Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 Michigan Counterplan
Bees

Floral mixes encourage bee diversity, health, and population growth

Tanda 21 (Amarjit S. Tanda, eminent research scientist, academician & administrator with four decades of experience. Among his various awards and recognition by professional societies are Elected Fellow of The Linnean Society of London, Honorary Member of the Australian Society of Plant Scientists, and Life Fellow of Entomological Society of India; Indian Journal of Entomology; “WILD BEES AND THEIR CONSERVATION”; ; October 7 2021)--amc

It has been revealed largely that the strength of floral wealth is a key framework for native bee diversity, when renovating prairies as in Minnesota, USA (Lane et al., 2020; Ritchie and Roser, 2020). Agro-environment actions, as flower strips have been accepted in Europe to increase biodiversity in assiduously managed agrolandscapes (Grass et al., 2016; Cole et al., 2020) and beneficial for bumblebees, honeybees, and hoverflies in Germany, Belgium, and in England (Wood et al., 2015). More flower supplies mostly helped in the improvement of bumblebee population, size, density and young ones number (Wood et al., 2015; Vaudo et al., 2018). The impact of AES was determined rarely (Batáry et al., 2015) and Geppert et al. (2020) observed the effect of organic practices and floral strips for bee population survival and development. Both actions were positively corresponding to pollinators’ strength and population and growth of bumblebee hives, but the efficiency of these actions relied firmly on the landscape around (Geppert et al., 2020). In England, (Wood et al., 2017) also assessed a Higher Level Stewardship farms—HLS to experiment if grown flowers helped the native solitary bee populations. For instance, as honeybees and bumble bees were positively influenced by the affair of Phacelia sp., solitary bees mostly foraged sunflower and seed mixes of wildblooms (Mallinger et al., 2020; Nichols et al., 2019). Still, a move in flower resources happened among the most environments of native bees facing stress and could result in the exhaustion of flower assets and alterations in the crop-pollinator web (Gérard et al., 2020; DEFRA, 2020). The restructuring of flower mixtures could also be effective in bee environments with maximum flower density in areas under crop and uncultivated land (Quinet et al., 2016; Moquet et al., 2017). Angiosperms should offer the flow of floral gifts throughout the flowering season for sufficient food needs (Vaudo et al., 2015; Filipiak et al., 2018) based on the floral phenology and specific behavior of bee species. Gresty et al., (2018) demonstrated that plants like Rosa canina, Malvasylvestris, and Ranunculaacris allured specifically those solitary bees living in cavities. This framework is pivotal for bee multiplication and abundance but is often neglected during the selection of bee-friendly flowering plant cultivars. This is accurate for the brood nutritional needs, which vary from adult requirements (Filipiak et al., 2018). The strength and nutritional power of crops like Brassica napus for Osmiabicornis) can positively help in the development rate of bee abundance (Bukovinszky et al., 2017; Filipiak, 2019). In fact, the variety of proteins and essential amino acids required is important for the growth and development of bee population. This can help bee species health through nutritional needs using floral assets available in the habitats, particularly in flower resource-exhausted environments. Different agrotechnology could also be tested such as friendly planting, which can enhance the quantity and quality as in the strawberry Fragariax ananassa and the borage Borago officinalis (Griffiths et al., 2020) but the effect on pollinator abundance was not studied. So it is difficult to describe the chemical toxicity taken from reports on honeybees and generalize about bumble bees and solitary bee taxa, furthermore, solitary bee’s sensitivity will be highly different. POSHBEE, European strategies could be beneficial in comprehending how pesticides can influence these native bee fauna and synergistic effect with other decline elements. Still, it has been demonstrated to also influence bee pollinators and is not a particular reaction to safeguard the bee world (Dicks et al., 2016; Egan et al., 2020). Egan et al., (2020) demonstrated a newly designed strategy that is known as Integrated Pest and Pollinators Management (IPPM; Biddinger and Rajotte, 2015) the same we propose to be called as, “Pollinator and integrated pest management technology (PIPMT)”, as this is a technology, or holistic strategy to amalgamate crop pollinators, bio-control agents, minimum use of pesticides and various other IPM procedures, aiming at the management of the pests below economic injury levels for enhancing the agriculture food production (Tanda, 2019, 2021a-h). Applied management actions are also recommended, such as the choosing of varieties with great bee pollinator allurement and maximum pest resistance. In Ireland, The Protecting Farmland Pollinators plan is reliant upon the designing of a crop bee pollinator assessing campaign which can permit growers to determine simply which control processes on agro lands Wild bees and their conservation 731 Amarjit S Tanda help to pollinators in decreased pesticides usage, offer little environments and floral resources for example, flowering pattern at the farmland level. Additionally, the Interreg-Sudoe Poll-Ole-GI project (2016-2019) focused recognizing and suggesting efficient practices as green infrastructures (GI) to positively effect on bee pollinator abundance and bee ecosystem amenity in the two most significant Mediterranean crops of arable farmland in the South-western European Space (SUDOE) which comprises Southern France, Spain, and Portugal, including sunflower and oilseed rape.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
Bees

Floral seed mixes are key to restoring bee communities

Burkle et.al 22 (Laura Burkle, Professor at Montana State University and director of the Conservation Biology and Ecology Program; Will Glenny, PhD., Ecology and Environmental Sciences, Montana State University; Justin B. Runyon, Research Entomologist; USDA; “Assessing Pollinator Friendliness of Plants and Designing Mixes to Restore Habitat for Bees”; January 2022; https://www.fs.usda.gov/rm/pubs_series/rmrs/gtr/rmrs_gtr429.pdf)--amc

Riparian plants had high pollinator visitation richness and supported specialist bees despite being spatially restricted to water sources. Salix bebbiana and Cornus sericea had relatively high observed species richness, compared to plant species that were more common throughout the study area. Riparian habitats serve as the interface between terrestrial and aquatic habitats and support high levels of biodiversity in the northern Rocky Mountains (Baril et al. 2011). High densities of floral resources, structural vegetation, and microclimates that improve nesting success, and a high degree of connectivity with other habitat patches, underscore the potential importance of riparian zones for pollinators (Williams 2011). Restoration efforts focused within riparian habitats are likely to play a critical role for conserving bee communities. Seed mixes could help restore whole pollinator communities by containing plants that support specialist bee species, which are the bees that are most vulnerable to habitat loss (Bommarco et al. 2010). Within this study, Salix bebbiana supported the most specialist bee species (n = 12), again suggesting that riparian habitats, early in the growing season, are concentrated areas of bee diversity. Salix bebbiana was visited primarily by bees within the family Andrenidae (commonly called mining bees), which is a speciose group of early season foraging species (Cane 2020; Nichols et al. 2019). Specialist Andrena species caught during this study included Andrena angustitarsata, Andrena bradleyi, Andrena commoda, Andrena illinoiensis, Andrena miserabilis, Andrena nasonii, Andrena persimulata, Andrena petristis, Andrena striatifrons, and Andrena trevoris. Phacelia hastata (n = 9) and Symphyotrichum ascendens (n = 7) were visited by the most specialist bee species among middle- and late-blooming plant species. These plant species were visited by bees belonging to several genera, including Hoplitis (Family: Megachilidae), Osmia (Family: Megachilidae), and Nomada (Family: Apidae). Specialists in these genera include Hoplitis grinelli, Osmia cyanella, Osmia dolerosa, Osmia marginipennis, Osmia longula, and Osmia pikei. Specimens of Nomada could only be identified to morphospecies (Appendix). Seed mixes containing plants in different phenologic groups might be required to support specialist bee species that are active at different times during the growing season.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
AI › 2NC --- AI --- UN CP

It solves---trust.

Timofey Dovbush et al. 22 (Timofey N. Dovbush---St. Petersburg Institute of ARSUJ, RLA of Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation, St. Petersburg, Russian Federation, 2022, accessed 7/19/2023, Challenges and Solutions in the Digital Economy and Finance, “International Legal and Economic Aspects of Regulation of Digital Technologies and Artificial Intelligence.” https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-031-14410-3_4)SAADK

Thus, the artificial intelligence development has a significant impact on the global economy and requires the adoption of comprehensive urgent measures for the legal and economic regulation of these technologies at the international level.

As a solution to these problems, it seems appropriate to create a special international body under the UN, the main task of which will be to analyze the consequences of the use of artificial intelligence and develop a comprehensive international treaty on the use of artificial intelligence.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
AI › 1NC --- AI --- UN CP

Collaborating with the UN solves---international regulation is key.

Timofey Dovbush 22 et al. (Timofey N. Dovbush---St. Petersburg Institute of ARSUJ, RLA of Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation, St. Petersburg, Russian Federation, 2022, accessed 7/19/2023, Challenges and Solutions in the Digital Economy and Finance, “International Legal and Economic Aspects of Regulation of Digital Technologies and Artificial Intelligence.” https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-031-14410-3_4)SAADK

Despite the problems discussed above, the countries of the European Union are trying to approve provisions on liability for harm caused by artificial intelligence at the level of national legislation.

For example, Article 7 of the German Road Traffic Act (StVG) provides for the liability of the owner of a motor vehicle even if the vehicle is equipped with artificial intelligence systems (Bundesamt für Justiz, 2021).

2023 Michigan Counterplan
Agriculture

Empirically proven to have a higher yield using less land and resources.

Emiliano Bellini 23, Emiliano joined pv magazine in March 2017. He has been reporting on solar and renewable energy since 2009. Emiliano is responsible for the daily news coverage on pv-magazine.com with a particular focus on European market. Emiliano also covers new technology, R&D, installations and company financial reporting. In its previous experience as a journalist, Emiliano has written about EdTech and new language technologies. “Agrivoltaics for vertical farming”, June 8th, 2023, PV Magazine, https://www.pv-magazine.com/2023/06/08/agrivoltaics-for-vertical-farming/#:~:text=An%20Italian%20research%20group%20has,use%20while%20increasing%20agricultural%20yield.//KOO

Scientists at the Polytechnic University of Marche in Italy have proposed to combine vertical farming with solar power generation from PV greenhouses in an effort to increase land utilization.

They defined solar greenhouses as “closed agrivoltaics (CA),” which would be a form of agrivoltaic project in which power generation and food production are implemented in a protected environment.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
Agriculture

Agrivoltaics solves for energy efficiency

Chris Malloy 21, Malloy is a writer from the Northeast now based in the Southwest. For stories, he has gone foraging in the southern Rockies and Sonoran Desert, trailed a quest to brew ale overnight in a forest, roamed a feral mountain orchard with cider-making scientists, and gone hunting with Apaches. He covers mostly food, culture, agriculture, the environment, and innovation. “Why combining farms and solar panels could transform how we produce both food and energy”, The Counter, 3-30-21, .//KOO

Agrivoltaics help to solve that spatial dilemma. They allow a given area to harvest the sun not only once, but twice — as fuel for crops and as a source of renewable energy. But space-saving isn’t all that has sparked the interest of researchers and advocates across the world, from the U.S. to Western Europe and Japan. Another kind of symbiosis can occur, with surprising benefits we are only just beginning to understand—an untapped synergy that may have the potential to transform the way we produce both food and energy.

For Barron-Gafford, the idea emerged organically from a challenge in his work. In 2012, he was looking for ways to quantify the temperature of large solar arrays, trying to determine how they might contribute to an urban heat island effect, or the phenomenon of cities being warmer than the surrounding countryside. He noticed that heat collected beneath the solar array, making the panels less efficient. Maybe, he thought, growing plants under the panels would cool them. Plants, after all, “exhale” water through a process called transpiration, losing water through their pores as they intake carbon dioxide for photosynthesis.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
Agriculture

Vertical Farming provides long term resilience for the ag sector.

Sai Sproothi Swamy 23. Staff Editor for the Vermont Journal of Law and is an IEE Research associate in environmental and business studies with a degree from the University of Waterloo. “How Can Vertical Farming Solve the Issue of Global Population Increase and Food Scarcity?” Vermont Journal of Environmental Law , ., May 2, 2023,. //KOO

According to the United Nations, the human population will reach 8.5 billion by 2030 and 9.7 billion by 2050. Most of the population increase will occur in developing countries. The drastic increase in population threatens global food security and places pressure on agricultural land. The United Nations Food and Agricultural Organization (UNFAO) estimates that food production must increase by 70 percent before 2050. The increase in food production will lead to resource scarcity and volatility. Conventional agriculture requires the consumption of 70 percent global water supply, and half of the world’s population will experience water scarcity by 2030. Current agriculture practices result in 40 percent of crops wasted, which signals that they are unsustainable to meet food demands for the expected population growth in 2030 and 2050. Furthermore, agricultural production has also been impacted by the drastic natural disasters from climate change, which has made agriculture production unreliable, volatile, and vulnerable to crop pests.

