2023
CNDI
Affirmative
1AC › Competitiveness Advantage
Brands ’20 – Professor of Global Affairs [Hal; Hal Brands is the Henry A. Kissinger Distinguished Professor of Global Affairs at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies (SAIS) and a scholar at the American Enterprise Institute. He is also a columnist for Bloomberg Opinion. He is the author or editor of several books regarding foreign policy and grand strategy; 10-1-21; "The End of China’s Rise”; https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/china/2021-10-01/end-chinas-rise; Foreign Affairs; accessed 6-23-2022; AH]
RING OF FIRE Eurasia has often been a deathtrap for aspiring hegemons: there are too many nearby enemies that can make common cause with offshore superpowers. For almost 40 years, a rising China avoided strategic encirclement by downplaying its global ambitions and maintaining friendly relations with the United States. But that period is over. As Beijing has become more aggressive in the South China Sea, the Taiwan Strait, and elsewhere, it has engendered hostility nearly all around. Over the past five years, the United States has abandoned engagement and embraced neo-containment. Washington has carried out its largest naval and missile expansion in a generation, imposed its most aggressive tariffs since World War II, and implemented its tightest restrictions on foreign investment since the Cold War—all directed at China. Arms sales and military support to frontline states have increased; U.S. technological sanctions are threatening to destroy Huawei and other Chinese firms. In 2021, China’s deputy foreign minister complained that “a whole-of-government and whole-of-society campaign is being waged to bring China down.” The United States’ turn against China has contributed to a broader backlash against Beijing’s power. In Northeast Asia, Taiwan has become more determined than ever to maintain its de facto independence, and the government has approved a bold new defense strategy that could make the island extremely hard to conquer. Japan has agreed to cooperate closely with the United States to fend off Chinese aggression in the region. Through its own belligerence, Beijing has given the U.S.-Japanese alliance an explicitly anti-China cast. The countries around the South China Sea are also starting to hedge against China. Vietnam is acquiring mobile shore-based missiles, Russian attack submarines, new fighter aircraft, and surface ships armed with advanced cruise missiles. Singapore has quietly become a significant U.S. military partner. Indonesia increased its defense spending 20 percent in 2020 and another 21 percent in 2021. Even the Philippines, which courted China for most of President Rodrigo Duterte’s term, is now reiterating its claims in the South China Sea and ramping up air and naval patrols. China’s ambitions are provoking a response beyond East Asia, too, from Australia to India to Europe. Everywhere Beijing is pushing, a growing cast of rivals is pushing back. The Quadrilateral Security Dialogue—a strategic partnership that includes Australia, India, Japan, and the United States—has emerged as a focal point of anti-China cooperation among the most powerful democracies in the Indo-Pacific. The new AUKUS (Australia–United Kingdom–United States) alliance unites the core of the Anglosphere against Beijing. The United States is forging overlapping mini-coalitions to ensure that advanced democracies stay ahead in key technologies, while the G-7 and NATO are staking out tougher positions on Taiwan and other issues. To be sure, counter-China cooperation remains a work in progress, because many countries still rely on trade with Beijing. But these interlocking partnerships could eventually form a noose around Beijing’s neck. FLAMING OUT China is a risen power, not a rising one: it has acquired formidable geopolitical capabilities, but its best days are behind it. That distinction matters, because China has staked out vaulting ambitions and now may not be able to achieve them without drastic action. The CCP aims to reclaim Taiwan, dominate the western Pacific, and spread its influence around the globe. Xi has declared that China seeks a “future where we will win the initiative and have the dominant position.” Yet that dream is starting to slip away, as growth slows and China faces an increasingly hostile world.
2023
CNDI
Affirmative
1AC › Competitiveness Advantage
Jonathan E. Hillman in 2021
director of the Reconnecting Asia Project at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington, D.C.; The United States’ Broken Infrastructure Is a National Security Threat; CSIS; https://www.csis.org/analysis/united-states-broken-infrastructure-national-security-threat
After years of promises and inaction, revitalizing U.S. infrastructure needs to be treated as a national security priority rather than a punchline. Few ideas have as much bipartisan appeal and economic potential. Increasing public spending on infrastructure to levels similar to the mid-twentieth century would create more than 3 million jobs by 2029 and boost productivity. The U.S. economy would grow by $2.70 for every dollar spent. But above and beyond the economic stakes, fixing U.S. infrastructure is a national security imperative. The strategic importance of infrastructure is not new, but it has grown in recent years due to climate change, innovation, and China’s rise. At stake is the United States’ military readiness, national resiliency, and global competitiveness. During the Cold War, President Dwight Eisenhower understood the link between infrastructure and military readiness. As he argued in his 1955 State of the Union Address, “A modern, efficient highway system is essential to meet the needs of our growing population, our expanding economy, and our national security.” Eisenhower worked with Congress to create the National Highway System, which enhanced the United States’ ability to move troops and evacuate large cities. Decades later, these capabilities were still on display. “The capacity of the U.S. highway system to support the mobilization of troops and to move equipment and forces to U.S. ports of embarkation was key to successful deployment,” Lieutenant General Kenneth R. Wykle explained to Congress after the First Gulf War. The problem, however, is that the National Highway System was designed to last until the 1970s. Years of underfunding has left a backlog of work for U.S. highways and bridges that exceeds $830 billion. Infrastructure is also essential for resilience, the ability to recover from adversity. Last year, the United States experienced 22 weather and climate disasters with losses exceeding $1 billion each, a new record. Combined costs reached $95 billion. No person or place is immune to these risks, which aging infrastructure magnifies. As a National Academy study explains, “If a community has weakened infrastructure, like a human body with a compromised immune system, it will not withstand trauma as well as one in good health.” Climate change is increasing these risks. Much of today’s infrastructure was built for a world that was cooler and less extreme, and it is now aging more quickly. Increased temperatures, precipitation, and storm severity that accompany climate change all degrade roads, bridges, and railways. Rebuilding infrastructure provides an opportunity to incorporate disaster resilience. It also provides an opportunity to increase energy efficiency and build a greener economy. Resiliency extends beyond natural disasters. As the U.S. government considers how to make supply chains for critical goods more resilient, investments in infrastructure will be essential for reshoring production. New domestic production will create new patterns for moving goods that infrastructure will need to serve. Investing in infrastructure would also incentivize for companies to set up shop in the United States. The United States is competing for much more than the attention of global companies. Infrastructure will influence whether the United States trains and attracts the brightest minds, whether it remains a leading hub for innovation, and whether U.S. workers and companies have the solid foundation required to export their goods and services to foreign markets. Right now, the sorry state of U.S. infrastructure is a drag on all these prospects. Digital infrastructure has become even more essential to daily life, a trend accelerated by the Covid-19 pandemic. However, over 40 million Americans still don’t have access to broadband. Investments in infrastructure are needed to close that divide and give U.S. communities access to the educational, health, and business opportunities that digital connectivity provides. Done right, investments in digital infrastructure could also position the United States to export more of these solutions, from Open RAN networks to smart city systems. China’s rise raises the stakes further. The United States is entering what could be a decades-long competition in which economic and technological power will matter just as much, if not more, than military might. Starting this race with decaying infrastructure is like lining up for a marathon with a broken ankle. Beijing understands the nature of this contest. Chinese leader Xi Jinping is championing “new infrastructure,” calling for major investments in 5G networks, data centers, industrial internet capacity, satellite services, and other digital infrastructure. With its Belt and Road Initiative, China has even rolled out a bigger infrastructure package beyond its borders than the United States has been able to muster at home. Washington should not attempt to match Beijing’s infrastructure activities, which keep bloated state-owned enterprises afloat, stoke corruption, and can destroy more value than they create. But the United States must rise to the challenge by making strategic investments in its own future at home and playing to its own strengths abroad. There are two paths ahead. The path not taken for ages—revitalizing U.S. infrastructure—will require courage and compromise. But it leads toward renewal, prosperity, and security. The current path—neglecting U.S. infrastructure—is easy and dangerous. It leads toward unpreparedness, fragility, and decline. The choice is simple: the city on the hill can shine again, or the world can watch as its lights go out.
