2023
Michigan
Affirmative
da › irs tradeoff
SSA 22(The Social Security Administration assigns Social Security numbers, and administers the Social Security retirement, survivors, and disability insurance programs. They also administer the Supplemental Security Income program for the aged, blind, and disabled. “Cost-of-Living Adjustment (COLA) Information | SSA.” Ssa.gov, 2023, www.ssa.gov/cola/. Accessed 19 July 2023.)//rhftw
Social Security and Supplemental Security Income (SSI) benefits for approximately 70 million Americans will increase 8.7 percent in 2023. The 8.7 percent cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) will begin with benefits payable to more than 65 million Social Security beneficiaries in January 2023. Increased payments to more than 7 million SSI beneficiaries will begin on December 30, 2022. (Note: some people receive both Social Security and SSI benefits) Read more about the . The maximum amount of earnings subject to the Social Security tax (taxable maximum) will increase to $160,200. The earnings limit for workers who are younger than "full" retirement age (see ) will increase to $21,240. (We deduct $1 from benefits for each $2 earned over $21,240.) The earnings limit for people reaching their “full” retirement age in 2023 will increase to $56,520. (We deduct $1 from benefits for each $3 earned over $56,520 until the month the worker turns “full” retirement age.) There is no limit on earnings for workers who are "full" retirement age or older for the entire year. Read more about the
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
da › court da
Andrew Hammond 20, Professor Hammond joined Maurer faculty in 2023. He was an Assistant Professor of Law and an Associate Professor of Law at University of Florida Levin College of Law. Hammond also previously taught in the College and the Law School at the University of Chicago., 07/13/20, University of Florida Levin College of Law, “TERRITORIAL EXCEPTIONALISM AND THE AMERICAN WELFARE STATE”, https://deliverypdf.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=188070086031106070068091005091110110004011091052061061010085126126027067086006099119037011125063116000098101017075085107030110020075007033072006092114093120067018103006065034067000088074067114070080089117108099125103008119017104093107071100115017073116&EXT=pdf&INDEX=TRUE, DShah
2. Challenging the Exclusion of Territorial Residents from Federal Public Benefits
The Supreme Court will revisit its decisions in Torres and Rosario, as territorial residents are currently challenging their exclusion from federal public benefits in the lower courts Last year, the First Circuit held that excluding Puerto Rican residents from the SSI program violates the equal protection guarantee of the Fifth Amendment.234 As recounted at the start of this Article, José Luis VaelloMadero was born in Puerto Rico in 1954 and hence a U.S. citizen by birth.235 He moved to New York in 1985. In June 2012, Vaello-Madero began receiving monthly SSI disability benefits, and in 2013, he moved back to Puerto Rico. When Vaello-Madero filed for his old-age Social Security benefits in Puerto Rico in June 2016, the federal agency informed him that it would discontinue his SSI benefits. The agency’s “Notice of Planned Action,” stated that Vaello-Madero had been “outside of the U.S. for 30 days in a row or more” since August 1, 2014, because the agency “consider[ed] the U.S. to be the 50 States of the U.S., the District of Columbia, and the Northern Mariana Islands.”236
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
da › generic indicts
Stevens 12(Jacqueline Stevens is the Johnson Visiting Assistant Professor of Politics at Pomona College, where she teaches political theory. Opinion | Political Scientists Are Lousy Forecasters (Published 2012). Accessed 7/12/23. The New York Times. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/24/opinion/sunday/political-scientists-are-lousy-forecasters.html )//rhftw
Political prognosticators fare just as poorly on domestic politics. In a peer-reviewed journal, the political scientist wrote that “we seem to have settled into a persistent pattern of divided government” — of Republican presidents and Democratic Congresses. Professor Fiorina’s ideas, which synced nicely with the conventional wisdom at the time, appeared in an article in 1992 — just before the Democrat Bill Clinton’s presidential victory and the Republican 1994 takeover of the House. Alas, little has changed. Did any prominent N.S.F.-financed researchers predict that an organization like Al Qaeda would change global and domestic politics for at least a generation? Nope. Or that the Arab Spring would overthrow leaders in Egypt, Libya and Tunisia? No, again. What about proposals for research into questions that might favor Democratic politics and that political scientists seeking N.S.F. financing do not ask — perhaps, one colleague suggests, because N.S.F. program officers discourage them? Why are my colleagues kowtowing to Congress for research money that comes with ideological strings attached? The political scientist Ted Hopf wrote in a 1993 article that experts failed to anticipate the Soviet Union’s collapse largely because the military establishment played such a big role in setting the government’s financing priorities. “Directed by this logic of the cold war, research dollars flowed from private foundations, government agencies and military individual bureaucracies.” Now, nearly 20 years later, the A.P.S.A. Web site trumpets my colleagues’ collaboration with the government, “most notably in the area of defense,” as a reason to retain political science N.S.F. financing. Many of today’s peer-reviewed studies offer trivial confirmations of the obvious and policy documents filled with egregious, dangerous errors. My colleagues now point to research by the political scientists and N.S.F. grant recipients James D. Fearon and David D. Laitin that claims that civil wars result from weak states, and are not caused by ethnic grievances. Numerous scholars have, however, convincingly criticized Professors Fearon and Laitin’s work. In 2011 Lars-Erik Cederman, Nils B. Weidmann and Kristian Skrede Gleditsch wrote in the that “rejecting ‘messy’ factors, like grievances and inequalities,” which are hard to quantify, “may lead to more elegant models that can be more easily tested, but the fact remains that some of the most intractable and damaging conflict processes in the contemporary world, including Sudan and the former Yugoslavia, are largely about political and economic injustice,” an observation that policy makers could glean from a subscription to this newspaper and that nonetheless is more astute than the insights offered by Professors Fearon and Laitin. How do we know that