2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › Turn – Renewables solve prices
Mike Jacobs is leading the Union of Concerned Scientists’s work on electricity markets and regulatory reform. More Fossil Natural Gas Won’t Lower High Energy Bills December 5, 2022 | 3:53 pm https://blog.ucsusa.org/mike-jacobs/more-fossil-natural-gas-wont-lower-high-energy-bills/
Adding more renewable energy, either at home or in the utility supply mix, would reduce consumer risk of having to pay higher costs. That reduction comes from the fixed-cost nature of renewables. Once a wind farm or solar project is built and financed, the cost is not going to change for a given quantity of energy produced from that project. If that quantity is only 10 percent of the supply, then high gas prices will affect 10 percent less of the energy purchased. If the renewable supply is 60 percent of the supply, the quantity impacted by the price spike is 60 percent lower. Let me explain with an illustration. Say prices rise $100 per megawatt hour (MWh) above the usual ~$35 per MWh, and the demand for electricity is 1,000 MWh per day. If all that was supplied by fossil natural gas—which has no price stability—consumers would pay $100,000 more than the norm each day. But if 60 percent of supply came from wind and solar, and only 40 percent is subject to the price spike, consumers would pay $40,000 each day above the usual amount.
Current system risks our energy security – clean energy transition solves energy prices
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › Turn – Renewables solve prices
Jaeger, et.al., 2022 , , and January 24, 2022 Renewable Energy Shouldn’t Be Blamed for Spiking Energy Prices — It's the Solution
One advantage of renewable energy is that the power prices are generally stable. Once the solar and wind farms are built, all they need is the sun or the wind. In contrast, electricity from gas or coal requires continuous fuel supply, which is vulnerable to disruptions in production and transport. Fossil fuel price spikes like this have happened before and will happen again. Meanwhile, the costs of solar have 85% since 2010 and the costs of both onshore and offshore wind have dropped about 50%. For residential or commercial energy users, investing in renewable energy, energy efficiency or other climate-friendly technologies can be a buffer against the market forces that affect fossil fuels. European households equipped with solar panels are an average of 60% on their monthly electricity bills during this crisis. Meanwhile, in the U.S., households heated with electricity will be largely unaffected by the crisis, only expected to see a increase in their bills compared to last year, while households heated with natural gas are expected to spend 30% more. Increased investment in renewable energy will increase supply and reduce prices. According to the IEA, if the world invests enough in clean energy to reach net-zero emissions, average household energy bills in advanced economies will be in 2030 and 2050 than they are today. This is not to mention that renewable energy creates than fossil fuels.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › Turn – Renewables solve prices
October 12, 2022 Can renewables solve the inflation crisis? https://www.energymonitor.ai/finance/regulation-policy/can-renewable-energy-solve-the-inflation-crisis/
For people across Europe and North America, life has suddenly become a lot more expensive. Energy costs are rising rapidly, and that in turn is driving inflation, which increases the price of everyday goods. According to , fossil fuel energy systems are a large and volatile component of common measures of inflation. The price increase of energy commodities and services has been larger than any other item in the US . Governments around the world are as citizens demand action to tackle inflation. In the US, President Biden chose to rename his infrastructure and climate package the . The reality is that policymakers have limited tools to deal with inflation directly. Much of the focus has been on monetary policy, with central banks raising interest rates and injecting large amounts of cash into the economy through borrowing, such as Germany’s €200bn energy self-bailout or Britain’s £200bn for tax cuts and . However, according to the Roosevelt Institute, governments and central banks have little power to mitigate the type of inflation we are experiencing now, which is driven by fossil fuel prices. The solution, it says, is to deal with the ongoing energy price volatility through government-led investment in renewable energy production and deployment. Energy-driven inflation “In our paper [which came out before the Inflation Reduction Act] we argue that a robust clean energy investment should be designed to prioritise low-income and frontline communities for a price stabilising effect from [that] investment in renewables,” says Kristina Karlsson, co-author of the Roosevelt Institute report. She notes that the perverse effect of energy-driven inflation is that it hurts low-income households most, because they are most exposed to . “Low-income households consume the least fossil fuels but are most exposed to price fluctuations,” she says. “Energy prices are the highest proportion of their household costs.” It is not unusual for inflation to be driven by energy costs. are a key driver of overall inflation and have historically triggered recessions, according to the report. The researchers make the argument that a transition away from fossil fuels towards renewables will have a stabilising effect on energy prices, for two reasons. First, renewable energy will bring the majority of energy consumption into the electricity sector, a highly regulated sector that has historically produced stable energy prices. Second, renewables prices are inherently stable compared with fossil fuels, and the EU is looking to that will give them more comparative stability. The clean energy transition would also improve existing inequities in energy burdens among renters, and among low-income and minority households, the Roosevelt Institute researchers argue.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › N/U: Prices high now
