Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Inflation DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – Wage Growth

Wage growth is sustainable now --- increase from the plan cause interest rate spikes.

Smialek 21 --- Jeanna Smialek writes about the Federal Reserve and the economy for The New York Times. She previously covered economics at Bloomberg News, “Wages are rising, but can they keep up with inflation?”, Nov 5th 2021, https://www.nytimes.com/2021/11/05/business/economy/wages-inflation.html

It is not yet clear which side of that equation — higher pay or higher prices — is going to win out, but the answer could matter enormously for the Federal Reserve and the White House. There are a few ways this moment could evolve. Wage growth could remain strong, driven by a tight labor market, and overall inflation could simmer down as supply chain snarls unravel and a surge in demand for goods eases. That would benefit workers. But troubling outcomes are also possible, and high on the list of worries is what economists call a “wage-price spiral.” Employees could begin to demand higher pay because they need to keep up with a rising cost of living, and companies may pass those labor costs on to their customers, kicking off a vicious cycle. That could make today’s quick inflation last longer than policymakers expect. The stakes are high. What happens with wages will matter to families, businesses and central bankers — and the path ahead is far from certain. “It’s the several-trillion-dollar question,” said Nick Bunker, director of research for the hiring site Indeed. For now, wage growth is rapid — just not fast enough to keep up with prices. One way to measure the dynamic is through the Employment Cost Index, which is reported by the Labor Department every quarter. In the year through September, the index’s measure of wages and salaries jumped by 4.2 percent. But an inflation gauge that tracks consumer prices rose by 5.4 percent over the same period. A different measure of pay, an index that tracks hourly earnings, did rise faster than inflation in August and September after lagging it for much of the year. And an update to that gauge on Friday showed that wages climbed 0.4 percent in October, which is roughly in line with recent monthly price increases. Over the past year, that measure is up by 4.9 percent. But the data on hourly earnings have been distorted by the pandemic, because low-wage workers who left the job market early in 2020 are now trickling back in, jerking the average around. The upshot is that the tug of war between price increases and pay increases has yet to decisively swing in workers’ favor. Whether wage gains eventually eclipse inflation — and why — will be crucial for economic policymakers. Central bankers celebrate rising wages when they come from productivity increases and strong labor markets, but would worry if wages and inflation seemed to be egging each other upward. The Federal Reserve is “watching carefully,” for a troubling increase in wages, its chair, Jerome H. Powell, said on Wednesday, though he noted that the central bank did not see such a trend shaping up. Recruiters do report some early signs that inflation is factoring into pay decisions. Bill Kasko, president of Frontline Source Group, a job placement and staffing firm in Dallas, said that as gas prices in particular rise, employees are demanding either higher pay or work-from-home options to offset their increased commuting costs. “It becomes a topic of discussion in negotiations for salary,” Mr. Kasko said. But for the most part, today’s wage gains are tied to a different economic trend: red-hot demand for workers. Job openings are high, but many would-be employees remain on the labor market’s sidelines, either because they have chosen to retire early or because child care issues, virus concerns or other considerations have dissuaded them from working. Grocery store managers in Dallas are earning as much as $175,000 in base pay compared to $125,000 before the pandemic, Mr. Kasko and his colleagues said, and employees are being nabbed away from firms like his for six-figure-salary recruiting jobs at corporations. Emily Longsworth Nixon, 27 and from Dallas, is one of Mr. Kasko’s employees. She herself is fielding five or six messages each day on LinkedIn trying to lure her away, she said, and the tight labor market has upended how she does her job. She tried to recruit a woman to an executive assistant position at a technology company that would have given her a $30,000 raise — and saw the candidate walk away for a counter offer of no additional pay but three work-from-home days each week. “After that, I had my tail between my legs for a couple of days; I had never thought to ask that,” she said, adding that employers need to know their candidates like never before as workers flex their power, taking home raises and other perks. “Before Covid, it was an employer-driven market.” Those in-demand workers could end up being better off in the long run, should their pay continue to chug higher even as supply chains heal and prices for used cars and couches moderate, allowing them to afford more. Pay gains might also become more sustainable for employers as virus concerns fade and employees trickle back from the labor market’s sidelines. And even if rapid wage increases persist, it is not absolutely the case that employers will be forced to drastically raise prices. Businesses could stomach a hit to their profits instead, or they could invest in technology that improves worker productivity. If fewer waitresses can sell the same number of dinners because customers are ordering from QR codes, for instance, employers will have leeway to pay more without taking a hit to their bottom line. Investment in automation has already moved up sharply by one metric, with orders of robots in the second quarter of 2021 up 67 percent from a year earlier, with demand spanning pharmaceutical industries, cars and electronics, according to the Association for Advancing Automation. “Companies can’t find people, I don’t care what the industry is,” said Jeff Burnstein, president of the association. But a happy outcome is not guaranteed. If today’s high prices do drive tomorrow’s wage negotiations and set off an upward spiral, the result could be a longer period of high inflation that prods the Fed to raise interest rates to tamp down demand and cool off prices, slowing the economy and possibly even sending it back into a recession. A scenario like that hasn’t taken place since the 1970s and 1980s. But a situation like the pandemic lockdowns and subsequent reopening has never happened at all. “We haven’t seen a wage-price spiral for decades, but we haven’t seen inflation like this for decades, either,” said Jason Furman, a Harvard University economist and former economic adviser in the Obama administration, calling the possibility of a wage-driven spiral “an open question.”

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Inflation DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – Spending

The plan causes inflation – the money they need ruins supply and demand ratios.

Smith ‘21

Jonathan Smith: Jon graduated from the University of East Anglia in 2014 with a first-class degree in Business Management. Joining Casterbridge Wealth in May 2017 Jon is responsible for founding and running the research department, growing it to meet the needs of our ever expanding business. Jon is the proud holder of the Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) Charter holder qualification which he achieved in September 2019. He enjoys deploying his analytical skills and using data to support and challenge ideas to form an investment opinion. A major part of Jon’s role at Casterbridge exploits his passion for ‘Tomorrow’s World’ and Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) beliefs as he is the lead Investment Manager on our Sustainable Impact Portfolios. Working at Casterbridge gives Jon the opportunity and flexibility to express his own investment thoughts and beliefs within the remits of the wider team and as a result enjoys working for a small company where his opinion and voice matter.; July 15, 2021; How do governments create money out of thin air?; ; //[TMS—GK]

In March 2020, the COVID-19 pandemic rocked economies worldwide. Millions of people lost their jobs, and many businesses struggled to survive or shut down completely. Governments responded with some of the largest economic relief packages in history— the United States alone spent $2.2 trillion on a first round of relief. So where did all this money come from? Most countries have a central bank that manages the money supply and is independent from the government to prevent political interference. The government can implement many types of economic policy, like decreasing people's taxes and creating jobs through public infrastructure projects, but it actually can’t just increase the money supply. The central bank determines how much money is in circulation at a time. So why can’t central banks authorize the printing of unlimited money to help an economy in crisis? They could, but that’s a short-term solution that doesn’t necessarily boost economic growth in the long-term, and can actually hurt the economy. Why? With more money in circulation, manufacturers of goods like food, clothing, and cars could respond to demand simply by raising prices, rather than manufacturing more of these goods and creating new jobs in the process. This would mean you could no longer buy as much with the same amount of money— a situation known as inflation. A little bit of inflation, about 2% a year, is considered a sign of economic health, but more can quickly derail an economy.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Inflation DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – Spending

The plan causes hyperinflation – asking the central bank to pump more money is tautological.

