2023
SDI
Affirmative
Off Case Answers › Other Solvency Mechs
Robert Greenstein (founder and President Emeritus of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. He is considered an expert on the federal budget and a range of domestic policy issues, including anti-poverty programs and various aspects of tax and health care policy.) June 13, 2019 “Commentary: Universal Basic Income May Sound Attractive But, If It Occurred, Would Likelier Increase Poverty Than Reduce It” https://www.cbpp.org/research/poverty-and-opportunity/commentary-universal-basic-income-may-sound-attractive-but-if-it
To be sure, there is a possible exception: a carbon tax that returns its proceeds to the public via a universal payment. For a carbon tax to have any chance of enactment in the not-too-distant future, however, it almost certainly will have to allocate a substantial part of its proceeds to uses that are necessary to get the votes to enact it in the first place, such as relief for coal-producing states or regions. There’s also a powerful case for using some of the proceeds to greatly expand and accelerate research into alternative energy technologies; a carbon tax likely won’t be sufficient by itself to arrest global warming. Thus, the proceeds available from a carbon tax to finance universal payments would likely be significantly constrained. If a carbon tax could pass, we might need to focus the proceeds available for these payments on low- and moderate-income families — so the payments would be adequate to offset the higher energy costs these families would face as a result of the tax — rather than extending the payments all the way up the income scale in universal fashion.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
Off Case Answers › Condition Funds CP
Megan Greenwell “Universal Basic Income Has Been Tested Repeatedly. It Works. Will America Ever Embrace It?” October 24, 2022 https://www.washingtonpost.com/magazine/2022/10/24/universal-basic-income/
Meanwhile, the concept of conditional cash-transfer programs — in other words, paying poor people for desirable behavior — was gaining steam in middle-income countries like Mexico and Brazil. In 2007, New York Mayor Mike Bloomberg launched a program called Opportunity NYC, which rewarded parents for tasks like taking their children to the doctor and completing job-training courses. The experiment had a moderate positive effect on families’ overall finances but did not boost academic performance among elementary-schoolers or increase families’ likelihood to seek preventive medical care, researchers found. Bloomberg did not extend the program when it expired in 2010. Among many poverty scholars and activists, conditional cash transfers are seen as a step in the right direction, but only a small one. To maximize the impact on poor people’s lives, they say, money must be a right, not a reward, because that’s the only way to empower people to make their own choices. “There are positive outcomes from conditional cash, there are positive outcomes from unconditional cash,” Kline says. “But I think for me, making it conditional misses a really fundamental value around trust, dignity, agency, freedom.” The word “dignity” comes up a lot among guaranteed-income advocates. Research shows that the vast majority of people don’t “waste” cash on vices like drugs and alcohol, but rather use even small amounts to improve their life circumstances dramatically. In a 2019 working paper, Nobel Prize-winning development economist Abhijit Banerjee and two co-authors concluded that the distribution of unconditional cash in low-income countries had positive effects on “income, assets, savings, borrowing, total expenditure, food expenditure, dietary diversity, school attendance, test scores, cognitive development, use of health facilities, labor force participation, child labor migration, domestic violence, women’s empowerment, marriage, fertility, and use of contraception, among others.”
2023
SDI
Affirmative
Off Case Answers › Small Business DA
Drexel University (Center for Hungry-Free Communities) “UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME: KEY TO REDUCING FOOD INSECURITY AND IMPROVING HEALTH” 2021 https://drexel.edu/hunger-free-center/research/briefs-and-reports/universal-basic-income/
Increased Entrepreneurship UBI encourages entrepreneurship as workers are able to pay for basic needs while they pursue a small business start-up. The Alaska Permanent Fund contributed to a 15% increase in entrepreneurial ventures among fund recipients. Entrepreneurship promotes self-reliance and autonomy and has been found to benefit the economy as a whole, specifically low-income communities, through job creation, wage increases, and price reductions on goods and services. Access to credit is one of the three main barriers for entrepreneurs and small business owners.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
Off Case Answers › Federalism DA
Abby Nick (Trinity College) “The Benefits of Guaranteed Basic Income: Lessons from Advocates” MAY 3, 2022 https://www.trincoll.edu/cher/blog/abby-nick-cwealf/
