Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI --- Universal Basic Income Aff › 1AC --- MSDI › 1AC --- Warming

The world is dying. Humanity is at a crossroads, we either fix the problem now or are doomed to destruction.

Fiona Harvey 5-17-2023. (Fiona Harvey Environment editor, . "World likely to breach 1.5C climate threshold by 2027, scientists warn." Guardian. Web. accessed 6-7-2023 < https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/may/17/global-heating-climate-crisis-record-temperatures-wmo-research >.)MSUCB

The world is almost certain to experience new record temperatures in the next five years, and temperatures are likely to rise by more than 1.5C above pre-industrial levels, scientists have warned. The breaching of the crucial 1.5C threshold, which scientists have warned could have dire consequences, should be only temporary, according to research from the World Meteorological Organisation (WMO). However, it would represent a marked acceleration of human impacts on the global climate system, and send the world into “uncharted territory”, the UN agency warned. Countries have pledged, under the 2015 Paris climate agreement, to try to hold global temperatures to no higher than 1.5C above pre-industrial levels, after scientific advice that heating beyond that level would unleash a cascade of increasingly catastrophic and potentially irreversible impacts. Prof Petteri Taalas, the secretary general of the WMO, said: “This report does not mean that we will permanently exceed the 1.5C specified in the Paris agreement, which refers to long-term warming over many years. However, WMO is sounding the alarm that we will breach the 1.5C level on a temporary basis with increasing frequency.” Global average surface temperatures have never before breached the 1.5C threshold. The highest average in previous years was 1.28C above pre-industrial levels. The report, published on Wednesday, found there was a 66% likelihood of exceeding the 1.5C threshold in at least one year between 2023 and 2027. New record temperatures have been set in many areas around the world in the heatwaves of the past year, but those highs may only be the beginning, according to the report, as climate breakdown and the impact of a developing El Niño weather system combine to create heatwaves across the globe. El Niño is part of an oscillating weather system that develops in the Pacific. For the past three years, the world has been in the opposing phase, known as La Niña, which has had a dampening effect on temperature increases around the world. As La Niña ends and a new El Niño develops, there is a 98% likelihood that at least one of the next five years will be the hottest on record, the scientists found. Taalas warned of the effects. “A warming El Niño is expected to develop in the coming months and this will combine with human-induced climate change to push global temperatures into uncharted territory. This will have far-reaching repercussions for health, food security, water management and the environment,” he said. “We need to be prepared.” The Arctic is heating much faster than the rest of the world, and this appears to be having an impact on global weather systems, including the jet stream, which has disrupted weather across the northern hemisphere in recent years. There is likely to be less rainfall this year in the Amazon, Central America, Australia and Indonesia, the report found. This is particularly bad news for the Amazon, where scientists have grown increasingly concerned that a vicious cycle of heating and deforestation could tip the region from rainforest into savannah-like conditions. Over the next five years, there is likely to be above-average rainfall in northern Europe, Alaska and northern Siberia, and the Sahel, according to the report. For each year from 2023 to 2027, the global near-surface temperature is predicted to be between 1.1C and 1.8C above the pre-industrial average, taken from the years 1850 to 1900. The world has warmed considerably in recent years. In 2015, when the Paris agreement was signed, requiring countries to hold global temperature increases to no more than 2C above pre-industrial levels while “pursuing efforts” to hold them to 1.5C, it was forecast that the chance of temporarily exceeding the 1.5C threshold within the following five years was zero. This November, governments will meet for the Cop28 UN climate summit, where they will assess progress towards meeting the goals of the Paris agreement. Known as the “global stocktake”, this assessment is likely to show that the world is far off track to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by the 43% this decade that is required to have a good chance of limiting temperature rises to 1.5C.

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI --- Universal Basic Income Aff › 1AC --- MSDI › 1AC --- China

That results in a new wave of nazi-ism.

Thayer Limited, LLC 7 January 2013 (The company's line of business includes providing various commercial services. Published by the USDOD. Accessed 12/7/2022 < > MSUCB

Given how endemic Chinese racism is, there should be no surprise that racism flourished during the Maoist years. This is despite official Marxist and Maoist ideology, which dismisses racism as an artifact of bourgeois thinking. Many of the racial divisions the Chinese made on the basis of race, were often reformulated in terms of “class.” So, while the ideas of race were officially taboo, the underlying arguments and beliefs had not changed according to Dikötter. “The messianic idea of unification (the datong, or “One World” ideal) was now expressed in a phraseology based on the concept of class struggle, whereas the artificial dichotomization between Chinese and Westerners in biological terms of ‘race’ was merely reformulated in social terms of ‘class.’ Eugenic theories were increasingly applied to the individual’s social origins: the best people were “born red.”127

Although there is nothing in Mao’s writings that deals directly with race, it is clear that his sense of nationalism was based on a strong racial consciousness and a sense of biological continuity for the Chinese. He perceived the Chinese nation, (minzu) [民族] as a biologically distinct group: being Chinese was a matter of culture, but more importantly, it was a matter of race. Dikötter submits that it was likely he coalesced the notions of “class” and “race” into a vision of the struggle of the “colored people” against “white imperialism.”128 Intellectual historian Stuart Schram writes that “Mao’s appeal is not merely to a union based on revolutionary principles, but to the visceral solidarity of peoples long oppressed and humiliated by the white powers of Europe and America.”129

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI --- Universal Basic Income Aff › 1AC --- MSDI › 1AC --- China

A Chinese hegemonic figure would result in totalitarianism 2.0.

