Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Impact Framing › Yes War

Reject preventable future nuclear war---it’s more likely and devastating than we are trained to believe and the only survivors will be the agents of destruction

Scarry 19, PhD, Professor of English at Harvard, (Elaine Scarry, 2019, Interview, Representations, 146.1)

RA: At the Buffalo conference on pain, you gave a paper that built on some of the insights of your then most recent book, Thermonuclear Monarchy. 1 In the book, you demonstrate the incompatibility of democracy and nuclear arms at least in part on the grounds that, by the nature of their deployment, nuclear arms make it impossible for the populace to consent to their use. In your talk, you made a different but related claim that focused on the relative silence of the population regarding nuclear arms in the post-Cold War era. You were concerned, in particular, with the difficulties of imagining the consequences of nuclear war. I wonder if you could expand on this second point: why it is so hard to think about nuclear war. ES: The two points are deeply related. The architecture of nuclear arms requires that the population be eliminated from the decision about going to war. It also requires that Congress be eliminated from the decision about going to war—just because the nature of the technology requires a tiny number of people to do the launch. The result of that architecture is that people eventually, over seven decades, have internalized the fact that they’re worthless when it comes to the need to defend the country and to carry out acts of mutual aid toward one another. We now simply abandon the right of self-defense and the right of mutual aid and give unlimited injuring power to the executive branch of government and fall silent. RA: How much responsibility, how much blame, does one give to the population for remaining silent? ES: That has always been a question. Gandhi said, ‘‘You can wake a man who’s asleep, but you can’t wake a man who’s pretending to be asleep.’’ His statement marks a fork in the road. If the population has been anesthetized and is genuinely asleep, then they are morally innocent (even if infantilized and terribly reduced as moral agents). If instead the population is pretending to be asleep, we are morally culpable: the population is complicit with the genocide that’s standing in the wings waiting to happen. During my lecture and in many years of working on disarmament, I stressed the first path and tried to outline why waking up is difficult. In recent months, I’ve moved closer to the position that your question identifies, the responsibility of the population. I feel the force of Martin Luther King’s statement, ‘‘There comes a time when silence is betrayal.’’ I’m almost at the point of believing that there is a wanton refusal to [recognize] see the imminent peril, a refusal to understand not just that we have a responsibility to reverse it, to dismantle it, but that we have the ability to do so, and that if we don’t, it is going to happen. I don’t know if it’s going to happen this year. Or whether it’s going to happen this century. But it’s almost inconceivable that it isn’t going to happen. RA: Why is it that people have such a hard time understanding this? If you allow that people might honestly and ardently be trying to understand, what is it that is getting in the way? ES: Four or five answers come to mind. First, people often lack key pieces of information. If you ask someone in this country which nations have nuclear weapons, they are likely to say Iraq (which has none), Iran (which has none), or North Korea (which has fewer than 60; leading experts say fewer than 20). The United States has 6,500. The United States and Russia together own 93 percent of the world arsenal: the other 7 percent is owned by the other seven nuclear states—in order of numerical possession, France, China, the United Kingdom, Pakistan, India, Israel, and North Korea (see fig. 1). An equally profound misconception held by US citizens is the belief that our nuclear architecture is for ‘‘defense’’ and ‘‘retaliation.’’ In fact we have had a ‘‘presidential first-use’’ policy for the whole nuclear age. The profound obscenity of that arrangement, which has only begun to be glimpsed with the current president, has been an equally grave moral wrong from day one. Second, even when American citizens [denizens] and residents have this information, the outcome is derealized by its being future—that is, the unreality something has by having not yet happened is conflated with the unreality something might have by being merely imaginary. People, it’s true, are uninformed. But once they become informed, even then the flash of insight fades from their eyes after about ten minutes. RA: Why do you think that is? ES: Because they think ‘‘future’’ equals ‘‘unreal.’’ But we need to stop and understand what we mean by ‘‘future.’’ If it takes 10,000 steps to put a nuclear architecture into place, 9,999 steps have already been completed: we know how to split the atom; we know how to provide enriched uranium; we know how to deliver the bomb; we’ve completed not only the theoretical steps but the materialization steps: we’ve made the bombs; we’ve completed the delivery systems—Ohio-class submarines, the land-based ICBMs, and airdelivery B-2s and B-52s. Unlike in China and India, the weapons in the United States are already ‘‘mated’’ to the delivery systems; they are on alert; specific weapons have been assigned to specific cities in the countries of present enemies and, yes, even potential enemies. One step remains: the order to launch. So 9,999 steps are present and accounted for; one remains undone. While the 9,999 steps took vast amounts of time and resources, the last one is designed to be carried out in minutes. The word ‘‘future’’ does not apply to the 9,999 steps, only to the last one. When people decline to address the nuclear peril on the grounds that it is an ‘‘unreal’’ worry because ‘‘following the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki it hasn’t yet happened,’’ they are unknowingly allying themselves with the position that our own Department of State and Department of Defense took in 1995. At that time, seventy-eight countries asked the International Court of Justice to declare the possession, threat of use, and use of nuclear weapons illegal on the basis of the humanitarian and environmental instruments such as the UN Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, the Geneva Protocols, the Declaration of Saint Petersburg, the Vienna Convention for the Protection of the Ozone Layer, the Rio Declaration on Environment and Poverty, and many others. Though the United States worked to invalidate the application of these protocols to our nuclear weapons one at a time, an argument they used over and over was that the firing of the weapons was ‘‘future,’’ hence ‘‘hypothetical,’’ hence ‘‘suppositional’’—this despite the billions of dollars that each year go into polishing and oiling the architecture of earth’s destruction to keep it in a present-tense state of constant readiness. RA: At the conference you also spoke about the problem of ‘‘statistical compassion.’’ ES: Let’s call that the third reason why the population is asleep. American indifference to our own genocidal nuclear architecture comes from the constraints on compassion when large numbers of people [become] stand to be injured. Public health physicians distinguish between narrative compassion (where one or two or three people are at risk) and statistical compassion (where thousands or millions are at risk).2 We’re fairly good at the first, and have many occasions to strengthen our capacity through daily acts of friendship and from reading literature. We’re terrible at the second, and have almost no training in strengthening our feeble abilities in this region. The nuclear peril of course entails the second: recent work on nuclear winter by Alan Robock and his colleagues shows that if even a small fraction of the current world arsenal is fired (one one-hundredth of one percent of the total available blast power), forty-four million people will be casualties on the first afternoon and one billion in the weeks following. The small shrug people make when the subject of nuclear weapons comes up—the little lift and fall of the shoulders—means they have just run a quick check on their interior brain-and-soul equipment and can report: nope, nothing in there in the way of statistical compassion. RA: Narrative compassion and statistical compassion seem to take place in widely separate spheres. How then do you see them coming into conflict with each other? ES: For me, a frightening example occurred in the Bulletin of Atomic Scientists, the wholly admirable body that sets the Doomsday Clock (now at two minutes to midnight) and that works round the clock to educate the people of the United States and the world about the hazards of nuclear weapons. Yet in commemorating the seventieth anniversary of the Nagasaki bombing in August of 2015, they published a historically factual narrative about the pilots of the plane delivering the atom bomb to Nagasaki, how many things went wrong and had to be repaired midflight. The lead-in read, ‘‘A typhoon was coming, the fuel pump failed, they had to switch planes, things were wired incorrectly, they missed their rendezvous, they couldn’t see the primary target, they ran out of gas on the way home, and they had to crash-land.’’ But the worst part was when ‘‘the Fat Man atomic bomb started to arm itself, mid-flight.’’3 The story, narrated in edge-ofyour-seat suspense, is an example of narrative compassion utterly preempting the possibility of statistical compassion: the crew might die, but if they had in fact died over the Pacific, tens of thousands of persons would not have been burned into nonexistence that day. RA: Your emphasis at the conference was on the nature of physical pain itself. ES: Yes, that was my central subject. In terms of our conversation now, we can say that a fourth and fifth reason for indifference arise from the difficulty of comprehending pain, whether it takes place in one person’s body or in the bodies of millions, and whether it occurs in the past, present, or future. (But if I were listing the reasons in the order of importance, these two would be near the top.) Once we exhaust a small handful of adjectives for physical pain, two (and almost only two) metaphors arise: the metaphor of the weapon (one may say it feels as though a knife is sticking in my shoulder blade even if it isn’t); and that of body damage (one may say it feels as though my elbow has snapped in two, even if it hasn’t). The Body in Pain concentrates on problems arising from the first; a later essay (‘‘Among Schoolchildren’’) concentrates on the second.4 Both metaphors, if carefully controlled, can help us understand the felt experience of another person’s pain; but both are highly volatile and can lead us far away from understanding. An example of the benign or genuinely expressive potential is provided by findings in neuroscience that we have mirror neurons that help us recognize another person’s physical pain. When you look at the actual experiments that were done, however, you see that the test subject is asked not to listen to a sufferer’s report of pain but to observe, for example, a pin being stuck into someone’s hand or the administration of a small electric shock. The experiments show not our comprehension of another person’s pain but our recognition of the aversivenes of being subjected to a weapon—often closely related to but by no means identical with physical pain. The very fact that a weapon can be separated from the site of the injury means that the attributes of pain can be lifted away from the sufferer and conferred on the agents inflicting the harm, so now it is not the pain that is world destroying but the inflictor of the pain. There are many examples of this in the case of nuclear weapons. For example, the mushroom cloud is often regarded as ‘‘awesome,’’ some even say ‘‘sublime.’’ But the hibakasha, the survivors in Hiroshima and Nagasaki, say, ‘‘We saw no mushroom cloud.’’ A mushroom cloud is what you see if you’re an observer far away, seated high in the sky in the airplane that dropped the weapon, or standing on the ground scores of miles beyond the radius of the harm. Like any sensible mortal, I admire J. Robert Oppenheimer, but his endlessly quoted statement following the Trinity test, ‘‘I remembered the line from the Hindu scripture ...I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds,’’ allows the scale of the injury to be transferred across the weapon and conferred on the agents, who now perceive themselves as magnificent, thrilling, almighty in their power. Oppenheimer even prefaces the quotation by saying that Vishnu here takes on a multi-armed form ‘‘to impress’’ the prince. The name he chose for the test, ‘‘Trinity,’’ shows this same fabrication of godlikeness. What if instead Oppenheimer had said, ‘‘I remembered the goddess Guanyin whose name means ‘The one who perceives the sounds of the world’ and the sounds I heard were excruciating cries, unbearable shrieks of tens of thousands scalded together in an instant of molten flesh.’’ The first statement is a fiction: Oppenheimer is neither a multi-armed god nor a three-personed god; the second statement (could we hear Guanyin) is accurate; if we could internalize and practice the second statement, we would disarm immediately. The image of the nuclear weapon, which might help make visible the pain and suffering it will bring about, instead captures the gigantic scale of the suffering, only to lift that ‘‘giganticism’’ away from the site of suffering altogether and confer it on the human agents—ordinary men, small in stature and in number, but who now appear gigantic. Insofar as any shred of ‘‘suffering’’ still remains visible, we believe it is the suffering of the now gigantic human agent who is in mighty peril. Thus the nation spends billions of dollars on a presidential fallout shelter while convincing the public that fallout shelters for the population are ridiculous. In Thinking in an Emergency, and again in Thermonuclear Monarchy, I contrast the Swiss shelter system—Swiss law requires that every house have a fallout shelter;5 the law was reaffirmed in a 2003 referendum that had an 80 percent turnout at the polls—with the staggering constructions that have been made in the United States for... the people? no—for the president and those close to him, a shelter inside a mountain, with buildings and a lake that is, according to observers, large enough for waterskiing. One country, Switzerland, believes in what the Swiss call ‘‘equality of survival’’; the other country, the United States, believes that only the agents of nuclear [disaster] holocaust deserve the chance for survival. Much more detail on the multiple presidential fallout shelters is described by Garrett M. Graff in a recent book, Raven Rock: The Story of the U.S. Government’s Secret Plan to Save Itself—While the Rest of Us Die. The nuclear architecture requires that either the weapon be invisible (buried in a submarine or buried in a cornfield, like the 450 ICBMs) or, when it is visible, it must become the path across which the magnificent prowess of the human agent is seen—he’s so thrilling, so important, so vulnerable; here, please, take my tax money, use all of it to protect the man who will launch our nuclear missiles. What should bring us to our knees in sorrow and shame instead brings about a dutiful salute to the thermonuclear monarch. If one thinks fallout shelters for the population are ridiculous (ignoring the fact that the medically sophisticated Swiss have data showing otherwise), then it is informative to contrast the money lavished on our nuclear architecture with ordinary forms of safety structures for the population like bridges, dams, roads, levees. The American Society of Civil Engineers, in their 2017 report on infrastructure, gave our bridges a ‘‘Cþ’’ (56,000 are ‘‘structurally deficient’’), our dams a ‘‘D’’ (2000 have a ‘‘high-hazard potential’’), our levees a ‘‘D’’ ($80 billion is needed for structural repair), and our roads a ‘‘D’’ (one out of every five miles of highway pavement is ‘‘in poor condition’’).6 Might Americans be given a choice on whether they want their taxes spent on infrastructure or—as is currently the case—on nuclear weapons and presidential fallout shelters? Or has ‘‘no taxation without representation’’ disappeared along with all our other basic democratic principles?(112-118) RA: That all follows from the instability of the weapon; what about the second field of representation, body damage? ES: The phenomenon of body damage is like the image of the weapon but works in a much different way—almost the opposite. Whereas the problem of the weapon is its very separability from the body (and the way to make it benign is to retether it to its referent in the body), the problem of body damage is that it overlaps, overrides, and eclipses the personhood of the one underneath the damage. Either one looks away, or, if one looks, one recoils. Visual artists and writers—from Peter Paul Rubens and Andrea Mantegna in the Renaissance to fin de sie`cle artists Ka¨the Kollwitz, Aubrey Beardsley, Edvard Munch, Joris-Karl Huysmans, to twentieth-century Guatemalan writer Miguel Asturias—all solve this problem by finding a way to double the location, so that personhood remains intact in our perceptual field even if the human body is at that moment being obscenely shredded. 118 Representations If you visit the Nagasaki Atomic Bomb Museum, you will probably find yourself, as I did, surrounded by young schoolchildren, who look with courage on the visages of those who were incompletely incinerated in the bombing of that city (see figs. 2, 3, and 4). In the United States, few adults face up to the faces of those harmed there. In February of 2016, the Central Square Library in Cambridge agreed to let me—and Joseph Gerson, an American Friends Service colleague—do a monthlong program on the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki with weekly lectures and an exhibit of books, drawings, and photographs. The morning after we put up the exhibit, we found all the photographs of injuries had been removed. The effort to put on an exhibit about Hiroshima and Nagasaki at the Smithsonian Institution in 1994 led to such controversy that it had to be canceled—with one exception: the Enola Gay (the plane that delivered the bomb) was put on display. Here we circle back to the phenomenon of the weapon being perceptually severed from the site of the pain. It’s in part because of museums like those in Hiroshima and Nagasaki that so many people in the Japanese population are passionately in support of nuclear disarmament. In preparation for a disarmament demonstration in New York, Cambridge and Boston activists (I include myself) worked for months to bring supporters to the march: after endless work, approximately one hundred did so. But one thousand Japanese men and women arrived that morning in New York; they carried a petition signed by six million of their countrymen, who collectively paid for the travel costs of the thousand who came. RA: Can you provide any examples of authors who ‘‘double the location,’’ as you have just described, ‘‘so that personhood remains intact’’ while the ‘‘human body is being ...shredded’’? ES: Miguel A´ngel Asturias’s Men of Maize begins with a heroic Indian in Guatemala, who ordinarily protects his people no matter what; he is able to do so, in part, because he has a level of sensory acuity that approaches genius. He knows the scent of every flower; he can discern the whole recipe of scents present in the forest in any given moment. The European colonizers can commit a slaughter of his people only if they can divert this heroic leader; and the only way to divert him is to subject him to horrible, scalding, obscene pain. Asturias must convey to us the felt experience of pain, the turning of the body inside out, and he chooses to do this through the associated phenomenon of body damage; but in order to do so without eclipsing the personhood of Gaspar Il´om, he decouples the body damage from the hero. The book opens with a dog, which the invaders have used as a test case for their pain-inducing poison laced with glass. The dog, in excruciating pain, zooms hysterically through the village square, covered with open sores, his penis erect, howling in a way that is aversive to everyone who hears and sees. This horrible scene conveys the obscenity of pain, the obscenity of bodily damage. By obscenity, I mean interior substances in the body which come before us without our consent, come before us before we are mentally prepared to comprehend what we are seeing. But the story separates this bodily desecration from the person, for now, having seen the dog, we need only be told that Gaspar Il´om has drunk this glass-laced poison to understand why he abandons his post, submerges himself in the lake, drinks all its waters, and eventually comes out. He has survived. But during the moments when he disappeared below the surface of the water, his people have been slain. RA: I wonder how you think about the role of the visual in that context. Do you think of the visual as akin to a language? ES: In visual art one can see the same phenomenon taking place, as when Ka¨the Kollwitz refuses to let an injured victim be portrayed as what Shelley called ‘‘a monstrous lump of ruin.’’ In her 1900 etching and aquatint The Downtrodden, she pushes the wounds on the body just beyond the body’s edge onto a linen sheet on which the person is lying. These mouthlike, liplike structures of open wounds are there but are not permitted to compromise figure 4. Photographs of survivors of the atomic bomb in the Nagasaki Atomic Bomb Museum. An Interview with Elaine Scarry 121 our recognition of the sufferer’s personhood. Even somebody like Aubrey Beardsley, in one of his posters, puts the wound in a tree rather than on the body of the woman. And yet the woman has attributes that make the viewer see the analogy, just like Marty South and the trees in your account of Hardy’s The Woodlanders [Scarry is referring to Rachel Ablow’s account in Victorian Pain]. Her posture, for example, is exaggeratedly erect and treelike. She wears a high-waisted skirt that is made to be a visual analogy with the tree. But our perception of her personhood remains uninterrupted. RA: One issue you have raised recently is the particular difficulty of thinking about the specific kinds of injuries caused by nuclear war, namely burns. There was a striking moment in your talk when you discussed the protocols used in burn units to help doctors and nurses in looking at burn victims. It seems so intuitively right that caretakers would have difficulty looking at these patients. It seems to suggest something about the limits on the imagination in terms of suffering. I’m wondering what it is about burns that makes it so hard to imagine the suffering they entail. Is it about the skin as the site of humanity? Is it about the face? ES: It is the visage. Without preparation and help, when we see the complete mutilation of the body, especially the face, we mistakenly feel we are seeing the mutilation of personhood. The ‘‘rule of nines’’ is devised to enable rescue workers to look at a gravely burned person and (instead of having their own minds shut down in sorrow and confusion and revulsion) to assess instantly the gravity of the injury, start appropriate treatment, and report the scale of the injury to the hospital awaiting the person’s arrival. Each part of the body is assigned an easy-to-remember number that is a multiple of nine (see fig. 5). Counting forms a key part in many forms of emergency rescue, and this is one instance. The numbers, once totaled, tell the rescuer the next step, such as whether to insert an IV for fluid resuscitation. The need to train the perceptions of those who hope to help those who are burned is also illustrated by a procedure called ‘‘staying.’’ During the years when I was part of a research group on suffering at the Hastings Center for Ethics, I heard a lecture by a physician-nurse who worked in a burn unit. She mentioned that because of the difficulty oflooking at a severely burned person, nurses assigned to burn units may begin to avert their eyes when speaking with a patient, decline to touch the patient, or stand at a greater distance each day, or request a transfer after a few days. To counteract these problems, caretakers can participate in a class on ‘‘staying’’ where they recognize the temptation to withdraw from the patient and practice trying to overcome that withdrawal. While the ‘‘rule of nines’’ and ‘‘staying’’ are brilliant inventions, we should recognize that in nuclear war there will be few rescue workers and nurses. A study in the Netherlands of what would happen if a terrorist brought into Rotterdam a very small 12 kg weapon (the size used in World War II) found that of those who had not immediately evaporated, four thousand persons would require burn beds.7 They noted that in all of the Netherlands there are only a hundred burn beds. A leading hospital in Boston, Mass General, has seven burn beds. The burn beds themselves—what few there are—will disappear in a nuclear strike. On the floor of the UK Parliament, the possession of four Trident submarines has repeatedly been justified by the potential need to bomb Moscow. In response, a Scottish study by John Ainslie looked at the scale of damage that would actually take place if a nuclear missile were launched against the Ministry of Defense building in Moscow: along with the Ministry of Defense, four major hospitals would be destroyed and four others subjected to fire and radiation that would make them inoperable. Thirty-one schools would also be destroyed with at least 700,000 children slain.8 If the missile is larger, so, too, will the disappearance of hospitals be larger. An article by Steven Starr, Lynn Eden, and Theodore A. Postol in the Bulletin of Atomic Scientists shows that if an 800-kiloton weapon were detonated above Manhattan, the center of the blast would be four times the temperature of the sun, and, within ‘‘tens of minutes,’’ a firestorm will cover 90 to 150 square miles. figure 5. Pocket card showing ‘‘Rule of Nines for Adult and Child,’’ Northwest Healthcare Response Network, https:// nwhrn.org/wp-content/ uploads/2018/08/BurnPocket-Card.pdf. An Interview with Elaine Scarry 123 RA: Was the artistic strategy that you just described of doubling the location so as to protect personhood apparent in the real-world examples you were citing, the Nagasaki children, the ‘‘rule of nines,’’ ‘‘staying’’? ES: I think so. It is not accidental that the Nagasaki Atomic Bomb Museum is itself physically beautiful in its architecture, or that as you enter you pass lavish cascades of paper cranes, inspired by the child Sadako Sasaki, like cherry blossoms in spring, or that you see an inscription about Nagasaki’s exceptional generosity to outsiders—its many centuries of open trade with foreign companies, a level of cosmopolitan hospitality not at that time found to the same degree in other regions of Japan; you see engraved inscriptions from Dwight D. Eisenhower and from the ‘‘United States Strategic Bombing Survey, Summary Report (Pacific War), July 1946’’ saying unequivocally that the atom bomb was not needed to end the war. All these elements, and many others, keep the personhood of the city’s inhabitants in view, side-by-side with the excruciating vision of burnt faces. The ‘‘rule of nines’’ lets one reconstruct the body out of a beneficent invention, toylike in its simplicity. In ‘‘staying,’’ the very name of the procedure holds the injury within the frame of sympathetic personhood. RA: Let’s return to Ghandi’s forking path. You’ve sketched the reasons why the US population is innocently sleeping. But what if they’re feigning sleep? ES: I am sometimes floored by the discrepancy between the attention we give to injuries that have happened when we can’t do anything to change them and the attention we give to injuries that haven’t yet happened when by intervention we absolutely can prevent them. I don’t know how to explain this. I have always assumed that those acts of trying to talk about the pain of torture victims in the 1970s in my case, or the pain of people in World War II, the Holocaust, that those acts are meant to act as a warning to the future. What is our motive for thinking about the unchangeable injuries of the past if not to increase our ability to prevent such injuries in the future? Yet almost incomprehensible is the distance between the willingness to think about events from the past we can’t possibly change and the complete comfort with feeling that future massacres need not concern us. Or worse, that one is slightly superior to protesting a wrong: intellectually superior because the moral wrong is an obvious moral wrong, and we only like to address sophisticated, hard to discern moral wrongs. It might be embarrassing to have to stand on a street corner with a sign or attend a public meeting. Imagine, though, if we forgave the complicity with past acts of enslavement or genocide by saying, ‘‘People saw that it was wrong, but they considered it too intellectually obvious, too compromising of their dignity, to have to stand up and protest.’’ Or take the argument that the aspiration to dismantle nuclear weapons is now many decades old, and we must turn to fresh undertakings: imagine that someone tried to defend those who tolerated slavery in 1860 because they had been hearing antislavery sentiment since 1820 and now considered such sentiments ‘‘stale.’’ We would never give a ‘‘pass’’ to anyone in the past who excused their inattention to slavery or the transfer of people to concentration camps on either of those two grounds; yet we believe such arguments release us from addressing weapons whose outcome is instant genocide. There are historical periods in which people were dissuaded from protesting because dissidents were beaten (Charles Sumner on the floor of the Senate) or killed (Dietrich Bonhoeffer in Germany). No such beatings or death threats excuse our own silence today. RA: Staying with this point about the relative ease of imagining pain past as opposed to pain in the future, do you attribute that to sentimentality? It sounds so reprehensible put in those terms. I wonder how you account for it. ES: I think you are right to worry that our attention to the past begins to look like sentimentality. The argument is sometimes made by academics that sympathy is less about compassion or the desire to ameliorate pain than it is a kind of cultural signaling of our moral goodness. To me that thesis seems horrifying: it lets the many who ignore past pain excuse their own inattention on the grounds that the few who do attend to pain are only doing so to announce their own goodness. So I feel a strong aversion to that argument; it works to reduce still further the number of those who show any wish to help. However, if it turns out that we only speak about irremediable injuries from the past while a huge architecture of massacre [is] stands waiting to be used, then one has to ask oneself: why were we looking at injuries in the distant past? Is it just sentimentality? Is it just cultural signaling?9

