Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Links – Universal Basic Income

Broad Republican opposition to universal basic income.

AUGUST 19, 2020 More Americans oppose than favor the government providing a universal basic income for all adult citizens https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2020/08/19/more-americans-oppose-than-favor-the-government-providing-a-universal-basic-income-for-all-adult-citizens/

The idea of the government providing a universal basic income for all adult citizens draws broad and intense opposition among Republicans, but is generally supported by Democrats, according to a new Pew Research Center survey. Nearly eight-in-ten Republicans and Republican-leaning independents (78%) oppose the federal government providing a universal basic income of about $1,000 per person, with 62% strongly opposed. A smaller share of Democrats and Democratic leaners (66%) favor a UBI, with just a third supporting the proposal strongly.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Links – Universal Basic Income

National momentum has shifted toward clear opposition to universal basic income

May 10 2021 MAY 10, 2021 https://www.mic.com/impact/universal-basic-income-why-doesnt-the-united-states-have-it-yet-74444134

In part, it comes down to a question of popularity. At the height of the 2020 presidential race last August, . Those who did support the idea of a UBI skewed younger and were mostly Black or Latinx, while white, older conservatives largely rejected the idea out of hand. But while the largely Republican opposition to UBI makes a degree of sense, in the context of the conservative movement's broader rejection of programs like welfare and food stamps, there is indeed a case to be made within certain corners of the GOP that UBI could, in fact, dovetail with their guiding principle of smaller government. A majority of Republicans , and within the libertarian wings of conservatism, some have argued that by issuing a blanket UBI in place of existing social safety net programs, it would ultimately eliminate huge swaths of government bureaucracy. For now, however, with momentum for UBI largely blunted on the national scale, it's increasingly likely that if Americans are to get something resembling a steady cost-of-living check from the government, it will be on a local level. Even in countries where UBI has been implemented — like Finland, which in 2017 became the first European Union nation to give it a try — it's been done on a .

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Links – Universal Basic Income

Universal basic income is a political non-starter in the US

Catherine Clifford Published Thu, Aug 31 2017 1:54 PM EDTUpdated Fri, Sep 1 201711:44 AM EDT A $1,000 per month cash handout would grow the economy by $2.5 trillion, new study says https://www.cnbc.com/2017/08/31/1000-per-month-cash-handout-would-grow-the-economy-by-2-point-5-trillion.html

Even as the idea of universal basic income is being studied by and discussed among the tech elite, the idea is a non-starter in the United States, according to some. , the founder and president of the D.C.-based think tank , called the notion too idealistic. “An effort to secure UBI would prove quixotic,” . Greenstein says universal basic income is both too expensive and impossible to get through Washington, D.C.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Block Link Extension (general)

Agenda items are zero sum.

Peter C. Carstensen 21, the Fred W. & Vi Miller Chair in Law Emeritus, University of Wisconsin Law School, February 2021, “The “Ought” and “Is Likely” of Biden Antitrust,” https://www.concurrences.com/en/review/issues/no-1-2021/on-topic/the-new-us-antitrust-administration-en

14. Similarly, despite bipartisan murmurs about competitive issues, the potential in a closely divided Congress that any major initiatives will survive is limited at best. In part the challenge here is how the Biden administration will rank its commitments. If it were to make reform of competition law a major and primary commitment, it would have to trade off other goals, which might include health care reform or increases in the minimum wage. It is likely in this circumstance the new administration, like the Obama administration’s abandonment of the pro-competitive rules proposed under the PSA, would elect to give up stricter competition rules in order to achieve other legislative priorities. 15. Another key to a robust commitment to workable competition is the choice of cabinet and other key administrative positions. Here as well, the early signs are not entirely encouraging. In selecting Tom Vilsack to return as secretary of agriculture, the president has embraced a friend of the large corporate interests dominating agriculture who has spent the last four years in a highly lucrative position advancing their interests. Given the desperate need for pro-competitive rules to implement the PSA and control exploitation of dairy farmers through milk-market orders, the return of Vilsack is not good news. Who will head the FTC and who will be the attorney general and assistant attorney general for antitrust is still unknown, but if those picks are also centrists with strong links to corporate America the hope for robust enforcement of competition law will further attenuate! 16. In sum, this is a pessimistic prognostication for the likely Biden antitrust enforcement agenda. There is much that ought to be done. But this requires a willingness to take major enforcement risks, to invest significant political capital in the legislative process, and to select leaders who are committed to advancing the public interest in fair, efficient and dynamically competitive markets. The early signs are that the new administration will be no more committed to robust competition policy than the Obama administration. Events may force a more vigorous policy—I will cling to that hope as the Biden administration takes shape.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Block Link Extension (general)

New fights are the only thing that can derail passage.

Thomas Gift & Julie M. Norman 2-1, Associate Professor of Political Science at University College London, Visiting Fellow at the Center for the Study of American Politics at Yale University, Ph.D. in Political Science from Duke University; Associate Professor of Politics and International Relations at University College London, Ph.D. in International Relations from American University, “For Joe Biden, could low expectations be a gift?”, The Hill, 02-01-2023, https://thehill.com/opinion/white-house/3838657-for-joe-biden-could-low-expectations-be-a-gift

A special counsel investigation. A GOP-led House hellbent on obstruction. A low-40s approval rating. Small wonder why conventional wisdom is that President Biden is already a lame duck. Yet as Biden’s second State of the Union address approaches, could low expectations actually be a gift for his personal brand of pragmatic politics?

Freed from the pressure of delivering for progressives (while simultaneously trying to keep moderates on board), a final two years of his term that eschew ideological purity and focus on getting things done could be just the second act Biden needs. It would be consistent with his values, popular with swing voters and in line with the platform he campaigned on in 2020. The question: Is Biden ready to be Biden?

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Uniqueness Extension

It’s an easy bipartisan compromise – Republicans support the economic & competition components while Democrats want to protect the environment

March 15 2023 Bipartisan Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism - A Political Unicorn? https://www.forbes.com/sites/arielcohen/2023/03/15/bipartisan-carbon-border-adjustment-mechanisma-political-unicorn/?sh=5e657edc68df

US legislators on both sides of the aisle must negotiate the details for any American CBAM. While partisan deadlock means swift legislative action from Congress to respond to all energy and climate needs is unlikely, legislators can still leverage very different priorities to arrive at a bipartisan compromise. For Republicans, who have done a drastic on tariffs and protectionism in the last 10 years, and are returning from free trade to protectionism and mercantilism, the CBAM is a popular way to simultaneously protect American jobs and manufacturing while gingerly dipping the toes in the climate change waters. For Democrats, who are historically more vocal about decarbonization, CBAM allows America to move more in line with the while reaching its . A CBAM also aligns with Democratic legislation such as the 2021 which promotes international cooperation on regulating carbon emissions, and the 2022 (CCA), which reflects a commitment to climate change through sustainable trade. For both parties and foreign policy practitioners, CBAM is also a tool to counter China.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Uniqueness Extension

Bipartisan support for a carbon border adjustment mechanism and it will incentivize reductions in emissions, solving warming.

