2023
SDI
Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Topic Terms › Federal Jobs Guarantee
James Olderham, 2020, “Green Jobs Guarantee, Coronavirus, and Public Sanitation,” Wright State University, , accessed 5/25/23, mw
What is the Green Job Guarantee? First, it is necessary to describe exactly how the Green Job Guarantee is intended to work, at least in a general sense. To do so, it may be most helpful to first understand the intent of a general Jobs Guarantee/ELR proposal. In general, a Federal Jobs Guarantee program could be defined as: “…a public option for jobs. It is a permanent, federally funded, and locally administered program that supplies voluntary employment opportunities on demand for all who are ready and willing to work at a living wage. While it is first and foremost a jobs program, it has the potential to be transformative by advancing the public purpose and improving working conditions, people’s everyday lives, and the economy as a whole (Tcherneva, 2018).” The general idea is that these types of jobs would generally be lower-skilled and require little training, which helps to both widen access to individuals of all skill levels and allow for people to be quickly put to work within the program. The main goal of the program is, of course, to solve the problem of less-than-full employment. Doing so would provide a boost to the economy by stimulating effective demand, and assisting in evening out the downturns of the business cycle. It is a counter-cyclical policy, very much in the Keynesian vein of thought. In addition to the practical economic goal of full employment, the policy has other expected benefits, including the establishment of a “labor standard” for the economy, inflation stabilization, a living income, and improved income distribution (Tcherneva, 2018). These benefits extend beyond the economic to improve social and general well-being among those employed by the policy and society at large. Whereas a general Job Guarantee addresses mainly the social and economic aspect of life, a Green Job Guarantee incorporates a third dimension – the ecological. In a very general sense, the Green Job Guarantee program is merely a Job Guarantee program that is specifically designed with the promotion of environmental sustainability in mind.
2023
SDI
Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Topic Terms › Federal Jobs Guarantee
Evan Mceldowney, 3-5-2021, "What is A Federal Jobs Guarantee?," Sunrise Movement, , accessed 5/25/23, mw
With so much work to be done, there’s no reason anyone in the richest country in the history of the world should be unemployed, underemployed, or working a job that isn’t in the national interest. It’s time to fulfill FDR’s promise, and Dr. King’s dream. It’s time for the government to guarantee good jobs for all.
A jobs guarantee is central to the mission of a Green New Deal and in the Green New Deal resolution already. It protects people from the risk of unemployment and establishes a labor force to do the critical work of building green infrastructure and caring for one another. It’s the best way for us to marshal the full resources of our government and people to transition our energy grid and transform our society. This year, when so many of us are un or underemployed due to COVID and the economic recession, we want to emphasize this critical component of a Green New Deal and demand the government guarantee a good job to anyone who wants one.
2023
SDI
Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Resolution › UBI – poverty target = guarantee income
Leah Hamilton, et al. 2021, “Does Frequency or Amount Matter? Testing the Perceptions of Four Universal Basic Income Proposals,” SOCIAL POLICY INSTITUTE RESEARCH, , accessed 6/16/23, mw
Economic volatility since the 2008 Great Recession and more recently, the COVID-19 pandemic has brought renewed public interest to an old idea: universal basic income (UBI). Andrew Yang, a technology entrepreneur who ran for the Democratic Party’s nomination for presidential candidate in 2020, is credited with raising awareness of UBI as a current policy option, proposing that all Americans receive $1,000 monthly. Several cities and some states have recently proposed or enacted basic income pilots. Most modern UBI proposals include three conditions: the payment should be distributed directly to individuals (rather than households), should not be means-tested, and hold no mandatory conditions (i.e. workforce or educational participation) to receive the payment (Johnson & Roberto, 2020). Put simply, UBI is “a periodic cash payment unconditionally delivered to all on an individual basis, without means-test or work requirement” (Basic Income Earth Network, 2020). However, basic income programs currently being piloted in cities such as Stockton, CA and St. Paul, MN are sometimes referred to as “guaranteed income” rather than basic income because they are means-tested to target low-income households. Whether universal or means-tested, basic income programs have no requirements for how the money is spent. That is, they may be conditional on income or not (universal), yet are unrestricted concerning benefit usage.
2023
SDI
Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Resolution › Substantially – UBI = 5 categories (Subsets)
Curtin, 2003 (John T. Curtin, Judge, United States District Court for the Western District of New York, Gateway Equipment Corp. -vs- United States of America, United States District Court for the Western District of New York, lexis)
The government cites Webster's Ninth New College Dictionary for the definitions of "limit" and "impairment" as suggesting "meanings equivalent to restriction and reduction, respectively." Item 30, p. 3, n.1. It posits that the word "substantially" suggests "an order of magnitude equivalent to 80% or 90%." Id. It concludes that "using those definitions, 'substantially limited' and 'substantially impaired' means that there must be an 80%-90% restriction and/ or reduction of use by virtue of the design of the CB-4000." Id.