Williams-Grut ‘20

Oscar Williams-Grut·Senior City Correspondent, Yahoo Finance UK; November 5, 2020; Why can't governments just print more money?; ]

So why can’t governments just print money in normal times to pay for their policies? The short answer is inflation. Historically, when countries have simply printed money it leads to periods of rising prices — there’s too many resources chasing too few goods. Often, this means every day goods become unaffordable for ordinary citizens as the wages they earn quickly become worthless. In Zimbabwe during the 2000s, monthly inflation reached as high as 80 billion percent, according to some estimates. The local currency was eventually abandoned in favour of the US dollar. In a famous instance known as “hyperinflation” in Germany during the 1920s, citizens were pictured taking wheelbarrows full of cash to shops to pay for basic goods. Spiralling prices then were more to do with the punishing reparations payments than money printing but it illustrates the problem. There’s a more technical reason why governments can’t simply print more money to pay off debt and pay for spending: they’re not in charge of it. In most developed nations central banks like the US Federal Reserve, Bank of England, or European Central Bank are charged with overseeing money supply. Central banks are independent of government although sometimes do coordinate with them. Central banks have churrned out billions in the last decade through quantitative easing — programmes of money printing meant to stimulate growth. By buying up debt, central banks free up cash to be invested elsewhere — hopefully in economically productive things like businesses or new technology. However, central banks are only interested in the health of economies rather than broader government concerns like defence, education, or healthcare. Separately, international investors could lose confidence in a country if its central bank is directly financing the government. Money supply and exchange rates are meant to reflect the size of an economy. If central banks are simply pumping out more money to pay off debt, it’s almost like a snake eating its own tail. Exchange rates would likely drop if this were to happen, leaving a country poorer and everyone worse off.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Inflation DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – Spending

Deficit spending will drive up inflation

Tunku Varadarajan, 2/18/22, (fellow at the American Enterprise Institute and at Columbia University’s Center on Capitalism and Society), The Wall Street Journal, “How Government Spending Fuels Inflation,” https://www.wsj.com/articles/government-spending-fuels-inflation-covid-relief-pandemic-debt-federal-reserve-stimulus-powell-biden-stagflation-11645202057, mm

“The Fiscal Theory of the Price Level” is the title of Mr. Cochrane’s next book, to be published in the fall. It’s a challenge to monetarism, the theory of controlling money as the chief method of stabilizing the economy. The new theory holds that when the overall amount of government debt is more than people expect the government to repay, we see inflation. The price of everything goes up, and the value of the dollar declines. How does this work? “The U.S. government has $20 trillion of debt outstanding,” Mr. Cochrane says. “That means, over the long run, people must expect taxes to exceed spending by $20 trillion to repay the debt.” But if they think the government will be able to pay back only $10 trillion in today’s money, “people will try to get rid of their government debt fast, before it is worth less. They try to sell it in order to buy other things,” driving up the price of everything else. “That keeps going until all prices have doubled—until the $20 trillion promise is only worth $10 trillion at today’s prices.”

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Inflation DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – Spending

The money the AFF needs the government to print results in hyperinflation and unprecedented economic decline – kills dollar value and imbalances the dollar/goods ratio.

Glum ‘23

Julia Glum is a graduate of the University of Florida, Julia has four years of experience in personal finance journalism and specializes in covering money trends.; Feb 24, 2023; Dollar Scholar Asks: Why Can't the Government Just Print More Money?; ; //[TMS—GK]

Why can’t we just print more money? “The answer, in one word, is inflation,” says Alan Cole, senior economic policy analyst at The Conference Board, a business-focused think tank. “[That’s] the binding constraint on governments, in the end, that keeps them from issuing gobs of currency and buying whatever they want with it.” It goes back to supply and demand. Increasing the money supply by, say, $32 trillion only introduces $32 trillion more into the economy. It doesn’t magically conjure $32 trillion worth of goods. More dollars chasing the same amount of goods would cause prices to spike — in a major way. Sean Snaith, the director of the University of Central Florida's Institute for Economic Forecasting, tells me that we’ve experienced a little of this recently: The government pumped money into the economy when the pandemic hit in 2020, and three years later inflation is still at 6.4%. Look at increased rent, egg and car prices. Paying a bunch for basics is “not terribly pleasant,” Snaith says, and that’s nothing compared to what would happen with $32 trillion extra floating around. Forget high inflation — we’d see hyperinflation, where prices could increase by millions of percentage points, Snaith says. A scenario like this “grinds an economy to a halt. Prices don't really function the way they should, and because money doesn’t hold its value, people don’t want to accept it as payment,” he says. Hyperinflation isn’t just a scary story. It’s happened repeatedly throughout history. In 1923 Germany, hyperinflation got so bad that workers were paid multiple times a day so they could use their wages to buy groceries before prices went up. In 2018 Venezuela, a 5-pound chicken cost 14.6 million bolivars… which is the equivalent of roughly $2. In 2008 Zimbabwe, teachers earned trillions of dollars a month — but a single loaf of bread cost 300 billion. “[Hyperinflation] essentially destroys the economy” and kills the value of paper currency, Snaith says. People resort to bartering, which can be disastrous. Imagine wanting to eat a hamburger for dinner and having to find a butcher willing to trade for it. There's also the fact that the U.S. government wouldn’t print a ton of money. Cole points out that protecting the value of the dollar is something that we as a nation have specifically deemed important. Price stability is literally written into the mandate of the Federal Reserve, and the Treasury Department has similar restrictions. “Neither the Treasury nor the Federal Reserve is really supposed to be going rogue and printing money in order to get us out of the debt ceiling standoff,” Cole says. The reason? Surprise! It's inflation. “Anything you do that undermines the value of the dollar and goes around the systems we have in place to issue more currency runs into the possibility of creating more inflation,” he adds. The bottom line Printing more money is a non-starter because it’d break our economy. “It would take care of the debt but at a price that’s far too high to pay,” Snaith says.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Inflation DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – Spending

Expansionary fiscal policy will trigger further interest rate hikes – that decimates the financial sector and spreads globally

Tobias Adrian and Vitor Gaspar, 11/21/ 2022, International Monetary Fund, “How Fiscal Restraint Can Help Fight Inflation,” https://www.imf.org/en/Blogs/Articles/2022/11/21/how-fiscal-restraint-can-help-fight-inflation, mm

Government support was vital to help people and firms survive pandemic lockdowns and support the economic recovery. But where inflation is high and persistent, across-the-board fiscal support is not warranted. Most governments have already dialed back pandemic support, as noted in our October Fiscal Monitor. With many people still struggling, governments should continue to prioritize helping the most vulnerable to cope with soaring food and energy bills and cover other costs—but governments should also avoid adding to aggregate demand that risks dialing up inflation. In many advanced and emerging economies, fiscal restraint can lower inflation while reducing debt. Central banks are raising interest rates to dampen demand and contain inflation, which in many countries is at its highest levels since the 1980s. Because rapid price gains are costly to society and detrimental to stable economic growth, monetary policy must act decisively. While monetary policy has the tools to subdue inflation, fiscal policy can put the economy on a sounder long-term footing through investment in infrastructure, health care, and education; fair distribution of incomes and opportunities through an equitable tax and transfer system; and provision of basic public services. The overall fiscal balance, however, affects the demand for goods and services, and inflationary pressures. A smaller deficit cools aggregate demand and inflation, so the central bank doesn’t need to raise rates as much. Moreover, with global financial conditions constraining budgets, and public debt ratios above pre-pandemic levels, reducing deficits also addresses debt vulnerabilities. Conversely, fiscal stimulus in the current high inflation environment would force central banks to slam on the brakes harder to curb inflation. Amid elevated public and private sector debt, this may raise risks for the financial system, as our Global Financial Stability Report described in October. Against that backdrop, policymakers have a responsibility to provide strong protections to those in need, while paring back elsewhere or raising additional revenues to reduce the overall deficit. Fiscal responsibility—or even consolidation where needed—demonstrates that policymakers are aligned against inflation. When fiscal adjustment is sustained, ideally through a medium-term fiscal framework that sketches the direction of policy over the next few years, it also addresses looming pressures on debt sustainability. These include aging populations in most advanced and several emerging economies, and the need to rebuild buffers that can be deployed in future crises or economic downturns. In our research, we use a stylized two country model (where the “home economy” may be the US or a group of advanced economies). We study two different approaches to curb inflation. The first relies exclusively on monetary tightening to cool the overheating economy, whereas the second involves fiscal consolidation. Both are constructed to have similar effects on economic growth, and each is effective in reducing inflation. Under the first, higher interest rates and the weaker growth contribute to rising public debt. Meanwhile, the currency appreciates as higher yields attract investors. Under the second approach, fiscal tightening cools demand without the need for interest rates to rise, so the real exchange rate depreciates. And with lower debt-service costs and smaller primary deficits, public debt declines. The real exchange-rate appreciation under tighter monetary policy implies that inflation falls a bit more, but this difference would diminish if more countries pursued these policies. Faced with high food and energy prices, governments can improve their fiscal position by moving from broad-based support to assisting the most vulnerable—ideally, through targeted cash transfers. Because supply shocks are long-lasting, attempts to limit price increases through price controls, subsidies, or tax cuts will be costly to the budget and ultimately not be effective. Price signals are critical to promote energy conservation and encourage private investment in renewables. The desirable fiscal stance and measures underpinning it will depend on country-specific circumstances, including current inflation rates and longer-term considerations such as debt levels and developmental needs. In most countries, higher inflation strengthens the case for fiscal restraint, calling for raising revenue or prioritizing spending that preserves social protection and growth-enhancing investments in human or physical capital. In the United States, the early-1980s disinflation under Federal Reserve Chairman Paul Volcker exemplified the challenges of controlling inflation. Inflation had become entrenched at high levels, and fiscal policy was expansionary. The Fed had to raise rates sharply to rein in inflation, causing a collapse in housing investment and historically large appreciation of the dollar. Manufacturing was hard hit, leading to calls for trade protectionism. That historical episode is relevant for many countries facing similar challenges today. A more balanced removal of policy stimulus, including fiscal restraint, can reduce the risk that some parts of the economy—especially those most sensitive to interest rates—experience disproportionate effects, or that large swings in the currency heighten trade tensions. This would also reduce risk globally. Less abrupt interest rate hikes would imply a more gradual tightening of financial conditions and mitigate financial stability risks. This would tend to limit adverse spillovers to emerging market economies and reduce the risk of sovereign debt distress. Avoiding a sharp appreciation of the US dollar or other major currencies would also lessen pressures on emerging markets that borrow in those currencies. While many central banks are tightening policy in response to the large and persistent rise in global inflation, the policy mix matters. Fiscal restraint will reduce the cost of bringing inflation back to target in a timely way, compared with the alternative of leaving monetary policy alone to act.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Inflation DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – Social Security

