2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Education › 2AC --- Education --- Stem Funding CP
DeAngelis 17 CATO institute “Governments Shouldn’t Even Fund Schools” Corey A. DeAngelis [senior fellow at the American Federation for Children, executive director at Educational Freedom Institute, senior fellow at Reason Foundation] JUNE 6, 2017 https://www.cato.org/blog/governments-shouldnt-even-fund-schools
Education reporters frequently make the claim that government ought to fund and operate educational institutions because schooling is a public good. However, since schooling fails both conditions required for a public good to exist, schools should not be publicly operated. Schooling is Not a Public Good According to the economic definition, a public good is non‐rival in consumption and non‐excludable. The first condition means that one individual’s consumption of the good does not hinder others’ abilities to use the product. Schooling fails this condition since students take up seats when receiving an education. The second condition means that the producer of the good is unable to exclude non‐payers. Schooling fails this part of the definition since school leaders can prevent students from attending their institutions, if necessary. Since schooling is not a true public good, the basic free‐rider problem does not exist. This is important because it means that government does not need to operate schools or force residents to pay for them. A Merit Good? When journalists claim that schooling is a public good, I believe they actually mean to say that education is a merit good since it produces positive externalities. When an educational product is purchased, both the consumer and the provider benefit, as in all other voluntary transactions. However, the rest of society may also benefit if schooling actually creates citizens that are more educated. This argument leads many scholars to support government subsidization of schooling. The Problem Obviously, schooling is only one channel through which people can achieve an education. Since children can learn in various settings, the current system of schooling may actually harm their overall educational levels. In other words, schooling may impose negative externalities on society through providing a less than optimal level of education to all children. Similarly, schooling likely creates a more obedient citizenry. This generates positive externalities, through less criminal activity, and negative externalities, through less creativity and technological innovation. Since there are large positive and negative externalities that result from schooling, in theory, it is impossible to determine the overall sign of the net spillover. Consequently, it is unclear whether we ought to tax or subsidize schooling; and even if we could somehow figure out the overall sign, we would not be able to determine the optimal magnitude of the intervention. We should recognize the fact that externalities do exist in education. However, as the founder of externalities conceded, we must also realize that attempting to reach the socially optimal level of schooling through government intervention may ironically result in much harm. Instead, we ought to limit this probable detriment by allowing individual families to seek ideal educational experiences for their own children.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Education › 2AC --- Education --- Stem Funding CP
Hanushek 04 Thomas B fordham institute “Who could be against "adequate" school funding?”
Eric Hanushek 6/23/2004 https://fordhaminstitute.org/national/commentary/who-could-be-against-adequate-school-funding
A variety of people have jumped into the breech to offer "scientific" answers to what is adequate. These people use different techniques - another example of good words gone bad - such as "professional judgment model," "successful schools model," or "cost function approach." This pseudo-science neglects two fundamental things. First, data on the currently inefficient use of funds cannot possibly tell us what would be required if more effective and efficient uses were made of resources. Second, it ignores the simple fact that determining the level of public spending on schools is a political decision, vested with legislatures and governors. It is not a scientific decision. But how could the quest for adequacy actually hurt schools? After all, they are likely to get more resources, and some of it might be productively used even if other portions are wasted. The answer can be seen in New York State, Kansas, Ohio, and a variety of other places. Once court mandates enter the picture, any discussions of true reform are pushed to the sidelines as the legislatures and state education agencies find themselves consumed by pure spending issues. Even more perniciously, if legislatures are to give more tax dollars - often a lot more dollars - to schools, they must be able to convince the public that they are not simply throwing more money at schools without any checks on the uses of those funds. That leads to an overwhelming tendency to centralize more and more school decision making in the state capital. This movement away from local decision making, where the truly important decisions are effectively made, is almost surely in the wrong direction. The motivation for adequacy suits is real. Many U.S. children are not receiving the education they should. But, courts and legislatures cannot, with any effect, simply decree that achievement must be higher. Working through what they can most easily alter - the level and distribution of funding - has proven entirely ineffective in promoting achievement, no matter how many times they stipulate that any added money should be spent effectively. Pushing on an unreformed system, as we have diligently done for several decades, is unlikely to be any more successful in the future than it has been in the past. When asked to rally around equity and adequacy in education, be skeptical because those words do not mean what you think - or what their promoters want you to think.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Economy › 2AC --- Economy --- NFT Gaming CP
BRE 23 (Blue Rhymez Entertainment by Mariana Berdianu with the intent and purpose of bringing forth talented indie musicians from across the globe, 3/18/2023, accessed 7/19/2023, Blue Rhymez Entertainment, “5 GRAVE REASONS WHY NFTS FAILED.” https://bluerhymez.com/2023/03/18/5-grave-reasons-why-nfts-failed/#:~:text=Limited%20Resale%20Value.&text=The%20initial%20hype%20around%20NFTs,and%20buyers%20with%20worthless%20assets.)SAADK
The potential for fraud and scams was exaggeratedly high from the start. As NFTs are a relatively new technology, there is an inherent risk that comes with unscrupulous individuals who take advantage of people unfamiliar with the technology. There have been plenty of fake NFTs being sold on online marketplaces or NFTs being sold without the permission of the artist. This has led to legitimate concerns about the reliability and veracity of NFTs, and the potential for artists and buyers to be exploited. You can read all about the most popular types of NFT scams (phishing, bidding scams, pump-and-dump scams, and counterfeit NFTs).
