Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Links & Internal Links › Link – UBI

UBI facilitates green energy transition and GND

Schuppert, ’21 – prof. at Universität Potsdam, PhD [Fabian, 03/21/19, The Conversation, “Green New Deal: universal basic income could make green transition feasible” https://theconversation.com/green-new-deal-universal-basic-income-could-make-green-transition-feasible-112898 6/22/23, JR]

Introducing a universal basic income would have advantages for delivering a Green New Deal. If the radical changes of the Green New Deal aren’t supposed to punish workers in the current fossil-fuel dependent economy, giving these people, who most likely will lose their jobs, a guaranteed alternative would create support for the transition and make sure that those most vulnerable to the proposed changes don’t get left behind.

Instead of creating state-funded jobs just for the sake of employing people, the state could empower many of its citizens to lead more sustainable lives as part of the green transition. A universal basic income might offer citizens time to engage in fulfilling community-based work that doesn’t generate profit but which has social value. Taking them out of their cars in long lines of commuter traffic and putting them in allotments growing food or in parks enjoying nature could help usher a whole new way of life.

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Links & Internal Links › Link – Renewables – Increase Domestic Demand for Natural Gas

Renewables would require more domestic natural gas for backup power --- a renewables only focus leads to energy poverty

Cohen ’21 – Senior Fellow at the Atlantic Council, Founding Principal of International Market Analysis [Ariel, 7/8/21, Forbes, “Why The Green Transition Can’t Happen Without Natural Gas” https://www.forbes.com/sites/arielcohen/2021/07/08/how-natural-gas-can-help-fuel-the-green-revolution/?sh=192d2ca73d82 6/23/23, JR] ***Note --- Andrea Stegher is President of the International Gas Union and a Senior Vice President Commercial & Stakeholder Engagement in the Italian energy giant SNAM

In a way, renewables are benefitting from the grids that were built before solar and wind expansion and which are serving to provide security and flexibility to the system. “Gas is not in competition with renewables,” comments Stegher. “Gas is the catalyst for and foundation of enhanced renewable capacity.”

“The integrated gas-based grids are essential when renewables are less effective due to bad weather, or the lack of wind or sunshine, as has been the case in the UK for the past month and has happened in California and Texas more dramatically,” Stegher argues. A fair distribution of costs in grid expansion needs to be addressed by policy makers.

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Links & Internal Links › Link – Renewables – Increase Domestic Demand for Natural Gas

Expanding renewables would increase domestic demand for natural gas

Mooney ’16 [Chris, 8/11/16, The Washington Post, “Turns out wind and solar have a secret friend: Natural Gas” https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/energy-environment/wp/2016/08/11/turns-out-wind-and-solar-have-a-secret-friend-natural-gas/ 6/23/2023, JR]

We’re at a time of deeply ambitious plans for clean energy growth. Two of the U.S.’s largest states by population, California and New York, have both mandated that power companies get fully 50 percent of their electricity from renewable sources by the year 2030.

Only, there’s a problem: Because of the particular nature of clean energy sources like solar and wind, you can’t simply add them to the grid in large volumes and think that’s the end of the story. Rather, because these sources of electricity generation are “intermittent” — solar fluctuates with weather and the daily cycle, wind fluctuates with the wind — there has to be some means of continuing to provide electricity even when they go dark. And the more renewables you have, the bigger this problem can be.

