2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC – Business Confidence
ERIC LEENSON & DAN GEIGER OCT. 17, 2017 1 PM PT Commentary: Why business should demand single-payer health care https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/opinion/commentary/sd-utbg-healthcare-single-payer-business-20171017-story.html
The powerhouse of America’s economy — small business — is being sabotaged. Yes, sabotaged — not by taxes, but by our health care system. Take it from Warren Buffett, chief executive of Berkshire Hathaway, who referred to our health care system as “the tapeworm of American economic competitiveness.” He asserts that medical costs harm the economy much more than taxes, and he and Berkshire’s vice chairman Charlie Munger (a Republican) favor a single-payer solution, sometimes referred to as “Medicare-for-all.” Small businesses are a huge sector of the California economy, representing more than 99 percent of all state businesses and providing jobs for 6.8 million, nearly half of all California’s private employees. Yet small businesses are among the most negatively impacted by our nation’s health care system’s runaway costs and corporate insurance system. Private businesses spent $637 billion on private health insurance in 2015 and are projected to spend more than $1 trillion by 2025. Healthcare costs represent more than 17 percent of U.S. GDP, significantly higher than any country in the world.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC – Jobs
Jason Lemon 20, 3-5-2020, Bernie Sanders' Medicare for All Would Likely Increase Wages, Create Jobs, Newsweek, , accessed 6-28-2023, // Griffith
A new analysis of the economic impact of a Medicare for All health care reform, like the signature policy proposal of Democratic presidential candidate Bernie Sanders, suggests that such a plan would not only increase wages for workers but also create additional jobs. Sanders, a progressive senator from Vermont who is currently a close second to former Vice President Joe Biden, the Democratic frontrunner, has long advocated for a universal or single-payer health care system. Critics argue that such a policy would lead to mass job loss and be an economic drain on the country, but the new analysis by the Economic Policy Institute (EPI) suggests the opposite would happen. Josh Bivens, EPI's director who conducted the study, wrote in the report that Medicare for All "would be unambiguously positive" for the labor market in the U.S., leading to a "boost in wages and salaries" as well as an "increase in job quality, while producing "a net increase in jobs."
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC – Jobs
Matt Bruenig 2017, Matt Bruenig is an American lawyer, blogger, policy analyst, and commentator. He rose to prominence as a blogger for American think tank Demos covering politics and public policy., September 19, 2017, “Single Payer Myths: Redundant Health Administration Workers,” People's Policy Project, http://peoplespolicyproject.org/2017/09/19/single-payer-myths-redundant-health-administration-workers/
One of the reasons why the current US health care system is so bloated is that it wastes a lot of labor on health insurance administration. Health care providers have to employ many people to make agreements with health insurers and to bill health insurers. Health insurance companies also have to employ many people to make agreements with health care providers and to pay the bills those providers send them. By streamlining billing and payments under a single national insurer, a single payer system would eliminate much of this work, which is one of its many charms. Critics argue that the elimination of this work would strike an intolerable blow to employment in the country. In reality, the loss of employment would be relatively small compared to the overall economy, should only be temporary, and can be cushioned through unemployment benefits and active labor market policies that help reallocate redundant workers into new jobs. Existing Labor Turnover One of the reasons for the pervasiveness of this myth is a lack of understanding of just how many people get separated from their job already every year. In 2016, 60 million people separated from their job at some point during the year. That is equal to 42 percent of the American workforce. Total Job Separations by Type (2001-2016) Of course, there is a difference between quitting a job (often for another job already in waiting) and being fired from a job. But if you look only at layoffs and discharges (grouped in the above graph as “dismissals”), you see that, in 2016, 20 million people were fired from their job, representing around 14 percent of the total US workforce. Being fired from a job without having another job waiting can be a very bad experience, but it is also a very common experience that does not generally have long-term negative economic consequences. Vulnerable Health Care Employment Figuring out how many people work “in health care” can be a little tricky. One way to do it is to look directly at health care professions as defined by the Occupational Employment Statistics (OES) codes. The Kaiser Family Foundation does this in their analysis saying that health care currently employs around 12.7 million people, or 9 percent of the workforce. The problem with this figure for our purposes here is that it defines health care workers by the work that they do rather than by the establishments they work for. This means it excludes occupation groups like Office and Administrative Support that are the most likely to be made redundant in a single payer transition. Actual health care workers, defined as those providing frontline health care services like doctors, nurses, medical technicians, and so on are the least likely to be made redundant by such a transition. Another approach is to isolate the relevant establishments in the North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) and then add up the number of people employed by those establishments in the types of professions threatened by bureaucratic streamlining. There are around 2.6 million jobs in Office and Administrative Support within health care provider establishments. This includes every establishment under NAICS 62 excepting social assistance establishments. There are also around 0.4 million total jobs under Direct Health and Medical Insurance Carriers (NAICS 524114). So, under this most liberal of possible interpretations, we are talking about a universe of 3 million jobs. If you were to lay off all 3 million of those workers, it would be equal to how many workers are already laid off in this country every 54 days. Of course, you would not lay off anywhere near that many people. Office and Administrative Support jobs include everything from HR jobs, payroll specialists, and people who answer the phone. Only a minority of those 2.6 million jobs are actually involved in the kinds of insurance intermediary work that is threatened by the switch, and even then some of those jobs will still remain in order to bill the national insurer. All 0.4 million medical insurance jobs are threatened, but at least some of those workers will be able to move into the smaller number of similar jobs created by the expansion of the public insurer (e.g. Medicare). Although it is hard to come up with a precise estimate, the likely number of jobs made redundant by the switch is a few hundred thousand over the course of a few years, this in a country where 1.6 million people are dismissed from their jobs every single month. Transitional Assistance Given the small numbers we are talking about in the context of the entire economy and given the fact that office and administrative skills are fairly portable to other sectors (non-health care establishments employ over 19 million people in such jobs), it is not at all clear that there needs to be any special program for reallocating those made redundant by this change. But even if there does not need to be such a program, single payer proposals generally contain one. For instance, here is how the issue is handled in Conyer’s HR 676: (e) First Priority In Retraining And Job Placement; 2 Years Of Salary Parity Benefits.