Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC ---Growth › Extension – Medical Debt

Rising health care costs will continue to be a drain on consumer spending and confidence.

Addie Fleron and The gathering storm: The uncertain future of US healthcare September 16, 2022 | Article https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/healthcare/our-insights/the-gathering-storm-the-uncertain-future-of-us-healthcare

End payers, already struggling to afford healthcare, have limited ability to absorb this potential acceleration in costs. Employers have continued to shift the cost of healthcare to employees. For example, 18 percent of employees were enrolled in high-deductible health plans in 2013. In 2021, 40 percent of employees were enrolled in these health plans. In addition, in 2019, the average family contribution to coverage was 32 percent for employees at companies with more than 500 workers and 53 percent at those with less than 499 workers. In our recent survey, 95 percent of employers stated that they would adjust benefits if cost increases were 4 percent or higher, with the most common changes being increasing employee cost sharing, shifting to high-deductible health plans, and optimizing the provider network. Consumers already face significant exposure to healthcare costs, as noted above, with the rising level of cost sharing in employer-sponsored insurance. In 2021, the average family faced an estimated annual exposure before coverage of $8,000 to $12,000. With $20,000 in average household savings in 2021, consumers’ ability to absorb this exposure is limited. Furthermore, 22 percent of consumers report having more than $1,000 of medical debt, 34 percent of those who chose to defer care stated it was due to lack of affordability, and 45 percent of consumers state that a $10 increase in the cost of a physician visit would lead them to avoid it. Moreover, while US workers are seeing nominal wage increases, inflation has eroded the gains, resulting in negative real earnings growth. Consumers’ satisfaction with employer-sponsored healthcare coverage is lower than their satisfaction with Medicare, Medicaid, or individual health insurance exchanges coverage. The government may also not be prepared to fund the increase in healthcare costs. The 2022 Medicare Trustees report projects that the hospital insurance trust fund balance will turn negative in 2028, limiting the federal government’s room to maneuver as it relates to costs. Recent implementation of 2 percent Medicare sequestration cuts illustrate this issue. If the Medicare trust fund needs to pay for additional healthcare spending, this timeline for trust fund insolvency could accelerate. In addition, federal debt stands at 123 percent of GDP. As the Federal Reserve raises interest rates and shrinks its balance sheet, interest payments on federal debt are expected to double as a proportion of the US budget between 2022 to 2027.

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC ---Growth › Extension – Medical Debt

Rising health care costs collapse consumer confidence and are causing rising medical debt.

ELIZABETH NAPOLITANO UPDATED ON: APRIL 17, 2023 / 11:51 AM / MONEYWATCH Health care now tops inflation among Americans' concerns, survey shows moneywatch .

Roughly 40% of adults report going into debt due to medical or dental bills, according to polling from the Kaiser Family Foundation, a nonprofit focused on health policy research. Additionally, roughly half of Americans say they struggle to afford health care costs, the survey shows. "It's like you are unprepared no matter how prepared you are," said Ally Ward from Chicago. She and her husband, Marcus, previously spoke with CBS News Consumer Investigative Correspondent Anna Werner in partnership with KFF Health News, about the that continues to follow them. The high cost of medical care has a disproportionate impact on people of color, as well as women, low earners and uninsured adults. Still, even those covered by health insurance "are not immune to the burden of health care costs," according to the KFF analysis. Approximately one-third of insured adults worry about paying their monthly health insurance premium, and 44% worry about affording their deductible, the survey found.

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC ---Growth › Extension – Medical Debt

Medical debt is uniquely destructive and private insurance can’t solve – universal care is key

MICHELLE ANDREWS January 24, 2017 “Medical Debt Is Top Reason Consumers Hear From Collection Agencies” Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation, NPR http://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2017/01/24/511269991/medical-debt-is-top-reason-consumers-hear-from-collection-agencies