March 15 2023 Bipartisan Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism - A Political Unicorn? https://www.forbes.com/sites/arielcohen/2023/03/15/bipartisan-carbon-border-adjustment-mechanisma-political-unicorn/?sh=5e657edc68df

A Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) allows a country to impose a price on carbon emitted during the production of goods in the country of origin as import fees, thus incentivizing greener manufacturing. This has been a perennial aspiration of environmentalists for decades that once languished in obscurity but is now rapidly becoming policy. Now, this step forward in climate policy may be legislated with bipartisan support in the US Congress, with far-reaching implications not just for the environment but the international economy.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Uniqueness Extension

Broad bipartisan momentum for a carbon border adjustment bill.

Emma Dumain 2023 | 05/16/2023 06:18 AM EDT Climate group with GO P roots a go-to for tariff push https://www.eenews.net/articles/climate-group-with-gop-roots-a-go-to-for-tariff-push/

Four senators — two Democratic, two Republican — plan to unveil proposals in coming weeks that would slap a tariff on carbon-intensive goods coming into the United States from abroad. Each bill will look very different in the approaches they take to establishing trade policy designed to leverage U.S. competitiveness while also addressing the climate crisis, but they’ll all have something in common: significant buy-in from the Climate Leadership Council. “It’s fair to say that any office that is working on a border carbon adjustment legislation or something related, we will have worked with them on it,” Greg Bertelsen, the council’s CEO, told E&E News in a recent interview. Since its launch nearly six years ago, CLC has become an important resource on Capitol Hill for lawmakers looking to formulate legislation around the increasingly popular concept of a carbon boarder adjustment mechanism (CBAM) that could mirror what the European Union is moving towards and serve as a counterweight to foreign adversaries like China. Armed with data, experts and insights, Bertelsen and his CLC colleagues have made themselves available to any member of Congress who wants to engage on this issue.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Uniqueness Extension

Lawmakers are motivated to get it done – the newly implemented EU CBAM has upped the stakes.

Emma Dumain June 8 2023 06:33 AM EDT Bipartisan bill would lay groundwork for U.S. carbon tariffs https://www.eenews.net/articles/bipartisan-bill-would-lay-groundwork-for-u-s-carbon-tariffs/

“The focus on the border tariff is the key, and the E.U. CBAM is coming at us one way or another, so that will provide a significant forcing event, and this adds information,” Whitehouse agreed. “It’s a fairly small thing, we can move quickly, we can get more information, and that’s — it’s all good.” One reason the CBAM concept has gained so much traction among conservatives is that there’s more to it than just a mechanism to fight global emissions and beat the climate crisis: It also would punish other countries, like China, that are producing goods with higher carbon intensities than the United States without consequences. Whitehouse and Coons have both suggested that language related to a carbon tariff into a legislative package to boost U.S. competitiveness with China — a follow-up to last year’s CHIPS and Science Act. Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) wants Democrats and Republicans to work on the package together. But it’s not clear whether the blueprints from Whitehouse, Coons, Cassidy and Cramer will align in time to become a part of “CHIPS 2.0,” nor is it certain there will even be a “CHIPS 2.0” to include it. In the meantime, the “PROVE IT Act” can fill a necessary void while fulfilling a necessary function, said Greg Bertelsen, CEO of the Climate Leadership Council, which is on CBAM proposals. For one thing, he said, mandating a study of U.S. products’ carbon intensity that would take two years from the date of enactment of the bill could actually take care of an important part of the equation while members of Congress reconcile their disagreements on the larger issues. For another, he continued, the “PROVE IT Act” responds not only to a practical need but also a desire from lawmakers.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Uniqueness Extension

The PROVE IT Act is bipartisan, will pass, and resolve emissions and economy concerns.

Coons.Gov, June 7 2023 Senators Coons, Cramer introduce legislation to study global emissions intensity and hold countries with dirty production accountable https://www.coons.senate.gov/news/press-releases/senators-coons-cramer-introduce-legislation-to-study-global-emissions-intensity-and-hold-countries-with-dirty-production-accountable

WASHINGTON – U.S. Senators Chris Coons (D-Del.)and Kevin Cramer (R-N.D.) today introduced the bipartisan Providing Reliable, Objective, Verifiable Emissions Intensity and Transparency (PROVE IT) Act that would direct the Department of Energy to conduct a comprehensive study comparing the emissions intensity of certain goods produced in the United States to the emissions of those same goods produced in the other countries. U.S. Senators Angus King (I-Maine), Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska), Martin Heinrich (D-N.M.), Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.), Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.), Bill Cassidy (R-La.), and John Hickenlooper (D-Colo.) are also co-sponsors. “The bipartisan PROVE IT Act will provide reliable data that’s needed to quantify the climate benefits of the United States’ investments in cleaner, more efficient manufacturing practices and to hold nations like China accountable for their emissions-heavy production of goods like steel,” said Senator Coons. “It will level the playing field and ensure our workers and producers are not unjustly penalized for their high environmental standards. Demonstrating our comparative advantage in emissions intensity, working with our allies and partners on data sharing, and building on that with future legislation will be a win for the climate, a win for American workers and manufacturers, and a win for global cooperation.” “The United States lives up to the highest environmental standards in the world, and the PROVE IT Act is an opportunity to bolster our advantage by backing it up with verifiable data,” said Senator Cramer. “Americans know and appreciate the stewardship that goes into the energy we produce and the goods we manufacture. Quantifying global data will prove our emissions-intensive goods are cleaner here at home while highlighting the countries who monetize their lax or nonexistent standards.” “Climate change is one of the most pressing, existential threats facing our country. As we race against time to find and implement solutions, we must be guided by the facts from a global perspective – and that means accounting for the carbon footprint of nations around the world,” said Senator King. “The PROVE IT Act is a bipartisan, commonsense effort to quantify emissions and then develop strategies to support the United States’ continued environmental leadership in manufacturing. America has taken historic steps to address climate change with clean energy investments, but we aren’t operating in a vacuum and there is still more work to be done. Along with much needed permitting reform, this bill would be a significant boost in our mission to find a clean, sustainable energy path forward that protects the planet for generations to come.” “I’m all-in on improving the infrastructure our communities rely on. At the same time, we need to make sure we don’t solve our infrastructure challenges at the expense of our climate,” said Senator Heinrich. “This bipartisan legislation will give us the data we need to effectively reduce greenhouse gas emissions from industrial products internationally and at home.” “This legislation will help give us an apples-to-apples comparison of manufacturing practices among industrialized nations,” said Senator Graham. “It will also provide important data to show the true costs of China dumping dirty products into our economy in an effort to undercut American manufacturers.” “As the European Union forges ahead with a strong carbon border adjustment, Congress should help support analysis of how competitive American manufacturers are in the global marketplace when the costs of carbon pollution are taken into account,” said Senator Whitehouse. “This bipartisan step should help private groups quantify the emissions intensity of goods produced here in America, and help us construct a carbon border adjustment of our own.” “Goods produced in the U.S. are the cleanest in the world,” said Senator Cassidy, M.D. “This study will help us better understand that advantage as we explore policies that reward cleaner U.S. production at the expense of countries that exploit the environment.” American manufacturers abide by some of the cleanest production standards in the world, and U.S. production is widely regarded as cleaner and more responsible than our competitors. The PROVE IT Act would obtain high-quality data to back up this claim up by determining the emissions intensity of domestically produced goods like steel, cement, glass, and aluminum, compared to those around the globe.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Uniqueness Extension

