Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA Answers --- ENDI 23 › AT: Impact---2AC/1AR › AT: Food Wars---1AR

The countries that matter for their impact are resilient and institutional responses prevent escalation.

Sarah Cliffe 16. Director of the Center on International Cooperation at New York University, 3/29/16, “Food Security, Nutrition, and Peace,” http://cic.nyu.edu/news_commentary/food-security-nutrition-and-peace

However, current research does not yet indicate a clear link between climate change, food insecurity and conflict, except perhaps where rapidly deteriorating water availability cuts across existing tensions and weak institutions. But a series of interlinked problems – changing global patterns of consumption of energy and scarce resources, increasing demands for food imports (which draw on land, water, and energy inputs) can create pressure on fragile situations. Food security – and food prices – are a highly political issue, being a very immediate and visible source of popular welfare or popular uncertainty. But their link to conflict (and the wider links between climate change and conflict) is indirect rather than direct. What makes some countries more resilient than others? Many countries face food price or natural resource shocks without falling into conflict. Essentially, the two important factors in determining their resilience are: First, whether food insecurity is combined with other stresses – issues such as unemployment, but most fundamentally issues such as political exclusion or human rights abuses. We sometimes read nowadays that the 2006-2009 drought was a factor in the Syrian conflict, by driving rural-urban migration that caused societal stresses. It may of course have been one factor amongst many but it would be too simplistic to suggest that it was the primary driver of the Syrian conflict. Second, whether countries have strong enough institutions to fulfill a social compact with their citizens, providing help quickly to citizens affected by food insecurity, with or without international assistance. During the 2007-2008 food crisis, developing countries with low institutional strength experienced more food price protests than those with higher institutional strengths, and more than half these protests turned violent. This for example, is the difference in the events in Haiti versus those in Mexico or the Philippines where far greater institutional strength existed to deal with the food price shocks and protests did not spur deteriorating national security or widespread violence.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA Answers --- ENDI 23 › AT: Impact---2AC/1AR › AT: Food Wars---2AC

Food shortages won’t cause war.

Jeremy Allouche 11. Research Fellow in water supply and sanitation @ Institute for Development Studies, former professor at MIT. “The sustainability and resilience of global water and food systems: Political analysis of the interplay between security, resource scarcity, political systems and global trade,” Food Policy, Vol. 36 Supplement 1, p. S3-S8, January

The question of resource scarcity has led to many debates on whether scarcity (whether of food or water) will lead to conflict and war. The underlining reasoning behind most of these discourses over food and water wars comes from the Malthusian belief that there is an imbalance between the economic availability of natural resources and population growth since while food production grows linearly, population increases exponentially. Following this reasoning, neo-Malthusians claim that finite natural resources place a strict limit on the growth of human population and aggregate consumption; if these limits are exceeded, social breakdown, conflict and wars result. Nonetheless, it seems that most empirical studies do not support any of these neo-Malthusian arguments. Technological change and greater inputs of capital have dramatically increased labour productivity in agriculture. More generally, the neo-Malthusian view has suffered because during the last two centuries humankind has breached many resource barriers that seemed unchallengeable. Lessons from history: alarmist scenarios, resource wars and international relations In a so-called age of uncertainty, a number of alarmist scenarios have linked the increasing use of water resources and food insecurity with wars. The idea of water wars (perhaps more than food wars) is a dominant discourse in the media (see for example Smith, 2009), NGOs (International Alert, 2007) and within international organizations (UNEP, 2007). In 2007, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon declared that ‘water scarcity threatens economic and social gains and is a potent fuel for wars and conflict’ (Lewis, 2007). Of course, this type of discourse has an instrumental purpose; security and conflict are here used for raising water/food as key policy priorities at the international level. In the Middle East, presidents, prime ministers and foreign ministers have also used this bellicose rhetoric.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA Answers --- ENDI 23 › AT: Internal Link---2AC/1AR › Alt Causes---1AR