2023
CNDI
Affirmative
1AC › Competitiveness Advantage
Atkinson 22, Robert D. Atkinson is the founder and president of the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation as well as an adjunct professor at Georgetown University’s Edmund A. Walsh School of Foreign Service. He has served in advisory roles in the Clinton, George W. Bush, Obama, Trump, and Biden administrations and is the author of four books, including Innovation Economics: The Race for Global Advantage., “How to Win the US-China economic war”, Foreign Policy, November 8, 2022, https://foreignpolicy.com/2022/11/08/us-china-economic-war-trade-industry-innovation-production-competition-biden/.//Isim
It is dawning on the United States that China is not just a military adversary but an economic one. The two countries are at war for primacy in both innovation and production capacity as much of Beijing’s economic gain in advanced industries comes at Washington’s loss—and vice versa. This trend is likely to continue. Chinese President Xi Jinping acknowledged as much last year when he stated, “Technological innovation has become the main battleground of the global playing field, and competition for tech dominance will grow unprecedentedly fierce.” Economic war is distinct from economic competition. Canada and the United States, for example, compete economically, but both nations understand that trade is conducted on the basis of a mutually beneficial comparative advantage. By contrast, China has launched massive frontal assaults on U.S. technology and industry capabilities. Beijing’s 2006 National Medium- and Long-Term Plan for the Development of Science and Technology can be considered an initial strike in this conflict, followed in 2015 by Xi’s “Made in China 2025” strategy. Both identified key technologies in which China sought to achieve self-sufficiency, and both are backed by restrictions on foreign firms’ market access in key industries, widespread intellectual property theft, forced technology transfers, enormous subsidies for Chinese firms, and much more. The latter document also added numerical targets for China’s market share in leading industries. Economic war is not unprecedented. From 1900 to 1945, Germany used a wide array of unfair trade practices to gain economic and political power globally, ultimately in service of its military power. But Beijing has taken economic war to another level. China’s long-standing and increasing attacks are designed to crush its competitors—and make the United States an economic vassal state. Former U.S. President Donald Trump’s trade war was a response—albeit a poorly formulated one—to China’s long assaults on U.S. industrial and technological capabilities. At the time, most experts in Washington ascribed this to Trump’s protectionist proclivities rather than a recognition that the United States was in a full-scale economic war. It is only in the last few years that the intent and extent of China’s economic aggression has become more widely understood. U.S. President Joe Biden’s new export ban on advanced chips and semiconductor equipment to China is evidence that he and some people in his administration have caught on. Despite Biden’s ban, the United States remains largely unprepared for a protracted economic war with China. Beijing’s innovation-mercantilist practices—which seek to gain a large share of advanced industry output by using tactics considered illegal by the World Trade Organization—go far beyond the industrial policies of other nations. Ignoring them and believing that China will change course—or assuming that China can’t succeed because it is not a democratic, free market country or has an aging population, as many U.S. policymakers do—is akin to putting its head in the sand and hoping for the best. The stakes are high: Winning the war will boost domestic wages, competitiveness, and economic and national security. Losing will do the opposite. The U.S. national security establishment takes planning for military war seriously. It spends significant resources on war-gaming exercises and supporting the U.S. Defense Department. It has numerous war colleges to study combat. It enlists endless consultants to advise on every aspect of war. It employs historians to learn from prior conflicts. And it coordinates with agencies from across the federal government. Such a system is largely absent for economic warfare. There is no planning. No assessment. No strategy. No economic security system. At best, there are individual programs and initiatives that fail to constitute a whole-of-government strategy or system. Absent an invasion of Taiwan, it seems there is no Chinese economic attack that could awaken Washington from its slumbers. Most of Washington does not—at least yet—see economic relations with Beijing in win-lose terms. Although policymakers understand that foreign adversaries can and do attack vital U.S. national security interests, they are less willing to acknowledge that the same can be true when it comes to vital U.S. economic interests. Indeed, most economic advisors still proffer the notion of comparative advantage, where trade is a mutually beneficial win-win. The United States, they say, might be good at producing passenger jets, whereas China is good at producing 5G equipment. But China’s massive subsidies and other unfair practices used to build up advanced domestic industries—in telecommunications equipment, high-speed rails, construction equipment, aerospace, semiconductors, biotechnology, clean energy, automobiles, computing, artificial intelligence, and more—have nothing to do with comparative advantage. They reflect a desire for dominance through industrial predation: boosting their own firms while crushing foreign competitors’ ability to compete. This is why there is a strong negative correlation between the change in the respective shares of global output that China and the United States held in advanced industries from 1995 to 2018. In other words, China gained shares in the industries the United States lost. Washington also persists in holding on to the free market doctrine that firms maximize economic welfare when they act in their own interests without government aid or strategic direction. Yet even the most devoted follower of economists Adam Smith or Friedrich Hayek believes that market forces alone will not generate a nation’s needed military capabilities. That’s why governments must intervene and plan. But too many experts in Washington don’t extend that logic to capabilities for economic war. To be sure, economic war and military war are different; there are few, if any, direct casualties from economic war, and battles take place over a much longer period of time. But both ultimately threaten the ability of the state to exist autonomously.
