Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Bomb Madagascar › NEG › 1NC

Natural Resources Boost The Economy

OECD 2011 (“THE ECONOMIC SIGNIFICANCE OF NATURAL RESOURCES: KEY POINTS FOR REFORMERS IN EASTERN EUROPE, CAUCASUS AND CENTRAL ASIA, accessed 7-1-23 https://www.oecd.org/env/outreach/2011_AB_Economic%20significance%20of%20NR%20in%20EECCA_ENG.pdf”)--DSP06

The wealth embodied in natural resources makes up a significant proportion of the wealth of most nations, often more than the wealth embodied in produced capital, therefore making natural resources management a key aspect of economic development (World Bank, 2006). Many countries have seen significant rises in revenues from natural resources due to the rise in commodity prices. Natural resources such as oil, gas, minerals and timber are expected to continue to play a significant role in resource abundant economies, as demand from rapidly growing economies increases, and as supplies of non-renewable resources decline and renewable resource harvests approach maximum sustained yield levels. Not surprisingly, countries richly endowed with natural capital have the potential to derive significant current income from resources. In addition to providing revenues to resources rich countries, natural resources can play a central role in poverty reduction efforts. The poor generally depend upon natural resources directly for their livelihoods, especially the rural poor. Consequently, policies that improve natural resources management can have immediate and meaningful poverty reduction impacts. Pro-poor natural resource management policies include, among others (OECD, 2008):

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Bomb Madagascar › NEG › 1NC

Madagascar is resource rich and corrupted

Joseph Kiprop 3-6-19 (Economics Journalist, “What are the Major Natural Resources Of Madagascar?, WorldAtlus accessed 7-1-23 https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/what-are-the-major-natural-resources-of-madagascar.html#:~:text=Madagascar%20is%20an%20African%20nation,classified%20as%20a%20developing%20economy.”)--DSP06

Madagascar is an African nation with a vast array of natural resources such as minerals, arable land, forests, fish, and the country's beautiful scenery. Despite Madagascar's enormous natural resources, the country is still classified as a developing economy. In 2018, according to data from the IMF, the Malagasy GDP was the 135th highest in the world at roughly $12.5 billion. The Malagasy economy is heavily reliant on the natural resources in the country. Fish One of Madagascar's essential natural resources is fish. Some of the common varieties of fish found in Madagascar's territorial waters include yellowfin tuna, black marlin, bonito, and sea bream. Fishing in Madagascar can be divided into three main categories, subsistence fishing, sports fishing, and commercial fishing. Most of the fishing in Madagascar takes place within the Indian Ocean. In Madagascar, subsistence fishing is mainly carried out by the local communities to supplement their diet. The subsistence fishermen in Madagascar rely primarily on traditional fishing methods such as spearing. The Malagasy fishermen also use smaller traditional vessels. Sports fishing in Madagascar is mainly carried out by visitors to the country. Some of Madagascar's most popular sports fishing areas include the Mitsio Archipelago and the Radama Archipelago. Mitsio Archipelago is popular with sports fishers because of its clear waters. Commercial fishing is one of Madagascar's essential economic activities. Madagascar's commercial fishing sector has attracted investment from foreign organization such as the EU. The Madagascan government allows the members of the EU to maintain a fleet of fishing ships in the country's territorial waters. The EU fleet in Madagascar is made up of fishing vessels from a variety of nations such as France, Spain, and Italy. The government of Madagascar has urged the country's fishermen to practice aquaculture to increase fish production in the country. Arable Land In 2016, according to data from the World Bank, arable land made up roughly 6% of the country's entire territory. The data indicated that from 1967 to 2016, the size of arable land in the country increased at an average rate of 1.15% each year. The increase in the size of arable land in Madagascar can be attributed to the importance of agriculture to the country's economy. In 2017, the Malagasy government estimated that the agriculture sector contributed approximately 24% of the country's GDP. Data from the Malagasy government also indicated that the majority of the country's labor force was involved in the agricultural sector. A 2010 study by the FAO indicated that there were roughly 2.4 million farms in Madagascar most of which were owned by small-scale farmers. Some of the most agriculturally productive areas in Madagascar are situated in the country's eastern edge as it receives relatively higher rainfall. Malagasy farmers grow a wide variety of crops such as sweet potatoes, maize, and coffee. Madagascar's agricultural sector faces several challenges such as over-reliance on traditional agricultural methods, poor infrastructure, and land fragmentation. Rice One of Madagascar's essential crops is rice which has been growing in the country for a long time. Rice in Madagascar is primarily grown to satisfy the local demand as it is one of the country's staple foods. The Betsielo Community is among some of the most famous rice growers in Madagascar. The Betsielo use the same rice growing techniques as communities in the Philippines and Singapore. The irrigation system that the Betsielo use is considered extremely efficient as it uses up almost all the water that is available. Another community in Madagascar which is famous for rice growing is the Merina community. Livestock Malagasy farmers keep a diverse array of livestock such as cattle, sheep, and pigs. The Malagasy government estimated that roughly 60% of the country's rural families were dependent on livestock to provide their income. In 2008, the Malagasy government estimated that the country was home to approximately 2 million goats and sheep and 10 million cows. In 2010, the FAO estimated that Madagascar produced roughly 250,000 tons of meat and more than 500,000 tons of milk. The Zebu is one of the most common breeds of cattle in the country. Malagasy farmers also keep large numbers of poultry, particularly chicken, with the government estimating that the sector produced roughly 19,000 tons of eggs. Forests In 2015, it was estimated that forests covered approximately 21.44% of Madagascar's land area and from 2005 to 2015, the size of Madagascar's land that was covered in forests decreased rapidly. There are several types of forests in Madagascar such as the lowland forests and dry deciduous forests. The lowland forests are home to a wide variety of trees such as the Dalbergia, Ocotea, and bamboo. A botanical study by the Malagasy government indicated that more than 80% of the trees in the lowland forests are endemic to the country. The lowland forests are also home to a wide variety of endemic animal species such as the lemur and the brown-tailed mongoose. Dry deciduous forests are mainly situated in the northern and western section of the country. The country's dry deciduous forests are considered among the most ecologically diverse in the world. Madagascar's forests face numerous challenges mainly from human activities such as logging, grazing, and burning. Minerals Madagascar has been blessed with a wide variety of minerals which play a critical role in the country’s economy. Some of Madagascar's most important minerals include gold, manganese, and copper. In 1904, it was estimated that Madagascar produced approximately 84,910 ounces of gold and in the following year, the quantity of gold produced in the country decreased to 76,197 ounces. Madagascar's mineral sector faces several challenges such as the country's insecurity and the low prices offered for the country's metals. Challenges That Face Madagascar's Economy Madagascar's economy faces several challenges such as the high rate of corruption in the country, insecurity, and the country's high poverty levels. In 2012 it was estimated that almost 78% of Madagascar's population lived below the poverty line. The Malagasy government has put in place several measures to reduce the poverty rate in the country and grow the country's economy.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Biotech › AFF › 2AC

