Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › Aff Answers › AT: Gambling

Can’t solve state debts – online gambling is a drop in the bucket

Jennifer Booton 12, Fox Business, Online Gambling Won't Solve State Debt Woes, But it Could Help”, http://www.foxbusiness.com/technology/2012/06/22/online-gambling-might-not-solve-state-debt-but-it-could-help/)

Social media marketing company Nowsourcing, which produced a related infographic for client casino.org last week, estimated that each of the 22 states that have commercial casinos made about $1.62 billion on average in 2011 in gambling revenues. Hypothetically, if all 50 states had legalized gambling, they would have made a collective $81 billion (50 x $1.62 billion) last year, it said. Of course, that’s not a perfect estimate, as state tax rates vary across the country and some states like Utah have long said they will never legalize any form of gambling. It’s also just a drop in the bucket compared with the billions of dollars in state debt (California alone is $28 billion in the hole, while Illinois is out $15 billion). Rose said even the most optimistic estimates on what the federal government could raise by legalizing Internet gambling is “literally insignificant” compared with the $15.7 trillion in national debt. "Debt is more a problem of excessive government spending," Walker said. "Until spending is limited, the ability of new tax revenues to have a significant effect on debt is limited." They also note that while revenue, jobs and other positives on the economy are easily measurable, it’s hard to put a dollar amount on the negative impact of gambling. Online poker would likely make it more difficult to regulate underage gambling and some argue it could help fuel gaming addictions among the so-called problem gamblers, which make up just 1% to 2% of the population, according to Walker. Yet, those concerns haven’t stopped big casino companies like Caesars, Wynn Resorts (WYNN) and MGM Resorts International (MGM) from buying up online poker sites and online gambling licenses ahead of an expected wave of legalization in the U.S., and they certainly haven't stopped people who want to play online poker from finding ways to do so. Wynn is also said to be in talks with Zynga (ZNGA) to create a strategic partnership that would help the casino giant capitalize on gambling and tap the social gamer's more than 230 million average monthly active users. Many of the acquisition-hungry casinos are looking to buy companies that have never taken bets from Americans, as it remains to be seen whether banned sites like PokerStars will be invited back after they were booted last year. However, PokerStars is a more than $1 billion business operating from the Isle of Man, a self-governing dependency of the United Kingdom located in the Irish Sea. If it were to legally relocate to the U.S. and face regulations, it would likely bring a slew of new jobs and billions in tax revenue. U.S. regulators could take a page out of Spain’s gambling playbook ahead of the sector’s sweeping changes and allow online poker operators who previously took bets from Americans pay a back-dated tax. While the recent move in Spain has been criticized and called desperate, the gambling companies have nevertheless started to pay up. Bwin.party digital last month said it would pay 33 euros ($41.5 million) to the Spanish Tax Ministry to meet the new regulations, while 888 paid about $9.3 million. PokerStars is said to owe as much as $257 million. “In Spain, they’re getting their money,” Rose said.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › Aff Answers › AT: Gambling

Empirics prove – online gambling won’t boost state economies – New Jersey proves

Terrence Dopp 14, Bloomberg News, “Online Gambling Slump Adds to Christie’s N.J. Budget Woes”, http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-05-27/online-gambling-slump-adds-to-christie-s-n-j-budget-woes.html)

Flagging online gambling is failing to bolster Atlantic City casinos that Governor Chris Christie has said are crucial to New Jersey’s rebound, compounding revenue shortfalls that threaten the state’s credit rating. Five months after New Jersey started allowing Internet betting, the business had its first monthly revenue decline in April. The drop adds to the woes of the 11 casinos, whose revenue has dropped 44 percent since peaking in 2006. New Jersey depends on Atlantic City for its jobs, its taxes and the seaside resort area’s draw as a tourist destination. The slump means less taxes for Christie, who said last week he would cut pension payments to close budget gaps. The Republican governor faced skepticism from analysts and lawmakers last May when he predicted New Jersey would earn $180 million from a 15 percent online-gaming tax this fiscal year. At the current rate, he’ll get about $12 million. “I don’t think anyone had the crystal ball to predict what the market would be,” Tom Ballance, chief operating officer of the Borgata Hotel Casino & Spa, the largest player in New Jersey’s online gambling business with a 36 percent share, said in a phone interview. Slow Start New Jersey is the most populous state to legalize gambling on the Internet, joining Nevada and Delaware. In April, New Jersey’s online revenue fell by $500,000 to $11.4 million. In Nevada, which limits Internet bets to poker, revenue was $926,000 in March, the most recent month for which data is available. In Delaware, it was $207,000. The business is struggling as banks decline to let their customers use credit cards for online gambling and software rejects players unless they’re physically in the state, according to Simon Holliday, founder of H2 Gambling Capital, a market research firm. In addition, online wagering isn’t available on all mobile devices, he said by e-mail, and some operators are holding back on marketing until the issues are sorted out. The tax decline adds to Christie’s fiscal woes. Revenue has missed his targets for three straight years, forcing him to revise projections and cut spending. On May 21, he said he’ll reverse course on promised pension contributions this year and next, after revenue missed his goals by as much as $875 million. Tourist Draw Christie, who took office in 2010, was counting on an Atlantic City revival to help boost tourism and turn around the economy. Casino revenue in the city, 60 miles from Philadelphia and 125 miles from New York, fell 6 percent to $2.8 billion last year. It was the seventh straight annual decline as neighboring states, including Pennsylvania, expanded gambling. Casino companies and their online partners lobbied for legalization, arguing that Web-based poker, blackjack and slots would bring in fresh spending. At their peak, the casinos provided more than $400 million of state tax revenue and employed more than 42,000 people. Last year, the state collected $205 million, including two months of taxes from Internet bets. In New Jersey, taxes from gambling are dedicated to state programs for senior citizens and the disabled. Assembly Speaker Vincent Prieto, a Democrat from Secaucus, said the state will struggle to cover the costs for such programs in coming years. “We need to look at them and be sure we fund those programs,” he said in an interview. “If that money’s not coming from there, we need to take a hard look at everything else we’re doing. Right now, as you see, it’s very difficult to come up with anything.” Lagging Behind Casinos were central to the “Jersey Comeback,” the post-recession theme that Christie touted at dozens of town-hall meetings in 2012, that never materialized. State unemployment, at 6.9 percent in April, remains higher than the national average and in neighboring Pennsylvania and New York. Since February 2010, the recessionary low point for New Jersey’s private employment, businesses have added 125,700 jobs, about half the number lost during the slump. New Jersey, with its rebound trailing the nation’s, won’t recover all those jobs until 2018, Nancy Mantell, director of the Rutgers Economic Advisory Service, said this month. Any revenue decline is bad for Christie, said David Redlawsk, director of the Eagleton Center for Public Interest Polling at Rutgers University. If the governor has his eye on the 2016 Republican presidential nomination, he can’t afford to raise taxes to deal with the drop, Redlawsk said. “In some sense, the revenue from online gambling is a harbinger of everything else,” Redlawsk said. “The failure of the New Jersey economy to rebound in the way other states have has meant everything is down, and he’s been unable to meet any revenue projections. The gambling revenue is just another blow.”

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › Aff Answers › AT: Gambling

Won’t bring in enough revenue – consumers quit.

