Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › INTERNALS › IL – Transition

Energy transition will take decades --- stable supplies of oil and gas are critical to powering the economy, military equipment and protect allies from energy shocks

Eberhart, 23 --- CEO of Canary, LLC (Feb 24, 2023,09:41am ES, Dan, “Ukraine War Illustrates Importance Of American Energy Dominance,” https://www.forbes.com/sites/daneberhart/2023/02/24/ukraine-war-illustrates-importance-of-american-energy-dominance/?sh=2cfd961570a6, JMP))

Biden continues to double down on the energy transition, a decision that may pay off in the long run. In the immediate future, though, America – and the world – will continue to depend on oil and gas to run their economies. Until tanks run on solar power, petroleum will continue to define energy security – and energy security is national security.

After the bloody events of the past year, Americans should take heart in North America’s resource abundance. Still, they should be equally concerned about the direction of U.S. energy policy and the unnecessary risk it poses to the nation.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – Renewables

Renewable compete with natural gas – decisions by some states prove the tradeoff

Saha, 19 – Director of US Clean Energy Economy Program, Ph.D. in Public Policy University of Texas at Austin [Devashree, 07/08/2019, World Resources Institute, “Natural Gas Beat Coal in the US. Will Renewables and Storage Soon Beat Natural Gas?” https://www.wri.org/technical-perspectives/natural-gas-beat-coal-us-will-renewables-and-storage-soon-beat-natural-gas 6/21/2023, JR]

In April 2019, in the heart of coal country, Indiana regulators rejected a proposal by its electric and gas utility, Vectren, to replace baseload coal plants with a new $900 million, 850 megawatt (MW) natural gas-fired power plant. Regulators were concerned that with the dramatic decline in the cost of renewable energy, maturation of energy storage and rapidly changing customer demand, such a major gas plant investment could become a stranded, uneconomic asset in the future. Regulators are now pushing Vectren to consider more decentralized, lower-carbon resources such as wind, solar and storage that would offer greater resource diversity, flexibility and cost effectiveness.

This decision is notable in a state where coal is still the primary energy fuel. At the same time, the Indiana decision hints at a broader transformation happening across the United States.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – Renewables

Natural gas and renewables compete but it’s too early to discount gas

Cohen ’21 – Senior Fellow at the Atlantic Council, Founding Principal of International Market Analysis [Ariel, 7/8/21, Forbes, “Why The Green Transition Can’t Happen Without Natural Gas” https://www.forbes.com/sites/arielcohen/2021/07/08/how-natural-gas-can-help-fuel-the-green-revolution/?sh=192d2ca73d82 6/23/23, JR]

Just as natural gas has competed with coal as the prime fuel for electricity in the last decades, renewables are putting pressure on the blue, clean-burning source of energy. The competition is fierce and will likely get worse. Yet, it is still too early to discount gas. This was the message at the 36th International Gas Congress in Croatia, where I spoke on Joe Biden’s plan to stop drilling on federal lands.

The International Gas Union (IGU), with over 160 members from the U.S. to Qatar, is a non-profit that advocates for natural gas as an integral part of the global energy system. The Vice President and the future (2025) President of IGU Andrea Stegher, a Senior Vice President Commercial & Stakeholder Engagement in the Italian energy giant SNAM, is convinced that the gas industry is facing a historic challenge but also a great opportunity. Gas was long hailed as a “transition” fuel from hydrocarbons to renewables. Given what we know about the state of technology and energy poverty around the world, gas should be around for many decades.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – Renewables

Renewable energy transition would hurt natural gas industries.

IEA (2020),

The Oil and Gas Industry in Energy Transitions, IEA, Paris https://www.iea.org/reports/the-oil-and-gas-industry-in-energy-transitions, License: CC BY 4.0