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Links & Internal Links › Link – Renewable Energy – Competition with Gas

Renewable compete with natural gas – decisions by some states prove the tradeoff

Saha, 19 – Director of US Clean Energy Economy Program, Ph.D. in Public Policy University of Texas at Austin [Devashree, 07/08/2019, World Resources Institute, “Natural Gas Beat Coal in the US. Will Renewables and Storage Soon Beat Natural Gas?” https://www.wri.org/technical-perspectives/natural-gas-beat-coal-us-will-renewables-and-storage-soon-beat-natural-gas 6/21/2023, JR]

In April 2019, in the heart of coal country, Indiana regulators rejected a proposal by its electric and gas utility, Vectren, to replace baseload coal plants with a new $900 million, 850 megawatt (MW) natural gas-fired power plant. Regulators were concerned that with the dramatic decline in the cost of renewable energy, maturation of energy storage and rapidly changing customer demand, such a major gas plant investment could become a stranded, uneconomic asset in the future. Regulators are now pushing Vectren to consider more decentralized, lower-carbon resources such as wind, solar and storage that would offer greater resource diversity, flexibility and cost effectiveness.

This decision is notable in a state where coal is still the primary energy fuel. At the same time, the Indiana decision hints at a broader transformation happening across the United States.

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Links & Internal Links › Link – Renewable Energy – Competition with Gas

Natural gas and renewables compete but it’s too early to discount gas

Cohen ’21 – Senior Fellow at the Atlantic Council, Founding Principal of International Market Analysis [Ariel, 7/8/21, Forbes, “Why The Green Transition Can’t Happen Without Natural Gas” https://www.forbes.com/sites/arielcohen/2021/07/08/how-natural-gas-can-help-fuel-the-green-revolution/?sh=192d2ca73d82 6/23/23, JR]

Just as natural gas has competed with coal as the prime fuel for electricity in the last decades, renewables are putting pressure on the blue, clean-burning source of energy. The competition is fierce and will likely get worse. Yet, it is still too early to discount gas. This was the message at the 36th International Gas Congress in Croatia, where I spoke on Joe Biden’s plan to stop drilling on federal lands.

The International Gas Union (IGU), with over 160 members from the U.S. to Qatar, is a non-profit that advocates for natural gas as an integral part of the global energy system. The Vice President and the future (2025) President of IGU Andrea Stegher, a Senior Vice President Commercial & Stakeholder Engagement in the Italian energy giant SNAM, is convinced that the gas industry is facing a historic challenge but also a great opportunity. Gas was long hailed as a “transition” fuel from hydrocarbons to renewables. Given what we know about the state of technology and energy poverty around the world, gas should be around for many decades.

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Links & Internal Links › Link – Green New Deal

Green New Deal seeks to end natural gas -- economically disastrous for impoverished communities in the US

CEA, 21 (April 20, Consumer Energy Alliance, “Green New Deal Would Cost American Consumers More Than $258 Billion – in JUST Four Appliances” https://consumerenergyalliance.org/2021/04/green-new-deal-would-cost-american-consumers-more-than-258-billion-in-just-four-appliances/, NK)

The “Green New Deal” is not such a good deal for American energy consumers. Designed to completely replace America’s use of abundant and affordable energy sources such as natural gas, the resolution’s goal is to make the country entirely dependent upon renewable energy. The Green New Deal is not a practical solution for American consumers, us many common household appliances, such as furnaces, water heaters, stoves, and dryers, are powered by natural gas and would have to be replaced at the expense of hardworking families across the country.

Most American households rely on natural gas for cooking, cleaning, or heating their homes. About 59.5 million households rely upon natural gas for heat.((https://www.eia.gov/consumption/residential/data/2015/hc/php/hc1.1.php)) At minimum, a new electric furnace and installation costs $2,500 for a total of more than $148.7 billion nationwide.((https://www.homeadvisor.com/cost/heating-and-cooling/install-a-furnace/))

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Links & Internal Links › Link – Green New Deal

Natural gas creates millions of new jobs and U.S. LNG exports reduce global carbon emissions from dirty coal plants and highly – Green New Deal would foreclose those benefits

Steidler, 19 --- senior fellow with the Lexington Institute, a public policy think tank in Arlington, Virginia (February 21, 2019, “Fueling a Green New Deal with Liquefied Natural Gas,” https://insidesources.com/fueling-a-green-new-deal-with-liquefied-natural-gas/, JMP))

Freshman Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez has gotten much attention by proposing a Green New Deal, a far-ranging proposal to shift the U.S. economy away from fossil fuels over the next decade while somehow creating millions of good-paying jobs.