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Impact Framing › Extinction First

Extinction outweighs

Seth D. Baum & Anthony M. Barrett 18. Global Catastrophic Risk Institute. 2018. “Global Catastrophes: The Most Extreme Risks.” Risk in Extreme Environments: Preparing, Avoiding, Mitigating, and Managing, edited by Vicki Bier, Routledge, pp. 174–184.

2. What Is GCR And Why Is It Important? Taken literally, a global catastrophe can be any event that is in some way catastrophic across the globe. This suggests a rather low threshold for what counts as a global catastrophe. An event causing just one death on each continent (say, from a jet-setting assassin) could rate as a global catastrophe, because surely these deaths would be catastrophic for the deceased and their loved ones. However, in common usage, a global catastrophe would be catastrophic for a significant portion of the globe. Minimum thresholds have variously been set around ten thousand to ten million deaths or $10 billion to $10 trillion in damages (Bostrom and Ćirković 2008), or death of one quarter of the human population (Atkinson 1999; Hempsell 2004). Others have emphasized catastrophes that cause long-term declines in the trajectory of human civilization (Beckstead 2013), that human civilization does not recover from (Maher and Baum 2013), that drastically reduce humanity’s potential for future achievements (Bostrom 2002, using the term “existential risk”), or that result in human extinction (Matheny 2007; Posner 2004). A common theme across all these treatments of GCR is that some catastrophes are vastly more important than others. Carl Sagan was perhaps the first to recognize this, in his commentary on nuclear winter (Sagan 1983). Without nuclear winter, a global nuclear war might kill several hundred million people. This is obviously a major catastrophe, but humanity would presumably carry on. However, with nuclear winter, per Sagan, humanity could go extinct. The loss would be not just an additional four billion or so deaths, but the loss of all future generations. To paraphrase Sagan, the loss would be billions and billions of lives, or even more. Sagan estimated 500 trillion lives, assuming humanity would continue for ten million more years, which he cited as typical for a successful species. Sagan’s 500 trillion number may even be an underestimate. The analysis here takes an adventurous turn, hinging on the evolution of the human species and the long-term fate of the universe. On these long time scales, the descendants of contemporary humans may no longer be recognizably “human”. The issue then is whether the descendants are still worth caring about, whatever they are. If they are, then it begs the question of how many of them there will be. Barring major global catastrophe, Earth will remain habitable for about one billion more years 2 until the Sun gets too warm and large. The rest of the Solar System, Milky Way galaxy, universe, and (if it exists) the multiverse will remain habitable for a lot longer than that (Adams and Laughlin 1997), should our descendants gain the capacity to migrate there. An open question in astronomy is whether it is possible for the descendants of humanity to continue living for an infinite length of time or instead merely an astronomically large but finite length of time (see e.g. Ćirković 2002; Kaku 2005). Either way, the stakes with global catastrophes could be much larger than the loss of 500 trillion lives. Debates about the infinite vs. the merely astronomical are of theoretical interest (Ng 1991; Bossert et al. 2007), but they have limited practical significance. This can be seen when evaluating GCRs from a standard risk-equals-probability-times-magnitude framework. Using Sagan’s 500 trillion lives estimate, it follows that reducing the probability of global catastrophe by a mere one-in-500-trillion chance is of the same significance as saving one human life. Phrased differently, society should try 500 trillion times harder to prevent a global catastrophe than it should to save a person’s life. Or, preventing one million deaths is equivalent to a one-in500-million reduction in the probability of global catastrophe. This suggests society should make extremely large investment in GCR reduction, at the expense of virtually all other objectives. Judge and legal scholar Richard Posner made a similar point in monetary terms (Posner 2004). Posner used $50,000 as the value of a statistical human life (VSL) and 12 billion humans as the total loss of life (double the 2004 world population); he describes both figures as significant underestimates. Multiplying them gives $600 trillion as an underestimate of the value of preventing global catastrophe. For comparison, the United States government typically uses a VSL of around one to ten million dollars (Robinson 2007). Multiplying a $10 million VSL with 500 trillion lives gives $5x1021 as the value of preventing global catastrophe. But even using “just" $600 trillion, society should be willing to spend at least that much to prevent a global catastrophe, which converts to being willing to spend at least $1 million for a one-in-500-million reduction in the probability of global catastrophe. Thus while reasonable disagreement exists on how large of a VSL to use and how much to count future generations, even low-end positions suggest vast resource allocations should be redirected to reducing GCR. This conclusion is only strengthened when considering the astronomical size of the stakes, but the same point holds either way. The bottom line is that, as long as something along the lines of the standard riskequals-probability-times-magnitude framework is being used, then even tiny GCR reductions merit significant effort. This point holds especially strongly for risks of catastrophes that would cause permanent harm to global human civilization. The discussion thus far has assumed that all human lives are valued equally. This assumption is not universally held. People often value some people more than others, favoring themselves, their family and friends, their compatriots, their generation, or others whom they identify with. Great debates rage on across moral philosophy, economics, and other fields about how much people should value others who are distant in space, time, or social relation, as well as the unborn members of future generations. This debate is crucial for all valuations of risk, including GCR. Indeed, if each of us only cares about our immediate selves, then global catastrophes may not be especially important, and we probably have better things to do with our time than worry about them. While everyone has the right to their own views and feelings, we find that the strongest arguments are for the widely held position that all human lives should be valued equally. This position is succinctly stated in the United States Declaration of Independence, updated in the 1848 Declaration of Sentiments: “We hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men and 3 women are created equal”. Philosophers speak of an agent-neutral, objective “view from nowhere” (Nagel 1986) or a “veil of ignorance” (Rawls 1971) in which each person considers what is best for society irrespective of which member of society they happen to be. Such a perspective suggests valuing everyone equally, regardless of who they are or where or when they live. This in turn suggests a very high value for reducing GCR, or a high degree of priority for GCR reduction efforts.

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Impact Framing › Extinction First

Extinction is the only egalitarian metric---anything else collapses cooperation on collective action crises and makes extinction inevitable

Khan 18 (Risalat, activist and entrepreneur from Bangladesh passionate about addressing climate change, biodiversity loss, and other existential challenges. He was featured by The Guardian as one of the “young climate campaigners to watch” (2015). As a campaigner with the global civic movement Avaaz (2014-17), Risalat was part of a small core team that spearheaded the largest climate marches in history with a turnout of over 800,000 across 2,000 cities. After fighting for the Paris Agreement, Risalat led a campaign joined by over a million people to stop the Rampal coal plant in Bangladesh to protect the Sundarbans World Heritage forest, and elicited criticism of the plant from Crédit Agricolé through targeted advocacy. Currently, Risalat is pursuing an MPA in Environmental Science and Policy at Columbia University as a SIPA Environmental Fellow, “5 reasons why we need to start talking about existential risks,” https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2018/01/5-reasons-start-talking-existential-risks-extinction-moriori/)

Infinite future possibilities I find the story of the Moriori profound. It teaches me two lessons. Firstly, that human culture is far from immutable. That we can struggle against our baser instincts. That we can master them and rise to unprecedented challenges. Secondly, that even this does not make us masters of our own destiny. We can make visionary choices, but the future can still surprise us. This is a humbling realization. Because faced with an uncertain future, the only wise thing we can do is prepare for possibilities. Standing at the launch pad of the Fourth Industrial Revolution, the possibilities seem endless. They range from an era of abundance to the end of humanity, and everything in between. How do we navigate such a wide and divergent spectrum? I am an optimist. From my bubble of privilege, life feels like a rollercoaster ride full of ever more impressive wonders, even as I try to fight the many social injustices that still blight us. However, the accelerating pace of change amid uncertainty elicits one fundamental observation. Among the infinite future possibilities, only one outcome is truly irreversible: extinction. Concerns about extinction are often dismissed as apocalyptic alarmism. Sometimes, they are. But repeating that mankind is still here after 70 years of existential warning about nuclear warfare is a straw man argument. The fact that a 1000-year flood has not happened does not negate its possibility. And there have been far too many nuclear near-misses to rest easy. As the World Economic Forum’s Annual Meeting in Davos discusses how to create a shared future in a fractured world, here are five reasons why the possibility of existential risks should raise the stakes of conversation: 1. Extinction is the rule, not the exception More than 99.9% of all the species that ever existed are gone. Deep time is unfathomable to the human brain. But if one cares to take a tour of the billions of years of life’s history, we find a litany of forgotten species. And we have only discovered a mere fraction of the extinct species that once roamed the planet. In the speck of time since the first humans evolved, more than 99.9% of all the distinct human cultures that have ever existed are extinct. Each hunter-gatherer tribe had its own mythologies, traditions and norms. They wiped each other out, or coalesced into larger formations following the agricultural revolution. However, as major civilizations emerged, even those that reached incredible heights, such as the Egyptians and the Romans, eventually collapsed. It is only in the very recent past that we became a truly global civilization. Our interconnectedness continues to grow rapidly. “Stand or fall, we are the last civilization”, as Ricken Patel, the founder of the global civic movement Avaaz, put it. 2. Environmental pressures can drive extinction More than 15,000 scientists just issued a ‘warning to humanity’. They called on us to reduce our impact on the biosphere, 25 years after their first such appeal. The warning notes that we are far outstripping the capacity of our planet in all but one measure of ozone depletion, including emissions, biodiversity, freshwater availability and more. The scientists, not a crowd known to overstate facts, conclude: “soon it will be too late to shift course away from our failing trajectory, and time is running out”. In his 2005 book Collapse, Jared Diamond charts the history of past societies. He makes the case that overpopulation and resource use beyond the carrying capacity have often been important, if not the only, drivers of collapse. Even though we are making important incremental progress in battles such as climate change, we must still achieve tremendous step changes in our response to several major environmental crises. We must do this even while the world’s population continues to grow. These pressures are bound to exert great stress on our global civilization. 3. Superintelligence: unplanned obsolescence? Imagine a monkey society that foresaw the ascendance of humans. Fearing a loss of status and power, it decided to kill the proverbial Adam and Eve. It crafted the most ingenious plan it could: starve the humans by taking away all their bananas. Foolproof plan, right? This story describes the fundamental difficulty with superintelligence. A superintelligent being may always do something entirely different from what we, with our mere mortal intelligence, can foresee. In his 2014 book Superintelligence, Swedish philosopher Nick Bostrom presents the challenge in thought-provoking detail, and advises caution. Bostrom cites a survey of industry experts that projected a 50% chance of the development of artificial superintelligence by 2050, and a 90% chance by 2075. The latter date is within the life expectancy of many alive today. Visionaries like Stephen Hawking and Elon Musk have warned of the existential risks from artificial superintelligence. Their opposite camp includes Larry Page and Mark Zuckerberg. But on an issue that concerns the future of humanity, is it really wise to ignore the guy who explained the nature of space to us and another guy who just put a reusable rocket in it? 4. Technology: known knowns and unknown unknowns Many fundamentally disruptive technologies are coming of age, from bioengineering to quantum computing, 3-D printing, robotics, nanotechnology and more. Lord Martin Rees describes potential existential challenges from some of these technologies, such as a bioengineered pandemic, in his book Our Final Century. Imagine if North Korea, feeling secure in its isolation, could release a virulent strain of Ebola, engineered to be airborne. Would it do it? Would ISIS? Projecting decades forward, we will likely develop capabilities that are unthinkable even now. The unknown unknowns of our technological path are profoundly humbling. 5. 'The Trump Factor' Despite our scientific ingenuity, we are still a confused and confusing species. Think back to two years ago, and how you thought the world worked then. Has that not been upended by the election of Donald Trump as US President, and everything that has happened since? The mix of billions of messy humans will forever be unpredictable. When the combustible forces described above are added to this melee, we find ourselves on a tightrope. What choices must we now make now to create a shared future, in which we are not at perpetual risk of destroying ourselves? Common enemy to common cause Throughout history, we have rallied against the ‘other’. Tribes have overpowered tribes, empires have conquered rivals. Even today, our fiercest displays of unity typically happen at wartime. We give our lives for our motherland and defend nationalistic pride like a wounded lion. But like the early Morioris, we 21st-century citizens find ourselves on an increasingly unstable island. We may have a violent past, but we have no more dangerous enemy than ourselves. Our task is to find our own Nunuku’s Law. Our own shared contract, based on equity, would help us navigate safely. It would ensure a future that unleashes the full potential of our still-budding human civilization, in all its diversity. We cannot do this unless we are humbly grounded in the possibility of our own destruction. Survival is life’s primal instinct. In the absence of a common enemy, we must find common cause in survival. Our future may depend on whether we realize this.