And expansionary fiscal policy will wreck the Fed’s anti-inflationary efforts – the 1980s prove

Willem Thorbecke, 9/19/22, (Senior Fellow; Research Institute of Economy, Trade & Industry in Tokyo, Japan) Financial Times, “Letter: Fiscal discipline is what the US economy needs,” https://www.ft.com/content/6aac3a0c-ecdd-4492-ac17-eab93472f2b5, mm

Frederic Mishkin is correct that the Federal Reserve must not imitate Paul Volcker’s mistake of easing monetary policy before inflation is defeated ( Opinion, September 15). President Joe Biden must also avoid Ronald Reagan’s mistake of running stimulative fiscal policy while the Fed is fighting inflation. In the 1980s, US deficits reached 5 per cent of gross domestic product. To offset this stimulus, the Fed was forced to raise rates to what Helmut Schmidt observed were their highest levels since the time of Christ. The combination multiplied government debt. Contractionary monetary policy and expansionary fiscal policy contributed to US current account deficits approaching 3 per cent of GDP. As the Fed seeks to reduce aggregate demand, as US Treasury rates have increased by hundreds of basis points since the start of 2022, and as the US current account reached 4.8 per cent of GDP in the first quarter of 2022, fiscal discipline is again essential.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Inflation DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – Social Security

Expanding social security would trigger massive fiscal stimulus

Max Richtman, 9/16/18, National Committee to Preserve Social Security and Medicare, “Social Security: An Economic Engine that Benefits Everyone,” https://www.ncpssm.org/documents/opeds-and-letters/social-security-an-economic-engine-that-benefits-everyone/, mm

The spending power of older Americans, bolstered by Social Security benefits, is a potent financial force. Businesses offer senior discounts to entice retirees, who tend to spend more of their money than other age groups. When Social Security beneficiaries help local businesses to prosper, those businesses hire additional workers and order more supplies, infusing the economy with even more money. Thanks to this ‘multiplier effect,’ every dollar paid in Social Security benefits produces $2 in stimulus to the economy. That adds up to more than $1.6 trillion dollars in national economic stimulus annually. Social Security benefits are responsible for sustaining some 10 million jobs, including roughly $400 billion in salaries and wages. With figures like these, even Wall Street must acknowledge that Social Security is incredibly good for Main Street. “Seniors are really important to local businesses,” says Abraham Kapusuz, former managing partner of a New Jersey restaurant that thrives on an older customer base. “During the early bird special, at least 80% of the customers are seniors. Most of their income is from Social Security. They contribute to the business – and the economy – bigtime.” But the opposite is also true. If Social Security benefits are cut, seniors will have less income to spend on goods and services – which is bad for Main Street. “If the government cuts Social Security benefits, it would affect the bottom line tremendously,” says Kapusuz. “Now you have to start laying off employees, which has a chain reaction throughout the local economy.” The National Committee to Preserve Social Security and Medicare has compiled fresh data on the economic impact of Social Security on congressional districts in all 50 states and U.S. territories. Most Americans would be surprised at how much money flows into their communities from those monthly Social Security checks, including red and purple states represented by aspiring benefit-cutters in Congress: In Florida, Social Security injects $70 billion into the state’s economy every year in the form of benefit checks to 4,532,000 retirees, disabled workers, survivors and children. Texas receives a $61 billion annual cash infusion through payments to 4,126,000 beneficiaries. 2.3 million Ohioans receive a total of $35 billion in Social Security benefits each year. It’s ironic that conservatives who purport to believe in ‘fiscal responsibility’ and a strong economy do not appreciate – or willfully ignore – these figures. Instead, they blew a $2 trillion hole in the federal debt with the Trump/GOP tax scheme (which has not trickled down to working people) and propose to cut Americans’ earned benefits to close the gap. If anything, this is the height of fiscal irresponsibility. The economic engine of Social Security is already humming. Why choke it with benefit cuts? The political right would like to use not only the Trump/GOP tax cuts, but projections about the program’s long-term finances, to cut Social Security. While it’s true that the Social Security trust fund will be able to pay roughly 80% of benefits after 2034 if Congress takes no action, legislation has already been introduced that would keep the program financially sound for the rest of the century while modestly boosting benefits, mainly by asking the wealthy to pay their fair share. In fact, the authors of two of those bills, Senator Bernie Sanders (I-VT) and Rep. John Larson (D-CT) have just launched “Expand Social Security” caucuses in the House and Senate, along with Senator Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) and other key members of Congress. The formation of these caucuses crystallizes the efforts of Social Security advocates and lawmakers to put more – not less – much-needed income into the hands of America’s seniors. This means not only boosting monthly benefits, but adopting a more accurate consumer price index for the elderly (CPI-E) and increasing the minimum benefit formula – all of which will provide even greater economic stimulus.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Inflation DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – UBI

Redistribution of wealth causes adverse market reactions and guarantees massive inflation

Heiner Flassbeck 2017 (Leibniz Information Centre for Economics, “Universal Basic Income Financing and Income Distribution – The Questions Left Unanswered by Proponents”, https://www.ceps.eu/system/files/IEForum22017_3.pdf)

