Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC › Impact › !- Global War-2NC

Recession leads to global warfare and eventual extinction

Baird 20 Baird, Zoe. “Equitable Economic Recovery Is a National Security Imperative.” Domestic & International (Dis)Order: A Strategic Response, Ed. Bitounis and King, Berkeley, CA, 2020, pp. 89–90.

Broadly shared economic prosperity is a bedrock of America’s economic and political strength—both domestically and in the international arena. A strong and equitable recovery from the economic crisis created by COVID-19 would be a powerful testament to the resilience of the American system and its ability to create prosperity at a time of seismic change and persistent global crisis. Such a recovery could attack the profound economic inequities that have developed over the past several decades. Without bold action to help all workers access good jobs as the economy returns, the United States risks undermining the legitimacy of its institutions and its international standing. The outcome will be a key determinant of America’s national security for years to come. An equitable recovery requires a national commitment to help all workers obtain good jobs—particularly the two-thirds of adults without a bachelor’s degree and people of color who have been most affected by the crisis and were denied opportunity before it. As the nation engages in a historic debate about how to accelerate economic recovery, ambitious public investment is necessary to put Americans back to work with dignity and opportunity. We need an intentional effort to make sure that the jobs that come back are good jobs with decent wages, benefits, and mobility and to empower workers to access these opportunities in a profoundly changed labor market. To achieve these goals, American policy makers need to establish job growth strategies that address urgent public needs through major programs in green energy, infrastructure, and health. Alongside these job growth strategies, we need to recognize and develop the talents of workers by creating an adult learning system that meets workers’ needs and develops skills for the digital economy. The national security community must lend its support to this cause. And as it does so, it can bring home the lessons from the advances made in these areas in other countries, particularly our European allies, and consider this a realm of international cooperation and international engagement. Shared Economic Prosperity Is a National Security Asset A strong economy is essential to America’s security and diplomatic strategy. Economic strength increases our influence on the global stage, expands markets, and funds a strong and agile military and national defense. Yet it is not enough for America’s economy to be strong for some—prosperity must be broadly shared. Widespread belief in the ability of the American economic system to create economic security and mobility for all—the American Dream— creates credibility and legitimacy for America’s values, governance, and alliances around the world. After World War II, the United States grew the middle class to historic size and strength. This achievement made America the model of the free world—setting the stage for decades of American political and economic leadership. Domestically, broad participation in the economy is core to the legitimacy of our democracy and the strength of our political institutions. A belief that the economic system works for millions is an important part of creating trust in a democratic government’s ability to meet the needs of the people. The COVID-19 Crisis Puts Millions of American Workers at Risk For the last several decades, the American Dream has been on the wane. Opportunity has been increasingly concentrated in the hands of a small share of workers able to access the knowledge economy. Too many Americans, particularly those without four-year degrees, experienced stagnant wages, less stability, and fewer opportunities for advancement. Since COVID-19 hit, millions have lost their jobs or income and are struggling to meet their basic needs—including food, housing, and medical care.1 The crisis has impacted sectors like hospitality, leisure, and retail, which employ a large share of America’s most economically vulnerable workers, resulting in alarming disparities in unemployment rates along education and racial lines. In August, the unemployment rate for those with a high school degree or less was more than double the rate for those with a bachelor’s degree.2 Black and Hispanic Americans are experiencing disproportionately high unemployment, with the gulf widening as the crisis continues.3 The experience of the Great Recession shows that without intentional effort to drive an inclusive recovery, inequality may get worse: while workers with a high school education or less experienced the majority of job losses, nearly all new jobs went to workers with postsecondary education. Inequalities across racial lines also increased as workers of color worked in the hardest-hit sectors and were slower to recover earnings and income than White workers.4 The Case for an Inclusive Recovery A recovery that promotes broad economic participation, renewed opportunity, and equity will strengthen American moral and political authority around the world. It will send a strong message about the strength and resilience of democratic government and the American people’s ability to adapt to a changing global economic landscape. An inclusive recovery will reaffirm American leadership as core to the success of our most critical international alliances, which are rooted in the notion of shared destiny and interdependence. For example, NATO, which has been a cornerstone of U.S. foreign policy and a force of global stability for decades, has suffered from American disengagement in recent years. A strong American recovery—coupled with a renewed openness to international collaboration—is core to NATO’s ability to solve shared geopolitical and security challenges. A renewed partnership with our European allies from a position of economic strength will enable us to address global crises such as climate change, global pandemics, and refugees. Together, the United States and Europe can pursue a commitment to investing in workers for shared economic competitiveness, innovation, and long-term prosperity. The U.S. has unique advantages that give it the tools to emerge from the crisis with tremendous economic strength— including an entrepreneurial spirit and the technological and scientific infrastructure to lead global efforts in developing industries like green energy and biosciences that will shape the international economy for decades to come.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC › Impact › !-Fragmentation- 2NC

Economic downturn leads to laundry list of impacts promising environmental destruction, social unrest, and widening inequality

McClennan 21 (Marsh, writing with the SK and Zurich Insurance Groups, Global Professional Services firm, advised by the National University of Singapore, the Oxford Martin School at Oxford University, Wharton Risk Management and Decision Processes Center at the University of Pennsylvania, “The Global Risks Report 2021,” World Economic Forum, )

The immediate human and economic cost of COVID-19 is severe. It threatens to scale back years of progress on reducing poverty and inequality and to further weaken social cohesion and global cooperation. Job losses, a widening digital divide, disrupted social interactions, and abrupt shifts in markets could lead to dire consequences and lost opportunities for large parts of the global population. The ramifications—in the form of social unrest, political fragmentation and geopolitical tensions—will shape the effectiveness of our responses to the other key threats of the next decade: cyberattacks, weapons of mass destruction and, most notably, climate change. In the Global Risks Report 2021, we share the results of the latest Global Risks Perception Survey (GRPS), followed by analysis of growing social, economic and industrial divisions, their interconnections, and their implications on our ability to resolve major global risks requiring societal cohesion and global cooperation. We conclude the report with proposals for enhancing resilience, drawing from the lessons of the pandemic as well as historical risk analysis. The key findings of the survey and the analysis are included below. Global risks perceptions Among the highest likelihood risks of the next ten years are extreme weather, climate action failure and human-led environmental damage; as well as digital power concentration, digital inequality and cybersecurity failure. Among the highest impact risks of the next decade, infectious diseases are in the top spot, followed by climate action failure and other environmental risks; as well as weapons of mass destruction, livelihood crises, debt crises and IT infrastructure breakdown. When it comes to the time-horizon within which these risks will become a critical threat to the world, the most imminent threats – those that are most likely in the next two years – include employment and livelihood crises, widespread youth disillusionment, digital inequality, economic stagnation, human-made environmental damage, erosion of societal cohesion, and terrorist attacks. Economic risks feature prominently in the 3-5 year timeframe, including asset bubbles, price instability, commodity shocks and debt crises; followed by geopolitical risks, including interstate relations and conflict, and resource geopolitization. In the 5-10 year horizon, environmental risks such as biodiversity loss, natural resource crises and climate action failure dominate; alongside weapons of mass destruction, adverse effects of technology and collapse of states or multilateral institutions. Economic fragility and societal divisions are set to increase Underlying disparities in healthcare, education, financial stability and technology have led the crisis to disproportionately impact certain groups and countries. Not only has COVID-19 caused more than two million deaths at the time of writing, but the economic and long-term health impacts will continue to have devastating consequences. The pandemic’s economic shockwave—working hours equivalent to 495 million jobs were lost in the second quarter of 2020 alone—will immediately increase inequality, but so can an uneven recovery. Only 28 economies are expected to have grown in 2020. Nearly 60% of respondents to the GRPS identified “infectious diseases” and “livelihood crises” as the top short-term threats to the world. Loss of lives and livelihoods will increase the risk of “social cohesion erosion”, also a critical short-term threat identified in the GRPS.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC › I/L › I/L- Low BCI -> Recession- 2NC

Business confidence drives business cycle fluctuations; the aff guarantees a recession with loss in GDP, GDP, lower stock prices, and higher inflation- all tanking confidence

Leduc 10 Sylvain Leduc, 11-22-2010, "Confidence and the Business Cycle," San Francisco Fed, https://www.frbsf.org/economic-research/publications/economic-letter/2010/november/confidence-business-cycle/