Michael Clarke 2022. (Dr Michael Clarke is an internationally recognised expert on the history and politics of the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region, People's Republic of China (PRC), Chinese foreign policy in Central Asia, Central Asian geopolitics, nuclear proliferation and non-proliferation and American grand strategy and foreign policy. He also regularly provides expert media commentary on Uyghur/Xinjiang and Chinese foreign policy-related issues to national and international media including the Wall Street Journal, USA Today, LA Times, Voice of America, BBC News, the New York Times, the Guardian, CNN and Reuters among others. Michael Clarke. "How China Is on the Verge of Totalitarianism 2.0." National Security College. Web. 2022. accessed 12-7-2022 &lt; https://nsc.crawford.anu.edu.au/department-news/13026/how-china-verge-totalitarianism-20 &gt;. MSUCB

Yet the scope of this challenge stretches beyond China’s potential to abuse technological “backdoors.” More than that, the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) is exploiting and exporting technological innovations to establish a panoptic form of governance—one through which it becomes possible for the state to constantly monitor individuals under the guise of “social management.” As a result, it’s important to investigate what this technological turn may mean for people both within China’s borders and beyond them. ** Totalitarianism 2.0**

It’s impossible to understand the CCP’s current approach to maintaining political power without also understanding its version of social management. As the political scientist Samantha Hoffman defines it, China “optimises interactions vertically (within the Party), horizontally (between agencies), and holistically, between the Party and society” in order “to improve governance capacity to shape, manage, and respond to social demands.” Crucially, the demands of society, as determined by the state, trump those of any person or group.

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI --- Universal Basic Income Aff › 1AC --- MSDI › 1AC --- China

Hegemony is empirically the most stable system and deters all conflict – decline causes transition wars

Robert Kagan, 17, 2-7-2017, Backing Into World War III, https://foreignpolicy.com/2017/02/06/backing-into-world-war-iii-russia-china-trump-obama/, Robert Kagan, Ph.D. in American History from American University, M.P.P. in Government from Harvard University, AVD

Think of two significant trend lines in the world today. One is the increasing ambition and activism of the two great revisionist powers, Russia and China. The other is the declining confidence, capacity, and will of the democratic world, and especially of the United States, to maintain the dominant position it has held in the international system since 1945. As those two lines move closer, as the declining will and capacity of the United States and its allies to maintain the present world order meet the increasing desire and capacity of the revisionist powers to change it, we will reach the moment at which the existing order collapses and the world descends into a phase of brutal anarchy, as it has three times in the past two centuries. The cost of that descent, in lives and treasure, in lost freedoms and lost hope, will be staggering. Americans tend to take the fundamental stability of the international order for granted, even while complaining about the burden the United States carries in preserving that stability. History shows that world orders do collapse, however, and when they do it is often unexpected, rapid, and violent. The late 18th century was the high point of the Enlightenment in Europe, before the continent fell suddenly into the abyss of the Napoleonic Wars. In the first decade of the 20th century, the world’s smartest minds predicted an end to great-power conflict as revolutions in communication and transportation knit economies and people closer together. The most devastating war in history came four years later. The apparent calm of the postwar 1920s became the crisis-ridden 1930s and then another world war. Where exactly we are in this classic scenario today, how close the trend lines are to that intersection point is, as always, impossible to know. Are we three years away from a global crisis, or 15? That we are somewhere on that path, however, is unmistakable. And while it is too soon to know what effect Donald Trump’s presidency will have on these trends, early signs suggest that the new administration is more likely to hasten us toward crisis than slow or reverse these trends. The further accommodation of Russia can only embolden Vladimir Putin, and the tough talk with China will likely lead Beijing to test the new administration’s resolve militarily. Whether the president is ready for such a confrontation is entirely unclear. For the moment, he seems not to have thought much about the future ramifications of his rhetoric and his actions. China and Russia are classic revisionist powers. Although both have never enjoyed greater security from foreign powers than they do today — Russia from its traditional enemies to the west, China from its traditional enemy in the east — they are dissatisfied with the current global configuration of power. Both seek to restore the hegemonic dominance they once enjoyed in their respective regions. For China, that means dominance of East Asia, with countries like Japan, South Korea, and the nations of Southeast Asia both acquiescing to Beijing’s will and acting in conformity with China’s strategic, economic, and political preferences. That includes American influence withdrawn to the eastern Pacific, behind the Hawaiian Islands. For Russia, it means hegemonic influence in Central and Eastern Europe and Central Asia, which Moscow has traditionally regarded as either part of its empire or part of its sphere of influence. Both Beijing and Moscow seek to redress what they regard as an unfair distribution of power, influence, and honor in the U.S.-led postwar global order. As autocracies, both feel threatened by the dominant democratic powers in the international system and by the democracies on their borders. Both regard the United States as the principal obstacle to their ambitions, and therefore both seek to weaken the American-led international security order that stands in the way of their achieving what they regard as their rightful destinies. It was good while it lasted Until fairly recently, Russia and China have faced considerable, almost insuperable, obstacles in achieving their objectives. The chief obstacle has been the power and coherence of the international order itself and its principal promoter and defender. The American-led system of political and military alliances, especially in the two critical regions of Europe and East Asia, has presented China and Russia with what Dean Acheson once referred to as “situations of strength” that have required them to pursue their ambitions cautiously and, since the end of the Cold War, to defer serious efforts to disrupt the international system. The system has checked their ambitions in both positive and negative ways. During the era of American primacy, China and Russia have participated in and for the most part been beneficiaries of the open international economic system the United States created and helps sustain; so long as that system functions, they have had more to gain by playing in it than by challenging and overturning it. The political and strategic aspects of the order, however, have worked to their detriment. The growth and vibrancy of democratic government in the two decades following the collapse of Soviet communism posed a continual threat to the ability of rulers in Beijing and Moscow to maintain control, and since the end of the Cold War they have regarded every advance of democratic institutions — especially the geographical advance of liberal democracies close to their borders — as an existential threat. That’s for good reason: Autocratic powers since the days of Klemens von Metternich have always feared the contagion of liberalism. The mere existence of democracies on their borders, the global free flow of information they cannot control, the dangerous connection between free market capitalism and political freedom — all pose a threat to rulers who depend on keeping restive forces in their own countries in check. The continual challenge to the legitimacy of their rule posed by the U.S.-supported democratic order has therefore naturally made them hostile both to that order and to the United States. But, until recently, a preponderance of domestic and international forces has dissuaded them from confronting the order directly. Chinese rulers have had to worry about what an unsuccessful confrontation with the United States might do to their legitimacy at home. Even Putin has pushed only against open doors, as in Syria, where the United States responded passively to his probes. He has been more cautious when confronted by even marginal U.S. and European opposition, as in Ukraine. The greatest check on Chinese and Russian ambitions has been the military and economic power of the United States and its allies in Europe and Asia. China, although increasingly powerful, has had to contemplate facing the combined military and economic strength of the world’s superpower and some very formidable regional powers linked by alliance or common strategic interest — including Japan, India, and South Korea, as well as smaller but still potent nations like Vietnam and Australia. Russia has had to face the United States and its NATO allies. When united, these U.S.-led alliances present a daunting challenge to a revisionist power that can call on few allies of its own for assistance. Even were the Chinese to score an early victory in a conflict, such as the military subjection of Taiwan or a naval battle in the South or East China Sea, they would have to contend over time with the combined industrial productive capacities of some of the world’s richest and most technologically advanced nations and the likely cutoff of access to foreign markets on which their own economy depends. A weaker Russia, with its depleted population and oil- and gas-dependent economy, would face an even greater challenge. For decades, the strong global position enjoyed by the United States and its allies has discouraged any serious challenge. So long as the United States was perceived as a dependable ally, Chinese and Russian leaders feared that aggressive moves would backfire and possibly bring their regimes down. This is what the political scientist William Wohlforth once described as the inherent stability of the unipolar order: As dissatisfied regional powers sought to challenge the status quo, their alarmed neighbors turned to the distant American superpower to contain their ambitions. And it worked. The United States stepped up, and Russia and China largely backed down — or were preempted before acting at all. Faced with these obstacles, the best option for the two revisionist great powers has always been to hope for or, if possible, engineer a weakening of the U.S.-supported world order from within, either by separating the United States from its allies or by raising doubts about the U.S. commitment and thereby encouraging would-be allies and partners to forgo the strategic protection of the liberal world order and seek accommodation with its challengers. The present system has therefore depended not only on American power but on coherence and unity at the heart of the democratic world. The United States has had to play its part as the principal guarantor of the order, especially in the military and strategic realm, but the order’s ideological and economic core — the democracies of Europe and East Asia and the Pacific — has also had to remain relatively healthy and confident.