these examples aren’t atypical cherries picked by a political theorist munching sour grapes? Because in the 1980s, the political psychologist Philip E. Tetlock began systematically quizzing 284 political experts — most of whom were political science Ph.D.’s — on dozens of basic questions, like whether a country would go to war, leave NATO or change its boundaries or a political leader would remain in office. His book “Expert Political Judgment: How Good Is It? How Can We Know?” won the A.P.S.A.’s prize for the best book published on government, politics or international affairs. Professor Tetlock’s main finding? Chimps randomly throwing darts at the possible outcomes would have done almost as well as the experts. These results wouldn’t surprise the guru of the scientific method, Karl Popper, whose 1934 book “The Logic of Scientific Discovery” remains the cornerstone of the scientific method. Yet Mr. Popper himself scoffed at the pretensions of the social sciences: “Long-term prophecies can be derived from scientific conditional predictions only if they apply to systems which can be described as well-isolated, stationary, and recurrent. These systems are very rare in nature; and modern society is not one of them.” Government can — and should — assist political scientists, especially those who use history and theory to explain shifting political contexts, challenge our intuitions and help us see beyond daily newspaper headlines. Research aimed at political prediction is doomed to fail. At least if the idea is to predict more accurately than a dart-throwing chimp. To shield research from disciplinary biases of the moment, the government should finance scholars through a lottery: anyone with a political science Ph.D. and a defensible budget could apply for grants at different financing levels. And of course government needs to finance graduate student studies and thorough demographic, political and economic data collection. I look forward to seeing what happens to my discipline and politics more generally once we stop mistaking probability studies and statistical significance for knowledge.
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
cp › courts cp
[Andrew Hammond, 2021, Michigan Law Review, ",", https://repository.law.umich.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=7788&context=mlr, Accessed 7-17-2023, LASA-LR]
The traditional judicial deference afforded to Congress means that it would most likely have a free hand to end territorial exceptionalism in the American welfare state. Moreover, even if the federal courts entertain constitutional challenges to how federal law treats Americans in U.S. territories, it will ultimately fall to Congress to amend the statutes governing Medicaid, Medicare, SNAP, and SSI.267 Fortunately, recent activity in Congress to shore up funding for food, medical, and disability assistance in the territories suggests that structural reform could be on the horizon. This Section discusses the various instances where, in the wake of financial and climate disasters, Congress has approved additional funding for welfare programs in the territories. It concludes by looking at various legislative proposals that could be combined for structural changes to these programs in the territories.
1. Emergency Relief: Economic Downturns, the Climate Crisis, and COVID-19 In the last decade or so, Congress has repeatedly provided supplemental funds to the American territories to help shore up the public benefits programs. Often Congress has acted in response to a rolling series of crises: the 2008 financial crisis, several hurricanes that have struck the islands, and, most recently, the COVID-19 pandemic.
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
cp › free association cp
Rios 7-17 – Rodney Rios graduated in political science and, later, Law from the University of Puerto Rico. Currently, he is studying Legislative Affairs at George Washington University. He's been published in Latino Rebels, The Orlando Sentinel, El Nuevo Día, and the University of Puerto Rico Law Review-Journal. (“A PUERTO RICAN UNIONIST SPEAKS" America’s Future, https://americasfuture.org/a-puerto-rican-unionist-speaks/) //ox
Some time ago, an essay by Mario Loyola was published explaining why Puerto Rico should be “freed,” as if the U.S. were somehow enslaving the island. This is a common rhetorical trope regarding Puerto Rico. Despite that mistaken supposition, the argument in favor of Puerto Rican independence fails to consider the consequences of independence for Puerto Rico and the United States. Recent events show that the world is experiencing a return of great power competition among nations. This requires that America take extreme care with its national security. A traditional aspiration for America’s security in the world has been superiority in the Caribbean Sea, to turn that sea into an “American lake.” The United States annexed Puerto Rico in 1898 as part of that strategy. To lose Puerto Rico would be to continue retreating from the Latin American region, to America’s detriment. Regardless of the status issue, the fact is that Puerto Ricans are Americans and, furthermore, during 1950-1952, Puerto Ricans followed a constitutional process very similar to Statehood in which they formed their own Constitution “within our union with the United States of America” as the document declares. This union was freely ratified by the Puerto Rican people and Congress and has been reaffirmed in numerous referenda many times. The dominant political parties in Puerto Rico are pro-union, be it Commonwealth status or Statehood. Freedom of speech, assembly, religion, the rule of law, due process, and free elections exist. Hardly the picture of an oppressed colony. As President George H.W. Bush said, “Freedom is not the same as independence.” Regardless, some policymakers assume that the way to resolve Puerto Rico’s economic problems is by letting it choose between Statehood or Independence. This is only partly correct. For example, Puerto Rico in 1952 became like a State before admission. The problem with the current status is that Puerto Rico lacks its political rights as a state. It lacks voting representation in Congress and the residual sovereignty (federalism) that states possess under the Constitution. The remedy to these problems is not to condemn Puerto Ricans, against their will, to independence but to finish the task begun in 1952 and admit it into the union. Former U.N. Ambassador Jeanne Kirkpatrick wrote that sometimes America errs in supporting regime change when three flawed assumptions are present: The belief that there is a reliable democratic alternative to the incumbent government, the idea that continuing the status quo is impossible, and the belief that any change will