Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 MNDI Affirmative
Extend – Solvency – UBI+ Reparation

If we adopt a racial lens, we would pass a UBI+ to begin the process of healing.

Bhattacharya, 2019 - of programs and strategy at the Insight Center for Community Economic Development [Jhumpa, June 19 Issue Brief. Roosevelt Institute, “Exploring Guaranteed Income Through a Racial and Gender Justice Lens.” TA Acc 6/10/23]

Lastly, healing needs to occur for communities that have been shortchanged, stolen from, and discriminated against. As part of our reconciliation process, we must recognize the long-term trauma that exists in communities from having to live in constant flux and scarcity for generations. Once we acknowledge this trauma, impacted people need tools to think differently and adjust to a society where everyone is truly seen and given the opportunity to thrive. We cannot expect people to just know how to live in this new world as America has never been a fully inclusive place. We need to uplift and tap into community based interventions that provide holistic support systems, including mental and physical health programs, cross-cultural unity building, anti-bias curriculum, and restorative justice programs. Eliminating State-Sponsored Wealth Extraction Policies That Are Executed through the Criminal Justice System We must recognize and eliminate the ways in which our state and local governments continue to strip and extract wealth from communities of color and women through our criminal justice system. The move towards mass incarceration and the criminalization of poverty have led to what amounts to debtor’s prisons where people are incarcerated simply because they cannot afford to pay a fine or fee or post bail (Los Angeles Times Editorial Board 2019). States and municipalities have to stop balancing their budgets on the backs of poor people of color and women through oppressive fines and fees, and we need to end the practice of money bail. Recognizing and eliminating all of the ways in which government extracts wealth from poor communities of color is a key step in reaching racial and gender equity. Curbing Corporate Power Policymakers and the public at large have to also take a hard look at how corporate America’s profit-motive outweighs the need to protect and care for people. The prioritization of profits over people has led to unprecedented levels of corporate power and greed, has left working people with little to no power, and has forced most of us to live deeply constrained lives with little to no room for economic mobility. By taming the power of those at the top of our economy and reviving worker power, we can build an economy that works for the many, not the few who can pay to play. CONCLUSION The pursuit of racial and gender economic equity should guide every single economic policy debate. A better nation is possible, and we need to have the tough conversations to get there. To achieve an inclusive, more equitable economy, we stop relying on single policy interventions and recognize—and implement—the plethora of complimentary approaches that are capable of redefining the American economy and our society. Racial and gender justice cannot be achieved without economic justice. By tackling wealth inequality through a tiered guaranteed income program, we can create the conditions where everyone in the US truly has the ability to build wealth and thrive.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
Extend – Solvency – UBI+ Reparation

A UBI+ policy is anti-racist - it begins to account for the history of racism in the US and it addresses disproportionate black poverty and unemployment

Bhattacharya, 2019 - of programs and strategy at the Insight Center for Community Economic Development [Jhumpa, June 19 Issue Brief. Roosevelt Institute, “Exploring Guaranteed Income Through a Racial and Gender Justice Lens.” TA Acc 6/10/23]

Universal + Basic Income Model The universal + basic income model is a tiered guaranteed income proposal, which accounts for the fact that Black people have faced systematic barriers to economic prosperity throughout US history. Conceived by Community Change President Dorian Warren, this model calls for an additional payment to be dispersed to Black families on top of the standard benefit given to all families over a period of time (Warren 2017b). The “plus model” acknowledges that the wealth created in the US is inextricably linked to Black labor, sweat, and tears, and this community has never received the benefits created from that labor. Due to persistent racial discrimination, Black unemployment consistently remains double that of white unemployment, and, as noted before, Black people are dramatically over represented in our criminal justice system due to over-policing and surveillance in Black neighborhoods. It is clear that the UBI + model is the closest implementation we currently have that could make a dent in racial wealth inequities. Given that Black families would receive more money than other communities, it begins to account for the centuries of disinvestment and discrimination Black communities faced, and continue to face, in the US. The plus model does not account for gender wealth inequities, but we can build on the premise of this model when assessing the implementation of a guaranteed income. We will also need to ensure that other wealth-stripping policies through the criminal justice system and other municipal debts that are racialized are eliminated.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
Extend – Solvency – UBI+ Reparation

A UBI+ accounts for racial injustice by increasing payments for African Americans – a UBI that reflects racial realities has the best chance to solve for racial inequality.

Nwogbo, 2021 – PhD Candidate in Philosophy at University of Sussex [Johnbosco, Dec 20, Doctoral Thesis “Racial Injustice And Philippe Van Parijs’ Distributive Justice Basis For The Universal Basic Income: Introducing The Filtered Leximinning Of Modified Real Freedom Theory Of Distributive Justice” TA]