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI --- Universal Basic Income Aff › 1AC --- MSDI › 1AC --- China

China is specifically trying to expand and displace the US as a world leader. This involves the end of alliances, massive territorial expansion, and global authoritarianism. You should prefer our evidence because it specifically filters through primary source documents that prove our arguments.

Rush Doshi 8-2-2021. (Rush Doshi was the director of the Brookings China Strategy Initiative and a fellow in Brookings Foreign Policy. He was also a fellow at Yale Law School’s Paul Tsai China Center and part of the inaugural class of Wilson China fellows. His research focused on Chinese grand strategy as well as Indo-Pacific security issues. He is currently serving in the Biden administration., . "The long game: China’s grand strategy to displace American order." Brookings. Web. accessed 5-17-2023 &lt; https://www.brookings.edu/essay/the-long-game-chinas-grand-strategy-to-displace-american-order/ &gt;.)MSUCB

As we enter this new stretch of acute competition, we lack answers to critical foundational questions. What are China’s ambitions, and does it have a grand strategy to achieve them? If it does, what is that strategy, what shapes it, and what should the United States do about it? These are basic questions for American policymakers grappling with this century’s greatest geopolitical challenge, not least because knowing an opponent’s strategy is the first step to countering it. And yet, as great power tensions flare, there is no consensus on the answers.

This book attempts to provide an answer. In its argument and structure, the book takes its inspiration in part from Cold War studies of US grand strategy.5 Where those works analyzed the theory and practice of US “strategies of containment” toward the Soviet Union during the Cold War, this book seeks to analyze the theory and practice of China’s “strategies of displacement” toward the United States after the Cold War.

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI --- Universal Basic Income Aff › 1AC --- MSDI › 1AC --- China

China is not a revisionist power in the traditional sense, rather, they have started a slow, creeping effort meant to gradually expand.

Ted Galen 1-17-2013. (Former Senior Fellow, Cato Institute, . "China as a Prickly, But Pragmatic, Revisionist Power." Cato Institute. Web. accessed 5-16-2023 &lt; https://www.cato.org/commentary/china-prickly-pragmatic-revisionist-power &gt;.)MSUCB

A notable and worrisome development in East Asia over the past two years or so is China’s markedly greater assertiveness on geostrategic issues. That development has led to speculation in US foreign policy circles, especially among hawkish types, that Beijing intends to overturn the regional status quo, threaten the interests of US allies, and ultimately challenge America’s dominant position in East Asia. Such fears are excessive, but there is no question that as China’s economic and military strength grows, so does its willingness to assert what Chinese leaders see as the country’s legitimate national interests. Unfortunately, PRC officials have sometimes pursued those interests without the appropriate subtlety.