Ethanol’s environmental benefits are FAKE

Leah Douglas 2/14/2022 (Washington-based award-winning journalist covering agriculture and energy; “U.S. corn-based ethanol worse for the climate than gasoline, study finds”; Reuters; Accessed 7/2/2023; https://www.reuters.com/business/environment/us-corn-based-ethanol-worse-climate-than-gasoline-study-finds-2022-02-14/) GH AB :(

Corn-based ethanol, which for years has been mixed in huge quantities into gasoline sold at U.S. pumps, is likely a much bigger contributor to global warming than straight gasoline, according to a study published Monday. The study, published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, contradicts previous research commissioned by the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) showing ethanol and other biofuels to be relatively green. President Joe Biden's administration is reviewing policies on biofuels as part of a broader effort to decarbonize the U.S. economy by 2050 to fight climate change. “Corn ethanol is not a climate-friendly fuel,” said Dr. Tyler Lark, assistant scientist at University of Wisconsin-Madison Center for Sustainability and the Global Environment and lead author of the study. The research, which was funded in part by the National Wildlife Federation and U.S. Department of Energy, found that ethanol is likely at least 24% more carbon-intensive than gasoline due to emissions resulting from land use changes to grow corn, along with processing and combustion. Geoff Cooper, president and CEO of the Renewable Fuels Association, the ethanol trade lobby, called the study "completely fictional and erroneous," arguing the authors used "worst-case assumptions [and] cherry-picked data." Under the U.S. Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS), a law enacted in 2005, the nation's oil refiners are required to mix some 15 billion gallons of corn-based ethanol into the nation's gasoline annually. The policy was intended to reduce emissions, support farmers, and cut U.S. dependence on energy imports. As a result of the mandate, corn cultivation grew 8.7% and expanded into 6.9 million additional acres of land between 2008 and 2016, the study found. That led to widespread changes in land use, including the tilling of cropland that would otherwise have been retired or enrolled in conservation programs and the planting of existing cropland with more corn, the study found. Tilling fields releases carbon stored in soil, while other farming activities, like applying nitrogen fertilizers, also produce emissions. A 2019 study from the USDA, which has been broadly cited by the biofuel industry, found that ethanol’s carbon intensity was 39% lower than gasoline, in part because of carbon sequestration associated with planting new cropland. But that research underestimated the emissions impact of land conversion, Lark said. USDA did not respond to a request for comment. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, which administers the nation's biofuel policy, is considering changes to the program. Under the RFS, Congress set blending requirements through 2022, but not beyond, giving the EPA authority to impose reforms. EPA plans to propose 2023 requirements in May.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Biotech › AFF › 2AC

Ethanol is bad for the environment

Ben Leiberman 4-11-2007(Law Degree George Washington University School of Law; “The Ethanol Mandate Should Not Be Expanded”; Backgrounder published by the heritage foundation; Accessed 7/1/2023; file:///C:/Users/akash/Downloads/policyarchive_file_12102.pdf; GH AB)

While a boon to Midwestern corn farmers and big ethanol producers like Archer Daniels Midland, ethanol has been bad news for the driving public. Ethanol usually costs more than gasoline, so adding it to gasoline increases fuel prices at the pump.4 Ordinary vehicles can use gasoline blends containing up to 10 percent ethanol, and specially modified vehicles can use fuel that is up to 85 percent ethanol. However, ethanol lowers fuel economy because a gallon of ethanol has only two-thirds of the energy content of a gallon of gasoline.5 Difficulties in transporting it to markets far from the Midwest and other logistical problems add further to the price of ethanol in several regions. Ethanol use at current levels has also led to skyrocketing corn prices as the available supply is split between food and fuel uses. This has led to higher prices for corn products and things such as corn-fed meat.6 The U.S. Department of Agriculture predicts that the ethanol mandate will continue to apply upward pressure on food prices in the coming years.7 Even the price of tortillas, the dietary staple of many low-income Mexicans, has been affected.8 No Appreciable Improvement in Energy Security Beyond costs, the claimed benefits of ethanol use have not materialized. For one thing, it does not reduce oil imports as much as promised, partially because a gallon of ethanol can do the work of (and therefore replace) only two-thirds of a gallon of gasoline. In addition: • A significant amount of petroleum-based products is used in growing corn, such as the diesel fuel for tractors and harvesters;9 • Certain components of gasoline must be removed before adding ethanol to prevent the overall blend from violating environmental requirements under Clean Air Act provisions, which are applicable in many parts of the country; and • Transporting ethanol requires more energy than transporting gasoline because ethanol transported by pipeline (the most energy-efficient means of transport) becomes contaminated by moisture along the way. Instead, ethanol is shipped via petroleum-using trucks, barges, and railroads. The current ethanol mandate will supplant only 1.1 percent of petroleum imports by 2012, without taking into account the petroleum inputs in ethanol production and use.10 Once these inputs are taken into account, that figure falls by half to about 0.5 percent, according to one analysis.11 Others suggest a somewhat higher percentage, but still in the very low single digits.12 In any event, the energy security gains from ethanol use are minute, especially in relation to its costs. Overrated Environmental Benefits The claimed environmental benefits of ethanol are also suspect. Although promoted as a means of reducing vehicular emissions that contribute to smog, ethanol is a mixed bag. It lowers some types of pollutants, such as carbon monoxide, but increases others, such as the evaporative emissions that contribute to smog.13 The fertilizer, pesticides, and irrigation required for corn farming in some areas also have negative environmental impacts.14 These impacts will only worsen if forests are cleared or marginal lands are planted to expand corn acreage to meet increasing demand.15 The President has touted the benefits of ethanol in reducing carbon dioxide emissions, which are linked to global warming.16 Carbon dioxide is a natural constituent of the atmosphere, but it is also the byproduct of the combustion of fossil fuels, including gasoline. By some measures, using ethanol in vehicles results in fewer carbon dioxide emissions than an equivalent amount of gasoline. However, after taking into account the carbon dioxide emitted from ethanol production, the reduction in emissions is modest.17 Overall, the costs of the ethanol mandate are substantial, while the benefits are small at best. The only real winners are the direct beneficiaries of this special-interest program