Vertical farming is one solution to food scarcity and prevents the volatility in agricultural production caused by climate change. Vertical farming is an agricultural practice that involves producing large quantities of crops in multistory buildings using controlled environmental conditions and nutrients to allow for fast crop growth and planned production. Vertical farming has become popular in recent years. Many countries, such as the United States, Japan, China, Netherlands, Dubai, United Kingdom, and France, have implemented successful vertical farm systems

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Investment Tradeoff DA › 2NC---Internal Link---R&D Key---Economy/Innovation

Investments in Research and Development Key to Economy, Security, and Innovation

West 22 Darrell M. West 10-10-2022, [Darrell M. West is a senior fellow in the Center for Technology Innovation within the Governance Studies program and a co-editor-in-chief of TechTank. He was the John Hazen White Professor of Political Science and Public Policy and Director of the Taubman Center for Public Policy at Brown University.] “R&D for the public good: Ways to strengthen societal innovation in the United States,” Brookings, https://www.brookings.edu/articles/rd-for-the-public-good-ways-to-strengthen-societal-innovation-in-the-united-states/

Investments in research and development are the most important . What countries spend on generating new knowledge, products, services, and processes is and technology innovation, and vital for national security and international competitiveness. In many different respects, such financing determines which nations will lead and what ones will lag behind. Yet there currently are a number of in the United States and we need to do more to safeguard our future. There are limitations in terms of vision, strategy, and policies that could keep us from achieving vital national goals. America will not be able to maintain its contemporary leadership role unless it about how to integrate important objectives into its R&D approach. In this report, I outline a number of steps necessary to strengthen R&D in the United States. In particular, I suggest devoting more R&D money for the public good as opposed to the generation of consumer products, using federal money to reduce geographic inequities, financing R&D to help mitigate the consequences of climate change, tying R&D spending to national inclusion and equity goals, supporting critical infrastructure and products, providing greater flexibility for state and local government to prioritize R&D goals, and training the next generation of R&D talent. The primacy of private investment In looking at current investments, it is clear that most of our current R&D money comes from the private sector. In 2020, for example, of the $708 billion invested in R&D, $517.4 billion came from businesses, compared to $142.8 from the public sector, $22.6 billion from higher education, and $25.1 billion from nonprofit organizations. Figure 1 shows the investment trends from 1982 to 2020, and the shift is quite striking. In 1982, the private ($40.7 billion) and public ($37.8 billion) sectors invested roughly the same amount of money. But 40 years later, businesses are investing 3.6 times as much money as the government. In 2020, the private sector provided $517.4 billion in R&D funding, compared to just $142.8 billion by the public sector. At one level, there is nothing wrong with businesses having primacy over government in R&D spending. America has a vibrant private sector that enables business leaders to scan the landscape, decide where there are investment opportunities, and position their firms for future value. It is a virtue of market capitalism that such decisions are privately-made and decentralized across a range of chief executives. But at another level, there are problems with the bulk of R&D coming from the business community. First, vital national interests may get overlooked to the detriment of the overall country. Second, likely will get advantaged over unprofitable societal innovations, even if the latter are important for public health and national security. Third, innovations that need to get financed in order to promote longterm public goods may receive short shrift over items that promise a quick payoff. Corporate leaders are under enormous pressure to meet quarterly revenue projections and that can skew their R&D allocation decisions. In an era of globalization, for instance, we have seen a number of cases where business leaders made decisions to outsource key products and components to other nations, such as China, India, and South Korea. As an example, largely was outsourced to Taiwan and South Korea despite the vitality of chips to the digital economy. When COVID upended global supply chains, our chip dependency on other countries limited growth in key sectors such as automotives and electronics. The same thing happened in regard to medical supplies and drugs. Many of these items were made in India and China due to their cheaper production costs, and during the pandemic, it was hard to get personal protective equipment and . This harmed our public health responses and made it difficult for health professionals and patients to get the materials needed to safeguard their health. These are just a few of the reasons why having relatively high business and can be problematic. It may skew priorities in ways that make complete sense from a business perspective but harm national objectives. Business decisions generally emphasize profitable innovations and major consumer items that will generate corporate value as opposed to R&D investments for the public good designed to fight hunger, deal with income inequality, further national security, or improve public health. The dominance of national government investment over that of states and localities It also is instructive to see which level of government is providing the bulk of R&D investment. Figure 2 breaks down the public investment numbers by national versus state/local monies and the numbers show how things have changed since 1982. At that point, the federal government ($4.8 billion) invested more than states and localities ($616 million), but the gap in actual dollars was not that large. Now, however, that difference has grown much larger in actual dollars. In 2020, the national government provided $46.2 billion in R&D, while states and localities generated $4.6 billion. This gap of $41.6 billion dollars shows that around 90 percent of government R&D comes from the federal government with relatively little activity from states and localities. The dominance by the federal government is not necessarily problematic. If national leaders are making productive decisions and supporting a range of innovations, that approach could be perfectly fine. National leaders may be enabling a wide range of , products, and services, and that could be beneficial for the entire nation. But federal dominance is problematic if the scope of innovation is limited and states and localities have little ability to prioritize based on their community needs and that innovations designed to address important community problems are neglected. In that situation, short-changing the vitality and diversity of local government can skew R&D decision-making and lead to important social priorities being ignored. Comparisons with other nations In its overall R&D investments as a percentage of GDP, the US compares favorably to the European Union and China, but not South Korea. Of Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development nations, South Korea invests 4.8 percent of its GDP in R&D, while the US invests 3.5 percent, Japan does 3.3 percent, China invests 2.4 percent, the European Union does 2.2 percent, and Canada invests 1.7 percent. Table 1. R&D Investment as percentage of GDP, 2020[graph omitted]

It is good news that America compares favorably to most other leading countries in R&D spending. These investments are one of the reasons the United States has relatively high prosperity and plays a leading world role. Yet if it aspires to be the best, it needs to be the top investor in the world. Its R&D needs to focus on major priorities and make sure its investments are propelling the public good, is inclusive and diverse in its objectives, and addresses longterm challenges such as geographical inequities, clean energy, and climate change. Investing in our future Moving forward, the United States needs to be more strategic in how it invests in R&D, the kinds of priorities being pursued, and the manner in which we make the decisions associated with these investments. There are a number of steps America should consider in order to further important objectives and fulfill key national goals. Pursue R&D for the public good The US should not rely just on the private sector for its R&D investments because such a focus likely would place greater priority on consumer products as opposed to items needed for national security, public health, and amelioration of key social problems. The country faces many challenges ranging from income inequality and racial inequity to geographic variations in prosperity and climate change. If we let business leaders make most of the R&D decisions, as is happening now, there is a risk they will prioritize profitable, consumer goods and services as opposed to innovations that address crucial difficulties. Where the public sector can play an important role is in identifying key problems and making sure that unprofitable but are supported and that America has the tools to address vital societal priorities. Use federal money to redress geographic inequities One key problem in the United States right now is the high level of geographical inequity. Brookings research shows that focuses on the East Coast, West Coast, and some metropolitan areas in between. This parallels work that demonstrates most venture capital investments today focus on three states: . There is little money invested in the heartland, and this promotes geographical inequality and exacerbates societal and political tensions. In its R&D decisions, the federal government should allocate money in a way that reduces geographical inequities and promotes the heartland. In a political system based on geographic representation, these types of inequalities fuel populism, ultra-nationalism, and political extremism. R&D allocations are not neutral but play a role either in reducing or exacerbating important challenges facing our current society. If we continue to put most of our R&D money onto the two coasts and a few metro areas in between, it will increase societal tensions and make it difficult to address important political and economic problems. We need tax and social policies that ease this transition, but we also need R&D spending that sees equity as an important societal goal and prioritizes new knowledge, products, and processes that are fair and equitable. Deploy R&D to help with climate change An important challenge facing every country around the world is climate change, extreme weather, and the transition to carbon-free energy. This challenge is going to affect every nation and require each place to increase its R&D investments to generate new products, processes, and services that mitigate negative effects and enable the transition to a fundamentally different kind of economy. Both governments and businesses should prioritize R&D that address climate change and help cope with extreme weather, clean energy generation, water management, and the economic effects associated with each of these transformations. Leaders should elevate climate change as a major factor in R&D decisions due to its relevance in transportation, energy, and agriculture. Tie R&D spending to inclusion and equity goals Achieving a fair, just, and inclusive society is important for the United States and other places around the world, and in coming years our society and politics will look very different than they do right now. We need tax and social policies that ease this transition, but we also need R&D spending that sees equity as an important societal goal and prioritizes new knowledge, products, and processes that are fair and equitable. This includes AI that is not biased, facial recognition software that is accurate regardless of skin tone, , and digital financial products that are available to all individuals. As one sign of current racial inequities, predominantly Black universities operate at a major financial disadvantage to other schools. Research by Christian Weller and colleagues at the Center for American Progress has found that Harvard University won in recent years than all the historically-black colleges and universities combined in America. This is just one way in which R&D spending needs to become more fair and equitable. Having strong infrastructure and products will be important for future prosperity and national security. This means not just physical infrastructure such as highways, trains, bridges, and dams, but digital infrastructure that provides high-speed broadband to all, builds an inclusive economy, and ensures that key digital components such as semiconductors and electronics are safe, secure, and plentiful in the United States. Right now, most of our electronics are made overseas and . American businesses cannot always count on ready supplies for their “just-in-time” manufacturing processes. For important goods and services, we need either to on-shore or near-shore production in friendly nations so there are few supply disruptions in case of global pandemics or international conflicts. Recent efforts by the national government to finance and is a step in the right direction. Provide greater flexibility for state and local governments Localities understand their community needs better than the federal government, and it would be beneficial for there to be greater flexibility in how they use R&D expenditures. With most current funds being controlled either by private businesses who can play cities and towns off against one another or national government leaders who may not understand local needs, states and localities are not well-positioned for future innovation. They don’t control the money that will propel future changes and they aren’t in a position to make sure their priorities are central to allocation decisions. We need to change that so that a greater diversity of R&D needs are met and that community priorities play a greater role in allocation decisions. Train the next generation of talent Training the next generation of R&D talent has to be a major priority for governments and businesses. The private sector will need the best talent in order to maintain its competitiveness and government agencies need people with the skills required in a digital economy. This requires money to make sure K-12 schools and higher education have the resources needed to train young talent and governments and businesses to provide adult education for older people who will need to upskill to remain competitive in the future economy. People will have to at ages 30, 40, 50, and 60 and there have to be substantial increases in support for adult education and workforce development.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Investment Tradeoff DA › 2NC---Internal Link---Climate

Startups at the forefront for solving climate change

Kaul 4-30-23 Rohit Kaul[] “Why Climate Tech Startups Have the Potential to Shape the Future of Humankind,” Nasscom Community, https://community.nasscom.in/communities/esg-sustainability/why-climate-tech-startups-have-potential-shape-future-humankind

The world is experiencing an unprecedented climate crisis, and as a result, the need for innovative solutions has never been greater. Climate tech startups have emerged as one of the most promising sources of hope for our planet's future. These companies combine cutting-edge technology with a focus on sustainability to create products and services that reduce carbon emissions, mitigate environmental damage and help us transition to a cleaner future. In this blog post, we'll explore why climate tech startups are so important in shaping the future of humankind and how they're changing our perception of environmentalism. What are climate tech startups? Climate tech startups are companies that use technology to tackle climate change and environmental issues. These startups aim to create innovative solutions that can reduce carbon emissions and help us transition towards a sustainable future. These companies focus on developing products, services or technologies that can be used across various industries, from energy production and transportation to agriculture and waste management. They take an interdisciplinary approach by bringing together experts in science, engineering, business, policy-making and other relevant fields. Climate tech startups operate under the premise that addressing climate change requires not only political will but also technological innovation. Their solutions often involve renewable energy sources such as solar power or wind turbines; smart grids for more efficient electricity distribution; electric vehicles with longer range capabilities; sensors for monitoring air quality and water pollution levels among others. By working towards a greener world through the development of new technologies, climate tech startups stand at the forefront of environmentalism in today's society. How climate tech startups are changing the way we think about environmentalism Climate tech startups are playing a vital role in changing the way we think about environmentalism. In the past, environmentalism was seen as something that only large companies or governments could address. However, climate tech startups are showing us that anyone can be part of the solution. One way they're doing this is by making sustainability more accessible and affordable for individuals and small businesses. By creating innovative products like energy-efficient appliances or sustainable packaging solutions, these startups are empowering people to make environmentally conscious choices without sacrificing quality or convenience. Another way climate tech startups are changing our perspective on environmentalism is by highlighting the economic benefits of sustainability. Rather than seeing it as a burden or cost, they're demonstrating how investing in clean energy and other sustainable practices can actually save money in the long run. These startups are also challenging traditional notions of what it means to be "green." Instead of focusing solely on reducing carbon emissions or conserving resources, they're taking a holistic approach that considers social and cultural factors as well. For example, some climate tech startups are developing products that address both environmental challenges and issues like access to clean water or food security. Climate tech startups have opened up new possibilities for addressing environmental challenges while also inspiring more people to get involved in efforts towards sustainability. What impact climate tech startups have on the future Climate tech startups are playing a crucial role in shaping the future of our planet. With climate change being one of the biggest challenges faced by humanity, these startups are providing innovative solutions to tackle this issue. By leveraging technology, they are creating new ways to reduce carbon emissions and conserve natural resources. One of the most significant impacts that climate tech startups have on the future is their ability to accelerate the transition towards a sustainable economy. These companies are developing cutting-edge technologies that enable businesses and individuals to reduce their carbon footprint while saving costs. This will help create a more resilient economy that can withstand shocks caused by climate change. Moreover, these startups also have tremendous potential in terms of job creation and economic growth. As more companies invest in green technologies, there will be an increasing demand for skilled workers with expertise in fields like renewable energy, smart transportation systems, and sustainable agriculture. Another impact of climate tech startups is their role in promoting environmental awareness among consumers. By offering eco-friendly products and services, they encourage people to adopt more sustainable lifestyles. This can lead to a cultural shift where sustainability becomes an integral part of our daily lives. Climate tech startups represent an opportunity for us all as we face the threat posed by climate change; They offer innovative solutions which could prove key factors within mitigating harm addressing issues related energy production greenhouse gas emissions reduction alongside other ecological conservation efforts sought after worldwide today! How climate tech startups are shaping the future of humankind Climate tech startups are paving the way for a more sustainable future. By developing innovative solutions that address some of the biggest challenges facing our planet, these companies are revolutionizing the way we approach environmentalism. Through their use of cutting-edge technology, climate tech startups are creating new opportunities to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and mitigate the effects of climate change. From renewable energy sources and carbon capture technologies to smart agriculture and circular economies, these startups are leveraging innovation to drive real change. One key advantage of many climate tech startups is their agility in responding to changing market conditions. Unlike large corporations with entrenched interests in fossil fuels, startup companies have the flexibility to pivot quickly in response to shifting trends and emerging technologies. Moreover, by working collaboratively with government agencies, academic institutions, and other stakeholders across sectors, climate tech startups have access to valuable resources that can help support their growth and development over time. It's clear that climate tech startups have enormous potential when it comes shaping the future of humankind. By continuing to innovate at breakneck speed while collaborating closely with others who share their vision for a sustainable world, they will undoubtedly continue driving progress toward a brighter tomorrow. Conclusion Climate tech startups have the potential to shape the future of humankind in unprecedented ways. With their innovative solutions, these companies are changing the way we think about environmentalism and paving the way for a more sustainable future. From renewable energy sources to carbon capture technologies, there is no shortage of opportunities for entrepreneurs looking to make a positive impact on our planet. As society continues to grapple with the challenges posed by climate change, it's clear that technology will play an increasingly important role in mitigating its effects. And as more people become aware of the urgent need for action, we can expect even more exciting developments from this rapidly-growing sector. So if you're passionate about tackling one of humanity's biggest challenges head-on and making a difference in your own unique way, consider starting or joining a climate tech startup today. Your efforts could be what makes all the difference!