2023
CNDI
Affirmative
1AC › Competitiveness Advantage
McBride and Siripurapu 21
James, Global Affairs writer, Ansu, writer and editor for the Daily News Brief, The State of U.S. Infrastructure; Council on Foreign Relations, https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/state-us-infrastructure
The $20 trillion U.S. economy relies on a vast network of infrastructure from roads and bridges to freight rail and ports to electrical grids and internet provision. But the systems currently in place were built decades ago, and economists say that delays and rising maintenance costs are holding economic performance back. Civil engineers raise safety concerns as well, warning that many bridges are structurally deficient and that antiquated drinking water and wastewater systems pose risks to public health. Meanwhile, Americans’ international peers enjoy more efficient and reliable services, and the U.S. lags behind other developed countries in infrastructure spending. Skeptics of federal spending have pushed for new models of private sector involvement, which they say is more efficient and cost-effective. Others argue that increased public spending will be necessary to meet the country’s growing needs. With the COVID-19 pandemic delivering a major economic shock, President Joe Biden has rolled out a sweeping plan to overhaul the nation’s infrastructure. In November 2021, Congress approved the largest federal investment in decades. How important is infrastructure to the U.S. economy? Economists argue that robust investment in infrastructure in the twentieth century set the foundation for the nation’s strong growth in the aftermath of World War II. And as engineer and historian Henry Petroski explains in his book , poor infrastructure can impose large costs on the U.S. economy. In addition to the threat to human safety of catastrophic failures such as bridge collapses or dam breaches, inadequately maintained roads, trains, and waterways cost billions of dollars in lost economic productivity. According to Petroski, the delays caused by traffic congestion alone cost the economy over $120 billion per year. Airports are another choke point: air transportation services support 1.4 million U.S. jobs, and international tourism brings in hundreds of billions of dollars of tax revenue. But some studies have found that delays and avoided trips due to the poor state of the nation’s airports over $35 billion per year. Many analysts say that investing in both new infrastructure and current maintenance would stimulate the economy. By increasing efficiency and reliability and lowering transportation costs, it would boost long-term U.S. competitiveness, insulate the economy from shocks, and create jobs. Economists generally see infrastructure spending as having a significant “multiplier effect,” meaning that the economic gains are greater than the amount spent. A [PDF] found that infrastructure investments added as much as $3 to gross domestic product (GDP) growth for every $1 spent, with a bigger effect during a recession.
2023
CNDI
Affirmative
1AC › Competitiveness Advantage
Paul Chinowsky in 2022
Professor of Civil Engineering, University of Colorado Boulder; America's aging infrastructure sags under the pressure of climate change;
The 1960s and 1970s were a golden age of infrastructure development in the U.S., with the expansion of the interstate system and widespread construction of new water treatment, wastewater and flood control systems reflecting national priorities in public health and national defense. But infrastructure requires maintenance, and, eventually, it has to be replaced. That hasn't been happening in many parts of the country. Increasingly, extreme heat and storms are putting roads, bridges, water systems and other infrastructure under stress. Two recent examples—an intense heat wave that pushed California's power grid to its limits in September 2022, and the failure of the water system in Jackson, Mississippi, amid flooding in August—show how a growing maintenance backlog and increasing climate change are turning the 2020s and 2030s into a golden age of infrastructure failure. I am a civil engineer whose work focuses on the impacts of climate change on infrastructure. Often, low-income communities and communities of color like Jackson see the least investment in infrastructure replacements and repairs. Crumbling bridge and water systems The United States is consistently falling short on funding infrastructure maintenance. A report by former Federal Reserve Board Chairman Paul Volcker's Volcker Alliance in 2019 estimated the U.S. has a US$1 trillion backlog of needed repairs. Over 220,000 bridges across the country—about 33% of the total—require rehabilitation or replacement. A water main break now occurs somewhere in the U.S. every two minutes, and an estimated 6 million gallons of treated water are lost each day. This is happening at the same time the western United States is implementing water restrictions amid the driest 20-year span in 1,200 years. Similarly, drinking water distribution in the United States relies on over 2 million miles of pipes that have limited life spans. The underlying issue for infrastructure failure is age, resulting in the failure of critical parts such as pumps and motors. Aging systems have been blamed for failures of the water system in Jackson, wastewater treatment plants in Baltimore that leaked dangerous amounts of sewage into the Chesapeake Bay and dam failures in Michigan that have resulted in widespread damage and evacuations. Inequality in investment Compounding the problem of age is the lack of funds to modernize critical systems and perform essential maintenance. Fixing that will require systemic change. Infrastructure is primarily a city and county responsibility financed through local taxes. However, these entities are also dependent on state and federal funds. As populations increase and development expands, local governments have cumulatively had to double their infrastructure spending since the 1950s, while federal sources remained mostly flat. Inequity often underlies the growing need for investment in low-income U.S. communities. Over 2 million people in the United States lack access to safe drinking water and basic sanitation. The greatest predictor of those who lack this access is race: 5.8% of Native American households lack access, while only 0.3% of white households lack access. In terms of sanitation, studies in predominantly African American counties have found disproportionate impacts from nonworking sewage systems. Jackson, a majority-Black state capital, has dealt with water system breakdowns for years and has repeatedly requested infrastructure funding from the state to upgrade its struggling water treatment plants. Climate change exacerbates the risk The consequences of inadequate maintenance are compounded by climate change, which is accelerating infrastructure failure with increased flooding, extreme heat and growing storm intensity. Much of the world's infrastructure was designed for an environment that no longer exists. The historic precipitation levels, temperature profiles, extreme weather events and storm surge levels those systems were designed and built to handle are now exceeded on a regular basis. Unprecedented rainfall in the California desert in 2015 tore apart a bridge over Interstate 10, one of the state's most important east-west routes. Temperatures near 120 degrees Fahrenheit (49 C) forced the Phoenix airport to cancel flights in 2017 out of concern the planes might not be able to safely take off. A heat wave in the Pacific Northwest in 2020 buckled roads and melted streetcar cables in Portland. Amtrak slowed its train speeds in the Northeast in July 2022 out of concern that a heat wave would cause the overhead wires to expand and sag and rails to potentially buckle. Power outages during California's September 2022 heat wave are another potentially life-threatening infrastructure problem. The rising costs of delayed repairs My research with colleagues shows