2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › UQ › UQ --- IRS Modernization / Growth now
Alms, N. (2023) IRS outlines tech modernization, CX plans as part of $80 billion overhaul, FCW. Available at: (Accessed: 02 July 2023).
IRS Commissioner Danny Werfel told reporters on Thursday that technology will be key to achieving the agency’s intentions to transform customer service at the agency and shrink the tax gap. Technology improvements will be foundational to the IRS’ plans to use long-term funding to “transform” the tax agency, IRS commissioner Danny Werfel said in a call with reporters about its plan for how it will spend the nearly $80 billion from the Inflation Reduction Act passed last year. The IRS wants to become a “world class customer service operation” with digital tools and modern platforms, the plan states, and to use the funding boost to fix staffing and capacity pain points the agency says come from years of underfunding by Congress. The agency also wants to use data and analytics to inform its auditing and compliance efforts as it looks to shrink the amount of unpaid taxes by the most wealthy Americans and corporations. “The plan released today is a bold look at what the future can look like for taxpayers and the IRS,” said Werfel. “Now that we have long-term funding, the IRS has an opportunity to transform our operations. “Underpinning everything,” he added, “is technology.” The strategic operating plan – released Thursday, over a month after its February due date set by Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen – has more than 190 discrete projects and over 200 specific milestones, Werfel said. Among them are a number of initiatives aimed at improving services, like addressing wait times for IRS phone lines and the processing of paper tax returns, both of which suffered during the pandemic, although the agency says they have already improved since it got IRA funding. Also featured are digital services for taxpayers. “In the first five years of the 10-year plan, taxpayers will be able to securely file documents and respond to notices online and securely access and download their data and account history,” said Wally Adeyemo, deputy secretary at the Treasury Department. The tax agency intends to improve online accounts with features like updated status tracking tools to get updates on refund and return processing, said Adeyemo. The IRS also plans to develop capabilities to “help taxpayers identify potential mistakes before filing, quickly fix errors that could delay their refunds and more easily claim credits and deductions they may be eligible for,” he said. The IRS also wants to rid itself of paper backlogs. It aims to eliminate paper backdogs by digitizing any paper forms and returns when it gets them and moving to “fully digital correspondence processes,” said Adeyemo. Already, the IRS a tool in February where taxpayers can submit certain requested documentation to the IRS online instead of mailing it, said Adeyemo. Another potential development is a “free, public electronic return-filing service option” run by the IRS. The agency is studying the feasibility of such a system now, as required by the law. The study is due in May. Another focus is the IRS’ core technology infrastructure. One goal is retiring outdated parts of core IRS tax systems and databases, some of which date back to the 1960’s, with the rare, long-term funding provided under the law, said Adeyemo. “The IRS is a patchwork of systems that today uses decades-old code and case management systems that don't interact with each other,” said Werfel, who called out data security. “There have been so many rapid changes involving data in recent years that the IRS must play catch up,” he said. “Taxpayer data is being held in old technology at the IRS. We need to invest in newer, modern technology to keep information safe for taxpayers, businesses and others. With long term funding, the IRS can address this.” The new roadmap also includes details on how it plans to divy up the investment among different priorities. Business systems modernization will get an estimated $4.8 billion, $3.2 billion for taxpayer services and $25.3 billion for operations support, although the plan notes that might not cover all of the costs associated with the customer service and tech modernization goals. “We believe that we will need an ongoing investment on top of the allocated IRA funding to deliver all of the transformation objectives outlined in this plan in taxpayer service improvements and information technology modernization,” the plan states, noting that Congress zeroed out appropriations for the business systems modernization account in fiscal 2023 appropriations. The roadmap also has a plea from Werfel for Congress not to shortchange IRS annual funding with the assumption that the agency can dip into the Inflation Reduction Act funding to cover the difference. “Any reduction in annual discretionary funds… will require IRA funding to be shifted to general operations… to the detriment of the service, technology and compliance initiatives envisioned to transform the IRS,” wrote Werfel.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › UQ › UQ --- IRS Modernization / Growth now
Insider, T. (2022) The reality of increased IRS funding, Forbes.
The Internal Revenue Service’s struggles in the face of limited resources are well-documented. Over the past decade, the IRS’s budget has increased only 9% (from approximately $12.4 billion in the to $13.7 billion in ). Over the same period, the agency’s civil and criminal enforcement efforts have been negatively impacted by the number of special agents – who conduct criminal investigations – dropping by 23% (from 2,618 in 2011 to 2,004 in 2021); the number of revenue agents – who handle audits – falling by 40% (from 13,969 to 8,321); and the number of revenue officers – who process collection matters – plummeting by 50% (from 5,621 to 2,783). Moreover, the IRS’s budgetary woes have forced the agency to make do with antiquated technology and undermanned call-centers that result in long wait times for taxpayers seeking guidance on their tax compliance. Given these shortcomings, it is unsurprising that the country faces a substantial “” between expected revenues and actual collections. The Inflation Reduction Act, which was signed into law this past August, reverses a years-long trend of budget cuts and includes almost $80 billion in additional funding for the IRS over the next 10 years. While about how the influx of funds could affect the historical decline in civil and criminal tax enforcement, the earliest and most substantial impact of the IRS’s newfound resources is likely to come from improved technology and customer service, which has the potential to alter the public’s perception of the agency for years to come. , the Inflation Reduction Act provides $45.6 billion for tax enforcement, including hiring more agents; $25.3 billion for operating expenses, including upgrading the agency’s telecommunications and information technology; and $3.2 billion to improve taxpayer services, including pre-filing assistance. , the prospect of over $45 billion being dedicated to enhanced tax enforcement has given rise to fears – stoked by and – that the IRS will be hiring an army of 87,000 new agents who will be scouring tax returns and ruining the lives of average Americans. The oft-quoted 87,000 number appears to come from a figure buried deep in . That report, however, suggests that the work force increases will be staggered over the ten years of planned spending, beginning with hiring approximately 5,000 additional employees in each of the first few years, followed by an additional 7,500 in year four with steady increases over the ensuing five years. Some additional context is important here. First, while the additional agents will be on-boarded over ten years, the IRS currently expects . As a result, hiring 87,000 employees over ten years will yield a net increase of 37,000. Moreover, if the IRS follows the hiring timeline set forth in the , it may actually suffer a net decrease in headcount between now and 2027. Second, retiring experienced agents will be replaced by novices, who will need training before they can effectively run criminal investigations and civil audits. , training new agents requires taking some veteran agents “offline” to guide their new colleagues. In other words, it will be many years before the new agents can contribute and getting them up and running will mean diverting scarce enforcement resources in the short term. Third, the suggestion that the 87,000 new IRS employees will serve in an enforcement role – either as special agents or revenue agents – is misleading. According to the most recent , in fiscal year 2021, the agency had a total of 78,661 full time employees, only 13,108 (17%) of whom conducted criminal investigations, performed civil audits or handled collection matters. The largest blocks of the remaining 65,553 IRS employees are customer service representatives (12,957); seasonal employees working in submission processing, account management and assistance, and integrity and verification operations (10,394); and tax examiners reviewing returns for completeness and coding them for computer processing as well as corresponding with taxpayers to obtain missing information (8,758). Shortly after the Inflation Reduction Act was signed into law, Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen to develop a plan for how it would use the $80 billion. While this plan is due in April 2023, the Treasury Department has that the majority of the net new hires will serve in customer service roles, like upgrading IT systems or answering taxpayer phone calls. Indeed, last month the agency’s plan to hire 5,000 new customer service representatives to improve taxpayer service before the next filing season, which suggests that the hiring of customer-service personnel will be front-loaded. In her latest , the National Taxpayer Advocate noted that while difficulty reaching an IRS customer service representative has been a substantial problem for many years, , as call volume nearly tripled and only 11% of calls reached a live person. As the Taxpayer Advocate noted, difficulty in reaching a representative disadvantages and frustrates taxpayers, and ultimately jeopardizes tax compliance. While the additional resources in the Inflation Reduction Act came too late to impact the filing season that ended earlier this week, to the extent a significant number of the IRS’s 37,000 net new hires employees are devoted to customer service roles, future filing seasons will run more smoothly and the public will reap the benefits of the increased funding, and may even soften its perception of the agency.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › UQ › UQ --- IRS Modernization / Growth now
Nathan W. Giesselman & Christopher P. Murphy Ginetta Sagan et al. (2020) What to expect from the IRS’ $80 billion strategic operating plan: Insights: Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP, Insights