More people have health insurance than ever before, but many still struggle to pay for care. A recently released report says medical debt is the No. 1 reason consumers reported being contacted by a collection agency. If efforts to overhaul the Affordable Care Act result in more people losing their coverage, those numbers could rise. The study by the federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau found that 59 percent of people who reported they had been contacted by a debt collector said it was for medical services. Telecommunications bills were the second most common type of overdue bill for which debt collectors pursued payment, at 37 percent, and utilities were third, reported by 28 percent. Unlike other types of debt, people with medical debt were prevalent across a range of income levels, credit scores and ages. A poll conducted in 2015 by NPR, The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and Harvard's T.H. Chan School of Public Health found that many people with health insurance still struggle to pay medical bills. Some 26 percent said health care expenses have taken a serious toll on family finances. The CFPB's survey sample was drawn from the agency's consumer credit panel, a random sample of credit records from one of the three major credit reporting agencies. Conducted between December 2014 and March 2015, the survey asked respondents about their experiences over the past year with debt collectors. Having medical debt turned over to collections can be a double whammy. "It's not just that people may be reluctant to go for care because of the debt they might incur," said Mark Rukavina, a Boston-based health care consultant whose work has focused on affordability and medical debt. "It might also ruin their credit." Having a medical bill in collection can substantially reduce consumers' credit scores, Rukavina said. The health law required nonprofit hospitals to take several steps to retain their federal nonprofit status, including establishing written policies for charity care. Hospitals must determine whether patients are eligible under their policies and provide charity care for those who are. Hospitals also must limit how much uninsured patients are charged and restrict aggressive billing and collections activities. Under those rules, nonprofit hospitals are barred from initiating "extraordinary collection actions," such as reporting to credit bureaus, garnishing wages or placing a lien on property or taking legal action, until 120 days after the first billing statement is sent. Although the rule doesn't apply to for-profit hospitals, the regulation introduced a federal standard for reporting medical debt, Rukavina said. The proportion of families that said they were having trouble paying their medical bills declined between September 2013, before the health law's insurance marketplaces opened in 2014, and March 2015, according to an analysis by the Urban Institute. The study found that the percentage of families that had problems paying medical bills declined from 22 percent in 2013 to 17.3 percent in 2015. Being uninsured, having a low income and enrolling in a high-deductible plan each increased the odds of having trouble paying medical bills, the study found. Republicans have vowed to press ahead with plans to repeal the Affordable Care Act, but since they don't have enough votes in the Senate to get a full repeal through, they are initially focusing on specific provisions that can be undone by a simple majority vote during the budget process. The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office reported Jan. 17 that under a Republican plan last year to partially repeal the law 18 million people would become uninsured in the first year, rising to 32 million in 2026. "Because more people would be uninsured, they'd be exposed to the full cost of their care and you'd very likely see the number of people who are carrying medical debt increase," said Sara Collins, vice president of health care coverage and access at the Commonwealth Fund, whose biennial insurance surveys examine issues of medical debt and underinsurance. If that happens, consumer protections could be even more important. Before the health law passed in 2010, some states passed hospital fair pricing laws that generally restricted how much hospitals could charge uninsured patients for care to no more than what is paid by public and private insurers. The law typically also required hospitals to provide free care to low-income uninsured patients. The laws were often initiated in response to aggressive billing and collection practices by hospitals, which would charge uninsured patients far higher rates than those paid by insured patients, who benefited from discounts negotiated by their health plans. The health law drew on elements of state fair pricing laws, and Sen. Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, was instrumental in adding those provisions, according to Rukavina. As such, they may be more likely to be retained in a Republican replacement to the law. State fair pricing laws typically reduce the amount that uninsured patients pay by about 25 to 30 percent, a recent study found. Since the Affordable Care Act passed there hasn't been much new activity at the state level on these laws, but that could change. "In an ideal world, these laws would be redundant or unnecessary," said Benedic Ippolito, a research fellow at the American Enterprise Institute who co-authored the study. "This type of legislation appears to be a little more relevant now than we would have thought it would be."

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC ---Growth › Extension – Medical Debt

Medical debt reduces consumer spending and economic growth

Driscoll and Williams, 2022 John Driscoll (President, Walgreens Health) and David Williams (President, Health Business Group), On an episode of , titled "What to Do About Medical Debt," hosts explored America's medical debt problem in great detail. August 26 2022 https://www.caretalkpodcast.com/post/americas-medical-debt-problem

One of the main causes of medical debt is the . Despite being the most expensive healthcare system in the world, the United States has some of the worst health outcomes among developed nations. This is due to a complex mix of factors, including the , , and a lack of regulation of healthcare costs. Another factor contributing to medical debt is the . While some people have insurance coverage through their employer or through programs such as and , many people are uninsured or underinsured. This means that they are responsible for paying for the full cost of their medical treatment, which can be prohibitively expensive. Medical debt can have a devastating impact on individuals and families. Many people are forced to choose between paying for medical treatment and other essential expenses such as rent, food, and utilities. This can lead to financial instability, debt, and even bankruptcy. Medical debt can also have long-term consequences, such as damaged credit scores and difficulty obtaining loans or credit in the future. The impact of medical debt is not limited to individuals. It also has broader societal implications. For example, medical debt can lead to a decrease in consumer spending and economic growth, as people are forced to cut back on spending in order to pay off their debts. It can also lead to higher healthcare costs overall, as providers pass on the cost of unpaid bills to other patients and insurance companies.

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC ---Growth › Extension – Medical Debt

Medicare for All is needed to prevent medical bankruptcy

Public Citizen, nonprofit consumer advocacy organization, 2023, Medicare-for-All Prevents Medical Bankruptcies, ,

Each year, nearly 650,000 people are pushed into bankruptcy by medical bills, accounting for more than 60 percent of all personal bankruptcies. It’s not just a problem for the poor or unemployed,  either – the majority of people experiencing medical bankruptcy were employed, college-educated homeowners. More surprising, nearly 80 percent had insurance at the time they got sick. Medicare-for-All would end medical bankruptcy once and for all. Americans would no longer have to pay outrageous amounts or go into debt in order to receive treatment. In addition, Americans would be protected over their lifetime because they would remain covered in the event they lost their job, started a business or went back to school, reducing the risk for catastrophic out-of-pocket health costs. 

Under Medicare-for-All, every American would finally be able to access health care without worrying about financial ruin. A UK resident recently commented on their health care system: “You don’t worry about healthcare, ever, for any reason. It’s just there. Like the police or the fire department. There are no bills, no paperwork, no deductibles, no insurance companies to deal with, no ‘patient statements,’ no risk of going bankrupt if you get the ‘wrong’ disease.” Imagine the security of knowing that your doctor will be there to take care of you when you are sick, regardless of your income.  

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC ---Growth › Extension – Medical Debt

Medical debt is a cyclical drain on economic growth.

