Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Disadvantage
AFF ANSWERS › Impact Answers › Russia Lose Turn

Helping Russia win is better – Current Ukrainian aggression will take Crimea – goes nuclear.

Rumer 23

EUGENE RUMER - Rumer, a former national intelligence officer for Russia and Eurasia at the U.S. National Intelligence Council, is a senior fellow and the director of Carnegie’s Russia and Eurasia Program.; FEBRUARY 17, 2023; Putin’s War Against Ukraine: The End of The Beginning; ; //[TMS—GK]

Even if a Ukrainian offensive is successful, notwithstanding these likely obstacles and heavy losses the Ukrainian army may suffer in the course of it, the war will not come to an end. A Ukrainian breakthrough in southern Ukraine could put at risk Russia’s hold on Crimea. The peninsula, annexed illegally by Russia in 2014, represents Putin’s most important geopolitical accomplishment. Its loss would not be an acceptable option for him, let alone a bargaining chip to use in negotiating the terms of ending the war. The annexation of Crimea was popular and welcomed by an overwhelming majority of Russians. Unlike Donbas, where the fighting has continued since 2014, Crimea was never contested militarily by Ukraine following the annexation, though it was not recognized by Ukraine as part of Russia. During the eight years preceding the February 24, 2022, escalation of Russia’s war against Ukraine, the Russian public had accepted the Kremlin’s slogan “Krym Nash” (“Crimea Is Ours”). In the eyes of the Russian public, the prospect of losing Crimea would lend credence to Putin’s claims that the war is being fought in defense of the homeland. In the past twelve months, there has been a great deal of speculation about Russian red lines and what actions by Ukraine and its Western supporters might cross them. The sinking of the Moskva, the blowing up of the Crimea bridge, and strikes well inside Russian territory were all accompanied by speculation about where those Russian red lines were and what might finally trigger a massive retaliation or even prompt Putin to order nuclear strikes against Ukraine. Putin did escalate—he ordered a partial mobilization and launched a bombing campaign against Ukrainian cities and critical infrastructure. But, thanks to Ukrainian resilience and ingenuity, the effects of this escalation proved to be less severe than had been feared, especially after Russian officials resorted to nuclear saber-rattling. The worst—a direct attack on a NATO country or a nuclear strike—did not happen, even though those suspected red lines had been crossed. This in turn led to arguments that Russia had no red lines and that they were self-imposed by the West, as well as speculation about why Putin had not yet ordered nuclear strikes. Nobody knows what could prompt Putin to resort to nuclear strikes. He no doubt understands the gravity of such a step, including the prospect of a direct NATO military response. But if there is one contingency that could move him to take it, the prospect of losing Crimea is a leading candidate among various such grim scenarios. It would amount to not just a defeat, but a humiliating defeat. Far from forcing Putin to negotiate at that point—aside from whether Kyiv would be inclined to halt its offensive with a major symbolic victory within reach—the loss of Crimea or its prospect would likely prompt him to resort to nuclear strikes. Thus, a Ukrainian breakthrough in the south of the country could be as likely to trigger a dramatic escalation of the war as to end it.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
AFF ANSWERS › Impact Answers › AT: Asia / Taiwan Impact

China won’t invade Taiwan based off of Ukraine

Menon, 23 – director of the grand strategy program at Defense Priorities, a professor emeritus at the City College of New York’s Colin Powell School for Civic and Global Leadership, and a senior research fellow at Columbia University’s Saltzman Institute of War and Peace Studies [Rajan and Daniel De Petris; 3/16/23; "What the United States Does in Ukraine Won’t Matter in Taiwan;" https://foreignpolicy.com/2023/03/16/usa-china-ukraine-taiwan-credibility-resolve/]

The o ne constant element in this slew of surprises has been the familiar claim that U.S. credibility is on the line and will rise or fall depending on the war’s result and that Ukraine must therefore be provided the weaponry it needs to prevail.

The logic underlying this assertion can be summarized as follows: If the United States does not stand firm against an adversary like Russia, some other rival, somewhere else, even one located far afield, will be emboldened to test the limits of America’s resolve. In short, every region is connected and every decision the United States makes will have global ramifications.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
AFF ANSWERS › Impact Answers › AT: Ukraine / Russia Impact – Not Nuclear

No risk of the conflict going nuclear.

Shinkman '23 – National Security Correspondent @ US News & World Report [Paul; 2/24/23; "Putin’s Hollow Nuclear Threat;" https://www.usnews.com/news/the-report/articles/2023-02-24/why-ukraine-wont-lead-putin-to-nuclear-war]

“The likelihood of Russia choosing – or Putin choosing – to use nuclear weapons directly against the West is astronomically low. It should not even be seriously considered at this stage,” says Katherine Lawlor, senior intelligence analyst at the independent Institute for the Study of War, which has fastidiously tracked Russia’s military movements since it first invaded Ukraine.

“Putin would love it if Western leaders believed that he might. He is many things, but he is not suicidal,” Lawlor says. She adds that Putin ultimately does not want war with NATO – particularly given the current state of the Russian army. “He couldn’t even win a conventional war in Ukraine.”

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
AFF ANSWERS › Turns › Renewables Cheaper

Displacement is fundable – renewables are the cheapest.

Roberts 19

David Roberts – VOX writer for energy and climate change; May 30, 2019; More natural gas isn’t a “middle ground” — it’s a climate disaster; ; //[TMS—GK]

3) Bulk renewables can displace both coal and gas In most markets, bulk renewables — utility-scale wind and solar power plants — are the cheapest form of power as measured by the “levelized cost of energy” (LCOE, which seeks to take all costs into account). This was confirmed last year by the financial advisory firm Lazard, which publishes annual LCOE estimates. BNEF also does yearly LCOE analysis and has found the same thing: The relentless decline of solar and wind costs has made these technologies the cheapest sources of new bulk electricity in all major economies, except Japan. This includes China and India, where not long ago coal dominated capacity additions, as well as the U.S., where the shale gas revolution has made gas cheap and abundant. Renewables are already driving down prices in wholesale markets and causing existing natural gas plants to be run at much lower utilization rates than they were designed (and financed) for. And renewables are only getting cheaper, while cheap natural gas can’t last forever.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
AFF ANSWERS › Turns › LNG Bad

LNG doesn’t solve climate- Methane emissions and polluting infrastructure increase emissions Gray Donald ‘22

Gray-Donald, Dave. “Don’t Buy the Hype: LNG Is Bad for the Climate.” Environmental Defence, 21 Dec. 2022, environmentaldefence.ca/2022/10/26/dont-buy-the-hype-lng-is-bad-for-the-climate/#:~:text=LNG%20emits%20about%20as%20much%20greenhouse%20gas%20(GHG)%20as%20coal&text=More%20recent%20studies%20have%20shown,while%20making%20and%20transporting%20LNG.