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Biotech › AFF › 2AC

Biotech is dangerous

Bruce M. Chassy 6/19/2013(PHD Cornell University; “Food Safety Evaluation of Crops Produced through Biotechnology”; Journal of the American College of Nutrition; Accessed 7/1/2023; https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/07315724.2002.10719261) GH AB:(

Agricultural biotechnology has been widely adopted in agriculture but is also the focus of controversy. Questions have arisen regarding food and environmental safety. In the US, responsibility for ensuring agricultural and environmental safety is delegated to the USDA and EPA, respectively. The FDA has primary responsibility for food safety, with the exception that the EPA has responsibility for the safety of proteins in plants associated with insect defense mechanisms. The food safety assessment, whether performed by the FDA or the EPA, requires evaluation of the safety of 1) the newly added DNA, 2) the safety of the newly introduced gene product and 3) the overall safety of the balance of the food. A paradigm called “Substantial Equivalence” guides the assessment. The principal food safety issues for new varieties crops are 1) potential toxicity of the newly introduced protein(s), 2) potential changes in allergenicity, 3) changes in nutrient composition, 4) unintended effects giving rise to allergenicity or toxicity and 5) the safety of antibiotic resistance marker-encoded proteins included with the transgene. All of these must be taken in the context of the predicted range of dietary exposures. The evaluation seeks to establish that there is a “reasonable likelihood of safety” and that new varieties are as safe as or safer than crops produced by traditional methods. Indeed, after extensive safety testing and some five years of experience with such crops in the marketplace, there is not a single report that would lead an expert food scientist to question the safety of such transgenic crops now in use.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Biotech › NEG › 2NC

Agribusiness is key to econ, only the plan solves.

Jayson Beckman & Amanda M. Countryman 2-21-2021 (Jayson Beckman is an Economist in the Agricultural Policy and Models Branch in the Market and Trade Economics Division. Dr. Amanda M. Countryman PhD associate professor of agriculture and resource economics, Purdue University; Wiley Online Library; Accessed 7/2/2023; https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/ajae.12212) GH AB:(

Much of the attention from COVID-19 has been on the impacts on tourism and other service sectors; but there has been a growing interest in issues pertaining to agriculture, including the decline in food away from home (FAFH) expenditures and effects on agricultural production including the closures of meat processing plants in the second quarter of 2020. One area featuring a wealth of analysis on COVID-19 is the potential impacts on macro-economic factors such as unemployment and GDP. Our work combines the two topics, filling a gap in the literature that has not been addressed: impacts on agriculture in economic analysis of COVID-19. We consider changes in production and trade, and changes in FAFH expenditures, unemployment, and fiscal responses that have occurred as a result of COVID-19. We gather data on actual changes to these components then use a simulation model to estimate the impact of these shocks on GDP. As such, we provide insight to the impact on the entire economy caused by changes in food and agricultural markets.

Our results indicate that for many regions, the impacts from agriculture play a large role in the economy-wide changes from COVID-19. This is particularly the case for those that have large expenditures on FAFH. The region with the largest decrease in GDP from agriculture in our results is the U.S. Although the production and trade shocks had little impact on GDP, the combined effects of all shocks lead to a reduction in GDP for the U.S. attributable to agriculture that is greater than the 5.4% share of agriculture in the national economy. An argument could be made, however, whether FAFH, could be considered as “agricultural” in the vein that most people think; however, this sector has a large share of their costs dedicated toward purchasing primary agricultural products and is a key source for food consumption. It should be noted that the changes to primary agricultural products and certain food processing sectors (dairy and meats) could influence agricultural markets for the next few years given the lags in production cycles attributable to agriculture. This would be particularly the case if supply chains are not able to evolve quickly, although there is evidence of food manufactures shifting strategies to become nimbler and more responsive to economic forces.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Biotech › NEG › 2NC

Ethanol does have promise as an alternative to gasoline

Farhan Khan 05-23 (Mechanical Engineer at Faculty of Engineering and Technology at Delhi Technological University; “EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATIONS ON THE USE OF TRANSIENT ETHANOL-DIESEL FUEL BLEND IN A DIESEL ENGINE: PERFORMANCE AND EMISSION STUDIES”; DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING DELHI TECHNOLOGICAL UNIVERSITY; Accessed 7/2/2023; http://14.139.251.106:8080/jspui/bitstream/repository/19913/1/Farhan_Khan_M.Tech_Thesis__2K21THE21.pdf) GH AB :(; *edited for ableist language