2023
SDI
Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Resolution › Substantially – UBI = 5 categories (Subsets)
Rebecca Hasdell, July 2020, “WHAT WE KNOW ABOUT UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME A CROSS-SYNTHESIS OF REVIEWS,” Stanford Basic Income Lab, , accessed 6/12/23, mw
A fully universal and unconditional basic income has never been implemented at scale. However, evidence from programs, policies and experiments that share features of a UBI can be used to approximate economic, social, health and other impacts. There are a growing number of contemporary literature reviews that report on the substantial evidence base of interventions that meet at least two or more features of a UBI. Since the 1990s, there has been a proliferation of cash transfers in low- and middle-income countries and increased attention to UBI in higherincome contexts. DEFINITIONAL FEATURES OF A UBI Universal: It is paid to every individual and not targeted to a specific population Unconditional: It involves no set conditions or sanctions and is given to those who are both employed and unemployed, voluntarily or not Cash payment: It is paid in cash, which allows recipients to convert their benefits however they choose Individual: It is paid on an individual basis (versus household-based) Periodic: It is a recurring payment rather than a one-off grant
2023
SDI
Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Resolution › 1NC Fiscal Redistribution
Jeffrey A. Miron, 2011, “Rethinking Redistribution,” National Affairs, , accessed 6/15/23, mw
Whether one agrees with it or not, this popular understanding of redistribution's purpose yields some useful criteria for assessing the degree to which our redistribution programs are actually succeeding. The aims of helping the poor and minimizing harm to everyone else, in other words, offer some specific ends against which our means of redistribution can be tested. By and large, those means take three forms. First, there are direct anti-poverty programs, like Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (what we commonly think of as welfare), food stamps, Medicaid, and the Earned Income Tax Credit. Second, there is progressive taxation, which transfers wealth from richer to poorer Americans across the income distribution. And third, there are policies that tilt economic outcomes in specific markets to benefit people with lower incomes (minimum-wage laws are a classic example).
2023
SDI
Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Resolution
Dr. James Weaver, 2-28-2023, "Economic Inequality Selected as 2023-2024 National Policy Debate Topic," No Publication, , accessed 6/24/23, mw
Resolved: The United States federal government should substantially increase fiscal redistribution in the United States by adopting a federal jobs guarantee, expanding Social Security, and/or providing a basic income.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
Aff › 2AC---Biz Con worthless
Cameron Bagrie, 18, (Cameron Bagrie, 8-9-2018, Spinoff, Business confidence is a hopeless indicator. But that doesn’t mean the economy isn’t in trouble, https://thespinoff.co.nz/business/09-08-2018/business-confidence-is-bullshit-but-that-doesnt-mean-the-economy-isnt-in-trouble, 6-20-2023) SCade
Business confidence has fallen off a cliff. Economist Cameron Bagrie says it’s meaningless, but other bad indicators can’t be ignored. The economy is headed for recession if you believe the readings from business confidence. Thankfully we can largely ignore business confidence readings. We can’t ignore other survey measures though that are saying growth has slowed and the official statistics are showing the same. The last three quarterly GDP prints have been 0.6, 0.6 and 0.5% and we only have data up to March 2018. That’s annualised growth in the low 2’s and a dip below 2% now looks likely. We have the potential for a growth pothole. That is becoming a concern as the wheels of the economy need to be turning and tax revenue coming in the door for social agenda demands to be met. A whopping net 45% of firms are pessimistic about the general economy according to the ANZ Business Outlook survey. That’s a level last seen around the global financial crisis. Of course, no one really believes things are that bad. We can’t blame the global scene as other countries would be seeing massive falls in confidence too if that was a key factor. Other countries are not. The New Zealand Institute of Economic Research (NZIER) is showing weak readings for business confidence within their Quarterly Survey of Business Opinion (QSBO) too. The good news is that business confidence is hopeless as an economic indicator. The correlation with economic growth is poor and I largely ignore business confidence readings. Changes in direction can provide some insightful information – whether things are picking up or slowing down, but not the levels. Businesses tend to be more upbeat regarding general confidence about the economy under a blue flag as opposed to a red one. Business confidence averaged minus 18 between 2000 and 2007. The economy (measured by real gross domestic product) grew on average by more than 3.5% per year. Yep, confidence was negative, but growth was positive. So, we ignore business confidence as an economic indicator. This is nothing new. It’s surprising headline business confidence figures receive so much attention.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
Aff › 2AC---Link Turn---UBI Entrepreneurship
Light ‘21, Jennifer. “Universal Basic Income's Impact on Entrepreneurship.” The Jr Executive, 22 January 2021, https://www.thejrexecutive.com/post/universal-basic-income-s-impact-on-entrepreneurship. Accessed 26 June 2023. [Jennifer Light is an economic journalist for JR Executive] //QSMIT
