2023
Michigan
Affirmative
1ac › 1ac---v1 › 1ac---framing
Cabanes 86 (José Alberto Cabranes is an American lawyer who serves as a senior United States circuit judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit and a former presiding judge of the United States Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court of Review. Cabranes, José A. “Puerto Rico: Colonialism as Constitutional Doctrine.” Harvard Law Review, vol. 100, no. 2, 1986, pp. 450–64. JSTOR, https://doi.org/10.2307/1341109. Accessed 19 July 2023.)//rhftw
Colonialism hurts. It hurts even those "colonials" who are most successful under a colonial arrangement and who most admire the colonial power and its institutions. They may be especially hurt be- cause their education and experience enhance their awareness of their subordinate status. Consequently, the history of decolonization in our time is in large measure the history of political action by colonial elites who lost tolerance for their "separate and unequal" place in the scheme of things.3 It is therefore not entirely surprising that Juan R. Torruella, a federal judge in the midst of a distinguished career in the service of the United States, is wounded and angered by a political and constitutional system that keeps the people of Puerto Rico, "a class of several million . . . citizens[,] in a subservient condition ad infinitum, with less rights than even aliens who reside in the United States" - an arrangement that "makes no sense and cannot today be sustained on legal, moral or logical grounds" (p. 268). Torruella defies the popular image of the crusader against inequal- ity and colonialism. A yachtsman in private life4 and a Republican in national politics, he was appointed by President Ford in I974 to the United States District Court for the District of Puerto Rico - a tribunal that for more than eighty years has enforced and embodied American law in Puerto Rico and to which no Puerto Rican was appointed until I952.5 Torruella served for several years as Chief Judge of that court6 before President Reagan appointed him a judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit. Torruella is the first Puerto Rican member of what for many decades has effectively been the court of last resort for Puerto Rico;7 he is, in fact, the first Puerto Rican to serve on any federal appellate bench. Torruella's brand of anticolonialism, however, is neither eccentric nor elitist. Torruella's views reflect those of the island's statehood movement, a movement that took root at the beginning of the century among Puerto Rico's blacks and poor whites, that for most of this century was led by members of the island's elite, and that today is broadly representative of all sectors of Puerto Rican society. His views are straightforward and uncomplicated and grounded in an appreci- ation of American history and values. Torruella argues that since I898, when Puerto Rico (along with the Philippines) was ceded by Spain to the United States, the island and its people have lived under colonialism professed or camouflaged - ruled, to one degree or an- other, by a government in Washington in which they play virtually no role and consigned to a separate and inferior position within the American constitutional system.8 In Torruella's view, colonial rule and the indignities of second-class citizenship can be ended not, as in the case of the Philippines, by granting the colony its independence9 - a choice studiously avoided for nearly ninety years by Puerto Rico's electorate'0 - but rather, by securing for Puerto Rico equality under American law This equality, he suggests, can be achieved fully through the po- litical process by admitting Puerto Rico to statehood in the American Union. But unless advocates of political change take the initiatives necessary to break the island's long-standing political and constitu- tional deadlock over the choice among statehood, independence, and commonwealth status,"1 substantial equality can be achieved only by judicial intervention to reject the constitutional doctrine of separation and inequality that has made it possible to establish and maintain colonialism within the American polity. What is the doctrine of "separate and unequal" upon which ninety years of colonial rule has rested - the doctrine that Torruella terms the "anachronistic remnants of the stone age of American constitu- tional law" that "stand[s] at a par with Plessy v. Ferguson in permit- ting disparate treatment of a discrete group of citizens" (p. 3)? It is, in substance, the set of principles articulated in I899 by Abbott Law- rence Lowell (then a professor of government and later President of Harvard University) in the pages of the Harvard Law Review'2- an interpretation of provisions of the Constitution that came to be styled "the doctrine of territorial incorporation. "13 Adopted by a plurality of the Supreme Court in the Insular Cases14 of I90I, and confirmed by the Court without dissent in I922 in Balzac v. Porto Rico,15 the doctrine held that territories could belong to the United States without necessarily being a part of the United States for all purposes; they could be "[territories] appurtenant and belonging to the United States, but not a part of the United States within the revenue clauses of the Constitution. "16
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
1ac › 1ac---v1 › 1ac---framing
Harper 20(Ph.D., Comparative Literature, New York University (2020) M.A., Comparative Literature, New York University (2017) B.A., English, Haverford College (2014) Harper, Tyler. “Unequal Survival: Climate Fiction, Paranoid Anthropocentrism, and the Politics of Existential Risk.”Academia.edu,June2020,www.academia.edu/43223715/Unequal_Survival_Climate_Fiction_Paranoid_Anthropocentrism_and_the_Politics_of_Existential_Risk. Accessed 13 July 2023.)//rhftw
Scholars analyzing Children of Men through the lenses of gender studies and/or critical race theory have often noted the intimate and co-constitutive entanglements of race and reproduction exhibited in film, bringing these analyses into dialogue with theories of reproductive futurism, biopolitics, and black studies. Diana Adesola Mafe, for example, has noted the extent to which Cuarón’s depiction of Zee trades in “centuries of racist and sexist Western iconography concerning the black female body,” and particularly tropes of black fecundity.1 In Mafe’s account, Zee thus emerges as a subversive figure whose transformative potential is thwarted by the fact that she exists solely as a cipher for male reflection within the narrative: “a pregnant Madonna and then Madonna with child, [functioning] as an object of awe, confusion, power, and worship but always on decidedly male terms.”2 A similar point is made by Zahid R. Chadhary, who casts Zee as symbolically overwritten. She is “too much,” Chadhary claims, “Eve, Madonna, Earth Mother, figure of subection, animal-like black woman, humanity’s last and only hope, excessively fertile black woman, [and] damsel in distress.”3 Rebekah Sheldon, likewise, has emphasized Kee’s simultaneous role as a “mitochondrial Eve” (a stand in for “the single woman thought to be of African origin from whom all subsequent members of the species Homo sapiens emerged”) and a second Mary, whose miraculous birth ushers in a period of redemption and renewal for the human race.4
However, while critics like Mafe, Chaudhary, and Sheldon have taken pains to emphasize the overtones of chattel slavery latent in the film’s depictions of a Western world saved by the (essentially forced) labor of a black, female refugee, considerably less attention has been paid to what remains implicit in this final scene. As the white scientist-saviors are revealed in the mist and the film cuts to laughing kids and frolicking birds, the practical bridge between this dystopian present and utopian future remains unspoken. Namely, it is left implicit that, insofar as Kee’s value to the Human Project lies in her immunity to the epidemic, she and her baby are destined to become little more than lab rats: poked, prodded, and experimented upon in the name of securing the survival of the human race, enabling those scientists to reverse engineer a cure to the apocalyptic infertility that threatens the species with extinction. In the film’s seamless transition from an infertile, ruinous present (Kee stranded, Ishmael-like, on a decrepit rowboat) to a restored, ecotopian future (jubilant children, chirping birds) the gendered, racialized labor that makes this rebirth possible is neatly erased from the narrative.
