Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
1NC › Scenarios › Middle East---1NC

High profits ensure rapid Middle Eastern arms racing and escalation.

El-Gamal & Jaffe ’18 [Mahmoud, and Amy. *professor in the Department of Economics at Rice University **Research Professor and Managing Director of the Climate Policy Lab at Tufts University. "The coupled cycles of geopolitics and oil prices." Economics of Energy & Environmental Policy 7, no. 2 (2018): 1-14.]perth

Authors have introduced the idea that the oil boom and bust cycle is coupled not only with the secular global business cycle but also endogenously with geopolitical cycles in military spending followed by military adventurism. Once again, high oil prices from 2011 to 2014 were accompanied by sharp increases in military expenditure in oil producing countries across the Middle East, which eventually has translated into escalating conflicts once oil prices receded (2014–2016). At the end of 2017, markets were caught between upward oil price momentum, driven by risk premiums related to these escalating conflicts, and the potential for higher competition among oil producers as technology advances has driven new oil supplies. As in past cycles, rising oil prices invite efficiency gains and wider adoption of alternative fuels.

In light of rising geopolitical risks across the Middle East, including key populations that are restive in Iran and Saudi Arabia, we revisit our prior work on regime change and oil supply disruptions. We survey our findings on potential medium-term production disruptions that would affect global supply adversely over periods of three to five years. We suggest that a longer lasting structural shift back to upward cycles could be expected if the proxy wars between Iran and Saudi Arabia in Yemen and the Levant intensify into overt war similar in magnitude to the Iran-Iraq war of the 1980s, wherein oil-production facilities were intentionally targeted and bombarded.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
1NC › Shell › Generic---1NC

High prices spark miscalc, arms racing, and war.

Bunzel ’18 [Theodore. *worked in the political section of the U.S. Embassy in Moscow and in international economics at the U.S. Treasury. “Do High Oil Prices Mean More International Conflict?” The American Interest. May 30, 2018. https://www.the-american-interest.com/2018/05/30/do-high-oil-prices-mean-more-international-conflict/.]perth

Does the relationship between oil prices and Russian behavior to which Bush alluded hold true? The higher the price of oil, the more aggressive Russia becomes? And what about other petrostates? Might it be true for those as well?

We may soon have more evidence for the proposition. Oil prices are brushing off 2016 lows and hitting three-year highs. Brent crude has been hovering above $70 a barrel since April, up from lows of around $30 in early 2016, fueled by OPEC production cuts and rising geopolitical tensions (over issues like the Iran deal). Though nuances, complications, and exceptions abound, the academic and historical evidence on balance tells us that, as we transition from a lower to a higher oil price regime, we can generally expect a darker geopolitical outlook. As rising oil revenues gives Russia, Saudi, Iran, and other oil-exporters an added sense of confidence, it may at least selectively inflame interstate tensions and lead to more aggressive behavior. That possibility, alongside an increasingly hawkish U.S. national security team and a President who appears to feel rather “unchained” of late, points to a potentially combustible mix just ahead.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
1NC › Shell › Generic---1NC

The plan’s green transition cedes oil production to petrostates---that spikes prices.

Bordoff & O’Sullivan ’21 [Jason, and Meghan. *Dean of the Columbia Climate School. **Professor of the Practice of International Affairs at the Harvard Kennedy School. “Green Upheaval.” Foreign Affairs. November 30, 2021. https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/world/2021-11-30/geopolitics-energy-green-upheaval.]perth

Traditional suppliers will benefit from the volatility in fossil fuel prices that will inevitably result from a rocky energy transition. The combination of pressure on investors to divest from fossil fuels and uncertainty about the future of oil is already raising concerns that investment levels may plummet in the coming years, leading oil supplies to decline faster than demand falls—or to decline even as demand continues to rise, as it is doing today. That outcome would produce periodic shortages and hence higher and more volatile oil prices. This situation would boost the power of the petrostates by increasing their revenue and giving extra clout to OPEC, whose members, including Saudi Arabia, control most of the world’s spare capacity and can ramp global oil production up or down in short order.

In addition, the transition to clean energy will wind up augmenting the influence of some oil and gas exporters by concentrating global production in fewer hands. Eventually, the demand for oil will decline significantly, but it will remain substantial for decades to come. Many high-cost producers, such as those in Canada and Russia’s Arctic territory, could be priced out of the market as demand (and, presumably, the price of oil) falls. Other oil-producing countries that seek to be leaders when it comes to climate change—such as Norway, the United Kingdom, and the United States—could in the future constrain their domestic output in response to rising public pressure and to hasten the transition away from fossil fuels. As a result, oil producers such as the Gulf states—which have very cheap, low-carbon oil, are less dependent on the financial institutions now shying away from oil, and will face little pressure to limit production—could see their market shares increase. Providing more or nearly all of the oil the world consumes would imbue them with outsize geopolitical clout, at least until oil use declines more markedly. Other countries whose oil industries might endure are those whose resources can be brought online quickly—such as Argentina and the United States, which boast large deposits of shale oil—and that can thereby attract investors who seek faster payback periods and may shy away from longer-cycle oil investments given the uncertainties about oil’s long-term outlook.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
1NC › Shell › Generic---1NC

Oil investment remains strong.

Worland ’23 [Justin. *reporter for Time. “BP’s Green U-Turn Shows Exactly Why the Energy Transition Is so Hard.” Time. February 10, 2023. https://time.com/6254378/bp-oil-profits-climate-energy-transition/.]perth

Two and a half years ago, after BP announced perhaps the most aggressive plans of any major oil and gas company yet to move away from fossil fuels, I asked Bernard Looney, the company’s CEO, about the reality that his commitment did not move fast enough to match the urgent science of climate change. His answer surprised me. Instead of defending his plans as aligned with scientific reality, he flipped the script and said that he kept hearing a bigger concern that the plans might be “too ambitious”—that they might make the company’s sustainability efforts unsustainable. At the time, many industry insiders questioned whether aggressively pursuing the energy transition would result in lower profits.

Looney told me that his vision was actually about generating more profit. “This isn’t some form of altruism or some form of charity… This is about creating sustainable value,” he said. “We can create value for our shareholders through this shift, and we would argue that we will create more value through this shift than we would if we keep doing what we’re doing.”

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Aff Answers › Alt › 2AC – AT: Refusal

Calls for refusal reproduce the colonial academic ways of knowing they criticize – the 1AC reinforces the status quo and produces academic distancing which merely masquerades as personal accountability

Love ‘15, (Heather, R. Jean Brownlee Term Associate Professor at the University of Pennsylvania, “Doing Being Deviant: Deviance Studies, Description, and the Queer Ordinary”, differences 2015 Volume 26, Number 1: 74-95)

Today, queer studies—prestigious but unevenly institutionalized—still signals absolute refusal or criticality—all anti- and no normativity. In their influential 2004 essay, “The University and the Undercommons” (and in the 2013 book that followed from it), Fred Moten and Stefano Harney rely on such an understanding of queer (as well as concepts borrowed from black studies, feminism, ethnic studies, and anticolonial thought). They call for betrayal, refusal, theft, and marronage as modes of resisting the iron grip of the academy, pointing to an uncharted, underground, and collective space they call the undercommons. “To enter this space,” they write, “is to inhabit the ruptural and enraptured disclosure of the commons that fugitive enlightenment enacts, the criminal, matricidal, queer, in the cistern, on the stroll of the stolen life, the life stolen by enlightenment and stolen back, where the commons give refuge, where the refuge gives commons” (103). Moten and Harney speculate whether the “thought of the outside” (105) is possible inside the university and suggest that if there is an outside, it is along the margins and at the bottom. Yet their imagination of that outside is indebted to the inside, in particular to the conception of deviance produced within sociology. Their account of the undercommons reads like a rap sheet, a list of the traditional topics of deviance studies: theft, homosexuality, prostitution, incarceration. Moten and Harney do not describe the undercommons, but rather ask their readers to join it, to participate in active revolt against professional and disciplinary protocols. To offer an objective account of the social position of radical academics would be to further business as usual in the academy; dwelling in the undercommons requires giving up on the usual protocols of description. Moten and Harney argue against the traditional role of the “critical academic” (105), which they see as just another turn of the professional screw, since work that opposes the academy does not challenge its basic structure or everyday operations. They argue that “to be a critical academic in the university is to be against the university, and to be against the university is always to recognize it and to be recognized by it, and to institute the negligence of the internal outside, that unassimilated underground, a negligence of it that is precisely, we must insist, the basis of the professions” (105). In contrast to the figure of the critical academic, they forward the image of the “subversive intellectual” who is “in but not of” the academy (101). Without dismissing the galvanizing effect of such a call to the undercommons, it is important to consider the limits of the refusal of objectification as a strategy. To be unlocatable, to be nowhere, to be in permanent revolt: Moten and Harney describe the path that queer inquiry laid out for itself. Objectification—recognition, description, critique—can be a way to reinforce the status quo, but it is also a way of acknowledging one’s institutional position and the real differences between inside and outside. Even the most subversive intellectuals in the academy are “on the stroll” in a metaphorical but not a material sense. The fate of those who came “under false pretenses, with bad documents, out of love” (101), if they survive, is to become “superordinates” in Becker’s sense. Whose side are we on? Can we hold onto the critical and polemical energy of queer studies as well as its radical experiments in style and thought while acknowledging our implication in systems of power, management, and control? Will a more explicit avowal of disciplinary affiliations and methods snuff out the utopian energies of a field that sees itself as a radical outsider in the university? To date, both the political and the methodological antinormativity of queer studies have made it difficult to address our implication in the violence of knowledge production, pedagogy, and social inequality. Such violence is inevitable, and critical histories of the disciplines—and the production of knowledge about social deviance—are essential. Undertaking such work, however, will not allow escape into a radically different relation to our objects because we are (as Moten and Harney also argue) part of that history—we are its contemporary instantiation. To imagine a social world in which those relations are transformed—in what Moten and Harney refer to as the “prophetic organization” (102)—may be crucial for the achievement of social justice, but to deny our own implication in existing structures is also a form of violence.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Aff Answers › Alt › 2AC – AT: Refusal

Refusal won’t transform the world—the role of scholars should be to facilitate change that promotes better material conditions for indigenous populations

Snelgrove ‘14 (University of British Columbia, Corey, Unsettling settler colonialism: The discourse and politics of settlers, and solidarity with Indigenous nation, Decolonization: Indigeneity, Education & Society Vol. 3, No. 2, 2014, pp. 1-32)

In spite of this worldly reflection, it is not the world that I want to live in. Thus, the term “settler” and the reason for its use, which brings forth the intimate and affective relationships to ancestral, social, cultural, economic, and political histories and presents which shape this world, necessarily leads not to pride, but rather to shame, frustration, alienation, and anger towards myself, other settlers, as well as the structures of settler colonialism. These feelings though also potentially signal an opening, a recognition of an un(der)realized interdependence. However, alone, these feelings are not sufficient. After all, I cannot just critique or declare that this world falls short of my desires and expect it to transform itself. Nor can I ignore the power differentials between settlers, as such willful acts risk stalling the decolonial engine. Instead, if these desires and simultaneous feelings of shame, frustration, alienation, and anger are to be at all transformative, they must be accompanied by thought and practice attentive to their respective sources; they must be guided by accountability and respect, care and renewal, with urgency and insurgency, to address and destroy the parasitical relations that exist between and among settlers and Indigenous peoples, as well as to support those (potentially) good relations that already exist, and those that we wish to establish between and among settlers and Indigenous peoples.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Aff Answers › Alt › 2AC – AT: Decolonization – Fails

Placing land return as the only solution enhances the subjugation of indigenous peoples – at best it’s impossible

Busbridge ‘17 (Rachel, Alexander von Humboldt Postdoctoral Fellow in Institut für Islamwissenschaft (Institute of Islamic Studies), Freie Universität Berlin [“Israel-Palestine and the Settler Colonial ‘Turn’: From Interpretation to Decolonization,” Theory, Culture & Society, First Published: January 23, 2017, p. 1-25)

The prescription for decolonization – that is, a normative project committed to the liberation of the colonized and the overturning of colonial relationships of power (Kohn and McBride, 2011: 3) – is indeed one of the most counter-hegemonic implications of the settler colonial paradigm as applied to Israel-Palestine, potentially shifting it from a diagnostic frame to a prognostic one which offers a ‘proposed solution to the problem, or at least a plan of attack’ (Benford and Snow, 2000: 616). What, however, does the settler colonial paradigm offer by way of envisioning decolonization? As Veracini (2007) notes, while settler colonial studies scholars have sought to address the lack of attention paid to the experiences of indigenous peoples in conventional historiographical accounts of decolonization (which have mostly focused on settler independence and the loosening of ties to the ‘motherland’), there is nevertheless a ‘narrative deficit’ when it comes to imagining settler decolonization. While Veracini (2007) relates this deficit to a matter of conceptualization, it is apparent that the structural perspective of the paradigm in many ways closes down possibilities of imagining the type of social and political transformation to which the notion of decolonization aspires. In this regard, there is a worrying tendency (if not tautological discrepancy) in settler colonial studies, where the only solution to settler colonialism is decolonization – which a faithful adherence to the paradigm renders largely unachievable, if not impossible. To understand why this is the case, it is necessary to return to Wolfe’s (2013a: 257) account of settler colonialism as guided by a ‘zero-sum logic whereby settler societies, for all their internal complexities, uniformly require the elimination of Native alternatives’. The structuralism of this account has immense power as a means of mapping forms of injustice and indignity as well as strategies of resistance and refusal, and Wolfe is careful to show how transmutations of the logic of elimination are complex, variable, discontinuous and uneven. Yet, in seeking to elucidate the logic of elimination as the overarching historical force guiding settlernative relations there is an operational weakness in the theory, whereby such a logic is simply there, omnipresent and manifest even when (and perhaps especially when) it appears not to be; the settler colonial studies scholar need only read it into a situation or context. It thus hurtles from the past to the present into the future, never to be fully extinguished until the native is, or until history itself ends. There is thus a powerful ontological (if not metaphysical) dimension to Wolfe’s account, where there is such thing as a ‘settler will’ that inherently desires the elimination of the native and the distinction between the settler and the native can only ever be categorical, founded as it is on the ‘primal binarism of the frontier’ (2013a: 258). It is here that the differences between earlier settler colonial scholarship on Israel-Palestine and the recent settler colonial turn come into clearest view. While Jamal Hilal’s (1976) Marxist account of the conflict, for instance, engaged Palestinians and Jewish Israelis in terms of their relations to the means of production, Wolfe’s account brings its own ontology: the bourgeoisie/proletariat distinction becomes that of settler/native, and the class struggle the struggle between settler, who seeks to destroy and replace the native, and native, who can only ever push back. Indeed, if the settler colonial paradigm views history in similar teleological terms to the Marxist framework, it does not offer the same hopeful vision of a liberated future. After all, settler colonialism has only one story to tell – ‘either total victory or total failure’ (Veracini, 2007). Veracini’s attempt to disaggregate different forms of settler decolonization is revealing of the difficulties that come along with this zero-sum perspective. It is significant to note that beyond settler evacuation (which may decolonize territory, he cautions, but not necessarily relationships) the picture he paints is a relatively bleak one. For Veracini (2011: 5), claims for decolonization from indigenous peoples in settler societies can take two broad forms: an ‘anti-colonial rhetoric expressing a demand for indigenous sovereign independence and self-determination ... and an ‘‘ultra’’-colonial one that seeks a reconstituted partnership with the [settler state] and advocates a return to a relatively more respectful middle ground and ‘‘treaty’’ conditions’. While both, he suggests, are tempting strategies in the struggle for change, though ‘ultimately ineffective against settler colonial structures of domination’ (2011: 5), it is the latter strategy that invites Veracini’s most scathing assessment. As he writes, under settler colonial conditions the independent polity is the settler polity and sanctioning the equal rights of indigenous peoples has historically been used as a powerful weapon in the denial of indigenous entitlement and in the enactment of various forms of coercive assimilation. This decolonisation actually enhances the subjection of indigenous peoples... it is at best irrelevant and at worst detrimental to indigenous peoples in settler societies. (2011: 6–7)

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Aff Answers › Alt › 2AC – AT: Decolonization

The alt can’t solve material decolonization OR cause their impacts.