There is lots of talk about fossil gas these days in Canada, and it can be a lot to keep up with. So what’s going on? And what does it mean for the climate? The war in Ukraine and potential fuel shortages in countries like Germany this winter have brought the issue of gas into the spotlight. The industry is saying the world needs more fossil gas (also known as “natural gas”), exported overseas in the form of Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG). Ramping up production of fossil gas and exporting it as LNG is a threat to the climate. But industry and supportive politicians are trying to convince us that LNG is a climate solution – a “bridge fuel” away from coal and towards cleaner energy. Most LNG projects, which take years to build, have been proposed or are already under construction on the West Coast, though there are a few companies eying the East Coast too. There are three glaring reasons why LNG exports are a climate disaster and unnecessary. They are also a significant Indigenous rights concern. LNG emits about as much greenhouse gas (GHG) as coal Methane from the production of fossil gas may make LNG about as bad a greenhouse gas emitter as coal. The argument from industry has been that gas is about 50 per cent cleaner burning than coal. But a key study industry cites only looked at emissions from burning the two fuels, not at the whole process, including the extraction, refining, and shipping. More recent studies have shown LNG and coal to have closer overall emissions, and LNG sometimes being even more emitting than coal. In part, this is due to the huge amounts of methane that leak into the atmosphere while making and transporting LNG. Methane is a much more potent GHG than carbon dioxide (CO2), and methane leaks have long been massively under-reported. Large volumes of methane can be released while fracking, the process of extracting gas from shale rock. Most gas in Canada is now made by fracking. Because methane releases are still under-reported, we don’t actually know the full extent of how bad LNG really is. The Alberta government has been doing an awful job tracking and controlling methane leaks, and shows little sign of improvement despite years of promises. Overall, the case that LNG is lower-emitting than coal is dubious at best. LNG might not displace coal, and even it if does, it’s still a fossil fuel Fossil gas is still a fossil fuel! Even if it were half as polluting as coal, that is still way too polluting to reduce emissions as fast as we need to, and have a good chance at limiting catastrophic climate change. And there is no evidence that LNG exports would necessarily reduce coal use around the world. Some new LNG facilities are being built near new coal facilities. The two together just add to the overall amount of fossil fuels being used. Which is exactly what we need to avoid. Some research shows that new LNG infrastructure may actually be displacing the adoption of renewable energy in Asia. We desperately need to move to renewables, and there is momentum in that direction. So we can’t backslide to LNG. Building new LNG infrastructure is a 20-year commitment, at least Building new LNG infrastructure locks in the fossil fuel economy for decades. Because infrastructure like pipelines and LNG export terminals last 20 years or more, it means that those facilities will keep polluting that whole time. Droughts and fires and flooding are bad enough now. We can’t risk adding new massive streams of pollution that make it worse. And when fossil fuels are not extracted, it turns out overall production and consumption of fossil fuels go down. A Stockholm Environment Study calculated that when a barrel of oil is not extracted in one location, there is an overall reduction in the amount of oil being extracted globally. It is not the case, as industry tries to tell us, that if we don’t supply the oil or gas, that someone somewhere else in the world will supply just as much. It turns out that less fossil fuel being produced means exactly that: less fossil fuels being produced. And that means less emissions. LNG projects also consistently violate Indigneous rights Canadian fossil gas and LNG export infrastructure is also being built in violation of the Indigenous rights, including the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP). Canada LNG, the biggest project, is being supplied with fossil gas through the Coastal Gaslink Pipeline, which runs through unceded Wet’suwet’en territory without consent of the hereditary leaders. There are also fracking operations in other Nations’ territories which they are protesting against. Fracking operations cut people off from their lands, and pollute the water. LNG is a highly polluting fossil fuel, and one we can’t afford to bet our futures on.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
AFF ANSWERS › Turns › LNG Bad

LNG’s a bridge fuel to climate disaster – causes one-third of global warming – any shift away solves.

Qusba 23

LEAH QUSBA - Leah Qusba is the executive director of Action for the Climate Emergency (ACE)., OPINION CONTRIBUTOR - 04/14/23; G7: Liquefied natural gas is a bridge fuel to climate disaster; ; //[TMS—GK]

The eyes of the world are on Sapporo, Japan this weekend as energy ministers of some of the world’s largest economies, the G7, meet to discuss global climate and energy policy. In early versions of the G7 draft publication, countries emphasized financing liquefied natural gas (LNG) exports as a supposed bridge fuel to a clean energy future. These claims were met with alarm and disgust from scientists, activists, policymakers and even some G7 nations — and frontline groups, youth advocates and other climate advocates jumped into action to ask the Biden administration take a stand against U.S. further LNG liquefaction and export expansion. Later drafts have since walked back language on investing in LNG exports, though, there is still much in the draft to spark concern. LNG is not a bridge fuel to a clean-energy future. The production and transportation of LNG results in significant emissions of methane, a potent greenhouse gas that is responsible for approximately 30 percent of global warming. The carbon footprint of LNG is often larger than that of coal, due to the leakage of methane during the production and transportation process. It’s a bridge that ends in a hotter, more dangerous world for all of us, especially the world’s most vulnerable people and ecosystems. We cannot afford to build that bridge—one there’s no coming back from. Last year, the G7 committed to ending financial support for the fossil fuel industry by the end of 2022. However, according to a report from Oil Change International, G7 countries financed $73 billion for fossil fuel projects between 2020 and 2022, over twice the financing they provided for clean energy during this time period ($28.6 billion). And just this week, the Biden administration approved LNG exports from Alaska Gasline Development Corp’s project. Japan, the host of both this weekend’s ministerial G7 meeting and the G7 summit in late May, is a primary culprit, hiding their financial support of fossil gas projects as part of their “Green Transformation Strategy”. Fossil fuel companies, of course, are in full support of this new tactic in which they capitalize on global instability and human suffering to further rig the system in their favor. The era of fossil fuels is coming to an end — and we need to accelerate it for the sake of humanity, ecosystems and life on earth everywhere. The U.S. and other G7 governments have used taxpayer money to prop up a dying industry for too long. We have already seen the decline of coal due to market pressures as renewable energy becomes more abundant and cost-effective. Without government financing of new LNG and other gas facilities around the world, these risky, dirty and harmful new projects would be dead on arrival. Many of these same countries, including the U.S., have already signed onto an agreement reached at COP26 in Glasgow committing to end “new direct public support for the international unabated fossil fuel energy sector within one year of signing this statement [end of 2022], except in limited and clearly defined circumstances that are consistent with a 1.5°C warming limit and the goals of the Paris Agreement.” The International Energy Agency has stated that no new investments can be made in fossil fuel infrastructure if we are to keep temperatures below the 1.5 degrees Celsius. Our message to the G7 is clear: Don’t be hypocrites. Honor your commitments and end financing and support of new LNG infrastructure.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
AFF ANSWERS › Turns › LNG Bad

Gas bridging fails – methane leakage and carbon lock-in make warming inevitable, only a chance the AFF’s transition solves.

