Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Impact---2NC/1NR › AT: No Food Wars---2NC

Food shortages are the largest proximate cause of conflict---studies overwhelmingly go negative.

Ore Koren 16. PhD Candidate in Political Science at U Minnesota and Benjamin Bagozzi, Assistant Professor of Political Science & International Relations at U Delaware 9-15-2016 “From global to local, food insecurity is associated with contemporary armed conflicts,” Food Security, DOI 10.1007/s12571-016-0610-x, http://www.benjaminbagozzi.com/uploads/1/2/5/7/12579534/koren-bagozzi-fs.pdf.

A growing number of studies of environmental stressors and social conflict posit that future wars will be fought over diminishing resources (Miguel et al. 2004; Burke et al. 2009;O ’ Loughlin et al. 2012; Scheffran et al. 2012 ). Building on insights from these studies, as well as other suggestive accounts (e.g. Brinkman and Hendrix 2011 ;Hendrix and Brinkman 2013 ; Messer and Cohen 2006 ;Prunier 2008 ), the present study demonstrates empirically, for the first time, the existence of a systemic relationship between conflict on the one hand, and food (in) security on the other, both globally and locally. Specifically, highly disaggregated cropland-based measures of food insecurity are shown to produce a significant effect on the incidence of inter and intra-state armed conflict worldwide. Unlike the majority of previous studies, which rely primarily on country-level indicators (Miguel et al. 2004 ; Burke et al. 2009 ; Scheffran et al. 2012 ;Buhaug 2010 ) or focus specifically on sub-Saharan Africa (Miguel et al. 2004 ; Burke et al. 2009;O ’ Loughlin et al. 2012;Buhaug 2010; Fjelde and Hultman 2014 ), the present approach uses geographic factors to estimate the regional sub-state distribution of conflict globally. Two agricultural output measures, the percent of cropland in a given region and the amount of cropland per capita within agricultural regions, are used to proxy for the demand and supply aspects of food security, respectively (Barrett 2010 ). Using logistic regression (i.e., logit) models, these measures are then paired with a large number of political, economic, and climatic indicators in order to estimate the direct effects of food security on violent conflict. Evidence suggests that conflict occurs in areas with higher access to, but lower availability of, food resources. Together these findings imply that food insecurity produces an independent effect on contemporary social and political conflict. While relatively little research directly addresses the relationship between food insecurity and conflict specifically, numerous studies have implied that such a relationship exists. For instance, in their analysis of the relationship between climate variability and conflict in Sub-Saharan Africa, Burke et al. found that B [t]emperature variables are strongly related to conflict incidence over our historical panel ^ (2009 , 20,670. See also Miguel et al. 2004 ; Koubi et al. 2012 ). They further hypothesize that, B [t]emperature can affect agricultural yields both through increases in crop evapotranspiration (and hence heightened water stress in the absence of irrigation) and through accelerated crop development...reducing African sta- ple crop yields by 10 % – 30 % per °C of warming ^ (ibid. 20,672). Somewhat more cautiously, O ’ Loughlin et al. conclude that, B [o]ur study and other studies question the evidence that climatic variability is uniformly driving up the risk of conflict in sub-Saharan Africa, ^ while also noting that B the positive association between instability and temperature may result from the harmful effects of high temperatures on food products such as maize ^ (2012, 18,347). While these conclusions were supported by subsequent studies (Raleigh and Kniveton 2012; Hendrix and Salehyan 2012 ;Hsiangand Meng 2014 ), other scholars question the validity of these findings and show that the incidence of conflict is primarily related to political and economic conditions (e.g. Buhaug 2010 ). In common with all these studies, however, is the insight that a major mechanism by which climate change increases the likelihood of conflict is through its effects on food supplies.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Impact---2NC/1NR › Turns Econ---2NC

US food supply shocks shred the global economy.

Gert Peersman & Jasmien De Winne 16. *Professor in Econ at Ghent University. De Winne is a Management Assistant at Strabag Belgium. "Macroeconomic effects of disruptions in global food commodity markets: Evidence for the United States". Brookings. 2016. https://www.brookings.edu/bpea-articles/macroeconomic-effects-of-disruptions-in-global-food-commodity-markets/

The authors compare their estimates on food supply shocks to the impact of similar economic shocks, such as to the global crude oil supply. They find that the impact of a rise in real food commodity prices on economic activity is roughly twice as large as the impact of a rise in crude oil prices of equal size, and that while the dynamic effects of both shocks on real personal consumption are more or less the same, the average food supply shock has a slightly stronger and more persistent impact on consumer prices than the average oil supply shock.

