shrugging it off, with today’s business leaders and workers finding a way to keep things running. The economy churns on.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › I/L › I/L- Not key to Global Econ

United States is not key to the global economy- economic downturns actually strengthen neighboring nations

Molavi 11 Afshin Molavi, 07-03-2011, "US economic power is part of a healthier global order," National,

Thus, the world faces the prospect of America slipping quietly into a "lost decade" of sluggish growth - of America sneezing and wheezing and coughing, but not facing a crisis moment. What will this mean for the world? Japan's growth throughout the 1970s and 1980s bolstered many of their Asian trading partners. Japan's demand was a boon. But Japan's lost decade in the 1990s did not stop the Asian tigers from rising. In some cases, countries such as South Korea and Taiwan even benefited from the Japanese slowdown, stealing away market share in key industries. The same may happen with an American "lost decade". A World Bank report in late 2009 noted that Latin American countries - the most exposed to American contagion - did not feel severe effects from the American crisis. The same goes for other emerging markets. So, perhaps the world will shrug off a steady American economic decline over the next five years. This is partly because the global economic pie is not a fixed size. As "the rest" rise, it grows. Thus, America controlled a quarter of the world's GDP in 1970 - roughly the same as today. But the pie is much bigger. Global GDP has tripled since 1970 and Asia today accounts for a quarter of global GDP. The pie is not only larger, but it is more balanced. Will there even be a "lost decade" after all? American corporations are sitting on large piles of cash. The problems with the economy have as much (perhaps more) to do with business confidence as with fundamentals. That could change. To be sure, the world is better off when America grows and produces and innovates. But if the declinists prove correct, then the cliché of "when American sneezes" will truly be tested once and for all. Or perhaps the world will be too busy to notice: emerging markets will be growing their middle classes, oil-rich Middle East states will be bolstering ties to Asia, and Chinese investments will flow across Africa and Latin America. And that sneezing $14 trillion (Dh51.4 trillion) economy would still be the envy of most countries around the world. We can put the cliché to rest: an American sneeze might not breed a global cold after all.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › I/L › I/L- Not key to Global Econ

US is pulling back from the global economy- a recession would have much smaller global impacts than the neg predicts

Djankov 21 Simeon Djankov, 04-19-2021, "The United States has been disengaging from the global economy," PIIE, https://www.piie.com/research/piie-charts/united-states-has-been-disengaging-global-economy