Cyberattacks

Eric Geller 4-6. Journalist covering cybersecurity and technology. His stories have explored efforts to protect elections from hackers, take down cybercrime gangs, improve the security of commercial and open-source software, and regulate vital U.S. infrastructure. He spent more than six years as a cyber reporter at Politico; prior to that, he covered tech policy and served as an editor at The Daily Dot. "The Dangerous Weak Link in the US Food Chain". WIRED. 4-6-2023. https://www.wired.com/story/us-food-agriculture-isac-cybersecurity/

IF HACKERS WANTED to debilitate American society, they would have trouble taking down the entire power grid or financial system, but they could do serious damage to the companies that make and deliver Americans’ food.

The US food and agriculture sector lacks the resources, expertise, and government support to protect itself and its products from a rapidly expanding range of cybersecurity threats, according to lawmakers, policy experts, and former government officials. These shortfalls leave gaps that foreign government operatives or cybercriminals could exploit to remotely disable farming equipment, contaminate fertilizer, cripple milk supplies, and kill chickens.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA Answers --- ENDI 23 › AT: Internal Link---2AC/1AR › Alt Causes---1AR

Water shortages.

Chloe Sorvino 22. Leads coverage of food and agriculture at Forbes, and writes the newsletter Fresh Take. "U.S. Farmers Struggle Through Drought To Bring Food To The Table But Face More Challenges Ahead". Forbes. 9-2-2022. https://www.forbes.com/sites/chloesorvino/2022/09/02/us-farmers-struggle-through-drought-to-bring-food-to-the-table-but-face-more-challenges-ahead/?sh=1f7dd9fafc08

Lack of summer rain forced Nebraska farmer Kevin Fulton to go underground to find water for his crops. Not a perfect solution: the Ogallala Aquifer, where Fulton tapped in, has pumping restrictions in some areas, just not where Fulton is located. That’s because the aquifer is running dry.

As drought extends its deadly fingers from California to the eastern side of the Mississippi River — a vast stretch of the continent that produces most of America’s food, including three-quarters of its beef cattle and 70% of its vegetables, fruits and nuts — farmers and ranchers are facing a double whammy. They have to go farther to find water and higher fuel costs are forcing them to pay more to pump whatever isn’t coming from the sky. That predicament is still better than what’s happened to the land that’s not irrigated, Fulton says.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA Answers --- ENDI 23 › AT: Internal Link---2AC/1AR › Alt Causes---1AR

Labor shortages and input costs

Cobank 23. "Rural Economy Likely to Face Challenges in 2023: Here's Why". Lancaster Farming. 1-26-2023. https://www.lancasterfarming.com/farming-news/ag-business/rural-economy-likely-to-face-challenges-in-2023-heres-why/article_f6e04374-1f5b-5bcb-9f06-b5e37cd214e4.html

Specialty Crops: Drought, Labor Shortages, Strong Dollar Among Headwinds

Specialty crop growers and processors face a multitude of headwinds in 2023. Costs of water, labor, fertilizer and other inputs are rising while a strong U.S. dollar and weakening global economy drag on the U.S.’s ability to sell products abroad.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA Answers --- ENDI 23 › AT: Internal Link---2AC/1AR › Alt Causes---2AC

Farm bill can’t solve---tons of other issues facing American agriculture.

Joby Young 23. Executive vice president at the American Farm Bureau Federation. "2022’s Top Ag Issues and A Look Ahead". American Farm Bureau Federation. 1-4-2023. https://www.fb.org/focus-on-agriculture/2022s-top-ag-issues-and-a-look-ahead

For many, 2022 was a year of change and transition. As we all thankfully watched the worst of the pandemic pass, new challenges arose, especially in farm country, as post-pandemic changes in consumer behavior, global supply chains, and monetary policy caused major shifts in the economy.

It was a year of transition for me personally, as I joined the American Farm Bureau as Executive Vice President. A priority for me once onboard was to get out and meet our members, so I traveled the country doing just that. I’m grateful to have been warmly welcomed into the Farm Bureau family and look forward to advocating for solutions in 2023.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA Answers --- ENDI 23 › AT: Link---2AC/1AR › Link Turn---1AR

There’s broad support for UBI across parties.

