2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › Link › L – FJG
Lowrey 2018
Annie, The Atlantic, “A Promise So Big, Democrats Aren’t Sure How to Keep It,” May 11, 2018 dmr
There is also the cost. “It would take a level of funding for which we would have to very much alter our fiscal outlook,” Jared Bernstein, who was former Vice President Joe Biden’s chief economist and is now at CBPP, told me. Small pilot programs aimed at stopping recidivism might pay for themselves. But a true jobs guarantee would cost something like $400 to $700 billion a year now, and vastly more during a downturn. There are other sticky questions. How much should these jobs pay, and what kind of benefits should they provide? Would a jobs guarantee foment inflation? What would a jobs guarantee do to our understanding of the interplay between inflation, employment, and growth anyway? Would the government get rid of unemployment insurance? Would the jobs be permanent? If not, is that really a guarantee that ends joblessness, once and for all? If so, would that sap the country of some of the ingenuity of its private workforce? What share of the economy would be involved in care work? How much would that represent a movement from uncompensated, kitchen-table care work to compensated, workplace care work? For some Democratic policy wonks, the trade-offs in both economic and political capital seem the most salient. What do you give up by implementing a jobs guarantee? What comes first: a public option for health insurance, or a major jobs plan, or an expansion of the Earned Income Tax Credit, or a universal child allowance, or a major educational debt-relief plan, or postal banking—all of which are ideas being pushed by Democratic presidential aspirants right now? “How much in life do you spend money on the last mile?” Gene Sperling, who was the director of the National Economic Council under Obama, asked me. “There are big, long-term unemployment problems, right? That’s complicated. Those are people who need a lot of help. They need a lot of support. Is that really the issue, or is the issue that the working poor are not making enough money to support their families? If you’re going to spend a trillion dollars on something huge …There’s an element here of people not thinking about what they’re actually trying to do.” In a technocratic sense, perhaps. But the technocratic problems that a jobs guarantee poses are not impossible to solve. There are good models. RecycleForce, for instance, cuts the recidivism rate of recently incarcerated individuals to 26 percent, versus a national rate of 64 percent, Keesling told me. And it saves the taxpayer $1.20 for every dollar invested. Surveys show that similar jobs programs have raised both earnings and employment rates for their participants, and also “decreased family public benefit receipt, raised school outcomes among the children of workers, boosted workers’ school completion, lowered criminal-justice system involvement among both workers and their children, improved psychological well-being, and reduced longer-term poverty,” a survey by the Georgetown Law Center on Poverty and Inequality found. “There may be additional positive effects, such as increased child-support payments and improved health.” Scaling up transitional jobs initiatives would be a good start, then. “There’s nothing resembling an entitlement that supports a person coming home from prison right now,” Sam Schaeffer, the executive director of the Center for Employment Opportunities, a New York-based nonprofit that provides jobs and training to the formerly incarcerated in 20 cities, told me. “To really tackle this challenge, there should be some unifying mechanism, with a mix of workforce programs, anti-poverty programs, nutrition assistance, housing, and more. We’ll pay $82 billion a year to incarcerate people. We don’t make anything like a similar investment on reentry.” There are also models stemming from TANF-EF. JobsNOW! in San Francisco offers a tiered program to help workers with different levels of readiness for a paid job. One tier pays participants while they enroll in job-readiness or vocational training, or a high-school diploma program. It also pays participants to do relatively low-skill work at a nonprofit. Finally, there is a wage-subsidy program, aimed at individuals with work experience. On top of that, the program provides case management and wraparound services, helping ensure that participants have Medicaid and food stamps. All in all, it has increased its 20,000 participants’ earnings by an average of 55 percent, and three in four no longer need cash assistance two-and-a-half years after exiting the program. The evidence for what works is out there, and the need especially great in certain communities and with certain individuals. Starting with pilots and scaling them up, as Booker wants to do, makes sense. So does Khanna’s model of directing state and local governments to figure out what works for them, as TANF-EF did. So does Sanders’s idea of having “hundreds” of public-works initiatives. For all the blue-sky thinking and talk of a national, public-jobs guarantee, Democratic policymakers do seem to be taking the idea seriously, but not literally, to borrow a phrase. The idea is to indicate to the country that they want to tackle the biggest challenges with the biggest solutions—not to figure out every detail, pay for every dollar, appeal to every voter, and pass a policy bar their colleagues on the other side of the aisle have shown no interest in. That gives Democrats room to experiment. “This is not a panacea to solve the jobs problem. It has to be attacked in multiple ways,” Khanna told me. “I would argue that this is a first, serious proposal that by my own admission I would say is not intended to be perfect.” It avoids putting them in the position of negotiating themselves down. “I see it as really opening the Overton Window in a way that is a quite useful for this debate,” Bernstein said. “I’m not in the business of negotiating with myself at this point. Let’s let all the good ideas blossom.” It vaults over the need to figure out the most difficult parts of the legislation, like how much or how to pay for such a proposal. “I’m not gonna presume how we pay for it,” Tanden said. “I do think the Republican tax plan indicates how little Republicans care about deficits when it comes to taxes. I’m not saying that we won’t care about this. But obviously it makes that an easier conversation.” It also acknowledges that Republicans are unlikely to get on board with big Democratic ideas, freeing liberals to think bigger. “We live in the era of tribalism,” Tanden told me. “It’s hard to think through a proposal if Republicans feel like doing any deal with Democrats is noxious. Ipso facto, when a Democrat proposes something, they cannot support it because it’s the Democrats have creating it. That does not allow for compromise.”
