2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Harms – Care Work
Schulz 2017 - Board of Directors of the United Nations Research Institute for Social Development [Patricia, Jan 31, Global Social Policy “Universal basic income in a feminist perspective and gender analysis” UP]
Feminist economists have for decades criticized mainstream economic theory for considering only remunerated work in the so-called production sector, and gross domestic product (GDP) still considers only this sector. Change occurs, there are now numerous publications and data in economic and social sciences addressing unpaid, care work and its relation to the various disadvantages that women face. But even with this new approach and the almost general recognition that gender equality is key to economic development, care work remains mainly female. Even though satellite accounts give information on the value of reproductive work, it is still either not really considered as work if provided for free in the private sphere or, if it is provided against pay, in a work relationship, it is often poorly paid and considered. Reproductive work, mainly accomplished by women the world over, for free or very little money, thus remains steadfastly insufficiently addressed in practice in the labor market and legislation, as well as the homes of people. Women pay a high price for providing the largest part of care work in the home, as this limits the access or choices of girls to education and the access of women to paid work, deprives them of the autonomy that goes with an income and the protection of social security systems when one is in place, and thus exposes them to the risk of poverty and dependence. In industrialized countries, work organization, labor legislation and social security systems developed progressively based on the model of the male breadwinner. Therefore, as most social security systems are (still) based on contributions linked to remunerated work, independent or salaried, the inferior income of women, their restriction to part-time jobs as well as the interruptions in their careers due to care responsibilities will directly impact the level of social protection they can expect in case of old age, disability, illness and so on, as well as expose them to depend on a partner and/or the (welfare) state.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Harms – Care Work
Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? ] EP
Cultural imperialism describes oppressed groups’ experiences of “how the dominant meanings of a society render the particular perspective of one’s own group invisible at the same time as they stereotype one’s group and mark it as the Other.” This involves universalizing and normalizing the dominant group’s experiences and culture and subordinating the group that “becomes reconstructed” as deviant and inferior due to its difference. This experience echoes W.E.B. Du Bois’s term, “double consciousness,” which arises when an oppressed subject is defined by both a dominant and a subordinate culture and chooses to reject the “devalued, objectified, stereotyped visions” associated with their group. Young claims that this experience, u nlike the other forms of oppression, does not deal with labor, but women’s experiences with labor call this claim into question. Feminists have consistently pointed out the problems with how we conceive of labor and how we treat the labor that women perform. This paper has already reviewed many of their complaints, but connecting them to the experience of cultural imperialism is important for understanding the connection between women’s experiences in and out of the workforce and their oppression. Although cultural imperialism and double consciousness generally describe the experiences of racialized minorities, not women, cultural imperialism still applies to women’s experiences. Work produces economic goods and services as well as social and political subjects. The work that we perform classes, racializes, and genders us. Work is organized by gender, and gender is enforced, performed, and recreated in arenas of work, particularly due to the gender differentiation of labor. The same can be said for racialized minorities who perform menial labor. Work also contributes to the ways in which society attaches value to different types of labor and thereby produces oppressive hierarchies based on race, gender, and class. Racial minorities who disproportionately perform stigmatized labor and women who perform caregiving labor risk being seen as contributing less to society. Presumably, this is why these workers are paid less, or not at all. Women of color experience these consequences most acutely because they are simultaneously paid less for their waged work and face the devaluation of their unpaid domestic labor. Though cultural imperialism and labor may not be linked explicitly, our culture around work and systems of labor which segregate individuals based on social divisions stigmatize and stereotype women. This renders women’s labor invisible while stereotyping women as deviant relative to men.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Framework - Gender + Race Lens
Bhattacharya 2019 - director of programs and strategy at the Insight Center for Community Economic Development [Jhumpa “Exploring Guaranteed Income through a Racial and Gendered Justice Lens” . . Accessed 23 June 2023 EO]
Much less attention has been paid to the role that the National Welfare Rights Organization (NWRO) played in advancing a guaranteed income, which reached over 100,000 members at the organization’s peak. The NWRO focused primarily on racial, gender, and economic justice. Many NWRO members were Black women who moved north from the sharecropping south and faced widespread employment discrimination. They clearly understood that their status as public assistance recipients was tied to being seen as laborers, rather than hard-working mothers, who were nonetheless deemed unworthy and undeserving of any assistance. They challenged the stigma of welfare and insisted that a decent standard of living was a right —one that should not be tied to waged work—while also emphasizing the work and value of caregiving. Movements such as these understood the potential that a guaranteed income had, and we owe it to ourselves—and to those who came before us—to understand how a guaranteed income needs to be designed in the 21st century in order to finish what began generations ago.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Framework - Gender + Race Lens
Bhattacharya 2019 - director of programs and strategy at the Insight Center for Community Economic Development [Jhumpa “Exploring Guaranteed Income through a Racial and Gendered Justice Lens” . . Accessed 23 June 2023 EO]