that the vulnerability of the national transportation system, energy distribution system, water treatment facilities and coastal infrastructure will significantly increase over the next decade due to climate change. We estimate that rail infrastructure faces additional repair costs of $5 billion to $10 billion annually by 2050, while road repairs due to temperature increases could reach a cumulative $200 billion to $300 billion by the end of the century. Similarly, water utilities are facing the possibility of a trillion-dollar price tag by 2050. After studying the issue of climate change impacts on infrastructure for two decades, with climate projections getting worse, not better, I believe addressing the multiple challenges to the nation's infrastructure requires systemic change. Two items are at the top of the list: national prioritization and funding. Prioritizing the infrastructure challenge is essential to bring government responsibilities into the national conversation. Most local jurisdictions simply can't afford to absorb the cost of needed infrastructure. The recent infrastructure bill and the Inflation Reduction Act are starting points, but they still fall short of fixing the long-term issue.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Feminist UBI NEG › Ks › Cap Root Cause
Audrey Gibbs and Gabby Klein, August 29, 2020, “Tools of the Patriarchy: The Money Tool, and the Persistent Wage Gap”, https://msmagazine.com/2020/08/29/tools-of-the-patriarchy-the-money-tool-and-the-persistent-wage-gap/
The Money Tool is a big one when it comes to systemic sexism and income inequality, and understanding the intersections between the patriarchy and capitalism are key to understanding the path towards lasting change. And even beyond the broader topics we’ve covered, women are systemically financially disadvantaged through many frustrating and intricate laws, such as the . If, as mentioned in the chart above, it costs more to be a woman and to offset something as simple as our monthly period … that means the wage gap is even bigger than we speculated. If women do not make as much money as men, and have to spend more money than men for personal care reasons, where does that fiscally leave women? Additionally, something as simple as men paying on a date, as we covered in our , is further complicated when it comes down to the dollar. Gender equality is an important aspect of a relationship, and many women believe in splitting costs as the correct way to establish and maintain equal grounds. While splitting drinks or paying for your dates ice cream is kind and egalitarian, what does that mean when you are making less than 0.81 cents to his dollar? Or an amount that could be as low as 0.54 cents (for Hispanic and Latino women) to a white man’s dollar? While money, definitely, is not everything—it is infused into the way we live. And as long as our society functions in a capitalistic manner, our work can and will be valued with a dollar amount.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Feminist UBI NEG › DA › Warming Turns Patriarchy
McClure and Dhillion 6/28 (Tess McClure and Amrit Dhillon, reporters, “Climate crisis linked to rising domestic violence in south Asia, study finds”, The Guardian, 6/28/2023, ) - CSC
As deadly heatwaves sweep through cities in India, China, the US and Europe amid the climate crisis, new research has found that rising temperatures are associated with a substantial rise in domestic violence against women. A study published in JAMA Psychiatry on Wednesday found a 1C increase in average annual temperature was connected to a rise of more than 6.3% in incidents of physical and sexual domestic violence across three south Asian countries. The study tracked 194,871 girls and women aged 15-49 from India, Pakistan and Nepal between 2010 and 2018, and their reported experiences of emotional, physical and sexual violence. It compared that data with temperature fluctuations across the same period. India, which already had the highest reported rates of intimate partner violence of the three, also had the biggest increase in abuse: with a 1C rise in heat came an 8% rise in physical violence, and 7.3% rise in sexual violence. Countries around the world are already in the grip of extreme temperatures and heatwaves. This month, India was reporting temperatures up to 45C (113F) and dozens of heat-related deaths, Mediterranean Europe emerged from a record-breaking April heatwave, Texas entered its third week of deadly heat with temperatures up to 46C, and China urged people in northern cities to stay indoors as temperatures of over 40C broke records. Michelle Bell, a professor of environmental health at Yale University and a co-author of the study, said that there were “many potential pathways, both physiological and sociological, through which higher temperature could affect risk of violence”. Extreme heat can lead to crop failures, buckle infrastructure, eat into economies, trap people indoors and render them unable to work – all factors that can place families under extreme stress and push up violence rates. The researchers found that although there was a heat-related increase in violence across all income groups, the largest increases were among lower-income and rural households. The Indian activist Suniti Gargi, who used to work with Uttah Pradesh’s commission for women, said heatwaves were an annual occurrence during the Indian summer. She is convinced the climate crisis is making them worse and connects them with the rising levels of domestic violence she has been seeing. “I’ve been seeing unusually high temperatures becoming more common,” she said. “They cause tremendous economic stress in families. If a man can migrate to another state to get work, it can help keep the home fires burning but when he cannot for whatever reason, his wife is at the receiving end of his anger and feelings of uselessness.” One woman, speaking through Gargi, said when the May and June heat hit and it became impossible for her husband to work in the fields, they would lose their only source of income. “He becomes angry because he feels helpless about not being able to feed the children,” she said. “When the frustration builds up and the children are whining and fighting, he takes it out on me. He also beats them too. He regrets hitting the children later but the next day when he still can’t go out and earn, he does it again.” The study by Fudan University, Shanghai, adds to a growing body of research showing how rising temperatures can fuel a more violent world, particularly for women. Previous research from Madrid found that when a heatwave hit, the risk of intimate partner femicide rose 40%, and in Kenya, women who experienced severe weather events – including heatwaves – had 60% higher odds of reporting intimate partner violence. Studies collating global data have found the risks of interpersonal violence increased by 2.3% and intergroup conflicts by 13.2% as temperatures rose. As well as social and economic factors, the heat can go to work on the human body. “There is growing evidence that extreme heat can affect stress, lower inhibitions, increase aggression, and exacerbate mental illness,” Bell said. Past research has found that acute heat exposure is associated with increased adrenaline production, which could activate higher aggression, and activate the brain areas associated with emotion regulation. Heatwaves are also associated with worsening the effects of mental illness, including anxiety and post-traumatic stress disorder.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Feminist UBI NEG › DA › Unemployment Turn
Milton Ezrati 19, economics and investment strategy consultant and serve as chief economist for the NY-based communications firm, Vested and contributing editor for The National Interest and an affiliate of the Center for the Study of Human Capital and Economic Growth at the University at Buffalo (SUNY). 1/15/19. “Universal Basic Income: A Thoroughly Wrongheaded Idea,” https://www.forbes.com/sites/miltonezrati/2019/01/15/universal-basic-income-a-thoroughly-wrongheaded-idea/?sh=25c2e78245e1