The introduction of a basic income without generating a rise in inflation is hardly imaginable. It would only be possible – and this is an absolutely essential condition – if the implementation of a UBI was the explicit result of state redistribution and if the redistribution measures are widely accepted by all powerful actors in the economy. This is basically unthinkable. For example, if the UBI were financed through higher VAT rates, this would clearly be inflationary, because companies would pass along the bulk of the higher taxes to customers. The consequences for those people relying fully on the UBI would be fatal. Their basic incomes would be insufficient for a decent living. Would the government then be obliged to step in and add conditional aid and social protection to the poorest? Imagining that one can achieve a massive redistribution of income without triggering adverse reactions through the markets is a dangerous illusion. Picture a monthly UBI of about €1,000 a month for a country like Germany. With a population of about 80 million people, the German government would need roughly €800 billion to finance the UBI. This additional revenue is more than the current tax total revenue in Germany, which stands at about €700 billion. Implementing a UBI would thus require a doubling of the tax current level. Some argue that the government would no longer pay social benefits and that the savings could be used to finance a UBI. But this is wrong. The government would indeed no longer be required to pay some €400 billion in social contributions, but it would also no longer receive social security contributions at a similar level. The social security systems in most countries, including Germany, have approximately balanced budgets. Some savings opportunities do exist, as the government normally subsidises pension systems, but the amounts are rather small given the overall burden of a UBI. On the other hand, totally un-solved is the question of health care. Health care contributions could not be covered by a UBI of €1,000 without pushing those fully dependent on UBI back into poverty. Hence, health care would either remain in the realm of the government, involving expenses of 10-15% of today’s GDP (roughly €300 billion), or a monthly UBI of €1,000 would clearly not be sufficient to allow for a decent and independent livelihood. But even a UBI of €1,000 would destroy the pillars of the system we are used to living in. Doubling government revenue by doubling tax rates would trigger a distributive struggle the likes of which we have never seen before. The ratio of taxes to GDP in most highly developed economies today is close to 25%. To raise the level of taxes and other contributions to 50% would be a revolutionary act. This act, however, would come with the acknowledgement that this is explicitly being done to allow quite a few people to avoid contributing anything tangible to the fabric of our societies anymore. The outcry of those who are expected to contribute as much as or even more than before would be ferocious. To be unmistakably clear: Given the distribution of power in our societies, it is preposterous to assert that the government would double its tax revenue without powerful groups – entrepreneurs, big companies and rich people – passing on the additional tax burden to customers and the powerless. It is cynical to talk about a UBI without talking about the distribution of power and the many different options available to powerful groups to avoid being taxed for this purpose. And if the powerful are indeed able to avoid significant extra payments and receive a UBI nevertheless, the overall effects on the distribution of income may be catastrophic. As said above, the most likely outcome is a spike in inflation, as an increase in the VAT rate will be the only tax measure accepted by the powerful groups. The negative effects of a bout of inflation on the distribution of income would fall on the poor and would immediately bring about a call for special and additional measure by the government to protect the poorest. Once that happens, Pandora’s box will be open, and many will ask for conditional measures to correct the dismal outcome of an unconditional basic income on the distribution of income.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Inflation DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – UBI

UBI would trigger runaway hyper-inflation

Archetto ‘18, foreign affairs officer at the Bureau of Political Military Affairs, US Department of State and a former security assistance officer at the Defense Security Cooperation Agency, Office of the Secretary of Defense (Greg, “Implementation of a ‘universal basic income’ program would be a disaster,” The Hill, https://thehill.com/opinion/finance/397192-implementation-of-a-universal-basic-income-program-would- be-a-disaster/)//BB

For example, in Finland — and a smattering of other countries — principalities and cities are currently experimenting with UBI using sample populations limited by age, employment status, and other factors, hardly “universal.” So far no definitive results have been gleaned on UBI’s efficacy, but in today’s millennial parlance, let me “save you a click.” In order to fully appreciate how UBI would work, you need to look at what it’s implementation would do to an entire economy, not just a fraction of it. If everyone suddenly had an extra $10K a year, and everyone knew that everyone had an extra $10K a year, prices would go up and inflation would rise, thus negating the perceived gains of such a program. Think of it this way. If you walk into a store right now, the price of any product is based on the maximum amount of money it can command in exchange for it in relation to the number of customers needed to pay that price and keep it moving off the shelves at a predictable pace. In other words, supply and demand. However, this is based on the fact that the shop owner has no way of knowing the wealth level of every customer that walks into his store. Now, if Scrooge McDuck waddled in, the shop owner could assume his wealth, deduce that he could afford to pay more, and try to raise the prices on the fly. However, that would be tough because prices are usually clearly marked. But generally, that price is set using the knowledge that any single customer that walks in at any given time has a wealth baseline of $0 and an upper bound of, say, $112 billion. But, if you add in the knowledge that everybody that walks into your store, because of UBI, now has a wealth baseline of X+$10K, don’t you think that shop owner would charge more for his products? He knows you can afford a higher price now. These price rises would then have reverberations throughout the economy. As prices went up, wages would need to follow, which would make prices go even higher in an upward inflationary spiral. This is essentially Milton Friedman’s “helicopter money” analogy.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Inflation DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – UBI

A basic income guarantee would trigger inflationary pressures and spur interest rate hikes – our evidence assumes all of the major UBI proposals.

William Mitchell, 5/31/17, (professor of economics and director at the Centre of Full Employment and Equity at the University of Newcastle), Billmitchell.org, “A Basic Income Guarantee does not reduce poverty,” https://billmitchell.org/blog/?p=36105, mm