Laing ‘15 (Anna Frances, Ph.D. candidate, School of Geographical and Earth Sciences, College of Science and Engineering, University of Glasgow, “Territory, resistance and struggles for the plurinational state: the spatial politics of the TIPNIS Conflict,” Ph.D. thesis, January 2015, p.215-216, http://theses.gla.ac.uk/5974/7/2015laingphd.pdf)

The use of indigeneity as a common signifier has fostered mobilisation across different ethnic groups. This process has been aided by NGOs and técnicos (technical experts) that accompanied the Eighth and Ninth Marches. NGO representatives facilitated meetings, provided training, funded activities and constructed written announcements and texts. These mediatory actors therefore helped to re-articulate the grievances of the marchers under the banner of indigenous rights. This could be seen in the writing of open letters to the government during both the Eighth and Ninth Marches, made possible through the aid of technical experts from one of the principle legal organisations defending indigenous rights in Bolivia CEJIS (Centro de Estudios Jurídicos e Investigación Social; Centre of Legal Studies and Social Investigation). Therefore, in order to ‘speak’ and be heard, the indigenous peoples have to undergo a process of representation through the language of legal rights. They therefore remain ‘subaltern’ because their attempts at self-representation fall outside the ‘the lines laid down by the official institutional structures of representation’ (Spivak 1996: 306). Thus, Glenn (2011) contends that the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples is ironic since it seeks the recognition of alternative epistemologies through civic institutions that have homogenising and universalising tendencies. However, as Fabricant notes in her work with the Landless Peasants Movement in Bolivia, movements ‘take NGO ideas and meld them with their own creative strategies to come up with solutions that will work for their communities’ (2012: 120). Moreover, Gustafson (2009b) offers a balanced interpretation of the ways that NGOs offer a language and model for politicising alternative worldviews. The indigenous movement consciously reifies certain strategic essentialisms whilst at other times actively resisting them. Indeed, indigenous knowledges do not exist outside of other knowledge forms (Walsh 2002). As Walsh argues ‘[t]he efficacy of the movement in fact derives from its ability to construct and use the correspondences among various contemporary knowledge positions […] in order to exercise political tactics and strategies’ (2002: 71). A politics of refusal is unlikely to advance indigenous demands. As such, Hale suggests an analytical framework based on the Gramscian notion of articulation to ask: will the subjugated knowledge and practices be articulated within the dominant, and neutralised? Or will they occupy the space opened from above while resisting its built in logic, connect with others, toward ‘transformative’ cultural-political alternatives that still cannot be fully imagined? (2002: 499). Indeed, there is the danger that identifying under a single indigenous label risks losing the complexities and processes that permeate the heterogeneous inter-ethnic collectivity of the lowland indigenous movement. This acts to disembody the identity claims from some of the more radical tangents of the movement. Mexican anthropologist Miguel Alberto Bartolomé argues that indigenous autonomy should contemplate ‘new modes of [interethnic, inter-cultural] social articulation that are more egalitarian than existing [ones]’ and that a multi-ethnic state ‘should explore all possible paths in the search for novel forms of conviviality between culturally distinct groups’ (2005: 146 cited in Gustafson 2009a: 998). Escobar similarly calls for a decolonisation that ‘can be started in earnest from a deessentialized perspective’ (2008: 305). Indeed, the movement seeks the recognition of plurality without the homogenisation of indigenous cultures or ideologies or the ranking of difference that necessarily works to subordinate some cultures and let others dominate. This project of emancipatory societal transformation is an on-going challenge for the lowland indigenous movement.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Aff Answers › Impact › 2AC – Extinction First

Existential fears need not be settler projections of demise but can be contingently appropriated to reverse indigenous erasure

Weiss 15—Ph.D. candidate, Anthropology, University of Chicago (Joseph, “UNSETTLING FUTURES: HAIDA FUTURE-MAKING, POLITICS AND MOBILITY IN THE SETTLER COLONIAL PRESENT,” Dissertation submitted to the Faculty of the Division of Social Sciences, Department of Anthropology, University of Chicago, December 2015, 223-232, dml)

And yet, something has changed in this landscape from the initial erasures of Native futurity we drew out in the first chapter. In the narratives of colonial actors like Duncan Campbell Scott, it was absolutely clear that “Indians” were disappearing because their social worlds were being superseded by more “civilized” ways of living and being, ones that these Native subjects would also, inevitably, in the end, adopt (or failing that, perish outright). There was a future. It was simply a settler one. But the nightmare futures of that my Haida interlocutors ward against in their own future-making reach beyond Haida life alone. Environmental collapse, most dramatically, threatens the sustainability of all life; toxins in the land and the waters threaten human lives regardless of their relative indigeneity, race, or gender (e.g. Choy 2011; Crate 2011). Put another way, the impetus for non-Haida (and non-First Nations subjects more generally) to be “united against Enbridge” with their indigenous neighbours comes in no small part because an oil spill also profoundly threatens the lives and livelihoods of non-Aboriginal coastal residents, a fact which Masa Takei, among others, made clear in Chapter 3. Nor is the anxiety that young people might abandon their small town to pursue economic and educational advantage in an urban context limited to reserve communities. Instead, the compulsions of capitalist economic life compel such migrations throughout the globe. The nightmare futures that Haida people constitute alternative futures to ward against are not just future of indigenous erasure under settler colonialism. They are erasures of settler society itself.

There is thus an extraordinary political claim embedded in Haida future-making, a claim which gains its power precisely because Haida future-making as we have seen it does not (perhaps cannot) escape from the larger field of settler-colonial determination. Instead, in Haida future-making we find the implicit assertion that Haida people can make futures that address the dilemmas of Haida and settler life alike, ones that can at least “navigate,” to borrow Appadurai’s phrasing, towards possible futures that do not end in absolute erasure. If Povinelli and Byrd are correct and settler liberal governance makes itself possible and legitimate through a perpetual deferral of the problems of the present, then part of the power of Haida future-making is to expose the threatening non-futures that might emerge out of this bracketed present, to expose as lie the liberal promise of a good life always yet to come and to attempt to constitute alternatives.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Aff Answers › Impact › 2AC – Extinction First

Vote AFF if the plan reduces existential risk---It’s a prerequisite to any other impact and scope neglect results in ignoring true risks

Seth D. Baum & Anthony M. Barrett 18. Global Catastrophic Risk Institute. 2018. “Global Catastrophes: The Most Extreme Risks.” Risk in Extreme Environments: Preparing, Avoiding, Mitigating, and Managing, edited by Vicki Bier, Routledge, pp. 174–184.

2. What Is GCR And Why Is It Important? Taken literally, a global catastrophe can be any event that is in some way catastrophic across the globe. This suggests a rather low threshold for what counts as a global catastrophe. An event causing just one death on each continent (say, from a jet-setting assassin) could rate as a global catastrophe, because surely these deaths would be catastrophic for the deceased and their loved ones. However, in common usage, a global catastrophe would be catastrophic for a significant portion of the globe. Minimum thresholds have variously been set around ten thousand to ten million deaths or $10 billion to $10 trillion in damages (Bostrom and Ćirković 2008), or death of one quarter of the human population (Atkinson 1999; Hempsell 2004). Others have emphasized catastrophes that cause long-term declines in the trajectory of human civilization (Beckstead 2013), that human civilization does not recover from (Maher and Baum 2013), that drastically reduce humanity’s potential for future achievements (Bostrom 2002, using the term “existential risk”), or that result in human extinction (Matheny 2007; Posner 2004). A common theme across all these treatments of GCR is that some catastrophes are vastly more important than others. Carl Sagan was perhaps the first to recognize this, in his commentary on nuclear winter (Sagan 1983). Without nuclear winter, a global nuclear war might kill several hundred million people. This is obviously a major catastrophe, but humanity would presumably carry on. However, with nuclear winter, per Sagan, humanity could go extinct. The loss would be not just an additional four billion or so deaths, but the loss of all future generations. To paraphrase Sagan, the loss would be billions and billions of lives, or even more. Sagan estimated 500 trillion lives, assuming humanity would continue for ten million more years, which he cited as typical for a successful species. Sagan’s 500 trillion number may even be an underestimate. The analysis here takes an adventurous turn, hinging on the evolution of the human species and the long-term fate of the universe. On these long time scales, the descendants of contemporary humans may no longer be recognizably “human”. The issue then is whether the descendants are still worth caring about, whatever they are. If they are, then it begs the question of how many of them there will be. Barring major global catastrophe, Earth will remain habitable for about one billion more years 2 until the Sun gets too warm and large. The rest of the Solar System, Milky Way galaxy, universe, and (if it exists) the multiverse will remain habitable for a lot longer than that (Adams and Laughlin 1997), should our descendants gain the capacity to migrate there. An open question in astronomy is whether it is possible for the descendants of humanity to continue living for an infinite length of time or instead merely an astronomically large but finite length of time (see e.g. Ćirković 2002; Kaku 2005). Either way, the stakes with global catastrophes could be much larger than the loss of 500 trillion lives. Debates about the infinite vs. the merely astronomical are of theoretical interest (Ng 1991; Bossert et al. 2007), but they have limited practical significance. This can be seen when evaluating GCRs from a standard risk-equals-probability-times-magnitude framework. Using Sagan’s 500 trillion lives estimate, it follows that reducing the probability of global catastrophe by a mere one-in-500-trillion chance is of the same significance as saving one human life. Phrased differently, society should try 500 trillion times harder to prevent a global catastrophe than it should to save a person’s life. Or, preventing one million deaths is equivalent to a one-in500-million reduction in the probability of global catastrophe. This suggests society should make extremely large investment in GCR reduction, at the expense of virtually all other objectives. Judge and legal scholar Richard Posner made a similar point in monetary terms (Posner 2004). Posner used $50,000 as the value of a statistical human life (VSL) and 12 billion humans as the total loss of life (double the 2004 world population); he describes both figures as significant underestimates. Multiplying them gives $600 trillion as an underestimate of the value of preventing global catastrophe. For comparison, the United States government typically uses a VSL of around one to ten million dollars (Robinson 2007). Multiplying a $10 million VSL with 500 trillion lives gives $5x1021 as the value of preventing global catastrophe. But even using “just" $600 trillion, society should be willing to spend at least that much to prevent a global catastrophe, which converts to being willing to spend at least $1 million for a one-in-500-million reduction in the probability of global catastrophe. Thus while reasonable disagreement exists on how large of a VSL to use and how much to count future generations, even low-end positions suggest vast resource allocations should be redirected to reducing GCR. This conclusion is only strengthened when considering the astronomical size of the stakes, but the same point holds either way. The bottom line is that, as long as something along the lines of the standard riskequals-probability-times-magnitude framework is being used, then even tiny GCR reductions merit significant effort. This point holds especially strongly for risks of catastrophes that would cause permanent harm to global human civilization. The discussion thus far has assumed that all human lives are valued equally. This assumption is not universally held. People often value some people more than others, favoring themselves, their family and friends, their compatriots, their generation, or others whom they identify with. Great debates rage on across moral philosophy, economics, and other fields about how much people should value others who are distant in space, time, or social relation, as well as the unborn members of future generations. This debate is crucial for all valuations of risk, including GCR. Indeed, if each of us only cares about our immediate selves, then global catastrophes may not be especially important, and we probably have better things to do with our time than worry about them. While everyone has the right to their own views and feelings, we find that the strongest arguments are for the widely held position that all human lives should be valued equally. This position is succinctly stated in the United States Declaration of Independence, updated in the 1848 Declaration of Sentiments: “We hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men and 3 women are created equal”. Philosophers speak of an agent-neutral, objective “view from nowhere” (Nagel 1986) or a “veil of ignorance” (Rawls 1971) in which each person considers what is best for society irrespective of which member of society they happen to be. Such a perspective suggests valuing everyone equally, regardless of who they are or where or when they live. This in turn suggests a very high value for reducing GCR, or a high degree of priority for GCR reduction efforts.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Aff Answers › Perm › 2AC – Perm – Environmental Reform

Challenging environmental injustice through state engagement is key – that includes action through the court

NoiseCat 16 (Julian Brave - enrolled member of the Canim Lake Band Tsq'escen in British Columbia where he was nominated to run for Chief in 2014 AND a graduate of Columbia University and the University of Oxford, “The Indigenous Revolution,” 11/24/16, https://www.jacobinmag.com/2016/11/standing-rock-dakota-access-pipeline-obama/)

Movements working to reshape infrastructure, environmental policy, financial systems, policing, and work will be of particular importance to indigenous people. Fossil fuel divestment and the “Keep It in the Ground” movement can weaken and even undermine companies seeking to exploit fossil fuels on indigenous lands. Regulations that dismantle financial instruments and policies that profit from natural resource speculation could divert and damage returns on capital flows. The abolition of mass incarceration would loosen the death grip of prisons and police on indigenous communities. Unions can turn individual workers into collective forces of resistance, helping drive up costs for developers and protect laborers from unsafe working conditions. Long-term efforts to reimagine work through full automation and a universal basic income could prevent laborers from having to seek such dangerous work in the first place. As Standing Rock has shown, indigenous nations that use their unique standing to advocate for viable alternatives to unjust systems will gain supporters. Our traditional territories encompass the rivers, mountains, and forests that capital exploits with abandon. Our resistance — to the pipelines, bulldozers, and mines that cut through our lands and communities — has greater potential than yet realized. Ours is a powerful voice envisioning a more harmonious and sustainable relationship with the natural world rooted in the resurgence of indigenous sovereignty. As long as indigenous people continue to make this argument, we are positioned to win policies, court decisions, and international agreements that protect and enlarge our sovereignty and jurisdiction. As our jurisdiction and sovereignty grow, we will have more power to stop, reroute, and transform carbon-based, capitalist, and colonial infrastructure. When the Justice Department halted construction of DAPL in October, they also said they would begin looking into Free Prior Informed Consent legislation. This is a minimal first step, and we must hold them to it. Longstanding alliances with progressive parties and politicians are key to our success. In the United States, Native people have worked with Democratic elected officials like Bernie Sanders and Raúl Grijalva to advance bills like the Save Oak Flat Act, which aimed to stop an international mining conglomerate from exploiting an Apache sacred site in Arizona. In Canada, First Nations have supported the New Democratic Party. In New Zealand, the Maori Rātana religious and political movement has an alliance with the Labour Party that stretches back to the 1930s. Some indigenous leaders, such as outspoken Aboriginal Australian leader Pat Dodson, a Labour senator for Western Australia, have won prominent positions in these parties. This does not mean, of course, that we should pay deference to elected officials. In 2014, Obama became one of the first sitting presidents to visit an Indian reservation when he travelled to Standing Rock. His visit was historically symbolic and emotionally important, but if Obama fails to stop DAPL, indigenous people should renounce him. Politicians are helpful when they change policies and outcomes. We cannot and should not settle for symbolic victories. If there is to be an enduring indigenous-left coalition, the Left must support indigenous demands for land, jurisdiction, and sovereignty. At their core, these demands undermine the imperial cut-and-paste model of the nation-state, stretching from Hobbes to the present, which insists that there is room for just one sovereign entity in the state apparatus. Thomas Piketty’s call for a global wealth tax implies an international governance structure to levy such a tax. He pushes us to think beyond the state. Similarly, indigenous demands for lands, jurisdiction, and sovereignty imply that we must think beneath it. As the Fourth World continues to push states to recognize our inherent, constitutional, and treaty rights as sovereign nations, the Left cannot remain neutral. To remain neutral is to perpetuate a long history of colonization. To remain neutral is to lose a valuable, organized, and powerful ally.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Aff Answers › Link › 2AC – AT: State Link

Understanding the intricacies of the state is a necessary component of dismantling it and ensuring the self-determining status of indigenous peoples as international nations.