Darren Heitner 14, Lawyer @ Heitner Legal, “The Battle Of Online Vs. Land-Based Casinos” 8/7http://www.forbes.com/sites/darrenheitner/2014/08/07/the-battle-of-online-vs-land-based-casinos/

State governments are struggling to find new sources of revenue to breathe life into their budgets. One of the main reasons many support the legalization of online casinos is the belief that such a move would help boost state tax revenues and stimulate such economies. When New Jersey passed and implemented its bill to allow online gaming, Governor Chris Christie predicted that internet casino gambling would bring in $160 million of revenue in its first year. However, this number was met with widespread skepticism from local lawmakers and experts within the industry who were ultimately correct in their assessment that Governor Christie’s calculation was slightly exaggerated; Fitch Ratings Service has the actual results being nearly 45% below expectations. Online gaming is not the sure bet many expected and land-based casinos seem to be the gamer’s preference when it comes to gambling. Yet, with the recent string of casinos closing, that may not be case for much longer. Recently, one branch of Harrah’s Casino – Harrah’s Tunica Hotel & Casino – closed in Mississippi. While some state that regulated online gaming will not come directly at the expense of land-based casino revenue, in order to fully benefit from gaming, casinos may have to choose whether to focus a significant amount of their efforts on either online or land-based casinos. Online Casinos There are multiple likely benefits attached to the expansion of online casinos. Although such proliferation of online gambling may provide the on-board states with minimal tax revenue – or not meet the lofty expectations as seen in New Jersey’s case – online casinos come with much less expenses, and therefore are predicted to produce a larger return than land-based casinos. Furthermore, online casinos allow gamers to participate without the requirement of leaving the comfort of their own home. This convenient aspect provides the player with flexibility to accomplish and enjoy partaking in a number of other tasks while attempting to win money. Along with the ability to complete other tasks, online casinos also permit players to easily jump from game to game with the click of a button. The benefits somewhat mirror those concerning staying at home to watch major sporting events vs. attending the events live, a battle previously referenced as the biggest sports rivalry in 2014. That flexibility comes with consequences for the online casino. Casinos would surely prefer that players have little-to-no distractions surrounding them that could easily take them away from the game at hand. It is much easier for one to quickly exit a game once frustration starts to mount when the winnings are slow to come. Also, as previously stated, the potential revenue gained from online casinos has not been as high as once anticipated. Along with the existence of outside distractions, another reason for this occurrence – at least as seen in New Jersey – is the difficulty would-be internet gamblers faced in signing online. With online casinos trying their best to abide by state regulations, some operators may exercise an abundance of caution in assuring that players actually reside in the state, a requirement websites must meet to keep their licenses needed to conduct business.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › Aff Answers › AT: Gambling

No impact on state budgets – it’s all political hype to benefit big casino companies

Paul Carpenter 14, The Morning Call, “Internet gambling revenue would do little to ease the state's budget deficit”, http://articles.mcall.com/2014-06-05/news/mc-pc-internet-gambling-revenue-20140605_1_online-gambling-internet-gambling-budget-deficit

Pennsylvania is facing a "growing" $532.5 million budget deficit, The Morning Call reported on Wednesday, and some politicians and some casino moguls see Internet gambling as a way to "help plug" it. A legislative study, it was reported, said revenue from a tax on the profits of online gambling could run $63 million in the first year. Meanwhile, The Philadelphia Inquirer said the deficit "could soar as high as $1.2 billion" in the coming fiscal year. If we go by that figure, revenues of $63 million would represent around one-19th of the deficit. That compares to the revenue that would be raised if Pennsylvania imposed a severance tax on the billions of dollars in gas now being extracted by the environmentally controversial hydraulic fracturing process. Such a tax probably could wipe out the entire deficit in one year. Hold that thought as we discuss the way most Pennsylvania gambling casinos seem to support legislation to allow Internet gambling — as long as nobody but the casinos is allowed to profit from it. Operators of the Sands Casino in Bethlehem, however, opposed the plan, fretting over the likelihood that, the Internet being what it is, youngsters would be among those suckered into online gambling, no matter what the rules say. (If you have naughty children, and if they know where you keep your credit cards, you might be worried.) At a state Senate committee hearing on the Internet gambling idea, The Morning Call story reported, the Sands indicated it "could make money on online gambling … but it's not enough to warrant the legal and societal risks that come with it." The Sands is owned by Las Vegas billionaire Sheldon Adelson, represented at the hearing by Andy Abboud, who compared Internet gambling to what happened to the tobacco industry, which was sanctioned for targeting children. "If that new [gambling] market is youth, then this is our Joe Camel moment," Abboud testified. Wednesday's story said Jay Pagni, spokesman for Gov. Tom Corbett, also expressed concern about the way online gambling would lure children. The proposal was supported by four other casino corporations, and powerful state Senate President Joe Scarnati, R-Jefferson, said it deserves serious consideration. That brings us to the Kafkaesque soap opera involving all these powerful figures, starting with Corbett, who took millions in "campaign contributions" from gas industry robber barons in Texas and Oklahoma while granting their request to be let off the hook when it came to severance taxes. That made Pennsylvania the only gas-producing state with no such tax, imposing instead picayune "impact fees." That tax could have done wonders for Pennsylvania's public schools, in addition to preventing budget deficit woe, so when Pagni, Corbett's press flack, was wringing his hands over the effect Internet gambling may have on children, I found it amusing. Scarnati was behind the illegal legislative pay grab (later overturned) a few years ago, and he was the force behind similarly illegal legislation (never overturned) that brought slot machine casinos to Pennsylvania in the first place. It also was Scarnati who introduced the impact fees to divert attention from the need for severance taxes. (Scarnati was second only to Corbett in the amount of "campaign contribution" money from gas industry interests, according to Common Cause Pennsylvania.) In 2009, when the state was in a snit over another deficit, legislators proposed adding table games to the casino slot machines as a way of solving the problem. On that occasion, Adelson was behind the table games idea, with Sands lobbyists spending huge sums of money in Harrisburg. That was even though table games are far more effective at separating suckers from their money, societal risks be damned, and the idea was implemented. In 2011, we learned that Adelson had demanded a deed restriction to require the prohibition of any public speech critical of the casino in a Bethlehem Redevelopment Authority public area near the Sands. The suppression of free speech in a public area, it seems, is not a societal risk. Finally, you may remember how Michael Cruz, an official of the Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board, assailed me for suggesting that slot machines were rigged and that the odds of anybody other than a casino shill winning a big jackpot are 50 million to one. There is plenty of evidence for my assertion, but my favorite stories were about powerful Pennsylvania politicians, all big supporters of the gambling industry, who won big jackpots at casinos. In 2008, then-Gov. Ed Rendell, won a $2,000 jackpot at the Harrah's Casino in Chester on his third slot machine spin. That was after casino bosses steered him to a particular set of machines. Fixed? Nah. Similarly miraculous jackpots were won by other gambling industry boosters, including state Sen. Flo Fabriuzio, D-Erie, state Rep. Frank Shimkus, D-Lackawanna, and state Rep. Frank Oliver, D-Philadelphia, although the gambling industry arranged some of those miracles across the state line. So now we need Internet gambling to help solve the state's budget deficit problem. I'm not a betting man, but if I were, I'd bet the gambling industry, even without Adelson's support, gets its way on that one.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › Aff Answers › AT: Taxes

