Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Disadvantage
2AC › Impact › Climate

No extinction---requires 12 degrees and adaptation

Sebastian Farquhar 17 master’s degree in Physics from the University of Oxford, leads the Global Priorities Project (GPP) at the Centre for Effective Altruism, et al., 2017, “Existential Risk: Diplomacy and Governance,” {DK}

The most likely levels of global warming are very unlikely to cause human extinction.15 The existential risks of climate change instead stem from tail risk climate change – the low probability of extreme levels of warming – and interaction with other sources of risk. It is impossible to say with confidence at what point global warming would become severe enough to pose an existential threat. Research has suggested that warming of 11-12°C would render most of the planet uninhabitable,16 and would completely devastate agriculture.17 This would pose an extreme threat to human civilisation as we know it.18 Warming of around 7°C or more could potentially produce conflict and instability on such a scale that the indirect effects could be an existential risk, although it is extremely uncertain how likely such scenarios are.19 Moreover, the timescales over which such changes might happen could mean that humanity is able to adapt enough to avoid extinction in even very extreme scenarios. The probability of these levels of warming depends on eventual greenhouse gas concentrations. According to some experts, unless strong action is taken soon by major emitters, it is likely that we will pursue a medium-high emissions pathway.20 If we do, the chance of extreme warming is highly uncertain but appears non-negligible. Current concentrations of greenhouse gases are higher than they have been for hundreds of thousands of years,21 which means that there are significant unknown unknowns about how the climate system will respond. Particularly concerning is the risk of positive feedback loops, such as the release of vast amounts of methane from melting of the arctic permafrost, which would cause rapid and disastrous warming.22 The economists Gernot Wagner and Martin Weitzman have used IPCC figures (which do not include modelling of feedback loops such as those from melting permafrost) to estimate that if we continue to pursue a medium-high emissions pathway, the probability of eventual warming of 6°C is around 10%,23 and of 10°C is around 3%.24 These estimates are of course highly uncertain. It is likely that the world will take action against climate change once it begins to impose large costs on human society, long before there is warming of 10°C. Unfortunately, there is significant inertia in the climate system: there is a 25 to 50 year lag between CO2 emissions and eventual warming,25 and it is expected that 40% of the peak concentration of CO2 will remain in the atmosphere 1,000 years after the peak is reached.26 Consequently, it is impossible to reduce temperatures quickly by reducing CO2 emissions. If the world does start to face costly warming, the international community will therefore face strong incentives to find other ways to reduce global temperatures.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
2AC › Impact › Climate

Warming stops at 3 degrees – new studies.

Nordhaus 20 Ted Nordhaus, an American author, environmental policy expert, and the director of research at The Breakthrough Institute, citing new climate change forecasts. [Ignore the Fake Climate Debate, 1-23-2020, https://www.wsj.com/articles/ignore-the-fake-climate-debate-11579795816]//BPS

Beyond the headlines and social media, where Greta Thunberg, Donald Trump and the online armies of climate “alarmists” and “deniers” do battle, there is a real climate debate bubbling along in scientific journals, conferences and, occasionally, even in the halls of Congress. It gets a lot less attention than the boisterous and fake debate that dominates our public discourse, but it is much more relevant to how the world might actually address the problem. In the real climate debate, no one denies the relationship between human emissions of greenhouse gases and a warming climate. Instead, the disagreement comes down to different views of climate risk in the face of multiple, cascading uncertainties. On one side of the debate are optimists, who believe that, with improving technology and greater affluence, our societies will prove quite adaptable to a changing climate. On the other side are pessimists, who are more concerned about the risks associated with rapid, large-scale and poorly understood transformations of the climate system. But most pessimists do not believe that runaway climate change or a hothouse earth are plausible scenarios, much less that human extinction is imminent. And most optimists recognize a need for policies to address climate change, even if they don’t support the radical measures that Ms. Thunberg and others have demanded. In the fake climate debate, both sides agree that economic growth and reduced emissions vary inversely; it’s a zero-sum game. In the real debate, the relationship is much more complicated. Long-term economic growth is associated with both rising per capita energy consumption and slower population growth. For this reason, as the world continues to get richer, higher per capita energy consumption is likely to be offset by a lower population. A richer world will also likely be more technologically advanced, which means that energy consumption should be less carbon-intensive than it would be in a poorer, less technologically advanced future. In fact, a number of the high-emissions scenarios produced by the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change involve futures in which the world is relatively poor and populous and less technologically advanced. Affluent, developed societies are also much better equipped to respond to climate extremes and natural disasters. That’s why natural disasters kill and displace many more people in poor societies than in rich ones. It’s not just seawalls and flood channels that make us resilient; it’s air conditioning and refrigeration, modern transportation and communications networks, early warning systems, first responders and public health bureaucracies. New research published in the journal Global Environmental Change finds that global economic growth over the last decade has reduced climate mortality by a factor of five, with the greatest benefits documented in the poorest nations. In low-lying Bangladesh, 300,000 people died in Cyclone Bhola in 1970, when 80% of the population lived in extreme poverty. In 2019, with less than 20% of the population living in extreme poverty, Cyclone Fani killed just five people. “Poor nations are most vulnerable to a changing climate. The fastest way to reduce that vulnerability is through economic development.” So while it is true that poor nations are most vulnerable to a changing climate, it is also true that the fastest way to reduce that vulnerability is through economic development, which requires infrastructure and industrialization. Those activities, in turn, require cement, steel, process heat and chemical inputs, all of which are impossible to produce today without fossil fuels. For this and other reasons, the world is unlikely to cut emissions fast enough to stabilize global temperatures at less than 2 degrees above pre-industrial levels, the long-standing international target, much less 1.5 degrees, as many activists now demand. But recent forecasts also suggest that many of the worst-case climate scenarios produced in the last decade, which assumed unbounded economic growth and fossil-fuel development, are also very unlikely. There is still substantial uncertainty about how sensitive global temperatures will be to higher emissions over the long-term. But the best estimates now suggest that the world is on track for 3 degrees of warming by the end of this century, not 4 or 5 degrees as was once feared. That is due in part to slower economic growth in the wake of the global financial crisis, but also to decades of technology policy and energy-modernization efforts. “We have better and cleaner technologies available today because policy-makers in the U.S. and elsewhere set out to develop those technologies.” The energy intensity of the global economy continues to fall. Lower-carbon natural gas has displaced coal as the primary source of new fossil energy. The falling cost of wind and solar energy has begun to have an effect on the growth of fossil fuels. Even nuclear energy has made a modest comeback in Asia.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
2AC › Impact › Climate