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
1ac › 1ac---v1 › 1ac---framing
Coughlan 4-24- 13 – Sean Coughlan is a editor at BBC News, “How are humans going to become extinct." BBC News Business (http://www. bbc. co. uk/news/business-22002530), accessed 7-19-23// dl >
First the good news. Pandemics and natural disasters might cause colossal and catastrophic loss of life, but Dr Bostrom believes humanity would be likely to survive. This is because as a species we've already outlasted many thousands of years of disease, famine, flood, predators, persecution, earthquakes and environmental change. So the odds remain in our favour. And in the time frame of a century, he says the risk of extinction from asteroid impacts and super-volcanic eruptions remains "extremely small". Even the unprecedented self-inflicted losses in the 20th Century in two world wars, and the Spanish flu epidemic, failed to halt the upward rise in the global human population. Nuclear war might cause appalling destruction, but enough individuals could survive to allow the species to continue.
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
1ac › 1ac---v1 › 1ac---framing
Shionoya 98 – Tsukumo Shionoya, who was famous as the translator of J. M. Keynes’s The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money, he learned modern economics and became an associate professor in 1964 and then professor in 1972 at Hitotsubashi University. He became the dean of the Faculty of Economics in 1985 and then the president of the university from 1989 to 1992. Serving as the head of the National Institute of Population and Social Security Research after his retirement from Hitotsubashi University, he continued his academic activity and was designated Bunkakorosha (a person of cultural merit) by the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology in 2002. (“‘Social Security and Moral Principles’" IPSS, https://www.ipss.go.jp/publication/e/R_s_p/No.7_P1.pdf) //ox
If a foundation of social solidarity is sought in the utilitarian philosophy, the answer will be that a summation of individual utilities is considered in its appraisal of policy and action. Unlike egoism, utilitarianism is an altruistic principle in that it is concerned with utility not only for a single individual but also for all other persons to an equal extent. However, since its criterion is a social aggregate of satisfaction, the design of institutions based on the distribution of income, wealth, and utility is not possible according to the utilitarian principle. If it is assumed that the poor will have an inferior capacity for enjoyment, the utilitarian solution is an unequal distribution of income that produces the greatest social aggregate of utility. Thus, a social security system cannot be based on utilitarianism.
Historically speaking, the implementation of the social security system and social policy preceded their theory, and values that supported the practical rules of the welfare state emerged from the moral judgments of ordinary people. In fact, aid to the poor and the weak was sustained by altruistic feelings and a sense of justice in a community. Utilitarianism could not formulate theoretically the moral sentiments of people. Rawls’s theory of justice succeeded in the theoretical formulation of a sense of justice held by people under the political institutions of democracy and established a paradigm of a just society in terms of a rational social contract by moral persons who are endowed with rights to be considered equally. As we shall see, although moral principles have proliferated since Rawls, his position is aptly characterized as “welfare liberalism.”
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
1ac › 1ac---v1 › 1ac---advantage
Nancy Altman & Eric Kingson 15, Nancy J. Altman has a forty-five year background in the areas of Social Security and private pensions. She is president of Social Security Works and chair of the Strengthen Social Security coalition. On the Social Security Advisory Board. Eric R. Kingson is professor of social work and public administration at Syracuse University. His previous books and publications address the politics and economics of the aging in America., 01/21/15, “Social security works! Why social security isn't going broke and how expanding it will help us all”, https://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=b1s_BAAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PR9&dq=social+security+expanding+united+states&ots=KZov4XgBE3&sig=tVL1L7928hjy0BJb3qMBCR7aRAw#v=onepage&q=social%20security%20expanding%20united%20states&f=false, DShah
Social Security has only one source of revenue that is progressive—where those with higher incomes pay proportionally larger amounts. That source is the dedicated revenue from the taxation of benefits. As explained in chapter 2, if your income is high enough, a portion of your Social Security benefits is treated as income when determining how much you must pay in taxes on April 15 each year.