The legislation is on the agenda and it has bipartisan momentum toward passage.

Emma Dumain June 8 2023 06:33 AM EDT Bipartisan bill would lay groundwork for U.S. carbon tariffs https://www.eenews.net/articles/bipartisan-bill-would-lay-groundwork-for-u-s-carbon-tariffs/

Senators from both parties have signed on to legislation that would calculate the emissions intensity of industrial materials produced in the United States. It’s a necessary step, advocates say, toward a carbon border adjustment mechanism, or CBAM, that would slap tariffs on carbon-intensive imports. “We need our own math,” said George David Banks, a conservative climate adviser and former climate official in the Trump administration. “The Europeans are moving forward with their own CBAM … and [they] will come up with our own math for us.” But the effort in the Sena te also underscores the challenges lawmakers face in creating a climate trade policy to harmonize with the European Union: Of the myriad CBAM frameworks currently under development on Capitol Hill on both sides of the aisle, a bill that would just mandate a study is so far the only measure that has been able to attract bipartisan consensus. “It’s easier to take a second step once you’ve taken a first step,” said Sen. Kevin Cramer (R-N.D.). “It can create a little momentum, but at the very least it creates a baseline from which to work, and it gets people thinking about it in a different context than, ‘Oh, my God, it’s a carbon tax.’” Cramer, with Sen. Chris Coons (D-Del.), on Wednesday introduced the “.” The bill would require the Department of Energy to study and determine the emissions intensity of nearly two dozen products made in the United States and by G-7 countries, free-trade agreement partners, foreign countries of concern and “countries that hold a substantial global market share for a covered product.” The list of “covered products” would include aluminum, iron, steel, plastic, crude oil, lithium-ion batteries, solar panels and wind turbines. The Energy Department would have two years to compile a report on its findings, in consultation with EPA, the U.S. Trade Representative and the Commerce and State departments. An update of the data would have to be published every five years. “Studying emissions intensity is not easy; it will take some time, it is complex, and, in particular, figuring out a fair process for imposing tariffs on countries that don’t have any transparency around their emissions is also going to be a complex part of any border carbon adjustment mechanism,” Coons said Wednesday. “So given there’s a bipartisan group that was interested in moving forward on this, I thought it was important that we introduce this piece and lay the foundation for the rest of the conversation.” Coons more comprehensive CBAM proposals in the past, while Cramer confirmed this week he is continuing to work on crafting a “trade deal” that could be reconciled with what the European countries are already doing. Joining Coons and Cramer as original co-sponsors of the bill are Sens. Angus King (I-Maine), Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska), Martin Heinrich (D-N.M.), Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.), John Hickenlooper (D-Colo.)., Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.) and Bill Cassidy (R-La.). Whitehouse is another longtime sponsor of CBAM legislation, proposing bills in previous Congress sessions that would have imposed a domestic price on carbon — something that might be necessary for ensuring a CBAM’s enforceability by the World Trade Organization but has long been politically divisive and not currently a part of the conversation in Congress. Cassidy told E&E News on Wednesday that he was looking at “early July” for introduction of what is expected to be the first comprehensive, Republican-led CBAM bill, which he will call the “Foreign Pollution Act.”

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC

Global warming causes every impact including extinction

Michael T. Klare, 1-13-2020, [Michael T. Klare, The Nation’s defense correspondent, is professor emeritus of peace and world-security studies at Hampshire College and senior visiting fellow at the Arms Control Association in Washington, DC. His newest book, All Hell Breaking Loose: The Pentagon’s Perspective on Climate Change, will be published this fall.], "How Rising Temperatures Increase the Likelihood of Nuclear War," Nation, , Xoxo 3/20/2021