Roberts 19

David Roberts – VOX writer for energy and climate change; May 30, 2019; More natural gas isn’t a “middle ground” — it’s a climate disaster; ; //[TMS—GK]

No one knows yet what Joe Biden meant when he promised a “middle ground” on climate strategy a few weeks ago (he’s expected to release some policy shortly). But the first thing I thought of when he said it was natural gas. Biden is likely to try to signal that he’s a centrist by embracing natural gas’s role as a bridge fuel. It’s a beguiling strategy for Democrats who are fearful of being seen as too liberal. But I’m afraid it’s a dead end. You see, all those arguments for natural gas that seemed so compelling during the Obama years have fallen apart. It’s now clear that if the world is to meet the climate targets it promised in Paris, natural gas, like coal, must be deliberately and rapidly phased out. There’s no time for a bridge. And clean alternatives are ready. Since climate policy promises to be a hot item this primary season, let’s quickly review the reasons natural gas has got to go. Helpfully, the think tank Oil Change International (OCI) has just put out a paper making those very arguments. Let’s review the five topline ones for why natural gas is not, and can not be, a bridge to a cleaner energy system. Methane leakage may make natural gas as bad as coal, but it’s not the reason gas has no future The paper leads with a quick note on methane leakage in natural gas production. Methane is a fast-acting greenhouse gas with enormous short-term impacts on climate. It leaks at every stage of the natural gas production and transportation process. While gas itself is less carbon-intensive than coal, if enough methane leaks during its production, its greenhouse gas advantages are wiped out. Does that much methane leak? Some studies have suggested that, yes, methane leakage is bad enough to make natural gas the greenhouse equivalent of coal. Other studies have suggested that gas still has an advantage (and proponents note that leakage could be reduced). For our purposes here, it doesn’t matter. None of the five arguments against natural gas rely on any particular estimate of leakage. All of them would apply even if natural gas achieved zero leakage (which is impossible). The same is true regarding the local environmental impacts of natural gas production (air pollution, habitat loss, earthquakes) — they are dreadful, but even if they were eliminated, the following arguments would still apply. 1) Gas breaks the carbon budget Honestly, this one is enough to rule out gas on its own. It’s simple: Even setting aside methane leakage, there’s too much carbon in the natural gas we’ve already discovered for us to stay within the carbon budget promised in Paris. Never mind finding more — if we burn what we’ve already found, we’ll bust the budget. The world’s nations have agreed to hold the rise in global average temperatures to no more than 2 degrees Celsius, with efforts to hold it to 1.5. (You will recall that the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change report that came out last year specifically investigated the difference in impact between 1.5 and 2 degrees. Long story short: The difference is substantial and 2 degrees would be horrific.) Staying within those targets leaves humanity with a limited amount of greenhouse gases it can still release — its carbon budget. The chart below from OCI is eye-opening. On the left is the carbon content of the “developed reserves” of fossil fuels around the world, i.e., “already-operating or under-construction fields and mines.” On the right are the carbon budgets for 1.5 and 2 degrees, respectively. If we burn the fossil fuels we are already exploiting, we will use up the 2-degree budget. Even if global coal use were eliminated overnight, burning the oil and gas we’re already digging up would blow the 1.5-degree carbon budget. OCI emphasizes the obvious implication: “There is no room for new fossil fuel development — gas included — within the Paris Agreement goals.” If the countries of the world are serious about their shared targets, they must cease new fossil fuel exploration and cancel plans for new wells and mines. The IPCC says the world needs to be half decarbonized by 2030, and fully decarbonized by 2050, to hit the 1.5-degree target. To give developing countries more room, wealthy developed nations like the US should ideally decarbonize faster. To do that, the US will have to phase out all fossil fuel use as fast as it conceivably can. There’s no room for a bridge. Policymakers must begin consciously encouraging and designing energy systems that run entirely on carbon-free resources. 2) Coal-to-gas switching doesn’t cut it Shutting down coal power plants and opening gas plants in their place will generally reduce emissions, depending on a variety of variables (again including methane emissions). Coal-to-gas switching is responsible for a big chunk of the emission reductions in the US electricity sector over the past few years. But one thing is certain: Coal-to-gas switching doesn’t reduce emissions to zero. And zero-as-soon-as-possible is the goal. In its New Energy Outlook for 2018, Bloomberg New Energy Finance (BNEF) ran a scenario in which global coal use was phased out by 2035 and the market was otherwise left to work. It found that gas would fill about 70 percent of the void. That is incommensurate with Paris targets. Even with a global coal phaseout, we’ll blow through the 2-degree target, much less the 1.5-degree target, unless gas is phased out as well. Fossil fuel industries respond by pointing to the potential for “negative emissions,” but all such technologies are speculative at scale and face potentially insurmountable challenges. Allowing gas infrastructure to continue being built on the hope that negative emissions will pan out is madness. 3) Bulk renewables can displace both coal and gas In most markets, bulk renewables — utility-scale wind and solar power plants — are the cheapest form of power as measured by the “levelized cost of energy” (LCOE, which seeks to take all costs into account). This was confirmed last year by the financial advisory firm Lazard, which publishes annual LCOE estimates. BNEF also does yearly LCOE analysis and has found the same thing: The relentless decline of solar and wind costs has made these technologies the cheapest sources of new bulk electricity in all major economies, except Japan. This includes China and India, where not long ago coal dominated capacity additions, as well as the U.S., where the shale gas revolution has made gas cheap and abundant. Renewables are already driving down prices in wholesale markets and causing existing natural gas plants to be run at much lower utilization rates than they were designed (and financed) for. And renewables are only getting cheaper, while cheap natural gas can’t last forever. Of course, LCOE is a limited measure. What matters for variable renewables is not their average cost but their value at particular times and locations. Wind and solar do, after all, come and go with the weather. Which brings us to ... 4) Gas isn’t needed for grid reliability Renewable energy skeptics like to claim that natural gas power plants are required on the grid to balance out variable renewable energy, which comes and goes with the wind and sun. OCI responds with three arguments. First, most natural gas plants being built these days are combined cycle gas turbine (CCGT) plants, which produce the cheapest power. “In the United States alone, around 24 gigawatts (GW) of CCGT capacity was commissioned in 2017 and 2018, and more than 14 GW was under construction at the beginning of 2019,” writes OCI. “There is more than 425 GW of CCGT capacity in operation globally.” But CCGT plants are not the plants that can ramp up and down quickly to balance renewables. They are big and relatively slow, meant to run at high utilization rates and provide bulk power. In other words, they compete with, rather than complement, renewables. Second, the faster natural gas plants — gas reciprocating engines (GRE) and open cycle gas turbines (OCGT), or “peakers,” named for their function of spinning up during peaks of energy demand — are increasingly being beat out by batteries, which respond even quicker. Wind and solar plants coupled with battery storage — which can compete directly with peakers — are getting cheaper. OCI cites a BNEF report showing that they “are already able to compete with new coal or gas plants on an LCOE basis in Germany, the United Kingdom, China, Australia, and the United States.” For now, most utility-scale battery storage is in the four-hour range. Those battery installations are expected to get cheaper than natural gas peakers in the early 2020s. But they still have somewhat limited application. However, OCI notes, “a study by Wood Mackenzie in 2018 found that six- and eight-hour battery storage systems, which are beginning to enter commercial operation today, can address 74 percent and 90 percent of peaking demand, respectively.” Once batteries get more sophisticated and cheaper, there won’t be much left for natural gas peakers to do. (For a longer look at how natural gas is getting displaced, see my article here.) Third, OCI argues that the key to stable, reliable grids is not any individual technology but the design of power markets and power systems. Today, in dozens of sometimes subtle and technical ways, they are designed around large, centralized power plants and one-way power flows. To keep grids reliable during the energy transition, policymakers need to redesign markets to encourage diverse portfolios of energy technologies, from distributed generation to storage and demand response. (The report contains some policy suggestions.) OCI doesn’t address the thorny question of whether getting to 100 percent clean electricity requires some form of dispatchable power (power that can be turned on and off), including nuclear and possibly natural gas or biomass with carbon capture and storage. (See here and here for more on that debate.) Regardless, it’s been fairly well demonstrated that we know how to get to 80 percent renewables — if there’s a modest role for gas in getting to 100, it certainly won’t look anything like the modern gas industry. 5) New natural gas infrastructure locks in carbon When big, capital-intensive assets get built, they tend to stick around. There are more than 400 natural gas plants in the US that were built in or before 1970. (Even older than me!) Utilities are currently incentivized to build precisely those big, capital-intensive assets. And once they are built, it doesn’t take much to keep them running. “Once capital has been sunk,” OCI writes, “operators can keep running a plant as long as it can sell power for more than the marginal cost of producing it — even if it incurs a loss on the invested capital.” That means even cheaper renewables won’t necessarily drive fossil fuel plants to retirement. Yet dozens of new natural gas pipelines, power plants, and export terminals are in some stage of planning. The US is on a natural gas building binge. Every bit of that gas infrastructure being built today must be retired before it is paid off, “stranded,” if the US is to have any hope of hitting its Paris targets. The more we build in coming years, the more we will have to abandon later. It probably won’t be big utility investors who get stuck with that bill. Endorsing the IPCC targets means phasing out natural gas So far in the Democratic primary, Beto O’Rourke, Jay Inslee, and Michael Bennet have released comprehensive climate plans. All of them acknowledge the imperative for the US to completely decarbonize by 2050 (Inslee targets 2045 and sooner if possible), per the IPCC. Once that goal is in place, there is no space for expansion of natural gas infrastructure — wells, pipelines, export terminals, or power plants. That circle cannot be squared. Rather, natural gas, like coal, must be phased out of the electricity system as rapidly as practically possible, and as many energy uses as possible must be electrified as fast as possible. It’s not clear whether mainstream Democrats fully understand that yet. The battle against coal was helped along by the market. Natural gas will not go as quietly; its economic footprint is much larger. Oil and gas companies have considerably more political clout than coal companies. There’s a whole new set of battles and tricky political dilemmas ahead. Nevertheless, supporting continued buildout of natural gas assets in the US is not “moderate” climate policy, nor a “middle ground.” It is an admission of failure, an acknowledgment that the US will not do its part to avert 2 degrees of warming and the horrors that will follow in its wake. No candidate should get away with claiming otherwise.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
AFF ANSWERS › Turns › Natural Gas = Warming