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Investment Tradeoff DA › 2NC---Link---Spending

Government spending directly results in capital crowd out

Smetters and Dinerstein 21 Kent Smetters [Dr. Smetters is the Boettner Professor in the Department of Business Economics and Public Policy at the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania, and is serving as the Faculty Director of The Penn Wharton Budget Model, as well as a faculty research fellow at NBER. He works in researching public economics as well as work in the public sector. He served as Deupty Assistant Secretary for Economic POliyc at the U.S. Department of the Treasury, a member of the bipartisan Blue Ribon Advisory Panel on DYnami Scoring convened by Congress, worked as an economist in the Congressional Budget Office, and consulted for the World Bank and Urban Institute. MA/PHD in economics from Harvard University.] and Marcos Dinerstein[ Ph.D. in economics from the University of Minnesota.] 6-28-21, “Explainer: Capital Crowd Out Effects on Government Debt,” UPenn Wharton Budget Model,

Summary: Government spending redirects real resources in the economy and can crowd out private capital formation. An additional $1 trillion debt this year could decrease GDP by as much as 0.28 percent in 2050. Introduction Production of output in an economy requires labor and real capital inputs. Capital includes real items such as machines and buildings as well as proprietary intangibles such as patents and software. To create more capital, certain goods and services are allocated from total domestic output to make new capital. Capital wears out and depreciates, so capital formation to restore productive capacity of the economy is required just to maintain a given level of economic output. Growth of the economy requires even more capital in order to keep up with growth of the labor force. Therefore, some portion of economic production must always be devoted to capital production. Broadly, when government action reduces the amount of capital investment in the economy, the long-run growth of the economy declines. This effect can be partially mitigated if new deficit-financing spending takes the form of human capital investment, public capital, and public goods such as research, which are also productive. Government actions which cause redirection of investment toward consumption may improve social welfare (by various metrics), but the economy might still be smaller than without that increased debt. With low government borrowing rates, it might seem that government borrowing would have little cost. However, when projecting expected (likely) future outcomes due to large deficits, the economy’s return to private capital investment must also be accounted, which is larger than the government borrowing rate. Government Redirection of Resources Government spending at any point in time can be financed with taxes or by selling more debt. In the case of taxes, the taxed entity may reduce investment in real capital because of its smaller after-tax budget. If government expenditures do not cause an offsetting increase in capital investment elsewhere in the economy, then the government’s policy reduces the total capital stock. Note that higher taxation may actually increase investment, as can happen when corporate investment is partially expensed and tax rates rise, thereby creating a tax incentive to shift cashflow from shareholder distributions and toward investment. In the case of debt issuance, the government collects real resources via voluntary transactions with economic agents who are willing to trade real resources today for the promise of real resources in the future. Debt buyers, including U.S. households saving for retirement, view this debt as savings, which reduces their savings in private investment. This substitution is called the ‘capital crowding-out effect' from government debt issuance. National saving, therefore, is reduced more when the new government debt is used to finance more immediate consumption (e.g., social transfers) compared to longer-term public investment (e.g., roads and pre-K education). Economic Effects of Government Debt To examine capital crowd-out effects in the PWBM framework, we consider three stylized new deficit-financed spending programs—increasing spending in 2021 by $100 billion, $1 trillion, and $10 trillion in the year 2021—into public projects that are not productive. The focus on non-productive spending allows us to estimate the outer-bound (worst case) of the reduction in long-run GDP. We first consider the case where some of the debt is financed by foreign investors. Partially Open Economy Table 1 shows results for the economy with baseline level openness and varying amounts of additional unproductive spending in a partially open economy where foreign investments buy 40% of new debt, which mitigates some of the crowding-out effect.

Households who buy government debt reduce their savings in productive private investments. As the spending is unproductive, the economy is poorer and total savings is lower due to capital crowd out. When the government spends $100 billion more in 2021 relative to the baseline economy, output goes down by 0.02 percent in 2031 and 2040, and by 0.03 percent in 2050. The decline in output is mainly due to a decrease in capital which goes down by 0.06 percent, 0.07 percent, and 0.08 percent in 2031, 2040, and 2050 respectively. Follow-on effects of lower wages are second-order in magnitude and do not significantly affect the outcome. The lower growth of the economy cumulates, so we see greater declines in capital and output as time proceeds. When the government spends an extra $1 trillion in 2021, output goes down by 0.23 percent in 2031, 0.24 percent in 2040, and 0.28 percent in 2050. The decrease in capital in this experiment is 0.65 percent in 2031, 0.69 percent in 2040, and 0.78 percent in 2050. In this case, since spending is larger, output is also slightly affected by a decrease in hours worked. This labor effect is due to a decrease in the average wage since there is less capital per worker and hence each worker is less productive. The drop in the average wage makes households switch from working to leisure. Increasing spending by $10 trillion relative to baseline decreases output by 2.44 percent, 2.66 percent, and 3.09 percent in 2031, 2040, and 2050, respectively. Output decreases at a greater rate than the increase in the extra spending. This non-linearity stems from the economy having fewer real resources to invest into real capital over time. We can see this non-linearity in the decrease in capital as well. Capital drops by 6.82 percent in 2031, 7.45 percent in 2040, and 8.59 percent in 2050. Lower growth’s cumulative effects produce the growing downward deviations from the baseline economy. Closed Economy Since foreign investors offset some of the resource loss and capital crowd-out in the partially open economy, we also examine a model with a fully closed economy. Results for when the economy is fully closed to new international investment are shown in Table 2.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Investment Tradeoff DA › 2NC---Link---Borrowing

Increased Government Borrowing Causes Crowd Out

Kenton 5-26-23 Will Kenton [Will Kenton is an expert on the economy and investing laws and regulations. He previously held senior editorial roles at Investopedia and Kapitall Wire and holds a MA in Economics from The New School for Social Research and Doctor of Philosophy in English literature from NYU.] “What is the Crowding Out Economic Theory?” Investopedia, https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/crowdingouteffect.asp#:~:text=The%20crowding%20out%20effect%20is%20a%20theory%20that%20suggests%20that,revenue%20for%20its%20own%20spending.

The crowding out effect is an economic theory that argues that rising public sector spending drives down or even eliminates spending. To spend more, the government needs added revenue. It obtains it by raising taxes or by borrowing through the sale of Treasury securities. Higher taxes can mean reduced income and spending by individuals and businesses. Treasury sales can increase interest rates and borrowing costs. That can reduce borrowing demand and spending. All told, these government activities are thought to result in the crowding out of spending by private individuals and companies. The crowding out effect theory suggests that rising public sector spending drives down private sector spending. To spend more, the government needs more revenue, which it gets through higher taxes and/or sales of Treasuries. This can reduce private sector income and loan demand, thus decreasing spending and borrowing. There are three main crowding out effects: economic, social welfare, and infrastructure. Crowding in suggests that government borrowing and spending can increase demand. The crowding out effect is based on the supply of and demand for money. According to the theory, as the government takes revenue-raising actions, such as increasing taxes or debt security sales, the consumer and business demand for resulting higher interest rate loans decreases. So does their desire to spend a potentially reduced amount of income. (Their desire to earn a higher rate of interest on their savings may also come into play.) Thus, the government crowds out their spending by increasing its own. Bear in mind that the crowding out effect theory runs counter to older, well-known economic theories that hold that government spending during periods of slowing economic activity actually increases spending by consumers and businesses by, essentially, putting more money in their pockets. One of the most common forms of crowding out takes place when a large government, such as that of the U.S., increases its borrowing and sets in motion a chain of events that results in the curtailing of private sector spending. The sheer scale of this type of borrowing can lead to substantial rises in the . This can absorb the economy's lending capacity and discourage businesses from making . Companies often fund capital projects in part or entirely through . The increased cost of borrowing money makes traditionally profitable projects that are funded through loans cost-prohibitive. Increased borrowing by large governments is considered to be a common cause of crowding out. The borrowing can force interest rates higher and dampen loan demand by those in the private sector. Reductions in corporate capital spending can partially offset benefits brought about through government borrowing, such as those of . However, this is only likely when the economy is operating at capacity. In this respect, government stimulus is theoretically more effective when the is below capacity. If this is the case, however, an economic downswing may occur. This can reduce the revenues that the government collects through taxes and spur it to borrow even more money. Theoretically, this, in turn, can lead to a vicious cycle of borrowing and crowding out. Crowding out may also take place because of , albeit indirectly. When governments raise taxes to introduce or expand welfare programs, individuals and businesses are left with less . This can reduce charitable contributions. In this respect, public sector expenditures for social welfare can reduce private sector giving for social welfare, offsetting the government's spending on the same causes. Similarly, the creation or expansion of public programs such as Medicaid can prompt those covered by private insurance to switch to the public option. Left with fewer customers and a smaller risk pool, private health insurance companies may have to raise , leading to further reductions in private coverage. Another form of crowding out can occur because of government-funded development projects. These can discourage private enterprise from launching similar projects in the same area of the market because they're now perceived as undesirable. Or corporate number crunchers might indicate that such investments are projected to be unprofitable. This often occurs with bridges and roadways, as government-funded development deters companies from building toll roads or other related infrastructure. Suppose a firm has been planning a capital project, with an estimated cost of $5 million, an assumed 3% interest rate on its loans, and a projected of $6 million. The firm anticipates earning $1 million in (NI). Due to the shaky state of the economy, however, the government announces a stimulus package that will help businesses in need. This raises the interest rate on the firm's new loans to 4%. Because the interest rate that the firm originally factored into its accounting has increased by 33.3%, its profit model shifts. The firm now estimates that it will need to spend $5.75 million on the project in order to make the same $6 million in return. Its projected earnings drop by 75% to $250,000. Therefore, the company decides that it would be better off pursuing a different project or halting major projects for the time being. , Post-Keynesian economics, and other macroeconomic theories posit that government borrowing in a modern economy operating significantly below can actually increase demand. It does so by generating employment and thereby stimulating private spending. This process is often referred to as "crowding in." The crowding in theory has gained some currency among economists in recent years after it was noted that, during the of 2007–2009, massive spending by the federal government on and other securities actually had the effect of reducing interest rates.1 Crowding out, if it exists, can be seen as negative because it can slow economic activity and growth. This can happen as higher taxes reduce spendable income and increased government borrowing raises borrowing costs and reduces private sector demand for loans. It's important to understand because it contradicts the well-understood theory that government spending boosts private sector spending and supports a vibrant economy. According to the theory's effect, it should reduce because it discourages spending and the demand for borrowing due to higher interest rates and reduced income. The crowding out effect is a theory that suggests that increased government spending ultimately decreases private sector spending. This is due to the higher cost of loans and reduced income that can result when the government increases taxes or borrows by selling Treasuries to obtain more revenue for its own spending.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Investment Tradeoff DA › 2NC---Link---Borrowing

Federal Government borrowing results in private sector crowd out

Peter G. Peterson Foundation 7-13-23 Peter G. Peterson Foundation [The Peter G. Peterson Foundation is a nonpartisan organization dedicated to addressing America’s long-term fiscal challenges to ensure a better economic future. Founded by Pete Peterson and led by Chairman and CEO Michael Peterson, the Foundation works with leading policy experts, elected officials, and the public to build support for solutions to put America on a sustainable fiscal path.] “The National Debt Can Crowd Out Investments in the Economy – Here’s How” Peter G. Peterson Foundation, https://www.pgpf.org/budget-basics/the-national-debt-can-crowd-out-investments-in-the-economy-heres-how