Turner ‘06 (Dale – member of the Temagami First Nation and Associate Professor of Government and Native American Studies @ Dartmouth College, This Is Not a Peace Pipe: Towards a Critical Indigenous Philosophy, p. 9-11)

These three projects, as a whole, will create what I call a 'critical indigenous philosophy.' The division of intellectual labour gives rise to both practical and philosophical problems. First, very few indigenous intellectuals are able - or even permitted - to undertake the first philosophical project: indigenous philosophies are highly specialized forms of knowledge, and not every indigenous intellectual has the right to know and articulate them. Second, there are few indigenous philosophers, and even fewer indigenous intellectuals, effectively engaging the Western European history of ideas. Word warriors explicitly engage the second and third projects, but ought to do so guided by their understandings of indigenous philosophy.12 At this time in our development as an intellectual culture (as part of mainstream intellectual culture), our numbers are small - to the dominant culture almost insignificant – which means that we must make our intellectual labour count – we need to be effective in engaging the existing legal and political discourses of the state. For us to make any successful inroads into mainstream intellectual culture, we will have to be very careful about how our ways of knowing the world are talked about, written about, and ultimately put to use in legal and political practices (such as Supreme Court decisions and public policies). Yet the 'our' I am referring to can be misleading. There is a great diversity of indigenous knowledge in the world, so we must consider making these intellectual inroads into the dominant culture as a community of indigenous intellectuals. In other words, our critical indigenous intellectual community would consist of intellectuals from many nations, all of them in dialogue with one another. Once our ways of thinking about the world are up for 'negotiation' in the legal and political discourses of states, we will be in the position of having to defend our world views as legal and political arguments. Sound arguments evolve from a series of propositions that can be shown to be true, and an indigenous intellectual community must construct these arguments so that they are coherent and most of all convincing. This imperative may be unjust, but our survival as independent and self-determining nations demands that we bow to it. However, this reality check is met with an indigenous imperative: indigenous peoples are not going away, and they will always claim that they own their homelands. Let me return to my earlier claim: If Aboriginal peoples want to assert that they possess different world views, and that these differences ought to matter in the political relationship between Aboriginal peoples and the Canadian state, they must engage the Canadian state's legal and political discourses in more effective ways. The sources of these differences lie in indigenous philosophies. Word warriors must protect these forms of knowledge from exploitation by indigenous and non-indigenous peoples, and must do so mainly by engaging Western European intellectual culture. Yet at the same time they must retain strong connections to their communities. If we want the indigenous intellectual community to benefit indigenous peoples, we must know what we are talking about in the political dialogue, and we must be clear about what we are doing in the process. There are no guarantees that what indigenous intellectuals do will ultimately bring about a higher quality of life for their communities. That said, indigenous peoples cannot allow the dominant culture to continue to dictate their legal and political realities. Greater participation in the state's legal and political practices is vital to our survival as indigenous peoples, but at this time in history it is by no means clear how we ought to participate.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Aff Answers › Link › 2AC – AT: State Link

The state is inevitable in the long term but abdicating a discussion of the intricacies of the state forecloses the knowledge necessary to combat the state.

Turner ‘06 (Dale – member of the Temagami First Nation and Associate Professor of Government and Native American Studies @ Dartmouth College, This Is Not a Peace Pipe: Towards a Critical Indigenous Philosophy, p. 113-114)

I do not agree that law does not have a role to play in securing a political relationship that will allow indigenous communities to thrive, but Monture is right to point towards indigenous philosophy as the source of our future well-being as indigenous peoples. Her work highlights another important point about indigenous intellectual communities: we must resolve our own societal problems, and in our own ways, but we cannot do so while we are still held in a legal and political straitjacket by the Canadian state. Her experiences as a law professor show how hostile the dominant intellectual culture can be, but it does not follow from this hostility that indigenous peoples must riot participate in these agonic communities. Regardless, Monture has travelled a rough road and continues to be an important and active voice in Canadian indigenous intellectual culture. Indigenous intellectuals, then - at least those who explicitly engage the legal and political discourses of the state - need to engage in three kinds of overlapping activities. First, they must engage colonialism in its physical and intellectual contexts and in the process strive to overcome the colonial mindset in both indigenous and non-indigenous communities. Second, they must protect and defend our 'indigeneity'; that is, they must work to ensure that indigenous ways of knowing the world are not devalued, marginalized, or ridiculed in the marketplace of ideas. Third and finally, an indigenous intellectual community must assert and defend the integrity of indigenous political rights in the legal and political discourses of the state. This is no easy task, but I see hope in many of the young indigenous and non-indigenous people who seek justice for indigenous peoples. Still, there is much intellectual work to be done. Alfred, Borrows, and Monture are not philosophers - that is, philosophers trained in the European tradition. Which leads one to ask: What can an indigenous person who is trained in European philosophy do to play a more effective role in the relationship between the indigenous political leadership, which finds its roots in indigenous philosophy, and the European intellectual tradition, which is used in articulating the content of Aboriginal rights discourse in Canada? 40 I believe there are two important roles a philosopher can play. The first is pedagogical. From my own experience, I have seen too many indigenous students come into university resisting the idea that learning European forms of knowledge, never mind critiquing European ways of thinking, is important for their intellectual development. Don't get me wrong - there are very good reasons for this resistance, and I don't think every person, indigenous or non-indigenous, is suited to this kind of intellectual journey. Indigenous professors are obligated to guide their students through complex intellectual landscapes so that they can begin to think for themselves how ideas relate to their indigeneity. Like all students, indigenous students need to learn bodies of knowledge in order to be able to think effectively; and if indigenous students leave university without at least knowing the social, legal, and political history of the Indian-white relationship, they have failed to receive a good education and their chances of becoming effective indigenous intellectuals are severely limited. But 'thinking about thinking' is the philosopher's intellectual domain, and indigenous philosophy professors can explicitly weave the third intellectual project into their teaching. As I stated earlier: indigenous intellectuals engage European ideas both as a philosophical exercise and as a political activity. It is not enough to simply engage European thought on its own terms; indigenous intellectuals need to critically engage European ideas, methodologies, and theories to show how they have marginalized, distorted, and ignored indigenous voices. In order to do this effectively, we must first come to understand, as best we can, the European history of ideas on its own terms.41 This means we need to understand how normative language - that is, the language that makes substantive claims about 'what is the case' - is put to use in a particular way of perceiving the world. Once we do understand, we can assess whether this normative language is useful for us as indigenous intellectuals.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Aff Answers › AT: Ontology › 2AC – AT: Ontology

Sweeping theories of radical indigenous ontological difference ignore the nuances of actual struggles that strategically repurpose settler categories

Rosenow, 19—Senior Lecturer in International Relations at Oxford Brookes University (Doerthe, “Decolonising the Decolonisers? Of Ontological Encounters in the GMO Controversy and Beyond,” Global Society, 33:1, 82-99, dml)