Higher state taxes erode the tax base and undermine revenue-raising

John Avlon 13, managing director of Daily Beast, “Jerry Brown Creates California Surplus Miracle, But Can It Last?” Daily Beast, January 15th, https://www.thedailybeast.com/jerry-brown-creates-california-surplus-miracle-but-can-it-last

Brown’s budget does begin to pay down the debt, but the outstanding amount dwarfs the pay-down. Of course, that hasn’t stopped liberal activists from demanding more money be spent immediately on social services, under the banner of “investment.” Moreover, there are real questions about whether the increased tax burden—especially on the wealthy—will end up eroding the state’s tax base in the near future. “There’s some doubt that high income taxpayers won’t either move to Nevada—or some other low or no-income tax state—or find other ways, such as delaying realization of cap gains, to avoid hefty new surtaxes—especially since their federal taxes are also increasing,” emails the Sacramento Bee’s Dan Walters. “California’s marginal income tax rate (federal plus state) is now highest in U.S. at highest level, about 52 percent.” But Walters acknowledges that Brown’s budget miracle is more or less legitimate, at least for now. “It’s mostly new revenue from sales and income tax hike approved by voters in November with a dash of economic recovery and a smidgen of creative bookkeeping such as slowing down some debt repayment and assuming renewal of a tax on health care providers to trigger some federal aid,” Walters’ continues. “But overall it’s mostly the new taxes.” Other Golden State observers take an even more skeptical view. “There is a reason Gov. Brown is known as Governor Moonbeam,” says KABC’s center-right John Phillips. “Structural deficits are everywhere, the nonpartisan Legislative Analyst’s Office says there’s still a $1.9 billion budget deficit, and rich people can’t cross the state line fast enough—taking revenues down almost 11 percent since the passage of his Prop 30 tax hikes with them. On the plus side, hey, we’re not Detroit!”

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › Aff Answers › AT: Taxes

Tax increases are insufficient – they can’t cover the massive scale of state budget crises

Michael Powell 11, NY Times, “Higher Taxes Wouldn’t End Some Deficits,” New York Times, January 19th, http://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/20/business/economy/20tax.html?mtrref=www.google.com

Set aside for a moment the ever-charged argument about whether income tax increases spook the wealthy and consider this question: What would an increase in the personal income tax of a size similar to that of Illinois do for other fiscally troubled states? The New York Times examined this question in three embattled places, New York, California and New Jersey. In New York, an increase of two percentage points in the state income tax could raise about $9 billion and perhaps tip the state into surplus. In California, a similar action could raise more than $13 billion, which would cover just a portion of that state’s yawning $25 billion deficit. In New Jersey, a jump of two percentage points in each of its income brackets could raise nearly $5 billion, which would probably leave the state with a $4 billion to $7 billion deficit. Under these assumptions, a household with the median income would pay at least $1,000 more a year in each of these states; a family making $200,000 would pay $4,000 more. That an income tax increase of such a size could not close budget gaps in California and New Jersey underlines the vast challenge confronting these states. In California, Mr. Brown has proposed a deep, billion-dollar cut in higher education and $4 billion worth of cuts in services for the poor and unemployed. Even a substantial increase in its state income tax — already much higher than in Illinois — would only soften the harshest blows. In Illinois, too, the income tax increase will not cover all the accumulated ills, from a multibillion-dollar deficit to a backlog of unpaid bills to its huge pension problems. For other states, though, such a tax increase would go much further in addressing at least the short-term problems. In Arizona, for instance, legislators during the last 17 years repeatedly cut income taxes, opening an annual hole of nearly $2 billion. That sum, according to Mark Muro, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution, approximates the size of the state’s annual deficit without taking into account the recession-driven drop in revenue. Matthew N. Murray, a professor at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville, who has studied state fiscal problems for the Brookings Institution, said: “In Illinois, the stark reality of the cataclysmic nature of their budget reality drove this income tax increase. But we’re going to see more states raising taxes over the course of the next few years largely because there’s only so much cutting you can do.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › Aff Answers › AT: Taxes

State taxes are cannibalized---doesn’t raise revenue.

David Gamage & Darien Shanske 17, David Gamage, Professor, Indiana University Maurer School of Law – Bloomington, and Darien Shanske, Professor, UC Davis School of Law, “Article: Tax Cannibalization And Fiscal Federalism In The United States,” Northwestern University Law Review, 111 Nw. U.L. Rev. 295, 2017

In theory, the tax cannibalization problem may occur whenever state governments and the federal government levy taxes on overlapping tax bases. We demonstrate that the tax cannibalization problem currently does occur with respect to state-level taxes on corporate income and capital gains, and possibly also ordinary income. n9 Specifically, we show that state governments' current top tax rates on these bases impose large, wasteful costs through tax cannibalization. [*299] Extrapolating from the existing empirical literature, we develop a model showing that a typical state's top corporate income and capital gains tax rates generate surprisingly large economic waste. n10 We propose federal-level reforms that could eliminate much of this economic waste while still maintaining the current levels for state governments' revenues and distribution. Through enacting these reforms, the federal government could produce a "win, win, win" for the federal government, state governments, and taxpayers. Let us now briefly elaborate the nature of the tax cannibalization problem with an example of state-level corporate income taxes. State-level corporate income taxes are currently vulnerable to a variety of distortionary responses that shrink the states' corporate income tax bases. These distortionary responses include various forms of tax avoidance and tax gaming. It is useful to divide these distortionary responses into two conceptual categories. The first conceptual category consists of distortionary responses that involve taxable activity relocating to other states. We label this category as "horizontal distortions." Because horizontal distortions involve taxable activity relocating across state lines, but remaining within the United States, horizontal distortions do not necessarily shrink the federal government's corporate income tax base. Important examples of horizontal distortionary responses to state-level corporate income tax rates include corporate taxpayers shifting their physical presence and sales activities from states that levy higher corporate income tax rates to states that levy lower corporate income tax rates. n11 The second conceptual category consists of the remaining distortionary responses that do not involve taxable activity relocating to other states. We label this category as "vertical distortions." In contrast to horizontal distortions, vertical distortions do typically shrink the federal government's corporate income tax base. Important examples of vertical distortionary responses to state-level corporate income tax rates include corporate taxpayers shifting real investment activities abroad, corporate taxpayers shifting reported profits to subsidiaries in foreign jurisdictions, corporate taxpayers shifting from equity financing to debt financing, and [*300] business taxpayers shifting from the use of corporate forms to partnership forms. n12 Vertical distortionary responses are the primary source of the tax cannibalization problem. Because vertical distortionary responses shrink both the state government's corporate income tax base and the federal government's corporate income tax base, vertical distortionary responses to state-level corporate income tax rates deprive the federal government of tax revenue. Moreover, the federal government levies much higher tax rates on the bases of corporate income, ordinary income, and capital gains, than do any state governments. Consequently, the federal government suffers much greater harm from vertical distortionary responses to state-level tax rates on these bases than do the state governments setting these tax rates. When vertical distortionary responses to a state government's tax rate deprive both the federal government and other states' governments of revenue, in the aggregate, we refer to this as "tax cannibalization." Throughout the remainder of this Article, we explain how tax cannibalization currently biases state governments' tax policy decisions and thereby results in large-scale economic waste. Indeed, we approximate that - because of tax cannibalization - the top corporate income and capital gains tax rates in some states currently exceed their national revenue-maximizing levels. In other words, reducing these tax rates could actually increase the overall tax revenues raised (in the aggregate) by the acting state government, the federal government, and other state governments. There are at least three reasons why the tax cannibalization problem is especially severe in the context of fiscal federalism in the United States. n13 First, state governments mostly piggyback on the federal government's tax-base-definition rules for corporate and personal income taxes. Second, the federal government currently levies tax rates on these bases that are amongst the highest in the world. Third, under the federal government's current tax-base-definition rules, the corporate income and capital gains tax bases are rather vulnerable to tax avoidance and tax gaming responses. The combination of these three factors results in state-level tax rates on corporate income and capital gains generating very large tax cannibalization.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › Aff Answers › AT: Currency

States are constitutionally blocked from printing US dollars because of gov 101. Other currencies would not work.