CONCLUSION What implications then do our revisions of Van Parijs's theory have for the basic income offer that results? The filtered leximin principle makes maximising the opportunities of members of the least well-off racial group lexically prior to maximising the opportunities of the least well-off group overall. The filtered leximin principle would rank a racially equal society with a certain income distribution above a racially unequal society where people in the bottom opportunity stratum are better off than in the bottom opportunity stratum in the racially equal society. Although economic or income inequality does not comport with many of our conceptions of justice, racial inequality likely comports with none of the conceptions of justice that would be considered legitimate or acceptable in the West today. For one thing, on some mainstream conceptions of justice, some people may well be said to be deserving of poverty, whereas no acceptable conception of justice contains the belief that some races deserve to be treated unequally. Moreover, as I suggested in responding to one of the rebuttals in chapter three, this is because a racially equal society is, all things being equal, one in which people’s fate depends more on their own decisions about their lives than on how people or social institutions treat them because of an immutable characteristic of theirs. It is inarguable that a racially equal society satisfies this criterion more than a racially unequal one.32 The theory that has developed from my revision of Van Parijs's is a theory of comparative justice in the truest Senian sense. Rather than aiming to identify some conception of an absolutely just society, it is more concerned with what is “justice-enhancing” or “inequality-reducing” with respect to the most obvious inequalities that we all agree do not comport with our sense of justice (Sen 2006). Racial inequality is just such an inequality, and my goal is a theory that identifies it as unjust and grounds policies that begin to reduce it. In terms of the basic income, there are at least two possibilities as to what the filtered leximin principle can be said to mandate: (a) Modifying capitalist society to first of all eliminate as far as possible all racial inequalities and then only subject to that introducing a basic income. The basic income is here treated in the way Van Parijs treats it, that is, as a way to raise the opportunities of those at the bottom. The elimination of racial injustice is to be sought in other ways. (b) Or alternatively, introducing a basic income that is designed so that it has the effect of reducing racial inequalities in the first instance. I take the latter route, because making significant modifications to capitalist society implicates the same institutions that are implicated by the introduction of a basic income. The gap between both envisioned by the first approach does not exist in reality. To be sure, it may be pointed out that it is still the case that the filtered leximin principle ranks dealing with racial inequality ahead of dealing with general economic inequality, which suggests that we should first aim to eliminate racial inequality in society as a whole, and then deal with economic inequality by introducing a basic income. In this telling of the story, a basic income is not as necessary a feature of a maximally just society as antiracial- inequality policies targeting the broader institutions of a capitalist society. What this argument misses, however, is that nothing prevents the basic income itself from being our way of eliminating racial inequality in capitalist economies. This is one way my basic income proposal differs from Van Parijs's. Whereas it is a means to deal with economic inequality in Van Parijs, the basic income is a means to deal with racial inequality in mine. I additionally take it to be the case that because the basic income is universal in character, it would have just as much of an effect on economic or income inequality as Van Parijs's basic income would. The main consequences of using the basic income to deal with racial inequality comes in terms of how it is funded and how some of it is given. Although I shall not go into what my account of basic income looks like in detail in this thesis, I shall highlight three things below that a basic income offer that draws from my revision of Van Parijs's theory (i.e. from the filtered leximinning of modified real freedom) would include. Whereas Van Parijs argues that if we are serious about leximinning people’s real freedom (or more specifically, their opportunities) in our capitalist societies we must introduce a basic income, I suggest that if we are serious about dealing with racial injustice in our capitalist society a basic income is unavoidable. The basic income Van Parijs's account leads to will no doubt be one that is not designed in any way to address racial inequality and so is likely to leave it unaffected. On my account, taking the filtered leximinning of people’s modified real freedom as our measure of justice, that is, taking seriously racial injustice, and the fact that some people’s opportunities are limited by racial injustice, requires introducing a universal basic income that reduces or eliminates racial injustice in the broader structures of our capitalist society.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
Extend – Solvency - Stigma

A basic income empowers African Americans by reducing black poverty and ending the link between work and welfare.

Shelby 2017 - prof of African and African American Studies and of Philosophy at Harvard University [Tommie, May 3, Boston Review, “A Blow to Ghettoization Basic income would empower marginalized black workers” Acc 3/23/23 TA]

I am largely in agreement with Brishen Rogers’s discussion of the virtues and limits of basic income. I am persuaded that a basic income would be insufficient for economic justice, that it needs to be joined with a more robust set of public benefits, greater state regulation of labor markets and work conditions, and enhanced bargaining power for workers. I also agree that the most persuasive case for basic income is based on both freedom and fairness—liberty and equality. Rogers does not, however, explore how a basic income might advance the cause of racial justice. Here, as with much else, I think we can learn from Martin Luther King, Jr., who insisted in Stride Toward Freedom (1958) that economic injustice and racial injustice are “inseparable twins.” Basic income would empower marginalized black workers by enabling them to refuse demeaning, insecure, exploitative jobs. After the passage of the Civil Rights Act (1964) and the Voting Rights Act (1965), King turned his attention to the plight of the ghetto poor—that segment of the black poor who, because of past and ongoing racial and economic injustices, are confined to segregated and deeply disadvantaged metropolitan neighborhoods. Indeed, he moved with his family to a ghetto on the west side of Chicago. He called for a civil rights–labor alliance that fused the traditional antiracist aims of the black freedom struggle with the economic egalitarian goals of the labor movement. King supported unconditional basic income for the poor as part of a “Bill of Rights for the Disadvantaged.” Such a measure was necessary, he thought, because of the negative impact automation was having on the employment prospects of ordinary wage laborers and because of the continuing economic marginalization of black urban poor. By extending King’s vision to current realities and opting for basic income over means-tested welfare, we can see how basic income could reduce the suffering of today’s black poor. In particular, basic income could significantly mitigate the burdens of ghettoization and mass incarceration. One of the virtues of basic income that Rogers highlights is how it would sever the link between work and welfare. This would, by itself, advance the cause of racial justice. The linking of work and welfare has a long tradition in American culture and politics. Among both conservatives and liberals, work is often seen as a duty and as an indispensable basis for personal dignity. Joblessness, as a result, has become an influential explanation for why ghettos persist: the fact that so many among the ghetto poor do not work regularly, proponents of the explanation argue, accounts for why people in these communities often remain poor. Some advocates of this view maintain that joblessness has negative ramifications beyond mere income disadvantage. For instance, joblessness is said to increase crime and juvenile delinquency, to encourage welfare dependency and single-mother households, to undermine self-esteem, and to foster a self-defeating ghetto subculture.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
Extend – Solvency - Stigma

A basic income would dispel racist stereotypes by empowering African Americans to avoid the choice between demeaning jobs and incarceration.