The United States’ openness to the global economy can be measured by the cross-border flows of goods and services (trade); of capital (foreign direct investment and other types of financial assets); and of people (immigration).[1] By some of the most central measures, depicted in the figures below, US disengagement from globalization has been significant, particularly in comparison to the general trend in and behavior of other large high-income democracies. Former President Donald J. Trump may have pursued that decoupling with his policies discouraging offshoring of US manufacturing and imposing tariffs on imports. But the trend of US deglobalization began with US administrations well before Trump took office in 2017. The figures also illustrate that these successive US governments’ efforts to protect selected domestic workers by insulating them from the global economy have already failed—the US workforce is no better off, and in many ways worse off, than other advanced democracies, which increased their openness to the global economy at the same time: Labor force participation in general and for women in particular is lower; manufacturing jobs have declined as a share of employment at the same rate; and labor earnings as a share of GDP have followed the same path. In his newly published article “The Price of Nostalgia: America’s Self-Defeating Economic Retreat” in Foreign Affairs, the bimonthly journal published by the Council on Foreign Relations, Adam S. Posen argues that making life better for American lower-income workers depends on the United States reopening to global economic cooperation and integration. The figures below showing signs of the deteriorating US role in the world economy were adapted from research for that article. US TRADE OPENNESS HAS NOT KEPT UP WITH THE WORLD US trade openness has not kept up with the world A common way to measure a country’s openness to trade is to add imports and exports in goods and services and divide the sum by its GDP. The larger the ratio, the more the country is integrated into international trade. Once seen as a force driving increased global trade openness, the United States is now lagging behind international trade expansion, more so since 2000. Global trade—i.e., total world exports plus imports of goods and services—increased from 38.8 percent of world GDP in 1990 to 60.8 percent in 2008. The United States has not kept up with this trend, however: US trade as a share of its GDP has risen more slowly than that of other countries, from 19.8 percent in 1990 to 29.9 percent in 2008 (panel a). The gap between global and US trade as a portion of the respective GDPs thus increased from 19.0 percentage points in 1990 to 30.9 percentage points in 2008 (panel b). Global trade as a share of world GDP plunged during the global financial crisis but has recovered slowly since then. US trade as a share of its GDP also plunged but after a short rebound has continued to fall. This decline expanded the difference between global and US trade openness to 34 percentage points in 2019, the largest gap in half a century. US TRADE OPENNESS HAS DECLINED WHILE THAT OF OTHER LARGE ADVANCED ECONOMIES HAS INCREASED US trade openness has declined while that of other large advanced economies has increased When measured by imports and exports as a share of its GDP, the United States has lagged behind not only the general trend of international trade expansion but also the upward trend in the other large advanced economies. This figure illustrates that the United States is also the only major advanced economy to have widened the gap with world trade in the last five years.[2] In Germany, Canada, and lately France exports and imports as a share of their respective GDPs have been close to or have exceeded world trade as a share of global GDP. Italy’s trade share of GDP surpassed that of the world in 2017-18 but dipped slightly below it in 2019. In Australia and Japan, like the United States, trade shares have declined compared with the global trend since 1970. But unlike the United States, their gaps have narrowed in recent years. In fact, Japan has been increasing its openness since around 2012. FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT INTO THE UNITED STATES HAS STAGNATED SINCE 2000 Foreign direct investment into the United States has stagnated since 2000 Foreign direct investment (FDI) into the United States has stagnated since 2000 after rapidly expanding from 1995 to 2000. In 2019, net FDI flows into the United States were 12 percent below their level from before the global financial crisis, declining from $318 billion (2.2 percent of GDP) in 2008 to $282 billion (1.3 percent of GDP) in 2019. FDI flows into the United States briefly surged in 2015-16 but have dropped back to a smaller share of GDP since then. It is useful to break out one component of FDI in the United States, equity capital, which takes the form of a foreign acquisition of a US venture, a merger with a US firm that involves additional investment, or an investment that starts from the ground up, known as “greenfield” investment. In 2018, mergers and acquisitions and greenfield investment into the United States declined, while those into most other major FDI destinations such as the 27 EU member countries and China increased. Actual greenfield investment—foreign capital coming into the United States and establishing or expanding businesses, in the process creating jobs and setting up offices, facilities, plants, and outlets—dropped from $13 billion annually in 2000 to $4 billion annually in 2019, while the US economy and total global greenfield investments grew. US IMMIGRANT POPULATION GROWTH HAS BEEN SLOWING FOR DECADES US immigrant population growth has been slowing for decades After surging in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, immigration to the United States began to decline largely as a result of restrictive immigration laws enacted in the 1920s. The Great Depression and World War II kept immigration levels down, with the immigrant share of the US population hitting a record low in 1970. But average annual growth of the US immigrant population sharply rebounded in the 1970s, reaching a peak of 4.6 percent in the 1990s, primarily because of important shifts in US immigration laws and increased immigration mainly from Asia and Latin America. US foreign-born population growth, however, began to slow in the 2000s. Average annual growth declined to 3.2 percent in 2000-06, fell further and stabilized at around 1.6 percent in 2006-15, before dropping further to 0.9 percent in 2015-19. The declining trend in immigration started well before President Donald J. Trump took office in 2017, but his policies and statements contributed to the further recent immigration declines. Factors other than US immigration curbs, such as declining interest from potential immigrants due to rising economic opportunities and aging populations at home, may also have contributed to the downward trend. THE IMMIGRANT POPULATION IN THE US IS NOW GROWING MORE SLOWLY THAN IN MOST OTHER ADVANCED ECONOMIES The immigrant population in the US is now growing more slowly than in most other advanced economies In most advanced economies, annual immigrant population growth rates have been largely stable over the last three decades, with some occasional spikes as in the case of Germany in 2015-20 as a result of its decision to welcome migrants from North Africa and the Middle East. Growth rates in Italy’s foreign-born population bottomed out in 2010-15, following a surge in the 2000s, and rebounded in 2015-20. Compared with immediately preceding years, the immigrant population in Japan also grew at a faster rate in 2015-20. Immigrant population growth in the United States has been declining since the 2000s, however (see figure 4 above; note that US data shown in this figure do not match those in figure 4 because of differences in methodologies used in the respective sources). Compared with other major advanced economies, the United States had the lowest annual growth rate of immigrant population in 2015-20. While the growth rate of the immigrant population in the United Kingdom has also been trending down, it was still higher in 2015-20 than in the United States. THE UNITED STATES HAS BECOME A LAGGARD IN WOMEN’S LABOR FORCE PARTICIPATION The United States has become a laggard in women’s labor force participation Women’s labor force participation rate (LFPR) in the United States—the percentage of prime working age women (25-54) who are employed or actively looking for work—rose steadily in the second half of the 20th century, especially in the 1960s through the 1980s. The increase slowed in the early 1990s, followed by a decline till 2015, when the rate picked up again. In other Group of Seven (G7) industrial democracies, women’s LFPR rose steadily between 2000 and 2015. In particular, the United Kingdom surpassed the United States in the early 2000s and Japan did so in the early 2010s (see panel c). Even after prime-age women’s LFPR rose starting in 2015 to 77 percent in the US by the end of 2019, it was still substantially lower than in every G7 economy except Italy. Moreover, the COVID-19 pandemic has recently reversed these gains, making a more persistent and larger dent in US female LFPR than in other advanced economies. The gap between labor force participation of women and men has widened during the pandemic, as female LFPR was hit harder (panel c) and has recovered more slowly than male LFPR (panel b). The pattern was different in some other G7 countries. LFPRs for women rebounded and exceeded their pre-pandemic levels in the United Kingdom and Canada in the latter half of 2020. MANUFACTURING EMPLOYMENT HAS BEEN DECLINING IN ALL ADVANCED ECONOMIES FOR DECADES Manufacturing employment has been declining in all advanced economies for decades Manufacturing employment as a share of total nonfarm employment in the United States has sharply declined over the past several decades, from an annual average 20.7 percent in 1980 to 8.5 percent in 2019. Manufacturing job loss, however, is not just a US phenomenon or even a trade deficit phenomenon. In fact, manufacturing employment has steadily declined in all high-income economies, even those with strong export sectors. From 1980 to 2019, for example, the manufacturing share of total employment decreased from 24.7 to 16.2 percent in Japan, 33.9 to 18.9 percent in Germany, and 21.6 to 16.3 percent in South Korea. US loss of manufacturing jobs is commensurate with that in other advanced economies. (Even in China, industrial employment has trended down since 2012, as shown in this PIIE Chart.) Critics attribute the decline in US manufacturing jobs to globalization, citing increased imports of manufactured goods and rising competition over the last 50 years, first from Japan and Germany, then from South Korea and Mexico, and now from China. Offshoring of manufacturing plants and jobs to low-wage locations abroad is also blamed. Other factors, however, may be more influential, including increased use of labor-saving technologies and improvements in productivity, which have reduced the need for more manufacturing workers. Productivity-enhancing technologies have made it easier to produce more goods with fewer workers. Changes in consumer demand, with rich-country consumers now spending more of their incomes on services rather than on manufactured goods, have also affected manufacturing employment. See more at PIIE’s microsite on globalization. LABOR’S SHARE OF NATIONAL INCOME FELL, THEN STABILIZED AT LOWER LEVELS, IN MOST ADVANCED ECONOMIES Labor’s share of national income fell, then stabilized at lower levels, in most advanced economies Labor’s share of GDP—the amount of a country’s GDP that workers get as compensation (wages, salaries, and benefits) in exchange for their work—is an important indicator of the extent to which workers share in an economy’s output. This share began to decline in several advanced economies in the 1980s and has recently stabilized at lower levels. From 1980 to 2019, labor’s share of GDP declined by 2.7 percentage points in the United States, 5.7 percentage points in Japan, 6.7 percentage points in France, 7.2 percentage points in Italy, and 10.1 percentage points in Australia. Some countries experienced a rise in the labor share after the global financial crisis: For example, Germany’s labor share increased by 3.7 percentage points from 2008 to 2019, Canada’s by 2.4 percentage points, and France’s by 1.6 percentage points. The US labor share, on the other hand, remained relatively flat after the financial crisis, decreasing slightly by 0.7 percentage point since 2008 to reach 59.7 percent in 2019. This overall downward trend can be attributed to many factors, including technological improvements and automation, effects of international trade and offshoring, faster depreciation of fixed capital and a shift to intangible capital, and boom-bust cycles. There is accumulating evidence that the combination of weakening workers’ bargaining power, and the rise of superstar firms and increased market concentration have played an especially large role. One recent study shows that large or superstar firms that pay a larger share of revenue to capital owners and distribute as profits, but a smaller share to their workers, are dominating markets and accounting for a bigger piece of all economic activity, while smaller firms that spend more on workers and less on capital are losing market share. A declining share of labor and a parallel rising share of capital in GDP is often associated with increased economic inequality: In the United States, as argued by Jason Furman and Peter Orszag, increased concentration and reduced dynamism in the economy have contributed to rising inequality and wage stagnation. The increasing closedness of the United States has not prevented, and arguably has contributed to, this concentration, with insulation of dominant US superstar companies failing to benefit lower-income workers. NOTES 1. Starting now, the Peterson Institute for International Economics (PIIE) will continue to track the deglobalization of the US economy, updating the data and comparisons regularly at www.piie.com. Other relevant measures of US withdrawal, to be covered in future, are adherence to international laws and standards, which can be tracked by the conduct of American business and government, participation in international organizations, and openness to ideas and norms from abroad (including the domestic acceptance or resistance to foreign cultures, brands, and innovations). 2. The United Kingdom is omitted from this figure due to the one-time shock of Brexit rendering recent data incomparable.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Link › AT: Causes Inflation

Jobs Guarantee doesn’t increase inflation

Tcherneva 18 Tcherneva, Pavlina R. 2018. “Job Guarantee: Design, Jobs, and Implementation,” Working Paper 902, Levy Economics Institute, Annandale-on-Hudson, NY

No. As above, the JG is superior inflation-fighting mechanism. There are many sources of inflation and the JG is not designed to fight them all, but it does not use the unemployed to slow down economic growth and tame inflationary pressures. The JG wage is expected to raise the wage floor, i.e., establish a genuine minimum wage of $15 for the economy as a whole. Any resulting increase in prices will be a one-time increase, which does not constitute inflation. Indeed, as explained above the countercyclical mechanism of the program ensures that the program offsets inflationary/deflationary pressures. So long as the JG wage is not indexed to prices, the program will not have an internal mechanism that produces or feeds a wage-price spiral. Legislation can ensure that the JG wage is periodically evaluated and adjusted with productivity and living costs. However, these adjustments will be discretionary. Any impact on prices will also be a one-time adjustment, and not inflation (which is a continuous increase in the general price level).