They highlight, that both types of shocks cause monetary policymakers to respond in different ways. A food price shock of 5 percent increases the Federal Funds rate by 24 basis points (a rise in 10 basis points leads to a fall in real GDP between 0.05 percent and 0.1 percent), whereas the rate decreases by 20 basis points, on impact, in response to a 10 percent oil shock. In other words, monetary policy seems to amplify the consequences of food market disruptions on economic activity. The authors estimate that monetary policy response to food market disruptions can potentially explain almost one-third of the effects of the shock.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Internal Link---2NC/1NR › Ag High---2NC

Ag exports are high.

USDA 23. US Department of Agriculture. “2022 Was Another Record Year for U.S. Farm Exports.” 2-10-23. https://www.usda.gov/media/press-releases/2023/02/10/2022-was-another-record-year-us-farm-exports

WASHINGTON, Feb. 10, 2023 – The American agricultural sector posted its best export year ever in 2022 with international sales of U.S. farm and food products reaching $196 billion, Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack announced today. Final 2022 trade data released earlier this week by the Commerce Department shows that U.S. agricultural exports increased 11 percent, or $19.5 billion, from the previous record set in 2021.

“This second consecutive year of record-setting agricultural exports, coupled with a record $160.5 billion in net farm income in 2022, demonstrates the success of the Biden-Harris Administration’s efforts to create new and better markets for America’s agricultural producers and businesses,” Vilsack said. “We’re strengthening relationships with our trading partners and holding those partners accountable for their commitments. We’re making historic investments in infrastructure to strengthen supply chains and prevent market disruptions. We’re knocking down trade barriers that hamper U.S. producers’ access to key markets. And we’re continuing to invest in export market development programs, partnering with industry to bring high-quality, cost-competitive U.S. products to consumers around the world.”

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Internal Link---2NC/1NR › Ag High---2NC

Agriculture is bouncing back now.

Produce Blue Book 23. "Report shows agriculture’s growing impact on U.S. economy, surpassing pre-pandemic levels – Produce Blue Book". Produce Blue Book. 3-21-2023. https://www.producebluebook.com/2023/03/21/report-shows-agricultures-growing-impact-on-u-s-economy-surpassing-pre-pandemic-levels/

Washington – Today 25 food and agriculture groups released the seventh annual Feeding the Economy report, revealing food and agriculture industries and their suppliers contribute over $8.6 trillion to the U.S. economy, nearly one-fifth of total national output and a 22% increase since the 2019 report.

Providing data on jobs, wages, and economic output, this farm-to-fork analysis illustrates the food and agriculture sector’s impact on local and nationwide economic activity. The data also underscores this sector’s resilience and reliability amid unprecedented global and domestic crises, including the commodity shock following the war in Ukraine and continued supply chain disruptions.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Internal Link---2NC/1NR › Ag High---2NC

Agriculture is strong now, but it’s not locked in.

John Bode 23. President and CEO of the Corn Refiners Association. He has been an active leader in federal food and agriculture policy for the past four decades, including three presidential appointments at the U.S. Department of Agriculture, where he was responsible for over half of USDA's budget "Opinion: U.S. agriculture is strong but held back by trade barriers ". Agripulse. 3-21-2023. https://www.agri-pulse.com/articles/19095-opinion-us-agriculture-is-strong-but-held-back-by-trade-barriers

It's an understatement to say that the U.S. food and agriculture industry has faced its fair share of trials over the past few years. Reckless cost and personnel cuts by railroads eroded supply chain infrastructure, a problem made plain by COVID-19 pandemic disruptions and recent rail safety issues. Unreliable foreign suppliers and ocean freight systems were exposed. The war in Ukraine led to the largest commodity crisis since the 1970s. Generally, supply chain disruptions turned global enterprise on its head.

And yet, according to Feeding the Economy, a new report released today by 25 food and agriculture organizations, the sector is powerful and has bounced back impressively, increasing its economic output in all 50 states compared to one year earlier. Agriculture-related economic activity accounts for 20% of the U.S. economy, reaching far beyond the farmgate. For example, there are more than twice as many American jobs manufacturing agricultural products as manufacturing automobiles.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Internal Link---2NC/1NR › AT: Alt Causes---2NC

Farm bill overcomes all alt causes to ag---risk mitigation programs provide a support backdrop for farmers that allows them to keep growing amidst the backdrop of the squo

Richard Guebert Jr. 23. President of the Illinois Farm Bureau. “Farm bill critical to keeping America’s food supply affordable.” https://rochellenews-leader.com/article/farm-bill-critical-to-keeping-americas-food-supply-affordable

General inflation is a long-term issue squeezing the pocketbooks of families across America, but the farm income forecast is a reminder that farmers are not benefiting from higher prices at the grocery store.