This section discusses the way that the outlook for oil and natural gas could be affected by an accelerated pace of energy transitions. There is a huge range of possible futures depending, for example, on the pace of technological innovation, the ambition of energy policies, market dynamics, societal trends and many other factors. The analysis refers to two scenarios included in the IEA WEO, but focuses mainly on the [Sustainable Development Scenario] SDS and some sensitivity cases around this Scenario. The SDS charts a pathway for the global energy sector fully aligned with the Paris Agreement by holding the rise in global temperatures to “well below 2°C … and pursuing efforts to limit [it] to 1.5°C”. This requires rapid and widespread changes across all parts of the energy system. The world is not on track to meet this Scenario. The IEA’s assessment, based on the policies in place today as well as those that have been announced (the STEPS), is that the momentum behind clean energy transitions is not enough to offset the effects of an expanding global economy and growing population. The STEPS does not see a peak in global energy-related CO2 emissions by 2040 – obviously far from the early peak and rapid subsequent decline in emissions targeted by the Paris Agreement. This disparity between the direction in which the world appears to be heading, on the one hand, and the wealth of scientific evidence highlighting the need for ever-more-rapid cuts in GHG emissions, on the other, is a crucial fault line in global energy. The projections in the STEPS suggest that, in the absence of more concerted policy action, demand for oil and (especially) gas would continue to grow to 2040, while coal demand would remain where it is today. However, the emissions trends in the STEPS would imply a 50% probability of a 2.7°C stabilisation (or a 66% chance of limiting warming to 3.2°C) – not nearly enough to avoid severe effects from climate change. Something has to give, and the pressure to act more forcefully on emissions is growing, visible in a groundswell of opinion in many countries in favour of aligning policy and investment decisions with a low-emissions future. This includes an increasing number of national and corporate commitments to net-zero emissions, typically by mid-century. In some sectors, notably electricity, this is enabled by everlower costs of some key renewable technologies. The SDS provides a way to explore the consequences of these types of rapid transitions across the energy sector as a whole. While emissions reductions are central to its design, it is not solely a climate scenario. It reflects a broader range of imperatives facing policy makers by also meeting objectives related to universal energy access and cleaner air, while retaining a strong focus on energy security and affordability.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – Carbon Tax

Carbon tax will increase price of natural gas and incentivize transition to renewables

Parry ’19 - Principal Environmental Fiscal Policy Expert at International Monetary Fund [Ian, 06/19, Finance and Development, “What Is Carbon Taxation” https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/fandd/issues/2019/06/what-is-carbon-taxation-basics, JR]

Carbon taxes, levied on coal, oil products, and natural gas in proportion to their carbon content, can be collected from fuel suppliers. They in turn will pass on the tax in the form of higher prices for electricity, gasoline, heating oil, and so on, as well as for the products and services that depend on them. This provides incentives for producers and consumers alike to reduce energy use and shift to lower-carbon fuels or renewable energy sources through investment or behavior.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – Carbon Tax

Advocates admits a carbon tax will undermine the natural gas industry --- stops pipelines and shipping terminals

Hsu, 21 --- D'Alemberte Professor, Florida State University College of Law (Summer, 2021, Shi-Ling Hsu, ECONOMIC JUSTICE: Carbon Taxes and Economic Inequality, 15 Harv. L. & Pol'y Rev. 551, Nexis Uni, JMP))

Of course, there is much, much more work to be done, well beyond the decline in coal usage. The next stage of decarbonization is the phasing out of fossil fuels generally, which it now appears, must take place sooner rather than later. 48 A carbon price must emerge soon to slow down natural gas exploration, and stall the quest for new pipelines and shipping terminals. That capacity must be replaced with renewable energy and energy storage technologies, which will require a carbon price in order to supplant natural gas as the fuel of choice for electricity generation. The economics of natural gas and renewable energy sources are different, but despite historically low gas prices, 49 wind and solar energy are competitive: the levelized cost of electricity for wind and solar energy 50 has declined rapidly, so that they are clearly lower than coal and generally (but not uniformly) lower than efficient [*561] combined cycle natural gas plants. 51 That does not necessarily translate into a cost advantage, as many considerations go into fuel choice, such as intermittency, traditionally a problem with renewable energy sources. 52 However, a carbon tax of $ 30 per ton of CO2 would add about $ 5.50 to a megawatthour of electricity generated by natural gas, which has levelized costs in the neighborhood of $ 30-40 per MWhr, 53 and could thus provide a decided advantage to renewable energy and energy storage technologies. That may bring about yet another transformation of the energy industry. Of course, a higher carbon tax would make that outcome a greater certainty.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – Carbon Tax

The US transitioning to renewables would end LNG use – That’s catastrophic because while the US can transition, Europe may still need LNG supply