3. Limited Resale Value
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Economy › 2AC --- Economy --- Textile CP
Francesco Nicolli 12 (Francesco Nicolli is a Research Associate at the Department of Economics and Management of the University of Ferrara. His main research interest hinges on econometric analysis of environmental policy and technological change. He was awarded a doctorate in Applied Economics from the University of Ferrara, and received a MSc in environmental and resource Economics from the University of Birmingham, UK. Since December 2020 he is Senior Research Fellow within the FACTS programme in FEEM, 2/12/2012, accessed 7/19/2023, Eviromental Economics and Policy Studies, “Resolving failures in recycling markets: the role of technological innovation.” https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10018-012-0031-9#Sec15)SAADK
Market failures are present when there are unexploited gains from trade, and, in effect, profitable opportunities are not being exploited. The fundamental causes of market failure in recycling markets are related to imperfect information, search and transaction costs, technological and consumption externalities, and other factors. Many of these factors are prevalent in markets for at least some recyclable materials. The prevalence of barriers and failures in recyclable material markets can be attributed to their very specific nature of supply and demand. Table provides an overview of some of the market failures and barriers which affect a number of selected markets.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Economy › 2AC --- Economy --- Tourism CP
Scott McCabe 22 (Scott Mccabe is Associate Professor of Tourism Management/Marketing at Nottingham University Business School. His research focuses on theorizations of tourist experience, social tourism, and marketing communications and branding. He writes on qualitative methods, particularly socio-linguistics, 6/13/2022, accessed 7/15/2023, Annals of Tourism Research, “Events as catalysts for communal resistance to overtourism.” https://www.sciencedirect.co/science/article/pii/S0160738322000895)SAADK
Over tourism has become a popular term to describe the presence of too many tourists within local communities, due to the level of tourism causing negative social impacts for those communities. Overtourism has been defined, for example, as “the excessive growth of visitors leading to overcrowding in areas…which have caused permanent changes to their [the local citizens'] lifestyles, denied access to amenities and damaged their general well-being” (Milano et al., 2019b:354). The negative reactions of local populations, in response to overtourism, have been conceived as social psychological responses and include antagonism, aversion or even aggression (Gössling et al., 2020). In some cases, the residents' strengths of feelings have been expressed through protests against tourism directed towards policymakers, the tourism industry or the tourists themselves (United Nations World Tourism Organisation, 2019). However, as a concept, overtourism remains relatively under-theorised as past analyses have failed to explain, adequately, the nuances and subtleties of ways that excessive tourism is associated with negative responses by local populations, including organised resistance to tourism initiatives (Koens et al., 2018).
Prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, which restricted mobility and largescale gatherings, tourism for events was one of the key drivers of international travel (Getz & Page, 2016). Analysts believe it may take several years for travel to resume to prepandemic levels and exactly how it will happen is uncertain, based on new variant strains, country-level economic confidence and local approaches to vaccination rollouts (VisitBritain, 2021). Yet pundits believe that pent up demand will lead to a return to pre-pandemic levels at some point and that destinations should be vigilant to a return to the problems of overtourism (International Monetary Fund, 2020). Therefore, an understanding of the reactions of host communities should be a priority policy issue, particularly in the context of large-scale events such as the Olympics, which are often associated with boosterish development and a legacy agenda (Arnegger & Herz, 2016). Tourism development plays a central part in legitimising bidding processes for mega-events, with the events linked to significant investment in national infrastructure projects, such as new stadia, public transport networks and the creation of new urban cultural zones to accommodate projected increases in tourism demand over the long term (Duignan, 2021). In more recent years, the hosting of prestige, international mega-events has been rooted in discourse of nation building and national politics, largely justified on the grounds of modernisation. Yet the literature notes that, whilst mega-events and event owners like the International Olympic Committee (IOC) provide platforms for local engagement and consultation in the bid and early planning stages, they tend to downplay local opposition in the periods preceding hosting. Therefore, local challenges, such as those associated with the negative social effects attributable to overtourism, are often downplayed or ignored (Judd, 1999). This is one example illustrating why mega-events have been criticised for distracting away from achieving national priorities to address social inequalities and other non-event related policy objectives, often referred to as the ‘bread and circuses’ debate (Roche, 2000; EventRights, 2022).
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Domestic Terrorism › 2AC --- Domestic Terrorism --- Prosecution CP
Englund 23 Brookings “Domestic terrorism is evolving. It needs imaginative counterterrorism.” Scott Englund [Assistant Dean – College of Strategic Intelligence,Federal Executive Fellow – Foreign Policy, Strobe Talbott Center for Security, Strategy, and Technology] January 18, 2023 https://www.brookings.edu/articles/domestic-terrorism-is-evolving-it-needs-imaginative-counterterrorism/
U.S. infrastructure is vulnerable, and effective attacks need not be sophisticated. The December 2022 attack on the North Carolina power grid could have easily been accomplished by one person with a legally-procured rifle and ammunition. The resulting damage, while not permanent or even long-lasting, was disruptive and dangerous. Though ultimately determined by the FBI not to be an act of terror, a Christmas 2020 bombing in Nashville severely damaged an AT&T transmission center that disabled cellular telephone networks throughout the central and southern United States for several hours. Over the past 50 years, U.S. infrastructure has been consistently subject to attack, though at a relatively low number of incidents per year. According to the Global Terrorism Database, between 1970 and 2020 there have been 102 attacks on U.S. infrastructure, at least 60 of which targeted the electrical grid. Since 2009, there has been a period of increased attacks on all targets in the United States — and infrastructure, specifically. Infrastructure attacks rose 70% in 2022 compared to 2021, according to Politico. The Department of Homeland Security’s Cyber and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) monitors 16 critical infrastructure sectors, including energy, food and agriculture, critical manufacturing, and financial services. CISA prioritizes critical infrastructure by weighing five considerations: 1) the safety and well-being of individuals in the community; 2) the value of an asset in the context of a community, region, or nation as a whole; 3) the effect of the loss of an asset on operations and dependencies, 4) the economic impact of a disruption of a service or asset, and 5) the general impact of the loss of a service or asset on a community or larger critical infrastructure sector. The loss of power transformers would rank very high in this risk framework and touch multiple critical infrastructure sectors. The accelerationist handbook cited above encouraged attacks against the energy infrastructure sector as being “sitting ducks, worthy prey” and “largely unprotected and often in remote locations.” North Carolina Governor Roy Cooper summarized the situation: “If someone with a firearm can do this much damage and get power out to tens of thousands of people, then obviously we need