In August 2022, the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) was signed into law, allocating approximately $80 billion to the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) over the next decade to improve the way it serves the public. On April 6, 2023, the IRS published a summarizing how it intends to spend the funds. The plan sets out 42 initiatives to fulfill five broad objectives: Improving the taxpayer experience to help taxpayers meet their obligations and receive tax incentives for which they are eligible. Quickly resolving taxpayer issues when they arise. Focusing expanded enforcement on taxpayers with complex tax filings and high-dollar noncompliance to address the tax gap. Delivering cutting-edge technology, data and analytics to operate more effectively. Attracting and retaining a skilled, diverse workforce and developing a culture that is better equipped to deliver results for taxpayers. The Congressional Budget Office estimates that the $80 billion will result in an increase in federal revenue of over $180 billion in the decade ahead, and the IRS predicts this figure is likely to be even greater. As a result, we anticipate that there will be an increase in enforcement efforts, both for taxpayers currently under constant audit and those who are not. At a minimum, corporations, partnerships and high-income individuals who are under constant audit should expect larger audit examination teams as well as investigation of more issues. For larger corporations, partnerships and high-income individuals that have not yet been audited, or are not under constant audit, we anticipate a greater likelihood of being selected for audit due to an increase in IRS staff and technology flagging potential issues. Faster Resolution of Issues One of the IRS’s key goals in deploying these funds is to quickly resolve taxpayer issues by expanding tax certainty and issue-resolution programs, including the creation of new pre-filing programs allowing taxpayers to settle potential compliance issues up front. The plan also calls for adequate staffing of existing programs that have under-delivered to taxpayers.In order to achieve this objective, steps would include: Expanding capacity, eligibility and accessibility for current pre-filing programs. Refining existing programs to address challenges. Developing additional, tailored tax certainty programs. Removing user fees from programs where appropriate.The IRS will first engage in outreach and campaigns to increase awareness of existing programs, then launch a pilot program to invite taxpayers to participate in pre-filing programs and identify priority areas for new tax certainty programs. The last phase would involve hiring specialists to expand existing programs. Expanded Enforcement To Target Complex Filings and High-Dollar Compliance Another key goal is to address the tax gap by expanding enforcement with regard to taxpayers with complex tax filings and high-dollar noncompliance. Businesses and households earning $400,000 or less will not see increased enforcement, the plan states. Instead, the focus will be on audits of large partnerships, large corporations, and high-income and high-wealth individuals. The IRS plans to use enhanced data and analytics to select compliance cases based on the highest risk of noncompliance, though it is unclear what this will mean in practice. This initiative is broken into a number of sub-initiatives, as summarized below. Improve the selection of cases. The IRS plans to employ improved analytics to aid in the selection of cases where the risk of noncompliance is predicted to be high, choosing enforcement approaches that maximize opportunities to improve and sustain taxpayer compliance. Steps would include: Building a centralized function for compliance planning and strategy. Building a unified compliance organization that enhances centralized case-planning and strategy and enables the IRS to refine business processes.Establishing a dynamic model for workforce allocation. Centralizing compliance analytics and developing a process to regularly model the population of tax returns. Developing a process for continually refining compliance analytics models based on feedback and new information. Developing and implementing a plan to improve the IRS Whistleblower Program. For large corporate taxpayers that are currently audited each year, it is unclear whether this initiative would result in an increase in coordinated audit approaches (with multiple taxpayers receiving “form” information document requests relating to specific issues that the IRS has elevated for attention). For taxpayers not currently under yearly audits, it is unclear how it would be determined which cases or particular taxpayers are at the highest risk of noncompliance. Increase enforcement activities. The plan aims to ensure tax compliance of large corporations and partnerships, and high-income and high-wealth individuals by increasing audit rates and other compliance treatments. Steps would include: Hiring and training staff needed to achieve appropriate compliance. Increasing staff in the Independent Office of Appeals to resolve any tax controversies arising from enhanced compliance efforts. Increasing staff in the Office of Chief Counsel to support compliance and appeals and to litigate cases. Refining approaches for enforcement and exploring new treatments using data and analytics. Under the plan, the IRS also intends to increase enforcement in key areas where audit coverage has declined while complying with the Treasury’s directive not to increase audit rates relative to historical levels for small businesses and households earning $400,000 per year or less. These key areas include employment, excise, and estate and gift taxes. Like the initiative described above, this one would also entail adding and training compliance staff, expanding the Independent Office of Appeals and Office of Chief Counsel staffs, and improving analytics. In addition, the plan states that this initiative would require developing enforcement approaches and compliance treatments tailored to each area where enforcement will be expanded. Enhance detection of noncompliance. The plan calls for enhanced detection of noncompliance as well as increased enforcement activities for complex, high-risk and novel emerging issues, including digital assets, listed transactions and certain international issues. Key steps to achieve this initiative include: Mobilizing resources to focus on high-risk and emerging issues that have not received appropriate enforcement attention. Improving, expediting and scaling detection of emerging issues, including building stronger feedback processes from all parts of the IRS. Establishing processes to respond more rapidly to emerging issues and develop treatments that can be deployed quickly and integrated into enforcement efforts. Hiring and training staff needed to achieve appropriate compliance rates. Promote fairness in enforcement activities. Under the plan, the IRS intends to promote fairness for taxpayers by addressing noncompliance in a balanced manner. This will be achieved by using research and data to help enforce tax laws and curtail any potential disparities in tax administration. The intends to regularly assess whether enforcement actions are disproportionately burdening certain demographic groups or customer categories and make adjustments. However, the plan notes that the additional funds provided by the IRA will not be used to increase audits of households or small businesses below the $400,000 threshold. In order to achieve these goals, steps include: Developing procedures to regularly evaluate the fairness of systems, selection tools and programs, compliance strategies and treatments. Improving enforcement practices to help ensure fairness in compliance and enforcement. Hiring and training staff who enable enforcement strategies that match risk and degree of noncompliance.This initiative, too, would rely in part on increased staff at the Independent Office of Appeals and Office of Chief Counsel. The IRS hopes to increase trust in the service, thus increasing voluntary compliance. Conclusion While the plan lists 42 total initiatives, it is clear that the focus is on using resources for detection of noncompliance and enforcement of tax laws, especially for large corporations, large partnerships and high-income individuals. At the same time, the plan seeks to offer clearer guidance in a proactive manner, which may prevent certain pitfalls in the filing process. The timeline to implement these changes spans several years, depending on the objective, with the earliest changes taking place in the 2023 fiscal year.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › NOTES › 1NC---IRS Tradeoff Disad --- Democracy
Dan Reiter 17, Professor at the Department of Political Science at Emory University, January, 2017, “Is Democracy a Cause of Peace?”, Oxford Research Encyclopedia, http://politics.oxfordre.com/view/10.1093/acrefore/9780190228637.001.0001/acrefore-9780190228637-e-287
Scholars have explored other means of assessing causation in the democratic peace, and have amassed three other types of evidence that support the conclusion that democracy causes peace: evidence demonstrating support for other empirical patterns suggested by democratic peace theory; evidence produced using experimental methods; and evidence produced using case studies. The first type of evidence explores for the existence of other empirical patterns predicted by democratic peace theory. If a theory predicts the existence of a variety of empirical patterns and these patterns are demonstrated through tests, we can be more confident in the validity of the theory, and in turn that observed correlations are causal and not just spurious. And, indeed, there is a wide array of quantitative empirical studies that provide support for various assumptions or implications of democratic peace theory, especially for institutionalist accounts of the democratic peace. Perhaps the central institutionalist explanation of the democratic peace proposes that elected leaders are motivated to avoid fighting wars, because the costs of wars will incite popular discontent in turn threatening their hold on power. Studies have demonstrated a number of empirical patterns consistent with this view. Democracies fight shorter wars (Reiter & Stam, 2002, ch. 7). Democracies suffer fewer casualties when they fight wars (Valentino et al., 2010), and when they fight, popular support for the leadership declines as casualties escalate (Mueller, 1973). The benefits of victorious wars may sometimes push democratic publics to accept the costs of war when they are confident of victory, and accordingly democracies almost never start wars they go on to lose (Reiter & Stam, 2002). During war, public support erodes as the perceived likelihood of victory declines (Gelpi et al., 2009). As the institutional explanation of the democratic peace would predict, variations of institutional and leadership form within democracies also affects conflict behavior, as in general more constrained states are less conflict prone (Reiter & Tillman, 2002). Consistent with the audience costs explanation, democracies can more effectively signal their resolve than at least some kinds of autocratic states (Schultz, 2001; Weeks, 2014). There are also some studies supporting elements of the normative explanation. For example, some studies have found that democracies are especially likely to use mediation or binding arbitration to resolve interstate disputes (Dixon, 1993; Raymond, 1994, 1996). In total, though there are certainly scholarly debates about some of these observed patterns,6 this collection of studies improves our confidence that democracy is causing peace in the manners described by democratic peace theory. The second type of evidence uses experimental methods. Some have proposed that experimental methods enjoy critical advantages over the analysis of observational data in assessing causation. Experimental methods are able largely to skirt some of the biggest causal inference problems associated with quasi-experimental methods, such as biased samples and nonrandom assignments of treatment. That said, the limitation of experimental methods is that, especially in international relations, they can only be used to test some arguments, or some components of arguments. For example, regarding the democratic peace an experimenter cannot take a set of states and then randomly assign some to be democratic and others to be non-democratic. That said, scholars have thus far been able to conduct survey and laboratory experiments that have tested some elements of the democratic peace. A number of surveys have found support for one of the core assertions of dyadic democratic peace theory: that citizens of democracies are significantly less likely to support the use of force against democracies as compared to using force against non-democracies (Geva et al., 1993; Johns & Davies 2012; Lacina & Lee, 2013; Mintz & Nehemia, 1993; Rousseau, 2005, pp. 219–232; Tomz & Weeks, 2013) Other experiments have tested elements of the audience costs variant of the democratic peace, showing that the public does inflict audience costs on leaders who back down in a crisis (Horowitz & Levendusky, 2012; Tomz, 2007; Trager & Vavreck, 2011). A third empirical means of demonstrating causation is to engage in process tracing through case studies. Scholars have presented several individual case studies of the democratic peace in events such as 19th-century American diplomatic crises, the 1898 Fashoda Crisis, the onset of World War II, the Spanish-American War, and many others (see Elman, 1997; Owen, 1997; Ray, 1995; Risse-Kappen, 1995; Rousseau, 2005; Schultz, 2001; for case studies presenting evidence against the democratic peace, see Layne, 1994). Some of these case studies demonstrate specific parts of the causal logic of the democratic peace, such as the ability of democracies to signal more effectively through invoking greater audience costs (Schultz, 2001), or the inability of elected leaders to manipulate public opinion or secretly drag their nations into wars the public would otherwise avoid (Reiter, 2012a). Perhaps the most striking case study of democratic peace dynamics is the pacification of Western Europe after World War II, democracy helping to dissolve immediately and completely one of the most violent interstate conflicts in modern history, the France-Germany rivalry (Russett & Oneal, 2001).
