2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Energy Independence Uniqueness Counterplan › 2nc Solvency
Saudi Arabia’s decrease in oil production provides an opportunity for the U.S. to rise as a key global exporter
Henneke, 6-9-23 – executive director at the Texas Public Policy Foundation (Robert, “OPEC just gave Biden an opening to start a new US energy boom” https://thehill.com/opinion/energy-environment/4037456-opec-just-gave-biden-an-opening-to-start-a-new-us-energy-boom/, The Hill, NK)
Just in time for summer vacation, gas prices are rising and American families are bracing for sticker shock. OPEC is doing its part to keep prices high by cutting production, and the Biden administration continues to hobble domestic production.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Energy Independence Uniqueness Counterplan › 1nc CP Energy Independence
Zinke, 22 --- Secretary of the Interior under President Trump, served as Montana’s congressman (March 16, 2022 12:00 AM, Ryan, “American energy dominance makes the world safer,” https://vp-mi.com/news/2022/mar/16/american-energy-dominance-makes-world-safer/, JMP))
I have no doubt that we are all watching the the events unfold in Ukraine with heartbreak and horror. And yet, we are seeing the inspirational courage of the Ukrainian people as they take up arms and fight for their families, liberty and their land.
The Biden Administration’s retreat and failure in Afghanistan coupled with their inability to deliver any meaningful deterrent to Putin’s onslaught over the past year has given the world a clear message: America under Biden will not or cannot protect and defend freedom. Our allies no longer trust us and our adversaries no longer fear us. Like negotiating with terrorist to rescue the abandoned Americans left in Afghanistan, the US and our allies are only able to caste ineffective sanctions in response. Why? An underlying reason is that Russian has an energy stranglehold on Europe that can be countered.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Energy Independence Uniqueness Counterplan › 1nc CP Energy Independence
Zinke, 22 --- Secretary of the Interior under President Trump, served as Montana’s congressman (March 16, 2022 12:00 AM, Ryan, “American energy dominance makes the world safer,” https://vp-mi.com/news/2022/mar/16/american-energy-dominance-makes-world-safer/, JMP))
Watching the news the past few days of the Russian invasion of Ukraine not only breaks my heart but is also a reminder that NATO’s response and sanction options would be far different if Europe had an energy option from the US. Rather than build America energy capacity to support NATO and our allies, the Biden administration is instead canceling domestic oil and gas leases, canceling critical pipelines, penalizing fossil fuel investment, and begging Saudi Arabia to produce more. Nuts.
But we can fix it! We can easily get back to a position of peace through strength and American energy dominance by restoring the American First Policies to include:
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Impacts › AT: Natural Gas => Emissions / Flaring
Smil, 21 (5/27/2021, Vaclav, He is a distinguished professor emeritus at the University of Manitoba and a Fellow of the Royal Society of Canada (Science Academy) “Natural Gas Is (Mostly) Good for Global Warming” https://spectrum.ieee.org/natural-gas-is-mostly-good-for-global-warming)
AS IT COMES up inside a production steel pipe, natural gas is usually a mixture of the lightest alkanes, which are hydrocarbons of the CnH2n+2 series. Methane (CH4) dominates (between 85 and 95 percent), followed by ethane (C2H6, typically 2 to 7 percent by volume), small amounts of propane (C3H8), butane (C4H10), and pentane (C5H12), and traces of carbon dioxide, hydrogen sulfide, and other gases. Gas processing removes most of these things before the final product, about 95 percent methane, reaches consumers.