As we all know, the amount of federal income taxes you pay is determined by a set of progressive income tax rates. The higher your income, the higher the percentage you pay in income taxes. The revenue collected from the taxation of a portion of Social Security benefits is dedicated to Social Security and Medicare.38
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
1ac › 1ac---v1 › 1ac---advantage
Andrew Hammond 20, Professor Hammond joined Maurer faculty in 2023. He was an Assistant Professor of Law and an Associate Professor of Law at University of Florida Levin College of Law. Hammond also previously taught in the College and the Law School at the University of Chicago., 07/13/20, University of Florida Levin College of Law, “TERRITORIAL EXCEPTIONALISM AND THE AMERICAN WELFARE STATE”, https://deliverypdf.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=188070086031106070068091005091110110004011091052061061010085126126027067086006099119037011125063116000098101017075085107030110020075007033072006092114093120067018103006065034067000088074067114070080089117108099125103008119017104093107071100115017073116&EXT=pdf&INDEX=TRUE, DShah
Specifically, Congress should make three major changes to the federal social welfare statutes. First, Congress should amend the Food Stamp Act to include American Samoa, the CNMI, and Puerto Rico.288 Second, Congress should also amend Titles XVIII and XIX of the Social Security Act to bring Americans who live in the five U.S. territories into the default eligibility framework for Medicaid and Medicare Part D subsidies.289 Finally, Congress should make all Americans, regardless of where they live in the United States, eligible for SSI, our national means-tested disability assistance. That could be done by simply revising the definition of the “United States” in the Social Security Act to include the remaining territories
Moreover, each of these legislative fixes could be included in larger pieces of legislation in the coming years. For instance, Congress could revise the SNAP program to include the three excluded territories in the next Farm Bill. Similarly, the Medicaid and Medicare fixes could be incorporated as part of a broader reform bill, just as Congress incorporated additional funds for the territories’ medical assistance in the Affordable Care Act. Of the programs discussed, SSI has been the quietest site of legislative activity, but even there Congress increased SSI benefits as part of its 2009 stimulus package.290 Instead of reacting to a series of rolling crises, Congress could end territorial exceptionalism in Medicaid, SNAP, and SSI, and thereby guarantee food, medical, and disability assistance to Americans in need, regardless of where they live in the United States.
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
1ac › 1ac---v1 › 1ac---advantage
Roman 15 - Jesse Roman received his MD from the University of Puerto Rico School of Medicine in 1983."The Political Determinants of Disaster Risk- (“The Puerto Rico Healthcare Crisis," Annals of the American Thoracic Society, https://www.atsjournals.org/doi/full/10.1513/AnnalsATS.201508-531PS) //ox
The Commonwealth of Puerto Rico is an organized nonincorporated territory of the United States with a population of more than 3.5 million U.S. citizens. The island has been the focus of much recent attention due to the recent default on its debt (estimated at more than $70 billion), high poverty rates, and increasing unemployment. Less attention, however, has been given to the island’s healthcare system, which many believe is on the verge of collapsing. Healthcare makes up 20% of the Puerto Rican economy, and this crisis affects reimbursement rates for physicians while promoting the disintegration of the island’s healthcare infrastructure. A major contributor relates to a disparity in federal funding provided to support the island’s healthcare system when compared with that provided to the states in the mainland and Hawaii. Puerto Rico receives less federal funding for healthcare than the other 50 states and the District of Columbia even though it pays its share of social security and Medicare taxes. To make matters worse, the U.S. Center for Medicaid and Medicare Services is planning soon to implement another 11% cut in Medical Advantage reimbursements. This disparity in support for healthcare is considered responsible for ∼$25 billion of Puerto Rico’s total debt. The impact of these events on the health of Puerto Ricans in the island cannot be entirely predicted, but the loss of healthcare providers and diminished access to care are a certainty, and quality care will suffer, leading to serious implications for those with chronic medical disorders including respiratory disease.
The Commonwealth of Puerto Rico has recently come into sharp focus because of its economic affliction and the implications to the larger American economy. However, it is the impact of these events on the island’s healthcare system that deserves significant attention. Already crippled by a growing debt currently standing at more than $70 billion, a poverty rate of 45%, and more than 12% unemployment, Puerto Rico appears to be spiraling into what some have characterized as the collapse of the island’s healthcare system (1). This unfortunate state of affairs has been precipitated by the downturn of the economy (healthcare makes up 20% of the Puerto Rican economy), decreasing reimbursement rates for physicians, and the progressive disintegration of the island’s healthcare infrastructure.
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
1ac › 1ac---v1 › 1ac---advantage
Miranda 7-20 – Carolina A. Miranda is a Los Angeles Times columnist focused on art and design, who also makes regular forays into other areas of culture, including performance, books and digital life. In her years at The Times, she has covered the ways in which communities are rethinking the nature of monuments, how architecture is shifting to accommodate a denser Los Angeles, the significance of political graphics in the post-Roe world and how narco-culture has permeated TV and the internet. She was a winner of the 2017 Rabkin Prize in Visual Arts Journalism and the 2021 Sigma Delta Chi Award presented by the Society of Professional Journalists. (“‘Places That Weren’t Supposed to Be Places’" The New York Review, https://www.nybooks.com/articles/2023/07/20/places-that-werent-supposed-to-be-places-caribbean-art///ox
The damage wrought by the hurricane, which the writer and geographer Joshua Jelly-Schapiro chronicled in these pages in 2017, wasn’t the only disaster. Puerto Rico had already had its capacity for resilience stretched by centuries of colonial rule—first by Spain, then the United States, which, since seizing control in 1898, has used the territory as sugar plantation, military base, medical lab, and tax haven (often aided and abetted by the island’s fair-skinned elite). When the hurricane hit, Puerto Rico was mired in a stew of toxic policies that, in the words of Morales, had turned it into “a hollowed-out shell of itself.” There was high unemployment, increasing emigration, a faltering economy, and a government drowning in so much debt (enthusiastically supplied by Wall Street banks) that it was teetering on the brink of default. What the hurricane made evident was the level of decay: the storm damaged 80 percent of Puerto Rico’s already flickering electrical grid. It also made evident the responsibility the US bore for the rot. It is Congress, after all, that has final say over Puerto Rican policy, and an unelected financial oversight board—also based in the US—that administers its economy.
