Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 Michigan Counterplan
AT: AI › 2AC --- AI --- UN CP

NO one listens to regulations.

Wolfgang Ertel 19 (Dr. Wolfgang Ertel is a professor at the Institute for Artificial Intelligence at the Ravensburg-Weingarten University of Applied Sciences, Germany, 2019, accessed 7/19/2023, Education: Artificial Intelligence, “Artificial Intelligence and Society.” https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Wolfgang-Ertel/publication/342110375_Artificial_Intelligence_and_Society/links/5ee29df7a6fdcc73be737f56/Artificial-Intelligence-and-Society.pdf)SAADK

Politicians from all countries and the United Nations need to urgently tackle this issue and address the ethical problems.

The situation is comparable to the invention of the nuclear weapons which ultimately were used. There is good reason to fear that killer drones will also end up being deployed. So does that mean research into Al should be stopped? If the answer to this question were 'yes', this would mean that some research into mathematics, neuroscience and other disciplines would also have to be banned.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
AT: AI › 2AC --- AI --- UN CP

Regulations are useless.

Sarah Kreps 21 (Dr. Sarah E. Kreps is an American political scientist, United States Air Force veteran, and policy analyst who focuses on U.S. foreign and defense policy. She is a professor of government at Cornell University, adjunct professor of law at Cornell Law School, and an adjunct scholar at West Point's Modern War Institute, 11/2021, accessed 7/19/2023, Foreign Policy at BROOKINGS, “DEMOCRATIZING HARM: ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE HANDS OF NONSTATE ACTORS.” https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/FP_20211122_ai_nonstate_actors_kreps.pdf)SAADK

One of the most aggressive proposed responses to AI proliferation has been an outright ban. But an all-out ban on AI is off the table because the civilian uses, such as for digital and writing assistants like Alexa and Google Smart Compose, are too ubiquitous. Bans on “unacceptable” uses of AI — defined as those “considered a clear threat to the safety, livelihoods and rights of people” — are designed to be more targeted (for example, to address facial recognition technologies) but are vague and therefore unlikely to succeed in stemming the development of AI technologies and their diffusion to nonstate actors.57

Calls for bans on specific applications of AI that might affect nonstate actors have become more common. One of the most visible proposals has been to regulate or ban lethal autonomous weapons; it is presented as the ethical approach for regulating these weapons.58 In 2017, Elon Musk and physicist Stephen Hawking called for a ban on “killer robots,” imploring the United Nations to ban both the development and use of AI-powered weapons.59

2023 Michigan Counterplan
AT: Agriculture › 2AC --- Agriculture --- Vertical Farming CP

Vertical Farms are unsustainable and impossible to implement

Jonathon Foley 18, Dr. Jonathan Foley is a climate & environmental scientist, writer, and speaker. He is also the Executive Director of Project Drawdown, the world’s leading resource for climate solutions, “No, Vertical Farms Won’t Feed the World”, August 1st, 2018, https://globalecoguy.org/no-vertical-farms-wont-feed-the-world-5313e3e961c0//KOO

We’re beginning to see a new fad in agriculture — so-called “vertical farms” that grow food indoors with energy-intensive, artificial life support systems.

In the last few years, a number of tech companies have designed “farms” that utilize artificial lights, heaters, water pumps, and computer controls to grow crops inside. These systems glow with a fantastic magenta light — from LEDs that are specially tuned to provide optimal light for photosynthesis — often with stacked trays of plants, one on top of the other. Some of this technology is new, especially the LEDs, although pot growers have used tools like this for years.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
Technology › 2NC --- Technology --- Soft Law CP

Soft law regulation is gas---UK proves!

Adam Thierer 22 (Adam Thierer was a senior research fellow at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University from 2010-2022. He specializes in innovation, entrepreneurialism, Internet, and free-speech issues, with a particular focus on the public policy concerns surrounding emerging technologies. Thierer serves on the U.S. Chamber of Commerce's Artificial Intelligence Commission on Competitiveness, Inclusion, and Innovation. He is also a member of the Federalist Society’s Regulatory Transparency Project, 4/2022, accessed 7/19/2023, Digital Governence Working Group, “Governing Emerging Technology in an Age of Policy Fragmentation and Disequilibrium.” https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4099605)SAADK

In September 2021, the UK Committee of Public Accounts, a parliamentary committee that evaluates the efficacy of government spending and regulatory programs, published a report on Principles of Effective Regulation. 87 The report’s preliminary findings echoed the concerns heard on this side of the Atlantic about the scale and pace of technological change overwhelming traditional regulatory mechanisms. “It is not clear that government and regulators are equipped to meet these challenges,” the report noted. “And the world which they regulate is changing rapidly—so regulators need to be able to adapt and act quickly to these new challenges.”88

The UK government took up these same themes in a comprehensive 2019 report on Regulation for the Fourth Industrial Revolution. 89 It spoke of the need for the government to develop “a more agile approach to regulation” that “is sufficiently flexible and outcomes-focused to enable innovation to thrive.” Further, it stressed the need “to enable greater experimentation, testing and trialling of innovations under regulatory supervision” and “build dialogue with society and industry” about how to better regulate new technologies.90 Sandboxing solutions, which the UK helped pioneer, are identified as a key part of this more decentralized and experimental approach to governance. Beyond sandboxes, the report said,

2023 Michigan Counterplan
Technology › 1NC --- Technology --- Soft Law CP

Only soft models solve---hard governance fails.

Adam Thierer 22 (Adam Thierer was a senior research fellow at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University from 2010-2022. He specializes in innovation, entrepreneurialism, Internet, and free-speech issues, with a particular focus on the public policy concerns surrounding emerging technologies. Thierer serves on the U.S. Chamber of Commerce's Artificial Intelligence Commission on Competitiveness, Inclusion, and Innovation. He is also a member of the Federalist Society’s Regulatory Transparency Project, 4/2022, accessed 7/19/2023, Digital Governence Working Group, “Governing Emerging Technology in an Age of Policy Fragmentation and Disequilibrium.” https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4099605)SAADK

Scholars are increasingly using the term “soft law” to describe the growing constellation of informal, iterative, experimental, and collaborative solutions for challenges surrounding new technologies. A surprisingly diverse collection of scholars from multiple disciplines and perspectives has written about and generally endorsed soft-law mechanisms.53

Soft-law governance mechanisms differ from hard law in that they lack the same degree of enforceability.54 In a sense, soft law is not really all that new. Many soft-law governance mechanisms have been tapped in the past, especially in information and communications technology policy circles.55 Today, however, soft law has taken on great importance because of the factors identified above, especially the pacing problem.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
Soil Erosion

Vegetation practices are practical, economically feasible, and benefit the environment

Prasad et.al 18 (Majeti N.V. Prasad; Professor at the University of Hyderabad, Hyderabad, India; Lander de J. Alves, Universidade Estadual de Santa Cruz (UESC); Fábio C. Nunes, Instituto Federal Baiano (IFBAIANO); Eduardo Gross, Universidade Estadual de Santa Cruz (UESC); Pedro A.O. Mangabeira, Universidade Estadual de Santa Cruz (UESC), Ilhéus, Brazil; Denise M. Loureiro, Bioconsultoria Ambiental Ltda; Hector H.S. Medrado, Indústrias Nucleares do Brasil; Paulo S.F. Bomfim, Indústrias Nucleares do Brasil; ScienceDirect; “Chapter 17 - Uranium Mine Waste Phytostabilization With Native Plants—A Case Study From Brazil”; 2018; https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B9780128129869000178;)--amc