—The Program shall provide that clerical, administrative, and billing personnel in insurance companies, doctors offices, hospitals, nursing facilities, and other facilities whose jobs are eliminated due to reduced administration— (1) should have first priority in retraining and job placement in the new system; and (2) shall be eligible to receive two years of Medicare For All employment transition benefits with each year’s benefit equal to salary earned during the last 12 months of employment, but shall not exceed $100,000 per year. How Economic Growth Works As a closing note, it is worth emphasizing that reallocating workers away from unnecessary tasks and towards new tasks is how economic growth works. Such a reallocation can be painful to those directly affected by it in the short-term, which is why humane societies create systems of unemployment benefits and institutions capable of helping people dislocated by economic changes get into new jobs. But the basic mechanics of finding ways to be more productive with the same amount of labor is fundamentally good. When people talk about single payer making some health administration workers redundant, they often characterize it as a purely negative thing. It is the “con” of single payer that is nonetheless outweighed by so many countervailing “pros.” But this is not quite right. Making the workers redundant is also a pro insofar as it creates a more prosperous society through greater economic efficiency.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC – Jobs
• March 5, 2020 Josh Bivens joined the Economic Policy Institute in 2002 and is currently EPI’s director of research. His primary areas of research include macroeconomics, social insurance, and globalization. Fundamental health reform like ‘Medicare for All’ would help the labor marketJob loss claims are misleading, and substantial boosts to job quality are often overlooked • https://www.epi.org/publication/medicare-for-all-would-help-the-labor-market/
Fundamental health reform like “Medicare for All” would be a hugely ambitious policy undertaking with profound effects on the economy and the economic security of households in America. But despite oft-repeated claims of large-scale job losses, a national program that would guarantee health insurance for every American would not profoundly affect the total number of jobs in the U.S. economy. In fact, such reform could boost wages and jobs and lead to more efficient labor markets that better match jobs and workers. Specifically, it could: Boost wages and salaries by allowing employers to redirect money they are spending on health care costs to their workers’ wages. Increase job quality by ensuring that every job now comes bundled with a guarantee of health care—with the boost to job quality even greater among women workers, who are less likely to have employer-sponsored health care. Lessen the stress and economic shock of losing a job or moving between jobs by eliminating the loss of health care that now accompanies job losses and transitions. Support self-employment and small business development—which is currently super low in the U.S. relative to other rich countries—by eliminating the daunting loss of/cost of health care from startup costs. Inject new dynamism and adaptability into the overall economy by reducing “job lock”—with workers going where their skills and preferences best fit the job, not just to workplaces (usually large ones) that have affordable health plans. Produce a net increase in jobs as public spending boosts aggregate demand, with job losses in health insurance and billing administration being outweighed by job gains in provision of health care, including the expansion of long-term care. While the overall effect of fundamental health reform on the labor market would be unambiguously positive, this does not mean policymakers should ignore the distress caused by job transitions forced by this reform. Specifically, policy support should be provided to help displaced health insurance and billing administration workers move into new positions. But we should not let critics of Medicare for All inflate the scale of this transition challenge or falsely present the number of jobs displaced in individual sectors as the net effect of reform on labor markets. The number of health insurance and billing administration workers who would need to transition implies an increase in the rate of overall job market churn that is relatively small: Job losses for these workers would be equivalent to one-twelfth the size of economywide layoffs in 2018.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC – Jobs
• March 5, 2020 Josh Bivens joined the Economic Policy Institute in 2002 and is currently EPI’s director of research. His primary areas of research include macroeconomics, social insurance, and globalization. Fundamental health reform like ‘Medicare for All’ would help the labor marketJob loss claims are misleading, and substantial boosts to job quality are often overlooked • https://www.epi.org/publication/medicare-for-all-would-help-the-labor-market/
A recent analysis of the economic effects of M4A (Pollin et al. 2018) includes the projection that up to 1.8 million jobs in the health insurance and billing administration sector (the divisions of hospitals and doctors’ offices dedicated to administrative processing of bills and payments) could be made redundant. These potential 1.8 million lost jobs are frequently presented as if they constitute the net employment effect of M4A. This is a deeply flawed misrepresentation of Pollin and his colleagues’ work. In fact, their estimates are a gross (not net) measure of job displacement or “churn”—the regular process of workers starting and leaving jobs during the course of their work lives. Relative to the scale of other gross measures of job churn, the churn associated with M4A is not large. It is true that one source of cost savings from the introduction of M4A is the reduced demand for insurance and billing administration. In turn, this reduced demand would shift employment out of these sectors. This could certainly cause challenges and economic distress for the workers within these sectors who are directly affected. But for some perspective, it is worth noting that 21.5 million workers were laid off in 2018 (BLS 2020b). If the 1.8 million workers that Pollin et al. (2018) identify as potentially being displaced by M4A were forced to transition over the four-year phase-in commonly identified with M4A plans, this would increase the national rate of layoffs by about 2%. It is also worth noting that even within just the finance and insurance sectors, there have been 1.7 million layoffs in the past four years (BLS 2020b). And yet it’s safe to say that very few people even in the business press have made any note of this. This is not a shock: Our economy generates a huge amount of job churn every year. This churn is the hallmark of growth in productivity—getting more economic output with fewer inputs. While productivity growth can indeed put downward pressure on jobs in the sector experiencing it directly, Autor and Salomons (2018) demonstrate that productivity gains within a given sector strongly boost job growth in other sectors, as the savings to households and businesses stemming from enhanced productivity increase purchasing power that supports demand for these other sectors’ outputs. If workers in the insurance or billing administration sectors were particularly hard-pressed for reemployment prospects because of geographic isolation or low average levels of educational credentials, their displacement might pose particular concern to policymakers. But employment in the health insurance and billing administration sectors is not particularly geographically concentrated, and Pollin et al. (2018) show that 56.5% of workers in these sectors have a four-year college degree or more education, a far greater share than the overall labor force (in 2018, 37.6% of workers had a four-year degree or more education, according to EPI 2020b).