Many lessons can be learned from both local and national basic income advocates that will help CWEALF advance similar programs. Advocates warned against opponents’ use of coded racist language explaining that much opposition to basic income programs is rooted in racial and economic discrimination. Furthermore, advocates recommend that programs focus on achieving individual agency and personal choice, a lesson proven in the research-based findings from various pilot programs. Recipients in three separate pilot programs reported increased individual agency and decision-making abilities. Finally, advocates urged that there is no better time to advocate for GBI programs as the pandemic has changed the dialogue around GBI and UBI. This is due in part to the high levels of unemployment and the stimulus checks that occurred as a result of COVID-19. In addition, there is much to be learned from recent initiatives for guaranteed or universal basic income in the US. These pilot programs have shown many positive research-based findings including increased mental and physical health. Decrease in unemployment and increase in civil and familial participation. These outcomes show that GBI will increase women’s opportunities to accumulate wealth, improve family health, and reduce reliance on other governmental programs.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
Off Case Answers › Politics DA
Katharine Miller (Stanford University) “Radical Proposal: Universal Basic Income to Offset Job Losses Due to Automation” October 20, 2021 https://hai.stanford.edu/news/radical-proposal-universal-basic-income-offset-job-losses-due-automation
During his campaign to become the 2020 Democratic candidate for president of the United States, Andrew Yang asserted that technological advances, including AI, will deprive one in three American workers of their jobs during the next 12 years. To avoid the economic crisis that such job losses would precipitate, Yang proposed that the United States government give every American adult a monthly $1,000 “Freedom Dividend” – also called a universal basic income, or UBI. Although Yang’s candidacy for president failed, his proposal for universal basic income continues to gain momentum across the country. Indeed, Yang says, a recent poll found that about two-thirds of Americans are now in favor of universal basic income. “This is now very much a mainstream policy that we’re going to see implemented,” he says. In fact, the U.S. government’s stimulus payments to ordinary Americans during the COVID-19 pandemic are considered a type of UBI; and several American cities, including Stockton, California; Los Angeles; Newark, New Jersey; and St. Paul, Minnesota, have recently piloted their own “guaranteed income” programs. Yang says UBI payments would benefit every American by permanently growing the economy and creating millions of jobs. “A universal basic income would enable millions of Americans to meaningfully transition in the time of economic transformation, including that brought by AI,” he says, “and it would improve our strength, health, and mental health; kids’ ability to learn; our civic engagement; and our public trust, confidence, and optimism.” Yang presented his UBI proposal anew at Stanford HAI’s “Policy and AI: Four Radical Proposals for a Better Society” conference, held Nov. 9-10, 2021. Below, watch the full presentation. Universal Basic Income: How It Would Work The idea of providing a guaranteed income to every adult has been around since the nation’s founding, when Thomas Paine proposed a “tax on heritage” to ensure a basic income for young people starting out without wealth. During the Nixon presidency, a version of universal basic income was almost passed by Congress. And Alaska has paid an annual oil dividend to all Alaska residents since 1982. Like Alaska’s program, Yang’s proposed Freedom Dividend has almost no strings attached: All U.S. citizens over age 18 would be eligible.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
Off Case Answers › Politics DA
E. Napoletano (former registered financial advisor and award-winning author and journalist) “An Unexpected Outcome Of The Covid-19 Pandemic: A Slew Of Universal Income Programs” May 12, 2022 https://www.forbes.com/advisor/personal-finance/universal-basic-income-programs/
The Covid-19 pandemic came into American lives like a wrecking ball, disrupting everything from income and employment to child care and education. But then, help arrived. Through multiple congressional acts, Americans received direct, no-strings-attached stimulus payments. Even the Child Tax Credit (CTC) was briefly transformed, sending many families monthly payments of up to $300 per qualifying child, before the payments ended abruptly in Dec. 2021. The U.S. Census Bureau reported that most households used those payments to meet daily living expenses like rent, utilities and food. With more Americans than ever feeling the benefits of these recent no-strings-attached direct income payments, it’s unsurprising that many polls find a majority of Americans now support some sort of universal basic income (UBI). In fact, several cities across the country have UBI-type programs slated to start or already in progress.
UBI popular
2023
SDI
Affirmative
Off Case Answers › Politics DA
Robert Greenstein (founder and President Emeritus of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. He is considered an expert on the federal budget and a range of domestic policy issues, including anti-poverty programs and various aspects of tax and health care policy.) June 13, 2019 “Commentary: Universal Basic Income May Sound Attractive But, If It Occurred, Would Likelier Increase Poverty Than Reduce It” https://www.cbpp.org/research/poverty-and-opportunity/commentary-universal-basic-income-may-sound-attractive-but-if-it
Megan Greenwell (Washington Post) “Universal Basic Income Has Been Tested Repeatedly. It Works. Will America Ever Embrace It?”