Methods of revegetation are widely used because they are the most practical and economically feasible for long-term mine rehabilitation. A suitable vegetation cover is not only beneficial to the restoration of contaminated land but also results in the prevention of surface soil erosion (Baker et al., 1994, Prasad et al., 2016, Truong, 1999). An adequate plant cover is beneficial in restoring contaminated soil and results in better welfare values, as well as in preventing soil erosion (Baker et al., 1994, Truong, 1999). Revegetation aims to achieve certain immediate goals, such as rapid erosion control, increased soil aggregation capacity, and tolerance to extreme conditions (e.g., low availability of water and nutrients), as well as provide long-term ecological and environmental balance (Khan et al., 2000, Maiti, 2012). The choice of species for recovery should be based on detailed knowledge of the floristic and phytosociological composition of environments similar to those to be recovered (Almeida, 2006). Prospecting and use of native species adapted to the local climate can contribute to the success of recovery actions, whereas the diversification of species favors ecological balance, productivity, and sustainability of the recovered area (Prasad et al., 2015). Grasses and legumes are widely used in the recovery of areas. It is known that legumes possess great potential for promoting nutrient cycling (Araújo and Costa, 2013, Maiti and Maiti, 2015), mainly because of their association with nitrogen-fixing bacteria. Similarly, grasses, with their profuse root systems, favor the establishment of symbiotic relationships with arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF) and other soil microorganisms, favoring their structuring and the consequent success of restoration actions (Rajkumar et al., 2012, Sarma and Prasad, 2015).

2023 Michigan Counterplan
Soil Erosion

Proper vegetation restoration practices reduce soil erosion

Li et.al 23 (Binbin Li, Assistant Professor of Environmental Science at Duke Kunshan University; Qilin He, Qilin He, PhD. candidate in the Chemistry program at MIT; Fengbao Zhang, Institute of Soil and Water Conservation, Chinese Academy of Sciences and Ministry of Water Resources; Nan Shen, Professor of Medicine and Director of Shanghai Institute of Rheumatology; Mingyi Yang, Institute of Soil and Water Conservation, Northwest A&F University; “Optimal clipping intensity for balancing soil erosion control and runoff production on revegetated slopes”; May 2023; https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0022169423004122?ref=pdf_download&fr=RR-2&rr=7e5e41f079192b20)-amc

Vegetation restoration is a safeguard measure to reduce soil erosion and protect the ecological environment, and can be effective for erosion Fig. 3. Runoff depth and soil loss under different clipping treatments, rainfall intensities, and slope gradients. Vertical bars and the middle horizontal lines mean standard error, mean the average value and n = 3. Fig. 4. Variation partitioning analysis differentiates the influences of rainfall intensity, clipping intensity, and slope gradient on soil erosion. The data represent the percentage of variation explained by each factor. Q. He et al. Journal of Hydrology 620 (2023) 129470 7 control under a wide range of environmental conditions (Fiener et al., 2011; Ran et al., 2013; Wu et al., 2020; Shi et al., 2022). Vegetation reduces soil erosion through the following processes: (a) protecting the soil from direct raindrop impact by intercepting raindrops and reducing their energy; (b) reducing surface runoff velocity by providing additional surface roughness; and (c) holding soil particles in place by physically binding soil particles together to form a mechanical barrier to soil and water movement (Ran et al., 2013; Hou et al., 2020; Shi et al., 2022). The above-ground and below-ground parts of vegetation have different relative contributions to the runoff production and soil loss (Zhou and Shangguan, 2007; Zhang et al., 2012; Li and Pan, 2018; Lin et al., 2019). Therefore, clipping management alters the limiting factor of the runoff and soil erosion processes by reducing the above-ground vegetation cover and retaining the roots and litter. Clipped vegetation with lower surface roughness could accelerate surface runoff velocity and increase the runoff generation (Prosser et al., 1995; Assouline and Ben-Hur, 2006; Ding and Fu, 2022). The retained stem-litter layer and roots maintain the soil resistance, thus preventing severe soil erosion (Lin et al., 2019; Ding and Fu, 2022). This is consistent with the findings that the effects of clipping intensity on runoff production and soil loss are not synchronized (Table 2 and Fig. 6). The increased runoff ratio is higher than the soil loss ratio at the optimal clipping intensity. Therefore, one aim of this study was to find an optimal vegetation clipping intensity to increase surface runoff yield and limit soil loss within an acceptable range. The recommended clipping intensity was between the light and heavy clipping intensity treatments with 23 % − 48 % vegetation cover after clipping. This result is lower than previous studies (Ran et al., 2013; Yan et al., 2013; Shi et al., 2022; Zhang et al., 2022), which may be due to the use of different methods to control vegetation cover. Previous studies (Yan et al., 2013; Hou et al., 2020; Shi et al., 2022) used scouring modeling experiments or simulated rainfall on artificial grassland with planted vegetation coverage rather than clipping natural grassland to specific coverages, which maintains the underground roots and some plant residues. Various vegetation components have different relative contributions to controlling runoff production and soil loss (Zhou and Shangguan, 2007; Zhang et al., 2012; Li and Pan, 2018; Lin et al., 2019). In general, the above-ground parts of vegetation (canopy, stems, litter, leaves, shoots) have a greater effect on reducing runoff and runoff velocity than the below-ground parts (roots), while the belowground parts are relatively more conducive to reducing soil loss than the above-ground parts (Lin et al., 2019; Ding and Fu, 2022). Based on the SI index results of RSM (Fig. 6a) and the critical slope for soil loss (Fig. 3d), the slope on which clipping management is applied should not exceed 36 %, which can be explained by the theory of previous studies (Koulouri and Giourga, 2007; Li and Pan, 2018; Han et al., 2021). Steep slopes have a limited capacity to control soil erosion, which exceeds the protective benefits of soil properties or plant cover.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
Soil Erosion

Natural geotextiles have a positive environmental impact

Saikia 22 (Dr. Purabi Saikia, Assistant Professor, Department of Environmental Sciences, Central University of Jharkhand; Pooja Mahajan, Assistant professor - Chitkara University; Ashish Praveen, Department of Botany at Markham College of Commerce; Vimal Chandra Pandey, Department of Environmental Science; ScienceDirect; “Chapter 7 - Multipurpose uses of fiber crops—Societal, economic, and environmental development”; ; 2022)--amc