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC – Jobs
• March 5, 2020 Josh Bivens joined the Economic Policy Institute in 2002 and is currently EPI’s director of research. His primary areas of research include macroeconomics, social insurance, and globalization. Fundamental health reform like ‘Medicare for All’ would help the labor marketJob loss claims are misleading, and substantial boosts to job quality are often overlooked • https://www.epi.org/publication/medicare-for-all-would-help-the-labor-market/
While it may seem counterintuitive, fundamental health reform like M4A is almost guaranteed to substantially expand employment in the health care sector overall, even taking reduced billing administration employment into account. Often people hear that fundamental reform is aimed at cost containment and then imagine that part of this cost containment will take the form of fewer jobs providing health care, but this is not necessarily the case. As noted before, the U.S. is an outlier in terms of how much it spends on health care, but its health care workforce as a share of the total workforce is not out of line with shares in other countries. For example, in 2017 the health care workforce in the U.S. was equal to 13.4% of the overall workforce, while the share averaged 12.9% in the 20 other richest OECD countries. Additionally, seven of these other countries had health care workforce shares equal to or higher than the U.S.’s 13.4%. Pollin et al. (2018) estimate that expanded access to health care could increase demand for health services by up to $300 billion annually. Given the current level of health spending and employment, this would translate into increased demand for 2.3 million full-time-equivalent workers in providing healthcare. Obviously all of the workers displaced from the health insurance and billing administration sectors could not necessarily transition into these jobs seamlessly, but well over 10% of workers in the health insurance sector, for example, are actually in health care occupations (e.g., they are doctors or nurses). Further, several M4A plans have provisions to pay for long-term care services. Reinhard et al. (2019) have estimated that in 2018, Americans provided roughly 34 billion hours in unpaid long-term care. If this care was divided up among full-time paid workers, it would require 17 million new positions. Of course, not all of this currently unpaid care would be converted into paid positions in the job market. But if even 10% of unpaid care translated into new jobs, it would create enough new demand for workers to essentially offset the displacement of workers in the health insurance and billing administration sectors.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC --- Wait Lists / Rationing
Carroll 12 (Dr. Aaron Carroll, MD, MS is a Professor of Pediatrics and Associate Dean for Research Mentoring at Indiana University School of Medicine, July 25, 2012. “Single payer does not equal increased wait-times.” http://www.pnhp.org/news/2012/july/single-payer-does-not-equal-increased-wait-times)
I can’t count the number of times I’ve been told this week that it’s just a “fact” that single payer systems lead to increased wait times. It appears that pointing out that this is not true is “rude”. So be it. Let’s start with some simple facts. Wait times occur when there are too many patients and too few appointment slots. That can happen when there are too few doctors or when there are too many people who want appointments. So, yes, if you have a doctor shortage, you can get increased wait times. If the system wants to keep spending low by limiting visit slots, you can get increased wait times. If you increase the number of insured people dramatically, you will get increased wait times. Note that any of those things can occur with or without a single payer system. They can occur with an entirely private system. If you massively decrease the number of uninsured, as the ACA will attempt to do, it’s entirely possible we will get wait times. This will happen whether people become insured through private insurance in the exchanges or through government insurance (Medicaid). The type of insurance is irrelevant. If there are way more patients calling for appointments, and the number of doctors is static, wait times will likely increase. So if wait times are your main concern, then you’re likely against reducing the number of uninsured by any means. The outcome is the same. None of this has anything to do with single payer. Now it’s possible that single payer systems can lead to increased wait times. In Canada, they keep spending what we put out. They do so partially by spacing out visits for elective procedures and such. That’s a , and it leads to some people waiting for elective care. But that’s an outcome of their financial conservatism, not the single payer system. Other countries () don’t have the same issues with elective procedures because they spend more money. Our single payer system (Medicare) has far fewer spending restraints, and does not suffer from the wait time problem. We could convert the entire country to Medicare tomorrow, increase the number of physicians, and have no wait times at all. We could convert the entire country to private insurance in a Switzerland-like system, make no changes to the number of physicians, and see wait times go through the roof. This really is a zombie idea.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC --- Wait Lists / Rationing
PNHP 16 (PNHP, Physicians for a National Health Program, compiled and contributed by Dr. S. Wollhandler, primary care physician, professor in the CUNY School of Public Health at Hunter College, adjunct clinical professor at Albert Einstein College of Medicine, and lecturer in medicine at Harvard Medical School, where she co-directed the general internal medicine fellowship program and practiced primary care internal medicine at Cambridge Hospital, Dr. D.U. Himmelstein, cofounded Physicians for a National Health Program, professor in the CUNY School of Public Health at Hunter College, adjunct clinical professor at Albert Einstein College of Medicine, and lecturer in medicine at Harvard Medical School. He has served as chief of the division of social and community medicine at Cambridge Hospital, 2016. “Single-Payer FAQ.” http://www.pnhp.org/facts/single-payer-faq#subsidies)
Won’t this result in rationing like in Canada? The U.S. already rations care. Rationing in U.S. health care is based on income: if you can afford care, you get it; if you can’t, you don’t. A recent study found that 45,000 Americans die every year because they don’t have health insurance. Many more skip treatments that their insurance company refuses to cover. That’s rationing. Other countries do not ration in this way. If there is this much rationing, why don’t we hear about it? And if other countries ration less, why do we hear about them? The answer is that their systems are publicly accountable, and ours is not. Problems with their health care systems are aired in public; ours are not. For example, in Canada, when waits for care emerged in the 1990s, Parliament hotly debated the causes and solutions. Most provinces have also established formal reporting systems on waiting lists, with wait times for each hospital posted on the Internet. This public attention has led to recent falls in waits there. In U.S. health care, no one is ultimately accountable for how the system works. No one takes full responsibility. Rationing in our system is carried out covertly through financial pressure, forcing millions of individuals to forgo care or to be shunted away by caregivers from services they can’t pay for. The rationing that takes place in U.S. health care is unnecessary. A number of studies (notably a General Accounting Office report in 1991 and a Congressional Budget Office report in 1993) show that there is more than enough money in our health care system to serve everyone if it were spent wisely. Administrative costs are at 31% of U.S. health spending, far higher than in other countries’ systems. These inflated costs are due to our failure to have a publicly financed, universal health care system. We spend about twice as much per person as Canada or most European nations, and still deny health care to many in need. A national health program could save enough on administration to assure access to care for all Americans, without rationing.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC --- Wait Lists / Rationing