Social entrepreneurship is the most crucial type of entrepreneurship, as it is startup companies that develop ideas and solutions to current social, cultural, and environmental issues, such as climate change. Unfortunately, entrepreneurship has been on the decline. According to the INC, “entrepreneurs have been in decline for 40 years due to fear of financial failure.” Furthermore, the Office of Advocacy explains that around one in twelve small businesses is doomed to close a year, most commonly due to low sales and restricted cash flow. To resolve the fear of failure and stimulate small businesses, a Universal Basic Income (UBI) of $1,000 a month should be implemented. Luckily, a UBI has the potential to stimulate entrepreneurship further and give businesses the push they need to start, and provide a safety net for companies. The largest concern of most small business startups is the lack of funding and spending ability. According to an NSBA study, more than 25% of small business owners say they aren’t able to obtain the funds they need to operate their business. Not only are legal fees expensive, but branding and web hosting sites are as well. According to Sammi Carmella, a writer for Business News Daily, average costs for a micro-business average around $3,000. The Journal of Small Business and Entrepreneurship quantifies that many small businesses were forced to finance through personal savings and credit cards. They explain, “over 80% of US entrepreneurs utilized personal sources of funding, accounting for 57% of all startup financing acquired during this period.” Additionally, a UBI would provide a sense of security for entrepreneurs. Blakeman explains that one of the major reasons for the decline in startups is the fear of failure. Fortunately, the Smith School of Business elaborates that a UBI eliminates one of a small businesses’ largest fears, a fear of failure. With a safety net to fall back on in times of need, it would provide entrepreneurs with the confidence necessary to continue social innovation and new product development. This is crucial for those who have less financial spending power to create a startup business, as it would alleviate the fear of failure. What does this mean in the long run for entrepreneurs and small business owners? The NSDMC explains that around 50% of businesses in the US are owned by minorities. Furthermore, these minority-owned businesses [and] pay close to $50 billion in tax revenue to the government. If these businesses don’t have the spending power to take risks and continue their startup, it could have devastating effects on the economy. Problematically, the USSC stated, “minority-owned firms are two to three times more likely to be denied credit, more likely to avoid applying for loans based on the belief that they will be turned down, and more likely to receive smaller loans and pay higher interest rates on the loans that they do receive.” This means that minority-owned businesses are less likely to have enough money to continue to grow their businesses without a UBI. The impact this has on the economy is enormous, because approximately 50% of the US GDP growth is because of increases in innovation. With no money for startups, to create businesses, and innovate, the US GDP is in trouble. However, a UBI is proven to work. Per QuantumRun, in some places where UBI was implemented, there was a 301 percent rise in entrepreneurship. There is data to show that for every 1 percentage point increase in the rate of entrepreneurship in a state, there is a 2 percent decline in the poverty rate. Therefore, with an increase in innovation, business, and an economic boost, a Universal Basic Income would result in an increase in the labor force. The Big Experience estimates over 4.6 million new estimated jobs would be created, through new business ventures.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
Aff › 2AC---Link Turn---M4A
EPI, 20, (EPI, EPI is an independent, nonprofit think tank that researches the impact of economic trends and policies on working people in the United States. EPI’s research helps policymakers, opinion leaders, advocates, journalists, and the public understand the bread-and-butter issues affecting ordinary Americans., 3-5-2020, Economic Policy Institute, Medicare for All would boost wages, expand workers’ options, and likely create jobs, https://www.epi.org/press/medicare-for-all-would-boost-wages-expand-workers-options-and-likely-create-jobs/, 6-20-2023) SCade
A new report from EPI research director Josh Bivens finds that Medicare for All would bolster the labor market, strengthen economic security for millions of U.S. households, and would likely boost the number of jobs in the U.S. labor market. Opponents of a single-payer health care system have quoted an analysis of the economic effects of Medicare for All that includes the projection that up to 1.8 million jobs in the health insurance and billing administration sector could be eliminated if the policy were implemented. Bivens notes that this number has been stripped of all context that is included in the original study, and is often misleadingly presented as the predicted net employment effect of Medicare for All. But while Medicare for All would indeed lead to lower demand for labor in the health insurance and billing administration sector, it would boost demand for other types of jobs overall. For example, expanded access to health care could increase demand for health services by up to $300 billion annually, which would translate into an increased demand for 2.3 million full-time health care workers. Further, several Medicare for All plans have provisions to pay for long-term care services, which would create jobs. In 2018, U.S. households provided roughly 34 billion hours in unpaid long-term care. If divided up among full-time workers, it would require 17 million new positions. Even if 10% of this unpaid care was converted to paid positions, it would create enough jobs to essentially offset the displacement of the health insurance and billing administration workers. Additionally, Bivens finds that Medicare for All would: Provide a potential boost to wages and salaries by allowing employers to redirect healthcare spending to workers’ wages. Increase job quality by ensuring that every job would come bundled with a guarantee of health care. Lessen the income loss, stress, and economic shock of unemployment and job transitions by eliminating the loss of health care that accompanies job-loss Support self-employment and small business development—which is low in the United States relative to other rich Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) countries—by eliminating the daunting cost of health care from startup costs. Inject new dynamism into the overall economy by reducing “job lock”, by allowing workers to go where their skills and preferences lie, not just to workplaces with affordable health plans. “A fundamental health reform like Medicare for All would be an unambiguously good policy for the labor market, for the economy overall, and for U.S. workers,” said Bivens. “Besides the obvious benefits of expanding health care to millions of uninsured and underinsured Americans, Medicare for All could raise wages, boost productivity, and help small business owners.”