Maria wasn’t one rupture, but many. The storm simply gave the unraveling a moniker and a marker in time. As Astrid Cruz-Negrón, an organizer based in Utuado, told the journalist Alana Casanova-Burgess last year, “It is as if Hurricane Maria never finished leaving us.”
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
1ac › 1ac---v1 › 1ac---advantage
Harvard Law Review 22 (Harvard Law Review, Harvard Law Review Volume 136, Issue 1, November 2022, https://harvardlawreview.org/print/vol-136/vaello-madero/#:~:text=Last%20Term%2C%20in%20United%20States,the%20territory%20as%20a%20whole.)
Despite making overtures to the Territory Clause, Justice Kavanaugh’s majority opinion did not deny that the right to equal pro- tection extends to Puerto Rico, as the judges below had found.65 Given the case’s posture and the Court’s precedents, even Justice Sotomayor and the reversed judges below agreed that the case should be analyzed on a rational basis standard.66 Because that standard is very deferen- tial,67 it is not surprising that the government prevailed. Still, by col- lapsing the equal protection analysis into the Territory Clause analysis, the majority found a rational basis for only one distinction — between Puerto Rico and the states — and not for the distinction between SSI candidates in Puerto Rico and those on the mainland. The result is the denial of Fifth Amendment equal protection rights to residents of the territories.
Declining to extend SSI to Puerto Rico, Congress implicitly made two distinctions. First, it distinguished Puerto Rico68 from the states, treating the two classes differently for social security purposes. Second, it distinguished between would-be SSI recipients living in Puerto Rico and those living on the mainland. Everyone in this case — the parties,69 the Justices,70 and the courts below71 — agreed that the Constitution required Congress’s distinction to have a rational basis, but they did not agree on which distinction needed a rational basis: the disfavored treatment of Puerto Rico vis-à-vis the states, or that of SSI candidates in Puerto Rico vis-à-vis SSI candidates on the mainland. This question was not squarely addressed by any opinion, was not briefed, and was not analyzed by the courts below. But it decides this case.
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
1ac › 1ac---v1 › 1ac---advantage
Morris et al 18 (Zachary Morris is an assistant Professor of Social Welfare at the Stony Brook University School of Social Policy. “The Political Determinants of Disaster Risk: Assessing the Unfolding Aftermath of Hurricane Maria for People with Disabilities in Puerto Rico,” Environmental Justice, https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/pdf/10.1089/env.2017.0043)
In comparison with other advanced economic countries, the United States is generally viewed as providing fewer protections against major social risks, such as unemployment, sickness, and old age. However, looking within the federal and territorial United States, one finds wide variation with some states providing more generous social assistance benefits (Temporary Assistance for Needy Families) and others greater access to medical assistance (Medicaid) for the poor. Yet, even when taking into account the wide discrepancies in risk protection, the meager basket of social welfare programs available to those in Puerto Rico stands out, particularly for those with disabilities. The lack of adequate social assistance and access to medical care, in particular, decreases the ability of people with disabilities to cope with and recover from disasters. The bare bones social welfare system in Puerto Rico can also be understood as a consequence of the island’s colonial status. Unlike other U.S. states, Puerto Ricans have no direct voting representation in the U.S. Congress. This structural disadvantage reduces the power and influence over the policymaking processes relevant to those with disabilities on the island. The Supplemental Security Income (SSI) is arguably the single most important safety net program in the United States. SSI provides a guaranteed income to those of low means who are aged 65 or older or who are blind or disabled adults and children. As of 2015, 8.3 million people in the United States received SSI payments, which average about $541 a month.36 SSI is an essential safety net program for those with disabilities, which comprise >85% of SSI recipients. Yet, Puerto Ricans are unable to access SSI benefits. SSI was created in 1971 and expanded upon the previous aged, blind, and disabled (ABD) program. But the SSI program was not made available in the U.S. territories, including Puerto Rico. As a result, Puerto Rico still provides the original ABD program, which has considerably less generous benefits ($75 a month vs. $541) than the modern SSI safety net for those with disabilities. Congress, recognizing this wide discrepancy in benefit levels, has many times considered expanding the SSI program to the territories, but expansion has, nevertheless, failed to pass both chambers of Congress. This policy leaves those with disabilities extremely economically vulnerable and thus less able to cope with and recover from disasters. This is especially stark when one considers that Puerto Rico has the highest rate of disabled adults living in poverty in the United States. In addition to the lack of SSI, Puerto Rico also receives a lower share of Medicaid funding from the federal government than other U.S. states. Nearly half of all Puerto Ricans receive health insurance through the Medicaid program. Yet, unlike the 50 states and the District of Columbia, federal funding for Puerto Rico’s Medicaid program is capped at an annual amount rather than through cost sharing with the federal government like the other U.S. states. This means that if the island requires additional funds for low-income healthcare programs, it must use its own territorial funds, which is itself hampered by the general fiscal crisis on the island and the imposition of wide ranging austerity measures. This structural inequity has created an enormous fiscal strain on the healthcare system in Puerto Rico and limits its ability to provide much needed care after the storm.
