2023
MNDI
Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › Solvency – Unions
Clemens 20 [Jeffrey & Michael R. Strain; October 2020; associate professor of economics at UC San Diego; director of Economic Policy Studies and the Arthur F. Burns Scholar in Political Economy at the American Enterprise Institute; National Bureau of Economic Research; “Public Policy and Participation in Political Interest Groups: An Analysis of Minimum Wages, Labor Unions, and Effective Advocacy”; 10.3386/w27902 KF]
Why do individuals join interest groups? Through what channels do interest groups and public policy affect one another? We study these questions by analyzing the interplay among labor unions, minimum wages, news coverage, and public opinion. Over the past decade, labor unions have played a significant role in advocating for state and federal minimum wage increases. Over this period, we find that each dollar in minimum wage increase predicts a 5 percent increase (0.3 pp) in the union membership rate among individuals age 16–40. We document four additional facts that shed light on the mechanisms that may underlie this finding. First, while we find increases overall in union membership, we find declines among the minimum wage’s most direct beneficiaries. This is consistent with a classic “free-riding” hypothesis. Second, we find increases in union membership among much broader groups that are not directly affected by the minimum wage. Third, we find that minimum wage increases predict increases in unions’ favorability ratings among the public. Fourth, we find that events in the legislative histories of minimum wage increases predict increases in counts of newspaper articles that simultaneously discuss the minimum wage and key players in the labor movement. Overall coverage of organized labor shifts towards articles that discuss the minimum wage. These facts are consistent with models in which a desire to affiliate with “effective advocacy” is an important driver of the decision to participate in unions and other politically oriented groups. Jeffrey Clemens Department of Economics University of California, San Diego 9500 Gilman Drive #0508 La Jolla, CA 92093 and NBER jeffclemens@ucsd.edu Michael R. Strain American Enterprise Institute 1789 Massachusetts Avenue, NW Washington, DC 20036 and IZA michael.strain@aei.org 2
2023
MNDI
Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › U – Racial wage gap
Derencourt et al 20 [Ellora, Clair Montialoux, Kate Bahn, “Why minimum wages are a critical tool for achieving racial justice in the U.S. labor market” https://equitablegrowth.org/why-minimum-wages-are-a-critical-tool-for-achieving-racial-justice-in-the-u-s-labor-market/]
Black and Latinx workers also are more likely to experience wage theft, where they are paid less than the statutory minimum wage by their employers, because of the ineffective enforcement of minimum wage standards. According to new research by Rutgers University labor market researchers Janice Fine, Jenn Round, Daniel Galvin, and Hana Shepherd, Black workers are 50 percent more likely than White workers to experience a minimum wage violation, and Latinx workers are 84 percent more likely to experience this serious labor market problem. Black women who are not U.S. citizens are 3.7 times—370 percent—more likely to experience a minimum wage violation, compared to White male U.S. citizens.
2023
MNDI
Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › Solvency – Racial wage gap
Wursten 22 [Jesse and Michael Reich “Racial Inequality and Minimum Wages in Frictional Labor Markets” https://irle.berkeley.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/racial-inequality-and-minimum-wages-in-frictional-labor-markets-12-23-22.pdf]
Racial wage inequality has increased since the 1980s; in the same period a patchwork of state minimum wages has developed, with lower minimum wages in states with higher proportions of black workers. Our causal analysis indicates that minimum wage policies have nonetheless reduced the racial wage gap (-10 percent in the overall economy, -56 percent for workers with at most a high school diploma earning less than $20 per hour). Moreover, the indirect benefits of these policies have led to wage gains for black workers that exceed the mechanical effect implied by strict policy compliance. This result is consistent with previous studies showing that affected workers largely spend their increased earnings to acquire a car. We demonstrate that the direct earnings effects of minimum wage policy are amplified as more black workers commute by car, allowing them to reach better paying jobs outside their previous search radius.
2023
MNDI
Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › Solvency – Racial wage gap
Derenoncourt 20 [Ellora and Claire Montialoux; economists at the University of California, Berkeley; 10-25; “To Reduce Racial Inequality, Raise the Minimum Wage,” https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/25/opinion/minimum-wage-race-protests.html]
Due to occupational segregation, discrimination, and other impacts of systemic racism, racial pay disparities are one of the persistent, structural features of the U.S. labor market (Wilson and Rodgers 2016). Despite some historical progress, in 2019 Hispanic workers were being paid 10.8% less than white workers with similar ages and education levels, and Black workers were being paid 14.9% less than comparable white workers (Gould 2020). Our analysis of shares of workers affected, combined with recent research on minimum wages and racial income and earnings gaps, indicates that raising the minimum wage to $15 by 2025 would substantially reduce racial pay inequality. Figure C shows that while the raise would increase wages for less than one out of five (18.4%) white workers, about one in three (31.3%) Black workers and one in four (26.0%) Hispanic workers would receive a pay increase. Because they are particularly underpaid, women of color would disproportionately benefit from the Raise the Wage Act: 22.9% of those who would receive pay increases are Black or Hispanic women.