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Off Case › States Counterplan

States – local experimentation key to national success

Megan Greenwell “Universal Basic Income Has Been Tested Repeatedly. It Works. Will America Ever Embrace It?” October 24, 2022 https://www.washingtonpost.com/magazine/2022/10/24/universal-basic-income/

Despite the setbacks at the federal level, philanthropic interest in guaranteed income continues to increase and the body of research on local programs continues to grow. No two experiments work exactly the same way — some are only for people making under a certain income, others are limited to certain neighborhoods or just for single parents — making each city feel like its own laboratory. Still, as in any movement — especially one where the greatest energy is at the local level — there are disagreements, some over substance and others over who gets the most attention. Unanswered questions range from the fundamental (should guaranteed income be provided to everyone, or more narrowly targeted to lift people out of poverty?) to the ultra-specific (should money be provided on prepaid debit cards or via online transfers?), and there is plenty of jockeying among movement leaders over who knows best. Three hundred and fifty miles down Interstate 5 from Stockton, the Compton Pledge has replaced SEED as the nation’s buzziest guaranteed-income experiment. The key difference: While most pilots are designed to investigate whether basic income works, the team in Compton sees that question as too obvious to merit discussion. Instead, they are studying the factors that make it work best. “Now we know that we should do this policy,” says Nika Soon-Shiong, the Compton Pledge’s co-director. “The question is really how. And unless we get more future-oriented, thinking about how and asking questions to inform the answer, we’re going to fail.” Soon-Shiong, 29, stands out among movement leaders. Its most visible proponents are Black; she is the daughter of ethnically Chinese, natively South African parents. She didn’t grow up in Compton, and she began studying basic income as a PhD student at Oxford University. And whereas many guaranteed-income advocates talk in detail about how a policy would have helped their own families, her father is billionaire bioscientist Patrick Soon-Shiong, who owns the Los Angeles Times and a share of the Lakers. She also voices a more radical case for guaranteed income, laced with language about prison abolition, defunding the police and reparations.

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Off Case › Politics Links

No momentum for basic income – Covid arguments no longer apply

Megan Greenwell “Universal Basic Income Has Been Tested Repeatedly. It Works. Will America Ever Embrace It?” October 24, 2022 https://www.washingtonpost.com/magazine/2022/10/24/universal-basic-income/

But empirical evidence does not rule the world, and it is far from clear that there is a political path forward for guaranteed income on a large scale. The city-level experiments cannot last forever: Stockton’s lapsed in early 2021, a few months after Tubbs lost his reelection bid to a Republican successor who showed no interest in trying to keep SEED going. On Capitol Hill, too, political momentum for handing out cash has waned. At the end of 2021, an extension of the expanded child tax credit — which was seen by many advocates as a key steppingstone to guaranteed income — was blocked by a Democrat representing the state with the sixth-highest poverty rate in the country.

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Off Case › Politics Links

Cash aid unpopular

Robert Greenstein (founder and President Emeritus of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. He is considered an expert on the federal budget and a range of domestic policy issues, including anti-poverty programs and various aspects of tax and health care policy.) June 13, 2019 “Commentary: Universal Basic Income May Sound Attractive But, If It Occurred, Would Likelier Increase Poverty Than Reduce It” https://www.cbpp.org/research/poverty-and-opportunity/commentary-universal-basic-income-may-sound-attractive-but-if-it

Some UBI supporters stress that it would be universal. One often hears that means-tested programs eventually get crushed politically while universal programs do well. But the evidence doesn’t support that belief. While cash aid for poor people who aren’t working has fared poorly politically, means-tested programs as a whole have done well. Recent decades have witnessed large expansions of SNAP, Medicaid, the EITC, and other programs.

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Off Case › Politics Links

Plan controversial - can’t overcome attitudes about work and poverty

Robert Greenstein (founder and President Emeritus of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. He is considered an expert on the federal budget and a range of domestic policy issues, including anti-poverty programs and various aspects of tax and health care policy.) June 13, 2019 “Commentary: Universal Basic Income May Sound Attractive But, If It Occurred, Would Likelier Increase Poverty Than Reduce It” https://www.cbpp.org/research/poverty-and-opportunity/commentary-universal-basic-income-may-sound-attractive-but-if-it

UBI’s daunting financing challenges raise fundamental questions about its political feasibility, both now and in coming decades. Proponents often speak of an emerging left-right coalition to support it. But consider what UBI’s supporters on the right advocate. They generally propose UBI as a replacement for the current “welfare state.” That is, they would finance UBI by eliminating all or most programs for people with low or modest incomes. Consider what that would mean. If you take the dollars targeted on people in the bottom fifth or two-fifths of the population and convert them to universal payments to people all the way up the income scale, you’re redistributing income upward. That would increase poverty and inequality rather than reduce them. UBI’s daunting financing challenges raise fundamental questions about its political feasibility, both now and in coming decades. Proponents often speak of an emerging left-right coalition to support it. But consider what UBI’s supporters on the right advocate. They generally propose UBI as a replacement for the current “welfare state.” That is, they would finance UBI by eliminating all or most programs for people with low or modest incomes. Consider what that would mean. If you take the dollars targeted on people in the bottom fifth or two-fifths of the population and convert them to universal payments to people all the way up the income scale, you’re redistributing income upward. That would increase poverty and inequality rather than reduce them. Yet that’s the platform on which the (limited) support for UBI on the right largely rests. It entails abolishing programs from SNAP (food stamps) — which largely eliminated the severe child malnutrition found in parts of the Southern “black belt” and Appalachia in the late 1960s — to the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC), Section 8 rental vouchers, Medicaid, Head Start, child care assistance, and many others. These programs lift tens of millions of people, including millions of children, out of poverty each year and make tens of millions more less poor. Some UBI proponents may argue that by ending current programs, we’d reap large administrative savings that we could convert into UBI payments. But that’s mistaken. For the major means-tested programs — SNAP, Medicaid, the EITC, housing vouchers, Supplemental Security Income (SSI), and school meals — administrative costs consume only 1 to 9 percent of program resources, as a CBPP analysis explains.[1] Their funding goes overwhelmingly to boost the incomes and purchasing power of low-income families. Moreover, as the Roosevelt Institute’s Mike Konczal has noted, eliminating Medicaid, SNAP, the EITC, housing vouchers, and the like would still leave you far short of what’s needed to finance a meaningful UBI.[2] Would we also end Pell Grants that help low-income students afford college? Would we terminate support for children in foster care, for mental health services, and for job training? Ed Dolan, who favors UBI, has calculated that we could finance it by using the proceeds from eliminating all means-tested programs outside health care — including Pell Grants, job training, Head Start, free school lunches, and the like, as well as refundable tax credits, SNAP, SSI, low-income housing programs, etc. The result, Dolan found, would be an annual UBI of $1,582 per person, well below the level of support most low-income families (especially working-poor families with children) now receive. The increase in poverty and hardship would be very large.[3] That’s why the risk is high that under any UBI that could conceivably gain traction politically, tens of millions of poor people would likely end up worse off. To further understand the risks, consider how working-age adults who aren’t working would fare. In our political culture, there are formidable political obstacles to providing cash to working-age people who aren’t employed, and it’s unlikely that UBI could surmount them. The nation’s social insurance programs — Social Security, Medicare, and unemployment insurance — all go only to people with significant work records. It’s highly unlikely that policymakers would agree to make UBI cash payments of several thousand dollars to people who aren’t elderly or disabled and aren’t working. (By contrast, there is political support for providing poor families that have no earnings with non-cash assistance such as SNAP, Medicaid, rental vouchers, Head Start, and the WIC nutrition program.)