While some commodity prices are rising, farmers are grappling with additional circumstances, such as drought, avian influenza and supply and labor costs. After accounting for business expenses, farmers’ share of the food dollar is only 7.4 cents.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Internal Link---2NC/1NR › Key to Agriculture---2NC

Solves food security and soil

Laleh Morshedi 17. Farhad Lashgarara, Seyed Jamal Farajollah Hosseini and Maryam Omidi Najafabadi, Department of Agricultural Extension and Education, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University. The Role of Organic Farming for Improving Food Security from the Perspective of Fars Farmers. November 14, 2017. Sustainability Journal 9:2086 – 2017

One of the most important problems of the world in the 21st century is food security [1], In Iran, on one hand, providing food for the growing population requires a tremendous increase in the level of agricultural production [2] and, on the other hand, given the importance of food security and the irreparable damage due to excessive use of agricultural chemicals, attention has been paid to organic farming [3]. The International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements (IFOAM) defines organic farming as a production system that maintains soil health, ecosystems, and humans. According to Lampkin, organic farming can be defined as "an approach to agriculture which aims at social, environmental and economic sustainability and animal welfare by minimizing the use of external resources, maximizing the use of locally-derived renewable resources and agro-ecosystem management and using the market to compensate for internalizing external costs" [4,5]. Organic farming is based on minimizing the use of external inputs, fertilizers, insecticides, and pesticides [6]. As defined by the World Food Summit in 1996, "food security" exists when all people at all times have adequate physical and economic access to enough safe and nutritious food to meet their needs for a healthy and active life [7]. Food security is a complex process that involves dimensions such as availability, access, utilization, and stability [8]. Owing to the high population of 7 billion people in the world, the dispute over the ability of organic farming to feed the world is high. Generally, large biotechnology companies, especially those that benefit from the use of pesticides and genetically-modified seeds, have raised the question of whether organic farming can feed the world or not. According to the FAO, the applicability of organic farming on production is dependent on the previous fanning systems. An over-simplification of the impact of the transition to organic farming on yields shows that, in developed countries, organic systems decrease yields; the range is dependent on the intensity of the external inputs used before conversion; in the so-called Green Revolution areas (irrigated lands), conversion to organic agriculture usually leads to almost identical yields; and in traditional rain-fed agriculture (with low external inputs), organic agriculture has the potential to increase yields [9J. Evaluation of the benefits and limitations of organic agriculture on food security is complex. The effect of the transition to organic practices will depend on the farmer and farming society, their skills, and the resources accessible to them. Organic agriculture can increase productivity, especially in situations where farmers are vulnerable to food shortages; it can increase income through higher financial value, and lower prices paid for inputs, or the combinations of these three. The variety of production in organic agriculture decreases the risk of crop failure and relevant food security and economic problems [lOj. Organic agriculture is a sustainable and environmentally friendly production system that offers developing countries a wide range of economic, environmental, and social benefits. Although organic fanning systems produce yields less than conventional agriculture, they are more profitable to farmers because consumers are willing to pay more [11]. Organic agriculture has three dimensions—social, economic, and environmental—and these three dimensions can improve food security. In the social dimension, organic farming requires more compact work and has the potential to contribute to long-term employment in rural areas. Organic farming plays an important role in employment in rural areas because of the hiring of more seasonal workers and, given the increases in organic food sales, however, opportunities are likely to continue in the occupations related to organic foods. Organic farming promotes entrepreneurship and decreases immigration in rural areas, thus, it enables new and different groups in the society to be involved in agricultural activities and will help to improve employment. Additionally, organic farming recognizes the value of indigenous and traditional knowledge and combines indigenous knowledge with production procedures which enhances social capacity while empowering farmers and local communities, which is consistent with achieving food security [9,10,12-14]. In the economic dimension, organic farming is a sustainable option for small farmers to improve food security and to enhance the overall performance of farm income, and it can be said that an increase in household income can increase food security. Organic farming reduces input costs besides the increase of the standards of living of small and marginal farmers [12,15-21]. Organic farming is cost-effective for farmers due to the lack of usage of chemicals (due to its expensive price), turning to inexpensive methods, such as biological resources rather than chemical fertilizers and pesticides. Other reasons that persuade farmers towards organic farming is the raising of product prices and consequently-increased profits from the sale of these products and the lack of intermediaries to sell them [22]. Organic farming uses existing local assets rather than consuming capital resources intensively, so poor farmers can improve their farm productivity and fertility while avoiding dependence on expensive external inputs. Organic farming can increase productivity and income, thus helping to improve food security. There are a large number of economic opportunities that lead to the increase of added value of organic products through processing and marketing activities and the improvement of food security in the long-term [9,12,16-20,23,24]. In the environmental dimension, organic farming improves soil quality, secures farm future, and offers environmental protection. The fertile soil leads to stability and is effective in the production cycle. More nutrients given to the soil result in less soil erosion and increase soil biodiversity, which improves food security in the long-term [20,25,26]. Additionally, in organic farming with minimum tillage, biological fertilizers, proper crop rotation and cover crops, green manure, etc., an increase in soil fertility occurs [18]. Organic farming enhances food security by improving resistance to diseases and pests, combating desertification by reducing soil erosion and protecting water resources, and maintaining and improving environmental services. Avoiding chemical residues and pesticides and consuming fresh products, acquiring healthy diets, and taking advantage of the nutritional value of organic products are among other motivations that improve food security [10,13,21,23,25-27].