Naureen S Malik, Malik is an Energy Reporter at Bloomberg who is also affiliated with Dow Jones Newswires and New York University. 9-13-2022, "US Power Prices Rise Most in 41 Years as Inflation Endures," Bloomberg,
August electricity bills for US consumers jumped the most since 1981, gaining 15.8% from the same period a year ago, according to the US Bureau of Labor Statistics.Natural gas bills, which crept back up last month after dipping in July, surged 33% from the same month last year, labor released Tuesday showed. Broader energy costs for a second consecutive month because of lower gasoline and fuel oil prices. Even with that drop, total energy costs were still about 24% above August 2021 levels.Electricity costs are relentlessly climbing because prices for the two biggest power-plant fuels -- natural gas and coal -- have surged in the last year as the US economy rebounds from the pandemic and as Russia’s war in Ukraine triggers an energy crisis in Europe. Another factor is the hot and humid summer across most of the lower 48 states drove households and businesses to crank up air conditioners. Americans likely used a record amount of power in the third quarter, according to US Energy Information Administration projections.New York’s state grid operator warned of a “sharp rise in wholesale electric costs expected this winter” with spiking global demand for fossil fuels, lagging supply and instability from Russia’s war in Ukraine driving up oil and gas prices, according to a Tuesday . Geopolitical factors are ultimately reflected in wholesale electricity prices and supply charges to consumer bills, the New York Independent System Operator said. Electricity price futures for this winter have increased fourfold from last year, with prices averaging near $200 a megawatt-hour, the grid operator said. That has been driven by natural gas futures for the upcoming winter, which are more than double current prices to nearly $20 per million British thermal units.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › N/U: Prices high now
Ivan Penn,Ivan Penn is a Los Angeles-based reporter covering alternative energy. Before coming to The New York Times in 2018 he covered utility and energy issues for nearly eight years at The Tampa Bay Times and then The Los Angeles Times. 1-4-2023, "Why Are Energy Prices So High? Some Experts Blame Deregulation.,"
Competition ought to have driven down the price of energy, but it has effectively left consumers paying more for power that should have been relatively cheap, said Tyson Slocum, who directs the energy program at Public Citizen, a research and advocacy group founded by Ralph Nader. “These markets are actually not very efficient. They’re not always the least-cost option.”Two economics professors reached a similar conclusion in a December about electricity markets. “We find that the higher markups charged by generation companies more than offset the efficiency gains, leading to higher wholesale prices,” wrote the researchers, Alexander MacKay of Harvard and Ignacia Mercadal of the University of Florida.One former state energy regulator, Brien Sheahan, who was chairman of the Illinois Commerce Commission, said energy costs could continue rising rapidly in the coming years, partly because utilities will spend hundreds of billions of dollars on the grid to address climate change and contend with more devastating weather extremes. While that spending could eventually lead to savings and a more reliable grid, it will probably drive up rates in the short term.Mr. Sheahan said costs were likely to rise more in deregulated states, like Illinois, because there will be fewer checks and balances on how utilities spend money than in regulated states. “It’s just going to get worse and worse and worse,” he said.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › N/U: Prices high now
Adam A. Millsap, 3-9-2023, "High Electricity Prices Will Go Even Higher Unless We Change Course," Forbes, , 7-2-2023, //mduff
Inflation remains stubbornly high despite the Federal Reserve’s interest rate increases. Energy has been one of the biggest drivers of inflation: It is up 8.7% over the last year. Even with the mild winter, electricity and natural gas prices are squeezing consumers in many parts of the country. Bringing energy prices down and keeping them low requires prudent investments in energy supplies and transmission lines. Sadly, the Biden administration and several state governments are making such investments harder, not easier. Electricity prices are up nationwide, but some places are really feeling the pain. As the figure below shows, electricity prices per kilowatt-hour (KWH) started increasing in nearly every part of the country by early 2022. In the New England Census Division—which includes Connecticut, Rhode Island, Massachusetts, Vermont, New Hampshire, and Maine—the already high price of electricity was 57% higher in January 2023 than in January 2021. The West South Central Division experienced the second largest price increase, up 36%, over the same period. The smallest increase was in the West North Central, where