APHA ‘20. “The Importance of Universal Health Care in Improving Our Nation’s Response to Pandemics and Health Disparities.” American Public Health Association, American Public Health Association, 24 October 2020, https://www.apha.org/policies-and-advocacy/public-health-policy-statements/policy-database/2021/01/14/the-importance-of-universal-health-care-in-improving-response-to-pandemics-and-health-disparities. Accessed 28 June 2023. [APHA publishes the American Journal of Public Health and is a leading advocacy voice for public health] //QSMIT
Another concern is rationing of medical services due to increased demands from newly insured individuals. Countries with universal health care use methods such as price setting, service restriction, controlled distribution, budgeting, and cost-benefit analysis to ration services.[45]
Counterpoint: The Unites States already rations health care services by excluding patients who are unable to pay for care. This entrenched rationing leads to widening health disparities. It also increases the prevalence of chronic conditions in low-income and minority groups and, in turn, predisposes these groups to disproportionately worse outcomes during the pandemic. Allocation of resources should not be determined by what patients can and cannot afford. This policy statement calls for high-value, evidence-based health care, which will reduce waste and decrease rationing.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC --- Wait Lists / Rationing
Thomas Waldrop OCT 18, 2019 The Truth on Wait Times in Universal Coverage Systems https://www.americanprogress.org/article/truth-wait-times-universal-coverage-systems/
In a fact sheet accompanying his recent executive order on Medicare, President Donald Trump falsely asserted that expanding coverage under Medicare for All would “force patients to face massive wait times for treatments and destroy access to quality care,” claiming that it would “increase your wait times, ration quality care, and stifle innovation.”1 President Trump is not the only person to make such claims. Health care industry actors and conservative groups have begun ramping up opposition to coverage expansion proposals. One such anti-Medicare for All ad, by conservative advocacy group One Nation, similarly argues that expanding coverage would dramatically increase wait times.2 However, the data—both from other nations with universal coverage and from historic expansions of coverage within the United States—show that this is not the case. Patients in peer nations generally have similar or shorter wait times than patients in the United States for a variety of services, refuting the argument that universal coverage would necessarily result in longer wait times in the future. This issue brief provides an overview of the factors that affect wait times, outlines evidence that suggests universal coverage need not increase wait times in the long run, and discusses policy solutions to mitigate any impact on wait times in the short run. Background Discussions of wait times often ignore the fundamental reality that, for many patients, wait times are already long. Where a patient lives has a significant effect on their wait time, largely due to provider concentration in more urban areas compared with more rural ones. For example, a 2017 analysis of hospital wait times found that mid-size metropolitan areas—cities such as Hartford, Connecticut—had 32.8 percent longer wait times than large metropolitan areas such as Washington, D.C.3 A recent article in the Journal of the American Medical Association further supports this idea.4 The study found that wait times at private-sector hospitals ranged from 16.5 days in New York City to 57.33 days in Boston, Massachusetts. The same study compared wait times between a similar set of private and U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) hospitals and found that VA hospitals had “significantly shorter” wait times than private hospitals, in part because wait times at VA hospitals have improved in recent years—now averaging 20 days—while wait times at private hospitals have stagnated at around 41 days.5 Insurance status also affects wait times. Generally, privately insured patients have shorter wait times than publicly insured patients, though the magnitude of this difference varies. A 2018 study by the Leonard Davis Institute of Health Economics in Philadelphia found that Medicaid beneficiaries’ wait times for new primary care physician (PCP) appointments were, on average, only two days longer than those for privately insured patients.6 Meanwhile, an examination of the impact of Medicaid expansion in Michigan found that wait times for PCP appointments were approximately one day longer on average, both before and after expansion.7 A similar study of 10 states found that privately insured patients were almost universally more likely than publicly insured patients to have wait times of less than one week for a new PCP appointment and were less likely to have a wait time of more than 30 days—which represented the 50th and 90th percentiles, respectively.8 This difference in wait times is largely attributable to differences in payment rates between payers, not any inherent advantage to private insurers. Many coverage expansion proposals address this issue of differing payment rates: Both the House and Senate versions of Medicare for All establish the federal government as the only payer, and the Center for American Progress’ Medicare Extra proposal indirectly lowers the rates that private insurers pay by limiting out-of-network providers to receiving no more than what the federal government pays.9 All of these studies, however, focus on insured patients. Newly released data from the U.S. Census Bureau estimate that the uninsured rate is approximately 8.5 percent, which amounts to more than 27 million people.10 Since discussions of wait times fail to consider these individuals, they paint a far rosier picture than the reality. Uninsured people are much more likely to postpone seeking care or skip needed care due to cost.11 And while specific data on wait times for uninsured patients are missing from the discussion, what is known is that being uninsured is associated with worse access to care and that, for some uninsured patients, their wait times are essentially infinite. Wait times in universal coverage systems Data from other nations show that universal coverage does not necessarily result in substantially longer wait times. In fact, there are a variety of circumstances in which the United States’ peer nations have shorter wait times. While the White House’s fact sheet largely focused on the United Kingdom’s health care system, no candidate currently running for president is proposing nationalizing health care providers like the U.K.’s National Health Service.12 The most comprehensive source of international comparative data on health care is the Commonwealth Fund’s “Mirror, Mirror” series, which, in 2017, examined a variety of metrics across 10 European countries and the United States. Four of these metrics were particularly useful for studying wait times.13 Patients reported that they saw a doctor or nurse on the same or next day the last time they sought medical care. Doctors reported that patients often experience difficulty getting specialized tests—for example, CT and MRI scans. Patients reported that they waited two months or longer for a specialist appointment. Patients reported that they waited four months or longer for elective or nonemergency surgery. On each of these metrics, the United States performed worse than several nations with universal coverage, though no individual nation outperforms the United States on every metric. For example, only 51 percent of U.S. patients reported being able to see a provider within a day, compared with 53 percent, 56 percent, and 67 percent of patients in Germany, France, and Australia, respectively.14 Similarly, nearly 30 percent of U.S. doctors reported that their patients have difficulty getting a specialized test, compared with only 11 percent and 15 percent of doctors in Australia and Sweden, respectively.15 U.S. outcomes on the other two metrics were better across the board but still show that the United States performs worse than other nations with more equitable health care coverage systems. For instance, in the United States, 4 percent of patients reported waiting four months or longer for nonemergency surgery, compared with only 2 percent of French patients and 0 percent of German patients.16 For specialist appointments, the situation is even worse: 6 percent of U.S. patients reported waiting two months or longer for an appointment, compared with only 4 percent of French patients and 3 percent of German patients.17