Published on March 11, 2023 America’s Healthcare Debt Is Deepening U.S. citizenshave access to unparalleled medical care, but the cost means millions will never receive it. https://www.worth.com/americas-healthcare-debt-is-deepening/

The United States’ profusion of healthcare facilities, technologies, and therapies are unavailable to most of the world. Yet, for most Americans who need medical care, our country’s unparalleled resources quickly become a curse. It’s no secret that the U.S. healthcare system often leaves its patients with unwieldy out-of-pocket costs. And for those who lack the proper financial funds, these costs can quickly spiral into medical debt. But what is the true extent of medical debt in the U.S.? How does it affect both individuals and communities? And how can those fortunate enough not to suffer from medical debt work to ameliorate the problem for those who do? The more likely one is to need medical care, the more likely one is to suffer from medical debt. Unlike other kinds of debt, accrued from things like purchasing a house, buying a car, or even going to college, medical debt is not incurred voluntarily. Those in higher income brackets are better able to pay off unexpected bills whereas, for people with limited financial resources, even the smallest, unforeseen medical expense can be unmanageable. Thus, rates of medical debt are at their highest in lower-income zip codes, disproportionately affecting areas that often are already suffering from the brunt of systemic oppression. The costs of healthcare have skyrocketed over the past fifteen years. According to a 2018 report by the , the cost of medical care increased by 16 percent from 2012 to 2016—an unduly excessive growth in comparison to the inflation rate of 4.5 percent for the same period. In cities such as New York and Tampa, medical care prices surged by almost 22 percent. In a 2021 annual employer survey, the Henry J. (KFF) found that the average annual insurance deductible for single workers is $1,669, four times the average deductible cost in 2006. The combined weight of escalated medical prices and rapidly rising insurance rates have exploded into a debt crisis for everyday Americans. A study by , released in 2021 and published by the American Medical Association found that almost 18 percent of Americans owed $140 billion in medical debt to debt collectors—a number that does not include data from the pandemic and is nevertheless almost double the $81 billion that JAMA estimated Americans owed in 2016. Another study done by KFF, investigating different federal data from the 2020 Survey of Income and Program Participation, gauged that Americans owed more than $195 billion in medical debt as of 2019. One of the most pernicious effects of medical debt is the cyclical nature in which it simultaneously entraps patients while preventing them from receiving the care they need. For fear of being unable to pay for care due to inflated deductibles or other factors, individuals are discouraged from seeking preventative treatments—treatments that could help avert emergency situations. When emergencies do arise, however, this lack of preventative care often snowballs into the extreme costs and ensuing debt that patients were attempting to avoid in the first place. George Halvorson Kaiser Permanente’s former chief executive explained in an investigation done by (KHN) that “people are getting bankrupted when they get care, even if they have insurance.” In addition to deterring people from seeking the care and treatments they need, the U.S. healthcare system also actively denies care to those who have already incurred medical debt. According to KHN’s study, 1 in 7 people with medical debt say that they have been denied access to care because of unpaid bills. The study also revealed that major health systems such as , , , and will take legal action against patients who are unable to pay. In fact, Over two-thirds of hospitals have policies that allow them to sue patients or even garnish their wages. The burden of medical debt is felt not only in the lives of individuals but also across communities, deepening systemic inequalities. According to the KFF analysis, Hispanic adults are 35 percent more likely, and Black adults are 50 percent more likely to struggle with outstanding healthcare costs than white adults. Women also report more medical debt than men due to expenses related to childbirth in combination with lower average incomes. Additionally, adults under the age of 30 are almost twice as likely to suffer from medical debt than those ages 65 and older. In exacerbating and reinforcing longstanding, pervasive social inequalities, medical debt is, at its core, a discriminatory practice.

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC ---Growth › Extension – Medical Debt

Health care debt drains consumer confidence & spending.

Lopes, et.al., 2022 Lunna Lopes , Audrey Kearney Follow @audrey__kearney on Twitter , Alex Montero , Liz Hamel Follow @lizhamel on Twitter , and Mollyann Brodie Follow @Mollybrodie on Twitter Health Care Debt In The U.S.: The Broad Consequences Of Medical And Dental Bills Published: Jun 16, 2022 https://www.kff.org/report-section/kff-health-care-debt-survey-main-findings/

Unexpected bills can be a major contributor to health care . Most adults with health care debt say the bills that led to their debt were from a one-time or short-term medical expense, which are often unexpected. Indeed, about half of adults – including three in ten of those who do not currently have health care debt – are vulnerable to falling into debt, saying they would be unable to pay a $500 unexpected medical bill without borrowing money. While about a third of adults with health care debt owe less than $1,000, even small amounts of debt can have significant financial consequences for some. Though a third of those with current debt expect to pay it off within a year and about a quarter expect to pay it within one to two years, nearly one in five adults with health care debt think they will never be able to pay it off. In their efforts to service or pay off their debt, adults with health care debt report making a number of sacrifices and enduring substantial financial consequences. Most report cutting back on household spending, and more than four in ten say they or a household member have used up all or most of their savings due to their health care debt. Many also report more serious consequences like skipping payment on other bills, delaying college or buying a home, or changing their housing situation as a result of their debt. In addition, about half of adults with health care debt say they have made what they feel to be a difficult sacrifice in order to pay down their debt. These sacrifices have left some individuals feeling as if they could not provide a good life for their families, or with a general sense that they will never be able to extricate themselves from debt. Other reported consequences of debt, such as being contacted by debt collectors and having their credit scores negatively affected, can lead to additional financial problems such as difficulty buying vehicles needed for work or buying or renting a home.