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Internal Link---2NC/1NR › Key to Agriculture---2NC

Farm bill is key to the resilience and profitability of American agriculture.

Reps. Randy Feenstra & Mariannette Miller-Meeks 23. Feenstra represents Iowa’s 4th District and is a member of the Agriculture Committee. Miller-Meeks represents Iowa’s 2nd District. "The 2023 farm bill: Protecting US agriculture’s productivity, profitability and competitiveness". Hill. 3-20-2023. https://thehill.com/policy/future-of-farming/3904321-the-2023-farm-bill-protecting-us-agricultures-productivity-profitability-and-competitiveness/

Agriculture is the beating heart of the American economy and the lifeblood of our rural main streets in Iowa. From hog farmers in Sioux County to corn growers in Washington County, farming runs through our veins in rural America — and federal policy must complement our proud traditions; not inhibit our productivity. For our country to remain the breadbasket of the world, we must pass a strong farm bill that protects the productivity, profitability and competitiveness of American farmers, producers and our agricultural community.

In basic economic terms, productivity measures the relationship between input and output. As technology has advanced and farming practices have evolved, American farmers have grown more food with fewer resources, and in turn, have helped to alleviate global food insecurity and cement America’s status as the world’s agricultural powerhouse. However, amid rising energy costs and record inflation fueled by trillions in wasteful government spending, the cost of basic inputs like feed, seed and fertilizer have skyrocketed, leaving our farmers and their families in a precarious economic situation. The current state of our economy underscores the need to protect vital programs in the farm bill like access to credit and funding for agricultural research and development. For example, credit accessibility at local banks and other financial institutions allows our farmers to purchase new equipment and precision agriculture technologies to remain productive even when economic conditions sour. At the same time, continued investment in research and development at our nation’s top academic institutions not only supports the livelihoods of American producers, but also fuels scientific breakthroughs that benefit agriculture.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Internal Link---2NC/1NR › Internal Link---Global Food Security---2NC

Farm bill is key to global food security.

Kimberly Flowers 18. Director of the Global Food Security Project at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) in Washington, D.C. & Kelsey Bachenberg – junior researcher with the CSIS Global Food Security Project, “The 2018 Farm Bill, Agricultural Research, and Implications for Global Food Security,” https://www.csis.org/analysis/2018-farm-bill-agricultural-research-and-implications-global-food-security