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › Uniqueness › U-Will Pass
Lynch 6/14 (Kerry Lynch joined AIN in December 2014 after a 25-year career with the Aviation Week, during her time there, she steered The Weekly of Business Aviation for five years and also oversaw business aviation content on the Aviation Week Intelligence Network, “House T&I Committee Unanimously Approves FAA Bill,” AIN, 6/14/2023, ) - MP
The House version of comprehensive FAA reauthorization legislation, , took a step forward today with the Transportation and Infrastructure (T&I) Committee passing it with a vote of 63-0. The bill, the Securing Growth and Robust Leadership in American Aviation Act, received unanimous approval by voting members after the committee spent wading through the nearly 170 amendments filed on it. The Republican and Democratic leadership on both the full T&I committee and aviation subcommittee stood in lockstep on the bill to ensure it remained a bipartisan effort. This included voting against some provisions that they would have otherwise supported. T&I Ranking Member Rep. Rick Larsen (D-Washington), for example, voted against a measure to lift the cap on passenger facilities charges, citing a desire to preserve the compromise reached on the bill. After passage, Larsen praised the committee’s approach, saying, “Every good bill is a product of good faith bipartisan compromise, and this bill is an example of that. There are things we would have liked more of and less of, but that's compromise. And I think it's a good product overall.” House T&I Chairman Sam Graves called the vote “step four of a 10-step process” and said there is still a long way to go. The bill must still marry with tax provisions—and one such provision under consideration would make flight and maintenance training eligible for 529 programs—and receive a full House vote. The Senate Commerce Committee, meanwhile, is set to consider its version of the bill tomorrow. Once Senate and House actions are complete, the two bodies will hash out their respective differences. Congress faces a deadline of September 30, when the FAA’s current authorization is set to expire. NBAA president and CEO Ed Bolen is “enthusiastic” about FAA reauthorization legislation even though the Senate and House bills are different, he noted this morning at the association’s regional forum at Westchester County Airport in White Plains, New York. “They are not identical bills, but they’re both strong,” he said. “Most importantly, they’re bipartisan and include provisions for workforce. We’re excited about what we see going on here.”
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › Uniqueness › U-Will Pass
Burgan 6/15 (Cate Burgan is a technology reporter, “House Panel Unanimously Passes FAA Reauthorization Act, Major Tech Provisions,” MeriTalk, 6/15/2023, ) - MP
The House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee Wednesday approved bipartisan legislation to reauthorize the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) and aviation safety and infrastructure programs for the next five years, by a unanimous 63-0 vote. The Securing Growth and Robust Leadership in American Aviation Act was introduced on June 9 by Transportation and Infrastructure Committee Chairman Sam Graves, R-Mo., Ranking Member Rick Larsen, D-Wash., Aviation Subcommittee Chairman Garret Graves, R-La., and Ranking Member Steve Cohen, D-Tenn., and includes several tech provisions to bolster security and innovation within the Federal aviation sector. The nearly 800-page bill will now go to the House floor for a vote, with hopes of getting it across President Joe Biden’s desk before the FAA’s current authorization expires on Sept. 30. “This bipartisan bill is critical to America’s global leadership in aviation, to our economy and millions of jobs, and to making the entire system safer and more efficient for all users and the traveling public,” said Chairman Sam Graves when his committee passed the bill on June 14 – after two full days of debate. The committee’s legislation comes after five grueling FAA reauthorization hearings, and one nationwide ground stop when the agency’s Notice to Air Missions system broke down earlier this year – sparking bipartisan concern over the agency’s outdated IT systems and cybersecurity.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › Uniqueness › U-Will Pass
O’Connor 6/12—AVweb's Editor-in-Chief, certificated aircraft dispatcher and graduate of Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University (Kate. “FAA Reauthorization Legislation Introduced.” AVweb, 12 June 2023,
Legislation to reauthorize the FAA has been introduced in both the U.S. House of Representatives and the U.S. Senate. On the Senate side, the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2023 was sponsored by Senate Committee on Commerce, Science and Transportation Chair Maria Cantwell, D-Wash., Ranking Member Ted Cruz, R-Texas, Aviation Subcommittee Chair Tammy Duckworth, D-Ill., and Subcommittee Ranking Member Jerry Moran, R-Kan. The House bill, called the Securing Growth and Robust Leadership in American Aviation Act, was introduced by House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee Chairman Sam Graves, R-Mo., with full Committee Ranking Member Rick Larsen, D-Wash., Aviation Subcommittee Chairman Garret Graves, R-La., and Aviation Subcommittee Ranking Member Steve Cohen, D-Tenn., co-sponsoring.
The FAA Reauthorization Act of 2023 (PDF) incorporates provisions for modernizing the National Airspace System (NAS), improving customer protections for airline passengers and expanding air travel service. It also looks to grow the aviation workforce, improve safety, fund airport infrastructure projects and continue research and development for innovative aviation technologies. In addition, the bill has provisions for improving aircraft accessibility for people with disabilities.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
1NC › FAA DA › 1NC—DA
Spratt & Dunlop 18—David Spratt, Research Director for Breakthrough, climate-policy analyst, co-founder of Carbon Equity; and Ian Dunlop, senior Advisory Board member at Breakthrough, Former Chair of the Australian Coal Association (What Lies Beneath: The Understatement of Existential Climate Risk. The Breakthrough Institute, Aug. 2018, pp. 13–15,
Climate change is an existential risk to human civilisation: that is, an adverse outcome that would either annihilate intelligent life or permanently and drastically curtail its potential.