Economic booms are often characterized by waves of optimism and the view that the economy is entering a new era in which the business cycle has been tamed. The idea that “this time, things are different” became pervasive during the expansion of the mid-2000s, just before the worst financial crisis since the Great Depression. New financial products were thought to have protected market participants by spreading risk widely, thereby justifying the surge in mortgage lending and the phenomenal run-up in house prices. Similarly, the emergence of new information technologies fueled a wave of euphoria that drove the stock market boom of the late 1990s and the longest economic expansion in U.S. history. A similar sense of confidence developed during the Roaring Twenties, spurred by new technologies such as autos and radio, financial innovations, and improved business practices. The Japanese boom of the 1980s with its ballooning property prices also shared some of these characteristics. Each of these episodes ended with a stock market crash when overly optimistic expectations were dashed. The proposition that confidence can influence the business cycle raises the question of how expectations are translated into actions that affect economic activity. One way that confidence can cause business cycle fluctuations is when people’s actions are influenced by what they think other people might do. For example, if customers start to fear that a bank may not be able to honor deposits, they may rush to withdraw their money before other customers do, triggering a run. The bank may fail and some people may lose their deposits. If this is repeated widely, a general loss of confidence in the financial sector can occur. Since fear is not always a rational process, even a solvent bank could suffer a run that mushrooms into a broad financial panic. Such a crisis of confidence could squeeze liquidity throughout the banking system, causing a contraction in credit that harms broad economic activity. If such a banking panic occurs, the economy settles in a bad equilibrium. But if there is no broad crisis of confidence in the financial system, the economy may settle in a good equilibrium. Clearly, confidence can ultimately dictate the outcome. Economists use what are called models of multiple equilibriums to describe this process. In these models, the economy can settle in different resting points. The level of confidence becomes one variable that can determine which one of these points the economy settles in. Banking crises often triggered sharp and deep downturns in the 19th and early 20th centuries. The creation of the Federal Reserve in 1913 as a lender of last resort and the introduction of deposit insurance in 1933 greatly reduced runs in the banking sector. However, confidence continues to play an important role. It was crucial during the 2007–2008 financial crisis when investors worried about which financial institutions were solvent. Investment banks and other nonbanks were particularly vulnerable because they did not have the option of emergency borrowing from the Federal Reserve through the discount window. Confidence is also a vital factor in the current European debt crisis as investors consider the possibilities of sovereign defaults. Over the past 10 years, macroeconomists have noted that confidence can also affect the economy if it is related to developments that might influence future economic performance. For instance, confidence could increase because of the emergence of innovative technologies that potentially boost future productivity and economic growth, as in the late 1990s or the 1920s. However, because such information is often very noisy, people may end up overreacting to it by being either too optimistic or pessimistic (see Jaimovich and Rebelo 2007). In macroeconomic models, this information changes people’s expectations about the future and thus their current economic decisions. Since it often takes time to deploy workers and build capital stock, businesses will add jobs and boost investment today in anticipation of future economic growth (see Den Haan and Kaltenbrunner 2009). In this way, optimism about the future can lead to an economic boom today, along the lines suggested by Pigou. But the boom may ultimately lead to a bust if new developments fail to fulfill the original expectations and sentiment sours. Recent empirical work Figure 1 Responses to an unexpected fall in the unemployment rate forecast A. Actual unemployment rate B. Inflation rate C. Short-term interest rate Note: Figures are generated from a six-variable system with the forecast of the 12-month-ahead unemployment rate, the actual unemployment rate, the inflation rate, stock prices, and the 10-year and 3-month Treasury rates. The system is estimated over the period 1960 to 2009. The role of confidence as a source of business cycle fluctuations remains controversial partly because it is difficult to measure its importance empirically. Clearly, confidence reacts to a host of economic developments. Identifying a causal link between confidence and economic performance is therefore challenging. Is confidence higher because the economy is booming or vice versa? In an influential paper that emphasizes the role new information and changes in expectations play in driving economic fluctuations, Beaudry and Portier (2006) use statistical methods to identify the economic impact of news affecting future productivity growth. They find that expectations of higher productivity have substantial effects, boosting current consumption, investment, and real GDP, and pushing stock prices higher in a pattern reminiscent of the 1990s. Moreover, they find that such news significantly drives business cycle fluctuations, accounting for more than 40% of changes in consumption, investment, and hours worked. Another way to assess how confidence affects economic activity is to look at surveys of professional forecasters. The surveys directly measure expectations, providing unique insights into how confident respondents are about future economic performance. Survey timing can be used to examine how changes in expectations affect the economy (see Leduc and Sill 2010 and Leduc, Sill, and Stark 2007). Since we know when surveys were conducted, we know what information was available when the forecasts were prepared. Clearly, forecasts can’t be affected by data that haven’t been released. On the other hand, forecasts can affect future data. We can therefore use the dates of data releases to help assess how changes in expectations affect economic performance. The three panels in Figure 1 examine the Livingston Survey, which compiles professional forecasts twice a year. The panels show how a fall in the survey’s median forecast of the unemployment rate correlates with the actual rates of unemployment and inflation, and a short-term interest rate. The black solid lines represent the response of a given variable, while the shaded areas are confidence bands that indicate how much confidence we can have that the mean response is different from zero. The figure demonstrates that optimism about economic performance about a year ahead leads to a significant pickup in activity today, represented by a fall in the actual unemployment rate and a rise in the inflation rate. Monetary policy Periods of the kind of strong confidence that drives economic booms have repeatedly generated criticisms that monetary policy fueled excessive levels of optimism by keeping policy overly accommodative. For instance, theoretical work by Christiano, Motto, and Rostagno (2006) suggests that central banks that focus heavily on inflation may end up stoking confidence-driven booms. In their model, expectations that good times are ahead lead to upward pressure on real wages as the demand for labor increases. If nominal wages adjust slowly, pressures develop for prices and the inflation rate to fall. As inflation declines below their target rate, policymakers respond by lowering interest rates. In this way, they end up fueling the boom. The evidence presented in panel C of Figure 1 suggests instead that historically, following an increase in confidence, monetary policy becomes more restrictive as the short-term policy interest rate rises. Monetary policy attempts to damp the boom by leaning against the rise in economic activity and inflation generated by rising expectations. Similarly, a wave of pessimism translates into a more accommodative monetary stance, as the economy weakens and inflation declines. Conclusion The boom-and-bust cycles in the United States and other parts of the world over the past two decades and the stock market collapses in 2000 and 2008 have prompted macroeconomists to take another look at the extent to which confidence, optimism, and changes in expectations may drive and amplify business cycle fluctuations. Recent empirical work indicates that these sentiments contribute significantly to economic ups and downs. Typically that means monetary policy remains accommodative when weakness in confidence becomes entrenched.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC › I/L › I/L- BCI Reliable- 2NC

BCI is largely accurate- empirics prove

IBIS 3-30 “Industry Market Research, Reports, and Statistics.” IBISWorld, 30 Mar. 2023, www.ibisworld.com/us/bed/business-sentiment-index/88232/.

The business sentiment index is highly correlated with the performance of the US business sector. Generally, if confidence levels surpass an index value of 50.0, the economy is considered to be expanding, whereas confidence below 50.0 indicates a contraction. After exceeding a value of 50.0 between 2002 and 2007, the index plummeted in 2008 due to the financial crisis. The September 2008 collapse of Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. led to a stock market collapse, detrimentally affecting most of the business sector. The resulting recession caused aggregate corporate profit to tumble, which eroded business confidence. However, as the economy stabilized in late 2009, business sentiment began growing again. Moreover, 2010 marked a landmark year for corporate profit performance, growing nearly 25.0% that year to reach a record high. The tremendous growth in profit led to a similarly large jump in business confidence, which increased 24.2% in 2010. The optimism that the economic recovery would be quick was dashed in the following years, though lingering unemployment, a struggling housing market and a tight credit market led to little economic growth. As a result, confidence fell moderately in both 2011 and 2012. In addition, the business sentiment index contracted 7.9% in 2015. The decline in 2015 can be attributed to many manufacturing businesses reporting a lower volume of new orders, with some businesses reporting weak demand from global consumers, notably consumers in China and Europe. This trend was exacerbated by significant declines in the price of crude oil and other commodities, contributing to weak growth, with business sentiment rising 0.1% in 2016. According to recent reports from the Institute for Supply Management, many manufacturing industries experienced growth in new orders, inventories and employment in recent years. These positive trends led to an estimated increase of 11.7% in the business sentiment index in 2017. In particular, paper products, machinery, transportation equipment, computer and electronic products as well as nonmetallic mineral products reported the most gains. Conversely, wood products and petroleum and coal products reported losses. However, this strong growth in 2017 slowed in 2018 before declining significantly in 2019, due primarily to trade tensions and other worries of economic weakness. Recession worries heightened significantly in 2020, due to economic effects of the COVID-19 (coronavirus) outbreak. However, attitudes significantly rebounded in 2021 as the vaccine was deployed and lockdown mandates were lifted, enabling most economic activity to resume. Accordingly, business confidence increased after these initial changes amid pent-up demand for services, which will lead to an inflated business sentiment level of 60.6 in 2021. In 2022, levels slightly eased due to surging inflation which has led to the Federal Reserve aggressively raising interest rates. Additionally, the Russian invasion of Ukraine has increased geopolitical tensions which has contributed to the decrease in business sentiment during the year. As a result of economic uncertainty, business sentiment levels decreased 10.0% to 54.5 during the year. Small businesses specifically have suffered throughout 2022 and into 2023, primarily due to spiking levels of inflation and sudden interest rate hikes. According to CNBC’s SurveyMonkey Small Business Survey, small business sentiment, in August of 2022, reached its lowest level since 2017. While larger businesses have been able to better adapt to increased costs, they still share a similar view. According to Reuters, business sentiment continues to skid during 2023 as worker shortages and inflation continues to effect business owners. Combined with economic uncertainty following the collapse of the Silicon Valley Bank, along with other regional banks, many businesses have expressed concerns about the health of the economy. With the potential for a recession lingering into 2023, business sentiment is forecast to decrease a further 7.7% during the year.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC › I/L › I/L- BCI Reliable- 2NC

Business confidence is a reliable economic indicator

Ndou, Gumata, and Ncube 18 Elphias Ndou, Nombulelo Gumata, Mthuli Ncube 1-9-2018, "Business Confidence Shocks and the Relevance of Exchange Rate Volatility and Economic Policy Uncertainty Channels," SpringerLink, https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-319-62280-4_20

Various empirical studies have established that the levels of business confidence may influence the stock market and other asset returns, investment and consumption decisions and are thus significant and form an integral part of the business cycles. For instance, Akerlof and Shiller (2009) allude to the fact that the “confidence multiplier” played a meaningful role during and after the depression. This suggests that economic recoveries without sufficiently strong levels of confidence are highly unlikely to last and be robust. Hence the conclusion that confidence is important. Furthermore, Silvia and Iqbal (2011) identify two factors that play a key role in the decision-making process of economic agents, namely ability and willingness. In this instance, ability is defined as a quantitative factor, which consists of, amongst other factors, income, financial assets and loans. On the contrary, willingness is a qualitative factor, which includes expectations about the economy, earnings and future ability. These are part of the integral channels through which confidence can result in “recession-recovery” and “boom-bust”. Fig. 20.1 depicts the direct and indirect channels transmitting the negative business confidence shocks to economy. The indirect channels are via the exchange rate volatility and economic policy uncertainty. The relevance of indirect channels has not been examined. As a consequence, the chapter fills existing policy research gaps through examining the role of the exchange rate volatility and economic policy uncertainty in the transmission of negative business confidence shocks to GDP growth, consumption expenditure growth and exports growth. Thus what would have happened to GDP, consumption and the exports in the absence of exchange rate volatility following a negative business confidence shock?

