Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Capital Gains Tax › Capital Gains Tax Bad

Capital gains taxes reduce international competitiveness, deter investment start-ups, and the government loses serious revenue.

Chris Edwards 20, 2-20-2020, The Capital Gains Tax Threat, Cato Institute, , accessed 7-3-2023, // rmmnshndr

The bad news is that Democrats are pushing many other tax hikes that are more viable. One terrible idea supported by all the top vote‐getters in Iowa and New Hampshire—Sanders, Warren, Biden, Buttigieg, and Klobuchar—is to hike the top capital gains tax rate from 24 to 40 percent. Capital gains taxes may seem obscure but limiting them is crucial to U.S. economic growth. Congress has kept capital gains tax rates below ordinary rates for most of the past century, and nearly all other advanced economies provide favorable rules for gains. One reason is inflation. If you buy a stock for $10 and sell it years later for $15, a share of the $5 gain is inflation, not a real return. A lower tax rate is a simple way to offset this unfair “inflation tax.” Capital gains taxes may seem obscure but limiting them is crucial to U.S. economic growth. Another issue is double taxation. Corporate share values generally equal the present value of expected future profits. If expected profits rise, share prices will increase, creating an individual capital gain. But future profits will also be taxed at the corporate level. This double tax on corporate equity biases companies to favor debt, which has the side effect of destabilizing the economy during recessions. International competitiveness is also a concern. Capital is mobile across borders, so higher capital gains taxes would prompt investment outflows. The U.S. federal‐state capital gains tax rate of about 28 percent is already higher than the average rate in other high‐income countries of just 18 percent, so we should be cutting our rate, not increasing it. Statistical studies, such as here and here, find that higher capital gains taxes produce lower investment. Furthermore, governments lose revenues from capital gains taxes when the rate is above about 20 percent because the tax base shrinks. Thus both the economy and the government would lose under proposed Democratic tax hikes. The rubber hits the road on capital gains when it comes to entrepreneurial finance. The reward that “angel investors” receive for putting their time and money into startup companies is a capital gain five or 10 years down the road. These are high‐risk investments, but the economy needs a diversity of startups to discover new products and technologies. Raising the capital gains tax would induce angels to shift their money to safer investments and the economy would be starved of the funding that high‐growth companies and technology industries rely on. Higher capital gains taxes would also reduce entrepreneurship. People considering launching startups would instead take safer wage jobs. The chance to earn a capital gain from a high‐growth startup would not be worth all the extra stress, risk, and hard work. When technology companies are acquired or go public, it generates a “wealth waterfall” as investors and employees sell shares and use their after‐tax gains to invest in new startups. Such wealth recycling has been central to Silicon Valley’s growth for decades. But Democratic plans would kill this reinvestment cycle and drain cash out of innovation hubs such as Silicon Valley. For the U.S. economy, startups are crucial because 8 percent of all companies go out of business each year. Startups fill the void, especially high‐growth and innovative startups called “gazelles.” From Apple Computer in the 1970s, to Amazon in the 1990s, to Airbnb today, gazelles are fueled by risk capital and favorable capital gains taxes have kept the fuel flowing.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Death Tax › Death Taxes Bad

Death Taxes stunt economic growth

Freeland and Portu 13, American Legislative Exchange Council 13, 9-12-2013, "The Death Tax," 

Moreover, though the revenue extracted via death taxes is small, the tax can be extremely burdensome for families. Even given the federal exemption of $5 million dollars (far lower than some states—Minnesota’s exemption is only $1 million, for example), relatively small and mid-sized businesses, farms, and ranches inherited by the children of entrepreneurs may be forced to sell the family business because they don’t have the cash on hand to pay the death tax on a business without divesting some or all of their parent’s labor of love.

By the same token, the small size of revenue the tax collects obscures one of the death tax’s largest costs. Death taxes create a major disincentive to save and the effect of that disincentive is substantial. A study authored by Lawrence Summers, the former head of President Obama’s Council of Economic Advisors and the Treasury Secretary under President Clinton, found that the death tax had lowered the total capital stock by over a trillion dollars. The capital stock can be defined as the total value of durable assets in an economy that aid in production. It is the machines, factories, tools, computers, software, and technical know-how (i.e. human capital) that aid in the production of goods and services. It’s hard to put a clear human price on such an economic consequence, but given that capital accumulation is the major driver of technological advancement, lower prices to consumers for goods and services, competitive firms that are able to expand hiring, and increasing wages of workers by improving labor productivity, it’s safe to say that each and every American, along with citizens of the world, is worse off as a result of the death tax.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Death Tax › Death Taxes Bad

Death Taxes are bad for the economy

Curtis Dubay 10, 7-20-2010, "The Economic Case Against the Death Tax," Heritage Foundation, 

The renewed death tax would once again inflict serious harm on family businesses, workers, and the economy. Congress should act before the end of the year to repeal this economically harmful tax permanently.

Tax on Jobs and Wages

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Progressive Income Taxes › Progressive Income Taxes Bad

Progressive taxes destroy the economy

David John Marotta Sep 10, 2012. ( David John Marotta. "A Progressive Tax Code is Economically Destructive." Forbes. Web. Sep 10, 2012. accessed 7-3-2023. <  >. mtrue - mrh)

Most Americans assume a progressive tax code is needed to promote equality and remove some of the burden of other taxes on those with the lowest income. But the progressive nature of the tax code changes behavior in many ways. As a result a progressive tax code is economically destructive.

To start with an obvious example, let's assume the tax rates on a business start at 10% and after a certain point reach 100%. How much money would be collected at the 100% rate? The answer, of course, is zero. No business would bother earning more money only to be obligated to give it all to the government.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Progressive Income Taxes › Progressive Income Taxes Bad

Progressive taxes destroy economy growth.

David John Marotta Sep 10, 2012. ( David John Marotta. "A Progressive Tax Code is Economically Destructive." Forbes. Web. Sep 10, 2012. accessed 7-3-2023. <  >. mtrue - mrh)

A progressive tax code discourages productivity, actually rewarding you for producing less. This system destroys much growth in the economy that would flourish otherwise. Purposefully doing this simply so the rich have less is evil, and it hurts society as a whole. Listen in political debates when the term "rich" is used with emotions that make it almost an economic slur.Our current system is complex enough to create many entitlement cliffs and marginal tax walls throughout the income spectrum. Tax simplification would eliminate many of these barriers to economic mobility and encourage greater productivity across the board. And one of these changes is a flatter tax and fewer deductions.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Progressive Income Taxes › Progressive Income Taxes Bad

Progressive tax unconstitutional and historically failed

Folsom, Dr. Burton W. 1999 “What’s Wrong with the Progressive Income Tax?” Mackinac Center, Accessed 3 July 2023