The use of fiber crops in the production of fibers is an environmentally friendly and cost-effective approach (; Mansor et al., 2019). Plant fiber production consumes 60% less energy than  processing and produces fewer emissions in the atmosphere (). Furthermore, fiber crop wastes are almost entirely biodegradable and organic in nature (Mochane et al., 2019). However, only a few studies have compared the impact of this category of biomaterials to the traditional counterparts, and most focused on the development of fiber-based composites. Biomaterials have been shown to have positive effects in several studies.  examined the life-cycle assessments of glass fiber-reinforced composite components with three natural fiber-reinforced composites. They concluded that plant fiber-reinforced composites were more environmentally beneficial due to lower environmental impacts as well as reduced weight and volume polymer matrix of plant having fiber content. also reported that hemp mats in glass fiber-reinforced thermoset composites are more ecologically safe than the conventional single use of glass fiber because of the lower resin and glass fiber, which reduces mineral extraction by 50%. Flax insulation products were also reported to reduce extraction by 77% (). observed that the manufacture of a hemp concrete wall is equivalent to that of a brick wall or concrete blocks with mineral wool in terms of resource exhaustion. The resulting value associated with is extremely low, implying that the manufacture of a hemp concrete wall is almost inexhaustible. Hemp fiber-reinforced vehicle parts have significantly more ecological potential in comparison to other or glass fibers (). The potential of other plant fibers such as jute, kenaf, flax, and banana was also reported by various researchers in the automobile and infrastructure industries as a sustainable alternative to nonenergy-efficient and expensive synthetic fibers such as carbon, glass, aramid, etc. (; ; ; ). Another environmental benefit of fiber crops is their utilization for energy generation as an alternative to conserve fossil fuels and also discussed in . stated that about 3% of heat generations, 3% of , and near about 1.5% of electric power supplied by energy crops globally. The International Energy Agency expects that biofuels will meet more than a quarter of the global transportation fuel demand by 2050 while at least 35 countries have mandated biofuel blending (Timilsina, 2014). The biomass of fiber crops is considered an important source of energy. However, if this biomass is not utilized in an efficient manner, it leads to wasted resources and atmospheric pollution. Unlike manufactured fibers, plant fibers are destroyed by either composted or microbial degradation and get wasted. The utilization of fiber crops as mentioned in is expected to help strengthen domestic energy security, reduce reliance on fossil fuels, and reduce greenhouse gas emissions from fossil fuel consumption. When fiber crops are used for heat production, they save more fossil energy than when they are used for electricity . This is mostly owing to the poorer conversion efficiency of the cogeneration process when compared to the efficiency of thermal conversion (Biewinga and Van der Bijl, 1996). However, as revealed, power production from fiber crops may achieve greater, or at least equivalent, reductions in fossil energy consumption per unit of land area than vehicle biofuels or . Upon analyzing the life cycle assessment (LCA) data from the production and use of plant fiber feedstocks in the manufacture of fiber composites, insulation boards, construction materials, ethanol, electricity, and cogeneration, it has been concluded that all these processes have environmental benefits in terms of reducing in comparison to conventional feedstocks (; ; , , ; ; ; ; Zampori et al., 2013; Prétot et al., 2014; ; Merta et al., 2018; Summerscales and Dissanayake, 2018; ). Żuk-Gołaszewska and Gołaszewski (2020) claimed that the hemp fiber crop absorbs about 2.5 tonnes of CO2 per hectare from the atmosphere, thus, lowering the greenhouse effect. Hence, increasing the production of fiber crops would encourage all the benefits associated with replacing fossil fuel feedstocks with biomass, including lowering greenhouse gas emissions and offering a sustainable energy source. Moreover, we should not overlook another positive impact in the oxygen produced by increasing cultivation of these crops.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
Soil Erosion

Natural geotextiles solve soil erosion

Prasad et.al 18 (Majeti N.V. Prasad; Professor at the University of Hyderabad, Hyderabad, India; Lander de J. Alves, Universidade Estadual de Santa Cruz (UESC); Fábio C. Nunes, Instituto Federal Baiano (IFBAIANO); Eduardo Gross, Universidade Estadual de Santa Cruz (UESC); Pedro A.O. Mangabeira, Universidade Estadual de Santa Cruz (UESC), Ilhéus, Brazil; Denise M. Loureiro, Bioconsultoria Ambiental Ltda; Hector H.S. Medrado, Indústrias Nucleares do Brasil; Paulo S.F. Bomfim, Indústrias Nucleares do Brasil; ScienceDirect; “Chapter 17 - Uranium Mine Waste Phytostabilization With Native Plants—A Case Study From Brazil”; 2018; https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B9780128129869000178;)--amc

17.2.9. The Use of Geotextiles control techniques have the potential to reduce runoff and soil loss and create favorable soil conditions for (Seutloali and Reinhard Beckedahl, 2015). In this context, the use of geotextiles stands out as an important tool in the reduction of soil erosion because it can significantly reduce soil loss and offer immediate soil protection (). Natural geotextiles constructed from organic materials are more effective in controlling soil erosion and more environment friendly (, ). Geotextiles may reduce runoff and soil erosion by improving soil quality and enhancing vegetation cover (, , ). Both handmade blankets, of our own confection, made with napier grass (Cenchrus purpureus) and industrialized blankets made from coconut fiber (Cocos nucifera), were used in URA. The purposes for using these plant blankets were to reduce erosion and obtain a uniform vegetation cover on the slope.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
Racism › 2NC --- Racism --- Surveillance Ban CP

Surveillance tech is rooted in racism.

[Stef Bernal-Martinez, 10-21-2020, "Surveillance Tech Is Not A Solution, It's A Familiar Threat," ACLU of Alabama, , js]

Birmingham’s newly purchased 1.3 million dollar surveillance technology doesn’t prevent or “solve crimes.”It responds to crimes that have already occurred by utilizing surveillance tools that have a documented record of racist targeting and increased criminalization of Black, brown and poor communities. Surveillance technology is rooted in a racist history that began in Birmingham and cities across the country experiencing acute state violence. The long hot summer of ‘67 saw civil unrest in Birmingham as a response to police brutality and white supremacist violence. The Kerner Commission, assembled by President Lyndon Johnson to address the summer of civil unrest, determined that cities like Birmingham experiencing civil unrest needed more economic programs and support for poor and disenfranchised communities. Ignoring those urgent recommendations, the Johnson administration decided, instead, to employ Simulmatics, a type of predictive surveillance technology, in response to the safety needs of the Birmingham community and communities across the country.The Birmingham City Council’s pivot towards surveillance technology in response to demands for safer communities is in line with the historical reliance on technological innovation to solve problems without considering the fact that, “when society defines, frames, and represents people of color as the problem, those solutions will often do more harm than good.”

2023 Michigan Counterplan
Racism › 1NC --- Racism --- Surveillance Ban CP

Surveillance Tech perpetuates violence against marginalized groups.