U.S. LNG exports to Europe lock in greenhouse emissions

Distracts from more durable solutions to promote energy security in both the U.S. and the EU

LNG exports from U.S. not enough to replace Europe’s imports from Russia – better to focus on demand

LNG investments tradeoff with clean energy

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
AFF ANSWERS › Link Answers › Natural Gas = Renewable

Biomethane is a renewable source for natural gas that will solve climate change – it is not a fossil fuel

Underwood, 19 [April 25, 2019, Joanna; Joanna D. Underwood is founder of Energy Vision, whose mission is to analyze and promote ways to make a swift transition to pollution-free renewable energy sources and to the clean, petroleum-free transportation fuels of the future.; “A Green New Deal for Natural Gas, Why ultral-low-carbon biomethane, aka renewable natural gas, deserves more attention from policy makers” https://www.greenbiz.com/article/green-new-deal-natural-gas, LK]

The U.S. Senate voted against the Green New Deal, but its interlinked climate, job and social justice goals are still percolating. Among the issues supporters and opponents alike have flagged is what role the natural gas industry should play in advancing them.  

Natural gas long has been considered a "bridge fuel" to renewables. During the Green New Deal debate, former Department of Energy leaders from both parties argued that natural gas is part of the clean energy future, because it burns cleaner than coal or oil, reduces coal use and smoothes out the variability of solar and wind generation. 

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
AFF ANSWERS › Link Answers › No GND Link

No link – Green New Deal revised and no longer calls for an end to fossil fuels

Colman, 2-4-19 [Zach Colman, February 4, POLITICO, "Green New Deal Won't Call for End to Fossil Fuels" www.politico.com/story/2019/02/04/green-new-deal-fossil-fuels-1142544, Accessed on June 23, NP]

The first effort by congressional climate advocates to define their “Green New Deal” will omit one of the most ambitious goals its supporters have demanded, sources told POLITICO on Monday: a firm date for ending oil, gas and coal development in the U.S.

The change is a compromise that may make the proposal more politically palatable for many of the Democrats’ presidential contenders in 2020, as well as for labor groups that compose a powerful portion of the party’s base. But it will disappoint many of the progressives who have rallied and staged sit-ins in the Capitol in recent months to demand swift action on climate change.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
AFF ANSWERS › Uniqueness Answers › Renewables Increasing Now

Non-uq: Inflation reduction act expands to renewables

Isaacs-Thomas ’22 [Bella, 8/17/22, PBS, “What the Inflation Reduction Act does for green energy” https://www.pbs.org/newshour/science/what-the-inflation-reduction-act-does-for-green-energy, Accessed on 6/23/22, JR]