The federal government is slated to borrow about $1.5 trillion this year, and that number is projected to nearly double over the next decade. One consequence of issuing such large amounts of federal debt is that it could “crowd out” investments by the private sector, making the economy less productive and stunting wage growth. To cover its budgetary shortfalls, the federal government raises money by issuing debt in the form of Treasury securities. That debt is commonly purchased by investors such as banks, investment funds, businesses, and individuals because it is generally considered a safe investment. However, the cash used to purchase such debt could alternatively be used for investment by private entities. Therefore, as government borrowing increases, fewer resources are available for other investments, which can hamper economic activity.Furthermore, increased federal borrowing puts upward pressure on interest rates. A Congressional Budget Office (CBO) study found that each percentage point increase in the debt-to-GDP ratio boosts inflation-adjusted 10-year interest rates by 2 to 3 basis points (.02 to .03 percentage points). The debt-to-GDP ratio is currently at 98 percent, and CBO projects that it will climb to 112 percent in the next decade, so by CBO’s measure, interest rates would be approximately 0.3 to 0.4 percentage points higher than they otherwise would be due to the country’s rising debt.Higher interest rates raise the price of borrowing, thereby deterring private investment. According to CBO estimation, the net result of this trade-off is that for every dollar the federal deficit increases, private investment would fall by 33 cents.Increased debt could hold back economic growth and diminish wages. Since 2019, the debt-to-GDP ratio has risen by nearly 20 percentage points, from 79 percent to 98 percent. CBO projects that the ratio will continue to grow, rising to 181 percent by 2053 if current laws generally remain the same. Under a scenario where discretionary spending remained around its current level (rather than declining), and revenues revert to their 50-year average (rather than rising), CBO projects that the debt-to-GDP ratio would increase to 262 percent; that trajectory would lower gross national product by 4.4 percent relative to the baseline and reduce income by $4,900 per person (in today’s dollars).There is a direct and critically important linkage between the country’s fiscal condition and economic outlook through the effect on private investment and interest rates. The federal government has the ability to tax and spend equitably, promoting growth across the economy and investing in national priorities. But it also must take care to do it effectively and responsibly, making sure not to restrain investment, which would hinder opportunity and prosperity for future generations.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Investment Tradeoff DA › 2NC---UQ---Startups

Startups facing crises with an uncertain economic environment – but still afloat

Goodkind 7-18-23, Nicole Goodkind[Nicole Goodkind is a senior markets reporter at CNN Business where she covers global financial makets, with a focus on global macro trends, stocks, and the economy at large; Cornell University School of Business] “US Startups are Having a Bad Year. Relief Isn’t Coming,” Yahoo News and CNN, https://finance.yahoo.com/news/us-startups-having-bad-relief-113646042.html?guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZ29vZ2xlLmNvbS8&guce_referrer_sig=AQAAAIEfngmljrklIDrLYmF3AOyRnkX91tTS203s4KE_OX-agVFCGXKUz_kIDHiq17zFDulVMmLkYvYzTyaARJUFmVN1ikDsHmJvUSdtnKdW9frKERYfWOgI7nphbLIOkgqwlMp0zTO7hR-OF0rEMb3IfzhpP8YPZrtEASt-wPHcm_08

US stocks are climbing and second-quarter corporate earnings are coming in strong (so far, at least). Investors on Wall Street are optimistic. Across the country, in Silicon Valley, the situation isn’t quite as good. The tech titans like Apple, Amazon, Alphabet and Microsoft are doing just fine – but their younger startup siblings are struggling to stay afloat. High interest rates, an uncertain economic environment and a banking crisis that hit Silicon Valley-adjacent banks hard have led to a shortage of funds for early-stage companies and a lack of opportunity for late-stage companies to cash out. Venture capital funding for startups across the globe halved in the first six months of the year, according to new Pitchbook data – it would have been even worse, they said, if there hadn’t been a big boost in AI investment. More than 400 companies haven’t been able to raise any new money since 2021, according to Pitchbook. Meanwhile, nearly 95% of all tech startups worth more than $1 billion aren’t able to generate a profit at all. The carnage is so bad that some insiders are calling this an extinction-level event for startups. For decades Silicon Valley has been a dominant contributor to the US economy and an integral part of the country’s culture. Could this really be the end? What’s happening: This spring Tom Loverro, general partner at venture firm IVP, tweeted that “the Mass Extinction Event for startups is underway,.” Startups, , were quickly becoming shutdowns. “Funding announcements get lots of headlines. Bankruptcy filings…less so.” Pitchbook and The National Venture Capital Association’s most recent report on the industry also takes a pessimistic view of the situation. Capital funding for young tech-driven companies has dried up significantly, and “the market could quickly hit a cliff if economic conditions worsen,” the report said. There are now more than 50,000 US-based, venture capital-backed companies – a figure that has doubled since 2016. But there’s a shortage of capital to fund them with. That pressure from diminishing capital availability means that companies at the seed stage saw their funding value decline by 26.3% in the second quarter of 2023 versus the first three months of the year, the report found. More mature companies are also feeling the burn. Through the first half of the year 2023, companies generated about $12 billion in value from 588 exit events (that’s when shareholders are able to cash out through an acquisition, IPO, buyout or merger). The full-year figure is now on track to come in as the lowest of the decade, according to the report. “An immense amount of capital remains trapped in late-stage and venture-growth-stage startups hesitant to gamble on whether their financial performance can withstand the intense scrutiny of the public markets,” found the report. Merger and acquisition activity has dried up over the past year as dealmakers contended with rising interest rates and fear of a recession — investment banking powerhouses Goldman Sachs () and Morgan Stanley () have both substantial drops in revenue and profit on that end. Fears of a softening economy and market volatility have also caused initial public offerings to dry up almost entirely. In 2022 the fell 94.8% to $8 billion, a 32-year low. That downturn has continued; the total capitalization of new stock in the first quarter of 2023 declined by 60% relative to last year, reported the Center for Research in Security Prices. That means there are a lot of startups worth a lot of money on paper, but they’re worried that if they try to cash out they’ll come up short of that number. Why it’s happening: Blame the Fed, as per usual. Higher interest rates to fight inflation “is one of the clearest symbols of change in the market,” said the report. The current federal funds rate is at its highest level since July of 2007. “This shift in the landscape has impacted all sectors and stages of the venture ecosystem with deals, exits, and fundraising all well below the high-water marks set in the past few years,” says the report. The banking stresses at the beginning of the year with the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank have also led to a drying up of credit available to startups. Extensive time is now going into treasury management at these banks, and they’re more reluctant to lend money to unproven companies, found Pitchbook. What it means: While startups are certainly far from extinct, there has been a serious culling in Silicon Valley that will likely continue on for some time. Just 19% of venture capital deals were made with startups based in the Bay Area this year; that’s down from 22% in 2020. Elizabeth Warren asks SEC to investigate Tesla Democratic Senator Elizabeth Warren asked the SEC to investigate Tesla and its board of directors to determine whether they violated securities laws after CEO Elon Musk took over Twitter last year, . In a to the Securities and Exchange Commission Monday, the Massachusetts senator said Elon Musk’s long list of responsibilities, from to remaining Tesla’s CEO, “have raised concerns about conflicts of interest, misappropriation of corporate assets, and other negative impacts to Tesla shareholders.” Warren added that the electric car company’s board failed to ensure it has acted in shareholders’ best interests. Chief among Warren’s concerns in the letter: funneling Tesla () resources into Musk’s Twitter takeover, conflicts of interest regarding advertising from other car companies, and possible labor law violations when transitioning some Tesla employees to Twitter. Warren is asking SEC chair Gary Gensler to conduct the review. Although former NBCUniversal executive Linda Yaccarino as the new CEO of Twitter last month, Musk has retained significant control over the site. AmeriCorps recovers record $84 million in tax breaks for low-income taxpayers AmeriCorps recovered a record $84 million in overlooked deductions, credits and tax breaks for low-income Americans in the 2023 tax season, the federal agency announced Friday reports . The organization for volunteerism and national service, created by President Bill Clinton in 1993, assisted in aiding over 113,000 taxpayers in more than 130 cities, according to a release. AmeriCorps annually teams up with local non-profits to ensure low-income taxpayers receive all tax breaks and credits for which they are eligible. Last year, the organization recovered about $14 million for taxpayers AmeriCorps spokesman Jonah Bryson told CNN. The record recovery was due to more volunteers being able to help in more cities, at more sites and collaboration with more nonprofit organizations. “We’ve been supporting tax relief programs nationwide for over 20 years, and they’re just one of many ways our network of service members support low-income families across America,” AmeriCorps CEO Michael D. Smith tells CNN, adding “We’re putting money right back into the pockets of those who need it most.”

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Interest Rates DA › 2NC---Impact---Bees

Food insecurity goes existential

 () Conflict of securing food : food insecurity is in effect creating an existential threat to human existence. SangSaeng, 59. p. 8. ISSN 1599-4880 https://strathprints.strath.ac.uk/83485/1/Hall_SangSaeng_2022_Conflict_of_securing_food_food_insecurity_is_in_effect

Link Between Food Security and Conflict In analysing the drivers of conflict, an entwined relationship exists between conflict and food security. They can both cause each other, thereby, creating a spiral of greed and grievance. Greed as control of the resources creates an effective market from which power is derived and includes the delivery and management of international aid by local actors. This is then followed by grievances from the recipients of unfair, or the perception of unfairness, allocation and access to contested resources. Conflict of securing food: food insecurity is in effect creating an existential threat to human existence 1 This is a peer-reviewed, accepted author manuscript of the following article: Hall, G. (2022). Conflict of securing food: food insecurity is in effect creating an existential threat to human existence . SangSaeng, 59, 8. There is clear evidence of the cyclical relationship between conflict and food security in the cases of intrastate conflict and violent civil unrest. Yemen and Syria provide large-scale examples today, though there are many more. The 2004 clashes between Fulani herders and Tarok farmers in Nigeria’s Plateau region killed 843 people, for example. The farmers protest in India, 2020-2021, left around 700 dead after the Indian Government passed three laws seen as detrimental to the farmers. As a basic human need, food insecurity is in effect creating an existential threat to human existence, thereby, the retort to violence is understandable and understood. UN Chief Guterres recognised the link on 18 May when discussing the impact of the war in Ukraine, “as we will discuss in the Security Council tomorrow, these frightening figures [the rise in global hunger] are inextricably linked with conflict, as both cause and effect.” Food insecurity creates conflict which worsens food insecurity; so the spiral continues and is problematic to break. Approaches have the traditional focussed on food assistance and peacebuilding initiatives alongside institution capacity building. The success of this approach has been limited, primarily as many of the areas affected by violent conflict have been away from the centres of power, such as the cattle raiding in the Karamoja Cluster – the border of Ethiopia, Kenya and Uganda – in 2004 that saw around 600 deaths and the loss of 40,000 livestock. The diffusion away from centres of power increases the political marginalisation and the grievance motivation of the sufferers of food insecurity. Effectively, this limits the potential of peacebuilding initiatives and institution building to have an impact over the long-term. Further, the provision of food assistance can worsen the problem as it creates an effective market during the aid distribution process. Local actors are empowered to deliver food assistance, which can be used to further their own objectives or strengthen their position at the expense of other actors. The result is that grievances are maintained and often increased, regardless of the level of assistance offered. The above presents a bleak picture, and one in which international organisations such as the United Nations and the World Food Program are challenged daily. However, that is only one aspect of the drivers of food insecurity. Essentially, they are situational issues. Conflict, like extreme weather, changing export restrictions, or energy prices, are variables and can be mitigated to an extent. The more significant issues in terms of developing solutions emanate from structural factors. The rising global population is the key structural issue impacting food security. The Food and Agriculture Organisation of the United Nations emphasises the issue by observing that around 800 million people faced hunger in 2020, despite the pledge to end all forms of food insecurity by 2030. Interestingly, the breakdown of the figure reveals that about 280 million people affected live in Africa and around 420 million live in Asia, which given the previous observation that it is Africa with the most food insecurity is surprising. The explanations that the high number Conflict of securing food: food insecurity is in effect creating an existential threat to human existence 2 represents the Asian continent is simply a product of high population numbers, which reinforces the link between population and food insecurity. Alternatively, food insecurity is the product of a conscious design by governing elites, as the indicators demonstrate that Asia has higher food security. The implication is that food security is used as a mechanism for control and expressing power in some Asian countries. For the international community, this drives home that an overall global approach to tackle food insecurity will not be successful, as the circumstances in different regions and countries are not the same. The issues that generate food insecurity are different; therefore, they benefit from the same approach to tackling the issue.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Interest Rates DA › 2NC---Impact---Bees

Bee population decline leads to food insecurity.

Palmer 22 [Brian, 5-2-2022, "A World Without Bees? Here’s What Happens If Bees Go Extinct," NDRC, https://www.nrdc.org/stories/world-without-bees-heres-what-happens-if-bees-go-extinct]

A lack of bees in agricultural areas is limiting the supply of some food crops, a new US-based study has found, suggesting that declines in the pollinators may have serious ramifications for global food security. Species of wild bees, such as bumblebees, are suffering from a loss of flowering habitat, the use of toxic pesticides and, increasingly, the climate crisis. Managed honeybees, meanwhile, are tended to by beekeepers, but have still been assailed by disease, leading to concerns that the three-quarters of the world’s food crops dependent upon pollinators could falter due to a lack of bees. The new research appears to confirm some of these fears. Of seven studied crops grown in 13 states across America, five showed evidence that a lack of bees is hampering the amount of food that can be grown, including apples, blueberries and cherries. A total of 131 crop fields were surveyed for bee activity and crop abundance by a coalition of scientists from the US, Canada and Sweden. “The crops that got more bees got significantly more crop production,” said Rachael Winfree, an ecologist and pollination expert at Rutgers University who was a senior author of the paper, published by the Royal Society. “I was surprised, I didn’t expect they would be limited to this extent.” The researchers found that wild native bees contributed a surprisingly large portion of the pollination despite operating in intensively farmed areas largely denuded of the vegetation that supports them. Wild bees are often more effective pollinators than honeybees but research has shown several species are in sharp decline. The rusty patched bumblebee, for example, was the first bee to be placed on the US endangered species list in 2017 after suffering an 87% slump in the previous two decades. Swaths of American agriculture is propped up by honeybees, frantically replicated and shifted around the country in hives in order to meet a growing need for crop pollination. Almonds, one of the two crops not shown to be suffering from a lack of bees in the study, are mostly grown in California, where most of the beehives in the US are trucked to each year for a massive almond pollination event. The US is at the forefront of divergent trends that are being replicated elsewhere in the world – as farming becomes more intensive to churn out greater volumes to feed a growing global population, tactics such as flattening wildflower meadows, spraying large amounts of insecticide and planting monocultural fields of single crops are damaging the bee populations crucial for crop pollination. Honeybee colonies are weaker than they used to be and wild bees are declining, probably by a lot According to the UN’s Food and Agriculture Organization, the amount of crop production dependent upon insect and other pollinators has increased 300% over the past 50 years. Pollination shortfalls could cause certain fruit and vegetables to become rarer and more expensive, triggering nutritional deficits in diets. Staple foods such as rice, wheat and corn won’t be affected, however, as they are pollinated via the wind. “Honeybee colonies are weaker than they used to be and wild bees are declining, probably by a lot,” said Winfree. “The agriculture is getting more intensive and there are fewer bees, so at some point the pollination will become limited. Even if honeybees were healthy, it’s risky to rely so much on a single bee species. It’s predictable that parasites will target the one species we have in these monocultural crop fields.” The paper recommends that farmers gain a better understanding of the optimal amount of pollination needed to boost crop yields, as well as review whether the level of pesticide and fertilizer put on to fields is appropriate. “The trends we are seeing now are setting us up for food security problems,” Winfree said. “We aren’t yet in a complete crisis now but the trends aren’t going in the right direction. Our study shows this isn’t a problem for 10 or 20 years from now – it’s happening right now.”