The OECD has just released a technical briefing paper (May 2017) – Basic Income as a Policy Option: Technical Background Note Illustrating Costs and Distributional Implications for Selected Countries – which, as the title suggests, explores the consequences of an “unconditional transfer paid to each individual” (BIG). It is a supporting document to a OECD policy brief (May 2017) – Basic Income as a Policy Option: Can it add up? . The OECD now has a research program it is calling – Future of Work. It turns out that my next book (written with Joan Muysken and to be published in 2018) will examine this topic. I will have more to say about the research we are engaged in for that project in the coming weeks. As before, you will be able to trace the notes I produce that will form the basis of this book via my blogs as the research process unfolds. The Technical Background paper provides “a more detailed description of … [the] … analysis, and shows more comprehensive results …” The OECD assumes that: 1. “a BI that would replace most cash benefits for working age households”. 2. “the provision of public services, such as health, education, care, or other in-kind supports is assumed to continue unchanged”. They note that if a government was “to take existing cash benefits paid to those of working age and to spread total expenditure on these benefits equally across all those aged below normal retirement age” the “resulting BI amount would be very much lower than the poverty line for a single individual”. Thus a “budget-neutral BI will be very far from eradicating poverty, whereas a BI set at the poverty line would be very expensive”. They demonstrate this using their Figure 1 (which I reproduce). So to aid interpretation, you can see that for Spain, for example, a BIG based on per-capita benefit spending would come up to around 35 per cent of the poverty line only, whereas the current social assistance benefit level is closer to 60 per cent of the poverty line (For a single-person household). In part, this arises as a result of the universality of the BIG. A targetted BIG is typically rejected by proponents. They add moral arguments to their narrative and claiming that a guaranteed minimum income is a right that all enjoy rather than only the poor. The OECD conclude that: … a BI at socially and politically meaningful levels would likely require additional benefit expenditures, and thus higher tax revenues to finance them. By taxing the BI alongside other incomes, its net value would fall for those in higher tax brackets, reducing its cost and making it more targeted to lower-income groups, who pay lower tax rates. Assuming, of course, fiscal neutrality. My reference to “current institutional arrangements” in the Introduction relates to this point. Most proponents of BIG [basic income guarantee] adopt neo-liberal macroeconomic conceptions of the fiscal capacity of the government and thus fall into believing that there are financial constraints on government spending that can only be relieved with higher taxation or increased debt issuance. Of course, those who understand Modern Monetary Theory (MMT) know, intrinsically, that a sovereign government is never revenue constrained because it is the monopoly issuer of the currency. In that case, it could simple increase its net spending (fiscal deficit) to facilitate the introduction of a BIG. But, in that situation, there are new problems as I will explain. Staying within the OECD’s neo-liberal frame, it notes that benefit systems and tax-free thresholds vary across countries, which means that a simple statement of who would win and who would lose by replacing benefits with a BIG is difficult to make. In terms of their “revenue-neutral BI, adjusted amount” model, they note that (setting the BI = existing GMI levels in the income support systems for Finland, Italy, France and the UK): 1. “In each of the four countries considered here, the largest average gains from a BI would occur among the lowest-income households … This arises as those who are not covered by social protection in existing systems for whatever reason (not having sufficient past contributions to qualify or non-take-up of benefits) and who hence have the lowest incomes would gain from the introduction of a universal BI.” 2. “The richest income group would lose overall in each country too” for various reasons pertaining to each country. 3. “in many cases those in work would see the amount they receive from the BI offset by higher income taxes as tax-free amounts were abolished. This is the case in Finland, the UK and the USA for example”. 4. “In France, those on higher incomes would actually lose between 5% and 10% of their income as the value of the zero- tax band is greater than the BI amount at these income levels, but those with lower earnings would gain.” 5. “In many other countries, however, a single person without children would see (often quite substantial) gains at all income levels … In these countries, gains generally increase with earnings for lower earnings ranges: the BI would not be means tested away, and peak at the point where entitlement to existing means-tested support expires.” 6. “Gains remain substantial in Japan and the Netherlands, however, as the BI amount still exceed additional tax payments made even at relatively high earnings levels.” 7. In Italy, “introducing a BI would involve very large percentage changes in incomes at low earnings levels, but … changes are small for those with higher income levels.” 8. “In Finland, France and Italy, large losses would occur among those who receive unemployment insurance benefits or early retirement pensions … The pattern in the UK is different: as the revenue-neutral BI amount is lower than the value of GMI benefits, lower-income groups often lose.” 8. “The extent of gains … suggests that replacing existing social protection systems with a BI along the lines described here would not be budget-neutral.” They provided Figure 4 to show the distributional consequences of a BIG (winners and losers by decile). The explanation for the patterns is complex and arises from the differences in the structure of tax and welfare systems in each country. I will leave it to you to examine each nation’s results if you are interested in more detail. The other approach they analysed was a “revenue-neutral BI, adjusted tax rates” – in other words, a higher BIG matched with revenue from varying taxes (up or down – depending on the current situation). They note that setting the BI = existing GMI levels in the income support systems: 1. “In Finland and France, this is little different from the previous variant” given the nature of the existing support structures. 2. “In Italy, this variant involves a big reduction in income taxes, which significantly benefits richer households but does little to increase the incomes of many poorer households”. 3. “The opposite is the case in the UK.” The poor and the middle income groups see no change but the highest income groups “would lose significantly”. The OECD Figure 7 (reproduced next) shows the winners and losers in detail across the income distribution. The columns show the shifts (up and down) from BIG, tax rises and benefit losses. The diamonds show the net result in absolute terms. The loss of benefits and increased tax burdens typically offset (or nearly) the benefits of the BIG for many cohorts. In both models, the OECD provide more detailed results of the winners and losers by family size and structure and age breakdowns. But the aim of the exercise was to establish the impact of the BIG on poverty? The OECD conclude that: 1. “Although there would be more winners than losers among low-income groups under a BI [basic income]… it would not prove to be an effective tool for reducing poverty”. 2. “In Finland and France, relatively good benefit coverage among poorer households means that poverty would be higher under both BI variants considered here as, despite benefit spending being much higher with a BI, it would be much less well targeted.” 3. “Even in Italy, where existing benefit spending is not well targeted on poorer households, poverty would be roughly the same in the case where existing spending was used to give everyone a BI rather than targeted on specific groups.” 4. “In the UK, the revenue-neutral BI amount is significantly below the level of existing GMI benefits, so it is perhaps unsurprising that this leads to much higher levels of poverty. However, even in the case where taxes are raised significantly to pay for a BI at the level of GMI benefits, the BI does not significantly reduce poverty.” 5. “Rather than reducing the overall headcount of those in poverty, a BI would change the composition of the income-poor population … In all countries, a reduction in poverty among those currently not covered by social protection systems would be offset by some of those who are covered by existing social protection systems and who lose out from the introduction of a BI moving into poverty.” So there you have it. A BIG as is typically proposed is not a magic cure for poverty. Under fiscal neutrality, the maximum sustainable BIG would be modest. Aggregate demand and employment impacts would be small, and even with some redistribution of working hours; high levels of labour underutilisation would persist. Overall this strategy does not enhance the rights of the most disadvantaged, nor does it provide work for those who desire it. It is obvious that persistent unemployment could easily be avoided by the introduction of the BIG if it was accompanied by a net government stimulus (deficit). This recognises that at all times, given the spending and saving decisions of the non-government sector, the existing unemployment level is the choice of the currency-issuing government – in other words, mass unemployment means that the deficit is too small relative to non-government saving desires. Without an appropriate fiscal stimulus, the basic income proposal would achieve full employment by persuading the unemployed to drop out of the labour force upon receipt of an income guarantee. The economy would move towards full employment by stealth – pushing workers out of the labour force rather than providing work for them. But the value of the currency would then fall given that nothing is provided in return for the government spending. The resulting inflationary bias would invoke interest rate adjustments (given the current inflation-first approach adopted by central banks) that would constrain the economy from achieving sufficient growth to offer real employment options to all aspiring workers. But then a further quandary emerges. The more generous BIG [basic income guarantees], would probably stimulate total spending such that there would be a shortage of labour at ‘full employment’, resulting from the artificial reduction of the full employment level of employment, which then compounds the inflationary pressure. The alternative is that the excess demand for goods would be increasingly met via imports with consequential effects for the exchange rate and the domestic price level, which would accentuate the inflationary pressure. Thus the introduction of a BIG [basic income guarantee] policy is likely to be highly problematic with respect its capacity to deliver both sustained full employment and price stability. A sound policy also has to be viable if the extremes of that policy are encountered. It is obvious that the basic income proposal does not satisfy that requirement. As more an more individuals opted for the basic income without work, output would drop dramatically and material prosperity would be violated. Leisure and consumption are closely related. Further, given the logic employed by the basic income proponents that the government providing the basic income is financially constrained, the logic means that as increasing numbers of workers ‘liberated’ themselves by taking the basic income, the capacity of the government to sustain it would diminish. In other words, on its own grounds, the basic income proposal is limited in scope. What about an MMT-style BIG? That is, one that recognises that the government would have no need to increase taxes to facilitate the introduction of the BIG. If there is mass unemployment, then the solution is for the government to expand its net fiscal impact (spending over taxation) and allow the deficit to rise. So shifting from a state of mass unemployment to the introduction of a basic income guarantee would require a net government stimulus (that is, an increasing fiscal deficit). In this regard, the basic income guarantee (funded by an increasing fiscal deficit) constitutes an indiscriminate Keynesian expansion and as it lacks any inbuilt price stabilisation mechanisms, inflationary pressures would result. Workers who draw income from the production cycle have also added output (via their labour) to that cycle. For a given level of productivity (output per unit of input), the more people that have access to income, spend that income at market prices, but do not add to output (that is, are supported in real terms by the production of others), the greater the inflation risk. Further, the greater the share of income generated in any period that is received by people who offer nothing in return, the higher the inflation risk. Under these circumstances, the more people pursue the ‘freedom’ on non-work under the basic income guarantee, the worse the situation becomes because for given productivity, this would mean the supply side of the economy keeps shrinking, while the demand side remains stable (depending on the level of the stipend). So we come back to the point that to minimise the inflation risk, the basic income stipend has to be small, which then, in turn, means the scheme hardly addresses the dignity of an independent existence. People have income security but are in poverty. We can explore this vulnerability further. If the government increases net spending (its deficit) to fund a generous basic income stipend then the demand for labour rises in response to the higher aggregate spending in the economy. Clearly, labour demand would higher than under a fiscally-neutral introduction of a basic income guarantee. The real issue is what happens to labour supply. If the stimulus was wrought via the payment of a generous basic income stipend, then it is reasonable to surmise that total labour supply would decrease. In other words, the level of employment that coincides with ‘full employment’ where everybody who wants a job can find one is artificially reduced in the presence of the basic income guarantee (if sufficiently generous). The real resource space available for the stimulus is thus reduced. The more people who took the stipend and withdrew from the labour force, the less real capacity there would be in the economy to respond to nominal spending growth. With less productive workers available, the stimulus would cause what economists call ‘demand-pull’ inflation. The inflation rate is pulled up by an incompatibility of nominal spending relative to productive capacity. Firms would compete for increasingly fewer workers and drive up wages, which would have the consequence of making the basic income stipend less attractive at the margin. Some ‘Malibu surfers’ might decide to resume work again. The government might respond by raising taxes and/or reducing government expenditure, which would tend to raise unemployment. The central bank, under the current regime that governs monetary policy, would also respond by raising interest rates. The combination of these policy responses would reduce the demand pressure, but to the extent that the inflationary process had assumed a cost-push form (distributional struggle over available real income), wage and price inflation may only decline slowly. It is thus possible that an unsustainable dynamic could be generated in which there are periodic phases of demand-pull inflation and induced cost-push inflation at low rates of unemployment, followed by contractionary policy and high rates of unemployment. These economic outcomes are consistent with indiscriminate (generalised) Keynesian policy expansions of the past. Our conclusion is that the introduction of a basic income guarantee which is designed to also sustain full employment (that is, to give all those who want to work the opportunity) is likely to be highly problematic given the likely inflationary consequences.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Inflation DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – UBI