President Donald Trump may not accept the scientific reality of climate change, but the nation’s senior military leaders recognize that climate disruption is already underway, and they are planning extraordinary measures to prevent it from spiraling into nuclear war. One particularly worrisome scenario is if extreme drought and abnormal monsoon rains devastate agriculture and unleash social chaos in Pakistan, potentially creating an opening for radical Islamists aligned with elements of the armed forces to seize some of the country’s 150 or so nuclear weapons. To avert such a potentially cataclysmic development, the US Joint Special Operations Command has conducted exercises for infiltrating Pakistan and locating the country’s nuclear munitions. Most of the necessary equipment for such raids is already in position at US bases in the region, according to a 2011 report from the nonprofit Nuclear Threat Initiative. “It’s safe to assume that planning for the worst-case scenario regarding Pakistan’s nukes has already taken place inside the US government,” said Roger Cressey, a former deputy director for counterterrorism in Bill Clinton’s and George W. Bush’s administrations in 2011. Such an attack by the United States would be an act of war and would entail enormous risks of escalation, especially since the Pakistani military—the country’s most powerful institution—views the nation’s nuclear arsenal as its most prized possession and would fiercely resist any US attempt to disable it. “These are assets which are the pride of Pakistan, assets which are…guarded by a corps of 18,000 soldiers,” former Pakistani president Pervez Musharraf told NBC News in 2011. The Pakistani military “is not an army which doesn’t know how to fight. This is an army that has fought three wars. Please understand that.” A potential US military incursion in nuclear-armed Pakistan is just one example of a crucial but little-​discussed aspect of international politics in the early 21st century: how the acceleration of climate change and nuclear war planning may make those threats to human survival harder to defuse. At present, the intersections between climate change and nuclear war might not seem obvious. But powerful forces are pushing both threats toward their most destructive outcomes. In the case of climate change, the unbridled emission of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases is raising global temperatures to unmistakably dangerous levels. Despite growing worldwide reliance on wind and solar power for energy generation, the global demand for oil and natural gas continues to rise, and carbon emissions are projected to remain on an upward trajectory for the foreseeable future. It is highly unlikely, then, that the increase in average global temperature can be limited to 1.5 degrees Celsius, the aspirational goal adopted by the world’s governments under the Paris Agreement in 2015, or even to 2°C, the actual goal. After that threshold is crossed, scientists agree, it will prove almost impossible to avert catastrophic outcomes, such as the collapse of the Greenland and Antarctic ice sheets and a resulting sea level rise of 6 feet or more. Climbing world temperatures and rising sea levels will diminish the supply of food and water in many resource-deprived areas, increasing the risk of widespread starvation, social unrest, and human flight. Global corn production, for example, is projected to fall by as much as 14 percent in a 2°C warmer world, according to research cited in a 2018 special report by the UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). Food scarcity and crop failures risk pushing hundreds of millions of people into overcrowded cities, where the likelihood of pandemics, ethnic strife, and severe storm damage is bound to increase. All of this will impose an immense burden on human institutions. Some states may collapse or break up into a collection of warring chiefdoms—all fighting over sources of water and other vital resources. A similar momentum is now evident in the emerging nuclear arms race, with all three major powers—China, Russia, and the United States—rushing to deploy a host of new munitions. This dangerous process commenced a decade ago, when Russian and Chinese leaders sought improvements to their nuclear arsenals and President Barack Obama, in order to secure Senate approval of the New Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty of 2010, agreed to initial funding for the modernization of all three legs of America’s strategic triad, which encompasses submarines, intercontinental ballistic missiles, and bombers. (New START, which mandated significant reductions in US and Russian arsenals, will expire in February 2021 unless renewed by the two countries.) Although Obama initiated the modernization of the nuclear triad, the Trump administration has sought funds to proceed with their full-scale production, at an estimated initial installment of $500 billion over 10 years. Even during the initial modernization program of the Obama era, Russian and Chinese leaders were sufficiently alarmed to hasten their own nuclear acquisitions. Both countries were already in the process of modernizing their stockpiles—Russia to replace Cold War–era systems that had become unreliable, China to provide its relatively small arsenal with enhanced capabilities. Trump’s decision to acquire a whole new suite of ICBMs, nuclear-armed submarines, and bombers has added momentum to these efforts. And with all three major powers upgrading their arsenals, the other nuclear-weapon states—led by India, Pakistan, and North Korea—have been expanding their stockpiles as well. Moreover, with Trump’s recent decision to abandon the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces (INF) Treaty, all major powers are developing missile delivery systems for a regional nuclear war such as might erupt in Europe, South Asia, or the western Pacific. Runaway warming: Expanses of ice are melting at unprecedented rates, with potentially grim geopolitical repercussions. (David Silverman / Getty Images) All things being equal, rising temperatures will increase the likelihood of nuclear war, largely because climate change will heighten the risk of social stress, the decay of nation-states, and armed violence in general, as I argue in my new book, All Hell Breaking Loose. As food and water supplies dwindle and governments come under ever-increasing pressure to meet the vital needs of their populations, disputes over critical resources are likely to become more heated and violent, whether the parties involved have nuclear arms or not. But this danger is compounded by the possibility that several nuclear-armed powers—notably India, Pakistan, and China—will break apart as a result of climate change and accompanying battles over disputed supplies of water. Together, these three countries are projected by the UN Population Division to number approximately 3.4 billion people in 2050, or 34 percent of the world’s population. Yet they possess a much smaller share of the world’s freshwater supplies, and climate change is destined to reduce what they have even further. Warmer temperatures are also expected to diminish crop yields in these countries, adding to the desperation of farmers and very likely resulting in widespread ethnic strife and population displacement. Under these circumstances, climate-related internal turmoil would increase the risk of nuclear war in two ways: by enabling the capture of nuclear arms by rogue elements of the military and their possible use against perceived enemies and by inciting wars between these states over vital supplies of water and other critical resources. The risk to Pakistan from climate change is thought to be particularly acute. A large part of the population is still engaged in agriculture, and much of the best land—along with access to water—is controlled by wealthy landowners (who also dominate national politics). Water scarcity and mismanagement is a perennial challenge, and climate change is bound to make the problem worse. Climate and Social Stress: Implications for Security Analysis, a 2013 report by the National Research Council for the US intelligence community, highlights the danger of chaos and conflict in that country as global warming advances. Pakistan, the report notes, is expected to suffer from inadequate water supplies during the dry season and severe flooding during the monsoon—outcomes that will devastate its agriculture and amplify the poverty and unrest already afflicting much of the country. “The Pakistan case,” the report reads, “illustrates how a highly stressed environmental system on which a tense society depends can be a source of political instability and how that source can intensify when climate events put increased stress on the system.” Thus, as global temperatures rise and agriculture declines, Pakistan could shatter along ethnic, class, and religious lines, precisely the scenario that might trigger the sort of intervention anticipated by the US Joint Special Operations Command. Assuming that Pakistan remains intact, another great danger arising from increasing world temperatures is a conflict between it and India or between China and India over access to shared river systems. Whatever their differences, Pakistan and western India are forced by geography to share a single river system, the Indus, for much of their water requirements. Likewise, western China and eastern India also