Shelby 2017 - prof of African and African American Studies and of Philosophy at Harvard University [Tommie, May 3, Boston Review, “A Blow to Ghettoization Basic income would empower marginalized black workers” Acc 3/23/23 TA]

There is considerable evidence that some Americans oppose welfare entitlement programs because they are prejudiced against blacks, with whom such programs are generally associated. A longstanding and deeply offensive stereotype about blacks is that they are lazy. The ghetto poor would also have grounds to refuse work, then, if they have a justified belief that their fellow citizens have erected a work regime because of racism, whether as a means to punish shiftlessness or as a paternalistic effort to correct habits of indolence. High-poverty neighborhoods with few good employment options lead some residents, especially those unemployed for long periods, to consider securing income through unlawful means. Ghetto poverty creates desperation and feelings of shame, and some, seeking to escape the weight of their social conditions, resort to crime. As a result, many who reside in ghetto neighborhoods have been incarcerated. Upon release their felony records make it difficult for them to find work or housing, as it is not illegal to deny a person a job or an apartment because they have been convicted of a felony. Most convicted felons were already disadvantaged by their limited skills, low educational achievement, and lack of work experience, and they are not eligible for many forms of public assistance. The formerly incarcerated are thus among the worst off in ghetto neighborhoods. Families who depend on them for support are also made worse off by high incarceration rates and the treatment of ex-convicts. Rogers rightly worries that if convicted felons were to be ineligible for basic income, they would likely become a permanent laboring underclass, forever stigmatized, exploited, and poor. But given the employment discrimination they face (particularly if they are black), many would turn, not to menial labor, but back to crime and so likely end up re-incarcerated, where a for-profit prison might still exploit their labor. Given the history of slavery and Jim Crow—three and a half centuries of gross and far-reaching injustices—no one can plausibly argue that the current, racially skewed distribution of resources is entirely the result of just appropriations and fair market exchanges. Nothing approaching adequate reparations for slavery or Jim Crow have been offered to the descendants of slaves or the victims of the segregation regime. Given that contemporary ghetto poverty is plausibly explained, at least in part, by historical injustices in appropriation and transfer (what some term structural racism), it is far from clear that welfare conditional on work or the denial of public benefits to former felons is justifiable. Therefore one of the strengths of basic income is that it would empower marginalized black workers by enabling them to refuse demeaning, insecure, exploitative, and low-paying jobs. They could do so without having to live in degrading forms of poverty and without having to bear the risks of the underground economy. Basic income would deal a real blow to ghettoization and mass incarceration. It would not solve all problems of racial or economic injustice. But any civil rights–labor alliance should seriously consider fighting for it.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
Extend – Solvency - Stigma

A UBI dispels racist stereotypes about welfare – stigmatization undermines the effectiveness of programs because dehumanization deters people from participating.

Bidadanure, 2019 - prof of Philosophy, Stanford University [Juliana Uhuru, Mar 5, Annual Review of Political Science “The Political Theory of Universal Basic Income” TA]

Last, but not least, UBI could help disrupt the racial tropes and racial resentment pervasive around the existing welfare system. Negative racist stereotypes of lazy black youth and welfare mothers have important consequences. For a start, they force those in need to think twice before claiming benefits, the risk of stigmatization and demonization being high. This explains in part low take-up rates. Racial tropes also serve to shame recipients to keep them in check and incentivize them further to find employment. Furthermore, there is now ample evidence that racial resentment contributes to low support for welfare. Even when programs do not in fact benefit nonwhites more than whites, the myth of the lazy black recipient contributes to a welfare backlash. The pervasiveness of racial stereotypes is thus concerning both because demonized populations are less likely to enjoy the full benefits of assistance and because it contributes to a welfare backlash that is worrying from a progressive perspective. A universal income support system would be less likely to stigmatize the target population, since all members of the community would get a UBI. If benefits are destigmatized, those worse off are less likely to suffer self-respect harms and to drop out of programs they require to live well.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
Extend – Solvency – Poverty

A Basic Income reduces racial inequality and poverty – research shows that it can close the racial income gap.

Chambers et al, 2022 – prof of political science at Trinity College [Stefani, with Abby Nick and Maddie Granato, May 3 “The Benefits of Guaranteed Basic Income: Lessons from Advocates” Acc 3/23/23 TA]

CONCLUSION Guaranteed basic income greatly reduces the need in communities and allows citizens to gain individual agency and make choices about their spending. By putting cash directly into people’s pockets we can combat income inequality and racial and generational poverty in the Connecticut area. Many lessons can be learned from both local and national basic income advocates that will help CWEALF advance similar programs. Advocates warned against opponents’ use of coded racist language explaining that much opposition to basic income programs is rooted in racial and economic discrimination. Furthermore, advocates recommend that programs focus on achieving individual agency and personal choice, a lesson proven in the research-based findings from various pilot programs. Recipients in three separate pilot programs reported increased individual agency and decision-making abilities. Finally, advocates urged that there is no better time to advocate for GBI programs as the pandemic has changed the dialogue around GBI and UBI. This is due in part to the high levels of unemployment and the stimulus checks that occurred as a result of COVID-19. In addition, there is much to be learned from recent initiatives for guaranteed or universal basic income in the US. These pilot programs have shown many positive research-based findings including increased mental and physical health. Decrease in unemployment and increase in civil and familial participation. These outcomes show that GBI will increase women’s opportunities to accumulate wealth, improve family health, and reduce reliance on other governmental programs. The fight for GBI is an important one in the state of Connecticut and CWEALF as an organization. Connecticut has one of the largest income inequalities in the country. Specifically, Hartford and New Haven have major issues in generational poverty (and compared to overall wealth in-state). More cash in people’s pockets keeps families financially secure and stimulates the local economy. Furthermore, GBI could reduce the racial income gap and finally bring many black families and individuals above the poverty line.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
Extend – Solvency – Poverty

A UBI helps African Americans who are disproportionately affected by unemployment.