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Link › No Link- Solves Unemployment

Jobs Guarantee solves unemployment issues with countercyclical policy- resolves all unemployment issues- even during economic downturns

Tcherneva 18 Tcherneva, Pavlina R. 2018. “Job Guarantee: Design, Jobs, and Implementation,” Working Paper 902, Levy Economics Institute, Annandale-on-Hudson, NY

When the economy enters a recession (on average, every seven years in the United States), firms lay off workers en masse. Government spending automatically increases, including on UI, TANF, and other anti-poverty programs. Other government programs attempt to grow the economy, such as tax or interest rate cuts, and subsidies or other incentives to private firms. While government spending always increases countercyclically in recessions, since the 1980s it has failed to produce strong job growth in recoveries. Jobless recoveries have become the norm. With the JG in place, as companies lay off workers in recessions, these same workers can transition directly to the JG. Without the JG, they face uncertain prospects of finding another job, and the meager unemployment assistance they receive ensures that they will curb their spending—they skip shopping trips, restaurant outings, or going to the movies. That ripple effect results in additional laid off workers—servers, cash register operators, movie ticket attendants, and many more. In a sense, one unemployed person throws another one out of work. The JG stops and prevents this vicious cycle. When private employment shrinks and workers are laid off, they transition into the JG. The increase in government expenditure on hiring those workers is the very stimulus the economy and the private sector need to recover from the depths of a recession. Spending patterns are much more stable when someone gets a job (as compared to UI) and the avalanche effect of layoffs is contained. As the economy begins to grow, those workers return to their old jobs or to other better-paying employment opportunities. The program shrinks as the economy expands. Thus the program is a countercyclical buffer, a complement to private sector activity. It expands in recessions and contracts in expansions, thus providing the needed countercyclical stabilization. It is superior to current stabilization methods, because it does not use the unemployed to stabilize growth and inflation, and thus drastically reduces the existing costs of unemployment (see question 15). It makes jobless recoveries a thing of the past by securing true full employment over the long run—in good times or bad.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Link › No Link- Solves Unemployment

Countercyclical policy is good for the economy- makes recessions milder, limits unemployment, and smooths business cycle fluctuations

Aster 22 Hannah Aster, 1-7-2022, "The Federal Job Guarantee: Pros, Cons, and History," Shortform Books, Excerpt: Job As a Right

Do you think having a job is a fundamental right for all people? What would the pros and cons of a federal job guarantee be? Has congress ever looked into making a program like this? Stephanie Kelton, economist and the author of The Deficit Myth, says that a federal job guarantee is crucial for establishing economic order. However, critics say that a program like this would cost too much and could lead to corruption. Continue reading to learn more about what a federal job guarantee could mean for the United States. Jobs As a Right To use the federal government’s extraordinary fiscal power to create a society that is more equitable, sustainable, and prosperous, Kelton proposes a federal job guarantee. She positions this as a crucial remaking of the economic order—having the federal government serve as an employer of last resort, guaranteeing the fundamental right to a job for anyone who wants one. As we’ve explored, the federal government can always create the dollars needed to finance the program. She writes that a federal job guarantee would reap important benefits for the economy and society as a whole. During regular slumps in the business cycle, people who would normally be laid off and remain without jobs for months or even years would instead have the option to be immediately rehired by the federal government. Participation in the program would be counter-cyclical—rising during recessions, shrinking during booms. It would also help to shore up state and local tax revenues during recessions because participants would now be earning paychecks and paying these taxes. This helps the economy avoid the typical cascading job losses that occur during a recession, when state and local governments are forced to lay off civil servants, firefighters, teachers, police officers, and other workers when tax revenues plummet. The federal jobs guarantee would benefit everyone, even those who don’t directly participate—because more jobs means more income and more consumers for businesses, which means more jobs and investment throughout the economy. The federal job guarantee would break the cycle of mass unemployment that spreads and causes business failures throughout the economy. A federal job guarantee would also improve the bargaining power of labor (because it would be easier for people in the private sector to leave bad or exploitative jobs), while setting a minimum federal standard for wages and benefits, as private-sector firms would have to compete for talent with the federal program. Perhaps best of all, the work done by participants in the program would help to address society’s most pressing needs. The federal job guarantee program could help redirect much-needed talent toward addressing shortages in nursing and eldercare; moving our energy grid toward a zero-emissions future; and repairing and modernizing the nation’s outdated infrastructure.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Link › Link Turn- JG Strengthens Econ

Low unemployment from FJG fosters a strong economy and minimizes downturns

Paul 18 MARK PAUL, WILLIAM DARITY, JR., AND DARRICK HAMILTON, 3-9-2018, "The Federal Job Guarantee," Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, Excerpts: Benefits of Permanent Full Employment

Benefits of Permanent Full Employment The benefits of permanent full employment in the U.S. economy through the creation of the NIEC would be substantial. They include, but are not limited to: The elimination of involuntary unemployment. A public option for employment means workers will no longer be forced into unemployment. The policy would eliminate cyclical and structural unemployment and provide workers with the dignity and sense of purpose that comes with employment. Furthermore, the elimination of involuntary unemployment would bypass the social and personal ills associated with unemployment, such as the erosion of skills, increased rates of physical and mental illness, suicide and attempted suicide, and failed relationships, among others.[31] A true floor in the labor market. While minimum- and living-wage laws have historically been implemented to place a floor in the labor market, they fail to provide viable pathways to employment or out of poverty for those looking for work but unable to obtain employment in the first place. The job guarantee would function as a de facto floor in the labor market, greatly increasing the bargaining position of workers throughout the economy. For private employers to attract employees, they would have to offer a job that is at least as good as the one offered by the government. The elimination of working poverty. Unemployment is one of the strongest predictors of poverty in the United States. Households whose usual breadwinners are out of work are three times more likely to be poor than working households.[32] The job guarantee would substantially reduce poverty by eliminating involuntary unemployment and setting a non-poverty wage and compensation floor in the labor market. Improving workers livelihoods as the Federal Reserve manages its dual mandate. As noted above, the Federal Reserve has a dual mandate—maximum employment and price stability. Through its use of monetary policy, the Federal Reserve plays a vital role in promoting full employment; however, monetary policy has proven insufficient for eliminating involuntary unemployment. Historically, the Federal Reserve has had a significant role in increasing unemployment as a result of combating any inflationary pressures that may exist in the economy. With a job guarantee policy in place, the Federal Reserve can conduct monetary policy without promoting rising levels of unemployment. In this scenario, the job guarantee program can maintain employment and consumption expenditures while the Federal Reserve employs monetary policy to reduce private investment in order to cool the economy. Thus, U.S. workers would be less vulnerable to the Federal Reserve not adhering to their responsibility of a dual mandate appropriately due to their cultural over-emphasis—a function of their close ties to the financial sector—on price stability. The restoration of local and state tax bases. By providing for full employment, the job guarantee will increase employment, and therefore expenditures and tax revenues for local and state governments. Although the job guarantee is designed as a universal program, more resources will flow to communities that currently have the highest rates of unemployment and underemployment (presumably because of higher uptake of NIEC employment opportunities). This will result in increased government resources to better serve their constituents. Macroeconomic stabilization. The job guarantee would function as a robust automatic stabilizer in the economy, maintaining levels of employment during economic downturns through direct hiring, and freely allowing workers to flow from the jobs program to the private sector during economic boom times. While workers may see some decrease in their purchasing power during an economic contraction, the job guarantee will automatically expand as demand for employment in the private sector contracts, providing a buffer to incomes and guarding against major pitfalls in effective demand. The provision of socially useful goods and services. During the Great Depression, the Works Progress Administration (WPA) and Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) were public employment programs designed to put Americans back to work. The programs were implemented near the height of the Great Depression, when the national unemployment rate reached 25 percent. These programs, implemented under the Roosevelt administration, provided goods and services that benefited all Americans by facilitating the logistics and technological expansion of our public infrastructure, including 650,000 miles of new or improved roads; 39,000 schools built, improved, or repaired; 4,000 new or improved utility plants; and 225,000 concerts performed. Under a job guarantee, even those who do not receive employment via the NIEC will likely benefit through the increased provision of public goods and socially desirable goods and services. Furthermore, the provision of productive goods and services will dampen inflationary concerns.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Link › Link Turn- JG Strengthens Econ