In ethanol, has emerged as a promising substitute for diesel engines, presenting a wide range of advantages and prospects in the quest for sustainable diesel engine operations. Ethanol is recognized as a low-emission fuel due to its derivation from renewable sources like corn, sugarcane, or cellulosic feed-stocks. By incorporating ethanol into diesel fuel blends, the overall carbon footprint of the engine can be reduced, thereby helping to mitigate climate change. Nevertheless, there are specific challenges and considerations associated with the practical application of ethanol in diesel engines. The primary limitations of ethanol in diesel engines include its relatively low energy content, lower cetane number, potential phase separation issues, as well as lower lubricity and viscosity properties. However, there are strategies available to overcome these challenges. One approach involves the implementation of an inline static mixer, which helps prevent phase separation and ensures a more homogeneous mixture of ethanol infused diesel blend. Additionally, a cetane number enhancer can be utilized to effectively manage and improve the cetane value of the ethanol infused diesel mixture, addressing the issue of lower cetane number. The experimental results demonstrate that the incorporation of ethanol inside the diesel fuel leads to a retardation [lull] in the ignition timing of the blend and a reduction in peak pressure values. This is attributed to the elevated enthalpy of vaporization of ethanol, which diminishes the temperature of the blend, consequently leading to a delay in ignition. However, when a cetane number enhancer is added to the blend, both the ignition timing and pressure values approach those of pure diesel fuel. This phenomenon can be ascribed to the capacity of the cetane number booster to decrease the ignition delay of the blend. Conversely, when ethanol is introduced to the diesel without a cetane number enhancer, the ignition delay is prolonged, leading to a reduction in the duration of combustion and, subsequently, a decrease in heat release. However, with the addition of the cetane number enhancer, the rate of heat release becomes closer to that of pure diesel because of increase in combustion duration. The incorporation of ethanol into diesel fuel leads to a rise in the brake specific fuel consumption of the mixture. This can be primarily attributed to the lower energy 52 content of ethanol. However, by escalating the proportion of the cetane number booster in the mixture, this value can be decreased because of the improved combustion duration. Similarly, the incorporation of ethanol into diesel results in an elevation in the brake thermal efficiency, and this value further improves with rising the proportion of cetane number enhancer. This enhancement can be credited to the delay in ignition caused by the substitution of ethanol, which reduces the available time for heat loss. At lower loads, the incorporation of ethanol in diesel results in increased emissions of hydrocarbon (HC) and carbon monoxide (CO). However, as the load increases, this increment in emissions diminishes. The possible explanation for this phenomenon lies in the high value enthalpy of vaporization of ethanol, which generates a cooling effect during the combustion process. This cooling effect can lead to incomplete combustion, thereby increasing the emissions of HC and CO. Ignition delay may also contribute to this effect. However, when a cetane number enhancer is added to the blend, these emissions tend to decrease. As the load increases, the emission of nitrogen oxides (NOx) also tends to increase. However, when ethanol is added to diesel, this emission is reduced. The significant enthalpy of vaporization of ethanol contributes to lowering the peak temperature inside the cylinder, thereby resulting in a decrease in NOx emissions. Furthermore, when a cetane number enhancer is introduced to the blend, the NOx emissions are comparatively reduced, particularly at higher loads. As the load increases, the emission of smoke exhibits a parallel pattern, indicating a corresponding increase. However, the addition of ethanol slightly reduces the smoke emission at higher loads. On the other hand, the impact of the cetane number enhancer on smoke emission is minimal, with only a slight effect observed. Future Scope Future research should focus on comparing the impact of various cetane number enhancers in the blend and determining the most effective one. Additionally, studies should be conducted to explore additives that can mitigate the corrosive nature of ethanol.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Biotech › NEG › 2NC

Biotech is critical to help countries recover from COVID

Abdullah Mohammad Shohael & Kathleen L. Hefferon 1-19-2023(Abdullah Mohammad Shohael Department of Biotechnology and Genetic Engineering, Jahangirnagar University; Kathleen L. Hefferon Department of Microbiology, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY; Agricultural Bioeconomy Innovation and Foresight in the Post-COVID Era; Science Direct; Accessed 7-1-2023; https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/B9780323905695000123) GH AB:(

Bangladesh is an agricultural country, and agriculture is the foundation of its economy. Climate change, followed by global warming, poses significant threats to agricultural production via a pool of abiotic stressors. Crop output is continually being hampered by several environmental factors, including but not limited to: drought, heat, cold, flooding, salt, and tropospheric ozone. Agricultural biotechnology has the potential to improve food and nutrition security while also increasing agricultural output by developing resilient climate-smart crops that are ready for future threats using cutting-edge biotechnological tools and techniques. Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs) are organisms that have had their original genetic structure changed or modified in a laboratory to innovate valuable traits. GMOs can play a vital role in achieving food security by increasing food production and availability while improving food quality and ensuring the availability of micronutrients and other nutraceuticals, and GM crops can improve farmers' economic and social status. The precise change at target areas made possible by recently discovered genome editing techniques holds enormous promise for crop enhancement. The primary advantage of genome editing technology is that techniques have been devised to remove the transgene, making crops created by genome editing and traditional breeding indistinguishable. To facilitate the commercialization of products derived from these technologies, governments should carefully consider the regulatory framework and establish appropriate regulations not to control but to move forward. More flexible efforts must be implemented into regulatory frameworks if we are to successfully harness the potential of technology and lead it toward good uses.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Biotech › NEG › 2NC

Biotech is the solution to end food scarcity

Sexton, Steven E. et al 1-2006(Steven E. Sexton; Ph.D. UC Berkeley assistant professor of public policy and economics at Duke University; Dr Leslie Martin; University of Melbourne; David Zilberman; Professor in the Agricultural and Resource Economics Department; “Biofuel and Biotech: A Sustainable Energy Solution”; University of California: Giannini foundation; Accessed 7/1/2023; ) Greenhill AB:(

Biotech Can Relieve Pressures on Agriculture Devoting all U.S. corn production to making ethanol seems unlikely, as does using one-sixth of world crop land for biofuel production, particularly considering other pressures on agriculture like the increasing demand for food from a growing world population with rising income. But in the United States, agricultural productivity tripled from 1950 to 2000 (See Figure 2). And since the 1960s, while the world population doubled from three to six billion, world agricultural production more than doubled, increasing per capita output by 25 percent. These advancements are owed to new irrigation technology, better pest abatement tools, and crop breeding. Giannini Foundation of Agricultural Economics 4 With the continued use of conventional technologies and biotechnology, there is potential to increase productivity by another 200 percent in the next several decades. Such growth could enable the agricultural community to continue meeting world demand for food, while also freeing nearly half of all crop land to energy production. The current generation of transgenics has infused staple crops like corn and rice with the naturally occurring Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt), a relatively innocuous, naturally occurring pesticide. These GM crops have increased yield as much as 80 percent and reduced chemical pesticide applications by 70 percent. Already, the next generation of GM crops is being developed. It will include crops that infuse additional nutrients into staple food sources like rice and wheat. It will produce less input-intensive crops and crops capable of growing on marginal land. It is expected to drive productivity growth and further reduce environmental externalities. It will also likely improve productivity of livestock systems by enhancing the efficiency of foods. The research community must assess to what extent these technological improvements can change supply and demand in the food system and make resources available for biofuel production. More Research Could Yield Energy Fix Although the diffusion of biotechnology has been extraordinarily fast by all accounts, there is strong opposition to it. Despite its proven ability to improve agricultural productivity (with particular benefit to poor and hungry regions of the world) and also mitigate environmental externalities, transgenics are criticized by policymakers and environmentalists who embrace the precautionary principle to stall adoption of GM technology. European leaders, for instance, have heavily regulated GMOs or banned them outright, limiting the market for transgenics and therefore the incentive to conduct additional research and development. Switzerland has called for a five-year moratorium on GMOs. And in California, initiatives have been placed on local ballots to ban GMO production within their jurisdictions. Critics cite food-safety concerns and environmental hazards as reasons for their opposition to GMOs. However, neither concern has been substantiated in the regions of the world where GM crops are used. GM crops are regulated more heavily than conventional crops and more agencies oversee the safety of their food products. Furthermore, genetically altered food crops have been in use for the better part of a century through selective breeding. The new development is the use of recombinant DNA to more quickly alter genetics. The environmental benefit of increased agricultural productivity is often downplayed and underemphasized. As Norman Borlaug pointed out in 2002, were the United States still employing the technologies of 1940, we would have needed an additional 575 million acres of agricultural land to meet current production. In other words, conventional technology and biotechnology have spared land for other uses equal to the area of the 25 U.S. states east of the Mississippi River. Furthermore, the current generation of agricultural biotechnology has significantly reduced pesticide applications. Monitoring of environmental impacts can continue without impeding growth of the technology. The energy crisis and climate change call for policies that remove constraints on the expansion of biotechnology, allow the technology to grow, and invest in improving biofuel technologies. Whereas the federal government, with its latest energy bill and limited approach to global warming, has yet to form a comprehensive response to these two issues, California is poised to be a pioneer in the development of these technologies and a leader in sustainable growth. With its educational-industrial complex— the interconnectedness of government, public research universities, and private entrepreneurs—California has a capacity for innovation unlike any in the world. The birthplace of many technological breakthroughs in the past half-century, from the Internet and information technology to biomedical advancements, California can be a leader in the response to global warming. Conservation is certainly important and efforts to modify behavior are admirable, but California’s contribution to the world should not emphasize reducing emissions and investing in tree-planting campaigns. California’s contribution should be more profound than producing corn or switchgrass for biofuel production. Our contribution should be an investment in research, and we should lead with new technologies that will benefit the world and, once and for all, address the related challenges of global warming and energy security.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Biotech › NEG › 1NC