[Ed Vogel, 5-21-2023, "Surveillance Technologies Don’t Create Safety. They Intensify State Violence.," Truthout, https://truthout.org/articles/surveillance-technologies-dont-create-safety-they-intensify-state-violence/ js]

However, while everyone is being tracked, not everyone is being pursued and criminalized; police choose to use surveillance technologies like ALPRs against specific, marginalized sets of people. Police make the subjective decision as to whom to monitor and how. Police then use these datasets to justify the ongoing criminalization of Black, Brown, queer, trans, immigrant, disabled and poor communities. Police then use the crime data they produce to call for more surveillance. The cycle repeats itself. Surveillance technologies intensify and exacerbate the criminalization of already heavily criminalized people.In reality, the use of surveillance technologies actually makes communities less safe. Instead of interrupting violence, these technologies invite it. First, surveillance tools increase the presence of police in communities which have been decimated by mass incarceration. Second, surveillance technologies increase the potential and threat of police contact, which always contains the possibility of physical violence. Finally, by enabling more interaction between residents and police, these technologies open the door for more residents to be subjected to abusive practices like stop and frisk, arrest, jailing and potentially prison time, simply because the technology initiated a police deployment, even if no violence was committed. All of this must also be considered against the fact that there is no conclusive evidence that any of these technologies have a clear impact on reducing harm or violence. In criminalized communities, surveillance technologies create the conditions for more violence by facilitating the purpose of policing — punishment, not safety.The ubiquity of digital surveillance technology is the latest example of how the state maintains a monopoly on defining what is the legitimate use of force and violence through law, policy and practice. Elected officials, judges and police create, define and enforce the legal boundaries which mark when force and violence can be used in acceptable ways under the law. With little public oversight or awareness, surveillance technologies have quickly been ushered into the realm of what are considered acceptable tools for use by police, schools, and other public agencies.In the abstract, proponents only speak to how these tools will be used to monitor people performing behaviors and actions which are currently deemed to be criminal. The rise of computing technologies birthed new methods of surveillance which police and other entities have implemented with little understanding of the full scope of the potential for invasive violence each tool has. Elected officials and law enforcement claim that these surveillance technologies are urgently necessary because they will help to curb violence and promote community safety. But we must ask, whose lives are made safer by these tools? The news from Wichita illustrates another layer of the state’s calculation regarding the legitimate use of force: Elected officials who approve surveillance technology contracts value order more than safety. Surveillance technologies inherently lack controls and preventative oversight is nearly impossible. The only accountability measure within these surveillance tools is an audit log of police use after the technology is used. Police can employ these tools for their own designs and then, if caught, ask for forgiveness later. This only becomes an issue for officers if they overstep the line on what the state defines as acceptable and are caught doing so, as in the Wichita case. These tools are violent, no matter if the tools are used properly or improperly.The lack of controls regarding the use of surveillance raises a question: When there is substantial evidence that police commit acts of domestic violence at higher rates than non-police, why is the state willfully giving them technologies which have the potential to enable more harm? On the surface, it does not appear that people experiencing domestic violence, for example, are included in the consideration of whose lives are worthy of being made safer. Further, the scope for abuse and violence extends beyond the elements of the Wichita case. If a police officer estranged from his wife can use ALPR data to monitor her, what about the avowed white supremacist police officer? What might a D.C. Metropolitan Police Department officer, who is a member or sympathizer of the Proud Boys, do with access to facial recognition technology after he snaps a few photos at a Pride march or Black Lives Matter protest? What if the supervisor of that officer is also a member of the Proud Boys and simply overlooks the use of this powerful technology to obtain a protester’s identity and their home address?At this point, this scenario may only be a hypothetical, but there are plenty of avowed white supremacists who work in law enforcement, and the January 6 attempted coup by white supremacists should confirm that this is a very real threat as an officer from the D.C. police actively shared intel with the Proud Boys leading up to the attempted coup. Whether performed or facilitated by police, the dogmatic and widespread adoption of invasive surveillance technologies could provide enough intelligence to enable a massive white supremacist attack, like the Greensboro massacre of 1979, or a massive coverup of patterns of racist violence, like Jon Burge’s tortuous regime as a Chicago Police Department commander. What the state defines as a legitimate use of force is not stable and can shift. The most glaring example of how the standards of legitimate surveillance can quickly shift is the recent restrictions on access to abortion. Before the 2022 Supreme Court’s Dobbs decision, seeking abortion services was a constitutionally protected act. Now, in many states, it’s considered criminal behavior. ALPRs, which were used by the officer in Wichita, might well be used by officers to track people crossing state borders in search of abortion services. The Dobbs decision created the conditions for states to criminalize a broader set of people. In doing so, the mass surveillance tools already deployed became more potentially violent to a new set of people overnight. The anti-transgender legislation push currently sweeping the country is another example.In addition to police and governments, another major player in the consideration of surveillance technologies are the companies peddling these products. Surveillance is profitable. Flock Safety alone has raised at least $380 million in venture capital funding since its founding in 2017 and has been valued at $3.5 billion. The profitability of the surveillance tools developed and sold by companies like Flock Safety, Motorola Solutions, Fog Data Science, Clearview AI and SoundThinking is an extended layer of the prison-industrial complex. The state not only has defined what is legal and acceptable violence but also has made that violence necessary for economic growth. And since capitalism and the prison-industrial complex have always been racialized, the violence of surveillance capitalism most heavily targets people of color, profiting off of harm inflicted on Black and Brown communities. While the line on what is acceptable violence can change, what hasn’t changed is the imperative of the state to protect corporate profits, white supremacy, and other systems of oppression. This should provide a reminder that when the state promises safety, we need to ask: “Whose safety?”

2023 Michigan Counterplan
Proliferation › 2NC --- Proliferation --- CTBT CP

United States ratification spurs global modeling.

Larioux 21 Faculty of Social Sciences Charles University “THE U.S. DEBATE ON THE RATIFICATION OF THE COMPREHENSIVE NUCLEAR-TEST-BAN TREATY” Alaïs Larioux January 2021 https://www.nonproliferation.eu/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/Alais-paper-3.pdf

First of all, when analyzing the various obstacles to the United States ratification to the Comprehensive Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty, one that appears in a very clear way is Russia. As mentioned previously, the United States suspected Russia to conduct low-yield test, though not respecting its commitment to the Test-Ban Treaty. Victor Slipchencko suggested that the U.S. would need the intervention of Russia on two matters: to elucidate the scope of the CTBT and on transparency or confidence building measures that could be implemented at operational test sites66. Discussions between the U.S. and Russia on these technical issues would be good solutions if they reveal that Russian suspected activities are not in violation of the CTBT. These technical talks should also officially demonstrate the differing understanding on their obligations and trying to harmonize them before a potential entry into force. Both Edward Ifft and Rose Gottemoeller agree that greater transparency would be the best solutions and would definitely help the U.S. in their CTBT ratification process, especially to convince the Republicans Senators.67 However, Rose Gottemoeller added that these talks should also include China and probably all the P5. This would help to raise confidence between States and a greater confidence would push the U.S. to ratify the Treaty. Alexandra Bell raised the point of regionalism. The path to U.S. ratification might be trying to make progress on some of the Annex II ratifications. Middle East is part of it. Israel might be the next Annex II State to ratify the CTBT, even though their internal negotiations are taking time. If Israel ratifies the Treaty, it might push other Middle East States to do the same. Moreover, several American security issues are linked with Israel, so it could definitely be a good push. Another suggestion that many specialists raised is that the United States could ask more from Iran when negotiating again the JCPOA. They could put the Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty on the table and make it part of the deal. It is actually something that might have been missed when initially dealing with Iran. Nevertheless, in the Middle East case, the real problem comes from Egypt. They stated that they would not enter in a new arms control agreement as long as Israel did not ratify the Non-Proliferation Treaty. Regarding South Asia, India and Pakistan are waiting for the move of China. And China is officially waiting for the United States to ratify the Treaty. China could definitely ratify the Treaty now, as they don’t have the same political constraints. However, in that case, it seems less probable to see a move without the U.S. help. There is a domino here: if the U.S. were to ratify the CTBT, they will be in a position to constraint the Chinese. If the Chinese join the CTBT, both China and the U.S. will have the moral authority above India and Pakistan to press them to ratify the Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty. Finally, all these moves would be a great help for the new administration in its ratification process to the Comprehensive Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty. Mainly, to convince Senators to vote in favor of the Treaty and for the Biden Administration to get the strength to work fully on nuclear testing issue.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
Proliferation › 1NC --- Proliferation --- CTBT CP

United States CTBT ratification creates legally binding norms- only solution to proliferation.