the price increased by only 7%. We need to generate more energy to keep prices low and stable. The Biden administration has focused on expanding the supply of wind and solar energy. The Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act earmarked billions of dollars to fund R&D, subsidized loans, and tax breaks for wind and solar projects. Wind and solar energy can be a useful part of the energy grid, but on their own they will not generate the energy Americans expect. In a recent essay, Paul Bonifas and Timothy J. Considine explain why variable renewable energy (VRE) sources like wind and solar cannot support the U.S. power grid. Unlike dispatchable energy sources—which can be ramped up or down depending on demand and include natural gas, nuclear, and coal plants—VREs require specific conditions to operate, namely sunny weather and wind. This creates some problems. First, the wind and the sun are somewhat finicky and are not always around when we want them. Grids that rely on wind and solar need back-up dispatchable sources of energy that can smooth out daily weather fluctuations. Second, peak energy demand typically occurs in the late afternoon or early evening, but peak solar generation usually occurs a few hours earlier while peak wind generation normally occurs at night. Again, this means that the mismatch between supply and demand needs to be corrected by dispatchable sources or wind and solar energy that is either stored or generated somewhere else and transmitted to where it is needed.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › N/U: Prices high now
and Commentary — 02 June 2023 Did affordability measures help tame energy price spikes for consumers in major economies? https://www.iea.org/commentaries/did-affordability-measures-help-tame-energy-price-spikes-for-consumers-in-major-economies
Households also faced record energy costs, though the price spikes were less extreme than those on wholesale markets. Long-term contracts, financial hedging and utilities' ability to amortise costs already prevented price spikes in global fuel markets from fully cascading to consumers, especially in the power sector where generation represents less than half of total electricity cost. Still, affordability measures played a sizeable role in 2022. Governments mobilised nearly to shield consumers from high prices. At least ten major economies directly stepped-in to control energy prices, by compensating utilities directly for losses or by temporarily cutting taxes and charges on energy. Nonetheless, retail natural gas prices increased by at least 30% in major European economies and in the United States in 2022. In the United Kingdom, where government measures focused on bill rebates rather than reduced taxes and charges, households had to pay 90% more per unit of gas.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › N/U: Prices high now
Statista Research Department, 6-28-2023, "U.S. retail electricity prices 2022," Statista, https://www.statista.com/statistics/183700/us-average-retail-electricity-price-since-1990//Jmorg
The retail price for electricity in the United States stood at an average of 12.5 U.S. dollar cents per kilowatt-hour in 2022. This is the highest figure reported in the indicated period and represents a year-over-year growth of over 12 percent. Nevertheless, the U.S. still has one of the lowest electricity prices worldwide. As a major producer of primary energy, respective energy prices are lower than in countries that are more reliant on imports or impose higher taxes. Prices development influenced by consumer sector When Thomas Edison developed a system to generate and distribute electricity, he would have known little about the dramatic impact his invention would create on civilization. In 21st Century America, electric power is omnipresent in people’s lives, as electricity powers factories, shops, homes, and even cars. On average, retail electricity prices in the U.S. grew by over 60 percent since the beginning of the century. However, not every sector has been affected equally by the said price increase. U.S. electricity prices for residential customers saw a much steeper increase in the period, while industrial prices remained relatively constant in the past decade. Reasons for increases in electricity prices The rising prices are justified by the costs of power production and power grid maintenance. Although the production cost of electricity generated from coal, natural gas, and nuclear sources remained relatively stable, the integration of renewable energy sources, investments in smart grid technologies, growing peak demand, power blackouts caused by natural disasters, and the global energy crisis in 2022 continued to trouble the electric utility industry in recent years. Average U.S. electricity prices per state can also vary widely, with Hawaii residents experiencing some of the highest rates in the country
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › N/U: Prices high now
Enbridge, Energy prices expected to stay at historic highs through 2023 July 27, 2022 https://www.enbridge.com/projects-and-infrastructure/public-awareness/line-5-newsroom/energy-prices-expected-to-stay-at-historic-highs-through-2023
Energy prices, including oil, natural gas, coal and electricity, will remain historically high through 2023, according to the . Released in June, the report indicates a variety of contributing factors, including geopolitical uncertainties and tight inventories. “Although we expect the current upward pressure on energy prices to lessen, high energy prices will likely remain prevalent in the United States this year and next,” said EIA administrator Joe DeCarolis.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › N/U: Prices high now