2023
MNDI
Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › Solvency – Racial wage gap
Khan ‘22 [Ashfaq and Rose Khattar; 7-7-2022; Former Policy Analyst; Director of Economic Analysis at Inclusive Economy, former economist at the Australian Treasury Department; Center for American Progress, "It's Long Past Time To Increase the Federal Minimum Wage", ]
Significant disparities exist across states Currently, there are 20 states that don’t have a minimum wage higher than the federally mandated minimum wage. (see Figure 1) States that have raised their minimum wages beyond the federal level have helped millions of low wage workers receive larger paychecks to better provide for themselves and their families. However, these increases have not occurred widely, with most states in the South having not raised their wages above the federally mandated $7.25 minimum. In 2021, more than half (53 percent) of all workers who earned at or below the federal minimum wage lived in the South, a region that is disproportionately African American, resulting in wide racial inequities. Furthermore, eight states—which include California, Nevada, Oregon, Washington, Minnesota, Montana, Alaska, and Hawaii—have abolished subminimum wages. Meanwhile 16 states, disproportionately in the South, use the federal tipped minimum wage of $2.13 per hour, adding to unequal wages across states. [GRAPH OMITTED] The failure of states in the South to increase their minimum wages has contributed to racial inequity—that is, part of the reason for large racial income gaps is because many Black workers live in the places where the minimum wage is lower than the rest of the country. These states, by policy design, also have weak economic safety nets, which mean that low-incomes earners have less support to meet their basic needs or weather emergencies, should one arise. These disparities are no coincidence: They are deeply rooted in the United States’ history of slavery, sexism, and racism. In 1938, the Fair Labor Standards Act was passed by the New Deal Congress, which required minimum wage and overtime compensation. With these federal labor laws, Southern congressmen were concerned that a minimum wage would not serve to be economically viable to the white supremacist plantation system they overwhelmingly relied on. Eventually, what led to the passage of a federal minimum wage law was a racist “compromise” with Southern Democrats, which excluded minimum wage requirements in the agriculture and service-sector industries that had painfully high concentrations of Black workers, particularly in the South. As a result, today, people of color are still overrepresented in minimum wage jobs. Similarly, subminimum wages and the culture of tipping emerged from racist and exclusionary policies that prevented African Americans from receiving adequate pay against the backdrop of limited job opportunities. After emancipation, though tipping was socially unfavorable, it was widely practiced in order to underpay and degrade Black workers, especially in the service sector. The $2.13 tipped minimum wage is the byproduct of policy choices that continue to perpetuate racial inequities.
2023
MNDI
Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › Solvency – Gender Pay Gap
Khan ‘22 [Ashfaq and Rose Khattar; 7-7-2022; Former Policy Analyst; Director of Economic Analysis at Inclusive Economy, former economist at the Australian Treasury Department; Center for American Progress, "It's Long Past Time To Increase the Federal Minimum Wage", ]
Women make up the majority—63.5 percent—of those that earn at or below the federal minimum wage. (see Figure 2) They are also substantially more likely to be tipped workers who often earn even below the minimum wage. [GRAPH OMITTED] Occupational segregation—as well as gender and racial discrimination—have shaped many features of the low-wage labor market today. Women and people of color, including Hispanic workers, are often likely to be employed in the service industry—as restaurant hosts, dishwashers, fast food cooks, child care providers, home health care aides, and cashiers—which represent nearly 74 percent of jobs that pay at or below the federal minimum wage. The historical division of the labor force—with some occupations seen as “women’s work”—has undervalued the work of women, especially women of color. The overrepresentation of women, and particularly women of color, among those earning at or below the federal minimum wage have contributed to persistent gender, ethnic, and racial pay gaps. In 2021, across all workers, women were paid just 73 cents for every dollar a man earns, while women of color experienced even larger pay gaps. The enduring concentration of women in minimum wage jobs illustrates persistent barriers in accessing good, quality jobs across the labor market. The popular belief that minimum wage workers are teenagers who work after school or on summer vacation is not accurate: Most minimum wage workers are adults in their prime working years between the ages 25 and 54, many of whom are supporting families and children. This has important gender implications, as women are the majority of federal minimum wage earners and also hold dual responsibilities in their households. White women are the majority of breadwinning mothers, and women of color are disproportionately more likely to be the breadwinners of their households. This means that, often, their families depend on these low earnings to make ends meet. Minimum wage earners are not typically early career individuals, but are most often women that also shoulder multiple responsibilities in their households.
2023
MNDI
Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › Solvency – Gender Pay Gap
Bleiweis et al ‘21 [Robin, Diana Boesch, and Areeba Haider; February 23; Former Research Associate, Women’s Economic Security; Policy Analyst, Women’s Economic Security; Former Research Associate; Center for American Progress, “Raising the Minimum Wage Would Be Transformative for Women,” https://www.americanprogress.org/article/raising-minimum-wage-transformative-women/,] F.F.
Another group that would particularly benefit from raising the minimum wage is essential workers. New CAP analysis finds that the majority—58 percent—of essential workers making an hourly wage under $15 are women. (see Figure 2) Essential workers are disproportionately women, people of color, and women of color most of all. Women essential workers make up nearly a quarter—23 percent—of all workers making under $15 an hour. And of the more than 7 million women essential workers who would experience a raise from the Raise the Wage Act, half are women of color. However, these numbers are likely underestimates; they do not include the many child care workers, teachers, and others who have been deemed essential by states and localities but largely been excluded from federal guidance surrounding “essential workers.” Essential workers, from nursing assistants to grocery clerks, have kept communities running in the midst of a global pandemic that has lasted nearly a year, in many cases while earning low wages, facing an increased risk of contracting the coronavirus, and experiencing increased mental health distress. As economist Rhonda V. Sharpe has aptly pointed out, the title of “essential worker” is a misnomer in terms of how the country actually treats workers: It is the work that is considered essential, but the worker—who is often underpaid and inadequately protected on the job—is effectively treated as expendable. Efforts to support low-wage essential workers beyond a national rhetoric that glorifies their “sacrifices” have hardly been enough; hazard pay initiatives have largely been temporary and at the discretion of the employers, workers who rely on tips have reported large decreases in income as the pandemic stretches on, and research suggests that workers in essential industries are more likely to die from COVID-19. To value workers means to treat them with dignity, to guarantee them a safe and healthy workplace, and, importantly, to pay them higher wages. Raising the minimum wage is a vital step to truly create that reality for all, including those deemed “essential,” who make up a majority of those who would benefit from the Raise the Wage Act.