to look at the different layers of infrastructure and hardening and make better decisions here.” The Duke Energy facility in North Carolina had sensibly prioritized keeping people safely away from the dangerous equipment on site. However, inexpensive pre-formed concrete barriers would have protected it against a relatively simple attack like the one that occurred in December 2022. On December 15, 2022 the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission ordered the North American Electric Reliability Corporation to study physical reliability standards at the nationwide power grid and determine if improvements were necessary. The legacy of 9/11 According to the Global Terrorism Database, between 2014 and 2020, there was an annual average of 20 terror attacks worldwide in which a vehicle was the primary or secondary weapon. In that same period, vehicles killed 277 people in terror attacks. Before 2014, such attacks averaged less than two per year. Since at least 2010, terror groups have encouraged the use of vehicles to attack civilians. Just as the 9/11 commission concluded that a “failure of imagination” blinded the U.S. national security enterprise to the September 11, 2001 terror attack vector, we risk repeating those failures. Like using a truck to run pedestrians down in a crowded place, the December 2022 attack against an electric grid in North Carolina is notable by its simplicity, accessibility, and effectiveness. This evolving threat has implications for counterterrorism and homeland security. Unfortunately, the United States has a long history of violence toward African-American and Jewish religious institutions. As illustrated in the chart above, religious institutions are the second-most targeted facility in the United States, followed by a general category of “businesses,” which includes places such as the Walmart attacked in El Paso, Texas in 2019, and the Pulse LGBTQ nightclub in Orlando, Florida in 2016. These targets are notable for the specificity of patrons, as indicated in comments by assailants, and the fact that they were relatively defenseless. In the Global Terrorism Database, the “private citizens and property” and “businesses” categories often includes attacks against these targets because of their perceived association with certain groups, most often people of color, the Jewish community, and LGBTQ community. Domestic counterterrorism is, by design, difficult to detect. A low-profile effort does not provide the same exhilarating satisfaction of a bunker-busting bomb, but is nevertheless effective. In 2021, U.S. President Joe Biden’s administration released a policy document focused entirely on countering domestic terrorism. First, it set out a four-point counterterrorism strategy. Second, it unequivocally stated that right-wing, racially motivated, and anti-government violent groups present the biggest threat. Finally, it recommended that the federal government address inequality experienced by marginalized U.S. populations.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Diversionary War › 2AC --- Diversionary Wars --- NFS CP
[Media Defense, No Date, “Dangers of a no first use policy”, https://media.defense.gov/2019/Apr/01/2002108002/-1/-1/1/DANGERS-OF-A-NO-FIRST-USE-POLICY.PDF,js]
Advocates argue that a U.S. no first use policy would reduce the risk of nuclear war. However, adoption of such a policy could increase the likelihood of devastating conflict, including one that escalates to nuclear war, by incentivizing non-nuclear strategic attack on, and coercion of, the U.S. or our allies and partners. Such a policy may change how adversaries and allies view the credibility of the U.S. nuclear deterrent and our resolve to use it when our vital interests are threatened. Operational scenarios exist in which the U.S. would consider first use. Retaining a degree of ambiguity and refraining from a no first use policy creates uncertainty in the mind of potential adversaries and reinforces deterrence of aggression by ensuring adversaries cannot predict what specific actions will lead to a U.S. nuclear response. Implementing a no first use policy could undermine the U.S. ability to deter Russian, Chinese, and North Korean aggression, especially with respect to their growing capability to carry out nonnuclear strategic attacks. Concerns of Allies and Partners From their inception, U.S. alliances with NATO, Japan, and South Korea have depended upon U.S. extended nuclear deterrence. A U.S. no first use policy would be deeply concerning to many of our allies and partners. Such a policy could undermine these relationships by suggesting the U.S. would not use the full means at its disposal to deter and respond to devastating, non-nuclear strategic attacks on our allies and partners—and could even incentivize U.S. allies and partners to pursue their own nuclear forces.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Disinformation › 2AC --- Disinformation --- Inoculation CP
Chloe Hadavas, 04-30-2020, "When Does Flagging False Content on Social Media Backfire?," Slate Magazine,
A published this month by researchers at New York University’s Tandon School of Engineering and the University of Indiana sought to answer these questions. The researchers found that credibility indicators, or flags, can reduce users’ intentions to share fake content on social media regardless of political orientation. In short, fact-checking sources are overwhelmingly trusted. Yet the more nuanced conclusion is that the effect of these flags varies significantly based on gender and political orientation: Men are more 1.5 times more likely to share news that’s been flagged as false, the study concluded, while Republicans are much more inclined to disseminate that news than Democrats or independents. The findings were based on an online study with 1,500 participants in the U.S. These participants saw 12 true, false, and satirical headlines marked with one of four types of credibility indicators: warnings that came from fact checkers, news media, the public, or artificial intelligence. Then, they were asked if they would share the article with friends. (The indicators from fact checkers and A.I. are the most relevant to current social media policies. Facebook, for instance, has to spot hoaxes copied and pasted by different accounts.) The most effective indicator by far was fact checkers. Participants intended to share 43 percent fewer headlines that were marked untrue by fact checkers: 61 percent fewer for Democrats, compared with 40 percent for independents and 19 percent for Republicans. As for A.I., Democrats intended to share 40 percent fewer untrue headlines with the A.I. indicator, versus 16 percent for independents. Notably, Republicans said they would share 8 percent more untrue news with the AI indicator. “We were not expecting that, although conservatives may tend to trust more traditional means of flagging the veracity of news,” said , a co-author of the study, in a . Admittedly, this is just one study, but it’s important for two reasons. First, it provides further evidence that the “backfire effect,” or the idea that fact-based corrections may actually reinforce false beliefs, isn’t as serious as some researchers have believed. Over the past decade, understanding around the effects of flagging misinformation has shifted away from the backfire effect, which was popularized by a . But the concerns over the effect has lingered. Facebook itself that “[a]cademic research on correcting misinformation has shown that putting a strong image, like a red flag, next to an article may actually entrench deeply held beliefs,” when it temporarily ditched the disputed flag in 2017. The general findings of the new study align with a by , a lecturer at the University of California, Santa Barbara, who also concluded that warning labels may indeed disincentivize Facebook users from sharing fake news. Second, the new research also provides insight into how partisanship and demographics affect misinformation campaigns—an area that’s so far been understudied. However, its conclusions should be taken with a grain of salt. The paper itself acknowledged the limitations of generalizing from this research, especially since even though they “carefully worded the indicators in a politically neutral way … [they] cannot rule out the influence of inherent systemic political biases regarding technology or the media.”