Biotech can help reduce Greenhouse gas emissions

Sexton, Steven E. et al 1-2006(Steven E. Sexton; Ph.D. UC Berkeley assistant professor of public policy and economics at Duke University; Dr Leslie Martin; University of Melbourne; David Zilberman; Professor in the Agricultural and Resource Economics Department; “Biofuel and Biotech: A Sustainable Energy Solution”; University of California: Giannini foundation; Accessed 7/1/2023; ) Greenhill AB:(

Just 150 years ago, 90 percent of U.S. energy was supplied by renewable sources. Today, renewables constitute a mere six percent of energy consumption in a U.S. economy that is heavily dependent on a finite supply of fossil fuels. To address this unsustainable situation, science and society are challenged to develop a longterm strategy to return to renewable sources of energy. Such a strategy should also address fuel price instability and contribute to containing climate change. Because agriculture is a key source of renewable energy, it has a role to play in the development of a sustainable energy supply. A transition to sustainable energy sources can be expected to withdraw resources from the production of foods, and increase food prices. In the short run, it may end chronic oversupply of some commodities. In the longer run, it may impose pressure on agriculture which must not just feed a world population that is expected to grow by three billion people in the next half-century, but also meet some of their energy needs. In this article, we demonstrate that while current biofuel production and agricultural biotechnology may not be sufficient to replace fossil fuels with renewable energy, they come close, and subsequent generations of these technologies offer greater promise. We make the case that California should invest in research that will improve these technologies and enable agriculture to meet world food demand and provide renewable energy within the next fifty years. This is a considerable challenge that requires a serious commitment from the research community. World agricultural productivity will have to more than double in the next 50 years, much as it did in the preceding 50 years. We will not be able to capitalize on the same increases in inputs and factor productivity, however. We will rely, in part, on advances in agricultural biotechnology, which promise to increase crop yield and produce staple crops that can grow on marginal land. The agricultural community has overcome significant challenges in the past. Agriculture met a six-fold increase in the world population from 1800-2000, with a ten-fold increase in agricultural production. Whereas extensive growth— increases in inputs—made possible such significant productivity gains in the past, growth today will be intensive, relying on total factor productivity rather than increases in land and water, two resources in low supply. Biotechnology offers new opportunities for productivity growth that can delay the onset of decreasing marginal returns. But the growth of agricultural biotechnology is constrained by regulation and bans that may be politically motivated. These constraints reduce productivity and diminish opportunities to develop 2 Giannini Foundation of Agricultural Economics technology. There is evidence that these barriers slow the growth of agricultural biotechnology relative to its potential. They constrain agriculture’s ability to address climate change and energy shortages. In the United States, for instance, the Department of Energy forecasts a growing gap between domestic energy production and consumption, as domestic production lags and demand increases due to a populous that is driving farther and more frequently in bigger cars (See Figure 1). The gap between domestic production and consumption must, of course, be made up by imports. But U.S. oil imports, particularly from the oil rich Middle East, are becoming increasingly untenable. Biofuel Offers Hope for Replacing Fossil Fuel In the field, we see technologies that have the potential to make biofuels a viable replacement of fossil fuels with further refinement of the production process and continued adoption and improvement of agricultural biotechnology. First-generation biofuel technologies can turn corn, sugar cane, and soy into fuel capable of powering cars and trucks. The next generation of these technologies—already being developed in laboratories—are expected to be more efficient. Already, the technology exists to convert a 56-pound bushel of corn into 2.5-2.8 gallons of ethanol. Sugar is extracted from starchy crops like corn, sugar cane, and sugar beets with enzymes, and then converted into ethanol by yeasts. The ethanol can then be used to power cars that can run on 100 percent ethanol, or a mixture of ethanol and gasoline, or cars that can switch between gasoline and ethanol. Even adding just 15 percent ethanol to gasoline can reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 40 percent. This technology has been widely adopted in Brazil, where 40 percent of automobiles operate on 100 percent ethanol. Not only does ethanol burn cleaner, but it has a higher octane that improves engine performance. Under current production methods, ethanol costs roughly $0.50 per gallon more than gasoline. The technology is viable when gasoline prices exceed $60 per barrel. There is an element of learning by doing that will improve the profitability of ethanol relative to other fuels. Furthermore, under more aggressive tax regimes, such as a carbon tax, the technology will become profitable. California, for instance, is considering increasing the gasoline tax consumers pay at the pump, moving the effective price of gasoline closer to ethanol. It has been estimated that if the world community began today to increase ethanol production each year to 34 million barrels in 2056, greenhouse gas emissions could be reduced by one gigaton of carbon. This would require the commitment of one-sixth of the world’s farmland to high-yield crops and ethanol production 50 times higher than it is today. In the United States, if all corn crops were devoted to ethanol production, ethanol could replace 20 percent of petroleum consumption. Minnesota, a Corn Belt state, could fully replace fossil fuels with ethanol if it devoted its entire corn production to the effort. The current biofuel capabilities are encouraging, but they are not good enough. Such crop and land commitments are not feasible. In addition, as demand for biofuel feedstocks grows, food prices are