James Kielkopf 14, Economist, Public Policy Consultant, Farmer, 7-23-2014, "Why doesn't the US Government print its own money?," Quora, https://www.quora.com/Why-doesnt-the-US-Government-print-its-own-money

Why we borrow as a means of creating money today The Federal Reserve was established as a politically agreeable solution to the pernicious problem of creating and disposing of money in a way that was deemed fair, reduced systemic financial risk, and contained internal rules which helped to prevent Congress from intervening in monetary policy in ways deemed hazardous to the nation's economic health but perhaps advantageous to a few politicians and their special interest constituents. Other ways of doing the exact same thing could have been done instead, including just letting Congress print the money it needs to pay its bills instead of taxing people (as it did during the US Civil War). But the central banking concept was implemented because it was seen to function more or less well in other countries and it allowed the American right wing to retain a kind of check on the limits of the power of the state to just print money and go into the business of producing things, pushing private industry aside by buying all of the productive assets. If forced to borrow money, and if forced to convert such currency to a rare, limited commodity like gold, at least Congress would be required to reconcile high levels of spending with higher interest rates and gold scarcity, providing an institutional brake on public spending. The US Federal Reserve was thus born out of the ongoing struggle between the rich to limit what government can take from them and the poor, to limit the damage the rich can do to them with their unreliable casinos from which markets for labor were based. What if we cut the Fed out of the middle? Anyone, except US States, can print their own currency and try to use it. The problem is finding someone who will accept it as payment -- the market for such a currency. Because the US Government requires citizens to pay taxes in US Dollars and nothing else, it creates a situation where people have to run around performing tricks throughout the year (perform labor for others o by selling other assets to others) to acquire enough pieces of paper called US Dollars to pay their taxes, providing a guaranteed market for such notes. This creates a condition where US Dollars become more acceptable than other other currency with higher risk of not finding a liquid market of things for which to exchange it, so everyone ends up using US dollars for everything, nowadays even in other countries.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › Aff Answers › Rights Turn

States can’t solve geographic inequalities, rights-based advantages, or racial discrimination. Federal standards are key to avoid local preferences in implementation.

Sarah K. Bruch et al 22, associate professor in the Joseph R. Biden, Jr. School of Public Policy and Administration and the Department of Sociology and Criminal Justice at the University of Delaware. Janet C. Gornick is a professor of political science and sociology, director of the Stone Center on Socio- Economic Inequality, and the James M. and Cathleen D. Stone Distinguished Chair in Socio- Economic Inequality at the Graduate Center at the City University of New York. Joseph van der Naald is a PhD candidate in the sociology program at the Graduate Center of the City University of New York. "Geographic Inequality in Social Provision: Variation across the US States" Measuring Distribution and Mobility of Income and Wealth, Chapter 16. //pipk

Over the past decade, inequality has gained increasing prominence in academic and policy circles. Importantly, one of the most significant shifts in the study of inequality is a growing appreciation of geographic inequality, specifically inequality across the 50 US states. Sparked in part by the landmark work of Raj Chetty and his colleagues, which has demonstrated that geography matters— where a child is born, or where an economically vulnerable family lands, shapes their wellbeing, and ultimately their life chances (Chetty and Hendren 2018; Chetty, Hendren, and Katz 2016; Chetty et al. 2020). Growing attention to the geographic aspects of inequality has focused greater attention on distributional inequalities within and between particular settings and jurisdictions (country, state, or local area). Social policy and policy variation are central to our understanding of these distributional inequalities.

The recent economic and public health crises— from the Great Recession of 2008 to the COVID- 19 pandemic— shine a bright light on these geographic inequalities and raise important political and policy questions not just about the extent of government or public responsibility for provision in relation to market or family responsibilities (Esping- Andersen 1990; Titmuss 1958) but, just as importantly, about what level of government might most efficiently, effectively, or equitably take on that public responsibility (Beland and Chantal 2004; Freeman and Rogers 2007; Obinger, Castles, and Leibfried 2005). Such jurisdictional or geographic inequalities are especially important for economically vulnerable families. Not only do the demographic and employment characteristics of poor families leave them disproportionately exposed to economic dislocations and business cycles (Bitler, Hoynes, and Kuka 2017; Moffitt and Ziliak 2020), but their place of residence and the ways they are positioned in relation to a shifting, geographically variable safety net offer a disparate and uneven policy response (Jusko and Weisshaar 2019; Laird et al. 2018). A bright light has also been pointed at not only the racially disproportionate impact of these economic and public health crises but also the multifaceted ways that racism is embedded in the design and implementation of social safety net policies (Alexander and Stivers 2020; Carten 2016; Michener 2019; Soss, Fording, and Schram 2011).

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › Aff Answers › No Equity

Local administration isn’t uniform, results in less uptake and reinforces inequality

Sarah K. Bruch et al 22, associate professor in the Joseph R. Biden, Jr. School of Public Policy and Administration and the Department of Sociology and Criminal Justice at the University of Delaware. Janet C. Gornick is a professor of political science and sociology, director of the Stone Center on Socio- Economic Inequality, and the James M. and Cathleen D. Stone Distinguished Chair in Socio- Economic Inequality at the Graduate Center at the City University of New York. Joseph van der Naald is a PhD candidate in the sociology program at the Graduate Center of the City University of New York. "Geographic Inequality in Social Provision: Variation across the US States" Measuring Distribution and Mobility of Income and Wealth, Chapter 16. //pipk

The decentralized nature of the social safety net for economically vulnerable families with children is one of the most important structural features of the US welfare state. Our research establishes that the extent of crossstate variation in the generosity and inclusiveness of safety net provision is extensive, thus constituting a crucial form of inequality— inequality in the treatment of similar needs and claims by people who happen to live in different states.

We argue that this form of inequality deserves more sustained attention, particularly with regard to policy design and reform. In designing social policies, there is a clear trade- off between uniformity through national provision, reflective of equality in social rights and equity considerations, and variability through state or local provision, indicating substantial inequality in rights and a lack of centralized effort aimed at equity in provision (Obinger, Castles, and Leibfried 2005). As Aaron Wildavsky (1985) famously noted, “federalism means inequality”— and our work confirms that.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › Aff Answers › No Equity

Geographic disparities means states can’t redistribute. Some states are just too poor, federal action is key

Brian Highsmith 19, Skadden Fellow, National Consumer Law Center. "The Implications of Inequality for Fiscal Federalism (or Why the Federal Government Should Pay for Local Public Schools)" 67 Buff. L. Rev. 407 //pipk

Many have missed the deep implications of economic inequality for core tenants of fiscal federalism. This framework shows that debates about the proper assignment of redistribution assume a different character depending on the preexisting level of inequality within the political community. Specifically, economic inequality raises the stakes of "fiscal splintering" for redistributive outcomes and possibilities: where economic resources are unevenly distributed across geography, the spatial definition of fiscal units takes on great significance. And the presence of economic inequality places a ceiling on local governments' ability to provide public goods or achieve redistribution, absent centrally-coordinated fiscal transfers.