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Democracy › 2AC --- Democracy --- Elections CP
[Current Affairs, 6-16-2022, "Proportional Representation Is a Terrible Idea That The Left Should Not Embrace ❧ Current Affairs," js]
Because PR lowers barriers to entry, it’s possible for left-wing parties to get off the ground. But there is little reason for left-wing parties to stay together, because it’s easy to start new competitive parties. This means not only that the existing parties—like the Democratic Party— splinter, but that new parties also struggle to stay together. The number of parties expands. Particular parties also become politically isolated from one another and from the general public. When parties can secure seats in the legislature by speaking to small percentages of the electorate, there is a strong incentive to specialize, to focus on some small part of the electorate, instead of the working class as a whole. Big, catch-all parties tend to lose voters to these smaller, more specialized parties. Over time, the bigger parties tend to break down, and you get large numbers of small parties catering to niche audiences. The more they do this the harder it is for them to build broad public support for their policies. In the Netherlands, there are many parties. Often, they focus on very narrow, specific slices of the electorate. In the lower house, there are 16 different parties, and even in the upper house, there are 14. There’s a party for democratic socialists, a party for social democrats, a party for environmentalists, a party for social liberals, a party for conservative liberals, a party for liberal conservatives, a party for economic liberals, two distinct parties for Christian democrats, a couple of right-wing populist parties, a party for Calvinists, a party for people who care about animal rights, and a party specifically for people over the age of 50. The last time any of these parties won more than 30 percent of the vote, the year was 1989. The large number of niche parties makes it impossible for any party to govern alone. This means there are always coalitions. Germany limits the number of parties by insisting that parties receive at least 5 percent of the vote before they receive representation. But even in Germany, there are half a dozen different parties with seats. Since World War II, not one German chancellor has governed without a coalition. Some people think coalitions are just dandy—after all, they ensure that legislation can only be passed with the support of a majority, and under PR, a legislative majority always reflects an electoral majority. British socialist Ralph Miliband had no problem with them.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Dead Zones
Xiao 19 (Canbo Ziao, Canbo Xiao got his Ph.D at Zhejiang University in 2021 and currently works at School of Marine Science, SYSU; Wei Fan, Ocean College, Zhejiang University, Zhoushan; Zhongzhi Yao, Ocean College, Zhejiang University; Yongfa Qiang, Associate Professor, Ocean College, Zhejiang University; Yiwen Pan, Ocean College, Zhejiang University; Ying Chen, Professor with the Ocean College, Zhejiang University; “On the total entrained flow rate of artificial downwelling”; ScienceDirect; ; June 1 2019)-amc
The most severe challenge for practical applications of artificial downwelling is due to limited energy resources in the open sea or high prices of using land-based electricity. To maintain the , the power supply must be sufficient to work against the buoyancy due to stratification. However, this may result in too high a cost for large-scale engineering, not to mention fabrication, deployment and maintenance Stigebrandt and Gustafsson (2007). should be a pressing need for the development of economically viable artificial downwelling.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Dead Zones
Koweek 20 (David Koweek, Marine scientist, worked at the Center for Ocean Solutions at Stanford University; Clara García-Sánchez, research scientist for the Carnegie Institute for science; Philip G. Brodrick, Department of Global Ecology, Carnegie Institution for Science; Parker Gassett, School of Marine Sciences, University of Maine; Ken Caldeira, Department of Global Ecology, Carnegie Institution for Science; ScienceDirect; “Evaluating hypoxia alleviation through induced downwelling”; June 1 2020; https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0048969720308445)--amc
Much work remains to understand the ecological benefits and risks of forced oxygenation in hypoxic ecosystems. Serious risks of downwelling include changes in circulation from reductions in stratification and associated changes in bottom water habitats, decreased loss rates of reactive nitrogen from decreased denitrification, and increased sediment storage of phosphorus that could become remobilized during another hypoxic event (). Downwelling would likely introduce to aquatic environments (tubes, pipes, cables, etc.) that may interfere with natural competition for space and predation dynamics. Biofouling of the downwelling equipment may reduce the operating efficiency of the downwelling equipment and increase maintenance costs through required equipment replacement on long-term deployments. Peak daylight dissolved oxygen concentrations in eutrophic areas are often associated with high concentrations of . Downwelling of warm surface water and high concentrations of particulate organic matter to depth may enhance respiratory fluxes that offset the hypoxia mitigation, or even exacerbate the hypoxia, by increasing the microbial respiration rate (temperature) and the organic material available to respire (particulate organic matter). These processes may operate independently, additively, or synergistically. Aeration has been shown to be ineffective in reducing the internal phosphorus loading of some lakes subject to high organic matter loading (Gächter and Wehrli, 1998, ). Large-scale downwelling could have unintended consequences by manipulating land-sea (). Termination shock, the rapid rebound to pre-intervention conditions, has been predicted in model simulations of artificial upwelling to increase ocean (Oschlies et al., 2010). There may exist similar risks of termination shock when downwelling to increase ocean oxygen content. Even if all of these adverse side effects are avoided, eutrophied aquatic ecosystems may not return to their pre-disturbance states ().