Jobs guarantee promises to strengthen the economy

Finn 17 Daniel Finn, 2-4-2017, "Why We Need a Federal Job Guarantee," No Publication, Excerpt: Section 5, Omitted: Sections 1-4

5. It’ll stabilize the economy. A FJG would bring us much closer to actual full employment, not the neoclassical full employment that subjectively allows for some optimal frictional unemployment. Most contemporary economists rely on the non-accelerating inflation rate of unemployment (NAIRU) to calculate this less-than-full full employment artificial statistic which functions as a disciplinary tool of the bourgeoisie, but this, according to Roger Farmer is “an idea past its sell-by date.” By full employment, we mean simply that everyone seeking a job gets one. We’d wager that if you asked the average American what full employment means to them, they’d give you a similar answer — a job for all. Indeed, a plurality of Americans will also tell you they support a FJG. The UBI would likely still leave a substantial segment of the population in poverty. As Belgian philosopher Philippe Van Parijs, one of the most prominent UBI advocates, acknowledged, even a large payment through the UBI won’t necessarily secure a comfortable living for all citizens. How about those without jobs, or those who earn below subsistence wages? Of course, a UBI coupled with a non-poverty wage option and strong unionization could seriously combat poverty. The UBI would eliminate the effective minimum wage of $0 currently offered in the United States, though it would fail to provide adequate employment for all that demanded it — a crucial shortfall of such a program. A FJG is a sounder mechanism to combat structural inequalities, for instance through closing the persistent unemployment gap experienced by stigmatized groups who face continued discrimination. (Note, since 1972 unemployment has average double digits for black workers and has never fallen below 7 percent — a level that is only reached during times of economic crisis — for white workers). Further, the FJG will have a strong macroeconomic stabilization effect. During economic downturns, it would expand and hire more people; it would then shrink during economic boom periods as people move from public to better-paying private employment. Pavlina R. Tcherneva, a leading voice on the FJG’s macroeconomic effects, argues that policies like the UBI have no counter-cyclical features. Thus, when the economy takes a downturn — say as it did in 2007 — basic incomes provide no automatic stabilizers to right the sinking ship. This is good for the economy as a whole. Rather than expanding the unemployment insurance rolls during economic busts, the FJG would put folks to work and moderate the business cycle. Federal workers’ paychecks will increase demand, which will increase economic growth. Many economists agree that today’s secular stagnation — insufficient demand — is contributing to continued “lackluster” growth after the Great Recession. Only modest upticks in growth for the foreseeable future will come if we continue the status quo. Finally, as a less costly program a FJG might be easier for a future left government to enact. Some estimate that basic income could easily cost more than $3 trillion each year, while others say it will only come to $2.7 trillion. The FJG, on the other hand, will cost orders of magnitude less. Even if we conservatively guess that fifteen million unemployed workers need jobs, funding the FJG would take about $750 billion. We want to build an inclusive economy. The FJG will build an economy that serves the working class more efficiently and effectively than the UBI. The benefits will be immediately and broadly distributed. The FJG will directly target the unemployed — remedying a key predictor of poverty. By providing universal employment, it will also counteract employers’ systematic discrimination against ex-offenders, recent military veterans, and certain racial groups. Furthermore, through providing a guaranteed job, workers will be emboldened to take new actions in the private sector. This could be just the policy to reinvigorate the labor movement, spurring unionization drives to improve working conditions. These benefits will result in the federal jobs raising beneficiaries and their families above the poverty line. The UBI can make no such guarantee. Not only would a federal job guarantee bring justice to the millions who desire work, but it would also address the long-standing unjust barriers that keep large segments of stigmatized populations out of the labor force. Finally, it would reverse the rising tide of inequality for all workers. By strengthening their bargaining power and eliminating the threat of unemployment once and for all, a federal job guarantee would bring power back to the workers where it belongs.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Link › Link Turn- Confidence- Aff good for BizCon

BizCon and Consumer Confidence both improve with Federal Jobs Guarantee- enough to prevent a recession

Segal 20 Jerome M. Segal, 5-20-2020, "Segal: Pandemic Requires Federal Jobs Guarantee," Medium, https://medium.com/@JeromeSegal/segal-pandemic-requires-federal-jobs-guarantee-c205e315f223