Traditional models of fiscal federalism overlook this important relationship. Orthodox models of decentralization argue that location-mobility of residents is a disciplining measure for local governments. The consensus view is that mobility limits the ability of local governments to achieve redistribution, because high-income people will exit when it is attempted. 97 Others point to evidence showing that locations decisions are relatively inelastic to support their conclusion that redistribution can happen at the local level.98 I show that this debate does not need to be settled in order to conclude that rising levels of economic inequality support moving redistribution to higher levels of governance.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › Aff Answers › States Fail

States can’t solve – bureaucracy, lack of insulation from external market, and inability to deficit spend

Saas and Williams ’20

(William Saas and Alex Williams, Economist at employ america masters in economics from bard university specializes in governmental automatic stabilizers Professor of Practice of Communication at Tulane University, “MONEY, MUSIC & METHOD WITH ALEX WILLIAMS”, Money On the Left, July 15, 2020, ) OC

Alex Williams: I meant in terms of what the proposal is, because the real serious proposal is that all of this stuff, funding wise, should be federalized. There’s no good reason to tie school quality to local wealth. There’s no good reason to tie infrastructure quality to local wealth. That whole structure exists just to replicate inequalities. There’s like no other reason for it, which is one of those things that MMT makes very obvious. Prior to thinking through MMT, you go, “Oh, no, these have to be tied to that because where are they going to get the money to pay for it?” If you take the MMT lens, then you go, “Oh, obviously these just need to be federalized.” It’s always already federalized after a fashion. It’s just that it’s being done so using a metric for calculating it that intentionally reinforces these inequities. So the big way is this stuff should all be federalized. States are basically outdated, illegitimate forms at this point. Maybe they should exist as administrative arms that don’t decide what the funding is. The smaller way of thinking about this is that you need to insulate states and locals from the business cycle, because they have no real ability to impact it. But it has a huge ability to impact them. And they have no ability to defend themselves from that impact. And so, the thesis project that I did was basically like, how do we provide intra-governmental stabilizers? Because there’s always been a lot of work on automatic stabilizers, generally. Things like, if unemployment goes up, there’s less spending, but then also, the government spends more on paying unemployment benefits so they kind of net out. Or like, “Oh, if income goes down, the amount of taxes taken out goes down also so the total net amount of income that leaves the economy is smaller because they automatically stabilize one another.” They ensure that the amount of demand is kept within a given band rather than allowed to vary freely. That happens for the economy as a whole, but given that states are unable to basically set up big fancy capital structures that make it so that their revenues and expenditures are correlated to one another, they need to be externally protected from the business cycle. And so, I was like, “Okay, so how do we do that?” Because, if you think about this as a condensed government balance sheet…let me take a step back here. So say there’s a recession, right? We all know that in a recession, the role of the government is to spend more money. Scott Ferguson: I’m not sure Congress knows that. Alex Williams: Haha yeah, although I bet Michael Bennett’s office knows this. Jerome Powell may know this. But the goal of the government as a consolidated entity–so state, municipal, and federal–is to spend more as a consolidated entity when the economy gets worse. This is easy at the federal level because of all these automatic stabilizers we were talking about. At the federal level, they can just spend. We’re in MMT land, we don’t have to provide justification for this. The problem is that as they’re doing that states and locals, because of their unique administrative status and unique legislative history and unique political orientations, are forced into doing the opposite of what should be done. In a recession, they cut spending and raise taxes because a lot of them have balanced budget amendments and a lot of them have statutory balanced budget requirements. But what’s interesting about it is that they are done locally. Each state has one in its constitution, as opposed to the eurozone, where there is a central authority that is saying you guys can’t go above X/Y debt and deficit relative to income. The states all individually are putting this on themselves and saying they vow not to do this because of a previous era where they are trying to do a confidence play to attract investment. They say “We’re not going to go bust as a state that looks…” It’s very Deadwood era. It’s very wild west. Everybody thinks that the government is just another kind of company. We need to prove that we’re not going to go bust so we’re going to have these balanced budget amendments. Last time there was a state that was actually bailed out was in the 1840s. The problem is basically that states can’t run deficits and have a tax base that is basically on flows and have a spending base that is basically on flows. So, their tax base is all things that change as flow rate variables–their income taxes, their corporate taxes, their sales taxes. When unemployment goes up, those tax revenues go down. And when unemployment goes down, those tax revenues go up. The problem is that when their tax revenues go down, their spending requirements go up–things like Medicaid, things like state level unemployment rolls. Spending goes up. And so, they are forced into a position where they either have to raise taxes to cover the additional spending, or cut spending on unrelated projects in order to not run a budget deficit. Municipalities are in the same scrap basically, except they are allowed to issue debt, but they’re subject to very stringent market discipline. Municipal bond yields spiked in 2008 and spiked in 2020. And we’re at a position where, if everybody suddenly gets worried, then they can no longer issue previously democratically approved bonds in order to build this, that, or the other thing. So this big systemic weakness is that everything below the federal level is mechanically procyclical. And this is the basic problem that the thesis is seeking to address. What can we implement so that is no longer the case? And the answer is we just have the federal government develop a mechanism for identifying when there is a recession, and then use that as a trigger to disperse money to states because they know that when unemployment moves, state tax revenues move. And so, we can balance those things out on net using econometric tools at our disposal and using the very safe assumption that it does not matter what size deficit the federal government runs. So that’s basically what the thesis is. And what a lot of the work since then has been is how exactly would you calculate the amount of money? How administratively would you set up the departments that would allocate that money? How should that money be allocated? How long should it go? Is there any legislative precedent? Yes, there is. There was an office of revenue sharing under the Treasury in the 1970s. So that’s how MMT ramifies down to the state and local level. The federal level can basically insulate the state and local level from any shocks if it so desires. Ideally, it would replace them entirely in terms of funding and would be just funding allocations from a single source. But that’s a much bigger haul than introducing new intra-governmental stabilizers.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › Aff Answers › Fiscal Volatility Turn

State redistribution is bad, exacerbates the consequences to recessions because it’s reliant on volatile income tax for revenue,

John R. Brooks II 14, Associate Professor of Law, Georgetown University Law Center. Fiscal Federalism as Risk-Sharing: The Insurance Role of Redistributive Taxation, 68 Tax L. Rev. 89 //pipk

This Article takes a new look at the tax assignment question and argues that the literature has largely misidentified the costs of state redistributive tax-and-transfer systems. The relevant costs, at least within the range of plausible current policies, are not from tax migration and crippling state tax competition, but rather from poor risk management - suboptimal insurance against income shocks, both for states and their residents. Thus states have some space to perform redistribution, but insurance against low income should be addressed nationally. The problem is that the central tool for both redistribution and income insurance is the same: the progressive income tax.