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC ---Doctors Turn
Liz Seegert, 5-25-2016, "What single-payer healthcare would mean to doctors," Medical Economics, http://medicaleconomics.modernmedicine.com/medical-economics/news/what-single-payer-healthcare-would-mean-doctors?page=0,3
What’s in it for doctors? Single payer could allow physicians to spend less time on administrative tasks and devote that time to actual patient care, says health economist Peter Hussey, PhD, a senior policy researcher at the RAND Corporation and director of the Health Services Delivery Systems Program for RAND Health. “It’s one less thing to worry about–if they’re going to have access to the drug you prescribed, or the referral you made,” Hussey says. Concerns about types of insurance, covered services, deductibles, different requirements and rates would disappear. PHNP’s Zarr projects that single payer would bring about a “dramatic” reduction of administrative overhead costs. The resulting savings would mean more revenue for practices. It could also potentially lower malpractice premiums by ensuring greater continuity of care and government assurances to pay for future costs of additional care. “We’re spending a lot of our time doing things we’re not well adapted to do. Doctors should be providing care, not on the phone arguing about the value of an MRI that should be covered in the first place,” Zarr says. But administrative simplicity will come with a lot of tradeoffs, experts say. Downsides of single payer for physicians Since the government sets prices in a single-payer system, doctors are left with little choice but to accept those rates or not participate at all. Critics contend the government will also dictate what services and treatments are covered based on financial considerations rather than medical necessity. That could reignite the “death panel” debate, allegations made by Republicans during the crafting of the Affordable Care Act, which claimed incorrectly that an anonymous panel would determine whether some sick people would receive health care as a way to control costs. Physician compensation would almost certainly drop, according to Hussey. While an apples-to-apples comparison is difficult, he points out that in Canada, which has government-set payment rates, physicians earn less than their American counterparts. Over the long term, he wonders if this could change how medicine is practiced. “Would it make it harder to be a physician and get by financially?” he asks. Kominski predicts a significant backlash should the U.S. try to hold down costs by reducing payments to physicians and hospitals. It will be difficult to persuade the medical profession to agree that for the good of the country they should start accepting lower payments for their services. “If it were easy to achieve we would have done it by now,” he says. Michael D. Tanner, senior fellow at the libertarian-leaning Cato Institute, has argued that in nations with universal healthcare, “attempts to control costs through governmental fiat have led to problems with access to care, either delays in receiving care or outright rationing.” He advocates more competition among insurers and providers within a free market system to generate cost savings. He has warned previously that an unlimited single payer model could bankrupt the country. Political, not medical, decisions will drive healthcare should single payer come to pass, predicts Robert E. Moffit, PhD., senior fellow at the conservative Heritage Foundation’s Center for Health Policy Studies. When unlimited demand collides with limited supply, “government officials will determine who, and under what circumstances, patients receive care,” he says. Basic economics dictates that the government cannot control demand, but it can control supply through a global budget or price controls on services. Under that scenario supply does not keep up with rising demand. At best, Moffit says, quality of care suffers. At worst, there will be unnecessary deaths. “And let’s not even get started on how it will further intrude on doctor-patient relationships,” he says. Moffit points to overcrowded hospitals, long waiting lists for simple procedures and poor quality of care under Britain’s National Health Service as examples of what can happen when healthcare becomes an unlimited entitlement. As for reduced paperwork, “CMS issues tens of thousands of pages of rules and edicts. The idea that physicians could escape paperwork is fantasy.” Increased demand, combined with reduced access will fuel more dissatisfaction among patients. That, in turn, could lead to more complaints and malpractice claims, Kominski says. He’s also concerned about the overall impact on patients’ health. Sanders’ plan in particular lacks detail about what will happen to value-based care or patient-centered care—models that CMS is promoting to improve outcomes and keep patients healthier. “I don’t want to see those advances thrown out the window because we have a single payer system and are basically saying you can go to any doctor or hospital you want,” Kominski says. The American Medical Association does not support single payer, but other organizations, including the American College of Physicians (ACP) and the American Medical Students’ Association, do. The American Academy of Family Physicians supports universal coverage but advocates a blend of fee-for-service, care coordination fees and a patient-centered medical home model. Zarr brushes aside doomsday scenarios. He contends that care delivery will largely stay in the hands of the private sector. He says single payer actually provides plenty of choice and gives physicians the freedom to practice how and when they want. He calls it the most important step for providers in “taking away the shackles” of the commercial insurers and allowing physicians to provide care that’s appropriate in a manner that’s appropriate. In addition, he predicts that single payer will reduce physician burnout and frustrations with the current system, where patients can’t afford to comply with care plans, and physicians end up providing less-than-optimal care. According to Zuckerman, the question becomes whether healthcare should be treated as a free market or a regulated utility. If you want everyone to be able to get it, like electricity, perhaps there needs to be more regulation of the process, and that means less competition, he says.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC ---Doctors Turn
Hellander 17 [Ida Hellander, MD, is a former executive director and director of national health policy (1992–2017) at Physicians for a National Health Program, 8-16-2017 https://www.thenation.com/article/can-medicare-for-all-succeed/]
Holland assets that physicians will have to be paid less under single payer, which is false. There are many advantages to a single-payer system, not least of which is the saving of $500 billion annually currently wasted on insurance overhead and excess provider bureaucracy—more than enough money to cover the extra costs of clinical care for the uninsured and underinsured, and to eliminate copays and deductibles for everyone, without cutting physician pay. Having said that, the single payer system will have the ability to shift more funding towards primary care over time, which would help with both access and costs down the road.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC ---Doctors Turn
Albright 15 [Logan Albright is Director of Fiscal Research at Capital Policy Analytics, Research Analyst for Freedom Works and a contributing editor for Mises Institute Canada, M.A. Economics – Georgia State University, 2-3-2015 https://mises.org/library/how-government-helped-create-coming-doctor-shortage]
For the last five years, attempts to reform America’s health care system have focused primarily on the demand side of the market, and specifically on the market for insurance. Yet, these reforms have not achieved significant improvements in health care outcomes, nor reductions in cost. As health care specialist John C. Goodman has pointed out in Forbes, the slowed growth of health care spending in the United States is a trend that correlates most closely with supply side reforms such as the availability of health savings accounts. Reductions in spending or costs are certainly not an effect of the Affordable Care Act.