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC ---Growth › Extension – Wage Growth

Medicare for all will raise wages

Austin Frakt, 2020 “Would your wages rise under Medicare for All?” //accessed 06/28/2023 CG

So will Medicare for all cause wages to rise if employers have to spend less on benefits? Research suggests the answer is “yes,” with the caveat that it may not be matched dollar for dollar for everyone. The precise relationship depends on the nature of the labor market, which varies across markets and jobs. The economic theory that explains why employees foot the bill for health insurance is this: Whether it’s in dollars or health insurance, what matters to workers is the total value of their compensation for work. (There are other workplace benefits, but none anywhere near as costly and important as wages and health insurance.)In a competitive and fluid labor market — where there are many similar employers and workers, and little difficulty in hiring or switching jobs — an employer that tries to undercut the prevailing market rate risks losing workers to competitors. Likewise, a worker who demands more could well be passed over for another who will accept the prevailing rate for total compensation.“Yes, an individual worker might get a little more or less than market compensation from time to time,” said Steven Pizer, a health economist  at the Boston University School of Public Health. “But if employment is fluid, there’s just no way, according to the theory, for that to happen consistently.” One option under Senator Bernie Sanders’s Medicare for all plan would reduce employer spending on health insurance by $9,000 per employee and raise taxes on the wealthy. Senator Elizabeth Warren’s plan would also raise taxes on the wealthy, but would aim to tax employers an amount intended to match what they would have spent on health care anyway.

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC ---Growth › Extension – Wage Growth

Universal health care boosts the probability of a job being a “good” job by almost 20% and is likely to boost wages.

• March 5, 2020 Josh Bivens joined the Economic Policy Institute in 2002 and is currently EPI’s director of research. His primary areas of research include macroeconomics, social insurance, and globalization. Fundamental health reform like ‘Medicare for All’ would help the labor marketJob loss claims are misleading, and substantial boosts to job quality are often overlooked • https://www.epi.org/publication/medicare-for-all-would-help-the-labor-market/

Medicare for All could increase job quality substantially by making all jobs “good” jobs in terms of health insurance coverage and by increasing the potential for higher wages. While the definition of a “good job” is always going to be a bit imprecise, the vast majority of U.S. workers would say that a good job is one that pays decent wages and that also provides the health insurance coverage and retirement income benefits that most of today’s workers can only reliably access through employment. Nearly half of jobs fail this test on account of health care coverage alone: In 2016, 46.9% of workers held jobs in which their employer made no contributions to the workers’ health care; for workers in the middle fifth of the wage distribution, 42.9% held jobs in which the employer made no contribution to their health care (EPI 2017). By making health coverage universal and delinking from employment, M4A would make it far easier for employers to offer good jobs in this regard, as every job would now be accompanied by guaranteed health care coverage. Further, as noted above, wages and salaries would have substantial room to grow if health care costs were taken off of the backs of employers. Schmitt and Jones (2013) estimate the share of good jobs—jobs that clear a specified wage floor and provide health and retirement coverage—in overall employment each year between 1979 and 2011. They then look at various policy changes that would boost this share. They find that providing universal health coverage would boost the probability that any given job in the economy is a good job by almost 20%—and that’s even before any potential boost to the share of jobs that are good jobs coming from cash wage increases provided as employers shed health care costs. The boost to job quality from making health coverage universal would be even greater for women workers, as women are currently less likely to receive employer-sponsored health insurance benefits from their own employers.

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC ---Growth › Extension – Wage Growth

Medicare for All will boost wage growth

May 28, 2019 at 3:47 pm CDT ‘Medicare for All’ Advocates Strategize to Win Over the Working Class https://pro.morningconsult.com/articles/medicare-for-all-advocates-strategize-win-over-working-class

Undeterred by accusations of socialism from Republicans and cautious skepticism from the Democratic establishment, single-payer advocates are mobilizing around a new strategy to keep the energy around their cause alive: positioning “Medicare for All” as a working-class issue that is designed to bolster the economy and ignite wage growth after decades of stagnation. Even as some Democratic candidates vying for the party’s nomination for president pass over full-fledged single-payer plans and align with the public option, often billed as the politically agreeable and modest alternative, lawmakers and activists on the frontlines of the push for Medicare for All -- led by Rep. Pramila Jayapal (D-Wash.) -- do not intend to settle for what they view as thinly veiled attempts to further enshrine the role of private insurers in the U.S. health care system. But advocates know if Medicare for All is to garner additional momentum, the fervor of the progressive base must extend to the working class, a voting bloc critical for a Democratic victory in 2020. Jayapal, co-author of the Medicare for All legislation in the House, said she remains confident as ever that Congress is moving in the direction of universal health care -- especially given that her bill has a larger labor coalition on board than ever before. As the cost of employer-sponsored health care continues to rise, “a lot of labor has come to understand that they’re leaving wages on the table by having to pay for health care,” Jayapal said. By taking health insurance off the bargaining table, she argued, workers are empowered to fight for other issues that are important to them. Kelly Coogan-Gehr, the assistant director of public and community advocacy for National Nurses United, said the union has been on the ground, canvassing, door-knocking and explaining to Americans in town halls that under the current system, employers use health insurance to disempower working people across the country. NNU, the largest organization of registered nurses in the country, is one of several progressive organizations leading the grassroots movement for Medicare for All, alongside groups such as Public Citizen and the Center for Popular Democracy. The argument that Medicare for All could directly counter wage stagnation is incredibly persuasive among workers, Coogan-Gehr said. If unions no longer have to exercise their power to bargain for better health care, it will open up “a world of issue fights,” she said, allowing employees to use their collective bargaining power to negotiate raises and make new demands on everything from safe staffing to workplace safety. “Because of the attachment of health insurance to one’s job, workers have been less willing to take direct action, to strike, to exercise basic rights to reconsolidate their power in the workplace,” Coogan-Gehr said.