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Case Answers › Solvency – Taxes

Taxes fail – there just isn’t enough money in the economy to justify the plan

Robert Greenstein (founder and President Emeritus of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. He is considered an expert on the federal budget and a range of domestic policy issues, including anti-poverty programs and various aspects of tax and health care policy.) June 13, 2019 “Commentary: Universal Basic Income May Sound Attractive But, If It Occurred, Would Likelier Increase Poverty Than Reduce It” https://www.cbpp.org/research/poverty-and-opportunity/commentary-universal-basic-income-may-sound-attractive-but-if-it

Some UBI proponents respond that policymakers could make the UBI payments taxable. But the savings from doing so would be relatively modest, because the vast bulk of Americans either owe no federal income tax or are in the 10% or 15% tax brackets. For example, if you gave all 328 million Americans a $10,000 UBI and the cost was $3.28 trillion a year (about $33 trillion over ten years) before taxes, then making the UBI payments taxable would reduce that cost only to something like $2.5 trillion or $2.75 trillion (or $25 trillion to $27.5 trillion over ten years). Paying For It. Where would the money to finance such a large expenditure come from? That it would come mainly or entirely from new taxes isn’t plausible. We’ll already need substantial new revenues in the coming decades to help keep Social Security and Medicare solvent and avoid large benefit cuts in them. We’ll need further tax increases to help repair a crumbling infrastructure that will otherwise impede economic growth. And if we want to create more opportunity and reduce racial and other barriers and inequities, we’ll also need to raise new revenues to invest more in areas like pre-school education, child care, college affordability, and revitalizing segregated inner-city communities. A UBI that’s financed primarily by tax increases would require the American people to accept a level of taxation that vastly exceeds anything in U.S. history. It’s hard to imagine that such a UBI would advance very far, especially given the tax increases we’ll already need for Social Security, Medicare, infrastructure, and other needs.

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Case Answers › Solvency – Catch All

Plan makes every area they say they fix worse – disincentives to work undermine the entire social safety net

Robert Doar (Morgridge Fellow in Poverty Studies at the American Enterprise Institute) “Universal Basic Income Would Undermine the Success of Our Safety Net” Spring 2018 https://www.bushcenter.org/catalyst/are-we-ready/doar-universal-basic-income

The American safety net is not perfect – not by a long shot – but it does a good job of ensuring that low-income Americans have enough support to meet their basic needs. The data are clear about that: Consumption poverty, which measures the wellbeing of the poor after accounting for safety net assistance provided by the government, declined to an all-time low of 3 percent in 2016. Thanks to a good economy and strong public assistance programs, very few Americans live in deprivation. Universal Basic Income (UBI) would be an unaffordable way to undermine our social safety net’s successes. UBI would transfer money away from those who need it most, change the distinctly American relationship between citizen and government, and sharply raise taxes or the national debt (or both). And critically, it would fail to improve upon our current safety net’s biggest weakness: UBI would destroy – not improve – incentives to work. Universal Basic Income would transfer money away from those who need it most, change the distinctly American relationship between citizen and government, and sharply raise taxes or the national debt (or both). The first problem is the money. A truly universal payment of $10,000 to every citizen every year adds up to a new expense of about $3 trillion, well more than we spend on our social safety net now, and close to the entirety of the tax revenue currently collected by the federal government. If any element of the current safety net is going to be preserved, taxes will have to be raised dramatically, beyond what is politically plausible or economically desirable, or the U.S. would have to borrow even more money than we already do. Proponents of UBI should have to answer: what social programs will be cut to make room for their proposal? Some of the money needed to pay for UBI would have to come from the middle- and lower-middle classes, either in reduced benefits or increased taxes, and they would then see some of their money transferred up to wealthier recipients of UBI. Money that would have been spent on programs for people in the lowest income quintiles would now be distributed universally, including to the uppermost income quintiles. This does not sound much like an anti-poverty program. Some of the money needed to pay for UBI would have to come from the middle- and lower-middle classes, either in reduced benefits or increased taxes, and they would then see some of their money transferred up to wealthier recipients of UBI. As for those not among the high earners, UBI would surely illustrate a basic law of economics and negatively affect the incentive to work and produce. One thing I saw clearly in my 19 years of working in safety net programs in New York was that when benefits rose, work and earnings declined. And in the major study of UBI-like programs provided in Seattle and Denver, substantial, unconditional payments were found to cause a near 14 percent decline in labor force participation, and a 27 percent reduction in hours worked by women. That’s a labor force drop-off greater than the difference between the highest participation rate we’ve ever seen in this country and the lowest. That doesn’t only mean people will be less driven than ever to earn their way out of poverty. Less work also means fewer “feelings of citizenship and social inclusion,” worse mental health and feelings of wellbeing, less happiness, worse self-esteem, even worse health among children, more crime, and way more drug abuse. The benefits of working are vast and well-documented, and anti-poverty programs should encourage work – not discourage it. UBI would also be an upheaval of the American relationship between citizen and state. American government was never meant to be a provider for all, and citizens never meant to rely on publicly-funded distributions. Under our Constitution, government is enlisted to protect our freedoms, not to provide for each and every citizen. In considering UBI, we need to be conscious of what it means for an individual to be financially independent, and how industrious, independent individuals have been the drivers of American ingenuity and progress. Americans who grow dependent upon the generosity of the state become its wards, and making them so will risk forfeiting what has made America the prosperous nation it is. There are other, far more effective ways to improve incomes and outcomes for poor and working-class Americans. Wage subsidies can ensure that working parents have more financial flexibility to support their families.

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Case Answers › Econ Defense

No Econ Impact

Walt 20 – Stephen M, the Robert and Renée Belfer professor of international relations at Harvard University. “Will a Global Depression Trigger Another World War?”, Foreign Policy, , 05-13-2020

One familiar argument is the so-called diversionary (or “scapegoat”) theory of war. It suggests that leaders who are worried about their popularity at home will try to divert attention from their failures by provoking a crisis with a foreign power and maybe even using force against it. Drawing on this logic, some Americans now worry that President Donald Trump will decide to attack a country like Iran or Venezuela in the run-up to the presidential election and especially if he thinks he’s likely to lose. This outcome strikes me as unlikely, even if one ignores the logical and empirical flaws in the theory itself. War is always a gamble, and should things go badly—even a little bit—it would hammer the last nail in the coffin of Trump’s declining fortunes. Moreover, none of the countries Trump might consider going after pose an imminent threat to U.S. security, and even his staunchest supporters may wonder why he is wasting time and money going after Iran or Venezuela at a moment when thousands of Americans are dying preventable deaths at home. Even a successful military action won’t put Americans back to work, create the sort of testing-and-tracing regime that competent governments around the world have been able to implement already, or hasten the development of a vaccine. The same logic is likely to guide the decisions of other world leaders too. Another familiar folk theory is “military Keynesianism.” War generates a lot of economic demand, and it can sometimes lift depressed economies out of the doldrums and back toward prosperity and full employment. The obvious case in point here is World War II, which did help the U.S economy finally escape the quicksand of the Great Depression. Those who are convinced that great powers go to war primarily to keep Big Business (or the arms industry) happy are naturally drawn to this sort of argument, and they might worry that governments looking at bleak economic forecasts will try to restart their economies through some sort of military adventure. I doubt it. It takes a really big war to generate a significant stimulus, and it is hard to imagine any country launching a large-scale war—with all its attendant risks—at a moment when debt levels are already soaring. More importantly, there are lots of easier and more direct ways to stimulate the economy—infrastructure spending, unemployment insurance, even “helicopter payments”—and launching a war has to be one of the least efficient methods available. The threat of war usually spooks investors too, which any politician with their eye on the stock market would be loath to do. Economic downturns can encourage war in some special circumstances, especially when a war would enable a country facing severe hardships to capture something of immediate and significant value. Saddam Hussein’s decision to seize Kuwait in 1990 fits this model perfectly: The Iraqi economy was in terrible shape after its long war with Iran; unemployment was threatening Saddam’s domestic position; Kuwait’s vast oil riches were a considerable prize; and seizing the lightly armed emirate was exceedingly easy to do. Iraq also owed Kuwait a lot of money, and a hostile takeover by Baghdad would wipe those debts off the books overnight. In this case, Iraq’s parlous economic condition clearly made war more likely. Yet I cannot think of any country in similar circumstances today. Now is hardly the time for Russia to try to grab more of Ukraine—if it even wanted to—or for China to make a play for Taiwan, because the costs of doing so would clearly outweigh the economic benefits. Even conquering an oil-rich country—the sort of greedy acquisitiveness that Trump occasionally hints at—doesn’t look attractive when there’s a vast glut on the market. I might be worried if some weak and defenseless country somehow came to possess the entire global stock of a successful coronavirus vaccine, but that scenario is not even remotely possible. If one takes a longer-term perspective, however, a sustained economic depression could make war more likely by strengthening fascist or xenophobic political movements, fueling protectionism and hypernationalism, and making it more difficult for countries to reach mutually acceptable bargains with each other. The history of the 1930s shows where such trends can lead, although the economic effects of the Depression are hardly the only reason world politics took such a deadly turn in the 1930s. Nationalism, xenophobia, and authoritarian rule were making a comeback well before COVID-19 struck, but the economic misery now occurring in every corner of the world could intensify these trends and leave us in a more war-prone condition when fear of the virus has diminished. On balance, however, I do not think that even the extraordinary economic conditions we are witnessing today are going to have much impact on the likelihood of war. Why? First of all, if depressions were a powerful cause of war, there would be a lot more of the latter. To take one example, the United States has suffered 40 or more recessions since the country was founded, yet it has fought perhaps 20 interstate wars, most of them unrelated to the state of the economy. To paraphrase the economist Paul Samuelson’s famous quip about the stock market, if recessions were a powerful cause of war, they would have predicted “nine out of the last five (or fewer).” Second, states do not start wars unless they believe they will win a quick and relatively cheap victory. As John Mearsheimer showed in his classic book Conventional Deterrence, national leaders avoid war when they are convinced it will be long, bloody, costly, and uncertain. To choose war, political leaders have to convince themselves they can either win a quick, cheap, and decisive victory or achieve some limited objective at low cost. Europe went to war in 1914 with each side believing it would win a rapid and easy victory, and Nazi Germany developed the strategy of blitzkrieg in order to subdue its foes as quickly and cheaply as possible. Iraq attacked Iran in 1980 because Saddam believed the Islamic Republic was in disarray and would be easy to defeat, and George W. Bush invaded Iraq in 2003 convinced the war would be short, successful, and pay for itself. The fact that each of these leaders miscalculated badly does not alter the main point: No matter what a country’s economic condition might be, its leaders will not go to war unless they think they can do so quickly, cheaply, and with a reasonable probability of success. Third, and most important, the primary motivation for most wars is the desire for security, not economic gain. For this reason, the odds of war increase when states believe the long-term balance of power may be shifting against them, when they are convinced that adversaries are unalterably hostile and cannot be accommodated, and when they are confident they can reverse the unfavorable trends and establish a secure position if they act now. The historian A.J.P. Taylor once observed that “every war between Great Powers [between 1848 and 1918] … started as a preventive war, not as a war of conquest,” and that remains true of most wars fought since then. The bottom line: Economic conditions (i.e., a depression) may affect the broader political environment in which decisions for war or peace are made, but they are only one factor among many and rarely the most significant. Even if the COVID-19 pandemic has large, lasting, and negative effects on the world economy—as seems quite likely—it is not likely to affect the probability of war very much, especially in the short term. To be sure, I can’t rule out another powerful cause of war—stupidity—especially when it is so much in evidence in some quarters these days. So there is no guarantee that we won’t see misguided leaders stumbling into another foolish bloodletting. But given that it’s hard to find any rays of sunshine at this particular moment in history, I’m going to hope I’m right about this one.