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
Aff › 2AC---Link Turn---FJG
L. Randall Wray and Stephanie Kelton, 11, (L. Randall Wray and Stephanie Kelton, 9-8-2011, Truthdig, What the Country Needs Is a New New Deal, https://www.truthdig.com/articles/what-the-country-needs-is-a-new-new-deal/, 6-2-2023) SCade
The problem is that the president believes we can cure our jobless problem by providing the proper incentives to the business community. And here he is committing one of the few big policy blunders from Lyndon Johnson’s War on Poverty. Like Johnson, who focused on retraining the unemployed for jobs that did not exist, Obama has focused on incentivizing the businesses community to hire workers to produce for customers that do not exist. Time and again, Obama has shown that he will only tinker around the edges, relying on the same tired supply-side initiatives that will not work: more incentives to build business confidence, subsidies to reduce labor costs and to promote exports, and maybe even tax cuts to please Republicans. He told a Labor Day crowd in Detroit that he wants to match the more than 1 million construction workers with an infrastructure-related rebuilding program to improve the nation’s roads and bridges. That is an improvement over his efforts to date, but it falls far short of the 20-plus million jobs we need. For more than two years, we’ve listened to policy wonks weighing in on the supposed recovery, reading great importance into every tiny click of the unemployment rate, fluctuation of retail sales data, rise or fall of the Dow, and — especially — the latest measure of business confidence and expectations. Economists and policymakers alike appear to believe that if we can only improve the outlook of our entrepreneurs, they will suddenly begin hiring. All the nation needs is a bit of Prozac slipped into the martinis of the captains of industry to turn this ship around. And the Republicans warn of the depressing effects of Obamacare, Dodd-Frank regulations and EPA restrictions that damage the sentiments on Wall Street. The truth is simple and contrary to these views. Business will not hire more workers until it has more sales. Consumers will not spend more until they’ve got more jobs. A private-sector recovery requires 300,000 new jobs every month. But the private sector doesn’t need 300,000 new workers per month to meet prospective sales. The new jobs can only come from the federal government — the only economic entity that can afford to hire. Obama’s 1 million infrastructure jobs is a nice down payment, but it is only three month’s worth. New workers will create the sales that firms need to justify new hiring. Still, we must think bigger if we are to create 20 million jobs. In his last State of the Union address, President Obama eloquently summed up the longer-term challenges we face. In many ways, they are similar to those that President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s America dealt with: a nation ill-prepared for the century in which it found itself, a nation that was “ill-fed, ill-clothed, ill-housed, and insecure.” Roosevelt’s was a nation with 19th century transportation, education and health care. The New Deal, World War II and President Johnson’s extremely successful Great Society programs transformed America. But America has fallen into disrepair, and again finds itself unprepared for the new century. A new New Deal is needed, with a comprehensive jobs program to again transform America. When it comes to the health and welfare of a nation, there is no economic policy that is more important than job creation. And yet decades of experience, in nations across the globe, provide ample evidence that while the private sector plays an important role, it cannot by itself provide employment for all who want to work. There is a way to do that: The government could serve as the “employer of last resort” under a job guarantee program modeled on the WPA (the Works Progress Administration, in existence from 1935 to 1943 after being renamed the Work Projects Administration in 1939) and the CCC (Civilian Conservation Corps, 1933-1942). The program would offer a job to any American who was ready and willing to work at the federal minimum wage, plus legislated benefits. No time limits. No means testing. No minimum education or skill requirements. The program would operate like a buffer stock, absorbing and releasing workers during the economy’s natural boom-and-bust cycles. In a boom, employers would recruit workers out of the program; in a slump the safety net would allow those who had lost their jobs to continue to work to preserve good habits, making them easier to re-employ when activity picked up. The program would also take those whose education, training or job experience was initially inadequate to obtain work outside the program, enhancing their employability through on-the-job training. Work records would be maintained for all program participants and would be available for potential employers. Unemployment offices could be converted to employment offices, to match workers with jobs in the program, and to help private and public employers recruit workers. Funding for the job guarantee program must come from the federal government — and the wage should be periodically adjusted to reflect changes in the cost of living and to allow workers to share in rising national productivity so that real living standards would rise — but the administration and operation of the program should be decentralized to the state and local level. Registered not-for-profit organizations could propose projects for approval by responsible offices designated within each of the states and U.S. territories as well as the District of Columbia. Then the proposals should be submitted to the federal office for final approval and funding. To ensure transparency and accountability, the Labor Department should maintain a website providing details on all projects submitted, all projects approved and all projects started. To avoid simple “make-work” employment, project proposals could be evaluated on the following criteria: (a) value to the community; (b) value to the participants; (c) likelihood of successful implementation of project; (d) contribution to preparing workers for employment outside the program.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