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › NOTES › 1NC---IRS Tradeoff Disad --- Democracy
Yellen, 22 (9-15-2022, Secretary Of Treasury, U.S. Department of the Treasury, Remarks by Secretary of the Treasury Janet L. Yellen at the IRS facility in New Carrollton, Maryland, 7-2-2023, ) //shelbor
Good morning, everyone. It’s great to be at the IRS today with so many remarkable colleagues. I would first like to acknowledge the IRS leaders who are here with us today. Thank you, also, to Commissioner Rettig, who is in Memphis today celebrating the 50th anniversary of the IRS facility there. I’m grateful for his hard work and leadership. I just finished a tour of the technology facilities at the New Carrollton Federal Building. These facilities are a model for the IT modernization that has long been needed at the IRS. Today, I want to spend some time discussing how the new IRS funding in the Inflation Reduction Act will make these types of investments possible – as well as its impact on the American economy. But first, I want to begin by speaking about the IRS itself. As our nation’s revenue collection agency, the IRS is a foundation of our government and society. The IRS collects 96% of the revenue that funds the federal government – supporting our priorities from national security to infrastructure to social security.[1] It also is one of the very few parts of the federal government that touches nearly every American household. IRS employees are known for their extraordinary dedication to public service. They have always served with distinction. But over the past couple of years, the employees of the IRS have been called to step up – even further – to serve the American people. While the country sheltered in place, many of you made sure the business of government continued. You worked long hours to deliver relief to American households. This includes three rounds of Economic Impact Payments and the monthly Child Tax Credit.[2] The work that you did ensured families got through a once-in-a-century event. And, in the case of the expanded Child Tax Credit, your work is said to had cut child poverty in half. You managed to deliver on these historic new programs while simultaneously fulfilling your tax administration responsibilities. But during the pandemic, even filing season was far from routine. For instance, on one day last year – March 15 – the IRS received 8.6 million phone calls.[3] This is over 20 percent of the phone calls that the IRS received in the entire year of 2019. Many of you are now working very hard to return the pandemic backlog of unprocessed returns to normal, healthy levels by the end of the year. You dealt with the unprecedented demand and uncertainty that came with being the nation’s tax administrator over the past two years. And you did it while the pandemic was surely disrupting your personal lives and you were called to juggle more responsibilities at home. I’ve heard so many stories of IRS employees who went above and beyond. During the start of the pandemic, from Andover to New Carrollton, your teams mounted an all-hands-on-deck effort to keep the IRS operational. For some facilities, this meant an extensive clean-up effort and provision of PPE to keep employees safe. For others, it meant sending hundreds of laptop bundles, including cables, power cords, and headsets, to enable employees to work remotely. I’ve also heard that one of your colleagues – a U.S. air force veteran – has long donated his time to provide free tax preparation services to his community. But during the pandemic, he went even further. He spent his Economic Impact Payments on additional laptops to build out the tax assistance site – so that more people could get help. And these stories are just the beginning. Just last month, here in New Carrollton, I heard that a team of your software developers completed the conversion of more than 200,000 lines of Assembly Language Code to Java. This is widely recognized as one of the most complex modernization efforts in all of government. And your team completed it more than a month ahead of schedule. I know many of you have worked weekends and traveled across the country to provide tax filing assistance to thousands of taxpayers. These are people who would otherwise not have had any help. So thank you. I want you to know how much I appreciate the work that you do. And I want you to hear from me: that especially amid the recent rise in deeply unfair and dangerous misinformation and threats, there is nothing more important to me than for you to be able to safely carry out your critical job for the American people. The work of the IRS is essential to our government and our country. So I’m glad that the President and I were able to secure $80 billion in new funding for the agency. Let me explain what this new funding will go toward – as well as how it will build a stronger and fairer economy. For decades, the IRS has been severely underfunded. Since 2010, the agency’s budget has declined by 18 percent in real terms.[4] This has had a severe impact on the size of the IRS workforce. Even though the filing population has grown significantly, the workforce is now the same size as it was in the 1970s – with fewer auditors than at any time since World War II.[5] Because of this, the IRS has had to scrape to get by. The IRS remains, in large part, a paper-based agency. Employees still open, and in some cases, transcribe paper returns by hand. Because of budget shortfalls, long-term modernization often must be cast aside to give employees bandwidth to address more immediate and urgent projects. Facing uncertain budgets year after year, the IRS is often forced to freeze external hiring or otherwise face risks that they cannot pay who they hire. This leads to delays for the American people and a reduced level of service. The American public – and you – deserve an IRS that meets its expectations in a modern society. That includes getting phone calls answered, solving problems online, and receiving refunds more expeditiously. America deserves an IRS that has first-rate technology instead of a half-century-old programming language as the backbone of its systems. And tax filing should be simple: I recently came across a statistic that it takes an average American 13 hours to file a tax return.[6] Compare that with Sweden. There, some taxpayers can file simply by replying to a text message. We can and must do better. The Inflation Reduction Act finally provides the funding to transform the IRS into a 21st century agency. While all the improvements won’t be done overnight, taxpayers can expect to feel real differences during the next filing season. Today, I’m announcing specific progress we’ll deliver on. First, it’s critical that all Americans – especially those in the working and middle class – can get tax help at an in-person location when they need it. For too long, IRS Tax Assistance Centers have been massively understaffed and under-resourced. No longer. By next year, every single center will be fully staffed. As a result, we will triple the number of Americans served at these centers. Last year, the IRS served around 900,000 Americans face-to-face. In the coming filing season, the IRS is projected to serve at least 2.7 million Americans. Second, due to chronic understaffing and high call volume, the IRS has been unable to provide the level of phone service that taxpayers deserve. During the most recent filing season, the IRS averaged a 10-15% level of service, meaning that it answered less than 2 of every 10 calls. In this coming filing season, we are committing the IRS to an 85% level of service. That means that over five times the number of calls will be answered. By hiring 5,000 additional customer service representatives, we will also cut phone wait times in half – from an average wait of nearly 30 minutes during the 2022 filing season to less than 15 minutes.[7] We will dedicate a team to resolving issues that arise when processing returns for taxpayers. Third, the IRS will firmly move into the digital age. Today, employees at the IRS still manually transcribe many paper returns. In this coming filing season, the IRS will automate the scanning of millions of individual paper returns into a native digital copy. For taxpayers, this means faster processing and faster refunds. The IRS will also build online capabilities to enable taxpayers to fully interact with the agency digitally. Currently, when taxpayers receive a notice from the IRS, they generally must respond via mail.[8] During this coming filing season, millions of taxpayers will be able to receive and respond to notices online. Fourth, to lay the groundwork for the future, I’ll convene industry-leading customer service experts from the private sector to make sure we hear their perspectives on the IRS modernization effort. We recognize that customer service in the future will look differently than customer service today. Consulting these experts – and employees at the IRS – will help us sketch out our vision of what the IRS of the next decade looks like. These are bold commitments that the IRS will deliver in just the next six months. And there’s more to come in the months and years beyond. In addition to an IRS that can finally serve the American people, we will also have an IRS that makes sure that everyone pays their fair share. The world has become more complex. Enforcing tax laws is not as simple as it was a few decades ago. Average tax returns for large corporations now reach 6,000 pages. And more complicated partnerships have skyrocketed from less than 5% of total income in 1990 to over a third today.[9] As a result, the tax gap – the amount of unpaid taxes – has grown to enormous levels. It’s estimated at $7 trillion over the next decade.[10] And since the IRS has lacked the resources to effectively audit high earners – whose audits are more complex and take more time – these high earners are responsible for a disproportionate share of unpaid taxes. To illustrate: In 2019, the top one percent of Americans was estimated to owe over a fifth of unpaid taxes – totaling around $160 billion.