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Case Answers › Economy – Jobs/Government Savings

Plan massively increases government spending and collapses incentive to work

Robert Doar (Morgridge Fellow in Poverty Studies at the American Enterprise Institute) “Universal Basic Income Would Undermine the Success of Our Safety Net” Spring 2018 https://www.bushcenter.org/catalyst/are-we-ready/doar-universal-basic-income

The American safety net is not perfect – not by a long shot – but it does a good job of ensuring that low-income Americans have enough support to meet their basic needs. The data are clear about that: Consumption poverty, which measures the wellbeing of the poor after accounting for safety net assistance provided by the government, declined to an all-time low of 3 percent in 2016. Thanks to a good economy and strong public assistance programs, very few Americans live in deprivation. Universal Basic Income (UBI) would be an unaffordable way to undermine our social safety net’s successes. UBI would transfer money away from those who need it most, change the distinctly American relationship between citizen and government, and sharply raise taxes or the national debt (or both). And critically, it would fail to improve upon our current safety net’s biggest weakness: UBI would destroy – not improve – incentives to work. Universal Basic Income would transfer money away from those who need it most, change the distinctly American relationship between citizen and government, and sharply raise taxes or the national debt (or both). The first problem is the money. A truly universal payment of $10,000 to every citizen every year adds up to a new expense of about $3 trillion, well more than we spend on our social safety net now, and close to the entirety of the tax revenue currently collected by the federal government. If any element of the current safety net is going to be preserved, taxes will have to be raised dramatically, beyond what is politically plausible or economically desirable, or the U.S. would have to borrow even more money than we already do. Proponents of UBI should have to answer: what social programs will be cut to make room for their proposal? Some of the money needed to pay for UBI would have to come from the middle- and lower-middle classes, either in reduced benefits or increased taxes, and they would then see some of their money transferred up to wealthier recipients of UBI. Money that would have been spent on programs for people in the lowest income quintiles would now be distributed universally, including to the uppermost income quintiles. This does not sound much like an anti-poverty program. Some of the money needed to pay for UBI would have to come from the middle- and lower-middle classes, either in reduced benefits or increased taxes, and they would then see some of their money transferred up to wealthier recipients of UBI. As for those not among the high earners, UBI would surely illustrate a basic law of economics and negatively affect the incentive to work and produce. One thing I saw clearly in my 19 years of working in safety net programs in New York was that when benefits rose, work and earnings declined. And in the major study of UBI-like programs provided in Seattle and Denver, substantial, unconditional payments were found to cause a near 14 percent decline in labor force participation, and a 27 percent reduction in hours worked by women. That’s a labor force drop-off greater than the difference between the highest participation rate we’ve ever seen in this country and the lowest. That doesn’t only mean people will be less driven than ever to earn their way out of poverty. Less work also means fewer “feelings of citizenship and social inclusion,” worse mental health and feelings of wellbeing, less happiness, worse self-esteem, even worse health among children, more crime, and way more drug abuse. The benefits of working are vast and well-documented, and anti-poverty programs should encourage work – not discourage it. UBI would also be an upheaval of the American relationship between citizen and state. American government was never meant to be a provider for all, and citizens never meant to rely on publicly-funded distributions. Under our Constitution, government is enlisted to protect our freedoms, not to provide for each and every citizen. In considering UBI, we need to be conscious of what it means for an individual to be financially independent, and how industrious, independent individuals have been the drivers of American ingenuity and progress. Americans who grow dependent upon the generosity of the state become its wards, and making them so will risk forfeiting what has made America the prosperous nation it is. There are other, far more effective ways to improve incomes and outcomes for poor and working-class Americans. Wage subsidies can ensure that working parents have more financial flexibility to support their families.

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Case Answers › Economy Advantage – Automation

The solution to automation is not basic income, its more education.

Robert Doar (Morgridge Fellow in Poverty Studies at the American Enterprise Institute) “Universal Basic Income Would Undermine the Success of Our Safety Net” Spring 2018 https://www.bushcenter.org/catalyst/are-we-ready/doar-universal-basic-income

If we are worried about the automation revolution making current jobs obsolete, we should focus on teaching soft skills and technological skills to low-skill workers and to people who do not attend college. Career and technical education provides many opportunities to prepare for a future in which understanding new technologies will be a paramount skill, and public policymakers could focus on ensuring that low-income people are properly supported as they gain the knowledge necessary to enter or reenter the workforce. The bottom line is that UBI gives up on work – with all the positive secondary effects work brings – in favor of an unaffordable overhaul of our current social safety net programs. We are not, and should not be, prepared to sacrifice our longstanding commitment to adapting to new circumstances and equipping people with new skills for a new economy. Without answers as to how we can pay for UBI, how it can avoid the pitfalls of a further shrinking labor force, and how we can maintain our distinctly American freedom, the UBI is a risk we cannot take.

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Case Answers › Economy Advantage – Automation

Automation creates jobs – no impact

Adi Gaskell 01-18-2022 Adi Gaskell is a contributor to Forbes, innovation consultant, writer, and has a postgrad degree in computing.

[Adi Gaskell, “AI creates job disruption but not job destruction”, Forbes, published 01-18-2022,

. Accessed 06/30/2023. //AH CCHS]

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Case Answers › Economy Advantage – Social Mobility

The plan increases poverty and doesn’t solve bureaucratic troubles

Robert Greenstein (founder and President Emeritus of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. He is considered an expert on the federal budget and a range of domestic policy issues, including anti-poverty programs and various aspects of tax and health care policy.) June 13, 2019 “Commentary: Universal Basic Income May Sound Attractive But, If It Occurred, Would Likelier Increase Poverty Than Reduce It” https://www.cbpp.org/research/poverty-and-opportunity/commentary-universal-basic-income-may-sound-attractive-but-if-it

Some UBI proponents may argue that by ending current programs, we’d reap large administrative savings that we could convert into UBI payments. But that’s mistaken. For the major means-tested programs — SNAP, Medicaid, the EITC, housing vouchers, Supplemental Security Income (SSI), and school meals — administrative costs consume only 1 to 9 percent of program resources, as a CBPP analysis explains.[1] Their funding goes overwhelmingly to boost the incomes and purchasing power of low-income families. Moreover, as the Roosevelt Institute’s Mike Konczal has noted, eliminating Medicaid, SNAP, the EITC, housing vouchers, and the like would still leave you far short of what’s needed to finance a meaningful UBI.[2] Would we also end Pell Grants that help low-income students afford college? Would we terminate support for children in foster care, for mental health services, and for job training? Ed Dolan, who favors UBI, has calculated that we could finance it by using the proceeds from eliminating all means-tested programs outside health care — including Pell Grants, job training, Head Start, free school lunches, and the like, as well as refundable tax credits, SNAP, SSI, low-income housing programs, etc. The result, Dolan found, would be an annual UBI of $1,582 per person, well below the level of support most low-income families (especially working-poor families with children) now receive. The increase in poverty and hardship would be very large.[3] That’s why the risk is high that under any UBI that could conceivably gain traction politically, tens of millions of poor people would likely end up worse off.