2023
MNDI
Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › Solvency – Gender Pay Gap
Majchrowska ’18 [Aleksandra and Paweł Strawiński; April 16; Faculty of Economics and Sociology, Institute of Economics, University of Lodz, Poland; Faculty of Economic Sciences, University of Warsaw, Poland, Dluga 44/50, 00-241 Warsaw, Poland; Economic Modelling, “Impact of minimum wage increase on gender wage gap: Case of Poland,” https://doi.org/10.1016/j.econmod.2017.10.021] F.F.
This paper analysed the impact of a significant increase in the minimum wage level, which was observed in 2008–2009, on the wage differences between men and women in the largest CEE economy—Poland. To check the potentially differentiated effects throughout wage distribution, the impact of this minimum wage increase on wage distribution was analysed separately for different age and educational groups. An innovative methodological approach combining the DiNardo et al. (1996) reweighting approach and Oaxaca–Blinder decomposition was proposed. Individual data from the Structure of Wages and Salaries survey provided by the CSO in Poland for the years 2006 and 2010 were used. The sample was limited to private sector workers, excluding those in agriculture. The results show that the minimum wage increase was the factor that significantly lowered the gender wage gap among young workers in Poland in 2006–2010. The impact of the change in workers' characteristics was small and/or insignificant. Moreover, the effects of minimum wage increases were negligible for middle-aged workers. The changes in gender wage gaps among educational groups were much smaller. Further, the robustness checks performed confirm the main findings. The results obtained in this paper are in line with both the authors' intuition and the findings for other countries. The minimum wage increase mainly affects the workers for whom the minimum wage is binding—those with low labour market experience and relatively poor qualifications. In these groups, statistically significant decreases in gender wage gaps were found. The authors' findings are in line with those of previous studies, both for more developed and developing countries. The above results confirm that minimum wage policy could be one of the tools used for decreasing the existing differentials in pay between men and women in former, centrally planned economies, where occupational segregation and existing differences in pay are relatively high (e.g. Strawiński et al., 2017).
2023
MNDI
Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › Solvency – Gender Pay Gap
Bleiweis et al ‘21 [Robin, Diana Boesch, and Areeba Haider; February 23; Former Research Associate, Women’s Economic Security; Policy Analyst, Women’s Economic Security; Former Research Associate; Center for American Progress, “Raising the Minimum Wage Would Be Transformative for Women,” https://www.americanprogress.org/article/raising-minimum-wage-transformative-women/,] F.F.
Raising the federal minimum wage would benefit workers in low-wage and essential jobs across the country. This is especially true for women—particularly women of color—who are concentrated in jobs, such as cashiers and child care, that pay at or a few dollars above the federal minimum wage. Currently, the federal minimum wage stands at just $7.25 per hour, and for tipped workers, the subminimum wage standard is an unconscionable $2.13 per hour. Making matters worse, the minimum wage has not budged since 2009, while costs have continued to rise, meaning that those working a minimum wage job today have less money than they did more than a decade ago to support their families and pay for basic necessities. Fortunately, Congress is now considering the Raise the Wage Act of 2021 which would gradually raise the federal minimum wage to $15 an hour by 2025 and phase out the subminimum wage for people who work for tips as well as people with disabilities. This column explains how raising the minimum wage would significantly benefit working women and their families, helping to ensure their recovery in the current recession and their economic security in the long term. The Raise the Wage Act would raise wages for nearly 32 million workers, according to analysis by the Economic Policy Institute (EPI) and the National Employment Law Project (NELP). The majority of workers who would benefit are women—59 percent, or nearly 19 million. In total, more than 1 in 4 working women, both those working full and part time, would see a raise. Women of color in particular would see substantial benefits, as many are segregated into low-wage jobs. Nearly a quarter—23 percent—of all workers who would see a raise are Black women or Latinas, an overrepresentation of their share of the U.S. workforce in 2020. (see Figure 1) This includes 3.4 million Black women and 4 million Latinas. Raising the minimum wage adds up to thousands more dollars for individual women every year. According to new analysis by the EPI and NELP, women working year-round, on average, would see an increase of about $3,500 in wages annually; and for Black women and Latinas, this figure increases to $3,700. This translates to a total wage increase of $66 billion for women working year-round. For mothers in particular, raising the federal minimum wage would increase their wages and allow them to better support their families. Original Center for American Progress analysis of 2019 data finds that, among mothers who would get a raise with a minimum wage increase, 65 percent are primary or sole breadwinners for their families. And an additional 19 percent of mothers who would benefit are co-breadwinners, earning at least 25 percent of their total household earnings. The EPI estimates that raising the minimum wage would lift wages for nearly 8 million mothers
2023
MNDI
Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › Solvency – Inequality Gap/Poverty
Engbom and Moser ’21 [Niklas and Christian; 5-24-21; Assistant professor at New York University Stern School of Business focusing on issues in macroeconomics and labor economics, Assistant Professor within the Economics Division at Columbia Business School and an affiliated faculty member within the Department of Economics at Columbia University., “Earnings Inequality and the Minimum Wage: Evidence from Brazil” IG]
In summary, Brazil saw a remarkable decline in wage inequality between 1994 and 2014, which was driven partly by a reduction in pay differences for identical workers across firms. We interpret this as evidence for the hypothesis that the decline in inequality over this period was the result of changes in firms’ pay policies and was not due solely to changes in worker composition. 3 Evidence on the effects of the minimum wage in Brazil 3.1 Evolution of Brazil’s minimum wage over time Motivated by the decline in wage inequality in Brazil, we now turn to a salient change in the labor market over this period: the rise in the minimum wage.10 Brazil’s statutory minimum wage is set at the federal level and stated in terms of a floor on monthly nominal earnings. There are no provisions for legal subminimum wages or differentiated minimum wages across demographics or economic subdivisions (Lemos, 2004). The minimum wage applies to workers with full-time contracts of 44 hours per week and is proportionately adjusted for part-time workers.11 Brazil’s real minimum wage deteriorated under high inflation in the years leading up to 1996, when a switch in government ignited a gradual ascent of the wage floor by 119 percent in real terms. By 2012, it reached 622 BRL per month, or 410 purchasing power parity-adjusted USD. If we account for aggregate productivity growth, this corresponds to a 44 log points rise in the minimum wage. To put these numbers into context, the minimum wage as a fraction of the median wage increased from around 34 percent in 1996 to 60 percent in 2012. Figure 2 shows a strong negative comovement between the minimum wage and the variance of log wages between 1985 and 2014, with a correlation of −0.92