When designing any policy—including a guaranteed income—to ensure that it promotes racial and gender wealth equity, it is imperative to understand the history of wealth accumulation in the US. Specifically, we must acknowledge and account for who has been given access to wealth building opportunities and who has been, and continues to be, denied. When wealth is passed on from one generation to the next, it crystalizes economic security from one generation to the next. Historical Policies and Practices Our nation has a troubled and lengthy history of rules that have driven today’s racial and gender wealth disparities. It is not, as we are too-often led to believe, personal behavior or individual choices that are the root causes of the economic stratification we see today; rather, it is a result of the systemic exclusion of wealth building opportunities for women and people of color. These exclusions can best be seen through specific time periods, including our nation’s founding, the Reconstruction and Jim Crow periods, and the New Deal era, but they are also reinforced through present-day policies or lack of policies that ensure equity (Flynn et al. 2017). America’s legacy of stealing land from Indigenous communities and enslaving Black people from other parts of the world underpin present-day wealth inequities: The denial of humanity to Black and Indigenous communities from the earliest days of our nation, and the systematic blocking and stripping of wealth from these communities, led to the accumulation of wealth for white people—and for the country more broadly. The end of the Civil War brought forth the Reconstruction era that moved the needle on racial equity, albeit for a fleeting period of time. Reconstruction was met with a fierce backlash that ushered in the Jim Crow era and a wave of new rules that systematically and legally excluded Black people—along with other people of color including Native Americans—from many social and economic opportunities, all while sanctioning separate and superior public facilities for white Americans. Notably, Black people were not allowed to live in white neighborhoods and were often denied voting power. This allowed for white communities to have access to well-funded schools and neighborhoods along with bank loans and other public and private aide institutions; inferior, underfunded, and sometimes no such facilities were offered to Black Americans. This reality further entrenched economic separation between white people and people of color in the US. The New Deal era greatly expanded pathways to economic mobility and security for white Americans, but it also erected more barriers for people of color. During the early days of New Deal negotiations, FDR made a political comprise to appease Southern Democrats and agreed to exclude agricultural and domestic workers—who were predominantly Black and Latinx—from being eligible for a range of benefits. The exclusions baked into the New Deal reinforced the inequities we see today. In 1935, the Social Security Act was created, but the early exclusions prevented many workers of color from receiving retirement benefits, even though they paid into it. This played a significant role in preventing workers of color from using their income to generate wealth and assets. In 1937, the Federal Housing Authority (FHA) became the first federal agency to openly advocate and support segregation between races, openly refusing loans to people of color, which curtail these communities’ ability to buy homes and restricted the neighborhoods in which they could live—all barriers to home ownership, which has been one of the most significant mechanisms for building wealth in the United States. In the 1940s, the largest federal public benefits program in history came about in the form of the GI Bill, a program that paid college tuition and gave low-interest home mortgages to returning veterans, ultimately providing a low-cost route to wealth creation. However, discrimination in college admissions and housing markets prevented most soldiers of color from using the GI Bill, which thus prevented an accumulation and transfer of wealth to future generations. Sexism and misogyny that are baked into our history and policy implementation have lead to gender wealth inequities. Historic policies denied women the ability to own property on their own or have property passed onto them, single women were not allowed to secure loans, and they were restricted in their ability to earn advanced degrees and improve their career prospects (Kijakazi and McCulloch 2018). Women have also been systematically paid less for the same jobs. In fact, a 2018 Hired.com report on wages in the workplace found that men were offered a higher salary than women for the same job at the same company 63 percent of the time (Hired.com n.d.). The report further noted that Black and Latinx women are consistently offered lower salaries than white men. Additionally, pay inequity plagues Millennial women: In 2013, the median income for Millennial women was $30,000 compared to $35,000 for men (Institute for Women’s Policy Research n.d.).
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Framework - Gender + Race Lens
Bhattacharya 2019 - director of programs and strategy at the Insight Center for Community Economic Development [Jhumpa “Exploring Guaranteed Income through a Racial and Gendered Justice Lens” . . Accessed 23 June 2023 EO]
By tackling wealth inequality, we can ultimately put America on the road to greater racial and gender economic justice. Income is crucial for building wealth, but efforts to improve incomes alone will not close gaps in wealth along racial and gender lines. As such, we also need to consider how anti-Blackness, xenophobia, and sexism have rigged the rules of our economy to deny certain populations equal access to prosperity and liberation. This will enable us to have a more comprehensive discussion about intersectionality and the numerous issues that need to be addressed—in addition to boosting incomes—in order to create the conditions where everyone in the US truly has the ability to build wealth and thrive. This paper proposes a multi-pronged approach to designing a guaranteed income policy that includes: • Dismantling narratives that dehumanize Black and brown people and question their deservedness to receive public assistance; • Eliminating state-sponsored wealth extraction through our criminal justice system; and • Establishing a truth and reconciliation process in the US. Incorporating these elements into a no-strings-attached cash benefit for all residents can create the conditions that are necessary for true gender and racial economic justice to be achieved.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Framework First
Zelleke, 2011 - The New School for General Studies, New York [Almaz, Policy & Politics vol 39 no 1, “Feminist political theory and the argument for an unconditional basic income” TA]