The legislation, signed Aug. 16 by President Joe Biden, does a lot of things, including tackling deficit reduction, health care access and prescription drug pricing, but addressing the energy industry and climate change is one of its most significant aims. “This is very much climate legislation,” said Brian Murray, interim director of the Nicholas Institute for Energy, Environment & Sustainability at Duke University, who added the bill offers “a significant bump” in the nation’s projected ability to reduce our greenhouse gas emissions. The goal of the bill is to put the country on a path to reduce greenhouse gasses by 40 percent below 2005 levels by 2030, Murray said – a meaningful increase compared to our current path, which is projected to reach a 25-percent reduction. (The U.S. has actually pledged to lower emissions by 50 to 52 percent under that same framework as part of the Paris Agreement, he noted.) That’s an important breakthrough for every living thing on Earth, but there also are more mundane benefits, including for anyone who drives a car or pays utility bills and has felt fuel costs rise this year. Every part of the economy has energy running through it — it literally “powers everything in our lives,” said Abigail Dillen, president of Earthjustice, a nonprofit that litigates environmental issues. But how we source that energy has a massive impact on the planet. The use and production of energy, which includes fuels that power vehicles and buildings, makes up the largest contribution of greenhouse gas emissions across the globe, according to the EPA. In the U.S., the transportation, electric power and industry sectors each make up around 25 percent of national emissions, the agency says. Building up the U.S. capacity to build renewable technology, like solar panels or electric vehicle components, and then ensuring people can use those things more easily by shoring up energy infrastructure is a key facet of the Inflation Reduction Act. Meanwhile, consumer-oriented provisions meant to make it more affordable for those with lower to middle incomes to access electric-powered options, from cars to heat pump systems and more.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
AFF ANSWERS › Uniqueness Answers › Biden Hurting Oil & Gas

Biden’s policies are undercutting domestic oil and gas production

Eberhart, 23 --- CEO of Canary, LLC (Feb 24, 2023,09:41am ES, Dan, “Ukraine War Illustrates Importance Of American Energy Dominance,” https://www.forbes.com/sites/daneberhart/2023/02/24/ukraine-war-illustrates-importance-of-american-energy-dominance/?sh=2cfd961570a6, JMP))

It’s why the previous administration pursued an “energy dominance” agenda – to ensure Americans were insulated from shocks to the energy market and help address global supply crises when they arise.

The Biden administration continues to treat the domestic oil and gas industry as the villain in recent events, accusing it of price-gouging, war profiteering, and, ironically, underinvesting in exploration and development of new supply despite federal policies that thwart domestic production at every turn. President Biden remains committed to a “Keep It in The Ground” strategy despite his rhetoric against high energy prices.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › IMPACTS › No Warming

Warming doesn’t cause extinction---new studies.

Nordhaus 20 Ted Nordhaus, an American author, environmental policy expert, and the director of research at The Breakthrough Institute, citing new climate change forecasts. [Ignore the Fake Climate Debate, 1-23-2020, https://www.wsj.com/articles/ignore-the-fake-climate-debate-11579795816]//BPS

Beyond the headlines and social media, where Greta Thunberg, Donald Trump and the online armies of climate “alarmists” and “deniers” do battle, there is a real climate debate bubbling along in scientific journals, conferences and, occasionally, even in the halls of Congress. It gets a lot less attention than the boisterous and fake debate that dominates our public discourse, but it is much more relevant to how the world might actually address the problem. In the real climate debate, no one denies the relationship between human emissions of greenhouse gases and a warming climate. Instead, the disagreement comes down to different views of climate risk in the face of multiple, cascading uncertainties. On one side of the debate are optimists, who believe that, with improving technology and greater affluence, our societies will prove quite adaptable to a changing climate. On the other side are pessimists, who are more concerned about the risks associated with rapid, large-scale and poorly understood transformations of the climate system. But most pessimists do not believe that runaway climate change or a hothouse earth are plausible scenarios, much less that human extinction is imminent. And most optimists recognize a need for policies to address climate change, even if they don’t support the radical measures that Ms. Thunberg and others have demanded. In the fake climate debate, both sides agree that economic growth and reduced emissions vary inversely; it’s a zero-sum game. In the real debate, the relationship is much more complicated. Long-term economic growth is associated with both rising per capita energy consumption and slower population growth. For this reason, as the world continues to get richer, higher per capita energy consumption is likely to be offset by a lower population. A richer world will also likely be more technologically advanced, which means that energy consumption should be less carbon-intensive than it would be in a poorer, less technologically advanced future. In fact, a number of the high-emissions scenarios produced by the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change involve futures in which the world is relatively poor and populous and less technologically advanced. Affluent, developed societies are also much better equipped to respond to climate extremes and natural disasters. That’s why natural disasters kill and displace many more people in poor societies than in rich ones. It’s not just seawalls and flood channels that make us resilient; it’s air conditioning and refrigeration, modern transportation and communications networks, early warning systems, first responders and public health bureaucracies. New research published in the journal Global Environmental Change finds that global economic growth over the last decade has reduced climate mortality by a factor of five, with the greatest benefits documented in the poorest nations. In low-lying Bangladesh, 300,000 people died in Cyclone Bhola in 1970, when 80% of the population lived in extreme poverty. In 2019, with less than 20% of the population living in extreme poverty, Cyclone Fani killed just five people. “Poor nations are most vulnerable to a changing climate. The fastest way to reduce that vulnerability is through economic development.” So while it is true that poor nations are most vulnerable to a changing climate, it is also true that the fastest way to reduce that vulnerability is through economic development, which requires infrastructure and industrialization. Those activities, in turn, require cement, steel, process heat and chemical inputs, all of which are impossible to produce today without fossil fuels. For this and other reasons, the world is unlikely to cut emissions fast enough to stabilize global temperatures at less than 2 degrees above pre-industrial levels, the long-standing international target, much less 1.5 degrees, as many activists now demand. But recent forecasts also suggest that many of the worst-case climate scenarios produced in the last decade, which assumed unbounded economic growth and fossil-fuel development, are also very unlikely. There is still substantial uncertainty about how sensitive global temperatures will be to higher emissions over the long-term. But the best estimates now suggest that the world is on track for 3 degrees of warming by the end of this century, not 4 or 5 degrees as was once feared. That is due in part to slower economic growth in the wake of the global financial crisis, but also to decades of technology policy and energy-modernization efforts. “We have better and cleaner technologies available today because policy-makers in the U.S. and elsewhere set out to develop those technologies.” The energy intensity of the global economy continues to fall. Lower-carbon natural gas has displaced coal as the primary source of new fossil energy. The falling cost of wind and solar energy has begun to have an effect on the growth of fossil fuels. Even nuclear energy has made a modest comeback in Asia.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › IMPACTS › AT: Worse for Emissions

U.S. adopting new regulations to reduce emissions and meet global “clean” energy standards

Cahill, 6-5-23 – Senior fellow with the Energy Security and Climate Change Program at CSIS (Ben, “Europe Wants Cleaner Gas. Can the United States Provide It?” https://www.csis.org/analysis/europe-wants-cleaner-gas-can-united-states-provide-it, NK)

U.S. liquefied natural gas (LNG) has been essential to global energy security since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. But environmental organizations worry that building LNG import terminals and gas infrastructure will “lock in” fossil fuel consumption, and some are suspicious about the environmental footprint of U.S. gas exports. For now, the European Union cannot afford to be choosy about alternatives to Russian gas, and concerns about emissions intensity have taken a back seat. But European buyers intend to seek “cleaner” or less emissions-intensive gas in the years to come. New methane regulations in the United States should help address these concerns and bolster the case for U.S. LNG.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is finalizing new rules on methane emissions from the oil and gas sector. These regulations would require monitoring for leaks at all well sites, establish tough emissions standards for certain equipment, impose new rules on gas flaring and venting, and incentivize companies to use advanced methane detection technology. The EPA is also drafting new greenhouse gas reporting requirements linked to the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) methane fee, which will apply to emissions above a certain level of methane intensity for upstream production as well as nonproduction petroleum and natural gas systems. The IRA requires the agency to update its greenhouse gas reporting requirements for petroleum and natural gas systems by August 2024, to ensure their reporting “is based on empirical data and accurately reflects total methane emissions.” The EPA aims to finalize its oil and gas methane regulations by this summer, and it may provide guidance on new reporting requirements for oil and gas facilities (under Subpart W of the Greenhouse Gas Reporting Program) by this fall.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › IMPACTS › Turns Warming

Natural gas is vital to balance the volatility of the renewables sector – it’s not abrupt and can complement.