[11] Data shows that less than half of all taxes from more complex sources of income are paid. Yet nearly all taxes due from wages and salaries – which are earned by ordinary Americans – are paid.[12] In sum, high earners are paying far less than they owe. This means that working families are shouldering a disproportionate burden of investing in our roads, schools, military, and more. This inequity is unacceptable. As leaders and employees at the IRS have warned for years now, enforcement of the law is not only a means to raise revenue. It is also a matter of fundamental fairness. It is important for honest taxpayers to know that, when they file their taxes accurately with the IRS, other people are doing the same. With your help, funding from the Inflation Reduction Act will go toward correcting this two-tiered tax system, where high earners play by different rules than working and middle-class families. Specifically, funding will go toward auditing more high earners who have not paid their full bill. With it, we are estimated to raise hundreds of billions of dollars in revenue. Importantly, I’ve directed that enforcement resources will not be used to raise audit rates for households making under $400,000 a year relative to historical levels. In fact, we expect audit rates for honest taxpayers to decline, once the IRS has the right technological infrastructure in place. This means a simpler tax filing season for taxpayers who are doing everything right. Last week, I gave an economic speech discussing how our administration’s plan will create a stronger, more resilient economy with greater fairness for all. I believe that adequately funding the IRS is core to our success. It raises the revenue for us to make important investments in our economic strength. It makes sure that all Americans are playing by the same rules. It avoids misallocation of resources in the economy at large. And it does so by deterring taxpayers from shifting their activities toward more opaque sources or engaging in tax evasion. In all, a strong IRS is critical to the economic success of this country – and I am heartened that we are finally reflecting that in our funding decisions. I want to close by returning to where I started. Over the coming weeks and months, you will be asked, yet again, to meet the moment. As with all big things, it will be difficult – but I hope it will be mostly exciting. You will help create a modernized IRS that serves people efficiently, collects taxes that are owed, and delivers credits and benefits to those who are entitled to them. You will be called to implement the Inflation Reduction Act’s new corporate tax reforms and the green tax credits, which are the largest investment in fighting climate change in our nation’s history. Soon enough, you will begin gearing up for the next tax filing season, with a mandate – and finally, resources – to properly serve the American people the way they deserve. I know that this is a day that many of you have worked toward, for so long. So thank you. I will do whatever I can to support you. And today, like every day, I am proud to be your colleague.Thank you.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › NOTES › 1NC---IRS Tradeoff Disad --- Democracy
Heckman, 23. (Jory Heckman, Reporter for Federal News Network, “IRS plans for 20,000 new hires by end of FY 2024 to replace aging workforce” Federal News Network. Web. 4-6-2023. Accessed 7-2-2023. https://federalnewsnetwork.com/hiring-retention/2023/04/irs-plans-for-30000-new-hires-by-end-of-fy-2024-to-replace-aging-workforce/#:~:text=Hiring%2FRetention-,IRS%20plans%20for%2020%2C000%20new%20hires%20by%20end,2024%20to%20replace%20aging%20workforce&text=The%20IRS%20is%20preparing%20to,experience%20and%20beef%20up%20enforcement. JBFunke)
The IRS is preparing to hire tens of thousands of new employees by the end of fiscal 2024, with many of those new hires going to improve taxpayer experience and beef up enforcement.The IRS outlined its hiring and workforce goals as part of the it released Thursday.More broadly, the plan describes how the IRS will spend nearly $80 billion, which is meant for the agency to rebuild its workforce and modernize its legacy IT over the next decade.The IRS plans to hire more than 10,000 employees before the end of this fiscal year, and nearly an additional 10,000 employees in fiscal 2024. Most of the hiring is focused on taxpayer services and enforcement.Newly confirmed IRS Commissioner Danny Werfel said the spending plan “is only the beginning of our work,” as the agency also looks at long-term ways to modernize its IT and shrink a growing tax gap between what taxpayers owe, and what the agency is able to collect.“For years, the agency has not had the resources to provide the service people deserve. Across all of our operations we’ve seen the impact. We’ve lost employees and seen our resources stretched thin with new mandates and an increasingly complex economy,” Werfel said. “The IRS looks forward to demonstrating how the actions under this plan will translate into real improvements for taxpayers.”
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › NOTES › 1NC---IRS Tradeoff Disad --- Terror
Hayes 18, Executive Director of the Nautilus Institute for Security and Sustainability, Ph.D. in Energy and Resources from the University of California-Berkeley, Professor of International Relations at RMIT University (Dr. Peter J., “Non-State Terrorism and Inadvertent Nuclear War”, NAPSNet Special Reports, 1/18/2018, )
The critical issue is how a nuclear terrorist attack may “catalyze” inter-state nuclear war, especially the NC3 systems that inform and partly determine how leaders respond to nuclear threat. Current conditions in Northeast Asia suggest that multiple precursory conditions for nuclear terrorism already exist or exist in nascent form. In Japan, for example, low-level, individual, terroristic violence with nuclear materials, against nuclear facilities, is real. In all countries of the region, the risk of diversion of nuclear material is real, although the risk is likely higher due to volume and laxity of security in some countries of the region than in others. In all countries, the risk of an insider “sleeper” threat is real in security and nuclear agencies, and such insiders already operated in actual terrorist organizations. Insider corruption is also observable in nuclear fuel cycle agencies in all countries of the region. The threat of extortion to induce insider cooperation is also real in all countries. The possibility of a cult attempting to build and buy nuclear weapons is real and has already occurred in the region.[15] Cyber-terrorism against nuclear reactors is real and such attacks have already taken place in South Korea (although it remains difficult to attribute the source of the attacks with certainty). The stand-off ballistic and drone threat to nuclear weapons and fuel cycle facilities is real in the region, including from non-state actors, some of whom have already adopted and used such technology almost instantly from when it becomes accessible (for example, drones).[16] Two other broad risk factors are also present in the region. The social and political conditions for extreme ethnic and xenophobic nationalism are emerging in China, Korea, Japan, and Russia. Although there has been no risk of attack on or loss of control over nuclear weapons since their removal from Japan in 1972 and from South Korea in 1991, this risk continues to exist in North Korea, China, and Russia, and to the extent that they are deployed on aircraft and ships of these and other nuclear weapons states (including submarines) deployed in the region’s high seas, also outside their territorial borders. The most conducive circumstance for catalysis to occur due to a nuclear terrorist attack might involve the following nexi of timing and conditions: Low-level, tactical, or random individual terrorist attacks for whatever reasons, even assassination of national leaders, up to and including dirty radiological bomb attacks, that overlap with inter-state crisis dynamics in ways that affect state decisions to threaten with or to use nuclear weapons. This might be undertaken by an opportunist nuclear terrorist entity in search of rapid and high political impact. Attacks on major national or international events in each country to maximize terror and to de-legitimate national leaders and whole governments. In Japan, for example, more than ten heads of state and senior ministerial international meetings are held each year. For the strategic nuclear terrorist, patiently acquiring higher level nuclear threat capabilities for such attacks and then staging them to maximum effect could accrue strategic gains. Attacks or threatened attacks, including deception and disguised attacks, will have maximum leverage when nuclear-armed states are near or on the brink of war or during a national crisis (such as Fukushima), when intelligence agencies, national leaders, facility operators, surveillance and policing agencies, and first responders are already maximally committed and over-extended. At this point, we note an important caveat to the original concept of catalytic nuclear war as it might pertain to nuclear terrorist threats or attacks. Although an attack might be disguised so that it is attributed to a nuclear-armed state, or a ruse might be undertaken to threaten such attacks by deception, in reality a catalytic strike by a nuclear weapons state in conditions of mutual vulnerability to nuclear retaliation for such a strike from other nuclear armed states would be highly irrational. Accordingly, the effect of nuclear terrorism involving a nuclear detonation or major radiological release may not of itself be catalytic of nuclear war—at least not intentionally–because it will not lead directly to the destruction