Jerome Segal, Presidential candidate of the Bread and Roses Party, has called for the enactment of a Federal Employment Guarantee as a new structure within which the United States would respond to the 36 million unemployed Americans caused by the Pandemic. He issued this statement: “In 1978 Congress passed the Humphrey-Hawkins Full Employment Act. In its original form, but stripped from the Act, was a Federal Employment Guarantee, and this is what we need today, a legal entitlement of every American to either a job, or free education and job training to enable future employment.” “If we had had an Employment Guarantee in place when the pandemic hit, we could have kept unemployment under 4%. Everyone who was not in an essential industry or service and could not work from home, would have been put on extended vacation from their existing job. It would have been illegal, so long as America was under lock-down, for any company outside of bankruptcy to fire any worker. At the same time, the cost of the vacation-with-pay, would have been picked up by the Federal Government, with direct payments either to businesses or to workers themselves.” “Instead, we have had the utter chaos of underfunded, uncertain and limited paycheck protection efforts, and tens of millions of people seeking unemployment insurance after being needlessly fired from jobs they should have retained. The cost of direct vacation pay would have been less than the hodge-podge of programs that Congress enacted, well below the cost of the stimulus package.” “At the same time, a Jobs Guarantee, would have given Americans not actively engaged in work, not only the income they need, but the security that when the pandemic abates, their job would still be there. This means consumer confidence, and this in turn implies business confidence, all of which is necessary for a strong and sharp economic recovery. Instead we have today widespread uncertainty and insecurity that will weigh down the economy long after the worse of the pandemic is behind us.” “It is not too late to enact a jobs guarantee. Right now we can enact a program that will help reverse the errors we have made. With new legislation, we can provide powerful incentives for companies that have laid off workers, to immediately begin the rapid re-hiring of their work force. Those not put into active work, would still be re-hired, going from being unemployed to being on extended vacation. The Federal government would assume this cost until workers were actually back on the job. Immediately, unemployment status would be ended for millions of workers. This would provide the 36 million unemployed not only with income security but with confidence in the future. And this in turn would limit pressure to re-open the economy prematurely.” “Secondly, the process of bringing workers back to the active workplace should be done within the basic Job guarantee framework, which is that Americans share an equal right to be actively employed — this means that companies do not bring back 3 workers at 40 hours a week, when they can bring back 4 workers at 30 hours a week. Job sharing should become the national norm both for resuming active employment, and for any future steps towards work de-activization whether caused by pandemics or national recessions.” “Inevitably, because of the current pandemic and in future economic downturns, there will be businesses that will fail, even with ample efforts to protect them. We can expect this in the airlines, in cruise ships, in hotels and among restaurants. Thus, some permanent job elimination is inevitable. A Federal jobs guarantee responds to this in four ways.” “First, there is the guarantee of education and re-training. This means deepening human capital. Workers that lose their jobs and cannot find employment, would be entitled to free higher education and/or free vocational re-training so that they would be able to successfully navigate to higher tiers of the job market.” “Secondly, we would have powerful policies to expand employment in the non-profit sector to provide services of vital importance. Here we would provide through the tax system, a refundable tax credit to all tax payers, on a sliding scale, of contributions they make to vital non-profits organizations that directly provide social services. People most in need would be empowered to support and expand those non-profits that most adequately respond to their needs. We would empower the homeless, empower the poorest and weakest among us.” “Third we would stimulate private sector employment through Federal contracts and government grants to pursue the Green New Deal objectives of transitioning to a “Do No Harm” ecologically sound economy.” “And fourth, we would pair the Green New Deal with A Beauty New Deal, a nationwide program of grants for artists and writers and performers, and for starting theatre repertory companies in every mid-sized city, and for planting 330 million flowering fruit trees in every town and city in the land.” “The Pandemic has thrown this country on its heels. At the same time, it offers us a once-in-a-generation opportunity to re-think the basics of our economic life and of the social contract which holds us together. The most basic of these elements, though vital, is not the Safety-Net or The Basic Income Net which say, “No one will go hungry,” it is The Employment Net which says “Everyone has a right to make a productive contribution to our national life.”

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › UQ › UQ – Economy Weak

US already barreling towards deep recession

Partington 5-31 Richard Partington, 5-31-2023, "UK and US poised to fall into recession as interest rates dampen growth," Guardian, https://www.theguardian.com/business/2023/may/31/uk-and-us-poised-to-fall-into-recession-as-interest-rates-dampen-growth

Stubbornly high inflation and higher borrowing costs are poised to drive the economies of the UK, Germany and US into recession, the leading rating agency Moody’s has warned. In a downbeat forecast for growth across advanced G20 economies, it said a ramping up of interest rates by central banks on both sides of the Atlantic was expected to weigh on economic growth this year. “We expect very weak growth in key advanced economies in particular, including mild recessions in the US, UK and Germany, and stagnant economic activity in France and Italy,” Moody’s said in a report. It comes as the world’s most influential central banks attempt to squeeze high inflation out of the system through the toughest round of rate increases in decades, amid concern over the potential for persistent pressure on living standards. Official estimates on Wednesday revealed a mixed picture across the eurozone, underscoring the challenge facing the European Central Bank, after French inflation eased to its lowest level in a year but Italy overshot analyst expectations. France’s annual inflation rate fell by more than expected to 6% in May, down from 6.9% in April. However, inflation fell by significantly less than anticipated in Italy to stand at 8.1% in May, down from 8.7% a month earlier. German inflation fell by more than expected to 6.3%, down from 7.6% a month earlier. The figures followed a bigger-than-expected decline in Spain, with a fall in inflation to 2.9%, raising hopes that price pressures across the eurozone could cool rapidly this year. Official estimates for the 20-country bloc as a whole are due on Thursday. Rory Fennessy, an economist at the consultancy Oxford Economics, said: “With inflation surprising to the downside in Germany and France, it is likely that eurozone inflation came down more than expected in May, closer to 6% from 7% in April. If inflation in June surprises to the downside, the chances of a July rate hike will diminish significantly.” Christine Lagarde, president of the ECB, warned this month that the eurozone’s central bank still had “more ground to cover” on interest rates, after increasing its key deposit rate by a quarter point to 3.25%. “We are not pausing. That’s very clear,” she said. Revised official figures for Germany revealed last week that the country slipped into recession at the start of this year, while concern is also mounting over the strength of the UK and US economies. The technical definition of a recession is two consecutive quarters of shrinking gross domestic product. Official figures last week showed inflation remained stubbornly high in the UK as households come under pressure from the fastest annual rise in food prices since the late 1970s. Britain has the highest inflation rate in the G7 group of advanced economies, after a fall to 8.7% in April, down from 10.1% in March. UK inflation figures for May are due to be published next month, with analysts warning that Rishi Sunak’s target to halve the inflation rate by the end of this year is increasingly at risk. Economists said last week that Britain’s stubbornly high levels of inflation were likely to push the Bank of England to push interest rates above 5% in order to “engineer” the conditions for a recession to bring down inflation. Moody’s said it expected Threadneedle Street to raise its key base rate by “at least” another quarter-point to 4.75% when the Bank’s policymakers next meet in June. US consumer prices have been slowing in recent months, dropping to an annual inflation rate of 4.9% in April. However, analysts have warned the US Federal Reserve could be forced to keep interest rates at high levels for longer than previously anticipated to squeeze persistent inflation out of the system. Economists are divided on whether the US could fall into recession in the second half of this year or in 2024. However, some suggest the country could manage a “soft landing” from high inflation without a recession. Moody’s warned that recent turmoil in the US banking system had highlighted how the rate cycle could trigger risks in the financial system. While strength in the US jobs market could delay an economic downturn, it said this might also risk fuelling high inflation – making it more likely for the US Federal Reserve to raise interest rates further. “Cooling economic activity and weaker labour market are necessary conditions for inflationary pressures in the economy to ease. Too much resilience for too long would require even tighter monetary policy,” the report said.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › UQ › UQ – Economy Weak