If anything, means-tested programs have fared somewhat better than universal programs in the last several decades. Since 1980, policymakers in Washington and in a number of states have cut unemployment insurance, contributing to a substantial decline in the share of jobless Americans — now below 30 percent — who receive unemployment benefits. In addition, the 1983 Social Security deal raised the program’s retirement age from 65 to 67, ultimately generating a 14 percent benefit cut for all beneficiaries, regardless of the age at which someone begins drawing benefits. Meanwhile, means-tested benefits overall have substantially expanded despite periodic attacks from the right. The most recent expansion occurred in December of 2015 when policymakers made permanent significant expansions of the EITC and the low-income part of the Child Tax Credit that were due to expire after 2017. In recent decades, conservatives generally have been more willing to accept expansions of means-tested programs than universal ones, largely due to the substantially lower costs they carry (which means they put less pressure on total government spending and taxes). The record of recent decades thus points to an alternative course — pushing for steady incremental gains through available mechanisms, including means-tested programs, to provide as much of a floor as possible for Americans of lesser means. In 1967, the safety net lifted out of poverty only 5 percent of Americans who would otherwise be poor. Fifty years later, in 2017, it lifted 44 percent of such people out of poverty, with programs like SNAP and the EITC playing crucial roles alongside Social Security. A multi-pronged strategy — making the Child Tax Credit fully refundable so that children benefit from it fully regardless of how low their families’ income and earnings are, substantially raising the minimum wage and strengthening the Earned Income Tax Credit, extending affordable child care and rental assistance to millions more families, enlarging SNAP benefits (as a Hamilton Project paper proposes), and strengthening Social Security benefits for low-income workers — would substantially strengthen the income floors. It would do so in ways that are far likelier than UBI to succeed politically and much less fraught with danger to the very people we most want to help.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
Off Case Answers › Topicality
Amritpal Kaur Sandhu-Longoria (USA TODAY) “Guaranteed basic income pilot programs are growing around the country, and community leaders are doing something about it” February 17, 2023 https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2023/02/17/how-universal-basic-income-program-works/11263986002/
What is a guaranteed basic income? A guaranteed basic income is a direct cash benefit from the government that provides people with money regardless of their employment status to support their basic needs. The movement is rooted in racial justice, and was first touted by Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and the Black Panther party. A universal basic Income differs, and provides everyone with a cash payment, on an individual basis and without an employment requirement, according to the Basic Income Earth Network.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
Off Case Answers › Topicality
Rema Hanna and Benjamin A. Olken (American Economic Association) “Universal Basic Incomes versus Targeted Transfers: Anti-Poverty Programs in Developing Countries” JOURNAL OF ECONOMIC PERSPECTIVES VOL. 32, NO. 4, FALL 2018 (pp. 201-26) https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/jep.32.4.201
Of the 17 Sustainable Development Goals articulated by the United Nations, number one is the elimination of extreme poverty by 2030. While future economic growth should continue to reduce poverty, it will not solve the problem by itself; thus, there is a potentially important role for national-level transfer programs that assist poor families in developing countries. Such programs are often run by developing country governments. Many countries have implemented transfer programs that seek to target beneficiaries: that is, to identify who is poor and then to restrict transfers to those individuals. Some people have begun to advocate for "universal basic income" programs, which dispense with trying to identify the poor and instead provide transfers to everyone. We begin by considering the universal basic income as part of the solution to an optimal income-taxation problem, focusing on the case of developing countries, where there is limited income data and inclusion in the formal tax system is low. We examine how the targeting of transfer programs is conducted in these settings, and provide empirical evidence on the tradeoffs involved between universal basic income and targeted transfer schemes using data from Indonesia and Peru—two countries that run nationwide transfer programs that are targeted to the poor. We conclude by linking our findings back to the broader policy debate on what tools should be preferred for redistribution, as well as the practical challenges of administering them in developing countries.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
****Case Extensions**** › Economy Advantage › Economy – Impact
Mann ’14 (Eric Mann is a special agent with a United States federal agency, with significant domestic and international counterintelligence and counter-terrorism experience. Worked as a special assistant for a U.S. Senator and served as a presidential appointee for the U.S. Congress. He is currently responsible for an internal security and vulnerability assessment program. Bachelors @ University of South Carolina, Graduate degree in Homeland Security @ Georgetown. “AUSTERITY, ECONOMIC DECLINE, AND FINANCIAL WEAPONS OF WAR: A NEW PARADIGM FOR GLOBAL SECURITY,” May 2014, )