of a targeted nuclear-armed state. Rather, it may be catalytic of non-nuclear war between states, especially if the non-state actor turns out to be aligned with or sponsored by a state (in many Japanese minds, the natural candidate for the perpetrator of such an attack is the pro-North Korean General Association of Korean Residents, often called Chosen Soren, which represents many of the otherwise stateless Koreans who were born and live in Japan) and a further sequence of coincident events is necessary to drive escalation to the point of nuclear first use by a state. Also, the catalyst—the non-state actor–is almost assured of discovery and destruction either during the attack itself (if it takes the form of a nuclear suicide attack then self-immolation is assured) or as a result of a search-and-destroy campaign from the targeted state (unless the targeted government is annihilated by the initial terrorist nuclear attack). It follows that the effects of a non-state nuclear attack may be characterized better as a trigger effect, bringing about a cascade of nuclear use decisions within NC3 systems that shift each state increasingly away from nuclear non-use and increasingly towards nuclear use by releasing negative controls and enhancing positive controls in multiple action-reaction escalation spirals (depending on how many nuclear armed states are party to an inter-state conflict that is already underway at the time of the non-state nuclear attack); and/or by inducing concatenating nuclear attacks across geographically proximate nuclear weapons forces of states already caught in the crossfire of nuclear threat or attacks of their own making before a nuclear terrorist attack.[17]
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › NOTES › 1NC---IRS Tradeoff Disad --- Terror
Tierney 18, George & Mary Hylton Professor of International Relations; Director Global Research Institute (GRI) (Michael, “#TerroristFinancing: An Examination of Terrorism Financing via the Internet,” International Journal of Cyber Warfare and Terrorism, vol. 8, no. 1, 01/2018, pp. 1–11)
2. TERRORIST FINANCING AND THE INTERNET As mentioned, terrorists’ use of the internet has become a major concern for security officials across the world in recent years. Like many other users, terrorists have found that the internet is an invaluable tool to share information quickly, in order to disseminate ideas and link up with likeminded individuals (Jacobson, 2010; Okolie-Osemene & Okoh, 2015). In this manner, terrorists use the internet for a variety of purposes, including recruitment, propaganda, and financing. As scholars have also noted, the internet is an attractive option for extremists due to the security and anonymity it provides (Jacobson, 2010). Yet while there have been a growing number of studies completed on the ways in which terrorist organizations use the internet to recruit and indoctrinate others, there has been relatively little focus on the methods by which terrorists finance themselves through online activities. Some researchers have attempted to fill gaps in this area by broadly studying internet aspects of terrorism financing. However, research on this particular aspect of terrorism financing still appears to be lacking, with little focus on new methods of terrorist financing via the internet or a marrying of strategies to combat online financing trends available to practitioners in the field. For instance, Sean Paul Ashley (2012) assessed the mobile banking phenomenon, which is prevalent in regions such as the Middle East and Africa, and provides extremists with the ability to easily connect to the internet and remit funds around the world. The decentralization of this kind of banking, due to the fact that brick-and-mortar facilities are not needed to conduct transactions, has allowed terrorist financiersto more efficiently move funds while avoiding detection from authorities. Other researchers,such as MichaelJacobson (2010), have studied the ways in which terrorists engage in cyber-crime to raise and move funds. For example, Jacobson (2010) found that online credit card fraud was a fairly major source of terrorist financing. By stealing a victim’s private credit information, terrorists are able to co-opt needed funds and provide support to themselves or their counterparts. Yet as James Okolie-Osemene and Rosemary Ifeanyi Okoh (2015) note, the internet is mostly used to augment and assist activities which occur in the physical world. In this way, it would appear that the internet is far more useful as a means to move funds globally in support of terrorism, rather than simply as a method to raise funds.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › NOTES › 1NC---IRS Tradeoff Disad --- Terror
GAO 23 (“IRS Needs to Complete Modernization Plans and Fully Address Cloud Computing Requirements,”
The mission of IRS, a component agency within the Department of the Treasury, is to (1) provide America’s taxpayers top quality service by helping them understand and meet their tax responsibilities, and (2) enforce the law with integrity and fairness to all. While it relies extensively on IT to carry out this mission, IRS has reported that modernization is needed to improve its core tax administration systems, operations, and cybersecurity. IRS has also reported that modernization is critical to improving customer experience and providing the kind of service taxpayers have come to expect. For example, IRS has previously reported that modernization will help address business and technical challenges due to constraints with the Individual Master File (IMF) program it has been using since 1970.10 These challenges include the inability to get a real-time view of the taxpayer account, quickly respond to tax code changes, provide enhanced analytical capabilities, and provide additional taxpayer account information to more effectively combat fraud and identity theft.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › NOTES › 1NC---IRS Tradeoff Disad --- Terror
Heckman, 23. (Jory Heckman, Reporter for Federal News Network, “IRS plans for 20,000 new hires by end of FY 2024 to replace aging workforce” Federal News Network. Web. 4-6-2023. Accessed 7-2-2023. https://federalnewsnetwork.com/hiring-retention/2023/04/irs-plans-for-30000-new-hires-by-end-of-fy-2024-to-replace-aging-workforce/#:~:text=Hiring%2FRetention-,IRS%20plans%20for%2020%2C000%20new%20hires%20by%20end,2024%20to%20replace%20aging%20workforce&text=The%20IRS%20is%20preparing%20to,experience%20and%20beef%20up%20enforcement. JBFunke)
The IRS is preparing to hire tens of thousands of new employees by the end of fiscal 2024, with many of those new hires going to improve taxpayer experience and beef up enforcement.The IRS outlined its hiring and workforce goals as part of the it released Thursday.More broadly, the plan describes how the IRS will spend nearly $80 billion, which is meant for the agency to rebuild its workforce and modernize its legacy IT over the next decade.The IRS plans to hire more than 10,000 employees before the end of this fiscal year, and nearly an additional 10,000 employees in fiscal 2024. Most of the hiring is focused on taxpayer services and enforcement.Newly confirmed IRS Commissioner Danny Werfel said the spending plan “is only the beginning of our work,” as the agency also looks at long-term ways to modernize its IT and shrink a growing tax gap between what taxpayers owe, and what the agency is able to collect.“For years, the agency has not had the resources to provide the service people deserve. Across all of our operations we’ve seen the impact. We’ve lost employees and seen our resources stretched thin with new mandates and an increasingly complex economy,” Werfel said. “The IRS looks forward to demonstrating how the actions under this plan will translate into real improvements for taxpayers.”
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Economy defense
Liao 19’ – Jianan, Shenzhen Nanshan Foreign Language School, China. “Business Cycle and War: A Literature Review and Evaluation”, Advances in Economics, Business and Management Research, Vol. 68, , 02-xx-2019
First, war can occur at any stage of expansion, crisis, recession, recovery, so it is unrealistic to assume that wars occur at any particular stage of the business cycle. On the one hand, although the domestic economic problems in the crisis/recession/depression period break out and become prominent in a short time, in fact, such challenge exists at all stages of the business cycle. When countries cannot manage to solve these problems through conventional approaches, including fiscal and monetary policies, they may resort to military expansion to achieve their goals, a theory known as Lateral Pressure. [13] Under such circumstances, even countries in the period of economic expansion are facing downward pressure on the economy and may try to solve the problem through expansion. On the other hand, although the resources required for foreign wars are huge for countries in economic depression, the decision to wage wars depends largely on the consideration of the gain and loss of wars. Even during depression, governments can raise funding for war by issuing bonds. Argentina, for example, was mired in economic stagflation before the war on the Malvinas islands (also known as the Falkland islands in the UK). In fact, many governments would dramatically increase their expenditure to stimulate the economy during the recession, and economically war is the same as these policies, so the claim that a depressed economy cannot support a war is unfounded. In addition, during the crisis period of the business cycle, which is the early stage of the economic downturn, despite the economic crisis and potential depression, the country still retains the ability to start wars based on its economic and military power. Based on the above understanding, war has the conditions and reasons for its outbreak in all stages of the business cycle.