Saha ’23 (Devashree Saha is the director of the Us Clean Energy Economy Program) “Natural Gas Beat Coal in the US. Will Renewables and Storage Soon Beat Natural Gas?,” World Resources Institute, 7/8/2019, https://www.wri.org/technical-perspectives/natural-gas-beat-coal-us-will-renewables-and-storage-soon-beat-natural-gas

What explains this growing shift where regulators and utilities look more toward solar, wind and battery storage than natural gas, as they phase out coal generation? Part of it is that state policymakers are adopting policies that support the build-out of renewable energy, such as through standards that require utilities to obtain a certain portion of their electricity from zero-emission sources (e.g. renewable portfolio standards) or standalone mandates requiring investor-owned utilities to procure significant amounts of storage. New York, for instance, has set an energy storage goal of 3,000 MW by 2030 and the New York Public Service Commission has called upon the state's six investor-owned utilities to conduct competitive solicitations to have a total of 350 MW of energy storage resources in service by end of 2022. California, Massachusetts, and New Jersey are a few other states that have established energy storage targets. However, the new economics of renewables are a significant factor behind this trend—especially in states that are still heavily fossil fuel-dependent. Renewable energy is now undercutting the cost of new natural gas generation in a growing number of regions. According to Lazard, a financial advisory firm, the levelized cost of energy (LCOE) for some renewables, especially onshore wind and utility-scale solar, is lower than the cheapest natural gas in many cases, even without subsidies factored in. LCOE—measuring the average cost of electricity over the life of a project—is one commonly used metric to compare the costs of different generation technologies. As IRENA has noted, however, "LCOE is a useful metric as a starting point for deeper comparison, it is not necessarily the most useful indicator of cost between different power generation technologies." The Lazard analysis also presents various caveats on the use of LCOE, e.g., it does not reflect various integration costs or potential social and environmental externalities. Research has shown that incremental system costs from adding non-dispatchable renewable generation are minimal up to penetration rates of 80 percent or more as long as appropriate investments are made in transmission and storage. Given that renewables produce no CO2 emissions or other air pollutants, and that the current integration costs of renewables are low, one can be confident that renewables will be a low-cost incremental source of generation for years to come. Recent data on power purchase agreements show consistency with Lazard's LCOE estimates. In June 2018, NV Energy set a new price record when it entered into a 300 MW power purchase agreement (PPA) with the Eagle Shadow Mountain solar project at $23.76/MWh for 25 years. The PPA was approved by Nevada regulators in December 2018. Last year Xcel Energy's all-source solicitation received a batch of bids whose medians were $18.10/MWh for a wind project, $21/MWh for wind plus storage, $29.50/MWh for solar, and $36/MWh for solar plus storage. While the cost of renewable and storage varies from market to market, these two examples show that the costs are dropping rapidly and the business case for using renewables in place of natural gas is becoming more compelling in many parts of the country. Renewables hold another price advantage over natural gas. Renewable energy costs are expected to continue falling, while the cost of gas generation can be volatile since it is tethered to the commodity price of natural gas. In the last 10 years alone, natural gas hit a high of almost $7 per mmBtus and a low of $1.75. (It is currently at $2.65.) Renewable energy costs, on the other hand, are forecasted to get cheaper in the coming years (removal of federal tax incentives may cause modest increases in the near term). Bloomberg New Energy Finance, in its New Energy Outlook 2019, reported that wind and solar are now cheapest across more than two-thirds of the world and that by 2030 they will "undercut commissioned coal and gas almost everywhere." Wood Mackenzie Power & Renewables expects battery prices to fall by more than 80 percent by 2040. Energy storage deployment is forecasted to grow thirteenfold, from a 12 gigawatt-hour market in 2018 to a 158 gigawatt-hour market in 2024, with much of the growth concentrated in the United States and China. Finally, investing in new gas plants is beginning to be seen as a risky proposition due to climate change concerns. In addition to concerns about methane leakage in natural gas production, building natural gas infrastructure—which has a relatively long lifespan—for the next three decades is beginning to be viewed as in tension with current climate goals. Limiting global warming to 1.5 degrees C (2.7 degrees F) above preindustrial levels, which scientists say is necessary for preventing the worst impacts of climate change, requires the United States to achieve carbon neutrality by midcentury. This is only possible if power sector emissions fall close to zero. This means that much of the planned and existing oil and gas infrastructure will have to be abandoned before the end of its life or retrofitted to include carbon capture and storage. Thus it risks becoming what investors call a "stranded asset." While it is hard to predict what policymakers will do in the future, if a price is put on carbon in the next few years, natural gas's future could become cloudier. A report from the Rocky Mountain Institute echoes this concern. In comparing the cost of four proposed gas plants in different parts of the country with regionally appropriate aggregations of renewable energy resources, the analysis finds that, in three of the four cases, the clean energy portfolio would cost 8-60 percent less than the four proposed gas plants today. With further cost reductions in clean energy and/or a modest $7.50 per ton price on carbon emissions, renewables will be cheaper in all four cases. Natural gas will play a significant role in the nation's future electricity mix in the coming years. The mix of energy sources used for generating electricity will continue to shift in response to changes in fuel costs and the development of renewable energy technologies. In parts of the country where natural gas is the most cost-effective energy source to replace coal-fired generation, pure economics and local grid context will dictate utility and energy regulator decisions to invest in new natural gas-fired generation. However, as this blog notes, a natural gas-centered energy transition would carry significant economic and environmental risks. Crossing the Natural Gas "Bridge" For years, natural gas has been viewed as a "bridge fuel,' a cleaner burning, low-cost alternative to coal while zero-emission options are developed. And indeed, the transition from coal to natural gas has conferred significant benefits in terms of reducing GHG emissions and air pollution. But with renewables quickly catching up to natural gas, could it be that we're getting to the end of the natural gas bridge and approaching the other side?