The conclusions reached in this thesis demonstrate how economic considerations within states can figure prominently into the calculus for future conflicts. The findings also suggest that security issues with economic or financial underpinnings will transcend classical determinants of war and conflict, and change the manner by which rival states engage in hostile acts toward one another. The research shows that security concerns emanating from economic uncertainty and the inherent vulnerabilities within global financial markets will present new challenges for national security, and provide developing states new asymmetric options for balancing against stronger states.¶ The security areas, identified in the proceeding chapters, are likely to mature into global security threats in the immediate future. As the case study on South Korea suggest, the overlapping security issues associated with economic decline and reduced military spending by the United States will affect allied confidence in America’s security guarantees. The study shows that this outcome could cause regional instability or realignments of strategic partnerships in the Asia-pacific region with ramifications for U.S. national security. Rival states and non-state groups may also become emboldened to challenge America’s status in the unipolar international system.¶ The potential risks associated with stolen or loose WMD, resulting from poor security, can also pose a threat to U.S. national security. The case study on Pakistan, Syria and North Korea show how financial constraints affect weapons security making weapons vulnerable to theft, and how financial factors can influence WMD proliferation by contributing to the motivating factors behind a trusted insider’s decision to sell weapons technology. The inherent vulnerabilities within the global financial markets will provide terrorists’ organizations and other non-state groups, who object to the current international system or distribution of power, with opportunities to disrupt global finance and perhaps weaken America’s status. A more ominous threat originates from states intent on increasing diversification of foreign currency holdings, establishing alternatives to the dollar for international trade, or engaging financial warfare against the United States.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
****Case Extensions**** › Economy Advantage › Economy – Impact
February 14, 2017, “Global financial resilience in a time of uncertainty”, Brookings Institute, Sterland was a Fulbright Scholar, and studied economics and public policy at Princeton and Sydney Universities, https://www.brookings.edu/blog/up-front/2017/02/14/global-financial-resilience-in-a-time-of-uncertainty/
Geithner’s analysis of the current risks in the U.S. financial system is sober but not alarmist. He correctly notes that financial regulation has materially improved the capital and liquidity buffers in the U.S. system as a whole and expanded the supervisory perimeter to include most major institutions. He emphasizes the inherent risks in the maturity transformation at the heart of modern finance – that is the practice whereby financial institutions borrow money on shorter timeframes than when they lend money out, that leaves banks and other institutions vulnerable to ‘runs’ on deposits. As financial sector experts are acutely aware, we can never know risks to the financial system with any certainty. Hence the need to assess system preparedness to respond to shocks. Liquidity risks appear to have risen in some U.S. financial markets. Some asset prices appear extended; in part, a result of the extended low interest rates that have been part of the macroeconomic response in the U.S. Non-bank financial activity is growing, in part in response to stronger regulation. However, strong memory of the 2008 crisis is probably placing some curb on the risk appetite of many players, assisted by the more intense prudential and macroprudential regulation brought forth by the crisis. As a result, the U.S. financial system risks did not figure prominently in the most recent International Monetary Fund’s survey of global financial risks. And the signs of strengthening demand and some welcome price pressures may reduce financial risks in the short term. The real risks in the U.S. will come in a time of prosperity and the seemingly inevitable complacency that sets in with investors and regulators. Nevertheless, and this is a point underplayed by Geithner, there are near-term risks to the domestic U.S. financial system emanating from outside the U.S., adding urgency to his overall arguments for focusing on resilience in U.S. policy settings. HOW AVAILABLE ARE U.S. MACROECONOMIC POLICY TOOLS IN A CRISIS? Beyond regulation, the larger risk at present is the limited firepower of macroeconomic policy to respond to any near-term shocks. Interest rates are still very low, and even with recent signs that they will soon rise, low long-term interest rates suggest that monetary policy will have less leeway in future to respond to shocks. This suggests that more of the burden of response needs to be carried by fiscal policy in the event of a future shock. Yet fiscal policy is constrained on both economic and political grounds. Nevertheless, fiscal policy tools would need to be deployed earlier in a shock to support demand and soften the economic and financial disruption. This course would pose fewer risks if fiscal policy were on a sounder long-term footing. Indeed, forging such a pathway or framework is an important component of overall crisis readiness. Pro-growth structural or productivity reforms could also help economic resilience, for example, by improving macroeconomic “speed limits” and fiscal sustainability. ARE ‘EMERGENCY POWERS’ SUFFICIENT? Limited macroeconomic firepower would suggest even more focus than usual on the effectiveness of financial regulation in preventing or limiting the severity of crises. In particular, this suggests ongoing importance for higher capital and liquidity provisioning, intensive supervision of crisis risks and preparedness (stress tests and the like), and retaining a wider regulatory perimeter (encompassing more activity in the non-bank sector and more system-wide monitoring), to make the system safer. One hopes that any “roll back” avoids watering down these important gains. Geithner’s top priorities for reform to further increase the safety of the system go against the grain of most critics, right and left. They involve increasing the discretion of regulators to deal with systemic crisis events, though within clear accountability frameworks. In particular, he advocates increased flexibility, over that allowed for in Dodd-Frank, to lend to institutions in an emerging crisis, and to use judgment in imposing losses on creditors in a failing institution (bailing-in) in a situation where this could set off a chain of dominoes in the system. Geithner’s analysis, though, gives scope to reform aspects of financial regulation while at least not further harming core crisis prevention goals. He says nothing (deliberately I suspect) of the Volker rule, which he has argued cogently elsewhere has less connection with the fragilities uncovered by the crisis. The extensive provisions covering conduct and other aspects of the finance industry’s operations involve policy tradeoffs which, while important, may not centrally affect the crisis mitigation goals of regulation. Not all reform of Dodd Frank is therefore synonymous with a return to crisis risk. But the threat of roll back of central pillars of crisis resilience such as capital and liquidity buffers is real. If such a course were chosen, the answer to the question “are we safe yet?” would be a resounding no, for the U.S. and global economies. Indeed, when the other macroeconomic vulnerabilities are added, the U.S. economy would be decidedly unsafe, and prone to even a relatively small shock having outsized consequences. Geithner comments, “Financial crises cannot be forecast. They happen because of inevitable failures of imagination and memory.” It would be a great pity if a defective collective memory led to an increase in systemic risk in the U.S. regulatory system—with possible international implications—so soon after the crisis.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