The most quoted schemes today would, according calculations from Commerce Department data, cost the federal government between $2 and 4 trillion a year, amounting to a 50% increase in current federal outlays or more than 10% of last year’s gross domestic product (GDP). Such a draw on the economy would markedly burden taxpayers and increase government debt with all the associated economic ills. At the same time, such a huge draw on federal financial resources would also preclude other government priorities, such as infrastructure refurbishment, including the building of hospitals and the construction of affordable housing. Both effects would undermine productive incentives and otherwise constrain both public and private investment in the economy. Economic activity and growth potentials would suffer accordingly, not the least because UBI payouts would do little to invest in the future except if recipients really do use the funds for education and training.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Feminist UBI NEG › DA › Unemployment Turn
Rachel
With a foundational, albeit limited, income under UBI, some Americans may choose to work part-time instead of full-time. Others may leave the labor force for years when they would have otherwise worked. Eduardo Porter writes that, as almost one quarter of US households make less than $25,000 a year, a $10,000 check each for two parents could change their decisions on how to balance work, child care, and other obligations, resulting in less full-time participation in the labor force.8
If people transition away from full-time work, the US economy would suffer. Macroeconomic theory holds that economic growth is dependent on three factors: increases in capital, advances in technology, and growth of the labor force. UBI has the potential to directly decrease the growth of the US economy, namely GDP growth, through reductions to labor force participation. With GDP shrinking, tax revenues would fall. This would in turn mean fewer resources to help the disadvantaged or to invest in the future, resulting in lower overall prosperity
2023
CNDI
Negative
Feminist UBI NEG › DA › Economy Links
Robert Doar 18, Morgridge Fellow in Poverty Studies at the American Enterprise Institute, 2018, “Universal Basic Income Would Undermine the Success of Our Safety Net,” https://www.bushcenter.org/catalyst/are-we-ready/doar-universal-basic-income
The American safety net is not perfect – not by a long shot – but it does a good job of ensuring that low-income Americans have enough support to meet their basic needs. The data are clear about that: Consumption poverty, which measures the wellbeing of the poor after accounting for safety net assistance provided by the government, declined to an all-time low of 3 percent in 2016. Thanks to a good economy and strong public assistance programs, very few Americans live in deprivation.
Universal Basic Income (UBI) would be an unaffordable way to undermine our social safety net’s successes. UBI would transfer money away from those who need it most, change the distinctly American relationship between citizen and government, and sharply raise taxes or the national debt (or both). And critically, it would fail to improve upon our current safety net’s biggest weakness: UBI would destroy – not improve – incentives to work.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Feminist UBI NEG › DA › Economy Links
Robert Doar 18, Morgridge Fellow in Poverty Studies at the American Enterprise Institute, 2018, “Universal Basic Income Would Undermine the Success of Our Safety Net,” https://www.bushcenter.org/catalyst/are-we-ready/doar-universal-basic-income
As for those not among the high earners, UBI would surely illustrate a basic law of economics and negatively affect the incentive to work and produce. One thing I saw clearly in my 19 years of working in safety net programs in New York was that when benefits rose, work and earnings declined. And in the major study of UBI-like programs provided in Seattle and Denver, substantial, unconditional payments were found to cause a near 14 percent decline in labor force participation, and a 27 percent reduction in hours worked by women. That’s a labor force drop-off greater than the difference between the highest participation rate we’ve ever seen in this country and the lowest.
That doesn’t only mean people will be less driven than ever to earn their way out of poverty. Less work also means fewer “feelings of citizenship and social inclusion,” worse mental health and feelings of wellbeing, less happiness, worse self-esteem, even worse health among children, more crime, and way more drug abuse. The benefits of working are vast and well-documented, and anti-poverty programs should encourage work – not discourage it.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Feminist UBI NEG › Case Turns › Social Service Cuts Turn
Battastoni, 2017 - PhD candidate in political science at Yale [Alyssa, Spring Dissent, “The False Promise of Universal Basic Income” TA]
It’s often noted that Milton Friedman as well as Martin Luther King, Jr. supported basic income—and the new generation of advocates is similarly eclectic, running the gamut from Trump-supporting venture capitalists like Thiel to “fully automated luxury communists” like Peter Frase. There are, in short, many different reasons for supporting UBI—and just as many versions of what it could be. One version functions as a kind of noblesse oblige—a handout to the unfortunates being made obsolete by robots smarter and more efficient than they are. Another version aspires to egalitarian universalism and challenges the legitimacy of privately accumulated wealth. There’s a version that sees UBI as the spark for a generation of entrepreneurs, and another that simply attempts to stave off a revolt of the precarious masses. Basic income is therefore often posited as a post-ideological solution suited to a new era of politics: the odd confluence of interest from the left and right tends to be read as a sign that political positions should be eschewed in favor of rational compromise. But UBI’s cross-ideological appeal is the bug, not the feature. Because basic income is politically ambiguous, it also has the potential to act as a Trojan horse for the left or right: left critics fret that it will serve as a vehicle for dissolving the remains of the welfare state, while proponents herald it as the “capitalist road to communism.” The version of basic income we get will depend, more than policies with a clearer ideological valence, on the political forces that shape it. Which is why the prospect of pushing for basic income in the United States right now—when the right controls everything—should be cause for alarm: UBI’s supporters on the left should proceed with caution.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Feminist UBI NEG › Case Turns › Social Service Cuts Turn
Greenstein, 2019 - President Emeritus of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities [Robert, June 13, “Commentary: Universal Basic Income May Sound Attractive But, If It Occurred, Would Likelier Increase Poverty Than Reduce It” TA]