Medora Lee USA TODAY Jan 25 2023 Electricity bills may continue to shock you even as overall inflation eases. Here's why. https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/personalfinance/2023/01/24/electricity-prices-inflation/11089430002/
While price hikes for gas, furniture, electronics and clothes are slowing down after a long stretch of sharp gains, one costly item isn't expected to get cheaper anytime soon: electricity. Economists say consumers should expect their electric bills to continue rising at a fast pace as liquified natural gas, a key fuel for generating electricity, remains in short supply in the U.S. and companies' operating costs rise. Average U.S. electricity prices could rise at a 10% clip again this year and possibly next, predicts Mark Wolfe, director of the National Energy Assistance Directors Association, even though to between 3% and 4% by year-end. Electricity rates in Illinois, for example, could continue to surge following a rise last year. The utility ComEd has asked state regulators for a over the next four years, starting in 2024. If that next round of hikes wins approval, household electric bills in Illinois would increase by an average of $4.25 a month each year, for a cumulative increase of $17 a month by 2027. That means rates there will have more than doubled since 2012, according to the Illinois Public Interest Research Group, a nonprofit advocacy group. Electricity rates are also rising elsewhere. While Illinois saw the third-largest percentage increase (32%) last year, New Hampshire and Hawaii took the top two spots at 40% and 38%, according to a survey released earlier this month by Texas electric power company Payless Power. “It’s fair to say, in aggregate, we’ll see upward pressure for 2023 on the cost consumers pay for electricity,” said Dallas Federal Reserve economist Jesse Thompson.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Block Extension › Framing XT
Murphy, Michaels, & Knappenberger 2017—Robert P. Murphy a Research Assistant Professor at Texas Tech University and a Senior Economist at the Institute for Energy Research // Patrick J. Michaels Director of Cato’s Center for the Study of Science // Paul C. Knappenberger Assistant Director of Cato’s Center for the Study of Science [“The Case Against a U.S. Carbon Tax,” Policy Analysis at Cato, No. 801, https://object.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/pubs/pdf/pa801.pdf]
“Fat Tails” and Carbon Taxes as Insurance? As a postscript to those observations, we note that the leaders in the pro–carbon tax camp are abandoning traditional cost-benefit analysis, claiming its use is inappropriate in the context of climate change. One reason given for this is concern over “fat tails”—concern that climate change could result in damages far greater than what is currently considered likely. Worries about fat tails lead some carbon tax proponents, like Harvard economist Martin Weitzman, to argue that, instead of treating a carbon tax as a policy response to a given (and known) negative externality, it should be considered a form of insurance pertaining to a catastrophe that might happen but with unknown likelihood.31 But that argument poses some serious problems. The most obvious is that the utility of such “insurance” is declining, given the emerging evidence that very large warming is unlikely. Beyond that, the whole purpose of the periodic IPCC reports was to produce a compilation of the consensus research to guide policymakers. But Weitzman and others argue that policymakers should be concerned about what we don’t know.32 That argument certainly has some merit, but, as economist David R. Henderson points out, broad-based uncertainty cuts both ways in the climate change policy debate. For example, it is possible that the Earth is headed into a period of prolonged cooling, in which case offsetting anthropogenic warming would be beneficial—meaning that a carbon tax would be undesirable.33 So why should one unlikely but troubling scenario shape our policy thinking but another unlikely but troubling scenario be ignored? Another problem with Weitzman’s approach—as Nordhaus, among other critics, has pointed out34—is that it could be used to justify aggressive and costly policies against several low-probability catastrophic risks, including asteroid strikes, rogue artificial intelligence developments, and bioweapons. After all, we can’t rule out humanity’s destruction from a genetically engineered virus in the year 2100, and what’s worse we are not even sure how to construct the probability distribution on such events. Yet few people would argue that we should forfeit 5 percent of global output to reduce the likelihood of one of the latter improbable catastrophes. Why then do some people make that argument about climate change? That question leads to another problem with the insurance analogy. With actual insurance, the risks are well known and quantifiable, and competition among insurers provides rates that are reasonable for the damages involved. Furthermore, for all practical purposes, buying insurance eliminates the (financial) risk. Yet, to be analogous to the type of insurance that Weitzman and others are advocating, a homeowner would be told that a roving gang of arsonists might, decades from now, set his home on fire, that a fire policy would cost 5 percent of income every year until then, and that, even if the house were struck by the arsonists, the company would indemnify the owner for only some of the damages. Who would buy such an insurance policy?