Pokraka 20 Responsible Statecraft “Why the US should ratify the treaty banning nuke testing” Abby Pokraka [Program Coordinator for the Center for Arms-Control and Non-Proliferation, MA in Political Science from the University of New Hampshire]

https://responsiblestatecraft.org/2020/10/26/why-the-us-should-ratify-the-treaty-banning-nuke-testing/

Twenty-four years ago, the Comprehensive Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty was adopted and opened for signature. Despite 71 signatures that day and 168 ratifications since, the treaty still has not entered into force. Now frustration grows over the lack of progress while whispers about possible new nuclear tests circle the globe. Decades of work and two solid years of negotiations went into creating the CTBT, and those efforts — and the security that would come from a global ban on all explosive testing — are now at risk. Since the first atomic test in 1945, 2,056 nuclear tests have been conducted by eight different nations, providing fuel for the fire that was the nuclear arms race. The United States and the former Soviet Union were the most prolific testers, pushing out masses of radioactive particles with every blast. Those particles contaminated drinking water and livestock, and were directly inhaled by humans, leading to cancer, miscarriages, and congenital illnesses from which people around the world have suffered for decades. Global support for a ban on nuclear testing grew until the near disaster that was the Cuban Missile Crisis provided a catalyst for the negotiation of the Limited Nuclear Test Ban Treaty. Signed by the United States, United Kingdom, and Soviet Union in 1963, the treaty banned nuclear testing in the atmosphere, outer space, and underwater. The LTBT stopped short of a total ban because, at the time, there were no clear mechanisms for verifying the absence of underground testing. Three decades passed before that would change. Having finally developed the multi-tiered mechanisms to detect nuclear tests, even at very low yields, countries came together to negotiate the CTBT. As designed, the treaty will help constrain nuclear weapons development and improvements, and prevent further environmental and human suffering. In order for the treaty to enter into force, eight of the remaining Annex 2 countries have to ratify the CTBT, including China, Egypt, India, Iran, Israel, North Korea, Pakistan, and the United States. The U.S. Senate voted on CTBT ratification on October 13, 1999 and while Americans overwhelmingly supported the agreement, the treaty fell short of the two-thirds majority needed for advice and consent. At the time, Senate treaty opponents voiced concern about the reliability of the U.S. nuclear arsenal in the absence of nuclear testing. There were also concerns about the treaty’s still-evolving verification tools. Those fears have since been addressed. The success of the Stockpile Stewardship Program allows U.S. scientists to conduct advanced simulations and experiments to better understand our nuclear stockpile and assist in modernizing these weapons. The treaty’s verification regime, the International Monitoring System, is able to detect nuclear explosions, even very low-yield blasts, anywhere on the planet through its 337 monitoring facilities. Once the treaty enters into force, this system will be accompanied by on-site inspections that can help ensure states are complying with the treaty. Other Annex 2 states seem to be in no hurry to ratify the agreement either. China has indicated that it is waiting for the United States to move first and will then follow suit. If that occurs, perhaps other Annex 2 states will follow. Pakistan is open to a regional moratorium on testing that if implemented could eventually lead to CTBT accession in South Asia. North Korea closed its nuclear test site, Punggye-ri, in 2018 and claimed it would join international efforts toward a ban on nuclear tests. It has not followed through on this commitment yet. Israel has signed the CTBT and hosts stations and a laboratory to support the IMS’s work, but is reportedly hesitant to ratify the treaty due to concerns over the intrusiveness of the treaty’s on-site inspection procedures. Egypt has hinted that its accession to any further arms control treaties is contingent upon Israel joining the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty. Israel counters by saying the CTBT and NPT are separate and it is counterproductive to link the two treaties. Prior to U.S. withdrawal from the JCPOA, there was hope Iran might ratify the CTBT, but it seems unlikely now without a resumption in diplomacy. Even as Annex 2 political foot-dragging continues, the CTBT has helped establish a strong international norm against nuclear testing. Its near universality has created international condemnation for the tests that have come after 1996 — those conducted by India and Pakistan in 1998, and North Korea five times since 2006. While a majority of nations continue to abide by the treaty’s norm against nuclear testing, that might not last forever. In 2017, Executive Secretary of the Comprehensive Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty Organization Lassina Zerbo said that “only an in-force CTBT will establish a legally binding norm […] bring a permanent end to the destabilizing practice of nuclear testing and constitute a firm barrier to a resumption of the nuclear arms race.” Modernization by nearly every nuclear weapon state, coupled with whispers about low yield testing and overt discussions in the Trump administration about a demonstration nuclear test will continue to erode the anti-testing norm unless the treaty actually enters into force. Countries and citizens around the world need to put significant pressure on the Annex 2 nations to sign and ratify the CTBT, finally bringing it into force. Resumed nuclear testing could result in a tit-for-tat escalation, which could lead to an arms race or even nuclear use. The United States has the most extensive testing record by far. If Washington decided to test again, other countries would certainly follow suit, since they have the most to gain from a world with no restraints on nuclear testing. In that process, millions of people could suffer, and the world would become a more dangerous place. That doesn’t suit the security interests of the United States or any country, for that matter. As the world collectively struggles with all that has happened in 2020, adding the threat of nuclear tests would be ludicrous. That is why, nearly a quarter of a century after its creation, it is time to finally bring the CTBT into force.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
Populism › 2NC --- Populism – 3rd Party CP

The US needs a “far center” agenda which people can rally around.

Miller 11

Matt, Spokesperson at the state department, (“Why we need a third party,” September 25th, The Washington Post, https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/why-we-need-a-third-party/2011/09/25/gIQALQLGxK_story.html)

Three reasons, mainly. First, both parties’ chief aim is to win elections, not solve problems. Second, both parties are prisoner to interest groups and ideological litmus tests that prevent them from blending the best of liberal and conservative thinking. Finally, neither party trusts us enough to lay out the facts and explain the steps we need to take to truly fix things.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
Populism › 1NC --- Populism – 3rd Party CP

Political polarization wrecks democracy.