Contemporary debates on the merits of a basic income take place in the literatures of distributive justice, citizenship, equality and public policy. Liberal egalitarian theories of justice, including those of Rawls (1971), Dworkin (2000) and White (2003), defend the legitimacy of some redistribution of income and wealth, but differ about how much is justified, and under what conditions. An unconditional basic income is thought by some liberal egalitarians to represent exploitation of ‘crazies’ – those who have high earnings to which they are morally entitled – by ‘lazies’ – those who prefer not to work, or decline the jobs that are available to them (Elster ,1986). Related to this exploitation objection, but grounded in an ideal of citizenship rather than of distributive justice, is the claim that the reciprocity principle requires, if not a strictly proportional relationship between effort and income, at least a relatively proportional ‘productive’ contribution to be eligible for the benefits of redistribution (White, 2003). The concept of independence is used both by basic income advocates, who see the universal grant as providing all citizens with the independence akin to that bestowed by an inheritance (Meade, 1993) or by inalienable voting rights (Pateman, 2005), and by its opponents, who argue that those dependent on income benefits can never achieve the independence necessary for full citizenship (Mead, 1986). Full consideration of the arguments for basic income is beyond the scope of this article. Here I focus on examining the premises on which the most salient objections to an unconditional basic income are constructed. I argue that traditional theories of justice and citizenship posit an ostensibly gender-neutral but clearly androcentric subject – the autonomous, ‘independent’ and dependant-free adult faced with a choice between employment and leisure. Dominant theories of justice and citizenship make this problematic presumption without fully understanding how that subject embodies a gender bias that is inimical to women’s equality. The effect of this gender bias in the realm of distributive justice in general, and in the basic income debate in particular, is the reinforcement of economic inequalities between those with disproportionate responsibility for care work and those without, through the undervaluing of care work as a social contribution, and through misconceptions about the extent to which care work can be commodified and those who now provide it unburdened of it. Training a feminist lens on justice and citizenship, through which androcentric theories are tempered by recognition of these dependencies and of the importance of care work, suggests the broad outlines of a feminist theory of justice and citizenship that promotes the fullest conception of distributive justice – one that embodies a substantive equality of the genders. Despite the existence of many thoughtful critiques of male-centric political theory and theories of justice, as well as numerous policies and policy proposals meant to address specific instances of gender inequality, a comprehensive feminist theory of justice has yet to be articulated. In relation to the basic income debate, I argue that not only does a feminist perspective on justice require an unconditional basic income, but also that is the only basis on which to defend the principle of unconditionality against the gender-biased claims of universal work or participation duties. Therefore, the debates around an unconditional basic income constitute a fruitful arena for the development of a feminist theory of justice. I begin this article with a brief survey of the feminist critiques of political theory and theories of justice, and of androcentric models of citizenship. Together these critiques suggest a more gender-inclusive model of citizenship and the broad outlines of a feminist theory of justice, in which an unconditional basic income plays a crucial role.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Framework First
Robeyns, 2001 – Chair Ethics of Institutions at the Utrecht University, Netherlands [Ingrid. “Will a Basic Income Do Justice to Women?: A Contribution to the Symposium on P. Van Parijs ’s “Real Freedom for All” Analyse & Kritik, vol. 23, no. 1 AC]
4.3 Women's Diversity and Spill-Over Effects It is clear that some women want to stay at home. In a liberal state, nobody can force them to work on the labour market and bring their children to day-care. And that is definitely a good thing, as for some women, doing housework and care labour is their best option, taking actual preferences, conditions and constraints into account. If a basic income would be introduced, for some women the best 102 Ingrid Robeyns option will shift from working outside the house (probably in bad circumstances, doing low-paid, boring work), to working at home. Crucial to the feminist concerns regarding basic income is women's diversity, and the spill-over effects the choices of one group of women have on the other. The different effects described in sections 2 and 3 will affect some groups of women differently from other groups. To summarise, low-skilled women with low labour-market attachment will definitely gain from a basic income. High skilled women with strong labour market attachment will lose from the reinforcement of gender roles and statistical discrimination. For other groups of women, some effects are offsetting others, so that the total effect is ambiguous.4 Hence, we face a dilemma. If we want to fully and unconditionally respect choices women make in the given gender-structured society, we see that some of those women are putting their own future well-being at risk, and at the same time worsen the constraints on other women's choices. We can not simply assume that all housewives have a 'false consciousness' and therefore we can not impose a paternalistic social policy. However, neither can we pretend to live in a society where no gender-related preference formation mechanisms and gender-related con-straints on choices exist-in other words, the pure liberal concept of autonomous fully informed choices is not helping us either. The question seems therefore how to maximise the individual capacity of real choice, while at the same time step by step abolishing the gender-and other groups-related constraints individuals face when making those choices.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Framework First
Goldblatt, 2021 - Professor of Law, University of the Witwatersrand [Beth “Basic Income, Gender and Human Rights” Acc 1/28/23 TA]
The basic income debate is both a process of claim-making and a means of exposing what is wrong with our existing systems. It is also an opportunity to consider new ideas for social and economic organisation. This has obvious appeal to feminists since the project of feminism is by its nature both critical of what we have, political in demanding change, and utopian in visualising a different way of structuring gender in society.116 This aligns well with aspects of the human rights project, an attempt to progressively realise a fairer world. As Philip Alston puts it:117 … the utopian vision may also provide the much-needed impetus to rethink the optimal shape of social protection explicitly designed to achieve universal realization of the human right to an adequate standard of living in the twenty-first century. Combining feminist and human rights arguments has the potential to offer a new angle into the basic income debate. A focus on a substantive, redistributive equality approach challenges discourses of minimalism that arise in discussion of a basic income. It also challenges the human rights discussion of a basic income to ensure that gender and equality are fully considered and built into understandings of a rights-compliant basic income proposal. Bringing rights-based arguments into the feminist debate encourages a careful consideration of the evolving framework of guidance on the interpretation of rights (particularly social and economic rights and non-discrimination/equality); and what this might mean for basic income as a policy choice and its specific formulation. Human rights, including ILO standards, direct attention to the requirements of a just social protection system and workplace which can reinforce feminist arguments for new social policies that extend justice to women and challenge sexual divisions of care and work.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Gendered UBI