Natural gas is abundant, low-cost, convenient, and reliably transported, with low emissions and high combustion efficiency. Natural-gas-fired heating furnaces have maximum efficiencies of 95 to 97 percent, and combined-cycle gas turbines now achieve overall efficiency slightly in excess of 60 percent. Of course, burning gas generates carbon dioxide, but the ratio of energy to carbon is excellent: Burning a gigajoule of natural gas produces 56 kilograms of carbon dioxide, about 40 percent less than the 95 kg emitted by bituminous coal.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Impacts › AT: Natural Gas => Emissions / Flaring
flaring is safer than releasing natural gas into the air
EIA 22 (November 7, 2022, U.S. Energy Information Administration “Natural gas and the environment” https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/natural-gas/natural-gas-and-the-environment.php)
Natural gas has many qualities that make it an efficient, relatively clean burning, and economical energy source. However, the production and use of natural gas have some environmental and safety issues to consider.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Impacts › AT: Natural Gas => Emissions / Flaring
Cahill, 6-5-23 – Senior fellow with the Energy Security and Climate Change Program at CSIS (Ben, “Europe Wants Cleaner Gas. Can the United States Provide It?” https://www.csis.org/analysis/europe-wants-cleaner-gas-can-united-states-provide-it, NK)
U.S. liquefied natural gas (LNG) has been essential to global energy security since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. But environmental organizations worry that building LNG import terminals and gas infrastructure will “lock in” fossil fuel consumption, and some are suspicious about the environmental footprint of U.S. gas exports. For now, the European Union cannot afford to be choosy about alternatives to Russian gas, and concerns about emissions intensity have taken a back seat. But European buyers intend to seek “cleaner” or less emissions-intensive gas in the years to come. New methane regulations in the United States should help address these concerns and bolster the case for U.S. LNG.
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is finalizing new rules on methane emissions from the oil and gas sector. These regulations would require monitoring for leaks at all well sites, establish tough emissions standards for certain equipment, impose new rules on gas flaring and venting, and incentivize companies to use advanced methane detection technology. The EPA is also drafting new greenhouse gas reporting requirements linked to the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) methane fee, which will apply to emissions above a certain level of methane intensity for upstream production as well as nonproduction petroleum and natural gas systems. The IRA requires the agency to update its greenhouse gas reporting requirements for petroleum and natural gas systems by August 2024, to ensure their reporting “is based on empirical data and accurately reflects total methane emissions.” The EPA aims to finalize its oil and gas methane regulations by this summer, and it may provide guidance on new reporting requirements for oil and gas facilities (under Subpart W of the Greenhouse Gas Reporting Program) by this fall.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Impacts › 2nc Key to Economy
Burgum 23 --- masters of business administration from Stanford 1980, governor of North Dakota since 2016 (March 7, 2023, Doug “Studies underscore oil and gas industry’s significant impact on North Dakota’s economy, communities” North Dakota, https://www.governor.nd.gov/news/studies-underscore-oil-and-gas-industrys-significant-impact-north-dakotas-economy-communities//CHC-MHT ☢️)
BISMARCK, N.D. – The oil and gas industry in North Dakota remains a powerhouse for the state’s economy, accounting for more than $42.6 billion in gross business volume, nearly 50,000 jobs and $3.8 billion in state and local tax revenues in 2021, according to two studies highlighted today by Gov. Doug Burgum, researchers from North Dakota State University and industry officials.
“The oil and natural gas industry continues to be a game-changer for North Dakota,” Burgum said. “Taxes and royalties paid by the industry support our state’s significant investments in infrastructure, schools, communities, tax relief and the Legacy Fund, among other areas. The industry’s resiliency in the face of challenges such as the pandemic, extreme weather, volatile prices and misguided federal policies, demonstrates that it will continue to play a critically important role in North Dakota’s economy for generations to come.”
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Impacts › 2nc Key to Economy
Eberhart, 23 --- CEO of Canary, LLC (Feb 24, 2023,09:41am ES, Dan, “Ukraine War Illustrates Importance Of American Energy Dominance,” https://www.forbes.com/sites/daneberhart/2023/02/24/ukraine-war-illustrates-importance-of-american-energy-dominance/?sh=2cfd961570a6, JMP))
Biden continues to double down on the energy transition, a decision that may pay off in the long run. In the immediate future, though, America – and the world – will continue to depend on oil and gas to run their economies. Until tanks run on solar power, petroleum will continue to define energy security – and energy security is national security.