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC › I/L › I/L- 2NC

Rising inflation from Jobs Guarantee Program brings a hard landing and economic devastation

Nam and Rosalsky 1-24 Rafael Nam and Greg Rosalsky, 1-24-2023, "A recession might be coming. Here's what it could look like," NPR, https://www.npr.org/2023/01/24/1150319679/recession-slowdown-inflation-interest-rates-jobs-employment-economy

Slowcession? Richcession? Or just recession? Whether in the supermarket aisle, or the corporate suite, a lot of people are expecting a recession – even if there's no certainty there will be one at all. Survey after survey shows fears of recession are high. It's easy to see why. The Federal Reserve is increasing interest rates in the most aggressive fashion since the early 1980s as it races to bring down inflation. And a recession is often the consequence when the central bank starts raising borrowing costs. It's almost impossible to find a CEO who isn't bracing for a recession ECONOMY It's almost impossible to find a CEO who isn't bracing for a recession The prospect of recession is certainly scary. But even if the U.S. is headed for one, it's worth keeping in mind that no two recessions are alike. A recession could be blip-ish, like the short, pandemic-induced one in 2020, or more like the economic tsunami that followed the 2008 housing meltdown. So, from recession with a small r to the so-called soft landing, here are some of the current predictions of what kind of economic slowdown the U.S. could be facing. The recession with a small r In a recent poll of economists, the World Economic Forum found that nearly two-thirds of the respondents believe there will be a recession in 2023. But here's the good news: Many analysts expect a relatively mild and short recession, or what is sometimes referred to as recession with a small r. Unlike the early 1980s, when the Fed's steep rate hikes sparked a brutal recession, this time around the economy still appears to be reasonably resilient despite grappling with the highest inflation rate in around 40 years. A big reason is the health of the labor market. Yes, there have been high-profile layoffs at companies such as Google and Amazon recently. But those announcements were largely about paring back staff after these companies over-hired during the pandemic. In fact, the overall data still shows employers continue to hire. A "We Are Hiring" sign is posted in front of a restaurant in Los Angeles on Aug. 17, 2022. The labor market remains resilient, raising hopes that any recession would be mild. Frederic J. Brown/AFP via Getty Images Employers added 4.5 million jobs last year, marking a pretty spectacular comeback from the depths of the pandemic. Of course, the Fed's rate hikes will likely lead to some job losses. The Fed in December projected the unemployment rate would rise to 4.6%, from the currently near-record low of 3.5%. But that still would be a historically low number. The 'slowcessation' Trying to come up with catchy terms to describe an event is something of a tradition in economics, though they rarely actually catch on, with a few exceptions such as "the Great Resignation" or "skimpflation" (which was coined in this newsletter). Sponsor Message Moody's Analytics is now giving it a try. "Slowcessation" is a forecast that the economy will undergo a difficult period of almost no growth but will ultimately avoid an actual contraction. It's an argument that others also believe. In a report laying out its thesis, Moody's argues that the economy still has plenty of things going for it, including healthy household finances, as well as strong corporate balance sheets. A woman shops outside of a store in Manhattan in New York City on July 28, 2022. Retail sales are starting to decline after staying strong during the pandemic, a potential early sign the economy is slowing down. Spencer Platt/Getty Images Moody's believes those could help offset the economic consequences of raising interest rates, such as higher borrowing costs, lower economic growth, and more volatile financial markets. "Under almost any scenario, the economy is set to have a difficult 2023. But inflation is quickly moderating, and the economy's fundamentals are sound," writes Mark Zandi, Moody's chief economist. "With a bit of luck and some reasonably deft policymaking by the Fed, the economy should avoid an outright downturn. If so, we may dub it a slowcession." The 'richcession' This one was coined by Wall Street Journal columnist Justin Lahart. Yes, journalists also try hard to come up with catchy terms, with a similarly poor track record of success. "Richcession" refers to a recession or near-recession that impacts the rich more than lower-income folks. That would be unusual because recessions typically hurt the relatively less well-off the most. Poorer people are already suffering in the current downturn, but Lahart and others say that if we do slip into recession, lower-income workers may find themselves more insulated than in previous recessions. January is often a big month for layoffs. Here's what to do in a worst case scenario The labor shortages during the pandemic forced many businesses to boost wages to recruit staff. Wage gains at the bottom of the income scale were proportionately larger than those at the top, although many workers' wage gains were partially eroded by inflation. Inflation is now easing but the wage gains remain. That factor should help lift the overall net worth of lower income workers as they face a potential recession. And the most recent labor data shows sectors that typically hire lower-income workers such as leisure and hospitality continued to hire strongly as Americans continued to dine out and take vacations. In fact, retail businesses, still remembering the nightmare of recruiting workers during the pandemic, are more keen to hold onto staff. That's also raising hope that those with lesser means could be spared some of the impact of an economic downturn. The soft landing Of course, there's no certainty the U.S. will have to endure a recession at all. The Fed has continued to argue it has a path to raise rates without sparking a recession, instead steering the U.S. into what's called "a soft landing" – a scenario in which the economy slows but doesn't contract, and unemployment doesn't spike significantly. Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell speaks during a news conference after a Fed policy meeting on Dec. 14, 2022 in Washington, D.C. The Fed is raising interest rates in the most aggressive fashion since the early 1980s. Alex Wong/Getty Images Some recent indicators point toward that more optimistic scenario. Inflation continues to moderate, with the annual rate falling to 6.5% in December from a peak of 9.1% in June. Some of the factors that especially worried the Fed are also trending in the right direction, including, most prominently, cooling wage and price increases. That has allowed the Fed to moderate the size of its rate hikes, and analysts now expect the central bank will raise rates by only a quarter percentage point at its meeting next week. Furthermore, China's end to its COVID-19 restrictions has raised hopes for a stronger global economy, which can have a positive impact in the U.S. as well. This cuts both ways, though, as increased demand for energy to power China's economy could result in higher oil and gas prices. The hard landing In an unpredictable world, no scenario can be ruled out – and neither can the prospect that the Fed's rate hikes will help spark a tough recession, or a hard landing in economic lingo. For one, the Fed could overdo the rate hikes, raising them more than necessary. Managing interest rates is an inexact science and mistakes can be dire. The Fed was widely blamed for keeping rates too low in the lead-up to the 2008 Global Financial Crisis, for example. Meanwhile, Russia's invasion of Ukraine continues to weigh on the global economy. Nobody can predict how the war there will ultimately end. Why we have a debt ceiling, and why this trip to the brink may be different POLITICS Why we have a debt ceiling, and why this trip to the brink may be different There is another, big potential risk on the horizon: the looming fight over the debt ceiling. Failure to raise the ceiling would leave the federal government unable to pay all of its bills, triggering a default. That would rattle financial markets around the world. Even if the government manages to avoid an actual default, simply coming close could raise borrowing costs and put a dent in people's retirement savings. In an interview with CNN, Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen warned not raising the country's debt limit has the potential to spark another "global financial crisis." A worst case scenario, for sure, and one that would likely end up sparking a recession — with a capital R.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC › I/L › I/L- 2NC

Any hit to the economy will cause a recession

Romans 23 Christine Romans, 5-9-2023, "How to characterize the American economy — from broken to just bizarre," CNN, https://www.cnn.com/2023/05/09/economy/us-economy-broken-or-bizarre/index.html

New York CNN — The US economy is going from broken to bizarre. Covid crashed the American economy three years ago with no playbook for the wild recovery that would follow. Shutdowns and disease outbreaks disrupted global supply chains, leading to the highest inflation in 40 years and (eventually) to aggressive rate hikes from global central banks. Economists have forecast for months that a recession is just around the corner. And yet, the US economy today is growing, the job market is strong, and the consumer is still spending. Contradictions abound. The headlines blare layoffs — from Walmart, Disney, Amazon, 3M, General Motors and Meta — but, overall, hiring picked up speed in April. The economy has added an astonishing 1.2 million jobs this year and the jobless rate matches the lowest since 1969. Despite Silicon Valley pink slips, there is still plenty of hiring happening in technology, especially in computer systems design and services. And construction sites are hopping. The government reported a record 7.9 million people employed in construction jobs in April. After decades of weak wage growth, workers have enjoyed the best pay gains in a generation, especially workers at the lower end of the pay ladder. Now that inflation appears to be going from a boil to a simmer, it means less of that pay bump is going to cover higher inflation. (Key readings on consumer and producer prices come Wednesday and Thursday.) Those higher wages may complicate the Federal Reserve’s inflation fight, but they may also be underpinning consumer spending, helping the economy avoid a recession. The long recession watch The narrative seems to shift by the week, in what has been the longest recession watch in memory. Stock markets had a banner winter on hopes the economy was on its way to a possible “soft landing.” Economic growth and inflation have cooled, without a corresponding spike in joblessness. Meantime, the Fed appears to be near the end of its rate-hike cycle. Goldman Sachs pegs recession odds at 35% and Fed Chair Jerome Powell last week said the economy could still skirt a recession. U.S. Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell Rear attends a press conference in Washington, D.C., the United States, on March 22, 2023. The Fed raised interest rates by 25 basis points at the conclusion of its two-day meeting on Wednesday, lifting the target range of the federal funds rate to 4.75-5 percent. (Photo by Liu Jie/Xinhua via Getty Images) The Fed lifts rates by a quarter point “Avoiding a recession is, in my view, more likely than having a recession,” Powell said. “But I don’t rule that out either. It’s possible that we have a mild recession,” he told reporters at a news conference following the central bank’s latest rate decision. Self-inflicted wounds Two dark horses have emerged to challenge the “soft landing” narrative: a regional banking crisis set off by little-known Silicon Valley Bank and a manufactured debt ceiling crisis due to political wrangling. The regional bank strain appears to have stabilized (for now) but the partisan drama over paying the country’s bills holds huge risks. The US could default on its obligations as soon as June 1 if Congress doesn’t address the debt limit before then, Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen said Monday. Yet markets have barely flinched. The S&P 500 is up almost 8% this year and the Nasdaq is up 17%. In this photo illustration, a Social Security card sits alongside checks from the U.S. Treasury on October 14, 2021 in Washington, DC. 5 ways a debt default could affect you “I think it’s going to be a difficult couple of weeks,” said Seema Shah, chief global strategist of Principal Global Investors. “As long as the equity market is coming across pretty firm, there’s very little pressure on Congress to come to some agreement. So you do need almost panic stations to arise in order to push them over that line, which is what happened in 2011 and 2013.” In 2011, Congress reached a deal to raise the debt ceiling two days before the date Treasury estimated money would run out. It triggered the worst week for financial markets since the 2008 financial crisis and earned the United States its first and only credit downgrade. The debate over raising the debt limit in 2013 forced a government shutdown. This time around, “the financial markets have not shown much anxiety,” said Greg Valliere, chief US policy strategist for AGF Investments. “Maybe the T bill market yields have moved higher, but I think for the stock market in general there’s a feeling that, you know, (it’s the) little boy who cried wolf [because] this will get solved at the last minute, which we’ve seen in the past. But this is different. I think the militants in the House are a new factor here and for the markets to be this sanguine to me is not warranted.” Essentially, many on Wall Street don’t expect lawmakers to understand the urgency of raising the debt ceiling until their constituents’ retirement accounts get hammered first.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC › Link- Jobs Guarantee › Link- Confidence- 2NC