Warren, 2017 – Fellow at the Roosevelt Institute [Dorian, May 3, Boston Review, “Reparations and Basic Income Basic income could function as reparations.” Acc 3/23/23 TA]

I come to basic income from a very different political tradition: black politics with a focus on race and political economy. It is this tradition that led both Martin Luther King, Jr., and the Black Panther Party to argue for full employment and a “guaranteed income” fifty years ago. Though they wanted these specifically for African Americans, they hoped they would be made available to all Americans. Five decades later it is about time the rest of us caught up to their vision. Black workers today face the exact same dual crisis of high unemployment and low-wage work that they did fifty years ago. The black unemployment rate is twice that of white workers at nearly every level of education. Thus one need not be only concerned with future trends to speculate that a basic income would help black Americans today, especially those who continue to be locked out of access to labor markets.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
Extend – Solvency – Poverty

A basic income disproportionately helps minorities because poverty and the pandemic hit them the hardest.

Bates, 2023 - writer for The Grio [Josiah January 23, The Grio “Some guaranteed income programs are ending, even as they gain popularity nationwide” TA]

At least 45 cities in the country started some kind of guaranteed income pilot program in 2020 or a few years preceding. The number of programs increased in the pandemic’s wake. Generally, a lottery determines recipients from a pool of eligible applicants. Payments vary from $200 to $1,000 a month. Some cities issue bi-weekly payments. “I was headed towards a deep depression, literally just a week prior to getting the call that I was accepted to the program,” Shamonique Jones, a Newark, New Jersey, resident told ABC News. Jones is a single mother who lives with her four children in a one-bedroom apartment. “I didn’t know how I was gonna get my kids’ uniforms [for school] … I was able to use that to get them their uniforms for school and be able to help us with the holidays and be able to provide Christmas presents for them. It just saved our lives.” Tashonna, a 24-year-old Louisville woman, told the Courier-Journal that her monthly payment of $500 from the city’s guaranteed income program lightens her burden. “It gives you a really big cushion to just make those decisions. If I have $500, do I still need another job or is this enough for me?” The pandemic disproportionately affected Black households, a number of which already survived in poverty. Before the outbreak, the unemployment rate for Black citizens in America was just over 6%. By the time COVID-19 hit, it exceeded 16%. Mayors for Guaranteed Income, a coalition that advocates for more cities to adopt guaranteed income programs, released a dataset that included demographic details and spending information on 20 pilot programs in America. Forty-one percent of the program participants were Black, and 77% of them were women.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
Extend – Solvency – Wealth Gap

Income transfers are necessary to close the racial wealth gap which has built up by centuries of racist institutions.

Ray and Perry 2020 – Senior Fellows at the Brookings Institution [Rashawn Ray and Andre M. Perry, April 15, 2020, Brookings Institution, “Why we need reparations for Black Americans” , June 22, 2023, LN]

Today, the average white family has roughly 10 times the amount of wealth as the average Black family. White college graduates have over seven times more wealth than Black college graduates. Making the American Dream an equitable reality demands the same U.S. government that denied wealth to Blacks restore that deferred wealth through reparations to their descendants in the form of individual cash payments in the amount that will close the Black-white racial wealth divide. Additionally, reparations should come in the form of wealth-building opportunities that address racial disparities in education, housing, and business ownership. In 1860, over $3 billion was the value assigned to the physical bodies of enslaved Black Americans to be used as free labor and production. This was more money than was invested in factories and railroads combined. In 1861, the value placed on cotton produced by enslaved Blacks was $250 million. Slavery enriched white slave owners and their descendants, and it fueled the country’s economy while suppressing wealth building for the enslaved. The United States has yet to compensate descendants of enslaved Black Americans for their labor. Nor has the federal government atoned for the lost equity from anti-Black housing, transportation, and business policy. Slavery, Jim Crow segregation, anti-Black practices like redlining, and other discriminatory public policies in criminal justice and education have robbed Black Americans of the opportunities to build wealth (defined as assets minus debt) afforded to their white peers.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
Extend – Solvency – Wealth Gap

Reparations are necessary to close the racial wealth gap in order to compensate for lost wages

Ray and Perry 2020 – Senior Fellows at the Brookings Institution [Rashawn Ray and Andre M. Perry, April 15, 2020, Brookings Institution, “Why we need reparations for Black Americans” , June 22, 2023, LN]

We know the monetary value that was placed on enslaved Blacks and the productivity of their labor, as well as the amount of the racial wealth gap. We’ve seen other groups receive restitutions while the federal government pulled back reparations for Black Americans. Accordingly, if we want to close the racial wealth gap and live up to our moral creed to protect “life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness,” a federal reparations package for Black Americans is in order. This package should include individual and collective public benefits that simultaneously builds wealth and eliminates debt among Black citizens. We assert that it should be similar to the Harriet Tubman Community Investment Act, which was recently heard before the Maryland General Assembly where Ray testified on its behalf. The Harriet Tubman Community Investment Act aims to atone for slavery and its legacy by addressing education, homeownership, and business ownership barriers. Individual payments for descendants of enslaved Black Americans The U.S. government owes lost wages as well as damages to the people it helped enslave. In addition to the lost wages, the accumulative amount of restitution for individuals should eliminate the racial wealth gap that currently exists. According to the Federal Reserve’s most recent numbers in 2016, based on the Survey of Consumer Finances, white families had the highest median family wealth at $171,000, compared to Black and Hispanic families, which had $17,600 and $20,700, respectively.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
Extend – Solvency – Wealth Gap

A UBI+ is anti-racist because it addresses disproportionate black unemployment and would account for accumulated inequality

Warren, 2017 – founder of The Economic Security Project [Dorian, Oct 10, “A Universal Basic Income +” Acc 3/23/23 TA]

We should imagine a robust UBI that advances racial and gender justice while simultaneously addressing the ills of 21st century capitalism. In fact, there is a model of UBI which is not only acceptable, but preferable to common proposals: The Universal PLUS Basic Income. It is identical to most UBI proposals but includes a pro-rated, additional amount for black Americans over a specified period of time. The Universal PLUS Basic Income draws on the concept of “targeted universalism” in designing social policies. Such a proposal would take into account the historical and cumulative disadvantages of income, wealth and inheritance afflicting black communities, and it would recognize that potential changes in the nature of work will disproportionately hurt black Americans. It would effectively function as reparations, in a grand bargain with white America: All would benefit, but those who suffered through slavery and continuing racism in the economy would benefit slightly more.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
Extend - Misperceptions

Misperceptions of the racial wealth gap are crucial because wealth reflects the culmination of past racist structures.