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC ---Growth › Extension – Wage Growth

Medicare for All increases wages and salaries – by decreasing employer costs for health insurance.

• March 5, 2020 Josh Bivens joined the Economic Policy Institute in 2002 and is currently EPI’s director of research. His primary areas of research include macroeconomics, social insurance, and globalization. Fundamental health reform like ‘Medicare for All’ would help the labor marketJob loss claims are misleading, and substantial boosts to job quality are often overlooked • https://www.epi.org/publication/medicare-for-all-would-help-the-labor-market/

Medicare for All could increase wages and salaries for U.S. workers by reducing employers’ costs for health insurance—freeing up fiscal space to invest in wages instead. The share of total annual compensation paid to American employees in the form of health insurance premiums rather than wages and salaries rose from 1.1% in 1960 to 4.2% in 1979 to 8.4% in 2018. If this post-1960 increase had been only half as large—and employers had spent the health cost savings on wages and salaries—the take-home wages of American workers would have been almost $400 billion higher in 2018. Given that the share of total compensation spoken for by health insurance premiums is starting from a high base today, any reform that managed to slow the excess growth of health spending going forward would go a long way in making space for faster growth of cash compensation.

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC ---Growth › Extension – Administrative Costs

US private health insurance spends unnecessarily exorbitant amounts on administrative costs

Diane Archer, 01-08-2020, (Diane Archer is president of Just Care USA, an independent digital hub covering health and financial issues facing boomers and their families and promoting policy solutions. She is the past board chair of Consumer Reports and serves on the Brown University School of Public Health Advisory Board. Ms. Archer began her career in health advocacy in 1989 as founder and president of the Medicare Rights Center, a national organization dedicated to ensuring that older and disabled Americans get the health care they need. She served as director, Health Care for All Project, Institute for America's Future, between 2005 and 2010.), "Medicare for all would save $600 billion a year in administrative costs," Just Care USA, , da: 06-26-2023, //mduff

A new paper by Steffie Woolhandler et al. in the Annals of Medicine exposes our health care system’s grave inefficiencies. It finds that the US currently spends more than $800 billion a year on administrative costs. Medicare for All would eliminate almost three-quarters of these costs and save more than $600 billion a year. The vast majority of Medicare for All’s savings would come from doing away with almost all provider-rate negotiations and bureaucratic headaches that come with having commercial health insurance. Today, literally thousands of health insurers must establish their own payment rates and their own set of rules for covering particular services. On top of that, the overwhelming majority of health insurers make a significant profit. In 2017, the US spent about one in three health care dollars (34.2 percent) on health care administration, $812 billion. In dollar terms, administrative costs added more than $2,497 to health care spending per person. Compared to Canada, which spent $551 per person on health care administration, the US spent almost five times more. Administrative functions represented just 17 percent of Canada’s health care spending.

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC ---Growth › Extension – Administrative Costs

Public health care spends less on administration than private insurance

Adam Gaffney, 5-12-22, (Adam Gaffney holds a medical degree and a Masters of Public Health. He is an assistant professor at Harvard Medical School, has published a book on historical medical access, and is highly active in discussions about medical policy.), “Medicare for All: Protecting Health, Saving Lives, Saving Money”, Senate Budget Committee, , da: 06-26-2023, //mduff

In 2017, 34% of healthcare spending was devoted to administration in the US — approximately twice the proportion spent on administration in Canada’s single-payer national health insurance system. Much of this administrative expense stems from the wasteful bureaucracy inherent to private health insurance. Compared to a public insurer like traditional Medicare, private insurers inflict numerous added costs, including profits for shareholders, bloated executive salaries, product and benefit design, marketing, and burdensome processes for disputing claims (needed to maximize profit). The CBO estimates that private insurance plans take 16.0% of their premium revenues for their overhead and profit. The National Health Expenditure Accounts (NHEA) historical year data provides a slightly lower estimate of 12% (author’s calculation; 2018-2020 three-year moving average). Publicly-funded plans operated by private health insurance companies, e.g. Medicare Advantage, have overhead similar to those of other commercial health insurance plans. An estimate from the Government Accountability Office (GAO) put overhead for Medicare Advantage plans (inclusive of profit) at 13.6% in 2011. Today, the share may even be higher. Using the 2020 NHEA estimate of Medicare net private health insurance costs (i.e. overhead) of $63.4 billion divided by 2020 estimates from the 2021 report of Medicare Trustees of $42227 in Medicare Part C +D spending gives a similar overhead of 15%. In comparison, traditional Medicare has an overhead of approximately 2% (author’s calculation from the 2021 Medicare Trustees report); a similar proportion is estimated by the CBO for overhead under Medicare for All. Nations with national health insurance systems, including Canada, have a similarly low insurance overhead. In other words, reducing insurance overhead of the overall US healthcare system to that of traditional Medicare could unlock enormous savings — funds that can then be used to cover the costs of a generous coverage expansion for all. And indeed, the CBO has estimated savings from such a reduction in insurance costs at over $400 billion annually. Some analyses have come to lower savings because they incorrectly projected that overhead of a single-payer system would be more than three times higher than that projected by the CBO.