Gürsan and Gooyert 21

Cem Gürsan is a PhD candidate of Methodology Chair at the Nijmegen School of Management, Radboud University. His work focuses on climate change, sustainability transitions, and preserving environmental stocks in transitions of socio-technical systems.; Dr. Vincent de Gooyert is Associate Professor at Radboud University. His research and teaching revolve around increasing understanding of, as well as intervening in, societal transformations towards sustainability.; The systemic impact of a transition fuel: Does natural gas help or hinder the energy transition?; Volume 138, March 2021, 110552; ; //[TMS—GK]

Many studies mention natural gas' potential role in the provision of secure and reliable energy. We distinguished three sub-categories under the energy reliability theme: intermittency, flexibility, and peak demand. Intermittency refers to renewables' characteristic of providing variable energy outputs. Wind and solar power produce energy when there is resource availability4. Generated but unused renewable energy cannot be utilized unless they are stored or transported. Furthermore, abrupt fluctuations in resource availability directly affect electricity generation output throughout the day. This makes it even harder to anticipate the electricity generation potential, to ensure the grids' stability, and thus to satisfy electricity demand reliably. Natural gas plants, however, can be leveled to an energy demand if needed. Thermal plants can reduce their electricity generation levels to secure the grids' stability when energy demand drops. Hence, natural gas plants can accompany renewable plants to balance the intermittent electricity generation (see studies [2,6,7,10,11] mentioning natural gas’ help with intermittency). Flexibility refers to the ability of swiftly increasing and decreasing energy production at will. As discussed, renewable energy plants' total electricity generation capacity is limited to the availability of renewable resources. When the energy demand exceeds resource availability, renewable plants cannot provide electricity even if the plant capacity is more than sufficient. To prevent blackouts and brownouts, the resulting energy gaps have to be satisfied. Natural gas can assist renewable plants in compensating such energy gaps because of its flexibility. Natural gas plants have short on-off cycles and thus compensate renewables' fluctuating differences between electricity supply and demand. If renewable power plants cannot satisfy the energy demand, gas plants can be switched on to secure continuous energy. If renewable energy plants can satisfy the energy demand, then gas plants can be turned off easily to minimize resulting emissions from burning gas (see studies [6,7,10,13] mentioning natural gas’ flexibility). Peak demand refers to the ability of providing sufficient energy even when energy consumption fluctuates at higher levels during specific time periods of the day. For example, energy demand would be higher during hot summer noons due to an increased air conditioning and refrigeration load, or in a cold winter night due to an increased heating load. Uncertainties in peak demands force the investors to overbuild capacity [74]. Renewable technologies need to be compensated by higher levels of overcapacities due to their dependence on resource availability. These overbuilt capacities lay dormant when there is no peak demand [74]. Providing continuous energy to the grid becomes harder when trying to satisfy the uncertain peak demands with uncertain renewable resource availability. In this endeavor, natural gas can help relatively inflexible renewable technologies to provide secure and reliable energy. To reduce the level of overcapacity in the electricity supply, natural gas “peaking” plants can complement renewable plants (see studies [10,14,40,63] mentioning natural gas’ peaking potential).

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › IMPACTS › Turns Warming

Best estimate’s we still need NG until 2050.

Rapier 18

Robert Rapier is a chemical engineer in the energy industry. Robert has 25 years of international engineering experience in the chemicals, oil and gas, and renewable energy industries, and holds several patents related to his work. He has worked in the areas of oil refining, oil production, synthetic fuels, biomass to energy, and alcohol production.; How Long Will Natural Gas Be A Bridge Fuel?; ; //[TMS—GK]

In a previous article, I addressed the reality that natural gas is already serving a bridge fuel between a past powered by coal and a future powered by renewables. Today, I want to discuss the factors that will influence the length of that bridge. Coal is a source of firm power, which means power that is guaranteed to be available when needed. This contrasts to wind and solar power, which are intermittent. They are available when the sun shines and the wind blows. That means that intermittent power sources require much more installed capacity than do firm power sources to produce the same amount of electricity over ti006D+zsazze. The capacity factor -- that is the amount of power produced divided by the power that would be produced if the power source was producing at full capacity at all times -- is around 90% for nuclear power, 70% for geothermal power, and 50-60% for coal-fired and natural gas-fired power. But annual power factors for wind and solar power are in the 25% to 35% range. This has two implications. One is that wind and solar power must have around double the installed capacity of firm power sources like coal to produce the same amount of electricity over time. But because these intermittent sources can sometimes see output fall dramatically, they must also have significant backup power supplies available. Opponents of using natural gas as a bridge to a renewable future argue that batteries can fulfill this backup role. They see the role of natural gas as simply filling a balancing role for renewables in times of extreme mismatches between supply and demand. It is probably true that this is the long-term solution, but cost-effective battery technology isn't quite ready to assume this role on a massive scale. That's why natural gas has become a bridge. But how long might that bridge be? We can look back at trends since 2000 and extrapolate with a thought experiment. The U.S. generated 2.0 trillion kilowatt-hours (kWh) of electricity from coal in 2000, 611 billion kWh from natural gas, and about 6 billion kWh from wind and solar power. By 2017, power generated from coal had fallen 700 billion kWh to 1.2 trillion kWh. Natural gas generation increased since then by 700 billion kWh to 1.3 trillion kWh, while wind and solar power grew by 300 billion kWh. (Including hydropower and biomass, renewables contributed a total of to 687 billion kWh in 2017). So, natural gas has more than doubled the contribution of wind and solar power to the power mix since 2017, but the growth rates for wind and solar have been far greater. So, let's extrapolate. The BP Statistical Review shows that in the U.S., the output of wind and solar power over the past five years roughly doubled. Although growth rates have slowed in recent years, let's make a generous assumption and project that they continue to double every five years. At that rate, it would take two more doublings of wind and solar output to equal the 2017 contribution of coal to the power mix. One more doubling beyond that would then also equal the 2017 contribution of natural gas to the power mix. So I think that makes a strong case the even with aggressive assumptions, coal will remain an important part of the power mix for at least another decade. (Although I believe it will be in the power mix far longer than this). Natural gas will continue to be an important bridge fuel during that time, and in the best case won't be phased out for at least 15 years. In reality, recent U.S. government policy decisions are likely to continue to slow the growth of wind and solar, even as they continue to become cheaper and cheaper. The speed of development of battery technology may also be a limiting factor. Thus, the U.S. is probably looking at natural gas as an important bridge fuel for at least two more decades. Globally, natural gas will probably continue to grow in importance through at least 2050.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › IMPACTS › Turns Warming

LNG’s been the transition fuel and it’s continuance is key to complete the shift away from coal.