At first blush, universal basic income (UBI) seems a very attractive idea, especially to a progressive. Yet it suffers from two serious problems. First, the odds are very high that an effort to secure UBI would prove quixotic. Second, and more disconcerting, any possibility of overcoming the formidable obstacles to UBI will almost certainly require a left-right coalition that has significant conservative support — and conservative support for UBI rests on an approach that would increase poverty, rather than reduce it. The key issues related to UBI include what it would cost, how it would be paid for, and the risks it poses. Let’s take these one at a time. The Cost There are over 300 million Americans today. Suppose UBI provided everyone with $10,000 a year. That would cost more than $3 trillion a year — and $30 trillion to $40 trillion over ten years. This single-year figure equals more than three-fourths of the entire yearly federal budget — and double the entire budget outside Social Security, Medicare, defense, and interest payments. It’s also equal to close to 100 percent of all tax revenue the federal government collects. Or, consider UBI that gives everyone $5,000 a year. That would provide income equal to about two-fifths of the poverty line for an individual (which is a projected $12,700 in 2016) and less than the poverty line for a family of four ($24,800). But it would cost as much as the entire federal budget outside Social Security, Medicare, defense, and interest payments. Some UBI proponents respond that policymakers could make the UBI payments taxable. But the savings from doing so would be relatively modest, because the vast bulk of Americans either owe no federal income tax or are in the 10% or 15% tax brackets. For example, if you gave all 328 million Americans a $10,000 UBI and the cost was $3.28 trillion a year (about $33 trillion over ten years) before taxes, then making the UBI payments taxable would reduce that cost only to something like $2.5 trillion or $2.75 trillion (or $25 trillion to $27.5 trillion over ten years). Paying For It Where would the money to finance such a large expenditure come from? That it would come mainly or entirely from new taxes isn’t plausible. We’ll already need substantial new revenues in the coming decades to help keep Social Security and Medicare solvent and avoid large benefit cuts in them. We’ll need further tax increases to help repair a crumbling infrastructure that will otherwise impede economic growth. And if we want to create more opportunity and reduce racial and other barriers and inequities, we’ll also need to raise new revenues to invest more in areas like pre-school education, child care, college affordability, and revitalizing segregated inner-city communities. A UBI that’s financed primarily by tax increases would require the American people to accept a level of taxation that vastly exceeds anything in U.S. history. It’s hard to imagine that such a UBI would advance very far, especially given the tax increases we’ll already need for Social Security, Medicare, infrastructure, and other needs. The Risk UBI’s daunting financing challenges raise fundamental questions about its political feasibility, both now and in coming decades. Proponents often speak of an emerging left-right coalition to support it. But consider what UBI’s supporters on the right advocate. They generally propose UBI as a replacement for the current “welfare state.” That is, they would finance UBI by eliminating all or most programs for people with low or modest incomes. Consider what that would mean. If you take the dollars targeted on people in the bottom fifth or two-fifths of the population and convert them to universal payments to people all the way up the income scale, you’re redistributing income upward. That would increase poverty and inequality rather than reduce them. Yet that’s the platform on which the (limited) support for UBI on the right largely rests. It entails abolishing programs from SNAP (food stamps) — which largely eliminated the severe child malnutrition found in parts of the Southern “black belt” and Appalachia in the late 1960s — to the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC), Section 8 rental vouchers, Medicaid, Head Start, child care assistance, and many others. These programs lift tens of millions of people, including millions of children, out of poverty each year and make tens of millions more less poor.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Feminist UBI NEG › Case Turns › Structural Inequality Turn
Bergmann ’08 (Barbara, Professor Emerita in Economics @ American University, “Basic Income Grants or the Welfare State: Which Better Promotes Gender Equality?”, BASIC INCOME STUDIES An International Journal of Basic Income Research, Vol. 3, Issue 3, December 2008)
Which regime promotes the further progress of this revolution, and which impedes it? Government provision or subsidization of child care in a welfare state encourages paid work for mothers. Large cash grants, such as BIG, encourage withdrawal from the paid labor force. So do lengthy paid parental leaves, such as those offered by Sweden, which can amount to an entire year, and can be extended to two years. These long leaves give employers a motive to deny women jobs that have duties that are not merely routine, that require on-the-job training, and that lead to promotions and careers. This provision is probably at least partly responsible for the persistence of the high degree of occupational segregation by sex that is characteristic of Sweden’s labor market. One alleged advantage for women that is claimed for BIG is that it would reduce their dependence on the labor market, a male-dominated arena, and thus a major site of their oppression. In fact, proponents of BIG proclaim that one of their aims is to allow parents to stay home with young children. Under current cultural conditions, the vast majority of those who would do that would be women with a high-waged male partner. A lone mother trying to live on BIG exclusively would be condemned to a standard of living far below the mainstream. For this reason, the full-blown implementation of BIG schemes in the near future should not appeal to those for whom gender equality is an important goal (Robeyns, 2001). Perhaps in the future, participation in housekeeping and parenting activities will have become less differentiated by gender. Then BIG would affect the behavior of both sexes more equally, and would have lost its anti-equality effect. In the meantime, it is not hard to believe that BIG would be more destructive of gender equality than Low Provision would. 4. Conclusion A welfare state with generous child care provision but without lengthy parental leaves would promote progress for women in the labor market, and would deliver goods, services, and cash grants to those with special needs, of which women presently form a major part. A BIG regime, by reducing women’s presence and success in the labor market, would reverse the gains in women’s status and opportunities. It would also fail to respond to the sizeable needs of the increasing cohorts of lone mothers. For those reasons, it would be even worse than the “Low Provision” regime of the United States. In terms of its effect on gender equality, it would be the worst of the three alternatives.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Feminist UBI NEG › Case Turns › Structural Inequality Turn
Bergmann ’08 (Barbara, Professor Emerita in Economics @ American University, “Basic Income Grants or the Welfare State: Which Better Promotes Gender Equality?”, BASIC INCOME STUDIES An International Journal of Basic Income Research, Vol. 3, Issue 3, December 2008)