This year Congress is expected to pass a piece of legislation that deeply affects the lives of all Americans and determines the strategic positioning of the United States in global agriculture for the next five years. The Farm Bill influences the food we eat, how we grow it, and the lives of the farmers who do so. Funding for agricultural research and development (R&D) only makes up a tiny sliver of the Farm Bill’s budget—about 0.2 percent in the 2014 bill—but it has profound consequences for U.S. agricultural competitiveness and global food security. The United States has historically been at the forefront of agricultural science and innovation, but our leadership is slipping: China has been outspending us 2 to 1 on agricultural research since 2013. Q1: What is the Farm Bill, and what does it have to do with agricultural research and development? A1: The first Farm Bill was dominated by farm support programs meant to ease the blow of the Great Depression. Since then it has evolved into an enormous omnibus bill that addresses a wide range of issues, spanning nutrition assistance, rural development, international food aid, and more. The legislation falls under the jurisdiction of the House and Senate Agriculture Committees and sparks strong opinions from diverse interest groups ranging from maritime unions to commodity associations. The 2014 Farm Bill authorized a projected $489 billion in mandatory federal spending between 2014 and 2018. Just four of the bill’s 12 titles—nutrition, crop insurance, conservation, and farm commodity support—make up 99 percent of its mandatory authorizations. Funded at over $390 billion, nutrition programming alone accounts for roughly 80 percent of the budget, with the bulk of this funding earmarked for the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), previously known as food stamps. Source: USDA Economic Research Service, “Projected Spending Under the 2014 Farm Bill,” . In comparison, the portion of the bill that supports agricultural research and extension received $800 million over five years. Despite this small share, these funds determine priorities for agricultural science related to crop diseases and pests, farm animal health, natural resource management, food safety, nutrition, and countless other areas critical to U.S. agricultural and food systems. The Farm Bill is the primary source of federal funding for agricultural science. With these resources, the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) funds the work of its three in-house research agencies—the Agricultural Research Service, the Economic Research Service, and the National Agricultural Statistics Service—as well as its extramural research wing, the National Institute of Food and Agriculture, which funds research through land-grant universities, state agricultural experiment stations, and other institutions at the state and local levels. The 2014 Farm Bill also authorized $200 million to establish the nonprofit Foundation for Food and Agriculture Research, which matches federal funding with private-sector donations to award grants for public-private collaborative research partnerships. Q2: What are the trends in U.S. public investment in agricultural R&D that impact our leadership position? A2: Despite a 40 percent return on investment, growth in U.S. public-sector funding for agricultural R&D slowed in the early 1980s, flatlined in the 1990s, and turned negative as of 2011. Inflation-adjusted public investments in agricultural R&D fell by 20 percent between 2008 and 2013. These trends are troubling on their own but even more so in light of the global context. As the United States steadily chipped away at agricultural research funding, rapidly growing economies—like China, India, and Brazil—did the opposite. As a result of these inverse patterns, the U.S. share of global public agricultural R&D investments fell by nearly half between 1960 and 2011, from 20 percent to 11 percent. Meanwhile, China ramped up spending almost eightfold between 1990 and 2013, overtaking the United States as the biggest investor in public agricultural R&D in 2008. U.S. federal funding for agricultural science has also deteriorated relative to other research areas. In 2012, the National Institutes of Health (one of the foremost federal biomedical research centers in the world) outspent USDA nearly 15 to 1 on research and development. There is no question that human health is a high priority for R&D dollars, but ensuring an adequate, healthy, and safe food supply plays a critical part in improving health outcomes. Q3: Why is public agricultural R&D important for U.S. agriculture? A3: American agriculture is competitive because it is productive. U.S. agricultural output grew by a staggering 268 percent from 1949 to 2007. Expanded agricultural production was due almost entirely to productivity growth, a metric for how efficiently inputs (land, labor, and other resources) are turned into outputs (crop and livestock yields), rather than an expansion of our agricultural footprint. R&D, paired with systems that bring discoveries from the laboratory to the field, is the principal driver of productivity growth. American farmers have benefited from a flood of breakthrough technologies and innovations—like high-yielding, drought-tolerant seeds and more efficient equipment—that have transformed farming as we know it. They have experienced first-hand how investments in public R&D can allow them to maintain their competitive edge both at home and abroad. Expanded output also suppresses consumer food prices, with particular benefits for low-income households, who typically spend a greater share of their income on food. U.S. annual agricultural productivity growth peaked at a rate of about 2 percent in the mid-1980s and has been slowing ever since. This is especially concerning in the face of global agriculture’s myriad new challenges: climate change, unfamiliar pests and diseases, and rising production costs, to name a few. Given such threats, U.S. agriculture will require “maintenance research” just to sustain current levels of productivity, let alone boost yields. With continued public-sector R&D divestment, slumping productivity growth is likely to persist. Stagnant productivity has negative implications beyond our domestic food supply. In the long term, losing ground on investments in agricultural R&D to other countries means losing our competitive edge to them, too. Failing to invest in the next generation of scientists would hamstring our scientific workforce well into the future, further diminishing our long-run leadership in global agricultural research. America’s competitive advantage is rooted in being on the cutting edge of scientific discovery. Q4: What are the global implications of U.S. agricultural R&D? A4: The United States has long been a leader in advancing the frontier of agricultural science. American scientists—often in partnership with international research institutions like CGIAR—tackle issues relevant to both domestic and global agriculture. Transformative techniques and innovations born of this research flow from the United States to the rest of the world. In poor countries that cannot afford to undertake their own agricultural research, these discoveries help farmers do more with less. When U.S. agricultural scientists partner internationally, it often produces dual wins for both domestic and global stakeholders. For example, in the last decade, USDA-funded scientists worked in collaboration with international researchers to address a virulent wheat stem rust, Ug99, which wrought havoc on wheat yields across Africa and Asia. Eighty percent of the global wheat supply was vulnerable to Ug99, including U.S. production, posing a potentially devastating threat to global food security (wheat accounts for 20 percent of calories consumed globally). But by using CGIAR breeding lines, scientists stopped the spread of the disease. By partnering with scientists internationally to address global challenges like wheat rust, the United States safeguards domestic agriculture against future threats, while simultaneously bolstering resilience and productivity around the world. Consumption growth coupled with dietary changes driven by increased incomes will boost demand for agricultural products from 60 percent to over 110 percent in the coming decades. Agricultural productivity growth is key to satisfying this rising demand, but it must be harnessed in a sustainable manner to safeguard the environment. However, productivity growth is not on course to meet forecasted demands and is especially lagging in developing countries, where population and consumption growth is concentrated. Increased investments in agricultural R&D and knowledge transfer systems will be essential to ensure food security in the developing world. The Farm Bill could help to chart a more food secure future by fostering international research collaboration that supports the strategic interests of both the United States and our partners. For example, Section 1402 of the Farm Bill, which covers agricultural research, extension, and education, could be enhanced by adding language that incentivizes international scientific collaboration through USDA. The Lugar Center agrees. The first point in its Principles for Public Investments in Agriculture Sciences, published this week, states “both domestic and international research need to work together on common goals.”