Kraus et al, 2019 - Sustainability Research Institute at the University of Leeds [Michael, with Ivuoma N. Onyeador, Natalie M. Daumeyer, Julian M. Rucker, Jennifer A. Richeson September 10 Perspectives on Psychological Science, “The Misperception of Racial Economic Inequality” https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/1745691619863049#tab-contributors KB]

Misperceiving the wealth gap Our analyses thus far examined perceptions of equality on a composite index of five economic outcomes, but disaggregating these findings reveals that the misperception of wealth equality is particularly severe (see Kraus et al., 2017). This is especially distressing given that wealth is the most consequential index of economic well-being, in that it provides a more effective safety net for families when facing unexpected financial shocks relative to other economic indicators, such as income (Darity, Hamilton, & Stewart, 2015; Hamilton, Darity, Price, Sridharan, & Tippett, 2015). Because it takes wealth to grow wealth, it is especially important to discern the extent to which Americans are (or perhaps are not) aware of the racial wealth gap in contemporary American society. Critically, the cumulative nature of wealth makes it particularly vulnerable to the effects of both past and contemporary discriminatory policies and practices (e.g., chattel slavery, Jim Crow, redlining)—practices that helped to produce the wealth gap in the first place and make it difficult for everyday Americans to track, or perhaps acknowledge, its magnitude across time. For these reasons, we conducted a nationally representative survey of American adults to examine perceptions of the racial wealth gap. The survey was broadly representative of the United States in terms of region, income, gender, and race (see Supplemental Material available online). As in our prior work, we expected respondents to underestimate the racial wealth gap between Black and White Americans across time (from 1963 to 2016). We also expected the overestimates to be greater in magnitude in the present than in the past, reflecting the American narrative of racial progress.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
Extend - Misperceptions

Misperceptions of Racism are widespread - Americans are willfully ignorant of racial inequality – research proves

Kraus et al, 2019 - Sustainability Research Institute at the University of Leeds [Michael, with Ivuoma N. Onyeador, Natalie M. Daumeyer, Julian M. Rucker, Jennifer A. Richeson September 10 Perspectives on Psychological Science, “The Misperception of Racial Economic Inequality” https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/1745691619863049#tab-contributors KB]

Abstract Racial economic inequality is a foundational feature of the United States, yet many Americans appear oblivious to it. In the present work we consider the psychology underlying this collective willful ignorance. Drawing on prior research and new evidence from a nationally representative sample of adults (N = 1,008), we offer compelling evidence that Americans vastly underestimate racial economic inequality, especially the racial wealth gap. In particular, respondents thought that the Black–White wealth gap was smaller, by around 40 percentage points in 1963 and around 80 percentage points in 2016, than its actual size. We then consider the motivational, cognitive, and structural factors that are likely to contribute to these misperceptions and suggest directions for future research to test these ideas. Importantly, we highlight the implications of our collective ignorance of racial economic inequality and the challenge of creating greater accuracy in perceptions of these racial economic disparities, as well as outline the steps policymakers might take to create messages on this topic that effectively promote equity-enhancing policies. We close with an appeal to psychological science to at least consider, if not center, the racial patterning of these profound economic gaps. Despite America’s tumultuous racial history (Massey & Denton, 1993), Americans generally believe the nation has made steady, consistent progress toward achieving racial equality (Brodish, Brazy, & Devine, 2008; Eibach & Keegan, 2006; Fisman, Jakiela, Kariv, & Markovits, 2015; Kraus & Tan, 2015). Narratives highlighting America’s path toward, if not achievement of, racial equality dominate national discourse, are widely communicated in both literature and popular culture, and are strongly endorsed in attitude surveys (Reeves, 2018). In this article, we argue and offer evidence that these beliefs about the inevitable march toward racial equality, especially in the context of wealth, are overly optimistic and unfounded.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
Extend – Moral Obligation

Reparations are justified by the fact that we are still living in a nation that was literally built by slave labor, which has never been compensated.

Inwood et al, ’20 - Department of Geography and Rock Ethics Institute, Pennsylvania State University [Joshua F.J. Anna Brand, Elise Quinn, December 19, 2020, Antipode, “Racial Capital, Abolition, and a Geographic Argument for Reparations”, , June 24, 2023, LN]

Debates over reparations for enslaved peoples began after the US Civil War, and over the century and a half since, these debates have taken different forms and have enjoyed varying degrees of political support (Craemer 2018). More recently, with the publication of Ta-Nehisi Coates’(2014) piece, “The case for reparations”, discussions over reparations have moved back into the political mainstream. We argue that understanding Lehman Brothers’historical develop- ment, from slavery through segregation and more contemporary practices of predatory lending, advances a geographic argument for reparations that attends directly to the political, economic and spatial contours of racial capitalism and directs our attention to the geographical promises of abolition democracy. Our argument for a geography of reparations not only incorporates broader discus- sions about infrastructure created by the enslaved (Cowen 2020)—the railroad lines initially built by the enslaved still in service—but speaks to a more fundamen- tal understanding of the way slavery gave rise to a range of financial practices and institutions that continue broader processes of capital exploitation. As we demonstrate, small business operators like the Lehman brothers pioneered a range of financial practices that foreshadow the contemporary financial land- scape. We argue the very foundations of the modern economy rest on the enslaved and the unfolding of the American political economy. By engaging in a broad reading of abolition democracy and connecting the projects of abolition with reparations we engage with the realities of racial capitalism and make a case for a geographic reading of reparations within an abolition framework for justice.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
Extend – Health Harms

The racial wealth gap destroys health, education, and resilience to economic downturns.