Federal Jobs Guarantee shakes business confidence- plan leads to loss of employees, rise in wages, and competition with government

Earle 18 PETER C. EARLE, 11-19-2018, "'Federal Jobs Guarantee' Idea Is Costly, Misguided, And Increasingly Popular With Democrats," Investor's Business Daily, https://www.investors.com/politics/commentary/federal-jobs-guarantee-democrats/

With the midterm victories in the House of Representatives, Congressional Democrats are likely to begin a full-court press on their most recent policy initiative: a federal jobs guarantee program. Senators Corey Booker, D-N.J., and Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., have advanced their own, and with the arrival in Congress of affirmed Democratic Socialists like Alexandra Ocasio-Cortez of New York and Rashida Tlaib of Michigan additional support seems likely. Several think tanks — including the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities (CBPP), Levy Economics Institute (LEI), PolicyLink, and the Center for American Progress — have proposed job guarantee plans. While there are minor differences between them, each essentially contemplates a massive, government-run program to provide work (at a predetermined wage) and benefits to enrollees on demand. Currently, individuals in the job market "sell" their labor to firms as much as firms "purchase" labor. Mutually, this transaction — employment — arises because both the employee and employer benefit; value is recognized reciprocally. With a federal jobs guarantee program, the government is inserted between the employee and the employer; the value proposition is limited at best. Centralized plans such as these forgo the most fundamental elements of markets — information, competition, and incentives — in favor of rote bureaucratic reckoning. A Daunting Task Simply finding work for tens of millions of job guarantee enrollees would be a formidable task; finding productive, impactful work catering to an individual's skills, in a given locality and in a timely manner, would be staggeringly difficult — if possible at all. The costs, too, are daunting. Both the CBPP and LEI reports project costs ranging from $450 billion to more than $600 billion, which put the proposed programs in the same league with the Pentagon in terms of discretionary spending. And while it is true that the cost of any of the federal jobs guarantee programs would be offset by savings in current unemployment insurance and poverty mitigation programs, neither of the estimates include costs of designing, staffing, and managing the proposed agency. In terms of potential enrollees, estimates start at roughly 10 million. According to LEI's high-end estimate of 17.5 million enrollees, the program would have more employees than the combined head count of the U.S. Department of Defense, the Chinese People's Liberation Army, Walmart, McDonalds, the U.K.'s National Health Service, the China National Petroleum Corporation, the State Grid Corporation of China, the Indian Railways, and the Indian Armed forces. A government organization of that size — 17.5 million job guaranteed individuals, with an untold number of administrators, managers, and other employees to attend to them nationwide — would become the largest public or private organization in history. It would also be the largest experiment in organizational efficiency in history, with the livelihoods of millions of newly government-dependent citizens hanging in the balance. Wage Inflation Another issue is the wage, which several plans recommend should be (or average) $15 per hour. With the increasing focus on "living wages," it will not be long before program directors discover that $15 per hour goes far further in Alabama than Hawaii, and the tendency will be to equalize cost-of-living disparities up, further increasing already massive costs. Two other factors: both the CBPP and LEI plans fail to account for the potential disruption to existing businesses — mostly small businesses, the engine of economic growth in the United States — which will inevitably occur when workers earning less than $15 per hour leave their private sector jobs for higher-paying employment with job guarantee placement. At present, more than 40 million Americans earn less than the proposed guarantee wage of $15 per hour, which could trigger a major shift of the U.S. workforce away from private employment, on to public rolls. It would also effectively force small businesses to compete directly against the federal government on the labor market. Prone To Fraud Finally, a government operation as colossal as a federal jobs guarantee program would inevitably be vulnerable to both political corruption and private rent seeking. As proposed — and however well-intentioned — the federal jobs guarantee program would cost more in two years than the entire New Deal did (in 2018 dollars). Rejecting these proposals does not mean turning a blind eye toward the plight of the under- or unemployed. There is a vastly better way: not only far less costly, but more consistent with traditional American values and respectful of the full potential that unemployed, underemployed, and employers offer. We must allow labor markets to work without the fetters of artificial controls such as minimum wages, restrictive licensing, coercive collective bargaining agreements and others, thereby permitting market signals to allocate labor to their greatest possible social benefit.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC › Link- Jobs Guarantee › Link- 2NC

Aff ruins the economy

Ozimek 18 Adam Ozimek, 4-24-2018, "Yes, The Jobs Guarantee Is Absurd," Forbes,

I gather from my last post that people want me to say more about why a jobs guarantee program is absurd. I've written about this before (here, here, and here), and my main point in that post was really just to be clear about how ridiculous I thought the program was. But if readers want more they can have it. The jobs guarantees that are being proposed out there have two purposes: end involuntary unemployment and ending low wages. This is really important because some defenders of jobs guarantees simply focusing on their role in providing jobs for people who truly struggle to find work even in a healthy labor market, and for those who lose them for cyclical reasons. But the jobs guarantee proposals in both rhetoric and policy details are clear: these polices are meant to guarantee everyone a good job. In the CBPP proposal the authors list as one of the 3 main recommendations of their report "The elimination of poverty wages through the pay structure of the NIEC". Their goal is to create a floor in the labor market below which private employers will not go: "Since the job guarantee places a floor in the labor market, employers will likely have to offer compensation packages at least as desirable as those offered under the NIEC" In case there is any confusion, the authors don't mince words, warning readers that "Make no mistake, this is a policy to transform the U.S. labor market". And they're right! They recommend a minimum wage of $24,600 which they translate to a minimum hourly wage of $11.83. At a first pass, private employers simply won't be able to offer less than this if they want to hire anyone. But they also argue for inclusion of health benefits, and since this is a guaranteed job you presumably can't easily be fired from, it also includes the best job security you can get. What's more, that's just the minimum wage in this program, and they expect the average worker will make $32,500, which translates to a minimum hourly wage of $15,60. And that's just the average, not the peak! Shutterstock Shutterstock Despite these generous benefits, they estimate this program will only require hiring about 10 million workers, all of whom are currently unemployed. While they admit "the job guarantee may result in the displacement of some workers currently employed in the private sector, especially at the low end of the labor market", they minimize this risk by pointing to the minimum wage literature. As such, their cost estimates don't assume any crowd out of private employers. Does that sound reasonable to you? They believe their program will prompt tens of millions of employers to raise wages, but this won't cause any disemployment or crowd out at private employers. By their own estimate, their program "may result in a comparable change within the labor market" as a $15 minimum wage, which affects 41 million workers. To believe there would be no crowd out despite this massive change requires the assumption every low wage worker in this country has productivity high enough to justify a good paying job, but employers aren't paying it now. Usually, liberal commentators are quick to tell us how bad low wage jobs are in the U.S. not just by pay but by working conditions. Wage theft, unpredictable hours, abusive bosses, tenuous employment at will, lack of opportunities for advancement are all allegedly widespread features of the low-skilled labor market. Are we to believe that workers will not abandon these jobs in droves for guaranteed government employment with benefits, or that employers will change overnight? I think these criticisms of working conditions are often overblown, but at the very least you can certainly easily be fired from a private sector job and turnover is quite high, making a guaranteed job clearly nicer in that important regard. And yes, many low-skilled jobs are far from pleasant. The idea employers would and could universally raise wages, offer full benefits, and upgrade job quality to prevent crowd out strikes me as absurd. For many advocates I think this risk isn't worth worrying about because it's not much of a risk to them. If the job guarantee ends up with 20, 30, or 40 million instead of the 10 million they expect than that's not really a problem because massively expanding the size of government isn't really a big deal. But it would be. The first problem is you lose the output those workers were producing. In that sense, their production is nationalized quite like when the government takes over an industry, except in this case they are taking over the labor instead of the capital. What's more, when employers of low skilled workers go out of business this will also harm the high skilled workers they employ. The second problem is what this will do to the size of government. Righ now there are about 21 million federal, state, and local government workers in the U.S. By the authors' calculations, the 10 million more jobs would increase government employment by a whopping 50%. If only 10 million private sector jobs are crowded out it would double the size of government. We are going to put to work 50% to 100% more government workers than we already do, and we should expect that the bill will approximately double as well. This brings me to the issue of what all of these people will do. It's alleged that there is a ton of work for government workers to do that isn't being done. Here is my challenge to the people who claim this: first have all the police officers, teachers, and other public sector workers who are allowed to retire at age 55 do this work instead of retiring. If the work is too strenuous for a 55 to 65 year old, then I'm going to question how realistic it is to guarantee that literally anyone can do it. If you say is impossible given political constraints from the power of government employees, then perhaps this is a reason to worry about drastically expanding the scope of government employment. When it comes to what work these people will do, read Matt Bruenig's criticisms of the alleged work that people in this program will do. Matt deserves praise for doing what I argued that more liberals should be doing: criticizing the absurdity of this program instead of trying to hold up a very watered down version of it that doesn't actually do what advocates and now politicians are actually proposing. It's not crazy for the government to want to improve job quality widely. It is crazy to say you are going to do that by the government directly offering everyone a good job. Tweak the program all you want, trying to make every job a good job via this mechanism is going to per se be a radical and massive undertaking and a bad idea. Policies should focus on subsidizing private employment of low-skilled workers and the government spending money on boosting wages directly. Honestly the idea is so bad I find the fact that we have to actually debate it far more interesting than actually debating it. It's a bad sign about the state of ideas on the left today.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC › Link- Jobs Guarantee › Link- 2NC

The Job Guarantee Program will devastate the economy

Bourne 18 Ryan Bourne, 4-24-2018, "A Jobs Guaranteed Economic Disaster," Cato Institute,