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Block Extension › Turns Case – Warming
Brad Plumer, 22, (Brad Plumer, Brad Plumer is a climate reporter specializing in policy and technology efforts to cut carbon dioxide emissions. At The Times, he has also covered international climate talks and the changing energy landscape in the United States. 2-2-2022, NYT, How Spiking Energy Prices Complicate the Fight Against Global Warming (Published 2022), https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/02/climate/oil-gas-prices-climate-change.html, 6-30-2023) SCade
There are also signs the gas crunch could undermine unity within the European Union over policies to fight climate change. Officials are currently debating a sweeping new set of clean-energy measures aimed at cutting emissions by 2030. Some nations, like Spain, have called for a faster shift away from fossil fuels to reduce Europe’s exposure to gas markets. But others, like Poland, have urged a delay in stricter climate action amid the crisis. And there’s the possibility that skyrocketing energy prices could bolster unrest akin to the “Yellow Vests” protests in 2018, which forced the French government to backtrack on plans to increase fuel taxes as a way to reduce emissions.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Block Extension › Turns Case – Warming
Brad Plumer, 22, (Brad Plumer, Brad Plumer is a climate reporter specializing in policy and technology efforts to cut carbon dioxide emissions. At The Times, he has also covered international climate talks and the changing energy landscape in the United States. 2-2-2022, NYT, How Spiking Energy Prices Complicate the Fight Against Global Warming (Published 2022), https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/02/climate/oil-gas-prices-climate-change.html, 6-30-2023) SCade
WASHINGTON — While world leaders have vowed to scale back the use of fossil fuels to help keep a lid on global warming, a drastic upheaval in the markets for oil, natural gas and coal could complicate the shift toward cleaner sources of energy. Global oil prices have soared to their highest level in seven years, nearing $90 per barrel, as fears grow of a Russian invasion of Ukraine. Europe is in the grips of a severe natural gas crunch that has roiled energy markets worldwide. And global demand for coal, the dirtiest of all fossil fuels, has surged to record highs as economies bounce back from pandemic lows. There’s a broader lesson here, energy experts said. Even as governments and businesses invest in low-carbon energy sources like wind and solar power, the world will remain deeply reliant on fossil fuels for years to come. Unless that transition is carefully managed, many countries could face volatile energy prices and other disruptions that, in turn, threaten to undermine support for policies to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Block Extension › Turns Case – Warming
Avi Salzman, 21, (Avi Salzman, 10-11-2021, Higher Energy Prices Are Bad News for the Environment, https://www.barrons.com/articles/higher-energy-prices-environment-51633976555, 6-30-2023) SCade
The power crunch causing energy prices to rise around the world is bad news for consumers, who will have to pay higher bills for electricity and heating. And it’s bad for the environment too, as countries and states turn to old pollution-heavy sources to bolster their power supply. Natural-gas prices in Europe and Asia hit record levels in the past week, and are at multiyear highs in the U.S. A decline in gas production and low levels of gas in storage have caused supplies to run short. The consequences could impact the environment. After starting the year by reducing coal production to meet climate goals, China has ramped it back up in order to make sure the country has enough power this winter. Coal mines in China’s Inner Mongolia region were reportedly ordered to increase production by 55%. There’s been a shift toward coal in some parts of Europe, too. The Utilities Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLU) was down 1.2% on Monday, but remains up 4.7% year to date. California, which has been ahead of other states in transitioning energy production to renewable sources, is considering adding more fossil-fuel capacity, at least for the short term. The California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) has issued two proposals that would expand the allowable natural-gas storage capacity at Southern California Gas Co.’s Aliso Canyon facility near Los Angeles. The proposals are designed to help the state cope with low gas supplies heading into the winter. A leak at that facility in 2015 forced thousands of people to be evacuated and caused gas emissions that some scientists said were worse for the climate than even the Deepwater Horizon explosion. L.A.’s city council has called on the governor to shut it down, but it now looks like the Aliso Canyon plant will become more important to state electricity needs in the near term. Some fossil-fuel industry proponents argue that the crunch shows that carbon-producing energy sources can’t be phased out quite so quickly. Fossil fuels are increasingly filling a void when renewables fall short, one coal executive said. “We’ve seen in the German power market in the last few weeks renewable power, which normally would contribute 55% of the German electricity mix only producing 35%,” said XCoal Energy and Resources CEO Ernie Thrasher in an interview with Daniel Yergin, vice chairman of IHS Markit. “So that void has to be filled by fossil fuels or other forms of energy, and the Germans are turning to coal for that.”