Rapier 18

Robert Rapier is a chemical engineer in the energy industry. Robert has 25 years of international engineering experience in the chemicals, oil and gas, and renewable energy industries, and holds several patents related to his work. He has worked in the areas of oil refining, oil production, synthetic fuels, biomass to energy, and alcohol production.; Sep 2, 2018 ;Natural Gas Is Already A Bridge Fuel; ; //[TMS—GK]

Since the turn of the century, a revolution has been underway in the power sector. Coal's share of power production has declined sharply. It appears that renewables are the future. But what role should natural gas play in reaching that future? Let's look at the data. By the Numbers According to data from the Energy Information Administration (EIA), in the year 2000, 71% of U.S. electricity generation was derived from fossil fuels. By 2017 the fossil fuel share had fallen to 63%. But the overall decline in fossil fuels is entirely because of a move away from coal for power generation. Coal's share of U.S. electricity generation between 2000 and 2017 fell from 51% to 30%. Renewables get a lot of credit for this decline, but the truth is that natural gas took most of coal's market share. Over the past 17 years, the natural gas share of power production doubled from 16% to 32%. Natural gas is now the largest source of power in the U.S. Renewables have grown as well. The total renewable share rose from 9.5% to 17%, but hydropower has always been responsible for the largest renewable contribution. In 2000 hydropower accounted for 275 billion kilowatt-hours (kWh) of electricity. By 2017, that was just a bit higher at 300 billion kWh. But modern renewables like wind and solar power soared from nearly nothing in 2000 to 300 billion kWh in 2017. Still, that is less than half the gains made by natural gas. From 2000 to 2017, power generated by coal fell by 700 billion kWh. Meanwhile, at the same time natural gas generation increased by 700 billion kWh. Falling Carbon Dioxide Emissions The impact of the huge drop in coal can be clearly seen in the emissions data. First, let me explain why coal has higher associated carbon dioxide emissions. Fossil fuels contain two different elements that produce energy: carbon and hydrogen. When carbon burns, it forms carbon dioxide. When hydrogen burns, it forms water vapor. Coal has a much higher concentration of carbon, whereas natural gas has much more hydrogen. Thus, when natural gas is burned, it produces relatively fewer carbon dioxide emissions. According to the BP Statistical Review of World Energy, the U.S. has reduced carbon dioxide emissions by 639 million metric tons per year since 2000. This leads all countries by far in reducing carbon dioxide emissions. Far behind in second place was the U.K., where emissions dropped by 165 million metric tons per year. At the same time China, by contrast, increased its carbon dioxide emissions by a whopping 6.8 billion metric tons per year, primarily a result of ~170% increases in both oil and coal consumption. Thus, those who wish to debate whether natural gas should be a bridge between a coal-fired past and a renewable future are missing the point. It is already serving as that bridge. In the next article, I will address how long that bridge might be, and how the U.S. model could serve as a model for the rest of the world.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › IMPACTS › Turns Warming

Natural gas is key – It acts as a bridge during the transition to renewable energy

International Energy Forum ‘21

“4 Reasons Natural Gas Is A Critical Part Of The Energy Transition,” International Energy Forum, September 20 2021 https://www.ief.org/news/4-reasons-natural-gas-is-a-critical-part-of-the-energy-transition

The versatility of natural gas is one key to its expected prominent role in the energy transition, serving as an energy source for all sectors including heating, cooking and industrial applications. When it comes to greenhouse gas emissions, natural gas has a significant advantage over coal, emitting about half the CO2. This makes it an attractive option for stabilizing the path to renewables while reducing carbon emissions in the short term. 1. Natural gas is a reliable, affordable energy source which enables innovation Aerial shot of gas pipes The impact of the COVID pandemic as well as of recent extreme weather events has drawn attention to the systemic risks that impact energy security. In many countries, nuclear power is being phased out or shelved, creating additional need for other technologies to provide a reliable baseload. Natural gas, as an easy to store, lower-carbon option, stands out as a good candidate to provide an uninterrupted, flexible energy supply in tandem with intermittent output from wind and solar while storage technologies are scaled up and innovative new energy pathways are explored. In a 2019 report, the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe (UNECE) said that the ability of natural gas to provide a relatively low carbon backup at peak energy usage times, rather than play a traditional role of round-the-clock baseload, may prove to be its greatest contribution to the energy transition. 2. It acts as a bridging ingredient in the hydrogen revolution Natural gas is also frequently cited as a driver of the energy transition because of its central role in the scaling up (production and transport) of hydrogen – which the European Union, among others, has predicted will play a key role in a future climate-neutral economy. The EU's hydrogen policy notes that although the cost of producing 'clean hydrogen' (made entirely using renewable electricity) is falling, it remains comparatively high. The EU strategy envisions the development of 'clean hydrogen' as a gradual trajectory, initially including 'hydrogen' from natural gas. 3. It is a key tool in the fight against energy poverty Although great progress has been made in ensuring access to electricity globally, in the Global South, over 700 million people remain cut off from electric power and clean cooking technologies. Almost 600 million of them live in Africa – and the continent accounts for less than 4 percent of annual global carbon emissions. Although renewable energy capacity is expanding rapidly, the technology faces challenges. For example, although Africa has 60% of the best solar resources globally, it is home to only 1% of installed solar PV capacity. Natural gas is a plentiful and valuable resource for countries from Algeria and Egypt to Ghana, Senegal and Mozambique. According to a report by the United Nations Economic Commission for Africa, the continent's traditional reliance on biomass, coal and oil means that a combination of renewables and other cleaner fuels such as natural gas is important in fast-tracking the energy transition. 4. Along with Carbon Capture and Storage, it can transform the energy sector Gas power plant In the short to medium term, and in conjunction with renewables and carbon capture, utilization, and storage (CCUS), new natural gas developments can complement the decarbonization of the energy sector. According to the UNECE report, carbon capture, use and storage offers a real prospect for natural gas to work with renewable energy sources on decarbonization. In particular, it helps to address the problem of how to cope with hard-to-abate emissions from heavy industry, notably steel, cement and petrochemicals. Scaling up of CCUS will be critical, given the scale and urgency of the decarbonization challenge – not only with respect to electricity generation, but also heating. An IHS Markit study illustrates how far the world is from electrification of heating – for instance, New York City's power system has 31GW total capacity, but would require 150GW capacity to electrify heating (133GW, with full deployment of heat pumps). Natural gas is unlikely, then, to be phased out in the near term, but will continue to play a role in the hydrogen production, in combination with accelerated deployment of CCUS until hydrogen produced from renewables or nuclear is economically viable as a fuel for heating. Natural gas can contribute to climate targets, and serves as a bridge to overcome technology gaps. In a report published earlier this year, the G20 observed that natural gas meets a considerable share of seasonal energy demand in many countries, offering resilience and security of supply in the face of adverse weather and volatile markets. In addition to this short-term role, the group suggested that an extensive roll-out of CCUS technology and hydrogen production in the longer term would enable natural gas to align with a net-zero pathway.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › IMPACTS › Turns Health