Forrest and Daymude 22

Stephanie and Joshua, Stephanie is a External Faculty Member of Brookings – Santa Fe Institute, Professor – School of Computing and Augmented Intelligence at Arizona State University, Director – Biodesign Institute at Arizona State University, Joshua is a Postdoctoral Researcher for Brookings – Biodesign Institute at Arizona State University (“Reducing extreme polarization is key to stabilizing democracy,” January 26th, Brookings, https://www.brookings.edu/articles/reducing-extreme-polarization-is-key-to-stabilizing-democracy/)

Political polarization, or the “violence of faction” James Madison warned of in Federalist 10, is as great a threat to democracy today as it was in 1787, dividing voters and their representatives into diametrically opposed camps that are unwilling to compromise or yield power to their opponents. Whether polarization is itself the core issue or merely a symptom, its current severity demands study and swift response if we hope to maintain a functioning democracy. The January 6th insurrection on Capitol Hill over one year ago, and the United States’ ongoing struggle to respond effectively to threats such as the COVID-19 pandemic and climate change, warn us of the dangers posed by unchecked polarization.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
Populism › 1NC --- Populism – 3rd Party CP

The creation of a third party is vital to combat political polarization which solves populism.

Aldrich 22

John Aldrich, Pfizer-Pratt University Professor of Political Science, Duke University (“Does America Need a Third Party? by Divided We Fall,” June 12th, Bill Track, https://www.billtrack50.com/blog/third-party/)

Modern American politics is marked by political division, partisan vitriol, and vilification of opposing party supporters. Over the past fifty years, American politics has seen an increasing partisan divide grow between the two major parties. At the same time, elected officials from these two parties determine the rules for their own elections. Left to their own devices, they have built a system that protects those in office rather than governing by the will of the people.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
Polarization › 2NC --- Polarization --- Daily Wire CP

Ben Shapiro’s knowledge of online propaganda make him a uniquely insidious threat.

Ruben Den, 03-27-2023, "Telling stories using platform affordances: an analysis on Ben Shapiro’s social media use," Diggit Magazine, https://www.diggitmagazine.com/articles/telling-stories-using-platform-affordances-analysis-ben-shapiro-s-social-media-use

The metrics of social media shape future actions by “making [information] valuable within a certain logic of measurement” (Georgakopoulou et al., 2020). Therefore, we should understand quantification as a form of meaning-making. We make something meaningful by quantifying it, and the number or metric resulting from this process of quantification becomes a site of meaning in its own right. In combination with the affordances of specific socio-technical platforms, quantification becomes a potent ingredient for stories to tell on social media. Numbers are incorporated into the complex, contextualized, co-constructed narratives on social media (Georgakopoulou et al., 2020). As we will see, Ben Shapiro is no exception in this regard. Georgakopoulou et al. (2020), describe three types of metrics on social media: 1) content metrics – numbers as part of what the story is about; 2) interface metrics – numbers we see in social media – likes, retweets, etc.; 3) algorithmic metrics – numbers used by platforms to algorithmically organize users and content, invisible to users. Quantified storytelling “implies storytelling across all three levels: stories about/with numbers using content metrics, numbered story responses relying mainly on interface metrics and the algorithmic shaping of stories and their circulation” (Georgakopoulou et al., 2020). In the current analysis, we thus examine how Ben Shapiro applies and uses quantified storytelling across all three levels to tell a metapolitical story. Multimodal discourse analysis For this research, we focussed on social media posts from Ben Shapiro during the 2022 US midterm elections. We specifically chose this moment because quantification becomes extra potent during an election, which revolves around polls, votes, census data, etc. On November 9th, 2022, when the election results were still pending, we took 50 screenshots of Shapiro’s posts on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram. These include 19 Facebook posts, 19 retweets, 2 original tweets, 6 retweets, and 4 Instagram Stories. With our focus on affordances and quantified storytelling, we subjected the screenshots to  (Kress, 2010). This method looks not just at how individual modes (text, picture, uptake metrics, etc.) communicate, but also at how they interact with one another to create meaning. A multimodal approach respects the meaning-making characteristics of quantification and allows us to analyze how metrics - which flow from platform affordances - construct, recontextualize, and give (new) meaning to messages. The design, features, and affordances of social media allow for quantified storytelling to take place on the levels of content metrics, interface metrics, and algorithmic metrics (Georgakopoulou et al., 2020). In our studied data, we see Ben Shapiro operating on all three levels in order to tell and spread his metapolitical stories. In the following sections, we analyze how Shapiro does this on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram. Ben Shapiro's stories on Facebook Facebook can be considered a platform where connecting is embraced and where most posts are indirect. When we look at Shapiro’s use of affordances on Facebook, it is notable that he and his team running the page mostly share links from his blog The Daily Wire for engagement, sometimes along with a short explanation from himself to boost the engagement. Occasionally he does not even add an explanation to his shared links from The Daily Wire. Shapiro uses this social media platform frequently, by posting approximately four times an hour or more. His posts reflect his Republican political views. We don’t always see literal numbers in Shapiro’s social media posts. This is especially true in the links to The Daily Wire he posts on Facebook. Still, we can consider a lot of his posts as part of quantified narratives. When a link is titled “John Fetterman Wins Hotly Contested PA Senate Race Against Dr. Oz: Projection” (Shapiro, 2022b), or “Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer Hangs On Despite Late Republican Surge: Projection” (Shapiro, 2022a), words like ‘wins’, ‘hotly contested’, ‘hangs on’, ‘late republican surge’ and ‘projection’ (when referring to a calculated expectation based on probability and statics) index a process of quantification. It is notable that he does not fully utilize the affordances Facebook offers to engage with an audience. For instance, he does not engage by responding to questions or engaging in debates and discussions (Jensen & Dyrby, 2013). One of the examples where he does post a link with a short explanation is the post about Emily Ratajkowski and her son. She buys her son a baby doll and a tea set, which clashes with Shapiro’s ideology (see figure 1). However, his facilitation starts and stops with that short explanation. There has been no further interaction from Ben Shapiro with the audience of this post. Besides the possibilities of sharing links and interacting with your followers, Facebook also has typical affordances for the users, such as liking, commenting, and sharing. In 2016, Facebook added ‘reactions’ as an extension of the Like Button to give people more ways to share their reactions to a post (Krug, 2016). Reactions include ‘Like’, ‘Love’, ‘Haha’, ‘Wow’, ‘Sad’, and ‘Angry’. Through this feature, Facebook facilitates direct, accessible interaction between Shapiro and his audience. These reactions become potent elements of quantified storytelling, and a perfect example of the co-constructedness of quantified narratives on social media (Georgakopoulou et al., 2020). On Facebook, reactions are visible to all users, so they have the potential to act as a powerful modality that, in interaction with other modalities like text and images, adds meaning to a message. We can see this in two posts by Shapiro on Facebook (see figure 2). A post about a democrat winning in the midterms elections gets mostly ‘Angry’ (> 60) and ‘Sad’ (> 20) reactions (Shapiro, 2022a), while a post about a republican winning gets mostly ‘Like’ (> 1.600) and ‘Love’ (> 250) reactions (Shapiro, 2022c). Here, we see the power of interface metrics as a site for meaning-making. Shapiro’s followers collectively give meaning to a post via their reactions. As a result, the post gets an extra layer of meaning. Not only do we see that a democrat has won the Michigan midterms, we also see that this is bad news according to ‘the people’. These interface metrics alleviate Shapiro from giving meaning to his news himself, helping him in keeping up his identity as an objective commentator. Shapiro's power on Twitter Contrary to Facebook, Twitter is a unidirectional platform where social expectations differ. There is no expectation that the people you follow need to follow you back, as with Facebook. The typical affordances here used by Shapiro and his audience are retweeting, co-tweeting, mentioning, and replying. These interface metrics are ambiguous. A like, retweet, or comment can have many different meanings. But at first sight, higher numbers do index a certain reliability or popularity of a tweet and the message it carries. This leads to a ‘more is better’ effect for both humans and algorithms. A tweet with a lot of likes is more likely to be picked up by the Twitter algorithms, and thus seen by humans on Twitter (Maly, 2022) and in the hybrid media system, e.g. in newspapers or talk shows. Within our data, Shapiro retweets considerably more than he actually tweets. In doing so, he is adding to both the interface metrics and algorithmic metrics. Likes, retweets, shares, number of comments, number of followers, and reactions are not only visible to the users of a platform, but they are also used by platforms to algorithmically order and make visible content and social interactions (Bucher, 2018). By adding his retweet to the count, Shapiro influences the narrative of the tweet His retweet – as a popular account – could urge the algorithm to push the tweet to a lot more people. This gives Shapiro the power to amplify the message of a tweet without actually adding any content. In doing so, he keeps a certain distance from the content and we don’t know what he thinks of it or why he retweets it. But adding his retweet to the count does influence the narrative of the tweet. It could index credibility for the tweet, it could index Shapiro’s support for the tweet, and it could add to the importance of the tweet in the larger discourse. Of course, it could also result in the exact opposite, depending on people's preconceived notions of Shapiro.  Additionally, Shapiro's retweeting behavior leads to the creation of an information environment. He builds a network of 'good channels' around him. In that sense, a retweet can be interpreted as a 'Ben Shapiro stamp of approval', prescribing the accounts he retweets to his followers and (to a lesser extent) his extended network. Such a retweet can result in a lot of extra exposure for the retweeted accounts, who might reciprocate this exposure, e.g. with a comment under Shapiro's retweet or a mention of Shapiro's account in a new tweet. In the long run, the Ben Shapiro stamp of approval can thus lead to more algorithmic uptake and visibility for Shaprio's account as well. The content Shapiro shares on Twitter tends to be more profoundly about his political opinions. During election time, content metrics play an even bigger role than they regularly do on social media. Democratic elections are inherently quantified (Rose, 1991). They revolve around census data, demographics, polls, votes, flipped states, policy plans, budgets, winners, losers, and more. Ergo, they revolve around numbers. So it is no surprise that we see a lot of content metrics in Ben Shapiro’s content and storytelling on Twitter. Take for example the post by @CalebHowe (2022) he retweeted. In this post we find many content metrics, telling the story of a republican who is winning.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
Polarization › 1NC --- Polarization --- Daily Wire CP