Evangel Penumaka et. al 21. With Isa Alomran & Abby Steckel, Researchers for Data For Progress. July 2021. Data For Progress. https://www.filesforprogress.org/memos/voters-support-a-guaranteed-income.pdf

These survey results show that a majority of likely voters broadly support a guaranteed income and associate it with positive impacts on their lives. The pandemic has exposed the financial and economic instability faced by working Americans on a day-to-day basis. Implementing a guaranteed income would be a vitally needed expansion to our existing social safety nets — and one that is popular across likely voters. A guaranteed income would ensure that we are taking the right steps for families to achieve secure financial futures and reduce the income inequality we see today. As city leaders begin to implement pilot programs for a guaranteed income throughout the U.S., they can do so knowing they have the support of voters behind them.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA Answers --- ENDI 23 › AT: Link---2AC/1AR › Link Turn---1AR

Supporting UBI is a winning political strategy---that builds PC.

Lucia Graves 21. Writer based in Washington, D.C., and a columnist for the Guardian. "Democrats Are Finally Unafraid to Be the Party of Free Money". New Republic. 1-8-2021. https://newrepublic.com/article/160842/ossoff-warnock-andrew-yang-money

When Yang first entered the presidential race, he and his idea of a “freedom dividend” were dismissed by mainstream Democrats, and political pundits used it to paint him as a joke. But his rise was a testament to how potent his idea was well before the recession started.

His hand has been considerably strengthened in these pandemic times. The $600 weekly unemployment sweetener that Congress seemingly walked backward into passing during its initial panicked response to the coronavirus crisis turned out to be an incredibly effective anti-poverty policy. It’s perhaps no wonder that simple promises of generosity were a potent political strategy in Georgia, where Ossoff and Warnock both improved upon Biden’s November showing. (Ossoff also outperformed his own Election Day numbers; Georgia’s jungle primary obscures such comparisons for Warnock.)

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA Answers --- ENDI 23 › AT: Link---2AC/1AR › Link Turn---1AR

UBI is a populist winner that attracts support from Republicans.

Bonnie Kristian 21. Former deputy editor and acting editor-in-chief of The Week. "Are pandemic relief checks making UBI inevitable?". The Week. 1-4-2021. https://theweek.com/articles/957862/are-pandemic-relief-checks-making-ubi-inevitable

Major crises can effect rapid changes in public opinion that otherwise would have required years or even decades to develop. Among the permanent opinion shifts of the COVID-19 pandemic, I expect to see a new — and perhaps even bipartisan — move toward universal basic income (UBI) or something like it, an evolution influenced by Americans' experience with pandemic relief checks, both the fact of them and the drawn-out political fights surrounding their passage.

UBI is exactly what it sounds like: a government income program which is not tied to recipients' employment (like unemployment insurance), age (like Social Security), income (like TANF), medical care (like Medicare or Medicaid), or food purchases (like SNAP). It's simply a monthly cash stipend that goes to everyone. The stipend could be big enough to cover all basic expenses (this is called a full UBI) or it could merely supplement other income (former Democratic presidential candidate Andrew Yang's proposal of a $1,000 per month "Freedom Dividend" is an example of this sort of partial UBI).

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA Answers --- ENDI 23 › AT: Link---2AC/1AR › Link Turn---2AC

UBI is bipartisan and a political winner that builds support across the aisle.

Zach Courtney 21. "Courtney: Senator Romney and Mayor Carter have it right. Just give people money." Minnesota Daily. 3-6-2021. https://mndaily.com/266074/opinion/courtney-senator-romney-and-mayor-carter-have-it-right-just-give-people-money/

How do we help Americans reach and stay in the middle class? Democrats argue in favor of increasing the minimum wage to $15 an hour. Republicans have long argued for tax cuts on the wealthy, which would eventually trickle down (the jury is back; this doesn’t work). In the last few years, there appears to be a new bipartisan solution to help Americans reach and stay in the middle class: universal basic income (UBI).