Aff › 2AC---Link Turn---FJG
Jerome M. Segal, 20, (Jerome M. Segal, 5-20-2020, Medium, Segal: Pandemic Requires Federal Jobs Guarantee, https://medium.com/@JeromeSegal/segal-pandemic-requires-federal-jobs-guarantee-c205e315f223, 6-17-2023) SCade
“If we had had an Employment Guarantee in place when the pandemic hit, we could have kept unemployment under 4%. Everyone who was not in an essential industry or service and could not work from home, would have been put on extended vacation from their existing job. It would have been illegal, so long as America was under lock-down, for any company outside of bankruptcy to fire any worker. At the same time, the cost of the vacation-with-pay, would have been picked up by the Federal Government, with direct payments either to businesses or to workers themselves.” “Instead, we have had the utter chaos of underfunded, uncertain and limited paycheck protection efforts, and tens of millions of people seeking unemployment insurance after being needlessly fired from jobs they should have retained. The cost of direct vacation pay would have been less than the hodge-podge of programs that Congress enacted, well below the cost of the stimulus package.” “At the same time, a Jobs Guarantee, would have given Americans not actively engaged in work, not only the income they need, but the security that when the pandemic abates, their job would still be there. This means consumer confidence, and this in turn implies business confidence, all of which is necessary for a strong and sharp economic recovery. Instead we have today widespread uncertainty and insecurity that will weigh down the economy long after the worse of the pandemic is behind us.” “It is not too late to enact a jobs guarantee. Right now we can enact a program that will help reverse the errors we have made. With new legislation, we can provide powerful incentives for companies that have laid off workers, to immediately begin the rapid re-hiring of their work force. Those not put into active work, would still be re-hired, going from being unemployed to being on extended vacation. The Federal government would assume this cost until workers were actually back on the job. Immediately, unemployment status would be ended for millions of workers. This would provide the 36 million unemployed not only with income security but with confidence in the future. And this in turn would limit pressure to re-open the economy prematurely.”
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
Aff › 2AC---Thumper---Labor (Old People)
Emily Peck, 23, (Emily Peck, 5-8-2023, Axios, Even the hot U.S. job market can't solve America's labor shortage, https://www.axios.com/2023/05/08/us-labor-shortage-older-workers, 6-21-2023) SCade
More and more Americans are getting too old to work. Why it matters: Even if the job market cools off from its current hotness, that could mean labor shortages will be with us for the long term. State of play: Declining fertility rates, and increasing life expectancy, is expected to lead to a drop in working-age populations across all G20 countries, according to projections cited in a recent report from Moody's Investors Service. "Korea, Germany and the U.S. are expected to see the sharpest declines over the next decade," Moody's states. Driving the news: The job market is still going strong, per the latest nonfarm payrolls report from the Labor Department. So-called "prime-age" workers are indeed working. The labor force participation rate among those age 25–53 is now at 83.3% — slightly higher than where it was in February 2020. But overall labor force participation — that is the share of the total population either working or looking for work — is still slightly lower than where it was then. That's partly to do with more older workers retiring. The big picture: The percentage of Americans age 55 and over has doubled over the last 20 years, as this 2020 paper notes, and that population (the baby boomers) is expected to grow. And while certainly many older Americans are working longer than ever before, they still do retire at some point. This was a demographic trend in place long before COVID-19 but was accelerated by the pandemic, which pushed many older workers into retirement. Moody's estimates that 70% of the decline in labor force participation since the end of 2019 was due to aging workers — about 1.4 million additional Americans retired.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
Aff › 2AC---Thumper---Rates
Guida 06-12, Victoria. “Fed poised for respite on rate hikes. Now the hurt begins.” Politico, 12 June 2023, https://www.politico.com/news/2023/06/12/fed-rate-hikes-pause-00101349. Accessed 26 June 2023. [Victoria Guida is an economics reporter covering the Federal Reserve, the Treasury Department and the broader economy.] //QSMIT
Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell is expected to pause his yearlong campaign of jacking up interest rates to curb inflation, offering a reprieve to consumers and businesses. But for many Americans, the pain from the Fed’s efforts to squeeze borrowing costs may only be beginning. Wall Street investors, who until just weeks ago were betting that Powell would start cutting rates in the coming months, are now expecting the Fed to keep costs high through at least the rest of the year, as both the job market and inflation have stayed stronger than expected. While the resilient economy has offered President Joe Biden a key talking point for his reelection, the prospect that high rates will continue to weigh on indebted households and firms as the race heats up could undercut his message of optimism. It could also shake public confidence by triggering the demise of more banks or other vulnerable businesses as the year wears on. “Keeping rates at these levels will pull more skeletons out of the closet,” said Laura Rosner-Warburton, a senior official at MacroPolicy Perspectives and a former staffer at the New York Fed. On the one hand, the central bank’s cautious approach increases the odds that the economy could slow gradually rather than sharply drop into recession — pulling off a so-called soft landing that would be a boon to Biden’s chances. But it also underscores how confounding the economy has been for central bank policymakers.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
Aff › 2AC---Thumper---Rates
David Payne, 23, (David Payne, 6-16-2023, Kiplinger, Kiplinger’s Interest Rates Outlook: Fed Pauses, But Is Not Done Raising Rates, https://www.kiplinger.com/economic-forecasts/interest-rates, 6-21-2023) SCade
Powell emphasized that rate hikes may NOT be over, however. In fact, rate projections by other members of the policy-making committee and the Board suggested that participants thought an average of two more quarter-point hikes may be necessary before the end of the year. The main reason given was that price inflation in the non-housing services sector of the economy (known as “core services”) is stubbornly high, and to bring it down might require additional slowing of the economy and easing in the labor market. As usual, Powell said that a decision on further hikes would be deferred to future meetings, the next of which is July 26.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
Aff › 2AC---Thumper---Inflation
Kristin Schwab, 23, (Kristin Schwab, 6-13-2023, Marketplace, We're in the stubborn phase of inflation cooling, https://www.marketplace.org/2023/06/13/were-in-the-stubborn-phase-of-inflation-cooling/, 6-21-2023) SCade
May’s consumer price index, released Tuesday, shows that inflation rose 4% last month from a year earlier. While that’s well below its peak of more than 9% last June, there’s a ways to go before the Federal Reserve reaches its target of 2% inflation. We’ve gotten to the part of the inflation journey where the Fed is trying to squeeze the last bits out of the toothpaste tube. But it’s slow going, according to David Wilcox, an economist at the Peterson Institute for International Economics and Bloomberg Economics. “The pathway ahead looks like it will take longer than anyone would prefer,” he said. Why? Well, it’s partly because when it comes to inflation, the most obvious and temporary problems tend to sort themselves out first: the pandemic and all the erratic consumer spending during its different phases, the initial shock to oil prices because of the war in Ukraine. Plus, “the supply chain issues that everyone talks about,” said economist Linda Hooks at Washington and Lee University. Now that those have mostly subsided, “the Federal Reserve is working with some very broad tools, and they’re aiming for a very small target,” she said. That’s tricky since a smaller target requires better aim. “What’s left is both the continued tight labor market and the underlying inertia of wages and prices,” said Jason Furman, an economist at Harvard University. Underlying inertia is what’s making this leg of the inflation journey so sticky. We’ve been here for so long that businesses have come to expect prices to rise every month.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
Aff › 2AC---UQ---Biz Con Destroyed
BW, 23, (BW, 5-24-2023, Business Wire, Confidence Among Small to Midsize Businesses Waning Amid Economic Downturn, https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20230524005199/en/Confidence-Among-Small-to-Midsize-Businesses-Waning-Amid-Economic-Downturn, 6-21-2023) SCade
The index depicts a sharp rise in business owners who are concerned about retaining their full staff over the next quarter, as layoffs persist despite relatively strong month-over-month hiring data. Almost half of respondents (48%) listed employee retention as a top concern, up 25% from Q1. Retaining employee headcount trailed worries about a recession (62%) and having enough skilled workers on staff (56%) as the most common concerns, with layoffs across many sectors continuing due to tightening credit conditions and inflation remaining stubbornly high. “There’s a lagging effect to last year’s interest rate hikes,” said Anna Rathbun, chief investment officer of CBIZ Investment Advisory Services. “The latest CBIZ Main Street Index shows the Fed’s actions, along with other factors, are starting to open more cracks in the foundation of the economy. A recession is like a zero-sum game. There will be winners and losers. We’re going to be keeping a close eye on the small and midsize businesses that are poised to do well during the downturn. The coming months will test the durability and savviness of business owners, especially those in industries that are not recession-proof.” Based on a survey conducted between April 24 and May 5, the index analyzed responses from 753 businesses with fewer than 100 employees in 31 industries across the U.S.