After the bloody events of the past year, Americans should take heart in North America’s resource abundance. Still, they should be equally concerned about the direction of U.S. energy policy and the unnecessary risk it poses to the nation.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Impacts › 2nc Key to Economy
API, 23 [5/16/2023 [American Petroleum Institute; API is a leader in the development of petroleum and petrochemical equipment and operating standards covering topics that range from drill bits to environmental protection. These embrace proven, sound engineering and operating practices and safe, interchangeable equipment and materials. Many have been incorporated into state and federal regulations and adopted by ISO for worldwide acceptance; API; “America’s Abundant Natural Gas and Oil Resources Deliver Americans Nearly $2 Trillion in Economic Trade & Job Benefits,” https://www.api.org/news-policy-and-issues/news/2023/05/15/abundant-natural-gas-oil-resources-deliver-americans-nearly-2-trillion-economic-trade-job-benefits LK]
WASHINGTON, May 16, 2023 — The American Petroleum Institute (API) today released new analysis on the growing economic contributions of America’s natural gas and oil industry in all 50 states, including investment in America ranging from taxes and workforce wages paid to indirect and induced jobs in retail, manufacturing, agriculture and other sectors throughout the energy supply chain. The study, commissioned by API and prepared by PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC), showed that the industry supported 10.8 million jobs and contributed nearly $1.8 trillion to the U.S. economy in 2021.
“Natural gas and oil delivers growing economic contributions to America that were nearly equivalent to Canada’s annual GDP last year. From Pennsylvania to California, America’s natural gas and oil workforce is the backbone of communities, supporting nearly 11 million careers throughout the energy supply chain,” API President and CEO Mike Sommers said. “America’s economic outlook is brighter when we are leading the world in energy production and this analysis serves as a reminder that we need policies and regulations that encourage investment and enable development.”
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Impacts › 2nc U.S. Energy Dominance Saves Europe
Denning, 22 – Bloomberg columnist [Liam Denning, July 26, 2022, Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering energy and commodities. A former investment banker, he was editor of the Wall Street Journal’s Heard on the Street column and a reporter for the Financial Times’s Lex column, https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/energy/elementsputin-natural-gasand-democracy/2022/07/25/a46b56a4-0c0e-11ed-88e8-c58dc3dbaee2_story.html /, EL]
An aficionado of judo, Russian President Vladimir Putin likes to turn his opponents’ strengths against them. In his energy war with the nations backing Ukraine, he can take advantage of a defining strength of the West: democracy.
Having denied Putin a quick victory, Ukraine is embroiled in a grinding war, relying on Western aid. The US and allies have also begun to slowly implement sanctions on Russia’s vital energy exports. Rather than wait around, Putin has weaponized them already. Reduced gas flows (with warnings they may drop further this week and heavy hints of outright cutoffs) have raised the prospect of idled factories and frozen homes across Europe this winter. The war has already fueled a spike in energy prices hitting consumers around the world.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Impacts › 2nc U.S. Energy Dominance Saves Europe
Eberhart, 23 --- CEO of Canary, LLC (Feb 24, 2023,09:41am ES, Dan, “Ukraine War Illustrates Importance Of American Energy Dominance,” https://www.forbes.com/sites/daneberhart/2023/02/24/ukraine-war-illustrates-importance-of-american-energy-dominance/?sh=2cfd961570a6, JMP))
The year-old war in Ukraine has had far-reaching impacts on energy markets over the past year, redrawing the global map of oil and gas flows and creating a new boom market for U.S. producers.