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Block Extension › Turns Case - Economy
National Academies Press, 2022, “The importance of Chemical Research to the US Economy”, https://nap.nationalacademies.org/catalog/26568/the-importance-of-chemical-research-to-the-us-economy
The size of the chemical economy is quite expansive and is a substantial portion of the U.S. economy. All sectors reliant on the U.S. chemical economy are responsible for $5.2 trillion, or 25%, of the U.S. gross domestic product, and the entire chemical enterprise supports 4.1 million jobs in the United States. The United States is home to 10 of the top 50 chemical companies and remains very competitive in the global chemical economy. However, other countries have seen large sustained investments in their chemical and overall research enterprises, including China and several others, and their rapid advances are starting to threaten U.S. leadership in chemistry.
Fundamental chemical research has played a critical role in the size and impact of the U.S. chemical economy. This can be directly shown with examples such as the development of lithium-ion batteries, the adoption of biocatalysis in synthetic methodologies, advances related to silicon chips, and widely impactful pharmaceuticals such as oral contraceptives and those developed to fight SARS-CoV-2. Additionally, when looking at chemistry-related patents, which are used as a proxy for the economic value of fundamental chemical research, we see a spillover of chemistry knowledge and products into other areas of the economy.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Block Extension › Turns Case - Economy
JUSTIN-DAMIEN GUÉNETTEJEETENDRA KHADAN|JUNE 22, 2022 The energy shock could sap global growth for years https://blogs.worldbank.org/developmenttalk/energy-shock-could-sap-global-growth-years
. The indirect effects can occur through trade and other commodity markets, through monetary and fiscal policy responses, and through investment uncertainty. Through these channels, energy prices can also have immediate repercussions—even absent discretionary policy responses—on fiscal and external balances.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Block Extension › Turns Case - Economy
Borla 14 Omar Borla, Director of the Center for Economic Policy and Analysis at the Caesar Rodney Institute, “High Electric Prices Hurt Economic Growth”, Inside Sources, http://www.insidesources.com/high-electric-prices-hurt-economic-growth/
Economic research on the impact of energy prices on economic growth has focused largely on the volatility of the price of oil, which has triggered numerous economic crises and recessions (the mid-1970s oil embargo is the first example that may come to mind.) In our case, the main objective is to isolate the impact of electricity prices on economic growth as measured by the Gross State Product (GSP.) In this initial report we measure the response of economic growth to changes in electricity prices. As this is an initial attempt to approach the problem, we can’t predict or assume right now what the long-term impacts of high electric prices will be. In other words, we are not considering technological changes that could make production more electricity-efficient. Our approach is based mostly in common sense: if the relative price of a production input increases in a state vs. the other inputs then in the short term, production of goods that use that input intensively will be negatively affected. The table below displays the calculation range of GSP growth (annual percentage of change) with respect to the percentage change in average electricity prices for the U.S., the state of Delaware and the surrounding states from 1997-2013. The table below shows how economic growth will vary when facing a percent change in electricity prices. The recessions of 2001 and 2008-2009 were factored into our calculations. The column on the left is the standard coefficient used in our calculation. Pay attention to the column on the right. The top number in each state’s block means we estimate how much each state loses per year in economic growth because of a 1% increase in electric prices. The number below is the margin of error