2023
MNDI
Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › Solvency – Inequality Gap/Poverty
Roberts ’21 [Lily and Ben Olinsky; January 27; Lily Roberts is the managing director of the Economic Policy Team at the Center for American Progress; Ben Olinsky is the senior vice president for policy and strategy at the Center; Senior Fellow; Center for American Progress, "Raising the Minimum Wage Would Boost an Economic Recovery—and Reduce Taxpayer Subsidization of Low-Wage Work", ] PS
Over the past decade, CAP research and policy recommendations have , with a particular focus on economic inequality that stems from structural racism and sexism. Decreasing income inequality and working toward the elimination of the wealth gap (another disparity that stymies overall growth) . Raising the minimum wage is one tool for combatting this inequality—and therefore stimulating growth. Women (and women of color in particular) are overrepresented in minimum wage work, and CAP research demonstrates that this is especially true in occupations in which but are paid as little as $2.13 per hour by their employer. The that “for women working full time in states with a minimum wage of $10 per hour or more, the wage gap is 34 percent smaller” than the wealth gap in states with a $7.25 minimum. CAP research shows that in 2017, and women in the economy. Nearly 59 percent of workers who are paid the federal minimum wage are women. Therefore, increasing the minimum wage is particularly likely to stimulate consumer spending. Black and Latino workers are disproportionately represented in occupations with the lowest wages. would get a raise under a $15 minimum wage. Decreased income inequality would lead to an increase in overall economic growth, as . Conclusion Rather than continuing to subsidize corporations that pay paltry wages to workers—which means that those workers must find necessary support in the social safety net—a higher minimum wage would boost millions of families out of poverty and further stimulate the economy. As we move toward a post-pandemic economic recovery, increased money to families who are the most likely to spend any marginal dollar will have an outsize effect on consumer spending. A minimum wage increase would give an overdue raise to workers and would be well-timed for an economic recovery.
2023
MNDI
Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › Solvency – Inequality Gap/Poverty
Spina ’14 [Alyssa Spina; Sept 24, 2014; The Public Purpose; “No One Should Work Full-Time & Live in Poverty”; ; CP]
In December 2013, President Barack Obama that deficit of opportunity is a bigger threat than our fiscal deficit and the growing income inequality in the US is the “defining challenge of our time.” Americans and the leaders of our country are concerned about economic recovery and stability. Moreover, stagnant (and dropping) wages combined with globalization and de-unionization, strip workers of the bargaining power and economic power they once possessed. No one should work full time and live in poverty. Raising the minimum wage for workers will not only help close the income gap, but also get local economies moving, benefit millions of families, and improve the overall health of our citizens and country. Indicators of an Insubstantial Minimum Wage Over the past 50 years, we have seen a in the nominal federal minimum wage from $1.60 in 1968 to $7.25. However, in real value, that $1.60 minimum wage in 1968 was actually $10.69, almost 50% more than the current minimum wage. In comparison, workers making minimum wage are nominally per hour making almost one-third of the average private-sector earner (who makes $20.31/hr). This vast inequality affects 28 million workers, of which 19 million would see a direct increase in their wages from an increased minimum wage. Right now, a full-time minimum-wage worker makes $14,500 a year which leaves families far below poverty lines for families of 2, 3, and 4. Five years and counting So why hasn’t the federal minimum wage changed in five years? A lot of the stagnation has to do with the public perception of those in poverty, the fear of “big government”, and the belief that higher wages are bad for the economy. For most of history, there has been a distinction between the deserving and undeserving poor, or that poverty is a matter of choice. Reagan once stated that (in terms of homelessness) . This school of thought holds that those in poverty are there not because of government failings, but rather because of poor choices. Viewing the cause of poverty as an intentional or inadvertent action taken by citizens. In essence, this reasoning blames the victim for their misfortune and poverty. Others may fear government intervention citing simple economic theory as reasons for why regulation of wages fails workers, but we have seen that . Dan Mitchell, a senior fellow at Cato Institute has said “Businesses are not charities and that they only create jobs when they think a worker will generate net revenue. Higher minimum wages, needless to say, are especially destructive for people with poor work skills and limited work experience.” This sentiment has been a common one within the opposition of raising the wage. The rhetoric of missing a rung on the ladder, free-market economies, and exaggerated minimum wage examples like $50 or $100 are employed to diminish the importance of a wage mandate. However, the rhetoric used comes mainly from those who are not making the minimum wage, or leaving in poverty, but from elites. Those with the power and resources to help solve poverty would not benefit from changing the structural and institutional causes of it, and might even jeopardize their power. [9] Connecting Poverty & the Minimum Wage A stagnant minimum wage is failing workers and failing the United States by stripping millions of people of the bargaining and economic power they once possessed, it has contributed to the collapse of the working class, and has far-reaching negative consequences. In the US, nearly 50 million people are considered poor. In March, Sen. Bernie Sanders said, “Unfortunately, despite our great wealth, more of our citizens are living in poverty than ever before and we have the highest rate of childhood poverty of any major country in the industrialized world. We have a moral responsibility to end childhood poverty in America.” More than 1 in 5 children in America live in households that lack consistent access to adequate food because their parents don’t make enough money. Michael Reisch, a professor of social justice