Note this date on your calendar: May 11, 1999. That’s "Tax Freedom Day"—the day when Americans stop working for government and start working for themselves. Each year the Tax Foundation in Washington, D. C. calculates the date based upon how many days of work the average citizen’s tax bill represents. This year, that average citizen will have to work 130 days to pay off his total tax bill, earning his "tax freedom" only on the 131st day, May 11. That’s one day later than last year and several months later than Tax Freedom Day was when the progressive income tax was first established in 1913. The principle behind the progressive income tax—which asserts that the more you earn, the larger the percentage of tax you must pay—is not what the nation’s Founders wanted. An attempt by Congress to impose one late in the nineteenth century was declared unconstitutional by the Supreme Court. It took a constitutional amendment, ratified in 1913, for such a tax to be legal. The income tax of 1913 started small, but grew quickly in size and scope. The top rate was first set at a mere 7 percent—and married couples were only taxed on income over $4,000 (equivalent to $80,000 in today’s dollars). During the tax debate, William Shelton, a Georgian, supported the income tax "because none of us here have $4,000 incomes, and somebody else will have to pay the tax." Or, as another wag later said, "Don’t tax you, don’t tax me, tax that man behind the tree." The seeds of class warfare were sown in the strategy of different rates for different incomes. It took the politicians less than one generation to sharply increase the tax and expand the base of those who had to pay it. Presidents Herbert Hoover and Franklin Roosevelt, using the excuses of depression and war, permanently enlarged the income tax. Under Herbert Hoover, the top rate was hiked from 24 to 63 percent. Under Franklin Roosevelt, the top rate was again raised — first to 79 percent and later to 90 percent. In 1941, in fact, Roosevelt proposed a 99.5 percent marginal rate on all incomes over $100,000. "Why not?" he said when an advisor questioned this tactic. After that proposal failed, Roosevelt issued an executive order to tax all income over $25,000 at the astonishing rate of 100 percent. He also promoted the lowering of personal exemptions to only $600, a tactic that pushed most American families into paying at least some income tax. Congress rescinded Roosevelt’s executive order, but approved the dropping of personal exemptions to only $600. The progressive income tax allows politicians to protect friends, punish enemies, and to tax certain groups to give benefits to other groups. In the 1920s, Senator James Couzens of Michigan said, "Give me control of the Bureau of Internal Revenue and I will run the politics of the country." When President Nixon discussed who he wanted as commissioner of internal revenue, he said, "I want to be sure that he is … ruthless … that he will do what he is told, that every income-tax return I want to see, I see. That he will go after our enemies and not go after our friends. It’s as simple as that."Fear and loathing of today’s IRS and disgust with an incomprehensible federal tax code has prompted a debate over the federal income tax that is sure to heat up as next year’s presidential campaign approaches. Some people want to replace the current system with a flat-rate income tax; others prefer a national sales tax. Perhaps the federal government’s bloated spending habits that require high taxes will be addressed as well. The size and complexity of the progressive income tax, its pervasiveness, and its susceptibility to political manipulation make it one of the most dramatic political and economic changes to have occurred in the twentieth century. In 1864, when the progressive income tax first became an issue in American politics, Congressman Justin Morrill of Vermont noted that "in this country we neither create nor tolerate any distinction of rank, race or color, and should not tolerate anything else than entire equality in our taxes." What Morrill said then applies to today as well: As Americans we should insist on equality in our tax code—and begin the next millennium by making the progressive income tax an oddity of our history, not a burden of our future.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Progressive Income Taxes › Progressive Income Taxes Bad

The Country with the World’s Most Progressive Taxes Has the World’s Highest Income Inequality. Progressive tax does not solve inequality.

Ehrenfreund, Max. “Analysis | the Country with the World’s Most Progressive Taxes Has the World’s Highest Income Inequality.” The Washington Post, July 16, 2017 www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2017/07/16/what-american-liberals-could-learn-from-south-africa/.

South Africa has the world's most progressive tax system, according to a new report. South Africa is also, by another measure, the world's most unequal country -- making it a cautionary example for U.S. liberals about the limited power of taxation to remedy inequality. Yes, taxing the rich more and the poor less can have benefits, but many experts argue inequality is more meaningfully addressed by spending on public programs that provide for people's basic needs while giving them an opportunity to get ahead. In particular, that requires ensuring people have access to education, training, transportation and health care. And funding those enterprises requires more than just soaking the rich. In northern European countries -- where economists have found that people who are born poor are more likely to make it into the middle class -- governments also rely on broad taxes that force the middle class to pay more as well. "The basic story is taxes do not change the income distribution," said Graham Glenday, a tax scholar at Duke University who was born in Cape Town, South Africa and plans to retire there."Changing the income distribution is much more of a dynamic thing that comes about if poor people can actually move up," he said. "That obviously takes, sometimes, generations."The new report, , ranks 152 countries on how well their economic policies are designed to address inequality. South Africa ranks first on taxation. The rich pay steeper rates, the corporate tax is hard to shirk and a national value-added tax includes exemptions for food and other staples that are major expenses for the poor. "It’s quite an efficient system that tries, to the extent that’s possible, to really, kind of, balance the equation," said Sipho Mthathi, the director of Oxfam South Africa. "It is one of the most efficient tax systems in the world." But despite ranking first in tax redistribution, South Africa ranks slides to 21st in the overall measure of addressing inequality, just ahead of the United States at 23rd. A poor score on the labor market -- South Africa does not have a minimum wage, for example -- brings down the country's general ranking. The other countries in the top 25 are all developed nations, almost all of them in Europe. Sweden ranks first, followed by Belgium, Denmark and Norway. There are many methods of measuring inequality, but among the most common is the Gini coefficient -- a measure of the share of income that would have to be redistributed to achieve perfect equality. Based on the Gini coefficient, South Africa is the most unequal country in the world among those for which data are available, according to . As of 2011 -- the most recent year for which data are available from the bank -- the coefficient was 0.63 in South Africa. Data from the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) show that inequality has increased in South Africa since 2000, when the Gini coefficient was 0.58. The coefficient for the United States was just 0.41 as of 2013, but that figure is still relatively high for a rich country. It is difficult to compare economic policies across countries. Different approaches may work better for some countries than others, and the data is not always available in the same form. Any ranking necessarily involves a degree of subjective judgment. For instance, Oxfam did not rank countries' systems of taxation according to a strict measure of fiscal progressivity -- that is, the distribution of the burden on people of different levels of income. (The northern European and Scandinavian tax systems also perform well in the report, despite the relatively high taxes paid by the middle class in those countries.) Instead, the authors of the report considered several factors. South Africa performed well on all of them. The South African government consistently collects between 27 percent and 29 percent of the country's gross domestic product in revenue, Glenday said. He added that those numbers are comparable to those for the United States -- where general government revenue totaled 33.5 percent of GDP in 2015, according to the OECD. That is despite the fact that the United States is a much richer country, where taxpayers can afford to pay much more. In the United States, GDP per person is more than 10 times that of South Africa. Indeed, Americans pay only  of the maximum amount of taxes that the government could theoretically collect, according to researchers at the International Monetary Fund. The estimates for South Africa are higher -- between 75 percent and 76 percent, depending on how the maximum is calculated. South Africa is able to collect so much in taxes in part because of a bureaucracy that is unusually effective for a developing country. While corruption is a serious problem in South Africa, the tax authorities have a reputation for professionalism. "They collect it very competently," Glenday said. Hefty penalties for cheating the system discourage abuse, according to Mthathi. "It’s created a culture where it’s not easy for people to just not follow the rules," she said. Another factor that might make South Africa's tax system particularly progressive is that about one fifth of tax revenue comes from taxes on corporate income. That is roughly twice the share of U.S. taxes that is paid by corporations. People who own corporations, whether privately or in the form of publicly traded stock, tend to be wealthier, and most economists believe that steeper corporate taxes tend to favor the poor and the middle class. An important exception is Kevin Hassett, President Trump's nominee to serve as chairman of the White House's Council of Economic Advisers. Hassett has argued that workers wind up paying a substantial share of corporate taxes in the form of reduced wages. By Oxfam's reckoning, though, the United States would fall in the rankings from 23rd to 29th if Trump's agenda were implemented. Despite decades of progressive, efficient tax policy in South Africa, the country's extreme inequality is stubbornly persistent. "It doesn’t mean that the country doesn’t have problems," Mthathi said. In particular, she said, South Africa could spend the money that it collects more efficiently to reduce poverty and create opportunity. The problem of corruption makes it more difficult for the government to achieve those aims. And as Glenday pointed out, South Africa's public education system is notoriously poor -- a grave obstacle to economic development over the long term. That is arguably a legacy of the era of apartheid, when schools for white students were much better than those for students of other ethnicities. Without good tax policy, South Africans might be much worse off, but that country's example suggests that progressive taxes on their own are not a solution to inequality. "It’s not just about collecting money, and making sure that is done is fairly and progressively," Mthathi said.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Progressive Income Taxes › Progressive Income Taxes Bad