we factored in. So again, using Delaware as an example, even though we estimate a loss of 3.76% of economic growth for a 1% increase in electric costs, the range is 2.25%. So the “true” cost of a 1% increase in electric prices ranges from as little as a 1.5% decrease in economic growth to an incredible 6% decrease in economic growth! This analysis had a few factors which limited our ability to make a more accurate prediction. One of them is that in 1997 the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis began a new series of GSP calculations. In order to make a more accurate guess we didn’t want to combine the “old” calculations with the “new” ones which is why we only go back to 1997. Two important conclusions emerge. First, GSP is very sensitive to changes in electric prices over time. Second, it is clear the correlation between high electric prices and lower or negative economic growth is statistically significant. As an additional reference, the average electricity price per kilowatt hour for the average American home from 1997-2013 was $6.74. Pennsylvania’s average was $7.29, Delaware’s was $8.07, Maryland’s was $9.36, and New Jersey’s $11.38. In terms of economic growth, Delaware posted 3.2% and it was the best performer of the group over the 16-year period.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Block Extension › Turns Case - Economy
Russell Tucker 14, Director, Strategic Analysis & Chief Economist at the National Rural Electric Cooperative Association, Zach Schloss, Michael Leitman, Dave Olivier, "Affordable Electricity and Economic Development: The Role of Electric Cooperatives in the 21st Century", www.nreca.coop/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/Final_NRECA_Affordable_Electricity_White_Paper.pdf
This study first illustrated the effects of increased electricity consumption (“pure work”) on U.S. economic growth. It then highlighted the impact of affordable electricity on economic productivity and the “useful work” done via U.S. electricity consumption. In its entirety, then, this study has identified a causal relationship running from affordable electricity to U.S. economic growth (see Figure 6). More specifically, as electricity prices rise and the implementation of cost-effective electricity-using technologies slows, the “useful work” done via electricity consumption falls, in turn suppressing economic growth. Conversely, as electricity prices fall and the adoption of cost-effective electricity-using technologies grows, electricity consumption rises, leading to more “useful work” and economic growth. While some scholars have observed a “decoupling” of the growth of electricity use and GDP in recent years (see de Bruyn & Opschoor, 1997; Smith, 2014; Spross, 2014; The World Bank, 1992), affordable electricity use remains a strong indicator of economic performance (see Figure 7) and has, if anything, become increasingly vital as the U.S. economy has come to rely more on digital technologies. As energy policy analyst Pierre-Olivier Pineau (2002) notes, electricity is not only “one of the building blocks” of modern economies, but it “has also been at the root of all productivity improvements in developed countries and it now fuels the ‘new digital economy’” (p. 999). This study reinforces the findings of much research that has continued to find a link between affordable electricity and the U.S. economy. Using U.S. data from 35 U.S. industrial segments since 1958, for example, Jorgenson has found that “in virtually all sectors of the U.S. economy, technical progress is total energy using,” meaning that decreases in the affordability of energy types like electricity decrease productivity growth in those industries and ultimately impede economic growth (Berndt, 1990). Writing with regard to the U.S., the World Economic Forum (2012) echoed these findings, explaining that because “electricity is an input for nearly all goods and services in the economy, an increase in electricity prices would be felt throughout the economy” (p. 18). All else being equal, if electricity prices were to rise or technological innovation were to be limited to the point that electricity became “unaffordable,” the ensuing decline in electricity consumption would abate economic progress by diminishing the effectiveness of labor, increasing unemployment, hindering industrial productivity, decreasing consumer spending on other goods and services, and limiting technological progress. In this sense, productivity and economic growth cannot be sustained without affordable electricity.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Block Extension › Turns Case - Economy
Loris, et al, 16—Herbert and Joyce Morgan Fellow in Energy and Environmental Policy, Thomas A. Roe Institute for Economic Policy Studies (Nicolas, with Kevin D. Dayaratna, Ph.D., Senior Statistician and Research Programmer, Center for Data Analysis, and David W. Kreutzer, Ph.D., Senior Research Fellow, Energy Economics and Climate Change, Center for Data Analysis, “Consequences of Paris Protocol: Devastating Economic Costs, Essentially Zero Environmental Benefits,” , dml)