Second, the economic origin for the outbreak of war is downward pressure on the economy rather than optimism or competition for monopoly capital, which may exist during economic recession or economic prosperity. This is due to a fact that during economic prosperity, people are also worried about a potential economic recession. Blainey pointed out that wars often occur in the economic upturn, which is caused by the optimism in people's mind [14], that is, the confidence to prevail. This interpretation linking optimism and war ignores the strength contrast between the warring parties. Not all wars are equally comprehensive, and there have always been wars of unequal strength. In such a war, one of the parties tends to have an absolute advantage, so the expectation of the outcome of the war is not directly related to the economic situation of the country. Optimism is not a major factor leading to war, but may somewhat serve as stimulation. In addition, Lenin attributed the war to competition between monopoly capital. This theory may seem plausible, but its scope of application is obviously too narrow. Lenin's theory of imperialism is only applicable to developed capitalist countries in the late stage of the development capitalism, but in reality, many wars take place among developing countries whose economies are still at their beginning stages. Therefore, the theory centered on competition among monopoly capital cannot explain most foreign wars. Moreover, even wars that occur during periods of economic expansion are likely to result from the potential expectation of economic recession, the "limits of growth" [15] faced during prosperity — a potential deficiency of market demand. So the downward pressure on the economy is the cause of war.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Economy defense
Walt 20 – Stephen M, the Robert and Renée Belfer professor of international relations at Harvard University. “Will a Global Depression Trigger Another World War?”, Foreign Policy, , 05-13-2020
One familiar argument is the so-called diversionary (or “scapegoat”) theory of war. It suggests that leaders who are worried about their popularity at home will try to divert attention from their failures by provoking a crisis with a foreign power and maybe even using force against it. Drawing on this logic, some Americans now worry that President Donald Trump will decide to attack a country like Iran or Venezuela in the run-up to the presidential election and especially if he thinks he’s likely to lose. This outcome strikes me as unlikely, even if one ignores the logical and empirical flaws in the theory itself. War is always a gamble, and should things go badly—even a little bit—it would hammer the last nail in the coffin of Trump’s declining fortunes. Moreover, none of the countries Trump might consider going after pose an imminent threat to U.S. security, and even his staunchest supporters may wonder why he is wasting time and money going after Iran or Venezuela at a moment when thousands of Americans are dying preventable deaths at home. Even a successful military action won’t put Americans back to work, create the sort of testing-and-tracing regime that competent governments around the world have been able to implement already, or hasten the development of a vaccine. The same logic is likely to guide the decisions of other world leaders too. Another familiar folk theory is “military Keynesianism.” War generates a lot of economic demand, and it can sometimes lift depressed economies out of the doldrums and back toward prosperity and full employment. The obvious case in point here is World War II, which did help the U.S economy finally escape the quicksand of the Great Depression. Those who are convinced that great powers go to war primarily to keep Big Business (or the arms industry) happy are naturally drawn to this sort of argument, and they might worry that governments looking at bleak economic forecasts will try to restart their economies through some sort of military adventure. I doubt it. It takes a really big war to generate a significant stimulus, and it is hard to imagine any country launching a large-scale war—with all its attendant risks—at a moment when debt levels are already soaring. More importantly, there are lots of easier and more direct ways to stimulate the economy—infrastructure spending, unemployment insurance, even “helicopter payments”—and launching a war has to be one of the least efficient methods available. The threat of war usually spooks investors too, which any politician with their eye on the stock market would be loath to do. Economic downturns can encourage war in some special circumstances, especially when a war would enable a country facing severe hardships to capture something of immediate and significant value. Saddam Hussein’s decision to seize Kuwait in 1990 fits this model perfectly: The Iraqi economy was in terrible shape after its long war with Iran; unemployment was threatening Saddam’s domestic position; Kuwait’s vast oil riches were a considerable prize; and seizing the lightly armed emirate was exceedingly easy to do. Iraq also owed Kuwait a lot of money, and a hostile takeover by Baghdad would wipe those debts off the books overnight. In this case, Iraq’s parlous economic condition clearly made war more likely. Yet I cannot think of any country in similar circumstances today. Now is hardly the time for Russia to try to grab more of Ukraine—if it even wanted to—or for China to make a play for Taiwan, because the costs of doing so would clearly outweigh the economic benefits. Even conquering an oil-rich country—the sort of greedy acquisitiveness that Trump occasionally hints at—doesn’t look attractive when there’s a vast glut on the market. I might be worried if some weak and defenseless country somehow came to possess the entire global stock of a successful coronavirus vaccine, but that scenario is not even remotely possible. If one takes a longer-term perspective, however, a sustained economic depression could make war more likely by strengthening fascist or xenophobic political movements, fueling protectionism and hypernationalism, and making it more difficult for countries to reach mutually acceptable bargains with each other. The history of the 1930s shows where such trends can lead, although the economic effects of the Depression are hardly the only reason world politics took such a deadly turn in the 1930s. Nationalism, xenophobia, and authoritarian rule were making a comeback well before COVID-19 struck, but the economic misery now occurring in every corner of the world could intensify these trends and leave us in a more war-prone condition when fear of the virus has diminished. On balance, however, I do not think that even the extraordinary economic conditions we are witnessing today are going to have much impact on the likelihood of war. Why? First of all, if depressions were a powerful cause of war, there would be a lot more of the latter. To take one example, the United States has suffered 40 or more recessions since the country was founded, yet it has fought perhaps 20 interstate wars, most of them unrelated to the state of the economy. To paraphrase the economist Paul Samuelson’s famous quip about the stock market, if recessions were a powerful cause of war, they would have predicted “nine out of the last five (or fewer).” Second, states do not start wars unless they believe they will win a quick and relatively cheap victory. As John Mearsheimer showed in his classic book Conventional Deterrence, national leaders avoid war when they are convinced it will be long, bloody, costly, and uncertain. To choose war, political leaders have to convince themselves they can either win a quick, cheap, and decisive victory or achieve some limited objective at low cost. Europe went to war in 1914 with each side believing it would win a rapid and easy victory, and Nazi Germany developed the strategy of blitzkrieg in order to subdue its foes as quickly and cheaply as possible. Iraq attacked Iran in 1980 because Saddam believed the Islamic Republic was in disarray and would be easy to defeat, and George W. Bush invaded Iraq in 2003 convinced the war would be short, successful, and pay for itself. The fact that each of these leaders miscalculated badly does not alter the main point: No matter what a country’s economic condition might be, its leaders will not go to war unless they think they can do so quickly, cheaply, and with a reasonable probability of success. Third, and most important, the primary motivation for most wars is the desire for security, not economic gain. For this reason, the odds of war increase when states believe the long-term balance of power may be shifting against them, when they are convinced that adversaries are unalterably hostile and cannot be accommodated, and when they are confident they can reverse the unfavorable trends and establish a secure position if they act now. The historian A.J.P. Taylor once observed that “every war between Great Powers [between 1848 and 1918] … started as a preventive war, not as a war of conquest,” and that remains true of most wars fought since then. The bottom line: Economic conditions (i.e., a depression) may affect the broader political environment in which decisions for war or peace are made, but they are only one factor among many and rarely the most significant. Even if the COVID-19 pandemic has large, lasting, and negative effects on the world economy—as seems quite likely—it is not likely to affect the probability of war very much, especially in the short term. To be sure, I can’t rule out another powerful cause of war—stupidity—especially when it is so much in evidence in some quarters these days. So there is no guarantee that we won’t see misguided leaders stumbling into another foolish bloodletting. But given that it’s hard to find any rays of sunshine at this particular moment in history, I’m going to hope I’m right about this one.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Warming defense
Lomborg 21 – Dr. Bjorn, President of the Copenhagen Consensus Center, Former Director of the Danish Government's Environmental Assessment Institute, PhD in Political Science at the University of Copenhagen, M.A. in Political Science at the University of Aarhus, BA from the University of Georgia. “Climate Change Calls for Adaptation, Not Panic”, Wall Street Journal, , 10-21-2021
It’s easy to construct climate disasters. You just find a current, disconcerting trend and project it into the future, while ignoring everything humanity could do to adapt. For instance, one widely reported study found that heat waves could kill thousands more Americans by the end of the century if global warming continues apace—but only if you assume people won’t use more air conditioning. Yes, the climate is likely to change, but so is human behavior in response.
Adaptation doesn’t make the cost of global warming go away entirely, but it does reduce it dramatically. Higher temperatures will shrink harvests if farmers keep growing the same crops, but they’re likely to adapt by growing other varieties or different plants altogether. Corn production in North America has shifted away from the Southeast toward the Upper Midwest, where farmers take advantage of longer growing seasons and less-frequent extreme heat. When sea levels rise, governments build defenses—like the levees, flood walls and drainage systems that protected New Orleans from much of Hurricane Ida’s ferocity this year.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Warming defense
Kerr et al. 19 – Amber, Energy and Resources PhD at the University of California-Berkeley, known agroecologist, former coordinator of the USDA California Climate Hub. Daniel Swain, Climate Science PhD at UCLA, climate scientist, a research fellow at the National Center for Atmospheric Research. Andrew King, Earth Sciences PhD, Climate Extremes Research Fellow at the University of Melbourne. Peter Kalmus, Professor and Chair in Climate Impacts at the University of Exeter, a lead author on the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change in Working Group. Richard Betts, Paleoclimatology PhD at the Climate Change Research Center, climate scientist at the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research. William Huiskamp, Postdoctoral research fellow, Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research. “Claim that human civilization could end in 30 years is speculative, not supported with evidence”, Climate Feedback, , 06-04-2019
This is hyperbole. The scenario constructed in this report does not have a “high likelihood” of occurring in part because it requires a confluence of circumstances coming together. While it’s certainly true that climate change will be damaging to society and the environment and many of the consequences will be severe this does not equate to a high likelihood of civilisation coming to an end.