No funds for UBI- allocating finances causes inflation and public backlash

Folwer 22, Kyle Folwer, Kyle Fowler is an American university student pursuing a business degree at Indiana University in Bloomington, Indiana, United States. He is passionate about discussions surrounding fiscal policy, monetary policy, and individual choice. Kyle is the spring 2022 intern with the Austrian Economics Center, The Austrian Economics Center, “UBI and Inflation: An American Case Study”, May 20, 2022, https://austriancenter.com/ubi-and-inflation-american-case-study///Isim

Traditionally a contemporary concept amongst the Left, Universal Basic Income (UBI) has recently become well-known amongst the American people. Currently, various UBI programs are being tried in parts of California, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Louisiana, New Jersey, and New York. Former 2020 presidential hopeful Andrew Yang brought mainstream attention towards UBI in the United States, campaigning for a monthly universal basic income of $1,000 for all American citizens. Yang’s plan is thorough and provides the proper setting for analysis of UBI. If Yang’s plan were to be passed by the United States Congress, every American from Bill Gates to West Virginia coal miners would be entitled to $1,000 per month, or $12,000 a year. To offset the cost of the UBI plan, Yang is advocating for a VAT tax, increased taxes on the highest earners, and a carbon tax. Yang projects $800-$900 billion in new revenue from economic growth resulting from UBI. The cost of the program is calculated to be extraordinary. Yang’s tax and UBI proposal would levy a net cost of -$1.482 trillion. To afford Yang’s plan, other financing options would have to be explored. These options include cutting existing government programs, raising taxes, borrowing more money, or printing more money. Cutting government spending The first possible way to finance UBI is by cutting current government retirement programs. American employees have paid taxes on their paychecks for social security and Medicare throughout their entire working careers. They have been ensured they would be entitled to these programs when they retire or reach the mandatory age. Despite the high costs required to finance these programs, they are immensely popular amongst the American people. While Yang’s plan promises UBI on top of social security benefits, some spending must be scrapped to afford the -$1.482 trillion net cost of the program. Given the popularity of American retirement programs, cutting them would result in a widespread backlash amongst the American people. Under Yang’s plan, welfare recipients would have the option to either keep their existing benefits or choose UBI. Since UBI is a no strings attached payment, the government will have no ability to enforce that it is spent for required items such as food, healthcare, and childcare. This is a risky proposition, given that drug use is higher amongst welfare recipients than the average American. If the terms of Yang’s UBI plan are to be enforced, UBI will be added as another welfare program, given existing welfare programs will not be canceled. Raising Taxes Raising taxes on the rich has been a rallying cry of left-wing Americans in recent years. But taxing the wealthiest Americans ultimately results in less consumer spending, counterintuitive to a goal of Yang’s UBI plan. Yang argues that UBI will genuinely improve the livelihood of America’s poorest residents, while he simultaneously argues for a VAT tax on purchases from larger companies. When VAT taxes are levied, job security can come into question. In addition, raising taxes is always an immensely unpopular proposition when it is proposed to the American people. A majority of Americans already feel that they pay too much in income taxes. Significant opposition and the costs associated with raising taxes for a UBI plan would force the American government to pursue other, dangerous financing options. Printing money One way in which the United States government finances its spending is through the use of the money printing press. The “print more money” argument, in general, is illogical, especially when applied to financing UBI. At the core of the coronavirus pandemic, the United States passed extensive economic stimulus to “stimulate” the American economy. In 2020, the Fed partook in actions which brought about the printing of more money, increasing the possibility of rampant inflation. This has seemingly been the case, as the latest CPI numbers increased by an astounding 8.3%, near a four-decade high. Printing more dollars for the purposes of UBI will increase inflation further. Borrowing Throughout the past few decades, American spending projects have been financed by borrowing. A likely scenario is that UBI would be financed through borrowing, the same way American COVID relief bills were funded. While unpopular, in recent years, American politicians have run up a budget deficit in the trillions, reaching an astonishing $3.13 trillion in 2020. In 2021, the United States allocated 5% of its total federal spending to paying the interest on its debts, for a total of $352.3 billion. As a reference point, the United States allocated $234.3 billion to pay for Veterans Benefits and Services. Is UBI important enough to accumulate more debt and interest, when 5% of the yearly federal budget is already used to pay interest accumulated on debt? Conclusion Undoubtedly, inflation is a significant issue facing the American public. For a nation that religiously relies on car travel and fossil fuel production, coronavirus spending and the energy price increase exacerbated by the Russia-Ukraine war has been disastrous for the economy. The cost of food and other essential goods will continue to rise, providing an additional cost on the average American. During this inflationary crisis, with nearly 15% of Americans living in poverty, inflation has caused significant suffering for the American people. While supporters argue that UBI will alleviate these pains, further spending will aid further inflation as American spending bills have done in recent years. As a result, Yang’s UBI plan does not make sense from an economic perspective, given its propensity for increasing inflation

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Inflation DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – UBI

Supply and demand mean UBI’s expanded money supply results in massive inflation.

CFI 23, CFI, “Universal Basic Income”, January 7 2023, https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/career/universal-basic-income-ubi///Isim

What is a Universal Basic Income (UBI)? While it does not yet exist as a practical reality in the United States, the concept of a universal basic income – or UBI – is similar to the concept of minimum wage. Each individual receives an agreed-upon minimum income (basic income) with the intent that the income allows a person to afford the basic cost of living while maintaining some semblance of financial security or independence. Universal Basic Income The key difference (besides the fact that UBI is theoretical) is the fact that the government would pay each individual a universal basic income instead of ensuring that the individual’s job paid him or her a minimum income. Summary Universal Basic Income (UBI) is a suggested system that would provide individuals a minimum income to help prevent destitution and to help eliminate glaring economic disparities. Some suggestions recommend that a UBI is paid to every individual making up to a set amount of income (e.g., $50,000 annually), whether they are employed or not. Other proposals recommend that a UBI is given only to individuals who’ve lost a job – or more specifically, individuals who lose their job to automation. The primary argument against, or drawback to, a universal basic income system is the potential for it to cause runaway inflation, which would ultimately raise the cost of living. How a Universal Basic Income System Would Work Because universal basic income is a proposed theory – one suggested to both help individuals afford the cost of living without a lifetime of debt and to help curb global economic inequality – several possible different approaches might be taken when it comes to putting a UBI into effect. Ultimately, a country’s government sends a universal basic income to individuals, either by check or as a direct deposit into a person’s bank account. Some UBI plans include sending a payment to every person regardless of their employment status. Other proposed plans would only send a payment to unemployed individuals. It’s important to note that the concept of UBI was first proposed in response to the suggestion that, in the near future, many people are going to lose jobs as robotic/artificial intelligence (AI) technology becomes more widely used. Sir Richard Branson (founder of Virgin Group) and Elon Musk (the name behind Tesla) both believe that mass automation is inevitable and that the institution of a universal basic income is the only way people will be able to survive. The main issue surrounding a UBI is how it would be funded. Some plans recommend taxation of the world’s wealthiest. Facebook co-founder, Chris Hughes, and author of the 2018 book, “Fair Shot,” wrote that employed individuals in the U.S., as well as anyone responsible for the care of someone else, should receive a minimum of $500 per month, provided they make $50,000 or less each year. Taxing the wealthiest 1% in the U.S. would be used to cover the cost. Drawbacks of a Universal Basic Income A UBI system is still a theoretical approach, one that comes with good intentions and noble goals. Still, widespread financial equality and independence offer the potential to cause some serious economic issues. One major issue with a universal basic income, raised by those who oppose such a practice, is inflation. It’s easy to see how the institution of a UBI may fuel inflation. If every individual is granted an unconditional income from the government, then there is money to be spent. Providing massive amounts of money to virtually every individual in the country translates to a massively expanded money supply. It means that there is a higher demand for goods and services that manufacturers and retailers produce and sell. The law of supply and demand dictates that, as demand pressure increases on producers and retailers, they must increase prices on the available supply of goods and services to avoid being overwhelmed by the increased demand. That is inflation. If the end result of a UBI turns out to be uncontrolled inflation, then the cost of living continues to increase. It would necessitate an increase in the level of universal basic income provided to all citizens or allowing the standard of living for UBI recipients to decline, as they are able to purchase fewer goods and services with the amount of UBI they receive. Unless something can be done to manage the situation, there would just be a vicious circle created of higher UBI leading to increased prices, leading to a necessary increase in the UBI amount, leading to still higher prices… you get the idea.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Inflation DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – Jobs Guarantee