Economic conditions are horrible now- aff can’t make them any worse

Phillip Braun, 5-3-2023, "A Recession Is Coming—And Here’s How We Know," Forbes,

For many months, economic arrows have been pointing to a likely slowdown in economic growth in the U.S., possibly indicating a recession. A contracting economy appears likely with the latest U.S. GDP report showing economic growth slowed to a 1.1% annual rate in the first quarter, well below the previous quarter when the economy expanded by a steady 2.6% according to The Bureau of Economic Analysis. My economic analysis leads me to believe the U.S. economy will go into recession, possibly as soon as the third quarter of this year, but more likely slightly later. Given that recessions are typically two or three quarters of economic contraction, I would expect the projected upcoming recession to persist into mid-2024 with lower levels of growth to follow. This is no cause for alarm, but it does signal that businesses and consumers alike are responding to the most visible culprit undermining the economy: persistent inflation. Inflation has been cutting into purchasing power for consumers, with retail sales in March 2023 down 1.2% from February, according to government data. Consumer spending is the single biggest driver of the U.S. economy, and it continues to be impacted by higher prices, with real personal consumption expenditures showing no growth in March. If this continues, it makes a recession almost inevitable, despite some signs that inflation has been cooling down somewhat. Prices Of Gas And Consumer Goods Rise As Inflation Hits 40-Year High Consumer spending is the single biggest driver of the U.S. economy, and it continues to be impacted ... Expectations of a recession are causing business investment to fall, declining by over 8% in real terms over the past year. Business inventories are still rising, but at a declining rate compared to a year ago. Wages are still rising, putting upward pressure on production costs, although also at a slower rate versus last year. For example, the Consumer Price Index (CPI) reading for March came in at 5% year-over-year, indicating inflation has fallen to a slower pace compared to 6% in February, as well as the 40-year high of more than 9% in June 2022. But inflation is still running hot overall, and well above the Federal Reserve’s long-term target of about 2%. In an attempt to control inflation, the Federal Reserve will have no choice but to continue its path toward higher interest rates. This week, the Fed raised interest rates by 0.25 percentage points—the same action it took in March. In a statement, the Federal Open Market Committee said it will “closely monitor incoming information and assess the implications for monetary policy” but, as Bloomberg reported, it did not repeat a line from its March statement about “some additional policy firming may be appropriate.” That is being interpreted by some observers as an indication that the Fed’s interest rate tightening may be over for now. The Fed may be more cautious about aggressively raising rates going forward with the economy slowing and potentially headed for recession. Persistently high inflation, slowing spending, declining investment, interest rate increases—this is a textbook scenario for a recession, and one that is being closely watched by business leaders and global economists alike. In fact, business leaders, investors, and consumers would do well to track a broad array of indicators to gain a more complete picture of the U.S. economy and where it’s headed. Here’s a sampling: Investing Digest: Know what's moving the financial markets and what smart money is buying with Forbes Investing Digest. Layoffs announced by several large companies—among them 3M, AmazonAMZN -0.9%, Meta (parent of Facebook), Goldman Sachs and others—tell a far different story than the labor market narrative of low unemployment. Job cuts and a slowdown in hiring indicate that the strength of the labor market is waning as a direct result of overall economic pessimism and concerns about recession. Over the past couple of years, nominal wages have been rising, roughly keeping pace with inflation. For example, in December 2022 median nominal wages grew by 6.1% while the CPI was up 6.4%. However, real wages growth (adjusted for inflation) is negative, which means U.S. household income overall has been hurt by inflation. As a result, household purchasing power has eroded, which points to recession. The class of 2023 is entering a more difficult job market. Data from the St. Louis Fed show an unemployment rate for college graduates of 5.4% in March 2023, up from 4.2% in December 2022. That reality could temper expectations among new graduates for first jobs and salaries. The U.S. housing market continues to slow, with existing home sales falling 2.4% in March 2023 from February levels and declining by 22% from a year ago. Higher mortgage rates have been largely to blame. Consumer sentiment has also turned downward, with indications that retail buyers are watching inflation and the economy overall with expectations of curbing their purchases. For example, a recent survey by CNBC and Momentive found that U.S. consumers could “buy less across more categories if inflation persists.” Tellingly, this attitude was found not only among lower-income consumers, but also those whose annual incomes are at least $100,000. Economic data of the nontraditional variety add some texture. While anecdotal, they do point to a more cautious consumer who thinks twice when making a purchase. Discretionary spending has been under pressure as consumers need to pay up more for necessities such as food and gasoline. While discretionary purchases may be associated with luxury goods, the decline goes far deeper into that—for example, into home goods, according to Costco. McDonald’s CEO Christopher Kempczinski recently highlighted the importance of tracking the number of units or menu items per order. Or, as he was quoted in a Tweet, whether someone will “add fries to their order.” Apparently it’s a global phenomenon: according to Reuters, rising prices are hurting Britain’s economy—and higher costs of seafood and potatoes could put as many as one-third of UK fish-and-chip eateries out of business. Admittedly, predicting economic turning points is difficult. However, much of the recent economic data is pointing in the direction of a recession. Many use the strength of the labor market as a counter argument; however, we are seeing slowing there, as well. .While employers are still hiring, the rate of growth in hiring is flat, while the number of job openings are still high, the number of openings is declining, falling 22% in March over last year, and new unemployment claims rose 11% in April over a year earlier. While a recession is not inevitable, consumers and business leaders cannot ignore its possibility. Consumers need to cut back on spending, especially on credit, while business leaders should look to reduce hiring and other expenditures, in particular, capital expenditures.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › UQ › UQ – Economy Weak

Recession coming next quarter

Pickert and Yoo 5-19 Pickert, Reade, and Kyungjin Yoo. “US Economy to Cool This Quarter, Hit Downturn in Second Half of Year.” Bloomberg.Com, 19 May 2023, www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-05-19/cooler-us-economy-seen-transitioning-to-second-half-downturn?leadSource=uverify+wall#xj4y7vzkg.

Forecasters see the US economy continuing to cool in the current quarter before a further slowdown in consumer spending and pullback in business investment cause the economy to shrink in the second half of the year. Gross domestic product is seen rising an annualized 0.5% in the second quarter, according to the latest Bloomberg monthly survey of 70 economists. While slightly better than the 0.2% rate expected a month ago, reflecting an upward adjustment in household spending to a still-weak 1%, the latest projection is less than half the first-quarter pace.

METRIC 2Q 3Q 4Q

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › UQ › UQ – Economy Weak

Economy already headed for recession- multiple sources agree

Goodkind 5-12 Nicole Goodkind, 5-12-2023, "Why current US recession warnings are unlike all the others," CNN, https://www.cnn.com/2023/05/12/investing/premarket-stocks-trading/index.html