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Case Answers › Quality of Life – Food Security

No correlation between food shortages and conflict – other factors

Buhaug et al. 15 – Halvard, Peace Research Institute Oslo, PRIO, Norway and Norwegian University of Science and Technology, NTNU, Norway. Tor A Benjaminsen, Norwegian University of Life Sciences, NMBU, Norway and Peace Research Institute Oslo, PRIO, Norway. Espen Sjaastad, Norwegian University of Life Sciences, NMBU, Norway. Ole Magnus Theisen, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, NTNU, Norway and Peace Research Institute Oslo, PRIO, Norway. “Climate variability, food production shocks, and violent conflict in Sub-Saharan Africa”, Enviornmental Research Letters, Vol. 10, No. 12, , 12-22-2015

Across all models, we find relatively weak and insignificant effects for domestic food production and we also note that the sign of the coefficients shifts between outcome types. In this sense, table 1 implicitly contrasts both claims that political violence is more prevalent when basic needs are met (Salehyan and Hendrix 2014) and claims that agricultural income shocks increase civil conflict risk (von Uexkull 2014). The results are consistent with Koubi et al (2012) and van Weezel (2015), however, who conclude that rainfall—a significant determinant of yields in SSA—has little impact on conflict either directly or through economic performance.

The covariate that best and most consistently explains temporal variation in political violence is the time-lagged conflict incidence indicator. Models 1–2 show that a new civil conflict is unlikely to break out if another one is already ongoing in the same country whereas Models 3–6, which capture the occurrence of less organized conflict, demonstrate that violence begets violence. Coups d'état (Models 7–8) exhibit a comparatively weak temporal correlation pattern in our data and are generally regarded as a highly unpredictable phenomenon (Luttwak 1979).

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Case Answers › Quality of Life – Food Security

No food wars

Vestby et al. 18 – Jonas, Doctoral Researcher at the Peace Research Institute Oslo, Ida Rudolfsen, doctoral researcher at the Department of Peace and Conflict Research at Uppsala University and PRIO, and Halvard Buhaug, Research Professor at the Peace Research Institute Oslo (PRIO); Professor of Political Science at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU); and Associate Editor of the Journal of Peace Research and Political Geography. “Does hunger cause conflict?”, , 05-18-2018

It is perhaps surprising, then, that there is little scholarly merit in the notion that a short-term reduction in access to food increases the probability that conflict will break out. This is because to start or participate in violent conflict requires people to have both the means and the will. Most people on the brink of starvation are not in the position to resort to violence, whether against the government or other social groups. In fact, the urban middle classes tend to be the most likely to protest against rises in food prices, since they often have the best opportunities, the most energy, and the best skills to coordinate and participate in protests.

Accordingly, there is a widespread misapprehension that social unrest in periods of high food prices relates primarily to food shortages. In reality, the sources of discontent are considerably more complex – linked to political structures, land ownership, corruption, the desire for democratic reforms and general economic problems – where the price of food is seen in the context of general increases in the cost of living. Research has shown that while the international media have a tendency to seek simple resource-related explanations – such as drought or famine – for conflicts in the Global South, debates in the local media are permeated by more complex political relationships.

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Case Answers › Quality of Life – Food Security

Basic income can’t solve root cause of food insecurity

Madison Korzun and Farzaneh Barak 23 Monika Korzun has worked in the Canadian food system in various capacities over the past 12 years, including academia, non-profit and industry. She currently holds a McCain Foundation Postdoctoral Fellowship. Farzaneh Barak (MSc, PhD), has over a decade of national and international experience in public health nutrition and food security in countries like Iran, Malawi, Uganda, and Canada.

[madison korzun and farzaneh barak, “Food Prices are not the Only Obstacle to achieving Food Security”, Dalhousie University, published 03-14-2023,. Accessed 06/30/2023. //AH CCHS]

Basic income doesn’t solve root cause of food insecurity Increasing food prices and stagnant incomes have been identified as . About . Economic barriers like food prices are not the only obstacles to food security. Our study, published by , outlines that systemic barriers like colonialism, racism and other systems of injustice are among the root causes of food insecurity in Canada. According to the of the United Nations, food security requires economic, physical and social access to food. Economic access involves factors such as income, poverty and food affordability. Physical access is related to infrastructure and facilities like roads and transportation. Social access focuses on ensuring people have access to all the necessary resources within society for nutritious and culturally appropriate foods. Food insecurity happens if any of these paths fail. The interlinked barriers to food security Our research reveals three major barriers to accessing food:, affordability, policies that perpetuate wealth and income disparity, and systemic forms of discrimination like colonialism and racism. The findings demonstrate that those living with a low income demand long-term solutions that comprehensively address all forms of food access.

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Case Answers › Quality of Life – Crime – Disease Impact

Disease can’t cause extinction

Ord 20 – Dr. Toby, Senior Research Fellow in Philosophy at Oxford University, DPhil in Philosophy from the University of Oxford. “The Precipice: Existential Risk and the Future of Humanity,”, Hachette Books, pg. 124-126, 03-03-2020

Are we safe now from events like this? Or are we more vulnerable? Could a pandemic threaten humanity’s future?10

The Black Death was not the only biological disaster to scar human history. It was not even the only great bubonic plague. In 541 CE the Plague of Justinian struck the Byzantine Empire. Over three years it took the lives of roughly 3 percent of the world’s people.11

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Case Answers › Quality of Life – Crime

Crime is declining now

Lori Robertson Posted on June 11, 2020 Trump Wrong on Crime Record

The , which is based on voluntary reporting by local police departments, publishes yearly estimates on both violent and property crimes. The long-term trend shows the estimated violent crime rate — crimes, including murder, rape, robbery and aggravated assault, per 100,000 people — peaked in the early 1990s, at 758.2 in 1991, and the rate has been on a steady drop since. It was less than half that, . The rate went up a bit in 2015 and 2016 and was 368.9 in 2018, the latest figure available. But the violent crime rate was lower in 2014 and even lower in the 1960s than it has been in recent years.

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Case Answers › Quality of Life – Crime

No evidence guaranteed income solves crime – it is a highly inefficient and expensive method to even try

Robert E. Wright (Senior Faculty Fellow at the American Institute for Economic Research) “Universal basic income isn’t a sensible crime-fighting tool” April 23, 2023 https://www.ocregister.com/2023/04/23/universal-basic-income-isnt-a-sensible-crime-fighting-tool/

Ahsha Safai, a member of San Francisco’s Board of Supervisors, recently opined in USA Today that a universal or unconditional basic income (UBI) would help San Francisco to alleviate its crime problem. The claim might signal the author’s virtue but it has no basis in reality and falls far short of passing a policy-grade cost-benefit analysis. No real UBI has yet been implemented anywhere so its effect on crime remains unknown. A real UBI would be an expensive policy with unknown effects on myriad important outcomes in education, health, and human freedom. So, even if it were to reduce crime, the overall cost of the reduction might prove prohibitively high in absolute terms. It would almost certainly be too high relative to alternative crime reduction policies, especially those with historical precedent. Numerous newspaper headlines suggest that UBI “pilots” and “experiments” have become ubiquitous and that they prove the efficacy of UBI programs. Such headlines mislead because none of the programs are universal (paid to everyone), unconditional (paid to all regardless of class, gender, race, religion, etc.), basic (neither too little nor too large), and income (a permanent stream of cash). Moreover, most US UBI pilot programs received funding from nonprofits, not from the taxes upon which they would ultimately have to rely. Their effects on work incentives therefore remain unknown. In other words, UBI pilot programs to date prove nothing other than the undisputed fact that most people will feel, and actually be, better off if they receive “free money” donated by a distant charity like manna from heaven. If Safai’s real goal is to reduce crime, that can be achieved at much lower cost than UBI. The gross cost of a UBI of $15,000 in San Fran (assuming the population remains around 815,000) would be about $12.25 billion per year. Given that non-San Francisco people will not willingly fund a San Francisco UBI, that money would have to come out of other city expenditures, which would be quite a feat given that its current budget is about $14 billion. Or it could come from higher taxes. Much of the UBI itself could be taxed back, leaving a net cost of, say, $2 billion/year. But how much crime reduction would $2 billion of income redistribution buy? And what else could $2 billion a year buy the city? More police officers, improved 911 services, additional job training programs, and such, as Safai suggests. More of the same old, critics of the status quo will complain.