UBI means different things to different people, but — generally speaking — it means giving cash payments to people without an income or work requirement (hence, universal). This is done either instead of or while cutting down on “in-kind” benefits like food stamps, housing vouchers or other programs. UBI advocates (like me) argue that it would cut down on increasingly large and complicated bureaucracy while simultaneously ensuring we have a sufficient social safety net. It’s a perfect example of both “keep it simple, stupid” and “more bang for your buck.”

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA Answers --- ENDI 23 › AT: Uniqueness---2AC/1AR › Delay---1AR

They can kick the can without any impact.

Alex Heider 5-30. "Former Ag Committee chair says the current Farm Bill could possibly be extended". RFD-TV. 5-30-2023. https://www.rfdtv.com/former-ag-committee-chair-says-the-current-farm-bill-could-possibly-be-extended

The Farm Bill deadline is just four months away, and there are growing concerns the important piece of legislation will not be done on time. However, Collin Peterson, the former House Ag Committee chair says that wouldn’t necessarily be a deal breaker.

“They could. I’d be surprised, but September 30th is not a drop-dead date. Nothing actually happens that day that’s going to cause any significant problems. I think they probably have till the end of the year to try to get something done. If it doesn’t get done by the end of the year, I think it’ll probably get extended. They’ll do a one-year extension, and then it’s an election year. I wouldn’t be surprised if you do a one-year extension, then you’ll end up with a two-year extension,” Peterson said.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA Answers --- ENDI 23 › AT: Uniqueness---2AC/1AR › Delay---2AC

Will be delayed.

Jorge E. Castro et al 5-30. With Marc J. Gerson, Patrick J. Holten, Loren C. Ponds. "Tax Take: Fix Me Now – Potential Implications Of The Secure 2.0 Technical Corrections Letter". Miller & Chevalier. 5-30-2023. https://www.millerchevalier.com/publication/tax-take-fix-me-now-potential-implications-secure-20-technical-corrections-letter

In addition to providing some clarity for a number of time-sensitive and important retirement provisions (including Roth plan catch-up contributions), the letter has potential implications for the broader technical corrections process. The introduction of a bipartisan and bicameral technical corrections bills in the House and Senate suggests a return to "regular order" – an encouraging development after years in which both parties' enactment of tax legislation on a partisan basis through reconciliation led to the politicization and breakdown of the process of getting technical corrections agreed upon and enacted. Furthermore, despite uncertainty around when the technical corrections bill might be introduced, it could be positioned for consideration at year-end when Congress must deal with several "must pass" bills including government funding, FAA reauthorization, and a farm bill extension that technically expire on September 30th but likely will get extended out until the end of the year.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA Answers --- ENDI 23 › AT: Uniqueness---2AC/1AR › Won’t Pass---1AR

Passing a farm bill is structurally unlikely in this congress.

Forrest Laws 23. "Farm bill looking increasingly less likely in 2023". Farm Progress. 2-23-2023. https://www.farmprogress.com/farm-business/farm-bill-looking-increasingly-less-likely-in-2023

Writing a new farm bill can be difficult under the best of circumstances but passing an ag law in the 118th Congress in 2023 or 2024 could prove to be especially challenging.

For openers, House Speaker Kevin McCarthy’s commitment to allow each of the government’s appropriation bills to be considered individually rather than in an omnibus spending resolution could take up a large portion of 2023.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA Answers --- ENDI 23 › AT: Uniqueness---2AC/1AR › Won’t Pass---1AR

The farm bill is derailed now.

Meredith Lee Hill 5-9. Food and agriculture policy reporter for POLITICO. She previously spent six years at NewsHour covering the 2016 and 2020 campaigns, the Trump and Biden administrations, Congress and economic policy. "Senate GOP leaders watch debt limit collide with their coveted farm bill ". POLITICO. 5-9-2023. https://www.politico.com/news/2023/05/09/debt-limit-farm-bill-00095844

Senate GOP leaders are growing concerned their party’s debt limit standoff with the White House could derail another top policy priority: the $1 trillion farm bill.