Economic experts are once again ringing the alarm bells over an imminent downturn. A US recession is coming, they say, in the second half of 2023. That time frame begins less than three weeks from now. JPMorgan CEO Jamie Dimon warned on Thursday of great economic danger lurking just over the horizon. Given the risks that lie ahead, he told Bloomberg news, “I would take a mild recession happily.” Billionaire investor Stan Druckenmiller didn’t mince his words this week at the Sohn Investment Conference. A hard landing is coming, he cautioned, and “it’s just naive not to be open-minded to something really, really bad happening.” For more than a year CEOs, economists, analysts and their kind have been warning of an imminent economic downturn, The economy, meanwhile, has remained relatively resilient through it all. Things weren’t great last year: Inflation hit a 40-year peak, gas prices were elevated, consumer sentiment plunged and markets fell by 20%. Still, the United States managed to avoid a recession. “This has been the most predicted potential recession in memory,” said Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond President Tom Barkin way back in January. So why should we listen now? There are two reasons, noted Paul Christopher, head of investment strategy at Wells Fargo: Higher interest rates and tightening credit. The Federal Reserve has raised rates higher and more quickly than they have in decades, and some say that the ongoing US regional banking crisis is an early warning sign of stress on the system. The Fed’s own experts predicted in March that “the potential economic effects of the recent banking-sector developments,” would lead to “a mild recession starting later this year.” Bank failures can make borrowing harder, which can curb spending and weigh on economic activity. A Fed survey, released Monday, confirmed that lenders are stiffening their standards in the wake of the banking collapses — demand for and supply of loans is now close to 2008 levels. “The bottom line for markets is that with inflation still at 5%, well above the [Fed’s] 2% inflation target, and the Fed not cutting rates anytime soon, credit conditions will continue to tighten and, as a result, a recession is coming that could be deeper or longer than the consensus currently expects,” said Torsten Slok, chief economist at Apollo Global Management. What comes next: The United States is approaching one year since inflation peaked at 9.1% in June of 2022. Historically, recession typically coincides with that peak, said Barry Gilbert, asset allocation strategist for LPL Financial. But that doesn’t mean we’re out of the woods. If the economy were to go into recession in the second half of the year, we could chalk up the more delayed economic downturn to a Fed that was initially behind the curve in fighting inflation along with monetary policy acting with its typical lag,” said Gilbert. Tailwinds from post-pandemic demand had also contributed to economic resilience, he added. Jamie Dimon talks debt ceiling Dimon sharply criticized former President Donald Trump on Thursday, saying the 2024 presidential candidate doesn’t understand the debt ceiling and what is at stake. It is just “one more thing he doesn’t know very much about,” Dimon told Bloomberg Television. Trump said in a CNN town hall Wednesday night that a default would be preferable to a result that doesn’t stop the government “spending money like drunken sailors.” Economists and congressional leaders on both sides of the aisle say an extended default would hurt the US economy, triggering widespread unemployment, surging interest rates and sparking a global downturn. Defaulting on the US debt would be “potentially catastrophic,” Dimon said Thursday. “The closer you get to it, you will have panic. Markets will get volatile, maybe the stock market will go down, the Treasury markets will have their own problems,” he said. “This is not good.” Dimon also expressed concerns that US creditworthiness could be downgraded, as it was during the 2011 debt limit crisis. Dimon told Bloomberg that he has been hunkering down in a so-called “war room” once a week in order to prepare JPMorgan Chase, the largest bank in the United States, for the possibility of a debt default. As the June 1 “X-date” approaches — when the US Treasury could run out of cash and extraordinary measures they’re currently using to pay all government obligations — Dimon said he will convene his war room more often. By May 21, he expects to meet every day. Twitter to get a new boss Elon Musk has been vowing to relieve himself of the top position at Twitter for some time. On Thursday, he took a step toward making good on that promise. “Excited to announce that I’ve a new CEO for X/Twitter. She will be starting in ~6 weeks!” Musk said in a tweet. But even as Musk prepares to step back from the CEO role, he will likely maintain significant control over the future direction of the company, reports my colleague Clare Duffy. After taking over the company in October, Musk cleared out the C-suite, dissolved the board and became both the CEO and sole director. Musk has faced criticism for a series of policy changes at Twitter, which often came without clear justification and raised concerns about the impact on Twitter’s users. Musk — who runs or is involved in numerous other companies, including Tesla (TSLA) — has also faced criticism from Tesla (TSLA) shareholders concerned that he is distracted by Twitter.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › UQ › UQ – Confidence Low

Investor and business confidence has substantially decreased

Duggan 5-24 Wayne Duggan, 5-24-2023, "Is The U.S. Economy Heading For A Recession?," Forbes Advisor, https://www.forbes.com/advisor/investing/is-a-recession-coming/

Since mid-2022, Americans have been told that a recession is just around the corner. But over the last nine months, there’s been no sign of any economic downturn in the U.S. What’s going on? Rising interest rates, high inflation, an inverted yield curve and an unexpected banking crisis have all been cited as reasons that a recession could be imminent. The New York Fed recession probability indicator suggests there is a 68.2% chance of a U.S. recession sometime in the next 12 months. That’s the highest reading in more than four decades. Other reliable economic indicators are flashing warning signs that the U.S. economy could soon be rolling over. But despite all these factors, the U.S. labor market remains strong, and economists are divided on whether or not a recession is inevitable in this unusual economic environment. Just because some experts believe the risk of a recession is rising, there’s no reason to panic. In fact, recessions are a relatively common occurrence—and they’ve often generated some attractive opportunities for long-term investors. What Is a Recession? There is no universal definition, but analysts and investors commonly consider two consecutive quarters of contracting gross domestic product (GDP) to be a recession. U.S. GDP gained 1.1% in the first quarter of 2023, and the Atlanta GDPNow model is currently projecting another 1.7% gain in U.S. GDP in the second quarter. By this common definition, we are not heading for a recession. In the U.S., the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) is tasked with officially calling recessions, although its definition of a recession is somewhat vague. NBER says a recession is “a significant decline in economic activity that is spread across the economy and that lasts more than a few months.” Right now companies are still hiring and consumers are still spending. In fact, the U.S. economy added 253,000 jobs in April, far exceeding economist estimates of 180,000 new jobs. That type of job growth doesn’t typically coincide with a U.S. recession. Why Are Investors Worried About a Recession? Back in March, the Fed projected full-year 2023 GDP growth of just 0.4%, suggesting economic growth could easily dip into negative territory in the second half of the year. Since then, the central bank has kept raising interest rates, and a minor banking crisis led to the failures of Silicon Valley Bank, Signature Bank and First Republic. The minutes from the April Fed meeting disclosed that officials thought the crisis could push the economy into recession. “Given their assessment of the potential economic effects of the recent banking sector developments, the staff’s projection at the time of the March meeting included a mild recession starting later this year, with a recovery over the subsequent two years,” stated the Fed meeting minutes. The Fed will release the minutes from its May meeting on May 24. Inflation Is the Tail That Wags the Dog The most recent core personal consumption expenditures price index data showed that this key measure of U.S. inflation was up 4.6% from a year ago. While it’s down significantly from peak 2022 levels, core PCE remains well above the Fed’s long-term target of 2%. That latter point is why the Fed has raised the federal funds target rate range by 5% since March 2022. But while raising rates can help lower inflation, the higher they go, the more expensive it becomes for U.S. companies to invest in innovation and growth. In addition, higher rates increase the costs of loans for regular Americans. Credit card balances, mortgage loans and auto loans are more expensive, reducing the disposable income people have to spend, weighing on corporate earnings and stock prices. Analysts are expecting S&P 500 companies to report a 6.3% year-over-year earnings decline in the second quarter, the third consecutive quarter of negative earnings growth. The banking crisis has further tightened credit markets, reducing banks’ willingness to lend to corporations and consumers. The Inverted Yield Curve Flashes a Recession Warning One warning sign of a U.S. recession has been flashing for investors since mid-2022. The yield on 2-year U.S. Treasury notes jumped above the yields on 10-year Treasury notes, a phenomenon known as a yield curve inversion. Inverted yield curves have historically been a strong economic recession indicator. Historically, two-thirds of the time the yield curve has inverted, the U.S. economy has fallen into a recession within 18 months. The last time the yield curve inverted was in late 2019, just a few months prior to the Covid-19 recession. In early 2023, the yield curve inverted to its deepest level since 1981. The Case Against an Imminent Recession Despite these warning signs, there are plenty of economists and analysts who say the U.S. economy is simply too healthy at the moment for a recession to be imminent. David Trainer, CEO of New Constructs, says investors can watch the earnings reports and guidance from discount retailer Walmart (WMT) as an indicator of the health of U.S. consumers. In May, Walmart reported first-quarter earnings and revenue beats and raised its full-year guidance. “Walmart is a bellwether for consumer spending and health, which is not in dire straits, but it is weakening,” Trainer says. “Walmart’s earnings add to the idea that a recession is not fully here yet but is likely coming, albeit more slowly and less severe than most expect.” U.S. retail sales grew 0.4% year-over-year in April, led by miscellaneous store retail sales growth of 2.4%. Retail sales growth fell short of economist estimates of 0.8%, but it was positive for the first time since January. Chris Zaccarelli, chief investment officer at Independent Advisor Alliance, says he has been pleasantly surprised by the resilience of the U.S. economy. “Retail sales came in strong again, showing how the consumer isn’t showing any signs of slowing down and that the recession many are forecasting is farther into the future than anyone would expect,” Zaccarelli says. The Labor Department’s May U.S. jobs report on June 2 could be particularly telling for investors who are on recession watch. Should You Be Worried About a Recession? If the U.S. does slip into a recession sometime in the second half of 2023 or early 2024, there’s no reason for investors to panic. First off, historically recessions don’t last very long. The average duration of a U.S. recession since World War II is just 11.1 months. The Covid-19 recession in early 2020 lasted just two months. U.S. recessions are fairly common. Since World War II, there has been about one U.S. recession every five years or so. While recessions can lead to job losses and other financial difficulties for Americans, they have historically been excellent buying opportunities for long-term investors. It can be extremely difficult for investors to time a market bottom perfectly, but the S&P 500 has generated a 40% average return in the 12 months following its low point of a U.S. recession. Some stocks even have a track record of performing relatively well during recessions. For example, Target (TGT), Walmart and Home Depot (HD) shares significantly outperformed the S&P 500 during both the 2020 and 2008 recessions. Jeffrey Buchbinder, chief equity strategist for LPL Financial, says there are certainly recession risks ahead, but investors shouldn’t under-appreciate how much the U.S. economic outlook has improved in recent months. “While the ‘better than feared’ label fit the past couple of earnings seasons quite well, based on the magnitude of upside surprises in the first quarter and encouraging guidance from corporate America, that’s probably underselling it,” Buchbinder says.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › UQ › UQ – Confidence Low