That trend has been most evident in Beijing’s disputes with Vietnam, the Philippines, and other Southeast Asian neighbors over the South China Sea. Not only are China’s territorial claims breathtakingly broad — encompassing nearly 80% of that body of water and its potential oil, gas and mineral resources — but the Chinese government has shown growing impatience with countries who dare to make competing claims. In October 2012, Beijing spurned a proposal from the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) for negotiations to establish a multilateral “code of conduct” regarding the South China Sea.

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI --- Universal Basic Income Aff › 1AC --- MSDI › 1AC --- China

China is a revisionist power devoted to a “post-Western” world.

Angela Stent 2-1-2020. (Nonresident Senior Fellow - Foreign Policy, Center on the United States and Europe, . "Russia and China: Axis of revisionists?." Brookings. Web. accessed 5-16-2023 &lt; https://www.brookings.edu/research/russia-and-china-axis-of-revisionists/ &gt;.)MSUCB

The China-Russia relationship has become an increasingly robust, pragmatic strategic partnership since 2014, in part because the United States is pursuing policies that have driven the two countries closer together. Presidents Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping are both authoritarian leaders whose primary preoccupation is regime survival and who are allergic to Western criticisms of their domestic systems and the repressive policies of their respective governments. China and Russia are revisionist powers in as much as they share a commitment to creating a “post-West” global order which takes their interests into account and is conducive to authoritarian rule.

Since Russia’s 2014 seizure and annexation of Crimea from Ukraine and the West’s subsequent attempts to isolate Russia, Putin has increasingly turned to China, which has enabled Russia to surmount the isolation and flourish on the world stage. Sino-Russian economic and energy ties are expanding. China is economically more important to Russia than vice versa and is Russia’s number one trading partner and the secondlargest purchaser of Russian military hardware. The new Power of Siberia gas pipeline will increase their energy interdependence. Sino-Russian cooperation in the military and high-tech fields is also growing. Their joint military exercises and air patrols, as well as joint work on artificial intelligence and biotechnology pose challenges to the United States.

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI --- Universal Basic Income Aff › 1AC --- MSDI › 1AC --- China

A Universal Basic Income would strengthen American hegemony – specifically to compete with our top priority: China.

Scott Singer and Ben Silvian November 09, 2021. (Scott Singer Scott Singer is a Ph.D. candidate in international relations at the University of Oxford. Ben Silvian is pursuing his Masters degree in technology management at Georgetown University. Follow him on Twitter @BenSilvian.. "How Universal Basic Income Can Advance the United States’ China Strategy." The Diplomat. Web. accessed 5-10-2023 https://thediplomat.com/2021/11/how-universal-basic-income-can-advance-the-united-states-china-strategy/ &gt;.)MSUCB

Earlier this summer, U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken outlined his foreign policy strategy of “domestic renewal,” aimed directly at arming the United States to compete with China. The strategy, articulated in an August 9 speech at the University of Maryland, focused predominantly on increasing infrastructure investment at home, reflecting the potential foreign policy benefits of the bipartisan infrastructure bill Congress passed last week.

In the weeks following the “domestic renewal” speech, we patiently awaited further elaboration of Blinken and President Joe Biden’s domestic policy-oriented China policy, some next steps to integrate the oft-segregated domestic and foreign policy worlds.

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI --- Universal Basic Income Aff › 1AC --- MSDI › 1AC --- China

United States hegemony is at a critical juncture – we need to start rebuilding ASAP.

Minqi Li 10-1-2022. (Minqi Li is a professor of political economy at the Department of Economics, University of Utah, USA, a Marxist and a representative of the New Left in China, . "The Collapse of American Hegemony and the Challenges of the 21st Century." Journal Luxembourg Web Accessed 5-10-2023 &lt; https://zeitschrift-luxemburg.de/artikel/the-collapse-of-the-american-hegemony-and-the-challenges-of-the-21st-century/ &gt; .)MSUCB

*** Original article was in German; it was translated by Google.

The Decline of the American Hegemonic Power

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Payroll/FICA Tax › Payroll Taxes Bad

Payroll cuts will help the Low/Middle class.

James C. Capretta July 23, 2020 The Case for a Payroll Tax Cut () (RMJ)