at the University of Maryland, has said that “Poverty not only diminishes a person’s life chances, it steals years from one’s life.” Frequently news stories appear discussing the alarming effects of poverty on health including increased occurrences of cancer, high rates of obesity, high levels of stress, and more. In fact, a recent study has shown that even those who “pull themselves up by their bootstraps” cannot escape the long-term, ill-health effects of poverty. Raising the minimum wage would provide a sound foundation to build a system that could begin to reverse and end the deleterious effects of poverty. Based on the Fair Market Rent for a two-bedroom unit, could help minimum-wage workers ($7.25/hr) afford more than 6 months of rent. Workers making $10.10 an hour rather than $7.25 would afford families 36 weeks of groceries. Raising the wage to $10.10 could help minimum-wage workers afford 103 tanks of gas each year (1 tank = 15 gallons, which is the average for a mid-size car.). Raising the wage to $10.10 could, over a year’s time, help minimum-wage workers afford the equivalent of 3.5 years of electricity. The government has a duty to invest in the well-being of its citizens, raising the federal minimum wage would benefit workers and in turn their families. After five years of stagnation, where the minimum wage hasn’t been adjusted to living costs, and an unprecedented, widening income inequality gap, it is time for a more comprehensive, up-to-date labor and wage policy. A policy that holds corporations more accountable and better protects employees.
2023
MNDI
Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › Solvency – Inequality Gap/Poverty
Acs et al ‘22 [Gregory Acs; Aug 1, 2022; Robert Wood Johnson Foundation; “Exploring the Effects of a $15 an Hour Federal Minimum Wage on Poverty, Earnings, and Net Family Resources”; https://www.rwjf.org/en/insights/our-research/2022/08/exploring-the-effects-of-a-15-an-hour-federal-minimum-wage-on-poverty-earnings-and-net-family-resources.html; CP]
A $15 an hour federal minimum wage in 2022 represents a large increase in the minimum wage in many parts of the US. If the higher minimum wage induced no change in employment, we project the annual family earnings of affected workers would rise by $5,600, and their net resources (considering changes in taxes and public assistance) would rise by $4,200. Poverty as measured by the SPM would fall by 2.4 percentage points and 7.6 million fewer people would be poor. On average, workers from all racial and ethnic backgrounds are projected to see earnings and net resource gains and reduced poverty, and Hispanic workers and their families are projected to see the greatest gains. That likely reflects the fact that, when compared with non-Hispanic affected workers, Hispanic affected workers are more likely to live with other affected workers, meaning more people in those families would see their earnings rise. That such a large increase in the minimum wage would not cause any displacement in the labor market is possible but not probable. When we account for the possibility of job loss by adapting a central finding from the literature on the sensitivity of employment to increases in the minimum wage in our projections, we find that 3.2 million workers will experience a job loss during the year that would otherwise not have occurred. Nevertheless, even accounting for this level of job loss, we project average earnings in families with at least one affected worker would rise by about $5,000, and net resources would rise by more than $3,700. About 6.9 million people would be lifted out of poverty, and the poverty rate would fall by 2.1 percentage points. Considerable debate and uncertainty exist about the sensitivity of employment to the minimum wage. If employment is more sensitive than we have allowed for in our projections, job losses would be higher and income gains would be lower. In projections not shown in detail here, we find that if employment was roughly twice as sensitive to the minimum wage as we have assumed in our projections allowing for job loss, about 5.5 million workers would experience a job loss they otherwise would not have at some point during the year, but 6.3 million fewer people would be poor, and the poverty rate would be 2.0 percentage points lower than without the increase in the minimum wage. 2 6 EXPLORING THE EFFECTS OF A $15 AN HOUR FEDERAL MINIMUM WAGE Our approach to projecting the impacts of raising the minimum wage draws on the frameworks used by CBO (2019) and NAS (2019) but with some notable differences. Rather than considering job loss in a given week or month, we focus on the number of workers who would experience job loss they otherwise would not have at any point during a year. Looking over a year window allows more workers to experience a job loss, so our overall job-loss projections will be higher than those from snapshot analyses. But we also allow workers projected to lose a job in one month to regain employment in some future month. Although some workers may end up working less time during the year, they will be paid more for the time they do work. In addition, we consider a larger minimum wage increase than NAS (2019) and consider the impact in 2022 rather than in 2025 as does CBO (2019). Both those factors would lead us to find larger effects than the other studies as we would expect a large wage increase to have larger effects on both poverty and employment. Raising the minimum wage may have broader macroeconomic effects we do not consider in this analysis. If employers passed along their higher-wage costs to consumers in the form of higher prices, the ensuing price increases would offset some of the buying power gained by workers. But if employers addressed the rising minimum wage by taking lower profits or by slowing the wage growth of more highly compensated employees and lower-wage workers were more likely to spend their new earnings than owners and the highly compensated, then the higher minimum wage could spur demand and growth in the economy. Debates about the minimum wage at the federal and state levels have been ongoing for decades, and they likely will continue for decades into the future. Projections of the potential effects of raising the minimum wage that use sophisticated analytic tools like the ATTIS microsimulation model can illustrate how different estimates of the employment effects of the minimum wage influence outcomes and inform those debates. Here, we provide a range of results that flow from what we consider reasonable assumptions; they are not meant to be upper or lower bounds but illustrations of how raising the federal minimum wage may play out under those assumptions as well as a sense of the how alternative assumptions could affect the results. Our projections generally suggest notable income gains and poverty reductions from a $15 per hour minimum wage. And although millions of workers may experience a job loss they otherwise would not have as a result of the minimum wage, the time they do spend working during the year will be paid at a higher rate, and their family members may also enjoy higher earnings. As such, even those workers who would experience a job loss are, on average, modestly better off over the course of a year.