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Interest Rates DA › 2NC---Impact---Bees

Inflation hurts bees.

Chase Sova and Eilish Zembilci, 3-17-2022, "Iowa beekeepers face inflation, supply shortage challenges," https://www.kcci.com/article/iowa-beekeepers-face-inflation-and-supply-shortage-challenges/39461419

DUBUQUE, Iowa (KCRG) — With temperatures warming up, beekeepers in eastern Iowa are starting to get ready for bee season, but twin economic impacts of inflation and supply shortages are causing concerns. KCRG reports H.R. Cook picked up beekeeping as a hobby when the COVID-19 pandemic started two years ago. "After COVID, you find yourself still with a hobby, well, I found myself with about 100,000 bees,” Cook said. Now, he also finds himself having to pay more for the materials he needs for beekeeping, which includes lumber, with prices that are up three to four times what they have been for the past 10 years. "All the way up to the honey bears, which are made in China, they have to be shipped from China,” he said. “There are millions of these honey bears sitting over on a cargo ship to glass jars that we put the honey in and we sell at the farmers markets.” But Cook said people who make a living out of beekeeping are probably feeling the impact the most. He explained commercial beekeepers usually ship their bees to California during the winter to pollinate almond trees, and now bringing them back with high gas prices and inflation is proving to be quite the challenge. “Now is the time where they have to bring them back, when they come back to the hives of Iowa,” he said. “The gas prices have almost doubled for diesel prices, so it is very expensive to get them back to Iowa for the commercial beekeepers to make a living.” Phylicia Chandler, a beekeeper and member of the Dubuque Swiss Valley Bee Club, said beekeepers are also dealing with supply shortages. She said she knows of other beekeepers who have struggled to find hive equipment and honey extractors. She emphasized not having the necessary equipment and materials could be very detrimental to beekeepers. "When we need something, we need it now,” she said. “And it can be a matter of if you are catching a swarm and you do not have what you need, then you have nowhere to put those bees if you do not have that extra hive.” However, Chandler said something good has come out of these trying times. She said she has noticed how so many beekeepers in eastern Iowa have come together to support one another. "Beekeepers work together, so if they are ever in need we call on other beekeepers to help us out,” she said.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Interest Rates DA › 2NC---Link---MMT

MMT leads to hyperinflation

Jonathan Hartley, "The Weakness of Modern Monetary Theory," No Publication, smemd