expected to increase, hurting consumers while benefiting producers and reducing farmer subsidies. Agriculture, therefore, has two challenges: develop high-yield feedstocks for biofuel and increase productivity of traditional crops to free land for energy production. The hope is that new technologies will make biofuel production more efficient and improve crop yields, reducing upward pressure on food prices and freeing land for energy production. The next generation of ethanol production, for instance, will make use of more efficient feedstocks than corn and sugar cane. Corn, in particular, is factor intensive and causes soil erosion. Cellulosic alternatives such as grasses, woody crops, wood waste, and paper, offer several advantages over traditional ethanol feedstocks. They can be grown on marginal land, require little fertilizer or water, and have higher energy content. History Figure 1: Total U.S. Energy Production and Consumption, 1980-2030 Source: Energy Information Administration 150 125 100 75 50 25 0 1980 1995 2004 2015 2030 (quadrillion Btu) Projections } Consumption Net Imports Production 3 Giannini Foundation of Agricultural Economics Figure 2. U.S. Agricultural Productivity: 1948-1996 Index (1987=1) 1.3 1.2 1.1 1.0 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 1996 Source: USDA-ERS: www.usda.gov/nass/pubs/trends/productivity.htm Output Input Productivity Giannini Foundation of Agricultural Economics Furthermore, because there is considerable land-area potential for cellulosic crops, there is no supply restriction. The United States has 76 million acres dedicated to corn, 12 percent of which is used for ethanol production. Total U.S. cropland exceeds 430 million acres. There is an additional 578 million acres of permanent pasture land that would be ideal for the production of switchgrass, a high-yield crop relatively tolerant to abiotic extremes. Cellulosic feedstocks are in use in Canada at a demonstration project, but are not commercially produced. The sole barrier to the widespread adoption of cellulosic alternatives is technological, according to members of UC Berkeley’s Energy Resources Group. The enzymes needed to convert cellulose are prohibitively expensive and inefficient, but new enzymes that will make this technology viable are said to be forthcoming. New enzymes that can convert starch to sugar more quickly and efficiently are already in the research pipeline, as well. Scientists are also working to replace yeast with bacteria that are less prone to infection and able to withstand extreme temperatures. Bacteria are less efficient than yeast, but genetic manipulation can resolve that deficiency. Advancements are also being made to improve biodiesel production, which has traditionally been produced from soy. Once a few technological hurdles are overcome, mustard is expected to serve as a feedstock. Mustard can be grown on land that is worth less than land used to grow corn and soy and can be beneficial to wheat production if used in rotation. Furthermore, mustard is an adaptable crop that can be genetically altered to meet specific needs. Biodiesel, like ethanol, burns cleaner than its petroleum counterpart and improves engine performance. Through a chemical process that converts vegetable oils, animal fats, and cooking grease to methyl esters, biodiesel has one of the highest energy balances of any renewable energy source. One gallon of liquid fuel yields 3.24 gallons of biodiesel. Petrodiesel, in contrast, produces only 0.83 gallons of diesel per gallon of liquid gas. Biodiesel production is low relative to U.S. consumption. The current generation of biodiesel could only replace 13.3 percent of domestic petrodiesel consumption if all vegetable oils, grease, and animal fats in the United States were employed in biodiesel production, according to a 1998 analysis by the USDA. Biodiesel does play a key role in greenhouse gas reduction efforts, however. U.S. EPA-mandated reductions in sulfur emissions require petrodiesel to be heavily refined, reducing the lubricity of the fuel. Adding even two percent biodiesel to petrodiesel can compensate for the lost lubricity. These ongoing efforts to improve biofuel technology are encouraging and the next generation of biofuels will offer even greater potential to replace fossil fuels. But the most significant constraint on biofuel production remains the availability of land and the productivity of crops used as feedstocks. Transgenic crops can, however, significantly lessen that constraint with their ability to greatly increase yields and reduce costs. They are expected to permit continued agricultural productivity growth as new genetically modified crops are developed. Advancements in agricultural biotechnology, then, will directly benefit biofuel production.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Ban Meat › AFF › 2AC

Eating meat is moral

Zangwill 21

Nick Zangwill 6 – 14 – 21 (British philosopher and honorary research professor at University College London and Lincoln University. He is known for his expertise on moral philosophy, and aesthetics. He has also written on metaphysics, epistemology, the philosophy of mind, and logic) “Our Moral Duty to Eat Meat” Cambridge University Press 7 – 1 – 23 https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-the-american-philosophical-association/article/our-moral-duty-to-eat-meat/8FBE9042D1AFDBDE56F6CE1B56D25C82 //EKoo (Elizabeth Koo)

Some people do not eat meat. It could be that they put their own self-interest before morality. Perhaps they do not like the taste, for example, or have some irrational taboo against it, just as irrational racial prejudice leads some people not to care about certain kinds of people or to harm them. Or it could be that they do not care about the welfare of conscious animals because speciesism leads them not to value a tradition that benefits those animals, in particular, speciesism causes them to ignore animals' pleasures and happiness. Whatever the psychological explanation, their practice is immoral. Eating meat is good, it is what we ought to do and our duty, and not to do so is bad and wrong. Where duty is in tension with self-interest, we should strive to put self-interest to one side and do our duty. Those happiness-deniers and life-deniers who have speciesist prejudices that prevent them from eating meat should strive to rid themselves of prejudice and do the right thing and eat meat.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Ban Meat › AFF › 2AC