****Case Extensions**** › Economy Advantage › Economy – Jobs
Megan Greenwell “Universal Basic Income Has Been Tested Repeatedly. It Works. Will America Ever Embrace It?” October 24, 2022 https://www.washingtonpost.com/magazine/2022/10/24/universal-basic-income/
Importantly for Tubbs and other politicians looking to sell conservatives on guaranteed income, the study found that SEED participants were more likely to find full-time employment than members of the control group. Recipients spent the biggest share of their cash on food, followed by other merchandise, utility bills, and gas and car maintenance. Less than 1 percent of the total allotted funds were used to buy tobacco or alcohol. “Honestly, I don’t think SEED could have gone any better,” Kline says. “I’m astounded at what a small little demonstration can do.” A year later, data from a D.C.-based guaranteed-income experiment showed similarly promising results. Thrive East of the River provided $5,500 to 600 families in Ward 8 during the pandemic, either as a lump sum or as five monthly payments. Although the program was too short-term to measure effects on employment, Urban Institute researchers found significant positive effects on recipients’ mental health, food security and ability to meet their children’s needs. Thrive wasn’t part of the mayors’ consortium launching guaranteed-income pilots, but policymakers embraced the Urban Institute data as an important part of the overall work. “Even my staff cautioned me about being so optimistic and confident, but I was going to bet on people,” Tubbs said, tilting back in his chair in the messy shed-turned-office that sits behind his home in a historically Black neighborhood of L.A. The SEED results “were particularly vindicating because everyone was like, ‘We need cash,’ but there were all these racist tropes. And the opposite of all the tropes is what the data showed was true.”
2023
SDI
Affirmative
****Case Extensions**** › Economy Advantage › Economy – Automation
For Leaders., 3-29-2023, "The Inevitable Need for Universal Basic Income in the Age of Artificial Intelligence," CEO, https://www.ceo.com/how-universal-basic-income-can-secure-our-future-in-the-age-of-ai// cb-khs
The 21st century has witnessed the rapid rise of artificial intelligence (AI), transforming nearly every aspect of our lives. While this technological revolution brings countless benefits, it raises concerns about job displacement and economic inequality. As AI continues to advance, the need for a Universal Basic Income (UBI) becomes increasingly apparent to address the growing challenges the labor force faces. AI's potential to put people out of work is not a baseless fear. In a widely cited study by Oxford University, researchers Frey and Osborne estimate that 47% of US jobs are at risk of automation in the next two decades. Similarly, a McKinsey Global Institute report suggests that between 400 million and 800 million individuals worldwide could be displaced by automation by 2030. Given these projections, it's crucial to explore potential solutions to mitigate the negative impacts of AI on the workforce. This is where UBI comes in. Several studies and experiments on UBI, such as GiveDirectly's Basic Income Experiment in Kenya, the Finnish Basic Income Experiment, the Alaska Permanent Fund, and the Stockton Economic Empowerment Demonstration (SEED), provide valuable insights into the potential benefits of implementing UBI as a response to the challenges posed by AI. UBI involves providing a regular, unconditional cash payment to all individuals, regardless of their employment status or income level. By offering financial security, UBI can help buffer the economic shocks caused by job displacement due to AI and automation. Here's why UBI may be an essential part of our future in the age of artificial intelligence: Reduced Poverty and Income Inequality: UBI can help bridge the growing income gap exacerbated by automation, disproportionately affecting low-skilled workers. Cash transfers from UBI programs have been shown to alleviate poverty, as demonstrated by the Alaska Permanent Fund and GiveDirectly's experiment in Kenya. Increased Financial Security: With the uncertainty of job stability due to AI, UBI can offer individuals a financial safety net. This sense of security can promote mental well-being, as observed in the Finnish Basic Income Experiment. Encouraging Entrepreneurship and Innovation: A guaranteed income can foster an environment where individuals feel secure in taking risks, such as starting their businesses or pursuing creative endeavors. This can drive innovation and potentially create new job opportunities in the long run. Supporting Education and Skill Development: UBI can help workers invest in their education and acquire new skills, making it easier for them to adapt to the changing job market and increasing demand for skilled labor in the age of AI. This investment in human capital can lead to a more resilient and adaptable workforce. Enhanced Social Safety Net: As traditional welfare programs may struggle to adapt to the rapidly changing labor market, UBI can serve as a more flexible and efficient safety net, reaching a broader population needing support. Promoting Health and Well-being: The financial security provided by UBI can reduce stress and anxiety related to job loss or economic instability. Healthier and less stressed individuals are more likely to contribute positively to society and the economy. Strengthening Consumer Spending: UBI can help maintain consumer spending in the face of job displacement, supporting economic growth and preventing a downward spiral caused by reduced demand for goods and services. While UBI is not a one-size-fits-all solution to the challenges posed by AI, it offers a promising avenue for addressing the societal and economic impacts of automation. By providing a financial safety net for individuals in an uncertain job market, UBI can help us navigate the rapidly changing landscape of the age of artificial intelligence.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
****Case Extensions**** › Economy Advantage › Economy – Automation
Norton 17 Andrew Norton is director of the International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED).