The massive piece of legislation serves as a key lifeline for not only the agricultural-heavy home states of nearly every Senate Republican leader, but for the rural economy in states like Montana, Ohio and Pennsylvania that the party hopes to win back in 2024.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA Answers --- ENDI 23 › AT: Uniqueness---2AC/1AR › Won’t Pass---2AC

Won’t pass---the farm bill is behind schedule now and congress is fighting about SNAP provisions.

Jim Wiesemeyer 6-5. Washington analyst for Pro Farmer, previously a Washington editor with Doane’s Agricultural Report and Washington editor and managing editor of the Washington Farmletter. "3 Reasons the Farm Bill is Behind Schedule". Drovers. 6-5-2023. https://www.drovers.com/news/ag-policy/3-reasons-farm-bill-behind-schedule

The Senate and House Ag committees are facing delays in drafting the next farm bill, and it is expected to be the most expensive farm bill to date, clocking in at around $1.5 trillion.

The process is “behind schedule” judging by past experiences with previous farm bills. Neither of the committees have established a timeline for crafting the legislation, although whispers have a draft coming before the August recess, or no later than September.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Impact---2NC/1NR › Climate Impact---2NC

Farm bill solves climate change

Daniel Rath et al. 23. PhD in Soil and Biogeochemistry from the University of California, Davis. “2023 Farm Bill Can Help Address Climate Crisis.” https://www.nrdc.org/bio/daniel-rath/2023-farm-bill-can-help-address-climate-crisis

The recently released Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) Summary report written by the world’s top climate science experts sends a clear message:

We are facing an unprecedented climate crisis caused by human activities and hitting 1.5 degrees C of global warming is likely to happ

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Impact---2NC/1NR › Forests Impact---2NC

Extinction.

Jennifer Skene 21, Natural Climate Solutions Policy Manager, International Program at the NRDC, Visiting Clinical Lecturer in Law at Yale Law School, JD from Yale Law School, “Our Climate Future Is Rooted in North America’s Forests”, https://www.nrdc.org/bio/jennifer-skene/our-climate-future-rooted-north-americas-forests

Forest protection, once the “forgotten” climate solution, has become an integral pillar of climate discussions. But while attention has largely focused on forests like those of the Amazon and Indonesia, the climate doesn’t hinge just on what happens in the tropics. It also depends on the boreal; the temperate rainforests of the Pacific; the conifer forests of the Rockies; the Northeastern coastal forests; the Southern wetland forests. These forests in North America are being lost or stripped of carbon rich mature trees right under our noses and need to remain standing and intact if we are going to achieve a climate-safe, sustainable future. As the Biden administration looks to act on its to reducing U.S. greenhouse gas emissions by at least 50% by 2030, it needs to embrace a bold new vision for forest protection that looks at how we can protect the climate-critical forest resources in our own backyard. 

North America’s forests, the homelands of Indigenous communities and havens of rich biodiversity, are some of the most carbon-dense areas on Earth. These forests are part of the global forest respiratory system that, each year, absorbs one-third of human-caused greenhouse gas emissions. They are also gatekeepers of vast stores of carbon locked safely out of the atmosphere in their soils and biomass. The Canadian boreal forest alone stores twice as much carbon as the world’s oil reserves, while U.S. forests collectively absorb the equivalent of about 12 percent of the nation’s annual carbon pollution. Their sentry stands between us and climate catastrophe. 

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Impact---2NC/1NR › Forests Impact---2NC

Farm bill key to North American forests.