Her plan amounts to turning success into failure by ignoring the vast economic and environmental benefits natural gas has provided to America in the past decade — and the opportunity to multiply these benefits in the decade ahead.

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Links & Internal Links › Link – Green New Deal

Green New Deal eradicates natural gas which is a cheap, clean energy source that reduces global emissions

LNG exports to China, India and Japan create shift away from dirtier coal

Weinstein, 19 --- adjunct professor of business economics at Southern Methodist University (07/31/19, BERNARD L., “Natural gas is the ‘real’ green new deal,” https://thehill.com/opinion/energy-environment/454824-natural-gas-is-the-real-green-new-deal/, NK)

Early this year, with great fanfare, several members of Congress proposed a “Green New Deal” to battle climate change through a rapid and drastic reduction in the production and consumption of fossil fuels. Specifically, the program called for eliminating pollution and greenhouse gas emissions (GHGs) by “greening” all new and existing buildings in the U.S., embracing distributed power generation and smart grids, and meeting 100 percent of electricity demand by 2030 with zero-emission energy sources — i.e., no fossil fuels and no nukes.

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Links & Internal Links › Link – Carbon Tax

Carbon taxing only the U.S. will move pollution abroad and undermine U.S. domestic manufacturing base

Muresianu and Bray 22 --- Policy Analyst, Director of European Policy at the Tax Foundation (November 3, 2022, Alex, Sean, “Carbon Taxes, Trade, and American Competitiveness,” https://taxfoundation.org/border-adjusted-carbon-tax-revenue/ Tax Foundation, NK)

Economists tend to favor carbon taxes as an ideal policy solution to address climate change.[1] By making the market reflect the social costs of carbon emissions, such a tax would incentivize emissions reduction and innovation, without creating a specific bias for or against different technologies.

But how carbon taxes interact with a globalized economy is more complicated. For one, it is possible that a carbon tax enacted only in America could merely move polluting activity abroad rather than drive down the overall level of carbon emissions.

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Links & Internal Links › Link – Carbon Tax

Carbon tax will increase price of natural gas and incentivize transition to renewables

Parry ’19 - Principal Environmental Fiscal Policy Expert at International Monetary Fund [Ian, 06/19, Finance and Development, “What Is Carbon Taxation” https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/fandd/issues/2019/06/what-is-carbon-taxation-basics, JR]

Carbon taxes, levied on coal, oil products, and natural gas in proportion to their carbon content, can be collected from fuel suppliers. They in turn will pass on the tax in the form of higher prices for electricity, gasoline, heating oil, and so on, as well as for the products and services that depend on them. This provides incentives for producers and consumers alike to reduce energy use and shift to lower-carbon fuels or renewable energy sources through investment or behavior.

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Links & Internal Links › Link – Carbon Tax

Affirmative author admits a carbon tax will undermine the natural gas industry --- stops pipelines and shipping terminals

Hsu, 21 --- D'Alemberte Professor, Florida State University College of Law (Summer, 2021, Shi-Ling Hsu, ECONOMIC JUSTICE: Carbon Taxes and Economic Inequality, 15 Harv. L. & Pol'y Rev. 551, Nexis Uni, JMP))