be for the better. As the economist and sociologist Thomas Sowell wrote, “History can be cruel to theories, as it has been cruel to peoples.” Many who discuss Puerto Rico, in the rare moments it enters into the national conversation, make the mistake of viewing the status problem in the way Kirkpatrick discussed. Historically, the independence movement in Puerto Rico has been supportive of America’s enemies and terrorism. And though these movements are not a majority on the island, they have misled voters of their intentions, feeding into legitimate frustrations over the lack of economic growth, corruption, and gridlock regarding the status problem. Unfortunately, these parties grew grew somewhat in support in the last elections. They have also been trying to form a coalition for the next election. It is possible that they could win a slim victory to the Governor’s mansion given the right circumstances. That might allow them to institutionalize themselves in Puerto Rican society, transform it and impose their will. Recent history is filled with examples of separatist parties achieving a small victory and transforming their societies according to their traitorous image, creating problems for the national government. Such is the case of Catalonia in Spain, Quebec in Canada, and Scotland in the United Kingdom. Moreover, expunging these ideas and movements is difficult once they become institutionalized. An anti-American, separatist government would mean that a part of the American Republic would side itself with America’s enemies. It would mean a friendly government for China’s challenges to America—an even more worrisome in the face of Chinese-Cuban cooperation in the Caribbean. Moreover, there has never been a political entity of American citizens in the history of the United States that has separated from the union. To allow Puerto Rico to do so would mean a new enemy regime in America’s primary sphere of influence, with the loss of a reliable source of soldiers, natural resources, and strategic land in the Caribbean. For Puerto Rico, it would mean sinking into extreme poverty and likely political instability since the pillars of Puerto Rico’s stability (the dollar, U.S. citizenship, the common defense, market, etc.) would be lost. The misery of independence is a worthy price to pay only for people who will not remain on the island to suffer the consequences. There are many other reasons to oppose independence, and I’d gladly discuss them with anyone in good faith. The entire progress and building of modern Puerto Rico has been due to its union with all the United States. It has benefited not only the island but also the American mainland. In short, Puerto Rico’s independence would be contrary to Puerto Rico’s interest and the rest of the United States. That is why Puerto Rico should become a State or, if not, remain a Commonwealth. For that reason, to quote the great American statesman and unionist Daniel Webster, “Liberty and Union, now and forever, one and inseparable!”
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
cp › statehood cp
Cruz-Martínez 19 (Gibrán Cruz-Martínez, Assistant Professor at the Complutense University and the Coordinator of the Master in Policy Analysis, Puerto Rico, Colonialism, and Neocolonialism. In: Ness I., Cope Z. (eds) The Palgrave Encyclopedia of Imperialism and Anti-Imperialism. Palgrave Macmillan, Cham, DOI: 10.1007/978-3-319-91206-6_125-2)//SW
Advocates of statehood argue that this is the only non-colonial status that guarantees US citizenship and a permanent status with the US. Moreover, Puerto Rico would gain representation in US Congress and the right to vote for the head of state. There would be equal access to social assistance and social security benefits, whereas now Puerto Ricans contribute to Medicare but are not entitled to receive Supplemental Security 14 Income in older age. Statehood advocates also argue that the political stability of the US will bring more inward investment. US Congress would have to accept the incorporation of a Spanish-speaking Latin American country during the xenophobic administration of Donald Trump. Not only would the new State come with an unsustainable debt of around US$72 billion plus over US$40 billion in unfunded pension obligations, but it would also have more representation in Congress than several less densely populated states. The US Government Accountability Office highlighted the high cost of statehood for Puerto Rico, adding US$2.3 billion in new federal taxes (Brito 2014; GAO 2014). A 2016 public opinion report shows that support for Puerto Rico’s statehood in the USA has risen from 35% in 2013 to 40% in February 2017 (Rasmussen Reports 2017). In addition, 39% disagree that Puerto Rico should become a state of the union and 21% are undecided. If we consider these numbers to be representative of the opinion of congressional representatives, there is still a long road to have an absolute majority favoring the incorporation of Puerto Rico. However, what is the desire of the residents in Puerto Rico toward the political status options and its relationship with the US?
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
cp › independence cp
Melendez-Oritz 4/25 (José Enrique "Quiquito" Meléndez Ortiz is a Puerto Rican politician affiliated with the New Progressive Party. He has been a member of the Puerto Rico House of Representatives since May 23, 2011. “Puerto Rico’s Political Status, an Issue of National Security,” The Hill, 4/25/23, https://thehill.com/opinion/congress-blog/3969872-puerto-ricos-political-status-an-issue-of-national-security/)//sz
The bipartisan that passed the House in December of 2022 is being reintroduced. The centenary debate about Puerto Rico’s ultimate political status usually revolves around the options that should be put before Puerto Rico voters in a plebiscite. There is little or no discussion about how U.S. security and foreign policy interests are affected by Puerto Rico’s uncertain political status and the adverse consequences to our nation’s interests in the Western Hemisphere could be affected with the possible outcomes of a plebiscite.
For decades, the U.S. dominance in the Western Hemisphere has been largely unchallenged. However, that is changing. Now China and are aggressively expanding their influence in the region. and . It is no coincidence that Cuba, Venezuela, and Nicaragua, which have facilitated Russia’s and China’s expanding presence in Latin America, have been promoting Puerto Rico’s separation from the United States. Alas, this has happened with the silent acquiescence of the United States. We can only expect that those countries that do not share the same democratic values cherished in America will support Puerto Rico’s independence movement.