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – GND

Turns inequality – The Green New Deal’s shift away from gas uniquely hurts lower-class Americans

Edwards 21

Rachel Edwards is an author for the Consumer Energy Alliance, 4-20-2021, "Green New Deal Would Cost American Consumers More Than $258 Billion – in JUST Four Appliances," Consumer Energy Alliance, https://consumerenergyalliance.org/2021/04/green-new-deal-would-cost-american-consumers-more-than-258-billion-in-just-four-appliances/

The “Green New Deal” is not such a good deal for American energy consumers. Designed to completely replace America’s use of abundant and affordable energy sources such as natural gas, the resolution’s goal is to make the country entirely dependent upon renewable energy. The Green New Deal is not a practical solution for American consumers, as many common household appliances, such as furnaces, water heaters, stoves, and dryers, are powered by natural gas and would have to be replaced at the expense of hardworking families across the country.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – GND

Green New Deal seeks to end natural gas -- economically disastrous for impoverished communities in the US

CEA, 21 (April 20, Consumer Energy Alliance, “Green New Deal Would Cost American Consumers More Than $258 Billion – in JUST Four Appliances” https://consumerenergyalliance.org/2021/04/green-new-deal-would-cost-american-consumers-more-than-258-billion-in-just-four-appliances/, NK)

The “Green New Deal” is not such a good deal for American energy consumers. Designed to completely replace America’s use of abundant and affordable energy sources such as natural gas, the resolution’s goal is to make the country entirely dependent upon renewable energy. The Green New Deal is not a practical solution for American consumers, us many common household appliances, such as furnaces, water heaters, stoves, and dryers, are powered by natural gas and would have to be replaced at the expense of hardworking families across the country.

Most American households rely on natural gas for cooking, cleaning, or heating their homes. About 59.5 million households rely upon natural gas for heat.((https://www.eia.gov/consumption/residential/data/2015/hc/php/hc1.1.php)) At minimum, a new electric furnace and installation costs $2,500 for a total of more than $148.7 billion nationwide.((https://www.homeadvisor.com/cost/heating-and-cooling/install-a-furnace/))

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – GND

Natural gas creates millions of new jobs and U.S. LNG exports reduce global carbon emissions from dirty coal plants and highly – Green New Deal would foreclose those benefits

Steidler, 19 --- senior fellow with the Lexington Institute, a public policy think tank in Arlington, Virginia (February 21, 2019, “Fueling a Green New Deal with Liquefied Natural Gas,” https://insidesources.com/fueling-a-green-new-deal-with-liquefied-natural-gas/, JMP))

Freshman Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez has gotten much attention by proposing a Green New Deal, a far-ranging proposal to shift the U.S. economy away from fossil fuels over the next decade while somehow creating millions of good-paying jobs.