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Internal Link---2NC/1NR › Internal Link---Global Food Security---2NC

Farm bill solves global war.

Robert Dole 17. Former Senate Majority Leader. "How the farm bill could make the world safer". World Food Program USA. 2-22-2017. https://www.wfpusa.org/articles/how-the-farm-bill-could-make-the-world-safer-2/

The first field hearing for the 2018 farm bill takes place Thursday in Manhattan, Kan. — a town just 130 miles from where I was born and raised. It’s a fitting location given the crucial role that farmers, lawmakers and political leaders from the Midwest have played in addressing hunger and promoting national security.

That’s because the farm bill won’t impact just American growers and consumers. It will also have an enormous impact on the world’s hungry people — and help stabilize an increasingly unstable world.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Link---2NC/1NR › Link---Democrats---2NC

Most democrats prefer targeted programs.

Stephen Loiaconi 21. Associate Producer at Firing Line with Margaret Hoover, MFA focused in Creative Writing from George Mason University. "As cities test guaranteed income, Dems push Biden on recurring payments". WWMT. 4-1-2021. https://wwmt.com/amid-pandemic-recovery-more-cities-test-guaranteed-income-projects

Democrats hope to extend the child credit for at least several more years, if not make it permanent. Republican Sen. Mitt Romney, R-Utah, has proposed a similar monthly credit for families, although his plan would also scale back some existing assistance programs.

Other Republicans have denounced both versions of the monthly child credit as the start of a slippery slope toward universal basic income that would unravel welfare reforms of the 1990s and disincentivize works. Proponents say $300 per child per month is not nearly enough to live on, but it could provide a boost that pulls millions of working families out of poverty.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Link---2NC/1NR › Link---Democrats---2NC

Liberals oppose basic income.

Isabel V. Sawhill 16. Senior Fellow of Economic Studies at Brookings’ Center on Children and Families, Future of the Middle Class Initiative. "Money for nothing: Why a universal basic income is a step too far". Brookings. 6-15-2016. https://www.brookings.edu/blog/social-mobility-memos/2016/06/15/money-for-nothing-why-a-universal-basic-income-is-a-step-too-far/

Robert Greenstein argues, however, that a UBI would actually hurt the poor by reallocating support up the income scale. His logic is inescapable: either we have to spend additional trillions providing income grants to all Americans or we have to limit assistance to those who need it most.

One option is to provide unconditional payments along the lines of a UBI, but to phase it out as income rises. Libertarians like this approach since it gets rid of bureaucracies and leaves the poor free to spend the money on whatever they choose, rather than providing specific funds for particular needs. Liberals fear that such unconditional assistance would be unpopular and would be an easy target for elimination in the face of budget pressures. Right now most of our social programs are conditional. With the exception of the aged and the disabled, assistance is tied to work or to the consumption of necessities such as food, housing, or medical care, and our two largest means-tested programs are Food Stamps and the Earned Income Tax Credit.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Link---2NC/1NR › Link---Democrats---2NC

UBI is not politically viable---it would require eliminating benefits that Democrats consider sacrosanct.