Europe has shown that it can live without Russian oil and gas, reducing Russian imports to below 20% of total consumption. The EU primarily has the United States to thank for the flexibility to achieve that rapid transition without throwing the continent’s economy into chaos.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Impacts › 2nc Asian War Impact
Sharman 2017 – Citing professor of Chinese studies and director of King's College London's Lau China Institute & Prof of Politics @ U of Warwick [05 February 2017, Jon, "US would go into any war with China with 'unparalleled violence', warn experts," www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-china-war-be-end-of-life-earth-nuclear-weapons-apocalypse-steve-bannon-donald-trump-white-house-a7561821.html
The United States would likely win because sending China's untested forces against the might of America's military would be like pitching farmers against Achilles and his warriors, said one, but even a conventional military victory would be a strategic disaster. It would set off a global economic crisis and create a potential power vacuum inside defeated China "the like of which we can't imagine". Mr Bannon said war would erupt in the South China Sea in "five to 10 years". He said: "They’re taking their sandbars and making basically stationary aircraft carriers and putting missiles on those. They come here to the United States in front of our face—and you understand how important face is—and say it’s an ancient territorial sea." The US and China have been engaged in a back-and-forth dispute over military build-up and territorial claims in the region for some years. In December the US said it would base its deadliest fighter jets in Australia, and days later China seized an unmanned US Navy drone. It followed a diplomatic spat around then-President-elect Trump's congratulatory phone call with Taiwan's Prime Minister Tsai Ing-wen, which broke with decades of US policy. Mr Trump has been forthright about China's influence, blaming it for the loss of American jobs. The war of words recently heated up when a Chinese military official was quoted as saying talk of war with the US under Mr Trump "are not just slogans, they are becoming a practical reality". Trevor McCrisken, associate professor of politics and international studies at the University of Warwick, said that if war broke out "we would be looking, I would imagine, at World War Three". He said: "I really do think that would be the end of life as we know it on Earth. "From a global strategic risk level I would say the last thing you want is war between the United States and any of the major powers because of the risks of escalation, obviously the potential for nuclear weapons to be used. The likelihood of nuclear exchange between the two principals involved is high." But, he added, the "overwhelming view of most policy-makers in Washington since at least the late 1970s" favours a form of "cooperative, if competitive" relationship with China. Dr Peter Roberts, director of military sciences at the Royal United Services Institute, said: "America would take military losses. They would lose thousands and thousands [of personnel]. But China would be utterly defeated. If America goes to war, it wages war in its totality. They would go to this with unparalleled violence and energy." The US has an "overall competitive edge" partly due to technological superiority, Dr Roberts said, but also because the four branches of its military—Army, Navy, Marine Corps and Air Force—are trained to work closely together. "It's demonstrated how it can use all those arms to deliver military victory," he said. In contrast, China's services operate "individually" and also have less, and less recent, combat experience compared to their American counterparts. "There's a huge difference between someone who's been in combat before, and someone who hasn't," Dr Roberts said, comparing the potential confrontation to one between Greek hero Achilles and farmers recruited from the fields. Kerry Brown, professor of Chinese studies and director of King's College London's Lau China Institute, said: "US naval superiority is massive. And if we are talking just military, then for sure, a conflict right beside China would hurt China more than the US. "It would, of course, totally upend supply routes, however, and probably cause a global recession. So it would, no matter who won in terms of military outcomes, be lose-lose and cut against the logic of self interest of both the US and China." Professor Brown added: "We have to expect this war of words to simply get worse. The best outcome is that the two sides ultimately compromise—China acts more responsibly, and stops its adventurism, and the US concedes it more space. The worst outcome would be a misunderstanding that would lead to real conflict."
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Impacts › AT: No Russian Escalation
UN, 6-23-23 [6-23-23, United Nations, “As War in Ukraine Escalates with Surge of Missile, Drone Attacks, Prospects for Peace Remain ‘Desperately Dim’, Senior Official Tells Security Council,” https://press.un.org/en/2023/sc15333.doc.htm, Accessed on 6/28/23, JR]
Briefing the Council, Rosemary Dicarlo, Under-Secretary-General for Political and Peacebuilding Affairs, reporting that Russian Federation missile barrages and drone attacks across Ukraine have nearly tripled in May, said that, in the 16 months since the beginning of the Russian Federation invasion, an estimated 9,083 civilians have been killed, including 530 children, and 15,779 have been injured, of which 1,086 were children. However, she emphasized that the actual figures are likely “considerably” higher.