Flanigan, 2018 - prof of leadership studies and law at the University of Richmond [Jessica, Jan 25, Slate “The Feminist Case for a Universal Basic Income” TA]
And because a basic income would make the decision to work more voluntary, women would no longer choose to remain in toxic jobs solely because they can’t afford not to. In this way, a UBI could address gender-based mistreatment in workplaces. By freeing women of their economic dependence on employers, a UBI would also improve women’s bargaining positions, enabling them to negotiate for more flexible hours or better conditions. But a UBI would not discourage work to an extent that would undermine the economy. People would still need to work to afford most consumer goods and luxuries. And unlike minimum wage requirements, touted by Fight for $15 activists, a UBI neither raises the cost of employing low-income workers relative to other workers nor disproportionately burdens employers to provide a decent standard of living for people in their communities. With an even starting ground, the opportunities to move beyond the lowest-paying work could be more readily available to marginalized workers who’ve been left out for too long. 2. Women Could Make Unfettered Decisions About How to Structure Their Families and Lives Child care is extraordinarily expensive, and women, especially single moms, end up shouldering an enormous burden for this cost. Some parents who would prefer to work are unable to because they cannot afford quality child care for their kids. Women are more likely to leave the workforce for this reason than men. A UBI for mothers and children would enable women who want to work to pay for child care. In addition, a UBI (including child benefits) would formally recognize and reward socially valuable labor that people currently perform outside of the paid economy, such as caregiving for children, disabled people, and elderly relatives. The UBI could amount to “wages for housework,” something feminists in the 1970s pushed for. Furthermore, because a UBI aims to pay all individuals and not households, it allows people to make decisions about marriage and cohabitation based their intrinsic desires, not based on tax policies such as the “marriage penalty” that working couples currently face or means-tested welfare programs that withhold benefits from women when their household income increases after marriage. A further benefit for families? With an added, guaranteed boost to their income, women in abusive relationships would have the financial security to leave, even if they lack qualifications or credentials that would enable them to support themselves and their families. UBI would do more than almost any other economic policy imaginable to make women less susceptible to abuse both in the workplace and at home.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Gendered UBI
Webster, 2019 - Head of research at Royal Society of Arts [Hannah March 8th Why Basic Income is a women’s issue, Royal Society of Arts, , EP]
Could a Basic Income benefit women’s rights? For welfare to more effectively support women, or to even go further and promote equality, there needs to be a radical change. At the RSA, we see a wider benefit in an overhaul of the British welfare system and are advocates for experiments of a Basic Income. Under such a system, everyone receives a fixed and equal monthly payment, which is neither means tested (based on what you earn) or sanctionable (able to be taken away due to behaviour). A primary motivation for this change is to re-empower individuals rather than enforce conditionality and limitations for those relying on welfare to survive. The policy has the potential to open up opportunities for women, however it is essential that lessons are learnt from the shortcomings of the current system. There are some clear and direct benefits to a Basic Income for women, particularly when looking at the policy in contrast to Universal Credit: Every payment is given to the individual if they are over the age of 18, meaning that financial agency is placed in the hands of the individual, not the household. This is an important distinction for women in abusive relationships who, in contrast to the current system, would no longer be financially dependent on their abuser. There is additional support for all children, with no arbitrary caps based on the size of the family. This opens up a greater opportunity to pay for both children and childcare, something which is currently a major barrier to mothers on welfare looking for employment. By removing the threat of sanctions for not accepting inappropriate work, women with children can seek employment that is flexible and tailored to their needs as a mother.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Gendered UBI
Mazurana and McKay, 2001 - Research Director of Gender, Youth, and Community at Tufts Univ. and contributor to The Irish Times [Dyan and Susan “Women, Girls, and Structural Violence: A Global Analysis”, TA]*** from backfile
The male bias inherent in (patriarchal) democracy has led to forms of patriarchal structural violence that relegate “women’s issues” to the “private” realm where they become “private matters” that the state does not address. This bias is perhaps nowhere clearer than in the issue of domestic violence, where male bias greatly impairs the ability of police, judges, and lawmakers from recognizing the violent behavior in the family. “The view that ‘as a family matter’ battery is less important, is based on men’s, not women’s perceptions” (Murray & O’Regan, 1991, p. 45). The multiple forms of domestic violence that women suffer have profound physical and psychological effects (Herman, 1992; Kelly, 1993), prompting international calls for domestic violence to be recognized as a form of torture (Copelon, 1994). Governmental support of patriarchal structural violence through its inattention to “private” matters is apparent throughout the world. Until 1991, the murder of a wife in Brazil was legal—it was considered an honor killing and was done to preserve the family’s honor because of a woman’s transgression. In many areas of the world, men are free to rape their wives with no threat of legal repercussions (Mertus, 1995). Other examples of government-sponsored patriarchal structural violence include laws and systems that condone particular forms of violence against women, deny women control over their bodies, provide no assistance with child care and maternity leave, make no attempt to remedy child support defaults, and fail to provide unemployment protection to women who work within the “private” realm in domestic service or farm work (Waring, 1988; Murray & O’Regan, 1991). Because governments rarely address patriarchal structural violence or fight for women’s rights, progress for women is largely made by women working for the recognition and enforcement of women’s rights. As a result, in countries such as Australia, Brazil, Britain, Columbia, India, Sri Lanka, and the United States, violence against women in the home has been identified and some forms of it criminalized (Fineman & Mykitiuk, 1994).