One of the most critical supply side issues in health care is the supply of qualified doctors. The Wall Street Journal has reported that the number of doctors per capita is in decline for the first time in two generations, and the American Association of Medical Colleges has predicted a shortage of 45,000 primary care physicians and 46,000 specialists by 2020.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC ---Doctors Turn
Dr. Jerald Winakur 16, Dr. Winakur practiced internal and geriatric medicine for 36 years and is an associate faculty member at the Center for Medical Humanities and Ethics at the University of Texas Health Science Center at San Antonio., June 2016, “A Single-Payer System Can Save Primary Care,” Caring For The Ages, Volume 17, Number 7,
The problem with Medicare, of course, is the fee schedule itself. It vastly undervalues the work that doctors like me do. At the same time, it overvalues the work of my sub-specialty colleagues. The fee schedule favors technology over touch, performing procedures over spending time with patients. Of course, Medicare didn’t pick numbers out of the air; the fee schedule has been unduly influenced by the richer and thus more powerful doctor groups that sit on the American Medical Association’s resource update committee. This secretive and specialist-stacked assemblage advises Medicare on setting procedural fees. Ninety percent of such advice finds its way into the schedule, which is why an otolaryngologist makes more money to clean wax out of an ear than a geriatrician gets for evaluating an 85-year-old woman who comes into the office after having had a “little spell.” I believe that a vibrant system of primary care is essential for patient wellbeing. Every one of us needs and deserves enough space for an unrushed visit and a thorough physical examination by someone who knows us and our unique circumstance and is available across time and sites of care to minister and to advocate. Patients who are under the watchful eye of a primary care physician receive less expensive medical care without sacrificing the quality of that care. Medicare may track every test I order, every consultant to whom I make a referral, every hospital admission I initiate. But Medicare has never known how many patients I saved from inappropriate testing and consultations, ED referrals, hospital stays, and LTC placements. And aside from the dollars saved, my patients have been spared many needless procedures and the associated morbidity these entail. Single-Payer Solution There is one simple way to accomplish this. A single-payer plan can tinker with the fee schedule and fi nally make it financially remunerative for young doctors to once again pursue primary care. Increase the routine doctor visit reimbursement codes signifi cantly — enough to allow primary care physicians to actually spend face-to-face time with patients. The 7-minute visit is unsatisfactory to patients and demoralizing to doctors. Undoubtedly, this is contributing to the greater than 50% burnout rate for primary physicians. Changing to a single-payer system will not require an infusion of more dollars into the system. It will require a rebalancing of what a sane single-payer system pays for the thousands of over-compensated procedure codes that currently exist. Yes, my specialty colleagues will be unhappy with such a proposal. But unless they want to take over the 24/7 responsibility of caring for the soon-tobe 75 million seniors with their complex medical histories, polypharmacy, and fraught social needs, my specialist friends should yield to the reality that our current system of crumbling primary care cannot accomplish this task without major change.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC ---Doctors Turn
Cathleen London 17, physician based in Maine who developed a cost-effective alternative to the standard EpiPen in response to skyrocketing prices, 5-6-2017, "Why are fiscal conservatives opposed to single-payer healthcare?," The Hill, http://thehill.com/blogs/pundits-blog/healthcare/332226-why-are-fiscal-conservative-opposed-to-single-payer-healthcare
If we are to be truly fiscally conservative, then single payer would be the only option that would be discussed. Medicare has a 3 to 5 percent overhead. There are no multi-million dollar executive salaries. There are no stockholders. There is minimal money spent on advertising and certainly none spent on lobbying. A simple glance at costs over the last few decades show very little rise in physician salaries but a giant leap in administrative overhead. Physicians have been overburdened with unfunded mandates and reporting and meaningless administrative hassles that take up the majority of our time and the joy out of medicine. Doctors go to medical school to learn to diagnose and treat disease. Spending two-thirds of our time not on patient care has resulted in physicians retiring early, switching careers and committing suicide.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC ---Doctors Turn
Eric Reinhart Dr. Reinhart is a political anthropologist and physician at Northwestern University.Feb. 5, 2023 - cut by ki
Doctors have long diagnosed many of our sickest patients with “,” a condition commonly associated with terminal illness that’s characterized by a sense of helplessness and loss of purpose. American physicians are now increasingly suffering from a similar condition, except our demoralization is not a reaction to a medical condition, but rather to the diseased systems for which we work. The United States is the only large high-income nation that doesn’t provide universal health care to its citizens. Instead, it maintains a lucrative system of for-profit medicine. For decades, of have occurred each year because health care here is so expensive. During the Covid-19 pandemic, the consequences of this policy choice have intensified. One study estimates at least in the United States could have been prevented by universal health care. In the wake of this generational catastrophe, many health care workers have been left shaken. “For me, doctoring in a broken place required a sustaining belief that the place would become less broken as a result of my efforts,” Dr. Rachael Bedard about her decision to quit her job at New York City’s Rikers Island prison complex during the pandemic. “I couldn’t sustain that belief any longer.” Thousands of U.S. doctors, not just at jails but also at wealthy hospitals, now appear to . that in 2021 alone, about 117,000 physicians left the work force, while joined it. This has worsened a chronic physician shortage, leaving many hospitals and clinics struggling. And the situation is to get worse. says he or she plans to leave practice in the coming years. To try to explain this phenomenon, many people have leaned on a term from for the consequences of overwork: burnout. Nearly two-thirds of physicians they are experiencing its symptoms.But the burnout rhetoric misses the larger issue in this case: What’s burning out health care workers is less the grueling conditions we practice under, and more our dwindling faith in the systems for which we work. What has been identified as occupational burnout is a symptom of a deeper collapse. We are witnessing the slow death of American medical ideology. It’s revealing to look at the crisis among health care workers as at least in part a crisis of ideology — that is, a belief system made up of interlinking political, moral and cultural narratives upon which we depend to make sense of our social world. Faith in the traditional stories American medicine has told about itself, stories that have long sustained what should have been an unsustainable system, is now dissolving. During the pandemic, physicians have witnessed our hospitals nearly fall apart as a result of in and . Long-ignored in the standard of care available to rich and poor Americans became as bodies were stacked in empty and . Many health care workers have been traumatized by the futility of their attempts to stem of death, with nearly one-fifth of physicians they knew a colleague who had considered, attempted or died by suicide during the first year of the pandemic alone.Although deaths from Covid have slowed, the among health workers has only increased. Recent exposés have further laid bare the structural perversity of our institutions. For instance, according to an investigation in The New York Times, ostensibly nonprofit charity hospitals have for receiving care to which they were entitled without cost and have turned large profits by exploiting tax incentives meant to promote care for poor communities. Hospitals are themselves and undercutting patient care while sitting on billions of dollars in cash reserves. Little of this is new, but doctors’ sense of our complicity in putting profits over people has grown more difficult to ignore. Resistance to self-criticism has long been a hallmark of U.S. medicine and the industry it has shaped. From through , doctors have to ward off the specter of “.” We have repeatedly defended health care as a business venture against the threat that it might become a public institution oriented around . This is in part because doctors that if health care were made a public service, we would lose our professional autonomy and make less money. For a profession that had to achieve elite status, this resonated.And so doctors learned to rationalize a deeply unequal health care system that emphasizes personal, rather than public, moral . We sit at our patients’ bed sides and counsel them on their duty to counteract the risks of obesity, heart disease and diabetes, for example, while largely ignoring how those diseases are tied to poor access to quality food because of economic inequities. Or, more recently, we find ourselves advising patients on how to modulate their personal choices to reduce their Covid risk while working in jobs with dismal safety practices and labor protections.Part of what draws us into this norm is that doctors learn by doing — that is, via apprenticeship — in which we repeat what’s modeled for us. This is, to a degree, a necessary aspect of training in an applied technical field. It is also a fundamentally conservative model for learning that teaches us to suppress critical thinking and trust the system, even with its perverse incentives.It becomes difficult, then, to recognize the origins of much of what we do and whose interests it serves. For example, a invented by the American Medical Association as part of a political strategy now dictates nearly every aspect of medical practice, producing not just endless administrative work, but also subtly shaping treatment choices.Addressing the failures of the health care system will require uncomfortable reflection and bold action. Any illusion that medicine and politics are, or should be, separate spheres has been crushed under the weight of over 1.1 million Americans killed by a pandemic that was in many ways a preventable disaster. And many physicians are now finding it difficult to quash the suspicion that our institutions, and much of our work inside them, primarily serve a moneymaking machine.Doctors can no longer be passive witnesses to these harms. We have a responsibility to use our collective power to insist on changes: universal health care and but also investments in and essential and .Neither major political party is making universal health care a priority right now, but doctors nonetheless hold considerable power to initiate reforms in health policy. We can begin to exercise it by following the example of colleagues at in the Bronx who, like before them, recently took steps to unionize. If we can build an organizing network through doctors’ unions, then to demand universal health care through use of via physicians’ control over health care documentation and billing, for example, could move from visions to genuinely actionable plans.Regardless of whether we act through unions or other means, the fact remains that until doctors to call for a fundamental reorganization of our medical system, our work won’t do what we were promised it would do, nor will it prioritize the people we claim to prioritize. To be able to build the systems we need, we must face an unpleasant truth: Our health care institutions as they exist today are part of the problem rather than the solution.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC ---Doctors Turn
Christopher Cai, 7-8-2021 Department of Medicine, Internal Medicine Residency Program at Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA Journal of General Internal Medicine How Would Medicare for All Affect Physician Revenue? https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11606-021-06979-z#:~:text=If%2C%20as%20studies%20suggest%2C%20Medicare,between%20%2439%2C816%20and%20%24157%2C412%20annually.