Adopting a federal jobs guarantee would crowd out businesses leading to inflation and would reduce private employment

Bourne 23

Chair for public understanding of economics, A Jobs guaranteed economic disaster, Cato institute, https://www.cato.org/blog/jobs-guaranteed-economic-disaster

In reality, the fiscal costs are likely to be much, much higher, and the economic welfare losses even more significant, because in the labor market and broader economy, a public jobs guarantee program would significantly crowd out productive private sector activity. This type of policy will radically alter behavior of both workers and businesses, and so the supply and demand for labor. The Census shows that, among those who worked in 2016, 70+ million Americans earned under $32,500 (the full‐​time job guarantee salary would be $31,200). Yes, not all of these would seek out positions on the jobs guarantee program. But a large proportion would, especially those employed in uncertain roles with low levels of job security. In fact, some even paid more than $31,200 might consider leaving their jobs to pursue guaranteed roles if they perceive better working conditions or an easier worklife (asked under what conditions someone would be fired from such a role, the Levy Institute paper suggests that you would be sacked for failing to go to work, but that your performance would not be judged by “private sector ‘efficiency criteria’”, for example.) It’s not inconceivable then that over 25 percent of the labor force could find itself part of the scheme. This crowd‐​out is likely to be particularly acute in low productivity regions, and (ironically) after economic downturns. A nationwide jobs guarantee program paying $15 an hour will be particularly attractive to workers in low wage regions, and by setting a de facto wage floor the program will prevent private investment in regions on the basis of cheap labor. Though no doubt there would be some demand spillovers from well‐​paid jobs, the net consequence is highly likely to be weaker private sector job creation in poor regions, which has been the experience of countries such as Britain with a nationwide minimum wages and public sector national pay bargaining. Proponents of the scheme see “higher labor standards” as a good thing, but absent productivity improvements, policies which raise labor costs significantly will reduce the quantity of workers demanded.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Inflation DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – Jobs Guarantee

A job guarantee will cause accelerating inflation

Standing ’20 (Guy. "Why A Basic Income Is Necessary For A Right To Work." Basic Income Studies 7:2. 2013. October 09, 2020 https://www.researchgate.net/publication/269594683_Why_a_Basic_lncome_ls_Necesary_for_a_Right_to_Work)

In a market economy, it is generally recognized by economists that some unemployment is necessary. Many economists believe that there is a "natural" rate of unemployment ground out by the structural characteristics of production and employment. Its closely related concept is the NAIRU, the "non-accelerating inflation rate of unemployment". One can dispute the methodology for conceiving and measuring these concepts but, at the very least, ever since the origin of the Phillips Curve in 1958, it has been accepted that if unemployment is pushed too low, inflationary pressures will become intense. If price rises and wage rises accelerate, economic problems multiply. In other words, guaranteeing everybody a job would create huge economic costs.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Inflation DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – Jobs Guarantee

A federal job guarantee causes wage inflation

Bruenig ’20 (Matt. "Some Notes On Federal Job Guarantee Proposals." People. March 22, 2018. October 09, 2020. https://www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2018/03/22/some- notes-on-federal-job-guarantee-proposals/)

The first statement suggests that the JG will actively compete for workers in the private sector. That is, the JG will lure workers out of their private jobs through superior compensation, thereby creating wage inflationary pressures. In his Nation piece, Sean McElwee makes this claim very explicitly, saying that nurses could quit their jobs at hospitals to work a JG job and that this would put upward wage pressure on the nursing profession. The second statement suggests that the JG will act as a buffer that absorbs workers in economic downturns and releases them in economic upturns. In this construction, the plan is not inflationary as it does not compete with private sector employment, but only scoops up those who would otherwise not be employed. This is a tension that runs throughout the JG world.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Inflation DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – Jobs Guarantee

The Phillips curve ensures any form of full employment to solve the AFF results in inflation and more unemployment.

TIT 23

THE INVESTOPEDIA TEAM -- Caleb Silver, Editor in Chief; Anna Attkisson, Senior Editorial Director; Hilarey Gould, Editorial Director, Financial Products and Services; Yasmin Ghahremani, Associate Editorial Director, Financial Products and Services; Alec McCabe, Associate Editorial Director, News; Ben Woolsey, Associate Editorial Director, Financial Products and Services; Mrinalini Krishna, Senior Editor, Investing News; Stella Osoba, Senior Editor, Trading and Investing; Taylor Tompkins, Economics Editor, News; Sienna Wrenn, Special Projects Editor; Clay Halton, Business Editor; Jess Feldman, Associate Editor, Special Projects; Colin Laidley, Associate Editor, News; Ward Williams, Associate Editor, Financial Products and Services; Diccon Hyatt, Reporter; Updated February 03, 2023; Full Employment: Definition, Types, and Examples; .; //[TMS—GK]

What Is Full Employment? Full employment is an economic situation in which all available labor resources are being used in the most efficient way possible. Full employment embodies the highest amount of skilled and unskilled labor that can be employed within an economy at any given time. True full employment is an ideal—and probably unachievable—situation in which anyone who is willing and able to work can find a job, and unemployment is zero. It is a theoretical goal for economic policymakers to aim for rather than an actually observed state of the economy. In practical terms, economists can define various levels of full employment that are associated with low but non-zero rates of unemployment. KEY TAKEAWAYS Full employment is when all available labor resources are being used in the most efficient way possible. Full employment embodies the highest amount of skilled and unskilled labor that can be employed within an economy at any given time. Economists define various types of full employment based on their theories as targets for economic policy. Many modern economists agree that some unemployment is necessary to avoid inflation and to allow workers to move between jobs, pursue education, or improve their skills. Unemployment of 5% or lower is often considered full employment in a real-world context. 1:26 Full Employment Understanding Full Employment Full employment is seen as the ideal employment rate within an economy at which no workers are involuntarily unemployed. Full employment of labor is one component of an economy that is operating at its full productive potential and producing at a point along its production possibilities frontier. If there is any unemployment, then the economy is not producing at full potential, and some improvement in economic efficiency may be possible. However, because it may not be practically possible to eliminate all unemployment from all sources, full employment may not actually be attainable. For many economists, newer understandings of full employment require some degree of unemployment to temper inflation and allow workers to move between jobs, pursue their education, or improve their skills. 1 An unemployment rate of 5% is often considered full employment. This level of unemployment is enough to minimize inflation and allow workers to move between jobs, but those wanting full-time work should be able to find a full-time job (even if it is not their preferred occupation). The Phillips Curve In terms of cyclical unemployment, many macroeconomic theories present full employment as a goal that, once attained, often results in an inflationary period. The link between inflation and unemployment is a prominent part of the Monetarist and Keynesian theories. This inflation is a result of workers having more disposable income, which would drive prices upward, according to the concept of the Phillips curve. This poses a potential problem for economic policymakers, such as the U.S. Federal Reserve, that have a dual mandate to achieve and maintain both stable prices and full employment. 2 If there is, in fact, a trade-off between employment and inflation, per the Phillips curve, then simultaneous full employment and price stability may not be possible. The Austrian School On the other hand, some economists also argue against the overzealous pursuit of full employment, especially via the over-expansion of money and credit through monetary policy. Economists of the Austrian School believe that this will result in damaging distortions to the financial and manufacturing sectors of the economy. This might even result in more unemployment in the long run by precipitating a subsequent recession as real resource constraints come into conflict with artificially increased demand for various types of capital goods and complementary labor. Types of Unemployment Unemployment can result from cyclical, structural, frictional, or institutional causes. Policymakers can focus on reducing the underlying causes of each of these types of unemployment, but in doing so they may face trade-offs against other policy goals. Structural The desire to encourage technological progress can cause structural unemployment. For example, when workers find themselves obsolete due to the automation of factories or the use of artificial intelligence. Institutional Institutional unemployment arises from institutional policies that affect the economy. These can include governmental programs promoting social equity and offering generous safety net benefits, and labor market phenomena, such as unionization and discriminatory hiring. Frictional Some unemployment may be unavoidable by policymakers entirely, such as frictional unemployment, which is caused by workers voluntarily changing jobs or first entering the workforce. Searching for a new job, recruiting new employees, and matching the right worker to the right job are all a part of it. Cyclical Cyclical unemployment is the fluctuating type of unemployment that rises and falls within the normal course of the business cycle. This unemployment rises when an economy is in a recession and falls when an economy is growing. 1 Therefore, for an economy to be at full employment, it cannot be in a recession that’s causing cyclical unemployment. The Phillips curve is cyclical. It posits that full employment inevitably results in higher inflation, which in turn leads to increasing unemployment. For the most part, macroeconomic policymakers focus on reducing cyclical unemployment to move the economy toward full employment. In this case they may face trade-offs against rising inflation or the risk of distorting other sectors of the economy. Cyclical unemployment, which is driven by changes in economic cycles, should not be confused with "seasonal unemployment," where there are changes in the workforce that predictably occur throughout the year, For example, jobs in the retail sector typically decrease after the traditional run-up to the holiday shopping season ends after New Year's. Unemployment rises when people hired for the holidays are no longer needed to meet demand. Types of Full Employment Due to the difficulty, and questionable desirability, of achieving true full employment, economists have developed other, more pragmatic goals for economic policy. Natural Rate The natural rate of unemployment represents only the amount of unemployment due to structural and frictional factors in labor markets. The natural rate serves as an achievable approximation of full employment while accepting that technological change and the normal transaction costs of labor markets will always mean some modest unemployment at any given point in time. Non-Accelerating Inflation Rate The non-accelerating inflation rate of unemployment (NAIRU) represents the rate of unemployment that is consistent with a low, stable rate of price inflation. The NAIRU is useful as a policy target for economic policymakers who operate under a dual mandate to balance full employment and stable prices. This is not full employment, but it is the closest the economy can be to full employment without excessive upward pressure on prices from increasing wages. Modern economists often mean the NAIRU when they refer to full employment. 1 Note that the NAIRU only makes sense conceptually and as a policy target if and when there is indeed a stable trade-off between unemployment and inflation, as posited by the Phillips curve.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Inflation DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – Jobs Guarantee