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
cp › independence cp
Rios 7-17 – Rodney Rios graduated in political science and, later, Law from the University of Puerto Rico. Currently, he is studying Legislative Affairs at George Washington University. He's been published in Latino Rebels, The Orlando Sentinel, El Nuevo Día, and the University of Puerto Rico Law Review-Journal. (“A PUERTO RICAN UNIONIST SPEAKS" America’s Future, https://americasfuture.org/a-puerto-rican-unionist-speaks/) //ox
Some time ago, an essay by Mario Loyola was published explaining why Puerto Rico should be “freed,” as if the U.S. were somehow enslaving the island. This is a common rhetorical trope regarding Puerto Rico. Despite that mistaken supposition, the argument in favor of Puerto Rican independence fails to consider the consequences of independence for Puerto Rico and the United States. Recent events show that the world is experiencing a return of great power competition among nations. This requires that America take extreme care with its national security. A traditional aspiration for America’s security in the world has been superiority in the Caribbean Sea, to turn that sea into an “American lake.” The United States annexed Puerto Rico in 1898 as part of that strategy. To lose Puerto Rico would be to continue retreating from the Latin American region, to America’s detriment. Regardless of the status issue, the fact is that Puerto Ricans are Americans and, furthermore, during 1950-1952, Puerto Ricans followed a constitutional process very similar to Statehood in which they formed their own Constitution “within our union with the United States of America” as the document declares. This union was freely ratified by the Puerto Rican people and Congress and has been reaffirmed in numerous referenda many times. The dominant political parties in Puerto Rico are pro-union, be it Commonwealth status or Statehood. Freedom of speech, assembly, religion, the rule of law, due process, and free elections exist. Hardly the picture of an oppressed colony. As President George H.W. Bush said, “Freedom is not the same as independence.” Regardless, some policymakers assume that the way to resolve Puerto Rico’s economic problems is by letting it choose between Statehood or Independence. This is only partly correct. For example, Puerto Rico in 1952 became like a State before admission. The problem with the current status is that Puerto Rico lacks its political rights as a state. It lacks voting representation in Congress and the residual sovereignty (federalism) that states possess under the Constitution. The remedy to these problems is not to condemn Puerto Ricans, against their will, to independence but to finish the task begun in 1952 and admit it into the union. Former U.N. Ambassador Jeanne Kirkpatrick wrote that sometimes America errs in supporting regime change when three flawed assumptions are present: The belief that there is a reliable democratic alternative to the incumbent government, the idea that continuing the status quo is impossible, and the belief that any change will be for the better. As the economist and sociologist Thomas Sowell wrote, “History can be cruel to theories, as it has been cruel to peoples.” Many who discuss Puerto Rico, in the rare moments it enters into the national conversation, make the mistake of viewing the status problem in the way Kirkpatrick discussed. Historically, the independence movement in Puerto Rico has been supportive of America’s enemies and terrorism. And though these movements are not a majority on the island, they have misled voters of their intentions, feeding into legitimate frustrations over the lack of economic growth, corruption, and gridlock regarding the status problem. Unfortunately, these parties grew grew somewhat in support in the last elections. They have also been trying to form a coalition for the next election. It is possible that they could win a slim victory to the Governor’s mansion given the right circumstances. That might allow them to institutionalize themselves in Puerto Rican society, transform it and impose their will. Recent history is filled with examples of separatist parties achieving a small victory and transforming their societies according to their traitorous image, creating problems for the national government. Such is the case of Catalonia in Spain, Quebec in Canada, and Scotland in the United Kingdom. Moreover, expunging these ideas and movements is difficult once they become institutionalized. An anti-American, separatist government would mean that a part of the American Republic would side itself with America’s enemies. It would mean a friendly government for China’s challenges to America—an even more worrisome in the face of Chinese-Cuban cooperation in the Caribbean. Moreover, there has never been a political entity of American citizens in the history of the United States that has separated from the union. To allow Puerto Rico to do so would mean a new enemy regime in America’s primary sphere of influence, with the loss of a reliable source of soldiers, natural resources, and strategic land in the Caribbean. For Puerto Rico, it would mean sinking into extreme poverty and likely political instability since the pillars of Puerto Rico’s stability (the dollar, U.S. citizenship, the common defense, market, etc.) would be lost. The misery of independence is a worthy price to pay only for people who will not remain on the island to suffer the consequences. There are many other reasons to oppose independence, and I’d gladly discuss them with anyone in good faith. The entire progress and building of modern Puerto Rico has been due to its union with all the United States. It has benefited not only the island but also the American mainland. In short, Puerto Rico’s independence would be contrary to Puerto Rico’s interest and the rest of the United States. That is why Puerto Rico should become a State or, if not, remain a Commonwealth. For that reason, to quote the great American statesman and unionist Daniel Webster, “Liberty and Union, now and forever, one and inseparable!”