2023
MNDI
Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › Solvency – Inequality Gap/Poverty
Parilla and Yiu ’21 [Joseph Parilla and Sifan Yiu; March 17th, 2021; Parilla is Director of Applied Research and Yiu is a Former Senior Research Analyst at Brookings Metro; The Brookings Institution; “A $15 minimum wage would help millions of struggling households in small and mid-sized cities achieve self-sufficiency”; ; CP]
On March 11, President Joe Biden signed the $1.9 trillion into law. But an earlier, House-passed provision to increase the federal minimum wage to $15 per hour . According to the Congressional Budget Office, the $15 federal minimum wage would have the earnings of low-wage workers and decreased poverty. In its absence, a national policy agenda focused on raising wages is still urgently needed. For now, at least, increasing the minimum wage will remain a bottom-up exercise led by local and state policymakers. In a new , we argue that raising the wage floor can not only help reduce poverty (a worthy goal unto itself), but it can also support individual and family self-sufficiency—the ability to cover living expenses without relying on public subsidies. To understand the landscape of struggling individuals and households, our report asked a simple question: Do individuals and families earn enough to make ends meet in the communities where they live? We found that for a large share of the U.S. population, wages leave them short of self-sufficiency. As of 2019 (the latest data available), 37% of U.S. households—38 million overall—did not earn a pre-tax, pre-transfer wage that allowed them to make ends meet, including 14 million households with children. Owing to historical racial injustices and structural inequities, 47% of Black households and 50% of Latino or Hispanic households struggle to make ends meet. A local perspective here is critical, because the share of households that struggle to make ends meet varies considerably across the United States due to diverging labor market conditions and costs of living. Over 40% of households were struggling to make ends meet in places such as Miami, Las Vegas, Orlando, Fla., and Los Angeles. In contrast, the struggling share of households was closer to 25% for Pittsburgh, Boston, and Seattle. To understand more precisely how the minimum wage or other policies might alleviate these challenges, we estimate a “family-sustaining wage” threshold for each metro area that would help lift half of its struggling households into self-sufficiency. Looking at all households, including those without children, family-sustaining wage thresholds range from $12 in Brownsville, Texas to $23 in San Jose, Calif. (Table 1). Among 53 metro areas with at least 1 million residents, the typical family-sustaining wage threshold is around $14.70 per hour—close to the value for regions such as Nashville, Tenn. and Birmingham, Ala. While wages and living expenses differ, every metro area has more struggling individuals and families than jobs that pay family-sustaining wages. Our lists these figures for 192 U.S. metro areas, and suggests that higher wage floors will not only reduce poverty and improve earnings for low-wage workers, but they also can make a meaningful difference in economic self-sufficiency—especially for households without children. Indeed, a key finding of our analysis is that the impact of a higher minimum wage on family self-sufficiency depends greatly on family composition. Consider a thought experiment in which the entire nation adopts a $15 minimum wage. Single-adult households account for 19 million of the nation’s struggling households—about half of such households—yet they represent more than three-quarters of households that could reach self-sufficiency with a $15 wage (Chart 1). On the other hand, 14 million—or 40%—of all struggling households are families with children, but they account for only 14% of households that would reach self-sufficiency with a $15 wage. The geographic variation is even more striking. Because the cost of living is substantially lower in smaller communities, households in small metro areas, micropolitan areas, and rural areas are more likely to reach self-sufficiency with a $15 federal minimum wage (Chart 2). Among the struggling households that would make ends meet with a $15 minimum wage, only 45% are in very large metro areas with populations exceeding 1 million—smaller than the 57% of struggling households they account for. Significant variations exist even within those large and very large metro areas. In the nation’s most expensive places—San Jose, Calif., San Francisco, Honolulu, Washington, D.C., and New York—fewer than 10% of struggling households would achieve self-sufficiency with a $15 hourly wage (Table 2). Many of these cities and their states have already enacted policies to their minimum wages. In comparison, more than two-thirds of struggling households in Madison, Wis., Lansing, Mich., and Pittsburgh would achieve self-sufficiency with a $15 hourly wage. Many of these metro areas contain large universities, and likely reflect the significant number of student households living (temporarily) on low wages. One strand of the debate about raising the federal minimum wage has registered concerns about disparate —particularly, that a $15 minimum wage would prove too costly for businesses in low-cost regional economies. But viewed from the perspective of workers and families, it is in those same smaller, more affordable cities where a higher minimum wage could lift the largest shares of struggling families into self-sufficiency. Notably, in many metro areas (including some large metro areas), a wage threshold set between $12 and $13 per hour would lift half of struggling households—a majority of whom are childless households—into self-sufficiency. In the end, economic self-sufficiency—whether households can make ends meet through their wage income alone—is just one metric for assessing the efficacy of policies like a minimum wage increase. But for the tens of millions of Americans struggling to afford the costs of living in their local communities, it’s arguably the metric that matters most.