Temperature rises that are now in prospect, after the Paris Agreement, are in the range of 3–5°C. At present, the Paris Agreement voluntary emission reduction commitments, if implemented, would result in planetary warming of 3.4°C by 2100,30 without taking into account “long-term” carboncycle feedbacks. With a higher climate sensitivity figure of 4.5°C, for example, which would account for such feedbacks, the Paris path would result in around 5°C of warming, according to a MIT study.31 A study by Schroder Investment Management published in June 2017 found — after taking into account indicators across a wide range of the political, financial, energy and regulatory sectors — the average temperature increase implied for the Paris Agreement across all sectors was 4.1°C.32 Yet 3°C of warming already constitutes an existential risk. A 2007 study by two US national security think-tanks concluded that 3°C of warming and a 0.5 metre sea-level rise would likely lead to “outright chaos” and “nuclear war is possible”, emphasising how “massive non-linear events in the global environment give rise to massive nonlinear societal events”.33 The Global Challenges Foundation (GCF) explains what could happen:
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
1NC › FAA DA › 1NC—DA
Arnold 22—Aviation writer for The Dallas Morning News, covering airlines, air travel and the aerospace industry (Kyle. “Airlines Are Finally Admitting Contrails Are an Environmental Problem.” Dallas News, 8 Dec. 2022,
Contrails — those lines of wispy white clouds that follow some jets — may not be so harmless.
Airlines and scientists are coming to a consensus that the water vapor trails created by airplanes at high altitudes may play a big role in global warming. That’s because those contrails, short for condensation trails, create clouds that trap heat in the atmosphere at the critical altitude where airliners fly.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
1NC › FAA DA › 1NC—DA
Victor & Engler 3/2—David G. Victor, Professor of innovation and public policy at the School of Global Policy and Strategy at UC San Diego, co-director of the campus-wide Deep Decarbonization Initiative; and Jeff Engler, CEO of Wright Electric, a startup manufacturing engines for electric airplanes (“How to Get Serious about Climate Change.” The Hill, 2 Mar. 2023, https://thehill.com/opinion/energy-environment/3881332-how-to-get-serious-about-climate-change)
For all the good news, however, these are just the first steps in a serious program to cut emissions. That’s because showering cash on today’s industries can’t eliminate the pollution of warming gases. That kind of profound change requires much more disruptive investment in wholly new kinds of technologies and businesses. On this front, the federal government could play a much bigger role by using its power to regulate pollution, pry open markets to more competition and actively back the disruptors.
Aviation is a leading example of how this new approach to transformative innovation could unfold. While aviation accounts for just 3 percent of global warming today, its share is rising — and technologies developed for aviation such as new kinds of propulsion systems that use electricity or hydrogen can have big impacts in other industries as well.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
1NC › FAA DA › 1NC—DA
Paddison 18—Editor of This New World, a series exploring some of the biggest global challenges, winner of the Gold Lovie Award (Laura. “Here’s What You Need To Know About The Federal Jobs Guarantee.” HuffPost, 6 July 2018, https://www.huffpost.com/entry/federal-job-guarantee-explained_n_5b363f4ae4b007aa2f7f59fc)//mgm
The jobs guarantee is a polarizing policy, with critics on both sides of the political spectrum.
A key concern with an idea this big and potentially unwieldy is the actual logistics of implementing it. How would the government and local communities be able to come up with suitable, socially beneficial jobs for potentially tens of millions of people? For Matt Bruenig, founder of the People’s Policy Project, a think tank, this is the main problem. “The idea that thousands of administrations across the country will be able to usefully employ random flows of labor with random sets of skills in random durations is fairly implausible,” he wrote in March.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
1NC › FAA DA › 1NC—DA
Burgan 6/15—Technology Reporter at MeriTalk (Cate. “House Panel Unanimously Passes FAA Reauthorization Act, Major Tech Provisions.” MeriTalk, 15 June 2023, https://www.meritalk.com/articles/house-panel-unanimously-passes-faa-reauthorization-act-major-tech-provisions)
The House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee Wednesday approved bipartisan legislation to reauthorize the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) and aviation safety and infrastructure programs for the next five years, by a unanimous 63-0 vote.
The Securing Growth and Robust Leadership in American Aviation Act was introduced on June 9 by Transportation and Infrastructure Committee Chairman Sam Graves, R-Mo., Ranking Member Rick Larsen, D-Wash., Aviation Subcommittee Chairman Garret Graves, R-La., and Ranking Member Steve Cohen, D-Tenn., and includes several tech provisions to bolster security and innovation within the Federal aviation sector.
2023
CNDI
Affirmative
2AC › States CP › States Fail – Gov needed
Cyrus 19 --- Ramenda Cyrus is the John Lewis Writing Fellow at The American Prospect. 8-14-2019 (“Is America Ready for a Universal Basic Income?” American Prospect. https://prospect.org/economy/is-america-ready-for-universal-basic-income/. Date Accessed: 7-21-2023.)
F4GI contends with all of these issues so that guaranteed income may be scaled up as efficiently as possible. It offers many forms of payment, from a prepaid card to Venmo. The application process takes just over a minute, and F4GI attempts to utilize databases that are already available to determine eligibility. And perhaps most important is the effort to determine how to make guaranteed and basic income actually happen, not rehash old data that decisively says such programs are effective.
However, even the best independent groups can’t possibly meet overall American needs. Only the government can do that—but there is little appetite for huge new benefit programs. Sen. Joe Manchin (D-WV) refused to support the Child Tax Credit expansion mentioned above, and it expired. Even if he had, the program had severe administrative problems that left many poor families out, as did the famous pandemic checks.
2023
CNDI
Affirmative
2AC › States CP › States Fail – Gov needed
Britannica 21 --- Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc. is a British-American company known for publishing the Encyclopædia Britannica, the world's oldest continuously published encyclopaedia. 2/25/2021 (“Pro and Con: Universal Basic Income (UBI)”. Encyclopedia Britannica. https://www.britannica.com/story/pro-and-con-universal-basic-income-ubi. Date Accessed: 7-21-2023.)
A universal basic income (UBI) is an unconditional cash payment given at regular intervals by the government to all residents, regardless of their earnings or employment status.