Democrats are plugging new energy into an old idea: a federal “Jobs Guarantee” program. Senator Cory Booker previously introduced legislation for a pilot in high unemployment communities. Now Senator Bernie Sanders will announce a plan guaranteeing a job or training paying $15 an hour and health‐​care benefits to every American worker “who wants or needs one,” in a host of public infrastructure, care giving and environmental upkeep projects. The scheme, seemingly based on a recommendation from the Levy Economic Institute, comes with grandiose purported benefits. It would, we are told, eliminate involuntary unemployment, deliver a living wage, boost GDP, reduce the cost of recessions, raise labor market standards, reduce environmental degradation, reduce racial inequality, and much else besides. If it sounds too good to be true, that’s because it is. There are severe problems with this idea, which can be loosely grouped under three “c’s”: costs, crowd out and corruption. Costs The Levy Economic Institute calculates up to 16 million could take part in such a program today (including the unemployed, those working part time seeking full time work and individuals currently inactive who might move into the labor market). Given the federal government would have to pay $15 an hour for full time jobs, plus benefits equal to 20 percent of wages, total labor costs per worker would be $37,440 per year. That’s before the cost of the materials for the programs and administration of the program itself. Even assuming some opt for part‐​time positions, and ignoring the non‐​labor program costs, we are talking about a gross cost of up to around 2.4 percent of GDP, significantly higher than the existing Medicaid program (2 percent of GDP). The net cost on these assumptions will be lower, of course. People who take jobs will require less in welfare payments and pay some back in taxes. Some might wisely consider it a risk for their employment fortunes to be tied to the whims of politicians and their willingness to fund this program, and so remain in the private sector. But even taking this into account, and assuming the policy generates the macroeconomic bounty that the Levy researchers expect, they still think the annual net cost will be between 0.8 and 2 percent of GDP, with the program employing up to 10 percent of the workforce. That would in itself be a huge new commitment to finance at a time when the long‐​term fiscal outlook is already dire, and the short‐​term deficit already expected to balloon to over 5 percent of GDP in the coming years. Crowd‐​out In reality, the fiscal costs are likely to be much, much higher, and the economic welfare losses even more significant, because in the labor market and broader economy, a public jobs guarantee program would significantly crowd out productive private sector activity. This type of policy will radically alter behavior of both workers and businesses, and so the supply and demand for labor. The Census shows that, among those who worked in 2016, 70+ million Americans earned under $32,500 (the full‐​time job guarantee salary would be $31,200). Yes, not all of these would seek out positions on the jobs guarantee program. But a large proportion would, especially those employed in uncertain roles with low levels of job security. In fact, some even paid more than $31,200 might consider leaving their jobs to pursue guaranteed roles if they perceive better working conditions or an easier worklife (asked under what conditions someone would be fired from such a role, the Levy Institute paper suggests that you would be sacked for failing to go to work, but that your performance would not be judged by “private sector ‘efficiency criteria’”, for example.) It’s not inconceivable then that over 25 percent of the labor force could find itself part of the scheme. This crowd‐​out is likely to be particularly acute in low productivity regions, and (ironically) after economic downturns. A nationwide jobs guarantee program paying $15 an hour will be particularly attractive to workers in low wage regions, and by setting a de facto wage floor the program will prevent private investment in regions on the basis of cheap labor. Though no doubt there would be some demand spillovers from well‐​paid jobs, the net consequence is highly likely to be weaker private sector job creation in poor regions, which has been the experience of countries such as Britain with a nationwide minimum wages and public sector national pay bargaining. Proponents of the scheme see “higher labor standards” as a good thing, but absent productivity improvements, policies which raise labor costs significantly will reduce the quantity of workers demanded. There’s good reason to expect the policy will reduce the efficiency and productive potential of the economy too. Taxes will eventually need to be raised to cover the net cost of the program. In infrastructure and care giving provision, costs will rise – because nobody would now work in these directly substitutable sectors for less than the wage and conditions offered in the job guarantee program. This will waste resources, and there’s highly likely to be overinvestment in lots of relatively low value ventures and programs to ensure workers are employed, especially given the explicit aim is to provide employment rather than deliver projects at low cost. Throwing resources at regions with higher levels of unemployment and after recessions too will work directly against market signals and deter the mobility of labor (in geographic and industrial terms) and capital to its most productive uses given prevailing market conditions. This is important: yes, employment is highly likely to have some positive externalities; but the real driver of better living standards over time are productivity improvements, discovered by market‐​based activity. Proponents of this policy seem to put an enormous weight on the idea that time out of the labor market has huge scarring consequences which could be ameliorated by any type of temporary employment. But the literature on this shows that temporary jobs do not provide the workers with skills to improve longer‐​term labor market outcomes. Corruption and incentives As if all these consequences were not bad enough, such a program will be ripe for corruption and political interference at the government, provider and individual level. Senator Sanders’ plan would be administered by the Department for Labor, with local and state governments submitting projects to regional offices for consideration. There’s a huge question mark on whether projects will be considered on economic grounds, when there might be an incentive for make‐​work schemes to aid particular politicians or indeed to put resources towards “public good” causes or NGOs more in line with the ethos of the governing party. For Democrats this might be for environmental issues. For Republicans it might be, say, for a wall on the southern border. NGOs and local public bodies themselves will have incentives to apply for federal funds for projects that would otherwise have occurred anyway, and to maximize the number of applications. Pork barrel projects would proliferate. What is more, at the individual level, the guarantee coupled with the purported unwillingness to judge worker performance on a commercial basis will incentivize low levels of work effort on the margin. Conclusion The Jobs Guarantee then is an extremely large and costly endeavor, which would have major economic consequences and risk a large federal politicization of the labor market and public project delivery. The US does have serious labor market issues to contend with — not least depressed labor participation and a weak productivity outlook — but are things really so bad that they require such a risky and extensive policy response? Well‐​paid jobs and low levels of real unemployment are outcomes desired by all. But attempting to achieve that through this program amounts to cracking a nut with a sledgehammer, undermining what matters far more for living standards: efficiency and productivity.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC › UQ- Economy › UQ- Confidence High/Moderate-2NC

Businesses confidence lowers, but remain optimistic, even following concerns of a recession

Medsger 4-10 Matthew Medsger, 04-10-23, "Business confidence slips but remains positive as signs of recession ease," Boston Herald, https://www.bostonherald.com/2023/04/10/business-confidence-slips-but-remains-positive-as-signs-of-recession-ease/

Confidence among the state’s employers saw a downturn in March, reversing slight gains seen in February and following the failure of several banks and while inflation continues to push prices and wages higher. “Business confidence fell precariously close to pessimistic territory during March as Massachusetts employers managed challenges ranging from inflation to rising interest rates to banking disruptions,” the Associated Industries of Massachusetts wrote in their March Business Confidence Index. According to the survey of Bay State employers, confidence fell from February to March by a full 2-points, slipping from 53.5% confidence to 51.5%. According to AIM’s math, that means businesses are feeling optimistic, but just barely, and that’s the lowest confidence the index has shown since October of last year. Sara Johnson, who chairs AIM’s board of economic advisors, said with the release of the index that improving economic activity elsewhere can account for retreating fears of a looming recession but that the index still shows employers are facing too tough a market for talent. “At the global level, we see recession averted, thanks to solid growth in mainland China and the emerging markets of Asia Pacific. The US economy had a strong start to 2023, but tightening financial conditions could undermine growth over the remainder of the year. Labor market conditions remain tight, keeping inflation above central bank targets in the US and Western Europe,” she said. This comes on the heels of nearly benchmark labor numbers for March — the Bureau of Labor Statistics says the nation gained 236,000 jobs, about 3,000 less than was forecast — and while the Biden Administration celebrated historically low unemployment numbers. “My economic agenda has powered an historic economic recovery. We’ve created 12.6 million jobs since I took office. The unemployment rate is close to the lowest it has been in more than 50 years and a record low for African Americans,” President Joe Biden said in a statement provided by the White House following the Friday release of the jobs report. That low unemployment rate is not helping employers when it’s time to find workers, a problem that has persisted for those businesses surveyed in AIM’s monthly index for most of the last year and which the association says is forcing companies “to scour a tight labor market for qualified workers.” AIM surveys more than 140 Bay State businesses to produce their monthly index, which they have published for more than three decades. According to AIM, business confidence hit historic highs in 1997 and 1998, with two months in either year showing 68.5% confidence, and hit a low in February of 2009, when it was 33.3%.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC › UQ- Economy › UQ- Economy- 2NC

US economy is in a precarious position. Any misstep- especially with unemployment- could tip the scales

Bachman 3-15 Daniel Bachman, 3-15-2023, "United States Economic Forecast Q1 2023," Deloitte Insights, https://www2.deloitte.com/us/en/insights/economy/us-economic-forecast/united-states-outlook-analysis.html

A potential “soft landing” for the US economy might just be in sight. The end-of-year decline in retail sales and industrial production were reminders that the economy is slowing, but January saw signs that the economy might still be growing too fast for the Fed’s liking.1 Some additional obstacles have appeared on the runway, however. Deloitte’s economic forecast remains optimistic but takes into account some very significant risks for the next year. Four key problems need to be solved for the economy to continue to grow: Labor markets need to loosen up. January 2023 saw employment rise by over half a million. That’s simply unsustainable when the working-age population is growing at a trend rate of about 50,000 per month. If employment doesn’t slow, wage growth could accelerate. The Fed would then respond very strongly, and continued interest rate hikes pose a clear danger for economic growth. The Fed raised interest rates quickly in 2022, and some impact of those interest rate hikes could show up in 2023. We still don’t know if the Fed was too aggressive in 2022. Deloitte’s baseline assumes that the impact of the rise in interest rates so far is not enough to push the economy into recession. Congress needs to vote to raise the debt ceiling. If it doesn’t do so, the US Treasury may be unable to pay its bills, which might lead to a drop in spending and, more importantly, severe financial market volatility (see the sidebar, “The looming debt ceiling problem”). Congress and the President need to agree on a budget for the federal government by October 1. The budget takes the form of 12 appropriations bills. A failure to pass and sign all of these appropriations bills by October 1 would lead to a decline in government spending. This is not likely enough to create a recession on its own, but it would certainly add to business uncertainty. Learn more Learn how to combat COVID-19 with resilience Explore the Economics collection Learn about Deloitte's services Go straight to smart. Get the Deloitte Insights app Observers of the US economy need to remember that there are two separate budget problems: the need to raise the debt ceiling and the need to pass appropriation bills to fund the government. Policymakers may connect them for political reasons; one possibility is a short-term debt ceiling hike in June to allow for a negotiation over them to be tied together. But that may not happen. In any event, current political arrangements, combined with must-pass legislation, pose a significant risk to US economic activity. Currently, however, the US economy is surprisingly healthy, given that it is coming off of a global pandemic, severe supply chain issues, and a war affecting a key global energy supplier. Labor market conditions alone provide a lot of support for the idea that the economy can achieve the desired soft landing (and, despite claims to the contrary, soft landings are not that unusual).2 Inflation remains a concern, but much less of one than it was a year ago. As long as US policymakers can avoid any damaging policy moves, like not lifting the debt ceiling, the signs are good that—after a few quarters of slow growth—the US economy will continue to innovate and create jobs, goods, and services. Scenarios Baseline (60%): Economic growth slows to a crawl in 2023, but never really declines enough to merit the label of recession. Tighter monetary policy, slow growth in Europe and China, higher energy prices, and an expensive dollar are significant headwinds for the economy. However, households continue to increase spending on pent-up demand for services such as entertainment and travel. Business investment continues to grow, particularly in information-processing equipment and software. Investment in nonresidential structures remains weak, however, as the oversupply of office buildings and retail space weighs on the market. And the housing market slump really is a recession for that sector. Inflation settles back to the 2% range by late 2023 as demand for goods slows and businesses solve their supply chain issues. Inflation comes back (10%): The decline in inflation due to slackening supply chain pressures proves to be temporary. Continued strength in the labor market pushes wages up, leading to higher costs and prices. The Fed, having attempted to slow inflation through shock therapy in 2022, proves reluctant or unable to slow the hot labor market enough to matter, and inflation settles in at about 6%. Nominal interest rates reach levels that would have been punishing just a few years ago, but economic activity remains relatively strong. The next recession (30%): The Fed’s focus on inflation leads it to minimize risks to the economy until it’s too late. On top of that financial shock, US authorities fail to come to a timely agreement on the debt ceiling and the 2024 budget. Although the financial shock is smaller than in 2008, the already weak economy contracts a substantial 2.7% by the end of 2023. The unemployment rate rises to over 5%, which alleviates some—but not all—of the pressure on the job market. The shock causes Congress and the President to focus on a budget solution, and the Fed to moderate policy. The economy bounces back in 2024.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC › UQ- Economy › UQ- Economy- 2NC