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Gendered UBI
Story, 2017 – writer for Basic Income.org [Rae, Breaking the Vicious Circle: Basic Income and Sexual Exploitation March 18, TA]
I had an abusive boyfriend once. He lured me in with promises of provision and vindication. But he was a perfidious son of a gun, because the initial half of his Janus face was insidiously torn aside, to reveal his deft capacity for creating insecurity, isolation and intellectual dissonance. My boyfriend, my great, devastating, intoxicating love, was prostitution. Yes, like any other lover of an abuser, I was hooked in by his exaggerated claims of support and potential for actualisation — “I will empower you! I will make you free!” — smoke screening an undercurrent of exploitative tendencies. For me, for others, by the time we understand this, we have become trapped. Some people may wince at my comparing prostitution to abuse. I have been usefully informed, on a number of occasions, that it is a simply a job as any other. That it is not sexual exploitation, because women choose to enter into it freely. But even if that were so, what if the same women can’t manage to leave when they decide they have had enough? How many times, after that point, must they be utilised for sex effectively against their true will, before it becomes a violation? Being trapped in prostitution, relationship violence and cycles of survival sex can indeed be crushing to a person’s sense of capacity and the “outside” world can look increasingly hostile and difficult to negotiate. Coercive control, which often operates in these situations, is manipulative and extremely sophisticated. It tells you that you are not capable of surviving — let alone thriving — in any other way, just as it depletes you. It is like living with a blade at your throat, but being told it is for your own protection. What does all this have to do with Universal Basic Income (UBI)? Because as with all of the most effective manipulations, it contains a kernel of truth. If a woman is told by her abuser or her pimp — or by the propaganda of living in prostitution — that she could not survive without them, that voice is solidified by the material experience of structural inequality that poor women suffer. The crossroads between class and sex-based oppression is, indeed, best exemplified by a woman having to make a daily decision between sexual or domestic abuse, and poverty. So if our toxic situation has been the source of our “income” — in exchange for domestic, reproductive or sexual labour — what do we do if we want to leave? Refuge recommends that women escaping abusive or exploitative situations should seek out emergency accommodation from friends or family, but often abuse victims have been systematically disenfranchised from such social support and, as with high numbers of women in prostitution, have come through the care system, many didn’t have it in the first place. Women’s refuges are suffering from closures and on average 155 women are turned away each day, according to Women’s Aid. Shockingly, women escaping domestic violence are not automatically considered in priority need for social housing. That is even before you even get to prostitutes; an even less likely group to be considered a “worthy” cause. Indeed, our current welfare system is based on nebulous arbitrations of “need” and “worthiness,” which are often further gunned through the dubious prism of abstract bureaucracy. The Conservative government has seemingly decided that it cannot trust the word of doctors in assessing someone’s capacity for work and so subject often extremely vulnerable people to further “assessments.” Women who have been in prostitution or domestic violence often suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and other psychological fragilities. For them these processes can be intimidating, due to the fear of being judged, blamed and dismissed as “undeserving.” This is even before we even get to the trials of unemployment benefit, not available to anyone whose partner works more than 24 hours per week — not much good if said partner has a predilection for controlling every aspect of your life. And if you’re under 35 and have no children you cannot suddenly decide to no longer submit to unwanted sex with men you don’t know, because you are not eligible for housing benefit contributions for your apartment. Or because you cannot find another job, due to your lack of experience or your anxiety, or both. Yes, I’ve seen many a woman make her Great Escape from abuse only to find her road blocked at every turn. Back she goes, to her hard fisted boyfriend or her brothel pimp — now more vulnerable and more convinced of the absolutenesses of her “destiny.” What is the first thing a woman escaping violence needs? To not have to “explain herself” to society — to beg even — to get the ticket out of her situation. Because asking such people to make the case for their right to freedom from abuse is an extension of that abuse. She has already had to try to explain to her “lover” why he should allow her to sleep safe that night, or to her pimp why she cannot work because her vagina has become torn and bruised. The idea behind UBI is that every member of society gets a basic monthly amount, irrespective of their social circumstances or their assumed worthiness. I am not going to make a more general case for UBI, as those arguments can be found elsewhere. However, it has instigated the twitching of my feminist ear because as a policy it has, under the right conditions, the potential to give victims of domestic violence and sexual exploitation a slightly easier out. In the 1970s there were a lot of debates about whether or not women should receive wages for housework, but many feminists felt that this would crystallise the idea that domesticity was women’s work. UBI on the other hand is a basic economic sustenance that is paid to a woman by virtue of her humanity, not her femininity, which is in any case a social imposition demanding of her submissive agreeableness. Of course UBI is not the full answer to the question of women’s exploitation. But because it does not require women to be the perfect victims, it is at least starting to ask the right questions.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Gendered UBI
Williams, 2021 -- Writer for Research and Data Section for UN Women. [Loui. April 21, Policy Brief No. 22 “Universal basic income: Potential and limitations from a gender perspective” https://www.unwomen.org/sites/default/files/Headquarters/Attachments/Sections/Library/Publications/2021/Policy-brief-Universal-basic-income-en.pdf UP]