Progressive tax would only harm the economy and further impoverish the poor. Progressive taxes hurt productivity and disincentivize work

Balfour, Brian. “Why Progressive Taxes Are Especially Harmful to Productivity And...” AIER, 28 Mar. 2023, www.aier.org/article/why-progressive-taxes-are-especially-harmful-to-productivity-and-harm-the-poor/.

Included in President Joe Biden’s recently released budget proposal are , among them an increase to the top marginal income tax rate. While the rate change, from 37 percent to 39.6 percent for income above $400,000 for single filers and $450,000 for married filers, appears minor, it nevertheless provides opportunity to explain why progressive marginal tax rates can be particularly harmful to the economy. Advocates typically express support for progressive income taxes couched in the language of “asking the rich to pay their fair share” and “equity.” It is fair for high income to be taxed at a steeper rate, supporters say, because the wealthy can afford to pay it. Moreover, taxing high income levels at a higher rate helps to equalize after-tax income. Combined with a welfare state that redistributes the income from rich to poor, progressives view this as a means to bring about greater income equality. But what if progressive taxes served as an especially harmful disincentive to work and productivity, and as a result would harm the poor more than help? Poverty is reduced through increased productivity, and in no other way. When productivity, and the resulting economic growth is stunted, it is the poor who are harmed disproportionately. With the guidance of a sound analytical framework provided by marginal analysis, we can understand why progressive taxes are extraordinarily problematic for productivity gains. Let’s take the example of Alex. For simplicity’s sake we’ll say he has a weekly income of $1,000. At a flat tax rate of 25 percent, his take home pay will be $750. Naturally, Alex will use this $750 to satisfy his highest-ranking goals that can be achieved with that amount of money, such as rent, groceries, and other vital utilities. On the flip side to that coin, assuming a 40-hour work week, Alex will have 128 hours of leisure time per week. Just like his salary, Alex will use these 128 hours of leisure time to satisfy his most urgently ranked goals for leisure, such as sleep, time with family, exercise, and the like. Now say Alex has an opportunity to work another 10 hours and earn another $250 of income. If the tax rate on that additional income was also 25 percent, Alex could take home an additional $187.50 after taxes. Sticking with our analysis based on marginal utility, we know that Alex will use that additional money to satisfy lower-ranking goals that can be achieved with money, ends not already satisfied with his original $750 paycheck. But he will also have to give up ten hours of leisure, and with each of those additional ten hours he forgoes, he will be giving up the satisfaction of a more-urgent goal he could have accomplished with his leisure time. The first additional hour of leisure he forgoes may not be that important to him, but giving up, say, the eighth, ninth, and tenth additional hours of leisure time will cause him to forgo an activity quite valuable to him. But even with that consideration, to Alex, the goals he can satisfy with the additional $187.50 may still be more valuable than what he could have done with those additional 10 hours of leisure. But what if the additional income fell into a higher tax bracket on the progressive income tax structure? Perhaps the tax rate applied on Alex’s extra hours was 75 percent. In other words, the additional $250 of income was taxed at a rate of 75 percent, leaving him just $62.50 in exchange for his extra ten hours of work. Alex may not find the $62.50 more valuable to him than what he must give up by foregoing another ten hours of leisure time – recall that he must do without more and more valuable goals, the more leisure time he forgoes. Additionally, in this scenario, we can say that the “price” to Alex of the additional 10 hours of leisure is reduced to only $62.50 due to the tax (he would only be forgoing $62.50 in order to enjoy 10 additional hours of leisure). At such a low “price,” Alex will tend to consume more leisure. This effect is especially likely given that the additional potential income would be used to satisfy progressively lower-ranking ends, while additional leisure time he would need to forego would have been dedicated to increasingly valuable ends. From this example, we can see that “progressive” tax rates are especially discouraging to people deciding whether to attain higher income through more work or higher salaries, because the additional income may be taxed at such a high rate that the worker decides it is not worth giving up additional leisure time. Using marginal analysis, we discover that the additional – or marginal – amount of money Alex earns through working more hours will be devoted toward satisfying less-urgent desires. Meanwhile, each additional – or marginal – hour of leisure he must forego requires him to miss out on increasingly important goals he wishes to accomplish with his leisure time. In sum, “progressive” taxes impose a particularly strong disincentive for more productive work. Depriving the economy of greater productivity curtails the alleviation of poverty, and as a result disproportionately harms the poor.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Value-Added Taxes › Value Added Taxes Bad

The VAT is not good for trade

Daniel J., 11 (7-26-2011, Daniel J., Cato Institute, The Case against the Value-Added Tax, 7-3-2023, ) //shelbor