Organized medicine in the USA is shifting its position toward single-payer reform, one version of which, “Medicare for All,” has gained substantial support in Congress. The American Medical Association recently left the Partnership for America’s Healthcare Future, a lobbying group that spent more than one hundred million dollars annually opposing both a public option and Medicare for All in federal election campaigns. In 2020, the American College of Physicians and the Society of General Internal Medicine went a step further, endorsing both public option and single-payer reforms. Yet, physician opinion on Medicare for All remains split, with most doctors concerned that such reform might decrease their income. While physicians are highly paid, these concerns are understandable given the burden of student debt, the length of medical training, and Medicare’s lower fees relative to private insurers’ Are such concerns supported by evidence? The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office (CBO) recently estimated payments to physicians in 2030 under current policies and five options for Medicare for All. It projects that without reform the weighted average of public and private payments to physicians will increase to 116% of the 2019 weighted average, versus between 108% and 117% under the various Medicare for All options analyzed.1 But because the CBO expects Medicare for All to increase society-wide utilization of care, it also predicts that providers’ total revenues would increase, even if fee levels were to decline. More specifically, the CBO projects that in 2030 providers’ total outpatient revenues would be between 5 and 9% higher under Medicare for All than without reform; physician services currently account for 78% of such revenue.1,2 These estimates assume that Medicare for All would not significantly alter the supply of physicians, which is currently limited by the supply of residency and medical school spots.1 Some scholars project even larger boosts to physicians’ take-home pay because the CBO estimates may understate practices’ savings from streamlined billing. If, as studies suggest, Medicare for All would free up roughly 5% of doctors’ work hours currently spent on billing, allowing them to increase patient care, per-physician revenue could rise by between $39,816 and $157,412 annually.2 While those figures may be an overestimate, since some providers might choose to spend the freed-up time on leisure activities rather than increased patient care, they may underestimate revenue changes, as fee-for-service providers have, in the past, responded to decreased Medicare reimbursement rates by increasing volume of services.1 The latter won’t apply to salaried providers, such as those working in capitated healthcare systems, but these providers are still likely to feel the benefits of administrative streamlining. Other prominent economic analyses of Medicare for All have also projected net increases in physicians’ revenue, even if current Medicare payment rates do not increase.3 Yet despite projecting increases in physicians’ revenues, almost all estimates of the overall costs of single-payer reform project savings, due to savings from administrative simplification.3 Hence, it appears possible to design a single-payer reform that would offer universal coverage without cost sharing, while increasing net revenue to providers and decreasing national health expenditures.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC ---Growth › Extension – Economy Impacts
Hal Brands, Henry Kissinger distinguished professor of global affairs at Johns Hopkins University’s School of Advanced International Studies and a resident scholar at the American Enterprise Institute, and Michael Beckley is an associate professor of political science at Tufts University, September 24 2021 China Is a Declining Power—and That’s the Problem: The United States needs to prepare for a major war, not because its rival is rising but because of the opposite Foreign Policy, https://foreignpolicy.com/2021/09/24/china-great-power-united-states/
Over the past 150 years, peaking powers—great powers that had been growing dramatically faster than the world average and then suffered a severe, prolonged slowdown—usually don’t fade away quietly. Rather, they become brash and aggressive. They suppress dissent at home and try to regain economic momentum by creating exclusive spheres of influence abroad. They pour money into their militaries and use force to expand their influence. This behavior commonly provokes great-power tensions. In some cases, it touches disastrous wars. This shouldn’t be surprising. Eras of rapid growth supercharge a country’s ambitions, raise its people’s expectations, and make its rivals nervous. During a sustained economic boom, businesses enjoy rising profits and citizens get used to living large. The country becomes a bigger player on the global stage. Then stagnation strikes. Slowing growth makes it harder for leaders to keep the public happy. Economic underperformance weakens the country against its rivals. Fearing upheaval, leaders crack down on dissent. They maneuver desperately to keep geopolitical enemies at bay. Expansion seems like a solution—a way of grabbing economic resources and markets, making nationalism a crutch for a wounded regime, and beating back foreign threats. Many countries have followed this path. When the United States’ long post-Civil War economic surge ended, Washington violently suppressed strikes and unrest at home, built a powerful blue-water Navy, and engaged in a fit of belligerence and imperial expansion during the 1890s. After a fast-rising imperial Russia fell into a deep slump at the turn of the 20th century, the tsarist government cracked down hard while also enlarging its military, seeking colonial gains in East Asia and sending around 170,000 soldiers to occupy Manchuria. These moves backfired spectacularly: They antagonized Japan, which beat Russia in the first great-power war of the 20th century. A century later, Russia became aggressive under similar circumstances. Facing a severe, post-2008 economic slowdown, Russian President Vladimir Putin invaded two neighboring countries, sought to create a new Eurasian economic bloc, staked Moscow’s claim to a resource-rich Arctic, and steered Russia deeper into dictatorship. Even democratic France engaged in anxious aggrandizement after the end of its postwar economic expansion in the 1970s. It tried to rebuild its old sphere of influence in Africa, deploying 14,000 troops to its former colonies and undertaking a dozen military interventions over the next two decades. All of these cases were complicated, yet the pattern is clear. If a rapid rise gives countries the means to act boldly, the fear of decline serves up a powerful motive for rasher, more urgent expansion. The same thing often happens when fast-rising powers cause their own containment by a hostile coalition. In fact, some of history’s most gruesome wars have come when revisionist powers concluded their path to glory was about to be blocked.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC ---Growth › Extension – Competitiveness
Zoë Baird 20. CEO and President of the Markle Foundation. A.B. Phi Beta Kappa and a J.D. from the University of California, Berkeley. “Equitable Economic Recovery Is a National Security Imperative”. https://www.markle.org/sites/default/files/Chapter-13-Baird-Equitable-Economic-Recovery.pdf
Broadly shared economic prosperity is a bedrock of America’s economic and political strength—both domestically and in the international arena. A strong and equitable recovery from the economic crisis created by COVID-19 would be a powerful testament to the resilience of the American system and its ability to create prosperity at a time of seismic change and persistent global crisis. Such a recovery could attack the profound economic inequities that have developed over the past several decades. Without bold action to help all workers access good jobs as the economy returns, the United States risks undermining the legitimacy of its institutions and its international standing. The outcome will be a key determinant of America’s national security for years to come.