FAA can’t solve global emissions

IEA 7/11 (The International Energy Agency is a Paris-based autonomous intergovernmental organisation, established in 1974, that provides policy recommendations, analysis and data on the entire global energy sector, “Aviation,” IEA, 7/11/2023, ) - MP

CO2 emissions from aviation have reached 80% of their pre-pandemic peak

Aviation emissions rose in 2022 to reach nearly 80% of their pre-pandemic peak in 2019. After increasing at an average of 2.3% per year from 1990 to 2019, direct CO2 emissions from fossil fuel combustion plummeted from more than 1 000 Mt CO2 in 2019 to less than 600 Mt CO2 in 2020 in the context of the Covid-19 pandemic. As demand from air passengers recovered in 2022, emissions increased in all regions with the exception of China (due to the zero-Covid policy) and Russia (due to the invasion of Ukraine), reaching almost 800 Mt CO2. CO2 emissions are expected to grow rapidly and to surpass their 2019 level around 2025. Multiple measures are required to promote the technologies, sustainable aviation fuels (SAF) and demand-side management needed to bring the currently rising emissions level below 1 000 Mt CO2 by 2030, in line with the NZE Scenario. Policy and fiscal support should prioritise improvements in energy efficiency, stimulating investment in pre-commercial and low-emissions SAF, and developing alternatives to jet kerosene, such as electricity- or hydrogen-powered aircraft. [Graph Omitted] From 2010 to 2019, average fuel efficiency per revenue tonne kilometre (RTK) equivalent travelled improved by 1.8% per year thanks to the introduction of more efficient aircraft and engines, with improvements over the decade nearly reaching ICAO’s aspirational goal of 2% per annum through 2050. However, efficiency improvements have not kept up with demand growth, which grew at an average rate of over 5% annually between 2010 and 2019. To stay on track with the Net Zero Scenario, efficiency will need to improve at a rate of 2% per year through 2030, on a par with the historical average improvements over the past two decades. In addition to technical efficiency improvements in engine and airframe designs, improvements in payload and traffic efficiency (i.e. the weight of cargo and number of passengers carried per aircraft) have also contributed to reducing the energy intensity of aircraft operation. Payload efficiency deteriorated between 2020 and 2022, as planes were flown with fewer passengers despite some compensatory increase in freight payloads in the bellies of passenger aircraft.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
2AC › Impact › Climate

Reauthorization can’t solve – efforts for sustainable efforts fail to address global CO2 emissions

IEA 7/11 (The International Energy Agency is a Paris-based autonomous intergovernmental organisation, established in 1974, that provides policy recommendations, analysis and data on the entire global energy sector, “Aviation,” IEA, 7/11/2023, ) - MP

Why is aviation important? Aviation accounts for a relatively small share of global emissions but is one of the most challenging sectors to decarbonise. Despite reductions in flying during the Covid-19 lockdowns, demand is expected to grow rapidly through 2030. New aircraft can be up to 20% more efficient than the models they replace, but growth in activity has historically outpaced efficiency improvement. Where do we need to go? Technology innovation is needed across the sector, including in production of low-emission fuels, improvements in aircraft and engines, and operational optimisation. Demand restraint solutions will also be needed to get on track with the Net Zero Emissions by 2050 Scenario – to curb growth in emissions and ultimately reduce them this decade. What are the challenges? Planned production capacity for sustainable aviation fuels will provide just a small fraction of jet fuel demand by 2027. Increasing the use of these fuels to get in line with the Net Zero Scenario will require supportive policies and a significant ramp-up of investments in production capacity. In 2022 aviation accounted for 2% of global energy-related CO2 emissions, having grown faster in recent decades than rail, road or shipping. As international travel demand recovers following the Covid-19 pandemic, aviation emissions in 2022 reached almost 800 Mt CO2, about 80% of the pre-pandemic level. Many technical measures related to low-emission fuels, improvements in airframes and engines, operational optimisation and demand restraint solutions are needed to curb growth in emissions and ultimately reduce them this decade in order to get on track with the Net Zero Emissions by 2050 (NZE) Scenario.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
2AC › I/L › Winners Win

It replenishes.