Ray and Perry 2020 – Senior Fellows at the Brookings Institution [Rashawn Ray and Andre M. Perry, April 15, 2020, Brookings Institution, “Why we need reparations for Black Americans” , June 22, 2023, LN]

Not only do racial wealth disparities reveal fallacies in the American Dream, the financial and social consequences are significant and wide-ranging. Wealth is positively correlated with better health, educational, and economic outcomes. Furthermore, assets from homes, stocks, bonds, and retirement savings provide a financial safety net for the inevitable shocks to the economy and personal finances that happen throughout a person’s lifespan. Recessions impact everyone, but wealth is distributed quite unevenly in the U.S. The woeful inadequacy of a government-sponsored safety net was made apparent in the wake of economic disasters like the 2008 housing crisis and natural ones like Hurricane Katrina in 2005. Those who can draw upon the equity in a home, savings, and securities are able to recover faster after economic downturns than those without wealth. The lack of a social safety net and the racial wealth divide are currently on display amid the COVID-19 crisis. Disparities in access to health care along with inequities in economic policies combine to make Black people more vulnerable to negative consequences than white individuals.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
Extend – History of Structural Racism

Wealth accumulation in America has plundered the lives and bodies of African Americans – the current distribution is a culmination of centuries of structural racism

Coates, 2014 – MacArthur Fellowship Winner. [Ta-Nehisi, June The Atlantic “THE CASE FOR REPARATIONS” https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2014/06/the-case-for-reparations/361631/ KB]

IV. “The Ills That Slavery Frees Us From” America begins in black plunder and white democracy, two features that are not contradictory but complementary. “The men who came together to found the independent United States, dedicated to freedom and equality, either held slaves or were willing to join hands with those who did,” the historian Edmund S. Morgan wrote. “None of them felt entirely comfortable about the fact, but neither did they feel responsible for it. Most of them had inherited both their slaves and their attachment to freedom from an earlier generation, and they knew the two were not unconnected.” Slaves in South Carolina prepare cotton for the gin in 1862. (Timothy H. O’sullivan/Library of Congress) When enslaved Africans, plundered of their bodies, plundered of their families, and plundered of their labor, were brought to the colony of Virginia in 1619, they did not initially endure the naked racism that would engulf their progeny. Some of them were freed. Some of them intermarried. Still others escaped with the white indentured servants who had suffered as they had. Some even rebelled together, allying under Nathaniel Bacon to torch Jamestown in 1676. One hundred years later, the idea of slaves and poor whites joining forces would shock the senses, but in the early days of the English colonies, the two groups had much in common. English visitors to Virginia found that its masters “abuse their servantes with intollerable oppression and hard usage.” White servants were flogged, tricked into serving beyond their contracts, and traded in much the same manner as slaves. This “hard usage” originated in a simple fact of the New World—land was boundless but cheap labor was limited. As life spans increased in the colony, the Virginia planters found in the enslaved Africans an even more efficient source of cheap labor. Whereas indentured servants were still legal subjects of the English crown and thus entitled to certain protections, African slaves entered the colonies as aliens. Exempted from the protections of the crown, they became early America’s indispensable working class—fit for maximum exploitation, capable of only minimal resistance. For the next 250 years, American law worked to reduce black people to a class of untouchables and raise all white men to the level of citizens. In 1650, Virginia mandated that “all persons except Negroes” were to carry arms. In 1664, Maryland mandated that any Englishwoman who married a slave must live as a slave of her husband’s master. In 1705, the Virginia assembly passed a law allowing for the dismemberment of unruly slaves—but forbidding masters from whipping “a Christian white servant naked, without an order from a justice of the peace.” In that same law, the colony mandated that “all horses, cattle, and hogs, now belonging, or that hereafter shall belong to any slave” be seized and sold off by the local church, the profits used to support “the poor of the said parish.” At that time, there would have still been people alive who could remember blacks and whites joining to burn down Jamestown only 29 years before. But at the beginning of the 18th century, two primary classes were enshrined in America. “The two great divisions of society are not the rich and poor, but white and black,” John C. Calhoun, South Carolina’s senior senator, declared on the Senate floor in 1848. “And all the former, the poor as well as the rich, belong to the upper class, and are respected and treated as equals.” In 1860, the majority of people living in South Carolina and Mississippi, almost half of those living in Georgia, and about one-third of all Southerners were on the wrong side of Calhoun’s line. The state with the largest number of enslaved Americans was Virginia, where in certain counties some 70 percent of all people labored in chains. Nearly one-fourth of all white Southerners owned slaves, and upon their backs the economic basis of America—and much of the Atlantic world—was erected. In the seven cotton states, one-third of all white income was derived from slavery. By 1840, cotton produced by slave labor constituted 59 percent of the country’s exports. The web of this slave society extended north to the looms of New England, and across the Atlantic to Great Britain, where it powered a great economic transformation and altered the trajectory of world history. “Whoever says Industrial Revolution,” wrote the historian Eric J. Hobsbawm, “says cotton.” The wealth accorded America by slavery was not just in what the slaves pulled from the land but in the slaves themselves. “In 1860, slaves as an asset were worth more than all of America’s manufacturing, all of the railroads, all of the productive capacity of the United States put together,” the Yale historian David W. Blight has noted. “Slaves were the single largest, by far, financial asset of property in the entire American economy.” The sale of these slaves—“in whose bodies that money congealed,” writes Walter Johnson, a Harvard historian—generated even more ancillary wealth. Loans were taken out for purchase, to be repaid with interest. Insurance policies were drafted against the untimely death of a slave and the loss of potential profits. Slave sales were taxed and notarized. The vending of the black body and the sundering of the black family became an economy unto themselves, estimated to have brought in tens of millions of dollars to antebellum America. In 1860 there were more millionaires per capita in the Mississippi Valley than anywhere else in the country.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
Extend – History of Structural Racism

Structural racism has precluded the accumulation of wealth by black families – housing discrimination prevented African Americans from building equity in homes.