Despite the force and importance of this argument, I have felt slightly uneasy when reading those conclusions. Focusing on radical ontological difference can easily lead to a romanticised reification of other peoples’ difference that is in danger of ignoring actual political struggles and demands on the ground. As Cusicanqui argues, those struggles might very well emerge out of an “indigenous modernity”, rather than an insistence on the right to one’s difference. By this she means that some Indigenous people aim to formulate a hegemonic vision for how to structure a society that is valid for everyone (Indigenous AND non-Indigenous): they work for a society that is in their “image and likeness”, and to use modern notions such as “citizenship” for this purpose, rather than rejecting the latter as irreconcilable with one’s own world.39 By contrast, some North American Indigenous intellectuals call for an Indigenous “resurgence” that, rather than seeking hegemony, altogether turns away from seeking recognition by wider (colonial) “society”. As Leanne Betasamosake Simpson points out, in such “resurgent mobilization … there is virtually no room for white people”. 40 But my unease was also emerging from something else, which is what I want to focus on in this article: the problem that encounters and conflicts are yet again made sense of within overarching structures of knowledge production rather than cultivation (despite the intention to do otherwise). As de la Cadena herself makes clear in the quotation above, what is encountered as “different” is inevitably described “in forms that I could understand” (my emphasis)—even whilst simultaneously recognising that one’s description does not capture what the encountered practices actually do. Sense-making, for de la Cadena, takes place at what could be called two levels: At a first level, there is the inevitable process of making sense of an alienating affective experience on the spot, from within one’s own framework of understanding the world. At a second level, then, de la Cadena attempts to make legible her grappling and not-understanding in the context of a book for an academically literate and interested audience—in other words, in the writing-up of her ethnographic research. In Rojas’ and Blaney and Tickner’s case, given that their articles do not aim to make an empirical contribution, sense-making takes place at what could be called a third level: what is drawn upon is the understanding that emerged out of the ethnographic work of others, which is brought into conversation with various bodies of theoretical work in order to make a conceptual contribution. This takes place via the coining of central concepts and the outlining of all-encompassing frameworks that are meant to help us understand the analytical, normative and political consequences of their argument for scholarly work more broadly. The ontological encounters of others are used to delineate the merits of ontological encounters in general, in IR and beyond. This objective leads to a particular way of developing and structuring a generic argument that makes it difficult to move beyond sense-making frameworks that are necessarily geared towards settling all those unsettling and disconcerting experiences that were the focus of the articles in the first place. This is also the problem of some central decolonial work. Drawing on Edouard Glissant, Mignolo, for example, critiques the “requirement of transparency” that forms the basis for understanding in Western social science scholarship. He argues for the “right to opacity” of those located on the other side of the colonial difference.41 But this claim sits at odds with his simultaneous desire to write a new, all-encompassing history of “the modern/colonial world system”. 42 And like in Rojas’ and Blaney and Tickner’s articles, terms such as “pluriversality”43 or “diversality”44 are coined in order to have a (one!) concept for a similarly all-encompassing solution to domination. While de la Cadena is critical of her own “anxiety to understand coherently (with which I meant clearly and without contradiction”), and while she points out how this “was often out of place”, 45 Mignolo as well as Rojas and Blaney and Tickner seek to place such anxiety in yet another coherent framework that holds everything together. The question arises whether this can be any different in scholarly work that is not directly based on ethnographic research itself, and which can therefore not lay claim to a direct experience of ontological controversies. This has become an important question for my own (likewise third-level) work on anti-GMO activism. My work to date has primarily aimed at making a conceptual contribution, and has relied on a conversation between the ethnographic research of others and various bodies of conceptual work, including decolonial and “ontological turn” literature.46 But as I have already indicated in relation to de la Cadena’s work, when writing up their research for academic purposes, even those who have directly experienced ontological encounters find it hard to resist the tendency to conclude their work with stringent, overarching, coherent conclusions that the Westerneducated reader can grasp and “take home”. In the next section, I will draw on two anthropological ethnographic texts that are significant for research on the GMO controversy to show how this works. The two texts that will be analysed in the next section engage with the GMO controversy in Paraguay and Mexico respectively, and they have stood out for me in the way they manage to convey a sense of unease and grappling with ontological encounters and conflicts. However, as the next section will show, they as well end up providing a framework and conclusions that can accommodate and make sense of the encountered ontological difference. 3. Ontological Encounters in the GMO Controversy According to Susana Carro-Ripalda and Marta Astier, much of the research that is carried out in relation to the question of what smallholder producers in the Global South truly think of (and say about) agricultural biotechnology is unable to grasp the “ontological incompatibility” that exists between the experienced human/nonhuman relations in small-scale agriculture on the one hand, and the logic that underlies genetic engineering (GE) on the other.47 This is precisely because most social research is itself grounded in the crucial modern/colonial nature-culture divide: the former can only be known through scientific means, while the latter can be known through the study of social/cultural/political practices. Knowledge about nature is about establishing “facts”, which are either true or false (i.e. nature as “one” is either correctly or incorrectly represented), while knowledge about culture is about studying meaning, which is necessarily (due to the existence of different cultures) multiple. The question of whether GMOs do or do not pose a “factual” danger consequently lies outside of the remit of the social sciences, which therefore focus on the social dimension of statements that are made about nature. But as Kregg Hetherington’s reflections on his own anthropological research journey in Paraguay make clear, this tacit signing-up to modern ontology can lead to difficulties in understanding the reality of the people one is interested in.48 Coming from a position in which he took for granted the scientific distinction between (proven) “fact” and “error”, Hetherington explains how he “translate[d]” the claims of the leader of a local peasant movement49 (Antonio) about the truth of (GM) soy “killer beans” into something else: Until this point, I had approached ethnography as an extended discussion with and about humans, and I was less interested in beans than I was with what Antonio said about them … To be blunt, Antonio kept pointing at the beans, and I kept looking at him … I was comfortable saying that this was a figure of speech, a kind of political rhetoric, or even to claim that this is what Antonio believed, all of which explicitly framed ‘la soja mata’ (soy kills) as data for social analysis, rather than analysis itself worthy of response.50 However, Hetherington points out that not believing in the truth of the killer bean did not prevent him from “participating in Antonio’s knowledge practices”. 51 Becoming involved in the anti-soy bean activism of the peasants, Hetherington became “part of the situation” that made the killer bean turn into a crucial agent in a court case that was brought against two soy farmers for the murder of two activist peasants. As a result, killer beans became transformed into a matter of national concern. Crucially for Hetherington, participation involved more than joining the situation in spite of his lack of belief: it led to him becoming immersed in a relation with both peasants and beans that started to have a physical impact on him—in de la Cadena’s words, he indeed became “partially connected”: 52 Beans didn’t scare me at first. Indeed, as a foreigner to the situation that gives rise to killer beans (a Canadian no less), giant fields of soy were a familiar, even a comforting sight. But it took only a few months with Antonio for me to start feeling the menace from those fields. Soon, the sweetish smell of glyphosate, recently applied, and especially the corpselike smell of 2, 4-D mixed with Tordon, could ruin my appetite and make me expect to see people emerge from their homes to show me pustules on their legs and stomachs.53 Similar observations are also found in Carro-Ripalda and Astier’s contribution to the 2014 Agriculture and Human Values symposium on the challenges of making smallholder producer voices being heard in relation to agricultural biotechnology.54 While most of the contributions to the symposium concentrate on how to tease out smallholders’ “real” voices in the most effective way, Carro-Ripalda and Astier critically reflect on their own perceived failure to become knowledgeable about smallholders’ voices in their research on GM maize cultivation in Mexico. It was through ethnographic fieldwork in rural areas in Central Mexico, in-depth structured interviews, focus groups, participant observation and, finally, a National Workshop in Mexico City with over 50 stakeholders (including smallholder producers) that Carro-Ripalda and Astier attempted to get a better sense of what the actual voices of peasants in the GM controversy were trying to convey.55 However, particularly the final workshop, which aimed to create conditions under which Mexican smallholder producers could speak on their own terms about GM maize cultivation, “unwittingly reproduced the conditions of exclusive, techno-scientific and regulatory spaces”. 56 The public discourse that centres on questions of safety, science, possibilities of regulation and problems of potential contamination, and which is upheld by both GM maize proponents and antiGMO activists, dominated the workshop debate. Even when present smallholders raised different concerns, the discussion always returned to the previous, main ones, as if those who had spoken differently “had not spoken at all”. The way that smallholders could articulate “their perceptions, ideas, and desires” was thereby “severely limited”. 57 Carro-Ripalda and Astier are focused on the dominance of one particular (techno-scientific, regulatory) discourse that, they maintain, disabled smallholder voices engaged in different discourses from speaking up or, when speaking, from being heard. In other words, smallholders were unable to adequately represent their own understanding of what is at stake in the GM maize controversy in Mexico. Considering what I have pointed out in the previous section, based on Rojas, difference is thereby transformed into an epistemological, rather than an ontological one: Carro-Ripalda and Astier’s argument is implicitly based on the assumption that, under the right conditions, difference can be translated into something that can be communicated to, and discussed with, other stakeholders. But the term “ontological incompatibility” that the authors themselves use indicates there is something else at play, which cannot easily be translated: the nature of the relation of smallholder producers to their “land, seed, crop, climate … as told and understood by themselves”; the “central place” that Maize continues to occupy in Mesoamerican pre-Hispanic cosmology, and “the social and cultural significance” that goes along with that.58 Carro-Ripalda and Astier’s emphasis on the problem of the dominant discourse, and the overarching Mexican structures of domination this discourse is related to (such as the “neoliberal vision of the Mexican agricultural future”59), makes it occasionally difficult to understand what the problem of “ontological incompatibility” really is about. At the end of the article, the place of the smallholder producers whom they have engaged seems once again clearly delineated and knowable: at stake for smallholders are, Carro-Ripalda and Astier argue, “their lives as maize cultivators, their pride in their craft and knowledge, and their ceremonially demanded right to information, choice and access to their ‘own resources’”. It is not just about “retaining ‘traditional’ ways of agriculture”, as the anti-GMO movement maintains, but also about claiming “political, economic and socio-cultural rights.”60 Though this certainly adds a significant dimension to the debate, it indeed simply seems to add to, rather than radically challenge, the frameworks that are conventionally used in the anti-GMO debate, as well as the frameworks that focus on how to bring out and represent other people’s “voices” in a better way. Is this simply unavoidable when it comes to the production of academic knowledge through/in academic writing? As already indicated in the previous section, academic writing pursues by definition the objective of enhancing knowledge and providing improved insight into a certain situation. In its very structure, an academic piece of work aims to resolve and settle, rather than to dislocate, to destabilise, or to provide discomfort. Carro-Ripalda and Astier’s article is meant to render legible their own encounter of ontological difference for an academic audience. Is it possible for the reader to dig below these representational strategies, and to relate more directly to their encounter of what they themselves call ontological incompatibility? And which has led them to brand their final workshop, in a quite un-academic way, as a “failure”? There are a few places in the article in which their inability to put into words and arguments all of “the complexity of experiences, relations and reasons that bind people to maize”61 is more obvious. Becoming attuned to this complexity is linked to the authors having to become at least “partially connected”—to yet again use de la Cadena’s phrase—to the relations they attempt to trace. It is interesting, for example, that Carro-Ripalda and Astier talk about “voices” as going beyond the semantic level, as conveying something acoustically, and as requiring a form of listening that shies away from asking pre-given questions. It is also interesting that some of that took place when they literally walked together with their interlocutors; precisely as it is emphasised by Blaney and Tickner:62 Despite the shortcomings of the workshop … we felt that that, through our research on the ground, we had engaged with male and female farmers, heard about their perspectives on GM and their visions of a rural future, and accompanied them to work in milpas and markets. So, what do smallholder farmers’ voices sound like? What meanings did they convey to us? We will provide here but a few of those sounds and meanings … 63 Despite returning to the idea of voices as conveying “meaning” in this quote, meaning is related to sounds, to walking together, to particular places with their own sounds, smells, and colours. The sample of actual “voices” Carro-Ripalda and Astier then choose to present yet again invoke an intricate sense of the relationality of farmers and nonhumans: It is a joy to plant, getting hold of the maize, of a beautiful cob which is pleasant, to go to the harvest, to look at pretty cobs, all regular. Because this is what sustains me. You can see the difference in the seeds straight away … You need to look at the cob and as soon as I grab it I see the difference. It is the person who knows the seed the one who chooses it [for replanting the following year].64 By contrast, GM maize is associated by the smallholders whom Carro-Ripalda and Astier cite with feelings of “artificiality, estrangement and distrust towards the created object (the GMO) in itself, not only because of deep ontological considerations … but because of the political and economic motives which are ‘assembled’ into it.”65 Although the authors make a distinction between ontology and politics/ economics here, their invoking of the “assemblage” precisely shows how the latter becomes part of ontology itself, and then (as in the case of Hetherington) impacts on the sensual, bodily connection with the maize. Understanding the relation between “things” in this way allows for an analysis of power and domination that has at least the potential of moving beyond pre-given frameworks; strategically suspending them in order to “sharpen [the] analysis of exactly how power operates, how relations are made and undermined, and with what consequences”. 66 Genetically modified maize is a problem because it is part of particular Mexican neoliberal visions and strategies, but in the context outlined by Carro-Ripalda and Astier, that vision is not only (and not even primarily) made sense of through given frames of knowledge, such as Marxist theories of the exploitation of labour, but sensually, through the way it disrupts the (physical) pleasure and joy that has sustained the farmer-maize-assemblage so far.67 GM technology externalises the maize from farmers and estrange them from their ways of life; and it is only through this externalisation that GM maize becomes perceivable as a potential source of “contamination”, as a danger against which farmers need to “defend” their seeds.68 Now, some might counter that the previous paragraph in practice only provides a fancy repackaging of the two well-rehearsed arguments brought forward by many anti-GMO activists: (a) that the problem of GMOs is an intrinsic property that makes it “unsafe” (which activists try to scientifically prove), and/or (b) that the fundamental problem of agricultural biotechnology is that it estranges farmers from their traditional, ancestral way of life, that it allows for their exploitation, and that it provides a further foothold for neoliberal visions of how the world should be ordered. Both arguments are grounded in modern ontology: the first goes down the route of science (contesting “facts” about the “nature” of GMOs on the basis of science itself), while the second goes down the “social” route by either making a case for the need to respect cultural multiplicity, or for the need to prevent economic exploitation. Some activists make use of all of these routes and arguments. Famous environmental activist and intellectual Vandana Shiva, for example, determines the alienating character of the GMO to be an intrinsic property, while at the same time depicting smallholder producers as intrinsic “‘reservoirs’ of local or indigenous knowledge or as ‘natural’ conservators of biodiversity through their traditional practices”. 69 According to Carro-Ripalda and Astier, this “unwittingly reinforce[es] images of smallholder producers as passive, timeless and voiceless.”70 This leads to precisely the sort of romanticised reification of “difference” that I have critiqued in the previous section of this article—paradoxically, in this case, on the basis of an ontology that is deeply modern, as it regards both “things” and “people” as ontologically stable and classifiable. By contrast, the authors of the two texts I have analysed in this section trace ontological encounters that cannot be contained by the nature/culture dichotomy. There is no pre-given (social) theory of neoliberalism and global power relations that dictates how the “voice” of the farmer needs to be made sense of. There is also no pregiven understanding of the “factual” (scientific) nature of GMOs. The notion of radical difference that comes up in these two texts emerged from precisely the “misunderstandings” that the encounter of ethnographers with “other people” and their relations brought to the fore; but importantly, it did not make any clearer to the ethnographer what the “stuff” that grounded the misunderstandings is actually composed of.71 Yet, somewhat paradoxically, despite all this emphasis on misunderstandings, incompatibility, grappling, failure, and critical self-reflection of one’s own assumptions—at the end of the day what is left for the readers (at least if they do not explicitly focus on the “ethnographic excess” found in the writings) is the impression that they know more about “stuff” than they did before: that they understand the situation better, that new knowledge has been produced, that the object of analysis is more transparent than it has been before. How can this subjugation of the encountered ontologically difference to academic strategies of comprehensive sense-making avoided (if at all)? This article itself is now coming up to what would normally be a conclusion—i.e. the treacherous waters of nailing its contribution to knowledge. Given that this article is yet again another “third-level” engagement with questions of ontology and decoloniality, the question is whether there is any way to avoid this pull of hegemonic modes of academic knowledge production. Rather than providing a conclusion and reiterate the core argument that the article has made, I will attempt to finish this piece by raising even more questions, and by providing some further reflections. 4. Turtles all the Way Down: (Further) Reflections on What Questions to Ask The pull of hegemonic systems of academic knowledge production is difficult to avoid. This is the case even in writings that are directly based on ontological encounters and controversies, and that reflect on the displacement that encountering different ontologies has entailed. But as I have indicated, this problem is even more pronounced in writings—like my own—that provide what I have previously called “third-level” sense-making of ontological encounters. The contribution of third-level analysis is usually a conceptual one, which makes it by definition veer towards the general and abstract rather than the concrete. In relation to the literature on decolonial thought and the ontological turn, this becomes manifest in three different (yet interrelated) ways: first, in the desire to provide an understanding of ontology that enables a conceptualisation of the former as multiple. Drawing on the work of Mario Blaser and Eduardo Viveiros de Castro respectively, Rojas and Blaney and Tickner argue that ontology can be thought of as multiple if reality is understood as always being “enacted” or “performed”. 72 This is what Blaser calls an understanding of ontology as “materialsemiotic”: one that defines reality as “always in the making through the dynamic relations of hybrid assemblages”. 73 Pinpointing it like this is inevitably geared towards answering the question of what reality as such, in general is about. Secondly, there is an ambition to coin the general normative-political project that arises out of this understanding with a singular concept, such as the pluriverse. Thirdly, arguments about ontological multiplicity and the emancipatory-decolonial political projects that arise out of its recognition are written for an audience of a particular discipline, such as IR: the aim is to provide a wholesale, general rethinking, or, indeed, “reconstruction” of the latter.74 What sort of questions drive conceptual work into that direction, and what desire “to know” underlies the questions? According to Cherokee philosopher Brian Yazzie Burkhart, for Native Americans “the questions we choose to ask are more important than any truths we might hope to discover in asking such questions”. 75 By contrast, Western knowledge is always (at least in the mainstream) propositional knowledge: “knowledge of the form ‘that something is so’”. Here, knowledge cannot be verified by referring to direct experiences: “there must be something underlying them and justifying them”. 76 Burkhart gives the example of the “routine response” given by “Western people” to Indigenous accounts of creation: “In [one] account, the earth rests on the back of a turtle. The Western response to this account is simply the question, ‘What holds the turtle?’” This question makes no sense to the Native storyteller, because the truth of the story lies in the paths to rightful action that it outlines, rather than what it has to say about the “reality” of the world. But when the Westerner insists on the question, the answer finally is: “‘Well, then there must be turtles all the way down’.”77 Equating Rojas’ and Blaney and Tickner’s work with European mainstream (hence analytic) philosophy seems, at first glance, incredibly unfair. After all, those authors precisely advocate the cultivating of knowledge by direct awareness or acquaintance in exactly the way that Burkhart identifies as typical for Native Americans. But on the other hand, the framework that circumscribes their emphasis on the need for “concreteness” is still an abstract one that wants to answer the question of how things really are and should be: enacted, performed, pluriversal, … The point is not whether this argument about reality and politics is right or wrong. The point is to recognise that it is driven by particular questions that might make no sense in the context of other intelligence systems, but that need to be addressed in an academic article in order to make a conceptual argument compelling, convincing and original for an audience that primarily sits (whether it likes it or not) within a Western, colonial, hegemonic system of knowledge production.78 And even when the contribution to knowledge production is not primarily conceptual, as in the “second-level” work that I have analysed in the previous section in relation to the GMO controversy, the final argument that is made (e.g. about peasants’ economic and cultural rights) is yet again lucid and comprehensible to an audience that seeks to comprehend “stuff” within modern parameters. Where to go from here (particularly as a white, European scholar)? As suggested by Tucker, one way might be to engage in much more direct, ethnographic research, which would enable more direct experience of ontological encounters. Despite previously-mentioned problems of even that research not going far enough, there is without doubt more space for providing a sense of grappling and dislocation if the originality of a piece of work is not purely grounded in the conceptual contribution it aims to make. However, not every scholar is able— body-, context- or funding-wise—to spend extensive periods of time in different places, and the ethical and political pitfalls of researching “radical difference” through fieldwork with—but often rather on—others have been pointed out by Indigenous scholars numerous times.79 But even for those unable or unwilling to do more primary, empirical research, there is space to push the boundaries of what can and should be written about (and how). For decades there have been attempts to provide “innovative” platforms, for example at conferences, to talk about “stuff” in different ways (e.g. through storytelling or artistic practices; not at least by e.g. Indigenous peoples themselves80). However, these “innovations” are still at the margins, and they will most likely never be able to compete with acknowledged knowledge production outlets such as journal articles and scholarly books. But even within the latter, there is always at least some space to push for more open-endedness, more reflection on the author’s embodied positionality, more auto-critique, more uncertainty and grappling (even if this is based on reading about the ontological encounters of others). Although this sort of embodied self-reflection on a writer’s “situatedness” (which in my own case means being “on the colonising side of a divide”81) has obviously been advanced by many critical scholars for decades (including feminists and post- as well as decolonial scholars), this article has hopefully shown that there is still (always) a need to go further, in order to more fundamentally challenge hegemonic, modern/colonial modes of knowledge production. The sense of unease that I have outlined in section two was particularly strong when reading conclusions that were geared towards making recommendations for the discipline of IR, or for “international politics”, as such. Aiming to make generic conclusions for entire disciplines, political fields, or global “issues” pushes the generality and abstraction of a contribution even further away from an advocacy of the concrete. Why, and to whom, does it matter whether IR, as a discipline, or international politics, as object of study, becomes more pluriversal or not? What are the actual benefits of the concept of the pluriverse in the first place? Or to pick up the theme of this special issue: why does it matter whether IR is, or should move into, a mode of affirmation rather than critique?82 Why is this a good question to ask—and for whom? This is not just a theoretical problem, but it has real-life consequences for actually-existing decolonial struggles. The desire for making a generic argument about relational ontologies and a pluriversal politics harbours the danger of making a huge variety of demands and struggles that often exist in tension and contradiction with each other commensurable. Indigenous demands for the repatriation of “their” land might be at odds with the social justice demands for redistribution and “the commons”. 83 For Blaney and Tickner, decolonial thought is commensurable with not just the ontological turn literature, but also feminist and other critical interventions.84 Mignolo and Arturo Escobar advocate a transnational fight for global justice and are enthusiastic about the potential of global movements to achieve that aim together.85 Like Mignolo, Rojas explicitly draws on the World Social Forum slogan “Another world is possible” as well as the Zapatistas slogan of “a world where many words fit” to make her case about the need for a pluriversal understanding of emancipatory-decolonial politics.86 While it can be argued that this problem of seeing all these struggles and demands as commensurable goes back to a lack of actual engagement with particular decolonial practices and battles, what I have argued in this article is that it is also related to the problem of how and what sort of knowledge is produced and valued in the Western academy: knowledge that is abstract, generic, and applicable beyond a specific context. Knowledge that is driven by the desire to know what is. Knowledge that desires to know what holds the turtle—all the way down.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Aff Answers › AT: Ontology › 2AC – State Good