[Norton, “Automation and inequality The changing world of work in the global South,” International Institute for Environment and Development, 2017, , accessed 6/28/2023] //abcchs
There is a range of mechanisms through which accelerating automation and digital innovation might affect inequality within countries. These include: boosting the advantage of wealth over labour; hollowing out of the workforce (relative declines in mid- and lower-skilled employment share); weakening of labour institutions; and erosion of the tax base (thereby weakening state capability for redistribution). As a recurring caveat — all of these effects can be influenced and reversed by policy and social action, so speculation about impacts needs to take that into account. The argument that automation will increase the advantage of capital over labour is simple and intuitive. Owners of robots will benefit more than workers they replace. This argument can also be seen as ‘Piketty amplified’, as the result is to boost returns to capital further ahead of returns to labour at the level of a whole national economy. In most industrialised countries, labour’s share of national income has been falling since the 1970s. And the process is also visible in some middle income countries, with a particularly steep drop in China.17 Automation is likely to increase this process under most scenarios, further concentrating wealth and income in fewer hands. The hollowing out of the workforce is already measurable in the manufacturing sector. Rodrik1 demonstrates that automation has been taking out more low-skilled jobs than medium- or high-skilled ones, increasing inequality. The data underpinning this important observation are quite broad-based, drawn from 40 countries (with a bias towards Europe) over the years 1995–2009, and providing a breakdown of manufacturing employment by three worker types: low skill, medium skill and high skill. Rodrik found that not only was there a steady reduction in manufacturing employment across the cohort, but also that virtually the entire reduction in employment over time comes from the low skill category. At the economy-wide level, however, this trend is not yet clear in many developed countries. The UK’s ‘Taylor Review’,47 for example, concludes that wage data in the UK labour market as a whole shows no evidence of ‘hollowing out’.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
****Case Extensions**** › Economy Advantage › Economy – Economic Stability
Megan Greenwell “Universal Basic Income Has Been Tested Repeatedly. It Works. Will America Ever Embrace It?” October 24, 2022 https://www.washingtonpost.com/magazine/2022/10/24/universal-basic-income/
Without a radical solution — like, say, giving people money with no strings attached — America will continue to be home to one of the worst rates of income inequality of any rich nation in the world. And from city to city, there is massive energy and momentum to keep expanding this experiment. But true believers also harbor a sense of anxiety about what the future holds. “I’m worried,” says Sean Kline, the associate director of Stanford University’s Basic Income Lab, “that these guaranteed income demonstrations are going to sunset and then it’s just going to go quiet.” For as long as America has had a poverty problem — which is to say, for its entire history — a small group of dreamers has proposed guaranteed income as a solution. The idea dates to the year the country was founded: Thomas Paine proposed a type of basic income in his 1776 pamphlet “Common Sense.” In the mid-20th century, it gained traction among Black American thinkers: In 1966, the Black Panthers’ Ten-Point Program demanded “employment or a guaranteed income” for everyone. A year later, the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. wrote in his last book — “Where Do We Go From Here: Chaos or Community?” — that government aid programs all have a “common failing: they are indirect. Each seeks to solve poverty by first solving something else. I am now convinced that the simplest approach will prove to be the most effective — the solution to poverty is to abolish it directly by a now widely discussed measure: the guaranteed income.”