Senate Republicans are reluctant to include a temporary payroll tax cut in the next coronavirus response bill even though the Trump administration is championing it. The arguments against this idea are unpersuasive. A payroll tax cut would work better than other options to help the middle-class and encourage a return to work. Moderate income households pay much more in payroll taxes than income taxes. Under current law, employers and employees both pay 7.65 percent of wages in Social Security and Medicare taxes. The Social Security tax (6.2 percent each for firms and workers) applies to wages earned below an annual upper limit ($137,700 in 2020). The Medicare portion of the tax (1.45 percent for both employers and employees) applies to all wages, without limit. For families with incomes in the second lowest quintile, the average payroll tax rate is 9.4 percent while the average income tax rate is -1.2 percent. The burden of the payroll tax falls almost entirely on workers. Firms pay the employer share of the tax but pass on as much of the cost as possible to their employees in the form of reduced wages. To the extent that the supply of labor is sensitive to the compensation offered by firms, a payroll tax cut could increase overall employment, although perhaps modestly. In the current environment, with millions of workers abruptly pushed out of jobs because of strict social distancing policies, a reduction in the payroll tax may entice some of the unemployed to re-engage in the labor market. The main benefit of a payroll tax cut would be an increase in take-home pay. For a worker at the median wage, a reduction in the payroll tax rate of 4 percentage points would be worth $2100 over the course of a full year, or about $175 per month. In combination with a tax rebate, a payroll tax cut would provide significant financial support to households, and thereby support economic recovery. Opponents argue that a payroll tax cut would undermine budget discipline in Social Security and Medicare by compromising the principle of self-financing. Social Security’s trust funds are credited with payroll tax collections, which then pay for program benefits. Medicare’s Hospital Insurance (HI) trust fund is likewise financed entirely by payroll tax receipts. Cutting payroll taxes will require holding the trust funds harmless for the revenue loss by substituting general revenue for lost payroll tax payments. Otherwise, both programs’ trust funds would face insolvency in short order. Current projections — which do not reflect the effects of the pandemic or the contraction it precipitated — show Social Security running out of reserves in 2035, and Medicare HI in 2026. Concerns about the effect of a payroll tax cut on trust fund integrity are overblown. The Medicare program is awash in subsidies. Over the period 2020 to 2029, the general fund will send $5.3 trillion to Medicare’s other trust fund, for Supplementary Medicare Insurance (SMI). In the late 1990’s, Congress shifted some home health expenses from HI to SMI to make the HI trust fund appear more solvent. The transfer did not lower Medicare’s overall burden on the budget. With HI running out of reserves soon, there are already proposals being floated to shift costs to SMI again. Medicare needs serious reform, to lower its burden on taxpayers over the long-term. The problem is not HI insolvency but total program spending. An excessive focus on the HI trust fund will only distract from the changes needed to sustain the program for future beneficiaries. Similarly, modernization of Social Security has been complicated by the myths surrounding the program’s trust funds. Many Americans believe their benefits are tied directly to what they paid in payroll taxes while working. In reality, benefit payments are calculated based on workers’ earnings, not their tax payments. Moreover, other factors also affect monthly benefits. The formula provides a higher rate of return to lower earnings than to higher earnings, and married couples get spousal benefits. The program also pays survivors of deceased beneficiaries and disabled workers. A year-long payroll tax cut, with general revenue holding the trust fund harmless, is unlikely to lead to a full-scale unraveling of the trust fund financing construct. However, if it opened the door to further payroll tax reforms, that would be a welcome development. For instance, today the payroll tax is applied uniformly to all wages, without regard to circumstances. Beneficiaries age 65 and older who are drawing benefits must continue to pay the tax on any additional earnings even when there is no possibility that the added wages will improve their monthly benefit payments. The implicit tax on work for those age 65 and older is high and discourages labor force participation among the elderly, even as lifespans increase. The payroll tax should be eliminated or reduced for older workers to encourage the extension of careers. Some critics of a payroll tax cut say it is less progressive than other options for supporting households. That is only true if the tax rate reduction is uniform across all earnings. The cut could be more pronounced at low levels of earnings and then pulled back as earnings rise. The tax cut could also be phased out entirely for households with wages above a certain level (such as $100,000). Republicans in Congress are reluctant to embrace a payroll tax cut not because the idea is without merit but because they fear a broader debate about the future of Social Security and Medicare. A temporary payroll tax cut is unlikely to precipitate such a conversation, but if it did, it would be another reason to embrace it.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Gas Tax › Gas Tax Bad

Increased Gas Tax Causes Extra Strain on American’s Budgets

https://www.howmoneywalks.com/should-gas-taxes-be-raised-a-look-at-the-pros-and-cons/#:~:text=The%20biggest%20downside%20of%20a,struggle%20to%20make%20ends%20meet. Should Gas Taxes Be Raised? A Look at the Pros and Cons. Travis H. Brown. November 4, 2015

The biggest downside of a high gas tax is that it would create one more cost for Americans, many of whom are still looking for work in a recovering economy. At the same time, wages are not growing fast enough to keep up with the cost of living; even some who are employed still struggle to make ends meet. A higher gas tax would strip away some of the relief Americans are experiencing as a result of the currently low prices. If prices go back up and a $1 gas tax is in place, Americans would end up paying even more: The $4-per-gallon prices we saw over the past few years would suddenly be $5.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Gas Tax › Gas Tax Bad

Californians Have Highest Gas Prices in Country Because of Unnecessary Taxes

Lawrence Hodge. March 21, 2022. Jalopik.

While the whole country is hurting over high gas prices, in part due to the Russian invasion of Ukraine and , California drivers are hurting really bad California currently has the highest gas prices in the country hitting a statewide average of $5.44 a gallon . A lot of that price is taxes. But, as , California drivers have been paying a secret tax since 2015 that no one really knows about and lawmakers haven’t done much about. Late last year, a r that $1.18 of California’s gas prices were made up of taxes and fees. But in 2015, things changed, and an additional tax quietly appeared, hitting the wallets of California drivers even more. That change was the in Torrance in 2015. That explosion sent the state’s gas prices higher. Damage from the explosion caused the refinery to run at half capacity, costing drivers some $2.4 billion. The tax came and never left, with UC Berkley economist Severin Borenstein calling it a “mystery gas surcharge.” Not much is known about it. From the: Borenstein said, the average mystery gas surcharge in California was 48 cents. That’s 17 cents higher than the average mystery surcharge in 2021, but only 1 cent higher than the average surcharge for December. Kara Greene, a spokeswoman for the Western States Petroleum Assn., said an average of $1.27 of each gallon of gas sold in California goes to taxes, fees and climate programs. Of that amount, 10 cents on average goes toward state and local sales taxes, the latter of which can vary widely, Greene said. Borenstein broke down how much drivers have paid in the tax since 2015 in a that goes in-depth about the tax. Taking into account the spot price of gas (spot price is the current market price of gas or any other commodity that can be bought and sold immediately) and the upcharge many gas stations have he estimates that drivers have paid billions in the mystery tax over the years: This decomposition of California’s elevated gasoline prices shows the significant source of the problem. Comparing 2010-2014 to 2015-2019, the spot price of California gasoline rose just 2 cents relative to spot gasoline elsewhere in the country, but the distribution and retailing margins increased 29 cents relative to the rest of the country. 29 cents per gallon translates to over $22 billion of the $26 billion MGS since 2015. So what have lawmakers have done about this mystery tax? Not much. Governor Newsom into the state’s gas prices by the attorney general… and that’s it. Not much has been said about it since then. Unfortunately, it could take years to do something about it while drivers continue paying a tax not many are paying attention to.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Gas Tax › Gas Tax Bad