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
cp › process › delay deficit
García et al 20 (Catherine García, PhD, Fernando I Rivera, PhD, Marc A Garcia, PhD, Giovani Burgos, PhD, María P Aranda, PhD, The Geroontological Society of America, “Contextualizing the COVID-19 Era in Puerto Rico: Compounding Disasters and Parallel Pandemics,” The Journals of Gerontology: Series B, Volume 76, Issue 7, September 2021, Pages e263–e267, ) //SW
In Puerto Rico, as on the U.S. mainland, adults aged 65 and older have access to health care through Medicare. However, spending per Puerto Rican enrollee is lower than that of any U.S. state, despite island-dwelling residents paying similar Medicare payroll taxes as U.S. citizens residing on the U.S. mainland (Perreira, 2017). Also, recent funding cuts in Medicare have caused severe financial losses to the Puerto Rican health care system, resulting in higher copays and the loss of benefits. Consequently, many individuals forgo seeking medical care when they need it, experience long waiting periods for medical treatment, and have difficulty adhering to medical regimens (Villa & Aranda, 2000; Wallace & Villa, 2003). Furthermore, federal grants awarded to Puerto Rico’s Medicare system through the Affordable Care Act (ACA) expired in 2017 and were not renewed by the federal government post-Hurricane Maria. Federal financial shortfalls and austerity measures have become a central feature defining the Puerto Rican health care system and have increased barriers to health care access and high-quality health care among Puerto Rico’s older adult population. These health care challenges are further exacerbated by delayed and low Medicare reimbursement payments (70% less than that in the mainland United States) that are the overwhelmingly driving force behind the substantial outmigration of physicians, physician assistants, and other health care workers from the island to the mainland United States (Roman, 2015, 2018). In sum, the constellation of the economic crisis, natural disasters, and ongoing COVID-19 outbreak has compounded and exacerbated obstacles that increase barriers to health care for the older adult population. Individually, any of these events can be expected to have stark consequences for population health. The cumulative effect of parallel pandemics, however, undoubtedly puts a strain on the health care system, resulting in increased barriers to quality health care access that may be a matter of life or death in the context of the ongoing coronavirus pandemic. This stark reality demands urgent and timely action by the U.S. Congress.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention identified the following people at risk from suffering severe illness from COVID-19: people aged 65 years and older, people with chronic lung disease or moderate to severe asthma, people with serious heart conditions, people with BMI (body mass index) of 40 or higher, and people with diabetes to only name a few (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2020). Older island-dwelling Puerto Rican adults are more likely to have diabetes, hypertension, and obesity than older adults residing in the U.S. mainland (Pérez & Ailshire, 2017), which makes older Puerto Ricans an especially high-risk group for COVID-19 outcomes. As COVID-19 infection cases and deaths continue to soar, we must place attention to this vulnerable and marginalized population. Notably, there needs to be increased attention on the older adults living in the island municipalities of Culebras and Vieques, who are facing different levels of consequences from these compounding disasters and are facing particular conditions as an “island of an island.” Overall, the health and well-being of Puerto Ricans have primarily been shaped by colonialism and the Commonwealth’s fraught relationship with the U.S. government. The human suffering of the Puerto Rican population is compounded by the predicted consequences of fiscal austerity, increasing income and wealth inequality, the debt crisis, significant emigration, and a dysfunctional health care system. Necessary governmental actions are required now to lessen the burden of parallel pandemics on older adults in Puerto Rico.
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
case › reparations addon › 2ac---reparations addon
Hernandez 22. (Javier A. Hernández is a distinguished author and advocate for Puerto Rican rights. He earned a B.A. in Political Science & International Relations from Florida International University; an M.A. in International Communication from The American University; and an M.S. in Education from Lehman College. Javier has also earned certificates in Diplomacy of Small States, Emergency Management, Homeland Security Planning, Global Security Issues, and Non-violent Conflict & Civil Resistance, Mano Magazine, October 27, 2022, “Puerto Rico’s Right to Colonial Reparations”, https://manomagazine.com/puertoricocolonialreparations//博洋.
Although the topic of colonial reparations for Puerto Rico has been ongoing for decades, there is a newfound interest, particularly within Puerto Rican circles. More and more people recognize that after 124 years of abuse, humiliation, human rights violations, and economic exploitation through colonialism the United States owes Puerto Rico compensation. According to the renowned lawyer, diplomat, and independence leader Wilma E. Collazo Reverón, Esq., Puerto Rico does have a right to reparations based on international law, particularly the UN Principles and Guidelines applicable to human rights violations.
As can be expected, the issue of reparations for Puerto Rico—or any colony for that matter—is controversial. It is easier to balance a camel on the head of a pin than to convince a colonizing country to pay reparations to its former colony.