A redistributive tax-and-transfer system, and a progressfive income tax in particular, not only funds the operations of government and provides for income redistribution, but also acts as a form of insurance against uncertain future income. This aspect of a progressive income tax is often forgotten in analyzing the tax, and that is particularly true in the fiscal federalism literature. 3 Because a progressive income tax provides for relatively high taxes when incomes are high, and for low taxes, exemptions, and transfers when incomes are low, it acts to reduce the volatility in annual after-tax income for taxpayers, and reducing volatility is the classic function of insurance. Thus one can distinguish the redistributive function of an income tax - redistributing income from those with high ability or endowment to those with low ability or endowment - from the insurance function of an income tax - a given taxpayer paying some premium today that is a function of the expected value of potential transfers to her in the future.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › Aff Answers › No Money

Jobs guarantee will be the most expensive undertaking of the US; no way states can fund.

Gulker ‘18 (Max Gulker has a PhD in Senior Research at Fellow American Institute for Economic Research.)

The primary goal of this report is to show why a federal job guarantee is a clear-cut case in which the proposed cure is worse than the disease. The proposals described by the CBPP and Levy reports would constitute nothing less than the single largest government intervention in US economic history. According to the reports’ own estimates, a federal job guarantee would incur a higher cost in one to two years than the entire New Deal in today’s dollars.4 A federal job guarantee would be monumentally expensive, return only limited value from the participants’ work, entail administrative challenges nearly impossible to solve, and be potentially disastrous for economic growth and the private labor market. Relying on rigorous but basic economics and data analysis, we find the following: • Job-guarantee participants would be placed in a system that eschewed the most fundamental ways that markets provide information and incentives, such as competition and freely set wages (section 3). • Under the authors’ own projections of ten to seventeen million participants, a federal job guarantee would, by several-fold, create the world’s largest organization (public or private) measured by employees (section 4). Under the authors’ own projections, the program’s annual cost would be comparable to that of the Pentagon (section 4).

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › Aff Answers › No Money

State budgets are running low—no way to fund jobs guarantee.

Schleider ’23 (David Schleicher is a professor at Yale Law School. He is the author of the book In a Bad State: Responding to State and Local Budget Crises.) https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/06/state-budgets-federal-funding-california-new-york/674264/

In its place will be a period of state fiscal retrenchment. Between the huge buckets of federal aid and the strong economy of the past few years, state budgets have never been healthier. Some states and cities have used this time to address long-standing fiscal problems and to sock away significant “rainy day” funds, which will ease the coming crunch. But others have not, instead using the money to build out new government programs or cut taxes, policies that will prove hard to reverse even when budgets get tighter. And they are getting tighter. Across the country, state and local tax and other revenues are declining, and the outcome will be particularly bad for transit agencies dependent on farebox revenue where many fewer people are riding transit and for cities reliant on downtown commercial property taxes where more people are working from home. When the flow of federal money to state and local budgets runs out, some jurisdictions—including California, Illinois, and New York City—will face enormous budget gaps. People have become used to the state and local politics that were ushered in by the full budgets written amid the growing economy of the late 2010s, and the boom in state revenue around COVID. During these flush years, even some liberal politicians supported tax cuts and even some conservative ones supported increasing pay for teachers. The next few years will not look like that. Rather than new programs and tax reductions, we are going to see a number of states and localities forced to cut back. Police departments will be partially defunded not because of political preferences but because of fiscal necessity, despite worries about crime; class sizes in public schools will increase because fewer teachers will be hired. Federal efforts to encourage green infrastructure will be partially frustrated by declining state and local investment. Some places will raise taxes. And, in the medium term, we are likely to see severe fiscal crises in at least a few jurisdictions, like what we saw in Detroit in 2013.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › Aff Answers › No Money

States fail at managing fiscal responsibilities.

Rocco ’20 (Rocco teaches Political Science at Marquette University in Milwaukee, Wisconsin) https://epublications.marquette.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1096&context=polisci_fac

Slide decks and press conferences notwithstanding, COVID-19 exposes not merely failures of leadership, but the structural defects of America’s brand of federalism as well. The allocation of critical responsibilities to state governments — from the financing of social programs to the administration of elections — has left civil and social rights dependent on one’s state of residence. States’ limited fiscal capacities make them particularly ill-suited for financing key responsibilities, including and especially public health, in the midst of an economic crisis. Furthermore, interstate competition for capital investment incentivizes states to decrease tax stringency and weaken labor protections. As Harold Laski put it in 1938, for states to compete with “the integrated power of giant capitalism is to invite defeat in every element of social life.” Given federalism’s impact on the COVID-19 response, the publication of Donald F. Kettl’s The Divided States of America: Why Federalism Doesn’t Work could hardly be more timely. A renowned scholar of public administration and intergovernmental relations, Kettl offers a lucid, searing critique of American federalism as a contributor to growing socioeconomic inequalities, both within and among states. Moreover, this inequality, he argues, has fueled a broader decline in Americans’ trust in government, as well as polarization and dysfunction in Washington, DC. Reversing these outcomes, Kettl suggests, will require major changes to the fiscal and administrative relationships among federal, state, and local governments. Yet in the absence of a more fundamental political reconstruction — including a restoration of the right to vote, a recovery of the right to organize and join a union, and the abolition of the carceral state — the structural inequalities of American federalism are likely to endure.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › NET-BENEFITS › NB – Federalism

Federal funding makes federal regulation inevitable – this hampers state autonomy

Neal McCluskey, 17. Director of the Cato Institute’s Center for Educational Freedom. “For the Love of Choice, Don’t Federalize It,” March 14, 2017. https://www.cato.org/publications/commentary/love-choice-dont-federalize-it

Federal money means federal regulation We should protect federalism both to ensure that differing methods of delivering choice can be tried without having to compete against a choice monopolist—an oxymoronic but all-too-real concept when discussing the feds—and to prevent national homogenization of private schools via the kinds of regulations that inevitably get attached to federal dough. On the first major concern—avoiding a monopoly choice system—I believe the most meaningful form of accountability is having to satisfy parents. But while I oppose most rules and regulations on schools participating in choice programs, I would never declare that my preferred amount of regulation is always and everywhere incontrovertibly right. Research does not make a slam-dunk case for any specific system. Research is limited, as are our minds. The way we learn what’s best now and continue to discover methods that may be better is to allow free action on a level playing field. Federalism helps us do just that. On the second point—federal “help” rendering once-autonomous private institutions increasingly homogenous—all major forms of choice are susceptible to government control to varying degrees. The danger is far greater when that control comes from Washington, because you can’t even move to another state to escape it.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › NET-BENEFITS › NB – Federalism

The CP gives state taxation authority and enhances federalism

Ruth Mason, 11. Visiting Associate Professor of Law, Yale Law School; Associate Professor of Law and Nancy and Bill Trachsel Corporate Law Scholar, University of Connecticut Law School. “Federalism and the Taxing Power,” California Law Review 99.4 (2011): 975-1035, JSTOR.