Gas taxes cause economic downturns and harm middle income families – turns case

Emma Boone 5/29/2015 (Journalist for Americans for Tax Reform) “Five Reasons to Not Raise the Gas Tax” NR

Last month President Obama signed a two-month extension of federal highway funding into law that will continue through July. This two-month patch has now intensified the transportation funding debate, with some in Congress calling for the biggest gas tax hike in over twenty years. The federal gas tax is currently 18.4 cents per gallon but some misguided lawmakers claim a much steeper 33.4 cents per gallon is necessary to fund the Highway Trust Fund (HTF) and its endless list of non-highway related projects.

As if common knowledge that keeping more money in American’s pockets will pump more money into the economy isn’t enough, here are 5 more reasons not to raise the gas tax:

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Gas Tax › Gas Tax Bad

Gas taxes do nothing

Randal O’Toole, 7-3-14 (Randal O’Toole is a former Senior Fellow for the Cato Institute) “Five Reasons Not to Raise the Gas Tax” NR

The federal Highway Trust Fund is running out of money, and some senators have proposed to fix the problem by raising gas taxes. This, however, is the wrong solution because it treats the symptom, and not the underlying reason for the shortfall. Here are five reasons for not increasing gas taxes.

1. The problem is not a shortage of funds but an excess of spending.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Gas Tax › Gas Tax Bad

Gas taxes negatively impact those in poverty

LeAnna Cumber, 5-16-21 (LeAnna M. Gutierrez Cumber is an American politician, lawyer and former teacher serving as a member of the Jacksonville City Council in Florida. Cumber previously served as a legislative counselor for the Office of Inspector General for the Department of Transportation during the Presidency of George W. Bush.) “Guest column: Why raising the gas tax is a bad idea” NR

I will not bury the lead. I am a hard “no” on the gas tax. Let me explain my position, and why you should be allowed to vote on doubling your taxes.

The federal gas tax has not been raised since 1993 for two main reasons. The gas tax is one of the most regressive taxes because it disproportionality negatively impacts lower-income residents. Gas taxes are a tax on a commodity that is a need not a luxury. The lower one’s personal income, the larger percentage of that income is spent on gas. Spending $1,600 per year on gas is more significant for a household making $40,000 annually than one making $80,000 annually. Lower-income residents tend to live farther from work, school and basic needs – like grocery stores -- causing them to purchase more gas. Lower-income residents tend to drive older, less fuel-efficient cars.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Gas Tax › Gas Tax Good

Gas taxes key to climate change

Los Angeles Times Editorial Board, 6-23-21 “Editorial: President Biden is wrong: The federal government should absolutely raise the gas tax” NR

How did a simple, logical and once-bipartisan policy such as the gas tax become such a political land mine that neither Democratic nor Republican presidents will touch it?

The federal taxes on gasoline and diesel fuel haven’t been increased in nearly 30 years, leaving less money over time to pay for roads, bridges and public transit improvements. But even a modest proposal to raise the tax by a few cents per gallon to help fund infrastructure investments has been batted down by President Biden.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Stepped Up Cost Basis Tax › Step Up Cost Basis Tax BAD

Stepped-up basis taxes only support the wealthy

Marr, Jacoby, and Bryant 19 Chuck Marr is the Vice President for Federal Tax Policy at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. Samantha Jacoby is a Senior Tax Legal Analyst with the Center’s Federal Fiscal Policy division. Kathleen Bryant is now a Legal Research Associate at The Tax Law Center at NYU Law.

[Chuck Marr, Samatha Jacoby, and Kathleen Bryant, “Substantial Income of Wealthy Households Escapes Annual Taxation Or Enjoys Special Tax Breaks,” CBPP (Center on Budget and Policy Priorities), 11/13/19, , accessed 7/3/22] //abcchs

One of the tax code’s largest subsidies for capital gains is the stepped-up basis tax break. If an investor holds on to an asset (such as stock) and passes it on to an heir instead of selling it, neither she nor her heir owes capital gains tax on its increase in value during her lifetime. (Technically, the asset’s basis — or the price paid for it — is “stepped up” to its fair market value at the time of inheritance.) Stepped-up basis encourages wealthy people to turn as much of their income into capital gains as possible and hold on to assets until death, when a lifetime of gain becomes permanently exempt from tax. (The asset, however, may be subject to the estate tax, as explained below.)Combined with the benefits of deferral and the other targeted capital gains tax breaks discussed above, stepped-up basis allows large corporate stockholders and other wealthy investors to pay no income tax on the increase in assets’ value during their lifetimes and then pass the assets on to their heirs, who pay no income tax on those inheritances. For example, Steve Jobs, the former Apple CEO, received an annual salary of $1, as reported on the company’s SEC filings.[26] Instead of a traditional salary, he received shares of Apple stock worth $75 million in the early 2000s.[27] He likely paid ordinary income tax on the value of those shares when he received them as income. But because he never sold the shares during his lifetime, he never paid tax on the subsequent massive gain as Apple’s stock skyrocketed.[28] At his death, Jobs’ Apple stock was worth roughly $2 billion, and all of that gain was permanently exempt from income tax.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Stepped Up Cost Basis Tax › Stepped Up Cost Basis Tax Good

Support for tax increase in the status quo. Politically feasible

Jacoby 22 Samantha Jacoby is a Senior Tax Legal Analyst with the Center’s Federal Fiscal Policy division.