2023
SDI
Affirmative
****Case Extensions**** › Economy Advantage › Economy – Economic Stability
Abby Nick (Trinity College) “The Benefits of Guaranteed Basic Income: Lessons from Advocates” MAY 3, 2022 https://www.trincoll.edu/cher/blog/abby-nick-cwealf/
This research is incredibly important as it will help CWEALF and citizens of Connecticut better understand the benefits of basic income programs and how best to advocate for them. Millions of Americans struggle every day to meet their basic life needs. Parents forfeit time with their children, people pick up second or third jobs, and some even refuse jobs that would push them into a certain bracket as they are reliant on other governmental programs. Cash is one of the most direct and effective ways to provide financial stability to those who are most in need. It offers the dignity and self-determination that other programs do not and allows citizens to take ownership of their own life and spending decisions. Years of research demonstrate that when given unrestricted payments, participants in UBI and GBI programs are able to pull themselves out of poverty and create economic stability for themselves and their families. The work CWEALF is doing is crucial to moving towards UBI programs in every state.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
****Case Extensions**** › Quality of Life Advantage › QoL – Food Security
FDI, 12 - Future Directions International, a Research institute providing strategic analysis of Australia’s global interests; citing Lindsay Falvery, PhD in Agricultural Science and former Professor at the University of Melbourne’s Institute of Land and Environment (Food and Water Insecurity: International Conflict Triggers & Potential Conflict Points, http://www.futuredirections.org.au/workshop-papers/537-international-conflict-triggers-and-potential-conflict-points-resulting-from-food-and-water-insecurity.html, Future Directions International)
There is a growing appreciation that the conflicts in the next century will most likely be fought over a lack of resources.¶ Yet, in a sense, this is not new. Researchers point to the French and Russian revolutions as conflicts induced by a lack of food. More recently, Germany’s World War Two efforts are said to have been inspired, at least in part, by its perceived need to gain access to more food. Yet the general sense among those that attended FDI’s recent workshops, was that the scale of the problem in the future could be significantly greater as a result of population pressures, changing weather, urbanisation, migration, loss of arable land and other farm inputs, and increased affluence in the developing world.¶ In his book, Small Farmers Secure Food, Lindsay Falvey, a participant in FDI’s March 2012 workshop on the issue of food and conflict, clearly expresses the problem and why countries across the globe are starting to take note. .¶ He writes (p.36), “…if people are hungry, especially in cities, the state is not stable – riots, violence, breakdown of law and order and migration result.”¶ “Hunger feeds anarchy.”¶ This view is also shared by Julian Cribb, who in his book, The Coming Famine, writes that if “large regions of the world run short of food, land or water in the decades that lie ahead, then wholesale, bloody wars are liable to follow.” ¶ He continues: “An increasingly credible scenario for World War 3 is not so much a confrontation of super powers and their allies, as a festering, self-perpetuating chain of resource conflicts.” He also says: “The wars of the 21st Century are less likely to be global conflicts with sharply defined sides and huge armies, than a scrappy mass of failed states, rebellions, civil strife, insurgencies, terrorism and genocides, sparked by bloody competition over dwindling resources.”¶ As another workshop participant put it, people do not go to war to kill; they go to war over resources, either to protect or to gain the resources for themselves.¶ Another observed that hunger results in passivity not conflict. Conflict is over resources, not because people are going hungry.¶ A study by the International Peace Research Institute indicates that where food security is an issue, it is more likely to result in some form of conflict. Darfur, Rwanda, Eritrea and the Balkans experienced such wars. Governments, especially in developed countries, are increasingly aware of this phenomenon.¶ The UK Ministry of Defence, the CIA, the US Center for Strategic and International Studies and the Oslo Peace Research Institute, all identify famine as a potential trigger for conflicts and possibly even nuclear war.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
****Case Extensions**** › Quality of Life Advantage › QoL – Food Security
Ore Koren, 11-23-2016, [Ore Koren is a PhD candidate at the University of Minnesota and a Jennings Randolph Fellow at the United States Institute of Peace], "Food scarcity causes conflicts — but so can food abundance. Here’s why.," Washington Post, , Xoxo 6.4.2021
The links between food scarcity and war Warmer countries are more war-prone — that’s what researchers studying the relationships between environmental factors and civil war argue. As global temperatures increase, prolonged heat waves reduce crop yields. The impact is strongest in tropical regions, which are more likely to experience the harshest effects of global warming. Lower crop yields increase the competition for remaining crops. And rising prices mean that many people cannot afford to buy food to compensate for resources lost because of climatic shifts. In countries that lack a social “safety net,” the only alternative in many cases is to obtain food through stealing, looting and — frequently — fighting over fertile land. Anecdotal evidence from eastern Africa and the Middle East, at least, supports this theory. Attempts to measure the linkages between climate change and armed conflict, however, have yielded mixed results, with some studies at least partly reaffirming these connections and others debunking them. Some regions adapt to climate conditions better than others Studies of the “Green Revolution” movement of the 1960s suggest that regions such as Asia were far more successful than Africa at adopting drought-resistant crops, which improved food security and helped offset the risk of war. Similar efforts in sub-Saharan Africa and the Middle East were weak and generally unsuccessful until the late 1980s. Three important points to