A jobs boom will worsen inflation, outpace wages, and trigger a recession

Zahn ‘22 (Max Zahn, business and technology reporter for ABC news, Master’s in Journalism from the Craig Newmark Graduate School of Journalism, Bachelor’s in English Literature and Philosophy from Oberlin College, “Why the jobs boom could worsen inflation and help trigger a recession,” December 9, 2022, https://abcnews.go.com/Business/jobs-boom-worsen-inflation-trigger-recession%20/story?id=94769664)-Emery

The economy has set off emergency sirens this year over growing recession fears, sky-high inflation and a battered stock market. But one area has allayed worries: jobs. Hiring last month exceeded expectations and defied warnings of a downturn. Moreover, in November, wages grew a blistering 5.1% compared to a year earlier, offering welcome relief for workers strained by price hikes. But the hiring boom could help send the economy into a prolonged downturn, turning the good jobs news into a grim omen, economists told ABC News. "It's confusing for people and rightfully so," Betsey Stevenson, a professor of public policy and economics at the University of Michigan, told ABC News. "How can a lot of jobs be bad for the economy?" A tight job market fuels rising wages, which often push companies to raise prices to make up for the added costs. In turn, inflation worsens and recession risks rise, they added. In addition, rising wages have offered less to workers than they appear to have at first glance, since income gains have trailed the pace of inflation, effectively slapping workers with a pay cut, the economists said. Here's what you need to know about how the hiring spree could deepen inflation and help trigger a recession, while leaving some workers worse off. Robust job growth could deepen inflation, but it isn't the primary cause of the current bout of high prices, economists said. Like so many economic problems, inflation comes down to an imbalance between supply and demand. When billions of people across the globe faced lockdowns, they shifted consumption to goods like Peloton bikes and couches, in some cases bolstered by wallets fattened with government stimulus. Meanwhile, a pandemic-era supply chain bottleneck dramatically slowed the delivery of the goods people wanted. In turn, demand far outpaced supply, sending prices skyward. This year, price hikes reached a 40-year high, triggering an aggressive series of interest rate hikes from the Federal Reserve meant to slash demand, slow the economy and curb costs. Price increases for some goods have cooled but remain highly elevated. "Nobody out there would tell you the main reason we have inflation today is businesses trying to chase too few workers," said Stevenson, of the University of Michigan.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Inflation DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – Jobs Guarantee

Jobs guarantee increases wages too fast, resulting in inflation

Bhandari 19; Ryan Bhandari- Former Senior Policy Advisor, Economic Program; March 25, 2019; What Is the “Federal Jobs Guarantee” and What Are People Saying About It?; ; [TMS—GK]

#4: Inflation would rise. A sudden increase in the cost of labor for businesses will lead to inflation throughout the economy because of higher business costs that will need to be passed on to consumers. In addition, when only those at the bottom of the income distribution get a defacto raise to $15, there are upstream consequences. Workers who were making $15 an hour may demand $20 an hour now. Workers making $20 an hour might want $25 an hour and so on. This may seem like a benefit, but “this is a story of serious wage-price spiral, unless we introduce other measures,” warns progressive economist Dean Baker.5 We have been very fortunate that inflation has been well under control for the last few decades. A federal jobs guarantee could change that pretty quickly.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Inflation DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – Jobs Guarantee

A federal jobs guarantee causes conflict with the private sector and weakens the productivity and output of the of the economy

Gulker ‘18 (Max Gulker, Senior Research Fellow at the American Institute for Economic Research, PhD in Economics from Stanford University, BA in economics from the University of Michigan, published by The American Institute for Economic Research, “The Jobs Guarantee: A Critical Analysis,” October 18, 2018, https://www.aier.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/JobGuarantee_0.pdf )-Emery

Both reports’ authors treat the ten million or more enrollees in a federal job guarantee as somehow cloistered from the labor market at large (which includes both private and government employers). The Levy report envisions a “buffer stock” of job-guarantee workers that will grow in times of downturns and shrink as more workers rejoin the traditional labor market in better times. One does not have to go deep into economic theory to see how this purportedly clean flow of workers would break down. The WPA offered temporary relief to those out of work during a national emergency of unprecedented proportions. While debates rage to this day as to the efficacy and impact of New Deal programs, those debates are of limited relevance to our current situation, where unemployment rates are near twenty-five-year lows. The infrastructure-construction projects that dominated WPA employment rolls would be more capital intensive than the other ideas put forward in both reports, adding further cost to the program. In addition, the lack of information conveyed by market signals would be compounded by more centralized program management. There is evidence that these issues arose during the years of the WPA itself. That program initially had a tiered wage-and-hours structure like the structure described in the CBPP report, which raised familiar concerns about competition with existing private sector jobs. Officials tried other schemes, including linking wages to those “prevailing” in private sector versions of the same work, and simply fixing hours and wages. These attempted solutions underscore the blunt instruments with which administrators must work when attempting to design a rational system from the top down. Whether nationally administered or delegated locally, it appears that finding and assigning work on the scale proposed would quickly turn their vision of a public good into a public burden. But the disruptive effects on the wider economy, to which we now turn, might prove far more burdensome. Neither report takes account of harm to the private sector caused by their proposals. In addition to the de facto minimum wage and benefits set by a job guarantee, one must consider the contraction in private labor supply that would result if a sizable fraction of the many millions of currently employed workers at the lower end of the wage distribution chose to leave their jobs and enroll in the federal program. The immediate result of more pay and benefits for the working poor is something everyone would like to see, all else equal. But the process would divert workers from the places in the economy where they are most productive to a labyrinthine bureaucracy, where even finding enough work to assign would be a challenge. This could greatly weaken the productivity of the overall economy, potentially leading to declines in output and even greater job loss. Contrary to the stated goal of not competing with the private sector, some industries could become entirely nationalized. For example, 875,000 home health aides and 1.3 million teachers’ aides currently employed by the private and public sectors earn less on average than proposed job guarantee wages. One might myopically say these workers deserve a raise, but turning these industries from conventional jobs into tasks assigned on demand would almost certainly result in poorer service to the young and elderly.