Richard Betts, Professor, Met Office Hadley Centre & University of Exeter:
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Warming defense
Kerr et al. 19 – Amber, Energy and Resources PhD at the University of California-Berkeley, known agroecologist, former coordinator of the USDA California Climate Hub. Daniel Swain, Climate Science PhD at UCLA, climate scientist, a research fellow at the National Center for Atmospheric Research. Andrew King, Earth Sciences PhD, Climate Extremes Research Fellow at the University of Melbourne. Peter Kalmus, Professor and Chair in Climate Impacts at the University of Exeter, a lead author on the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change in Working Group. Richard Betts, Paleoclimatology PhD at the Climate Change Research Center, climate scientist at the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research. William Huiskamp, Postdoctoral research fellow, Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research. “Claim that human civilization could end in 30 years is speculative, not supported with evidence”, Climate Feedback, , 06-04-2019
Scientists who reviewed IFLScience’s story found that it failed to provide sufficient context for this report—differentiating, for example, between speculative claims and descriptions of peer-reviewed research. In particular, the story’s headline (“New Report Warns ‘High Likelihood Of Human Civilization Coming To An End’ Within 30 Years”) misrepresents the report as a likely projection rather than an exploration of an intrinsically unlikely worst case scenario.
See all the scientists’ annotations in context.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Warming defense
Cascio 19 – Jamais, a professional futurist who has been exploring the intersection of environmental, technological, and cultural change for 25 years. Selected by Foreign Policy magazine as one of their Top 100 Global Thinkers in 2009, Cascio specializes in plausible scenarios of the future. He is a Distinguished Fellow at the Institute for the Future, where he works on a wide array of projects. Cascio’s written work has appeared in both academic and popular journals and collections. “The apocalypse: It’s not the end of the world”, Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, Vol. 75, No. 6, pg. 269-272, , 10-28-2019
There’s a 25- to 50-year lag between the emission of atmospheric carbon and its persistent impact on temperature. This means the environmental disruption attributable to global warming we’re seeing now is the result of carbon emissions up through the 1980s. It also means we could cut off all carbon emissions today, globally, and still see another generation of warming. Beyond the environmental, economic, and human consequences, imagine the political impact of taking bold action that produces no observable benefits for 20 years, or even longer.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Warming defense
Zing Tsjeng, 19, 2-27-2019, executive editor and the author of the Forgotten Women book series, "The Climate Change Paper So Depressing It's Sending People to Therapy", [https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/vbwpdb/the-climate-change-paper-so-depressing-its-sending-people-to-therapy], AVD
"Deep Adaptation" is quite unlike any other academic paper. There's the language ("we are about to play Russian Roulette with the entire human race with already two bullets loaded"). There's the flashes of dark humor ("I was only partly joking earlier when I questioned why I was even writing this paper"). But most of all, there's the stark conclusions that it draws about the future. Chiefly, that it's too late to stop climate change from devastating our world—and that "climate-induced societal collapse is now inevitable in the near term." How near? About a decade. Professor Jem Bendell, a sustainability academic at the University of Cumbria, wrote the paper after taking a sabbatical at the end of 2017 to review and understand the latest climate science "properly—not sitting on the fence anymore," as he puts it on the phone to me. What he found terrified him. "The evidence before us suggests that we are set for disruptive and uncontrollable levels of climate change, bringing starvation, destruction, migration, disease, and war," he writes in the paper. "Our norms of behavior—that we call our 'civilization'—may also degrade." "It is time," he adds, "we consider the implications of it being too late to avert a global environmental catastrophe in the lifetimes of people alive today." Even a schmuck like me is familiar with some of the evidence Bendell sets out to prove his point. You only needed to step outside during the record-breaking heatwave last year to acknowledge that 17 of the 18 hottest years on the planet have occurred since 2000. Scientists already believe we are soon on course for an ice-free Arctic, which will only accelerate global warming. Back in 2017, even Fox News reported scientists' warnings that the Earth's sixth mass extinction was underway. Erik Buitenhuis, a senior researcher at the Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research, tells me that Bendell's conclusions may sound extreme, but he agrees with the report's overall assessment. "I think societal collapse is indeed inevitable," he says, though adds that "the process is likely to take decades to centuries." The important thing, Buitenhuis says, is to realize that the negative effects of climate change have already been with us for some time: "Further gradual deterioration looks much more likely to me than a disaster within the next ten years that will be big enough that, after that, everybody will agree the status quo is doomed." "Jem's paper is in the main well-researched and supported by relatively mainstream climate science," says Professor Rupert Read, chair of the Green House think-tank and a philosophy academic at the University of East Anglia. "That's why I'm with him on the fundamentals. And more and more people are." Read's key disagreement with Bendell is his belief that we still have time to snatch victory from the jaws of defeat, saying, "I think it's hubris to think that we know the future." But that doesn't mean Bendell's premise is wrong: "The way I see it, deep adaptation is insurance against the possibility—or rather, the probability—of some kind of collapse," says Read. "'Deep Adaptation' is saying, 'What do we need to do if collapse is something we need to realistically plan for?'" When I speak to Bendell, he tells me he thinks of "Deep Adaptation" as more of an ethical and philosophical framework, rather than a prophecy about the future of the planet. "The longer we refuse to talk about climate change as already here and screwing with our way of life—because we don't want to think like that because it's too frightening or will somehow demotivate people—the less time we have to reduce harm," he says with deliberation. What does he mean by harm? "Starvation is the first one," he answers, pointing to lowering harvests of grain in Europe in 2018 due to drought that saw the EU reap 6 million tons less wheat. "In the scientific community at the moment, the appropriate thing is to say that 2018 was an anomaly. However, if you look at what's been happening over the last few years, it isn't an anomaly. There's a possibility that 2018 is the new best case scenario." That means, in Bendell's view, that governments need to start planning emergency responses to climate change, including growing and stockpiling food. He minces his words even less in his paper: "When I say starvation, destruction, migration, disease, and war, I mean in your own life. With the power down, soon you won't have water coming out of your tap. You will depend on your neighbors for food and some warmth. You will become malnourished. You won't know whether to stay or go. You will fear being violently killed before starving to death." Should people start building bunkers and buying bulletproof vests? "There's no way of getting through this unless we try together," he says. "We need to help people stay fed and watered where they live already to reduce disruption and reduce civil unrest as much as we can." Of the Silicon Valley financiers prepping for the apocalypse in New Zealand, he says: "Once money doesn't matter anymore and the armed guards are trying to feed their starving children, what do you think they'll do? The billionaires doing that are just deluded." Bendell wasn't always this gloomy about the state of the world. He once worked for WWF, one of the biggest environmental charities in the world, and in 2012 founded the Institute for Leadership and Sustainability (IFLAS) at the University of Cumbria. The World Economic Forum named him a Young Global Leader for his work. So how did he end up writing a paper that determined that civilization—and environmental sustainability as we currently understand it—is doomed? "Since the age of 15, I've been an environmentalist," he tells me. "I've given my life professionally and personally. I'm a workaholic, and it was all about sustainability." Once he sat down with the data, however, he realized that his field was quickly becoming irrelevant in the face of oncoming climate catastrophe. "It would mean not getting super excited about the expansion of your recycling program in a major multinational," he says. "It's a completely different paradigm of what we should be looking at." What he didn’t expect was for the paper to take off online. "It was aimed at those people in my professional community and why we're in denial," he says. "When I put it out there, I didn’t expect 15-year-olds in schools in Indonesia to be reading it with their teachers." He says that "Deep Adaptation" has been downloaded over 110,000 times since it was released by IFLAS as an occasional paper. "Someone in the alternative economics and bitcoin crowd told me, 'Oh, everyone's talking about deep adaptation in London at all the dinner parties,'" he laughs. Researchers from the Institute for Public Policy Research (IPPR), an established progressive think-tank, consulted Bendell's paper in the process of writing its new report, "This is a crisis: Facing up to the age of environmental breakdown." Laurie Laybourn-Langton, its lead author, told me via email: "I appreciated the frankness of the report in facing up to issues that so many in research and policy communities seem unwilling to. We don't subscribe to the view that social collapse is inevitable, however." He explains: "This is partly because it's so hard to predict the outcomes of the complex and uncertain process of environmental shocks interacting with social and economic systems. We simply don't know. That said, they shouldn’t be disregarded as a potential outcome, and so we are calling for greater levels of preparedness