Jamelle Bouie 21, columnist for The New York Times, formerly chief political correspondent for Slate magazine, 2/5/21, "What is "political capital" anyway?" New York Times, ProQuest

In this telling, “political capital” is finite. When you spend it, you lose it, and if you spend it on the wrong things, you can’t get it back. But that doesn’t make any sense.

Actual “capital” isn’t spent; it is invested. The point is to get a return on that investment by directing capital to some productive use. The point of capital, in other words, is to produce more capital.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
2AC › I/L › Biden Fails

Biden has zero PC.

James Politi 22, Washington Bureau Chief; Financial Times, 6/23/2022, “Biden’s blues: is the US president out of political capital?” *edited for language

But it also reflected a more disturbing reality for the 79-year-old president: in the space of just 17 months, he has already burnt a lot of the political capital he had when he walked into the Oval Office in January last year.

According to the Realclearpolitics.com polling average, just 39.6 per cent of voters approve of Biden’s performance in the White House so far, compared with 54.9 per cent who disapprove — a wide gap of 15 percentage points that will be hard to close.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
2AC › I/L › PC Fake

Polarization renders political capital useless.

Ryan Teligator 21, B.A. in Political Science and Government from Bowdoin University, 5/20/21, "When is Change Possible? Presidential Power as Shaped by Political Context, Constitutional Tools, and Legislative Skills," https://digitalcommons.bowdoin.edu/honorsprojects/258/

My research does not support Greenstein’s theory. Instead, my findings align more closely with those of George Edwards in At the Margins, where he argues that the “national preoccupation with the chief executive is misplaced,” and that presidential power is, in fact, limited in the Constitution’s “purposefully inefficient system in which the founding fathers’ handiwork in decentralizing power defeats even the most capable leaders.”50

Instead of focusing on legislative skills as a source of presidential influence, Edwards argues that party support and public support are more important. Legislative skills are only critical for “members of Congress who remain open to change after other influences have had their impact.”51 In a time as polarized as today, where very few members of Congress are “open to chang[ing]” their vote, these skills play a minor role in legislative negotiations. Similar assertions are made in another book by Edwards, Predicting the Presidency. He argues that exploiting existing opportunities (consolidating existing party and public support) is much more important for presidential success than creating opportunities (convincing legislators to change their vote vis a vis legislative skills).52

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
2AC › I/L › PC Fake

Political capital doesn’t solve OR deplete.

Paul Waldman 20, Communication PhD at the University of Pennsylvania, Politics Columnist at the Washington Post, Washington Post, 12/2/2020, “Joe Biden has to move fast,” https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2020/12/02/joe-biden-has-move-fast/

As David Roberts of Vox observes: In 2009, Obama and his aides made the mistake of thinking that their major initiatives had to be rolled out one at a time in sequence, because he had a finite store of “political capital” that had to be spent carefully. But political capital is not something that exists apart from any particular issue; it isn’t a special sauce that has to be poured on a policy in order to make it palatable.

And with the parties as polarized and unified as they are, political capital has become all but meaningless. There may have been a time when a popular president possessed so much capital that a senator from the opposition party would feel compelled to support him on part of that president’s agenda, but that time is long gone. There is no account Biden can draw on to turn Republican “no” votes into “yes.”

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
2AC › Link › No Link - Green Deal

GND is popular

Kaufman 18 (Alexander C. Kaufman is a Senior Business Editor at The Huffington Post, “Green New Deal has overwhelming bipartisan support, poll finds. At least, for now,” Grist, 12/19/2018, ) - MP