2023
MNDI
Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › Solvency – Inequality Gap/Poverty
Cooper et al ’21 [David Cooper, Zane Mokhiber, and Ben Zipperer; March 9, 2021, Cooper is the Director of the Economic Analysis and Research Network (EARN), Zane Mokhiber is a Director of Data Management and Analysis Zipperer is a Senior Economist; Economic Policy Institute; Raising the federal minimum wage to $15 by 2025 would lift the pay of 32 million workers; https://www.epi.org/publication/raising-the-federal-minimum-wage-to-15-by-2025-would-lift-the-pay-of-32-million-workers/; CP]
Even when we restrict our analysis to workers in both critical infrastructure and nontelework occupations, we find a significant impact. The Raise the Wage Act would lift the pay of between 19.4 million and 19.9 million such workers, or roughly six out of 10 of all affected workers. Regardless of the specific definition, it is clear that tens of millions of essential and front-line workers are underpaid and would benefit from a much higher minimum wage. Poverty would decrease and economic security would increase under a $15 minimum wage The five-decade decline and stagnation of the minimum wage has prevented millions of people, often children, from maintaining an adequate standard of living. Notably among minimum wage workers struggling to get by are those whose incomes are so low they fall under the federal poverty threshold. Poverty reduction From its origins, the minimum wage has been an important policy tool in the fight against poverty. The Fair Labor Standards Act was enacted in 1938 “to protect this Nation from the evils and dangers resulting from wages too low to buy the bare necessities of life.” Thirty years later, higher wages were one of five key demands of the Economic Bill of Rights of the 1968 Poor People’s Campaign (Johnson 2018). Unfortunately, infrequent and inadequate increases in the national minimum have reduced it to a poverty wage. Figure E shows that a full-time minimum wage worker in 1968 would have earned roughly $22,000 a year (in 2021 dollars), but today their counterpart could earn only about $15,000 working full time. As a consequence, a single parent working full time would be in poverty if they earned the federal minimum wage and had no other source of income. In 2019, about 29.1 million children and nonelderly adults lived in poverty (Semega et al. 2020). By raising wages for some full-time workers above their respective poverty threshold, the Raise the Wage Act would play a meaningful role in reducing the extent of hardship among low-wage workers and their families. A $15 minimum wage by 2025 would reduce the number of people living in poverty by up to 3.7 million (see Figure F). To calculate this poverty reduction, we apply poverty reduction estimates from Dube (2019b) to the average minimum wage increase expected under the Raise the Wage Act. Dube finds that a 10% increase in the minimum wage reduces nonelderly poverty by somewhere between 2% and 4%. After accounting for already scheduled state and local minimum wage increases, we find that the Raise the Wage Act would raise the average, effective minimum wage across the United States by 30% in 2025, thus reducing the number of nonelderly people in poverty by between 6% and 12%, or roughly 1.8 million to 3.7 million people. If we assume the age distribution of poverty reduction is similar to the actual poverty distribution, the Raise the Wage Act would raise 1.3 million children out of poverty.
2023
MNDI
Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › Solvency – Small Biz growth
Willingham ’21 [Caius Z.; 2-25-2021; a research associate for Economic Policy at the Center for American Progress.; Center for American Progress, "Small Businesses Get a Boost From a $15 Minimum Wage", https://www.americanprogress.org/article/small-businesses-get-boost-15-minimum-wage/]BG
For the United States to achieve a meaningful economic recovery that lifts up all families, Congress must raise the federal minimum wage to $15 per hour, including for tipped workers and workers with disabilities. Raising the minimum wage would benefit small businesses and the economy at large. While critics of a fair wage argue that a $15 minimum wage would put a heavy burden on small businesses, economic literature demonstrates that these concerns are not borne out by the facts.
Small businesses across the country are in dire need of assistance to weather the remainder of the pandemic and rebound during the recovery. The number of small businesses currently operating is down almost 34 percent compared with January 2020.8 Almost one-third of small businesses surveyed by the U.S. Census Bureau in early January 2021 reported that the pandemic has had a “large negative effect” on their operations.9 Small businesses are a crucial part of the U.S. economy, employing about one-third of the workforce, according to the most recent available data.10 As a result, small businesses are a crucial part of the recovery and need meaningful federal aid to rebuild.