Debbie Stabenow 3/1/23, holds a master’s degree from Michigan State University, the senior United States senator from Michigan, “Chairwoman Stabenow Opening Statement at Hearing on Conservation and Forestry Programs in the Next Farm Bill”, https://www.agriculture.senate.gov/newsroom/dem/press/release/chairwoman-stabenow-opening-statement-at-hearing-on-conservation-and-forestry-programs-in-the-next-farm-bill

This Committee has a very important job ahead of us – passing the next Farm Bill with strong, bipartisan support, and it’s our job to make sure it supports our farmers, our families, and our environment.

Our farmers have a critical job to do as well – growing food, fiber and fuel for our country and our world while also protecting our land and water. This is nothing new for those of us in Michigan, where protecting the Great Lakes is part of our DNA.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Impact---2NC/1NR › Sustainability Impact---2NC

That solves extinction from environmental degradation.

Mauricio Quintero-Angel 18. Professor of Agricultural Engineering, Ph.D. in Environmental Sciences, Universidad del Valle-Colombia, https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Mauricio_Quintero-Angel/publication/322011429_Tendencies_and_challenges_for_the_assessment_of_agricultural_sustainability/links/5a3d43f4458515f6b039bf3d/Tendencies-and-challenges-for-the-assessment-of-agricultural-sustainability.pdf

3. Ecological degradation in food production and the need for new sustainable paradigms in agriculture From the neolithic period, different human groups have developed agriculture, devising processes for the obtention of seeds, sowing, plantation maintenance, harvest and exchange and commercialization of food. In many cases these activities have altered the dynamic balance of ecosystems, and in the Anthropocene, the agriculture is recognized as a primary driver of global change and as the main contributor to environmental risks (Foley et al., 2011). The degradation of ecosystems (their structure, dynamic and evolution) for food production can be explained in two ways: • By the appropriation processes of natural resources and environmental services, where any intervention generates negative impacts on environment; • By disposing residues to the environment. According to González de Molina and Toledo (2014) these emanations should be analyzed by both the quality as well as the quantity of the materials of the residues, meaning if they are recyclable or not by nature or if they surpass or not the natural recycling capacity. Nevertheless, when the appropriation of nature is done disregarding the productive vocation of the ecosystems, its capacity to renovate itself and its existence is threatened. This in turn generates certain changes that end up affecting society (Toledo, 2008). For example, a reduction on crops productivity or the use of agrochemicals to attenuate the loss of soil fertility. In these cases the farmer spends a great amount of time recovering the ecosystem, generating additional negative pay offs causing the producer to overexploit its labor to balance the relation. It could be considered that nature generates penalizations to wrong decisions made by the producer, accumulating in time and space, which could lead to a collapse of the material base and even the disappearance of populations, states or civilizations, requiring sustainable interventions over the ecosystems (González de Molina and Toledo, 2014). Nonetheless, processes such as the circulation, transformation and specially consumption increase the pressure over nature. According to González de Molina and Toledo (2014) in human history the volumes of materials-products that circulate as well as the distances covered before they are consumed, have increased. Going from the non-merchant and non-monetary trade, to the trade mediated by money, private property and markets. The latter results in a vast network of trades that is intimately linked to the transformations where the old relation, direct and almost immediate between appropriation and consumption gets blurred (González de Molina and Toledo, 2014). These authors argue that at a global level and at the beginning of the XXI century, consumption constitutes a powerful factor that demands incentive and even subordinates the other metabolic processes. Examples around the world could explain the important role of consumption. For example, a global increase in the levels of meat consumption, is recognized as one of the greatest threats to tropical ecosystems and biodiversity (Machovina and Feeley, 2014). Livestock production accounts for up to 75% of all agricultural lands (Foley et al., 2011), so that a rise in the consumption of meat products increases the demand for animal feed and consequently changes the land uses with the associated negative environmental impact on ecosystems and biodiversity. Also, it is known that agri-food systems in which higher calories are consumed by humans stem from animal products that have a higher total calorie throughput (Mayer et al., 2015). Likewise, another interesting example is related to commerce between northern and southern countries. After the XX century, the consumption in northern countries and the international commerce with southern countries has been a factor that has promoted the expansion of agricultural border and has contributed to intensifying the exploitation of the soil in southern countries. This represented an increase in volumes of foods and produced agricultural raw materials, as well as in increased productivity by having higher yields per hectare (Pérez, 2006); with associated environmental costs and natural heritage exhaustion. According to Pérez (2006) the increases on productivity are very important in economic terms, but these have associated environmental implications a: i) The ecological footprint caused by the intensive introduction of energetic inputs based on non-renewable resources produce energetically deficient agriculture that is of low ecological sustainable value; and, ii) absolute increments on the use of other natural resources such as water, since the dynamic on the use of the soil has a relation of correspondence in the dynamic of the use of hydric resources for agricultural activity. The strong pressure over nature by conventional agriculture, and also the permanent demand of food by the increasing human population, implies the necessity of new paradigms for an agricultural production in the frame of productive tendency of ecosystems. In relation to this Leff proposes: The environmental crisis takes us to rethink reality, to understand its tracks of complexity and the linking of the complexity of the being and of the thinking process, of reason and passion, of sensitivity and intelligibility, so that from there, open new roads of knowledge and new existential senses for the reconstruction of the world and the reappropriation of nature (Leff, 2006). In this new perspective, the modern world crisis must be considered, especially in the rural sector, as a consequence of the transgression of the biophysical limits of the planet for food production. For Toledo et al. (2009), the way to approach the crisis is through the improvement of the reduced ways in which traditional models as well as the modern ones articulate each other and with nature. Thus, bringing about the concept of sustainable development, which allows perceiving an alternate modernity that is really the adoption of a new method of appropriation of nature. In this sense, sustainable agriculture can be understood as the management and use of agroecosystems in a way that the biological diversity, productivity, regeneration capacity, vitality and functioning capacity are maintained. So that important biological, economic and social functions at a local, national and international level can be met (today and in the future) without damaging other ecosystems (Lewandowski et al., 1999). Sustainability can be reached through agricultural practices based on the adequate and profound knowledge of ecological processes in production units and their context. Therefore, agreeing with Gliessman a greater comprehension and evaluation of the current productive processes is required to focus agricultural production toward social and economic changes that promote sustainability (Gliessman, 1998).