But when asked “how much do you support or oppose” the aforementioned suite of policies, 81 percent of registered voters say they either “somewhat support” or “strongly support” the plan, according to new survey results shared exclusively with HuffPost from the Yale Program on Climate Change Communication and George Mason University. Ninety-two percent of Democrats supported the idea, including 93 percent of liberal Democrats and 90 percent of moderate-to-conservative Democrats. But 64 percent of Republicans ― including 75 percent of moderate-to-liberal Republicans and 57 percent of conservative Republicans ― also backed the policy goals outlined in the Green New Deal. 88 percent of independents endorsed the policies as well. “Given that most Americans have strong support for the components and ideas of the Green New Deal, it becomes a communication strategy problem,” Abel Gustafson, a postdoctoral associate at Yale who co-authored a report on the findings, said by phone Sunday. “From here, it’s about how you can pitch it so you can maintain that bipartisan support throughout the rest of the process.” The survey’s description of the Green New Deal’s tenets did not mention that more than 40 progressive members of Congress are championing the policy. The group includes Representative-elect Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (a Democrat from New York), Representative John Lewis (a Democrat from Georgia) and Senator Jeff Merkley (a Democrat from Oregon). Study after study shows Americans evaluate policies more negatively when they are told politicians from an opposing party back the ideas, and more positively when they are told politicians from their own party are in support. The findings therefore indicate that although most Republicans favor the Green New Deal in principle, they are not yet aware that the plan is proposed by the political left. 98 percent of loyal Democrats 66 percent of loyal Republicans 96 percent of voters who cast ballots for President Barack Obama in 2012, President Donald Trump in 2016, and Democrats in the 2018 midterms 93 percent of voters who cast ballots for Obama, then Trump, then Republicans in 2018 The polling, published in The New York Times, came from Data for Progress, the left-leaning think tank behind the most comprehensive blueprint for a Green New Deal to date. Polling also finds that Americans consider global warming a real issue and support policy changes to address it. Yale survey data from August found: 70 percent of Americans recognize global warming is happening 57 percent understand humans are causing the temperature rise 85 percent support funding research into renewable energy 77 percent support regulating carbon dioxide as a pollutant 63 percent support requiring utilities to generate one-fifth of their electricity from renewables That made the latest findings on the Green New Deal ― one of the first major national surveys to use that term specifically ― “exciting but not necessarily surprising,” Gustafson said. “The way we described the Green New Deal in our survey was by emphasizing the qualities that resonate with both sides, that it creates jobs and strengthens America’s economy and also accelerates the transition from fossil fuels,” he said. “We’re not surprised that conservatives support those things.” Other polls show strong support for guaranteeing green jobs to unemployed Americans, a policy increasingly discussed as a vehicle for a Green New Deal but one that the Yale survey did not explicitly cite. In September, Data for Progress released polling that found 55 percent of eligible U.S. voters supported a jobs guarantee, while 23 percent opposed. When the jobs are green, that support remained the same, but the share of those outright opposed fell to 18 percent. “Democrats, Republicans, and independents alike understand that they live on the same planet, the same country,” Corbin Trent, a spokesman for Ocasio-Cortez, said when read the Yale survey results over the phone. “We need highways, jobs, and improved infrastructure, and we need a 100 percent renewable-energy economy.” The Green New Deal barreled into mainstream political discourse a little over a month ago after languishing for more than a decade on the fringes of policy debates. A new wave of progressive Democrats reclaimed the term ahead of November’s midterm election to describe the type of large-scale economic mobilization scientists say is required to keep global warming within 2.3 degrees F, beyond which sea-level rise and extreme weather are forecast to be catastrophic.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
2AC › Link › No Link – FJG

Research shows Job Guarantee is popular across all parties

Rader 6/15/23 [Katie Rader&Carissa Guadron, Assistant Professor in the Department of Political Science at Christopher Newport University and a board member of the Center for Working Class Politics. “What Running on a Jobs Guarantee Could Mean for Democrats” https://www.thenation.com/article/politics/jobs-guarantee-democrats/iz]

In many ways, Randolph’s insight continues to ring true. Even in a strong economy, workers have fought for more jobs—in fact, this is when workers have had the most leverage to do so. Bold jobs programs and full employment have long been linked to a strong economy in workers’ minds. According to new analysis of the American National Electorate Survey, since the 1940s, less-educated voters have “differentially support[ed] predistribution policies,” or in other words, a federal jobs guarantee, higher minimum wages, and policies that generally strengthen the workers’ positions in our economy. Our current moment reflects some of the same lessons. While unemployment rates are low, the rates for those who are underemployed are twice as high and demands for an economy with more good jobs persist. Despite policy roadblocks, progressives should listen to this call and proffer a vision that puts bolder jobs programs like full employment back on the agenda. In fact, one of the clearest findings from a new survey launched by the Center for Working Class Politics (CWCP) is the persistence of support for progressive jobs proposals as part of a broader economic strategy. In our first study, titled “Commonsense Solidarity,” we found that candidates who run on bread-and-butter economic issues like jobs policies fare better with working-class voters than candidates that do not. In the survey we just launched, “Trump’s Kryptonite,” respondents were given the choice between candidates with a variety of demographic characteristics and policy positions, including two jobs policies: one a more moderate and mainstream jobs proposal, and the other advocating a bold federal jobs guarantee. Both policies were broadly popular across the group of respondents, underscoring the continued importance of jobs policies for American voters. Democrats, regardless of class, overwhelmingly supported the federal jobs guarantee in our survey by a margin of nearly four to one, signaling the popularity of this proposal across the Democratic base. But our results revealed important differences in support for these policies based on the party and class of respondents. First, and most significantly, while both policies were popular across the pool of respondents, the progressive jobs guarantee was most popular among working-class respondents—and not just those who identified as Democrats but also working-class independents and Republicans as well. Importantly, working-class people from either party were more likely to prefer progressive economic policies than their middle- and upper-class counterparts. Working-class independents were also much more likely to support a jobs guarantee than middle-class independents by as much as 20 percentage points. Not only did some Republicans and independents respond favorably to this policy, but the jobs guarantee was also the only economic policy proposal viewed positively by respondents across all parties, which could indicate that it is less likely to generate electoral backlash for a political candidate in a competitive district. In fact, we found that even in the face of Republican opposition messaging, broad support for a jobs guarantee actually increased slightly.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
2AC › Link › No Link – FJG

Federal Job Guarantee popular.