If Congress uses tax expenditures and penalties to regulate areas traditionally or constitutionally reserved to the states, then such tax regulation raises federalism concerns similar to those raised when Congress makes conditional grants to the states.95 Thus, to the extent that we are concerned about the federalism impact of conditional grants, arguably we also should be concerned about the federalism impact of tax expenditures and penalties. Among the values that federalism promotes is horizontal competition among the states for residents who are free to move to any state in the Union. Competition forces state governments to respond to the political preferences of their residents.96 The states’ smaller size compared to that of the nation also may facilitate political participation,97 at least when a single voter’s voice carries more weight in state than federal elections.98 Similarly, the smaller size of states, coupled with uneven distribution of voter preferences across the country, facilitates policy diversity: each state can adopt policies that reflect the preferences of its residents, which may differ from national preferences or from preferences of residents of other states.99 Closely related to this is the idea that states may devise different ways to pursue similar policy goals, thus serving, in Justice Brandeis’ famous words, as “laborator[ies]” for “social and economic experiments.”100 Federalism also promotes vertical competition between the federal and state governments. Although the federal and state governments do not compete for residents, James Madison predicted that they would compete for the affections of the governed.101 For any regulatory area not exclusively assigned to the federal or state governments by the Constitution, Madison envisioned that the people would choose their regulator.102 If they trusted the federal government more, the people would invest more power with the federal government, or vice versa. 103 In this way, Madison believed that the federal and state governments would check each other, so that neither would become oppressive.104 It is not necessary to repeat at length here the well-known claim that conditional federal spending jeopardizes federalism values.105 Instead, it should suffice to draw the analogy between federal grant spending and federal tax spending. When it conditions grants upon states’ implementation of particular policies, the federal government thereby reduces the scope for state policy experimentation and competition. Similarly, when the federal government uses federal tax law to reach past the states to regulate private taxpayer behavior though tax expenditures and penalties, it may leave less room for states to implement different or contrary policies. Where federal tax incentives reward taxpayers for engaging in particular activities, such as education,106 home ownership,107 and the purchase of private health insurance,108 those tax incentives may displace the expression of local values and local political preferences. Similarly, to at least some extent the federal government may override local political decisions when it uses tax penalties to discourage certain activities, such as smoking, gambling, and driving. If, in order to secure federal subsidies or avoid federal penalties, taxpayers strive to meet federal (rather than local) standards, then the taxing power raises concerns similar to those raised by the spending power.109 Specifically, if the federal government uses its taxing power to enlarge the scope of its regulatory influence beyond its constitutionally enumerated powers, it reduces the areas in which the states can compete with the federal government and with each other. Thus, just as commentators have accused Congress of using conditional federal grants to crowd out state regulation,110 so too may Congress use federal taxes to crowd out state regulation. Ultimately, the extent of this problem depends on unanswered empirical questions regarding the extent to which federal taxing and spending displaces state and local regulation in similar substantive areas. The impact of federal taxes on state legislative choices also depends on legal questions, such as whether the federal government may use taxes to achieve ends that lie beyond its other constitutionally enumerated powers, and whether such regulation can preempt state taxes and regulations. Parts II and III consider these legal issues.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › NET-BENEFITS › NB – Localism

Local authority is key to respond to existential challenges – municipalities matter most

Price, 21 – Ben Price. CELDF Community Organizer. Ben was our first community rights organizer. He joined the staff in 2004, focusing on communities in Pennsylvania.

[Ben Price, "BOOK FOREWORD: Empowering Municipal Sustainability," CELDF, 10-9-2021, https://celdf.org/2021/10/book-foreword-enabling-municipal-sustainability/, accessed 2-9-2023]

In Empowering Municipal Sustainability: A Guide for Towns, Cities, and Citizens, Alexandra Lajoux presents an extensive review of tools available to citizens and to locally elected officials in their quest to respond to constituent demands for community sustainability. The book has global reach but is made in America, where citizen empowerment is sorely lacking. Most Americans seem to believe that all the governing that matters happens in state capitols and in Washington D.C.—and those centers of power are far beyond our reach and influence. The reason for this outward-looking stance toward government, and perhaps for Lajoux’s presentation of options for the governments located in our own hometowns, is that community residents have generally given up hope that local authority exists to set policy and respond to quality of life and existential challenges, such as the relationship between local industrial and extractive projects and cancer rates, habitat loss, and climate change. When it comes to decisions being made about our communities — all without public input or consent — the general consensus seems to be, as the saying goes, you can’t fight City Hall. People don’t bother asking anymore why does it so often have to be a fight? They just don’t bother. What may be mistaken for apathy and disengagement from the public life of community is in fact a general malaise and resignation stemming from once vibrant local engagement that was met by downward looks and shaking heads, as municipal officials intoned again and again, we wish we could help, but our hands are tied. Most Americans not only wouldn’t think to try using their municipal government to vindicate local interests and aspirations; they just flat-out don’t think seriously about the government closest to them. They’ve been trained to stay away from public meetings of the local government, with the imposition of three-minute public comment sessions — before municipal meetings address substantive issues; and with often-conflicted citizen advisory committees that have no power and amount to a repository for tabled issues where all good ideas go to die. The setting aside of their aspirations for the future of their community has been normalized by the routine granting of conditional uses and variances to the comprehensive plans and the zoning laws intended to realize those aspirations. The threat of unbudgetable litigation from corporate applicants for permits at-odds with local aspirations account for the constant recommendations from municipal attorneys to grant variances and ignore toothless, aspirational documents like comprehensive land use plans. I’ll be honest: my long experience working with municipal leaders and fed-up residents has taught me that many of the tools reviewed here by Alexandra Lajoux don’t work and were never intended to work when the interests of the community conflict with the commercial interests of large corporations. When People try to use municipal government to protect their community and local environment from, for instance, state chartered and permitted waste disposal and resource extracting businesses, they discover how thoroughly the law has been crafted to eliminate local governing authority over corporate behavior within a municipality’s nominal jurisdiction. So, why this emphasis on municipal government as the last, best hope for achieving sustainability? Lajoux makes clear that it’s within our municipally-organized hometowns that all the living and dying, all the industrial assaults on our environment and all the first-hand encounters with the challenges of modern life occur. It’s where we live and laugh and love, and for each of us, it’s the place that matters most in the world. Alexandra Lajoux is an optimist, trying to uncover every possible avenue for municipal governments and their citizens to achieve local sustainability. From assessing challenges to sustainability, to making an inventory of available assets, to developing a practical plan to realize a community’s sustainability aspirations, Lajoux charts an idealistic path, using tools like comprehensive land use planning, zoning, land trusts, equitable taxation and budgeting. It is hard not to notice that the author touches on these and many other tools and processes in her exploration of the role municipalities might play in achieving sustainability goals, but in the end her recommendation is for a less traditionally constrained strategy. In fact, in Chapters 10 and 11, Lajoux minces few words as she advocates for the two cornerstones of the Community Rights strategy: The Right of Local, Community Self-Government, and the Rights of Nature. These two legal concepts depart radically from the deprivations of democratic governance that are laced throughout the highly restricted menu of hierarchically administered legal codes and regulations proffered as the outer contours of municipal authority. This volume can serve as a civics lesson worth getting familiar with. It is a necessary addition to the collective knowledge of local self-government and a guidebook, as the title suggests, for “Towns, Cities and Citizens,” which covers traditional authorities and processes your hometown can try-out in the quest for real sustainability. But it’s necessary to say, as Lajoux’s concluding chapters suggest, that the pathological relationship between municipal, state, and federal power makes local sustainability all but illegal when the interests of the public come into conflict with the interests of the so-called “private sector.” The whole of the U.S. judiciary has privileged that “private sector” with legal rights that immunize corporate actors from public governance. Hence the need for a radical approach to living well, democratically, and justly, in the face of a received system of law that does violence with impunity to our families, our natural environment, our civic lives and our most cherished values.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › NET-BENEFITS › NB – Localism