[Jacoby, “Biden Proposal Would Eliminate Tax-Free Treatment for Much of Wealthiest Households’ Annual Income,” CBPP (Center on Budget and Policy Priorities), 5/6/22, , accessed 7/3/22] //abcchs

A proposal in President Biden’s 2023 budget would ensure that households with more than $100 million in wealth pay at least 20 percent of their annual income in income tax. That includes their unrealized capital gains, which is the main source of income for many of these households and which, unlike millions of taxpayers’ wages and salaries, now goes untaxed unless the holder sells the asset — a glaring and long-standing flaw in the tax code that lets some of the country’s wealthiest go through life without paying annual income taxes. And importantly, several aspects of the proposal would ease administrability, refuting critics’ claims that such a tax isn’t workable. For most of the income spectrum the progressive individual income tax generally works as it should, with higher-income households paying a larger share of their incomes in tax than households with lower incomes. Someone whose annual salary is $500,000, for example, will pay income taxes at a higher effective rate than someone whose salary is $50,000. But this relationship often breaks down at the very top because capital gains, the primary source of income for many of the country’s richest people, aren’t taxed until the assets the gains are based on are sold. A major ProPublica investigation last summer brought public attention to this major flaw in the tax code, finding that several of the world’s richest people, including Amazon founder Jeff Bezos and Tesla CEO Elon Musk, paid relatively little in federal income taxes, even managing to pay zero in federal income tax in some years. Moreover, because of the “stepped-up basis” loophole, if these wealthy people never sell their assets that gain in value — in technical terms, they never realize capital gains from the assets’ appreciated value — the income tax that would be owed on those gains will simply be erased when their heirs inherit the assets. As discussed in greater detail below, the President’s budget separately proposes to end this major loophole for wealthy households. The budget would also end the special discounted rate that applies to capital gains. Some might claim that unrealized capital gains shouldn’t be taxed as “income” because the asset owner hasn’t received cash in exchange for the asset, whose value can rise (or fall) until the asset is sold. But this argument ignores that the wealthy receive significant new value — or income — from their assets, even before they sell. Unrealized gains make asset owners better off in very real ways: stock purchased 20 years ago for $20 million that’s now worth $100 million has the same value as $100 million of stock purchased today (and that has no unrealized gains yet). And, if asset owners want to access large amounts of cash, they can borrow against their holdings without ever generating taxable income. As ProPublica noted, in 2021 Musk pledged some 92 million shares, worth about $57.7 billion as of late May that year, as collateral for personal loans. And as the Wall Street Journal reported last year, “Banks say their wealthy clients are borrowing more than ever before, often using loans backed by their portfolios of stocks and bonds.” One financial advisor called the associated tax benefits “stunning.” There’s also some precedent under current law for taxing unrealized gains each year. Stock brokers, for example, include their unrealized gains (and losses) in their taxable income each year. Though Biden’s proposal would broaden the scope of unrealized gains that are taxed, policymakers could look to aspects of these existing rules to inform the proposal’s implementation. The proposed minimum tax would apply to a small subset of very wealthy taxpayers and would phase in based on wealth — starting for households with more than $100 million in assets and applying fully at $200 million. The proposal includes several thoughtful design mechanisms that would ease administration of the tax, including: Timing. The Biden proposal would treat a wealthy person’s annual minimum tax liability as a “prepayment” of tax that would have been due if they had sold their investment assets that year — essentially, a down payment on future tax owed when assets are sold or after the owner’s death. Prepayment is analogous to employers withholding income and payroll taxes from their workers’ paychecks every month (a prepayment), with filers paying any balance due (or receiving a refund) at tax time. Once the minimum tax is imposed, households subject to it could make prepayments over nine years for previously accrued gains and five years for gains accrued after enactment. Spreading out the payments in this way would help these households account for having gains in one year and losses the next, a situation that critics claim make taxing unrealized gains impractical. According to Jason Furman, former chair of President Obama’s Council of Economic Advisers, spreading payments “would solve this problem for most taxpayers, because if the gains disappear, they would have paid only a fifth of the taxes upfront and wouldn’t be on the hook for future tax payments.” The Biden budget would also end the stepped-up basis loophole for those with capital gains greater than $5 million for a single taxpayer ($10 million for couples). This proposal complements the minimum tax, which is only a partial prepayment of the full tax liability on unrealized gains. By applying the capital gains tax at death and then subtracting the prepayments already made, the proposal would ensure the full amount of tax is paid and no double taxation occurs.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Capital Gains Tax › Capital Gains Tax Bad

The capital gains tax is mankind’s worst invention and a net-revenue loser.