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
case › constitution addon
Cheatham & Roy 22 - Amelia Cheatham is a first-year MIA candidate studying International Security Policy and International Conflict Resolution and Diana Roy covers Latin America and immigration for CFR.org. She has previously written on hemispheric affairs for the Center for International Policy and the Inter-American Dialogue. She holds a bachelor’s degree in international relations from American University, where she also studied Spanish. ("Puerto Rico: A U.S. Territory in Crisis," Council on Foreign Relations, ) //ox
Article 4, Section 3, of the U.S. Constitution, known as the territorial clause, gives Congress broad authority to govern U.S. territories. Puerto Rico is the most populous U.S. territory. Others include American Samoa, Guam, the Northern Mariana Islands, and the Virgin Islands. They are granted various measures of self-rule, but lack their own sovereignty. Though Puerto Ricans are U.S. citizens eligible for military conscription and subject to federal laws, they lack full congressional representation. A single member of the U.S. House of Representatives, known as the resident commissioner, represents the island’s interests but has no voting power; Jenniffer González-Colón has held the position since 2017. Nor can Puerto Rico residents cast ballots in U.S. general elections, though presidential candidates curried support on the island in 2020 to win votes from the Puerto Rican diaspora in the primary race. Puerto Rico also lacks economic sovereignty. The U.S. dollar is its currency, U.S. federal regulators oversee its businesses, and U.S. laws dictate its trade policy. Residents pay most federal taxes; their contributions totaled more than $4 billion in fiscal year 2021. However, Puerto Ricans generally do not pay federal income tax, and they continue to enjoy the tax exemptions that have historically incentivized outside investment. Largely because of these exemptions, residents receive fewer federal benefits than other Americans. Puerto Rico residents are ineligible for the Earned Income Tax Credit and earn less, on average, in Social Security and veterans’ benefits. However, some benefits could change as a result of legal challenges. In August 2020, a district court judge ruled that denying island residents several forms of federal assistance, including Supplemental Security Income (SSI), is unconstitutional. The federal government appealed the decision, and in November 2021, the case was heard by an appeals court, which held that Puerto Rico’s exclusion from the SSI program violates the Fifth Amendment. In April 2022, the Supreme Court reversed that decision. Like most U.S. states, the island receives billions of dollars more in federal spending, including on Medicare and Social Security, than its residents pay in taxes. In addition, the U.S. government has allocated more than $25 billion in disaster-recovery funding to the island since 2017. What is the island’s economic outlook? Puerto Rico continues to be ravaged by a sustained recession. Annual economic growth fell by roughly 12.5 percent overall between 2004 and 2020, while Puerto Rico’s population shrunk by more than 16 percent. It has also struggled under a large public debt in recent years, totaling about $70 billion—or 68 percent of gross domestic product (GDP)—in 2020. Puerto Rico’s downward spiral has been compounded by natural disasters, government mismanagement and corruption, and the COVID-19 pandemic. Unable to borrow on global markets, Puerto Rico was in economic limbo for years after turning over its budget to an independent control board appointed by Washington as part of a plan to restructure its debts. Making matters worse, in 2019, U.S. authorities arrested former high-level officials in a corruption scandal, leading to the resignation of Governor Ricardo Rosselló. The island’s average household income is about one-third of the U.S. average, and its poverty rate is more than twice that of the poorest state, Mississippi. Meanwhile, the territory’s unemployment rate has stayed at almost twice the national average for the past decade, at times reaching double digits. However, it fell to about 8 percent in 2021 and has continued to drop. In January 2022, a federal judge approved a final plan between the PROMESA board and Puerto Rico’s government, paving the way for the island to escape bankruptcy and resume making payments to creditors. The deal cuts $33 billion in total debt obligations down to $7.4 billion, lowering Puerto Rico’s annual debt payments from nearly $4 billion to just over $1 billion. Supporters say the deal puts the island on a sustainable path while avoiding any cuts to public pensions, which had been a major point of contention. However, critics are wary of the resolution. Some argue that cutting debt without requiring deeper structural reforms means problems are likely to repeat. Others worry that maintaining pension obligations—which amount to $2.3 billion yearly—will prove unsustainable. Advocacy groups such as the Center for Popular Democracy say the deal will result in more economic austerity, including cuts to health care and education. They echo many critics who oppose the PROMESA process on the grounds that it undermines the territory’s already weak self-rule. PROMESA’s oversight board will remain in place until Puerto Rico meets several financial milestones—three more years at least.
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
case › financial crisis addon
Biggs 23 (Andrew, Senior Fellow, Social Security reform, Public and private sector compensation, State and local government pensions. “Why Cut Social Security and Medicare? Here’s Why,” Forbes, 2/9/23, aei.org/op-eds/why-cut-social-security-and-medicare-heres-why/)//sz
Some people say that Social Security doesn’t contribute to the budget deficit and so there’s no reason to cut it. Not so. The Congressional Budget Office explicitly that Social Security’s “contribution to the federal deficit” last year was nearly $100 billion, while Medicare added almost $400 billion more. Going forward, the federal budget is balanced if you leave out Social Security and Medicare. But if we don’t resolve the Social Security and Medicare funding problems, our debt will grow to unsustainable levels. Having spent six years on the managing Puerto Rico’s bankruptcy, I can tell you – and the people of Puerto Rico can tell you even better – that a financial crisis is a terrible thing to live through.
Some people say that Social Security and Medicare are self-financing – we paid our taxes and we’re only getting back what we paid. Again, not true. The Social Security Administration that a typical couple retiring today will receive about 30% more in benefits than they paid in taxes. By the end of the decade, that rises to a 50% bonus. And those bonus benefits don’t come out of thin air; they come from additional taxes that their kids will have to pay. For Medicare, the bonus to current retirees – and the cost passed to our kids – is .