What could universal basic income mean for gender equality? Feminist perspectives vary on the significance of UBI for gender equality. The feminist case for UBI Feminists supporters argue that an individual income such as UBI could help guarantee women’s economic autonomy in the face of ongoing discrimination in employment and increase their bargaining power in (and beyond) families and communities. UBI would remove the exclusionary pitfalls and stigma attached to means-tested schemes, as well as avoid the paternalistic and sometimes coercive implementation practices documented for some conditional cash transfers. It may also avoid the ‘unemployment traps’ sometimes experienced by welfare recipients who risk losing their benefits should they increase their labor force participation— with particular detriment to single parents and people with disabilities. A secure and reliable income on an individual rather than household level could be especially important for those seeking to leave violent partners or unhappy relationships, by cushioning the financial shocks of partnership dissolution that tend to leave women and transgender and gender-diverse people worse-off than men. Research on cash transfers also suggests that a regular inflow of cash can in some cases mitigate intimate partner violence, including by improving emotional and mental wellbeing through reduced economic stress. In the context of employment, UBI may provide the necessary safety net to exit exploitative working conditions or buffer income instability for those unable to access waged work. Employment discrimination can make it especially difficult for transgender and gender-diverse people to access safe and secure employment. For example, in the European Union alone at least nine member States do not protect against discrimination in employment on grounds of gender identity. Some feminist proponents of UBI also celebrate its potential to reshape patriarchal gender norms around paid work and unpaid care, since no person is relegated to being a masculinized ‘breadwinner’ or feminized ‘caretaker’ in order to have income security. If combined with the provision of affordable quality care services, UBI could potentially encourage a more equitable distribution of care among genders. Indeed, some argue that UBI could lead to higher valuation of a range of non-commodified activities, including voluntary, emotional/affective and creative pursuits. Given that UBI is paid to individuals regardless of kinship relations, it could also support a range of diverse family forms, including cohabiting and extended families and ‘families of choice’ formed by many LGBTIQ people. Whether and to what extent these positive effects materialize will depend to a large degree on specific design features, including whether the UBI’s benefit level allows for maintaining an adequate standard of living. What can we learn from existing UBI schemes? No national-level UBI scheme meeting the criteria defined above has been carried out, and the implications of a long-term scheme at that level are largely unknown.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Gendered UBI
Williams, 2021 -- Writer for Research and Data Section for UN Women. [Loui. April 21, Policy Brief No. 22 “Universal basic income: Potential and limitations from a gender perspective” https://www.unwomen.org/sites/default/files/Headquarters/Attachments/Sections/Library/Publications/2021/Policy-brief-Universal-basic-income-en.pdf UP]
There is also a scarcity of gender-sensitive analyses of UBI pilots at any scale. However, a small-scale UBI pilot carried out in Madhya Pradesh, India, between 2011 and 2012 points to tentatively positive outcomes for gender equality. In this trial, the Self-Employed Women’s Association (SEWA) partnered with the United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) with hopes of providing a viable alternative to poorly implemented, targeted welfare schemes. A monthly transfer equivalent to 20-30 percent of the income of low-income families was given to 6,000 adults and children. Six months into the intervention, those receiving the transfer experienced a statistically significant increase in food sufficiency, with an especially large increase for Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe households. School attendance increased for all children, with teenage girls seeing the greatest gains. The proportion of children with healthy weight increased from 39 per cent to 58 per cent during the trial period, and this effect was greatest for girls aged 2-5 years. The receipt of the unconditional transfer was also associated with increased decision-making abilities for women, including greater influence on household spending. Although women’s labour force participation rate did not change, the kinds of work women did shifted to increase their incomes and agency, including a big increase in own-account activities rather than casual wage work.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Gendered UBI
Flanigan, 2018 - prof of leadership studies and law at the University of Richmond [Jessica, Jan 25, Slate “The Feminist Case for a Universal Basic Income” TA]
The case for a basic income, a policy that would give all citizens cash payments at regular intervals throughout their lives, is gaining traction. Prominent tech entrepreneurs like Elon Musk, academics across the ideological spectrum from Philippe Van Parijs to Charles Murray, labor organizers like Andy Stern, and policymakers such as Michael Tubbs, the 27-year-old mayor of Stockton, California, support basic income policies as a way of reducing poverty and mitigating the negative impact of unemployment due to automation. But they understate the feminist case for giving people cash. Proponents of the UBI would do well to acknowledge the gender implications of the policy, and feminists, in turn, should throw their support behind the movement. Here are the top three reasons UBI is a feminist cause: 1. Women Are More Likely to Be Poor Globally, women are more likely to live in extreme poverty than men. In the United States, women as a group are poorer than men due to the economic burdens associated with caregiving and the segregation of women into “pink-collar” industries that typically pay less than male-dominated industries. One of the main benefits of implementing a UBI in the U.S. and elsewhere is that giving people cash is a relatively direct and effective way to fight poverty. The basic income is also a matter of economic justice for women as a whole. While capitalism has been beneficial to women on balance, the current system reflects historical patterns of female exclusion from labor markets and policies that denied property rights to women. For example, throughout the 19th century and into the 20th century, married women lacked legal protections for their property rights under the legal doctrine of coverture. And until the 1980s, husbands retained unilateral control over marital property in some jurisdictions. As I have argued elsewhere, a UBI would make capitalism more just by compensating those who live with the legacy of historical and enduring economic injustices. And because a basic income would make the decision to work more voluntary, women would no longer choose to remain in toxic jobs solely because they can’t afford not to. In this way, a UBI could address gender-based mistreatment in workplaces. By freeing women of their economic dependence on employers, a UBI would also improve women’s bargaining positions, enabling them to negotiate for more flexible hours or better conditions. But a UBI would not discourage work to an extent that would undermine the economy. People would still need to work to afford most consumer goods and luxuries. And unlike minimum wage requirements, touted by Fight for $15 activists, a UBI neither raises the cost of employing low-income workers relative to other workers nor disproportionately burdens employers to provide a decent standard of living for people in their communities. With an even starting ground, the opportunities to move beyond the lowest-paying work could be more readily available to marginalized workers who’ve been left out for too long. 2. Women Could Make Unfettered Decisions About How to Structure Their Families and Lives Child care is extraordinarily expensive, and women, especially single moms, end up shouldering an enormous burden for this cost. Some parents who would prefer to work are unable to because they cannot afford quality child care for their kids. Women are more likely to leave the workforce for this reason than men. A UBI for mothers and children would enable women who want to work to pay for child care. In addition, a UBI (including child benefits) would formally recognize and reward socially valuable labor that people currently perform outside of the paid economy, such as caregiving