Richard W. Rahn 21, 11-22-2021, The capital gains tax: One of the worst inventions of mankind, Washington Times, , accessed 7-3-2023, // rmmnshndr

Would you vote for a tax that frequently taxes people at an effective rate of 100% or more, misallocates investment, reduces economic growth and job creation, often becomes almost impossible to calculate, and in many cases reduces, rather than increases, revenue for the government? The tax to which I refer is the capital gains tax – one of the worst inventions of mankind. Capital gains are the alleged “profits” on the sale of non-inventory assets, such as stocks, bonds, commodities, real estate, and even personal property like jewelry and art. So-called “capital gains” are price changes most often caused by inflation, which, of course, is caused by incompetent or corrupt governments. The value of the U.S. dollar is now about one-twenty-fifth of its value back in 1914 when the Federal Reserve (the U.S. central bank) was formed – mainly to provide for monetary stability. So much for that idea. If you had bought a small RV park back in 1987 (when the consumer price index was about half of what it is today) for $100,000 and then sold it this year for $200,000, the government would claim you had a capital gain of $100,000 upon which you owe tax. If you live in a high-tax state, the tax on the “gain” could be as much as 33% or $33,000 – even though the purchasing power of the investment has not increased. By taxing nominal rather than real gains and restricting loss deductions, the capital gains tax becomes a non-legislated wealth tax and a government theft of property. There is much talk about making the tax code fairer. There is nothing fair about the IRS taxing government-caused inflation. Some excellent tax lawyers have argued that there is no basis in law for taxing the inflationary portion of capital gains. It is merely something the IRS decided to do on its own – without a law – decades ago. Given the economic damage that taxing inflation does, as well as its fundamental unfairness, it might be stopped if large numbers of taxpayers just refused to pay the tax on the inflationary portion of the gain as a peaceful protest against government tax abuse. Some countries explicitly allow for the indexing of a capital gain for inflation. Other countries have no capital gains tax at all because they recognize what a destructive tax it is. And many other countries limit capital gains taxes to certain classes of assets, such as art objects. The taxpayer often has a great deal of discretion when to realize a capital gain – the date of the sale. Capital gains tax rates have been raised and reduced many times in the U.S. and other countries, so there is considerable empirical evidence of the effect of rate changes on realizations. High tax rates cause what is known as a “lock-in effect,” where people desire to sell an asset, but the capital gains tax rate makes it prohibitive. Such an effect increases misery and misallocates capital. Many studies have been done about the relationship between capital gains tax rates and capital gains tax revenues. Because of the discretionary nature of most capital gains realizations, they are very sensitive to the rate. The Reagan Treasury, after a detailed study, concluded that the short-term revenue-maximizing capital gains tax rate was between 15 and 20%. Other studies have concluded that the revenue-maximizing rate is less than 28%. Studies have concluded that the very long-run revenue-maximizing rate is probably zero because the capital gains rate falls on capital and thus reduces investment, employment, and growth. Without a capital gains tax, economic growth would be higher, and this higher growth would increase tax revenues from less destructive taxes, such as those on consumption. The current maximum federal capital gains tax is 23.8%. The just-passed House “Build Back Better” (BBB) bill would push the top rate to 31.8%, which would also be the top rate in states with no state income tax like Florida, Texas, Tennessee, Nevada, Wyoming, South Dakota, and Alaska. On the flip side, citizens of states with high state income tax rates like California, New York, and New Jersey would find themselves paying destructive rates from 43 to 45%. The IRS has now claimed that any capital gain or loss resulting from the use of a cryptocurrency needs to be reported. As cryptocurrencies increasingly replace government currencies, the bookkeeping job will become impossible. Who could practically keep track of the price of every cryptocurrency they purchase and then calculate the adjusted price if they are using it to buy toothpaste or newspaper? Even now, the capital gains tax record-keeping requirements are near impossible for most people. Who has perfect records of every improvement they have made to their homes over the decades to correctly calculate the basis when they sell? Taxing capital gains and losses on commodities trading is downright stupid. In real terms, over time, losses and gains tend to balance out (a zero-sum game); and given that people are more likely to report losses than gains, the tax is a net revenue loser.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Capital Gains Tax › Capital Gains Tax Bad

It is a false assumption that the burden of capital gains taxes falls on large corporation and big businesses, the reality is small businesses feel the pain and cannot hire workers.

Curtis Dubay 21, 5-13-2021, Raising the Capital Gains Tax: Who Does it Really Hurt?, No Publication, , accessed 7-3-2023, // rmmnshndr

But in the current debate over President Biden’s proposal to increase capital gains taxes by more than 80%, these entrepreneurs and potential employees are the forgotten men and women. The president and his allies contend that only a few Americans will pay the higher taxes, however that ignores the millions that will pay the price of the proposed tax increases. As American Action Forum President and former Congressional Budget Office Director Doug Holtz-Eakin astutely points out, the total amount of capital gains hit by the President’s rate increase is an astounding 67%. The economic models and past history all reach the same conclusion: when you significantly increase taxes on capital gains you get significantly less capital investment. Given that the proposed tax increases from the president would impact two-thirds of capital investment, the impact will be particularly devastating for economic growth and job creation. Related Congress Should Restore Immediate R&D Expensing for U.S. Businesses – Here’s Why U.S. Chamber Applauds Senate Approval of U.S.-Chile Tax Treaty Many might assume that the reduction in investment only impacts big businesses, but smaller ones feel the pain too. They need funds from investors to launch their businesses and to grow. Without those funds, they cannot hire workers. Raising the capital gains rate is also self-defeating from a revenue perspective. When the rate goes up, not only do investors cut back on new investment, those with pre-existing gains hold on to them longer. The end result is less revenue. Both the Tax Foundation and the Penn Wharton Budget Model find that effect. The dumbest tax increase, indeed. Not only will higher capital gains rates hurt current workers, it will hurt current and future retirees. A higher rate, immediately upon enactment, reduces the value of all stocks. That means everyone saving for retirement, or anyone who has already retired, will see the value of their 401Ks fall.