US economy has slowed growth, but aff causes disruption that pushes us over the brink into a recession

Casselman 4-27 Ben Casselman, 4-27-2023, "U.S. Economy Continues to Grow, but More Slowly," No Publication, https://www.nytimes.com/2023/04/27/business/economy/gdp-q1-economy.html

The housing market is slowing. Businesses are pulling back on hiring and investment. But American consumers are keeping the economy out of a recession — at least for now. Gross domestic product, adjusted for inflation, rose at a 1.1 percent annual rate in the first quarter, according to preliminary data released by the Commerce Department on Thursday. That was down from a 2.6 percent rate in the last three months of 2022 but nonetheless a third straight quarter of growth after output declined in the first half of last year. The Federal Reserve’s efforts to cool off the economy are having an effect. The housing sector shrank for the eighth consecutive quarter, and business investment in equipment fell for the second quarter in a row. Both areas are heavily influenced by interest rates, which policymakers have raised repeatedly over the past year to tamp down inflation. But those declines were more than offset by robust spending by consumers, which rose at an annual rate of 3.7 percent, the fastest growth since mid-2021, when the Covid-19 vaccine rollout lifted the economy. Consumers have been buoyed by a strong job market and rising wages, which have helped them weather the combination of rising prices and higher borrowing costs. “You never want to bet against the U.S. consumer is what you learn over and over again,” said Stephen Juneau, an economist at Bank of America. Spending on services such as travel and restaurant meals continued to rebound from pandemic lows, and spending on goods also rose after four straight quarters of declines.

Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis By The New York Times

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Economy DA – UTNIF – Starter Packet › 1NC › Shell- Business Confidence- 1NC

Economic crises lead to global wars

Liu 18 Qian Liu, 11-13-2018, "The next economic crisis could cause a global conflict. Here's why," World Economic Forum,

The response to the 2008 economic crisis has relied far too much on monetary stimulus, in the form of quantitative easing and near-zero (or even negative) interest rates, and included far too little structural reform. This means that the next crisis could come soon – and pave the way for a large-scale military conflict. BEIJING – The next economic crisis is closer than you think. But what you should really worry about is what comes after: in the current social, political, and technological landscape, a prolonged economic crisis, combined with rising income inequality, could well escalate into a major global military conflict. spence161_SAUL LOEBAFP via Getty Images_semiconductor industrial policy Politics 1 In Defense of Industrial Policy MICHAEL SPENCE justifies government intervention to alter market outcomes – and explains the right way to go about it. The 2008-09 global financial crisis almost bankrupted governments and caused systemic collapse. Policymakers managed to pull the global economy back from the brink, using massive monetary stimulus, including quantitative easing and near-zero (or even negative) interest rates. But monetary stimulus is like an adrenaline shot to jump-start an arrested heart; it can revive the patient, but it does nothing to cure the disease. Treating a sick economy requires structural reforms, which can cover everything from financial and labor markets to tax systems, fertility patterns, and education policies. Policymakers have utterly failed to pursue such reforms, despite promising to do so. Instead, they have remained preoccupied with politics. From Italy to Germany, forming and sustaining governments now seems to take more time than actual governing. And Greece, for example, has relied on money from international creditors to keep its head (barely) above water, rather than genuinely reforming its pension system or improving its business environment. The lack of structural reform has meant that the unprecedented excess liquidity that central banks injected into their economies was not allocated to its most efficient uses. Instead, it raised global asset prices to levels even higher than those prevailing before 2008. In the United States, housing prices are now 8% higher than they were at the peak of the property bubble in 2006, according to the property website Zillow. The price-to-earnings (CAPE) ratio, which measures whether stock-market prices are within a reasonable range, is now higher than it was both in 2008 and at the start of the Great Depression in 1929. Digital Only Subscribe to PS Digital Access every new PS commentary, our entire On Point suite of subscriber-exclusive content – including Longer Reads, Insider Interviews, Big Picture/Big Question, and Say More – and the full PS archive. SUBSCRIBE NOW As monetary tightening reveals the vulnerabilities in the real economy, the collapse of asset-price bubbles will trigger another economic crisis – one that could be even more severe than the last, because we have built up a tolerance to our strongest macroeconomic medications. A decade of regular adrenaline shots, in the form of ultra-low interest rates and unconventional monetary policies, has severely depleted their power to stabilize and stimulate the economy. If history is any guide, the consequences of this mistake could extend far beyond the economy. According to Harvard’s Benjamin Friedman, prolonged periods of economic distress have been characterized also by public antipathy toward minority groups or foreign countries – attitudes that can help to fuel unrest, terrorism, or even war. For example, during the Great Depression, US President Herbert Hoover signed the 1930 Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act, intended to protect American workers and farmers from foreign competition. In the subsequent five years, global trade shrank by two-thirds. Within a decade, World War II had begun. To be sure, WWII, like World War I, was caused by a multitude of factors; there is no standard path to war. But there is reason to believe that high levels of inequality can play a significant role in stoking conflict. According to research by the economist Thomas Piketty, a spike in income inequality is often followed by a great crisis. Income inequality then declines for a while, before rising again, until a new peak – and a new disaster. Though causality has yet to be proven, given the limited number of data points, this correlation should not be taken lightly, especially with wealth and income inequality at historically high levels. This is all the more worrying in view of the numerous other factors stoking social unrest and diplomatic tension, including technological disruption, a record-breaking migration crisis, anxiety over globalization, political polarization, and rising nationalism. All are symptoms of failed policies that could turn out to be trigger points for a future crisis. Voters have good reason to be frustrated, but the emotionally appealing populists to whom they are increasingly giving their support are offering ill-advised solutions that will only make matters worse. For example, despite the world’s unprecedented interconnectedness, multilateralism is increasingly being eschewed, as countries – most notably, Donald Trump’s US – pursue unilateral, isolationist policies. Meanwhile, proxy wars are raging in Syria and Yemen. Against this background, we must take seriously the possibility that the next economic crisis could lead to a large-scale military confrontation. By the logic of the political scientist Samuel Huntington , considering such a scenario could help us avoid it, because it would force us to take action. In this case, the key will be for policymakers to pursue the structural reforms that they have long promised, while replacing finger-pointing and antagonism with a sensible and respectful global dialogue. The alternative may well be global conflagration.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Economy DA – UTNIF – Starter Packet › 1NC › Shell- Business Confidence- 1NC

Low confidence kills economic growth- drives us into a recession

Elmassah 22 Suzanna Elmassah, 4-1-2022, "US consumers' confidence and responses to COVID-19 shock," Emerald Insight, https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/REPS-10-2021-0098/full/html

Nevertheless, academics and policymakers agree that the erosion of confidence ensured the longevity and depth of crises (Valášková and Klieštik, 2015). Social scientists believe that a sufficient level of confidence is crucial for stabilizing and maintaining the social, political and economic systems (Roth, 2009). Periods of high political or economic instability are commonly related to significant consumer confidence fluctuations that result in high variations in consumption patterns. Moreover, consumers' willingness to consume and purchase is adversely affected by uncertainty (Acemoglu and Scott, 1994). Therefore, the negative impact of heightened uncertainty on consumption levels, even if the consumer's financial status is unchanged, can cause a decrease in consumption. Since 1978, the US has faced numerous major crises and incidents that have broadly influenced the country's political and economic performance and worsened consumer confidence. For example, the US economy witnessed a severe recession in the early 1980s triggered by the Federal Reserve's disinflationary fiscal policy, followed by the impact of the Iraqi attack to Kuwait in 1990 (Garner, 1981), the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001 (Witte, 2014), and the financial crisis emerging from the growth of high-risk loans between 2007 and 2010 which resulted in the worst economic crisis since the Great Depression (Ellis, 2009). Recently, the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic is considered the latest and most widely spreading global shock. It started from China in the last quarter of 2019 and quickly spread worldwide. By September 2020, the number of confirmed cases worldwide was more than 34 m, with more than 984,000 confirmed deaths (WHO, 2020). Since there was no effective cure or vaccine available, many regions implemented partial or complete lockdown in the affected areas to minimize the spread of the virus, which have badly affected economies internationally. It is estimated that the pandemic reduced global economic growth in 2020 to an annualized rate of about −3.2%. The US economy has been adversely hit by this pandemic, with a 3.4% drop in its growth rate in 2020 compared to the previous year (Jackson et al., 2021). In 2020, the number of COVID-19 cases in the US increased sharply from mid-March and then started to decline at the beginning of April as a result of the impact of strict public health measures such as stay-at-home and social distancing restrictions. Yet, as the strict public health measures were gradually lifted on a state-by-state basis, cases began to rise, reaching a countrywide high in July 2020 and then started to gradually decrease. The number of infections started to rise again in October and reached its highest peak in mid-December 2020 (Figure 1). Although it is difficult to explain the main reason of rising cases, one contributing factor has been the return to school for US students. At the time of writing, the US has over 6.8 m confirmed COVID-19 cases, with over 200,000 deaths by the same period (WHO, 2020). The lockdown measures have negatively affected the US economy where millions of Americans lost their jobs and incomes. The Pew Research Center survey conducted in August 2020 found that Americans who have experienced job or wage loss (either personally or in their household) due to COVID-19 had difficulties to pay their bills, rent or mortgage, used money from their savings or borrowed money from family or friends (Parker et al., 2020). Accordingly, personal consumption expenditure has been affected by this lockdown and partial business closures, in addition to the spread of the COVID-19. The pandemic has in fact provoked a dramatic shift in consumer confidence and behaviors. Overall, US consumers seemed to have adjusted to pandemic restrictions by relying on unemployment benefits, personal savings and credit to sustain their consumption activities (Kobayashi et al., 2020; WHO, 2020). The recovery from COVID-19 crisis will happen when consumers regain sufficient confidence to increase their effective demand significantly. The present erosion of consumer confidence may make trust more critical than ever before, necessitating effective policies targeting confidence-building through different channels.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Economy DA – UTNIF – Starter Packet › 1NC › Shell- Business Confidence- 1NC