for children, disabled people, and elderly relatives. The UBI could amount to “wages for housework,” something feminists in the 1970s pushed for. Furthermore, because a UBI aims to pay all individuals and not households, it allows people to make decisions about marriage and cohabitation based their intrinsic desires, not based on tax policies such as the “marriage penalty” that working couples currently face or means-tested welfare programs that withhold benefits from women when their household income increases after marriage. A further benefit for families? With an added, guaranteed boost to their income, women in abusive relationships would have the financial security to leave, even if they lack qualifications or credentials that would enable them to support themselves and their families. UBI would do more than almost any other economic policy imaginable to make women less susceptible to abuse both in the workplace and at home. 3. Respect: Universal, Rather Than Targeted Assistance, Will Defy Stereotypes Historically, feminists not only critiqued outright sexism but also the paternalism of efforts to protect women from the world by robbing them of their autonomy. Paternalism has long been used to justify policies that limit women’s and other marginalized people’s choices, like bans on abortion, or sex work, or women working in dangerous industries, on the grounds that they are incapable of deciding for themselves how to live their lives. Today, many social policies in the U.S. are influenced by extremely paternalistic thinking that perpetuates discriminatory stereotypes about women’s abilities to make informed and reasonable decisions for themselves. Conservative complaints about welfare recipients spending benefits on junk food and luxuries have been part of a more general racialized narrative, which has informed existing welfare policy and also perpetuated offensive and stigmatizing stereotypes about members of marginalized groups, especially women of color. But liberals who support limiting the provision of benefits to housing, food, and health care are subject to the same charges of paternalism when they advocate for in-kind benefit policies (such as food transfers and food vouchers) that perpetuate a politics of suspicion and mistrust, instead of supporting cash benefit programs. Most of the arguments against UBI also ring of paternalism. How could we trust that low-income women would use the money to do the things I’ve detailed here? Low-income people, like the rest of their fellow citizens, are generally the best judges of whether a profession or purchase is in their overall interest, and the evidence suggests that recipients of cash transfers generally spend their income on necessities. Trusting women and all people with the right to spend their money how they see fit, as UBI allows, would push back against decades of paternalistic social policy.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Gendered UBI
Bhattacharya 2019 - director of programs and strategy at the Insight Center for Community Economic Development [Jhumpa “Exploring Guaranteed Income through a Racial and Gendered Justice Lens” . . Accessed 23 June 2023 EO]
Sexism and misogyny that are baked into our history and policy implementation have lead to gender wealth inequities. Historic policies denied women the ability to own property on their own or have property passed onto them, single women were not allowed to secure loans, and they were restricted in their ability to earn advanced degrees and improve their career prospects (Kijakazi and McCulloch 2018). Women have also been systematically paid less for the same jobs. In fact, a 2018 Hired.com report on wages in the workplace found that men were offered a higher salary than women for the same job at the same company 63 percent of the time (Hired.com n.d.). The report further noted that Black and Latinx women are consistently offered lower salaries than white men. Additionally, pay inequity plagues Millennial women: In 2013, the median income for Millennial women was $30,000 compared to $35,000 for men (Institute for Women’s Policy Research n.d.). Occupational segregation also plays a significant role in furthering gender inequity as it pushes women, particularly women of color, into lower paid industries and jobs (Bhattacharya, Price, and Addo 2019). The National Women’s Law Center recently reported that while women make up about half of the American workforce, they comprise 70 percent of employees whose jobs paid less than $10 per hour (Tucker and Patrick 2017). Given that income is one of the primary factors in building wealth, pay inequity and occupational segregation mean that women own less wealth than men in the 21st century. A Guaranteed Income Is Rooted in Racial and Gender Justice Movements As a means to address economic and racial injustice, a guaranteed income has a notable history of being uplifted by racial justice advocates and movements. We must acknowledge that the legacy of a guaranteed income is inextricably linked to racial justice. Looking at historical precedents, much attention is focused on the Black Panther Party’s 1966 10-point platform, which called for offering every person employment or a guaranteed income. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., also called for a guaranteed income, outlining his own proposal in his final book, Where Do We Go from Here: Chaos or Community?
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Gendered UBI
Flanigan, 2018 - prof of leadership studies and law at the University of Richmond [Jessica, Jan 25, Slate “The Feminist Case for a Universal Basic Income” TA]
3. Respect: Universal, Rather Than Targeted Assistance, Will Defy Stereotypes Historically, feminists not only critiqued outright sexism but also the paternalism of efforts to protect women from the world by robbing them of their autonomy. Paternalism has long been used to justify policies that limit women’s and other marginalized people’s choices, like bans on abortion, or sex work, or women working in dangerous industries, on the grounds that they are incapable of deciding for themselves how to live their lives. Today, many social policies in the U.S. are influenced by extremely paternalistic thinking that perpetuates discriminatory stereotypes about women’s abilities to make informed and reasonable decisions for themselves. Conservative complaints about welfare recipients spending benefits on junk food and luxuries have been part of a more general racialized narrative, which has informed existing welfare policy and also perpetuated offensive and stigmatizing stereotypes about members of marginalized groups, especially women of color. But liberals who support limiting the provision of benefits to housing, food, and health care are subject to the same charges of paternalism when they advocate for in-kind benefit policies (such as food transfers and food vouchers) that perpetuate a politics of suspicion and mistrust, instead of supporting cash benefit programs. Most of the arguments against UBI also ring of paternalism. How could we trust that low-income women would use the money to do the things I’ve detailed here? Low-income people, like the rest of their fellow citizens, are generally the best judges of whether a profession or purchase is in their overall interest, and the evidence suggests that recipients of cash transfers generally spend their income on necessities. Trusting women and all people with the right to spend their money how they see fit, as UBI allows, would push back against decades of paternalistic social policy.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Gendered UBI
Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? C]