Coates, 2014 – MacArthur Fellowship Winner. [Ta-Nehisi, June The Atlantic “THE CASE FOR REPARATIONS” https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2014/06/the-case-for-reparations/361631/ KB]

Elegant Racism “If you sought to advantage one group of Americans and disadvantage another, you could scarcely choose a more graceful method than housing discrimination.” Read more It was in these early years that Ross began to understand himself as an American—he did not live under the blind decree of justice, but under the heel of a regime that elevated armed robbery to a governing principle. He thought about fighting. “Just be quiet,” his father told him. “Because they’ll come and kill us all.” Clyde Ross grew. He was drafted into the Army. The draft officials offered him an exemption if he stayed home and worked. He preferred to take his chances with war. He was stationed in California. He found that he could go into stores without being bothered. He could walk the streets without being harassed. He could go into a restaurant and receive service. Ross was shipped off to Guam. He fought in World War II to save the world from tyranny. But when he returned to Clarksdale, he found that tyranny had followed him home. This was 1947, eight years before Mississippi lynched Emmett Till and tossed his broken body into the Tallahatchie River. The Great Migration, a mass exodus of 6 million African Americans that spanned most of the 20th century, was now in its second wave. The black pilgrims did not journey north simply seeking better wages and work, or bright lights and big adventures. They were fleeing the acquisitive warlords of the South. They were seeking the protection of the law. Clyde Ross was among them. He came to Chicago in 1947 and took a job as a taster at Campbell’s Soup. He made a stable wage. He married. He had children. His paycheck was his own. No Klansmen stripped him of the vote. When he walked down the street, he did not have to move because a white man was walking past. He did not have to take off his hat or avert his gaze. His journey from peonage to full citizenship seemed near-complete. Only one item was missing—a home, that final badge of entry into the sacred order of the American middle class of the Eisenhower years. In 1961, Ross and his wife bought a house in North Lawndale, a bustling community on Chicago’s West Side. North Lawndale had long been a predominantly Jewish neighborhood, but a handful of middle-class African Americans had lived there starting in the ’40s. The community was anchored by the sprawling Sears, Roebuck headquarters. North Lawndale’s Jewish People’s Institute actively encouraged blacks to move into the neighborhood, seeking to make it a “pilot community for interracial living.” In the battle for integration then being fought around the country, North Lawndale seemed to offer promising terrain. But out in the tall grass, highwaymen, nefarious as any Clarksdale kleptocrat, were lying in wait. From the 1930s through the 1960s, black people across the country were largely cut out of the legitimate home-mortgage market. Three months after Clyde Ross moved into his house, the boiler blew out. This would normally be a homeowner’s responsibility, but in fact, Ross was not really a homeowner. His payments were made to the seller, not the bank. And Ross had not signed a normal mortgage. He’d bought “on contract”: a predatory agreement that combined all the responsibilities of homeownership with all the disadvantages of renting—while offering the benefits of neither. Ross had bought his house for $27,500. The seller, not the previous homeowner but a new kind of middleman, had bought it for only $12,000 six months before selling it to Ross. In a contract sale, the seller kept the deed until the contract was paid in full—and, unlike with a normal mortgage, Ross would acquire no equity in the meantime. If he missed a single payment, he would immediately forfeit his $1,000 down payment, all his monthly payments, and the property itself. The men who peddled contracts in North Lawndale would sell homes at inflated prices and then evict families who could not pay—taking their down payment and their monthly installments as profit. Then they’d bring in another black family, rinse, and repeat. “He loads them up with payments they can’t meet,” an office secretary told The Chicago Daily News of her boss, the speculator Lou Fushanis, in 1963. “Then he takes the property away from them. He’s sold some of the buildings three or four times.” Ross had tried to get a legitimate mortgage in another neighborhood, but was told by a loan officer that there was no financing available. The truth was that there was no financing for people like Clyde Ross. From the 1930s through the 1960s, black people across the country were largely cut out of the legitimate home-mortgage market through means both legal and extralegal. Chicago whites employed every measure, from “restrictive covenants” to bombings, to keep their neighborhoods segregated. Their efforts were buttressed by the federal government. In 1934, Congress created the Federal Housing Administration. The FHA insured private mortgages, causing a drop in interest rates and a decline in the size of the down payment required to buy a house. But an insured mortgage was not a possibility for Clyde Ross. The FHA had adopted a system of maps that rated neighborhoods according to their perceived stability. On the maps, green areas, rated “A,” indicated “in demand” neighborhoods that, as one appraiser put it, lacked “a single foreigner or Negro.” These neighborhoods were considered excellent prospects for insurance. Neighborhoods where black people lived were rated “D” and were usually considered ineligible for FHA backing. They were colored in red. Neither the percentage of black people living there nor their social class mattered. Black people were viewed as a contagion. Redlining went beyond FHA-backed loans and spread to the entire mortgage industry, which was already rife with racism, excluding black people from most legitimate means of obtaining a mortgage. Explore Redlining in Chicago A 1939 Home Owners’ Loan Corporation “Residential Security Map” of Chicago shows discrimination against low-income and minority neighborhoods. The residents of the areas marked in red (representing “hazardous” real-estate markets) were denied FHA-backed mortgages. (Map development by Frankie Dintino) “A government offering such bounty to builders and lenders could have required compliance with a nondiscrimination policy,” Charles Abrams, the urban-studies expert who helped create the New York City Housing Authority, wrote in 1955. “Instead, the FHA adopted a racial policy that could well have been culled from the Nuremberg laws.” The devastating effects are cogently outlined by Melvin L. Oliver and Thomas M. Shapiro in their 1995 book, Black Wealth/White Wealth: Locked out of the greatest mass-based opportunity for wealth accumulation in American history, African Americans who desired and were able to afford home ownership found themselves consigned to central-city communities where their investments were affected by the “self-fulfilling prophecies” of the FHA appraisers: cut off from sources of new investment[,] their homes and communities deteriorated and lost value in comparison to those homes and communities that FHA appraisers deemed desirable.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
Extend – History of Structural Racism

Racial exploitation has continued from slavery through current predatory lending practices – reparations are necessary to challenge this entire Structure – other solutions are short sighted.