Pilot UBI or more limited basic income programs that give a basic income to a smaller group of people instead of an entire population have taken place or are ongoing in Brazil, Canada, China, Finland, Germany, India, Iran, Japan, Kenya, Namibia, Spain, and The Netherlands as of Oct. 20, 2020
2023
CNDI
Affirmative
2AC › States CP › States Fail – Gov needed
Greenwell 22 --- Megan Greenwell is a journalist in New York. She is writing a book about private equity and how it affects workers. 10/24/2022 (“Universal Basic Income Has Been Tested Repeatedly. It Works.” Washington Post. https://archive.is/r8X4f#selection-289.0-289.61. Date Accessed: 7-21-2023.)
Ultimately, though, getting more money to more people requires the type of massive funding that only governments can provide. FGI recently announced partnerships with two government-run programs in California, one in Sonoma County and one in Long Beach. Tubbs, meanwhile, is now working as an adviser to California Gov. Gavin Newsom, who last year approved a $35 million fund to create additional guaranteed-income pilots. “I am a hyper-pragmatist,” Tubbs says. Community Love Fund “is great for the five women in Roxbury. It’s going to change their lives. But there’s thousands who need it, and governments scale, right?”
2023
CNDI
Affirmative
2AC › Politics DA › Plan Popular
Schulte, 20 – Producer, Writer, and Video Editor at The Hill
[Gabriela Schulte, “Poll: Majority of voters now say the government should have a universal basic income program,” 8-14-2020, https://thehill.com/hilltv/what-americas-thinking/512099-poll-majority-of-voters-now-say-the-government-should-have-a/, accessed 6-23-2023]
A majority of voters believe the government should have a universal basic income program, up from 12 percentage points in 2019, a new Hill-HarrisX poll finds. Fifty-five percent of registered voters in the Aug. 2-5 survey were in support of universal basic income, while 45 percent were not. The Hill-HarrisX poll found support for the program has gradually grown in the past year. In a , 43 percent of voters said the government should have universal basic income and in a , support grew 6 percentage points to 49 percent. The survey found an increase in support across demographic groups, primarily among younger voters and Democratic voters. Sixty-nine percent of voters ages 18 to 34 and 35 to 49 were in favor of universal basic income, a 14 percentage point and 16 percentage point increase, respectively. Support has not yet reached the majority among older voters in the survey, however, it grew from 21 percent in February 2019 to 34 percent in August 2020 among voters 65 years old and beyond. Seventy-one percent of Democratic voters and 56 percent of independent voters believe the government should have a universal basic income program, a 15 and 12 percentage point increase from last February, respectively. Among Republican voters, support grew from 27 percent last winter to 34 percent support in August 2020.
2023
CNDI
Affirmative
2AC › Politics DA › Plan Popular
Bridgend, 19 [BridgeND, BridgeND is a bipartisan student political organization that brings together Democrats, Republicans, and all those in between to discuss public policy issues of national importance, The bipartisan Case for a Universal Basic Income, The Observer, February 13, 2019 ]
To begin, conservatives do not disagree with the notion of aiding the low-income; after all, proof of a poverty trap in the United States is undeniable. Additionally, . Wise conservatives understand these issues yet disagree with current programs, which show minimal results yet create large bureaucracy. Traditional entitlement programs have proven to be ineffective due to burdensome requirements, government bureaucracy and diminished ease-of-access. . In addition, our current welfare state has added to the poverty trap. . With this in mind, it surprises no one that conservatives want a new system, so then the question turns to which system would best provide necessary aid to the impoverished while minimizing government interference. Enter the Universal Basic Income (UBI). This radical solution to a pressing issue may not be as radical as most people believe. Alaska, one of the most conservative states, implemented one in 1976 through building a fund which they invested in the oil industry; the returns are distributed to all citizens through a dividend. Alaska has found overwhelming success. , .
2023
CNDI
Affirmative
2AC › Politics DA › Plan Popular
Si, 3/25/23 [Kristen Si, Kristen Si is an MIT graduate who has been writing for the Sampan for about a year. The Economic Movement Behind Universal Basic Income, Sampan, March 25, 2023]
As UBI in its purest sense would be a very costly program to fund, many pilot programs across the country have opted to instead implement guaranteed income programs. These programs aim to also provide enough money to provide for basic living needs on a regular basis, but do so only for individuals who have been screened on the basis of income and demographics and show demonstrated need for these resources. Guaranteed income has already become a popular idea. According to a 2021 poll by Data for Progress, 55% of potential voters either strongly supported or somewhat supported a federal policy providing $500-1000 of monthly income to individuals regardless of employment status. While UBI has recently gained more widespread attention, the concept is far from a new idea. UBI has its roots all the way back in 1795, when the Speenhamland System was implemented to help supplement abnormally low wages made by farmers during a time of famine. Since then, UBI has seen forms of implementation in various places around the world, but the base principle has always stayed the same – to support citizens living in poverty. In 1983, the Alaska Permanent Fund was established, which provided a payment of about $1000 per year to nearly all state residents. In a University of Alaska study done in 2016, “estimates show that the Alaska Permanent Fund Dividend has lifted 15,000 to 25,000 Alaskans out of poverty annually.” A similar program was implemented in Iran with additional optimistic results. A 2010 law called the Targeted Subsidies Reform Act provided more than 73 million people with a monthly payment of about $45 USD per person in a household. According to a July 2019 study by UNICEF, Iranian poverty rates showed declines within a year of program implementation. Furthermore, a March 2020 report by researchers at McMaster University found that a UBI program implemented in Ontario had another effect – a significant decline in the number of visits to health practitioners and emergency rooms.
*Researched the author quals.