Welfare reform has subjected Black women in particular to rights violations. Discourse around welfare directly stigmatizes Black women by associating them with “the welfare queen.” In contrast with “the welfare mother who draws upon the moral capital attached to American motherhood, the welfare queen constitutes a highly materialistic, domineering, and manless working-class Black woman” who relies on the “public dole[.]”73 This stereotype harms Black women and marks their children as a potential menace to society—as “criminals, crackheads, and welfare cheats waiting to happen”—before they are even born.74 Their mothers are blamed for birthing this generation of future dependents, as though Black people, rather than an unjust social order, cause inequality.75 Those who aim to control Black women’s reproduction have used welfare reform to restrict Black female fertility by controlling the number of children born to women receiving public assistance. Attempts to limit the number of children they have include incentives for poor women to use long-acting contraceptives and family caps.76 To incentivize the former, legislators have made Norplant and other options available through Medicaid and offered cash bonuses to women on welfare who use it. To enforce the latter, states have denied additional payments for children born to women already receiving benefits through AFDC. Political actors do not mention race when discussing these policy options, but race still informs welfare debates. Even though most families who benefited from AFDC were not Black, Black women have disproportionately relied on this form of government aid, and the American public associates them with welfare. Contemporary welfare policies “share features of eugenic thinking” which emphasize the importance of “reducing the cost of subsidizing the unfit.”77 Current family caps are not based on “notions of recipients’ genetic inferiority” but “are seen as a way of ridding America of the burden poor people” impose, especially those of color.78 PRWORA makes women of all races more vulnerable to men and privileges those who conform to standards of White, wealthy, heterosexual domesticity. The bill specifically states that “marriage is the foundation of a successful society.”79 To support this, legislators cited statistics on teenage and nonmarital childrearing— anxieties about which have long been linked to Whites’ fears about communities of color having more children. The bill also aims to promote “job preparation, work, and marriage” and to “encourage the formation and maintenance of two-parent families.”80 The bill later states that a “mutually faithful monogamous relationship in the context of marriage is the expected standard of human sexual activity” and that “bearing children out-of-wedlock is likely to have harmful consequences for the child, child’s parents, and society.”81 Congress and the Clinton Administration voiced support for a very specific type of family—one that aligned with standards of heterosexual and monogamous marriage, middle-class work patterns, and whiteness. Due to this bias, welfare reform favored married women who did not necessarily have to work outside the home even if their families needed welfare because only one parent had to work. These incentives reward women who want to care for their children and decide to marry and thus become dependent on a man.82 Welfare rights organizer Johnnie Tillman described AFDC as forcing women to trade “a man” for “the man”; as we can see, the reverse is also true.83
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Gendered UBI
Danaher, 2014 - a lecturer at the National University of Ireland, [John July 14, Feminism and the Basic Income (Part One) TA]
The second argument holds that feminists should embrace the UBI because of its potential to reduce the sexual division of labour. The traditional division of labour is that of the male breadwinner and the female caregiver. If UBI has the potential to raise the status of non-waged work, then it could also, potentially, encourage more men to engage in that type of work. This might allow for some de-gendering of work roles. The mechanisms for this are likely to be indirect. The UBI wouldn’t actively reward unpaid work, it would simply make it a more viable option. I’ll be talking about this more in part two. The third argument holds that feminists should embrace the UBI because it could reduce existing labour market segregation. This is essentially just the flip-side of the previous argument. One of the problems with the sexual division of labour is that it impairs women’s access to paid employment. If women are forced, demanded or expected to engage in unpaid work within the home — and if men are not — then the opportunities for women to access paid employment are limited. So if the UBI can reduce the sexual division of labour, it could also increase the access to paid employment. This would also represent an improvement over existing welfare systems where entitlements are dependent on total household income. In support of this, Fitzpatrick gives the example of systems in which the benefits payable to an unemployed man are actually reduced if his spouse/partner is working. This can encourage women in low-pay work to give up that work. The fourth argument holds that feminists should embrace the UBI because it will reduce the burden placed upon women by the welfare state. The idea here is that women are often the chief “victims” of the bureaucracy of the traditional welfare system. Due to social panics about “welfare queens” and the like, women often experience intrusive means-testing and enquiries into their personal lives in order to prove eligibility for welfare. The unconditional nature of the basic income cuts out those intrusions.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Gendered UBI
Williams, 2021 - Research and Data Section, UN Women [Loui, Policy Brief No. 22 “Universal Basic Income: Potential And Limitations From A Gender Perspective” TA]
For the purposes of this brief, UBI is defined as a cash transfer that is (a) individual, in that it goes directly to each person rather than to a household; (b) continuous, in that it is provided on an ongoing basis; (c) unconditional, in that it does not depend on labour market participation or the fulfilment of conditions; and (d) universal, in that it is paid to all.9 These features distinguish UBI from most existing social protection systems, although the relationship between UBI and social protection continues to be debated. UBI is noncontributory, meaning eligibility and benefit levels do not depend upon prior contributions. This makes it different to (contributory) social insurance systems, which tend to benefit those who are employed in the formal economy across their lifetime, and which feminists have long critiqued for being entrenched in male-breadwinner models and heteronormative bias, as well as for providing lesser protection to those who do not participate in full-time formal employment due to employment discrimination or caregiving responsibilities.10 UBI is also different to the majority of non-contributory social protection programmes, including cash transfers, which are often narrowly targeted to poor households and have been criticized by feminists for imposing cumbersome conditionalities on women recipients (such as ensuring children’s attendance at school or health clinics) and excluding families with lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, intersex or queer (LGBTIQ+) members.11 UBI is distinct from a social protection floor, which refers to nationally defined access to essential health care and income security for all across the life course.12 However, some argue that UBI could form an essential part of a social protection floor.13