Some proponents claim that a VAT is good for trade because it is “border adjusted.” This means that the VAT is imposed on imports and there is no VAT on exports (all previous VAT payments are rebated when products are sold to foreigners). For mercantilists worried about trade deficits, this is seen as a positive feature. But not only are they wrong on trade, they do not understand how a VAT works. Protectionists seem to think a VAT is akin to a tariff. It is true that the VAT is imposed on imports, but this does not discriminate against foreign‐produced goods because the VAT also is imposed on domestic‐produced goods. Under current law, American goods sold in America do not pay a VAT, but neither do German‐produced goods that are sold in America. Likewise, any American‐produced goods sold in Germany are hit be a VAT, but so are German‐produced goods. There is a level playing field. The only difference is that German politicians seize a greater share of people’s income, which helps explain why per‐capita living standards are only about twothirds of U.S. levels according to OECD data. So what happens if America adopts a VAT? There is no change in Germany. The government continues to tax American‐produced goods in Germany, just as it taxes German‐produced goods sold in Germany. There is no reason to expect a VAT to cause any change in the level of imports or exports from a German perspective. In the United States, there is a similar story. There is now a tax on imports, including imports from Germany. But there is an identical tax on domestically‐produced goods. And since the playing field remains level, protectionists will be disappointed. Politicians in Washington, by contrast, will be delighted since they get more money whenever any products are sold. Notwithstanding this analysis, some people doggedly assert that a VAT must be good for trade and competitiveness because the rebate ensures that there is no tax built into the price of America exports. It is true that the corporate income tax undermines competitiveness and makes America a less‐attractive location for producing goods and services, particularly since the United States has one of the world’s highest tax rates on business income. This is an argument for lowering or repealing the corporate income tax, not an argument for a VAT. The VAT is anti‐saving, not pro‐saving Advocates of the value‐added tax commonly claim that the levy would boost saving. The superficially compelling argument for this assertion is that the VAT is a tax on consumption, so the imposition of such a tax will make saving relatively more attractive. But this simple analysis overlooks the fact that saving is simply deferred consumption. The tax is simply postponed until the point when consumption occurs. There is no avoiding the tax. [Chart Ommitted] People who save usually earn some sort of return (such as interest, dividends, or capital gains). This means they will be able to enjoy more consumption in the future. But that does not change the calculation. The above chart compares a consumption‐base tax system (on the left side) and a comprehensive‐type tax regime such as the current internal revenue code (on the right side). In either case, the imposition of a VAT does not alter incentives to consume today or consume in the future. To be sure, incentives to save would be boosted if all of the double taxation on the right side was eliminated. But that’s because anti‐savings provisions embedded in the current tax system would e repealed. Imposing a VAT would have no impact. Simply stated, the VAT is not pro‐saving. But this is not the end of the story. A VAT, like an income tax or payroll tax, drives a wedge between pre‐tax income and post‐tax income. This means, of course, that a VAT also drives a wedge between pre‐tax income and post‐tax consumption – and this is true for current consumption and future consumption. This tax wedge means less incentive to earn income, and if there is less total income, this reduces both total saving and total consumption. Honest VAT proponents often admit that the levy will not boost the savings rate or the total level of savings, but they say that other potential tax increases will have a much worse impact on incentives to save. This is true, at least if the other tax options are higher income tax rates, higher corporate taxes, higher capital gains taxes, and other options that would exacerbate the double taxation in the current tax code. But this is not an argument for a VAT. It’s an argument against raising other taxes.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Value-Added Taxes › Value Added Taxes Bad

The VAT is associated with higher tax burdens.

Daniel J., 11 (7-26-2011, Daniel J., Cato Institute, The Case against the Value-Added Tax, 7-3-2023, ) //shelbor

Proponents often claim that a VAT is a form of tax reform rather than a tax increase. This certainly is a theoretical possibility, but there is no real‐world evidence for this hypothesis. No political jurisdiction anywhere on the planet has ever adopted a VAT and eliminated an income tax. It has always been an “add‐on” tax. Not surprisingly, this is why VATs are associated with higher overall tax burdens. The chart shows what happened in EU-15 nations. Prior to the VAT’s adoption, European nations had average tax burdens of less than 30 percent of GDP. Today, tax burdens consume nearly 40 percent of GDP. [Chart Omitted] The tax burden in non‐VAT nations also has increased, but not nearly as much. The chart also compares the increase in the share of output taken by tax authorities in the United States and EU-15 nations. The chart shows that Western European nations in 1965 had slightly higher taxes, on average, than the United States. Following the enactment of the VAT, however, the gap widened dramatically. It’s possible, of course, that the overall tax burden in Europe would have climbed just as rapidly in the absences of a VAT. But it is difficult to see how this could have happened. Income tax rate already are very high, and may even be at or above the “revenuemaximizing” level, suggesting that higher tax rates could backfire because of reductions in taxable income. Payroll tax rates also are high, as are taxes on energy, alcohol, and tobacco. The past couple of years certainly suggest that politicians view the VAT as a convenient tax to increase. The following chart, from a recent European Commission report, shows that the average VAT rate has jumped significantly since 2008. There’s every reason to believe US lawmakers also would view the VAT as a money machine that would enable them to avoid much‐needed belt tightening of the federal budget. [Chart Omitted] The VAT is associated with higher tax burdens on income and profits. Proponents sometimes admit that a VAT increases the overall tax burden, but they claim that some of the new revenue is used to finance lower personal and/or business income taxes. This certainly is a potential result. Unfortunately, that’s not what has happened in Europe. The chart shows that the tax burden on income and profits has climbed since the VAT was implemented. [Chart Omitted] Some people in the business community are being lured to support the VAT by promises of better tax treatment of corporate income. Yet the data on corporate taxation shows that the adoption of a VAT was followed by a steeper burden on profits in EU-15 nations. [Chart Omitted] To be sure, corporate tax rates have dropped in recent decades, so it’s possible that some of the added corporate tax revenue is a “Laffer Curve” response to better tax policy. But the lower tax rates are the result of tax competition beginning in the 1980s, whereas VATs were implemented starting in the 1960s.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Value-Added Taxes › Value Added Taxes Bad

VATs are associated with bigger government

Daniel J., 11 (7-26-2011, Daniel J., Cato Institute, The Case against the Value-Added Tax, 7-3-2023, ) //shelbor