2023
CNDI
Affirmative
2AC › Politics DA › Plan Popular
Pesantez, 20 [Gabrielle Pesantez, My name is Gaby and I’m a senior in Mather House studying History. My main interests and previous coursework have been in European and Latin American legal and imperial history. I chose the History concentration for its flexibility and incredible professors. Outside of the department, I study French and Italian and serve on the Board of the Harvard Undergraduate Women in Law Association and Harvard Latina Empowerment & Development Conference. I have previously worked as a Research Assistant at the Center for European Studies and have written for the Harvard Undergraduate Law Review, Harvard Crimson, Harvard College Economics Review, and Harvard College History Review. I am currently an intern for the U.S. Foreign Service, where I’ve gotten to use my academic knowledge of European history and the legal foundations of the European Union to work on political and economic issues at the Department of State’s E.U. Office. , Universal Basic Income: A Bipartisan Solution to COVID’s Economic Turmoil, Harvard Economics Review, August 3, 2020.]
A UBI clearly has the potential to introduce positive change in the realm of Americans’ individual and overall economic security. Jack Dorsey, C.E.O. of Twitter, recently 3 million dollars to help fund U.S. Mayors for Universal Basic Income pilot programs in 15 cities. These pilot programs test the tangible impacts of UBI payments within local communities, measuring UBI’s potential as an economic empowerment mechanism. The Mayors for Universal Basic Income coalition is led by Mayor Michael Tubbs of Stockton, who a local UBI pilot program in his community in late 2018. Recent findings from the Stockton pilot program that 40 percent of tracked monthly spending went to purchasing food, with participants investing their UBI funds in nutritious, high-quality food for their families. Beyond alleviating food insecurity, the Stockton UBI allowed participants to and invest newfound time or money into their individualized, immediate needs. Mayor Tubbs, that many Republican-leaning states “have the highest rates of economic insecurity and poverty [in the country,]” is confident that both parties will see value in supporting UBI proposals. The one point of contention standing in the way of this potentially transformative entitlement ultimately lies in the method of financing the UBI. Fortunately, Democratic and Republican politicians might be accepting of a plan like Yang’s: the VAT can serve as a form of progressive taxation when used to fund the UBI and somewhat similar taxes have previously been by Republican Senators Ted Cruz and Rand Paul, along with former House Speaker Paul Ryan. Though critics of the VAT might argue that the tax is regressive, as lower-income consumers spend a greater proportion of their income purchasing goods compared to their higher-income counterparts, proposals such as Yang’s account for these concerns. Yang’s plan that not all goods, namely groceries and clothing, would be subject to the VAT. According to the Yang campaign’s estimates, a consumer would have to at least 120,000 dollars worth of taxable goods before having spent a sum equivalent to their UBI payment. In a time of immense political polarization, when Democrat-backed progressive forms of taxation are unlikely to win approval by the, a UBI promises both parties a chance to close the partisan divides while helping struggling Americans in dire times. Results from pilot programs and current UBI experimentation have already begun to the immense personal value, comfort, and stability that a UBI can offer. Our lack of a substantial social safety net is clear. Social distancing requirements continue to on the assistance that normally-operational social, health, and legal service providers can offer to vulnerable individuals. Right now, direct cash assistance is more important than ever, but temporary stimulus payments should not be the end of this debate. Amidst so much uncertainty, a UBI offers an opportunity for genuine collaboration in the movement to reimagine and revitalize social security. The U.S. should seize the opportunity to permanently plug the holes in the social safety net, finally offering its citizens a long-awaited, substantive form of economic empowerment
2023
CNDI
Affirmative
2AC › Politics DA › Plan Popular
Mcnair, 21 – former editorial assistant for LendingTree
[Kamaron Mcnair, “72% of Americans Support Some Form of Universal Basic Income (UBI),” MagnifyMoney, 9-20-2021, https://www.magnifymoney.com/news/universal-basic-income-survey/, accessed 6-23-2023]
At least 7 in 10 Americans support some form of universal basic income, with 35% “definitely” favoring the policy and 38% supporting it under certain conditions (i.e., income, citizenship and employment). Support for UBI in some form significantly decreases among high earners, men and Republicans. Among those not in favor of UBI, the No. 1 reason is a fear that the policy would remove the incentive to work (noted by 68% of opponents), followed by the possibility of higher taxes (53%). Those supportive of UBI largely believe in its ability to lift people out of poverty (60%). The same percentage (72%) of those who support UBI believe we should guarantee that all Americans have enough money to afford basic needs like food and shelter. However, the majority of consumers think UBI shouldn’t go to every adult in the U.S., but rather citizens and/or those below a certain income threshold (both 43%). 22% of Americans say they need UBI to make ends meet, and this figure climbs even higher among women (25%) and parents with children younger than 18 (28%). 2 in 3 respondents say they’d spend a hypothetical UBI on living costs and other necessities. Majority of consumers support some form of UBI Politicians looking for a popular initiative could be advised to explore legislative options for universal basic income. UBI in some form garners approval from 72% of consumers. While 38% might change their mind under certain circumstances, a strong 35% of folks support UBI in any form. Each demographic breakdown of UBI support tracked by the MagnifyMoney survey bolsters the finding that higher earners are less likely to back the idea. A 2018 Grinnell College poll found Republicans on average have higher incomes than Democrats, with 26% of Republicans earning more than $100,000, compared with 20% of Democrats. While the policy idea wins a majority approval on both sides of the political aisle, Democratic voters are more likely to support UBI than Republicans: Democrats: 88% support, 12% don’t Republicans: 53% support, 47% don’t Independents: 72% support, 28% don’t Democrats (28%) are more likely than Republicans (18%) to contact their elected officials about UBI, but those calling aren’t necessarily in favor. In fact, 7% of both Democrats and Republicans report calling their representatives to oppose UBI. Additionally, 11% of independent voters have made calls to oppose the idea. Those earning $100,000 annually or more are significantly less likely to support UBI than any other income group, with 64% saying they would endorse some form. Folks earning less than $35,000 support UBI the most, with 76% in favor. Support for UBI drops slightly among the middle income brackets, but hovers within a few percentage points among each