Energy insecurity has adverse health effects

Mayer 22, A. Fossil fuel dependence and energy insecurity. Energ Sustain Soc 12, 27 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1186/s13705-022-00353-5

The origins of the concept of energy insecurity are diverse, and some researchers have used terms like “fuel poverty” to describe much the same issue. Energy systems that seem ostensibly secure at a macro-scale may still not provide an equitable distribution of energy services. For instance, several studies in some of the world’s most affluent nations find evidence of significant energy insecurity at the household scale, which in turn has deleterious consequences on individuals in those households. Energy insecurity is a mediating mechanism between socio-economic status and health outcomes—that is, low-socio-economic status households often struggle to attain needed energy services, which in turn has negative health consequences [13]. Using French data, [17] and [18] find that energy insecurity is associated with lower self-rated health, these findings were echoed by [19]. Using a sample from a low-income neighborhood in a major metropolitan region of the U.S., [16] find that energy insecurity is associated with lower self-rated health, sleep problems, depression, and asthma. Also studying a metropolitan area in the U.S., [15] connect energy insecurity problem behaviors in children. Several studies have connected issues like lack of thermal comfort, drafty and cold buildings, and potential intermittency to various indicators of well-being, such as self-rated health [12, 16, 17, 19], asthma, depression and sleep problems [16], increased youth hospitalizations [15] and excess mortality during cold months [27].

Energy insecurity has increasingly been recognized as a barrier to human development and flourishing in low- and middle-income nations. The challenges created by energy insecurity are diverse and often context specific. For instance, inadequate electric grids create household reliance on stoves that burn combustible fuels like wood—these stoves are a fire hazard and the smoke that they create endangers the health of women who often perform cooking duties [28,29,30]. The poor indoor air quality engendered by cook stoves is also a threat to the health of children and the elderly [31]. Lack of reliable lighting at night can make it difficult for children to study at night, and lack of electricity is likely a contributor to illiteracy and low formal education [32,33,34]. In Ghana and Nigeria, energy-insecure households forgo basic necessities to pay for energy and their children are more likely to miss school days [14] Access to electricity is essential for the development of firms and effective institutions. Electricity allows for households to start businesses or otherwise engage in activities that generate employment and income [33, 35, 36].

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › IMPACTS › Turns Econ

High natural gas prices ensure economic decline – scares businesses and causes massive layoffs

Msiska 21

Samuel Msiska-Content Writer on Tech, Finance, Web3 & Crypto; October 21, 2021; The Impact of Natural Gas Prices on Economic Recovery and Emerging Economies as Prices Soar More Than 90%; ; //[TMS—GK]

Natural Gas Volatility and Economic Recovery The sharp spike in natural gas prices poses a potential threat to the global economic recovery, thus slowing growth in some parts of the world. In Europe, the situation has become critical as natural gas prices have soared 600% this year alone, affecting key economic areas in the region such as fertilizer manufacturing and agriculture. Prices have increased in the U.S. by more than 112% since January. The side effect of higher natural gas prices is that as the prices jump, inflation — the increase in prices over a period of time — also follows, as the price for inputs ascends. For example, when gas prices rise it costs more to make fertilizer, in turn increasing fertilizer prices, which in turn pushes prices for agricultural products higher. Rising natural gas prices could also affect employment, which is a solid indicator of economic growth, and negatively impact economic recovery. Rising gas prices may cause businesses to hold off on hiring because of uncertainty about the health of the economy. Concern about the economy’s future can cause businesses to spend less. Less spending results in less production, causing fewer sales. This situation can affect a company’s hiring plans or, in the worst case, cause massive layoffs. Some Natural Gas Companies by Region Williams Companies Inc. (NYSE: WMB) is an American energy company focused on gas extraction, processing, and transport. The company owns more than 13,000 miles of gas pipelines in many shale regions, including North Dakota, Texas, and Pennsylvania. On average, Williams Companies Inc. produces 1.2 billion cubic feet of natural gas per day. PetroChina Company Limited (NYSE: PTR) is a Chinese oil and gas company with its headquarters in the Dongcheng district, Beijing. The company is currently the largest manufacturer of oil and gas in the Asian region. YPF SA (NYSE: YPF) is an Argentine energy company engaged in the exploration, production and transportation of oil and natural gas. In addition to natural gas, the company also offers diesel, lubricants, asphalts and many other crude oil products. Tokyo Gas Co. Ltd (TYO: 9531) is a Japanese company based in Minato-ku, Tokyo. Its core business is the production, supply, and sale of natural gas. The company is the main supplier of natural gas to major cities, including Tokyo, Kagawa, and Saitama, and has a pipeline network of more than 40 thousand miles. Natural Gas and Emerging Economies The recent spike in natural gas prices may not have severely hit developed countries, but for emerging economies, the pinch can be stern. Take for instance a country like Thailand, which depends heavily on natural gas for power generation. A surge in natural gas prices means the price of electricity would also rise. These high costs would impact the economies of companies that make fertilizer, steel, and other manufacturing industries that require a huge amount of electricity. For such nations, the ideal solution would be to have natural gas manufacturing companies within the country so they can produce it locally. One of the companies that is helping developing countries produce natural gas locally is NG Energy International Corp. (TSX.V: GASX), (OTC: GASXF), (FRA: 56PQ). NG Energy is a publicly-traded E&P company focused on developing natural gas fields in Colombia. Over the past year, the company has made significant progress towards reaching production status from its most developed asset, the Maria Conchita field, which is located in the Guajira Basin on Colombia’s Caribbean coast. The Maria Conchita field is expected to be fully connected to national infrastructure via a 14km pipeline by the end of the year, and once connected, the pipeline will contribute 15-25 MMSCFPD at full capacity. The company recently announced a non-brokered private placement for C$8 million. A portion of the proceeds from the financing will allow the company to expedite the drilling program at the company flagship, the Sinu-9 block, by building roads and drilling pads concurrently rather than consecutively. The company has been granted an environmental license to drill out 22 targets at Sinu-9 which sits next door to Canacol Energy’s (TSX: CNE) main production field and holds prolific exploration potential. The rising price of natural gas poses a potential problem to economic recovery. However, it could prove to be advantageous for NGE, which is set to reach producing status and commence flagship exploration in the midst of the global price surge.