share a river, the Brahmaputra, for their vital water needs. The Indus and the Brahmaputra obtain much of their flow from periods of heavy precipitation; they also depend on meltwater from Himalayan glaciers, and these are at risk of melting because of rising temperatures. According to the IPCC, the Himalayan glaciers could lose as much as 29 percent of their total mass by 2035 and 78 percent by 2100. This would produce periodic flooding as the ice melts but would eventually result in long periods of negligible flow, with calamitous consequences for downstream agriculture. The widespread starvation and chaos that could result would prove daunting to all the governments involved and make any water-related disputes between them a potential flash point for escalation. SUPPORT PROGRESSIVE JOURNALISM If you like this article, please give today to help fund The Nation’s work. As in Pakistan, water supply has always played a pivotal role in the social and economic life of China and India, with both countries highly dependent on a few major river systems for civic and agricultural purposes. Excessive rainfall can lead to catastrophic flooding, and prolonged drought has often led to widespread famine and mass starvation. In such a setting, water management has always been a prime responsibility of government—and a failure to fulfill this function effectively has often resulted in civil unrest. Climate change is bound to increase this danger by causing prolonged water shortages interspersed with severe flooding. This has prompted leaders of both countries to build ever more dams on all key rivers. India, as the upstream power on several tributaries of the Indus, and China, as the upstream power on the Brahmaputra, have considered damming these rivers and diverting their waters for exclusive national use, thereby diminishing the flow to downstream users. Three of the Indus’s principal tributaries, the Jhelum, Chenab, and Ravi rivers, flow through Indian-controlled Kashmir (now in total lockdown, with government forces suppressing all public functions). It’s possible that India seeks full control of Kashmir in order to dam the tributaries there and divert their waters from Pakistan—a move that could easily trigger a war if it occurs at a time of severe food and water stress and one that would very likely invite the use of nuclear weapons, given Pakistan’s attitude toward them. The situation regarding the Brahmaputra could prove equally precarious. China has already installed one dam on the river, the Zangmu Dam in Tibet, and has announced plans for several more. Some Chinese hydrologists have proposed the construction of canals linking the Brahmaputra to more northerly rivers in China, allowing the diversion of its waters to drought-stricken areas of the heavily populated northeast. These plans have yet to come to fruition, but as global warming increases water scarcity across northern China, Beijing might proceed with the idea. “If China was determined to move forward with such a scheme,” the US National Intelligence Council warned in 2009, “it could become a major element in pushing China and India towards an adversarial rather than simply a competitive relationship.” Severe water scarcity in northern China could prompt yet another move with nuclear implications: an attempted annexation by China of largely uninhabited but water-rich areas of Russian Siberia. Thousands of Chinese farmers and merchants have already taken up residence in eastern Siberia, and some commentators have spoken of a time when climate change prompts a formal Chinese takeover of those areas—which would almost certainly prompt fierce Russian resistance and the possible use of nuclear weapons. In the Arctic, global warming is producing a wholly different sort of peril: geopolitical competition and conflict made possible by the melting of the polar ice cap. Before long, the Arctic ice cap is expected to disappear in summertime and to shrink noticeably in the winter, making the region more attractive for resource extraction. According to the US Geological Survey, an estimated 30 percent of the world’s remaining undiscovered natural gas is above the Arctic Circle; vast reserves of iron ore, uranium, and rare earth minerals are also thought to be buried there. These resources, along with the appeal of faster commercial shipping routes linking Europe and Asia, have induced all the major powers, including China, to establish or expand operations in the region. Russia has rehabilitated numerous Arctic bases abandoned after the Cold War and built others; the United States has done likewise, modernizing its radar installation at Thule in Greenland, reoccupying an airfield at Keflavík in Iceland, and establishing bases in northern Norway. Increased economic and military competition in the Arctic has significant nuclear implications, as numerous weapons are deployed there and geography lends it a key role in many nuclear scenarios. Most of Russia’s missile-carrying submarines are based near Murmansk, on the Barents Sea (an offshoot of the Arctic Ocean), and many of its nuclear-armed bombers are also at bases in the region to take advantage of the short polar route to North America. As a counterweight, the Pentagon has deployed additional subs and antisubmarine aircraft near the Barents Sea and interceptor aircraft in Alaska, followed by further measures by Moscow. “I do not want to stoke any fears here,” Russian President Vladimir Putin declared in June 2017, “but experts are aware that US nuclear submarines remain on duty in northern Norway…. We must protect [Russia’s] shore accordingly.” Call to disarm: Despite long-standing public pleas to abolish nuclear weapons, the Pentagon continues to prioritize defense over decarbonization. (Kyodo via AP Images) On the other side of the equation, an intensifying arms race will block progress against climate change by siphoning resources needed for a global energy transition and by poisoning the relations among the great powers, impeding joint efforts to slow the warming. With the signing of the Paris Agreement, it appeared that the great powers might unite in a global effort to slash greenhouse gas emissions quickly enough to avoid catastrophe, but those hopes have since receded. At the time, Obama emphasized that limiting global warming would require nations to work together in an environment of trust and peaceful cooperation. Instead of leading the global transition to a postcarbon energy system, however, the major powers are spending massively to enhance their military capabilities and engaging in conflict-provoking behaviors. Since fiscal year 2016, the annual budget of the US Department of Defense has risen from $580 billion to $738 billion in fiscal year 2020. When the budget increases for each fiscal year since 2016 are combined, the United States will have spent an additional $380 billion on military programs by the end of this fiscal year—more than enough to jump-start the transition to a carbon-​free economy. If the Pentagon budget rises as planned to $747 billion in fiscal year 2024, a total of $989 billion in additional spending will have been devoted to military operations and procurement over this period, leaving precious little money for a Green New Deal or any other scheme for systemic decarbonization. SUPPORT OUR WORK WITH A DIGITAL SUBSCRIPTION. Get unlimited access: $9.50 for six months. Meanwhile, policy-makers in Washington, Beijing, and Moscow increasingly regard one another as implacable and dangerous adversaries. “As China and Russia seek to expand their global influence,” then–Director of National Intelligence Dan Coats informed Congress in a January 2019 report, “they are eroding once well-established security norms and increasing the risk of regional conflicts.” Chinese and Russian officials have been making similar statements about the United States. Secondary powers like India, Pakistan, and Turkey are also assuming increasingly militaristic postures, facilitating the potential spread of nuclear weapons and exacerbating regional tensions. In this environment, it is almost impossible to imagine future climate negotiations at which the great powers agree on concrete measures for a rapid transition to a clean energy economy. In a world constantly poised for nuclear war while facing widespread state decay from climate disruption, these twin threats would intermingle and intensify each other. Climate-​related resource stresses and disputes would increase the level of global discord and the risk of nuclear escalation; the nuclear arms race would poison relations between states and make a global energy transition impossible. RELATED ARTICLE The Nation WANT TO STOP CLIMATE CHANGE? START WITH THE US MILITARY William Astore But such an outcome is not inevitable. Mass movements have emerged to close coal plants, halt fracking, block the construction of fossil fuel infrastructure, and divest from fossil fuel companies. Swedish climate activist Greta Thunberg, with her School Strike 4 Climate campaign, has inspired millions of young people around the world to engage in climate activism. On the nuclear side, groups like Global Zero and Back From the Brink are campaigning for a global no-first-use policy by the nuclear-armed states; in Congress, progressive Democrats fought to deny funds for the procurement of new missiles that would have violated the terms of the INF Treaty.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC

The post debt ceiling boost of Republican unity and Biden’s PC will allow passage of the Prove It Act to implement a carbon border tax – a key step toward reducing global warming.

June 7, 2023 at 6:00 a.m. EDT A bipartisan plan to punish global climate laggards: Tax them New legislation in Congress would lay the groundwork for tariffs on imports from countries with looser environmental rules https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/2023/06/07/carbon-border-tax/

In a rare example of a bipartisan climate policy, momentum is growing on Capitol Hill for a plan to tax imports from China and other countries with looser environmental standards. Sens. Christopher A. Coons (D-Del.) and Kevin Cramer (R-N.D.) on Wednesday will introduce a bill that would lay the groundwork for America’s first carbon border tax, according to shared with The Washington Post before its broader release. The senators’ goal is to impose fees on iron, steel and other imports from countries that are not significantly reducing greenhouse gas emissions. The bipartisan bill, dubbed the Prove It Act, would take a crucial first step toward this goal. It would require the Energy Department to study the emissions intensity of certain products — including aluminum, cement, crude oil, fertilizer, iron, steel and plastic — that are produced in the United States and in certain countries. “Using trade to advance American manufacturing — and to disadvantage dirty or high-emissions products — is ultimately the only way we’re going to put effective pressure on China, Russia and India to dramatically reduce their emissions,” Coons said in an interview on Tuesday. Cramer said Republicans are increasingly interested in a carbon border tax as a way to counter China and protect U.S. businesses. “China’s sort of an easy target,” Cramer said. “They are the ones producing cheap stuff. But there are other players besides China that are dirty producers taking advantage of our system.” Co-sponsors of the bill include two other Republicans — Sens. Lindsey O. Graham (S.C.) and Lisa Murkowski (Alaska) — as well as Sens. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.), Martin Heinrich (D-N.M.), John Hickenlooper (D-Colo.) and Angus King (I-Maine). The measure comes after the European Union in April on carbon-intensive imports. The decision will require importers to in 2026, although they will have to start accounting for the carbon emissions associated with their products in October. The bill also comes after Democrats last year enacted the most ambitious climate bill in U.S. history. The devoted billions of dollars to curbing harmful emissions and . No Republicans voted for the climate law, with Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) saying it amounted to “a war on American fossil fuel.” But conservatives have increasingly embraced the idea of taxing imports from foreign adversaries — an idea that meshes with former president Donald Trump’s that wielded tariffs as weapons.

2023 SDI Counterplan
MSDI States CP › Aff Answers › Offense---Puerto Rico Disad

Turns the CP – systematically debilitating the economies of the poorest parts of the U.S. exacerbates structural violence and inequality.

Associated Press, 22 [3-15-2022, Associated Press, NBC News, Puerto Rico formally exits bankruptcy following largest public debt restructuring, 7-4-2023, https://www.nbcnews.com/news/latino/puerto-rico-formally-exits-bankruptcy-largest-public-debt-restructurin-rcna20054] //AshAN

SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico — Puerto Rico’s government formally exited bankruptcy Tuesday, completing the largest public debt restructuring in U.S. history after announcing nearly seven years ago that it was unable to pay its more than $70 billion debt. The exit means that the U.S. territory’s government will resume payments to bondholders for the first time in several years and will settle some $1 billion worth of claims filed by residents and local businesses. “This is a significant success,” said Natalie Jaresko, executive director of the federal control board that oversees Puerto Rico’s finances and its debt restructuring process. “Remaining in bankruptcy has been a drag on the economy in multiple ways.” The bankruptcy [it] led to widely criticized austerity measures on an island that paid some $1 billion in fees to consultants and lawyers and in other expenses during the process. The exit was a priority for the board and Jaresko, who previously announced . A replacement has not been named yet. The board is expected to remain in place until Puerto Rico has four consecutive balanced budgets, a feat that has yet to be achieved. The was approved by a federal judge in January. It reduces claims against Puerto Rico’s government from $33 billion to just over $7.4 billion, with 7 cents of every taxpayer dollar going to debt service, compared with 25 cents previously. “This is a transcendental moment,” said Gov. Pedro Pierluisi. “The plan is not perfect ... but it has a lot of good things.” The with Pierluisi and previous administrations, particularly on a proposal to reduce certain monthly pension benefits that was ultimately scrapped. The plan also deposits $1.5 billion into public pension systems and creates a pension reserve trust that will be funded with more than $10 billion in upcoming years. “For decades, past governments have neglected to put aside enough money,” Jaresko said.

2023 SDI Counterplan
MSDI States CP › Aff Answers › Offense---Puerto Rico Disad

Puerto Rico has a poverty rate of 44%

Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, 22 [3-14-2022, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, Tax Credit Expansions Expected to Significantly Reduce Poverty in Puerto Rico, 7-4-2023, https://www.cbpp.org/blog/tax-credit-expansions-expected-to-significantly-reduce-poverty-in-puerto-rico] //AshAN