O’Neill 20 (Thomas O’Neill is a journalist for Brown Political Review, December 29 2020, Radical or Reasonable? The Case for a Federal Jobs Guarantee, //CH)

A federal jobs guarantee is not a new idea. In fact, President Franklin Delano Roosevelt proposed one in his Economic Bill of Rights. Every American, he asserted, has the right to “a job; an adequate wage and decent living; a decent home; medical care; economic protection during sickness, accident, old age, or unemployment; and a good education.” As part of his famous New Deal to combat the Great Depression, FDR established the Works Progress Administration (WPA), a government agency dedicated to employing unskilled, out-of-work Americans for public infrastructure projects across the nation. Around 8.5 million people gained employment through the WPA. Unlike many New Deal programs which were struck down by the US Supreme Court, the WPA dissolved in 1943 as the US wartime economy boomed and reached full employment.

"American capitalism, as it stands, fails its workers and fails its citizens.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
2AC › Uniqueness

Poison pill amendments thwart reauthorization - bill can’t pass

Silk 6/23 (Robert Silk provides coverage and analysis of route networks, service offerings and distribution as well as airline industry trends and political/policy debates, “A dispute over pilot training is stalling the FAA reauthorization bill,” TravelWeekly, 6/23/2023, ) - MP

Meanwhile, the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science & Transportation had been set to begin considering amendments to the draft text of its reauthorization bill on June 15 before a late amendment related to pilot training led the committee's Democratic leadership to cancel the hearing and pause the process indefinitely. The amendment submitted by Republican Sen. John Thune of South Dakota and Arizona Sen. Krysten Sinema, an independent who caucuses with the Democrats, would authorize the FAA to establish new, tailored training pathways that could reduce by 250 the number of flight hours certain aspiring pilots must accrue to crew a commercial flight. Under existing regulations, pilots generally must log 1,500 hours to fly for a commercial carrier. Military pilots must log 750 hours. Pilots being trained as part of a four-year university program must log 1,000 hours. Pilots being trained as part of two-year college program must log 1,250 hours. The amendment would only apply to military pilots and pilots being trained in a university or college setting. Supporters of the existing regulations, most notably including the Air Line Pilots Association (ALPA) union and the surviving family members of the 2009 Colgan Air/Continental Express crash that killed 49 passengers in a failed landing in Buffalo, N.Y., credit those regulations with preventing U.S. commercial airline crashes since it went into effect in 2013. But critics of the rule say that tightly tailored training programs are more effective in preparing pilots to fly commercial aircraft than requiring them to accrue lots of undefined flying hours, often on aircraft types not used by airlines. ALPA took a firm stance against the Thune-Sinema amendment just before Senate transportation committee leadership canceled the June 15 hearing, saying that it would weaken pilot training and qualification requirements. "This poison pill amendment undermines the current aviation safety regime that has resulted in the safest period in air travel in history," ALPA president Jason Ambrosi wrote in a June 15 letter. Committee member Tammy Duckworth (D-Ill.), who flew helicopters in the Iraq war, used even harsher language to describe the measure during a speech on the Senate floor. "A vote to reduce the 1,500-hour rule for pilot training will mean blood on your hands when the inevitable accident occurs as a result of an inadequately trained flight crew," she said, adding that it was 10 years of flying that enabled her to survive an incident in which her helicopter was hit by a rocket-propelled grenade.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
2AC › Uniqueness

Won’t pass now

Duncan and Aratani 6/15 (Ian Duncan is a reporter covering federal transportation agencies and the politics of transportation, Lori Aratani writes about transportation issues for The Washington Post, “Senate deal would add four long-distance flights to National Airport,” Washington Post, 6/15/2023, ) - MP