Reviewing the experience of other developed nations is probably the best way to assess the likely impact of a VAT in the United States. Western European nations are especially useful case studies since the VAT was implemented in that late 1960s and early 1970s, thus providing about 40 years of evidence. Unfortunately, that data suggests a VAT means bigger government. As seen in chart, the burden of government spending in “EU-15” nations is significantly larger than it is in the United States. What makes this comparison especially revealing is that government spending in EU-15 nations was quite similar to U.S. spending levels back in the mid‐1960s, shortly before VATs were implemented. The burden of government spending has increased in both the United States and Europe, but the increase in Europe has been larger (though government spending has jumped significantly in the Bush‐Obama years, thus making the comparison less dramatic than it was 10 years ago). There is a debate in the academic literature about whether the VAT causes higher spending, or whether the relationship is the other way around. In other words, do higher taxes lead to higher spending or does higher spending lead to higher taxes? That is an interesting question, but largely irrelevant. A bigger burden of government spending is misguided, and that is true if politicians implement a VAT (or increase the rate) so they can spend more in the future. And it is true if politicians implement a VAT (or increase a rate) because they spent more in the past. In either case, the additional spending is made possible by the VAT. Proponents of an add‐on VAT often claim that their goal is to reduce deficits and debt. This presumably makes the idea of a new tax more politically palatable. This may be a clever strategy, but even a superficial look at the data shows that European nations with VATs heavily rely on borrowed money. Indeed, the sovereign debt crisis in Greece, Ireland and other European nations only exists because deficits and debt got out of control. Deficits in Europe are much higher today than they were in the pre‐VAT days. But oneyear snapshots of red ink can generate unfair comparisons because most nations today have unusually high levels of government borrowing because of a weak global economy. Government debt figures are more appropriate since they represent accumulated fiscal balances, so they capture both good years and bad years. But this approach is even more damning for VAT advocates. Average government debt is much higher today in EU-15 nations than it was before VATs were adopted. Moreover, the chart shows that the average level of debt in EU-15 VAT nations is higher than it is in the United States. These numbers are especially significant given that the U.S. has just finished a 10‐year period featuring record deficits. Yet even with all the additional red ink caused by the Bush‐Obama spending binge, VAT nations in Western Europe still have more higher levels of debt. Some argue that this means that VATs cause higher deficits. That may be true, but it is difficult to prove or disprove such a hypothesis. Another plausible explanation is that VATs have no impact on red ink. According to this hypothesis, the propensity to use debt‐financed spending varies across nations based on political and cultural tolerances for red ink. Southern European nations, for instance, almost always have higher levels of deficits and debt than Nordic nations. That was true before the VAT was implemented, and that is true now that all of the nations have a VAT. This means that the real impact of a VAT is to allow governments to finance more spending, while still maintaining whatever level of red ink that they can get away with given varying national circumstances.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Close Corporate Loopholes › Closing Corporate Loopholes Bad

Closing corporate loopholes can’t raise necessary revenues and hurts the low and middle class, increase incentives to avoid taxes, decreases innovation, and hurts the economy

Diez Reus International Law Firm [“Closing Corporate Tax Loopholes”, Lexology, 03-03-2013, . Accessed 07/03/2023.]//ahcchs

During the recent presidential campaign, the issue of whether corporate tax loopholes should be closed was a hot topic. Neither party likes the current tax system for corporations. Both Democrats and Republicans agree it is riddled with too many loopholes. However, the process of closing corporate tax loopholes is not as easy as it seems. If done incorrectly, it could possibly hurt the poor and the working middle class, as well as remove incentives for businesses to invest. According to economists Hane Gravelle and Thomas Hungerford from the Congressional Research Service, “it may prove difficult to gain more than $100 billion to $150 billion in additional tax revenues through base broadening.” Even if all loopholes were eliminated, the government would not be able to raise trillions of dollars because taxpayers likely would change their behavior to avoid higher levies. Furthermore, more than simply raising taxes on the “rich,” closing loopholes could negatively impact the middle class and poor. As Robert Rubin, President Clinton’s Treasury secretary explained, reducing tax expenditures “will not raise nearly the revenue needed for sufficient deficit reduction without increasing taxes on the middle class significantly.” It is also important to consider that some loopholes serve vital public purposes such as the research and development tax credit. This credit encourages companies to conduct more research, which benefits their employees, other businesses, and ultimately customers—who pay taxes. In summary, Congress must carefully assess the impact on society of closing any of the current tax loopholes. Closing all loopholes may not raise the desired revenue, and worse, could motivate people to simply adjust their finances to avoid higher taxes and hurt the overall economy in the long run.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Close Corporate Loopholes › Closing Corporate Loopholes Good

Closing corporate loopholes key to increase revenue and boost small businesses

Jon Whiten Former Vice President for NJPP. He also led NJPP’s strategic communications efforts, managed its finances and operations, researched key economic justice issues and engaged in advocacy and outreach. [“Closing Corporate Loopholes: A Win-Win”, New Jersey Policy Perspective, 01-28-2016, . Accessed 07-03-2023.]//ahcchs

“Some highly-profitable companies exploit tax laws like a corporate shell game to avoid paying their fair share,” said Sen. Raymond Lesniak, prime sponsor of the legislation. “They create phantom subsidiaries to ‘shift profits’ away from New Jersey. By closing this loophole the state could generate as much as $200 million a year. This will help address the fiscal needs of the state.” “Every year when we sit down and work out New Jersey’s budget, we have to make hard spending decisions based on available revenues,” added Senate Budget Chairman Paul Sarlo, a co-sponsor of the bill. “Closing tax loopholes would ensure that multistate and multinational corporations doing business in New Jersey are paying their full tax bill, resulting in a modest boost to the budget and a big help to small businesses throughout the state.” How does combined reporting work? Here’s the quick explanation: It treats the parent company and subsidiaries of multistate corporations as one entity for state corporate income tax purposes. Their nationwide profits are added together and the state then taxes the share of the combined income generated in the state. While this doesn’t prevent profitable corporations from shifting profits to dummy corporations in Delaware and other states, it does eliminate the New Jersey tax break they currently get if they do so. “We need to close these loopholes, capture this revenue, and hold multistate companies to the same level of accountability as the rest of New Jersey,” said Sen. Linda Greenstein, a co-sponsor of legislation. “This is an issue of fairness and shared responsibility.” The majority of states that tax corporate income – 25 of 45 – currently mandate combined reporting, as does the District of Columbia. Many of these states have had this policy on the books for decades, but a growing number of states – most recently Connecticut – have joined them in recent years. “Combined reporting, quite simply, is a policy that works,” said Assemblyman Jamel Holley, who has sponsored the Assembly version of the legislation. “I hope that more of my colleagues in the Assembly will soon join me and Assemblyman Dancer in advocating for this essential step to level the playing field for small businesses and better invest in the assets that are proven to grow the economy.” The press conference coincided with the release of , which shows that nearly all of New Jersey’s largest employers are already subject to combined reporting in other states. “Most of New Jersey’s largest employers already operate in combined reporting states and, in some cases, have been doing so for decades. For them, combined reporting is nothing out of the ordinary and is accepted as another cost of doing business,” said Sheila Reynertson, Senior Policy Analyst at NJPP and author of the report. “This is the clearest evidence yet that adopting combined reporting would not harm New Jersey’s business climate. In fact, it would greatly improve the business climate by allowing small and locally owned businesses to better compete with their multistate and multinational counterparts.” “The money I earn goes back into my community and so do the taxes I pay,” said Erick Cedano, the owner of Graphic Core LLC and Fast Photo Plus in Elizabeth. “Unlike multistate corporations, I don’t hide my earnings in other states. A combined reporting bill would ensure a level playing field for everyone and ensure that communities across the state served by small businesses have the funding they need to prosper, and that we can meet the challenges facing us with success.” Cedano is a member of the New Jersey Main Street Alliance, a statewide organization representing more than 1,500 independently owned businesses. Closing corporate loopholes is a top priority of the small business community across New Jersey.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Close Corporate Loopholes › Closing Corporate Loopholes Good