The American Rescue Plan’s expansions of the Child Tax Credit and Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) are expected to significantly reduce poverty in Puerto Rico, according to two studies published by organizations based in Puerto Rico. The two credits combined could provide more than $2 billion to Puerto Rico families in 2022 as they file their 2021 taxes. The expansions are critically important for Puerto Rico, which has among the highest poverty rates in the country: 44 percent for its general population and an even higher 57 percent for children. Moreover, the measures are welcome relief , an ongoing bankruptcy process, devastating natural disasters, and the pandemic. Last March’s Rescue Plan a long-standing flaw that limited the Child Tax Credit to families with three or more children in Puerto Rico. Now, for the first time in nearly 20 years, families with one or two children can claim the credit — a move that makes roughly 89 percent of, or 304,000, families with children in the territory newly eligible. That’s according to a by the Youth Development Institute (YDI), a public policy institute focusing on child poverty in Puerto Rico, which also found that a full 97 percent of families in the territory are now eligible for the credit. Puerto Rico is also benefiting from the temporary expansion of the Child Tax Credit that the Rescue Plan made available across the country. Among other improvements to the credit in 2021, that law boosted the maximum credit amounts from $2,000 per child to $3,600 for children under age 6 and to $3,000 for older children, and made the full credit available to families with low or no earnings in a year (often called making the credit “fully refundable”). The combination of the local, permanent expansion of Child Tax Credit eligibility with national, temporary expansion of the credit is expected to boost the median income of Puerto Rico families living under the poverty threshold by 53 percent this year, as they file their 2021 taxes, the YDI study finds. To expand Puerto Rico’s local EITC program, meanwhile, the Rescue Plan permanently extended to the territory an annual federal supplement of $600 million (that will be adjusted for inflation). This represents the first-ever federal EITC dollars for Puerto Rico since the federal credit’s creation nearly half a century ago, and allows the territory to roughly quadruple its EITC, making it more comparable in size to the federal credit. Last August Puerto Rico took advantage of the federal supplement by expanding its local EITC, significantly boosting benefits and expanding eligibility. The maximum credit now ranges from $1,500 for workers with no children to $6,500 for workers with three or more children, up from previous amounts of $300 and $2,000, respectively. Moreover, workers aged 19 and up are now eligible (compared to those 27 and up before), as are self-employed workers (who previously were only eligible at the discretion of Puerto Rico’s Treasury secretary). And both the minimum and maximum income levels at which people qualify have also been significantly expanded. The EITC expansions are expected to benefit an additional 211,500 households in Puerto Rico, according to a by Espacios Abiertos (EA), a public policy institute focusing on government transparency and accountability. The new EITC would now reach as many as 466,000 households in Puerto Rico, nearly double the 255,000 households previously eligible. Some 55,000 newly eligible households would be lifted above the poverty threshold. The studies don’t examine the combined effect of the Child Tax Credit and EITC on poverty in Puerto Rico, though illustrative examples show significant impacts. This year, for instance, a single mother who is making the federal minimum wage (roughly $15,000 annually) and has a 5-year-old daughter would be able to claim a Child Tax Credit of $3,600 and an EITC of $3,500. That would boost her annual income by $7,100, or 47 percent, and bring it above the poverty threshold of about $18,700. It’s worth noting that while the fix for the Child Tax Credit’s family-size exclusion is permanent, the national expansion of the credit is only temporary. Congress should therefore to make full refundability of the credit permanent as well as additional improvements in the credit. If they don’t, the credit’s anti-poverty effects in Puerto Rico (and elsewhere) will surely decline. It’s also important to note that families in Puerto Rico claiming the Child Tax Credit must do so directly with the IRS, whereas they can claim the EITC through Puerto Rico’s Treasury Department. Given the historical absence of these credits in Puerto Rico and the novelty of the expansions, uptake is expected to build gradually over time. Intensive outreach efforts, including from EA and YDI, will help as many families as possible take advantage of these credits.

2023 SDI Counterplan
MSDI States CP › Aff Answers › Offense---Puerto Rico Disad

Puerto Rico’s total annual budget is $12.4 billion – Puerto Rico has a population of 3.2 million and a poverty rate of 44%, meaning the counterplan gives 12,000 dollars to 1.4 million citizens. That rounds out to about 17.2 billion dollars.

DÁNica Coto, 22 [7-1-2022, DÁNica Coto, AP News, Puerto Rico board approves budget as legislators quibble, 7-4-2023, https://apnews.com/article/caribbean-government-spending-puerto-rico-pedro-pierluisi-687a76107f7556de763afcf558c01648] //AshAN

SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico (AP) — The federal control board that oversees the finances of Puerto Rico’s government approved a $12.4 billion general fund budget Thursday for the U.S. territory after legislators failed to approve one amid intense bickering. The board’s version of the budget was rejected last month by Gov. Pedro Pierluisi because it reduced government spending by $100 million. He said at the time that legislators would submit their own version, but the presidents of the island’s Senate and House of Representatives clashed and failed to approve anything before the July 1 deadline. “It’s unfortunate that the legislative process tied to the central government’s budget was very controversial and took too long,” Pierluisi said in a statement. He said lawmakers wasted an opportunity to include things that would be beneficial for Puerto Ricans, noting that while the board included some public policies he had insisted on, “certainly other important ones are missing.” The island’s House of Representatives was scheduled to meet Thursday evening to try and approve another version of the budget, but the board already certified its version. The overall $28 billion budget included the $12.4 billion general fund for day to day expenses as well as federal funding and money from a fund for specific uses. The overall budget includes $5.5 billion for public health, $4.6 billion for education and $1.3 billion “to protect future government pensions from economic uncertainty,” as well as $3.1 billion for families and children, $2.6 billion for pension payments and $1.1 billion for debt related obligations. The budget comes as Puerto Rico’s government emerges from the biggest U.S. municipal bankruptcy in history after declaring in 2015 that it could not pay its more than $70 billion public debt, which accumulated through decades of mismanagement, corruption and excessive borrowing. It also had more than $50 billion in public pension liabilities. Puerto Rico’s government filed for bankruptcy in 2017, a year after Congress created the financial oversight and management board for the territory. Board chairman David Skeel said the certified budget sets aside more than $700 million in capital expenditures, including more than $170 million for housing and more than $150 million in public works to help revitalize the island’s economy. “After years of deficits that resulted in inadequate funding for critical services, Puerto Rico is now able to provide significant investments to improve the quality of life for Puerto Rico residents and businesses,” he said. The island is still trying to recover from deadly hurricanes and earthquakes in recent years as well as a lengthy economic crisis that deepened amid the pandemic.

2023 SDI Counterplan
MSDI States CP › Aff Answers › 2AC – Links to NB

Links to the net benefit - Voters can’t distinguish who does the plan—they’ll put it on the states.

Haney 2013, Patrick Haney, “Coercion by the Numbers: Conditional Spending Doctrine and the Future of Federal Education Spending,” Case Western Reserve Law Review, Vol. 64, Is. 2,

First, the confluence of increased federal control through conditional spending and the tradition of local and state control 196 complicates the electorate’s task of determining whom to hold responsible. Voters intuitively connect education policy to local and state decision makers. Even voters that acknowledge the federal government’s increased role in education must undertake the exhausting task of tracing federal funding to know who is responsible for what. As a result, few voters have a firm grasp of the division of policy authority between federal, state, and local authorities. Adding to the confusion, substantial federal involvement in education policy adds not a second but a third layer into the equation. To properly assess whom to hold accountable in education and to what degree, a voter must understand the fluid involvement of school administrators, local school board members, state school board members, state legislators, governors, members of Congress, the U.S. Department of Education, and the President.197 The involvement of more decision makers additionally enables all of them to maintain plausible deniability. In other words, federal involvement creates more outlets for deflecting blame. Accordingly, both policy makers and policy implementers gain political insulation.198 And as the electorate’s ability to administer accountability diminishes, meaningful democratic participation in education dwindles.