Her plan amounts to turning success into failure by ignoring the vast economic and environmental benefits natural gas has provided to America in the past decade — and the opportunity to multiply these benefits in the decade ahead.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – US Consumption

LNG projects will make the U.S. an export superpower but a push for decarbonization makes funding harder to secure

McCormick ’23 [Myles, 4/17/23, Financial Times, “Rising costs and competition threaten US boom in LNG projects,” https://www.ft.com/content/e7f3681f-3f0a-40de-ab65-65f62c7d6acb 6/24/23, JR]

Intense competition between developers and escalating costs are complicating efforts to bring new liquefied natural gas projects online in the US, even as the fallout from Russia’s invasion of Ukraine creates huge appetite for American fuel exports. A new wave of multibillion-dollar LNG projects on the US coast of the Gulf of Mexico has gathered pace over the past year as the energy upheaval triggered by the war prompts a global dash to secure fossil fuels from vast Texas shale fields. Since Moscow began its full-blown invasion of its neighbour 14 months ago, four projects, together worth $40bn, have reached the crucial final investment decision (FID) milestone. But others have faced repeated delays as they vie with each other to secure the long-term purchase agreements needed to underwrite their projects and contend with sharply escalating construction and financing costs. “It’s dramatically more expensive,” said Charif Souki, who pioneered the development of the US LNG export industry more than a decade ago. “There are fewer and fewer construction companies that can actually handle these kinds of loads. But you have to confront . . . your supply chain issues and all the cost inflation.” Souki, who now heads up developer Tellurian, has seen his $25bn Driftwood development flounder after a fundraising failure last year led pivotal buyers to abandon the project. This month it announced plans for the sale and leaseback of land as it scrambles to raise funds. Two other projects that developers had hoped would reach FID by the end of March — Energy Transfer’s Lake Charles conversion and Next Decade’s Rio Grande terminal — have been delayed to later in the year. The Biden administration and European Commission have made the expansion of US LNG exports a cornerstone of securing energy supplies in Europe as the continent looks to purge Russian gas from its national economies. Projects under construction or entering service will increase US capacity by roughly 70 per cent once they all come online by 2027, making the country the world’s pre-eminent LNG superpower: this year the US will leapfrog Australia and Qatar to boast the world’s biggest export capacity. If every potential project in the pipeline was to come online, they would triple US capacity by 2030, according to Wood Mackenzie. But analysts expect many of these to fail, as a race to build them in time intensifies and funding for long-term fossil fuel projects in a decarbonising world becomes harder to secure. Reaching the FID stage requires securing enough solid deals to underwrite the financing needed to pay for its construction. As costs rise, that is proving tricky. “You’ve seen a really competitive market among different developers,” said Giles Farrer, head of LNG research at Wood Mackenzie. “So to secure customers, companies have bid right down to the margin.” Now many have to contend with rampant supply chain inflation pushing up the cost of construction, while rising interest rates have increased financing costs. That would probably force some to renegotiate offtake deals, said Farrer, delaying projects and allowing others to muscle in. But even as some struggle, other more established players have been successful in capitalising on the thirst for US molecules and locking in contracts that have allowed them to plough ahead with big new projects. Sempra Energy last month pushed ahead with a plan to build a 13.5mn tonnes a year plant in Port Arthur, in south-east Texas; a week earlier Venture Global moved forward with the second phase of its 20mn tonnes a year Plaquemines facility in Louisiana, having given the green light to phase 1 in May; last summer Cheniere Energy gave approval to a 10mn tonnes a year expansion of its facility at Corpus Christi in Texas.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – US Consumption

Oil and gas production likely to increase through 2050 and will facilitate LNG exports but less availability will increase prices and cause exports to decline

U.S. Energy Information Administration, 3-3-2022 [U.S. Energy Information Administration, 27 April, U.S. Energy Information Administration, “Annual Energy Outlook 2022” https://www.eia.gov/outlooks/aeo/narrative/production/sub-topic-01.php Accessed on 23 June, NP]

We project U.S. consumption and production of petroleum and other liquids to grow through 2050. Domestic consumption and production levels of petroleum and other liquids remain relatively close to one another through most of the projection period in the Reference case. Consumption increases by 15%, and production increases by 17% from 2021 to 2050. However, consumption and production of specific petroleum products vary. We also project consumption and production of natural gas to grow through 2050. During the projection period, natural gas production grows by almost 24%, approximately twice as fast as consumption. Much of this growth in natural gas production is exported as liquefied natural gas (LNG). By 2050, we project that approximately 25% more natural gas will be produced than consumed in the United States. Together, these Reference case trends highlight the continued growth in demand for U.S. natural gas and petroleum products.