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Dead Zones
Gaines et.al 21 (Steve Gaines, director of the UC Santa Barbara Marine Science Institute, UCSB Acting Dean of Science and Acting Vice Chancellor for Research, and principal investigator for the Sustainable Fisheries Group; Phoebe Racine, Bren School of Environmental Science & Management; Anna Claire Marley; Bren School of Environmental Science & Management; Halley E. Froehlich, Environmental Studies, UCSB; Ian Ladner, Ilan MacAdam-Somer, and Darcy Bradley, Marine Science Institute, UCSB Marine Science Institute, University of California, Santa Barbara; “A case for seaweed aquaculture inclusion in U.S. nutrient pollution management,”
Seaweed’s nutrient assimilation capacity changes significantly across species and environmental conditions (e.g., , temperature, water clarity, etc. ). There is general agreement that both N and P need to be controlled in , and configuring seaweed aquaculture for nutrient assimilation will require location, temporal, and species-specific policies and design. While there are many ecosystem services that seaweed aquaculture can provide, there are also externalities. Just as farmed seaweeds can be used to reduce eutrophication, they can also divert nutrients away from webs . Further, deploying farm infrastructure in the water alters local and increases the potential for and the spread of , . Species with opportunistic biological attributes, such as sargassum and , could be grown more safely with sterile strains . More generally, impacts can be minimized through informed siting, farming at lower densities, and rigorous monitoring , . is also necessary to maximize nutrient assimilation services while avoiding potential and conflict with existing industries.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Critical Infrastructure
Fadi Aloul, A.R. Al-Ali, Rami Al-Dalky, Mamoun Al-Mardini, Wassim El-Hajj 12, International Journal of Renewable Energy and Smart Grid (IJRESG), (Vol. 1, No. 1), September 2012, http://www.ijsgce.com/uploadfile/2012/1011/20121011121836539.pdf//KOO
Smart grid network introduces enhancements and improved capabilities to the conventional power network making it more complex and vulnerable to different types of attacks. These vulnerabilities might allow attackers to access the network, break the confidentiality and integrity of the transmitted data, and make the service unavailable. As proposed in [2],[3], the following vulnerabilities are the most serious in smart grids:
1) Customer security: Smart meters autonomously collect massive amounts of data and transport it to the utility company, consumer, and service providers. This data includes private consumer information that might be used to infer consumer’s activities, devices being used, and times when the home is vacant.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Climate
Terrapass, 22[Terrapass, a social enterprise that provides carbon offsetting products. , “How Does Carbon Capture Help Fight Climate Change?,” 6-22-2022, Terrapass, https://terrapass.com/blog/how-does-carbon-capture-help-fight-climate-change/ , maizemg]
Carbon capture has the potential to reverse climate change, but it is essential to fight climate change with many different tactics. Carbon dioxide is the primary culprit responsible for causing the greenhouse warming effect that is driving climate change. The more carbon that is removed and prevented from the atmosphere, the less the planet will warm and experience shifts in climate. As carbon capture technology improves, we will see industries reducing the amount of carbon that is in the atmosphere. However, a transition to clean and renewable energy technology is also essential in reducing our overall greenhouse gas emissions. Direct air capture and good forestry practices can help reduce the amounts of CO2 in the atmosphere once we have stopped emitting carbon altogether. While we wait for direct air capture technology to improve, our best opportunity is to support sustainability projects. One way you can get involved is through participating in carbon offsetting, which reduces your carbon footprint and supports sustainable activities. Capturing Carbon for a Better Future With carbon capture technologies continuously improving, we have even more tools to combat the changing climate. Capturing carbon from factories proves to be very efficient, and capturing carbon directly from the air presents a great opportunity to reduce atmospheric carbon levels. Whether it is stored in a safe way under the Earth or recycled for a different use, capturing carbon seems to present an incredible opportunity for us to prevent global warming and climate change.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Climate
Baxter, 17 [Tom Baxter, Senior Lecturer in Chemical Engineering, University of Aberdeen, “It’s time to accept carbon capture has failed – here’s what we should do instead,” 8-23-2017, TheConservation , https://theconversation.com/its-time-to-accept-carbon-capture-has-failed-heres-what-we-should-do-instead-82929/, maizemg]
For years, optimists have talked up carbon capture and storage (CCS) as an essential part of taking emissions out of electricity generation. Yes, build wind and solar farms, they have said, but they can’t be relied on to produce enough power all the time. So we’ll still need our fleet of fossil-fuel-burning power stations; we just need to stop them pumping carbon dioxide (CO₂) into the atmosphere. Most of their emphasis has been on post-combustion capture. This involves removing CO₂ from power station flue gases by absorbing them into an aqueous solution containing chemicals known as amines. You then extract the CO₂, compress it into a liquid and pump it into a storage facility – the vision in the UK being to use depleted offshore oil and gas fields. One of the big attractions with such a system is it could be retrofitted to existing power stations. The big let-down But ten years after the UK government first announced a £1 billion competition to design CCS, we’re not much further forward. The reason is summed up by the geologist Lord Oxburgh in his contribution to the government-commissioned report on CCS published last year: The problem is that the process is costly and energy intensive. For a gas-fired power station, you typically have to burn 16% more gas to provide the capture power. Not only this, you end up with a 16% increase in emissions of other serious air pollutants like sulphur dioxide, nitrogen oxides and particulate matter. Concerns have also been expressed about the potential health effects of the amine solvent used in the carbon capture. You then have to contend with the extra emissions from processing and transporting 16% more gas. And all this before you factor in the pipeline costs of the CO₂ storage and the uncertainties around whether it might escape once you’ve got it in the ground. Around the world, the only places CCS looks viable are where there are heavy state subsidies or substantial additional revenue streams, such as from enhanced oil recovery from oilfields where the CO₂ is being pumped in. Well, say the carbon capture advocates, maybe another technology is the answer. They point to oxy-combustion, a system which is close to reaching fruition at a plant in Texas. First proposed many years ago by British engineer Rodney Allam, this involves separating oxygen from air, burning the oxygen with the fossil fuel, and using the combustion products – water and CO₂ – to drive a high-pressure turbine and produce electricity. The hot CO₂ is pressurised and recycled back into the burners, which improves thermal efficiency. It has the additional advantage that CO₂ is also available at pressures suitable for pipeline transportation. It is, according to some enthusiasts, the “holy grail” of CCS. Admittedly it looks promising, but I wouldn’t go that far. It’s not suitable for retrofitting existing power stations. With many existing stations viable for several decades, this will do little for immediate emissions. And you are still obtaining