* The index assesses a range of timely trends, including business sentiment, areas of growth and decline, and price changes due to inflation and inventory levels. The data was evaluated from an overall perspective, as well as based on company size, region and industry. An interactive infographic with the results is available on the CBIZ website. Key findings include: 51% of respondents have a negative or neutral outlook on the economy: As multiple economic indicators point to a slowing economy, the index revealed that only 49% of respondents reported positive or very positive business confidence over the next six months. Additionally, more than seven in 10 expected a further downturn in the economy, on par with last quarter’s survey. Sharp rise in concerns about employee retention amid unsettled labor market: A rising number of businesses are concerned about retaining employees amid a labor market that is experiencing steady hiring but also layoffs across many sectors. More than 48% of respondents listed employee retention as one of their key concerns this quarter. Over 75% of companies raised prices of goods and services in the last quarter: More than three in four businesses reported price increases by at least 1% over the past three months, up from 72% in Q1, due to high inflation remaining persistent, low inventory levels or other factors. Additionally, more than 55% of businesses said they’ve raised prices by 5% or more. Rising interest rates are having a greater impact on business funding: Twenty-seven percent of respondents said higher interest rates have impacted the funding needs of their businesses, up from 17% in the first quarter. Meanwhile, 64% of companies reported experiencing higher borrowing costs, a figure that remains unchanged from last quarter.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
Aff › 2AC---UQ---Biz Con Destroyed
Matthew Medsger, 23, (Matthew Medsger, Matthew Medsger is a Boston Herald reporter covering politics and the State House, or anything else which may occur. Matthew also reported on the environment and science at the Nashua Telegraph and crime at the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review. , 6-5-2023, Boston Herald, Business confidence turns pessimistic for the first time since 2020, https://www.bostonherald.com/2023/06/05/business-confidence-turns-pessimistic-for-the-first-time-since-2020/, 6-20-2023) SCade
Business confidence among the state’s employers fell last month to the lowest level seen since the height of the pandemic, according to a recent survey of Massachusetts employers. The Associated Industries of Massachusetts, in its monthly Business Confidence Index, says Massachusetts business owners’ faith in the economy plunged half-a-point in May, dropping from 50.1% to 49.6% and continuing a downward trend that first began in November. And while a half point may not sound like a lot, the move is significant as a reading below 50 indicates a pessimistic outlook. “Massachusetts employers turned pessimistic about the economy for the first time since December 2020 last month as the state economy slowed to a crawl and the Federal Reserve continued to raise interest rates,” the survey reads, in part. The index, taken well ahead of Friday’s unexpected report from the Bureau of Labor Statistics showing the economy had added a further 339,000 jobs and before President Biden’s negotiated deal to suspend the debt ceiling until 2025 had cleared Congress, reflects an ongoing concern among employers that the nation may be barreling toward economic recession or policy driven calamity. “Businesses have been stung by both stubbornly high inflation and persistently high interest rates, which have dampened demand and raised costs. It’s unfortunately not surprising that the Future Index indicates that business leaders expect these conditions to worsen further,” Michael Tyler, Chief Investment Officer at Eastern Bank Wealth Management and Vice Chair of AIM’s Board of Economic Advisors said with the survey’s release. “Thankfully, a possible recession would likely be shallow and short, cushioned by a strong jobs market and healthy consumer spending,” Tyler said. Though circumstances may have seemed particularly dire to business owners as of last month, according AIM President John Regan, doing away with concerns of a U.S. default and the consequences of what might follow will hopefully put the minds of employers at ease. “The President and Congress did the right thing in hammering out an agreement that will maintain the stability of the global financial system. Employers need all the predictability they can get as the economy continues to slow down,” Regan said. Friday’s jobs report also showed a slight uptick in the unemployment rate, which has Fed watchers wondering if the economy has slowed enough that Federal Reserve Chair Jay Powell could consider a pause in the central bank’s on-going crusade against inflation via raises to the key interest rate, an eleventh of which may or may not materialize out of June’s meeting of the Board of Governors. AIM surveys more than 140 Bay State businesses to produce their monthly index, the first of which was published in July of 1991. According to AIM, business confidence hit historic highs in 1997 and 1998, with two months in either year showing 68.5% confidence, and hit a low in February of 2009, when it was 33.3%.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
2NC › Impact › 2NC---A2: No Impact
Gallea and Rohner 21 – Quentin, PhD, postdoctoral researcher in political economy at the University of Zürich. Dominic, Faculty of Business and Economics, University of Lausanne. “Globalization mitigates the risk of conflict caused by strategic territory”, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Vol. 118, No. 39, , 09-28-2021
This contrasts with an intellectual tradition of arguing that globalization, business, and trade may—by fostering interdependence—curb the incentives for engaging in domestic and international conflicts. This argument has its roots ranging as far back as the thinking of De Montesquieu [1758 (2)] or Angell [1909 (3)], has been refined verbally by an array of “liberalist” scholars in international relations (see the survey in ref. 4), and has recently been scrutinized in formal game-theoretical models (see, e.g., refs. 5 and 6).