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC ---Growth › Extension – Administrative Costs

Medicare is that cheap EVEN after payer other federal entities for their services

Daniel Marans 3-9-2017. ( Daniel Marans. "Insurance Companies Just Accidentally Made The Case For Medicare For All." HuffPost. Web. 3-9-2017. accessed 9-6-2017. &lt; <span class="skimlinks-unlinked">http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/insurance-companies-medicare-for-all_us_58c1b1fae4b054a0ea690dc8</span> &gt;. Phops)

Some critics claim the Medicare figures are misleading, because the government insurance program benefits from Social Security Administration and Internal Revenue Service help in collecting the taxes it needs to fund its operations. In fact, Medicare reimburses the other federal agencies for their services, according to Paul Van de Water, a senior fellow at the liberal Center on Budget & Policy Priorities. “The notion that there are all these federal costs that are not accounted for is absolutely positively false,” Van de Water said. There are risks and tradeoffs of a single-payer system, like the possibility that insurance coverage will provide fewer benefits than the private insurance market, according to Austin Frakt, a health economist for the Department of Veterans Affairs with academic posts at Boston University and Harvard. And there are other systems for bringing down costs, like all-payer rate setting, which allows multiple insurers to negotiate provider prices as a single unit, Frakt added. But “if you look just at cost control, you almost can’t do better than single payer,” Frakt said. Thanks, America’s Health Insurance Plans!

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC ---Growth › Extension – Administrative Costs

Medicare for All would save hundreds of billions of dollars annually and decreases administrative costs by 400%

APHA ‘20. “The Importance of Universal Health Care in Improving Our Nation’s Response to Pandemics and Health Disparities.” American Public Health Association, American Public Health Association, 24 October 2020, https://www.apha.org/policies-and-advocacy/public-health-policy-statements/policy-database/2021/01/14/the-importance-of-universal-health-care-in-improving-response-to-pandemics-and-health-disparities. Accessed 28 June 2023. [APHA publishes the American Journal of Public Health and is a leading advocacy voice for public health] //QSMIT

Counterpoint: Some models of single-payer universal health care systems estimate savings of $450 billion annually.[37] Others estimate $1.8 trillion in savings over a 10-year period.[38] In 2019, 17% of the U.S. GDP was spent on health care; comparable countries with universal health care spent, on average, only 8.8%.[39]

Counterpoint: Health care services in the United States are more expensive than in other economically comparable countries. For example, per capita spending on inpatient and outpatient care (the biggest driver of health care costs in the United States) is more than two times greater even with shorter hospital stays and fewer physician visits.[40] Overall, the United States spends over $5,000 more per person in health costs than countries of similar size and wealth.[40]

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC ---Growth › Extension – Administrative Costs

Medicare For All would save more than $500 billion in administrative costs alone.

Kemp, et.al., 2019 This report was written by Eagan Kemp, health care policy advocate for Public Citizen’s Congress Watch division. Taylor Lincoln, research director for Congress Watch, provided guidance and aided in the collection and analysis of data. Susan Harley, deputy director of Public Citizen’s Congress Watch division, and Lisa Gilbert, vice president for legislative affairs, edited the report. Steve Knievel, advocate for Public Citizen’s Access to Medicines Program, and Michael Carome, director of Public Citizen’s Health Research Group, provided subject matter expertise and guidance. THE CASE FOR MEDICARE-FOR-ALL Public Citizen Feb 4 2019 https://www.citizen.org/wp-content/uploads/migration/the_case_for_medicare-for-all_-_february.pdf

Around one-third of U.S. health care dollars are spent on administrative functions, including insurance company overhead; administrative costs of hospitals, practitioners, nursing homes and other providers; and costs incurred by employers in managing their workers’ benefits.20 Studies have routinely found that the United States has the highest rate of administrative health care costs among wealthy countries.21 Excessive administrative spending is wasteful because it doesn’t do anything to treat patients or improve public health. Through simplified administration under Medicare-for-All, some researchers have estimated that we would save more than $500 billion a year.22 Increased administrative costs are one of the key reasons that health care costs have risen sharply over the past 40 years. Costs relating to managing health insurance are a major component of these rising administrative costs. Private insurers spend around 12 percent of their annual budgets on administration. 23 Traditional Medicare is much more efficient, spending only around two percent on administrative costs.24 In a seminal study published in the New England Journal of Medicine in 2003, researchers concluded that administrative functions consumed 31 percent of U.S. health care costs, compared to just 16.7 percent in Canada.25 A breakdown of those costs, as measured on a per capita basis, is below [Figure 5]. In 2014, two of the authors from that New England Journal of Medicine article published a follow-up study comparing the expenditures for administrative functions at hospitals in the United States, Canada and several western European countries. They concluded that administrative costs consumed around 25 percent of U.S. hospital spending, far above most comparable countries [Figure 6]. 27 If hospital administrative spending were brought in line with more efficient countries, the U.S. could save more than $150 billion each year on hospital spending alone, the researchers concluded.28 Other researchers have investigated the costs that administrative functions consume on a per physician basis for group medical practices. In a study published in Health Affairs in 2009, researchers surveyed physicians in practices of one to two, three to nine, and 10 and above. They concluded that administrative functions alone cost more than $68,000 annually per physician, with fairly similar amounts paid by each category of practice size. 29 In a study published in JAMA in 2018, researchers concluded that administrative activities cost primary care practices an average of almost $100,000 per physician.30 This figure is not only striking in its size of nearly $100,000, but fairly consistent with the finding of practices devoting about $68,000 to administrative functions about a decade earlier [Figure 7].