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
1ac › 1ac---v1 › 1ac---advantage
Schweitzer 22 [Dan Schweitzer is the director for Center for Supreme Court Advocacy in the National Association of Attorneys General, 5-4-2022, National Association of Attorneys General, "Supreme Court Report: United States v. Vaello Madero, 20-303,", https://www.naag.org/attorney-general-journal/supreme-court-report-united-states-v-vaello-madero-20-303/, Accessed 7-15-2023]/dedee
Justice Sotomayor dissented. She offered multiple reasons why the denial of SSI benefits to needy U.S. citizens living in Puerto Rico fails the deferential, but not “toothless,” rational-basis test and violates the Fifth Amendment: “When the relationship between a statutory classification and its goal is ‘so attenuated as to render the distinction arbitrary or irrational,’ that distinction violates equal protection.” First, she wrote, the denial of SSI significantly impacts needy U.S. citizens in Puerto Rico, who may not qualify for the predecessor program to SSI and, if they are eligible, the benefits are not comparable to SSI. Second, the Califano and Harris decisions (1) mistakenly assume that Puerto Ricans contribute nothing to the ∫; (2) do not stand for the proposition that tax status justified any and all unequal treatment of Puerto Rico residents; and (3) “do not preclude an equal protection challenge to a uniform, federalized, direct-to-individual poverty reduction program like SSI.” Third, SSI establishes a direct relationship between the recipient and the federal government, and residency has no bearing on the purpose of the program. Fourth, “[i]t is ‘antithetical to the entire premise of the [SSI] program’ to hold that Congress can exclude citizens who can scarcely afford to pay any taxes at all on the basis that they do not pay enough taxes.’“ Justice Sotomayor also noted that “tax status did not preclude Congress’ extension of SSI to the Northern Mariana Islands, undermining that justification as a rational basis to distinguish Puerto Rico from the States.” In response to the majority’s concerns about possible consequences of ruling in Vaello Madero’s favor, Justice Sotomayor noted the “dramatic repercussions” of tying residency/tax status to federal benefits, suggesting that residents in states that “pay less into the Federal Treasury than residents of other States” could also be denied benefits.
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
1ac › 1ac---v1 › 1ac---advantage
Totenberg 22 (Nina Totenberg is NPR's award-winning legal affairs correspondent. “High Court upholds excluding Puerto Ricans from aid for disabled and blind,” NPR, 4/21/22, https://www.npr.org/2022/04/21/1094128297/high-court-upholds-excluding-puerto-ricans-from-aid-for-disabled-and-blind)//sz
Two justices — Clarence Thomas and Neil Gorsuch — filed concurring opinions. The Gorsuch concurrence was a stinging denunciation of the court's precedents when it comes to those who live in U.S. territories. "I join the court's opinion," he wrote, "because no party asks us to overrule" those prior decisions.
A century ago in the Insular Cases, this court held that the federal government could rule Puerto Rico and other territories largely without regard to the constitution," he wrote. "It is past time to acknowledge the gravity of this error and admit what we know to be true: the Insular Cases have no foundation in the constitution and rest instead on racial stereotypes. They deserve no place in our law."
2023
Michigan
Affirmative
1ac › 1ac---v1 › 1ac---advantage
Van Dam 22 (Andrew, Columnist at the Department of Data, “People are fleeing Puerto Rico, Guam and every other U.S. territory. What gives?” Washington Post Department of Data, )
For much of the postwar era, America’s territories thrived. Remnants of the age of imperialism, the five far-flung Caribbean and Pacific outposts added residents faster than most states. But the 2020 Census revealed a troubling turn: Every territory is now shrinking, losing population faster than any state.
The synchronized swoon flummoxed us. They appear to have so little in common!
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Technology › 2AC --- Technology --- Soft Law CP
Gary Marchant et al. 20 (Gary Marchant is a Regents Professor and Faculty Director of the Center for Law, Science & Technology at the Sandra Day O'Connor College of Law at Arizona State University, 2020, accessed 7/19/2023, Jurimetrics, “LESSONS FOR ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE FROM HISTORICAL USES OF SOFT LAW GOVERNANCE.” https://heinonline.org/HOL/LandingPage?handle=hein.journals/juraba61&div=9&id=&page=)SAADK
Alongside examples where soft law and stakeholder's interests align, the historical case studies also illustrate instances where the lack of incentives, or conflicting ones, discouraged soft law implementation. In her article, Bowman reflects on initiatives such as the Principles for the Oversight of Nanotechnologies and Nanomaterials that were meant to shape the behavior of firms in the nano sector, but failed to motivate compliance because of their "high-level nature" and absence of "clear and actionable objectives."35 Thierer points out a similar outcome with Internet content moderation initiatives.36 Despite the support of dominant sector firms, the Internet Content Rating Association and the Platform for Privacy Preferences were unable to convince the increasingly large number of site developers that constantly cataloging all of their content was in their interest.37
Conflict in reaching a consensus between groups with differing incentives can derail efforts to create soft law. The National Telecommunications and Information Administration invited consumer and industry groups to develop guidelines for the commercial use of facial recognition technology. Unfortunately, the consumer groups decided to collectively walk out of the initiative upon realizing that their counterparts were not inclined to make pro-consumer commitments on this technology's implementation.38 A similar situation occurred with the Do Not Track privacy system promoted by the World Wide Web Consortium.39 Notwithstanding the support of the government (through the FTC) and privacy advocates, industry partners disagreed, making a consensus impossible to reach. Thus, the initiative failed.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Technology › 2AC --- Technology --- Soft Law CP
Gary Marchant et al. 20 (Gary Marchant is a Regents Professor and Faculty Director of the Center for Law, Science & Technology at the Sandra Day O'Connor College of Law at Arizona State University, 2020, accessed 7/19/2023, Jurimetrics, “LESSONS FOR ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE FROM HISTORICAL USES OF SOFT LAW GOVERNANCE.” https://heinonline.org/HOL/LandingPage?handle=hein.journals/juraba61&div=9&id=&page=)SAADK