Energy is a key building block for economic opportunity. Carbon-dioxide-emitting fuels, such as coal, oil, and natural gas, provided 87 percent of America’s energy needs in the past decade, and have been the overwhelming supplier for over a century.[5] Restricting the use of conventional energy sources as laid out by the Obama Administration’s INDC will significantly harm the U.S. economy. Americans feel the pain of higher energy prices directly, but also indirectly through almost all of the goods and services they buy, because energy is a necessary component of production and service. Higher energy prices will disproportionately hurt the poorest Americans, who spend the highest percentage of their budget on energy bills. Companies will pass higher costs on to consumers or absorb the costs, which prevents hiring and new investment. As prices rise, consumers buy less, and companies will drop employees, close entirely, or move to other countries where the cost of doing business is lower. The result is fewer opportunities for American workers, lower incomes, less economic growth, and higher unemployment. In order to estimate the impact on the economy of the Paris Protocol policies, we estimated the economic impact of a tax equivalent to the EPA’s annual estimates of the social cost of carbon (SCC) in a manner similar to one of our previous studies.[6] Since the crude oil export ban has been lifted, however, we incorporated this change into our simulations of both current policy as well as the Paris agreement. The SCC purports to quantify the economic damages associated with a single metric ton of carbon dioxide emissions over the course of a 300-year time horizon. At their core, these models are fundamentally flawed because their damage functions are arbitrary. Heritage research has also found that these models are extremely sensitive to reasonable changes in assumptions; in fact, under some assumptions one of the models provides a negative SCC, suggesting net economic benefits to carbon dioxide emissions. The Administration insists on using these models anyway.[7] We used the Heritage Energy Model (HEM),[8] a clone of the National Energy Modeling System 2015 Full Release (NEMS),[9] to quantify the economic impact of instituting the regulations associated with the policies stemming from the Paris agreement. We did so by modeling a $36 carbon tax increasing in conjunction with the EPA’s annual estimates of the SCC. Modeling tax changes as a substitute for quantifying the economic impact of regulatory proposals is a widely accepted practice. To negate the analytical impacts of a tax’s income transfer, 100 percent of carbon-tax revenue is returned to taxpayers.[10] Policies adapted from domestic regulations emphasized in the Paris agreement will affect a variety of aspects of the American economy. As a result of the plan, one can expect that by 2035, there will be: An overall average shortfall of nearly 400,000 jobs; An average manufacturing shortfall of over 200,000 jobs; A total income loss of more than $20,000 for a family of four; An aggregate gross domestic product (GDP) loss of over $2.5 trillion; and Increases in household electricity expenditures between 13 percent and 20 percent. Chart 1 illustrates the impact that American policies adopted from the Paris Protocol will have on employment. As Chart 1 shows, the impact of the Paris agreement on manufacturing is quite devastating. In terms of overall employment, the agreement ends up killing more than 300,000 jobs by 2035. Chart 2 provides sector-by-sector analysis of this impact.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Block Extension › Turns Case - Economy
Guan, et.al., , , , , , , , , , , & volume 8, pages304–316 (2023) Burden of the global energy price crisis on households https://www.nature.com/articles/s41560-023-01209-8
High energy prices impose cost burdens on households in two ways. On the one hand, fuel price rises directly increase household fuel bills (for example, for heating and cooling, cooking and mobility). On the other hand, energy and fossil feedstock inputs needed for the production of goods and services for final household consumption will lead to higher prices of household-expenditure items12,13. Due to the unequal distribution of income, reflected in different household consumption patterns, surging energy prices could affect households in very different ways11,14,15. Unaffordable costs of energy and other necessities would push vulnerable populations into energy poverty and even extreme poverty16. Understanding how global energy prices are transmitted to households through global supply chains and how they are affected is crucial for effective and equitable policy design.
Energy poverty