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC ---Growth › Extension –Cost Savings

Medicare for All reduces total healthcare spending and saves the economy money in the short term and long term

Laura Kurtzman January 15th, 2020 (Laura has a master’s in journalism from Columbia and she leads communications at UNCF) “Single-Payer Systems Likely to Save Money in US, Analysis Finds” https://www.ucsf.edu/news/2020/01/416416/single-payer-systems-likely-save-money-us-analysis-finds Accessed 6/28/23 /ESIEV

A single-payer healthcare system would save money over time, likely even during the first year of operation, according to nearly two dozen analyses of national and statewide single payer proposals made over the past 30 years. The study, published Wednesday, Jan. 15, 2020, in PLOS Medicine, comes as California Gov. Gavin Newsom has named a state commission to find ways to achieve universal coverage, possibly through a single-payer system, and as the Democratic presidential candidates are debating “Medicare for All” proposals on the national stage. The U.S. spends more on healthcare than any other country, yet is one of only a few developed nations that does not provide universal coverage. Under proposed single payer bills, such as “Medicare for All,” a unified public financing system would replace private insurance, similar to the healthcare system in Canada and many other wealthy nations. To estimate what would happen if the United States adopted a single-payer system, researchers from UCSF, UCLA and UC Berkeley examined 22 economic analyses by government, business and academic organizations of national and state-level single payer plans, including proposals made in Massachusetts, California, Maryland, Vermont, Minnesota, Pennsylvania, New York and Oregon. These analyses were used by policymakers to evaluate the proposals, estimating savings the plans would create through simplified billing and lower drug costs while also taking into account increases in health spending that would arise as newly insured people sought healthcare. The researchers found that 19 of the 22 models predicted net savings in the first year after implementation, averaging 3.5 percent of total healthcare spending. The researchers were able to estimate longer-term savings by using cost projections made in 10 of the models, which looked as far as 11 years into the future. These studies assumed that savings would grow over time, as the increases in healthcare utilization by the newly insured leveled off, and the global budgets adopted by single-payer systems helped to constrain costs. By the 10th year, all modeled single payer systems would save money, even those that projected costs would initially increase. “Even though they start with different single designs and modeling assumptions, the vast majority of these studies all come to the same conclusion,” said James G. Kahn, MD, MPH, a professor in the UCSF Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, and a member of the Philip R. Lee Health Policy Institute. “This suggests that fears that a single-payer system would increase costs are likely misplaced.” Savings from simplified payment administration and reductions in drug prices and other efficiencies ranged from 3 to 27 percent, with the largest savings found in plans that lowered drug costs. Higher initial costs were associated with plans that had low co-pays or none at all, offered rich benefits, or that did not expect savings from lower drug and medical equipment costs. This means that across the political spectrum, there is near consensus among these economists that a single-payer system would save money. CHRISTOPHER CAI The models were created by analysts from different political perspectives, and they provided a range of cost estimates in the first year of operation, from 7 percent higher to 15 percent lower. The researchers found that the economic models that were supported by left-leaning funders or that were done by academics found slightly larger net savings. But analyses supported by more conservative funders or performed outside of academia still predicted single-payer systems would yield savings. “This means that across the political spectrum, there is near consensus among these economists that a single-payer system would save money,” said Christopher Cai, a third-year medical student at UCSF and the study’s first author. “Replacing private insurance with a public system is essential to achieving these savings.”

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC ---Growth › Extension –Cost Savings

Economic benefits; increased taxation revenue & economic productivity

Nelson, Jaeger. the unit chief of the fiscal policy studies unit at the Congressional Budget Office in the Macroeconomic Analysis Division/Graduated from Indiana University with a Ph.D. in economics/research fields are computational macroeconomics and public economics, “Economic Effects of Five Illustrative Single-Payer Health Care Systems.” Congressional Budget Office, February 2022. . -sammy

This paper builds on previous studies published by the Congressional Budget Office about single-payer health care systems. It uses a general-equilibrium, overlapping-generations model to analyze the economic and distributional implications of five illustrative single-payer health care systems. The systems vary by their payment rates to providers, degree of cost sharing, and inclusion of benefits for long-term services and supports (LTSS). The economic effects of financing a single-payer system are beyond the scope of this paper. However, the results can be paired with some of CBO’s previously published estimates of the economic effects of financing a large and permanent increase in government spending. We analyze six channels through which a single-payer system would affect the economy: ■ The composition of workers’ labor compensation would change because employers would no longer provide health care benefits and would pass along the savings to employees, increasing their taxable wages. ■ Households’ health insurance premiums would be eliminated, and their out-of-pocket (OOP) health care costs would decline. ■ Administrative expenses in the health care sector would decline, freeing up productive resources for other sectors and ultimately increasing economywide productivity. ■ Reduced payment rates to providers would increase productivity and efficiency in providing health care; however, some of the reduction in payment rates would be passed through to workers’ wages in the health care sector and throughout the supply chain. ■ Longevity and labor productivity would increase as people’s health outcomes improved. ■ LTSS benefits would further reduce OOP spending, provide payments for care that is currently unpaid, increase wages among workers providing care, and allow some unpaid caregivers to increase their hours worked at their primary occupation. In this analysis, we found that economic output would be between 0.3 percent lower and 1.8 percent higher than the benchmark economy 10 years after the single-payer system was implemented, without incorporating the effects of financing the system. Under a single-payer system, workers would choose to work fewer hours, on average, despite higher wages because the reduction in health insurance premiums and OOP expenses would generate a positive wealth effect that allowed households to spend their time on activities other than paid work and maintain the same standard of living. If the system was financed with an income or payroll tax, gross domestic product (GDP) would be between approximately 1.0 percent and 10 percent lower by 2030, depending on the specification of the single-payer system and the details of the financing policy. Moreover, that wealth effect would boosts households’ disposable income, which they could then split between increased saving and nonhealth consumption. Although hours worked per capita would decline, the effect on GDP would be offset under most policy specifications by an increase in economywide productivity, an increase in the size of the labor force, an increase in the average worker’s labor productivity, and a rise in the capital stock. Additionally, we found that average private nonhealth consumption per capita would rise by about 11.5 percent by 2030. The average rise in nonhealth consumption is larger than it would be if the effects of financing the system were included in the analysis. The effects of a single-payer health care system on nonhealth consumption would be felt differently by people of different ages and incomes. The percentage increase in lifetime nonhealth consumption would be largest among younger and lower-income households after the system was implemented. If the system was financed with an income or payroll tax, nonhealth consumption per capita would be between approximately 3 percent higher and 7 percent lower by 2030, depending on the specification of the single-payer system and the details of the financing policy