Government warnings can fall short if the soft law's target is not incentivized to act. Diana Bowman's article describes programs implemented by the United Kingdom, the United States, and Australia intended to identify nanobased products in the marketplace.10 All of these soft law programs failed for several reasons: (1) no threat of punishment; (2) government attempts to burden entities with onerous information requests: (3) confidentiality of the data was not guaranteed; and (4) lack of transparency regarding the purpose of the initiative.11 As a result, a negligible number of organizations participated in the reporting schemes.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Soil Erosion
Li et.al 23 (Binbin Li, Assistant Professor of Environmental Science at Duke Kunshan University; Qilin He, Qilin He, PhD. candidate in the Chemistry program at MIT; Fengbao Zhang, Institute of Soil and Water Conservation, Chinese Academy of Sciences and Ministry of Water Resources; Nan Shen, Professor of Medicine and Director of Shanghai Institute of Rheumatology; Mingyi Yang, Institute of Soil and Water Conservation, Northwest A&F University; “Optimal clipping intensity for balancing soil erosion control and runoff production on revegetated slopes”; May 2023; https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0022169423004122?ref=pdf_download&fr=RR-2&rr=7e5e41f079192b20)-amc
Although our study determined the erosion control and runoff augmentation performance of different clipped grasslands during the field experiments, there are still some limitations. This study was conducted using short-term controllable simulated rainfall experiments, and the rainfall amounts and intensities of natural rainfall events are lower than in the simulated rainfall experiments. Therefore, the optimal clipping intensity inferred here may be lower in practical application. In addition, the influence of grassland clipping management on plant cover, litter mass and root biomass exhibited significant (), which affects the temporal variability of grassland runoff generation and soil erosion. Therefore, long-term field observations are needed to compensate for possible shortcomings of short-term experiments. Future studies should focus on the temporal variability of hydrological and erosional characteristics of clipped vegetations based on long-term field experiments with natural rainfall. Despite these limitations, the analysis of runoff maintenance and soil loss control of different clipping management practices is useful and could potentially contribute to the sustainability of vegetation restoration functions in semi-arid areas.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Soil Erosion
Burgstaller 19 (Dr. Christoph Burgstaller, Prof. Dr. Christoph Burgstaller is the managing director and head of research at the Transfercenter für Kunststofftechnik (TCKT) in Wels, Austria, as well as a professor for plastics engineering at the University of Applied Sciences Upper Austria in Wels. ; Martina Prambauer, Transfercenter für Kunststofftechnik GmbH; Corinna Wendeler, Spitalverbund Appenzell Ausserrhoden; Jörn Weitzenböck, a senior researcher at the TCKT; Science Direct; “Biodegradable geotextiles – An overview of existing and potential materials”; https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0266114418300979?fr=RR-2&ref=pdf_download&rr=7e8fd4c9bf3d2b14; February 2019)--amc
The time period, in which the geotextile needs to maintain its structure and mechanical properties depends on the assigned function and soil properties. Principally the time frame for degradable geotextiles can vary between a few month and one or two years. However due to environmental influences, such as heavy rain or microbiological attack, premature aging of the fiber mats can shorten the lifespan of geotextiles tremendously (Bhattacharyya et al., 2010a). Microbial activity decreases with increasing lignin content and the related reduction in water uptake. As lignin is distributed throughout the whole plant cell the penetration of water into the cellulose cell walls is reduced, which also results in lower swelling of the fibers. Coir fibers, which have a lignin content of approximately 30%, show the highest durability, however the mechanical properties, which are obtained by high cellulose contents, are reduced. A stability of about three years was observed for geotextiles products, which were based on uncoated coir fibers and exposed to UK highland conditions (Ghosh et al., 2009).
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Racism › 2AC --- Racism --- Surveillance Ban CP
[Gabby Bush 28 October 2021, "Surveillance: What is it good for?," Pursuit, , js]
It is easy to get tied up in the bad stories about technologies that track and monitor us. Surveillance technologies can be readily, and often accurately, criticised as invasive, creepy and riddled with power imbalances that compromise the rights and privacy of the surveilled. On the other hand, the widely adopted QR check-in apps used to better control the COVID-19 pandemic show that when presented with a public interest cause, we are sometimes prepared to be monitored, if only temporarily. In some circumstances then, some monitoring – done fairly and in good faith – might be justified by the good it produces. For example, allowing students to sit their exams remotely with the use of privacy safe exam proctoring technologies could be life changing for those with disabilities or accessibility issues that make it difficult to attend campus, or those who cannot afford to live near campus.The same could be said for other technologies. At Centre for Artificial Intelligence and Digital Ethics (CAIDE), our next project is monitoring the monitoring technologies in the workplace. Here again, we see the relevance of context and the problem that is being addressed in assessing the role of the technology, and the non-technological and less privacy invading alternatives. For example, using Artificial Intelligence (AI) to scan density limits in buildings at part of ongoing COVID-19 management might be efficient and effective. But organisations also need to be asking if this is something that can be done without identifying or collecting data on individual workers.Similarly, applications that monitor the use of hard hats on building sites could be a non-invasive way to ensure that employees are kept safe and to ensure occupational health and safety (OHS) compliance. But in implementing a system like this, organisations need to go beyond just the end goal and consider the wider impact on the rights and privacy of their workforce.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Proliferation › 2AC --- Proliferation --- CTBT CP
Cotton and Lankford 16 Fox news opinion “Why the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty is Still a Bad Idea” Senators Tom Cotton (R-Arkansas) and James Lankford (R-Oklahoma) MAY 23, 2016 https://www.cotton.senate.gov/news/op-eds/cotton-and-lankford-op-ed-in-fox-news-opinion-and-quotwhy-the-comprehensive-test-ban-treaty-is-still-a-bad-idea-and-148