group earning less than $100,000: Less than $35,000: 76% support, 24% don’t $35,000-$49,999: 75% support, 25% don’t $50,000-$74,999: 72% support, 28% don’t $75,000-$99,999: 75% support, 25% don’t $100,000 or more: 64% support, 36% don’t Men — who on average than women — are less likely to support UBI than women: Men: 69% support, 31% don’t Women: 74% support, 26% don’t And when it comes to age, baby boomers — the wealthiest generation — are the least likely to support UBI, deviating from their younger counterparts by 13 to 25 percentage points: Gen Zers (ages 18 to 24): 83% support, 17% don’t Millennials (ages 25 to 40): 81% support, 19% don’t Gen Xers (ages 41 to 55): 71% support, 29% don’t Baby boomers (ages 56 to 75): 58% support, 43% don’t According to MagnifyMoney senior economic analyst Jacob Channel, younger folks tend to make less money, so they logically would be interested in this form of government aid. For baby boomers, Channel says the culture in which they came of age plays a role. “On top of that, because they’re wealthier than younger generations, baby boomers tend to be a little bit more conservative with money,” Channel says. “They’re more concerned about things like inflation and higher taxes than younger generations are, largely because those issues would be more likely to negatively impact them.” Pandemic inspires more UBI support The coronavirus pandemic and the resulting economic fallout inspired many to rethink how people have their needs met — and whether it’s the government’s responsibility to meet them. The stimulus payments offered a glimpse into possible UBI outcomes, as the checks allowed many families to pay off some debt or cover necessary expenses. As a result, 45% of consumers say the pandemic made them more supportive of UBI, versus just 14% who say the crisis made them less supportive of the idea.
2023
CNDI
Affirmative
2AC › Inflation DA › 2AC – L/T Ubi S Inflation
UBI Works’ 22 [UBI Works; August 24, 2022; Advocacy organization for UBI implementation, backed by economics professors and presidential candidate Andrew Yang; “Basic Income – Will it cause inflation? Evidence from Canada and around the world shows how direct cash can ease the pain of rising costs”; https://www.ubiworks.ca/blog/basic-income-inflation]
Basic Income would ease the pain of inflation – lessening its impacts on Canadian households – by ensuring everyone has the money they need to meet rising costs, at a time when wages are barely keeping up. Basic Income puts existing money to better use. Basic Income would put billions of dollars already in our economy to better and more productive use, rather than introduce new money into the market. It redirects money to help those in need and who will spend it on basic necessities, which stimulates our economy, creates jobs, and supports local businesses. As Basic Income advocate Reverend Chris Butler wrote in the Chicago Tribune: “Contrary to what misinformed fearmongers might suggest, a basic income could ease inflation. Most economists agree that inflation is caused by introducing new money into the market, not by redistributing it… A basic income would not cause inflation; it would help families facing rising costs.” We’ve shown how to pay for Basic Income without taxing the vast majority of Canadians or printing new money: by funding it with contributions from our financial sector, fewer tax breaks for large companies, and fewer subsidies for the wealthiest. This is how we can build a ‘trickle-up’ economy that encourages economic growth while lifting millions of Canadians out of poverty. Existing Basic Income-like programs haven’t caused inflation. We already have a Basic Income in Canada that works and has not made life more costly for Canadians: the Canada Child Benefit (CCB), a Basic Income for families, contributes over $46 billion a year to our economy, creating more than 450,000 jobs, while lifting over 250,000 families out of poverty. For every $1 given to Canadian families, $2 is generated in economic activity. There’s no indication that the CCB has caused inflation. Instead, it has reduced the number of households facing severe food insecurity by 1/3 and has been hailed as "overwhelmingly" responsible for reduced poverty and income inequality in Canada. In the US, 132 economists signed an open letter in 2022 calling for the extension of the Child Tax Credit (CTC) – their version of the CCB – saying it would not “meaningfully increase inflation”, but would help families “keep up with the everyday costs of keeping a family afloat”. Basic Income expert Scott Santens noted that the CTC has functioned “as a protective shield against inflation.” Seniors benefits like Old Age Security and Guaranteed Income Supplement have been instrumental in drastically reducing poverty among our elderly (although there is still much work to be done to eliminate it entirely), with no evidence that this has caused inflation. Similarly, data shows that CERB and other emergency benefits contributed to the largest one-year reduction in poverty in nearly 50 years. Unconditional cash lowers prices in the US. In Alaska, where there is universal dividend for every resident, funded by their natural resources, it’s common for businesses to offer discounts when the cheques roll out to capture this extra spending capacity. That’s right – prices go down when the cheques go out. Interestingly, with the introduction of this dividend in 1982, Alaska went from having the highest rate of inflation in the US to the lowest. (Source: Wouldn’t Unconditional Basic Income Just Cause Massive Inflation? by Scott Santens) For Alaskans, unconditional cash meant less inflation, not more. Some businesses offer sales when the Alaska dividend cheques go out all residents. Basic Income means more entrepreneurship – and more competition. One more reason Basic Income won’t cause inflation: it doesn’t reduce competition between sellers of goods and services. Businesses would continue to compete for our money by offering high quality at reasonable prices – with or without Basic Income. In fact, Basic Income would actually increase competition in many sectors by fostering entrepreneurship. It would act as seed capital for countless entrepreneurs who would otherwise be stuck in dead-end jobs or unable to take the risk. Studies from around the world have shown that Basic Income increases people’s ability to start or expand a business, increases interest in starting a business, and boosts local business revenues. As Scott Santens wrote: “where basic income experiments have been actually tried and studied, the result in each case is increased entrepreneurship…This means more people competing for basic income dollars, with better goods and services and lower costs. All of this represents real evidence to counter any fear of inflation." Basic Income helps ease the pain of inflation. There are many factors causing life to become increasingly unaffordable – global supply chain shocks, inadequate housing policy, and automation melting wages, to name a few. Basic Income has been shown to help ease the pain of inflation, reducing poverty and helping with affordability when jobs are no longer enough. So the next time you hear the false rumour that Basic Income causes inflation, remember that the data has already proven the opposite: Basic Income makes life more affordable, not less.