Corporate Tax Loopholes are Unfair

Office of the Press Secretary, 2014. (Office of the Press Screatry, "Weekly Adress; Closing Corporate Tax Loopholes" Obama White Hous. Web. 7-26-14. accessed 7-3-2023.<https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/the-press-office/2014/07/26/weekly-address-closing-corporate-tax-loopholes>. IsEis)

The President highlighted the need to close one of the most unfair tax loopholes that allows companies to avoid paying taxes here at home by shifting their residence for tax purposes out of the country. The President has put forth a budget that does just that, and he has called for business tax reform that makes investment in the United States attractive, and creates incentives for companies to invest and create jobs here at home. And while he will continue to make the case for tax reform, the President is calling on Congress to take action and close this loophole now. Hi, everybody.  Our businesses have now added nearly 10 million new jobs over the past 52 months.  The unemployment rate is at its lowest point since September 2008 – the fastest one-year drop in nearly 30 years.  401(k)s are growing, fewer homes are underwater, and for the first time in more than a decade, business leaders around the world have declared that the world’s number one place to invest isn’t China; it’s the United States of America – and our lead is growing. None of this is an accident.  It’s thanks to the resilience and resolve of the American people that our country has recovered faster and come farther than almost any other advanced nation on Earth. But there’s another trend that threatens to undermine the progress you’ve helped make.  Even as corporate profits are as high as ever, a small but growing group of big corporations are fleeing the country to get out of paying taxes.  They’re keeping most of their business inside the United States, but they’re basically renouncing their citizenship and declaring that they’re based somewhere else, just to avoid paying their fair share. I want to be clear: this is only a few big corporations so far.  The vast majority of American businesses pay their taxes right here in the United States.  But when some companies cherry pick their taxes, it damages the country’s finances.  It adds to the deficit.  It makes it harder to invest in the things that will keep America strong, and it sticks you with the tab for what they stash offshore.  Right now, a loophole in our tax laws makes this totally legal – and I think that’s totally wrong.  You don’t get to pick which rules you play by, or which tax rate you pay, and neither should these companies. The best way to level the playing field is through tax reform that lowers the corporate tax rate, closes wasteful loopholes, and simplifies the tax code for everybody.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Close Corporate Loopholes › Closing Corporate Loopholes Good

Closing Corporate Tax benefits society for a laundry list of reasons—raises government revenue, strengthens investments, opens jobs, and overall boosts economy

Christopher Meyer , 2020. (Christopher Meyer, idk. "Closing Corporate Tax Loopholes Is Still the Right Choice for a Thriving Maryland" Forbes. Web. 9-29-20. accessed 7-3-2023.<https://www.mdeconomy.org/corporatetax/>. IsEis)

A well-designed revenue system is essential for maintaining Maryland’s economic health throughout the ups and downs of our state’s economy. An effective tax code supports the building blocks of a thriving community, such as health care, education, and transportation. Just as importantly, a fair tax code ensures that everyone contributes their share to maintain those building blocks – including families, local businesses, and large corporations. The public investments our taxes make possible are especially vital amid a weak economy, when every job created or protected can soften the blow to families and communities. However, large, multistate corporations are often able to wield their economic and political power to artificially reduce their tax responsibilities in Maryland. Corporate tax loopholes make it harder for the state to invest in basic services and further tip the scales of our economy in favor of the wealthy and powerful few. This harms communities across Maryland as well as small, local businesses that cannot exploit similar loopholes. The greatest harms often fall on communities of color, women, people with disabilities, and other Marylanders who face economic roadblocks built by centuries of lopsided policy choices. If we enact a few smart reforms to close corporate tax loopholes, we can put more money in the pockets of public health professionals, teachers, and other workers whose daily efforts keep Maryland communities going. Strong evidence makes clear that an effective corporate tax code enables investments that benefit families and businesses alike and can protect local economies during hard times. Contrary to misleading claims by antitax advocates, cleaning up Maryland’s corporate tax code is the right choice for our economy today and in the decades to come. Key Findings: Closing corporate tax loopholes would raise significant revenue by preventing large, multistate corporations from artificially lowering their tax responsibilities. This can enable the state to strengthen investments in things like health care and education, or to minimize cuts during a downturn. State services provide an immediate boost to the economy by creating decent jobs that enable families to afford necessities.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Wall Street Tax › Wall Street Tax Bad

Wall street tax decreases investment and has multiple negative econ impacts

Congressional Budget Office. 12-13-2018. ( Congressional Budget Office, federal agency within the legislative branch of the United States government that provides budget and economic information to Congress. "Impose a Tax on Financial Transactions." Congressional Budget Office. Web. 12-13-2018. accessed 7-3-2023. < https://www.cbo.gov/budget-options/54823 >. JBFunke)

A disadvantage of the option is that the tax would discourage all short-term trading, not just speculation—including some transactions by well-informed traders that stabilize markets and help establish efficient prices that reflect more information about the fundamental value of assets. Empirical evidence suggests that, on balance, a transaction tax could make asset prices less stable. In particular, a number of studies have concluded that higher transaction costs lead to more, rather than less, volatility in prices. (However, much of that evidence is from studies conducted before the rise of high-frequency trading, which now accounts for a significant share of trading in the stock market.)The tax could also have a number of negative effects on the economy stemming from its effects on asset prices, the cost of capital for firms, and the frequency of trading. Traders and investors would seek to recoup the cost of trading by raising the return they required on financial assets, thereby lowering the prices of those assets. The tax would be small relative to the returns that investors with long-term horizons could earn, so the effect on asset prices would be partly mitigated if traders and investors reduced the frequency of their trading—but less frequent trading would lower liquidity and reduce the amount of information reflected in prices. Consequently, investment could decline (even though higher tax revenues would lower federal borrowing and thus increase the funds available for investment) because of increases in the cost of issuing debt and equity securities that would be subject to the tax and potential negative effects on derivatives trading, which could make it more difficult to efficiently distribute risk in the economy. The cost to the Treasury of issuing federal debt could increase because of the increase in trading costs and the reduction in liquidity. Household wealth would decline with the reduction in asset prices, which would lower consumption.In addition, traders would have an incentive to reduce the taxes they owed, either by developing alternative securities not subject to the transaction tax or by moving their trading out of the country (although offshore trades by U.S. taxpayers would be taxed). Such effects would be mitigated if other countries enacted financial transaction taxes. Several members of the European Union have such taxes, and since 2011, members have been negotiating whether to implement a common system of transaction taxes.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Wall Street Tax › Wall Street Tax Bad