Riya Cyriac 21. Data Engineering Intern at USAA, Executive Director of the Young Writers Initiative. "Universal Basic Income Doesn’t Really Have Political Viability". Texas Orator. 11-1-2021. https://thetexasorator.com/2021/11/01/universal-basic-income-doesnt-really-have-political-viability/

The novel coronavirus pandemic introduced many new ideas to the world, including quarantine, Zoom University, rapidly developed vaccines, a spike in social media activism, and a fiery election cycle that destabilized the United States in unforeseen ways. However, COVID-19 also brought a much older idea back to the political scene: universal basic income. The Freedom Dividend, for example, gained national attention as a signature policy position of 2020 Democratic Presidential Candidate Andrew Yang. Though Yang only received a small portion of the American vote, his candidacy reignited this decades-old idea supported by prominent social leaders like Martin Luther King Jr. Universal Basic Income has been explored globally through small-scale pilot programs in Spain, Alaska, and India. The stimulus checks distributed earlier this year, a form of basic income, may have been a highly contentious issue in Congress, but an overwhelming majority of the American public supported the direct cash payments. Does this mean that Universal Basic Income has strong political viability? The answer is less clear cut.

While the CARES Act stimulus payments have seen wild popularity, UBI does not enjoy the same support among the public. In a poll conducted by Pew Research, only 45% of American voters support the proposition, with 62% of Republicans strongly against it and only 33% of Democrats strongly in favor. The popularity also changes depending on race, age, and income, and typically there is far less support amongst older Americans: so far, 72% of them are against the proposition.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Link---2NC/1NR › Link---Republicans---2NC

It’s a non-starter for Republicans---it is incompatible with their basic assumptions about welfare.

LA Times 21. Los Angeles Times Editorial Board. "Editorial: America is taking baby steps towards universal basic income". Los Angeles Times. 3-14-2021. https://www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2021-03-14/stockton-biden-child-tax-credit-universal-basic-income

The $1.9-trillion COVID-19 relief bill that President Biden signed into law Thursday includes an initiative that looks a lot like guaranteed income for families. Starting in July, parents of children ages 17 and younger will get monthly cash grants of up to $300 per child, to spend however they please.

Could this be the start of a broader effort to combat poverty with bigger monthly checks? Some signs point to yes. Although no Republicans voted for the COVID bill, there has been bipartisan support in Congress for increasing the child tax credit and for turning it into a monthly payment, rather than a once-a-year reduction in one’s income taxes.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Link---2NC/1NR › Link---Republicans---2NC

UBI has strong opposition from Republicans.

Juliegrace Brufke 20. Congressional reporter at the Hill. "GOP lawmakers slam proposals for guaranteed income amid pandemic". The Hill. 4-29-2020. https://thehill.com/homenews/house/495392-gop-lawmaker-slam-proposals-for-guaranteed-income-amid-pandemic/

House Republicans are pushing back on the idea of providing a minimum guaranteed income to Americans amid the financial fallout of the coronavirus pandemic.

Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) expressed an openness to the concept on Monday during an interview with MSNBC while discussing the financial aid recently approved by Congress to help bolster the economy.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Link---2NC/1NR › Link---UBI Unpopular---2NC

Federal basic income has broad opposition in congress.

Sarah Holder 21. Writer for CityLab in New York, focused on urban politics, housing, and work. "The Year Basic Income Programs Went Mainstream". Bloomberg. 12-28-2021. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-12-28/the-u-s-cities-giving-residents-direct-cash-payments

As local programs sprouted up in cities across the U.S. in 2021, more than 60 mayors joined a coalition to advocate for the policy in their cities and nationally. Among Democrats, at least, it is no longer considered radical to propose giving low-income residents money with none of the traditional strings of welfare attached. And at the national level, Congress engaged in its own temporary mass cash distribution program, in the form of stimulus checks to the vast majority of Americans.

Still, the local programs are small in scale and duration, and the nationwide push to expand them comes as the quest for a federal guaranteed income policy has not yet succeeded. The fate of the closest thing to it — the child tax credit — hangs in the balance. Since July, the U.S. government has sent eligible parents between $250 and $300 a month for each child they have. With Congress in a stalemate on the federal spending bill, the chance of extending the benefit, which is set to expire at the end of December, looks unlikely. And there is still significant debate among those on the left over whether the massive government investment it would require to take basic income national should be a higher priority than other social programs like universal health care or affordable housing.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Link---2NC/1NR › Link---UBI Unpopular---2NC

Empirics---supporting for UBI has ended political careers.