2023
CNDI
Affirmative
2AC › Inflation DA › 2AC – UBI Doesn’t Hurt Inflation
Ensuring Everyone, 22 – Advocate for UBI
[Ensuring Everyone, “Basic Income – Will it cause inflation?,” UBI Works, 8-24-2022, https://www.ubiworks.ca/blog/basic-income-inflation, accessed 6-23-2023]
But among some newcomers to Basic Income, there’s a false concern that it could cause inflation – a mistaken belief that building a guaranteed income floor for those who need it could somehow reduce the purchasing power of our dollars. There are many things that can cause inflation, but there is no evidence that Basic Income is one of them. In fact, the data shows quite the opposite. Basic Income would ease the pain of inflation – lessening its impacts on Canadian households – by ensuring everyone has the money they need to meet rising costs, at a time when wages are barely keeping up. Basic Income puts existing money to better use. Basic Income would put billions of dollars already in our economy to better and more productive use, rather than introduce new money into the market. It redirects money to help those in need and who will spend it on basic necessities, which stimulates our economy, creates jobs, and supports local businesses. As Basic Income advocate : “Contrary to what misinformed fearmongers might suggest, a basic income could ease inflation. Most economists agree that inflation is caused by introducing new money into the market, not by redistributing it… A basic income would not cause inflation; it would help families facing rising costs.” We’ve shown without taxing the vast majority of Canadians or printing new money: by funding it with contributions from our financial sector, fewer tax breaks for large companies, and fewer subsidies for the wealthiest. This is how we can build a ‘trickle-up’ economy that encourages economic growth while lifting millions of Canadians out of poverty. Existing Basic Income-like programs haven’t caused inflation. We already have a Basic Income in Canada that works and has not made life more costly for Canadians: the (CCB), a Basic Income for families, contributes over $46 billion a year to our economy, creating more than 450,000 jobs, while lifting over 250,000 families out of poverty. For every $1 given to Canadian families, $2 is generated in economic activity. There’s no indication that the CCB has caused inflation. Instead, it has reduced the number of households facing and has been hailed as for reduced poverty and income inequality in Canada. In the US, 132 economists in 2022 calling for the extension of the Child Tax Credit (CTC) – their version of the CCB – saying it would not “meaningfully increase inflation”, but would help families “keep up with the everyday costs of keeping a family afloat”. Basic Income expert that the CTC has functioned “as a protective shield against inflation.” Seniors benefits like Old Age Security and Guaranteed Income Supplement have been instrumental in drastically reducing poverty among our elderly (although there is still much work to be done to eliminate it entirely), with no evidence that this has caused inflation. Similarly, data shows that CERB and other emergency benefits contributed to the largest one-year reduction in poverty . Unconditional cash lowers prices in the US In Alaska, where there is universal dividend for every resident, funded by their natural resources, it’s common for when the cheques roll out to capture this extra spending capacity. That’s right – prices go down when the cheques go out. Interestingly, with the introduction of this dividend in 1982, Alaska went from having the highest rate of inflation in the US to the lowest. (Source: by Scott Santens) For Alaskans, unconditional cash meant less inflation, not more. Some businesses offer sales when the Alaska dividend cheques go out all residents. Basic Income means more entrepreneurship – and more competition. One more reason Basic Income won’t cause inflation: it doesn’t reduce competition between sellers of goods and services. Businesses would continue to compete for our money by offering high quality at reasonable prices – with or without Basic Income. In fact, Basic Income would actually increase competition in many sectors by fostering entrepreneurship. It would act as seed capital for countless entrepreneurs who would otherwise be stuck in dead-end jobs or unable to take the risk. have shown that Basic Income increases people’s ability to start or expand a business, increases interest in starting a business, and boosts local business revenues. As : “where basic income experiments have been actually tried and studied, the result in each case is increased entrepreneurship…This means more people competing for basic income dollars, with better goods and services and lower costs. All of this represents real evidence to counter any fear of inflation." Basic Income helps ease the pain of inflation. There are many factors causing life to become increasingly unaffordable – global supply chain shocks, inadequate housing policy, and automation melting wages, to name a few. Basic Income has been shown to help ease the pain of inflation, reducing poverty and helping with affordability when jobs are no longer enough. So the next time you hear the false rumour that Basic Income causes inflation, remember that the data has already proven the opposite: Basic Income makes life more affordable, not less.