Leaders of a Senate committee reached a tentative deal Thursday to add four long-distance flights at Reagan National Airport, dealing a setback to D.C.-area lawmakers and the airport’s management, which have campaigned to leave current restrictions in place. The agreement was described by three people familiar with the deal who spoke on the condition of anonymity because it hasn’t been publicly announced. It represents an important bipartisan endorsement by key senators as part of a broader aviation bill Congress needs to pass by the fall. The deal is also a modest victory for a coalition backed by Delta Air Lines that is seeking more access to the federally owned airport. Still, the fate of the aviation bill remains unclear. The Senate Commerce Committee was scheduled to have a hearing Thursday to consider amendments and advance the legislation, but Sen. Maria Cantwell (D-Wash.), the committee’s chairwoman, canceled the session to give negotiators more time to work out a dispute over airline pilot qualifications. The Senate deal would need to pass other hurdles before it could become law. The House Transportation Committee advanced its own version of the aviation bill Wednesday with bipartisan support, but it does not address the issue of flights at National. Word of an agreement to add flights drew criticism from the region’s four senators: Virginia’s Mark R. Warner and Tim Kaine, and Maryland’s Ben Cardin and Chris Van Hollen, all Democrats. They argued that Dulles International Airport, more than 10 times the size of National, is better positioned to handle long-haul flights and additional air traffic. “We will strongly oppose any FAA reauthorization that destabilizes this tried-and-true equilibrium by expanding the number of flights or passengers into and out of National,” they said in a joint statement. “Any such interference by Congress would disrupt the balance among the region’s airports, generate longer lines and more delays at DCA, create more noise for nearby residents, and hurt local economies in both of our states.” Congress faces a Sept. 30 deadline to pass an aviation bill before the current law authorizing the Federal Aviation Administration expires. Committee leaders in the House and Senate have been trying to ease a bill forward while sidestepping controversial issues, but they were unable to avoid them as negotiations continued this week. Qualifications for pilots have proved to be especially thorny as some airlines push to loosen them amid what they say is a shortage of qualified crews. In the House, the Transportation Committee adopted an amendment largely along party lines that would raise the mandatory airline pilot retirement age from 65 to 67. The idea has the support of some airline industry organizations, but it is opposed by pilot unions that say it would be unsafe. The amendment was proposed by Rep. Troy E. Nehls (R-Tex.), who has a brother who is a Delta pilot and a member of a group advocating to raise the age. The amendment won the support of House Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.), according to four people familiar with the House committee’s negotiations who spoke on the condition of anonymity to describe private talks. The offices of Nehls and McCarthy did not respond to requests for comment. In a letter to lawmakers this week, the Air Line Pilots Association, the nation’s biggest pilot union, said it would oppose the aviation bill over the proposed retirement age change. “The rash decision to move an amendment on changing the statutory pilot retirement age, without consulting agencies responsible for safety, or studying potential impacts of such a change as has been done elsewhere is a politically driven choice that betrays a fundamental understanding of airline industry operations, the pilot profession, and safety,” the group wrote. The holdup in the Senate on Thursday was over an amendment proposed by Sens. John Thune (R-S.D.) and Kyrsten Sinema (I-Ariz.) that would allow pilots to accrue .up to 250 hours toward the 1,500 flight hours typically required to fly for an airline by participating in a training program. “In response to several members’ concerns over an amendment related to pilot training, Sen. Cantwell postponed the markup as members rightly wanted additional time to focus on safety,” said Tricia Enright, a Democratic committee spokesperson. Hannah Hurley, a spokeswoman for Sinema, said the amendment had broad bipartisan support and “empowers the FAA to determine the safest way to train pilots and continues Kyrsten’s laser focus on increasing aviation safety.” Senate seeks to boost consumer protections, aviation safety in FAA bill Sen. Tammy Duckworth (D-Ill.), chairwoman of the aviation subcommittee, said on the Senate floor Thursday that reducing required flight hours would “represent a serious risk with no reward.” “It represents an unacceptable backsliding, a dangerous complacency in an industry where complacency kills,” she said. At National, the addition of long-distance flights revolves around two special measures that govern access to the airport. It is subject to a 1,250-mile perimeter that limits the distance flights can travel. At the same time, the FAA manages a system of arrival and departure slots to handle airplane traffic. The Commerce Committee deal reached Thursday would add four slots that could be used to service destinations outside the perimeter, people familiar with the agreement said. The Metropolitan Washington Airports Authority, which operates National and Dulles, said it had no comment on a deal that was in its early stages. National’s position as one of two U.S. airports owned by the federal government — Dulles is the other — makes it vulnerable to the whims of Congress, which has long chafed at the rules put in place in the 1960s. National’s proximity to Capitol Hill has led to numerous efforts over the years to add flights to more distant cities. Despite there being two other major airports in the region, Dulles and Baltimore-Washington International Marshall, members of Congress typically prefer National, the nation’s only airport outside New York subject to FAA limits on takeoffs and landings because of capacity constraints. While Congress has sought — and twice won — exemptions to increase the number of flights outside the 1,250-mile limit, the latest push has drawn in airlines that traditionally stood on the sidelines. In April, the new Delta-led group launched a campaign to lobby for more long-distance service at the airport. The Capital Access Alliance said slot and perimeter rules were stifling competition and leading to higher airfares. Weeks later, the Coalition to Protect Regional Airports, a group backed by rival United Airlines, jumped into the fray, arguing that National is too congested. Chief executives of Alaska Airlines, American Airlines and United released a joint statement this week underscoring their opposition to operational changes to flights at National. An FAA study said that adding flights would lead to more delays and that the airport doesn’t have enough gates to accommodate more air traffic. The agency, however, said it would be possible to add long-distance flights if the overall number of round-trip journeys did not increase.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
2AC › Uniqueness

Democrats refuse to pass the FAA – reduced pilot training hours leads to more flight death

Britschgi 6/16 (Christian Britschgi is an associate editor at Reason who covers property rights, housing policy, transportation policy, and regulation, Senate Democrats Say Modernizing Airline Pilot Training Requirements Will Kill People, Reason, 6/16/2023, ) - MP