and moving fossil fuels in large quantities, with the resultant emissions along the way. Finally, my experience would indicate that there is always very significant cost growth with new technology scaled up to industry. Number crunching One UK post-combustion CCS project that was cancelled earlier this year was the joint-venture between SSE and Shell at the Peterhead gas-fired ation in northeast Scotland. It aimed to capture 10m tonnes of CO₂ over a 10-year period and store it 2km under the North Sea. Let’s put this saving into context. The diagram below summarises the amount of power produced and used in the UK. It shows that the country uses 108 terawatt hours (TWhrs) of domestic electricity per annum. UK electricity generation/consumption Of this domestic usage, 16% goes to cooking. Boiling kettles makes up 34% – that’s 5.9TWhrs per annum, the equivalent of a 670MW power station. Domestic kettle use is particularly inefficient as we regularly overfill our kettles. We could save at least half the energy if we boiled only what we need to make tea and coffee. That would negate the need for 335MW of power. Now compare that to what CCS would have saved from Peterhead – 85% of a 400MW gas turbine, or 340MW. Simply by not overfilling our kettles, we could remove about the same amount of CO₂. Unlike CCS, let alone oxy-combustion, we could do this immediately, for free, and cut our electricity bills and remove various air pollutants at the same time. Of course, being kettle smart will only deliver a fraction of the UK’s required carbon reduction goals. It’s only about 3TWhrs out of the approximately 170TWhrs produced by gas-fired power in the UK each year. But it hopefully illustrates why energy efficiency is a much smarter way of reducing carbon and other harmful air emissions than CCS. If we took the same approach to lighting, computer monitors, TVs on stand-by, running water and everything else, it becomes a very different proposition. If we could achieve the aim of a carbon-neutral house, we could shut down half the UK’s existing gas-fired power stations. And if industry and other non-domestic consumers made energy savings of the order of 20%, that would bring down the gas-fired power requirement by a corresponding percentage. Is 20% realistic? As a chemical engineer with a 40-year industrial career, I am confident it is. Key areas to be considered would be pump and compressor efficiency, energy use in separation processes, combined heat and power, furnace fuel management, green concrete and energy integration. Together with the government giving greater priority to renewable energy like offshore wind and solar, you have a viable plan for delivering the UK’s carbon goals. CCS may still have its place, but as a means of removing carbon emissions from burning things like wood and rubbish as opposed to fossil fuels. Suffice to say it looks more promising on that front. But in short, it is time for governments to stop wasting time and money on technologies like CCS that aren’t working. They need to finally get serious about leading a major drive for energy efficiency instead.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Climate
Robertson, 22 [Bruce Robertson, Bruce Robertson is an Energy Finance Analyst – Gas/LNG at the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis, “Carbon capture has a long history. Of failure,” 9-1-2022, Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, , maizemg]
Carbon capture and storage is an old technology, first commercialized in the 1970s. Back then it was called enhanced oil recovery, because the carbon dioxide recovered from oil and gas production was injected into depleted oil and gas reservoirs to re-pressurize them and extract more hydrocarbons. As the climate change movement gained momentum, the oil and gas industry wisely rebranded enhanced oil recovery as a “climate-friendly” process with a new name: carbon capture utilization and storage. Today, over 70 percent of carbon capture projects are, in fact, enhanced oil recovery projects used to produce more oil and/or gas, resulting in yet more greenhouse gas emissions. The Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis has estimated that most of the total captured carbon throughout history found its use in enhanced oil recovery—approximately 80–90 percent. Only a small proportion of carbon capture projects (approximately 10–20 percent) have stored carbon in dedicated geological structures without using it for oil and gas production. Despite its long history, carbon capture is a problematic technology. A new IEEFA study reviewed the capacity and performance of 13 flagship projects and found that 10 of the 13 failed or underperformed against their designed capacities, mostly by large margins. The natural gas processing sector dominates the application of carbon capture technology. The gas production process requires the removal of carbon dioxide. While many gas companies now claim to produce “carbon-neutral” gas or liquefied natural gas, this is little more than marketing hubris. The “carbon-neutral” tag has been obtained by using carbon capture to capture the 10–15 percent of Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions (the emissions generated from producing natural gas) during the gas production process or by purchasing carbon offsets. Yet up to 90 percent of emissions from oil and gas do not occur at production. Instead, these emissions, called Scope 3 emissions, occur when the product is actually used, that is, burnt. As shown in our study, capturing Scope 3 emissions, the biggest chunk of emissions created from using the product, is not being accounted for in these “carbon-neutral” claims. Apart from the poor performance of carbon capture projects, carbon capture in power plants has shown a track record of technical failures since 2000. Close to 90 percent of the proposed global carbon capture capacity in the power sector has failed at the implementation stage or was suspended early. Even if the carbon dioxide can be injected underground, there is no guarantee that it will stay there and not leak into the atmosphere. There are several real-world examples of failure to keep gas underground. The best example is the California Aliso Canyon gas leak in 2015, the worst man-made greenhouse gas disaster in US history, when 97,000 metric tons of methane leaked into the atmosphere. While the leak at Aliso Canyon was a methane, not carbon dioxide, leak, depleted oil and gas reservoirs are commonly used to store captured carbon dioxide. The problems encountered at Aliso Canyon could also be encountered with carbon dioxide at a carbon capture project. Another failure was the In Salah project in Algeria, a carbon capture project with a total cost of US$2.7 billion. Injection started in 2004 and was suspended in 2011 due to concerns about the integrity of the seal and suspicious movements of the trapped carbon dioxide under the ground. The entire efficacy of the carbon capture process has been called into question by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. In its special report on Carbon Dioxide Capture and Storage, the IPCC stated: “CO2 storage is not necessarily permanent. Physical leakage from storage reservoirs is possible via (1) gradual and long-term release or (2) sudden release of CO2 caused by disruption of the reservoir.” Carbon capture has been used as a justification for new oil and gas projects. It has a history of poor performance, only captures a fraction of the total emissions from the lifecycle of oil and gas production and its long-term efficacy is questionable. It is no solution for a climate-constrained world.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Civil Unrest › 2AC --- Civil Unrest --- Policing CP
[Melissa Morgan, 11-30-2021, "Community Policing: A Better Way to Improve Policing or a Bust?," No Publication, , js]