Ed Kilgore 19. Political columnist for Intelligencer, formerly Vice President for Policy at the Democratic Leadership Council; Communications Director for U.S. Senator Sam Nunn; and a federal-state relations aide to three governors of Georgia. "George McGovern Proposed a Universal Basic Income. It Didn’t Go Well for Him.". Intelligencer. 3-18-2019. https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2019/03/yangs-usd12-000-ubi-was-pioneered-by-george-mcgovern.html

For political observers of a certain vintage, long-shot presidential candidate Andrew Yang’s proposal to give every American adult $1,000 a month brought back a distinct memory from 1972. That year Democratic presidential nominee George McGovern also proposed writing a $1,000 check to every American — $1,000 a year, however (there’s been a lot of inflation since then).

To put it mildly, it did not go over well. Even though McGovern eventually abandoned the proposal, and even though it was similar to the “negative income tax” idea crafted by famed free-market economist Milton Friedman and briefly considered by Richard Nixon, the plan became a potent symbol of the Democrat’s alleged radicalism, fiscal irresponsibility, and wooly thinking. Even before Republicans began mocking him over it, primary rival Hubert Humphrey — hardly a conservative on domestic issues — blasted the proposal with both barrels, claiming it would lead to a massive middle-class tax increase while undermining incentives to work. It probably caused McGovern more grief than anything else he had control over in that campaign, which ended with him losing 49 states to Nixon.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Link---2NC/1NR › Link---UBI Unpopular---2NC

Congress is fiercely opposed to any form of basic income.

John Manning 21. Columnist at International Banker. "Has the Time for Universal Basic Income Finally Arrived?". International Banker. 4-19-2021. https://internationalbanker.com/finance/has-the-time-for-universal-basic-income-finally-arrived/

But arguably the biggest challenge for UBI as a viable policy is the fierce opposition that it and all proposals of guaranteed-income programmes face in Congress—whether UBI itself, enhanced unemployment benefits or boosted minimum wage. In the US, this opposition has typically come from the Republican side of the political aisle, which has consistently argued that government-allocated income should be distributed only to those who have earned it. According to the Pew Research Center, nearly eight in ten Republicans and Republican-leaning independents (78 percent) oppose the federal government providing UBI of about $1,000 per person, with 62 percent strongly opposed. A smaller 66 percent of Democrats and Democrat-leaners favour a UBI, with just a third supporting the proposal strongly.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Link---2NC/1NR › Link---UBI Unpopular---2NC

UBI costs political capital.

Rich Whitney 21. Attorney from Carbondale, Illinois, now working as an appellate public defender. "How Universal Basic Income Can Help Build a Solidarity Economy". Non Profit News | Nonprofit Quarterly. 9-22-2021. https://nonprofitquarterly.org/how-universal-basic-income-can-help-build-a-solidarity-economy/

III. UBI would be an immense improvement over existing, means-tested social-welfare programs.

Because it would be universal, UBI would allow government to eliminate a great deal of the wasteful bureaucracy and the time-consuming and often humiliating means-testing practices that accompany most current welfare programs.

2023 ENDI Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Uniqueness---2NC/1NR › PC Key---2NC

Biden’s commitment is key to push forward negotiations.

Ellyn Ferguson 5-10. Reports on agriculture and food issues for CQ Roll Call, and has reported from Washington. For nearly 20 years she worked as a Washington-based reporter for Gannett covering the overhaul of federal welfare programs and the writing of several farm policy bills, including the 1996 overhaul. Member of the North American Agricultural Journalists and the National Press Club, former president of the Regional Reporters Association, and holds a degree from the University of Florida in Journalism. "Biden, Agriculture committee leaders to discuss farm bill goals". Roll Call. 5-10-2023. https://rollcall.com/2023/05/10/biden-agriculture-committee-leaders-to-discuss-farm-bill-goals/

The top four farm bill writers and President Joe Biden will meet Thursday to discuss the legislation amid concerns that an impasse in debt ceiling negotiations between the White House and House Republicans could slow progress on the wide-ranging policy bill for agriculture.

Uncertainty over the debt ceiling led House Armed Services Chairman Mike D. Rogers, R-Ala., on Tuesday to indefinitely delay a markup of the fiscal 2024 defense authorization bill. Subcommittees had planned to mark up their sections of the bill Thursday and Friday.