Less than a year before the novel coronavirus spread across the globe, Ray Dalio, Bridgewater Associates founder and billionaire intellectual, published an article on what he saw as the inevitable path for monetary, economic, and fiscal policy. In it, he partially endorsed a view that has emerged since the Great Recession: When monetary policy cannot provide further accommodation after nominal short-term interest rates hit the zero bound, additional fiscal spending is needed as stimulus. This is not a particularly unusual position. Indeed, over the years, many mainstream Keynesian economists have expressed support for this approach — Harvard economist Lawrence Summers refers to it as "black hole" or "secular stagnation" economics. A year following Dalio's article, with Covid-19 cases and death tolls mounting, governments in major developed countries around the globe appeared to endorse this view, authorizing deficit-financed spending amounting to between 5% and 10% of gross domestic product (GDP). Given that government-induced shutdowns designed to combat the spread of the virus contributed to unprecedented levels of unemployment, there was certainly a case for such measures. Dalio's article, however, put a radical twist on the traditional zero-lower-bound calls for more government spending by endorsing a novel, heterodox economic theory known as "modern monetary theory," or MMT. The defining feature of MMT — and what distinguishes it from more established, mainstream economic theories — is its insistence that, so long as a government's debt is denominated in its own currency, there is no upper limit on the state's monetary borrowing. In other words, public debt is irrelevant; a country's central bank can always avoid default by printing more money. Such printing, MMT proponents further argue, can go on without any inflationary consequences. They thus call for economists to shed their superstitious fear of debt and for policymakers to unleash the full power of unlimited, risk-free government spending. It should come as no surprise that some of the loudest support for MMT in the United States comes from the progressive wing of the Democratic Party. After all, if measures of public debt signify nothing beyond future currency-production goals for the U.S. Treasury, then there is no real limit to the amount government can spend on massive programs like universal free college, a Green New Deal, a universal basic income, or a universal jobs guarantee. Moreover, in this moment of profound economic uncertainty, when policymakers are turning to deficit spending in hopes of averting complete financial meltdown, the apparent blank check that MMT advocates offer holds a certain appeal to panicked economists and legislators on both sides of the aisle. Yet the sudden need for deficit spending in the wake of a global pandemic should not be used as an excuse to embrace MMT. While they may be convenient, MMT's central claims regarding the harmlessness of deficits, debt, and mass currency production are not only flatly false, they are deeply dangerous. Theoretical considerations and historical examples not only strongly undermine the central tenets of MMT, they also serve as a critical reminder to policymakers — particularly in a moment when deficit spending may truly be necessary — of what happens when governments fail, over long periods, to take responsible measures to balance their checkbooks throughout the business cycle. GROWING OUT OF DEBT MMT derives from a heterodox theory known as "chartalism," which emerged during the early 20th century as a rebuttal to the mainstream prevailing theory of money. According to the latter, money developed spontaneously as a medium of exchange because engaging in transactions through currency is more efficient than bartering. German economist Georg Friedrich Knapp challenged this theory in his 1905 book , arguing that money originated with states' attempts to direct economic activity. A given currency thus derives value not based on its status as a commodity — an object with either intrinsic or exchange value — but because taxes levied by a state are payable in the currency that the state issues. Knapp's chartalist theory of money as "a creature of law" was echoed in John Maynard Keynes's , in which Keynes asserted that money is "peculiarly a creation of the State." It appeared again in Russian-born British economist Abba Lerner's 1947 article bearing the title, "Money as a Creature of the State." Lerner also drew on chartalist theory to develop the concept of "functional finance," which suggests that because states can pay their debts by printing money, states with fiat currencies do not face any debt constraints when borrowing in their own currency. The only constraint they face, then, is that of inflation, which he argued is a result not of monetary policy, but of too much government spending. He also believed that inflation could be controlled by higher taxes, which would reduce the amount of money circulating in the economy. In recent years, a few economic theorists who had previously described themselves as "post-Keynesian" in the vein of Lerner have revived chartalism as an explanation of money creation. William Mitchell, a professor of economics at the University of Newcastle, was the first to coin the phrase "modern monetary theory" in reference to this emerging school of thought. MMT builds on functional finance's removal of debt constraints on government borrowing. However, it diverges from Lerner's theory in at least one significant way: MMT theorists reject monetary policy's relevance to inflation. According to MMT, then, governments can borrow and print as much of their own domestic currency as necessary without causing inflation. Consequently, MMT proponents like Dalio understand modern governments to be laboring under false and harmful assumptions regarding the threat of public debt. To understand MMT's appeal — along with its theoretical flaws — it helps to understand macroeconomic theories of government debt. According to these theories, aside from default, there are only three ways to reduce such debt: first, by reducing fiscal deficits; second, through higher economic growth; and third, by using central banks to print money and monetize debt. The first option often gets the most attention from mainstream economists, while MMT proponents insist that governments pursue the third. Olivier Blanchard, a well-known macroeconomist and the 2018 president of the American Economic Association (AEA), recently drew the public's attention to the oft-neglected second option: a state's capacity to grow out of public debt. In his AEA presidential address, Blanchard made a case for why debt "might not be so bad" as economists had previously assumed by arguing that the potential for economies to grow their way out of debt is less appreciated than it should be. He pointed to new evidence presented in his AEA presidential lecture, "Public Debt and Low Interest Rates," to back up his claims. Left-leaning economists like Harvard's Summers and Jason Furman have seized on such statements to argue that we need to worry less about government debt at present, as there is still ample fiscal space before we hit any meaningful limits on its sustainability. And yet despite these new findings — which may truly legitimize higher deficit spending — Blanchard acknowledges that there is still some limit to borrowing. In arguing for greater debt toleration, Blanchard observes that for most of the post-war period, real GDP growth (g) has been higher than real interest rates (r). He further observes that when real growth is higher than real interest rates (i.e., r-g < 0), economies can grow their way out of an existing debt stock with relative ease as the higher tax revenues from higher g offset the growth of r. To be sure, America has grown its way out of its debt stock in the past. In a 2018 New York Times column, Paul Krugman correctly observed that the United States did not pay back the debt accumulated from WWII through taxes or spending cuts. Instead, the nation grew its way out, something that it was able to do in part because real growth was higher than real interest rates for most of the 20th century and the country's debt-to-GDP ratio remained below 100%. Productivity growth was also much higher during that century, bringing more tax revenue to the government's coffers, as macroeconomists like Northwestern University's Robert Gordon have demonstrated. But what if debt persistently grows at rates higher than g? In other words, is Blanchard's model scalable to even higher levels of debt-to-GDP? In short, the answer is no — at least not beyond a certain point. Annual values of r for the G-7 countries across higher levels of government debt-to-GDP show that, at higher levels of debt as a fraction of GDP, this beneficial r-g actually declines. It thus appears the "Blanchard effect" — where r-g < 0 and nations can therefore grow out of debt — ends as debt-to-GDP reaches between 50% and 100%, depending on the country. The United States, which holds the world's reserve currency, appears to be at the higher end of that range, giving it more fiscal space. What is causing the Blanchard effect to diminish as debt-to-GDP approaches 100%? More or less, it's the same story that Carmen Reinhart and Kenneth Rogoff presented in their 2010 paper, "Growth in a Time of Debt," in which they observed that growth declines non-linearly with debt-to-GDP, hitting a flashpoint somewhere around the 100% mark. In other words, lower growth at higher levels of government debt-to-GDP percentages makes it more difficult for an economy to grow its way out of a debt burden, thus diminishing the Blanchard effect. While there was some controversy surrounding data errors underlying Reinhart-Rogoff, and there remains debate over where the exact tipping point for government debt is, the empirical finding of an inverse relationship between real GDP growth and a government's debt-to-GDP ratio is very much a real one. THE CONSTRAINTS ON DEBT MMT proponents often point to the debt-to-GDP ratio in Japan at nearly 250% of GDP as a validation of their claim that deficits don't matter. However, as economists Mark Greenan and David Weinstein show, Japan has avoided a fiscal crisis by keeping its expenditures growth on social pensions and health care low while raising its value-added tax. Japan's central bank has also held short-term interest rates close to zero for decades while keeping long-term interest rates low by engaging in record rounds of long-term asset purchases of government bonds (an approach it calls "yield curve control"). If the path of interest rates in Japan were to change, interest costs would rise rapidly. There are certainly special qualities that give the United States an added ability to borrow. For instance, financial economists Arvind Krishnamurthy and Annette Vissing-Jørgensen have demonstrated that the U.S. Treasury has a unique ability to borrow at lower rates, which arises in part because of the safety and liquidity benefits that come from its debt being issued in the world's reserve currency. Yet this special quality does not eliminate the fact that, sooner or later, one does run out of other people's money. Eventually, interest costs on government debt become as large as the state's revenue, at which point investors, no longer believing the government to be solvent, will refuse to buy bonds or lend to the government at manageable interest rates. So while the United States almost certainly could stomach more debt at present, interest costs will eventually subsume all other government revenues. Interest rates being close to zero certainly slows down this process (and negative interest rates reverse it slightly), but once inflation eventually rises, so too will interest rates and the interest costs of public debt. What the Blanchard example demonstrates is that, while there is plenty of room for economists to disagree about what levels of public debt are tolerable (even at levels higher than those at present), there still is an upper bound to the sustainability of government borrowing. Indeed, there is no doubt among mainstream economists that such an upper bound exists. Blanchard himself acknowledged its presence in a recent public rejection of MMT, saying "the deficit, unless very small, cannot be fully financed through non-interest bearing money creation, without leading to high or hyperinflation." MMT advocates, however, deny the existence of this limit on debt printed in a government's own currency. They therefore embrace the third option for public-debt reduction — using central banks to print money and monetize debt. MONEY PRINTING AND INFLATION MMT proponents argue that central banks can print money without triggering dangerous levels of inflation. This claim not only overlooks the theoretical considerations outlined above, it also ignores the dark history of debt monetization leading to hyperinflation. As Thomas Sargent famously documented in his 1982 classic, The Ends of Four Big Inflations, printing money and monetizing debt — even when that debt was partly denominated in local currency — led to devastating inflation in Austria, Hungary, Poland, and Weimar Germany during the first half of the 20th century. Austria and Hungary — two states formed through the dissolution of the Austro-Hungarian Empire — found themselves greatly diminished in both size and power following WWI. Since Austria-Hungary was deemed an aggressor of the war, its successor states owed the Allies substantial amounts in war reparations. To pay off the reparations while alleviating large-scale food shortages and unemployment, the Austrian government ran significant deficits — which it financed by selling treasury bills to the Austrian section of the liquidated Austro-Hungarian bank. At the same time in Hungary, political turmoil led to considerable budget shortfalls, which the government financed by borrowing heavily from the Hungarian section of the bank and increasing the volume of low-interest loans issued to private entities. As a result, both the Austrian crown and the Hungarian krone depreciated rapidly while domestic prices rose. This led to flight from each currency by domestic actors and foreign investors alike and, ultimately, to hyperinflation in both countries. Poland, meanwhile, emerged from WWI as an independent nation after over a century of foreign rule. Cobbled together from portions of Austria-Hungary, Germany, and Russia, Poland inherited inflated currencies from these three partitioning powers — each of which had financed their respective participation in WWI through the printing press — and an empty treasury. The fighting in Poland did not end in 1918, either, as the nation found itself in a second war with Soviet Russia that lasted until the fall of 1920. In order to settle this and other border disputes, and to rebuild after the devastating WWI occupation, Poland amassed substantial debt. Like both Austria and Hungary, Poland financed its deficit spending by printing massive amounts of currency. In 1918, one U.S. dollar was equivalent to nine Polish marks; by the end of 1923, that same dollar was worth 6,375,000 Polish marks. Of the four post-WWI cases of hyperinflation Sargent covers, none looms larger in the historical imagination than that of Weimar Germany. Germany had financed its war effort through deficit spending and suspension of the gold standard, believing that it would be able to achieve a swift, decisive victory and pay off its debt by annexing wealthier territories and imposing reparations on its defeated enemies. What occurred was very much the opposite: Over four long years of fighting, Germany accumulated considerable war debt while significantly devaluing its currency, the German mark. And since Germany was on the losing side of the war, instead of being paid reparations, it owed staggering levels of reparations to the Allies at the war's end. Making matters worse, the Reparations Commission demanded Germany pay 132 billion gold marks as part of the London Payment Plan. The German government responded by printing more German marks to pay what it owed, which only devalued its currency further. In 1922, Germany failed to pay an installment it owed to France, which prompted the French occupation of Germany's primary industrial region to ensure repayment. The German government responded by calling for what amounted to a strike, then offered the workers financial support — again, financed by printing more currency and issuing loans at interest rates far below the rate of inflation. By 1923, German currency was worthless: One U.S. dollar at the time was equivalent to 4,210,500,000,000 German marks. But hyperinflation is not just a phenomenon of the distant past. In fact, instances of hyperinflation have occurred over recent decades in countries like Brazil, Zimbabwe, and Venezuela. Brazil experienced hyperinflation in the final decades of the 20th century. This resulted from its decision to pay down high external debt but avoid raising taxes. Instead, the country turned to printing money. By 1990, inflation reached a monthly rate as high as 82.4%. Hyperinflation in Brazil was only resolved when it created a separate unit of account, the Unidade Real de Valor, or URV, to exist parallel to its existing currency, the cruzeiro. Ultimately, this new unit of account became the Brazilian real, replacing the cruzeiro and quashing the inflationary spiral. For Zimbabwe, the trouble began in the late 1990s, when the government adopted several spending plans — including the compulsory government purchase of white-owned commercial farms and generous pension plans for veterans of the country's war of independence — without budgeting for them. This triggered panic among foreign investors, who pulled capital from the Zimbabwean markets, thereby causing a crash of the country's currency. Subsequent unwise military ventures drove Zimbabwe further into debt. Meanwhile, the forced seizure of farmland and resulting violence nearly halted all agricultural production. Since the Zimbabwean economy was too fragile to grow its way out of debt, and imposing new taxes to raise revenue was a political non-starter, monetary and fiscal authorities began to monetize the country's debt by printing more money. This ultimately led to hyperinflation so extreme — at an estimated 79,000,000,000% per month in November 2008 — that Zimbabwe was effectively forced to substitute its own currency with the U.S. dollar shortly thereafter through a process economists call "dollarization." The seeds of Venezuela's ongoing struggles with hyperinflation were sown in the early 2000s, when the nation's economy and the value of its currency, the bolívar, became heavily dependent on revenues from oil exports. The rise in oil prices that largely coincided with President Hugo Chávez's term in office — from 1998 until his death in 2013 — ensured a steady stream of foreign revenue into government coffers. This allowed the Chávez regime to increase deficit spending in pursuit of its socialist policy agenda. Then in 2014 — a year after Chávez's successor, Nicolás Maduro, took office — the global price of oil collapsed, leading to a steep decline in government revenues. Foreign demand for the bolívar to purchase Venezuelan oil fell, contributing to a decline in the currency's value. The Venezuelan economy was already in recession at the time, but instead of pulling back on Chávez's generous social-welfare programs or increasing taxes, Maduro's regime responded by ramping up deficit spending and printing more currency to finance the government's debts. By 2016, hyperinflation had set in. At the end of 2018, inflation rates in Venezuela reached an estimated 80,000% per year. As these examples demonstrate, the correlation between currency printing and hyperinflation is undeniable, the causal relationship intuitive. Yet MMT proponents continue to contest it. In their canonical MMT textbook , William Mitchell, L. Randall Wray, and Martin Watts state that "[n]o simple proportionate relationship exists between rises in the money supply and rises in the general price level." Wray, a Bard College professor and one of MMT's key proponents in academia, has gone on to say "there is no empirical evidence to support the belief that raising interest rates fights inflation." Stephanie Kelton, author of  and former advisor to Senator Bernie Sanders's presidential campaign, argues that inflation is the result, not of monetary policy, but of "overspending" — spending beyond what it takes for an economy to reach "full employment" (which she defines not according to the mainstream economic concept of "natural rate of unemployment," but as the 0% unemployment rate that would occur under a government jobs guarantee). Such claims fly in the face of both historical evidence and traditional macroeconomic theory. And it's worth remembering, too, that hyperinflation often hurts the poor the most, since consumption makes up a greater fraction of their incomes. ECONOMIC THEORY OR POLITICAL MOVEMENT? Since MMT was first developed, mainstream economists have repeatedly pointed out its flaws. A recent Chicago Booth IGM Forum survey of 50 of the most respected academic economists found that not a single respondent agreed with the central claims of MMT regarding deficits, currency production, or inflation. Even left-leaning Keynesian economists like Summers and Krugman have loudly denounced MMT claims as "dangerous" and "obviously indefensible," respectively. Perhaps the strangest feature of MMT, then, is the simple fact that it has managed to develop the following it currently enjoys. Economics professors, billionaire thought leaders, and several members of Congress (including, most notably, Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez) have heaped lavish praise on MMT as the economic theory of the future. So how does MMT live on? To start, many MMT economists have found financial support from billionaire backers like the late Leon Levy, who helped establish the Levy Economics Institute of Bard College that employs MMT economists to this day. More recently, Warren Mosler, a former hedge-fund manager and one of MMT's intellectual architects, co-founded and provided financial support for the Center for Full Employment and Price Stability at the University of Missouri-Kansas City, which also employs MMT economists. Yet with no serious mainstream economists stepping up to do anything other than attack MMT, how does this theory of economics continue to cultivate a base of high-profile supporters? An answer to this question may have to do with the peculiar nature of MMT, which, upon closer inspection, appears to have more in common with a political or moral ideological movement than it does with a theory of economics. Like other ideologues, MMT advocates begin with the assertion that their policy goals — providing jobs for all, paying for college for all, etc. — are correct. From there, they assume that the means to achieve these ends must exist. This is not a falsifiable scientific theory; it is rather a political and moral statement by those who believe in the righteousness — and affordability — of unlimited government spending to achieve progressive ends. In this regard, MMT advocates have come to resemble mid-20th-century communists who argued that the Soviet Union could not possibly be a true socialist regime because a true socialist regime could only generate positive outcomes. Beyond the mere absence of substantive arguments for their position, MMT advocates often obfuscate and redirect criticism rather than directly addressing it. Krugman has come to refer to attempts to engage MMT advocates as a game of "Calvinball" — a reference to the game played in the Calvin and Hobbes comic series in which the players constantly change the rules in transparently self-serving ways. Any time outsiders attempt to disparage or critically engage MMT, they are met not with a detailed rebuttal using empirical evidence or quantitative reasoning, but by MMT's advocates insisting the critics simply don't understand the theory. Krugman is not alone in his frustration: Mercatus Center economist Scott Sumner has said, "MMT has constructed such a bizarre, illogical, convoluted way of thinking about macro[economics] that it's almost impervious to attack." This may sound like an unreasonable assessment of a theory that has found support among academics, entrepreneurs, and federal legislators. But the agendas of the annual MMT conferences held in New York serve as powerful evidence for its truth. Given all the criticism MMT has received from the economic establishment, one would think the conference would, like any other academic conference, be devoted to presenting empirical and theoretical studies, furthering research, and prompting serious scholarly debate. Instead, almost all MMT conference sessions have been based on political activism, with session titles such as "the future of jobs-guarantee advocacy," "building the jobs guarantee coalition," "MMT as an international movement," and "community strategy and institutional buildout." This makes MMT conferences look less like academic conferences and more like political conventions. MOVING BEYOND MMT MMT initially gained traction in the popular press largely through the efforts of several left-leaning journalists, including several at Bloomberg Media, who began promoting MMT advocates like Kelton in their online and television platforms. Other media outlets, including the New York Times and the Wall Street Journal, initially ignored the claims Kelton and the like were making but more recently have begun describing calls for increased deficit spending as an "MMT approach." Yet many non-MMT economists, like Blanchard, argue that there's room for similar spending increases while still believing there exists a limit to how much deficit spending a government can engage in without triggering perilous levels of inflation. If MMT is ever to be understood and defended, or exposed and refuted — if, in other words, it is to be meaningfully engaged at all — we need to be clearer about what MMT is and what it is not. MMT comprises two central claims — that there need be no upper bound on government debt, and that money can be printed without any inflationary consequence. Increased deficit spending alone is not necessarily "an MMT approach" or some sort of validation that "MMT is right," per today's parlance. Rather, it can easily fit under the frameworks of either Keynesianism, whose adherents endorse deficit-financed government spending during recessions, or even supply-side economics, whose supporters on the right endorse deficit-financed tax cuts. Along with neoclassical economics — which argues that, barring default or inflation, all government debt must eventually be paid back in the same amount of future taxes accounting for interest — each of these approaches recognizes that there is an upper bound on government borrowing. MMT, to put it bluntly, does not. Indeed, what makes MMT unique is that it's the only school of thought (should it be even considered as such) to combine calls for not only increased, but unlimited deficit spending with the argument that central banks can print money to pay off these debts without prompting inflation. There is simply no truth to this assertion. In fact, the reality is much the opposite: As interest costs consume increasing portions of revenue, at a certain point, the government cannot afford to borrow any longer. If the government resorts to printing money to pay its debts, inflation will ultimately follow. In searching for radical theories to advocate radical policies, MMT apologists have inadvertently come to endorse an approach to economic theory that not only flies in the face of decades of economic research and historical precedent, but would be devastating if ever tested. By tempting progressive politicians into endorsing "dangerous" and "obviously indefensible" economic theories, MMT advocates are setting the stage for potentially disastrous policymaking. For the very reason that MMT advocates completely gloss over Milton Friedman's famous adage that "inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon," MMT could very well be one of the most dangerous economic ideas of our time. As long as academics, entrepreneurs, politicians, and media figures continue to indulge or promote it, those who know better need to shed light on its shortcomings. Once those in academia and the media begin to speak honestly about what MMT is instead of what they wish it was — when they cease conflating the theory with the policies its advocates also happen to endorse — MMT will be revealed as a grossly inadequate foundation for public policy. Policymakers can then turn their attention to the practical tradeoffs involved in balancing current needs, the imperative to invest in the future, and the undeniable costs of debt. There is no easy way to manage that balance, and pretending otherwise won't help anyone.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Interest Rates DA › 2NC---Link---MMT