Of course, there is much, much more work to be done, well beyond the decline in coal usage. The next stage of decarbonization is the phasing out of fossil fuels generally, which it now appears, must take place sooner rather than later. 48 A carbon price must emerge soon to slow down natural gas exploration, and stall the quest for new pipelines and shipping terminals. That capacity must be replaced with renewable energy and energy storage technologies, which will require a carbon price in order to supplant natural gas as the fuel of choice for electricity generation. The economics of natural gas and renewable energy sources are different, but despite historically low gas prices, 49 wind and solar energy are competitive: the levelized cost of electricity for wind and solar energy 50 has declined rapidly, so that they are clearly lower than coal and generally (but not uniformly) lower than efficient [*561] combined cycle natural gas plants. 51 That does not necessarily translate into a cost advantage, as many considerations go into fuel choice, such as intermittency, traditionally a problem with renewable energy sources. 52 However, a carbon tax of $ 30 per ton of CO2 would add about $ 5.50 to a megawatthour of electricity generated by natural gas, which has levelized costs in the neighborhood of $ 30-40 per MWhr, 53 and could thus provide a decided advantage to renewable energy and energy storage technologies. That may bring about yet another transformation of the energy industry. Of course, a higher carbon tax would make that outcome a greater certainty.

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Uniqueness › AT: Gas Phase-out Now

Natural gas demand will be sustained from demand for LNG and gradual phase in of renewables

Baker, 23 --- Natural Gas Intelligence Writer (Andrew Baker, May 19, 2023, LNG Exports Seen Boosting North American Natural Gas Demand Through Next Decade and Beyond, https://www.naturalgasintel.com/lng-exports-seen-boosting-north-american-natural-gas-demand-through-next-decade-and-beyond/, BDP)

North American natural gas demand is likely to grow by roughly 25% over the next 10 years and stay resilient through 2050 as the world shifts to lower-carbon energy, according to new projections from Wood Mackenzie.

LNG exports are expected to drive the incremental demand, which will largely be supplied through continued growth in associated gas from the oily Permian Basin and gas-directed drilling in the Haynesville Shale, researchers said in the new report.

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Uniqueness › AT: Non-Unique – Inflation Reduction Act

Inflation Reduction Act was balanced – also included expansion for oil and gas production

Isaacs-Thomas ’22 [Bella, 8/17/22, PBS, “What the Inflation Reduction Act does for green energy” https://www.pbs.org/newshour/science/what-the-inflation-reduction-act-does-for-green-energy 6/23/22, JR]

In order to win West Virginia Sen. Joe Manchin’s approval, wins for oil and gas production were also added to the Inflation Reduction Act – a fact that environmental advocates aren’t keen on.

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Uniqueness › AT: Non-Unique – Renewables Now

Priced in -- oil and natural gas will still remain the most consumed fuels despite current renewable projections

Chicaiza, 22 [ Melissa, 27 December, Energy in Depth, “Year in Review: U.S. Oil and Natural Gas Industry Hits Record Production to Meet Rising Global Demand in 2022.” Energy in Depth, 27 Dec. 2022, www.energyindepth.org/year-in-review-u-s-oil-and-natural-gas-industry-hits-record-production-to-meet-rising-global-demand-in-2022/, Accessed on 23 June 2023, NP]

U.S. Energy Consumption Continued to Grow With Oil & Natural Gas As Top Fuels

The EIA 2022 Annual Energy Outlook forecasts that while the renewable energy market grows steadily, oil and natural gas will remain the two most-consumed energy sources in the United States, driven by increasing population growth and economic development. From EIA:

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Uniqueness › AT: Non-Unique – Renewables Now

Biden’s signal of support is giving oil and gas industries confidence now despite existing renewables

Friedman, 23 – New York Times climate and environment writer [Lisa; March 14; Lisa Friedman is a reporter on the climate desk, focusing on climate and environmental policy in Washington. She has covered eight international climate talks and chased climate-related stories from the bottom of a Chinese coal mine to the top of snow-capped Himalaya Mountains; New York Times, “Big Oil Gets It’s Mojo Back, Huge profits and higher demand have empowered the industry.” https://www.nytimes.com/2023/03/14/climate/oil-gas-industry.html, LK]

To sum it up, confidence is high in the oil and gas world. That’s very different from where we were just a couple of years ago and it has important implications for the global transition to cleaner energy. 