2023 SDI Counterplan
MSDI States CP › Aff Answers › Perm – Do the CP

Should requires immediacy.

SUMMERS, Justice, 11-8-1994, "Kelsey v. Dollarsaver Food Warehouse of Durant," Oklahoma State Law Network, , Xoxo 9/20/2020

13 "Should" not only is used as a "present indicative" synonymous with ought but also is the past tense of "shall" with various shades of meaning not always easy to analyze. See 57 C.J. Shall § 9, Judgments § 121 (1932). O. JESPERSEN, GROWTH AND STRUCTURE OF THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE (1984); St. Louis & S.F.R. Co. v. Brown, 45 Okl. 143, 144 P. 1075, 1080-81 (1914). For a more detailed explanation, see the Partridge quotation infra note 15. Certain contexts mandate a construction of the term "should" as more than merely indicating preference or desirability. Brown, supra at 1080-81 (jury instructions stating that jurors "should" reduce the amount of damages in proportion to the amount of contributory negligence of the plaintiff was held to imply an obligation and to be more than advisory); Carrigan v. California Horse Racing Board, 60 Wash. App. 79, 802 P.2d 813 (1990) (one of the Rules of Appellate Procedure requiring that a party "should devote a section of the brief to the request for the fee or expenses" was interpreted to mean that a party is under an obligation to include the requested segment); State v. Rack, 318 S.W.2d 211, 215 (Mo. 1958) ("should" would mean the same as "shall" or "must" when used in an instruction to the jury which tells the triers they "should disregard false testimony"). 14 In praesenti means literally "at the present time." BLACK'S LAW DICTIONARY 792 (6th Ed. 1990). In legal parlance the phrase denotes that which in law is presently or immediately effective, as opposed to something that will or would become effective in the future [in futurol]. See Van Wyck v. Knevals, 106 U.S. 360, 365, 1 S.Ct. 336, 337, 27 L.Ed. 201 (1882).

2023 SDI Counterplan
MSDI States CP › Aff Answers › Perm – Do the CP

Perm: do the CP - federal government” includes state governments in a shared division of power – Washington DC is the “central government”

Legal Dictionary 16 [Federal Government. August 7, 2016. https://legaldictionary.net/federal-government/]

A federal government is a system of government that divides the power between a larger central government, and the local and regional governments beneath it. In the United States, the federal government’s powers were established by the Constitution. Perfect examples of federal governments are those that function best in large countries with a broad diversity among its citizens, though where a common culture still exists, which ties everyone together. To explore this concept, consider the following federal government definition. Definition of Federal Government Noun A system of government in which power is divided between a central, larger government, and the local, regional, or state governments beneath it. Origin 1635-1645 Latin foederal – (league)

2023 SDI Counterplan
MSDI States CP › Aff Answers › Perm – Do Both

Federal and state implementation avoids politics and gives better chance for the policy to be successful.

Abbe Gluck 2011 - Associate Professor of Law and Milton Handler Fellow, Columbia Intrastatutory Federalism and Statutory Interpretation: State Implementation of Federal Law in Health Reform and Beyond, Faculty Scholarship Series. Paper 3815, Yale Law Journal

There also might be a more instrumental story to tell, one in which the states are relied upon not for some reason related to the traditional federalism values (as they are to some extent when Congress nationalizes state experiments or looks to state bureaucracies as partners in federal statutory entrenchment) but rather one in which the states are utilized as more direct vehicles of federal regulatory aggrandizement. Specifically, I want to highlight the possibility that Congress might design statutes around state-based implementation for the purpose of gradual field entry into areas traditionally dominated by state law. A federal statute that marks new legislative terrain for the federal government but relies - at least in the beginning - on the states to implement it might be a way for the federal government to "claim the field" as one suitable for federal regulation, but at the same time rely on state expertise and state political cover while the federal government gets up to speed. Statutes like these have political benefits. Most obviously, they allow Congress to leave the initial extent of the federal role vague, a strategy that might make the intrusion more acceptable to legislators who otherwise would resist these moves. To be sure, the fact that the federal government offers states the chance to implement new federal statutes does not diminish the reach of federal legislative authority. But by retaining the states in the lead role for implementation, such statutes might be more politically palatable to those who generally resist federal aggrandizement or prefer "smaller" government or local variation.

Giving states the lead role in implementation also might assuage concerns of legislators who are suspicious of, or politically opposed to, the current executive branch's policy agenda. Particularly in times of divided government, some members of Congress might trust their home-state counterparts more than the administrative appointees of the President to fill in the interstices of new federal programs. Work in the political science realm has, indeed, documented an increase in such delegations toward the states and away from the federal government in times of divided government.'os Others have documented how Southern congressmen pushed early implementation of federal welfare programs through the states to preserve the political economy of the region. o6 Seen in this light, varied state implementation -and in particular, allowing for less aggressive implementation by some states - might, in fact, be a necessary part of the political deal to get some federal statutes passed in the first place. That is, the possibility of state-based dissent that often is described as a pathology in traditional federalism theory may actually be a beneficial safety valve that, on occasion, makes new federal legislation possible. At the same time, however, these state-led statutes are likely to extend the federal influence further into the field over time. One way in which this may happen is simply that the public will get more comfortable with the idea of federal regulation in the field, thereby allowing for uncontroversial expansion later."' Political science and historical accounts of the early years of the welfare provisions of the Social Security Act offer an example of this progression."' But there is also a more direct way in which these kinds of statutes contribute to nationalizing statutory power. As stated above, most statutes of this nature have an "opt out" provision for the states.o 9 If one or more states do opt out of administering the new federal scheme, the federal government usually must step in. These moments are "field-claiming" opportunities for the federal government: the federal government is provided with a smaller-scale, lower-visibility way (running the program in just a handful of states) to build expertise in an area traditionally outside its purview than taking over an entire new area at once. These opportunities may allow the federal government to build a track record in the area while at the same time acclimating the public to federal government regulation in what was once thought to be state domain. Over time, it seems likely that these incremental moves will work a subtle shift in the public understanding of the traditional state-federal boundaries. And while the boundaries being moved are not formal boundaries in a constitutional sense, they surely inform and shape our everyday understandings of the state-federal relationship. These "soft" federalism lines, in fact, may be more important to understanding what "federalism" means today than the Constitution, particularly because formal constitutional law no longer frequently operates to police the boundaries of state and federal 110 power.