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC ---Growth › Extension –Cost Savings

Medicare for All would save nearly 20% on costs – notably decreases in administrative costs and pharmaceutical prices.

Kemp, et.al., 2019 This report was written by Eagan Kemp, health care policy advocate for Public Citizen’s Congress Watch division. Taylor Lincoln, research director for Congress Watch, provided guidance and aided in the collection and analysis of data. Susan Harley, deputy director of Public Citizen’s Congress Watch division, and Lisa Gilbert, vice president for legislative affairs, edited the report. Steve Knievel, advocate for Public Citizen’s Access to Medicines Program, and Michael Carome, director of Public Citizen’s Health Research Group, provided subject matter expertise and guidance. THE CASE FOR MEDICARE-FOR-ALL Public Citizen Feb 4 2019 https://www.citizen.org/wp-content/uploads/migration/the_case_for_medicare-for-all_-_february.pdf

Numerous studies have analyzed the prospective effectiveness of single-payer plans nationally and at the state level, as well as other universal coverage approaches. 15 Most of these studies found savings, to varying degrees. These findings are supported by the experiences of countries that already have universal health care and provide care more efficiently than the United States. 16 A recent study by the Political Economy Research Institute at the University of Massachusetts-Amherst found that Medicare-for-All could save nearly 20 percent versus our current system, with the largest sources of savings being increased administrative efficiency and significantly lower pharmaceutical prices.17 Even a recent study by a researcher at the Koch Brothers-funded Mercatus Center, reached conclusions on overall health spending that would result in $2 trillion in lower health care spending over a ten-year period starting in 2022. 18 However, previous studies have found even higher savings from administrative efficiency than were cited in that study.19

2023 SDI Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC ---Growth › Extension –Cost Savings

Medicare for All yields significant cost savings – numerous studies and the empirical example of Medicare prove

Kemp, et.al., 2019 This report was written by Eagan Kemp, health care policy advocate for Public Citizen’s Congress Watch division. Taylor Lincoln, research director for Congress Watch, provided guidance and aided in the collection and analysis of data. Susan Harley, deputy director of Public Citizen’s Congress Watch division, and Lisa Gilbert, vice president for legislative affairs, edited the report. Steve Knievel, advocate for Public Citizen’s Access to Medicines Program, and Michael Carome, director of Public Citizen’s Health Research Group, provided subject matter expertise and guidance. THE CASE FOR MEDICARE-FOR-ALL Public Citizen Feb 4 2019 https://www.citizen.org/wp-content/uploads/migration/the_case_for_medicare-for-all_-_february.pdf

Numerous studies have concluded that Medicare-for-All would yield significant cost savings. But there is also a very simple exhibit to turn to: Medicare, itself. Although Medicare’s costs have increased over time in real dollars, they have risen much more slowly than the cost of care for Americans covered by private health insurance. Since 2009, Medicare’s costs (adjusted for inflation) have actually fallen [Figure 2]. 6 This accomplishment is all the more remarkable because Medicare primarily treats elderly patients with more chronic and complicated health conditions than the population as a whole. Medicare coverage in its current state is not as generous as the plan we envision but represents a strong foundation on which Medicare-for-All would be built. As we seek to build a Medicare-for-All system, it is important to learn from countries that already provide universal health care. While studies comparing different countries’ health care systems and outcomes invariably find the United States suffers numerous dubious distinctions, other countries’ systems have faults, as well. For instance, many countries’ health care systems have gaps in the types of services they cover and, because of out-of-pocket costs, some percentage of residents of every country in the world report going without necessary care because they cannot afford it. By understanding both best practices and areas for improvement, we can build a uniquely American health care system that guarantees access to care. We are at a rare moment in time, in the window of what might be a once-in-a-century opportunity to boldly reshape our health care system to expand and improve access to care such that we could potentially leap-frog the countries that currently outperform us in health outcomes. Such a clear surge in support for Medicare-for-All that our nation is experiencing holds the promise of taking us from worst-to-first when it comes to providing guaranteed access to health care. In this report, we highlight research from a variety of scholars and researchers to answer the key questions about Medicare-for-All and lay out a path for finally achieving health care coverage for everyone in the United States.