Sweeping theories of radical indigenous ontological difference ignore the nuances of actual struggles that strategically repurpose settler categories

Rosenow, 19—Senior Lecturer in International Relations at Oxford Brookes University (Doerthe, “Decolonising the Decolonisers? Of Ontological Encounters in the GMO Controversy and Beyond,” Global Society, 33:1, 82-99, dml)

Despite the force and importance of this argument, I have felt slightly uneasy when reading those conclusions. Focusing on radical ontological difference can easily lead to a romanticised reification of other peoples’ difference that is in danger of ignoring actual political struggles and demands on the ground. As Cusicanqui argues, those struggles might very well emerge out of an “indigenous modernity”, rather than an insistence on the right to one’s difference. By this she means that some Indigenous people aim to formulate a hegemonic vision for how to structure a society that is valid for everyone (Indigenous AND non-Indigenous): they work for a society that is in their “image and likeness”, and to use modern notions such as “citizenship” for this purpose, rather than rejecting the latter as irreconcilable with one’s own world.39 By contrast, some North American Indigenous intellectuals call for an Indigenous “resurgence” that, rather than seeking hegemony, altogether turns away from seeking recognition by wider (colonial) “society”. As Leanne Betasamosake Simpson points out, in such “resurgent mobilization … there is virtually no room for white people”. 40 But my unease was also emerging from something else, which is what I want to focus on in this article: the problem that encounters and conflicts are yet again made sense of within overarching structures of knowledge production rather than cultivation (despite the intention to do otherwise). As de la Cadena herself makes clear in the quotation above, what is encountered as “different” is inevitably described “in forms that I could understand” (my emphasis)—even whilst simultaneously recognising that one’s description does not capture what the encountered practices actually do. Sense-making, for de la Cadena, takes place at what could be called two levels: At a first level, there is the inevitable process of making sense of an alienating affective experience on the spot, from within one’s own framework of understanding the world. At a second level, then, de la Cadena attempts to make legible her grappling and not-understanding in the context of a book for an academically literate and interested audience—in other words, in the writing-up of her ethnographic research. In Rojas’ and Blaney and Tickner’s case, given that their articles do not aim to make an empirical contribution, sense-making takes place at what could be called a third level: what is drawn upon is the understanding that emerged out of the ethnographic work of others, which is brought into conversation with various bodies of theoretical work in order to make a conceptual contribution. This takes place via the coining of central concepts and the outlining of all-encompassing frameworks that are meant to help us understand the analytical, normative and political consequences of their argument for scholarly work more broadly. The ontological encounters of others are used to delineate the merits of ontological encounters in general, in IR and beyond. This objective leads to a particular way of developing and structuring a generic argument that makes it difficult to move beyond sense-making frameworks that are necessarily geared towards settling all those unsettling and disconcerting experiences that were the focus of the articles in the first place. This is also the problem of some central decolonial work. Drawing on Edouard Glissant, Mignolo, for example, critiques the “requirement of transparency” that forms the basis for understanding in Western social science scholarship. He argues for the “right to opacity” of those located on the other side of the colonial difference.41 But this claim sits at odds with his simultaneous desire to write a new, all-encompassing history of “the modern/colonial world system”. 42 And like in Rojas’ and Blaney and Tickner’s articles, terms such as “pluriversality”43 or “diversality”44 are coined in order to have a (one!) concept for a similarly all-encompassing solution to domination. While de la Cadena is critical of her own “anxiety to understand coherently (with which I meant clearly and without contradiction”), and while she points out how this “was often out of place”, 45 Mignolo as well as Rojas and Blaney and Tickner seek to place such anxiety in yet another coherent framework that holds everything together. The question arises whether this can be any different in scholarly work that is not directly based on ethnographic research itself, and which can therefore not lay claim to a direct experience of ontological controversies. This has become an important question for my own (likewise third-level) work on anti-GMO activism. My work to date has primarily aimed at making a conceptual contribution, and has relied on a conversation between the ethnographic research of others and various bodies of conceptual work, including decolonial and “ontological turn” literature.46 But as I have already indicated in relation to de la Cadena’s work, when writing up their research for academic purposes, even those who have directly experienced ontological encounters find it hard to resist the tendency to conclude their work with stringent, overarching, coherent conclusions that the Westerneducated reader can grasp and “take home”. In the next section, I will draw on two anthropological ethnographic texts that are significant for research on the GMO controversy to show how this works. The two texts that will be analysed in the next section engage with the GMO controversy in Paraguay and Mexico respectively, and they have stood out for me in the way they manage to convey a sense of unease and grappling with ontological encounters and conflicts. However, as the next section will show, they as well end up providing a framework and conclusions that can accommodate and make sense of the encountered ontological difference. 3. Ontological Encounters in the GMO Controversy According to Susana Carro-Ripalda and Marta Astier, much of the research that is carried out in relation to the question of what smallholder producers in the Global South truly think of (and say about) agricultural biotechnology is unable to grasp the “ontological incompatibility” that exists between the experienced human/nonhuman relations in small-scale agriculture on the one hand, and the logic that underlies genetic engineering (GE) on the other.47 This is precisely because most social research is itself grounded in the crucial modern/colonial nature-culture divide: the former can only be known through scientific means, while the latter can be known through the study of social/cultural/political practices. Knowledge about nature is about establishing “facts”, which are either true or false (i.e. nature as “one” is either correctly or incorrectly represented), while knowledge about culture is about studying meaning, which is necessarily (due to the existence of different cultures) multiple. The question of whether GMOs do or do not pose a “factual” danger consequently lies outside of the remit of the social sciences, which therefore focus on the social dimension of statements that are made about nature. But as Kregg Hetherington’s reflections on his own anthropological research journey in Paraguay make clear, this tacit signing-up to modern ontology can lead to difficulties in understanding the reality of the people one is interested in.48 Coming from a position in which he took for granted the scientific distinction between (proven) “fact” and “error”, Hetherington explains how he “translate[d]” the claims of the leader of a local peasant movement49 (Antonio) about the truth of (GM) soy “killer beans” into something else: Until this point, I had approached ethnography as an extended discussion with and about humans, and I was less interested in beans than I was with what Antonio said about them … To be blunt, Antonio kept pointing at the beans, and I kept looking at him … I was comfortable saying that this was a figure of speech, a kind of political rhetoric, or even to claim that this is what Antonio believed, all of which explicitly framed ‘la soja mata’ (soy kills) as data for social analysis, rather than analysis itself worthy of response.50 However, Hetherington points out that not believing in the truth of the killer bean did not prevent him from “participating in Antonio’s knowledge practices”. 51 Becoming involved in the anti-soy bean activism of the peasants, Hetherington became “part of the situation” that made the killer bean turn into a crucial agent in a court case that was brought against two soy farmers for the murder of two activist peasants. As a result, killer beans became transformed into a matter of national concern. Crucially for Hetherington, participation involved more than joining the situation in spite of his lack of belief: it led to him becoming immersed in a relation with both peasants and beans that started to have a physical impact on him—in de la Cadena’s words, he indeed became “partially connected”: 52 Beans didn’t scare me at first. Indeed, as a foreigner to the situation that gives rise to killer beans (a Canadian no less), giant fields of soy were a familiar, even a comforting sight. But it took only a few months with Antonio for me to start feeling the menace from those fields. Soon, the sweetish smell of glyphosate, recently applied, and especially the corpselike smell of 2, 4-D mixed with Tordon, could ruin my appetite and make me expect to see people emerge from their homes to show me pustules on their legs and stomachs.53 Similar observations are also found in Carro-Ripalda and Astier’s contribution to the 2014 Agriculture and Human Values symposium on the challenges of making smallholder producer voices being heard in relation to agricultural biotechnology.54 While most of the contributions to the symposium concentrate on how to tease out smallholders’ “real” voices in the most effective way, Carro-Ripalda and Astier critically reflect on their own perceived failure to become knowledgeable about smallholders’ voices in their research on GM maize cultivation in Mexico. It was through ethnographic fieldwork in rural areas in Central Mexico, in-depth structured interviews, focus groups, participant observation and, finally, a National Workshop in Mexico City with over 50 stakeholders (including smallholder producers) that Carro-Ripalda and Astier attempted to get a better sense of what the actual voices of peasants in the GM controversy were trying to convey.55 However, particularly the final workshop, which aimed to create conditions under which Mexican smallholder producers could speak on their own terms about GM maize cultivation, “unwittingly reproduced the conditions of exclusive, techno-scientific and regulatory spaces”. 56 The public discourse that centres on questions of safety, science, possibilities of regulation and problems of potential contamination, and which is upheld by both GM maize proponents and antiGMO activists, dominated the workshop debate. Even when present smallholders raised different concerns, the discussion always returned to the previous, main ones, as if those who had spoken differently “had not spoken at all”. The way that smallholders could articulate “their perceptions, ideas, and desires” was thereby “severely limited”. 57 Carro-Ripalda and Astier are focused on the dominance of one particular (techno-scientific, regulatory) discourse that, they maintain, disabled smallholder voices engaged in different discourses from speaking up or, when speaking, from being heard. In other words, smallholders were unable to adequately represent their own understanding of what is at stake in the GM maize controversy in Mexico. Considering what I have pointed out in the previous section, based on Rojas, difference is thereby transformed into an epistemological, rather than an ontological one: Carro-Ripalda and Astier’s argument is implicitly based on the assumption that, under the right conditions, difference can be translated into something that can be communicated to, and discussed with, other stakeholders. But the term “ontological incompatibility” that the authors themselves use indicates there is something else at play, which cannot easily be translated: the nature of the relation of smallholder producers to their “land, seed, crop, climate … as told and understood by themselves”; the “central place” that Maize continues to occupy in Mesoamerican pre-Hispanic cosmology, and “the social and cultural significance” that goes along with that.58 Carro-Ripalda and Astier’s emphasis on the problem of the dominant discourse, and the overarching Mexican structures of domination this discourse is related to (such as the “neoliberal vision of the Mexican agricultural future”59), makes it occasionally difficult to understand what the problem of “ontological incompatibility” really is about. At the end of the article, the place of the smallholder producers whom they have engaged seems once again clearly delineated and knowable: at stake for smallholders are, Carro-Ripalda and Astier argue, “their lives as maize cultivators, their pride in their craft and knowledge, and their ceremonially demanded right to information, choice and access to their ‘own resources’”. It is not just about “retaining ‘traditional’ ways of agriculture”, as the anti-GMO movement maintains, but also about claiming “political, economic and socio-cultural rights.”60 Though this certainly adds a significant dimension to the debate, it indeed simply seems to add to, rather than radically challenge, the frameworks that are conventionally used in the anti-GMO debate, as well as the frameworks that focus on how to bring out and represent other people’s “voices” in a better way. Is this simply unavoidable when it comes to the production of academic knowledge through/in academic writing? As already indicated in the previous section, academic writing pursues by definition the objective of enhancing knowledge and providing improved insight into a certain situation. In its very structure, an academic piece of work aims to resolve and settle, rather than to dislocate, to destabilise, or to provide discomfort. Carro-Ripalda and Astier’s article is meant to render legible their own encounter of ontological difference for an academic audience. Is it possible for the reader to dig below these representational strategies, and to relate more directly to their encounter of what they themselves call ontological incompatibility? And which has led them to brand their final workshop, in a quite un-academic way, as a “failure”? There are a few places in the article in which their inability to put into words and arguments all of “the complexity of experiences, relations and reasons that bind people to maize”61 is more obvious. Becoming attuned to this complexity is linked to the authors having to become at least “partially connected”—to yet again use de la Cadena’s phrase—to the relations they attempt to trace. It is interesting, for example, that Carro-Ripalda and Astier talk about “voices” as going beyond the semantic level, as conveying something acoustically, and as requiring a form of listening that shies away from asking pre-given questions. It is also interesting that some of that took place when they literally walked together with their interlocutors; precisely as it is emphasised by Blaney and Tickner:62 Despite the shortcomings of the workshop … we felt that that, through our research on the ground, we had engaged with male and female farmers, heard about their perspectives on GM and their visions of a rural future, and accompanied them to work in milpas and markets. So, what do smallholder farmers’ voices sound like? What meanings did they convey to us? We will provide here but a few of those sounds and meanings … 63 Despite returning to the idea of voices as conveying “meaning” in this quote, meaning is related to sounds, to walking together, to particular places with their own sounds, smells, and colours. The sample of actual “voices” Carro-Ripalda and Astier then choose to present yet again invoke an intricate sense of the relationality of farmers and nonhumans: It is a joy to plant, getting hold of the maize, of a beautiful cob which is pleasant, to go to the harvest, to look at pretty cobs, all regular. Because this is what sustains me. You can see the difference in the seeds straight away … You need to look at the cob and as soon as I grab it I see the difference. It is the person who knows the seed the one who chooses it [for replanting the following year].64 By contrast, GM maize is associated by the smallholders whom Carro-Ripalda and Astier cite with feelings of “artificiality, estrangement and distrust towards the created object (the GMO) in itself, not only because of deep ontological considerations … but because of the political and economic motives which are ‘assembled’ into it.”65 Although the authors make a distinction between ontology and politics/ economics here, their invoking of the “assemblage” precisely shows how the latter becomes part of ontology itself, and then (as in the case of Hetherington) impacts on the sensual, bodily connection with the maize. Understanding the relation between “things” in this way allows for an analysis of power and domination that has at least the potential of moving beyond pre-given frameworks; strategically suspending them in order to “sharpen [the] analysis of exactly how power operates, how relations are made and undermined, and with what consequences”. 66 Genetically modified maize is a problem because it is part of particular Mexican neoliberal visions and strategies, but in the context outlined by Carro-Ripalda and Astier, that vision is not only (and not even primarily) made sense of through given frames of knowledge, such as Marxist theories of the exploitation of labour, but sensually, through the way it disrupts the (physical) pleasure and joy that has sustained the farmer-maize-assemblage so far.67 GM technology externalises the maize from farmers and estrange them from their ways of life; and it is only through this externalisation that GM maize becomes perceivable as a potential source of “contamination”, as a danger against which farmers need to “defend” their seeds.68 Now, some might counter that the previous paragraph in practice only provides a fancy repackaging of the two well-rehearsed arguments brought forward by many anti-GMO activists: (a) that the problem of GMOs is an intrinsic property that makes it “unsafe” (which activists try to scientifically prove), and/or (b) that the fundamental problem of agricultural biotechnology is that it estranges farmers from their traditional, ancestral way of life, that it allows for their exploitation, and that it provides a further foothold for neoliberal visions of how the world should be ordered. Both arguments are grounded in modern ontology: the first goes down the route of science (contesting “facts” about the “nature” of GMOs on the basis of science itself), while the second goes down the “social” route by either making a case for the need to respect cultural multiplicity, or for the need to prevent economic exploitation. Some activists make use of all of these routes and arguments. Famous environmental activist and intellectual Vandana Shiva, for example, determines the alienating character of the GMO to be an intrinsic property, while at the same time depicting smallholder producers as intrinsic “‘reservoirs’ of local or indigenous knowledge or as ‘natural’ conservators of biodiversity through their traditional practices”. 69 According to Carro-Ripalda and Astier, this “unwittingly reinforce[es] images of smallholder producers as passive, timeless and voiceless.”70 This leads to precisely the sort of romanticised reification of “difference” that I have critiqued in the previous section of this article—paradoxically, in this case, on the basis of an ontology that is deeply modern, as it regards both “things” and “people” as ontologically stable and classifiable. By contrast, the authors of the two texts I have analysed in this section trace ontological encounters that cannot be contained by the nature/culture dichotomy. There is no pre-given (social) theory of neoliberalism and global power relations that dictates how the “voice” of the farmer needs to be made sense of. There is also no pregiven understanding of the “factual” (scientific) nature of GMOs. The notion of radical difference that comes up in these two texts emerged from precisely the “misunderstandings” that the encounter of ethnographers with “other people” and their relations brought to the fore; but importantly, it did not make any clearer to the ethnographer what the “stuff” that grounded the misunderstandings is actually composed of.71 Yet, somewhat paradoxically, despite all this emphasis on misunderstandings, incompatibility, grappling, failure, and critical self-reflection of one’s own assumptions—at the end of the day what is left for the readers (at least if they do not explicitly focus on the “ethnographic excess” found in the writings) is the impression that they know more about “stuff” than they did before: that they understand the situation better, that new knowledge has been produced, that the object of analysis is more transparent than it has been before. How can this subjugation of the encountered ontologically difference to academic strategies of comprehensive sense-making avoided (if at all)? This article itself is now coming up to what would normally be a conclusion—i.e. the treacherous waters of nailing its contribution to knowledge. Given that this article is yet again another “third-level” engagement with questions of ontology and decoloniality, the question is whether there is any way to avoid this pull of hegemonic modes of academic knowledge production. Rather than providing a conclusion and reiterate the core argument that the article has made, I will attempt to finish this piece by raising even more questions, and by providing some further reflections. 4. Turtles all the Way Down: (Further) Reflections on What Questions to Ask The pull of hegemonic systems of academic knowledge production is difficult to avoid. This is the case even in writings that are directly based on ontological encounters and controversies, and that reflect on the displacement that encountering different ontologies has entailed. But as I have indicated, this problem is even more pronounced in writings—like my own—that provide what I have previously called “third-level” sense-making of ontological encounters. The contribution of third-level analysis is usually a conceptual one, which makes it by definition veer towards the general and abstract rather than the concrete. In relation to the literature on decolonial thought and the ontological turn, this becomes manifest in three different (yet interrelated) ways: first, in the desire to provide an understanding of ontology that enables a conceptualisation of the former as multiple. Drawing on the work of Mario Blaser and Eduardo Viveiros de Castro respectively, Rojas and Blaney and Tickner argue that ontology can be thought of as multiple if reality is understood as always being “enacted” or “performed”. 72 This is what Blaser calls an understanding of ontology as “materialsemiotic”: one that defines reality as “always in the making through the dynamic relations of hybrid assemblages”. 73 Pinpointing it like this is inevitably geared towards answering the question of what reality as such, in general is about. Secondly, there is an ambition to coin the general normative-political project that arises out of this understanding with a singular concept, such as the pluriverse. Thirdly, arguments about ontological multiplicity and the emancipatory-decolonial political projects that arise out of its recognition are written for an audience of a particular discipline, such as IR: the aim is to provide a wholesale, general rethinking, or, indeed, “reconstruction” of the latter.74 What sort of questions drive conceptual work into that direction, and what desire “to know” underlies the questions? According to Cherokee philosopher Brian Yazzie Burkhart, for Native Americans “the questions we choose to ask are more important than any truths we might hope to discover in asking such questions”. 75 By contrast, Western knowledge is always (at least in the mainstream) propositional knowledge: “knowledge of the form ‘that something is so’”. Here, knowledge cannot be verified by referring to direct experiences: “there must be something underlying them and justifying them”. 76 Burkhart gives the example of the “routine response” given by “Western people” to Indigenous accounts of creation: “In [one] account, the earth rests on the back of a turtle. The Western response to this account is simply the question, ‘What holds the turtle?’” This question makes no sense to the Native storyteller, because the truth of the story lies in the paths to rightful action that it outlines, rather than what it has to say about the “reality” of the world. But when the Westerner insists on the question, the answer finally is: “‘Well, then there must be turtles all the way down’.”77 Equating Rojas’ and Blaney and Tickner’s work with European mainstream (hence analytic) philosophy seems, at first glance, incredibly unfair. After all, those authors precisely advocate the cultivating of knowledge by direct awareness or acquaintance in exactly the way that Burkhart identifies as typical for Native Americans. But on the other hand, the framework that circumscribes their emphasis on the need for “concreteness” is still an abstract one that wants to answer the question of how things really are and should be: enacted, performed, pluriversal, … The point is not whether this argument about reality and politics is right or wrong. The point is to recognise that it is driven by particular questions that might make no sense in the context of other intelligence systems, but that need to be addressed in an academic article in order to make a conceptual argument compelling, convincing and original for an audience that primarily sits (whether it likes it or not) within a Western, colonial, hegemonic system of knowledge production.78 And even when the contribution to knowledge production is not primarily conceptual, as in the “second-level” work that I have analysed in the previous section in relation to the GMO controversy, the final argument that is made (e.g. about peasants’ economic and cultural rights) is yet again lucid and comprehensible to an audience that seeks to comprehend “stuff” within modern parameters. Where to go from here (particularly as a white, European scholar)? As suggested by Tucker, one way might be to engage in much more direct, ethnographic research, which would enable more direct experience of ontological encounters. Despite previously-mentioned problems of even that research not going far enough, there is without doubt more space for providing a sense of grappling and dislocation if the originality of a piece of work is not purely grounded in the conceptual contribution it aims to make. However, not every scholar is able— body-, context- or funding-wise—to spend extensive periods of time in different places, and the ethical and political pitfalls of researching “radical difference” through fieldwork with—but often rather on—others have been pointed out by Indigenous scholars numerous times.79 But even for those unable or unwilling to do more primary, empirical research, there is space to push the boundaries of what can and should be written about (and how). For decades there have been attempts to provide “innovative” platforms, for example at conferences, to talk about “stuff” in different ways (e.g. through storytelling or artistic practices; not at least by e.g. Indigenous peoples themselves80). However, these “innovations” are still at the margins, and they will most likely never be able to compete with acknowledged knowledge production outlets such as journal articles and scholarly books. But even within the latter, there is always at least some space to push for more open-endedness, more reflection on the author’s embodied positionality, more auto-critique, more uncertainty and grappling (even if this is based on reading about the ontological encounters of others). Although this sort of embodied self-reflection on a writer’s “situatedness” (which in my own case means being “on the colonising side of a divide”81) has obviously been advanced by many critical scholars for decades (including feminists and post- as well as decolonial scholars), this article has hopefully shown that there is still (always) a need to go further, in order to more fundamentally challenge hegemonic, modern/colonial modes of knowledge production. The sense of unease that I have outlined in section two was particularly strong when reading conclusions that were geared towards making recommendations for the discipline of IR, or for “international politics”, as such. Aiming to make generic conclusions for entire disciplines, political fields, or global “issues” pushes the generality and abstraction of a contribution even further away from an advocacy of the concrete. Why, and to whom, does it matter whether IR, as a discipline, or international politics, as object of study, becomes more pluriversal or not? What are the actual benefits of the concept of the pluriverse in the first place? Or to pick up the theme of this special issue: why does it matter whether IR is, or should move into, a mode of affirmation rather than critique?82 Why is this a good question to ask—and for whom? This is not just a theoretical problem, but it has real-life consequences for actually-existing decolonial struggles. The desire for making a generic argument about relational ontologies and a pluriversal politics harbours the danger of making a huge variety of demands and struggles that often exist in tension and contradiction with each other commensurable. Indigenous demands for the repatriation of “their” land might be at odds with the social justice demands for redistribution and “the commons”. 83 For Blaney and Tickner, decolonial thought is commensurable with not just the ontological turn literature, but also feminist and other critical interventions.84 Mignolo and Arturo Escobar advocate a transnational fight for global justice and are enthusiastic about the potential of global movements to achieve that aim together.85 Like Mignolo, Rojas explicitly draws on the World Social Forum slogan “Another world is possible” as well as the Zapatistas slogan of “a world where many words fit” to make her case about the need for a pluriversal understanding of emancipatory-decolonial politics.86 While it can be argued that this problem of seeing all these struggles and demands as commensurable goes back to a lack of actual engagement with particular decolonial practices and battles, what I have argued in this article is that it is also related to the problem of how and what sort of knowledge is produced and valued in the Western academy: knowledge that is abstract, generic, and applicable beyond a specific context. Knowledge that is driven by the desire to know what is. Knowledge that desires to know what holds the turtle—all the way down.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Aff Answers › FW › 2AC – Scenario Planning Good