An equitable recovery requires a national commitment to help all workers obtain good jobs—particularly the twothirds of adults without a bachelor’s degree and people of color who have been most affected by the crisis and were denied opportunity before it. As the nation engages in a historic debate about how to accelerate economic recovery, ambitious public investment is necessary to put Americans back to work with dignity and opportunity. We need an intentional effort to make sure that the jobs that come back are good jobs with decent wages, benefits, and mobility and to empower workers to access these opportunities in a profoundly changed labor market.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC ---Growth › Extension – Competitiveness
Khatri, N. (2021). [Khatri - Associate Professor in the Department of Health Management and Informatics, School of Medicine, University of Missouri, Columbia, USA, Crony Capitalism in US Health Care: Anatomy of a Dysfunctional System (1st ed.). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003112204]MSU-CJK
Wasteful, Starving Other Sectors of Economy The US health care system on its current trajectory is simply unsustainable (Institute of Medicine Report, 2012; OECD, 2020). A recent review of 54 unique peer-reviewed research publications on the waste in the US health care system estimates the total annual waste to be in the range of $760 billion to $935 billion, accounting for approximately 25 percent of the total annual health care spending in the US (Shrank, Rogstad, & Parekh, 2019). This waste is more than the entire US defense budget in 2019. It is also more than the total Medicare spending in 2019. The estimated ranges of total annual cost of waste in the US health care system in the six commonly identified domains of waste are as follows: failure of care delivery ($102 billion to $166 billion), failure of care coordination ($27 billion to $78 billion), overtreatments ($76 billion to $101 billion), pricing failures ($231 billion to $241 billion), fraud and abuse ($56 billion to $84 billion), and administrative complexity ($266 billion). The waste in the health care system, which is approaching a trillion-dollar mark annually, is wiping out efficiency, productivity, and wealth created by other industries and other parts of the US economy (Girod, Hart, & Weltz, 2018; Horowitz, 2018; Manufacturing Institute, 2013; Milliman Medical Index, 2020). A news article entitled “Health Care Will Bankrupt the Nation” sums up the extent of the problem in the US health care system rather well (Riedl, 2017). By straining national, state, and family budgets, the US health care system is contributing to the starvation of other vital sectors, such as infrastructure and education, which have contributed notably to America’s wealth, ingenuity, and competitiveness: “If the US budget collapses after hemorrhaging too much red ink, the main culprit will be rising health care costs”, but not the entitlement programs such as social security (Horowitz, 2018). Absent some workable solution, spending on health care is likely to sink the federal budget, generating levels of debt that would hold back the economy and potentially spark a global crisis of confidence in United States’ ability to borrow. Federal spending on health care (mostly Medicare and Medicaid) rose from 14.4% of all federal outlays in 1990 to about 31% in 2018 – one of the main reasons the national debt grew to $21.5 trillion in 2018 (Wolf- Mann, 2018). Alarmed by the costs of health care in the United States, the Chairman of the Federal Reserve, Jerome Powell, noted: “It’s no secret: It’s been true for a long time that with our uniquely expensive healthcare delivery system …, we’ve been on an unsustainable fiscal path for a long time” (quoted in Wolf-Mann, 2018). One of the factors contributing to the decline of American manufacturing may very well be the high cost of health care in the US. In the ten years ending in 2012, employer costs for employee health care insurance increased by 66 percent – an increase in the structural cost disadvantage for US sfirms of 5.2 percentage points (Manufacturing Institute, 2013). Over the years, employer-provided health care costs have been growing much faster than the prices of products and services they sell. In 2018 in the US, the total cost of insurance for a typical family of four eclipsed $28,653, according to the Milliman Medical Index (2020). The employer contributed $16,368 and the employee contributed $12,285 ($7,703 as payroll deduction and $4,582 as out-o f- pocket costs). The employer’s contribution of $16,368 per employee adds to the cost of production in a significant way, making US manufacturing less competitive. One way to deal with the prohibitive costs of employee health care and to remain competitive for manufacturers is to move their production overseas. A scrutiny of the 2018 uprising of school teachers across many states such as Arizona, Colorado, Kentucky, North Carolina, Oklahoma, and West Virginia suggests that the funding cuts due to rising health care costs over the last two decades underlie these resentments and uprisings (Yan, 2018). For example, protests in West Virginia were ini- tially sparked by the state government taking away the health insur- ance coverage of school teachers. The cost of health care keeps rising at a much faster rate than the rate of inflation and increase in national income, thus leaving no money in state budgets for salary increases of teachers. School teachers across the nation have poor salaries and need to do other jobs, in addition to teaching, to be able to support them- selves and their families. The annual waste in the US health care system of $760 billion to $935 billion is more than ten times the annual budget of the US Department of Education of $60 billion in 2019. Further, while the annual health care expenditure on Medicare in 2019 increased by 4.6 percent and projected to increase by about the same rate in 2020, the annual budget of the US Department of Education in 2019 shrank by $8 billion from 2018 and is expected to dwindle further in 2020. Similarly, the US infrastructure – roads, airports, and power and electricity – has been deteriorating for quite some time. At one time, the US had by far one of the best infrastructures in the world, but not anymore. Even developing countries have either already caught up or catching up the US in the overall quality of their infrastructure. An international traveler is not likely to be too impressed with many airports in large US cities.