The meat industry is key to the economy – CP destroys it

P. Scott Shearer 6 – 20 – 16 (vice president of the Bockorny Group Inc., a leading bipartisan government affairs consulting firm in Washington, D.C. With more than 30 years experience in government and corporate relations in state and national arenas, he is recognized as a leader in agricultural trade issues, having served as co-chairman of the Agricultural Coalition for U.S.-China Trade and co-chairman of the Agricultural Coalition for Trade Promotion Authority. Scott was instrumental in the passage of China Permanent Normal Trade Relations and TPA. He is past chairman of the USDA-USTR Agricultural Technical Advisory Committee for Trade in Animals and Animal Products and was a member of the USAID Food Security Advisory Committee. Prior to joining the Bockorny Group, Scott served as director of national relations for Farmland Industries Inc., as well as USDA’s Deputy Assistant Secretary for Congressional Affairs (1993-96), serving as liaison for the Secretary of Agriculture and the USDA to Congress. ) Meat industry supports U.S. economy by over $1 trillion” National Hog Farmer 7 – 1- 23 https://www.nationalhogfarmer.com/animal-well-being/meat-industry-supports-us-economy-over-1-trillion //EKoo

The U.S. meat and poultry industry accounts for over $1 trillion in total economic output or 5.6% of gross domestic product according to a new economic impact study by the North American Meat Institute. Barry Carpenter, president of NAMI, said, “The companies and the people that produce, process, distribute and sell nutritious meat and poultry products are an essential part of the U.S. economy. We are proud that we provide millions of quality jobs in every state and every sector of the U.S. economy and that these jobs ensure people in North America and around the world have access to our high quality, nutritious and affordable products.”

Key findings of the study:

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Ban Meat › AFF › 2AC

Lab-grown meat overtaking vegetarian meat subs is “25 time worse for the climate than real beef” says a study.

Chadwick 23

Jonathan Chadwick 5 – 10 – 23 (science and technology reporter at MailOnline since 2019. He studied at the universities of Reading and Sydney before completing his journalism training in Brighton. He's previously written for Laboratory News, Tech Monitor, ZDNet and The Argus) “Burger lovers rejoice! Lab-grown meat is up to 25 times WORSE for the climate than beef, study claims” Daily Mail 7 – 1- 23 https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-12067409/Lab-grown-meat-25-times-WORSE-climate-beef.html //EKoo

Lab-grown meat has been touted as a way to save the planet, but a new study suggests its green credentials are not as solid as many believe.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Ban Meat › NEG › 2NC

Meat production “most destructive tech…on earth” predicted to cause “10 million deaths a year,” GHG emissions to pass 2 degree warning target of Paris Agreement by 2050” despite developing, viable CPs.

Tad Friend 9-23-19 (staff writer at The New Yorker since 1998. He contributes to the magazine’s Letter from California and has examined the venture capitalist Marc Andreessen, Silicon Valley’s quest for eternal life, and Donald Glover, among many other subjects. His piece on suicides at the Golden Gate Bridge, “Jumpers,” inspired the documentary film “The Bridge” and the Sleater-Kinney song “Jumpers.” His work has been chosen for “The Best American Travel Writing,” “The Best American Sports Writing,” “The Best American Crime Reporting,” and “The Best Technology Writing.” In 2020, he won a James Beard award for feature writing for an article about meatless meats. He is the author of a memoir, “In the Early Times,” published in 2022, as well as “Cheerful Money: Me, My Family, and the Last Days of Wasp Splendor” and “Lost in Mongolia: Travels in Hollywood and Other Foreign Lands,” a collection of his articles. Previously, he was a contributing editor at Esquire and Outside.) Can a Burger Help Solve Climate Change? The New Yorker 7-1-23 https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2019/09/30/can-a-burger-help-solve-climate-change //EKoo

Most people like them even better dead. Americans eat three hamburgers a week, so serving beef at your cookout is as patriotic as buying a gun. When progressive Democrats proposed a Green New Deal, earlier this year, leading Republicans labelled it a plot to “take away your hamburgers.” The former Trump adviser Sebastian Gorka characterized this plunder as “what Stalin dreamt about,” and Trump himself accused the Green New Deal of proposing to “permanently eliminate” cows. In fact, of course, its authors were merely advocating a sensible reduction in meat eating. Who would want to take away your hamburgers and eliminate cows?

Well, Pat Brown does, and pronto. A sixty-five-year-old emeritus professor of biochemistry at Stanford University, Brown is the founder and C.E.O. of Impossible Foods. By developing plant-based beef, chicken, pork, lamb, dairy, and fish, he intends to wipe out all animal agriculture and deep-sea fishing by 2035. His first product, the Impossible Burger, made chiefly of soy and potato proteins and coconut and sunflower oils, is now in seventeen thousand restaurants. When we met, he arrived not in Silicon Valley’s obligatory silver Tesla but in an orange Chevy Bolt that resembled a crouching troll. He emerged wearing a T-shirt depicting a cow with a red slash through it, and immediately declared, “The use of animals in food production is by far the most destructive technology on earth. We see our mission as the last chance to save the planet from environmental catastrophe.”

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Ban Meat › NEG › 2NC

Violence against women connected historically and symbolically to violence against animals. Killing or using either’s reproductive systems forcibly is “not that bad.”

Girlboss ND (a community of strong, curious, and ambitious women redefining success on our own terms. We are here to inform, entertain, and inspire action through the content and experiences we create. We are unapologetic in our beliefs and values of supporting girls and women who are chasing dreams both big and small) “Why I See Meat Eating As A Femnist Issue – And I Wish More Women Did” Girlboss 7 – 1 – 23 https://girlboss.com/blogs/read/meat-eating-is-a-feminist-issue //EKoo

Perhaps only subconsciously, violence against women and girls has been linked to violence against animals in my mind since childhood. Growing up, I remember hearing, “Animals belong to mankind,” almost as often as hearing, “Wives, submit to your husbands.” I’ve never been hunting, but I passed my hunter safety course the same year that my fundamentalist Christian church hosted its first “rape prevention” class for pre-teen and teenage girls. This is the story of how being vegan, for me, is as much about ending a lineage of abuse against—and ownership of—human female bodies as it is about fighting animal cruelty.

“It must not have been that bad then,” my mom said between sips of coffee. I’d just finished telling her that, although I’d long since fallen out of love with him, I would always care about my physically, emotionally, and sexually abusive ex.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Ban Meat › NEG › 1NC

Key to stop climate change is cutting meat demand.

Fiona Harvey 10 – 26 – 22 (environment editor of the Guardian) “Meat consumption to two burgers a week to save planet, study suggests” The Guardian 7-1-23 https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/oct/26/cut-meat-consumption-save-planet-climate-crisis-fossil-fuels //EKoo

Meat consumption should be reduced to the equivalent of about two burgers a week in the developed world, and public transport expanded about six times faster than its current rate, if the world is to avoid the worst ravages of the climate crisis, research has suggested.