The Obama administration has recently started to pitch the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty (CTBT) to the American people. As they begin yet another politically motivated public relations campaign, it's important to remember the Senate rejected this deeply defective treaty in 1999, and the case against ratification today is stronger than it was then. In the shadow of another North Korean nuclear test, illicit rocket launch, and the catastrophic Iran nuclear deal, the Obama administration advocating for a flawed international nuclear-weapons treaty is mindboggling. This is the same administration that brought us the futile "Russian Reset," three new North Korean nuclear tests, and the New START Treaty capitulation. And that doesn't include the legacy of letting the bedrock of security in Europe for the last three decades, the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces (INF) Treaty, crumble on President Obama's watch. Those issues aside, the CTBT is simply not in our national-security interests. First, the U.S. nuclear deterrent is vital to our security. It's what prevents major powers, like Russia or China, or rogue regimes, like North Korea or Iran, from attempting a nuclear strike against the United States and allies. But that deterrent is greatly diminished-and the prospect for nuclear war greatly increased-if there is any doubt about the readiness of U.S. weapons. Our safety and security depends on the working order of our nuclear forces and there is no room for error. This is especially true at a time when Russia is issuing nuclear threats against NATO allies. Our nuclear forces are only a deterrent if they are credible. Nuclear weapons do not improve with age. They are composed of inherently unstable parts and materials whose nature changes over time. And while advances in supercomputing and modeling, along with adequate funding for maintenance programs, provide a degree of security in the aging of these weapons, they aren't perfect. There may come a day when weapons specialists will tell the President they cannot certify the viability of the U.S. nuclear-weapons stockpile without taking a weapon off of the shelf and testing it. On that day, the President should not be forced to decide between violating a legally binding treaty or putting the security of the United States at risk. Second, the treaty doesn't define the activity that it purports to ban: nuclear weapons-testing. The Clinton administration determined that the United States would define the CTBT as prohibiting tests that produce any nuclear yield. But other states, including Russia, have not agreed to that definition. A "ban" that lets treaty signatories decide for themselves what constitutes a test is no "ban" at all. This means that under the Clinton interpretation of the CTBT, Russia and other U.S. adversaries would have the ability to conduct tests to improve the effectiveness and reliability of their nuclear stockpiles, but the U.S. would not. For instance, Russia, which is modernizing its nuclear weapons, could improve warheads designed for an autonomous underwater nuclear-delivery system and low-yield strikes in Europe. Those who might claim that Russia would never violate the spirit of the CTBT should remember that Russia signed the CTBT in 1996, but according to the 2009 report of the bipartisan Perry-Schlesinger Commission on America's Strategic Posture, "apparently Russia and possibly China are conducting low yield tests." In contrast, the United States has not carried out a test producing any nuclear yield since President George H. W. Bush directed a moratorium on testing in 1992. Third, compliance with the CTBT would be unverifiable. While verification technologies have advanced in the last 17 years, so have the ways our enemies hide or mask illicit tests. In some instances, underground tests of small tactical nuclear weapons could be carried out with no abnormal seismic activity detected. And where seismic activity is detectable, we can't be sure that current technology could confirm a test by detecting radioactive traces. As the Director of the Defense Intelligence Agency, General Vincent Stewart, recently testified, no radionuclides have been detected from the North Korea nuclear test that occurred over three months ago and they have a "very robust capability to deceive, contain, hide their full capability and capacity." The room for cheating in the CTBT highlights a reoccurring problem with treaties: while the U.S. honors its agreements, rogue nations and Russia do not. This has been the rule, not the exception. Look no further than the INF Treaty, Conventional Forces in Europe Treaty, Open Skies Treaty, Chemical Weapons Convention, and Biological Weapons Convention to see examples of Russia's tortured definition of compliance. If the CTBT enters into force, the United States would be legally bound to its obligations. No reasonable person can say it would bind countries like Russia, China, Pakistan, North Korea, and Iran in this same way. In 1999, the Senate rejected the poorly negotiated and unverifiable CTBT. It should remain dead.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Proliferation › 2AC --- Proliferation --- CTBT CP
Spring 07 The heritage foundation “Ratifying the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty: A Bad Idea in 1999, a Worse Idea Today” Baker Spring [Former Kirby Research Fellow in National Security Policy] June 29, 2007 https://www.heritage.org/homeland-security/report/ratifying-the-comprehensive-test-ban-treaty-bad-idea-1999-aworse-idea
Section 3122 of the Senate version of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2008 (S. 1547) would express the sense of Congress that the Senate should consent to the ratification of the 1996 Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty (CTBT). The CTBT would permanently prohibit explosive tests of nuclear weapons by the United States. U.S. ratification of the CTBT and the treaty's entry into force would jeopardize the vital national security interests of the United States by undermining its nuclear deterrent. Procedural Problems Procedurally, it is inappropriate for the Senate to even be considering the language in Section 3122. The Senate voted to reject ratification of the CTBT on October 13, 1999. This was a determinative action regarding CTBT ratification. Following that action, the treaty should have been returned to the executive branch, and the United States should have announced to other treaty signatories that it was no longer seeking ratification and reserved the right to take actions contrary to the object and purpose of the treaty. Furthermore, S. 1547 is under the jurisdiction of the Senate Armed Services Committee. Treaty ratification properly falls under the jurisdiction of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee. As such, the Senate Armed Services Committee has usurped an