The most significant destruction of civilian infrastructure took place on 6 June when the Kakhovka Dam was damaged, she continued, adding that, although the exact circumstances remain unclear, some 80 communities along the Dnipro River were reportedly flooded, with tens of thousands of people directly affected. Dozens of people lost their lives. Damaged sewer systems and the lack of clean water heighten the risk of waterborne diseases. She urged Russian Federation authorities to ensure unfettered access to all areas in need.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Impacts › AT: No Russian Escalation
Francis, 6/21/2023 – senior fellow with the Atlantic Council’s Eurasia Center (Diane Francis, June 21 2023, Altantic council, Putin’s nuclear threats will escalate as Ukraine’s counteroffensive unfolds, https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/ukrainealert/putins-nuclear-threats-will-escalate-as-ukraines-counteroffensive-unfolds/, BDP)
Ukraine’s counteroffensive is still in its early stages but concerns are already mounting that Russia may eventually resort to desperate measures in order to stave off defeat. At present, fears are focused primarily on Vladimir Putin’s nuclear saber-rattling, which is expected to escalate as the counteroffensive unfolds.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy has recently warned that Moscow may intend to blow up the Russian-occupied Zaporizhzhia Nuclear Power Plant in southern Ukraine. Meanwhile, US President Joe Biden acknowledged on June 19 that the threat of Putin using nuclear weapons is “real.” Days later, Ukrainian military intelligence chief Kyrylo Budanov accused Russia of mining the cooling pond used to control temperatures at the Zaporizhzhia plant’s reactors. Clearly, an occupied nuclear plant that is blown up becomes a nuclear weapon.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Impacts › 2nc European Energy Instability Impact
Holstein 20 — Alex Holstein, Managing Partner at Holstein & Gray, a consulting firm specializing in international government relations, MSc in Russian and Post-Soviet Studies from the London School of Economics, 2020 (“Invisible Warfare: NATO and the Geopolitical Storm on the Market Economy Horizon,” Geopolitical Monitor, October 21st, Available Online at https://www.geopoliticalmonitor.com/invisible-warfare-nato-and-the-geopolitical-storm-on-the-market-economy-horizon/, Accessed on 11-11-2021)
But before we even get to that very worst of the worst-case scenarios of a direct collision between a NATO ally and Russia, even the slightest escalation in the region, considering its vital energy resources, could have a devastating impact on global markets, which in itself would kick off a wave of instability and eventual warfare.
As market economies evolve and integrate by engaging commerce and leveraging technology, the blend between national security and socio-economic imperatives becomes even more prescient. This carries with it both advantages and disadvantages. Traditionally, NATO military forces have relied on critical civilian infrastructure such as communications, food and water, industrial capacity, civil transport and energy supplies to conduct operations. The additional rise of non-kinetic asymmetric threats – cyberwarfare, information warfare, EMP attack – against non-traditional targets, such as banks or major multinational corporations that comprise key components of this critical infrastructure, adds an entirely new dimension to the defense requirements of the 21st century. In addition to dealing with more conventional kinetic threats from traditional and emerging adversaries, NATO must prepare itself for this new era of invisible warfare through deeper strategic cooperation with the private sector and corporate entities.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Links & Internal Links › Internal Link – Certainty Key
Miles, et. al, 22 --- fellow in global natural gas for the Center for Energy Studies Steven R. Miles, Gabriel Collins, Anna Mikulska, Baker Institute, August 18, 2022 “US Needs LNG to Fight a Two-Front Gas War,” https://www.bakerinstitute.org/research/us-needs-lng-fight-two-front-gas-war, CHC-MHT ☢️]
As Russian forces invaded Ukraine in the early winter of 2022, it seemed Europe’s dependence on natural gas from Russia might leave European nations with a stark choice: capitulate and accept Russia’s aggression, or suffer a potentially catastrophic energy shortage with dire economic, political, and social consequences. Fortunately, concerted action by the United States and its allies produced a liquified natural gas (LNG) ‘GasLift’ that flooded European terminals and succeeded in pulling Europe through the winter of 2022. But launching a winter 2023 GasLift to supply sufficient energy to Europe could prove considerably more challenging given further Russian gas reductions, unexpected LNG facility outages, and possible domestic export restrictions in some countries.