The State of Climate Action 2022 report examined global progress on 40 indicators that would be key to halving global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by 2030, in line with the goal of limiting temperature rises to 1.5C above pre-industrial levels.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Ban Meat › NEG › 1NC

Meat demand “creates future pandemics,” making “Covid-19 pandemic look like a ‘dress rehearsal’ says scientists.” History of pandemics agrees.

Dalton 21

Jane Dalton 1 – 30 – 21 (trained journalist writes news, features and opinion pieces at The Independent, often specialising in animal welfare and conservation. She frequently exposes cruelty and wrongdoing through hard-hitting exclusives. She is also interested in adult social care. During her early career on local papers, Jane won the Feature Writer of the Year award at Senews and was runner-up Reporter of the Year for the Emap media group. A graduate in French and Russian, she was regional editor at The Sunday Times before joining The Independent) “Meat-eating creates risk of future pandemic that ‘would make Covid seem a dress rehearsal’, scientists warn” The Independent 7 – 1 – 23 https://www.independent.co.uk/climate-change/news/meat-coronavirus-pandemic-science-animals-b1794996.html //EKoo

Demand for regular supplies of affordable meat will create future pandemics that will make Covid-19 pandemic look like a “dress rehearsal", scientists are warning.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Art › AFF › 2AC

Perm Do Both-- Human engagement is still possible through the policies enacted by the plan

Stewart Lockie 1-20-23 (James Cook University, Cairns, Australia, environmental sociologist.) “Sociologies of climate change are not enough. Putting the global biodiversity crisis on the sociological agenda” Taylor Francis Online https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/23251042.2023.2170310 Access Date: 7/1/23—VS

Biodiversity and the ecosystem services it provides are deteriorating at rates unprecedented in human history – deterioration driven, principally, by land and sea use change, overexploitation of biodiversity resources, climate change, pollution, and invasive alien species (IPBES Citation2019). The Kunming-Montreal Framework thus aims to transform societies’ relationship with biodiversity and to galvanize ‘urgent and transformative action’ by government and non-government actors to reverse biodiversity loss. At the same time, the framework respects national sovereignty, human rights, the contributions and rights of indigenous peoples and local communities, the diversity of concepts and values people bring to understanding and managing biodiversity, the importance of gender equality, socioeconomic development, and inter-generational equity, and so on. Implementation is to be based on an ecosystem approach underpinned by science, traditional knowledge, innovation, education, and finance.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Art › AFF › 2AC

Climate change too much of a risk now—CP takes too long

Luke Kempt et al 22 (Kempt was in the Centre for the Study of Existential Risk, and Darwin College, University of Cambridge, Cambridge CB2 1SB, United Kingdom. Chi Xu; School of Life Sciences, Nanjing University, Nanjing 210023, China. Joanna Depledge; Cambridge Centre for Environment, Energy and Natural Resource Governance, University of Cambridge, Cambridge CB2 3QZ, United Kingdom. Kristie L. Ebi; Center for Health and the Global Environment, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195. Goodwin Gibbins; Future of Humanity Institute, University of Oxford, Oxford OX2 0DJ, United Kingdom. Timothy A. Kohler; Department of Anthropology, Washington State University, Pullman, WA 99164-4910 Santa Fe Institute, Santa Fe, NM 87501 Cluster of Excellence ROOTS – Social, Environmental, and Cultural Connectivity in Past Societies, Christian-Albrechts-Universität, Kiel, 24118 Germany. Johan Rockström; Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, 14473 Potsdam, Germany. Marten Scheffer; Department of Environmental Sciences, University of Wageningen, 6708PB Wageningen, The Netherlands. Hans Joachim Schellnhuber; Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, 14473 Potsdam, Germany, Earth System Science Department, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100190, China. Will Steffen; Fenner School of Environment and Society, The Australian National University, Canberra, ACT 2601, Australia. Timothy M. Lenton; Global Systems Institute, University of Exeter, Exeter EX4 4QE, United Kingdom.) “Climate Endgame: Exploring catastrophic climate change scenarios” PNAS https://www.pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073/pnas.2108146119#sec-3 Access Date: 7/1/23—VS

There are four key reasons to be concerned over the potential of a global climate catastrophe. First, there are warnings from history. Climate change (either regional or global) has played a role in the collapse or transformation of numerous previous societies (37) and in each of the five mass extinction events in Phanerozoic Earth history (38). The current carbon pulse is occurring at an unprecedented geological speed and, by the end of the century, may surpass thresholds that triggered previous mass extinctions (39, 40). The worst-case scenarios in the IPCC report project temperatures by the 22nd century that last prevailed in the Early Eocene, reversing 50 million years of cooler climates in the space of two centuries (41).

This is particularly alarming, as human societies are locally adapted to a specific climatic niche. The rise of large-scale, urbanized agrarian societies began with the shift to the stable climate of the Holocene ∼12,000 y ago (42). Since then, human population density peaked within a narrow climatic envelope with a mean annual average temperature of ∼13 °C. Even today, the most economically productive centers of human activity are concentrated in those areas (43). The cumulative impacts of warming may overwhelm societal adaptive capacity.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Art › Neg › 1NC

People become aware of the impacts of climate change through Eco Art

Ariunaa Jargalsaikhan 21 (Certified Public Accountant (Lifetime) MONICPA. Certified Tax Accountant. MACTA. Licensed Auditor. Mongolian Institute of Certified Public Accountants) “CAN ECO ART HELP MONGOLIA SOLVE THE CLIMATE CRISIS?” Jargal Defacto https://jargaldefacto.com/article/can-eco-art-help-mongolia-solve-the-climate-crisis?lang=en Access Date: 7/1/23—VS

Eco Art is an influential agent of education, civic mobilization, and community activism. This spring, twelve graphic design students from the Mongolian Academy of Fine Arts and 111 children participated in the “Nogoonbaatar” (Green Hero) Eco Art Festival. Their art is a sobering reminder of the destructive impacts of greenhouse gas emissions. Below are just a few examples of their work:

Alongside children’s art, the “Nogoonbaatar” Eco Art Festival presented artworks by sixteen artists who turned the streets of a northern Ulaanbaatar ger district into a vibrant outdoor exhibition. The main site was once a wasteyard. Mr. S. Ulziitogtokh turned it into “Uulyn Park” in 2012 (Google maps mistakes it for Nogoon Nuuryn Park). The key attraction is a reservoir where neighborhood children can ice-skate in the winter and row boats in the summer.