Blair: We find that community policing doesn’t live up to its promise when implemented in the Global South. Community policing doesn’t build trust between citizens and police, it doesn’t lead to citizens to share the kinds of tips and information with police that might improve police efficiency, and, perhaps not surprisingly then, it does not lead to lower crime. This disappointing result was apparent across all six contexts and for all of the primary outcomes we measured. Is there an alternative to community policing, or ways to reform these systems, that would make them more efficacious at creating the desired outcomes? Weinstein: We carefully examined each of the six contexts, including through interviews with the police agencies and the research teams, to make sense of this null result. We identified three primary constraints that may have impeded the implementation of community policing: (a) a lack of prioritization of these new practices by police leadership (b) the rotation to new posts of police officers who had championed the effort and were trained to implement it and (c) limited resources to follow up on the concerns raised by citizens.The bottom line is that community policing isn’t positioned to deliver increased trust and collaboration in environments with limited incentives and resources to enable police to change their behavior. Our conclusion is that community policing should be seen as an incremental reform that can make a difference in well-resourced police departments with strong incentives to be responsive to citizen concerns. But when those conditions are absent, an incremental approach can’t deliver. More systemic reforms are required. How does the data from your work fit into broader issues of equity, just representation, and racism that communities across the world continue to grapple with?Blair: In many ways community policing appears to be the ideal policy for this moment, where so many are demanding that police abuse be reduced while also reducing crime victimization. Community policing is meant to do both, constructing a virtuous cycle between citizen-police cooperation, trust, and crime reduction. Our null results sound a note of caution: it may not be so simple. We observed big barriers to implementing this shift in policing, and barriers that likely affect other incremental policies. To address equity in the way governments enforce the law, we may need more systematic changes to how we organize the police and hold them accountable.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Chinese Aggression › 2AC --- Chinese Aggression --- NFU CP
Keith B. Payne, 7-6-2016, ( Dr. Keith Payne served as the Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Forces Policy and as a Senior Advisor to the Office of the Secretary of Defense) "Once Again: Why a "No-First-Use" Policy is a Bad, Very Bad Idea," RealClearDefense, https://www.realcleardefense.com/articles/2016/07/06/once_again_why_a_no-first-use_policy_is_a_bad_very_bad_idea_109520.html//PL
The Obama Administration reportedly is seriously considering adopting a “No-First-Use” (NFU) nuclear policy.[1] A prospective NFU policy would be a US commitment never to be the first to use nuclear weapons—as opposed to existing policy that retains some ambiguity regarding when and if the US would use nuclear weapons. An NFU policy would eliminate that ambiguity for US adversaries. It sounds warm and progressive, and has long been a policy proposal of disarmament activists. NFU has, however, been rejected by all previous Democratic and Republican administrations for very sound reasons, most recently by the Obama Administration in 2010. The most important of these reasons is that retaining a degree of US nuclear ambiguity helps to deter war while adopting an NFU policy would undercut the deterrence of war. How so? Under the existing policy of ambiguity, potential aggressors such as Russia, China, North Korea or Iran must contemplate the reality that if they attack us or our allies, they risk possible US nuclear retaliation. There is no doubt whatsoever that this risk of possible US nuclear retaliation has deterred war and the escalation of conflicts. In fact, the percentage of the world population lost to war has fallen dramatically since US nuclear deterrence was established after World War II.[2] That is an historic accomplishment. The fatal flaw of the warm and progressive-sounding NFU proposal is that it tells would-be aggressors that they do not have to fear US nuclear retaliation even if they attack us or our allies with advanced conventional, chemical, and/or biological weapons. They would risk US nuclear retaliation only if they attack with nuclear weapons. As long as they use non-nuclear forces, a US NFU policy would provide aggressors with a free pass to avoid the risk now posed by the US nuclear deterrent. Promising potential aggressors that they can use modern conventional, chemical or biological weapons against us or our allies without fear of possible US nuclear retaliation will encourage some to perceive greater license to do precisely that. Numerous historical case studies demonstrate without a doubt that some aggressors look for such openings to undertake their military moves to overturn a status quo they deem intolerable. They do not need to see a risk-free path to pursue aggression, only a path that allows them some vision of success, however improbable that vision may seem to others. The great advantage of current US nuclear policy is that the US nuclear deterrent helps to shut down the possibility that would-be aggressors contemplate such paths. A US NFU policy would be particularly dangerous at a time when both Russia and China may be armed with chemical and biological weapons and are pursuing expansionist policies in Europe and Asia, respectively, to overturn the status quo.[3] Russia is by far the strongest military power in Europe. It has moved repeatedly against neighboring states since 2008, forcibly changing established borders in Europe for the first time since World War II and issuing explicit nuclear first-use threats in the process. Only several months ago, Russia reportedly rehearsed the invasion of Norway, Finland, Sweden and Denmark in a military exercise involving 33,000 troops.[3] In Asia, China is the strongest military power and is expanding its reach against US allies, including by building and militarizing islands in the South China Sea. At a time when key US allies face unprecedented threats from powerful neighbors, the US should not reduce the calculation of risks Russia and China must confront in their respective expansionist drives by adopting a US NFU policy. Indeed, saying so should be considered a breathtaking understatement in a world in which aggressors still exist, as do advanced conventional, chemical and biological weapons, and another world war using “only” such modern non-nuclear weapons could cause death levels far beyond the 80-100 million souls lost in World Wars I and II. In addition, the Obama Administration declares nuclear nonproliferation to be its highest nuclear policy goal.[5] Yet, US adoption of an NFU policy would mean that the United States could no longer assure allies with its nuclear umbrella. No longer would their foes confront the deterring risk of US nuclear retaliation should those foes consider a devastating conventional, chemical or biological attack on US allies and partners. Pulling down the US nuclear umbrella so precipitously would compel some allies and partners who have foregone nuclear weapons in the past, on the basis of the promised US nuclear deterrence umbrella, to consider acquiring their own nuclear weapons. This could include South Korea and Japan. As such, additional nuclear proliferation is virtually an inevitable consequence of a US NFU policy. Now is not the time for US adoption of an NFU policy; the risks of doing so are too great. Such was the unanimous conclusion of the bipartisan Congressional Strategic Posture Commission in its 2009 report: the United States, “should not abandon calculated ambiguity by adopting a policy of no-first-use,” because doing so “would be unsettling to some U.S. allies. It would also undermine the potential contributions of nuclear weapons to the deterrence of attack by biological weapons.”[6] In 2010, the Obama Administration’s Nuclear Posture Review explicitly agreed with this conclusion. Why change now? Since then, global security threats facing the United States and allies have only increased, as, correspondingly, have the reasons for continuing the decades-long Republican and Democratic consensus against an NFU policy.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Biodiversity