Republicans in Congress are trying to slightly pare back America's uniquely high flight-hour requirements for pilots, over the objections of some Democrats and unionized pilots who argue it'll see commercial airliners falling from the sky. Working its way through both the Senate and House right now is legislation that would reauthorize the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) for the next five years. Included in the House's reauthorization bill is a provision that would let aspiring airline pilots count up to 250 hours of simulator time toward the 1,500 flight hours they need to get certified. Currently, they can only count 100 simulated hours toward that requirement. The 1,500-hour requirement is a relatively new one. It was enacted by Congress in the wake of the 2009 Colgan Air crash in upstate New York that killed 50 people and was partially blamed on pilot error. The previous requirement had been 250 hours of flight time. That's a big increase that's out of step with what most other countries require. "Looking internationally, there's no comparison. The U.S. is the exception in its really high watermark for pilot training," says Marc Scribner, a transportation researcher at the Reason Foundation (which publishes this website). Safety regulators haven't found any relationship between the hour cap and safety. Airlines say the 1,500-hour rule is contributing to a worsening pilot shortage. Buoyed by those arguments, the House managed to pass its FAA bill out of committee this week. But when Sens. Kyrsten Sinema (I–Ariz.) and John Thune (R–S.D.) tried to include changes to the 1,500-hour cap in the Senate's FAA legislation, all hell broke loose. A hearing where the FAA bill was going to be marked up was canceled. Opponents of the change started accusing supporters of trying to kill people.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
2AC › Uniqueness

Amendment to FAA Bill encumbers the bill- unlikely senate will pass soon

Hansen ’23 Hansen, Ronald J. “FAA Bill Still Stuck in Senate after Fight over Sinema-Backed Pilot Training Rule.” The Arizona Republic, 22 June 2023, . – NT Bruno Diaz

The Senate won’t pass a bill to reauthorize the Federal Aviation Administration anytime soon because the committee considering the measure hasn’t resolved a divide over relaxing pilot training rules. An amendment allowing the FAA to consider changing the training requirements backed by Sens. Kyrsten Sinema, I-Ariz., and John Thune, R-S.D., halted the Senate Commerce Committee before it could advance the latest, multi-year plan for the nation’s flying operations and safety rules to the full chamber. That brought harsh condemnation from Sen. Tammy Duckworth, D-Ill., a former military helicopter pilot who predicted supporters of the industry-backed amendment would have “blood on your hands.” On Thursday, Sinema wouldn’t respond to Duckworth’s broadside and said FAA reauthorization remains in a holding pattern. “I don’t respond to other people’s remarks,” she said. “What I do is keep my head down and continue doing the work. I am continuing to pursue a bipartisan resolution to the outstanding questions that exist in FAA reauthorization.” Sinema wouldn’t say when the committee will be able to settle on a bipartisan solution. “I don’t make predictions. I think it’s not today. That’s for sure,” she said. The Senate has limited committee work scheduled Friday and its members are scheduled to work in their home states from next week until mid-July.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
2NC › Impact › Competitiveness

FAA solves competitiveness with China

Burgan 6/15 (Cate Burgan is a technology reporter, “House Panel Unanimously Passes FAA Reauthorization Act, Major Tech Provisions,” MeriTalk, 6/15/2023, ) – MP

Improving FAA efficiency and operations: The bill makes targeted changes to the organizational structure of the FAA to improve the overall efficiency of the agency, allow for innovation, and streamline the regulatory process; Growing the aviation workforce: This bill addresses workforce challenges by removing barriers to pursuing aviation careers, expanding the aviation workforce pipeline, improving training standards, and more; Upholding America’s gold standard in safety: The bill addresses several safety issues, including the recent uptick in runway incursions, to ensure the United States, and the FAA, remain the world’s gold standard in aviation safety; and Encouraging aviation innovation: America has been a leader in aviation innovation. Unfortunately, due to bureaucratic hurdles, endless research, and pilot programs that are not leading to the development and incorporation of new technologies, China and other countries are beginning to surpass the United States. The bill encourages the safe yet more efficient testing and integration of new technologies, such as drones and Advanced Air Mobility, into the airspace. “The Securing Growth and Robust Leadership in American Aviation Act is the most comprehensive aviation legislation the Transportation and Infrastructure Committee has ever approved. This legislation will help to improve the passenger experience for all travelers while laying the groundwork for innovators and new technologies to advance in America,” said Aviation Subcommittee Chairman Garret Graves. “This legislation will make the Federal Aviation Administration’s structure more certain, predictable, and capable of facilitating improvements and innovations in our national airspace,” he added. “These transformational changes will ensure that the United States can continue to set the gold standard in aviation safety while leading the world in aviation innovation.”

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
2NC › Impact › Solves Climate

Only federal action can spur modeling

Spitz 16, Global Climate Network (John, “Global climate policy leaders argue for U.S. leadership on climate change”, 4/28/16, )