Business Confidence has tanked

Pickert 5-9 Reade Pickert, 5-9-2023, "US Small-Business Optimism Falls to Lowest Level in a Decade," Bloomberg, https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-05-09/us-small-business-optimism-falls-to-lowest-level-in-a-decade#xj4y7vzkg

US small-business sentiment fell in April to the lowest level in a decade, reflecting dimmer prospects for the economy and sales that are causing firms to dial back investment plans. The National Federation of Independent Business optimism index decreased by 1.1 points to 89, the group said Tuesday. A gauge of owners’ sentiment about future business conditions slipped to a four-month low, while a measure of sales expectations was the weakest since August. That contributed to a pullback in business investment. Less than one in five firms said they’re planning capital outlays — such as spending on new equipment and expanded facilities — in the next few months, the smallest share since the onset of the pandemic. US Small-Business Sentiment Stumbles to Decade Low | Flagging optimism prompts firms to reconsider capex plans Only a net 3% of respondents said it was a good time to expand. While a touch better than the prior month, the share is still among the smallest on record. A combination of elevated inflation, high interest rates, tighter credit conditions and recession concerns continue to weigh heavily on sentiment. And as business begins to slow, fewer owners are choosing to raise prices. The share of owners who reported raising average selling prices declined for a fifth-straight month to a more than two-year low of 33%. The survey suggests there was not a material change in credit conditions for small businesses in the month. In fact, the group’s measure of the availability of loans improved somewhat from a decade-low in March, but remains low. Historically low unemployment and aggressive wage increases at big firms have made it difficult smaller firms to attract and retain workers. A net 45% of respondents reported vacancies they could not fill in the month, and 40% reported raising compensation.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › UQ › UQ – Confidence Low

Confidence reaches 10 year low

Mutikani 5-9 Lucia Mutikani, 5-9-2023, "US small business sentiment slumps to more than 10-year low," Reuters, https://www.reuters.com/markets/us/us-small-business-optimism-deteriorates-april-nfib-says-2023-05-09/

WASHINGTON, May 9 (Reuters) - U.S. small business confidence fell to more than a 10-year low in April on worries about the near-term economic outlook and persistent worker shortages, but there were few signs that businesses were having difficulties accessing credit. The National Federation of Independent Business (NFIB) said on Tuesday its Small Business Optimism Index dropped 1.1 points to 89.0 last month, the lowest level since January 2013. It was the 16th straight month that the index remained below the 49-year average of 98. Higher interest rates tied to the Federal Reserve's battle to tame inflation combined with tighter credit conditions following recent financial market stress are stoking fears of a recession this year. A fight over raising the federal government's borrowing cap is also helping to cloud the economy. While the survey hinted at an economic slowdown, economists cautioned against reading too much into the drop in sentiment. "The decline is broadly in line with the weakness in consumer sentiment seen over the past year," said Michael Pearce, lead U.S. economist at Oxford Economics in New York. "As we've argued before, though, measures of sentiment are often a poor guide of what is likely to happen in the economy because it tells us more about how business owners are feeling, rather than what they are doing." The share of owners expecting better business conditions over the next six months fell two points to a net negative 49%. A net negative 19% expected higher inflation-adjusted sales, down four points from March. Thirty percent reported all their credit needs were met, up a point from the prior month. Fifty-nine percent said they were not interested in a loan, unchanged from March. A net 6% reported their last loan was harder to get than in previous attempts, down three points, while 4% reported financing was their top business problem, up one point from March. "While owners are becoming more pessimistic, April's report should help allay concerns that credit is becoming completely unaccessible for small businesses," said Charlie Dougherty, a senior economist at Wells Fargo in New York. JOB VACANCIES A Fed survey of bank loan officers published on Monday showed credit conditions for businesses and households continued tightening in the first months of the year, but this appeared to be the result of the U.S. central bank's aggressive interest rate hikes rather than the cliff-like decline in credit some feared after the March collapses of Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank. Though the Fed has signaled it may pause its fastest monetary policy tightening campaign since the 1980s, the economy has yet to feel the full effects of the cumulative 500 basis points of hikes in the policy rate since March 2022. Forty-five percent of owners reported job openings that they could not fill, up 2 points from March. The vacancies were concentrated in construction and transportation. Thirty-seven percent of the owners had vacancies for skilled workers, up three points from March. The government reported last week that there were 1.6 job openings for every unemployed person in March. The share of small business owners reporting that inflation was their single most important problem dipped one point to 23%, and was 14 points lower than last July's peak, which was the highest reading since the fourth quarter of 1979. About 33% of owners reported raising average selling prices, down 4 points. Government data on Wednesday is expected to show consumer prices increased strongly in April, but services costs outside housing are forecast to have risen moderately. Reporting by Lucia Mutikani; Editing by Paul Simao