Palmer, 22 [Johnathan Palmer, Executive Director of Conservation Technology for the Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS) leadership roles in a number of key initiatives including SMART, the Conservation Social Science Partnership, Wildlife Insights, and WildLabs, degrees in Mathematics (BSc, Nottingham, UK), Applied Social Sciences (MSc, Oxford) and Geographic Information Systems (MSc, London) and an MBA (Edinburgh Business School), “Conservation Technology: Navigating the Hype,” 4-8-2022, WCS Conservation Solutions ,https://medium.com/wcs-conservation-solutions/conservation-technology-navigating-the-hype-ccb908db6958/, maizemg]
Technology investments are inherently risky. For a quarter of a century, the Standish Group — an IT advisory firm — has produced the Chaos Report, an evaluation of IT project success rates. Much has changed in technology over 25 years, but one thing has remained the same: 25 percent of technology projects deliver their expected functionality on time and within budget. This measure of success is for projects in well-resourced organizations. The success rate is likely to be significantly lower in the field of nature conservation, where the latest cutting-edge innovations face the obstacles common in remote and resource-challenged environments. Do conservation leaders have the tools they need to assess risk, balancing their technology investments between high risk/high yield and low-risk/low yield investments? There are no global assessments of the success rate of conservation technology projects and no specific tools to help conservation leaders differentiate between the next great innovation, a reliable return, and snake oil. “Conservation is like many other industries when it comes to technology investments. ‘Shiny toys’ and promises of panaceas have risks that we have to carefully evaluate.” Yet all is not lost. Around the same time that the Standish Group produced the Chaos Report, another tech advisory firm, Gartner, developed a concept called the Hype Cycle to allow IT leaders to understand expectations and hype by how we perceive a given technology over five distinct phases in time. The first phase they call the “Technology Trigger,” our first brush with a new tech idea, which leads immediately into a period of “Inflated Expectations.” Upon realizing a solution is not a silver bullet, we hit the “Trough of Disillusionment,” when nearly everyone wants to walk away. Then a few enlightened souls identify real-use cases that deliver affordable and sustainable outcomes. That leads to the final phase, the “Plateau of Productivity,” where the tool has well-understood value and becomes one of the many solutions in our technology toolbox. The hype cycle is not an argument against investing in early-stage development of technology, but a tool to help leaders choose to invest at the right stage of development to deliver on their own specific goals. That has particular utility in a conservation context. “Paradoxically, when criticism of a technology starts reaching a crescendo, it’s often the best time to start investing in partnerships with academia and others to identify scalable use cases with clear value propositions.” Most conservation practitioners are very familiar with this cycle, both personally and professionally. Conservation drones are a good recent example. A decade ago, there were promises of drones transforming all aspects of field conservation. An “Animals’ Air Force” was on its way. Drones were going to monitor national fisheries and revolutionize conservation and save scientists’ lives. But it turned out that most high-impact use cases required military-grade solutions and millions of dollars. Conservation organizations put their heads together to develop a small but valuable set of affordable-use cases for drones began emerging: to extend the range of law enforcement monitoring efforts, to conduct aerial censuses of seabird and other animal colonies, to ground-truth habitat classification, and to help rangers avoid direct contact with illegal or dangerous situations. While there is no annual assessment of the maturity of conservation technologies, it’s fairly easy to assess where many solutions fall on the Hype Cycle. Early on, there is a huge amount of buzz, with a vocal group calling to include the tool in every project plan and funding proposal. This is the Peak of Inflated Expectations, inviting skepticism about investing in speculative moonshots. “In the final phase of the hype curve, the ‘Plateau of Productivity,’ the tool has well-understood value and becomes one of the many solutions in our technology toolbox.” Most of the solutions selected during this period will fail. Unless you have very specific insight on what will scale and have lasting impact, the best advice is to avoid investing conservation dollars until the technology has matured. Paradoxically, when criticism of a technology starts reaching a crescendo, you are entering the Trough of Disillusionment. Despite its name, this is the right time for conservation organizations to start investing in partnerships with academia and others to identify scalable use cases with clear value propositions. Once — or if — we hit the Slope of Enlightenment, we start seeing proposals to scale the technology to 10s, 100s and 1,000s of deployments. Proposals don’t guarantee progress and it is only rarely that we reach this scale and hit the Plateau of Productivity. At this phase, disillusioned investors are long gone, replaced by those who understand how scale drives impact. Now we face a new dilemma: to invest in new technologies that disrupt the market or focus on tried-and-tested solutions.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
AT: Bees
Burkle et.al 22 (Laura Burkle, Professor at Montana State University and director of the Conservation Biology and Ecology Program; Will Glenny, PhD., Ecology and Environmental Sciences, Montana State University; Justin B. Runyon, Research Entomologist; USDA; “Assessing Pollinator Friendliness of Plants and Designing Mixes to Restore Habitat for Bees”; January 2022; https://www.fs.usda.gov/rm/pubs_series/rmrs/gtr/rmrs_gtr429.pdf)--amc
It is important to consider practical strategies of seeding that will maximize the cost-effectiveness and cover of desired forbs in restoration settings, including the seeding rates and orientation of planting. Seeding at higher densities is important for forbs to outcompete and suppress invasive plant species (Carter and Blair 2012; Jaksetic et al. 2018). However, increasing seeding density has diminishing returns for restoration projects. While seeding at higher densities improves the cover of native forbs, the gains could be offset by the cost of native forb seeds (Wilkerson et al. 2014). For private lands in the Northern Rockies, the suggested seeding rate using seed mixes that contain annuals and short- and long-lived perennials is 500–600 seeds m-2 (Pokorny et al. 2020), while the suggested seeding rates using seed mixes containing annual and perennial grasses, forbs, and shrubs in prairies of northeastern Colorado have been suggested as high as 1,366 live seeds m-2 (Barr et al. 2017). Additionally, planting native forbs in alternating rows reduced competition from seeded grasses, resulting in higher survival rates among native forbs when compared with seeding native forbs and grasses in the same rows (Pokorny et al. 2020). Understanding the seeding densities and orientation that maximize cover of native forbs and improve bee habitat, without unnecessarily increasing costs of restoration projects, will require additional research in wildland settings.