2023
CNDI
Affirmative
2AC › Inflation DA › 2AC – UBI Doesn’t Hurt Inflation
, 20 – Writer for People’s Policy Project
[, “Understanding Claims About Basic Income and Inflation,” People's Policy Project, 3-18-2020, https://www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2020/03/18/understanding-claims-about-basic-income-and-inflation/, accessed 6-23-2023]
A variety of elected officials are currently proposing that the federal government send cash payments to every person in the country (sometimes called a “universal basic income” or “UBI”) as a way of responding to the recession. These calls have resurrected claims that a UBI is inflationary. Such claims circulate widely among advocates of workfare and in certain niche internet circles. But these claims are nonsensical and deceptive. In this post, I walk through these claims to promote better understanding of the issue. Deceptive Language Many people who claim that UBI is inflationary also belong to the Modern Monetary Theory (MMT) community. One of the key rhetorical moves of that community is to talk about government spending as if it separate from government revenue (e.g. taxes). This way of speaking goes against convention and therefore tends to mislead people who are used to conventional ways of talking about government programs. It is precisely this rhetorical move that is behind the claim “a UBI is inflationary.” What they actually mean when they say that is “disbursing UBI payments without collecting offsetting taxes is inflationary.” But they never explicitly say the “without collecting offsetting taxes” part because, as mentioned already, they have all decided to talk about spending as if it is separate from taxes. This is a fun semantical game to play I suppose, but that’s all it is: a game. Everyone who advocates for a UBI as a permanent fixture of the economic system also advocates for using some set of taxes or other revenue to fund it (or, in MMT language, “offset it”). For those advocates, the taxes are packed into the word “UBI.” Thus when those advocates say “a UBI is not inflationary,” what they mean is that “a UBI with offsetting taxes is not inflationary.” If you’ve followed along so far, you see now that everyone has actually wound up at the exact same spot. Both claims are true: A UBI [without offsetting taxes] is inflationary. A UBI [with offsetting taxes] is not inflationary. Everyone is just talking past one another, primarily because the MMT people are using an idiosyncratic way of speaking while being opaque about doing so. Transfer Payment Nonsense In addition to the word games above, there is another strand of argument that circulates in this MMT world that is just straightforwardly nonsensical. Though they rarely spell it out so clearly, the argument goes like this: Transfer payments are inflationary. A UBI is a transfer payment. Therefore, a UBI is inflationary. Right off the bat, you can see that this argument also contains within it the rhetorical move where you assume that “transfer payments” or “UBI” are being done by themselves with no offsetting taxes (i.e. being done with seignorage). But more than that is going on in this particular point. Transfer payments are payments governments make (almost always in cash) to various populations as part of the welfare system. Social Security and SSI payments are transfer payments. Unemployment benefits are transfer payments. Pell grants are transfer payments. Food Stamps are transfer payments. And so on. All transfer payments are “inflationary” in the same way that MMT people accuse the UBI of being inflationary. Many people don’t realize this because, though you can find this point buried in various MMT writings and presentations, the popular advocates are very selective about when they bring up inflation. A proposal to increase transfer payments via a UBI will always cause MMT people to talk about inflation. But a proposal to increase transfer payments via an increase in Social Security benefits won’t. There is no theory-based reason for this selectivity: all transfer payment increases cause inflation, so defined. But it’s a political calculation they make. When accusing transfer payments of being inflationary, the MMT people very often also say that government spending on public employee wages is not inflationary. This becomes a key reason why you are supposed to favor a job guarantee, which pays people “wages,” over more conventional transfer programs like unemployment benefits, which pays people “transfer payments.” This is completely nonsensical of course. Government spending on public employee wages is inflationary, so defined. It is no different than government spending on transfer payments in this regard. In both cases, the government gives an individual cash that they then go out and spend on goods and services. It makes no difference for inflation if the person who received the cash sat at home and watched TV (“transfer payment”) or instead raked leaves in the park (“job guarantee wages”). The inflation (again, so defined) comes when they spend the money trying to buy good and services. The reason some JG advocates don’t seem to understand this is because their minds have been captured by a very literal interpretation of and the . Put simply, there is a general notion that inflation occurs when there is more money chasing the same number of goods. With that notion in mind, it is then observed that public employee wages are counted in the national accounts as output, meaning they boost GDP. But transfer payments are not counted that way. So, the reasoning then goes that public employee wages increase output and therefore lead to “more money chasing more goods” (not inflation) while transfer payments do not increase output and therefore lead to “more money chasing the same number of goods” (inflation). This is simply confused. To understand why, consider the case of public school teachers. There are a little over public school teachers in the US and they collectively receive a little under . In the national accounts, that $200 billion will be counted towards GDP and reasonably so: teachers probably do produce about $200 billion worth of educational services each year. But the government does not charge students or their parents for those services. It does not collect any revenue from those services. And because it does not collect any revenue from the users of the service, those $200 billion of wages are not offset at all. They are purely inflationary just like an unemployment check would be and just like JG wages would be, which is why we need taxes to fund public schools (or “offset the inflation caused by teacher wages” to again use the special language of MMT). If you press some of the high priests of the MMT world hard enough, they will sometimes admit this point. For instance, in 2016, Rohan Grey (a second tier MMT advocate) pushed Randy Wray (one of the high priests of MMT) to address this directly. Grey raised the point this way: If you put $1 trillion into solar panels and those solar panels were just installed — they weren’t sold, they were just given away. That $1 trillion is now out there in people’s pockets and presumably private sector demand is going to absorb that. It seems to be that the product of the job guarantee, unless its sold, is not necessarily absorbing the purchasing power demands being created by the income that’s being given for it. Wray responds to this point, not by trying to show that through some magic JG wages won’t be inflationary, but instead by saying that a JG program would actually be very small, something like 1 percent of GDP. And so while JG wages would be inflationary (just like UBI payments are inflationary), the inflation is not something to worry about because the program is simply not very big. Hyman Minsky, who is revered in MMT world, also acknowledged that the JG (or a public jobs program more generally like the WPA) is clearly inflationary unless its output is sold to generate government revenue: If the WPA output is useful and is sold, WPA-type relief for the unemployed is less inflationary than unemployment insurance. If the WPA output is useful even if it is not sold in a market, then it makes a contribution to the well-being of those who find the output useful, and, presumably, a tax or user’s fee offset to all or part of the WPA spending could be collected. So in summary, this particular version of the argument that the “UBI is inflationary” is really just an application of the broader argument that “transfer payments are inflationary.” And while it is true, under the way MMT people use words, that transfer payments are inflationary, it is also true that all other government spending is inflationary, including spending on public employee wages and including spending on JG wages. The whole line of critique is one big head fake.