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---at: can’t target individuals/hard to allocate
Vélez 22 (Katerina Martínez Vélez, University of Missouri PhD Candidate, “Trouble in Paradise: Puerto Rico’s Routine Exclusion From Federal Benefit Programs as a Result of the Alien-Citizen Paradox,” The Business, Entrepreneurship and Tax Law Review Journal, Volume 6, Issue 2, Article 9, 2022, )//SW
In previous litigation regarding the exclusion of territory residents from SSI benefits, the Government has argued that it is rational for Congress to “draw the line” of who qualifies for SSI benefits at a community-wide level, rather than an individual level, because of income fluctuations.151 For instance, an individual with an unstable income may be required to pay income taxes in one year but not another. However, the Supreme Court considers this argument to be unpersuasive.152 By that same logic, it is possible for Puerto Rican residents to pay income taxes one year but not another, whether because they were employed by the federal government, had income from outside of the Island, or lived within the 50 States.153
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---at: can’t solve---disability
Respaut 16 - Robin Respaut covers health, biotech and financial for Reuters in San Francisco. Prior to joining the health team, Robin won awards for her reporting on hurricanes Irma in Florida and Maria in Puerto Rico, where she was one of the only national reporters on the island during the devastating storm. (“Congress should consider help for Puerto Rico's disabled: Task force" Reuters, https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-puertorico-disability/congress-should-consider-help-for-puerto-ricos-disabled-task-force-idUSKBN14A27B) //ox
The report, released Tuesday, cited a December 9 Reuters investigation that detailed the scant support for island residents with severe mental and physical problems. Most get nothing. Those who do get benefits receive an average of $74 a month - about a tenth of what the U.S. gives the disabled in its 50 states. Reuters also revealed wide disparities in support among U.S. territories.
Sen. Orrin Hatch - a Republican from Utah who heads the bipartisan Congressional Task Force on Economic Growth in Puerto Rico - did not immediately respond to requests for comment Wednesday. The task force recommended that Congress consider providing Puerto Rico and other U.S. territories the same Supplemental Security Income (SSI) benefits it grants to the states. Four of five U.S. territories - Puerto Rico, Guam, American Samoa and the U.S. Virgin Islands - have been excluded from SSI since the program launched in the 1970s. The fifth territory, the Northern Mariana Islands, gets the same SSI benefits as a state, with an average payment of $560 monthly, in part because it negotiated its territory status at about the same time Congress enacted the SSI program. Disabled Puerto Ricans, by contrast, receive much less through a nearly forgotten program administered by the Administration of Children and Families (ACF), a division of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---at: can’t solve---disability
[Kathleen Romig and Sam Washington, 5-4-2022, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, "Policymakers Should Expand and Simplify Supplemental Security Income,", https://www.cbpp.org/research/social-security/policymakers-should-expand-and-simplify-supplemental-security-income, Accessed 7-12-2023, LASA-LR]
Among the territories, only residents of the Northern Mariana Islands receive SSI. Puerto Rico, Guam, and the Virgin Islands receive a federal block grant called Aid to the Aged, Blind, and Disabled (AABD), which provides far lower benefits and has more restrictive eligibility criteria than SSI. American Samoa has neither SSI nor AABD.
AABD is much more restrictive than SSI. Unlike with SSI, federal law caps the annual funding that the territories receive for AABD and other adult assistance programs, and that cap hasn’t changed since 1997.[35] A GAO study estimated that in 2011, federal spending on AABD was less than 2 percent of what it would have been if Puerto Rico residents received full SSI benefits, and that monthly benefits for an individual receiving AABD are less than 15 percent of the benefits that SSI would provide, all else being equal.
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---at: no money for plan
Nancy Altman & Eric Kingson 15, Nancy J. Altman has a forty-five year background in the areas of Social Security and private pensions. She is president of Social Security Works and chair of the Strengthen Social Security coalition. On the Social Security Advisory Board. Eric R. Kingson is professor of social work and public administration at Syracuse University. His previous books and publications address the politics and economics of the aging in America., 01/21/15, “Social security works! Why social security isn't going broke and how expanding it will help us all”, https://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=b1s_BAAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PR9&dq=social+security+expanding+united+states&ots=KZov4XgBE3&sig=tVL1L7928hjy0BJb3qMBCR7aRAw#v=onepage&q=social%20security%20expanding%20united%20states&f=false, DShah
In addition to premiums, Social Security has other sources of income. In any year that Social Security has more income than outgo, the surplus is held in trust and invested in interest-bearing treasury bonds backed by the full faith and credit of the United States.34 These are the safest investment on the planet. (If you have heard that the trust funds aren’t real and the bonds are worthless IOUs, you will learn the truth in chapter 10.)
Thanks to past surpluses, the Social Security trust funds have accumulated reserves of $2.8 trillion.35 The interest from the investments of these funds accounted for about 12 percent of Social Security’s total income in 2013, or $103 billion in that one year alone.36 By law, these funds can only be invested in interest-bearing United States’ obligations or in entities whose principal and interest are guaranteed by the United States.37 While Social Security’s principal is secure and its income is fixed, bonds tend to produce less income over time than investment in stocks. To get a higher return, Social Security could diversify its portfolio by investing a portion of its assets in broad-based stock funds. Virtually all other pension funds have this kind of diversified investment portfolio, including most public pensions. Assets of the Railroad Retirement Plan, the Federal Reserve Board Plan, the Tennessee Valley Authority Plan, many state plans, and Canada’s Social Security system are invested in equities. That’s because higher market returns could be realized simultaneously with achieving the paramount goal of advancing the economic security of workers and their families.