Inwood et al, ’20 - Department of Geography and Rock Ethics Institute, Pennsylvania State University [Joshua F.J. Anna Brand, Elise Quinn, December 19, 2020, Antipode, “Racial Capital, Abolition, and a Geographic Argument for Reparations”, , June 24, 2023, LN]

This is indicative of the way Lehman Brothers and other Wall Street firms stoked and profited off of the subprime mortgage market and engaged in practices that targeted vulnerable communities. In a series of articles, sociologist Jacob Faber (2013) found that even when they met income and other requirements that could have qualified for better loans, Blacks and Latinos were disproportionately targeted for subprime loans with higher fees and cost more money. In other words, “wealthier minorities were targeted for subprime loans when they could have qualified for prime loans”(Faber 2013:328). Cowen and Lewis (2017:274) note that the effects of the subprime loan crisis are massive, displacing thousands of “Black people from the inner city and the dramatic dispossession of Black wealth”. These extractive and exploitative prac- tices directly connect Lehman Brothers and other Wall Street financial services with much longer legacies of discrimination and exploitative practices outlined in the firm’s history. Far from seeing the 2007 mortgage crisis and subprime mort- gages as anathema to the system, it is central to understanding how variegated landscapes of difference are central to capital’s workings. By focusing on Lehman Brothers and the rise from dry goods salesmen, to cotton factors, to commodity traders to a global financial behemoth, and at every step of this growth and change, the variegated landscape of racial exploitation was the foundation stone on which their profits rested. The mortgage and investment products pushed on minority communities were designed to extract the maximum profit from these communities, and these prof- its were bundled and sold to investors. These extractive practices were rolled into myriad pension plans, retirement plans, 401ks, and other investments that pushed Lehman stock prices into record territory. As we argue in the next section, this fuller history calls into question the broader debate about reparations. If the sys- tem itself, as we argue, is entirely and wholly wrapped in race in ways that extend and advance practices of exploitation that are rooted in the very structure of capi- tal itself, then reparations that do not fundamentally undermine, transform, or destabilise the system of extraction, then these are short-term solutions to long-term structural problems. Given the way capital relies on geographic configurations of place and power, geography must be central to this rethinking and reorganising of capital. Reparations are central to that project.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
Extend – History of Structural Racism

An American history of institutional racism has left African Americans with an enormous racial wealth gap. This devastates black communities, denying them health care and exposing them to the Pandemic.

Farooqi, 2021 – LA Times columnist [Sana, Mar 21 HPHR “The Case for Universal Basic Income as a Tool for racial Justice” https://hphr.org/30-article-farooqui/ KB]

The racial wealth gaps in the United States stem from the country’s foundation, when indigenous lands were colonized and reaped for white Americans’ profit by enslaved and uncompensated Black labor. Enslaved Black Americans were denied centuries of wealth accumulation. Post Emancipation, failure to follow through with the 40-acres land grant policy further stymied Black wealth-gathering.6 Simultaneous legal measures like segregation and the collapse of the Freedman’s Savings Bank continued to strip Black people of economic gains. State-sanctioned violence in wealthy Black communities like Wilmington, North Carolina and later in Tulsa, Oklahoma continued economic dispossession, reversing even whispers of prosperity.6 Adding insult to injury, Black Americans were barred from the same structural wealth-gathering mechanisms provided to white Americans, such as the initial Social Security Act, the benefits of the GI Bill, and access to nonpredatory housing loans.7 Indeed, Black Americans were expected to pay into Social Security benefits they couldn’t access, and fight for a country that would explicitly deny them resources afforded to others. More recently, redlining, occupational segregation, and disproportionate incarceration feeds the cycle of racialized wealth dispossession. Redlining forces Black and brown Americans into living on underfunded and often environmentally unsafe areas. This modern segregation removes access to resources such as bank loans (which factor in zip-codes as a risk predictor), well-funded schools, and even nutritionally competent grocery stores. A lack of access to well-funded schools hurt students’ chances of applying for and receiving higher education, which in turn limits entry to well-paying jobs with health insurance and potential savings. Higher police presence in redlined areas and the racially based criminalization of minor offences lead to disproportionately higher numbers of incarcerated Black and brown men. Due to both the stigma of imprisonment and stunted career growth, this results in a loss of income during incarceration and reduced opportunities post-release.7 The cycle of racially driven economic harm is institutionally supported by past and current policies. The consequences are stark: the median wealth for Black families in 2019 was $17,000, compared to $171,000 for white families.6 In other words, Black families have $10 in assets compared to every $100 for white families.8 Similarly, in 2019 a full 19 percent of Black households had zero or negative net worth, compared to 9 percent of white households; that the COVID-19 pandemic has widened this disparity is not an unfounded assumption.6 The idea that this state of affairs illustrates a specific failure of Black Americans to pull themselves up by the bootstraps is both offensive and laughable; how is it possible when they’re constantly denied boots to even wear. As the COVID-19 pandemic has displayed, there is a tangible health-based toll to this systemic racism. Reduced life expectancies, higher rates of premature death (almost 30 percent), barriers to regular healthcare, and continuous exposure to zip code-based environmental toxins are all manifestations of racism and racist policies.8 Public health practitioners are aware of this, though the more palatable phrase “the social determinants of health” is often used to describe these effects; never mind that the social determinants of health are upheld by a legacy of racism. Regardless, these health and economic disparities are driven by structural policies, and therefore require a structural solution for change and rectification. The time to implement change is immediate, with the difference of wealth between white Americans and people of color at its highest point in 25 years.7 The pandemic’s economic fallout is already worsening this divide and will continue to do so unless bold action is taken.