help in understanding South Sudan’s worsening crisis These efforts met with limited success because of the types of grain available and other socioeconomic complexities, which left these regions food insecure. Had Syria successfully adopted drought-resistant crops, for instance, the social unrest of 2011 might have taken a different, less-violent course. As researchers continue to debate how climate change and its effects on global food stocks will impact food security in future decades, short-term environmental “shocks” such as droughts or floods have become more frequent in many parts of the world and are a potentially salient cause of armed conflict. These environmental disturbances can lead to sharp price increases that, in turn, can cause another well-established tradition: the food riot, when civilians take to the streets to protest high food prices. Where and why food prices lead to social upheaval Low-income countries are particularly susceptible because high food prices in these situations have an especially destabilizing effect. In these countries, high food prices expose the government’s lack of ability to shield consumers. They also create opportunities for civilians to mobilize against the regime. Even in locations where food is sourced locally, drought-induced shocks may incite violence against civilians when rebel groups seek to appropriate local food supplies. My research documents this happening not only in the Syrian conflict but also in India and Thailand during a 2004 drought. Riots, protests and massacres are among the types of unrest that can lead to civil war — and all can be linked to food conflicts. How can an abundance of food lead to war? Food scarcity, however, is only one aspect of food security. Whether people have easy access to food resources is also important. So even in countries where plenty of food is available, a large share of the population might still go hungry. As Nobel Laureate Amartya Sen notes, “Starvation is the characteristic of some people not having enough food to eat. It is not the characteristic of there being not enough food to eat.” Grievances over food and the necessity to secure access to food resources can motivate marginalized groups to participate in rebellions and wars. A number of scholars are researching how inequitable access to food affects violence within the state. As Ben Bagozzi and I show in a recent paper, armed actors worldwide are motivated to fight over local food resources. Here’s why these conflicts tend to happen in regions with more food crops, not less. For rebel groups, securing — and controlling — food resources is vital for the insurgency to advance. And when the government is slow or unable to supply combat rations, state forces also may be forced to extract food supplies from the local population, So scarce food resources in a region locked in conflict act as both fuel and reward for hungry combatants. Access to more local food resources, especially in the case of rebel groups, can also be used to attract recruits, as happened in Sierra Leone and Somalia. Regions where wheat and barley are grown are also an important source of support for the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria. It’s not just funded by oil and looting. How the Islamic State uses agriculture. The focus on how the demand for food resources influences armed conflict complements the research done on the effects of food scarcity. It also explains why agricultural areas see more violence. In these regions, individuals live largely on locally grown food. If the government’s safety nets are mismanaged or weak, those who control access to food can more easily recruit individuals and operate for a longer period of time. And this also explains why there is an uptick in violence during times of more rainfall — for instance, in sub-Saharan Africa. By providing armed groups with an added motivation to fight as well as the ability to expand their numbers and strength, local food security can therefore shape global conflict patterns.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
****Case Extensions**** › Quality of Life Advantage › QoL – Food Security
MIT Sloan, 20 [9-30-2020, Improving Recipients’, MIT Sloan, A Universal Basic Income could help the world’s poorest weather crises, including pandemics, by improving recipients’ food security and health, says new MIT research, 6-28-2023, ] //AshAN
Cambridge, Mass., September 30, 2020— A examining the effect of Universal Basic Income (UBI) in Kenya shows that cash transfers improved recipients’ food security and health and these gains sustained through the policy responses to the Covid-19 pandemic and the hungry season. Beneficiaries of a basic income experienced less hunger, sickness, and depression, both before and after the country implemented restrictions to tackle Covid-19, according to the research.
The research was conducted by Tavneet Suri, Associate Professor of Applied Economics at the , , the Ford Foundation International Professor of Economics at MIT, Michael Faye of Give Directly, the international charity, Paul Niehaus at University of California at San Diego, and the late Alan Krueger of Princeton, and it is being published as a working paper.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
****Case Extensions**** › Quality of Life Advantage › QoL – Crime
Rohit Choudhry Mar 4 2015 Addl DG in the Punjab Police
Good policing a must for economic growth
CRIMINAL activity can drag the entire economy by discouraging domestic and foreign direct investments, reducing the competitiveness of business organisations, and reallocating resources. It creates uncertainty and inefficiency in the business environment. Thus, law and order is considered an important function for the state to perform and is placed among minimal functions of the state in addressing market failure. In today's globalised world, the increasing flows of economic investment and business traffic between the nations bring into focus the relationship between investment confidence and security and crime, the latter being important in terms of both official crime rates and the fear of crime. Recently, the Government of South Africa, in its green paper on policing acknowledged that high levels of violent crime in South Africa are having a significant negative impact on the country's economy. Rise of violent crimes was costing the country dearly due to loss of productivity and foreign investment.