While a small body of empirical research has linked trade to interstate wars (4, 5, 7, 8), the arguably even more pressing question of how globalization and trade affect domestic conflicts has received even less attention.† This is a major gap in the literature, given that since World War II, roughly 80 to 90% of wars have been within rather than between states (11). Hence, the goal of the current article is to study the question of how places close to strategically important trade routes may be more or less subject to civil conflict and how their fate is affected by surges in globalization.‡
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
2NC › Impact › 2NC---A2: No Impact
Elise Labott, 21, (Elise Labott, Elise Labott, a columnist at Foreign Policy and an adjunct professor at American University’s School of International Service., 7-22-2021, Foreign Policy, Get Ready for a Spike in Global Unrest, https://foreignpolicy.com/2021/07/22/covid-global-unrest-political-upheaval/, 6-21-2023) SCade
To call 2021 the summer of discontent would be a severe understatement. From Cuba to South Africa to Colombia to Haiti, often violent protests are sweeping every corner of the globe as angry citizens are taking to the streets. Each country has different histories and realities on the ground, particularly in Haiti, where years of violence and government corruption culminated two weeks ago in the assassination of President Jovenel Moïse. But they all faced a perfect storm of preexisting social, economic, and political hardships, which fallout from the COVID-19 pandemic only inflamed further. And they are merely a foreshadowing of the post-coronavirus global tinderbox that’s looming as existing tensions in countries across the world morph into broader civil unrest and uprisings against economic hardships and inequality deepened by the pandemic. It has also exposed weaknesses in food security and dramatically increased the number of people affected by chronic hunger. The United Nations estimates around one-tenth of the global population—between 720 million people and 811 million—were undernourished last year. The impacts of climate change and environmental degradation have only compounded the despair. Take the Sahel, where, due to a toxic cocktail of conflict, COVID-19 lockdowns, and climate change, the scale and severity of food insecurity continues to rise. Countries such as Ethiopia and Sudan are among the world’s worst humanitarian crises, with catastrophic levels of hunger. Droughts and locusts are coming at a critical time for farmers ready to plant crops and are stopping herders in their tracks from driving their livestock to greener pastures. The global vaccine shortage is fueling the instability. A majority of Africa is lagging far behind the world in vaccinations, meaning COVID-19 will continue to constrain national economies and, in turn, become a source of potential political instability. The same is true for much of Latin America and Asia, where countries don’t have enough vaccines to protect their populations and simmering sources of protest—such as rising living costs and deepening inequalities—are more likely to boil over. The global risk firm Verisk Maplecroft has warned that as many as 37 countries could face large protest movements for up to three years. A new study by Mercy Corps examining the intersection of COVID-19 and conflict found concerning trends that warn of potential for new conflict, deepening existing conflict, and worsening insecurity and instability shaped by the pandemic response. The group found a collapse of public confidence in governments and institutions was a key driver of instability. People in fragile states, already suffering from diminished trust in their government, have felt further abandoned as they face disruptions in public services, rising food prices, and massive economic hardships, such as unemployment and reduced wages. Supply chains disrupted during the pandemic have seen food prices skyrocket, while in the global recession humanitarian aid budgets are being slashed, bringing many countries to the brink of famine. For the first time in 22 years, extreme poverty—people living on less than $1.90 a day—was on the rise last year. Oxfam International estimates that “it could take more than a decade for the world’s poorest to recover from the economic impacts of the pandemic.” The shocks caused by the pandemic have also eroded social cohesion, further fraying relations between communities and deepening polarization. That is especially true in the United States, where social and political pressures both deepened the health crisis and were themselves worsened by it. All of this should serve as a clarion call to countries that they can’t prepare for, or respond to, future health crises in a vacuum—but must anticipate an economic, political, and social crisis. This is true for any severe shock, which brings the potential for a breakdown in public order.