NATURAL GAS EXPORTS INCREASE WITH PRODUCTION, DRIVEN BY GLOBAL DEMAND AND CONTINUED CONSTRUCTION OF NEW LNG EXPORT FACILITIES

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › UNIQUENESS › AT: Renewables Now

Priced in -- oil and natural gas will still remain the most consumed fuels despite current renewable projections

Chicaiza, 22 [ Melissa, 27 December, Energy in Depth, “Year in Review: U.S. Oil and Natural Gas Industry Hits Record Production to Meet Rising Global Demand in 2022.” Energy in Depth, 27 Dec. 2022, www.energyindepth.org/year-in-review-u-s-oil-and-natural-gas-industry-hits-record-production-to-meet-rising-global-demand-in-2022/, Accessed on 23 June 2023, NP]

U.S. Energy Consumption Continued to Grow With Oil & Natural Gas As Top Fuels

The EIA 2022 Annual Energy Outlook forecasts that while the renewable energy market grows steadily, oil and natural gas will remain the two most-consumed energy sources in the United States, driven by increasing population growth and economic development. From EIA:

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › UNIQUENESS › AT: Renewables Now

Biden’s signal of support is giving oil and gas industries confidence now despite existing renewables

Friedman, 23 – New York Times climate and environment writer [Lisa; March 14; Lisa Friedman is a reporter on the climate desk, focusing on climate and environmental policy in Washington. She has covered eight international climate talks and chased climate-related stories from the bottom of a Chinese coal mine to the top of snow-capped Himalaya Mountains; New York Times, “Big Oil Gets It’s Mojo Back, Huge profits and higher demand have empowered the industry.” https://www.nytimes.com/2023/03/14/climate/oil-gas-industry.html, LK]

To sum it up, confidence is high in the oil and gas world. That’s very different from where we were just a couple of years ago and it has important implications for the global transition to cleaner energy. 

A huge decision on Alaska 

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › UNIQUENESS › U – Clean Energy Declining

Ukraine conflict has thrown cold water on clean energy transition --- there will be a greater reliance on fossil fuels

Clemente, 5/8/2023 --- Principal at JTC Energy Research Associates, LLC, B.A. in International Relations from Penn State University, with a minor in Statistical Analysis, M.S. in Homeland Security from San Diego State University, with a focus on Energy Security, and an MBA from St. Francis University, with a focus on Energy Economics (May 08, 2023, Jude, “Wind and Solar Aren’t Nearly Enough: Why Biden Is Suddenly Supporting Fossil Fuels,” https://www.realclearenergy.org/articles/2023/05/08/wind_and_solar_are_not_nearly_enough_why_biden_is_suddenly_supporting_fossil_fuels_897517.html, JMP))

Nobody loves the Biden administration’s new EPA regulations to force huge amounts of electric cars onto the power grid more than the beleaguered coal industry.

Electric cars and the overarching goal of electrification will surely surge U.S. electricity demand, a sector that has been flat at 4,100 terawatt hours since the Great Recession 15 years ago (see figure).

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › UNIQUENESS › U – Clean Energy Declining

Clean energy transition unlikely now because it is too costly and mineral intensive

Clemente, 23 --- --- Principal at JTC Energy Research Associates, LLC, B.A. in International Relations from Penn State University, with a minor in Statistical Analysis, M.S. in Homeland Security from San Diego State University, with a focus on Energy Security, and an MBA from St. Francis University, with a focus on Energy Economics (Feb 19, 2023,07:00pm EST, Jude, “The Overprivileged West’s Delusion Of ‘Transitioning Away From Oil’” https://www.forbes.com/sites/judeclemente/2023/02/19/the-overprivileged-wests-delusion-of-transitioning-away-from-oil/?sh=3389ce6d3f1c, JMP))