MMT can’t solve—causes inflation and bad policymaking

Warren Coats "Modern Monetary Theory: A Critique," Cato Institute, smemd

Modern monetary theory (MMT) claims that government can spend more freely by borrowing or printing money than is assumed by conventional monetary theory. According to Mackintosh (): The most provocative claim of the theory is that government deficits don’t matter in themselves for countries — such as the U.S. — that borrow in their own currencies… . The core tenets of MMT, and the closest it gets to a theory, are that the economy and inflation should be managed through fiscal policy, not monetary policy, and that government should put the unemployed to work. MMT has become popular with Green New Dealers because it claims to remove or at least loosen traditional constraints on government spending. Although MMT makes much of its preferred way of looking at the process of producing money, it does not credibly reveal more scope for deficit spending without inflation. Its proposal to use taxation as a monetary policy instrument ignores decades of efforts to separate monetary policy decisions from fiscal/​spending decisions in light of the differences in the political motivations of each. In fact, despite its efforts to change how we view monetary and fiscal policies, MMT abandons market‐​based countercyclical monetary and fiscal policies for targeted central control over the allocation of resources. It would rely on specific interventions to address “road blocks” upon the foundation of a government‐​guaranteed employment program. MMT is an unsuccessful and empty attempt to convince us that we can finance the Green New Deal and a federal job guarantee program painlessly by printing money. But it remains true that shifting our limited resources from the private to the public sector should be judged by whether society is made better off by such shifts (). Printing money does not produce free lunches. This article reviews MMT’s approach to describing the process by which money is produced by banks (broad money) and by the central bank (base money). It analyzes whether MMT’s characterization of the process reveals new, previously overlooked opportunities for the government to spend more without taxing more. It dissects MMT’s claim that because it can borrow in its own currency it can spend more — by printing more money — without crowding out private sector activity. It concludes by analyzing MMT’s claim that monetary policy should be shifted from the central bank to the fiscal tax authorities. How Is Money Produced Today? MMT motivates its case for monetary finance and the use of taxation to regulate the money supply by explaining the money supply process with a different emphasis than is usual. The traditional story for the fractional reserve banking world we live in is that a central bank issues base or high‐​powered money (currency held by the public plus bank reserves held at the central bank), and banks produce more money on top of that. The public deposits some of the central bank’s currency in banks, which provides banks with money they can lend. When a bank lends such deposits, it deposits the loan in the borrower’s deposit account with her bank, thus creating more money for the bank to lend. This famous money‐​multiplier story, a favorite in Money and Banking classes, reflects a money supply much larger than the base money issued by the central bank. In July 2008, base money (M0) in the United States was $847 billion dollars while the currency component of that plus the public’s demand deposits in banks (M1) was almost twice that — $1,442 billion dollars. Including the public’s time and savings deposits and checkable money market mutual funds (M2) the amount was $7,730 billion. I am reporting data from just before the financial crisis in 2008 because after that the Federal Reserve began to pay interest on bank reserve deposits at the Fed in order to encourage them to keep the funds at the Fed rather than lending them and thus multiplying deposits. This policy greatly decreased the ratio of total money to base money — that is, it reduced the money multiplier. In October 2015, at the peak of base money, M0 was $4,060 billion, of which only $1,322 billion was currency in circulation, and M1 was $3,018 billion! In Where Does Money Come From? (), the authors argue that banks create deposits by lending rather than having to receive deposits before they can lend. However, this well‐​known aspect of the bank money supply process is only part of the story. While a bank loan (an asset of the bank) is extended by crediting the borrower’s deposit account with the bank (a liability of the bank), the newly created deposit will almost immediately be withdrawn to pay for whatever it was borrowed for. Thus, the willingness of banks to lend in the first place must depend on their expectations of being able to finance their loans (from existing or new deposits, by borrowing in the interbank or money markets, or by the repayment of previous loans) at an interest rate less than the rate on their loans. The money multiplier version of this story assumes a reserve constraint — namely, that the central bank fixes the supply of base money. The MMT version highlights the fact that monetary policy these days targets interest rates at which the central bank lends leaving the supply of base money to be determined by the market. The central bank sets a policy interest rate as the instrument by which it influences the amount of credit banks wish to supply. In order to maintain its target interest rate, the central bank lends or otherwise supplies to the market whatever amount of base money is needed to cover private bank funding needs at that rate (). As a result of the lags in the effects of monetary policy, the rate is set and adjusted as needed in the expectation of achieving the central bank’s inflation target one to two years in the future. With the Federal Reserve’s introduction of interest on bank reserves, including excess reserves (those in excess of the amount required by regulation), banks’ management of their funding needs for a given policy rate now involves drawing down or increasing their excess reserves. Adherents of MMT therefore argue that “money is created ‘endogenously’ to finance spending” (: 18). Like post‐​Keynesians, they contend that “loans create deposits” and “repayment of loans destroys deposits” (ibid.). The market determination of the money supply at a given central bank interest rate is, in fact, similar to the way in which the market determines the money supply under a currency board system. When a central bank is subject to currency board rules, it passively supplies whatever amount of money the market wants to buy and hold at the official (fixed) price of the currency (e.g., the fixed exchange rate or price of gold). However, as elaborated further below, unlike a price anchor and currency board rules, which have a stable equilibrium, an interest rate target does not. If, for example, the interest rate target is below the market’s equilibrium real rate, the resulting increase in bank credit and money will increase prices pushing the targeted nominal rate further and further below its real equilibrium. Thus, targeting inflation requires continuous adjustments in the intermediate interest rate target. How Is Base Money Produced? MMT applies the same approach to the creation of base or high‐​powered money by the government as it does to the creation of bank deposits by the private sector. As Fullwiler, Kelton, and Wray : 19) note: The State must spend or lend its HPM [high‐​powered money] into existence before banks, firms, or households can get hold of coins, paper notes, or bank reserves… The issuer of the currency must supply it first before the users of the currency (banks for clearing, households and firms for purchases and tax payments) have it. That makes it clear that government cannot sit and wait for tax receipts before it can spend — no more than the issuers of bank deposits (banks) can sit and wait for deposits before they lend. The fact that the public/​taxpayers can’t have the government’s money until the central bank (which MMT consolidates with the rest of the government for analytical convenience) issues it does not mean there is a free lunch, as MMT suggests. Central banks can finance government spending by purchasing government debt either directly or from the market, but this does not give the Treasury carte blanche to spend without concern about taxes, deficit finance, or inflation. The well‐​known fact that government spending and tax collections can create and destroy money is the reason that central banks work hard to neutralize their effects on bank liquidity. In the United States, the Treasury’s Tax and Loan Accounts (TT&L) with commercial banks are not part of M1. Likewise, balances held at the Fed in the Treasury General Account (TGA) are not part of M0. Thus, ceteris paribus, whenever the government spends balances in the TGA it increases M1. Similarly, if it debits its TT&L balance with a bank and credits the recipient of its spending, M1 is increased. If it debits its balances with the Fed, both M0 and M1 are increased. In fact, most of the day‐​to‐​day injections and withdrawals of liquidity in the banking system by central banks are for the purpose of neutralizing the effect on M0 of the government’s inflows and outflows of funds (so‐​called defensive operations). If central banks attempted to forecast these Treasury shocks to liquidity in order to offset them, they would undertake open market operations in the indicated amounts. Given the back and forth nature of these Treasury injections and withdrawals, the Fed’s open market operations almost always take the form of repurchase or reverse repurchase agreements, both of which are of limited duration and thus self‐​reversing. However, forecasting the amounts actually needed to stabilize liquidity is very difficult. Instead, the Fed, like all other central banks with developed money markets, sets interest rate targets (policy rates around which they set lending and deposit rates) at which they will automatically supply or drain reserves. If the increase in money from a government expenditure exceeds the public’s demand (thus reducing interest rates), or the destruction of money resulting from tax payments or public purchases of government debt reduces money below the public’s demand (thus increasing interest rates) the public will repay central bank loans or borrow at its policy interest rate. Or stated differently, if money financed government spending increases money above the public’s demand, the injection of M0 will be replaced by the central bank with government debt. The money supply that results from all of this depends on the policy interest rate set by the central bank given the state of the economy. Setting or targeting the short‐​term money market interest rate (the central bank’s policy rate) is thus the critical instrument of monetary policy in today’s world. Since the great recession in 2008, the Federal Reserve has paid interest on bank deposits with the central bank including excess reserves (bank deposits with it in excess of their required reserves under Regulation D). These reserves substitute for and play the same role as bank holdings of government securities sold to them by the central bank. In some countries where the central bank holds no government securities that could be sold to the market to stabilize liquidity, they issue their own bonds. If the central bank sets its policy rate below the market equilibrium rate, it will supply base money in quantities that exceed market demand for money and will stimulate aggregate demand. If it persists in holding short‐​term interest rates below the equilibrium rate it will eventually fuel inflation, which will put upward pressure on nominal interest rates requiring ever increasing injections of base money until the value of the currency collapses (hyperinflation). If instead the central bank money’s price is fixed to a quantity of something (or better still a basket of commodities) and is issued according to currency board rules (the central bank issues or redeems any amount demanded by the market at the fixed price), arbitrage will adjust the supply so as to keep the market price and the official price approximately the same. Unlike an interest rate target, a quantity price target is stable (). Does the Story Matter? There is nothing new in the above discussion of the monetary process, but MMT wants us to believe that it reveals an unexploited opportunity for government to spend more freely and without taxation, either by borrowing in the market or directly from the central bank. According to Tymoigne and Wray (: 2): One of the main contributions of Modern Money Theory (MMT) has been to explain why monetarily sovereign governments have a very flexible policy space that is unencumbered by hard financial constraints. Not only can they issue their own currency to meet commitments denominated in their own unit of account, but also any self‐​imposed constraint on their budgetary operations can be by‐​passed by changing rules. As Tymoigne and Wray () note, it doesn’t matter whether the debt financing takes place by selling debt to the public, which removes the money created by government spending, or sells debt (bonds) directly to the central bank, which then sells it to the public in order to remove the money created by the government spending. The money created will be reabsorbed one way or the other as a byproduct of maintaining the central bank’s policy interest rate. Either way, the public’s holdings of public debt are increased and its holdings of money unchanged. The greater scope for public spending comes, as MMT sees it, from greater scope for issuing public debt. Critical to MMT’s message is that such debt does not crowd out private investment. MMT advocates are aware that at some point idle resources will be used up and that this process would then become inflationary, but this caveat is generally acknowledged only when MMT proponents are pressed on it. In this regard MMT is a throwback to the old Keynesianism, which implicitly assumed a world of perpetual unemployment. When the government increases its command of the economy’s resources, those resources are no longer available elsewhere. Two questions are important in evaluating the desirability of such spending: (1) Does deficit spending increase or decrease overall output (the size of the pie)? Or (2) Does it simply reallocate resources from the private to the public sector? When the economy is operating at full employment, a reallocation, by crowding out private investment or consumption in order to finance more government spending, has only second‐​order (if any) effects on the size of the pie (often negative) (). Whether we take account of the future tax liabilities created by this debt in the public’s assessment of its net wealth — and, therefore, experience “Ricardo equivalence” () — or not, we must ask where the public found the resources with which it bought the debt. Did it substitute Treasury bonds for corporate bonds — that is, did the government’s debt (or monetary) financing of government spending crowd out private investment thus leaving private sector wealth unchanged (or reduced, if taking account of Ricardian equivalence), or did the resources come from reduced private consumption (i.e., increased private saving)? Any impact on private consumption will depend on what government spent its money on. Whether the shift in resources from the private sector to the public sector is beneficial depends on whether the value of the government’s resulting output is greater than is the reduced private sector output that financed it. Debt/​money financing of increased government spending will increase the public’s holdings of government debt, but not necessarily of financial wealth overall and certainly not of real wealth. One way or another, government spending means that the government is commanding resources that were previously commanded by the private sector. If the government takes resources by spending newly created money in excess of increases in the public’s demand for money, prices will rise until the real stock of money falls back to what the public wants to hold. This outcome is the economic equivalent of the government defaulting on its debt, contrary to MMT’s claim that default is impossible. Moreover, this inflation tax is generally considered the worst of all taxes because it falls disproportionately on the poor. In fact, Tymoigne and Wray () rarely mention or acknowledge the distinction between real and nominal values that are, or should be, so central to discussions of monetary policy. The exception to this scenario is if the resources taken by the government were idle (i.e., unemployed), which is obviously the world MMT proponents think we are in. Once again, MMT proponents claim to have exposed greater fiscal space than is suggested by conventional analysis. They claim that government can more freely spend to fight global warming or to fund guaranteed jobs or other such projects by printing (electronic) money. However, the market mechanism they offer for preventing such money from being inflationary (the market response to an interest rate target that replaces unwanted money with government debt) implies that such spending must be paid for with tax revenue or borrowing from the public. Both, in fact all three financing options (taxation, borrowing, and printing money), shift real resources from the private sector to the public sector and only make society better off if the value of the resulting output is greater than that of the reduced private sector output. There is nothing new here. According to three prominent MMT adherents: Politicians need to reject the urge to ask “How are we going to pay for it?” … We must give up our obsession with trying to “pay for” everything with new revenue or spending cuts… . Once we understand that money is a legal and social tool, no longer beholden to the false scarcity of the gold standard, we can focus on what matters most: the best use of natural and human resources to meet current social needs and to sustainably increase our productive capacity to improve living standards for future generations []. Indeed. But if the government increases its use “of natural and human resources” it reduces their availability to the private sector. The means by which that transfer is affected (printing money, taxing, or borrowing) is how it is paid for. If MMT is serious about an inflation constraint on money finance, it has introduced nothing new. Tymoigne and Wray (: 2, 5) proclaim that a government that can borrow in its own currency has an unlimited capacity to pay for the things it wishes to purchase and to fulfill promised future payments, and has an unlimited ability to provide funds to the other sectors. Thus, insolvency and bankruptcy of this government is not possible. It can always pay… . All these institutional and theoretical elements are summarized by saying that monetarily sovereign governments are always solvent, and can afford to buy anything for sale in their domestic unit of account even though they may face inflationary and political constraints. Nevertheless, inflating away the real value of obligations (government debt) is economically a default. If proponents of MMT eliminate inflationary finance, then MMT’s claim to have revealed greater fiscal space comes down to greater borrowing capacity than normally claimed. Ironically, most economists think that the U.S. government already has a serious debt problem even before piling on more debt as advocated by MMT (). The federal government’s current gross debt is $22 trillion, which is 105 percent of U.S. GDP or $181,884 per taxpayer. Alarmingly this year’s federal budget deficit is $984 billion at the peak of the economic business cycle when a cyclically balanced budget would require a budget surplus. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projects continued increases in U.S. gross debt from existing legislation and projects that the debt‐​to‐​GDP ratio will increase to 108 percent by 2023 (, Table 2, and , Table 3). The reason for the MMT’s radical view seems to be the belief that the natural rate of interest is zero. This would explain Wray’s claim that “Treasury debt could be eliminated entirely if the central bank were to simply pay interest on reserves, or if the Fed were to adopt zero as its overnight interest rate target. In either case … there would be no need for sales of sovereign debt” (: 95). Even with the zero real interest policy rate of the last decade, a nominal interest rate of 2 percent requires almost half a trillion dollars in interest payments from the federal government budget of 4.3 trillion dollars. The global savings glut of recent years that has lowered real equilibrium interest rates may not last forever as the population continues to age (). The large current account deficits that now finance almost half of the federal budget deficit require an attractive risk‐​adjusted return on government debt, without which investment crowding out would be greater (). Such debt cannot grow without limit without debt service costs absorbing the government’s entire budget, and even the inflation tax has its hyperinflation limit (abandonment of a worthless currency). The U.S. debt would need to grow a lot larger before the world would lose confidence in our ability to service it (i.e., to print money that was not inflationary), but there is a limit. As doubts began to rise, so would the risk premium required in the interest rate offered on U.S. debt. Its share of the federal budget could increase rapidly as additional borrowing occurred (for increases in the debt and rolling over of existing debt). As lender confidence in U.S. debt evaporates, the plunge over the debt cliff can be rapid as we saw a few years ago in Ireland, Spain, and Greece. Fiscal Policy as Monetary Policy Government spending increases the money supply, and the payment of taxes reduces it. Much of a central bank’s monetary activities are undertaken to neutralize the liquidity shocks of the mismatch of the timing of government spending and receipt of revenue — so‐​called defensive operations. MMT wants to use taxation to manage the money supply rather than for government financing purposes. MMT wants to shift the management of monetary policy from the central bank to the treasury. In doing so it ignores the accumulated wisdom on the difficulty and undesirability of doing so. Some critics of MMT fault it for its explanatory simplification of consolidating the central bank and treasury on the grounds that it doesn’t reflect existing legislation giving central banks operational independence (it certainly doesn’t fit the eurozone with the ECB and 19 separate governments in the system). But this criticism misses the real point. If it were desirable to remove the existing barriers to central bank monetary financing of the government, it could be done. The relevant question is whether this way of thinking about and characterizing monetary and fiscal policy produces a more insightful and useful approach to formulating fiscal/​monetary policy. Does it justify shifting the responsibly for monetary policy from the central bank to the treasury? Should taxes be levied so as to regulate the money supply rather than finance the government (though it would do that as well)? I have only reviewed the articles cited here and they do not address the traditional arguments that have favored the use of central bank monetary policy over fiscal policy (beyond automatic stabilizers) for stabilization purposes. Would MMT replace setting an interest rate target with something else — such as a money supply target — as the basis for its monetary policy–driven choice of taxation? I assume that MMT would continue to support the basic principles of good taxation when making monetary policy adjustments to tax revenue (). If tax revenue is a tool for managing the money supply and inflation (rather than financing government), what principles or models would guide tax policy? How would the government manipulate the sluggish adjustments in tax revenue to smooth over the monetary shocks of government spending and revenue mismatches? None of the challenges of the use of fiscal policy as a countercyclical tool (flexible timing, what the money is spent for, and so on) established with traditional analysis have been neutralized by the MMT vision and claim of extra fiscal space. In fact, as we will see below, despite their advocacy of fiscal over monetary policy for maintaining price stability, MMT supporters have little real interest in and no clear approach to doing so as they prefer to centrally manage wages and prices in conjunction with a guaranteed employment program. The existing arrangements around the globe (central banks that independently execute price stability mandates and governments that determine the nature and level of government spending and its financing) are designed to protect monetary stability from the inflation bias of politicians with shorter policy horizons — the time inconsistency problem (). The universal assignments of responsibilities for monetary policy and for fiscal policy to a central bank and a treasury or finance ministry are meant to align decisionmaking with the authority responsible for the results of its decisions (price stability for monetary policy and welfare‐​enhancing levels and distribution of government spending and its financing for fiscal policy). It is the sad historical experience of excessive reliance on monetary finance and the costly undermining of the value of currencies that have led to the worldwide movement to central bank independence. MMT ignores that history and its lessons. The establishment of central bank operational independence in recent decades is rightly considered a major accomplishment. MMT advocates bring great enthusiasm for more government spending especially on their guaranteed employment and Green New Deal projects, which will need to be justified on their own merits. MMT’s way of viewing money and monetary policy adds nothing to the arguments for or against these policies. Its enthusiasm for printing money and borrowing increase already present dangers to the monetary stability so important for economic growth. Former Treasury Secretary Larry Summers recently denounced MMT for ignoring this inflation risk (). The Bottom Line MMT advocates reject the macro fine‐​tuning of traditional Keynesian analysis. They believe that government should be directly involved continuously over the cycle, by putting in place structural macroeconomic programs that directly manage the labor force, pricing mechanisms, and investment projects, and constantly monitoring financial developments… . But MMT goes beyond full employment policy as it also promotes capital controls for open economies, credit controls, and socialization of investment. Wage rates and interest rate management are also important [: 44–45]. No wonder Congresswomen Alexandria Ocasio‐​Cortez (D-NY) likes MMT. For all of its fascination with how money is produced (via government spending and bank lending), the programs favored by MMT, such as government guaranteed employment, must be evaluated on their merits in the traditional way. As an aside, I see many potential problems with a government guarantee of employment and would prefer a guaranteed minimum income, which would provide a comprehensive safety net and leave job and other choices to individuals rather than to government administrators of a jobs program. MMT attempts, unsuccessfully in my opinion, to repackage and resurrect the empirically and theoretically discredited Keynesian policies of the 1960s and 70s. A 2019 survey of leading economists showed a unanimous rejection of MMT’s assertions that (1) “Countries that borrow in their own currency should not worry about government deficits because they can always create money to finance their debt,” and (2) “Countries that borrow in their own currency can finance as much real government spending as they want by creating money” (). MMT is an effort to justify more government spending on programs favored by AOC and her friends with claims of fiscal space that can be liberated by printing money. Its arguments do not add up (). Both the excitement and motivation for MMT seem to reflect the desire to promote a political agenda, without the hard analysis of its pros and cons — its costs and benefits.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Interest Rates DA › 2NC---Link---Generic