Simulating scenarios is vital to prevent them – breaks down biases and opens up possibility for imagining new worlds

Baum et al. ‘18 (Global Catastrophic Risk Institute. 2018. “A Model for the Probability of Nuclear War.” SSRN Electronic Journal. Crossref, doi:10.2139/ssrn.3137081.)

For as long as some states possess nuclear weapons, there will be some chance that these weapons will be used in war. How high of a chance this is—the ongoing rate of nuclear war, or its probability over some time period—is an important factor in several major policy issues. However, there have been few attempts to model or quantify this probability. This paper presents a detailed model of nuclear war that can be used to understand and quantify the probability of nuclear war. This paper stops short of quantifying the probability because that would require more detailed analysis than one paper can provide. However, some important conclusions are nonetheless obtainable. First and foremost, the probability of nuclear war can be modeled and quantified. Attempting to do so is not doomed to hopeless guesswork. This paper presents one approach to doing so, drawing on prior studies by Hellman (2008), Barrett et al. (2013), and Barrett (2016). The approach is based on identifying and modeling nuclear war scenarios, i.e. the range of ways that nuclear war can occur. Scenario modeling is attractive because it breaks the probability of nuclear war into smaller, more manageable parts, many of which can be informed by historical incidents. Scenario modeling is valuable both for quantifying the probability and for helping people understand how nuclear war is likely to occur. Scenario modeling provides quantitative and qualitative insights that are valuable for crafting policies to efficiently and effectively reduce the probability of nuclear war. This paper models fourteen different nuclear war scenarios. Six scenarios occur when a nuclear-armed state intentionally makes a first-strike nuclear attack: three involving intentional escalation and three involving inadvertent escalation. Eight scenarios occur when a nuclear32 armed state falsely believes that a nuclear attack has already occurred and makes what it believes is a retaliatory nuclear attack. The three intentional escalation scenarios are the traditional focus of nuclear weapons debates. These are the scenarios for which nuclear deterrence should be most effective. The other eleven scenarios all involve some sort of mistake, either in inadvertent escalation or in the false perception of a threat. The preponderance of inadvertent and false-belief scenarios raises questions about the reliability of nuclear deterrence. Exactly how reliable nuclear deterrence is requires quantification of the probabilities of the various scenarios, which is beyond the scope of this paper. Several factors cut across all fourteen scenarios. One is the severity of geopolitical tensions felt by nuclear-armed states. Higher tensions make states more inclined to use nuclear weapons. Wars and crises are more likely to commence and to escalate. Non-war nuclear detonations are more likely to be blamed on other states. False alarms are more likely to be mistaken as real attacks. Reducing tensions and improving relations with nuclear-armed states is a clear means of reducing the probability of nuclear war, and it could be an especially effective one. Another cross-cutting factor is the strength of the norm against nuclear weapons use. This norm appears to have played a role in the avoidance of nuclear war since WWII (e.g., Tannenwald 1999). It works by raising the threshold required for states to decide to use nuclear weapons. The higher the threshold, the less likely some incident will cross it. This holds for incidents across all fourteen scenarios, though it may hold to a lesser extent for the four scenarios involving non-war nuclear detonations, because in these scenarios, the norm has already been broken. Efforts that strengthen the norm against nuclear weapons use, such as the recent humanitarian initiative to stigmatize nuclear weapons (e.g., Borrie and Caughley 2013), could be another effective means of reducing the probability of nuclear war. Strengthening the norm against nuclear weapons use may be an underappreciated benefit of the humanitarian initiative. A third cross-cutting factor is the reliability of nuclear weapons systems. This includes the weapons themselves and the technologies and people who use them. It also includes everything from systems for monitoring for incoming attacks to systems for launching and detonating the weapons. The more reliable they are, the less probable nuclear war is, especially for the eight false-belief scenarios.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Aff Answers › FW › 2AC – Fiat/Legal Details Good

Debate is imperfect, but only our interpretation can harness legal education to understand the law’s strategic reversibility paired with intellectual survival skills that help us navigate and contest violent structures. This is the most plausible internal link from debate to meaningful social and political agitation for social justice.

Archer ‘18 (Deborah N., Associate Professor of Clinical Law @ NYU School of Law, “POLITICAL LAWYERING FOR THE 21ST CENTURY,” draft, pp. 1-43) *Edited*

Many law students are overwhelmed by injustice. When faced with the reality of systemic inequities, even the most committed students may surrender to hopelessness, despair, and inaction. This is not because they have stopped caring about injustice, but because they cannot envision a path from injustice to justice. Many do not have the tools to navigate systemic injustice or respond to interwoven legal and social ills. This article contends that although clinical legal education provides an excellent opportunity to offer students the skills, experience, perspective, and confidence to grapple with today’s complex social justice issues, it has not sufficiently responded to the changing educational needs of our students by teaching law students how to most effectively utilize litigation alongside other tools of systemic reform advocacy.