A huge decision on Alaska 

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Uniqueness › --- XT: Ukraine Conflict Revitalizing Traditional Energy

Ukraine conflict revitalizing support for traditional energy sources at the expense of clean energy

Clemente, 22--- Principal at JTC Energy Research Associates, LLC, B.A. in International Relations from Penn State University, with a minor in Statistical Analysis, M.S. in Homeland Security from San Diego State University, with a focus on Energy Security, and an MBA from St. Francis University, with a focus on Energy Economics (May 22, 2022,07:00pm EDT, Jude, “Exposed By Putin, The Energy Know-Nothings Must Now Go Away,” https://www.forbes.com/sites/judeclemente/2022/05/22/exposed-by-putin-the-energy-know-nothings-must-now-go-away/?sh=12096306135b, JMP))

I’m convinced that the silver lining in this horrific war is that Putin has awoken the West from its energy slumber.

Even the most blind are beginning to see.

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Uniqueness › 2nc Uniqueness – Clean Energy Declining

Transition to clean energy plagued by number of barriers --- natural gas still in demand

Clemente, 5/8/2023 --- Principal at JTC Energy Research Associates, LLC, B.A. in International Relations from Penn State University, with a minor in Statistical Analysis, M.S. in Homeland Security from San Diego State University, with a focus on Energy Security, and an MBA from St. Francis University, with a focus on Energy Economics (May 08, 2023, Jude, “Wind and Solar Aren’t Nearly Enough: Why Biden Is Suddenly Supporting Fossil Fuels,” https://www.realclearenergy.org/articles/2023/05/08/wind_and_solar_are_not_nearly_enough_why_biden_is_suddenly_supporting_fossil_fuels_897517.html, JMP))

Progress towards an energy transition appears to be significantly lagging the optimistic projections and any reduction in government mandates and subsidies could make many investments unprofitable, and at least some elements of the energy transition appear to be driven by irrational exuberance – Michael Lynch, Energy Policy Research Foundation, 2022

The loudening insistence that renewables should displace, not just supplement, fossil fuels and nuclear energy in the power sector has some undeniable problems.

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Uniqueness › 2nc Uniqueness – Clean Energy Declining

Ukraine conflict has thrown cold water on clean energy transition --- there will be a greater reliance on fossil fuels

Clemente, 5/8/2023 --- Principal at JTC Energy Research Associates, LLC, B.A. in International Relations from Penn State University, with a minor in Statistical Analysis, M.S. in Homeland Security from San Diego State University, with a focus on Energy Security, and an MBA from St. Francis University, with a focus on Energy Economics (May 08, 2023, Jude, “Wind and Solar Aren’t Nearly Enough: Why Biden Is Suddenly Supporting Fossil Fuels,” https://www.realclearenergy.org/articles/2023/05/08/wind_and_solar_are_not_nearly_enough_why_biden_is_suddenly_supporting_fossil_fuels_897517.html, JMP))

Nobody loves the Biden administration’s new EPA regulations to force huge amounts of electric cars onto the power grid more than the beleaguered coal industry.

Electric cars and the overarching goal of electrification will surely surge U.S. electricity demand, a sector that has been flat at 4,100 terawatt hours since the Great Recession 15 years ago (see figure).

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Uniqueness › 2nc Uniqueness – Biden Support Oil & Gas

Biden signaling support for fossil fuels – new infrastructure demonstrates

Lefebvre ’23 [Ben, Interviewed by John Yang, 4/2/23, PBS, “Biden’s complex relationship with oil and gas, despite campaign promises” https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/bidens-complex-relationship-with-oil-and-gas-despite-campaign-promises 6/23/23, JR]

In 2020, Joe Biden promised to move the U.S. away from fossil fuels. But the Biden administration has a complicated relationship with the oil and gas industry — it has moved forward on plans to drill federally owned lands, auctioned off 73 million acres in the Gulf of Mexico, and approved the controversial Willow project in Alaska. POLITICO energy reporter Ben Lefebvre joins John Yang to discuss.

Read the Full Transcript