Basic Income, VAT, MMT, and Taxes all still lead to Inflation

Kyle Fowler, 5-20-2022, "UBI And Inflation: An American Case Study," Austrian Economics Center, https://austriancenter.com/ubi-and-inflation-american-case-study/

Although universal basic income might be an admirable goal, it is an unachievable policy (in the United States), putting more pressure on inflation. Traditionally a contemporary concept amongst the Left, Universal Basic Income (UBI) has recently become well-known amongst the American people. Currently, various UBI programs are in parts of California, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Louisiana, New Jersey, and New York. Former 2020 presidential hopeful Andrew Yang brought mainstream attention towards UBI in the United States, a monthly universal basic income of $1,000 for all American citizens. Yang’s plan is thorough and provides the proper setting for analysis of UBI. If Yang’s plan were to be passed by the United States Congress, every American from Bill Gates to West Virginia coal miners would be entitled to $1,000 per month, or $12,000 a year. To offset the cost of the UBI plan, Yang for a VAT tax, increased taxes on the highest earners, and a carbon tax. Yang $800-$900 billion in new revenue from economic growth resulting from UBI. The cost of the program is calculated to be extraordinary. Yang’s tax and UBI proposal a net cost of -$1.482 trillion. To afford Yang’s plan, other financing options would have to be explored. These options include cutting existing government programs, raising taxes, borrowing more money, or printing more money. Cutting government spending The first possible way to finance UBI is by cutting current government retirement programs. American employees have on their paychecks for social security and Medicare throughout their entire working careers. They have been ensured they would be entitled to these programs when they retire or reach the mandatory age. Despite the high costs required to finance these programs, they amongst the American people. While Yang’s plan UBI on top of social security benefits, some spending must be scrapped to afford the -$1.482 trillion net cost of the program. Given the popularity of American retirement programs, cutting them would result in a widespread backlash amongst the American people. Under Yang’s plan, welfare recipients would have the option to their existing benefits or choose UBI. Since UBI is a no strings attached payment, the government will have no ability to enforce that it is spent for required items such as food, healthcare, and childcare. This is a risky proposition, given that drug use amongst welfare recipients than the average American. If the terms of Yang’s UBI plan are to be enforced, UBI will be added as another welfare program, given existing welfare programs will not be canceled. Raising Taxes Raising taxes on the rich has been a rallying cry of left-wing Americans in recent years. But taxing the wealthiest Americans ultimately results in , counterintuitive to a . Yang UBI will genuinely improve the livelihood of America’s poorest residents, while he simultaneously argues for a VAT tax on purchases from larger companies. When VAT taxes , job security can come into question. In addition, raising taxes is always an immensely unpopular proposition when it is proposed to the American people. A majority of Americans already they pay too much in income taxes. Significant opposition and the costs associated with raising taxes for a UBI plan would force the American government to pursue other, dangerous financing options. Printing money One way in which the United States government finances its spending is through the use of the money printing press. The “print more money” argument, in general, , especially when applied to financing UBI. At the core of the coronavirus pandemic, the United States passed to “stimulate” the American economy. In 2020, the Fed actions which brought about the printing of more money, increasing the possibility of rampant inflation. This has seemingly been the case, as the latest CPI numbers an astounding 8.3%, near a four-decade high. Printing more dollars for the purposes of UBI will increase inflation further. Borrowing Throughout the past few decades, American spending projects have been financed by borrowing. A likely scenario is that UBI would be financed through borrowing, the same way American COVID relief bills . While unpopular, in recent years, American politicians have run up a budget deficit in the trillions, an astonishing $3.13 trillion in 2020. In 2021, the United States 5% of its total federal spending to paying the interest on its debts, for a total of $352.3 billion. As a reference point, the United States allocated $234.3 billion to pay for Veterans Benefits and Services. Is UBI important enough to accumulate more debt and interest, when 5% of the yearly federal budget is already used to pay interest accumulated on debt? Conclusion Undoubtedly, inflation is a significant issue facing the American public. For a nation that religiously relies on car travel and fossil fuel production, coronavirus spending and the energy price increase exacerbated by the Russia-Ukraine war has been disastrous for the economy. The cost of food and other essential goods , providing an additional cost on the average American. During this inflationary crisis, with of Americans living in poverty, inflation has caused significant suffering for the American people. While supporters argue that UBI will alleviate these pains, further spending will aid further inflation as American spending bills have done in recent years. As a result, Yang’s UBI plan does not make sense from an economic perspective, given its propensity for increasing inflation.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Interest Rates DA › 2NC---UQ---Interest Rates

Interest Rates stable in squo—Fed unlikely to make further changes

Meredith 23 [Sam Meredith, 7-14-2023, “Nobel Prize-winning economist says there’s no need for the Fed to keep hiking interest rates,” CNBC, ] smeMD

Nobel Prize-winning economist Christopher Pissarides believes there’s no need for the Federal Reserve to keep raising interest rates in the coming months, saying policymakers at the U.S. central bank should instead look to take a breather in the battle against inflation. His comments come shortly after data on Wednesday showed U.S. inflation fell sharply to a two-year low of 3% in June. The reading appeared to underscore the Fed’s relative success in containing price rises following a rapid increase in interest rates. The Fed has previously signaled its intent on pushing ahead with additional monetary policy tightening. “It takes time for these to have their full effect, so given that inflation is moving in the right direction, that interest rates are high, I would just wait and see what happens next,” Pissarides, a professor at the London School of Economics, told CNBC’s “Street Signs Europe” on Thursday. “I don’t expect anything to happen to make them want to increase interest rates more, but I would definitely wait this time,” he added. Pissarides was jointly awarded the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences in 2010 for his work on the economics of unemployment. The U.S. central bank held its key borrowing rate steady in a target range of 5% to 5.25% last month, but policymakers at the meeting indicated the likelihood of half a percentage point more of additional tightening before the end of 2023. Fed Chair Jerome Powell has repeatedly reinforced this message, saying at a forum in late June that he expects multiple rate hikes ahead, possibly at an aggressive pace. “Inflation is coming down, the labor market is not as tight as it was — or at least not getting tighter — so I don’t think there will be inflationary pressure coming from that direction,” Pissarides said. “On balance, I don’t think there will be a need for further hikes in the [United] States at least, Europe might be a different story but the [United] States not.” ‘We need clarity’ Pissarides acknowledged his call for a pause stood in contrast to the view of some economists and investors, but said “that’s what I would do if I were there.” Investors see a more than 92% chance of a 25-basis-point hike at the end of the Fed’s two-day policy meeting on July 26, according to the CME’s Fedwatch tool, before cuts are seen from early next year. Asked whether the primary reason the Fed may consider further raising interest rates would be to push inflation down toward 2% sooner rather than later, Pissarides replied, “It could be, but you see here we need more patience.” He added, “You were absolutely right when you said that the last bit is always more difficult than the beginning, especially when you are very high, it is easy to come down quickly.” Pissarides nevertheless said that inflation persisting at or around 3% — rather than the Fed’s target of 2% — is not likely to cause problems for the U.S. economy, adding that this is “too small a difference” in the inflation rate. “Be patient. Businesses will react better if they think that eventually we are going to get there, and they will pursue their longer-term investment plans. And we’ll get there even faster if that doesn’t do anything,” Pissarides said. “We need clarity,” he continued. “They could say we’re seeing a softer landing coming, and we’re seeing delays in going down to 2% because the last bit is always difficult, but we have done well so far and let the economy take its course. It is a free market, well-functioning economy.”