2023
MNDI
Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › Solvency – Productivity
Khan and Khattar ’22 [Ashfaq Khan; 7-7-22; Khattar studied economics at the Harvard Kennedy School; American Progress; “It’s Long Past Time to Increase the Federal Minimum Wage”; https://www.americanprogress.org/article/its-long-past-time-to-increase-the-federal-minimum-wage]
It has been since the federal minimum wage was increased: Since July 2009, the federal minimum wage has remained at $7.25 per hour. In fact, in inflation-adjusted terms, it has declined by over this time. A failure at the federal level to raise the minimum wage has resulted in a majority of states stepping in to fill the vacuum. Now, 20 states—disproportionately in the South—that have not raised their wage floors above the federal minimum to take action. Top of Form
Bottom of Form
2023
MNDI
Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › Solvency – Productivity
Hong Soon Kim and Soocheong Jawn; Professor at School of tourism and hospitality; 04-2019; No Publication, "Minimum wage increase and firm productivity: Evidence from the restaurant industry", ]//HD
This study also provides some meaningful implications for industry practitioners. The current study showed that the minimum wage may function as an instant driver for firm productivity, suggesting that employees' motivation to work can be stimulated by increasing the minimum wage rate and that firms may benefit in the form of improved productivity. The results of this study further showed that this effect is more discernable in low-wage restaurants, which implies that an increase in the minimum wage is more effective and critical for low-income workers. Furthermore, this study also showed that full-service restaurants are more (positively) sensitive to minimum wage change than limited-service restaurants. Therefore, it is recommended that industry professionals should cope with the minimum wage policies by focusing on implementing initiatives that can maximize enhanced work efforts and the restaurant's productivity, especially in full-service restaurants. In addition, this study also provides critical implications for enhancing employee motivation. This study revealed that a minimum wage increase can enhance firm productivity greatly the first year after an increase but then drops in the second year. Additionally, its effect disappears two years after the minimum wage was increased. The restaurant industry can learn from this positive effect, primarily in the first year, of wage increases on productivity. That is, the result implies that restaurant firms could continuously maintain enhanced motivation and productivity gains through continuous increases in wages rather than big step-like increases every few or several years. Therefore, it is recommended that managers of restaurant firms consider continuously raising wage levels or increasing wages every two years to consistently obtain enhanced work efforts and improved productivity. This study also provides implications for policy makers. It is suggested that policy makers should consider introducing legislation that guarantees systematic and gradual increases in the minimum wage rate. The existing step-wise growth of the federal minimum wage implies that the magnitude of the minimum wage increase may be greater than restaurant firms can handle at the point of increase. This may create issues for industry practitioners and lead them to oppose new minimum wage rate policies. Therefore, systematic and gradual increases based on national could alleviate the distress associated with upswings for restaurants.
2023
MNDI
Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › Solvency – Productivity
International Labour Organization, ‘16 ("Effects on labour productivity: Minimum wages and productivity: a brief review of the literature", 4-29-16, ]//HD
Recent studies have shown that minimum wages not only help to reduce wage dispersion and to channel productivity gains into higher wages, but they also can contribute to higher labour productivity – both at the enterprise level and at the aggregate economy-wide level. At the enterprise level, workers may be motivated to work harder. They may also stay longer with their employer, gaining valuable experience and also encouraging employers and employee to engage in productivity-enhancing training. At the aggregate level, minimum wages can result in more productive firms replacing least productive ones – and surviving firms becoming more efficient. These mechanisms can increase overall economy- wide productivity. A large number of experimental studies have supported the hypothesis formulated by Akerlof in 1982 that employees consistently provide higher effort levels in response to higher wages, the so-called “efficiency wage” theory. Most of these studies have focused on pay levels of individual firms, showing that higher pay compared to elsewhere can attract more experienced and motivated applicants. Higher pay can also elicit greater commitment and productivity from existing employees (Ehrenberg and Smith, 2009). The effect of minimum wages - as opposed to higher wages in individual firms - on workers’ motivation has also been found to be positive. Using a standard natural experiment design Georgiadis (2013) for example found that the U.K. national minimum wage has operated as a kind of “efficiency wage” in the residential care homes sector, increasing motivation and leading to a reduction in the level of worker supervision required. Experimental evidence in the U.S. by Owens and Kagel (2010) also points to a positive relationship between minimum wages and workers' effort, leading to the conclusion that – if well-designed – minimum wages can generate improved outcomes where employees have higher wages and employers have the same, or slightly higher, average labour cost.
2023
MNDI
Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › Solvency – Productivity
Jayachandran 20 [Seema Jayachandran; June 18th, 2020; Professor of Economics and Public Affairs at Princeton University; The New York Times; “How a Raise for Workers Can Be a Win for Everybody”; https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/18/business/coronavirus-minimum-wage-increase.html; CP]
Two new studies show that giving pay raises to low-wage workers is good for consumers, too. That finding could add momentum to efforts to help grocery store clerks, nursing home workers and delivery drivers who are being paid a despite their efforts being so essential during the current pandemic. The new research shows that raising the improves workers’ productivity, which translates into businesses offering higher-quality service. Because many customers are willing to pay more when quality improves, a company can raise its prices without losing sales volume. That means that profits need not suffer even though employee salaries increase. Moreover, because companies are getting better performance from workers in return for paying them more, a higher minimum wage does not necessarily lead to fewer jobs. With a more productive work force, more economic value is being created and there is more money to go around, so a higher paycheck for one person does not imply another person’s loss. The federal minimum wage of $7.25 an hour has not increased since 2009, though Democrats in the House of Representatives have tried to raise it. State and local governments can set their own minimum wage, provided that it is above the federal rate. For example, minimum wage is $8.70 an hour and state’s is $11.80. s is $15.59 an hour. The two new studies, one focused on nursing homes and the other on department stores, looked at the effects of minimum wage changes made at various levels of government. While they are both still working papers and have not appeared in scholarly journals, they were conducted rigorously, by my estimation, and the evidence they offer deserves consideration in the debate on the minimum wage, particularly during our current health and economic crises. The nursing home study, by the economist Krista Ruffini, a at the Minnesota Federal Reserve, has in the current pandemic. The improvements in quality it found may be a very a big deal: They imply fewer medical complications and, perhaps, a longer life for patients.