authority properly given to a different committee. Persistent Problems with the CTBT Substantively, the shortcomings of the CTBT that the Senate found in 1999 persist today. The requirements of the treaty have not changed in any way since 1999, and the United States' security continues to require a nuclear arsenal that is safe, reliable, and militarily effective. Such an arsenal depends on preserving the option to conduct explosive tests of the weapons already in the arsenal for the purpose of developing new weapons to meet new requirements. CTBT ratification by the United States and its entry into force would lead to the same unacceptable outcomes that caused the Senate to reject the treaty in 1999. They are: Irreversible Nuclear Disarmament. Permanently forgoing explosive tests of nuclear weapons will lead to U.S. nuclear disarmament. While the disarmament process will take an undetermined amount time, it is inevitable for two reasons. First, testing prohibition will foreclose the modernization steps necessary to keep the deterrent effective under changing circumstances. Proliferation is already changing these circumstances significantly; the U.S. arsenal, meanwhile, is designed to deter the former Soviet Union. The United States will eventually retire the weapons that are no longer suited to current purposes, with nothing to replace them. The second reason that a permanent testing prohibition will lead to disarmament is that questions will emerge about the safety and reliability of the weapons in the arsenal and stockpile. These concerns will cause the United States to remove those weapons. In short, a permanent ban on explosive testing will result in disarmament brought about by atrophy. A Papering Over of Problems in the Stockpile. A treaty-based ban on the explosive testing of nuclear weapons creates a perverse incentive to refrain from fixing problems with the stockpile. Technicians responsible for maintaining a safe, reliable, and militarily effective arsenal and stockpile will feel immense pressure not to take any steps that are inconsistent with the treaty. Policymakers will demand that the technicians never find a need to conduct an explosive test, but rather just withdraw and dismantle the questionable weapons. However, testing is the most effective way to address problems with the stockpile. Specifically, testing is the best way to ensure that fixes to weapons have resolved any known problems. Further, testing is the only way to develop new militarily effective weapons to meet new requirements and missions. A Weakening of the Standards of Good Arms Control. The CTBT does not meet basic standards of arms control agreements that serve the national interest: It fails to reduce the risk of conflict; it undermines U.S. security commitments to its allies; and it is unverifiable and unenforceable. Ultimately, it makes arms control an end in itself, as opposed to a means to the end of improved security. New Circumstances Increase Dangers of CTBT Ratification Today's circumstances make U.S. ratification of the CTBT an even worse choice than it was in 1999. The Senate needs to consider the following three points: There has been considerable atrophy in the U.S. nuclear weapons production complex, stockpile, and arsenal since the end of the Cold War. The United States has been observing a unilateral testing moratorium and last conducted an explosive nuclear test in 1992. The weapons in its current arsenal, generally speaking, were designed to last for 20 years. Some weapons are already exceeding their design age. No new classes of nuclear weapons have been designed and built since the testing moratorium began. Reports regarding the impact of the atrophy are starting to surface. A recent National Defense University study addresses the U.S. nuclear weapons complex: "While interest in nuclear weapons is rising in the rest of the world, the United States since the end of the Cold War has experienced an erosion of institutional interest and expertise in U.S. nuclear capabilities." In April 2005, the General Accountability Office found that the new methodology for assessing and certifying nuclear weapons "is still incomplete and evolving." Even the nominee to head the National Nuclear Security Administration, Thomas P. D'Agostino (who has not has not been shy about touting the purported successes of the Stockpile Stewardship Program), acknowledged problems before the House Subcommittee on Strategic Forces on March 20. He testified that the directors of the nation's nuclear weapons laboratories have raised concerns about their ability-absent nuclear testing-to assure a reliable nuclear weapons stockpile over the very long-term, absent nuclear testing. The nuclear threat is expanding. Established nuclear powers (Russia and China), new de facto nuclear powers (India, North Korea, and Pakistan), and aspiring nuclear powers (Iran) are moving forward in establishing or expanding their nuclear capabilities. Russian leaders continue to believe that a modernized nuclear arsenal plays a central role in their national strategy. China is expanding the number of nuclear-capable missiles in its arsenal. India and Pakistan conducted nuclear tests in 1998, and North Korea conducted one in 2006. Iran continues to defy multilateral demands that it freeze its program for enriching uranium. Without the option to conduct tests in the future, the United States will see lesser powers equal and eventually surpass its nuclear capabilities. Nuclear proliferation is creating the need for a modern U.S. nuclear arsenal that is suited to maintaining stability in a multi-polar setting. The U.S. nuclear arsenal is suited for the bipolar setting of the Cold War; it is not designed to address nuclear multi-polarity created by proliferation. Indeed, the Cold War nuclear deterrence policy and the arsenal it created are likely undermining nuclear stability and increasing the prospect for the use of nuclear weapons. A permanent ban on nuclear testing will bar the United States from developing a new nuclear-deterrent posture. The new arsenal should include nuclear weapons, along with conventional and defensive weapons, that support a damage limitation strategy. Such a strategy aims to prevent or limit the damage from attacks by enemies armed with weapons of mass destruction. Conclusion. For both procedural and substantive reasons, the Senate should not encourage ratification of the CTBT. The Senate rejected ratification in 1999 for good reasons, and those reasons are still pertinent today. Further, the effectiveness of the U.S. nuclear deterrence posture has declined in recent years for reasons of atrophy within the weapons complex and changing international circumstances. The United States has no margin for error in maintaining its national security in the context of its nuclear deterrent. Senate consent to the ratification of the CTBT entails nothing less than gambling with the survival of the United States.