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Impact---2NC/1NR › AT: No Food Wars---2NC

Food is the likely cause of global conflict. Solving it is a conflict dampener.

Sinéad Lehane 17. Research manager for Future Directions International’s Global Food and Water Crises Research program. Her current research projects include Australia’s food system and water security in the Tibetan Plateau region. Shaping Conflict in the 21st Century—The Future of Food and Water Security. February 2, 2017. www.hidropolitikakademi.org/shaping-conflict-in-the-21st-century-the-future-of-food-and-water-security.html

In his book, The Coming Famine, Julian Cribb writes that the wars of the 21st century will involve failed states, rebellions, civil conflict, insurgencies and terrorism. All of these elements will be triggered by competition over dwindling resources, rather than global conflicts with clearly defined sides. More than 40 countries experienced civil unrest following the food price crisis in 2008. The rapid increase in grain prices and prevailing food insecurity in many states is linked to the outbreak of protests, food riots and the breakdown of governance. Widespread food insecurity is a driving factor in creating a disaffected population ripe for rebellion. Given the interconnectivity of food security and political stability, it is likely food will continue to act as a political stressor on regimes in the Middle East and elsewhere. Addressing Insecurity Improving food and water security and encouraging resource sharing is critical to creating a stable and secure global environment. While food and water shortages contribute to a rising cycle of violence, improving food and water security outcomes can trigger the opposite and reduce the potential for conflict. With the global population expected to reach 9 billion by 2040, the likelihood of conflict exacerbated by scarcity over the next century is growing. Conflict is likely to be driven by a number of factors and difficult to address through diplomacy or military force. Population pressures, changing weather, urbanization, migration, a loss of arable land and freshwater resources are just some of the multi-layered stressors present in many states. Future inter-state conflict will move further away from the traditional, clear lines of military conflict and more towards economic control and influence.