The Empire exponentially increases polarization and disinformation.

Miles Parks, 7-19-2021, "Outrage As A Business Model: How Ben Shapiro Is Using Facebook To Build An Empire," NPR, https://www.npr.org/2021/07/19/1013793067/outrage-as-a-business-model-how-ben-shapiro-is-using-facebook-to-build-an-empire

Ben Shapiro rules Facebook. The conservative podcast host and author's personal Facebook page has more followers than The Washington Post, and he drives an engagement machine unparalleled by anything else on the world's biggest social networking site. An NPR analysis of social media data found that over the past year, stories published by the site Shapiro founded, The Daily Wire, received more likes, shares and comments on Facebook than any other news publisher by a wide margin. Even legacy news organizations that have broken major stories or produced groundbreaking investigative work don't come anywhere close. Daily Wire articles with  such as "BOOK REVIEW: Proof That Wokeness Is Projection By Nervous, Racist White Women Who Can't Talk To Minorities Without Elaborate Codes" regularly garner tens of thousands of shares for the site, and Shapiro is turning that Facebook reach into a rapidly expanding, cost-efficient media empire — one that experts worry may be furthering polarization in the United States. "There's a demand amongst certain subsets of the public for outrage politics," said Jaime Settle, director of the Social Networks and Political Psychology Lab at the College of William & Mary in Virginia. "This happens on both the left and the right. But the people who do this on the right have just found a lot more successful ways of doing it." The Daily Wire did not respond to interview requests from NPR for this story. The site produces little original reporting but instead mostly repackages journalism from traditional news organizations with a conservative slant. That alone wouldn't be noteworthy; the circle of life online means information is written and rewritten in a seemingly infinite loop. But The Daily Wire has turned anger into an art form and recycled content into a business model. In May, The Daily Wire generated more Facebook engagement on its articles than The New York Times, The Washington Post, NBC News and CNN combined. Other conservative outlets such as The Blaze, Breitbart News and The Western Journal that publish aggregated and opinion content aimed at invoking outrage have also generally been more successful at generating engagement than legacy news outlets over the past year, according to NPR's analysis, which used data compiled by the media intelligence company NewsWhip. The success of these outlets on Facebook may also undermine conservatives' oft-repeated claims that the social media network has an anti-conservative bias. Tracking the amount of engagement a post or outlet gets on Facebook is not the same thing as tracking the number of people the content actually reaches through the platform. In October, Facebook  showing that the sort of conservative clickbait that performs well in engagement metrics was not actually being seen by as many people as articles from the more mainstream news outlets. But it's not clear that that holds true this year.  reported last week that Facebook tinkered with the idea of a tool that would make reach data public in addition to engagement data but scrapped it after it also showed false and misleading stories rising to the top of that data. A Facebook spokesperson did not return a request to provide reach data or comment for this story. Regardless, The Daily Wire is clearly successful. The company is growing and profitable, according to Jeremy Boreing, The Daily Wire's co-CEO,  in January that the company plans to expand more into entertainment and further build out its smartphone app. "As we grow, and our tech becomes more proprietary, we can provide additional infrastructure for conservatives on the internet," Boreing told Axios. While other media publications have seen their engagement numbers on Facebook fall off this year, The Daily Wire has stayed fairly constant, according to NPR's analysis. "I'm depressed by it, but I'm not that surprised," Settle said. "This has everything to do with the psychology of news consumers and the broader issues with polarization in American culture." ''We're opinionated, we're noisy, and we're having a good time'' The articles The Daily Wire publishes don't normally include falsehoods (with ), and  it is committed to "truthful, accurate and ethical reporting." But as Settle explains, by only covering specific stories that bolster the conservative agenda (such as negative reports about socialist countries and polarizing ones about race and sexuality issues) and only including certain facts, readers still come away from The Daily Wire's content with the impression that Republican politicians can do little wrong and cancel culture is among the nation's greatest threats. An NPR review of stories on The Daily Wire about the COVID-19 pandemic over the past two months found   about potential side effects from COVID-19 vaccines, but none that portrayed the scientifically demonstrated efficacy of the vaccines or that focused explicitly on the hesitancy that has slowed the U.S. rollout. Often the site's headlines seem like a conglomeration of conservative buzzwords: "CNN Medical Expert Urges We Must Make Life 'Hard' For Unvaccinated, Test Them Twice-Weekly" and "DeSantis Team Offers 'Don't Fauci My Florida' T-Shirt, Triggers Leftists." NewsGuard, a company started by journalists that rates the credibility of news sites based on a  of factors,  a 57/100. "They tend to not provide very much context for the information that they are providing," Settle said. "If you've stripped enough context away, any piece of truth can become a piece of misinformation." Publicly the site does not purport to be a traditional news source.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
Polarization › 2NC --- Polarization --- Abolish FPTP CP

Democracy solves climate (tbh just pull one out of an aff file this card lowk sucks)

Bernauer, Thomas; Bättig, Michèle B. 2009 “National institutions and global public goods Are democracies more cooperative in climate change policy?”