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---at: can’t solve disasters
Morris et. al 18 - Dr. Zachary A. Morris is an assistant professor at the School of Social Welfare, Stony Brook University, Stony Brook, New York. Dr. R. Anna Hayward is an associate professor at the School of Social Welfare, Stony Brook University, Stony Brook, New York. Ms. Yamirelis Otero is a masters student in social welfare at the School of Social Welfare, Stony Brook University, Stony Brook, New York. ("The Political Determinants of Disaster Risk: Assessing the Unfolding Aftermath of Hurricane Maria for People with Disabilities in Puerto Rico," ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE, https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/pdf/10.1089/env.2017.0043) //ox
People with disabilities are frequently identified as a group needing specific attention in disaster planning and response. Disability, according to the widely adopted International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF) framework of the World Health Organization, can be understood as the dynamic interaction between an individual’s health, including mental and physical chronic health conditions, and the contextual factors that limit an individual’s ability to participate fully in society. What made people with disabilities especially vulnerable in Puerto Rico? We argue that focusing exclusively on the lack of mobility or poor health can only provide an incomplete account of the disaster risk experienced. Missing from this usual explanation is an evaluation of the underlying causes of the vulnerability. Drawing from sociopolitical and environmental justice (EJ) frameworks, we argue that at the core of what made those with disabilities in Puerto Rico acutely susceptible to disaster risk was political. First, there was the history of environmental degradation in Puerto Rico that exposed many in the population to health hazards and that made people with disabilities at risk when disaster struck. Second, there was the failure to extend a modern safety net to the citizens of a U.S. territory that could protect against the most elementary forms of social risks, including those encountered by people with disabilities in a natural disaster. Thus, in our analysis, environmental and social protection go hand in hand in mitigating the risks encountered during disaster events. In highlighting these political determinants of disaster risk, we aim to demonstrate the relevance of EJ and social welfare policy as important factors in the protection against extreme weather events. Our analysis further suggests that there should be greater attention in the research literature on disaster risk that combines social policy and EJ perspectives. We approach this topic as scholars of the applied academic discipline of social work, which we think is particularly well suited for such interdisciplinary research. Drawing from a social justice perspective, social work scholars can provide a full picture of the disaster risk experienced by people with disabilities by integrating different fields of study, such as disability studies, social policy, and EJ.
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---at: SSI fails
Konish 22 - Prior to joining CNBC, Konish worked as an editor at InvestmentNews and On Wall Street covering issues affecting financial advisers and their clients. She has also written for Dow Jones and The Associated Press. Konish earned her bachelor’s degree in English and Spanish from Rutgers University and a master’s in journalism from the Medill School of Journalism at Northwestern University. (“Supreme Court decision may hurt Puerto Rico residents who need access to federal disability program, expert says," CNBC, https://www.cnbc.com/2022/04/21/supreme-court-decision-hurts-puerto-ricans-who-need-federal-benefits.html) //ox
“This decision makes clear Congress has a number of urgent priorities to address with SSI: increase the benefit level; update outdated rules so that beneficiaries can work, save for emergencies, and get married without getting penalized; and now, extend SSI benefits to the American people living in Puerto Rico,” Brown said in a statement.
Without access to SSI, some Puerto Rico residents may fall through the cracks when it comes to federal government benefits. “There is this gap for people who don’t have a qualifying work history for Social Security, who qualify only for low benefits and would have supplemental benefits through SSI,” Romig said. Moreover, because receiving SSI benefits often automatically qualifies recipients for Medicaid, it could make it more difficult for Puerto Rico residents to access health coverage, as well, she said. “It’s inequitable to have American citizens, just because of their address, lose access to an important benefit,” Romig said of SSI.
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---at: SSI fails
Andrew Hammond 20, Professor Hammond joined Maurer faculty in 2023. He was an Assistant Professor of Law and an Associate Professor of Law at University of Florida Levin College of Law. Hammond also previously taught in the College and the Law School at the University of Chicago., 07/13/20, University of Florida Levin College of Law, “TERRITORIAL EXCEPTIONALISM AND THE AMERICAN WELFARE STATE”, https://deliverypdf.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=188070086031106070068091005091110110004011091052061061010085126126027067086006099119037011125063116000098101017075085107030110020075007033072006092114093120067018103006065034067000088074067114070080089117108099125103008119017104093107071100115017073116&EXT=pdf&INDEX=TRUE, DShah
History provides needed context as to how this came to pass. Prior to 1950, no federal Social Security payments were made to residents of Puerto Rico or the U.S. Virgin Islands. Congress debated whether to extend public benefits to both territories.194 Ultimately, the enacted bill, H.R. 6000, meant that employment in Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands would be covered through Social Security’s contributory programs, and Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands were treated like states.195 The Social Security Amendments also meant that Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands were able to administer the AABD programs similar to states.196 In 1958, Congress extended AABD to Guam.197 The fifty states and the District of Columbia also operated AABD into the 1970s.
In 1972, Congress replaced, and President Nixon signed into law, the various state-administered AABD programs with a national means-tested disability program called Supplemental Security Income (SSI).198 Congress excluded Guam, the U.S. Virgin Islands, and Puerto Rico from SSI,199 but extended eligibility to residents of the Northern Mariana Islands a few years later.200 There are some exceptions for children who live in one of the excluded territories but whose parents are serving in the U.S. military.201 The federal government still provides funding to the territories to help pay for costs of providing cash assistance to the needy, aged, blind, or disabled, but this funding is significantly less than comparable expenditures for SSI.202
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---at: social security can’t solve
Racine et al 21 (Karl Racine, the former and first-elected Attorney General of Washington, D.C. leads bet-the-company litigation, investigations, and enforcement actions, while also leading the firm’s State Attorneys General practice. “Dear SCOTUS, 3.5 Million Americans in territories deserve same federal benefits,” AP Newsroom, 11/9/21,
What do Puerto Rico, Guam, the U.S. Virgin Islands, the Northern Mariana Islands and American Samoa all have in common? They , like Supplemental Security Income and food stamps that lift families and children out of poverty.
By now, you’re thinking that there must be a good explanation for why 3.5 million American citizens – 98% of whom are – are excluded from these benefits.