An important difference between BIG and a welfare state is that in a BIG regime benefits are spread evenly over the population, while in the latter most benefits are targeted toward those with special needs that are expensive to fill – those who have children requiring constant care, those whose income is insufficient for decent housing, those whose children could profit from an expensive college education, and so on. Obviously, a high proportion of those having such needs are women, lone mothers in particular. Benefits targeted toward those with particular needs can be universal in the sense of being open to all who have such needs regardless of income, marital status, or gender. But targeting allows awarding very expensive benefits to only part of the population -- those in particular need of them -- without requiring that huge sums be expended to deliver to everybody benefits of equal value. A second difference is that BIG gives cash, while a welfare state gives a significant proportion of benefits in the form of goods and services, or vouchers that can only be spent on these. This insures that public money goes to fill publicly agreed-upon needs and that taxpayers’ money is not spent on things of lower public priority or that are wasteful, such as gambling or larger cars. Another feature of in-kind benefits is that they deter labor force participation less than cash benefits do. On the contrary, some in-kind benefits, such as child care, encourage it. The targeting and non-cash features of a welfare state reduce opposition to the state provision of benefits. When expensive benefits in the form of goods and services are given to those who obviously need them, the fact that they are not given to those who do not need them is not a cause for resentment, or at any rate less of a cause for resentment than the distribution of hugely unequal cash benefits would be. The superiority of a welfare state over BIG for the support of lone mothers is obvious. If they hold jobs, and relatives are unavailable to care for their children, the cost of decent-quality child care may amount to half their earnings or more. A BIG might pay in whole or part for child care, but using it in this way puts lone mothers at a disadvantage compared to those who can use the BIG grant to raise their standard of living – better food, clothing, housing. A welfare state, by contrast, recognizes the particularly acute needs of lone mothers and addresses them, and creates an equalizing effect not provided by BIG. The vast majority of lone-mother families cannot have a mainstream standard of living without earning a salary plus receiving government help with health insurance, high quality child care, higher-education expenses, andhousing. In the absence of such provision, even a BIG of $10,000–20,000 going to such a family would not suffice to put it on a par with other families, because the lone-mother family would have to spend the BIG on child care or forego paid work. It is increasingly important that government programs be structured to address the needs of lone mothers and their children. Lone mothers are not some minor part of the population. The proportion of the population living with a spouse dramatically declines year by year, as marriages are delayed to later ages and the high divorce rate persists. At the same time, the proportion of children born to unmarried women increases. The households of unmarried cohabitants, into which an increasing proportion of children are being born, are even less stable than the households of married people. Lone mothers are chronically short of time, and the majority have low earnings. In 2006 in the United States, the median two-earner family had income of $76,000, the one-earner couple had $54,000, while the lone mother had $29,000. Clearly, the lone-mother family is very far down on the totem pole. Part of the public resents births to lone mothers as imposing taxpayer costs that births to married couples avoid. Such resentments are minimized when lone mothers are earners (i.e., they are not “lazy”), and the in-kind benefits they get are also available to other parents.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Feminist UBI NEG › Case Turns › UBI Fails
Un Women, 2021, "Universal Basic Income: Potential and Limitations from a Gender Perspective", UN Women Policy Brief, 3/4/2021, - Annie
Feminists have also expressed doubt about how far UBI truly challenges ongoing gender- and race-based inequalities in unpaid care and paid employment.26 They have cautioned that, rather than shifting gender norms on care, UBI in higher income contexts and heterosexual partnerships may mean that women cut back on paid work while men continue in full-time employment and receive additional income on top. UBI would therefore be little more than a “housewives wage”, reinforcing gender inequalities.27 The impacts of this potential reshuffling of household labour on migrant domestic workers remains unknown.28 Given the enormous fiscal implications, most UBI schemes will likely not be generous enough to cover basic living costs, meaning that recipients will require additional sources of income, particularly from paid work. In this regard, UBI cannot make up for lack of fulfillment of worker’s rights or access to decent work, especially for women and transgender and gender-diverse people experiencing multiple and intersecting inequalities in access to employment. Trade unionists have rightly warned that UBI does not solve issues of low pay, precarious work or lack of negotiating power in the workplace and could potentially detract from the need to tackle exploitative labour conditions and strengthen workers’ rights, including through living wages, universal job guarantees, affirmative action, unionization and collective bargaining.29 In this case, UBI would merely act as a band aid for a broken economic system and divert attention from more radical, transformative change needed to address structural inequalities. Finally, UBI raises important questions around who is included in a purportedly ‘universal’ scheme. For example, if receipt were attached to narrow notions of citizenship, incarcerated or formerly-incarcerated persons (a group often including disproportionately high numbers of people of colour and people living in poverty), migrants and their children (particularly those who are undocumented), unhoused people and those without government-issued IDs that reflect their identity (including many transgender and intersex individuals) might all experience exclusionary treatment.30 Box 2 further discusses the extent to which UBI could address structural inequalities.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Feminist UBI NEG › Case Turns › UBI Fails
Katrin Hermann, 9/28/21, permanent author at A Path for Europe "Reimagining Care: Feminist degrowth and UBI," A Path For Europe (PfEU), - Myra
A main concern with this proposal is that instead of enabling more women to enter the labour market, they instead continue to perpetuate the caregiver role and exit the labour market completely, while men continue to free-ride on their unpaid domestic work. As Pateman argues, democratization must be included in debates on UBI; meaning “women’s freedom and standing as citizens” must be recognized as well. Thus, it should be noted that UBI is not a panacea – due to the deeply entrenched patriarchal norms about men and women’s roles in productive and reproductive work (which then become institutionalized norms), introducing a basic income will not suddenly overcome this challenge. Within the EU, the Universal Basic Income proposal is still a topic of debate. Though well-known philosophers and economists such as Philippe van Parijs have endorsed the idea, the main fear relates to its effect on the labour market.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Feminist UBI NEG › Case Turns › Workplace Discrimination Turn
Koslowski and Duvander ’18 (Allison, Professor of Social Policy and Research Methods @ the University of Edinburgh and Ann-Zofie, Professor of Demography @ Stockholm University, “Basic Income: The Potential for Gendered Empowerment?”, Social Inclusion (ISSN: 2183–2803) 2018, Volume 6, Issue 4, Pages 8–15 DOI: 10.17645/si.v6i4.1487)