Democracy has a positive and significant effect on policy output and on the emission level variable. These effects are substantial: a one-point increase in democracy (around 17 percent on the 1…7 scale) produces a 3.2 percent increase in policy output and a 1 percent increase in policy outcome defined in terms of emission levels. If democracy levels change from those of China (minimum) to those of Canada (maximum), this increases policy output by 19 percent and improves emission levels by 6 percent. These results support hypotheses (1) and (2). Hypothesis (1) (as tested in Model 1, Table 3) claims that more democratic countries exhibit greater political commitment to climate change mitigation. Hypothesis (2) (as tested in Model 3, Table 3) holds that more democratic countries perform better in reducing their emissions, though this effect is likely to be weaker. Indeed, the democracy coefficient in Model 3 is significantly smaller than in Model 1.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
Polarization › 2NC --- Polarization --- Abolish FPTP CP

The two party system will absolutely destroy democracy – shift to ranked choice solves

Drutman 20 [Lee Drutman is a senior fellow in the Political Reform program at the think tank New America, co-host of the Politics in Question podcast, and author of the new book, Breaking the Two-Party Doom Loop: The Case for Multiparty Democracy in America.] "The two-party system is killing our democracy," Vox, https://www.vox.com/2020/1/23/21075960/polarization-parties-ranked-choice-voting-proportional-representation 1-23-2020 RE |dd

There is nothing inevitable about our dysfunctional government. There is no good reason why our national political institutions should descend into zero-sum hyper-partisan trench warfare, or why we should experience yet another year of existential political dread, fearing that if our side loses the 2020 election, America will be irrevocably broken. The reason we are in this mess is because we now have, for the first time, a genuine two-party system. We’ve had two major parties for a long time, but for many decades Republicans and Democrats weren’t cleanly split. Some liberals inhabited the GOP; some conservatives called themselves Democrats. The two parties contained enough multitudes that American politics functioned sort of like a multiparty democracy in practice That’s all changed. We are now in an era in which we have two truly distinct national parties, organized around two competing visions of national identity. It works against, not with, our political institutions. It’s a disaster and it’s driving us all crazy. The way out is to replace our current two-party system with a system that represents the true diversity of Americans — a multiparty system that’s more fluid and responsive to Americans’ political preferences and that dissolves our binary partisanship. To get there, we need to change the way we elect our representatives. Instead of holding elections in congressional districts where the single candidate who gets the most votes wins, we need to move toward a proportional representation system, currently used in many advanced democracies. In such a system, if a party gets 40 percent of the vote in a state, then 40 percent of that state’s congressional delegation will represent that party — straightforward and intuitive. Our two-party system is largely a product of our antiquated voting process. We have plurality voting in the US — that is, the winner is whoever gets the most votes in the field even if they don’t nab a majority of the votes. For example, if candidate A gets 49 percent of the vote, candidate B gets 48 percent, and fringe candidates combine for the remaining 3 percent, candidate A is the sole winner — even though 51 percent voted against them. But nothing in the Constitution requires this system. Congress could pass a bill tomorrow changing how we vote. Change won’t happen overnight. And yes, change of any kind at all seems unlikely. But big democracy reforms have happened throughout American history. Women’s suffrage, the direct election of senators, the Voting Rights Act – all these were at some point improbable notions. They happened when citizen dissatisfaction rose to unsustainable levels and crystallized into demand for specific reforms. We are in a new age of dissatisfaction. More and more Americans are afraid for our political future. Our democracy is flashing warning signs; all-or-nothing hyper-partisanship is destroying the overarching norms of democratic stability, mutual toleration, and forbearance. This is exactly how democracies die. Our two-party doom loop, explained In a democracy, we need to be able to agree to disagree, and agree on a fair process to resolve what we disagree about. Self-governance depends on electoral losers accepting their losses, and on electoral winners giving the losers the freedom to dissent and criticize, and a fair chance to compete in the next election. Hyper-partisanship threatens all this by raising electoral stakes to impossible heights, and making the other party seem so extreme and dangerous that the thought of them winning is simply unacceptable. Once the parties polarize in a two-party system, the danger is that polarization becomes a self-reinforcing dynamic — a doom loop. The more the two parties take strongly opposing positions, the more different they appear. And the more different they appear, the more the other party comes to feel like a genuine existential threat to the other. Understandably, many on the left believe the problem is simply the Republican Party, and if only Democrats could win decisive majorities, American democracy would work better. After all, Republicans have pushed a much more aggressive version of “constitutional hardball” — they’ve pursued partisan gerrymandering more enthusiastically, they’ve actively impeded the ability of Democratic constituencies to vote, and they broke precedent by not giving a sitting president the opportunity to get even a hearing on his Supreme Court nominee. But given the evenly balanced strength of the two parties nationally, and the ways in which the Senate and the Electoral College are biased toward the rural party (generally Republicans), Democrats are not likely to win decisive majorities any time soon. Even if you believe Republicans are the problem, the two-party system ensures that Republicans can keep doing what they are doing simply by virtue of being the only viable alternative for voters who can’t see themselves as Democrats. Moreover, the idea that if only one party could gain the permanent upper hand is itself a perpetuation of the doom loop. And yet, it’s a natural and sensible reaction to current politics, if you think that we’re stuck with our two-party system. Why multiparty democracy? The way out of the crisis is to break the zero-sum doom loop of hyper-partisanship. That means having more than two parties, ideally between four and six — enough to represent the ideological diversity of the country, and offer enough space for different coalitions and alignments, but not so much fragmentation to render coalition formation overly difficult and overwhelm voters with too many choices. To allow for more parties, we’d have to change the way we vote. Right now, we elect our congressional representatives in single-winner, plurality elections — that is, we hold 435 separate elections for the House, each decided by a plurality. So a party that gets 48 percent of the vote gets in a district wins everything, while a party that gets 46 percent of the vote gets nothing, since there can only be one winner. This system renders third parties as spoilers and directs almost all political ambition into one of the two leading parties. Instead of the current system, I propose that we elect representatives in multi-winner, proportional elections, in which multiple members of Congress represent an electoral district, and parties’ share of seats more closely reflects their share of votes. Multiple parties can thrive because they don’t need to win a plurality in order to get representation.