How can clinical education prepare law students to navigate issues of systemic discrimination and injustice? Clinical teaching’s signature pedagogical vehicle involves students providing direct representation of individual clients in straightforward, manageable cases in which students focus on discrete legal issues, take full ownership of the case, and see it through from beginning to end.1 These cases train students to be creative problem solvers for individual clients. However, this model does not effectively prepare students to address and combat structural or chronic inequality. The individualized model also provides relatively limited opportunities for students to address the intellectual and skills-based challenges of lawyering on a larger scale.2 Complex cases allow students to explore the complicated relationship between justice, law, and politics.3 They introduce students to many of the skills needed to integrate rebellious or political lawyering into their practice, including working with others to brainstorm, design, and execute an advocacy strategy; helping to build and participate in a coalition; engaging in integrated advocacy; and analyzing the outside forces that help shape outcomes, including organizational capacity, challenges of enforcement, and potential political backlash.4

2023 UTNIF Kritik
2NC › Alt › 2NC – Alt – Refusal Solves Climate – Moten and Kelley

Indigenous refusal is necessary to disrupt modernity’s antiblack and settlerist logic of possession that results in ecological destruction

Moten and Kelley 17 (Fred, Professor of Performance Studies at New York University; Robin D.G., Professor of American History at the University of California, Los Angeles, “Robin D.G. Kelley & Fred Moten In Conversation,” transcribed from 31:49-55:57)

MOTEN: Well, um, first, I mean, the work I did around, um, you know, the ASA’s, um, you know, decision to endorse the academic and cultural boycott of Israel was really minimal and minor compared to a lot of other people who were really out front, um, and, and have been working tirelessly for that for many, many years. Um, and I think, you know, the, my contribution was more, you know, rhetorical in many ways in, in, in, and, and maybe, maybe theoretical only in the most minimal sense, in the sense that what I wanted to do was a couple of things. First, to recognize that, um, you know, let's say that the conditions of what people call modernity, um, in, in, in, in, or global modernity, that the fundamental conditions that make that up are, you know, settler colonialism. And I think we can talk about settler colonialism in ways that are broader than the normal way that we usually think of them as a set of violent and brutal relations between Europe and the rest of the world. Because I think it's really important. And, and, and again, our, our mutual friend and mentor Cedric Robinson, pointed this out emphatically, and in brilliant ways early on, that settler colonialism is also an intra-European affair. Um, and it's important to understand that. It's important to understand this historic relationship between settler colonialism in the enclosure of the commons, um, which is part and, part of the origins of, of what we now know or understand as capitalism. But if we understand that settler colonialism, that the transatlantic slave trade, um, and that, you know, the emergence of a set of philosophical formulations that essentially provide for us some modern conception of self that has as its basis a kind of possessive, heteronormative, patriarchal individuation, right? That's what it is to be yourself on the most fundamental level. You know, and if you ask anybody in the philosophy department, they'll tell you that that's true, you know, and they won’t be joking, right, that, um, that, these, that these constitute the basis of, of our modernity. But for most of the people who live in the world, actually for everybody who lives in the world, although most of the people in live in the world are actually able to both recognize this and say this, that modernity is a social and ecological disaster that we live, that we now attempt to survive. Okay? And if we take that up, then part of what's at stake is that we recognize that feminist and queer interventions against heteronormative patriarchy, that Black interventions against the theory and practice of slavery, which is ongoing, that indigenous interventions against settler colonialism constitute the general both practical and intellectual basis for not only our attempts to survive, but also our attempts to, as I said before, save the Earth. And, and I put it in terms that the great poet Ed Roberson puts it; not just to save the Earth, but to see the Earth before the end of the world. And this is an emergency that we're in now and it's urgent. Um, and I believe that there’s a specific convergence of black thought and indigenous thought that situates itself precisely in relation to, and is articulated through, the interventions of queer thought and feminist thought that we want to take up. And, and it, and it strikes me as, for me at least, it's, it's a way of taking up a kind an—it's, it’s a way of imagining how one might be able to, how we might be able to walk more lightly on the Earth. To honor the Earth as we walk on it, as we stand on it. To not stomp on it, to not stomp all over it, where every step you take is a claim of ownership. And, and this is one way to put it, would be to not so presumptuously imagine that the Earth can be reduced to something so paltry and so viciously understood as what we usually call home. This is part of the reason why the queer and the feminist critique is so important. It's a critique of a general problematic notion of domesticity. It's like another way of being on the Earth that doesn't allow you in some vicious and brutal way to claim that it is yours, right? Um, this is important and this is so, you know, often the methods that we use to claim the Earth as ours involved fences, borders. This manifests itself on a private level from household to household, but it also manifests itself on a national level, and at the level of the nation state, and it's not an accident that settler colonial states take it upon themselves to imagine themselves to be the living embodiment of the legitimacy of the nation state as a political and social form. For me, there's two reasons to be in solidarity with the people of Palestine. One is because they're human beings and they're being treated with absolute brutality, but the other is that there's a specific resistance to Israel as a nation state. And for my money, to be perfectly clear about this, I believe that this nation state of Israel is itself an artifact of antisemitism. If we thought about Israel and Zionism, not just as a form of racism that results in the displacement of Palestinians, but if we also think about them as artifacts of the historic displacement of Jews from Europe, right, in the same way that we might think of, let's say Sierra Leone or Liberia as artifacts of racist displacement, okay. If we think about it that way, okay, and another, and the reason I'm saying this is just to make sure that you know that there's a possible argument against the formulation that criticism of Israel is anti-Semitic when we know that Donald Trump is a staunch supporter, that people like Pat Robertson in the United States are staunch supporters that help us to the fact that you can be deeply anti-Semitic and support the state of Israel. These things go together. They're not antithetical to one another. So that it becomes important for us to be able to suggest that resistance to the state of Israel is also resistance to the idea of the legitimacy of the nation state. It's not an accident that Israel has taken upon itself, that when Israel takes upon itself, when the defense of Israel manifests itself as a defense of its right to exist, this is important. It's a defense, not just of Israel's right to exist, but of the nation state as a political form’s right to exist. And nation states don't have rights. What they're supposed to be are mechanisms to protect the rights of the people who live in them, and that has almost never been the case, and to the extent that they do protect the rights of the people who live in them, it's in the expense, it's at the expense of the people who don't, okay. So part of what's at stake, one of the reasons why it's at, it's important to pay particular attention to this issue, why we ought to resist the ridiculous formulation that singling out Israel at this moment is itself anti-Semitic is because it's important to recognize that Israel is the state.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
2NC › Alt › 2NC – Alt – Radical Imaginary Framing – Sefa Dei

Prefer invoking radical imaginaries as a form of decolonial subversive politics that resists genocidal logics

Sefa Dei 18 – professor at Ontario Institute for Studies in Education of the University of Toronto Director for the Centre for Integrative Studies at OISE/UT and Carnegie African Diaspora Fellow [George J., ““Black Like Me”: Reframing Blackness for Decolonial Politics” 2018, Educational Studies, 54:2, 117-142, DKP]

We must evoke a form of “radical indigenism” (Garroute, 2003) for Black and African peoples everywhere to engage in decolonial resistance and subversive politics. The goal is to destabilize Western hegemonies in knowledge, economics, and political and material practices. Colonialism has been unending in the power and reach of its ideas and imperial designs. We must, therefore, claim the language of land and territory in discussions about African Indigeneity as a project of decolonization. Land is both metaphorical and concrete. The metaphorical is to allow us to claim that sense of belonging to place, space, and history. It is metaphorical because this Indigeneity resides in our bodies and cultural memories as well as our spiritual and psychic senses.

A distinction between Indigenous and Indigenous settler societies could be helpful. Indigenous helps theorize the shared experiences and histories of peoples whose Lands were and/or have been dispossessed by colonial and imperial forces and those Indigenous in settler communities/nations who still struggle to uphold their legal claims and titles to ancestral Lands. For Black peoples living in both Africa and White colonial settler communities like Turtle Island [Canada] we are implicated in discussion of settlerhood violence. We are not complicit in the sense of perpetuating colonial violence against Indigenous peoples. But the discussion implicates us in how we own up to our responsibilities and begin to build solidarities to support struggles against White colonial settler violence (see Dei, 2017b; McClure, 2015; McKittrick & Woods, 2007). I agree that citizenship on stolen Lands is very problematic because it is tied to Land dispossession and the displacement of peoples through violent global genocidal processes. The colonial state uses citizenship to legitimize itself. For Black and African bodies claims of colonial citizenship implicate us as much as our labor was used to serve White colonial capital projects. The fact that Whiteness itself has been a colonial fabrication (Cesaire, 1972) and we must understand the colonial history behind that settler state (Smith, 2010). And for Black and African peoples, our existence, however, cannot be reduced to simply a search for citizenship nor in the service for capital (King, 2014, 2016)

2023 UTNIF Kritik
2NC › Impact › 2NC – ! – AT: Util – Masur

Predictions of linear chains resulting high magnitude conflicts are impossible and always serve to discount ongoing violence

Masur 7 [Jonathan, Bigelow Fellow and Lecturer in Law, University of Chicago Law School, “Probability Thresholds”, 92 Iowa L. Rev. 1293]