Even negative talk about Federal Jobs Guarantee guts confidence

Barkin 19 Barkin, Tom. “Confidence, Expectations and Implications for Monetary Policy.” Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond, 11 July 2019, www.richmondfed.org/press_room/speeches/thomas_i_barkin/2019/barkin_speech_20190711.

In addition, the business reaction function has gotten faster. Short-termism has increased as activism in the market for corporate control has shifted companies’ focus. Just as with consumers, I think firms’ resilience is down. They start with lower confidence—another “hangover” from the Great Recession. At the same time, businesspeople tell me the length of the current upturn makes them nervous that another recession might be right around the corner. The speed of the reaction function may be exacerbated by higher leverage. Corporate debt as a percentage of GDP is at an all-time high. Levered companies—and their creditors—have a bias toward taking action on negative news. This can mean cutting costs, reducing staff or pricing for volume. Taken together, all these factors lead to an asymmetry in which firms are much more cautious about the downside than they are optimistic about the upside. Perhaps both consumers and businesses have a higher bar for spending decisions. It’s possible that some of the tepid recovery from the Great Recession was a self-fulfilling lack of belief in the strength of the economy. Firms’ fear of failure could have prevented them from making investments even in the presence of reasonable returns. This negative tilt, or asymmetry, continues today. Firms are frustrated with political polarization and uncertainty about trade and regulation. This limits their pricing courage and caps the upside on their spending and investment decisions. For these reasons, a drop in confidence could lead to lower investment, lower output and eventually lower employment. If employment is placed at risk, consumption won’t be far behind. And that would place us in more serious difficulty. Put another way, I don’t discount the idea that we could talk ourselves into a recession.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Economy DA – UTNIF – Starter Packet › 1NC › Shell- Business Confidence- 1NC

Business confidence rises, but is still cause for concern

Rogers 5-4 Kate Rogers, 5-4-2023, “Small business confidence rises slightly, but inflation, economic concerns dim outlook,” CNBC,

Optimism has ticked up on Main Street, according to the latest quarterly small business survey from CNBC and SurveyMonkey, but many business owners still have a negative view of the economy. Inflation, labor and supply chain disruptions remain the top three risks, with higher prices far and away the No. 1 concern. In the wake of the collapse of several regional banks, roughly half of small businesses lack confidence in the banking system. Inflation top concern for small business owners, new CNBC survey finds WATCH NOW VIDEO01:03 Inflation top concern for small business owners, new CNBC survey finds While the mood on Main Street has brightened, concerns about the economy, stubborn inflation and the banking system are weighing on small business owners, according to the latest quarterly survey from CNBC and Momentive. Small business confidence for the second quarter rose slightly to 46 from 45 in the first quarter, though that still remains below the baseline for optimism. Forty percent of owners describe their current business conditions as good, up from 34% in the first quarter and nearly half (46%) say they project revenue to increase in the next year. But just 21% say they’d describe the economy as good or excellent — less than half of those that described the economy as “poor” (44%), as challenges continue with inflation and the ongoing labor crunch. The CNBC|SurveyMonkey Small Business Survey was conducted from April 17 through April 24 among more than 2,200 small business owners across the country using Momentive’s platform. Inflation remains the No. 1 concern The top issue for owners is inflation, with 91% expressing worry about price pressures and 41% saying it is their No. 1 concern. Less than a third of owners polled say they have confidence in the Federal Reserve — which raised rates again on Wednesday but signaled a pause may be ahead — to control inflation, unchanged from last quarter. The labor shortage and supply chain disruptions round out the top three concerns for Main Street in the survey. Inflation is proving stubborn based on the latest economic data and has been an ongoing concern for Bill Belknap, president of AEONRG, a construction company based in Downingtown, Pennsylvania. Belknap works in government contracting and said higher inflation rates impact his bidding prices. He’s happy to see the progress made in inflation coming down over the last year but would like to see the trajectory continue. “I would hope that we would get back down to the 2% to 3% interest rates as a goal for all of us, which would greatly help our predictability of being able to propose [bids]” he said. “What I see is a snowball effect with increased inflation unpredictability, with other people raising their prices … having that moderation and predictability is very significant to us achieving success.” Banking crisis, higher rates weigh With the collapse of regional banks Silicon Valley Bank, Signature Bank and First Republic, the safety of banks and the ability to access capital is also on the minds of small business owners. More than 60% say they are banking with community or regional banks, and the survey shows owners are split evenly between those who express confidence in America’s banking system and those who do not. The majority of owners polled say they are confident their business capital is secure, but almost half say it isn’t easy for them to access capital to operate. For some, the lending environment is beginning to shift, but the movement started prior to the latest banking collapses. Mitchel Sellers, who runs Iowa Computer Gurus in Des Moines, Iowa, and has been in business for 17 years, says while he hasn’t been turned down for a loan recently, he is being asked for more information during the application process. “It is a tightening where banks are asking more questions, and it’s becoming harder to get loans,” Sellers said. “I believe business development is being stifled because of interest rate raises. We aren’t expanding in ways that I would want to because I have to pay 6.5% interest on a loan that a year ago I would have paid 3% on. So that is limiting my development and our ability to expand.” Even before the Fed took its benchmark rate to a target range of 5% to 5.25% on Wednesday, many business loans were firmly above the double-digit percentage mark when factoring in the SBA loan market prime rate of 8% in April. Fed Chair Jerome Powell: Cooling labor market points to possibility of avoiding recessionWATCH NOW VIDEO02:36 Fed Chair Jerome Powell: Cooling labor market points to possibility of avoiding recession The higher interest rate environment is showing up in the latest polling from the National Federation of Independent Business, which tracked a sentiment decline for the month of March and a sharp drop in the ability to get a loan. This is a dynamic that Roth MKM analysts say is “unseen” outside of or prior to recessions. Fed Chair Jerome Powell said on Wednesday afternoon that he continues to believe a soft landing is possible for the economy, but hedged his words adding that a “mild recession” is also possible. Fed staffers’ position has been to expect a mild recession. Sellers said the environment is informing the moves he makes next for his business. “We are hedging our bets by making sure that some of the things that we don’t use, like a line of credit that we haven’t used in eight years, we retain simply so that if I need it in the future I don’t have to get approved again,” he said. “So we’ve not been told ‘no,’ but it is definitely a fear and a reason why we are making very strategic decisions to not take certain growth opportunities … because I wouldn’t want to not be able to finance or adjust or get the working capital we might need in the future.”

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Economy DA – UTNIF – Starter Packet › 1NC › Shell- General- 1NC

US economic decline ripples, creating global fragmentation- threatening the global economy with widespread famine, poverty, political instability, and inevitable conflict

Schneyder 23 Alban Schneyder, 1-27-2023, "Fighting the recession to avoid fragmentation of the world," Le Cercle des économistes, https://lecercledeseconomistes.fr/en/fighting-the-recession-to-avoid-fragmentation-of-the-world/

As international institutions predict an economic slowdown in 2023, Gayle Smith warns of the risks of a recession in developed and developing countries. Fragmentation of the world, increase of extreme poverty and famine, decrease of development aid… Gayle Smith advocates a modernization of development banks and a bold solution to the emerging countries’ debt problem. A paper written for the Rencontres Économiques de Washington. If we fail to act to divert a global recession – or simply fail to help insulate the world’s low- and middle-income countries from the consequences of such a recession – we risk the creation of two separate economies serving different populations, rather than a single global economy for all of the world’s people. Young people faced with yet another global recession – the third in less than twenty years – will not draw the same conclusions about the world that their counterparts did in the aftermath of the Second World War, which ushered in a new era of stability and global cooperation. Instead, today’s youth will continue to lose faith in an international system that they have reasonably concluded does not represent their values, interests or futures. That is precisely why discussions about the future of the global economy cannot be limited to the wellbeing of high-income states, but must also include low- and middle-income countries and the young people who now represent almost 25% of the world’s population. A decline in poorer countries would threaten developed countries And there’s another reason to think holistically, and tackle managing the global economy by looking beyond just its top G20 economies. It is neither modern nor wise to regard these countries as irrelevant to the global economy other than as perpetual recipients of assistance – and any stated belief in equity would suggest as much. What is being overlooked is that these countries are potential net contributors to the global economy – if the world has the wisdom to make the investments needed. Unlike wealthier countries that have been able to turn to central banks, stimulus spending and supplemental budgets to dampen the effects of the global pandemic, previous recessions, and the fallout from the Russian invasion of Ukraine, poorer countries lack the access to the capital that can provide that kind of resilience. Even before the pandemic, finances in low-and middle-income nations were tight, and debt was high. And now, years later, skyrocketing food and energy prices – coupled with increased global interest rates – have stretched budgets even further. Sixty percent of low-income countries are now at risk of acute debt distress. Individually the collapse of these relatively small economies poses little risk to the global economy. But their collective decline would represent a major threat to global political stability and to the broader global economy which cannot be ignored. More than 600 million people living with food insecurity This is to say nothing of the human suffering that is already increasing in the face of widespread economic decline. Already today, there are more than 600 million people living with food insecurity, and since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, 72 million more people have joined their ranks. We’re witnessing the first increase in extreme poverty in 25 years, and net losses in recent past gains in health and education. To make matters worse, a global economic downturn will lead many of the world’s major donors to slash foreign aid budgets in order to avoid cuts to more domestically focused, politically sensitive programs. These cuts will have a cascading effect on low-and middle-income countries, worsening already tenuous economic and humanitarian situations around the world. The social and developmental consequences of a global recession are clear and alarming. Fortunately, the courses of action most likely to avert these consequences are equally apparent. Reinventing multilateral institutions The most impactful move world leaders could make would be to reimagine and modernize the world’s multilateral development banks by enacting the five recommendations of the Capital Adequacy Framework report, which could yield the capital needed to build the resilience that poorer countries need to reduce their increasing vulnerability to exogenous shocks, including a global recession. These changes could unlock between $400 billion and one trillion dollars in urgently needed capital. At the same time, world leaders can tackle a looming debt crisis and avoid another, long-term economic catastrophe. Revitalizing the Common Framework and the Debt Service Suspension Initiative are important steps, but a bigger and bolder solution – along the lines of HIPC – will likely also be needed. This time around it will be harder – the debt composition and the politics are more complex, and the underlying causes of recurrent debt crises have not, as yet, been addressed. But managing a global economy buffeted by crisis and inaction will ultimately prove more difficult and more expensive.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Economy DA – UTNIF – Starter Packet › 1NC › Shell- General- 1NC