to these shocks." Not everyone was so taken with the paper. Bendell submitted it to a well-respected academic journal for publication, with little success. Sustainability Accounting, Management and Policy Journal (SAMPJ) told me that the paper was in need of "major revisions" before it would be ready for publication. Bendell ended up publishing it through IFLAS and his blog. "The academic process is such that I took that as an effective rejection," he explains, saying that the reviewers wanted him to fundamentally alter his conclusions. "I couldn't completely rewrite the paper to say that I don't think collapse is inevitable. It was asking for a different paper." Emerald, the scholarly publisher that owns SAMPJ, says it takes issue with how Bendell frames its reception of its paper on his blog: "the study on collapse they thought you should not read—yet." A spokesperson told me: "The decision was arrived at based on the merit of the submitted article and the double blind peer review process integral to academia and the advancement of knowledge. SAMPJ, and [editor Carol Adams] are proud members of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and adhere to the highest ethical standards in publishing. We see no evidence that the decision of Major Revision was politically motivated. "Emerald requested the author correct their blog post to reflect the facts. This request was unfortunately ignored. The post continues to imply the paper was rejected because it was deemed too controversial. The paper was not rejected, and was given a Major Revision due to the rigorous standards of the scholarly output of the journal." Bendell says he did reply to Emerald's request to amend his blog post—but only if they would consider telling him the decisions of those who reviewed his paper. (Under the double blind peer review, reviewers' decisions are anonymous.) "That title can be read in a number of ways," he says. "It is a paper that the reviewers didn't want you to read. They didn't want it published." Climate gloom and doom is nothing new—doomsday preppers have been stockpiling their freeze-dried food rations for decades now. But Bendell's paper appears to have hit a unique nerve, especially given that the average scientific paper is estimated to be read by only three or so people. Rupert Read tells me that he was sent it simultaneously by three other academics when it was published. But it hasn’t trended on Twitter. It hasn't been pushed by a celebrity. It was briefly mentioned in a Bloomberg Businessweek article, but that's it. "Deep Adaptation" is that unique social phenomenon: an academic paper that has gone viral through word of mouth. Nathan Savelli, a 31-year-old high school life coach from Hamilton, Canada, was recommended the paper by a local environmental activist. Reading it sent him spiraling into depression. "I guess in some ways it felt like I was diagnosed with a terminal illness," he tells me. "If I'm being honest, it was a mix of heartbreaking sadness and extreme anger." Savelli felt so low that he sought help from a climate grief support group organized by 350.org, the global grassroots climate movement. "I had attended counseling in the past for other issues, but never a group session, and thought it might be something helpful for me," he tells me. Did it help? "I'm not sure I'd say it alleviated my grief, but it was definitely comforting to be around people who understood what I was feeling." And therein lies the problem with "Deep Adaptation:" if you accept that the paper is entirely correct in its prediction of collapse, how do you move on with your life? How do you even get out of bed in the morning? "I'm aware of what difficult emotions it triggers," Bendell acknowledges. "I do believe that if you’ve come across this [paper], then absolutely some grief and despair is very natural. Why isn't that OK? We all die in the end. Life is about impermanence." On his blog, he lists several sources for psychological support, including several groups on Facebook and LinkedIn that discuss collapse and offer help to those struggling to come to terms with the conclusions of his paper. But, Bendell adds, reading the paper has been "transformative" for some. "People find a new boldness about living life on their own terms—actually connecting to their heart's desire. How do they wish to live, and why don't they live that way now rather than postponing it?" In one case, it even helped prompt one high-ranking academic to quit her job and the city. In December of 2017, Dr. Alison Green left her post as the pro vice-chancellor of Arden University. She had read the IPCC report warning that the world is nowhere near averting global temperature increases, as well as the 1,656-page National Climate Assessment on how climate change is now dramatically affecting our lives—and then she read Bendell's paper.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Warming defense
Zycher 21 – Dr. Benjamin, Senior Fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, Doctorate in Economics from UCLA, Master in Public Policy from the University of California, Berkeley, and Bachelor of Arts in Political Science from UCLA, Former Senior Economist at the RAND Corporation, Former Adjunct Professor of Economics at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) and at the California State University Channel Islands, and Former Senior Economist at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology. “The Case for Climate Change Realism”, AEI, , 06-21-2021
Unable to demonstrate that observed climate trends are due to anthropogenic climate change — or even that these events are particularly unusual or concerning — climate catastrophists will often turn to dire predictions about prospective climate phenomena. The problem with such predictions is that they are almost always generated by climate models driven by highly complex sets of assumptions about which there is significant dispute. Worse, these models are notorious for failing to accurately predict already documented changes in climate. As climatologist Patrick Michaels of the Competitive Enterprise Institute notes:
During all periods from 10 years (2006-2015) to 65 (1951-2015) years in length, the observed temperature trend lies in the lower half of the collection of climate model simulations, and for several periods it lies very close (or even below) the 2.5th percentile of all the model runs. Over shorter periods, such as the last two decades, a plethora of mechanisms have been put forth to explain the observed/modeled divergence, but none do so completely and many of the explanations are inconsistent with each other.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Warming defense
Sebastian Farquhar 17 leads the Global Priorities Project (GPP) at the Centre for Effective Altruism, et al., 2017, “Existential Risk: Diplomacy and Governance,” https://www.fhi.ox.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/Existential-Risks-2017-01-23.pdf
The most likely levels of global warming are very unlikely to cause human extinction.15 The existential risks of climate change instead stem from tail risk climate change – the low probability of extreme levels of warming – and interaction with other sources of risk. It is impossible to say with confidence at what point global warming would become severe enough to pose an existential threat. Research has suggested that warming of 11-12°C would render most of the planet uninhabitable,16 and would completely devastate agriculture.17 This would pose an extreme threat to human civilisation as we know it.18 Warming of around 7°C or more could potentially produce conflict and instability on such a scale that the indirect effects could be an existential risk, although it is extremely uncertain how likely such scenarios are.19 Moreover, the timescales over which such changes might happen could mean that humanity is able to adapt enough to avoid extinction in even very extreme scenarios. The probability of these levels of warming depends on eventual greenhouse gas concentrations. According to some experts, unless strong action is taken soon by major emitters, it is likely that we will pursue a medium-high emissions pathway.20 If we do, the chance of extreme warming is highly uncertain but appears non-negligible. Current concentrations of greenhouse gases are higher than they have been for hundreds of thousands of years,21 which means that there are significant unknown unknowns about how the climate system will respond. Particularly concerning is the risk of positive feedback loops, such as the release of vast amounts of methane from melting of the arctic permafrost, which would cause rapid and disastrous warming.22 The economists Gernot Wagner and Martin Weitzman have used IPCC figures (which do not include modelling of feedback loops such as those from melting permafrost) to estimate that if we continue to pursue a medium-high emissions pathway, the probability of eventual warming of 6°C is around 10%,23 and of 10°C is around 3%.24 These estimates are of course highly uncertain. It is likely that the world will take action against climate change once it begins to impose large costs on human society, long before there is warming of 10°C. Unfortunately, there is significant inertia in the climate system: there is a 25 to 50 year lag between CO2 emissions and eventual warming,25 and it is expected that 40% of the peak concentration of CO2 will remain in the atmosphere 1,000 years after the peak is reached.26 Consequently, it is impossible to reduce temperatures quickly by reducing CO2 emissions. If the world does start to face costly warming, the international community will therefore face strong incentives to find other ways to reduce global temperatures.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › I/L Defense – Won’t solve economy
United States correspondent Jun 9, 2023 – 7.40am https://www.afr.com/world/north-america/us-carbon-border-tax-could-spark-china-tariff-on-australia-20230609-p5df8o
The bill, dubbed would punish China and other exporting countries that have more lax pollution controls and dirtier manufacturing processes than the US. : “The bipartisan Prove It Act will provide reliable data that’s needed to quantify the climate benefits of the US investments in cleaner, more efficient manufacturing practices and to hold nations like China accountable for their emissions-heavy production of goods like steel.” However, economists such as the American Institute for Economic Research’s Samuel Gregg warn that such a tax could be an excuse for further trade protectionism between the US and China, with likely spillover effects for Australia. This proposed carbon border tax is being presented in the rhetoric of climate change, but it’s very much a protectionist move,” Dr Gregg said.