Over 15 years in the business, easily the smartest people I’ve met in energy reside in Calgary and Toronto:

“Don’t get caught up in the supply story. The demand is insatiable. It’s unstoppable. And it’s growing aggressively globally. And the world has become selfish since Covid came along...you’re protecting yourself and to protect yourself you will throw out all of your environmental concerns...and look to protect yourself and that means burning more oil...in the developing world there’s a scramble to get out of poverty...it’s even accelerated because of Covid because of the lack of attention those countries got from the developed world,” Rafi Tahmazian, Senior Portfolio Manager, Canoe Financial, 2022

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › UNIQUENESS › U – US Selling to Europe

New standards will reduce emissions and strengthen U.S. LNG industry globally

Cahill, 6-5-23 – Senior fellow with the Energy Security and Climate Change Program at CSIS (Ben, “Europe Wants Cleaner Gas. Can the United States Provide It?” https://www.csis.org/analysis/europe-wants-cleaner-gas-can-united-states-provide-it, NK)

These regulatory efforts align with international engagement on greenhouse gas reductions. At the 27th 2022 UN Climate Change Conference (COP27), a joint declaration between energy importers and exporters committed to reduce methane, carbon dioxide, and other emissions from the oil and gas value chain. In April, the U.S.-EU Energy Council extended these goals, aiming to “develop an internationally aligned approach for transparent measurement, monitoring, reporting, and verification for methane and carbon dioxide emissions across the fossil energy value chain.” The Department of Energy and the State Department have now pulled together a working group on these issues involving some 20 countries.

It is still early days for these efforts, and the underlying challenges are not easy to solve. One example is methane measurement, reporting, and verification (MRV) standards. At present, companies looking for ways to improve emissions accounting must make sense of industry protocols, a global reporting framework called the Oil and Gas Methane Partnership (OGMP 2.0), voluntary gas certification schemes and emissions registries, and frameworks for LNG cargo emissions accounting. Each has merit but none has universal approval, although the European Union’s proposed methane legislation strongly supports OGMP 2.0. Even if one gold standard were to emerge, policymakers are underestimating the difficulty of integrating methane measurement data from various sources such as satellites and aerial surveys. Some segments of the LNG value chain such as shipping could prove especially challenging.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › UNIQUENESS › U – US Selling to Europe

U.S. oil and gas are providing Europe with critical energy to check Russian domination

Lefebvre 2023 – Covered the Energy Industry for the past Decade [Ben Lefebvre, March 28, 2023, “How American Energy helped Europe best Putin”, https://www.politico.com/news/2023/02/23/american-energy-europe-putin-00083750 AA]

The Russian troops who poured into Ukraine a year ago had a seemingly powerful weapon to keep Kyiv’s would-be allies cowed — Moscow’s dominance of Europe’s oil and gas supplies.

A year later, that strategy has backfired.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › UNIQUENESS › U – More LNG Now

Government is approving more LNG export facilities

Humpert ’23 [Malte, 4/17/23, High North News, “Biden Administration Renews Green Light for Alaska LNG Project” https://www.highnorthnews.com/en/biden-administration-renews-green-light-alaska-lng-project 6/23/23, JR]

As part of an ongoing global push to produce and export more liquified natural gas (LNG), the US government renewed its approval of the proposed Alaska LNG facility.

The project, overseen by the Alaska Gasline Development Corporation, pitches the construction of a 1,300km pipeline from Alaska’s North Slope to deliver natural gas to a future liquefaction terminal on the Kenai peninsula.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › UNIQUENESS › U – More LNG Now

U.S. LNG production is growing – new projects show demand is going to keep rising

Disavino 6-23-23 (Scott, “US LNG project approvals on track for record new volumes,” https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/us-lng-project-approvals-track-record-new-volumes-2023-06-23/, NK)

NEW YORK, June 23 (Reuters) - U.S. liquefied natural gas (LNG) developers are on track to approve three export projects capable of processing 5.1 billion cubic feet per day (bcfd) of gas in the first half of the year, a record volume for new LNG projects in any year.

The U.S. became the world's largest LNG producer by installed capacity in 2022 driven by the boom in LNG plant construction and a decade of surging shale gas discoveries. U.S. LNG exports are poised to reach 12.1 bcfd this year and 12.7 bcfd next year.