Should the state not take action too with regard to gender equalities? Norms will develop: there is no such thing as total ‘real’ freedom. Legal frameworks how- ever, such as parental leave policies can see changes to norms, even those as deeply embedded as parenting practices. In Sweden, such statements are hardly contro- versial, but choice and gender equality are sometimes contrasted, and the limits to state intervention are con- stantly renegotiated. Basic income would potentially change the bound- aries for state intervention, which for many sounds intu- itively positive, and may well bring many benefits. How- ever, if the state does not intervene regarding gender- equality, gender norms will be determined by other less visible forces, such as the power dynamics within house- holds. It is likely that a universal basic income has the potential for empowerment for all, but for this to be achieved, attention will need to be paid to its potential for gendered outcomes. The concerns raised here regarding the limitations of empowerment for women from a basic income— particularly with regard to whom remains holding the baby, doing the majority of domestic work and the ma- jority of both formal and informal care work—are not in themselves arguments against the implementation of a basic income. However, there are certainly strong rea- sons to not let basic income replace other structures that have been shown to be relevant for gender equality, in particular the ones directed at supporting families, such as parental leave and childcare services. McLean (2015, p. 2) notes that ‘basic Income is in some ways a microcosm of wider feminist controversies regarding how the state can recognise the unpaid work women largely do without reinforcing existing inequal- ities, also known as Wollstonecraft’s Dilemma (Lister, 1995; Pateman, 1988)’. Indeed, feminists involved with policy making sometimes find themselves falling into one of two camps: that of a more pragmatic approach and that of a more idealistic approach. The former aim to take the situation they see at a current time in front of them, such as mothers doing most of the childcare, and to sup- port women in that situation. The latter might rather take issue with the root imbalance of this situation and aim to create a new situation where fathers are doing more childcare. Arguably, many aspects of the current Swedish welfare state are more radically ambitious than the idea of basic income in that it seeks change to the gendered division of both paid and unpaid work. The implemen- tation of a basic income would be gender-neutral and so, in theory, fathers and mothers would have the same sup- port. In practice, however, and especially given the likely low level of basic income, this policy might have the (un- intended) consequence of encouraging a return to the breadwinner model of parenting, with one parent bet- ter able to stay at home, but another parent still need- ing to remain firmly attached to the labour market. Once again, we have a political movement, which has not fully embraced the challenge from radical feminism to move us beyond the ‘fundamental biological condition’ as ob- served by Shulamith Firestone (1970, p. 1) towards an equal distribution of care work.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Feminist UBI NEG › Case Turns › Workplace Discrimination Turn
Robeyns ’01 (Ingrid Robeyns, PhD, Chair in Ethics of Institutions at the Ethics Institute of Utrecht University, “Will a Basic Income Do Justice to Women?”, Analyse & Kritik, 22, 5/1/2001, https://www.degruyter.com/document/doi/10.1515/auk-2001-0108/html?lang=en)
A last second order effect is an expected increase of statistical discrimination against women. Statistical discrimination is a form of indirect discrimination based on the fact that a person belongs to a group that has certain characteristics. These characteristics are used as proxies for the average productivity of that group. Women on average get one or two children and take maternity leave. They also work less hours on the labour market than men, and bear more responsibility for the household and the care of the children and the elderly. They have more career interruptions and are more absent from the workplace. For all these reasons, it is assumed by many employers that women are on average less productive than men. Furthermore, it is rational for an employer to think of an individual woman that she will share these characteristics of her group, as he has no information on her future commitments. Hence, an employer discriminates a woman (by not hiring her or giving her a lower wage) because the employer has no exact information on her productivity and therefore his perception of the average productivity of all women will count. A woman who does not want children, or wants to make a career or has a husband who takes half of the household responsibilities, will still bear the consequences of the fact that other women are more 'child and household oriented'-which is perceived as a good indicator for lower productivity. This implies that if a basic income is introduced, and a group of women decreases her labour supply, it will also be expected from other women that they will be less labour market attached. Hence, a basic income will probably worsen the statistical discrimination against women. One could argue that if statistical discrimination increases efficiency, this efficiency gain can be used for the worse off, for example women. If one follows this argument, statistical discrimination should not per definition be morally condemned. However, I strongly oppose to this argument. First, the little empirical research on discrimination that contains detailed and direct information on productivity (e.g. Wenneras/Wold 1997) shows that even when a woman is two times as productive as a man, employers might prefer to offer a job to him instead of her. I would therefore argue that the best assumption to start from is that statistical discrimination lowers aggregate productivity and efficiency. Nevertheless, this efficiency suboptimality can sustain because of three elements. First, it is rational for employers who have no information on individual productivity to use groups-based proxies. Second, perception biases (which can be formed by sexist, racist or other believes) can lead to a misfit between the observed proxies and real productivity. And finally, I see no reason why other considerations next to productivity (like a preference for employee homogeneity or preferences for certain types of people) would not interfere with the profit maximising strategies of employers hiring people. Furthermore, even if statistical discrimination would lead to efficiency gains, it should still be condemned on moral grounds. It violates the basic principle of equal concern and respect for all individuals. Therefore, I think it is a real challenge for theorists of justice, including basic income proposers, to find strategies to end statistical discrimination and integrate them in their theories.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Feminist UBI NEG › Case Turns › Distraction Turn
Koslowski and Duvander ’18 (Allison, Professor of Social Policy and Research Methods @ the University of Edinburgh and Ann-Zofie, Professor of Demography @ Stockholm University, “Basic Income: The Potential for Gendered Empowerment?”, Social Inclusion (ISSN: 2183–2803) 2018, Volume 6, Issue 4, Pages 8–15 DOI: 10.17645/si.v6i4.1487)
Many claims are made on what a basic income might achieve. Claims for a basic income include re- ducing poverty and benefit traps, cutting bureaucracy, matching security systems to better correspond with changes in working life, increasing wages, supporting cre- ativity and entrepreneurship, reducing unhealthy depen- dencies within relationships, increasing wellbeing, and the list continues (Kela, 2016). Some also claim that a basic income would reduce gender inequalities in soci- ety (McKay, 2001). However, the basic income move- ment makes no claims to be an explicitly feminist project (whilst acknowledging there are various feminisms).
In some ways, a basic income would be similar to existing ‘cash for care’ policies, which are not generally associated with increased gender equality (e.g. Mandel, 2009). In part, this is because such cash benefits reduce political pressure to provide comprehensive care, educa- tion and health services. Although advocates of a basic in- come are clear that a basic income only replaces benefits up to that amount, and in no way replaces existing ser- vices, it is quite common in parental leave policy debates, that cash benefits are explicitly used instead of provid- ing care services for very young children (e.g., Kurowska, 2019). The concern is that should such political trade-offs around resources occur, and should a basic income be seen as a replacement for early years education and care services as political compromise kicks in, this would have significant gendered implications.