The rest of the world needs the United States to lead on cutting carbon pollution and to jump-start a clean energy race, an influential group of climate change experts from China, India, South Africa, and the United Kingdom will say Thursday, July 22. In conjunction with the Center for American Progress, the Global Climate Networks group of leading think tanks from major economies will take time out of talks on climate change action to ask the United States for leadership at a forum event hosted by CAP. Distinguished experts from the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences and India’s The Energy and Resources Institute will say that without the United States at the forefront, a successful global response to the urgent problem will be nearly impossible. Andrew Light, Senior Fellow at the Center for American Progress and GCN coordinator says: The science of solving global warming has set a clear marker for global success: cutting global emissions in half by 2050 in order to have a chance of holding temperature increase at two degrees Celsius. This can’t be done only by developed countries. All of the major carbon polluters in the developed and developing world must cooperate on a common solution. But no one will cooperate on a common solution unless the world’s largest per capita emitter, the United States, gets in the game. We must demonstrate not only that we can reduce our emissions but also that we can contribute funds to a global effort that will mobilize sufficient private capital to get all parties pulling in the same direction toward success.” Professor Jiahua Pan, director of the Research Centre for Sustainable Development at CASS in Beijing says: “China is already investing heavily in clean energy and has closed inefficient coal power plants, but to spur a technological revolution we need a very strong signal from the U.S., which remains the world’s biggest market. What matters to Beijing is a clear and unequivocal signal from Washington that the U.S. is serious; passing a climate bill in the Senate would go a long way toward sending that signal.” Dr. Arabinda Mishra, head of climate change at TERI in Delhi says: “The Indian government now has an ambitious mission to install more solar panels than anywhere in the Western world, but if other big economies such as the U.S. were to exploit clean energy to the full, it would be cheaper for all of us. We have to limit carbon pollution globally and yet India and other developing countries cannot make enough of a difference unless there’s strong leadership from the world’s largest economy.”

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
2NC › Impact › Solves Climate

Reducing US emissions is key to successful international mitigation.

Podesta & Stern 2020 - *Founder and a Member of the Board of Directors of the Center for American Progress. He served as Chief of Staff for U.S. President Bill Clinton and Counselor to U.S. President Barack Obama, overseeing climate and energy policy. **Senior Fellow at the Brookings Institution and served as Special Envoy for Climate Change under U.S. President Barack Obama.

*John & **Todd, May/June 2020, A Foreign Policy for the Climate, Foreign Affairs, https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/united-states/2020-04-13/foreign-policy-climate

The United States’ relative absence from climate mitigation and adaptation efforts under the Trump administration has been highly problematic. U.S. resources, influence, and expertise—not to mention the United States’ enormous carbon footprint—make the country an indispensable player in such discussions and actions. Pull the United States out of the equation, and the energy and focus dedicated to fighting climate change dwindles from Beijing to New Delhi to Brasília. In spite of the recent lull, however, the United States’ policy toward climate change could be rapidly transformed, especially with a new president in the White House. We have sketched out what the changes could look like if climate were made the central organizing principle of U.S. foreign policy. The public, for its part, is increasingly eager to be led, as are large swaths of the business community. The international community will doubtless remain a bit wary of the sharp turns that U.S. politics can produce, but other countries are hungry for the United States to lead again. A new president who sees the climate threat for what it is could make a game-changing difference. It is late in the day, but not yet too late.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
2NC › Impact › Solves Climate

ATC modernization solves aviation emissions—fuel and contrails.

Spinardi 15—Senior Lecturer at the University of Edinburgh's School of Engineering (Graham. “Up in the Air: Barriers to Greener Air Traffic Control and Infrastructure Lock-in in a Complex Socio-Technical System.” Energy Research & Social Science, vol. 6, Mar. 2015, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.erss.2014.11.006)

Aviation contributes to climate change by increasing levels of greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide, ozone and water vapour, and by stimulating the creation of cirrus cloud around ‘contrails’ (condensation trails) that reflect more energy back to the earth than they reflect away from the earth. Total ‘radiative forcing’ – simply put, atmospheric warming – due to aviation is thought to be about three times that due to aircraft carbon dioxide emissions alone [60, p. 18]. Using biofuels (assuming that these can be sourced in a way that is both environmentally and economically desirable) would thus only be a partial solution.

More efficient ATC offers a ‘win-win’ outcome, with both environmental and economic benefits. For example, a 2000 report on aviation and the environment by the US Government Accounting Office (GAO) noted that:

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
2NC › Impact › Solves Climate

Solves inequality, climate, and competitiveness

DeGood and Walter 23 (Kevin DeGood is the director of infrastructure policy at American Progress. Karla Walter is the senior director for employment policy at American Progress, “5 Policy Priorities for the Federal Aviation Administration Reauthorization,” American Progress, 3/20/2023, ) - MP

Raise pay and benefits for workers in federally supported airports. Airport service workers—including cleaners, wheelchair agents, baggage handlers, ticketing agents, caterers, concessions workers, passenger service agents, and lounge workers—are at a breaking point. Although they have provided essential services throughout the pandemic and are supporting the safe return to normalized travel, these workers are typically paid substandard wages and benefits.10 For example, according to 2015–2019 American Community Survey data, the median earnings for aircraft cleaners are just $13.99 per hour.11 Service workers whose jobs are funded through direct federal contracting have long enjoyed protections to ensure they are paid market wages and benefits. Research shows that these sorts of standards boost earnings and equity in a government supported sectors and support safe and efficient services by reducing turnover and encouraging a well-qualified workforce.12 Congress should incorporate language from the Good Jobs for Good Airports Act into the FAA bill which would extend pay and benefit protections to service workers at commercial airports—which receive billions of dollars in federal funding every year.13 Taken together, these policies will ensure that the U.S. aviation system is efficient and competitive; advance environmental sustainability and keep our global climate commitments; and improve job quality for thousands of airport service workers. Each year, the federal government spends billions of dollars on airport infrastructure and system operations. These five policy reforms will make sure that federal funds yield the greatest economic, environmental, and social benefits in the years to come.