Wall street tax decreases investment, hurts econ, and isn’t functional, a laundry list of reasons

Alex Muresianu and Nicole Kaeding, 2018. ( Alex Muresianu, Nicole Kaeding, Muresianu - Policy Analyst at the Tax Foundation, focused on federal tax, degree in economics and minors in finance and political science, Kaeding - was Vice President of Policy Promotion and Economist with the National Taxpayers Union Foundation, and Vice President of Federal and Special Projects at the Tax Foundation, and has worked at the Cato Institute and Americans for Prosperity Foundation. "A Financial Transactions Tax Is A Retread of Bad Ideas." Tax Foundation. Web. 6-20-2018. accessed 7-3-2023. < https://taxfoundation.org/financial-transactions-tax-wall-street-retread-bad-ideas/ >. JBFunke)

Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY) recently endorsed a proposal to implement a financial transactions tax of .03 percent on every Wall Street transaction.This proposal is not new: Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) proposed one in his tax plan when he ran for president in 2016, and many other progressive lawmakers have championed this idea. Its defenders cite that the rate (.03 percent) is low, while the base (financial transactions) is relatively broad, which theoretically indicates that it would raise significant revenue while not hurting the economy too much. Furthermore, advocates say the tax would be very progressive.However, despite the good intentions behind it, the financial transactions tax would cause or worsen many economic problems if implemented. While the tax would follow one principle of sound tax policy, a low rate and broad base, in this case, the tax would function like a gross receipts tax, creating tax pyramiding, violating a sound tax policy principle.The tax also violates another principle. Income should only be taxed once. Financial transactions taxes tax the act of trading itself, on top of existing capital gains, personal income, and corporate income taxes. For that reason, Gillibrand’s proposal would distort economic decision-making and raise the cost of investment.According to a Congressional Budget Office (CBO) report from 2011 on a proposal to impose a .03 percent tax on financial transactions, such a tax would “raise the cost of financing new investment… [and] reduce output and employment.” Furthermore, the financial transactions tax may also hurt smaller investors the most, as transaction costs tend to be much bigger for small, individual investors than for large, institutional ones.A financial transactions tax would distort asset markets, as types of securities traded more frequently would be taxed much more than assets traded less frequently. This distortion would lead to investors holding certain assets longer than they should in order to avoid the tax. The tax also decreases liquidity and increases transaction costs.While supporters of the tax assert that making short-term investing less attractive will rein in speculation and limit volatility, the evidence for this claim is mixed at best. While the financial transactions tax might discourage speculation, it will also discourage transactions between well-informed investors; furthermore, much of the research on the issue of volatility suggests that higher transaction costs correlate with more volatility, not less.Financial transactions taxes are also not surefire revenue generators. In the 1980s, Sweden imposed a financial transactions tax, and, thanks to the relative mobility of capital markets, 60 percent of trades moved to different markets. Not only did this behavior mean that the financial transactions tax raised little revenue, it also drove down revenue for the capital gains tax, ultimately lowering total government receipts.The tax might also worsen government finances in other ways. The CBO report on financial transactions taxes notes that the tax will increase the cost of financing state and local governments. More importantly, the tax would hurt state pension plans by both reducing their asset values and raising transaction costs. At a time when many states’ pension plans are in dire financial straits, the new tax could worsen an already-serious problem.While the financial transactions tax might sound like smart, low-rate, broad-base tax policy, the nature of capital markets would mean that such a tax would not only lower incentives to invest, but also disproportionately negatively affect smaller investors. Furthermore, there’s little convincing evidence that the tax would achieve the goal of reducing economic volatility, or consistently raise revenue. If Sen. Gillibrand is looking to support new government programs, she should consider a less distortionary and economically harmful tax to finance them.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Wall Street Tax › Wall Street Tax Bad

Wall street taxes (aka financial transaction taxes) reduce economic investment and suck

Boesen 1-11-2021. ( Ulrik Boesen, senior policy analyst at the Center for State Tax Policy at the Tax Foundation, "The Drawbacks of State Taxes on Financial Transactions." Tax Foundation. Web. 1-11-2021. accessed 7-3-2023. < https://taxfoundation.org/state-tax-financial-transactions/ >. JBFunke)

Historical examples both in the U.S. and abroad suggest that lawmakers should be careful when designing taxes for the financial market. A well-functioning financial market provides a key service for businesses and entrepreneurs in need of capital or risk management. In addition, it provides savers with a chance to get a better return than they would get with a standard savings account—especially with interest levels near zero.Nonetheless, imposing an FTT to raise revenue has been, and is being, discussed by lawmakers at both the federal and state levels. During the Democratic Party’s presidential primary contest in 2020, a few candidates supported FTTs at the federal level.[3] At the state level, lawmakers in New York and New Jersey are discussing levying such taxes.[4] There is also federal opposition to FTTs. In October 2020, Representatives Patrick T. McHenry (R-NC) and Bill Huizenga (R-MI) introduced the Protecting Retirement Savers and Everyday Investors Act, which would prohibit states from imposing FTTs that could affect residents of other states.[5]Transaction taxes more generally are quite common at the state level. Many states impose a version of a transaction tax known as the real property transfer tax, which is commonly a low-rate levy on the transfer of real property.The issues with levying a tax on financial transactions are related to the nature of the financial markets. First, financial transactions are a flawed tax base as the tax is levied every time a security is transferred, resulting in tax “pyramiding” similar to the effect of a gross receipts tax. “Pyramiding” refers to a tax that is levied on the same economic activity many times over—in this case, each time a share is traded. Second, an FTT would raise transaction costs, which would result in a lower trading volume and lower liquidity as even low rates could be punitive, especially for low-margin high frequency trading (HFT).[6] Low liquidity (or quoted depth) makes it more difficult for traders to buy and sell shares at the best price level. Third, taxing trades might result in investors holding on to the securities to avoid the tax, regardless of whether they should actually be holding on to them.[7] Disincentivizing trading is not ideal as economists generally think of trades as highly valuable activity that benefits both parties. Fourth, an FTT would result in income being taxed multiple times. FTTs tax the act of trading itself, on top of existing capital gains, personal income, and corporate income taxes.States can limit the adverse effects of an FTT by making certain design choices but are unlikely to avoid them completely. They must consider a number of tax policy trade-offs related to this design. Choice of tax base will impact market participant behavior and choice of rate will impact market volume and liquidity. This paper discusses those trade-offs and presents arguments against an FTT as both a revenue tool and deterrent of “undesired” trading.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Raise Social Security Cap › Raising Social Security Cap Bad