Deference to the executive has become a judicial shibboleth and, in most cases, appropriately so n157 - the executive is peculiarly capable of [*1329] assessing and evaluating national-security threats. n158 But when courts afford this deference, inflation of the threatened harm is one of the natural consequences. As the subject matter moves further outside of the courts' competence - in other words, as the probability of an event drops and it becomes less susceptible to judicial evaluation - that effect increases, and deference becomes an ever more decisive factor in the weighing of costs and benefits. n159 Moreover, low-probability, high-magnitude harms are particularly susceptible to governmental inflation. The lowest-probability harms involve especially acute informational asymmetries between the government and the court (and the opposing party). The less likely an event is to occur - and the more dramatic the threat - the less likely it is that background information relating to the event's potential causes or antecedents will have seeped into the public domain. The explanation echoes in the nature of both low-probability events and high-magnitude harms. First, a potential harm of great magnitude n160 can assume only a few forms (remember that this must also be a harm catalyzed by speech). A war. A riot. A revolution. An act of terrorism or violence, necessarily with a substantially destructive weapon. A significant combat loss, such as the sinking of a troop transport. These categories define nearly the entire universe of relevant high-magnitude speech harms. Such harms share one essential, salient characteristic: they all concern topics that are especially - if not exclusively - within the expertise of the executive branch. n161 Only the [*1330] executive can know if the publication of a ship's schedule will lead to the sinking of a transport because only the executive knows when the transports sail or how much submarine activity they are likely to encounter. n162 Only the executive can know whether the publication of partial plans for the hydrogen bomb will actually make it more likely that some terrorist or rogue nation could acquire the bomb, since only the executive knows what other information is yet to be published or how difficult it is to obtain plutonium and tritium on the world market. n163 And only the executive can know whether opening the deportation hearing of a potential terrorist to the news media will give other terrorists valuable information about American anti-terrorism methods because only the executive knows what those methods are or how they relate to what the hearing might divulge. n164 High-magnitude harms are national-security-implicating harms, and national-security-implicating harms are the province of the executive. Second, and in concomitant fashion, low-probability harms rarely involve simple causal relationships - if A, then B, but only with small probability. More frequently they require a series of only loosely dependent probable occurrences, the interaction of disparate parties, or fortuitous conjunctions of unrelated events. The greater the number of moving parts and the more complex the relationships that a particular speech act must catalyze in order for a harm to occur, the more difficult and costly it is for a court to make an independent assessment of that harm's likelihood. The link is with Brandenburg's "imminence" requirement: once a potential causal chain has become so attenuated that an event will not necessarily occur "imminently," that chain likely involves a sufficiently large number of links that a court will have difficulty assessing the relevant probability absent some strong indication from the government. n165 It is endemic to the structure of American government that these types of decisions fall within the near-exclusive competence of the executive. n166 The question that remains is how to cope with the systemic distortions that result. [*1331] Throughout history, when the executive has exaggerated threats to justify speech restrictions, it typically has exaggerated low-probability threats, transmogrifying them from negligible dangers into constitutionally cognizable harms. n167 These are the types of dangers that will be more particularly within the executive's competence than the courts', and these are the types of dangers for which small adjustments in probability will produce the greatest impact. n168 B. Low-Probability Mathematics and the Difficulty of Weighing Costs and Benefits What the executive cannot do for itself, the courts and the populace will do for it. The cognitive-science literature offers a fairly robust description of the extraordinary difficulties that individuals have when coping with low-probability threats or even when rationally evaluating low-probability events. n169 Individuals tend to drastically overrate the statistical value of low-probability harms as a purely mathematical matter, substantially overpricing those harms when compared with harms of more easily quantifiable probabilities. It is worth pausing now to note that by the use of the word "individuals" here and in the following Sections, I do not mean only the great proverbially unwashed masses, as distinct from the noble and rational judiciary. A significant body of literature substantiates the belief that judges are highly susceptible to the same sorts of cognitive errors and biases that plague non-judicial decision-making. n170 And while there is reason to believe that experts may not succumb to all of the biases that interfere with a layperson's ability [*1332] to make rational choices, n171 judges are not experts (at assessing national security threats, for instance) - they are intelligent, educated generalists. n172 That fact is, of course, part of what makes deference to administrative agencies and executive actors appropriate in the first instance. n173 Absent any strong indication that judges will succeed in dodging the cognitive pitfalls that speckle typical rationality, this Article treats judicial and nonjudicial actors alike. n174 1. Low-Probability Value Inflation Study after study has demonstrated that individuals experience great difficulty, purely as a matter of estimation and intuition, when dealing with high-magnitude, low-probability threats. For many years, economists, lawyers, regulators, and other types of decision-makers routinely have used statistical measures of the value of a human life when performing cost-benefit analyses and making regulatory decisions. Analysts obtain these value-of-life numbers by looking at the salary premiums that workers demand for more dangerous jobs, n175 the amounts that people will pay to avoid certain every-day risks, n176 or by simply performing surveys that ask hypothetical questions regarding what an individual would be willing to pay to avoid a peril of some fixed probability. While these estimates are hardly exact, they are well accepted and widely used within the risk-management industry and usually conform to a reasonably limited range of values. The value of life is most commonly priced at around $ 7 million. n177 Importantly, though, these calculations are made almost always with reference to fairly [*1333] commonplace risks (workplace accidents and the like) that occur with significant probability. n178 Yet when the probability that a harm will occur drops significantly, toward a chance of one in hundreds of thousands or one in a million, individuals' responses to the same types of risk-assessment questions change drastically. The average person is willing to pay far more to avoid an exceedingly low-probability harm than the standard $ 7 million value of life would predict. In one survey, respondents confronted with a probabilistic threat to their lives of 1 in 100,000 were willing to pay approximately $ 220 to avoid the danger, which corresponds to a value of life of $ 22 million - already well above the typical $ 7 million benchmark. n179 But when a parallel set of respondents were asked about a threat to their lives of only 1 in a million probability, they were still willing to pay on average $ 100 to avoid it, placing their estimated value of life at $ 100 million - nearly fifteen times the usual number and five times the value for a threat of tenfold greater probability. n180 Another study displayed this effect in even starker relief. Respondents were willing to pay, on average, $ 15 per airplane flight to lower the risk of a terrorist attack on that flight from 1 in a million to 1 in 10 million. n181 This price, for a risk reduction of 9 in 10 million, corresponds to a value of life of approximately $ 16 million, already well above the typical amount. But this effect exploded when respondents were asked what they would pay to eliminate that final 1 in 10 million chance. The average person was willing to spend more than $ 16 in the face of only a 1 in 10 million probability of harm, pricing her life at a whopping $ 160 million. n182 Other studies have revealed a similar effect, with individuals even willing to pay more to avoid smaller risks than to avoid larger ones. n183 The consequences of this type of value inflation are straightforward and severe. A judge or juror performing cost-benefit analysis on a speech act that [*1334] threatens a harm of high magnitude and low probability will be inclined to substantially overvalue the "cost" side of the ledger, compared to a higher-probability harm of similar statistical value, simply because of the low probability itself. This willingness to overpay to avoid low-probability threats will result in systematic oversuppression of speech in the presence of low-probability, high-magnitude harms; too little speech will occur when compared to either the result of an unadulterated cost-benefit analysis or to a balancing of speech against only higher-probability harms. By screening out the very lowest-probability events and their drastic distortions of cost-benefit analysis (again, valuations of life increase fivefold as the probability of harm drops from 1/100,000 to 1/1,000,000), a probability threshold will act as a crude check on this anti-speech bias. 2. Low-Probability Risk Insensitivity The studies described above reveal two coordinated effects. First, as threats grew smaller, the actuarial value of life increased rapidly. n184 In the presence of small probabilities, individuals functioned as poor cost-benefit balancers. But what should not be overlooked is the fact that these inflated cost-of-life values resulted from peoples' willingness to pay approximately equivalent amounts of money to eliminate all "small" risks, even when they actually differed in probability by an order of magnitude. Low-probability value inflation is thus part and parcel of what one might describe as low-probability insensitivity - layperson inability to distinguish between various tiny probabilities, even when they differ by as much as a factor of ten. n185 Another experiment highlights this effect and is worth describing in some detail. A 1998 survey told respondents a fictional story about a chemical plant that was at risk of releasing dangerous chemicals into the atmosphere above a nearby community. n186 The survey described an insurance company engaged in writing policies for affected community members and then provided an estimate of the probability of a chemical release (some surveys listed it at 1 in 100,000, some at 1 in 1 million, and some at 1 in 10 million). n187 Each survey provided only one of the three values. The surveys then offered comparison data regarding the probability of a car accident and asked four questions: [*1335] (1) whether the plant posed a serious health and safety risk to those living in the community, (2) whether the plant could operate in a manner that was safe for the community, (3) how serious is the risk of death posed by the plant, and (4) how close to the plant respondents would be willing to live. n188 Remarkably, respondents proved almost completely insensitive to the ten-fold gradations in risk between each of the three scenarios. In their responses to the four questions, they graded the threat of a chemical release as "medium" (corresponding approximately to a risk of "3" on a scale of 1 to 5) irrespective of which of the three probabilities appeared on the survey they were given. n189 The survey respondents apparently viewed small risks as exactly that - and only that; the statistically enormous differences between them did not even register. As one commentator suggests, it is likely that for risks in these domains "the relevant probability is "low, but not zero,' and ... finer distinctions are unhelpful." n190 A number of other studies have documented the same effect even among individuals presented with two differing risk situations side-by-side. n191 In contexts ranging from automobile fatalities, n192 to serious automobile injuries, n193 to hazardous waste, n194 to pesticides used on fresh produce, n195 and even to oyster-borne illnesses, n196 survey respondents displayed an utter inability to modulate their willingness to pay for increases in safety according to how much those safety increases actually would diminish the probability of harm. In one study, nearly half of survey respondents were willing to pay [*1336] more for a reduction in the probability of death from an unspecified cause from 2 in 100,000 to 1 in 100,000 than they were for a reduction in the probability of death from a similarly unspecified cause from 20 in 100,000 to 15 in 100,000 - despite the fact that the second reduction is fivefold greater. n197 It seems that individuals simply experience great difficulty at evaluating low probabilities with any consistency or accuracy. n198 Like its partner value inflation, probability insensitivity will tend to bias cost-benefit results systematically in favor of curtailing speech to protect against prospective harms. As probabilities of harm decrease, individuals pay less and less attention to fine gradations, pushing results towards the high-probability end of the spectrum. Failure to recognize or appreciate the true size of a small probability represents the type of cognitive error that tends to compel decision-makers to accept restrictions on otherwise beneficial activities that they would not permit under an accurate cost-benefit analysis. 3. The Tyranny of Small Mistakes Compounding the errors introduced into low-probability cost-benefit analysis by the cognitive biases described above is the fact that when it comes to low-probability events - indeed, when it comes to small numbers generally - small mistakes can produce enormous consequences. Estimations of large-magnitude damages are relatively robust. Underwriters, actuaries, and other risk assessors have become adept at gauging the damage that a putative danger might cause within reasonable limits. Working values for the cost of human life, major injuries, or damage to particular types of property exist, and risk experts employ them widely. n199 But more to the point, small mistakes are dwarfed by the enormous monetary baselines employed in such risk assessments. A very conservative estimate might place the value of the damage from the September 11th attacks on the World Trade Center at approximately $ 25 billion. n200 Even if that figure is off-target by a substantial amount, such as $ 2 billion, the overall effect on any resulting computation will be less than 10%. Probability assessments, on the other hand, introduce far greater uncertainty into any calculation. As this Article describes, speech harms [*1337] depend upon the actions of one or more intervening parties, as well as any number of other compounding or confounding factors. The probabilities involved in these events - which themselves invoke questions regarding, for example, the motivations or capabilities of some terrorist or military organization - hardly conduce to easy rational estimation. n201 There is a reason why these cases are discussed so frequently in qualitative terms and so rarely with reference to quantified probabilities. n202 Moreover, small errors in low-probability estimations introduce enormous variation into cost-benefit calculations. The mathematical point is both mundane and crucial: if the government believes that an event will occur with a probability of 2 in 100,000 if certain speech is allowed to take place, but the actual probability is, in fact, 1 in 100,000, n203 then the statistical estimate of harm is off by 50%. When the uncertainties endemic to assessing speech-related harms are coupled with standard probability indifference, errors of this magnitude seem almost inevitable. It is important to note that low-probability errors of this type are not themselves systematically biased toward either overestimation or underestimation of statistical harm. The mathematics of small probabilities work only as a lens, magnifying the effect of whatever errors have already taken place. Yet, as the rest of this Section describes, those errors are likely to be mistakes of over-estimation: miscalculations tending to inflate and overemphasize the dangers attendant to speech. Enhanced by the mathematics of small numbers, these upward biases will magnify ephemeral threats into constitutionally significant events. [*1338] C. Dreadful Harms, Emotional Responses, and the Availability Heuristic In addition to the purely mathematical errors that attend efforts to cope with small numbers and low probabilities, the types of low-probability, high-magnitude harms involved in free-speech cases often invoke strong emotional responses that further skew attempts to perform rational cost-benefit analysis. Two complementary cognitive effects are manifest. First, individuals tend to overreact to harms from "dreadful" or "unknown" sources or other types of harms that invoke a particularly significant emotional response. High-magnitude harms resultant from speech are almost always of this type; terrorism, riots, and the like are not the stuff of ordinary experience, and their effects upon the public mood is far greater than the number of casualties would indicate. Second, individuals tend to overvalue harms that have special temporal salience, harms that resonate with recent experience, or threats that seem similar to ones they have heard about in the near past. The effect of this type of cognitive bias - the "availability heuristic" - is obviously context-specific; modern citizens are not likely to inflate the threat of a troop transport being sunk in the same fashion as Americans living during the Second World War might have. Yet, at least one class of potential high-magnitude speech harms, terrorism, remains of obvious salience today. Moreover, the low-probability threats that present themselves in any era - those threats that galvanize the government into attempts to curb speech - are likely to have great contemporaneous relevance, if for no other reason than for the fact that the government will attempt to make the citizenry aware of them as a part of its campaign to justify its restrictions on speech. High-magnitude, low-probability speech harms are thus, by their very nature, likely to tap into these heuristic biases. The result is a systematic overemphasis of low-probability threats, an effect that the First Amendment's probability threshold is meant crudely to counteract. 1. Emotions, Fear, and First Amendment Events It is not surprising to learn that individuals respond more vociferously to emotionally charged threats or events. Emotion is, by definition, something that individuals experience outside of their purely rational modes of cognition - but that nevertheless influences individual preferences n204 - and a phenomenon that taps into both rational and extrarational centers will undoubtedly produce some type of heightened effect. What is striking is the degree to which emotional appeals can penetrate what ought to be purely rational decision-making processes and the extent to which they can skew the outcomes of those endeavors. [*1339] Experiments have demonstrated that individuals are willing to pay substantial premiums to avoid emotionally laden dangers above and beyond what they would spend to eliminate banal risks of the same magnitude and probability. In one study, subjects were willing to pay as much as 45% more to avoid a risk that had been described to them in emotional terms than they were willing to pay to avoid the same risk - a risk of death with the same probability - when they had been offered the risk in emotion-neutral terms. n205 Another study obtained similar results by looking at responses to threats of electric shock. n206 These examples, alongside many others, n207 reveal a more particular trend: individuals will respond more strongly to "dreadful" or "catastrophic" dangers and to dangers that they cannot control than they will to typical, everyday harms. n208 The effect can become extremely pronounced in the context of improbable threats, as individuals "focus[] their attention on the outcome rather than the low probability of the harm." n209 It is the "catastrophic potential" of a threat - not its low probability or the statistical risk it actually poses - that dominates individual assessments. n210 The most immediate application of this notion is to terrorism, and indeed, many commentators have concluded that mere invocation of the threat of terrorism "evokes vivid images of disaster, thus crowding out [rational] probability judgments" and enhancing the amount that individuals would sacrifice to avoid such a harm. n211 But the principle extends to many of the types of low-probability, high-magnitude harms that might be expected to arise from speech. To some degree, the effect reaches all low-probability, high-impact harms; a "catastrophic" harm is simply one that is large, and individuals will naturally respond most strongly to large, fearsome threats of all types. But the harms associated with reckless speech are particularly susceptible to these types of emotional over-reactions, partly because they necessarily involve the machinations of faceless third parties who act upon the speech. Wars, riots, terrorism, military disasters, and the [*1340] chaos of the mob - these speech-induced threats conjure up dreadful images and inspire fear in a way that even mass disasters such as earthquakes and floods apparently do not. n212 Fear is a powerful inducement to action, n213 and speech-borne threats catalyze reactions far beyond what quotidian risks such as car accidents might produce, n214 whether or not they offer a comparably smaller statistical threat. n215 One intuitive consequence of this response is that individuals will tend to focus systematically upon the "worst case," since it is that case that will trigger the strongest emotional response. n216 In one experiment, subjects received information about a potential risk from two parties: industry and the government. n217 For some subjects, the government described the risk as high and industry described it as low; for some subjects it was the opposite. Yet, in all cases, respondents viewed "the high risk information as being more informative," regardless of the source. n218 Experiments such as this one would make it seem that our skewed perspective on the probability of dreadful events might be triggered, in part, by our pessimistic willingness to believe that they may well occur - whether or not that willingness is attributable entirely to the vivid emotional picture that such harms paint. n219 The likely consequence is a decision-making populace prepared to believe the worst whenever they are provided with competing characterizations of a level of risk. In speech cases, the worst-case scenario will of course be the one suggested by the censor. Therefore, it may be that even if the government did not hold an information monopoly over assessments of speech harms n220 - and even if the government's opinion were not entitled to [*1341] special deference n221 - the mere fact that the government was forecasting the most severe outcome would tilt the scales against other predictions. 2. The Availability Heuristic Operating alongside the overemphasis on "dreadful" or terrible harms is the tendency of individuals to overestimate the likelihood that an event will occur when an example of that event comes readily to mind. n222 This effect, known as the "availability heuristic," is the product of the very human tendency to focus on whatever evidence is most cognitively salient at any given moment. n223 It is by definition context-specific; what is news today - and therefore foremost in the minds of most individuals - may well not be news tomorrow. Thus, the availability heuristic may favor certain impressions on one day and a completely different set mere weeks or months later. Nor does the availability heuristic necessarily systematically favor the government or the speaker. A widely publicized story of police abuse - the unwarranted beating of a suspect, for instance - can trigger the availability heuristic and cause the public to misjudge the extent to which law-enforcement authorities are overstepping their lawful boundaries. One week later, news of the urban riot that erupted as a consequence of this act of police brutality could induce the same public to believe that the citizenry has run amok and that the authorities are doing an inadequate job of policing the community. n224 The only factor is how easily a decision-maker can summon an instance of the event in question to mind. It is worth noting also that the evidence and theory behind the availability heuristic would seem to conflict to some degree with the observation - offered by the same commentators who have recorded the enhanced public reaction to particularly dreadful or frightful events - that individuals respond more strongly to "unknown" dangers. n225 Yet the disagreement is not, in fact, so stark. The answer is revealed through the types of risks that these commentators classify as "unknown": nuclear accidents, genetic mutations, food irradiation, and the like. n226 The claim, then, is not the facially bizarre assertion that individuals are responding to risks that they do not know of; instead, they react most strongly to threats [*1342] that have been much discussed within the press but that are sufficiently complex or "scientific" that the average layperson cannot comprehend them. The availability heuristic would predict similar outcomes. The impact of this tendency on how the American public perceives the types of low-probability harms that speech might engender is far from one-sided. Certain types of these threats would appear foreign or anachronistic to modern eyes. Recent American history is hardly full of examples of speech acts inciting urban riots or pogroms, n227 and the United States has not had a troop transport sunk due to the publication of its sailing date in quite some time. The availability heuristic might, in many cases, lead decision-makers to underestimate the probability that those types of harms will materialize; these are among the types of catastrophic events that are hard to imagine taking place in the modern United States. In fact, the period of McCarthyism during the 1940s and 1950s, an era characterized by what are now viewed as excessive assaults on the freedom of speech, n228 arguably retains greater salience than nearly any other series of events with such an obvious speech valence. The availability heuristic thus might augur generally greater protection for speech than conventional cost-benefit models would prescribe. There is, however, at least one more powerful counter-consideration: the importance of terrorism. As of 2005, the terrorist threat remains perhaps the single most salient issue of public policy, and the events of September 11th maintain a position of prominence in the minds of people across the country. n229 The availability heuristic thus would predict that decision-makers will systematically and severely inflate their estimates of the probability of a terrorist event as one or more memorable examples come immediately to mind. Not coincidentally, the vast majority of cost-benefit speech cases that have come before the courts in recent years - and the vast majority that are expected to arrive in courtrooms in the near future - are terrorism cases. n230 [*1343] The availability heuristic may not be applicable ubiquito sly, but it is likely to have a substantial impact in the most crucial of contexts