Localism solves existential environmental and socioeconomic risks – key to both the proximate efficacy of policy and a race to the top informing global policy – especially on climate and inequality

Murray ‘19 [Ashley Murray, D.C. Bureau Chief at the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, MA Media Communication, specialization in Environmental Journalism, Point Park University; internally quoting Joseph Sabino Mistick, Duquesne University law professor, and George Dougherty, University of Pittsburgh public administration professor; “Sticking their tongue out and sticking their nose in -- cities try to tackle social issues,” Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 6-2-2019, https://www.post-gazette.com/local/city/2019/06/02/Is-action-at-the-city-level-a-trend-Experts-and-mayors-say-yes-and-no/stories/201906020044]

Mayor Bill Peduto sat alongside business, nonprofit and education leaders at Carnegie Mellon University in April to talk about the role that cities can play — in basically, saving the planet. The panel discussion focused on the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals, 17 areas to be accomplished by 2030, including no poverty; zero hunger; gender equality; decent work and economic growth; and sustainable cities. “There’s been an amazing shift over the past 10 years in the role of cities in addressing major issues, whether climate change or [the] refugee crisis,” Mr. Peduto said. “Organizations, maybe not federal governments, understand that solutions lie at the local level.” Cities have been flexing their muscles. Albuquerque, N.M., raised the minimum wage to $8.20. Georgetown, Texas, only buys renewable energy. Minneapolis mandates paid sick leave for businesses with six or more employees. Cuyahoga County, Ohio, voted last week to ban plastic bags. And dozens of cities are refusing to aid federal law enforcement on matters of immigration, becoming so-called “sanctuary cities.” Law and municipal government experts say that cities “sticking their tongue out” at state and federal government is nothing new. Others see a trend that is wasting taxpayer money as cities like Pittsburgh take bold political stances that end up in drawn-out legal battles. While jockeying between levels of government is characteristic of a federalist system, critics argue that state power over cities is settled law. Pittsburgh's progressive agenda Since taking the reins in 2014, the Peduto administration has prioritized networking with other cities, joining up with the Rockefeller Foundation's 100 Resilient Cities. Mr. Peduto attended the U.N. climate conference in Poland in December; in April, he spoke on gun reform at the U.S. Conference of Mayors in Ohio. But several items on his progressive agenda have been challenged. Pittsburgh currently is mired in lawsuits over restrictions on firearms and requiring businesses to offer paid sick leave and landlords to accept federal low-income housing vouchers. “I stood up and said wait a minute, City of Pittsburgh, you don’t have the authority,” said the Apartment Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh’s Jim Eichenlaub. His organization won two lower court rulings against the city’s ordinance that told landlords they had to accept federal Section 8 vouchers. The city has appealed the ruling to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. Meanwhile, the state’s highest court has yet to rule on the city’s paid sick leave ordinance; it heard arguments in the fall of 2018. The city invited several more legal challenges in April when it passed three gun-control ordinances. Council members Corey O’Connor and Erika Strassburger wrote the laws in conjunction with the mayor’s office, just seven weeks after a gunman killed 11 people at the Tree of Life synagogue. Local, state and national gun-rights groups, including the National Rifle Association, filed multiple lawsuits, pointing to Pennsylvania law that prohibits local governments from regulating firearms. Mr. Peduto vows that the city will take the fight all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court. “We go through these periods in which cities choose to make political statements by adopting laws that they should know full well they do not have the authority to adopt,” said Joseph Sabino Mistick, Duquesne University law professor and former Allegheny County and City of Pittsburgh employee. “We’re seeing that quite a bit in Pittsburgh. They are political statements, ideology statements. From a common sense point of view, some of them are quite appealing, but they, in many cases, are just not legal,” he said. “… When they do that, it’s not without consequences and cost to the taxpayers.” (The city maintains it’s receiving pro bono legal representation from the national gun-control advocacy group Everytown for Gun Safety.) But state power over cities — established in a late 19th century “practical and longstanding” ruling, commonly referred to as Dillon’s Rule — isn’t going away any time soon, Mr. Mistick said. A 1907 case called Hunter v. City of Pittsburgh, which decided a debate over the joining of Pittsburgh with what was then Allegheny City, is still cited as a landmark case upholding the legal framework. If Mr. Peduto or city council want change on firearms, family leave or a whole other host of issues, they should be “knocking on doors” in Harrisburg, Mr. Mistick said. A trend? So is city action on hot-button issues a trend? Yes and no, experts say. “In a lot of ways in the history of U.S., this actually has been going on from the very beginning,” said George Dougherty, a University of Pittsburgh public administration professor. Before World War II, the federal government was limited in scope, and “it was the New Yorks and Chicagos and New Orleans of the world that brought about substantial changes ... that made cities a lot cleaner. Public health became a focus, and the leaders in that really were cities,” he said. It’s not odd for them to take the lead, he said. Think: LGBTQ protections. “What is odd and interesting is that now cities are beginning to flex more muscle in taking on issues that have been defined as federal in the past 30 or 40 years,” he said. A popular argument from proponents for local action is that gridlock in Washington is pushing cities to act. Another argument is that the trend is not so much in cities taking action, but in the “rapid adoption” of preemptive legislation, as Lauren E. Phillips details in a 2017 Columbia Law Review article. “Largely supported by organizations like the National Rifle Association” in the 1980s, Ms. Phillips writes, “almost all states now preempt local gun regulation.” In the first quarter of 2017, roughly 20 states introduced preemption bills prohibiting local employment regulations in a reaction to cities raising the minimum wage and mandating paid sick leave. Specifically, she cites an Ohio preemption law banning local governments from moving the needle on minimum wage just six months before Cleveland was to hold a public vote on the issue. According to local reports Thursday, the Ohio state Legislature has already introduced a bill that would preempt any local bans on plastic bags. Arguments for city influence Activists and elected officials point to growing urban centers as justification for a larger role in American, and global, decision-making. The U.N. predicts 68% of the world population will live in urban areas by 2050. Immigration and environment are existential issues, city advocates say. “Defending our borders, issues of citizenship and so forth are clearly federal responsibilities,” Mr. Dougherty said. “However, the way the federal government has dealt with it creates a lot of local problems.” Cities for Action, a coalition of 175 cities — to which Mr. Peduto’s name is signed — advocates for pro-immigrant federal policies and ways to manage immigration at the local level, including civics education and municipal ID programs. While they’re some of the biggest economic engines, cities also have the biggest carbon footprints. “Our studies show that about 70% of greenhouse gas emissions can be attributed to cities,” said David Miller, former Toronto mayor and North American director for C40, a network of cities committed to reducing emissions. “If cities control those levers, their action can make a direct impact.” Municipal governments often have direct control over buildings, transportation and solid waste, he said. “I just came from Tokyo where a group of cities were meeting to present on the positions the G20 should be taking to help solve issues of climate and equality,” Mr. Miller said. “That wouldn’t have been possible 20 years ago.” Those possibilities are why Pittsburgh City Councilwoman Strassburger said she’s in the camp of cities “being a hotbed of innovation.” “There’s a lot to be learned by pushing boundaries at the local level,” she said.