It wouldn’t work

Andrew G. Biggs 02/25/15 Senior fellow PhD, government, London School of Economics, MSc, financial economics, University of London, MPhil, social and political theory, Cambridge University, BA, philosophy, Queen’s University of Belfast “Eight reasons why we shouldn’t raise the cap on social security tax” https://www.aei.org/articles/eight-reasons-shouldnt-raise-cap-social-security-taxes/ RAY-SOLORIO

The Center for American Progress has a new study arguing for raising the maximum earnings on which workers pay Social Security taxes. The limit is currently $118,500, and raising it would garner some substantial revenue to shore up Social Security. But there are a lot of reasons why it might not make sense at all. CAP’s argument is pretty much this: Since 1983, an increasing share of total earnings have “escaped” taxation by Social Security. In 1983, 90 percent of total earnings were subject to taxation. Today, only about 83 percent of earnings are taxed, meaning that 17 percent are “escaping.” From most progressives’ perspective, this pretty much settles the debate on whether we should raise – or preferably eliminate – the Social Security “tax max.” It’s by far progressives’ favorite solution to the Social Security funding problem and, for many of them, their only solution. But there are a whole bunch of other reasons we should think carefully before raising the tax max. Here are eight: 1. Social Security didn’t start in 1983. And over the program’s entire history, an average of just 84 percent of wages have been taxed, practically equal to today’s 83 percent. In fact, from 1950 through 1972, upward of 20 percent of total earnings generally weren’t taxed by Social Security. From the CAP authors’ perspective, the Social Security tax base was more inequitable during those two decades than it is today. 2 The tax max helps distinguish Social Security from a “welfare” program. Under the Roosevelt administration’s original plans, high earners wouldn’t even have participated in Social Security, much less paid multiples more in taxes than they’ll collect in benefits. Eliminating the tax max would change the character of the program. 3 Even if we raised the Social Security tax max to cover 90 percent of total earnings, we would still need to increase the payroll-tax rate by roughly 2.7 percentage points – immediately and permanently — to cover the program’s full promised benefits over the next 75 years, based on CBO projections. Progressives don’t talk about this very much, but they need to. 4 The main reason that a greater share of earnings are falling above the tax max is that health costs are eating away at earnings for low-income and middle-income earners. Raising the tax max is a Band-Aid. Instead, fix rising health costs. 5 Our tax max isn’t unusually low. In Canada, payroll taxes are capped at the average wage; in the U.K., they’re capped at 1.15 times the average wage; and Germany and Japan at 1.5 times the average wage. Social Security’s tax ceiling is 2.9 times the average wage. 6 It’s a fat tax increase. Today’s top federal tax rate on earned income is about 45 percent. Adding state income taxes boosts it to around 50 percent – and in California, over 58 percent. Eliminating the tax max effectively raises the top tax rate by around 12 percentage points. We could call that Scandinavian levels of taxation, except their taxes are lower 7 And these higher marginal tax rates would be before we’ve done anything to fix Medicare and Medicaid. 8 Economists Emmanuel Saez and Jeffrey Liebman concluded that, due to income shifting and behavioral responses, net tax collections from eliminating the tax max would be 40 percent less than SSA’s static projections. This means that one of the biggest tax increases in history would still leave a huge Social Security shortfall.

2023 SDI Evidence
Taxes Good/Bad › Raise Social Security Cap › Raising Social Security Cap Good

Eliminating cap will stabilize social security

Aimee Picchi 03/03/23 reporter for CBS money watch “One way to fix social security? “Smash he cap” https://www.cbsnews.com/news/social-security-benefits-tax-cap-2023/ RAY-SOLORIO

Social Security is heading for a funding cliff, with its trust fund reserves  by 2033 — an outcome that would mean beneficiaries would face a 25% shave on their monthly checks. But there is a way to fix most of the funding shortfall, policy experts say: "Smash the cap." That refers to the Social Security tax cap, a feature of the program since it was launched in the 1930s following the Great Depression. Essentially, any income over the earnings cap isn't subject to the Social Security payroll tax, which is 6.2% for workers and an additional 6.2% for employers.  In 2023, the tax cap stands at $160,200, which means any income above that amount is exempt from the payroll tax. As a result, middle- and lower-income workers bear a much greater tax burden in funding Social Security than the 6% of Americans who earn above the threshold, according a new  from the left-leaning Center for Economic and Policy Research. "If you make over that cap, like 6% of the population does, you could be paying 1% of your income or even less than that," noted Sarah Rawlins, program associate at CEPR. Yet a middle-income worker earning less than the $160,200 cap in 2023 will pay an effective tax rate that is six times higher than the millionaire's tax burden, she noted. That's why the Congressional Budget Office (CBO), a federal agency that provides financial analyses of policy issues, calls the Social Security tax cap "" — middle- and low-income workers pay a much greater share of their income toward the program than the rich. Eliminating or lifting the tax cap could help stabilize Social Security's trust fund by providing more revenue to the program, Rawlins said. A December  by the CBO found that eliminating the cap for earnings over $250,000 would keep the trust fund solvent through 2046. Meanwhile, some lawmakers are proposing changes that include both getting rid of the tax cap and other changes to address Social Security's funding challenges. Senator Bernie Sanders, an Independent from Vermont, and Senator Elizabeth Warren, a Democrat from Massachusetts, in February  that would stabilize the trust fund for the next 75 years. Among their plans: Lift the tax cap for people earning $250,000, and add the Social Security tax to investment and business income, which is currently exempt from the tax. Raise the retirement age? Others oppose raising taxes on higher-income Americans as the answer to fixing Social Security. Last year, the Republican Study Committee, a group of House conservatives,  the retirement age for claiming Social Security to age 70, up from today's full retirement age of 66 to 67 years old. While House Speaker Kevin McCarthy has said Social Security won't be on the chopping block during the ongoing debt ceiling debate, pushing the retirement age higher isn't a new approach. For instance, the full retirement age was 65 until 1983, when changes to the program took into account the fact that Americans were living longer and the retirement age was raised to 66 or 67 (depending on one's birth year). Americans' longer lifespans are part of the argument that Republican lawmakers make in favor of lifting the Social Security retirement age: the "miracle" of longer life expectancy means that workers can wait to get their benefits, according to Republican Study Committee's . Regardless of whether people can actually work until they are 70, raising the retirement age is effectively a benefits cut because today's workers would lose out on between three and four years of benefits. Based on the average Social Security benefit for retirees, raising the retirement age to 70 would equate to a loss of at least $65,000 in payments for the typical beneficiary. Still, with a divided Congress, for now it's unlikely that either the Democrats or Republicans could push through their changes to stabilize Social Security.