Further economic strains will trigger a deep recession instead of a slight business-cycle slowdown

Zar 5-11 Jenna Zar, 05-11-2023 , "Consumer-led economic slowdown to hit the US," Economist Intelligence Unit, https://www.eiu.com/n/consumer-led-economic-slowdown-to-hit-the-us/

US economic data sent mixed signals throughout the first quarter of 2023. These mixed signals suggest that the US economy is at a turning point, coming out of a year of robust, but unsustainable, growth in 2022 and heading into a slowdown. Although downside risks persist, this will feel more like a business-cycle slowdown than a typical recession, followed by a modest recovery in 2024. Early signs of consumer strain are appearing For now, consumer spending remains the strong point of the US economy. However, this will slow more noticeably in the second quarter and contract slightly in the third as prices remain high and the full weight of monetary tightening over the last year comes to bear. The report highlights several economic indicators that are starting to weaken—including the savings rate, credit-card balances and loan delinquencies—suggesting that this consumer-led slowdown may be on the way. What does this mean for economic growth? Real private consumption surged by 3.7% quarter on quarter (annualised) in the first quarter of 2023. This helped to support real GDP growth of 1.1% in the first quarter, despite a steep decline in private inventories. However, even this story was mixed. Strong consumption growth in the first quarter was really a January story. A jump in real incomes at the start of 2023, together with still-low unemployment, helped to drive consumer spending. This had already started to taper off in February and March, and we do not expect this pace of growth to continue into the second quarter.” CAILIN BIRCH, GLOBAL ECONOMIST AND LEAD US ANALYST, EIU Manufacturing indices have been softening for several months, although the impact of this on overall GDP has thus far been offset by continued consumer demand. The two sectors will likely turn down in tandem in the coming months. The Fed has reached the end of its tightening cycle Previously expectations were for the Fed to raise interest rates a final time in June 2023. However, the failure of a third mid-size US bank in May and the looming debt-ceiling deadline in June mean that the Fed is likely to pause its tightening cycle for now.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Economy DA – UTNIF – Starter Packet › 1NC › Shell- General- 1NC

Federal Jobs Guarantee Program doesn’t address current issues with unemployment and will only make them worse

Bhandari 19 Ryan Bhandari, 3-25-2019, "What is the “Federal Jobs Guarantee” and What are People Saying About It?”, No Publication,

An idea that is sure to get attention during the 2020 primaries is “a guaranteed federal job,” a proposal The New York Times noted was “a big idea from a bygone era.”1 It’s easy to see why people are interested in ideas that help people earn a good life, but how would this specific policy work in practice and what kind of effect would it have overall on the economy? Some, like Stony Brook University Professor Stephanie Kelton, a former advisor to Senator Bernie Sanders and proponent of the federal jobs guarantee, argue that bringing millions more into guaranteed federal jobs would lead to more buying power and contend that “it’s clear the economy as a whole does far better, and that means that the private sector does far better.” Yet, that opinion is far from universal. Others, like Annie Lowery in The Atlantic, approach the idea with a healthy skepticism: “But guaranteeing every American a job means ... finding work for people in every town in half a continent. It means accommodating the homeless, the violent, the drug addicted, and the illiterate in the workforce. It means expanding the Department of Labor to become something like the size of the Department of Defense…. It is a trillion-dollar logistical puzzle, wrapped in a politically fraught stimulus effort, inside an experimental economic enigma. And none of these proposals quite know how to solve it.” In this memo, we unpack the policy and lay out five concerns that potential supporters should be aware of. What is the federal jobs guarantee? A federal jobs guarantee is as simple as it sounds on the surface: everyone in the country will be guaranteed a job by the US government should they desire one. There are two versions right now gaining attention. One plan is written by academics Mark Paul, Sandy Darity, and Darrick Hamilton. The other was written by Pavlina Tcherneva. In general, these plans promise: Guaranteed jobs in infrastructure repair, ecological restoration, caregiving, and community development projects. Benefits like health insurance, paid sick leave/vacation, and retirement plans. Control for state and local governments that will decide which kinds of jobs to create. A reduced uptake of welfare programs and unemployment insurance as well as decreased criminal justice costs. The key difference between the two plans is the minimum wage for the new jobs. The Tcherneva plan establishes a $15 minimum wage and the Paul et al. plan calls for an $11.80 minimum wage for all federally guaranteed jobs. Yet, both have the same underlying goal: Permanently solve the problem of involuntary unemployment by making the federal government the employer of last resort. What are the Concerns? Ensuring people have the opportunity to work and earn a good life is a shared value across the country. But, the federal jobs guarantee approach raises a number of concerns. And voters seem to be wary of it. In our polling, only 9% support a new program that guarantees a full-time government job—36 points less than those who support a new program where government works with business to create more good-paying jobs in the private sector. Among just Democrats, the divide was starker: 14% support a federal jobs guarantee while 59% want government to work with business to create private sector jobs. Politics aside, the federal jobs guarantee raises five substantive concerns. #1: It solves a different problem. Right now there are over seven million open jobs and six million unemployed people. Yet, many of these jobs are going unfilled. Why? Many people don’t have the right mix of skills or training. New jobs are often in different places than old ones. Childcare and transportation are often prohibitively expensive. And others struggle with opioid addiction and other conditions. And yet, a federal jobs guarantee doesn’t address any of this. Even during economic downturns, there are better and far more efficient ways to help workers and communities such as targeted public works programs, hiring credits for employers, temporary tax cuts for working families, extended unemployment insurance, and money to shore up state and local budgets. #2: The cost is enormous. A federal jobs guarantee will cost at least hundreds of billions of dollars per year and much more during a recession when the employment rolls for the government would naturally increase. Here are the cost estimates from both plans based on people participating in the jobs guarantee: 10 million people 15 million people Paul et al Plan $560 billion/year $840 billion/year Tcherneva Plan $468 billion/year $702 billion/year With annual federal outlays at roughly $4.5 trillion, we’re talking about anywhere from a 10-20% increase in spending to pay for the jobs guarantee. As for how to pay for it, advocates are split on whether it should be paid for at all. Paul et al. provide a few possible tax increases but don’t devote much attention to the matter. Stephanie Kelton says, “What the models show is you can do this without creating an inflation problem and therefore why would you pay for it with tax increases of one kind or another?”2Even though the cost of the program could be partially offset through decreasing social assistance costs, it’s still very uncertain how and when these savings would materialize. What we’re left with is a new program taking up funding that could be used instead for things like increased childcare, training support, expanded health care coverage, and more. #3: It could crowd out tens of millions of private sector jobs. There are currently 54 million people who earn $15 an hour or less. When they find out the federal government is offering $15 an hour plus benefits and permanent job security, many of those workers would quit their current job and join the federal workforce.3 Companies that could afford to would raise wages to keep some of these workers; other companies would simply go out of business. The labor markets would be controlled by the government in ways never seen before in America. And even if just half of low-wage private sector workers quit, the number of federal employees would rise by between 35 and 40 million.4 Costs to the government would then rise to anywhere from $1.6 trillion to $2.24 trillion per year, and the private sector would see massive repercussions. #4: Inflation would rise. A sudden increase in the cost of labor for businesses will lead to inflation throughout the economy because of higher business costs that will need to be passed on to consumers. In addition, when only those at the bottom of the income distribution get a defacto raise to $15, there are upstream consequences. Workers who were making $15 an hour may demand $20 an hour now. Workers making $20 an hour might want $25 an hour and so on. This may seem like a benefit, but “this is a story of serious wage-price spiral, unless we introduce other measures,” warns progressive economist Dean Baker.5 We have been very fortunate that inflation has been well under control for the last few decades. A federal jobs guarantee could change that pretty quickly. #5: It would be an administrative nightmare. Finally, matching millions of workers to the jobs envisioned under a jobs guarantee would be an administrative nightmare to implement. State and local governments will be tasked with finding the productive work to do, but how do we train millions of people to do these jobs? How does the Department of Labor oversee the millions of new jobs to make sure they’re legitimate? What are the qualifiers for the kind of work that’s eligible? What if a right-leaning state wants jobs done that a left-leaning federal government deems unproductive or socially unacceptable like building an oil pipeline or opening up a coal mine? Finally, how does the federal government fire workers who are guaranteed a job? Tcherneva argues that workers can be fired for not showing up or threatening the safety of others, but what about extremely poor performance? Conclusion The gravitational pull of a jobs guarantee is understandable. Uncertainty around job stability and the future of work has left many people very nervous. They don’t know when their next raise is going to be, and they don’t know if their job is going to exist ten years from now. Some on the political left believe the federal jobs guarantee provides comfort to voters by ensuring that anyone who wants a job will be provided one by the government. But behind this catchy slogan are a series of substantive issues that potential supporters should seriously consider.