The gathering storm in Asia further heightens Europe’s gas insecurity. Russia took advantage of extremely tight markets and uncertainty by nationalizing the Sakhalin II LNG plant just days after outages at major LNG plants in the US and Australia, challenging the gas security of US allies in Asia, particularly Japan and South Korea. Compounding matters, China’s “live-fire” military exercises in the Taiwan Strait effectively blockaded Taiwan’s two LNG import terminals, signaling future energy insecurity for the island.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Links & Internal Links › AT: Turn – We Free Up Gas For Europe
Investments, LNG export contracts and European import capacity
Soraghan & Anchondo, 22 (03/28/2022 07:05 AM EDT, Mike Soraghan, Carlos Anchondo, “Biden’s LNG deal with Europe jolts gas critics,” https://www.eenews.net/articles/bidens-lng-deal-with-europe-jolts-gas-critics/, JMP))
Natural gas producers are applauding President Biden’s pledge to export more U.S. gas to Europe as environmental groups fume that the trans-Atlantic deal undercuts Biden’s commitment to address climate change.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Links & Internal Links › AT: Turn – We Free Up Gas For Europe
U.S. LNG cleanest in the world – helps Europe meet climate goals
Baker, 22 (March 28, 2022, Andrew, “Plan to Send More U.S. LNG to Europe Met With Optimism by Natural Gas Industry,” https://www.naturalgasintel.com/plan-to-send-more-u-s-lng-to-europe-met-with-optimism-by-natural-gas-industry/, JMP)
The oil and natural gas industry praised the Biden administration’s announcement last week of a joint U.S.-European Union (EU) task force to increase liquefied natural gas (LNG) supply to Europe.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Links & Internal Links › AT: Turn – We Free Up Gas For Europe
U.S. Energy Information Administration, 3-3-2022 [U.S. Energy Information Administration, 27 April, U.S. Energy Information Administration, “Annual Energy Outlook 2022” https://www.eia.gov/outlooks/aeo/narrative/production/sub-topic-01.php Accessed on 23 June, NP]
We project U.S. consumption and production of petroleum and other liquids to grow through 2050. Domestic consumption and production levels of petroleum and other liquids remain relatively close to one another through most of the projection period in the Reference case. Consumption increases by 15%, and production increases by 17% from 2021 to 2050. However, consumption and production of specific petroleum products vary. We also project consumption and production of natural gas to grow through 2050. During the projection period, natural gas production grows by almost 24%, approximately twice as fast as consumption. Much of this growth in natural gas production is exported as liquefied natural gas (LNG). By 2050, we project that approximately 25% more natural gas will be produced than consumed in the United States. Together, these Reference case trends highlight the continued growth in demand for U.S. natural gas and petroleum products.
NATURAL GAS EXPORTS INCREASE WITH PRODUCTION, DRIVEN BY GLOBAL DEMAND AND CONTINUED CONSTRUCTION OF NEW LNG EXPORT FACILITIES
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Links & Internal Links › Link – UBI
Büchs ’21 – PhD Humboldt University Berlin, MSc University of Berlin [Milena, 07/22/2021, ScienceDirect, “Sustainable welfare: How do universal basic income and universal basic services compare?” https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S092180092100210X 6/22/23, JR]
UBI could improve democracy as it would give people greater freedom over their use of time and hence greater capacity to participate in democratic processes (Casassas, 2016; Raventós, 2007). However, this only holds if supply of labour really decreases under UBI as its supporters claim. Furthermore, whether or not greater availability of time would result in increased participation and more democratic policy-making would depend on the design of democratic institutions. In more general terms, several UBI trials have shown that UBI can change people's self-perceptions and relationships in ways that could be beneficial for political participation and support for green policies. In several trials, the receipt of UBI was associated with lower stress and anxiety levels (Lawhon and McCreary, 2020), perhaps because the payment gave people a greater sense of social security. Potentially, UBI could thus make people feel more connected to the state and reduce perceptions of individual risk, which could increase political support for green policies (ibid.).